38
Cover Planning January 2016 I-70 East Final Environmental Impact Statement

I-70 East Final EIS - Attachment P - Cover PlanningColumbine Street Cover Extensions. Through conversation and deliberation at each table, each community member present at the Workshop

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: I-70 East Final EIS - Attachment P - Cover PlanningColumbine Street Cover Extensions. Through conversation and deliberation at each table, each community member present at the Workshop

Cover Planning

January

2016

I-70 East Final Environmental Impact Statement

Page 2: I-70 East Final EIS - Attachment P - Cover PlanningColumbine Street Cover Extensions. Through conversation and deliberation at each table, each community member present at the Workshop

This page intentionally left blank.

Page 3: I-70 East Final EIS - Attachment P - Cover PlanningColumbine Street Cover Extensions. Through conversation and deliberation at each table, each community member present at the Workshop

I-70 COVER OVERALL PLANNING PROCESSCDOT, DENVER, AND DENVER PUBLIC SCHOOLS

NOVEMBER 2013 MARCH 2015 APRIL 2015FRAME WORK PLAN PUBLIC MEETING “PLAN YOUR PARK” COMMUNITY WORKSHOP PLAN PROGRAM DEVELOPMENT

During the course of the development of a preferred design for the I-70 East reconstruction, CDOT, Denver and Denver Public Schools engaged the Elyria and Swansea Neighborhood to provide feedback on design options. Following preliminary identification of the Preferred Alternative in the Supplemental Draft EIS, the cover planning process was initiated. The community was invited to participate in the development of a preferred cover concept design.

In March 2015, Community Workshop #1 was held at Swansea Recreation Center to gather public input on the desired uses and organization of the I-70 cover and Swansea Elementary School outdoor space. Following a brief presentation on the history of the project and the common elements of successful open spaces, the community broke up into 10 tables of 6 to 10 people to participate in an interactive “Chip Game”.

The purpose of the Chip Game was to allow the community to locate desired uses across the site. Each table was supplied with a requirements list -including playground spaces, multi- purpose field and parking - for Swansea Elementary and a range of programmatic options for space outside of the school grounds. Through conversation and deliberation, each table developed a program and organization of uses for the cover.

Following Community Workshop #1, the Community Advisory Committee - comprised of neighborhood residents, business owners and Swansea Elementary personnel - was convened to review the Chip Game results, which were also grouped into three common themes. Based on comments from the Committee, the three themes were further documented to create three Conceptual Framework Options that also introduced concepts about pedestrian circulation to and through the cover and school sites.

What YOU want on the I-70 Cover ... The Results are IN! Lo que a USTED le interesa ver sobre la Cubierta de la I-70 … ¡YA TENEMOS los Resultados!

Page 4: I-70 East Final EIS - Attachment P - Cover PlanningColumbine Street Cover Extensions. Through conversation and deliberation at each table, each community member present at the Workshop

I-70 COVER OVERALL PLANNING PROCESSCDOT, DENVER, AND DENVER PUBLIC SCHOOLS

MAY 2015 JUNE 2015 JULY 2015CONCEPT DESIGN REFINEMENT “THE SCORE CARD” COMMUNITY WORKSHOP PREFERRED CONCEPT CHOSEN

PREFERRED CONCEPT CHOSEN

Through direction from the Communty Advisory Committee, the three Conceptual Framework Options were further refined into two Preferred Design Alternatives for the I-70 cover. Included as part of the Alternatives were 3-dimensional perspective images that illustrated the proposed design qualities of cover. These Preferred Design Alternatives were again presented to the Community Advisory Committee, and the input and feedback from the Committee was used to further refine the Alternatives.

In June 2015, Community Workshop #2 was held at Swansea Recreation Center to gather public input on the Preferred Design Alternatives with the goal of using community input to select a Preferred Concept. Following a brief presentation on the history of the effort and details of the two Preferred Design Alternatives, the community broke up into tables of 6 to 8 people to participate in an interactive activity to evaluate the alternatives.

The purpose of the activity was to allow the community to evaluate the Alternatives based on their ability to meet the goals of the cover based on 5 distinct pieces of the plan: the Non-School Program Elements, Circulation, Field & School Yard Configuration, School Fencing Style, and the Clayton and Columbine Street Cover Extensions. Through conversation and deliberation at each table, each community member present at the Workshop was encouraged to fill out a scorecard that reflected the success of each plan relative to the 5 distinct elements.

