Important cases of medical negligence in Indiarfhha.org/.../LAW/important_cases_of_medical_negligence.pdf©RFHHA , AIIMS Page 5 Balbir Singh Makol v. Chairman, M/S. Sir Ganga ram Hospital

©RFHHA , AIIMS Page 1

Important cases of medical negligence in India

A.

A.Saibaba Goud (Dr.) v. Mrs. L. Thomas, 2002 (1) CPJ 199 (AP SCDRC)

SAmbi Reddy v. KKR ENT Hospital and Research Institute & Anr. 1997 (3)CPR 316(TN SCDRC)

A.H. Rizvi (Dr.) v. Ku. Divya Mittal.2001 (3) CPJ 223 (UP SCDRC)

A.K. HAzarika v. Straight X-Ray& Clinical Lab, Complaint Petition No. 122of 1992, decided on

9.10.93 (Assam SCDRD) (unreported)

A.K.Pias v. Karithas Hospital. 1992 (1) CPJ 182 (Ker. SCDRC)

A.M. Mathew V. Director, Kauna Hospital & Ors. 1998 (1) CPJ 476: 1998 (1) CPR 39 (Ker.

SCDRC)

A.M Mulla (Dr.) V. Mahaksab Ismailsab Nanawada, 1999 (2) CPR 353(Ker. SCDRC)

A.P, Joseph & Anr. V. Dr. Kunjannamma Mathai & Anr, 1997 (3) CPJ 382(Ker. SCDRC) 551

A.S.Chandra (Dr.) V. Union of India. (1992) 1 Andhra Law Times 713

A.S Mittal & Ors. V. State of Up & Ors. AIR 1989 SC 1570:1989 (3)SCC 223:1989(2) JT 419 (SC)

A.S. Mohanan v. Dr. Joseph George & Ors. 1998 (2) CPR 116: 1998 (2) CPJ 528(Ker. SCDRC)

A.V Janaki Amma (Amt.) v. Union of India, 2004 (7) CLD 662 (AP-HC)

Abdul Kadar Suleman Allana v. SAptarshi Medical & Research Centre Pvt. Ltd. & Anr.,2000 (3)

CPJ 258 (Mah. SCDRC)

Achutrao HAribhau Khodwa & Ors. V. State of Maharashtra & Ors. JT 1996(2)SC 624: AIR 1996

SC 2377: 1996 (2) SCC 634: 1996(2) Scale 328: 1996 (2) Supreme 751:1996 ACJ 505 (SC)

Adams v. State, 429 P 2d 109, Wash 1967

Adarsh BAraria (Amt.) v. Dr. P.S. HArdia, 2000 (2) CPR 188 (MP SCDRC)

Additional Director, C.G.H.S Pune v. Dr. R.L Butani, 1996 (1) CPJ 255 (NCDRC)

Administrator, Natal v. Edouard, 1990 (3) SA 581


Adoration Convert v. Cicily, 2001 ACJ 1605 (Ker.) (DB)

Ahmed Rashid Abdul Majid Bhuraveala v. United India Insurance Co. Ltd.,1996 (1) CPJ110(AP

SCDRC)

Air India v. Suganda Ravi Mashelkar, 1993 (1) CPJ 63 (64) (NCDRC)

Ajay H.Katharia (Dr.) v. Car Mart Pvt. Ltd. & Anr., 2000 (3) CPJ 502(Mah. SCDRC)

Ajit Kaur (Dr.) v. State of Punjab, 1986 ACJ 696 (P&H-HC)

Akerele v. The King,[1943] AC 255: 168 LT 102: [1943] 1 All ER 367

Akhil Bhartiya Grahak Panchayat and Anr. V. Dr. Jog Hospital, 1993 (2) CPR 252:1993 (3) CPJ

1(Mah. SCDRC)

Akshay Lal jah v. Dr. Shyam Narain Arya, 2003 (1) CLD 125 (Bih. SCDRC)

Aleymma Varghese v. Dewan Bahadur Dr. V. Varghese & Ors., 1997 (3)CPJ 165(Ker. SCDRC)

Allan v. Greater Glasgow Health Board, 1998 SLT 580

Allen v. Bloomsbury Health Authority, (1993) 1 All ER 651

Alok Kumar Chakraborty v. Dr. Gautam Biswas & Anr., 1996 (2)CPJ 368 (WB SCDRC)

Alphic Finance Ltd. V. P. Sadasivam and another , 2001 (3) SCC 513

Altaf Hussain Farooqui v. Dr. Ashok Mathure & Ors., 1998 (1) CPR 427(Mah. SCDRC)

Amar Jwala Paper Mills (India) and Anr. V. State Bank of India, 1998 (8) SCC 387

Amar Singh v. Frances Newton Hospital, 2001(1)CPJ8:2001(1)CPR 379(Punj.SCDRC)

Amblappa v. Sriman D. Veerbhan Hegade, 1999 (3) CPR 72 (Karn. SCDRC)

Amir Ali Shakir v. St. John’s Medical College Hospital, Bangalore, 1996(1) CPJ 169 1995 (3) CPR

174 (Karn. SCDRC)

Anil Nadir (Dr.) v. Dr. Rakesh Dullu, 2003 (3) CPR 308: 2003 (3) CPJ 401(Del. SCDRC)

Anjana Verma v.Dr.Ashok KumarThakur&Ors., 2003 (2) CPR 475:2003 (6) CLD 583 : 2003 (2)

CPJ 210 (Bih. SCDRC)

Anjani Kumar v. Madras Medical Mission & Anr., 1998 (2)CPJ 308 (TN SCDEC)

Annam Vijaya Bhaskar Reddy v. (Dr.) V.S Reddy, 2003 (5) CLD 906 (AP SCDRC)


Anthony Dass A. V. Ex. Engineer, Earth Movers Division, BEM, KGF, 1997 (3) CPJ 224(Karm.

SCDRC)

Anthony v. Grey, (1936) 1 All ER 540

Anumalla Satyanarayana (Dr.) v. K. Shankar, 2000 (1) CPJ 288: 1999(3) CPR 316 (AP SCDRC)

Anup K.Ghose v. Dr. T.K. Biswas, 1997 (3) CPJ 469 (WB SCDRC)

Anup Kumar Jana v. Dr. Pabitra Chaterjee, 1998 (1) CPR 693, (WB SCDRC)

Anup Kumar v. S.M. Kanwar, 1993 (1) CPJ 45:1993 (1) CPR 113 (NCDRC)

Anuradha Kapil (Smt.) v. Dr. Suresh, 2001 (1) CPR 336 (MP SCDRC)

Aparna Doraisamy v. Dr. Anandan, 1999 (2) CPR 5 (TN SCDRC)

Aparna Dutta v. Apollo Hospital Enterprises Ltd., 2002 ACJ 954 (Mad, HC)

Aphraim Jayanand Rathod v. Dr. Shailesh Shah, 1996 (1) CPJ 243: 1996 (1) CPR 547(Guj.

SCDRC)

Archana (Smt.) & Ors. V. Chaudhari Trust Hospital & Ors. , 1998 (1) CRP 556(Mah. SCDRC)

Archana Paul and etc. Etc. V. State of Tripura & Ors., AIR 2004 Gau.-HC7

Arizona v. Maricopa Country Medical Society,475 US 332: 73 L.Ed. (2d) 48

Arun Balakrishanan Iyer and Anr.V.Soni Hospital and others,AIR2003 Mad.-HC 389

Arun Kumar Mishra v. Dr. Purshottam Singh, 1998 (3) CPR 284: 1998 (3) CPJ 573(Bih. SCDRC)

Aruna Ben D.Kothari & Ors. V. Navdeep Clinic & Ors. , 1996 (3) CPJ 605(Guj. SCDRC)

Aruna Mani Mishra Sanchalika Swati Sewa Sanstha Hospital, S.S.S. Hospital Mahmoodabad,

District Sitapur v. Smt. Bhagwati & Anr., 2003(1) CPR 157:2003(1)CPJ 69 (UP SCDRC)

Aruna Trikha (Smt.) v. Sehra Medical Centre, 2002 (1) CPJ 75 (NCDRC)

Arvind K. Hemant Lal Shah v. Bombay Hospital Trust, 1992 (2) CPR 154(Mah. SCDRC)

Ascher v. Gutirrez, 533 F 2d 1235, DC CA 1976

Asha Rani v. Dr. Rohit Grover & Ors., 1996 (3) CPJ 259 ( Chd. UTCDRC)

Asha v. Rohini Hospital , 2003 (1) CLD 537 (Del. SCDRC)

Ashok Kumar v. Dr. Suresh Sharma, 2001 (1) CPJ 478 (Punj. SCDRC)


Ashok Dhawan (Dr.) v. Surjeet Singh, 1997 (1) CPJ 82: 1997 (1) CPR 169 (NCDRC)

Ashok Kumar Aneja v. Dr. Harish Kohli,2003 (2) CPJ 290:2003 (2) CPR 471(Uttaranchal-

SCDRC)

Ashok Kumar Choudhary v. Shashi Bhushan Singh, 2004 (1) CPR 8 (Bih. SCDRC)

Ashok Kumar Singh v.Mohan Thakur, 2000 (2) CPJ 220:2000 (3) CPR 202(Bih. SCDRC)

Ashpal Singh v. Sher Singh, 2002 (1) CPJ 73 (Del. SCDRC)

Avtar Singh Bhatora v. Dr. Swarn Prakash Garg, 2001 (1) CPJ 197: 2001 CPR 44(Punj. SCDRC)

B

B.Ashok Kumar (Dr.) v. Kamma Narasimha Swamy,2003 (3) CLD 670 : 2004 (1) CPJ 55(AP

SCDRC)

B.Mahidhar Reddy v. Apollo Hospitals, 2003 (6) CLD 373 (AP SCDRC)

B.Murali Krishna Reddy v. Smt. Dr. E. Adilaxmi, 2003 (5) CLD 672 (AP SCDRC)

B. NArasaiah (Dr.) v. Kande Laxmaiah, 1998 (1) CPJ 489 (AP SCDRC)

B.C. Joshi v. Dr. SAndeep Kumar & Ors., 2002 (2)CPJ 125 (Del. SCDRC)

B.H Tolani v. Rajasthan Housing Board, 1993 (1) CPJ 524 (Raj. SCDRC)

B.S. Agarwala v. State of Orissa, 1993 (2) CPJ 1066 (Ori. SCDRC)

B.S Hegde v. Dr. Sudhanshu Bhattacharya, 1993 (3) CPR 414 (NCDRC)

Babanrao Yadav v. Lion Tarachand Bappa Hospital, 2003 (1) CPJ 365: 2002 (3) CPR329(Mah.

SCDRC)

Babita Jha v. State of Bihar & Ors., 2002 (3) CPR 392 (Bih. SCDRC)

Baby Ramya, represented by her father K. Raji Reddy v. Dr. (Mrs.) Aruna Reddy & Anr.,1996 (1)

CPR 244 (AP SCDRC)

Badri Parsad Rai v. Dr. M.L. Peshin, 2003 (3) CPR 119 (Uttaranchal-SCDRC)

Bailey v. Belinfante, 218 SE 2d 289, Ga 1975


Balbir Singh Makol v. Chairman, M/S. Sir Ganga ram Hospital and Ors., 2000 (1) CPR

45(NCDRC)

Baldev Singh & Anr. v. Arya Hospital-cum-Daulat ram Memorial Medical Centre & Ors., 1997 (3)

CPJ 528 (Chd. UTCDRC)

Baleshwar Prasad & Ors. (Dr.) v. Firtu Das Mahant, 2003 (2) CPR 112:2003 (2) CPJ 457

(Jharkhand SCDRC)

Balwinder Kumar v. Arya Hoapital, 2001 (2) CPR 394 (Chd.- UTCDRC)

Bandhua Mukti Morcha v. Union of india, (1984) 3 SCC 161: AIR 1984 SC 802

Basidhar Panigrahi v. Chief Medical Officer, Ganjam and Ors, 1993(1) CPR 94(Ori. SCDRC)

Barcia v. Society of the New York Hospital,241 NYS 2d 373, NY 1963

Barkway v. South Wales Transport Co., (1950) 1 All ER 392

Barnete v. Chelsea and Kensington Hospital Management Committee, (1968) 1 All ER1068\

Barnnett v. Bachrach, 34 A 2d 626, Dc 1943

Barrie in moore v. Lewisham Group, HMC (1959)

Basant Mahadev Samvatsar v. Dr. Sudhir Mahashabde & Ors., 2000 (3) CPR 349 (MP SCDRC)

Basant Seth & Anr. v.Regency Hospital Ltd.,OP No.99 of 1994,Decided on22.1.2002(NCDRC)

Baseo v. State of Pepsu, AIR 1956 SC 448

Basudev Goswami v. Dr. Bhaskar Das & Anr., 2001 (3) CPJ 262 (WB SCDRC)

Bee Enn General Hospital v. Sunita Kaloo, 2003 (2) CLD 137 (J&K-HC)

Beena Gark v. Kailash Nursing Home, 2002 (3) CPR 254: 2002 (3) CPJ 99 (NCDRC)

Behal Hospital & Medical Research Centre, though Manager, Dr. Vinay B. Behal v. Sh. Sahi Ram

& Ors., 2003 (1) CPR 49-2003 (1) CPJ 14 (Raj SCDRC)

Benarr v. Kettering Health Authority, (1988) 138 NLJ 179

Beringer v. Lackner, 73 NE 2d 620, III 1947

Beti Bai Saxena (Smt.) v. Dr. S.L.Mukherjee & Ors.., 2001 (3) CPJ 251:2001(2) CPR 163(MP

SCDRC)


Bhagbat Saran Agarwala & Ors. V. State of Orissa & Ors., 1993 (2) CPJ 1066 (Ori SCDRC)

Bhagwan DAss Arora v. Dr. Ashok Singal, 1999 (#) CPJ 345 (Punj SCDRC)

