29
PROPOSED EXXON HELP ASSESS TtlE I RESEARCH PROGRAlvl TO GREENHOUSE EFFECT. i +l '' I t I r'i : I t I I I I I i I I I t) EDl,lARD A, 6ARVEY HENRY SHAtll I,IALLACE S, BROECKER TARO TAKAHASHI PRESENTED TO: DR. LESTER I{ACHTA RESOURCES LABORATORY IC AND AT}1 OSPHERIC ADIVI I l I STRAT tJ NATIONAL AIR OCEAN NI ION IvlARCH 26, 1g7g

I i EDl,lARD A, I S, · drill in ocean depths l-lell over looo feet, solnletiivles as i'iuch as 5ooo feet relvlain in one location for thlo to three 14onths at these depths, the ocean

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    5

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: I i EDl,lARD A, I S, · drill in ocean depths l-lell over looo feet, solnletiivles as i'iuch as 5ooo feet relvlain in one location for thlo to three 14onths at these depths, the ocean

PROPOSED EXXONHELP ASSESS TtlE

I

RESEARCH PROGRAlvl TOGREENHOUSE EFFECT.

i+l'' I

tIr'i:

It

III

II

iIII

t)

EDl,lARD A, 6ARVEYHENRY SHAtll

I,IALLACE S, BROECKERTARO TAKAHASHI

PRESENTED TO:

DR. LESTER I{ACHTARESOURCES LABORATORY

IC AND AT}1 OSPHERIC ADIVI I

lI

STRATtJNATIONAL

AIROCEAN NI ION

IvlARCH 26, 1g7g

Page 2: I i EDl,lARD A, I S, · drill in ocean depths l-lell over looo feet, solnletiivles as i'iuch as 5ooo feet relvlain in one location for thlo to three 14onths at these depths, the ocean

,d

PRO6RAI'I 6OAL

DETERIVIINE THE LIKELIIlOOD

USE EXXON EXPERTISE AND FACILITIES TO llELP

OF A GLOBAL GREEN-llOUSE EFFECT

v

Page 3: I i EDl,lARD A, I S, · drill in ocean depths l-lell over looo feet, solnletiivles as i'iuch as 5ooo feet relvlain in one location for thlo to three 14onths at these depths, the ocean

\./

RATIOl'lALE FOR EXXON INVOLVE14ENT

I DEVELOP EXPERTISE TO ASSESS TtlE POSSIBLEIIVI PACT OF TllE GREENHOUSE EFFECT ON EXXONBUSINESS

O FORPI RESPONSIBLE TEAI'1 THAT CAN CREDIBLYCARRY BAD NEl^lS, IF ANY, TO THE CORPORATION

I PROVIDE THE GOVERNl'lENT l^lITH HIGrl OUALITYINFORIViATION TO REDUCE TllE BUSINESS RISK OFINADECIUATE GOVERNtvlENT POLICY

O GENERATE IrlPORTANT SCIENTIFIC INFORtvlATION THATl,{ILL ENHANCE THE EXXON IlvlACE AND PROVIDE PUBLICRELATIONS VALUE

\l

Page 4: I i EDl,lARD A, I S, · drill in ocean depths l-lell over looo feet, solnletiivles as i'iuch as 5ooo feet relvlain in one location for thlo to three 14onths at these depths, the ocean

ct')trJd.lrla-ll-JOa

=>Ee,(9oe,o-J-(Jtrl(t)lJJe.

<r)G

FlJl

->F

lrlJ

tl-to-

&.==)tlJ.l ct)F<7

lrlO

=(J

GI

l.r.I OF(Je,

(JIJHl-lJ-J<(J

lrl(J

(J

(o

-tFz,LrJct)(t)Lrl

tr^lE,:=etC.)

ot--EEoF<l'l.IF=<eUI

(J O

-lrj

<Lr-LI-

(DuJo

aF<c,/', lrlO

(JCJO

o

Fu-ta-Ll-J

n=o(JOF-oo-(Jr.-. F

f- &.