Following Community Workshop #2, scores from the activity were compiled. In each of the 5 scored categories, Design Alternative 1 was ranked the highest among the two alternatives in meeting the goals of the cover project, although there were also some variations to Alternative 2 that were supported. Based on community feedback, the design team is currently developing a Preferred Conceptual Design for the cover and school site. This plan will be available for community review in August 2015.

INVOLVE CONNECTIONS COMMUNITY RECREATIONAL

OPPORTUNITIES

SAFE, LIVABLE,

COMFORTABLE

PARTICIPACIÓN CONEXIONES COMUNIDAD RECREATIVAS SEGURIDAD

ALTERNATIVE 2ALTERNATIVE 1

Page 5: I-70 East Final EIS - Attachment P - Cover PlanningColumbine Street Cover Extensions. Through conversation and deliberation at each table, each community member present at the Workshop

MA

RC

H 4

, 2

01

5 C

OM

MU

NIT

Y W

OR

KS

HO

P S

UM

MA

RY

I-7

0 H

igh

wa

y C

ov

er

Stu

dy

MA

RCH

201

5

Page 6: I-70 East Final EIS - Attachment P - Cover PlanningColumbine Street Cover Extensions. Through conversation and deliberation at each table, each community member present at the Workshop

COM

MU

NIT

Y W

ORK

SHO

P C

DO

T an

d th

e C

ity a

nd C

ount

y of

Den

ver j

oine

d to

geth

er to

eng

age

the

com

mun

ity a

nd

gath

er id

eas

to e

xplo

re p

ossib

ilitie

s fo

r out

door

use

s fo

r the

cov

er th

at w

ill sit

ove

r the

fu

ture

I-70

Eas

t Hig

hway

. A c

omm

unity

wor

ksho

p w

as h

eld

on M

arch

4, 2

015

at th

e Sw

anse

a Re

crea

tion

Cen

ter a

s pa

rt of

this

effo

rt. A

ppro

xim

atel

y 10

1 pe

ople

atte

nded

the

wor

ksho

p. A

dditi

onal

opp

ortu

nitie

s to

pro

vide

inpu

t are

pla

nned

for t

he fu

ture

.

The

wor

ksho

p w

as h

eld

from

5:3

0PM

to 7

:30P

M a

nd in

clud

ed 1

5 m

inut

es o

f “O

pen

Hou

se”

follo

wed

by

a pr

esen

tatio

n gi

ven

by re

pres

enta

tives

from

CD

OT,

City

of D

enve

r, Sw

anse

a El

emen

tary

, and

Des

ign

Wor

ksho

p. T

he p

rese

ntat

ion

revi

ewed

a p

roje

ct

timel

ine,

goa

ls, a

nd in

trodu

ced

the

idea

of “

Shar

ed S

pace

” be

twee

n th

e sc

hool

and

the

com

mun

ity o

n th

e co

ver.

Follo

win

g th

e pr

esen

tatio

n, c

omm

unity

mem

bers

bro

ke in

to s

mal

l gro

ups

for a

“D

esig

n Yo

ur S

pace

” ga

me

and

faci

litat

ed d

iscus

sion.

Eac

h gr

oup

was

giv

en a

bla

nk b

ase

map

of

the

site

and

a se

ries

of tr

ue-to

-scal

e “c

hips

,” re

pres

entin

g di

ffere

nt p

rogr

ams

and

spac

es.

Each

gro

up h

ad to

com

e to

a c

onse

nsus

on

the

type

s of

pro

gram

s an

d th

eir a

rrang

emen

t w

ithin

the

site.

Afte

r all

grou

ps h

ad c

ompl

eted

the

gam

e, fo

ur ta

bles

out

of t

en p

rese

nted

th

eir d

esig

n ba

ck to

the

com

mun

ity.

The

outc

ome

of th

is co

mm

unity

wor

ksho

p he

lps

the

desig

n te

am d

evel

op d

esig

n al

tern

ativ

es th

at re

spon

d to

the

need

s of

the

scho

ol a

nd th

e de

sires

of t

he c

omm

unity

. Fo

od, c

hild

car

e, a

nd S

pani

sh tr

ansla

tion

wer

e av

aila

ble

to e

ncou

rage

par

ticip

atio

n fro

m

all m

embe

rs o

f the

com

mun

ity.