Bhairu lal v. Rajasthan State Electricity Board, 1992 (3) CPJ 1656 (Raj SCDRC)

Bhajan Lal Gupta v. Mool Chand Kheraiti Ram Hospital, 2001 (1) CPJ 31 (NCDRC)

Bhal Chandra’s Case, AIR 1968 SC 1319: 1968 Cri. LJ 1501: 1969 ACJ 87 (SC)

Bhanupal v. Dr. Prakash Padode and Ors., 2000 (2) CPJ 384: 2000 (3) CPR 356 (MP SCDRC)

Bharat II Gurjar v. Newciti Hospitals, 2003 (1) CLD 1019 (AP SCDRC)

Bharat Pathology Laboratory v. Mangi Lal Vyas, 2003 (3) CPJ 94 (NCDRC)

Bhargava Nursing Home v. Mrs.Charan Kamal Kaur,2003(3)CLD 351(Chd.-UTCDRC)

Bhavchanbhai Manjibhai Lakhani v.Dr.Bhupendra D.SAgar, Complaint No.378 of 1991 Decided

on 26.8.1993 (Guj. SCDRC) (unreported)

Bhim Singh v. State of J&K, (1985) 4 SCC 677: AIR 1986 SC 494

Bhiwani Dutta v.P.G.I.Chandigarh,1998(2)CPJ 102: 1998(1)CPR 548(Chd.UTCDRC)

Bhogi Lal Chimanlal v, Nanavati, AIR 1931 Bom. 409: (1931) 33 Born LR 648

Bholi Devi v. State of Jammu and Kashmir & Ors., AIR 2002 J&K (HC)65

Bhupendra Nath Dass v.Maharaj Ram Krishna Mission Seva Pratisthan&Ors.,1998(1) CPJ

377:1998 (2) CPJ (WB SCDRC)

Biharilal Thavait v. Dr. Prakash Ladikar, 1999 (3) CPJ 535 (MP SCDRC)

Biju @ Paul Joseph v. Dr. K. Kunhu Mohammed & Ors., 1997 (3) CPJ 316(Ker. SCDRC)

Birbal Singh & Ors. V. ESI Corporation & Ors., 1993 (2) CPJ 1028

Birdhi Chand Meena v. Dr. Prabhakar Sethi & Anr., 2003 (1) CPJ 45 (Raj. SCDRC)

Biswanath Chakraborty(Dr.)v.Mrs.China Sinha&Ors..,2002(2)CPJ 329(WB SCDRC)

Blyth v. Birmingham Waterworks Co., (1856) II Ex. 781

Bolam v.Friern Hospital Management Committee,[1957]2All ER 118:1 BMLR 1 (QBD)

Bolotho administratrix of the Estate of Bolitho v. City and Hackney Health Authority, (1997)4 All

ER 771 Bourgeois v. Davis, 337 So 2d 575, La 1976


Bridges v. Directors, etc. Of N.L.RY., (1873-74) LR7 HR.213

Brij Mohan Kher v.Dr.N.H.Banka and Ors.,1995(1)CPJ 99:1994(3)CPR 140:1994(3)CP 197

(NCDRC)

Buchan v.Ortho, Pharmaceuticals (Canada) Ltd. Robins, (1986) 25 D.L.R. (4th

) 658,669 (Ont; C.A.)

Bull and another v. Devon AHA, (1993) 4 Med LR 117

Butler v. Layton, 164 NE 920, Mass 1929

C

C. Sivakumar v. Dr. John Arthur & Anr. 1999(1) CPR 367 (TN SCDRC): 1998 (3) CPR 436 (TN

SCDRC)

C.A Philomina v. Dr. Vijaya Kumar Kodali, 2003(1) CLD 709: 2003 (3) CPJ 403:2003 (3) CPR

485(AP SCDRC)

C.C. Chaubal (Dr. V. Pankaj Srivastava, 2003 (3) CPR 20: 2003 (5) CLD 871 (NCDRC)

C.S. Subramanian (Dr.) v. Kumarasamy & Anr. (1994) 1 MLJ 438

C.V. Mathew (Dr.) V. P. Babu, 2000(1) CPJ 134: 1999 (3) CPR 461 (Ker. SCDRC)

Calcutta Medical; Research Institute v. Bimlesh Chatterjee & Ors. , 1999 (1) CPR3 (NCDRC)

Carrigan v. Roman Catholic Bishop, 178 A 2d 502, NH 1962

Cassel and Co. Ltd. V. Broome, (1962) AC 1027 (HL)

Cassidy v. Ministry of Health, (1951) 2KB 3641: (1951) 1 All ER 574

CCI. Chambers Co-op. Housing Society Ltd. V. Development Credit Bank Ltd., AIR 2004 SC 184

CDR Hospitals v. Smt. Nirmala Manaseh, 2001 (2) CPR 69 (NCDRC)

CES v. Superlinics (Australia) Pty. Ltd., (1995) 38 NSWLR 47

Ch. Padma v. Sudha Nursing Home, 2002 (1) CPJ 53 (AP SCDRC)

Chaman Singh Faujdar & Ors.V.German Remedies Ltd. & Anr. 1992 (2) CPJ 915 1992(1) CPR

603 (Raj. SCDRC)


Champaben Babul al v. C.V. Shah Medical Centre, 1992(1) CPR 667 (Guj. SCDRC)

Chanchal Ostwal (Smt.) v. SDM Hospital and Dr.Nimish A. Shah, Decided on 28.11.92 by Raj.

SCDRC (Unreported)

Chandra Sagar D. Rajput v. Dr. Dinesh J. Shah, 1999 (1) CPJ 434 (Mah. SCDRC)

Chandrikaben v.Shree Vijay Vallabh Sarvajanik Hospital, 2004 (7) CLD 254(Guj. SCDRC)

Charan Singh v.Healing Touch Hospital & Ors.2003(2) CPR 95:2003 (3) CPJ 62:2003 (6) CLD 46

(NCDRC)

Charan Singh v. Healing Touch Hospital, 2000 (3) CPJ 1:2000 (#) CPR 1(SC)

Charanjit Kaur & Ors.v. Manjit Kaur, 1999 (1) CPR 559 (Punj. SCDRC)

Cheroth Suhara v. Dr. K.K. Subramanian & Anr. 1995 (1) CPR 258 (Ker. SCDRC)

Chester v. Afshar, (2002) 3 All ER 552

Chin Keo v. Government of Malaysia, 1967 ACJ 379 (P.C.England)

Christian Medical Centre v. A. Shahjahan, 1998 (#) CPJ 242 (AP SCDRC)

Christy v. Saliterman, 179 NW 2d 288, Minn 1970

Clark v. Reading and District HMC, (1963) 107 SJ 115

Collins v. Hertfordshire Country Council, (1947) 1 All ER 633

Commander Sohan Singh Sandhu (Retd.) v. Dr. H.K. Bedi, Cardiology Deptt. & Anr. 1999 (1) CPR

550 (Chd-UTCDRC)

Commercial Officer, Office of the Telecom District Manager, Patna v. Bihar State Warehousing

Corporation, 1993 (1) CPJ 42 (44) (NCDRC)

Commissioner, Hindu Religious Endowments Madras v. Sir Lakshmindra Thirtha Swamiar of Sri

Shiur Mutt, 1954 SCR 1005

Common Cause v. Drug Controller of India, 1991 (2) CPJ 698

Common Case,A Regd.Society v.Union of India & Ors.,(1999)6 SCC 667:JT 1999(5) SC 237: VII

(1999) CLT 76 (SC): AIR 1999 SC 2979

Commr. Of Inland Revenue v. Maxse, (1919) 1 KB 647 (657)


Consumer Education Research Society & Anr. V. Dr. Ratilal B.Patel & Ors. 1994(2) CPJ 342 (Guj.

SCDRC)

Consumer Protection Council & Anr. V. Parul Clinic Maternity Home and Hospital& Ors., 1996 (2)

CPJ 157: 1996 (!) CPR 585(Guj. SCDRC)

Consumer Education & Research Centre v. Union of India, 1995 (3) SCC 42

Consumer Protection Council and Ors. V. Dr. S. Sundaram & Anr.1998(2) CPJ 3 1997(@) CPR

162 (NCDRC)

Consumer Unity and Trust Society v. State of Rajasthan & Ors., 1992 (1) CPR 259 (NCDRC)

Consumer Unity and Trust Society v. State of Rajasthan & Ors., 1991 (1) CPR 241 (NCDRC)

Cook v.J.L Kier & Co. Ltd., (1970) 1 WLR 774: (1970) 2 All ER 513

Cosmopolitan Hospital Pvt. Ltd. And Anr. V. Vasantha P.Nair and Cosmopolitan Hospital Pvt.

Ltd.V. V.P. Shantha and Ors. 1992 (1) CPJ 302: 1992 (1) CPR 820 (NCDRC)

Coupland v. Arabian Gulf Petroleum Co. (1983) 3 All ER 226 (CA)

Crawford v. Charing Cross Hospital, (1953) the Times, 23rd

April & 8th

Dec

Crits v. Sylvester, (1956) 1 DLR (2d) 502,508

Crossman v. Stewart, (1977) 82 DLR (3d) 677

Croichman v. Burke, (1997) 40 BMLR 163

Crouch v. Most, 432 P 2d 250, NM 1967

D

D. Savitri Devi v. Medwin Hospitals, 2003 (5) CLD 635 (AP SCDRC)

D.C Bhawani Parasad v. Krishna Nursing Home.1997 (1) CPJ 483(Karn. SCDRC)

D.D Trikha (Dr.) v. Dr. Devender Mahant & Ors. 2002 (2) CPJ 116 (NCDRC)

D.H. Kumari v. Director, Nizam’s Institute of Medical Services, 2003 (5) CLD 805 (AP SCDRC)


D.K Basu v. State of West Bengal, AIR 1997 SC 610

D’Souza v.Pushpapati Nath Sarkar, 1968 Cri LJ 405 (Cal.)

Dale v. Muthali, (1976) 78 DLR (3d) 588

Daly v. Mcneil Laboratories, 509 f 2d 617, CCA 6, 1975

Darshan Kaur v. Dr. J.S Sodhi & Ors. 1999 (1) CPR 522 (Chd.- UTCDRC)

Darshan Singh Barsa v. Dr. Jasbir Singh & Ors. , 1998 (2) CPJ 45: 1998 (1) CPR 304 (Punj.

SCDRC)

Darshini Devi v. Rajeshwar Prashad, 1998 (1) CPJ 358 (HAr. SCDRC)

Dashrathbhai Keshabhai NAi v. Dr. Pravin C. Patel & Anr. 1998 (3) CPJ 30: 1999 (1) CPR 12

(Guj. SCDRC)

Davidson v. Connaught Laboratories, (1980) 14 C.C.L.T. 251, 276 (Ont. H.C)

Davis v. Wilmerding, 24 SE 2d 337, NC 1943

Daya (Smt.) v. Dr. Rohit Goel & Ors. 2000 (1) CPJ 232 (UP SCDRC)

Deepak Behl v. Dr. Narendra M. rege, 1999 (3) CPR 11 (Mah. SCDRC)

Deepak Gokaran v. Chairman, Mahant Gurmukh Singh Charitable Hospital Trust & Anr. , 2003 [1]

CPJ 518 [Del. SCDRC]

Deramma & Ors. v. Superintendent, Area Hospital & Ors. , 1997 [3] CPJ 613 [AP SCDRC]

Derr v. Bonney , an American case, 231 p 2d 637, Wash, 1951

Devendra Kantilal Nayak & Ors. V. Dr.Kalyani Ben Dhruv Shah& Anr., 1997 (1) CPJ 103 (Guj.

SCDRC)

Devendra Kumar Sharma v. Post gradute Institute of Medical Education & Reseach, 2002 (1) CPJ

211(Chd. UTCDRC)

Devendra Madan (Dr.) v. (Smt.) Shakuntla Devi, 2003 (1) CLD 447: 2003(1) CPJ 57 (NCDRC)

Devi Rani v. N Prakash rao & Ors., 2002 (3) CPR 258: 2002(3) CPJ 123 (APSCDRC)

Dharmendra K.Mishra v. Dr. Akhnri S.Sinha, Medico lab, 1996 (2) CPR 192 (Bih. SCDRC)

Dharngdhara Chemical Works Ltd. V. State of Saurashtra, 1957 SCR 152 at P. 157


Di Filliopo v. Preseton, 173 A 2d 333, Del 1961

Dig Vijay Sinh A. Zata v. Dr. Narendra T. Vani & Ors. , 1995 (1) CPJ 186 (Guj. SCDRC)

Dilbagh Hussain v. Harjinder Kaur, 2000(3) CPJ 17: 2000(3) CPR 467 (Punj. SCDRC)

Dilip Kumar Biswas v. Mothari Medical Centre, 1999 (3) CPJ 609:2000 (1) CPR 502 (WB

SCDRC)

Dinesh Kaushal v. Dr. K.K.Khurana, 2002 (1) CPJ 414(Chd.-UTCDRC)

Dipti De SArkar v. SAIL, 1993 (2) CPJ 1209:1993(1) CPR 640 (Ori. SCDRC)

Director, Mary Queen’s Mission Hospital Allegry Clinic v. M.J.Jose, 1999 (2) CPR 7 (Ker.