tv, O

o- lJ-trj

JE=l- lrl

cJ) e:=<F(J-,<

F-

ryr".{ lrlF&,tra :=O

(J

-

c/)r=-

c9 =7

c)<e,O

- l.r.l c/)&,F

al.LtLrJ -

l-LlAO

.-H-

c/, (J=f, o

r-...u-=LLF

LI.-<(3Ox-(-)>< F{I.J.J

G,

c\ u-l=oLt-O

CJU)(v,

z,Lr- rJ- <

o tv,

F lrl

eECJ)::) <r-t- o

Eo

ct)(\

-tlloO

Z,CJF=>-c€u.luHF(JElr|OFAr-

.i,O

OH

(.)F<(a

\\

Page 5: I i EDl,lARD A, I S, · drill in ocean depths l-lell over looo feet, solnletiivles as i'iuch as 5ooo feet relvlain in one location for thlo to three 14onths at these depths, the ocean

NI'1ON) ION SI 9NIUV31]1S3u0J l^l 0uJ N0lIl.lBIuIN0J Zol ltuiHds0t^t tv

u0J 0ttNn0Jtv 3B 10NNV3 SltnJllss0J ld0uJ zol lHl J0 "Igr-0r ,rtSivldtx0uddv

NOI TU7IlIlN ]3NJlISSOJ OI OsJNBIUI]V N33B SVH ]SV]U]NI SIHl

NOIINIO/1]U lVIUlSNONI ]H1 3]NIS UV],{U3d 'Ah 1V gNISV]U3NI N]]B SVH 3USHdSOhI 1V ]HJ01 zol J0 N0tlt00v ltN390d0uHrNv tvnNNV lHr

N0tlnt0/\lu IVIUlSn0NIlHi tlNIs 'tsr 0lsvtuJNI svH zol rtulHds0t^J1v

slNlN0dl,t03 ttulHds0htlv u3Hl0 0Nv zot J0S1]431 gNISV3U]NI ]HI ,\S HlUV] 3H1 hJ OUJ NOIlVIOVU

OSUVUJNI JO NOIIdUOSgVIU 3H1 /\B OsSNV] ]]NVIVS1Vl/IU]lJ1 S,H1UV1 ]H1 NI 1]SdN NV

F

r

NOITINIJ3[

Page 6: I i EDl,lARD A, I S, · drill in ocean depths l-lell over looo feet, solnletiivles as i'iuch as 5ooo feet relvlain in one location for thlo to three 14onths at these depths, the ocean

The Carbon Cycl e

1 978

Fluxes in Gt/aPool sizes in Gt

/Photosynthes i s

56

t

FuelCombus t i on

5

Terrestrial Biosphere

,III{ri'liI,l

4:i;

Decompos i ti on25

Res pi ratlon31

Gas Exchange90 90

12,000(7,300 recoverabl e)

L{vi ng0rganl c

800

Dead0rganic(Humus )

I 000-3000

Surface l^later0issolved Carbon

580Thermocl lne

0issolved Carbon6 ,600 Aquat i c

Deep lrlaterDissolved Carbon

3l ,900Reacti veSediments

400

Fossil Fuels and Shale 0ceans

Page 7: I i EDl,lARD A, I S, · drill in ocean depths l-lell over looo feet, solnletiivles as i'iuch as 5ooo feet relvlain in one location for thlo to three 14onths at these depths, the ocean

O{x

xo-J><<HLt.l (J co<t)

FLr.flJJ

(J&,trJ</)trle,lr

I

e.=lrjJtrao&,o-

Ou)

=7 lrl

cJ) ct')

lrJ trl

ct)UJ

Lr-o

c/)Ll.t

r.l.JC\ U.I

C\ =E(3(-)O

O_

(J O

(J

ct)

tJJ(_)

u.- o&,

r<lJt

trqF

U.t

- z,

ry,Clt

r-{ LLJ lrl

ct) uJ :E

o(J=o-E

H l-'

c/)(Je,llto-Ft.LJo-Ltj<q9

CJ) CDz.oz,a

(J<XlXtr.tUJ Z,

Lrl

cJ)Etl.ll.l'J

(J&,LLIcJ)l.rj&,

c\L9

C)-

(_)

-t Lt_

lrl O

Ao=,EOE

C/)lr!

rv,

FCL

LLI

=o

c\O(J

d.lJ-

lrlO

F

uJ=q9<7

lrt

(J IJ.

xolrl4.

e,ol-t.J r-.