Page 7: I-70 East Final EIS - Attachment P - Cover PlanningColumbine Street Cover Extensions. Through conversation and deliberation at each table, each community member present at the Workshop

SMA

LL G

ROU

P D

ISCU

SSIO

NS

EXPL

ORE

D... Ach

ievi

ng b

oth

the

NE

ED

S o

f the

SC

HO

OL

and

the

DE

SIR

ES

of t

he C

OM

MU

NIT

Y

Page 8: I-70 East Final EIS - Attachment P - Cover PlanningColumbine Street Cover Extensions. Through conversation and deliberation at each table, each community member present at the Workshop

SMA

LL G

ROU

P D

ISCU

SSIO

NS

EX

PLO

RED

...

CO

MM

UN

ITY

CO

NC

ER

NS

• A

ir Q

ualit

y

• D

urat

ion

of C

onstr

uctio

n

• Fu

ndin

g So

urce

s fo

r M

aint

enan

ce

• H

ealth

of C

hild

ren

• Pa

rkin

g an

d A

cces

s

• Po

llutio

n

• Sa

fety

Page 9: I-70 East Final EIS - Attachment P - Cover PlanningColumbine Street Cover Extensions. Through conversation and deliberation at each table, each community member present at the Workshop

THE

“D

ESI

GN

YO

UR

SPA

CE

” G

AM

ED

ESIG

N Y

OU

R SP

ACE

GA

ME

| BA

SE M

AP

JUEG

O D

E D

ISEÑ

O D

ETU

ESP

ACI

O |

MA

PAB

ÁSI

CO

PR

OP

OS

ED

NE

W E

NT

RY

PR

OP

OS

ED

EC

E D

OO

R

PR

OP

OS

ED

BU

S D

RO

P O

FF

PROPOSED SHUTTLE DROP OFF

PU

ER

TA E

CE

PR

OP

UE

STA

EC

E

UB

ICA

CIÓ

N P

AR

A D

EJA

R P

AS

AJE

RO

S D

E

AU

TOB

US

ES

PR

OP

UE

STA

UBICACIÓN PARA DEJAR PASAJEROS DE VEHÍCULOS DE TRASLADO PROPUESTA

NU

EV

A E

NT

RA

DA

PR

OP

UE

STA

120’

60’

30’

0 1”=3

0’

The

“Des

ign

Your

Spa

ce”

gam

e is

a co

llabo

rativ

e ex

erci

se th

at a

llow

s co

mm

unity

mem

bers

to s

ugge

st w

hich

type

s of

faci

litie

s, p

rogr

ams,

and

land

scap

e tre

atm

ents

shou

ld b

e in

stalle

d on

the

I-70

East

Cov

er

and

whe

re th

ey m

ight

be

loca

ted.

Each

gro

up w

as g

iven

a b

lank

bas

e m

ap o

f the

site

an

d a

serie

s of

true

-to-sc

ale

“chi

ps,”

repr

esen

ting

diffe

rent

pro

gram

s an

d sp

aces

. Rul

es o

f the

gam

e in

dica

ted

thre

e sc

hool

pro

gram

s th

at h

ad to

pla

yed

with

in c

lose

pro

xim

ity to

the

scho

ol b

uild

ing.

The

se

incl

uded

: a m

ulti-u

se fi

eld,

pla

ygro

und

area

s, a

nd

park

ing/

drop

-off.

All

othe

r chi

ps re

pres

ente

d op

tiona

l pro

gram

type

s.

Ther

e w

ere

also

a n

umbe

r of b

lank

chi

ps w

hich

al

low

ed c

omm

unity

mem

bers

to w

rite-

in th

eir o

wn

idea

s.

Gro

ups

had

45 m

inut

es to

com

e to

a c

onse

nsus

abo

ut

thei

r des

ign.

Afte

r the

gam

e w

as c

ompl

ete,

four

out

of

the

ten

tabl

es p

rese

nted

thei

r des

ign

to th

e re

st of

the

com

mun

ity p

rese

nt.