SCDRC)

District Manager, Telephones, Patna v. Dr. Tarun Bharthuar, 1992 (1) CPJ 47 (49) (NCDRC)

Divisional Controller, KSRTC v. MAhadeva Shetty, 2003 (7) SCC 197

Donoghue v, Stevenson, (1932) AC 562 (HL)

Dudhi Ben Navghanbai v. Dr. Ashok Bhai H. Pathak & Anr. , 1996(2) CPR 69 (Guj. SCDRC)

Dulieu v. White, (1901) 2 KB 669,P.679

E

Edler v. Greenwich & Deptford Hospital, The Times, March 7, 1993

Elizabeth Rani v. Dr. A.N. HArilal & Ors., 2003 (3) CPJ 149 (TN SCDRC)

Emeh v. Kensington and Chelsea and Westminster Area Health Authority, (1984) 3 All ER 1044:

(1985) QB 1012

F

F. v. R.(1982) 33 SASR 189,201

Fakhruddin Abbs Bharmal v. Dr. Dasgupta & Ors. , 1998 (3) CPR 365 (Mah. SCDRC)

Fakir Mohan Bhuyan v. Dr. G.C. Pothal and Ors. , 1999 (1) CPR 140 (Ori. SCDRC)


Feency v. Young, 181 NYS 481, NY 1920

FORCE v. Dr. M. Ganeswara Rao & Ors., 1998 (3) CPR 251 : 1998(1) CPJ 413 (AP SCDRC)

Foster v. Englewood Hospital Association,313 NE 2d 255, III 1974

Fraster v. Vancouver General Hospital, (1951) 3 WWR 337 Affirmed in (1952) 3DLR 785

Fredette v. Wiebe, (1986) 29 DLR (4th

) 534

Freese v. Lemmon, 210 N.W. 2d 576 (S.C. of lowa) (1973)

G

G.Bala Saroj v. C.D.R. Hospital, 2003 (2) CLD 198 (APSCDRC)

G.Bhart v. Dr. G. Sarangapani (dead) by Lrs, 1997 (1) CPR 466 (AP SCDRC)

G.Murali (Dr.) v. Moratkal Kalarikkal Janardhanan, 1999 (2) CPR 14 (Ker. SCDRC)

G.Padmanabhan Nair v. G.M. Kerala State Road Transport Corporation, 1989 ACJ 873(Ker.- HC)

G.Suresh Kumar v. Director, Nizam Institute of Medical Sciences(NIMS),2003(3) CLD 377 (AP

SCDRC)

G.D Jiladia (Dr.) v. Minor Dharmistha Chhotubhai Goswami & Anr. , 2003 (2) CPR 490:2003 (2)

CPJ 381: 2004 (8) CLD 87 (Guj. SCDRC)

G.K.B. Optics & Ors. V. Mrs. Nima Roy, 1996 (2) CPJ 135 (WBSCDRC)

Gangadharan (Dr.) v. K.A. Abdul Salam, 2003 (3) CLD 40 (Ker. SCDRC)

Gangapam Ramalinga Reddy v. Appollo Hospital, 2003 (1) CLD 494 (AP SCDRC)

Ganta Mohana Laxmi v. Dr. C.V. Ratnam, 2003 (6) CLD 360 (NCDRC)

Gare Devamma & Ors. V. Supdt. Area Hospital & Ors., 1997 (3) CPJ 613 (AP SCDRC)

Geeta Devi v. Dr. Ketki Gark, 1999 (2) CPR (Punj. SCDRC)

Geetha Kumari v. Dr. Mrs. Anita Ranjan, 1995 (2) CPR 393 (Ker. SCDRC)

Ghanshyamdas Bhagwandas v.State of M.P,1997 ACJ 182:1977 Cri LJ 1373(MP-HC)

Ghisa Ram v. Dr. P.K. Bansal, 2003 (2) CLD 347: 2004 (1) CPR 24 (Del. SCDRC)


Gian Chand Aggarwal (Dr.) v. Darshana Devi, 2002(1) CPJ 351 (Punj. SCDRC)

Giannarelliv. Wraith, 81 ALR 417

Giesen, International Medical Malpractice Law (1988), Para 255

Gill v. Hartfort Accident and Indemnity Co., 337 So 2d 420,Fla 1976

Gladwell v. Steggall, (1839) 5 Bing NC 733: 8 LJCP 361

Glare Devamma & Ors. V. Suprintendent, Area Hospital& Anr., 1997 (3) CPJ 613 (APSCDRC)

Gloning v. Miller, (1954) IDLR 372

Golia v. Health Insurance Plan of Greater New York, 166 NYS 2d 889, NY,1957

Goorkani v. Tayside Health Board, [1991] 3 Med LR 33

Gordon v. Wilson, [1992] 3 Med LR 401

Governor-General in Council v. M.T. SAliman, (1948) ILR 27 Pat. 207

Govind Bilumal Sindhi v. Dr. Kiran M. Doshi, 1999 (3) CPR 123 (Mah. SCDRC)

Govind Ram Aggarwal v. Dr. V.P. Gupta & Anr., 2003 (2) CPJ 110: 2003 (3) CPR

360(Uttarancahal SCDRC)

Graham v. Sisco, 449 SW 2d 663, Pa 1966

Gujrat State Road Transport Corparation v. Kamlaben Valjibhai Vora, 2002 (3)TAC 465: 2002

ACJ 780 (Guj.) (DB)

Gunturu Ajaya Kumar v. Dr. K. Rama Rao, 2003 (6) CLD 785 (AP SCDRC)

Gurmit Mahal v. Chauhan Nursing Home Pvt. Ltd. & Anr., 1998 (3) CPR405 (Chd.-UT CDRC)

Gurpreet Kaur v. Dr. R.K. Bhutani, 1993 (3) CPJ 355:1993 (3) CPR 409 (NCDRC)

Gursewak Kaur v. Dr. Jaskaran Singh, 1996 (3) CPJ 300 (Punj. SCDRC)

Guru Teg Bahadur Sahib (Charitable) Hospital v. D.K. Nayyar, 2002 (1) CPR 442 (Punj. SCDRC)


H

Hv. Royal Alexandra Hospital forChildren [1990] 1 Med. L.R. 297 (N.S.W.S.C.)

HAase v. Garfinkel, 418 SW 2d 108, Mo 1967

Hans Raj v. Dr. K.S. Chugh, 2000(1) CPR 310 (Chd.-UTCDRC)

Hanuman Dass v. Usha Rani, 1978 ACJ 310

HArbhajan Singh v. Dayanand Medical College and Hospital & Anr., 1996 (3) CPJ 263: 1994(1)

CPR 518 (Punj. SCDRC)

Harbhajan v. State of Punjab, AIR 1966 SC 97

Hardeep Kaur v. (Dr.) (Smt.) Satinder Saluja, 2003 (5) CLD 793: 2003 (2) CPR 415 (MP SCDRC)

Hari Bhai Leghar Bhai Solanki v. Dr. Suresh Parikh, 1994 (1) CPJ 373 (Guj. SCDRC)

Hari Kishan v. Sukhbir Singh, (1988) 4 SCC 561 : AIR 1988 SC 2187

Hari Mohan & Co. V. Kailashpati Pandey, 1994 (1) CPJ 344 (Bih. SCDRC)

Hari Shanker Singh v. Sukhbir Singh, (1988) 4 SCC 561

HAri bhai Lagharbhai Salon v. Dr. Suresh Parikh, 1994 (1) CPJ 373 (Guj. SCDRC)

HAripada Saha v. State of Tripura, 2002 ACJ 1877 (Gau.)

HArjeet Kaur v. Santokba Durlabhji Memorial Trust, 2003 (5) CLD 1066 (Raj. SCDRC)

HArjiwanbhai Khoda Bhai Gohil v. Dr. Yogendra D. Shah, 1997 (3) CPR 517 (Guj. SCDRC)

HArjot Ahluwalia (minor) though his parents v. Spring Meadows Hospital and Ors. 1997 (2) CPJ

98: 1997 (3) CPR 1 (NCDRC)

Harkanwaljit Singh Saini (Dr.) v. Gurbax Singh , 2003 (1) CLD 611: 2003 (1) CPJ 153 (NCDRC)

HArris v. Harris, (1973) 1 Lloyds Rep. 445

Harvinder Kaur v. Dr. (Mrs.) Sushma Chawla & Anr. , 2001(3) CPJ 143 (Punj. SCDRC)

Hatcher v. Black, Times July 2, 1954

Hay v. University of Alberta Hospital, [1991] 2 Med LR 204


Heaps v. Peerite Ltd., (1937) 2 All ER 60:81 Sol Jo 236

Health v. Burkshire Health Authority, [1991] 8 BMLR 98 QBD

Hedley Byrne & Co. Ltd. V. Heller & Partner Ltd., 1964 AC 465: (1963) 2 All ER 575

Heirs and LR’s of the Deceased Arvind Kumar Himmatlal Shah v. Bombay Hospital Trust,

Complaint No. 20 of 1992 Decided on 10.6.1992 (Mah. SCDRC)

Helen C. Rebello and Ors. V. Maharashtra State Road Transport Corporation, AIR 1998 SC 3191

Hemant Bahadur Singh Parihar v. Dr. Mrs. Maya Pathak, 2000 (1) CPR 191 (MP SCDRC)

Hemant Kumar v. Dr. Sanjay Sharma & Anr., 2003 (2) CPR 418 (MP SCDRC)

Hemina Hitesh Kotak & Ors. V. Dr. Ashok Nathawani & Ors., 2003 (1) CPJ 252 (NCDRC)

Hepworth v. Kerr, (1995) 6 Med LR 139, p. 139

Heramerlal v. Dr. Ajoy Paul & Ors., 2002 (2) CPJ 248 (WB SCDRC)

Herxheimer and Young, (1990) 140 New I.J. 859

High Commissioner for India v. I.M. Lall, (1948) LR 75 IA 225

Hilarious Institute & Clinical Laboratories v. Mohan Das, Appeal No. 497/95 Decided on 20.4.1995

by the Ker. SCDRC (Unreported)

Hindustan Paper Corporation Ltd. V. Dhir Copy House, 1992 (2) CPR 753 1992 (2) CPJ 558

(NCDRC)

Hogan v. Almand, 205 SE 2d 440, Ga 1974

Hogmann v. Blackmon, 241 So 2d 752. Fla 1970

Hollis v. Dow Coming Corpn., (1993) 103 DLF (4th

) 520

Holmes v. Ashford, [1950] 2All E.R. 76

Hotchkiss v. National City Bank, (1911) 200 Fed. 287

Hundley v. St. Frances Hospital, 327 P 2d 131, Cal 1958

Hunter v. Hamlay, (1955) SLT 213


I

I.Ahmed (Dr.) v. Sumitra Biswas, 2002 (2) CPJ 275 (WB SCDRC)

I.K Raju (Dr.) v. Masaqrapu Ramalakshmi, 2003 (6) CLD 502 (AP SCDRC)

Idu Beg’s case, (1881) 3 All 776

Incollingo v. Ewing, 282 A 2d 206, Pa 1971

Inderjeet Singh v. Dr. P.K. Bhatia & Anr. , 1998 (3) CPJ 289 (HAR. SCDRC)

Indian Medical Association & Ors. V. V.P. Shantha & Ors. JT 1995 (8) SC 119: AIR 1996 SC 550:

1995 (6) SCC 651: 1995 (3) CPJ 1 (SC): 1995 (3) CPR 412 (SC)

Ishwar Das Lakhraj Ramchandani v. Dr. P.J. Bunch & Anr. , 1995 (3) CPJ 549 (Guj. SCDRC)

J

J.Gopal v. Nagarjuna Blood Bank, 2003 (2) CPJ 434: 2003 (2) CLD 714 (AP SCDRC)

J.J Merchant v. Dr. Shrinath Chaturvedi, 2002 (5) Supreme 337: 2002 CTJ 757 JT 2002 (6) SC 1

J.N. Shrivastav (Dr.) v. Rambiharilal and Ors., AIR 1982 MP 132

J.P Goel (Dr.) v. Smt. Pushpa Verma, 2002 (1) CPJ 28: 2002 (1) CPR 467 (Del. SCDRC)

Jackson v. Mountain Sanitarium, 67 SE 2d 57, NC 1951

Jacob George (Dr.) v. State of Kerala, (1994) 3 SCC 430: JT 1994 (3) SC 225

JAgan Nath v. Jinadl Dental and Orthopedic Clinic of Kaithal & Anr., 1994 (1) CpJ 119 (Har.

SCDRC)

Jagat Narayan Chaube v. Dr. Achal Sepaha, 2003 (6) CLD 606: 2004 (1) CPJ 435 (MP SCDRC)

Jagdeep Mohanlal Kakadia v. Ophthalmics and Drugs India & Ors. , 1997 (3) CPR 229 (Guj.

SCDRC)

Jai Prakash Saini v. Director , Rajiv Gandhi Cancer Institute and Research


Centre & Ors. 2003 (1) CPJ 305: 2003 (2) CPR 202 (Del. SCDRC)

Jaiwati (Smt.) v. Parivar Seva Sanstha, 1999 (3) CPJ 167 (Del. SCDRC)

Jan Sangharsh Morcha v. State of Gujrat, 2001 (1) AJR 397 (Guj.)

Janak Kanimathi Nathan (Dr.) v. Murlidhar Exnath Masane, First Appeal No. 740 of 1994 Decided

on 17.4.2002 (NCDRC)

Janak Kumari v. Dr. Balwinder Kaur “Nagpal & Anr. , 2003 (2) CPJ 28 (NCDRC)

Janaki S. Kumar & Anr. (Dr.) v. Mrs. Sarafunnisa, 2000 (1) CPJ 66:1999 (3) CPR 472(Ker.

SCDRC)

Jasmine Patel (Dr.) (Miss) v. Dr. R.J. Manekshaw & Ors.., 1997 (3) CPJ 14:1997(2) CPR 223

(NCDRC)

Jasmine Patel (Dr.) (Ms.) v. Dr. R.J. Maneksa and Ors., 2000 (1) CPR 421(Mah SCDRC)

Jaswinder Singh v. J.S. SAini, 2000 (2) CPJ 262 (Chd.-UTCDRC)

Jay Laxmi Salt Works (P) Ltd. V. State of Gujrat, (12994) 4 SCC 1:JT (1994) 3 SC 492

Jayantilal Govindlal Parmar v. Managing Trustee. & Ors. , 1997 (1) CPJ 295: 1997(2) CPR 9 (Guj.