&.-Lr-J (JFE,-

l-a(J

tl.l(9>.-t-.(->xlrla-,tJ-lc9 z,&,

Etoe,F<Ct)

(J

IJF{ lll

d, e.

F trj

c/) -

lrl O

-E,

ct)E,OU-l

F<FtrA

d,O-:=

lrle,lrl-J-o-C4Oa-

j7Ld(Jc)

bJe, trt

lz.

lrjF(J.2, xi--.

Lt.l

'l\

Page 8: I i EDl,lARD A, I S, · drill in ocean depths l-lell over looo feet, solnletiivles as i'iuch as 5ooo feet relvlain in one location for thlo to three 14onths at these depths, the ocean

PROPOSED PROGRAlvlS

OCEAf'l SAtvlPL I NG PROGRAIVI

TANKER SAt'lPLINC SYSTEtvl

DRILLINC SHIP STATION

LAND BIOTA SAfvlPLING PROGRAlvl

.P.ROGRAlvlS FUt'lDING

D O E / EX X O N

EXXON

EXXON

st

C-T3 AND C-1'I SAlvlPLING

J

l.III

;IdiI

II.lII

Page 9: I i EDl,lARD A, I S, · drill in ocean depths l-lell over looo feet, solnletiivles as i'iuch as 5ooo feet relvlain in one location for thlo to three 14onths at these depths, the ocean

OBJECTIVES OF OCEAN SAIlPLING

0 DETER14 INE

FLUX =

COZ FLUX BET}lEEN AND OCEANAIR

ENT)(TRANSFER COEFFICI X (DRIVINC FORCE)

,-l DRIVIN€ FORCE DETERlvlINED FROII TANKERS AS A

FUNCTI0N 0F c0r ,LOCATIOI{, ETC.-ATM

COc 'tsw

STUDY AS A FUNCT

TEIqPERATURE,

TRANSFER COEFFICIENT DETERIVIIl'lEDSHIPS BY TRACERSEA-STATE, ETC I

FROf'l DRION OF

ILLINGl^lEATlJER,

t cR0sscllEcK RATE 0F C0z EXCHANGE ACR0SS TllE AIR-SEA INTERFACE USIN6 C-14 RELEASED DURING ATOIi ICBO14B TESTS AS TRACER

,.1

II

iil

I

tI

I

Page 10: I i EDl,lARD A, I S, · drill in ocean depths l-lell over looo feet, solnletiivles as i'iuch as 5ooo feet relvlain in one location for thlo to three 14onths at these depths, the ocean

TANKER PROGRAivl

c TANKERS !\lILL SAl/lPLE CONTINUOUSLYATlvl 0SPtl ERIC C0Z T0 t 0,5 pprlv0 CEAN C0Z T0 t 0,5 ppMVSEA AND AIR TEI\lPERATURE TORELATIVE HUIVI IDITYBAROllETRIC PRESSURESALINITYSEAl^lATER pH

U,

t 0,1"c

0

c

TANKER l,lILL ALSO SAII PLE SURFACEC-1II ON A PERIODIC BASIS

SEAl^lATER FOR

",r'

DEPTH THERIVIOf'4ETERS t.lILL BE USED PERIODICALLYTO DETERf'IINE THE TElvlPERATURE PROFILE OF THEOCEAN ALONG THE TANKER ROUTE

I

I

I

i

Page 11: I i EDl,lARD A, I S, · drill in ocean depths l-lell over looo feet, solnletiivles as i'iuch as 5ooo feet relvlain in one location for thlo to three 14onths at these depths, the ocean

TANKER PROGRA14 (CONTINUED)