Page 10: I-70 East Final EIS - Attachment P - Cover PlanningColumbine Street Cover Extensions. Through conversation and deliberation at each table, each community member present at the Workshop

OU

TCO

ME

S O

F G

RO

UP

EX

ER

CIS

E

Page 11: I-70 East Final EIS - Attachment P - Cover PlanningColumbine Street Cover Extensions. Through conversation and deliberation at each table, each community member present at the Workshop

Bou

lder

Wal

l Pl

aygr

ound

B

lack

top

Gam

es

Sand

box

Mul

ti-us

e Fi

eld

Foot

ball

Socc

erB

aseb

all

Fris

bee

Caf

es

Com

mun

ity

Gar

den

Tabl

e G

ames

C

hess

Che

cker

sPi

ng P

ong

Chi

nese

Che

cker

s

Skat

e Pa

rk

Law

n G

ames

Hor

sesh

oeB

occe

Bal

lLa

wn

Bow

ling

Cro

quet

G

iant

Jen

gaLa

dder

Tos

s

Wat

er F

eatu

re /

Spla

sh P

adM

ulti-

use

Cou

rts

Pave

d C

ourt

sB

aske

tbal

lTe

nnis

Futs

al

Pavi

lion

/ Pi

cnic

Spa

ceFl

exib

le

Plaz

a Sp

ace

Exer

cise

Food

Tr

ucks

Res

troo

ms

Info

rmal

Law

nA

mph

ithea

ter

500

Peop

leC

omm

unity

Ev

ents

10

0 Pe

ople

TABL

E 1

TABL

E 2

TABL

E 3

TABL

E 4

TABL

E 5

TABL

E 6

TABL

E 7

TABL

E 8

TABL

E 9

TABL

E 10

TOTA

L C

HIP

S PL

AYED

28

132

96

106

1113

2810

2310

833

169

11

% T

ABL

ES

100%

80%

20%

90%

60%

100%

60%

90%

90%

90%

100%

100%

100%

70%

100%

100%

50%

60%

TA

BU

LATI

NG

CH

IPS

This

diag

ram

tabu

late

s al

l of t

he o

ptio

nal c

hips

. As

per t

he ru

les

of th

e ga

me,

a

mul

ti-use

fiel

d, th

ree

play

grou

nds,

and

par

king

/dr

op-o

ff ha

d to

be

incl

uded

in e

very

de

sign.

Page 12: I-70 East Final EIS - Attachment P - Cover PlanningColumbine Street Cover Extensions. Through conversation and deliberation at each table, each community member present at the Workshop

Com

mun

ity

Even

ts

100

Peop

le

Pavi

lion

/ Pi

cnic

Spa

ceFl

exib

le P

laza

Sp

ace

Bou

lder

Wal

l A

mph

ithea

ter

500

Peop

le

Wat

er F

eatu

re /

Spla

sh P

adR

estro

oms

PLA

YED

AT

EV

ERY

TA

BLE

Page 13: I-70 East Final EIS - Attachment P - Cover PlanningColumbine Street Cover Extensions. Through conversation and deliberation at each table, each community member present at the Workshop

5 M

OST

PLA

YED

CH

IPS

12

3

45

Com

mun

ityG

arde

n Pa

vilio

n /

Picn

ic S

pace

Flex

ible

Pla

za

Spac

e

Res

troom

sC

omm

unity

Ev

ents

10

0 Pe

ople

Page 14: I-70 East Final EIS - Attachment P - Cover PlanningColumbine Street Cover Extensions. Through conversation and deliberation at each table, each community member present at the Workshop

(Add

ition

al)

Mul

ti-us

e Fi

eld

Skat

e Pa

rk

Caf

es

Exer

cise

(Add

ition

al)

Play

grou

nd

5 LE

AST

PLA

YED

CH

IPS

12

3

45

Page 15: I-70 East Final EIS - Attachment P - Cover PlanningColumbine Street Cover Extensions. Through conversation and deliberation at each table, each community member present at the Workshop

OTH

ER

PR

OG

RA

M ID

EA

S FR

OM

TH

E C

OM

MU

NIT

Y

gre

enho

uses

shad

e

tree

s

sand

vol

leyb

all

tot

pla

ygro

und

pic

nic

area

s

wal

king

trai

ls

drin

king

foun

tain

s

flow

er g

ard

en

light

ing

seat

ing

bik

e p

arki

ng

bik

e re

pai

r st

atio

n

Page 16: I-70 East Final EIS - Attachment P - Cover PlanningColumbine Street Cover Extensions. Through conversation and deliberation at each table, each community member present at the Workshop

CO

MM

ON

TH

EM

ES

FOR

TH

E S

CH

OO

L SI

TE

• Sc

hool

par

king

and

dro

p-of

f at t

he c

orne

r of 4

7th

and

Thom

pson

Ct.

• M

ulti-U

se F

ield

sho

uld

be w

est

of T

hom

pson

Ct.