SCDRC)

Jayendra Maganlal Pandey v. Dr. Lalit P.Trivedi & Ors. , 1997 (1) CPJ 11 (Guj. SCDRC)

Jitendra Nath v. Dr. (Mrs.) Manju Geeta Mishra & Ors. , 1995 (2) CPJ 96 (Bih. SCDRC)

John Andrade v. P.D. Hinduja National Hospital and Medical Research Centre & Ors., 1998 (1)

CPR 579, (Mah. SCDRC)

Joint Director of Health Service v. Sahai, AIR 2000 Mad. 305

Jolly v. Chief Secretary Hospitals of Cleveland, (19689) 540 NE 2d 1370 (Ohio)

Jones v. Livox Quarries Ltd., [1952] QB 608

Joseph Alias Animon & Anr. V. Dr. Elizabeth Zachariah & Ors. , 1997 (1) CPJ 96 (Ker. SCDRC)

Joseph Ollapally & Ors. V. New India Assurance Co. Ltd. & Ors. , 1996 (3) CPJ 528 (Karn.

SCDRC)

Joslin Chrysostom (Dr.) v. S. Lourdu, 2001 (3) CPJ 126: (2002) 1 CPR 150 (TN SCDRC)


Jot Maternity and Children Hospital & Anr. V. SAnjogita, 2003 (3) CPJ 136: 2003 (1) CPR 171

(Punj. SCDRC)

Jugbir Singh v. Dr. Manoj Sharma & Anr., 2003 (2) CPJ 467 (Del. SCDRC)

Jaggan Khan v. State of M.P., AIR 1965 SC 831: (1965) 1 Cri. LJ 763 (SC)

Jyothi Vivek & Ors. (Dr.) v. Pradeep & Ors., 1998 (1) CPJ 191: 1997 (3) CPR 220 (Ker. SCDRC)

K

K. Jayaram v. Poona Hospital and Research Centre & Ors., 1993 (3) CPJ 70: 1994 (1) CPJ

23: 1994 CCJ 311 (NCDRC)

K.Kuttapan v. Benigar Hospital & Ors. , 1996 (1) CPR 462 (Ker. SCDRC)

K.MAhabala Bhat (Dr.) v. K. Krishna, 2001 (3) CPR 137:2002 (2) 127 (NCDRC)

K.Mahendran v. Dr. O. Satyanarayana, 2003 (5) CLD 645 (AP SCDRC)

K. Sridhar (Dr. )v. Budda Lakshmikantham, 2003 (3) CLD 207 (AP SCDRC)

K.Ummaer v. Jubilee Mission Hospital, Trichur & Anr. , 1997 (3) CPJ 432 (Ker. SCDRC)

K. VAsantha v. Teja Hospital , 1993 (1) CPR 20 (TN SCDRC)

K.C. Nasa (Dr.) v. Sahib Cjhand Sharma, 2003 (6) CLD 26: 2003 (3) CPR 509: 2003 (3) CPJ

622 (Del. SCDRC)

K.E. Rajesh v. President, District Co-operative Hoapital & Anr. , 2000 (3) CPJ 354: 2000 (1)

CPR 144 (Ker. SCDRC)

K.G. Krishanan (Dr.) v. Praveen Kumar (Minor), 2003 (3) CLD 705: 2003 (2)CPR 38: 2003

(2) CPJ 125 (NCDR C)

K.K Radha (Mrs.) v. Dr. G.U Su\hekhar & Anr.., 1994 (3) CPJ 376 (Ker. SCDRC)

K.K. Radha v. P.P. Isnail, 1994 (3) CPJ 376 (Ker SCDRC)


K.M. BalaKrishanan @ Premnath v. Padma Ayurveda Vaidyasala and Research Centre &

Ors.., 2003 (3) CPJ 645 (TN SCDRC)

K.N.Lal v. Dr. R.K. Akhaury, 1997 (3) CPJ 112 (Bih. SCDRC)

K.S. Bhatia v. Jeevan Hospital, 2003 (6) CLD 382 (NCDRC)

K.V . Narayani v. Dr. P. Gopinathan, 2001 (3) CPJ 498 (Karn. SCDRC)

Kailash Chandra, 2000 (1) Crimes 359 (MP)

Kailash Kumar Sharma v. Dr. Hari Charan Mathur, 1997 (3) CPJ 41: 1997 (2) CPR 126

(NCDRC)

Kalavati (Smt.) v. State of Himachal Pradesh, AIR 1956 SC 5

Kalawati v. State of Himachal Pradesh, 1988 ACJ 780 (HP-HC)

Kamlesh Gupta & Ors. v. Dr. OM Prakash Sadana & Anr., OP No. 96 of 1994, Decided on

28.2.2000 (NCDRC)(unreported)

Kamlesh Gupta & Ors. v. Dr. Abhijit Roy Chaudhary & Ors., 2000 (3) CPR 498 (WB

SCDRC)

Kamta Prasad Singh (Dr.) V. Nagina Prasad, 2000 (3) CPJ 283 (Bih. SCDRC)

Kaniya Prasad G. Mishra & Ors. V. Dr. SAtyanarayana Vishwakarma ans Anr. , 1997 (1) CPJ

322 (Guj. SCDRC)

Kanhaiya Kumar Singh v. Park Medicare & research Centre, 1999 (3) CPJ 9(NCDRC)

Kanhaiya Singh v. Secretary/Administrative Officer Vevekanand Polyclinic & Ors., 2003 (3)

CPJ 263 (UP SCDRC)

Kashi Ram Bhim Rao Kamble v. Dr. Udaya A. Patil & Anr. , 1998 (3) CPJ 614(Mah.

SCDRC)

Kashi Ram Bhim Rao Kamble v. Dr. Udaya A. Paul, 2001(3) CPR 117 (NCSCDRC)

Kasturilal Ralia Ram Jain v. State of U.P, AIR 1965 SC 1039: (1965) 2 Cri. 144: (1965) 1

SCWR 955

Katakam Sujatha v. Hira Hospital,2003 (5) CLD 718 (AP SCDRC)


Katra Satyanarayana v. Lakshmi Nursing Home, 2003 (3) CLD 535: 2003 (2) CPR 219: 2003

(2) CPJ 262 (AP SCDRC)

Kedar Nath v. State, AIR 1965 All. 233

Kennedy v. Parrott, 90 SE 2d 75, NC 1956

Kent v. Griffits, (2000) 2 All ER 474

KLhairati Lal v. Dr. Kewal Krishan, 1998 (!) CPJ 181 (Punj. SCDRC)

Katri (II) v. State of Bihar, 1981 (1) SCC 627

Khushaldas v. State of M.P., AIR 1960 MP 50: 1960 Cri LJ 234

King v. Carney, 204 Pac 270, Okla 1922

King v. King (1987, C.A.; (unreported))

Kiran Bala Rout v. Christian Medical College & Hospital & Ors., 2003 (1) CPR 238

(NCDRC)

Kiran Sharma (Smt.) v. Dr. Kavata Saluja, 2003 (2) CLD 256 (MP SCDRC)

Kiranjeet v. Dr. Nirlep Kaur , 1999 (3) CPJ 208 (Chd. UTSCDRC)

Kirtilal Gelchand SAnghvi v. Medical Suprintendent, Chaturbhuj Hospital & Anr. , 1998 (3)

CPJ 45: 1997 (3) CPR 506 (Guj. SCDRC)

Kishan garh Marbles ()P)Ltd. V. Gujrat State Financial Corp., 1991 (1) CPJ 103 (NCDRC)

Klaus Mitterbachert v. The East India Hotels Ltd., AIR 1997 Del. 201

Kody Elcot Ltd. V. Dr. C.P. Gupta, 1996 (1) CPJ 7 (NCDRC)

Krishna HAzra (Smt.) v. Dr. S.K. Bindai, 2001 (2) CPR 491 (WB SCDRC

Krishna Kant De v. Dr. T. Roy & Ors. , 1996 (!) CPR 364 (WB SCDRC)

Krishna Kumari Gupta v. Gurbax Sheesh Singh, AIR 1985 All 85: 1985 ACJ 457 (ALL-HC)

Krishna Mini Tewari v. Dr. (Mrs.) Gouri BAndyopadhyay & Ors., 2003 (1) CPJ 286 (WB

SCDRC)

Krishna Prasad (Dr.) v. State of Karnatka, 1989 ACJ 393 (Karn.- HC)


Krishnan v. State, 2003 (7) SCC 56: 2003 SCC (Cri.) 1577 : AIR 2003 SC 2978: 2003 Cri LJ

3705 (SC)

Kumbach v. Hollands. [1973] 3 All ER 907

Kuhn v. Banker, 13 NE 2d 242, Ohio 1938

Kuljit Kaur v. B.R.S. Heart Institiute and Research Centre, 2003 (6) CLD 317 (Chd.-

UTCDRC)

Kulvinder Kaur v. Dr. Kiranpreet Kaur Makkar & Ors. , 1997 (2) CPJ 355 (Punj. SCDRC)

Kunhikrishnan Nambiar P.V. & Ors. V. Sreechitra Tirumal Institute for Medical Science and

Technology 2001 (3) CPJ 86 (Ker. SCDRC)

Kusum Bakshi Ahlawat (Dr.) (Mrs.) v. G.P. Singh, Mahnager, Administration & Ors., 1993

(3) CPJ 1135 (Har. SCDRC)

Kusum Sharma & Ors. (Smt.) v. Batra Hospital and Medical Research Centre & Ors., 2000

(3) CPJ 18 (NCDRC)

L

L.v.M., (1978) 2 NZLR 519

L.D. Bajaj (Fauji Doctor) (Cancer Hospital) (Dr.) v. Hari Chand, 20003 (1) CPR 328: 2003 (3) CPJ

49 (Punj. SCDRC)

Lakhan Singh v. Mst. Geetwa Devi, 2003 (1) CPR 504: 2003 (6) CLD 941 (Jharkhand SCDRC)

Lakshmanan Prakash (dr.) v. State, 2001 ACJ 1204 (Mad.- HC)

Lakshmi Rajan v. Malar Hospital Ltd. & Anr., 1997 (3) CPJ 242: 1998 (3) CPJ 586: 1997 (3) CPR

90 (TN SCDRC )

Lalluram Meena v. Dr. S. Mathur & Anr. , 2001 (3) CPJ 200(Raj. SCDRC)

Laxman Balkrishana Joshi (Dr.) v. Dr. Trimbak Bapu Godbole, 1968 ACJ 183 (SC):AIR 1969 SC

128: 1969 (1) SCR 206


Laxman Singh v. Gurmit Kaur, AIR 1979 P& H-HC 50 (FB)

Laxman Thamappa Kotgiri v. Union of India & Ors., 1998 (1) CPR 665 (Mah. SCDRC)

Laxmi Agarwal v. Dr. K.K. Gupta, 2003 (2) CLD 381 (MP SCDRC)

Laxmi Engg. Works v. P.S.G. Industrial Institute, (1995) 3 SCC 582

Laxmi Joy Prasad v. Dr. Cameroon & Ors., 1998 (1) CPJ 336: 1998 (2)CPR 450 (WB SCDRC)

Laxmi narain v. Esitha Nursing Home And Amish X-Ray & Anr., 2001 (3)CPJ 394 (UP SCDRC)

Laxmi Narain v. Eshita Nursing Home and Amish X-Ray & Anr., 2001 (3) CPJ 394 (UP SCDRC)

Laxmi Narain v. Eshitha Nursing Home and Amish X-Ray *\& Anr., 2001 (3) CPJ 394 (UP

SCDRC)

Leela bai v. Sebastian & Ors., 2002 (2) CPJ 363 (Ker.-HC) (DB)

Leena Bhattarcharjee v. Nightangle Diagnostic and Eye Care Research Centre

(P) Ltd., 2003 (6) CLD 706: 2004 (1) CPR 130 (WB SCDRC)

Lekhraj v. Bharaj Nursing Home & Anr., 1998 (2) CPJ 335 (Punj. SCDRC)

LIC of India v. SAnjeev Mahendra Lal Shah, 1996 (1) CPR 129 (NCDRC)

Lindsay v. Mid. Western Health Board, (1991) Irish Law Times Reports

Lovelace Medical Center v. Mendez, (1991) 805 P 2d 603

Lucknow Development Authority v.M.K.Gupta,1994(1)SCC 243:1994(1)CPR 56: IAIR 1994 SC

787: 1993 (3) CPJ 7 (SC)

M

M.ArunachalaVaidivel and Ors. V. Dr. N. Gopalkrishan, 1992 (2) CO\PJ 764(TN SCDRC)

M.Dravidamani (Dr.) v. Dr. S.P. Paramasivam, 2001 (1) CPJ 68 (TN SCDRC)

M.Jeeva v. R. Lalitha, 1994 (2) CPJ 73: 1994 (2) CPR 517 (NCDRC)

M.Parimanan v. Dr. C.P. Jaganathan & Ors., 1998 (1) CPR 273 (TN SCDRC)

M.Ramesh Reddy v. State of Andhra Pardesh, 2003 (1) CLD 81 (AP SCDRC)


M.Sriniwas v. Dr. (Smt.) Rama Thulasi, 2003 (1) CLD 214: 2003 (1) CPJ 449:2003 (2) CPR

242 (AP SCDRC)

M.Subramani & Ors. V. Christu Jothi Hospital & Anr., 1998 (3) CPR 428 (NCDRC)

M.Vijaya (Smt.) v. Chairman & Managing Director of Singareni Colliery Co. Ltd., AIR 2001

AP 502 : 2002 ACJ 32 (AP- HC) (FB)

M.C Mehta v. Union Of India, (1987) 1 SCC 395: AIR 1987 SC 965

M.C Mehta v. Union Of India, air 1987sc 1086: (1987) 1 Com LJ 89: (1987) 1 ACC 157:

(1987) 1 SCC 395: (1987) 1 Supreme 65: 1987 SCC (Lab) 37: (1987) 4 LJ Rep. 104

M.J. Joseph v. Dr. P.J.John, 2001 (!) CPJ 409: 2001 (1) CPR 5 (Ker. SCDRC)

M.K. Gourikutty & etc. (Dr.) v. M.K. Madhwan &Ors.,AIR 2001 Ker.- HC 398:2002 ACJ

1356 (Ker.) (DB)

M.P. Agarwal v. Dr. M.R. Jain, Complaint No. 125 of 1993 Decided on 9.1.1996 by Raj.