3 TANKER l^lILL BE ABLEA PARTICULAR ROUTEPER YEAR DEPENDINCDEIl AND

TO REPEAT lvlEASUREIVIENTS ALONGANYl^lHERE FROf\l 1O TO qO TI14ESON ROUTE LENGTrl AND PETROLEUlv!,/

c

c

TANKER PROGRA[I l^l

DURING THE FIRSTLL BE EXPANDED FROlvlYEAR TO FIVE BY THE

ONE ROUTETHIRD YEAR

SOI'1E TANKER ROUTESCROSS AREAS hIII EREl^lORK HAS BEEN DONE

PROPOSED IRELATIVELY

N TllIS PROGRAIILITTLE OCEANOGRAPHIC

t.f.ir

,ttr'IIiL

)tttII

0 TllE DATA COLLECTED !^I ILL BE USED TO DETERlnlILEVELS ON A REGIONAL AND SEASONAL BASIS INTHE ATlvlOSP11ERE AND THE OCEANS

NE PC02BOTH

Page 12: I i EDl,lARD A, I S, · drill in ocean depths l-lell over looo feet, solnletiivles as i'iuch as 5ooo feet relvlain in one location for thlo to three 14onths at these depths, the ocean

DEEP WATER I,IELLINGS ANO TANKER ROUTES

$\ 'oonn otut, Cfloo*"

A oooo

Tanker SamplingTracks

$bo /"ta: Wa

0O o.s .=

oo

-t'- a.

- .qr Equa tor

fr'-'=.. '.s, / I

I!!ItI

i

I

I

I

i',

Page 13: I i EDl,lARD A, I S, · drill in ocean depths l-lell over looo feet, solnletiivles as i'iuch as 5ooo feet relvlain in one location for thlo to three 14onths at these depths, the ocean

pcoz 'I 0 - atm. IN THE SURFACE WATER OF

JULY 1972 - MARCH '1973THE ATLAI''ITIC 0CEAN

1) 5: !) l, It

@t12

.?a

#,li*9l lJ

(

AlI Exxon Atlantic tanker routes.

(

Page 14: I i EDl,lARD A, I S, · drill in ocean depths l-lell over looo feet, solnletiivles as i'iuch as 5ooo feet relvlain in one location for thlo to three 14onths at these depths, the ocean

pCOe l0-b atm. I}I THE SURFACE WATERS OF THE PACiFiC OCEAN

AUGUST 1973 . JUNE ]974

<3 Xtr

Exxon routes(

Pacific tanker rou tes .0ther tanker routes*-(:

Page 15: I i EDl,lARD A, I S, · drill in ocean depths l-lell over looo feet, solnletiivles as i'iuch as 5ooo feet relvlain in one location for thlo to three 14onths at these depths, the ocean

I'lII.. III

i!

iI

II

II

iI

ll

it:i

iiIIII

lrIil.tIII!tIlt'IIi;titIIII

DRILLING SHIP PROGRAI'I

0 EXXON CONTRACTED DRILLING SHIPS ARE PRESENTLYEXPLORING lvlANY DEEP l4lATER AREAS AROUND THEI^IORLD

DRILL IN OCEAN DEPTHS l-lELL OVERlOOO FEET, SOlnlETIIVlES AS I'IUCH AS5OOO FEETRElvlAIN IN ONE LOCATION FOR ThlOTO THREE 14ONTHS

AT THESE DEPTHS, THE OCEAN IS USUALLY WELLSTRATIFIED, AND IS SUITABLE FOR TRACER GASSTUDY

g,

0

J

Page 16: I i EDl,lARD A, I S, · drill in ocean depths l-lell over looo feet, solnletiivles as i'iuch as 5ooo feet relvlain in one location for thlo to three 14onths at these depths, the ocean

*J

DRILLINC SllIP PROGRAfVI (COl'lTII.|UED)

O t{EASURElvlENT OF SURFACE l^lATER RADON-222 PROFILESAND l,lEATHER DATA CAN BE USED TO DETERII INE THERATE OF GAS EXCI.IANGE AS A FUNCTION OF l^lIND SPEEDAND SEA STATE