• Pl

aygr

ound

s ge

nera

lly lo

cate

d so

uth

of th

e sc

hool

.

• G

arde

ns g

ener

ally

loca

ted

near

sch

ool

Page 17: I-70 East Final EIS - Attachment P - Cover PlanningColumbine Street Cover Extensions. Through conversation and deliberation at each table, each community member present at the Workshop

OTH

ER

CO

MM

ON

TH

EM

ES

• St

rong

des

ire fo

r ope

n an

d fle

xibl

e la

wn

in a

dditi

on to

the

scho

ol’s

mul

ti-use

fiel

d

• Ea

st en

d sh

ould

be

a

com

bina

tion

of g

reen

and

plaz

a sp

ace

• Th

ree

mai

n al

tern

ativ

es fo

r

mul

ti-use

fiel

d:•

Orie

nted

eas

t-wes

t; lo

cate

d on

the

far w

est s

ide

• O

rient

ed e

ast-w

est;

cent

rally

lo

cate

d on

the

cove

r•

Orie

nted

nor

th-so

uth

Page 18: I-70 East Final EIS - Attachment P - Cover PlanningColumbine Street Cover Extensions. Through conversation and deliberation at each table, each community member present at the Workshop

THA

NK

YO

U F

OR

YO

UR

INPU

T!

As

the

desig

n fo

r the

Eas

t I-7

0 C

over

mov

es fo

rwar

d, w

e w

ill ta

ke

all p

rogr

ams

unde

r con

sider

atio

n. P

leas

e ke

ep in

min

d th

at n

ot

all p

rogr

ams

are

poss

ible

but

we

will

seek

the

best

com

bina

tion

of

reso

urce

s an

d am

eniti

es th

at b

alan

ce th

e ne

eds

of th

e sc

hool

with

the

desir

es o

f the

com

mun

ity.

Page 19: I-70 East Final EIS - Attachment P - Cover PlanningColumbine Street Cover Extensions. Through conversation and deliberation at each table, each community member present at the Workshop

JUN

E 9

, 2

01

5 C

OM

MU

NIT

Y W

OR

KS

HO

P S

UM

MA

RY

I-7

0 H

igh

wa

y C

ov

er

Stu

dy

JULY

201

5

Page 20: I-70 East Final EIS - Attachment P - Cover PlanningColumbine Street Cover Extensions. Through conversation and deliberation at each table, each community member present at the Workshop

COM

MUN

ITY

WOR

KSHO

P

CD

OT

and

the

City

and

Cou

nty

of D

enve

r joi

ned

toge

ther

to e

ngag

e th

e co

mm

unity

and

ga

ther

inpu

t on

two

diffe

rent

des

ign

alte

rnat

ives

for t

he I-

70 E

ast H

ighw

ay C

over

. Fiv

e ke

y el

emen

ts of

eac

h de

sign

wer

e di

scus

sed,

incl

udin

g:

- N

on-S

choo

l Pro

gram

-Circ

ulat

ion

-Fi

eld

and

Scho

ol Y

ard

Con

figur

atio

n

-Sch

ool F

enci

ng S

tyle

-Cla

yton

+ C

olum

bine

Stre

et C

over

Ext

ensio

ns

The

com

mun

ity w

orks

hop

was

hel

d on

June

9, 2

015

at th

e Sw

anse

a Re

crea

tion

Cen

ter

as p

art o

f thi

s ef

fort.

App

roxi

mat

ely

50 p

eopl

e at

tend

ed th

e w

orks

hop.

The

resu

lts o

f thi

s co

mm

unity

wor

ksho

p w

ill be

use

d to

dev

elop

the

pref

erre

d co

ncep

t for

the

high

way

cov

er.

The

mee

ting

was

hel

d fro

m 5

:30

to 7

:30

and

cons

isted

of a

25

min

ute

pres

enta

tion

to

expl

ain

the

elem

ents

of d

esig

n al

tern

ativ

es fo

llow

ed b

y a

faci

litat

ed s

mal

l gro

up e

xerc

ise.

Each

par

ticip

ant w

as g

iven

a “

scor

e ca

rd”

and

was

ask

ed to

rank

the

elem

ents

of th

e tw

o pl

ans

from

1-3

(3 b

eing

the

best

use

of th

e sit

e). P

artic

ipan

ts w

ere

also

enc

oura

ged

to

ask

ques

tions

to th

e fa

cilit

ator

and

exp

lain

the

reas

onin

g fo

r the

ir re

spon

ses.