SCDRC (unreported)

M.Ramesh Reddy v. State of Andhra Pradesh, 2003 (1) CLD 81 (APSCDRC)

M.S. Bahatambre (Dr.) v. Babu K.Kople, 2000 (3) CPJ 366 (Mah. SCDRC)

Machineni Rama Rao (Dr.) v. D. Padmavathi @ Padma Sree, 2002 (1) CPJ 380 (AP SCDRC)

Madan Mohan v. Dr. Ashwani Sood, 1996 (2) CPJ 204 (Har. SCDRC)

Madhu Rana (Dr.) (Mrs.) v. Smt. Bimla Gupta, 1999 (3) CPJ 224 (Del. SCDRC)

Madhu v. Narendra Kumar, 1990 ACJ 159 (MP-HC)

Madhya Pardesh State Road Transport Corporation v. Sudhakar, AIR 1977 SC 1189

Madhyamgram Consumers Welfare Society v. Dr. Kalyan Kumar Chaatterjee & Ors., 2002

(@) CPJ 381 (WB SCDRC)

Mharaj Prasad Agarwal v. Dr. M.R. Jain Complaint No. 125 of 1993 decided on 9.1.1996 by

Rajasthan SCDRC (unreported)

Mahesan v. Malaysia Govt. Officers Co-operative Housing Society Ltd., (1978) 2 All ER 405

(411) (PC)


Mohan v. Osborne, (1939) 1 All ER 534, 548-91939) 2 KB 14: 160 LT 39: 83 Sol. Jo. 134

Makhan Singh v. Dr. Prem Singh, 2002 (3) CPR 320 (Punj. SCDRC)

Malkhan Singh v. Modern X-ray Sonography & Photo Centre, 2000 (2) CPJ 441:2000 (3)

CPR 60 (MP SCDRC)

Mallet v. Pirkey, 466 P 2d 466, Colo 1970

Manager, Martin Medical Centre & Ors. V. E. V. Thomas, 1999 (1) CPR 466 (Ker. SCDRC)

Managing Director, Rohini Hospital v. L. Sunil Reddy, 2004 (1) CPJ 299 (AP SCDRC)

Mangi Lal v. State of M.P., JT 2004 (1) SC 81

Manilal Natha Bhai & Ors. V. Dr. Tushar N. Shah, 1997 (1) CPJ 560: 1997 (2) CPR 15(Guj.

SCDRC)

Manish Agarwal v. Administrator, Kamla Nehru Memorial Hospital, 2001 (1) CPJ 42(UP

SCDRC)

Manjit Singh Sadhu (Dr.) v. Uday Kant Thakur, 2002 (3) CPR 42 (Jharkhand SCDRC)

Manju Kumar Chaudhary & Anr. v. S.K. Ghosh, 1997 (3) CPJ 246 (WB SCDRC)

Mappooyan v. Dr. Premavathy Elango, 1991 (2) CPR460 (TN SCDRC)

Master Asok Kumar v. Agadi Nursing Home & Anr., 1995 (3) CPJ 142: 1995 (1) CPR 517

(Karn. SCDRC)

Master Mritunjay v. Virender Arya, 1996 (3) CPJ 429 (Chd. UT CDRC)

Master P.M Ashwin & Ors. v. MAnipal Hospital Banglore & Ors., 1997 (1) CPJ 238: 1997

(1) CPR 393 (Karn. SCDRC)

Mathurea Matho (Mistry) v. Dr. Bindeshwar Jha “Bindu”, 2003 (1) CPJ 535: 2003 (2) CPR

274 (Bih. SCDRC)

Maya Bagchi v. Dr. SAmir Sen Gupta & Anr., 1996 (2) CPR 180 (WB SCDRC)

Mayanard v. West Midlands Regional Health Authority, (1985) 1 All ER 635 (HL)

Mayo Hospital v. Sunil Tiwari, 1997 (3) CPJ 387: 1997 (3) CCPR 574 (<|MP SCDRC)

Mayo v. Mcclung, 64 SE 2d 330, Ga 1951


McQuary v. Eastwood, (1886) 12 O.R. 402

Md. Aslam v. Ideal Nursing Home, 1997 (3) CPJ 81 (NCDRC)

Medical Superintendent, Geetha Maternity & Nursing Home v. Shaikh Mahaboob Saheb,

2003 (6) CLD 736 (AP SCDRC)

Meena Vyas v. City Nursing Home and Hospital and Another, 2002 CCJ 1537 (Punj.

SCDRC)

Meenakshi (Mrs.) v. Dr. Surekha SAchar Hospital & Maternity Home (Regd.) & Anr. , 1999

(1) CPR 616 (Punj. SCDRC)

Meghdut Gordhanbhai Thakkar v. Dr. Anupama Vidhyut Bhai Desai & Anr. , 1997 (1) CPJ

5.3: 1997 (2) CPR 9 (Guj. SCDRC)

Mehboob Alam (Dr.) v. State of U.P., AIR 2001 All 374 (DB)

Midland Silicones Ltd. V. Scruttons Ltd., (1960) 2 All ER 737: (1961) 1 QB 106: (1960) 3

WLR 372: 104 SJ 603, confirmed in (1962) 1 All ER 1

Mitchel v. Dicksen, (1954) AP PD 519

Mohammed Aynuddin v. State of A.P., AIR 2000 SC 2511: 2000 Cri LJ 3508 (SC): 2000 (7)

SCC 72: 2000 SCC (Cri) 1281

Mohan Mahindroo v. New India Assurance Company & Anr. 1997 (1) CPJ 585 (HP SCDRC)

Mohd. Azzimuddin v. Dr.Nagabhushnam, 2003 (5) CLD 653 (AP SCDRC

Mohd. Ishfaq v. Dr. Martin D.’Souza, 2003 (1) CPJ 116 (NCDRC)

Mohd. Ubain Siddiqui v. Dr. Ramesh Kumar Upadhyaya, 2000 (1) CPR 77 (UP SCDRC)

Mohr. V. Williams, 104 NW 12, Minn 1905

Moore v. Tremelling, 78 F 2d 821, CCA 9, 1935

Morgan Stanley Mutual Fund v. Kartick Dass and Ors., 1994 (2) CPJ 7 (SC)

Morrison v. Forsyth, [1995] 6 Med LR 6

Moti Bai Dalvi Hospital v. M.L. Govilkar, 1991 (1) CPR 334: 1991 (2) CPJ 684 (MAh.

SCDRC)


Muktiar Chand & Ors. (Dr.) v. State of Punjab & Ors., (1998) 7 SCC 579: 1998 (5) SCALE

501

Mumbai Grahak Panchayat v. (Dr.) (Mrs.) Rashmi B. Fadnavis & Ors. , 1996 (1) CPR 137:

1996 NCJ 226: 1998(1) CPJ 49 (NCDRC)

Municipal Corpn. Of Greater Bombay v. Laxman Iyer, 2003 (8) SCC 731

Murari lal Maurya v. Rallis India Ltd., 1993 (3) CPR 396 (MP SCDRC)

Murlidhar Eknath Masane v. Sushrusha Citizen Co-op. Hospital Ltd. & Anr. , Complaint No.

203/92, decided on 29.1031994 by Mah. SCDRC (unreported)

N

N.C SArin v. Moolchand Khairatiram Hospital & Ors., 1996 (2) CPJ 418 (Del. SCDRC)

N.Lalitha Krishna (Dr.) v. Mrs. Deepa Nair, 2000 (1) CJ 340: 2000 (2) CPR 469: 2001 CCJ 1286

(AP SCDRC)

N. Nagendra Rao & Co. v. State of A.P., JT 1994 (5) SC 572: 1996 ACJ 505:AIR 1994 SC 2663:

(1994) 6 scc 205

N. Nirmala v. (Dr.) Nageswar Reddy, 2003 (5) CLD 812 (AP SCDRC)

N. Paduranga Rao v. State of A.P., 1975 (2) AP LJ 277

N. Sandhya Rani (Dr.) v. M.K. Kalpana, 1999 (3) CPJ 6 (AP SCDRC)

N. Saravanan Bhavanantham v. Diabetes Research Centre & M.V. Hospital forDiabetes & Ors.,

1999 (1) 605 (TN SCDRC)

N.D. Srivastava v. S.K. Srivastava, 2003 (6) CLD 482 (UP SCDRC)

N.K. Kohli v. Bajaj Nursing Home, 2003 (6) CLD 308: 1999 (2) CPR 79 (MP SCDRC)

N.S. Sajpta v. New Ruby Hospital, 2000 (2) CPJ 345: 1999 (3) CPR 29 (Punj. SCDRC)

N.T. Subramanyam (Dr.) v. B. Krishna Rao & Willingdon Nursing Home,1993 (3) CPJ 1557 (TN

SCDRC)


N.T. Subramanyam (Dr.) v. B. Krishna Rao, 1996 (2) CPJ 233: 1996 (2) CPR 247(NCDRC)

Nachhatar Singh v. Malkeet Singh, 2001 (2) CPJ 237 (Punj. SCDRC)

Nadiya v. Proprietor Fathima Hospital, 2001 (3) CPJ 572 (Ker. SCDRC) 582Nagaraj Murthy v. Dr.

Rajendran, 2003 (1) CLD 508 (Karn. SCDRC)

Nagarmal Modi Sewa Sadan v. Anita Devi, 2002 (3) CPR 163 (Jharkhand SCDRC)

Nand Kishore Prasad v. Sister Grace, Kurji Holi Family Hospital, 2003 (1) CLD 722:2003 (3) CPJ

331l 2003 (3) CPR 503 (Bih. SCDRC)

Narayan Chaudhary & Anr. (Dr.) v. Dr. (Mrs.) Rita Podder & Ors., 1997 (3)CPJ 557: 1998 (3) CPJ

66 (WB SCDRC)

Narcinva V. Kamat v. Alfredo Antonio Doe Martins, 1985 ACJ 397

Narendra Singh Rastogi v. Shaskiya Gyara Panch Trust & Anr., 2002 (2) CPJ 3 (MP SCDRC)

Naresh Kumar v. Sunil Blood Bank Ltd., 1991 (1) CPJ 645 (Del. SCDRC)

Nathu Lal v. State of M.P., AIR 1966 SC 43

Nationakl Hospital & Anr. V. Muhammed Najeeb, 2003 (1) CPR 653 (Ker. SCDRC)

National Justice Compania Naviera SA v. Prudential Assurance Co. Ltd.,“The Ikarian Reefer”,

[1993] 2 Lloyd’s Rep. 68, 81 – 82, Q.B.D.

Naved Ahmed v. Dr. Rakesh Kacker, 2000 (1) CPJ 201 (UP SCDRC)

Neena Gupta v. Dr. Kanwarjit Kochhar, Cmplaint case No. 489 of 1993, decided on5.1.1996 by

Chd. –UT CDRC (unreported)

Neha Kumari & Anr. V. Apollo Hospital & Ors., 2003 (1) CPJ 145 (NCDRC)

Nettleship V. Weston , [1971] 2 QB 691

New India Assurance Co. Ltd. & Anr. v. P.P. Khanna, 1997 (2) CPJ 1 (NCDRC)

New India Assurance Co. Ltd. V. Rajendra Singh Bajaj, 2003 (3) CPR 87 (MP SCDRC)

Newman v. Anderson, 217 NW 306, Wise 1928

Newman v. Hounslow & Spelthorne Health Authority (1985, Q.B.D. unreported)

Mga Myat Thin, (1898) PJ LB 426


Nihal Kaur & Ors. v. Director, P.G.I. Chandigarh, 1996 (3) CPJ 112 (Chd. –UT CDRC)

Nilabati Behara v. State of Orissa, 1993 (2) SCC 746

Nirmala R. Pranab & Anr. V. Dr. Kalpana Desai & Ors., 1998 (3) CPJ 66: 1998 (3) CPJ527 (Mah.

SCDRC)

Nirmalendu Paul v. Dr. P.K. Bakshi, 2001 (1) CPJ 466 (WB SCDRC)

Nita Singh & Ors. V. Dr. Karnail Singh, 1998 (3) CPJ 39 (Punj. SCDRC)

Nuruddin Kutubuddin Bulati v. Dr. L.N. Vohra & Anr. , 1995 (1) CPJ 455:1995 (2) CPR 424 (Mah.