O DEEP l,{ATER SAI'lPLINC CAN ALSO BE PERFOR14ED TOENHANCE OUR UNDERSTANDINC OF DEEP OCEAN IXCHANGE0F c0z, RAD0N-222, AND 0THER cHEtl IcAL TRAcERs

uf

Page 17: I i EDl,lARD A, I S, · drill in ocean depths l-lell over looo feet, solnletiivles as i'iuch as 5ooo feet relvlain in one location for thlo to three 14onths at these depths, the ocean

<./,A-lll-IoF=d,oLr-:

Cl)

OGT

lrJC-)lrlO(JItlEtJ=c\

oFV,(L

a-Je,

-Ooc./.) lrlt.Ltct) <J-o- z,=

-tctJF

r-{=FU)ao

r-. lJ_

IJFO

O

F{ (-9

tre e, z.

trl 7

--I<F<

=7 C/'

LD O

?V.

ts< CD

ElCt)

lrJ -

=) e,

:D

C}

cr)lrJI

ll-Od,o-lrle.JG

IF

c.n

lr I

trlr-lIc)trae,CJ

c,lrlFl.t.l(JLL

oF(JO<

:D F<

C-1(9O

Eo_ul-

tv, lrl

H=e,O-F{UJ

Olrl</)-F>

J:4o<-I=?=U-l<

=-e,LDod.o-d.lrj=7F

O<

LI.F<lrJ

l!

FF

))

Page 18: I i EDl,lARD A, I S, · drill in ocean depths l-lell over looo feet, solnletiivles as i'iuch as 5ooo feet relvlain in one location for thlo to three 14onths at these depths, the ocean

INFORIVlATION YIELDS (COllTINUED)

III

lq

{

I(ItI

tftF.l

IIittIli

tI

vI

bp'

sl

ATII OS P HE R I C C I RCU LAT I ON+ Tl.lE VARIATIONS l,lILL HELP DETERfVI INE

CLOBAL AIR CIRCULATION PATTERNS ANDCOULD BE A USEFUL CONTRIBUTION TOTHE TRANSIENT TRACES PROGRAlvl NOl^lBEGINNING UNDER DOE FUNDINC

0CEAN I C PC0Z+ ltlILL BE USED TO ESTABLISH GLOBAL

SEAl^lATER CIRCULATION PATTERNS+ BY CROSSIlrlG UPl.lARD AND DOl,{Nl^lARD

ADVECTION ZONES THE SEASONAL ANDYEARLY EXCHANCE OF SURFACE ANDDEEP hlATER l,lILL BE 14ONITORED

0CEANIC AND ATPl0SPHERIc eC02+ 1,{ILL BE USED TO ESTABLISH THE

CONCENTRAT-ION GRADIENT ACROSSTHE INTERFACE

Page 19: I i EDl,lARD A, I S, · drill in ocean depths l-lell over looo feet, solnletiivles as i'iuch as 5ooo feet relvlain in one location for thlo to three 14onths at these depths, the ocean

INFORI'IATION YIELDS (CONTINUED)

\dr'

+ THE CONCENTRATION VARIATIONSACCORDING TO SEASON AND REGIONhlILL BE USED TO CENERATE I,I OREACCURATE C0z EXCHANGE IvI0DELS

OCEAN TEIVIPERATURE PROFI LFS+ }lILL BE USED TO DETERlvlINE TtlETHICKNESS OF THE SURFACE l.lATERLAYER AND ITS VARIATION ACCORDINGTO SEASON AND REGION

+ TII IS l,lILL PROVIDE ADDITIONALINFORII ATION ON OCEAN CIRCULATIONPATTERNS AND l,lIND EFFECTS ONOCEAN II IXING

SALINITY+ t.lILL BE UsED TO DEFINE OcEAN

l^lATER IVIASSES+ IT IS ALsO USED TO cORREcT

THE RAl^l rC02 lvltASUREtt'lENTS

viIiIII

II

II

i

Page 20: I i EDl,lARD A, I S, · drill in ocean depths l-lell over looo feet, solnletiivles as i'iuch as 5ooo feet relvlain in one location for thlo to three 14onths at these depths, the ocean

aIr I

-F-aoCJ

-,OH F

trl !-{ <t)

oe,

AFALLTz,

z, (J

,rlAA<e.

c. trj

e,F<

=:30lrl

^=:=LrJF-F

lrltrct <d.

