20
Image Rights of Athletes - Scope and Protection dr. Vesna Bergant Rakočević Senior Judge, Higher Court of Ljubljana

Image Rights of Athletes - Scope and Protection › Documents › About EJTN › Administrative Law 2016 › A… · Image Rights of Athletes - Scope and Protection dr. Vesna Bergant

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    4

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Image Rights of Athletes - Scope and Protection › Documents › About EJTN › Administrative Law 2016 › A… · Image Rights of Athletes - Scope and Protection dr. Vesna Bergant

Image Rights of Athletes

- Scope and Protection dr. Vesna Bergant Rakočević

Senior Judge, Higher Court of Ljubljana

Page 2: Image Rights of Athletes - Scope and Protection › Documents › About EJTN › Administrative Law 2016 › A… · Image Rights of Athletes - Scope and Protection dr. Vesna Bergant

Tina Maze

Slavoj Žižek

Page 3: Image Rights of Athletes - Scope and Protection › Documents › About EJTN › Administrative Law 2016 › A… · Image Rights of Athletes - Scope and Protection dr. Vesna Bergant

Zinedine Zidane - Zizou

David Beckham - Becks

Novak Djokovic - Nole

Rafael Nadal - Rafa

Page 4: Image Rights of Athletes - Scope and Protection › Documents › About EJTN › Administrative Law 2016 › A… · Image Rights of Athletes - Scope and Protection dr. Vesna Bergant

Of course NOT.

The concept of translative

transfer of this right

Is it possible that

an athlete totally

transfers his/her

personality right?

Page 5: Image Rights of Athletes - Scope and Protection › Documents › About EJTN › Administrative Law 2016 › A… · Image Rights of Athletes - Scope and Protection dr. Vesna Bergant

• May the sponsor demand from the athlete to

change a haircut or delete a tattoo?

• May such demand be made by his team, NF or IF?

• May the sponsor claim changing athlete’s name?

Page 6: Image Rights of Athletes - Scope and Protection › Documents › About EJTN › Administrative Law 2016 › A… · Image Rights of Athletes - Scope and Protection dr. Vesna Bergant

Milan Gurović

Nick Symmonds

James Rodriguez

Page 7: Image Rights of Athletes - Scope and Protection › Documents › About EJTN › Administrative Law 2016 › A… · Image Rights of Athletes - Scope and Protection dr. Vesna Bergant

Nick Symmonds

The biggest thing that rubs me the wrong way is

that governing bodies want to control the space

I feel I should control. There ought to be open

discussion.

Page 8: Image Rights of Athletes - Scope and Protection › Documents › About EJTN › Administrative Law 2016 › A… · Image Rights of Athletes - Scope and Protection dr. Vesna Bergant

Primož Peterka

Page 9: Image Rights of Athletes - Scope and Protection › Documents › About EJTN › Administrative Law 2016 › A… · Image Rights of Athletes - Scope and Protection dr. Vesna Bergant

Maria

Sharapova? Maria Sugarpova

US Open 2013

Page 10: Image Rights of Athletes - Scope and Protection › Documents › About EJTN › Administrative Law 2016 › A… · Image Rights of Athletes - Scope and Protection dr. Vesna Bergant

Garry Andrew

“Buddha” Hocking

(Geelong Cats)

"When Whiskas approached

me with this proposal I

actually had a giggle.”

"It's not going to change me,

changing my name."

Whiskas

Page 11: Image Rights of Athletes - Scope and Protection › Documents › About EJTN › Administrative Law 2016 › A… · Image Rights of Athletes - Scope and Protection dr. Vesna Bergant

• An athlete signed a contract with company A for

commercial use of his image rights; may the

company A transfer these rights to company B?

• Who is entitled to seek protection if the company C

exploits the image of an athlete?

Page 12: Image Rights of Athletes - Scope and Protection › Documents › About EJTN › Administrative Law 2016 › A… · Image Rights of Athletes - Scope and Protection dr. Vesna Bergant

Oliver Kahn v. Electronic Arts, OLG Hamburg 25. 4. 2003

Page 13: Image Rights of Athletes - Scope and Protection › Documents › About EJTN › Administrative Law 2016 › A… · Image Rights of Athletes - Scope and Protection dr. Vesna Bergant

When is the commercial use of athlete’s image

violation of his/her rights?

• identification

• lack of permission (scope, means, territory, time

limits)

• the use is not free

Page 14: Image Rights of Athletes - Scope and Protection › Documents › About EJTN › Administrative Law 2016 › A… · Image Rights of Athletes - Scope and Protection dr. Vesna Bergant

Free use

• public interest

• freedom of expression

• marginal, coincidental use

Page 15: Image Rights of Athletes - Scope and Protection › Documents › About EJTN › Administrative Law 2016 › A… · Image Rights of Athletes - Scope and Protection dr. Vesna Bergant
Page 16: Image Rights of Athletes - Scope and Protection › Documents › About EJTN › Administrative Law 2016 › A… · Image Rights of Athletes - Scope and Protection dr. Vesna Bergant
Page 17: Image Rights of Athletes - Scope and Protection › Documents › About EJTN › Administrative Law 2016 › A… · Image Rights of Athletes - Scope and Protection dr. Vesna Bergant

Infringed interest?

• non-material, strictly personal (identity, honor,

goodwill, privacy); Tolley v J S Fry and Sons [1931]

• economic, commercial

Page 18: Image Rights of Athletes - Scope and Protection › Documents › About EJTN › Administrative Law 2016 › A… · Image Rights of Athletes - Scope and Protection dr. Vesna Bergant

Sanctions

• fictive license fee

• corrective advertising award

• damages (blurring, tarnishment)

• unfair competition protection

Page 19: Image Rights of Athletes - Scope and Protection › Documents › About EJTN › Administrative Law 2016 › A… · Image Rights of Athletes - Scope and Protection dr. Vesna Bergant

• www.waynerooney.com

• www.waynerooney.co.uk

• www.wayne-rooney.com

• www.waynerooneyonline.com

• www.davidbeckham.ws

UDRP; transfer or cancellation if

• identical or confusingly similar to a trademark of another

• registered by a party who has no rights or legitimate interest in that domain name and

• registered and used in bad faithWayne Rooney

Page 20: Image Rights of Athletes - Scope and Protection › Documents › About EJTN › Administrative Law 2016 › A… · Image Rights of Athletes - Scope and Protection dr. Vesna Bergant

Thank you for your

attention!