SCDRC)

O

O.Aisha Bi v. J.R. Danilal, 2003 (5) CLD 915: 2003 (3) CPJ 178: 2003 (3) CPR 100 (NCDRC)

O.A. Varadadesigan v. Chief Medical Officer (Ortho.) Govt. General Hospital, 1992 (2) CPR 71

(TN SCDRC)

Om prakash Sekri v. Pritam Singh, 1984 ACJ 435 (P&H-HC)

Ophthalmics and Drugs India v. Dr. Jagdip Mohanlal Kakadia & Ors., 2003 (3) CPJ 21 (NCDRC)

Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. V. Miss Amisha Jain, 1996 (2) CPJ 183 (Del. SCDRC)

Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. V. SAtyavarapu Satyanarayana, 2003 (5) CLD 957 (AP SCDRC)

Owens v. Sykes, (1936) 1KB 192

P

P. Madanmohan Rao (Dr.) v. Khaja Moizuddin, 2004 (7) CLD 313 (AP SCDRC)

P.Mani v. Sri Ramachandra Medical College 2000 (3) CPJ 190 (TN SCDRC)

P. Narasimha Rao (Dr.) v. Gundarapu Jaya Prakash, AIR 1990 AP 207: 1990 ACJ 3350 (AP

HC)

P. Raveendram v. Fort Hospital, 2001 CCJ 1251 (Ker. SCDRC)


P. Sudhakar v. Gowri Gopal Hospital, 2004 (1) CPJ 329 (AP SCDRC)

P.Venkata Lakshmi (Smt.) v. Dr. Y. SAvitri Devi & Ors., 2001 (3) CPJ 402 (AP SCDRC)

P.Venkata Lakshmi v. Dr. Y. Savitha Devi, 2003 (5) CLD 207: 2003 (3) CPR 52 (NCDRC)

P.B. Thailramani (Dr.) v. R.M. Joshi, RP No. 339 of 1993 Decided by the National

Commission on 3.2.1994 (Unreported)

P.C. Dwivedi (Dr.) v. Smt. Kamaklabai Pandey, 2003 (2) CLD 916: 23003 (3) CPJ 170 (MP

SCDRC)

P.G.I., Chandigarh v. Jaspal Singh & Ors., 2000 (3) CPJ 32 (NCDRC)

P.N. Bhaskaran & Anr. (Dr.) v. Mrs. Molly Robinson & Anr. , 2000(1) CPJ 81: 1999 (3) CPR

442 (Ker. SCDRC)

P.N.De Souza v. Emperor, AIR 1920 All 32 : (1920) 42 All 272

P.N. Sudhankar Gupta v. Anugraha Vittala Nursing Home, 1997 (1) CPJ 266 (KArn.

SCDRC)

P.P. Ismail v. K.K. Radha, 1998 (1) CPJ 16: 1998 (1) CPR 171 (NCDRC)

P.P. Ismail v. Kerala State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission & Ors. 1994 (2) CPJ

449

P.R. Sumangi v. Kairali Medical Centre & Anr., 1997 (3) CPR 418: 1998 (1) CPJ 208 (Ker.

SCDRC)

P.S. Govindarajan v. General Manager, Integral Coach Factory & Ors. 1993 CPJ 1211 (TN

SCDRC)

Padmabai v. M.P. State Road Transport Corporation, II (1999) ACC 281 (DB)

Pallattu George & Anr. V. Dr. Thamkamma Punnoose & Anr. , 1997 (3) CPJ 341: 1997 (3)

CPR 167 (Ker. SCDRC)

Pankajbhai Nagjibhai Patel v. State of Gujrat, AIR 2001 SC 567

Paramjeet Kaur & Ors. V. Doaba Hospital & Anr. , 1998 (2) CPJ 265: 1998 (2) CPR 93

(Punj. SCDRC)


Pardeep Seth & Ors. V. Dr. Ashok Sarwal & Anr. , 1998 (1) CPJ 612 (HAr. SCDRC)

Parmanand Katara v. Union of India, 1989 (4) SCC 286: AIR 1989 SC 2039: 1989 ACJ 1000

: 1989 (4) SCC 286

Paschim BAnga Khet Mazdoor Samity & Ors. V. State of West Bengal & Anr. 1996 (4)

Supreme 260: AIR 1996 SC 2426: 1996 (4) SCC 37: JT 1996 (6) 43 (SC)

Patel v. Adhya, (1985) CA 168

Payne v. St. Heliera Group of Hospitals 1952 CLY 2442

Perry v. Hodgson, 148 SE 659, Ga 1929

Peters v. Fulhar, BMJ dt. 27.3 1954, p. 767

Philips India Ltd. V. Kunju Punnu, 1975 ACJ 311 (Bom,- HC)

Pinnamaneni Narasimha AR (Dr.) v. Gundavarapu Jayaprakash, AIR 1990 AP-HC 207

Piyush verma (Dr.) v. Jabar Singh, 2002 (1) CPR 391 (UP SCDRC)

Plydell v. Aubyn, (1993) (unreported)

Poona Medical Foundation Ruby Hall Clinic v. Maruti Rao L. Titkare, 1995 (1) CPJ 232:

1995 (1) CPR 661 (NCDRC)

Poonam Verma v. Ashwin Patel & Ors. , JT 1996 (3) CPR 205 (SC): AIR 1996 SC 2111 :

1996 (4) SCC 332: 1996 (2) CPJ 1 (SC)

Poonam Verma v. Dr. Ashwin Patel & Anr. , 1995 (1) CPJ 11: 1995 (1) CPR 661

Prabha Chaoudhry & Anr. (Dr.) (Smt.) v. Shantilal Jain, 2004 (1) CPJ 307 (MP-SCDRC)

Pradeep Kumar H. Trivedi v. Dr. Mahesh V. Shah, 1995 (3) CPR 533 (Guj. SCDRC)

Prafulla K. SAhoo v. Dr. B.B PaTHNAIK, cd Case no. 185 of 1991 decided on 20.5.1993 by

Ori. SCDRC (unreported)

Prafulla Kumar Das v. Apollo Hospital & Ors., 20002 (2) CPJ 106 (NCDRC)

Prashanta Kumar Chakarborty v. Dr. JAhar Dabnath, 2000 (3) CPJ 91 (WB SCDRC)

Pratibha Rani v. Suraj Kumar , (1985) 2 SCC 370

Prem NAth Hospital v. Poonam Mangla & Anr. , 1998 (2) CPJ 205 (HAr. SCDRC)


Prendergast v. Sam & Dee, (1989) 1 Med LR 36: (1988) Independent, 17 March (QBD) : This

decision affirmend on appeal: (1989) Times, 14 March, CA

Public Health Trust v. Brown, (1980) 388 So 2d 1084

Public Prosecutor v. E.O. Christian, 1971 ACJ 20 (AP- HC)

PUDR v. Union of India , (1982) 3 SCC 235

Pulfinbarger v. Day, 24 Cal Rptr 533, Cal. 1962

Punjab National BANk v. K.B. Shetty, 1991 (2) CPR 633: 1991 (2) CPJ 639 (NCDRC)

Punjab State v. Surinder Kaur, 2001 ACJ 1266 (P&H-HC)

Punjab Nursing Home v. Kailash Marodia, 2003 (2) CLD 852 (MP SCDRC)

Pushpa Thakur v. Union of India, 1984 ACJ 559 (SC)

Pyare Lal Verma v. Dr. A.K Gupta & Ors. , 1993 (3) CPR 144 (HAr. SCDRC)

Q

Queen, NRI Hospital v. B. Rama Krishna Rao, 2004 (8) CLD 51 (AP SCDRC)

Quintal v. Laurel Grover Hospital, 397 P2d 161, Cal 1964

R

R.Shanmuga Chandra Vadivu v. Sir Ivan Stedford Hospital, 200(3) CPJ 299 (TN SCDRC).

R.B.Kapoor (Dr.)v. Phool Dev Prasad, 1996(3)CPJ 477 (Har.SCDRC)

R.C.Sharma(Dr.)v.Jage Ram, 2003(1) CPJ 248 (NCDRC)

R.C.Singhal (Dr.)v. Smt.Urmila mathur, Appeal No.1334/Cs of 1992, decided On 11.11.1994

( UP SCDRC) (unreported)

R.D. Hattangadi v. Pest Control (India) Ltd. (1995) 1 SCC 551: 1995 SCC (Cri.) AIR 1995

SC 755

R.K.Agarwal v. Dr. B. Mukhopadhya, 1995 (1) CPJ 260: 1994 (3) CPR 574 (Bih. SCDRC)


R.K.Jain (Dr.)v. Sunil, 1999(3) CPJ 546 (MP SCDRC)

R.L.Sethi v. Dr.Somnath Chakraborti,2001 (2) CPR 379 (WB SCDRC)

R.M.Joshi v. Dr.P.B.Tahilramani, 1993 (3) CPJ 12 (Mah. SCDRC)

R.P.Dahiya v. Dr. Pradeep Aggarwal and another ,2002 CCJ 649 (Har.SCDRC)

R.P. Sharma v. State of Rajasthan, AIR 2002 (Raj.-HC-Jpr.-Bench)104

R.V. Rao (Dr.) v. Dr. Y.R. Krishna, 2003 (1) CPJ 210 (MP SCDRC)

Rabinarayan Sahoo v. Dr. B. Jayaram Patra & Ors. 2004 (1) CPJ 3 (NCDRC)

Rahul Sinha & Ors. V. Dr. Alok Mitra & Ors., 1995 (2) CPJ 227: 1995 (1) CPR 835

(NCDRC)

Raj Kumar Agarwal v. Dr. B. Mukhopadhyaya, 1995 (1) CPJ 260: 1994(3) CPR 574(Bih.

SCDRC)

Raj Kumar v. Ajay Gupta, 2001 (1) CPJ 495 (UP SCDRC)

Rajani (Mst.) v. Nihal Singh, 2001 (1) TAC 708

Rajani Shukla v. Rajendra Kumar Agarwal, 2003 (1) CLD 347: 2003 (1) CPJ 551:2003 (2)

CPR 238 (MP SCDRC)

Rajeev Kumar v. Dr. V.K. Biswas & Ors. , 1998 (2) CPJ 494: 1998 (2) CPR 149(Bih.

SCDRC)

Rajinder Lal v. Dr. Rulda Singh, 1996 (2) CPR 364 (Chd-UT SCDRC)

Rajinder Singh v. Batra Hospital & Medical Research Centre & Anr., 2003 (3) CPJ558 (Del.

SCDRC)

Rajkuwarbai & Anr. (Smt.) v. Dr. R.R. Dhoot, 1993 (3) CPR 2 (Mah. SCDRC)

Rajmal v. State of Rajasthan, AIR 1996 Raj. –HC 80

Rajni Bansal v. D.C. Mittal & Ors. , 1997 (3) CPJ 511 (Har. SCDRC)

Rakesh Goyal (Smt.) v. Senior Divisional Manager, Life Insurance Corporation of India,

1997 (1) CCC 66 (HP SCDRC)

Rakesh Jain (Dr.) v. Rakesh Kumar Khare & Ors., 2003 (1) CPJ 27 (MP SCDRC)


Rakesh Nath Mehrotra (Dr.) v. Atul Pradhan & Ors., 2000 (1) CPR 405(UP SCDRC)

Rakesh Ranjan Gupta v. State of UP & Anr.,1999 ACJ 807 (SC)

Ram Babu v. Dr. Anjani Kishore Prasad, 1997 (3) CPJ 112:1998 (2) CPR 224:1998 (2) CPJ

684 (Bih. SCDRC)

Ram Biharilal v. Dr. J.N. Shrivastav, AIR 1985 MP –HC 150 (DB)

Ram Kali v. State of Haryana and others, 2003 ACJ 752 (P& H -HC)

Ram Kissen Das Dhanuka v. Satya Charan Law, (1949) LR 77 LA. 128

Ram Rattan Sharma v. Government of Medical College & Hospital, 2003 (2) CLD903: 2003

(3) CPR 215 (Chd. –UTCDRC)

Ram Singh A. Parmar v. Sampat Raj C Shah, 1993 (2) CPR 496 (Guj. SCDRC)

Ramesh Bhai P. Prajapati & Anr. V. Dr. P.N. Nagpal, 1997 (1) CPJ 471 (Guj. SCDRC)

Ramesh Chandra v. Randhir Singh, AIR 1997 All 330

Rameshwar Pd. Agrawal (Dr.) v. Mohd. Abas Ansari, 2000 (1) CPJ 433:1999 (2) CPR 386

(Bih. SCDRC)

Ramji Lal v. Sarvodaya Medical, 1995 (1) CPR 833:1995 (2) CPJ 234 (NCDRC)

Ranjit Kumar Das v. Medical Officer, E.S.I. Hospital & Ors., 1997 (3) CPJ 336:1998 (1) CPR

165 (WB SCDRC)

Ranjit Singh Buttar (Dr.) v. Sewa Singh, 2000 (2) CPJ 180 (Punj. SCDRC)

Rashmi B. Fadnavis & Anr. (Dr.) (Mrs.) v. Mumbai Grahak Panchayat & Ors., 1996 (1) CPR

137: 1998 (3) v. CPR 34 (NCDRC)

Ravinder Gupta & Ors. (Dr.) v. Ganga Devi, 1993 (3) CPR 255 (Har. SCDRC)

Ravindra Kulkarni (Dr.) v. Balasaheb Gangaram Gavade, 1999 (3) CPR 219(Mah.SCDRC)

Rees v. Sinclair, (1974) 1 NZLR 180

Rekha Gupta (Smt.) v. Bombay Hospital Trust & Anr., 2003 (2) CPJ 160(NCDRC)

Rekha V. Kamble v. Dr. N.M. Agrawal, 1999 (3) CPJ 75: 1999 (3) CPR 1 (Mah. SCDRC)


Renu Jain v. Escorts Heart & Research Institute, 1992 (2) CPJ 391 (NCDRC)

Revathy & Anr. v. Dr. Chandra & Anr., 2001 (1) CPR 600 (TN SCDSRC)

Rich v. Pierpont, 1862, 3 F & F 36

Riggs v. Christier, 173 NE 2d 610, Mass 1961

Rina Prakash (Smt.) v. Dechi Ganpati & Ors., 1994 (3) CPJ 358 (Karn. SCDRC)

Robinsons v. Salford Health Authority, (1992) 3 Med LR 270

Roe v. Ministry of Health, (1954) 2 All ER 131: (1954) 2 Q.B. 66 (1954) 1 W.L.R. 128:98

Sol. Jo 319

Rogers v. Whitaker, (1992) Aust. Torts Rep. 81: 1993 (109) ALR 625

Rohini Devi (Ms.) v. Dr. H.S. Chudavat, 2001 (3) CPR 172 (NCDRC)

Rohini Devi v. Dr. H.S. Chudavat & Anr., 1995 (1) CPJ 334: 1994 (3) CPR 621(Raj.SCDRC)

Rohini Pritam Kabadi (Smt.) v. R.T. Kulkarni, 1996 (3) CPJ 441:1998 (1) CPR 142(Karn.