F-.

--tFcr)<rHZ,<

&.lJ Ct)

Ct't

Jz,o-

eEF{

lJ.J <H

-F<z, (Jd,

(ftrJ

C') J

:EJ<tl.J

trl<-JH

trl-=rV,LrlFlrlF

c.r)a'J-OF>.OLL

</, >4oir<F

r-l lrt

z,te-trtatltc)EtFFG

O(Jtrt(JCt-,>

Ll.J CA

c/re,e,=LL<J-(JZ,r<

:D<(JFtrt(J<uJ<trACJ=

OlrJO

l(J-Jr{J:E

<./) C) LrJ <t') O

- (D

J

\'"|

Page 21: I i EDl,lARD A, I S, · drill in ocean depths l-lell over looo feet, solnletiivles as i'iuch as 5ooo feet relvlain in one location for thlo to three 14onths at these depths, the ocean

LrJCDF>>{<

O

(J C/)

FX<tJ-l (9

LD7_JzZ,HlrjOO

<]<>FALLJJ<(J

2 d,

:= (-)

-,<=) J

tJ_Lr--lF<

CNo(Je,OlJ-

QLLI

-)1FOCJc/)atrlz,OF=tY,Olr-.

alrl<t)=f,Lt-ltraJ=e,(5Od,no-c/)

c9--JE,a

c/) lrl

LD F-r

tr-J O:F<FIJF(J&,<e,tFc4.o

: c.t) e.

u-o-<O

<ts{

lrlFLLE:f.A

tJ-l F

d'-F

ctl F_ 2,

<z.z,o

o:3F

(f L,.,'x

ct) F

J

LL=Jz,

cld ur <

?FOlrtFtrl

r< (9

F Lt-

(J LrJ Z,

clte, u_t z. F

u-=orJLl-

lrj lJ

)-.{ Z,

lrJ-d,FO

OF:3Hlrl(J

clt a :E

T.<&, F

u-t c)LrJ Fr =

(.J >

l4JLdtrJFF=<(JO

_H>Z.F<clr=l<<H

tlO

J-l

cr1 <Ftrl=_F<CcIO

HLTJtJ-loL)=atY

F=u)J=F{i-oc"l

\

Page 22: I i EDl,lARD A, I S, · drill in ocean depths l-lell over looo feet, solnletiivles as i'iuch as 5ooo feet relvlain in one location for thlo to three 14onths at these depths, the ocean

PROGRA14 RESULTS AND BENEFITS

II EANS OF P

ON YEARLYAND OCEAN I

0

,

A RELATHIGHLYAND REG

SAlvlPLISCIENTOF THE

IVELY INEXPENSIVEUSEFUL INFORII ATIONIONAL ATl{OSPHERIC

INFORllATRCULATION

ON ON BOTHPATTERNS

ON THE FINDINGSAND OTHER PART

ROVIDIl\lG, SEASONALC PROCESSES

ATMOSPHERIC AND

ISSUED JOINTLYICIPATIN6 INSTI-

e

0

0

IlvlPROVED AIR-OCEAN CARBON EXCHANGE llODEL

t

t'{

i,

i,ttt.r

Iq(.It

j

I

4

N

I

I

ADDITIONALOCEANIC CI

REPORTS FROI'I EXXONl^lITH LAf4ONT-DOHERTYTUTIONS

G VESSELS l^lILL BEFIC IVIEASURE14ENTSCARBON BUDGET OR

AVAILABLE FORTO ENHANCE OURRELATED AREAS

ADDITIONALUNDERSTANDING

Page 23: I i EDl,lARD A, I S, · drill in ocean depths l-lell over looo feet, solnletiivles as i'iuch as 5ooo feet relvlain in one location for thlo to three 14onths at these depths, the ocean

THEORY OF LAND B I OTA SAlvlPLING

INCREASE INFOSSIL FUEL

ATI\1OSPI-IERICCOlvlBUSTION

coz t\lAY BE DUE ToOR FOREST CLEARINC

t,o S0URCE 0F

ISOTOPESc - I3AND P

c-1rl

coz t4AY BE IDENTIFIED BY CARB0NIN THE ATIVI OSPlJEREIS PRESENT IN FOSSIL FUELSLANTSIS PRESENT ONLY

III

It

III!