SCDRC)

Rookes v. Barnard, (1964) AC 1129 (1221) (HL)

Rose v. Friddell, 423 SW 2d 658, Tex, 1967

Ross v. Counters, (1979) 3 All ER 580; Junior Books Ltd.v. Veitchi Co. Ltd., (1982) 3 All ER

201 (HL)

Rourke v. Bouton, The Times, 23rd

June 1982

Rudick v. Prineville Memorial Hospital, 319 F 2d 764, CCA 9, 1963

Rudal Shah v. State of Bihar, 1983 (3) SCR 508: AIR 1983 SC 1036

Rukmani v. State of Tamil Nadu, AIR 2003 Mad.-HC 352

Rylands v. Fletcher, (1868) LR 3 HL 330

S

S. Gurunathan (Dead) (Dr.) v. Vijaya Health centre, 2003 (1) CPR 222 (NCDRC)


S. Iqbal Khan v. Child Trust Hospital, Madras, 1994 (3) CPR 233 (TN SCDRC)

S. Kantamma v. Medicity Hospital, Madras, 1994 (3) CPR 233 (TN SCDRC)

S. Krishan Rao & Ors. V. Sudha Nursing Home & Ors., 2001 (3) CPJ 478 (AP SCDRC)

S. Rama Rao v. Bantwal Sulochana Madhava Shenoy Trust (Regd.) & Ors. , 1997 (1) CPJ

301 (Karn. SCDRC)

S. Ramanujam v. Dr. C.P. Sreekumar, 1999 (1) CPR 4914 (TN SCDRC)

S. Suresh Kumar v.Anand Hospital & Anr., 1996 (3) CPJ 534 (TN SCDRC)

S. Tharani v. Southern Railway Headquarters Hospital, 1999 (3) CPR 336 (TN SCDRC)

S.A. Quershi v. PadodeMemorial Hospital and Research Centre, 2002 CCJ 98 (MP SCDRC)

S.B Dutt (Dr.) v. University of Delhi, 1959 SCR 1236

S.B Jain (Dr.) v. Moon Devi & Anr., 1998 (2) CPJ 239 (Har. SCDRC)

S.B Kadkol v. Dr. N. Chandershekhara & Ors., 2000 (1) CPR 131 (Karn, SCDRC)

S.B. Nayyar (Dr.) v. Bhupinderpal singh, 2003 (3) CLD 52 (Punj. SCDRC)

S.B Tiwari v. Dr. D. Panavadhyani, 1996 (1) CPJ 301 (NCDRC)

SB. Venkatappa v. Dr. Kasthuri S. Shallikeri & Anr. , 1995 (2) CPR 80 (Karn. SCDRC)

S.K Iyengar v. Bombay Hospital and Medical Research Centre & Ors., 2001 (1) CPJ 23

(NCDRC)

S.K. Sharma v. Dr. P.B. Desai, 2000 (3) CPJ 407: 2001 (1) CPR 68 (Mah. SCDRC)

S.K Sharma v. Dr. Praful B. Desai, 2003 (2) CPJ 90 (NCDRC)

S,K, Sukur v. State of Orissa, 1991 (2) CPJ 202 (NCDRC)

S.L Dhawan (Dentist) (Dr.) v. Post Graduate Medical Institute & Research Centre and Six

Ors., 1998 (2) CPR 425: 1998 (3) CPJ 128 (Chd.-UT CDRC)

S.N Namboodiri (Dr.) v. Haneefa, 1998 (1) CPJ 389 (Ker. SCDRC)

S.P. Gupta v. Union of India, (1981) Supp. SCC 87: AIR 1982 SC 149

S.V. Panchori & Ors. V. Dr. Kaushal Pandey & Ors. 1999 (1) CPR 385 (Mah. SCDRC)

SA’d v. Robinson and Ors., [1989] 4 BMLR 13 QBD


Sachin Aggarwal @ Vicky (through guardian) v. Dr. Ashok Arora, 1993 (1) CPJ 113 (Har.

SCDRC)

Sai Medical Stores v. R.D Gupta, 1992 (2) CPJ 515 (MP SCDRC)

SAif Ali v. Sidney Mitchell & Co. (1980) 1 AC 198

SAlgaocar Medical Research Centre v. R.B. Raikar, 1996 (2) CPJ 209: 1996 (2) CPR 50

(NCDRC)

SAlinder @ Surender v. Dr. Vijay Gupta & Ors. , 1998 (3) CPJ 352 (Har. SCDRC)

Samar Nath Mukherjee v. Dr. SAroj Ghosh, 2000 (#) CPJ 216: 2000 (3) CPR 332 (WB

SCDRC)

Sambhu Singh v. Kamrun Nissa, 1992 (2) AJR 339: 1992 (2) TAC 354: 1992 (2) ACC 494:

1992 ACJ 516 (Orissa)

SAntosh Bhardwaj (Smt.) v. Post Graduate Institute of Medical Science, 2002 (1) CPR 375

(Chd.-UT-CDRC)

Santosh Kaur Sodhi v. Dr. Vijay Mujoo, 2003 (2) CLD 751: 2003 (2) CPJ 344 (Chd.-

UTCDRC)

SAntosh Sharma v. State bank of india, 1991 (2) CPJ 262: 1991 (1) CPR 103 (NCDRC)

SAnzari v. Rosefeld, 167 A 2d 625, NJ 1961

SAraswati (Mrs.) v. M/s Vimla Hospital (P) Ltd., 2000 (1) CPJ 115 (TN SCDRC)

Saraswati Parakhoi v. Grid Corporation of Orissa, 2001 ACJ 874 (Ori.) (DB)

SArwan Singh v.State of Punjab, AIR 1978 SC 1525

SAtish Bnasal v. Rajeev Gandhi Cancer Institute, 2002 (1) CLD 5 (NCDRC)

Satish Chandra Shukla v. Union of India , 1987 ACJ 628 (MP-HC)

SAtish Goswami v. Dr. Kammela Sreedhar, 2003 (2) CLD 323 (AP SCDRC)

SAtwant Kaur (Mrs.) v. Dr. Kanwaljit Kaur, 1998 (2) CPR 458: 1998 (1) CPJ 298 (Punj.

SCDRC)

SAtya Arti (Dr.) (Mrs.) v. Smt. Shashi Sharma, 2003 (1) CLD 149: 2003 (3)


CPR 17: 2003 (1) CPJ 612 (J&K-HC)(DB)

SAu Madhuri v. Dr. Rajendra & Ors., 1996 (3) CPJ 75 (NCDRC)

Saunders. V. Leeds Western H.A., (1993) CPJ 75 (NCDRC)

SAvita v. State of A.P., 1999 ACJ 454 (A.P.) (DB)

SAvita Y. Chaudhari v. Dr. Ghanshyam G. Kochure, Complaint No. 672/92 Decided on

8.2.1994 (Mah. SCDRC)(Unreported)

SAvitri Devi v. Union of India, 2003 (1) CPR 240 (Punj. SCDRC)

SAvitri Singh v. Dr. Ranbir Pd. Singh, 2003 (3) CLD 383: 2004 (1) CPJ 25 (Bih. SCDRC)

Scott v. London and St. Katherine’ Docks, (1865)2 H&C 596

Scott v. Salem Country Memorial Hospital, 280 A 2d 843, NJ 1971

Selfe v. IIford and District Hospital Management Committee, 1970 Times, 26 November

Sethu Raman Subramanian Iyer v. Triveni Nursing Home & Anr., 1998 (1) CPJ 110

(NCDRC)

Sewa Ram v. Dr. Vitual K. Gupta, 1999 (2) CPR 68 (Punj. SCDRC)

Shahjahan Siddiquie & Anr. V. Ruby General ?Hospital & Anr., 2003 (2) CPJ 182 (WB

SCDRC)

Shahul Hameed & Anr. V. Apollo Hospital Enterprises & Ors., 2002 (2)CPJ 189 2002

(3)CPR 1 (TN SCDRC)

Shailesh Shah (Dr.) v. Aphraim Jayanand Rathod, First Appeal No. 597/95, Decided on

8.5.2003 (NCDRC)

Shakuntla Sharma v. State of U.P., 2001 ACJ 620 (All-HC) (DB)

Sham Lal & Ors. (Dr.) v. Mrs. Saroj Rani & Ors., 2003 (1) CPJ 47 (NCDRC)

Shanta (Mrs.) v. State of A.P. and Ors., 1997 (3) CPJ 481 (AP-HC) (DB)

Shanti & Anr. V. Post Graduate Institute of Medical Education & Research, 1998 (1) CPJ 609

(Chd.-UT CDRC)

Shanti Devi v. Dr. C.K Mittal & Anr., 1998 (3) CPJ 7 (Har. SCDRC)


Sharad Vaidya (Dr.) v. Paulo Joel Vales (deceased by LRs) and ors., 1994 ACJ 835 (Bom.-

HC, Panaji Bench)

Shashikala & anr. V. Command Hospital (Air Force) & Ors. , 2003 (2) CPJ 84 (Karn.

SCDRC)

Shashikumar v. Dr. Suresh Harve, 2003 (2) CLD 236 (Kar. SCDRC)

Shefali Bhargava v. Indraprastha Apollo Hospital, 2003 (1) CLD 910 : 2003 (1) CPJ 216:

2003 (3) CPR 58 (NCDRC)

Sheikhupua TransportCo. Ltd. V. Northern India Transporters Insurance Co. Ltd.,AIR 1971

SC 164

Shibu v. St. Joseph Hospital & Ors., 1995 (3) CPR 177 (Ker.SCDRC)

Shikha v. Dr. Ashok Jindal, 2003 (1) CPJ (NCDRC)

Shiv Gopal v. Dr. (Smt.) Sudha Gupta & Anr., 2000 (1) CPR 243 (UP SCDRC)

Shivaji Gedeo Chavan v. Chief Director Wanless Hospital & Anr., 1995 (#) CPJ 43

(Mah. SCDRC)

Shivkumar Gautam (Dr.) v. Alima B. & Ors., 1999 (1) CPR 592 (MP SCDRC)

Shobha v. Government, NCT of Delhi, AIR 2003 Del.-HC 399

Shri Ganesh Trading Co., Saugar v. State of Madhya Pradesh, 1972 MPLJ 864 (FB)

Shubh Lata v. Christian Medical College, 1995 (1) CPJ 365 (Punj. SCDRC)

Shushrusha Citizens Co-op. Hospital & Anr. V. Murlidhar Eknath Masane, 2003 (2) CPJ 127

(NCDRC)

Shyam Kumar (Dr.) v. Rameshbhai Harmanbhai Kachhiya, 2002 (1) CPR 320 (Guj. SCDRC)

Shyam Sunder Tantia & Anr. (Dr.) v. Deepika & Ors., 2002 (1) CPJ 411 (Raj. SCDRC)

Shyam Sunder v. State of Rajasthan, AIR 1974 SC 890: (1974) 1 SCC 690: 1974 ACJ 296

Sidway v. Bathlem Royal Hospital, (1985) 1 All ER 643 (HL): (1985) 2 WLR 480 (HL) :

1985 AC 871


Sidharth Batta v. Dr. Maj. Gen.M.L.Magotra, 2003 (2) CLD 266L: AIR 2003 NOC 477

(J&K-HC)

Simmon v. Health Laundry Co., (1910) 1 KB 543

Sir Gangaram Hospital v. D.P. Bhandari and Ors., 1992 (2) CPJ 397 (NCDRC)

Siva Ram v. Stat, AIR 1965 Alll 196

Slater v. Baker, (1767) 2 Wils. 359

Smita Ashok Bangal (Mrs.) v. Noorjehan Israr Ahmed Ansari & anr. , 2000 (3) CPJ 132

(Mah. SCDRC)

Smith v. Barking, Havering and Brentwood HA, (1994) 5 Med LR 285

SMN Consumer Protection Council & Anr. V. Ganga Hospital & Anr., 1994 (3) CPJ 237 (TN

SCDRC)

Soni Kumari (Minor) v. Dr. Nagendra Narain Bhagat, 2003 (1) CPJ 196: 2003 (1) CPR 321:

2004 (7) CLD 388 (Bih. SCDRC)

Sourindra Mohan Ghosh v. D. V. Pahwa, 2001 (1) CPR 200: 2002 (2) CPJ 243 (WB SCDRC)

Special Machines v. Punjab National Bank, 1991 (1) CPJ 78: 1991 (1) CPR 52 (NCDRC)\

Spring Meadows Hospital & Anr. V. Harjot Ahluwalia (through K.S. Ahluwalia) & Anr.,

1998 (3) CPR 1 (SC): 1998 (1) CPJ 1: JT 1998 (2) SC 620

Sr. Louie & Ors. (Dr.) v. Smt. Kannolol Pathumma & Anr., 1993 (1) CPR 422 (NCDRC)

Srikrishan Nursing Home v. Smt. P. Yasoda & Ors., 1997 (3) CPJ 532 (AP SCDRC)

Stacey v. Chiddy, [1993] 4 Med LR 216 affirmed in [1993] 4 Med LR 345

State Government v. Vijay Singh, 2003 (3) CPJ 382 (Uttaranchal SCDRC)

State of Gujrat v. Dr. Maltiben Valji Bhai Shah, 1994 ACJ 375 (Guj HC)

State of Gujrat v. Laxmiben Jayantilal Sikligar, AIR 2000 Guj. 180 (DB)

State of Haryana & Ors. V. Smt. Santra, (2000) 5 SCC 182: AIR 2000 SC 1888: 2000(1) CPJ

53 (SC)

State of M.P & Ors. V. Ashram, 1997 ACJ 1224


State of M.P v. Sundari Bai and Anr., AIR 2003 MP-HC 284

State of Maharashtra v. Kanchanmala Vijaysingh Shirke & Ors., JT 1995 (6) SC 155

State of Rajasthan v. Vidyawati, AIR 1962 SC 933: (1963) SCJ 307: (1962) 2 SCA 362