IIIiI

rC

IN PLANTS

O IVIEASURING RELATIVE CHANGE OF C-13 AND C-14IN STORED BIOlulASS CAN YIELD INFORlllATION ONTHE S0URcE 0F THE C0z THA'T lrlAS pREsENTDURING PLANT GROl^lTH

Page 24: I i EDl,lARD A, I S, · drill in ocean depths l-lell over looo feet, solnletiivles as i'iuch as 5ooo feet relvlain in one location for thlo to three 14onths at these depths, the ocean

Global Carbon Isotope Di stri buti on

#=-on ffi=

Foss i 'l Fue lc-t3 _ffi - -c'tn

fJ$ = -rooz

'Terrestri al Bios phere

?# = -r.*

&l* - -0.,'

0ceans

c-l3ffia-l affi= -lo to

Atmospheric Carbon Isotope Ratios

Year

Biosphere 6nly

25'l FF

50r'FF

75t FF

- 75% Bio

- 50ts Bio

- ?51[ Bio

Fuel only

oPo(-)

Page 25: I i EDl,lARD A, I S, · drill in ocean depths l-lell over looo feet, solnletiivles as i'iuch as 5ooo feet relvlain in one location for thlo to three 14onths at these depths, the ocean

C9

o-=(/)o€a4.

.t=(9Od,o-

az,C\F-lI(JrfrF-lI(.)Fz,aLr-J

ooe,o-L!F

-<FO

-Cr)

tr-J Z,Cg.C\

-l r,r

-, --l

O-

FH

I -

e.cJ<\ (./) -,

lrl :1-

Itl -l

I I

d. l

FL)ID

LtJc)?Fn. r-{

lrloo=-FIF

.t

o>c9FO

Z,l-a

>4FFCJ<<€O

FM,

CD U) O

-7

trl.t-<>Fz.o

aLdJ_tclr <

. lrl

r--< <-JFO

.4O

-l-.<l'l

c/)

?l.r.jElrtIY(J>z, e,HO

FJ

F-{e.

:EIrI

:E>-,oh{E

C9FuJaF- z,

orda

etrlFu-UJ(D

cJ) Z,

* -

.J-E(J

Fox:=

Ct)F

)< LJ-J

=E O

_t-!J

o(J-FtvFo=)

= Ct)

O

O

l'.{ct)

E

atJ-lCJ)Oo-Oeo-

(9 lrjO

==2-C-)

Foc)<(3

: (I)

Ul trj

El _l

H<catJ.t_roo=

tY.A(DtrAct)F<au-J72.<?:==F-{JE,c/)=LrJ=FJ<

trtoe,>

lrjc/,:=O

Ih

Page 26: I i EDl,lARD A, I S, · drill in ocean depths l-lell over looo feet, solnletiivles as i'iuch as 5ooo feet relvlain in one location for thlo to three 14onths at these depths, the ocean

a-,-oxxtrl(f,Otfr4SZI=e,(5oe.CLAlrl&,ou-JtoLr.r C\€-o€+\J

:.

F=EE(9c)ECLIJElJ.Io'->crFod,(J

lrl

=EOcJ) ar.d

t_tFtral 7

C')<lrl

JID

G,

L&l

z,trt-t(!,-,ct)

==

:E<(J e,&,

(D

ue,ct) o_LIcrl-Olrl

-tF-

r<

F<z, u)r<<

Ed.(9od,o-(9ao-=-ct)

CL

C"

C9z.tv,eF=-trl=Ll.l

o-=o

trlz,.-l =

=oFF=)<oc)oaY,Elrl(JOc &,o1l-

lrlatJ(JCr)

=tv,(9otv,CL

au-Jct)oo-OE14

=-tV,(9oe,CL

F=,lJ-t

=rrje,C,)

lrl=

u-la::Eo-

))

o

Page 27: I i EDl,lARD A, I S, · drill in ocean depths l-lell over looo feet, solnletiivles as i'iuch as 5ooo feet relvlain in one location for thlo to three 14onths at these depths, the ocean