State of U.P. v. Hindustan Lever Ltd., AIR 1972 All 486: 1972 all LJ 501

State of U.P. v. Krishna Gopal, JT 1988 (3) SC 544: AIR 1988 SC 2154

State of U.P. v. Tulsi Ram, AIR 1971 All. 162: 1970 All Cri R 429: 1970 all WR (HC) 160

State v. Devaki Amma, 1971 ACJ 45 (Ker.- HC)

Study Circle Society v. Choithram Hospital & Research Centre, 2000 (2) CPJ 436: 2000(3)

CPR 321 (MP SCDRC)

Subhashsis Dhar v. Smt. Sanjukta Sengupta, 1999 (3) CPJ 29 (NCDRC)

Subhasis Bakshi v. West Bengal Medical Council, (2003) 2 ACE 403 (SC)

Subhlata v. Christian Medical College, 1995 (1) CPJ 365 (Punj. SCDRC)

Subraia Kumar Ghost v. Dr. Adit Dey & Ors., 2002 (1) CPJ 431 (WB SCDRC)

Sudhanshu Bhattacharya (Dr.) v. B.S. Hedge, 1993 (3) CPR 414 (NCDRC)

Sudheendra Medical Mission Hospital & Ors. V. V.R. Kennen, 2003 (2) CPJ 146: 2003 (5)

CLD 211 (NCDRC)

Sukhchain Singh v. Chandigarh Administration Though Secretary Health & Anr., 2003 (5)

CLD 211 (NCDRC)

Sukhwarsha Rani v. General Hospital, through Secretary Health & Ors., 2000 (1) CPR 337

(Chd.-UTCDRC)

Suman Bai v. State of M.P., AIR 1982 MP 62

Suman Jain & Ors. V. Insol Tertiary Care Hospital, though Sh. Daljeet singh Gujral, its

Managing Director & Ors., 2003 (1) CPR 131 (Punj. SCDRC)

Sunakar Bhol v. Amar Drug House, 1992 (2) CPJ 938 (Ori. SCDRC)

Sunil Rungta (Dr.) v. Dr. Chandreshekhar agarwal, 2002 (3) CPR 30:2002 (3) CPJ

266(Jharkhand SCDRC)


Sunita Vasant Heganawar & Ors. V. Miraj Medical Centre 1994 (2) CPJ 544: 1994 (3) CPR

214 (Mah. SCDRC)

Supriti Modak (Smt.) v. Dr. Gokul Ch. Modak, 2001 (2) CPJ 219 (WB SCDRC)

Suraj Singh v. Dr. Manoj Kankaney, 2000 (2) CPJ 293 (UP SCDRC)

Surinder Kumar (Laddi) & Anr. V. Dr. SAntosh Menon & Ors., 2000 (1) CPR 23 (Punj.

SCDRC)

Surjit Kaur v. Dr. Deepak Kaura, 2003 (2) CLD 764:2003 (1) cpj 622 (Chd. UTCDRC)

Sutton v. Population Service Family Planning Programme Ltd. , The Times, 7.11.1981

Suvarna Baljekar v. Rohit Bhatt \, 1996 (2) CPJ 75: 1996 (2) CPR 13 (NCDRC)

Suyash Hospital (P) Ltd. V. Prassanna Kumar Ojha, 2003 (2) CLD 451: 2003 (2) CPJ 150

(NCDRC)

Swanson v. Wilson, (1953) 3 D.L.R. 171

Syad Akbar v. State of Karnataka, AIR 1979 SC 1848 : 1979 Cri. LJ 1374 (SC): 1980 SCC

(Cri) 59: 1980 (1) SCC 30

Syed Zahid Ali v. Dr. Jaya Prakash Pliwal, 2000 (1) CPJ 129 (MP SCDRC )

Szekeres v. Robinson, (1986) 715 P 2d 1076

T

T. Hareendran Nair v. Dr. P. Ashokan, 1995 (1) CPJ 220 (Ker. SCDRC)

T. Padmabhan v. Hindustan Maternity Home, Decided by the Kerala State Commission

Hindustan Times, Delhi, 9.11.98

T. Rama Rao v. Vijaya Hospital & Anr., 1997 (3) CPJ 59 : 1997 (3) CPR 477 (TN SCDRC)

T.T. Thomas (Dr.) v. Smt. Elisa, AIR 1987 Ker – HC 52: 1986 Ker. LT 1026:1987 ACJ 192

(Ker-HC) (DB)


T. Vani Devi (Dr.) (Smt.) v.Tugutla Lakshmi Narasaiah Alias Narasa Reddy, 2003 (1) CLD

860 : 2003 (1) CPJ 180:2003 (1) CPR 325 (NCDRC)

T.M.T. Panjali v. S Jamuna Lokanathan, 1999 (2) CPR 408 (TN SCDRC)

T.V. Krishna (Dr.) v. S.K. Afsar, 2003 (6) CLD 958 (AP SCDRC)

Tankship (U.K.) Ltd. v. Morts Dock & Engineering Co., (1961) 1 All ER 404 (PC)

Tapan Kumar Nayak & Ors. v. State of Orrisa & Ors., 1997 (2) CPJ 14:1997 (2) CPR 104

(NCDRC)

Tapas Das Gupta v. Dr. Kalyan Mukerjee, 2002 (2) CPJ 73 (WB SCDRC)

Tarachand Jain v. Ganga Ram Hospital, 1999 (3) CPJ 53 (NCDRC)

Tarasoff v. Regents of the University of California, 551 P(2d) 334 (1976)

Tarun Kumar Pramanik v. Dr. Kunal Chakraborty & Ors., 1995 (2) CPR

Tarun Thakore v. Dr. Noshir M. Shroff, 2003 (1) CLD 62 (NCDRC)

Thake v. Maurice, (1986) QB 644: (1986) 1 All ER 479

Thomarina Marcel D’Cruz v. Management of St. Joseph’s Boys Higher Secondary School &

Ors., 1998 (1) CPJ 340 (TN SCDRC)

Thumu Padma v. Dr. Hemlatha, 2003 (6) CLD 108 (AP SCDRC)

TMT. Chandra v. Mahesh & Ors., 2000 (1) CPJ 361: 2000 (2) CPR 129:2001 CCJ 1362 (TN

SCDRC) Treasury Officer & Member Secretary, Pensioner Medical Fund & Ors. v.

G.K. Joshi, 1996 (1) CPJ 22 (Raj SCDRC)

Trilochan Pradhan (Dr.) v. R.P. Acharya, 1999 (1) CPR 247 (Ori.-SCDRC)

U

U.K. Kinni & Anr. (Dr.) v. K. Vasudeva Pai & Ors. 2001 ACJ 2141 (Karn. -HC) (DB)

Udale v. Bloomsbury Area Health Authority, (1983) 2 All ER 522

Uday Kant Jha v. Moolchand Khairaiti Ram Hospital, 2003 (4) CLD 922 (Del. SCDRC)


Uday Shankar Bhagat v. Santosh Kumar Sah, 2004 (1) CPR 64 (Bih. SCDRC)

Ujjain Charitable Trust Hospital v. Ramesh Chandra & Ors., 2003 (3) CPJ 181 (MP

SCDRC)

Uma Pinglay v. Dr. N.P. Mookherjee & Ors. , 1997 (2) CPR 160 (Karn. SCDRC)

Uma v. Dr. Nishu Kharbanda & Anr. , 1997 (2) CPJ 580 (Har. SCDRC)

United State Shipping Co. v. Ship St. Abbans, AIR 1931 PC 189

Urmila Upadhyay Gynaecologist Surgeon (Dr.) v. Anjani Kumar Panday, 2002 (3) CPR 240

(MP SCDRC)

Usha Mehrotra (Mrs.) v. Apollo Hospitals Enterprises Ltd., 1999 (2) CPR 453(SCDRC)

Usha Rajput v. Sir Ganga Ram Hospital, 2003 (1) CLD 352 (Del. SCDRC)

Usha v. G.B. Namboodiri, 1986 ACJ 141 (Ker -HC)

Uttaranchal Forest Hospital Trust v. Smt. Raisan, 2004 (1) CPJ 257 (Uttaranchal -SCDRC)

V

V. Chandra Sekar v. Malar Hospital Ltd., 2001 (1) CPJ 137: 2001 (1) CPR 628 (TN SCDRC)

V. Chandrasekhar v Apollo Hospitals Enterprises Ltd., 1994 I.L.W. 68 (Mad-HC) (DB)

V. Chitralekha v. Director & Superintendent, I.O.G. & Ors., 1998 (1) CPJ 124(TN SCDRC)

V.Vassanda Coumarry v. DR. T. Ramachandrudu, 1998 (3) CPR 277 (Pondi SCDRC)

V.P. Chopra v. Dr. S.P. Kumar, 2003 (2) CLD 567 (Del. SCDRC)

V.P. Shantha & Ors. V. Cosmopolitan Hospitals Pvt. Ltd. & Ors. , 1997 (1) CPR 377(Ker.

SCDRC)

Vadlamudi Nageswara Rao v Dr. Koneru Gangadhara Rao M.D.D.G.O., 2004 (8) C; D (1)

(AP-SCDRC)


Vaghri Gopal Bhai v. Parmar Navalben Balabhai & Anr. , 1993(1) CPR 526 1993 (2) CPJ

1038 (Guj. SCDRC)

Valdez v. Percy, 217 P 2d 422, Cal 1950

Vaqar Mohd. Khan& Anr. v. Dr. S.K. Tondon, 2002 (2) CPJ 169 (MP SCDRC)

Varanasi Subrahmanyam v. Dr. G. Ravi Kumar, 2003 (3) CLD 593 : 2004 (1) CPJ 125 (AP

SCDRC)

Ved Khuller (Dr.) v. State, 1988 ACJ 328 (J&K-HC)

Venkappa v. Devamma, (1956) Mad. 1381

Venkatesh Iyer v. Bombay Hospital Trust, 1998 (2) TAC 820 (Bom.)

Venkatesh v. Tamil Nadu, AIR 1993 SC 1230

Vijay H. Mankar v. Dr.(Mrs.) Mangla Bansod & Ors., 2000 (1) CPJ 37 (NCDRC)

Vijaya Raghavan v. Dr. Dheg, 2000 (3) CPJ 251 (TN SCDRC)

Vijayamma (Mrs.) v. Apollo Diagnostic Centre & Ors., 2002 (1) CPJ 230 (AP SCDRC)

Vimlesh Dixit v. Dr. R.K. Singhal, 2004 (1) CPJ 123 (Uttaranchal SCDRC)

Vinitha Ashok (Smt.) v. Lakshmi Hospital, AIR 2001 SC 3914: 2001 (8) JT 142: 2001 (6)

Scale 476: (2001) 8 SCC 731 : 2001 (4) Supreme 225 : 2001 (6) SLT 735: 2001 (3) KLT 606:

2002 (1) CPJ 4 (SC) Vinitha Ashok v. Lakshmi Hospital & Ors., 1992 (2) CPJ 372

(NCDRC)

Vinod Kumari Srivastav v. Hindustan Aeronautics Ltd., 2003 (1) CPJ 246 (UP SCDRC)

Vinubahi Parshottamdas Patel v. Vijay K. Ajmera, 1997 (1) CPR 348 (Guj. SCDRC)

Vivek Sahay (Dr.) v. Ajay Prasad @ Ajay Prasad Gupta, 2003 (3) CLD 101: 2002 (3) CPR

303 (Jharkhand SCDRC)

Voluntary Organization in Interest of Consumer Education (VOICE) v. Registrar Tamil Nadu

State Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, 2003 (1) CLD 1045: 2003 (2) CPJ 33

(NCDRC)


W

Wahid Khan v. Dr. Mohd. Abdul, 1999 (3) CPJ 304 (UP SCDRC)

Walker v. Semple, (1993) CA 573

Warren v. Greig and White, The Lancet, 1935, Vol. LP 330

Weld Blundell v. Stephens, 1920 AC 956-86 (HL)

West v. Shephard, 1964 AC 326: (1963) 2 All ER 625 : (1963) 2 WLR 1359 (HL)

White v. Board of Governors of Westminster Hospital, The Time 26th

October 1961

White House v. Jordan, (1980) All ER 650: (1979) 3 WLR 150

White House v. Jordan, (1981) 1 All ER 267 HL:

Whiteford v. Hunter, (1950) 94 Sol. Jo 758: (1950) WN 553

Whiteford V. Wittaker Memorial Hospital, 169 SE 2d 563, Va 1969

Wilsher v. Essex Area Health Authority, (19860 3 All ER 801 (CA)

Wise v. Kaye, (1962) 1 QB 638

Wood v. Thurston, 1953 -1-C.L.C. 687

Woronka v. Sewall, 69 NE 2d 581, Mass 1946

Wright v. Wellock, 1971 RTR 228

X

Xv. Hospital Z & Anr., 1998 (6) SCALE 230: 1998 (7) JT 626: 1998 (8) SCC 296

X v. Hospital Z, 2003 (1) CLD 1:2003 (1) SCC 500:2003 (1) CPJ 14:2003 (1) CPR 298 (SC)

X v. Hospital Z, AIR 2003 SC 644

Y

Y.K. Ramamurthy v. Dr. L.P. Nagarajaiah. 1997 (1) CPJ 525: 1997 (2) CPR59 (Karn. SCDRC)


Yoginder Beri v. Grover Eye and E.N.T. Hospital & Ors., 2001 (3) CPJ 106(Chd. UTCDRC)

Younghusband v. Luftung, (1949) 2 KB 354

Z

Zirker v. Robertson, (1897) 30 NSR 61

Documents

Important cases of medical negligence in Indiarfhha.org/.../LAW/important_cases_of_medical_negligence.pdf©RFHHA , AIIMS Page 5 Balbir Singh Makol v. Chairman, M/S. Sir Ganga ram Hospital