PROPOSED PROGRA14 SCllEDULE (CONTINUED)

\./

PHASE II (FIVE-YEAR PROGRAlvl)

IlvlPLEfvlENT FULL-SCALEUP TO FIVE DIFFERENTIVlENT)

I4

0

f{EASUREI{ENT l^lIr$/n B0 EXX0N

TANKERROUTES

PRO6RA14(t ll $/n

NG

GOVERN-US1,

c CONTINUE DRILLINC Sl{IP PRO6RAlvl ATL0CATI0NS (r$/n 50 EXX0N)

CONTINUE LAND BIOTADI'FFTRENT SOURCES (

SUITABLE

GEOGRAPt{ICALLY0 TH)

yl

Page 28: I i EDl,lARD A, I S, · drill in ocean depths l-lell over looo feet, solnletiivles as i'iuch as 5ooo feet relvlain in one location for thlo to three 14onths at these depths, the ocean

{-ooo)F{t(.looolr{

OOr-tOOF-l

oLft

otrrOtrlot.cio@

Orn

o o

t\ co

trr tjr.:f

lr\ lJ\

r{r.{

F\

oor.r\@rro$tv\l.r.lFtFl

(O

Fl

ootf\oorrl

t.rr{-

cO

Lr\ FlFl

5- F-{

oo(ooolft

ol\

-f tf.l

r-l--t

N1

OO

(OFl

NI\Fl

(O

t..\ t\\Fl

Fl

JJ---)Lt-

=e,(-Doe,o-

C\IcoolF-l

Oooorr{Ot

t-\O)

F.{

oOF{oOr-{I

GA

.{l r

o r

cl I

ctcol

l rjr

r cc

1 o

Ctt I Lo

.{l Fr

Ln r

[J1NIN

|f\

Lt-oFU)o(JEtdF=F(,t-Ll

@(ttt\Ol

FI

ootnrnO

OI.J.l [n

.-t C\l

IJU)

---l-o-

(,/>o-_-l--ct)

(-DJJd.a

ILl-l.d.CJ)

,

<lLrJEFca

(,FF<t i-rj

)-=

F. .,-\

.:1.O

-= v-.

r...2 d J

e. u) <,d. <.9 e. Z.uJo

rloV. d.

>Z F.z. d-

z, F-

LrJ

F

-l _t

<-F=O:'

F(J

U> U)_t

-J

oo<t) <t)

a c./>

LrJ Lr-lu- u-O

Od,eo_ o_I

t-

FOJFF

Page 29: I i EDl,lARD A, I S, · drill in ocean depths l-lell over looo feet, solnletiivles as i'iuch as 5ooo feet relvlain in one location for thlo to three 14onths at these depths, the ocean

GREENHOUSE TFFECT

it.I

t.

J.

5.

6.

Develop background

Oevelop research program

Obtain ER&E management approval

Advise Exxon Corp. & affiliatesAdvise DOE of program

Plan program with affiliates( Exxon International, EUSA, etc.)Arrange universi ty partnersh.ip

0esignate program manager

0rder and assemb'le i nstrumentatl on

Begin Phase I- Tanker No. I- Drilling Ship

Land biota measurements

l. Prepare and submit proposals to DOE

2, Publ ish initiai results3. 0rder additionai equipment

1. Begin Phase II- 5 tankers- 9 drilling ships- 2 different land biota sources

5. Awareness anq corporatedissemination of i nformati onon overa lI prob lem

Fundi ng

$ Source

20 K ER&E

30 K ER&E

GBL Units

IP'l P

1PIP'I P

IP

1P7.

B.

9.

0.

5k

5k

50k

125 k

ER&E

ER&E

ER&E

ER&E

DOEER&EER&E

ER&E

iP1.3 P

IP

6P

275 k ER&E25 k ER&E75 k ER&E

30 k ER&E

30 K ER&E

425 k DoE

6.8225160

70

Mkk

k 0.1 P

I