Bas

ed o

n th

e fe

edba

ck p

rovi

ded

by th

e co

mm

unity

mem

bers

, the

des

ign

team

will

deve

lop

a pr

efer

red

plan

incl

udin

g th

e el

emen

ts m

ost d

esire

d by

the

com

mun

ity.

Page 21: I-70 East Final EIS - Attachment P - Cover PlanningColumbine Street Cover Extensions. Through conversation and deliberation at each table, each community member present at the Workshop

SMA

LL G

ROU

P D

ISCU

SSIO

NS

EXPL

ORE

D...

Two

desig

n al

tern

ativ

es a

nd

the

five

elem

ents

with

in e

ach

desig

n: N

on-S

choo

l Pro

gram

, C

ircul

atio

n, F

ield

and

Sch

ool

Yard

Con

figur

atio

n, S

choo

l Fe

ncin

g St

yle,

Cla

yton

+

Col

umbi

ne S

treet

Cov

er

Exte

nsio

ns

Page 22: I-70 East Final EIS - Attachment P - Cover PlanningColumbine Street Cover Extensions. Through conversation and deliberation at each table, each community member present at the Workshop

ALTE

RNAT

IVE

1AL

TERN

ATIV

E 2

THE

TWO

ALTE

RNAT

IVES

Page 23: I-70 East Final EIS - Attachment P - Cover PlanningColumbine Street Cover Extensions. Through conversation and deliberation at each table, each community member present at the Workshop

NON

-SCH

OOL

PROG

RAM

The

key

diffe

renc

es b

etw

een

Alte

rnat

ive

1 an

d A

ltern

ativ

e 2

wer

e in

the

user

gro

ups

that

they

wou

ld a

ttrac

t. A

ltern

ativ

e 1

prov

ided

a la

rge

area

for c

ourt

spor

ts th

at c

ould

in

clud

e ba

sket

ball,

futsa

l, an

d ot

her c

ourts

. Alte

rnat

ive

2 w

as m

ore

focu

sed

on p

rogr

am

for y

oung

er c

hild

ren.

A “

tot-lo

t” fo

r non

-scho

ol a

ge c

hild

ren

and

a se

ries

of p

lay

hills

wer

e pr

ovid

ed n

ext t

o th

e w

ater

feat

ure.

Bot

h A

ltern

ativ

es p

rovi

ded

form

al g

arde

ns, fl

exib

le

plaz

a sp

ace,

and

an

info

rmal

law

n in

var

ious

con

figur

atio

ns.

Page 24: I-70 East Final EIS - Attachment P - Cover PlanningColumbine Street Cover Extensions. Through conversation and deliberation at each table, each community member present at the Workshop

CIRC

ULAT

ION

Both

Alte

rnat

ives

1 a

nd 2

util

ized

the

sam

e co

nfigu

ratio

n fo

r par

king

, dro

p-of

f, an

d ci

rcul

atio

n fo

r sch

ool a

nd n

on-sc

hool

veh

icul

ar a

nd b

ike

faci

litie

s. A

ltern

ativ

e 1

prov

ided

str

ong

and

dire

ct n

orth

-sout

h an

d ea

st-w

est p

edes

trian

circ

ulat

ion

link

whi

le A

ltern

ativ

e 2

prov

ided

a m

ore

swee

ping

and

exp

erie

ntia

l circ

ulat

ion

patte

rn. I

n A

ltern

ativ

e 2

the

mai

n Ea

st-W

est c

onne

ctio

n is

situa

ted

to th

e so

uth

of th

e m

ulti-p

urpo

se fi

eld.

Page 25: I-70 East Final EIS - Attachment P - Cover PlanningColumbine Street Cover Extensions. Through conversation and deliberation at each table, each community member present at the Workshop

FIEL

D AN

D SC

HOOL

YAR

D CO

NFI

GURA

TION

Alte

rnat

ive

1 an

d 2

diffe

red

in th

eir fi

eld

orie

ntat

ion

by A

ltern

ativ

e 1

prov

idin

g an

eas

t-w

est o

rient

atio

n an

d A

ltern

ativ

e 2

prov

idin

g a

north

-sout

h co

nfigu

ratio

n. T

he fi

eld

size

rem

aine

d ro

ughl

y th

e sa

me

in b

oth

scen

erie

s to

pro

vide

ade

quat

e sp

ace

for t

he s

choo

l. A

ltern

ativ

e 2

brou

ght l

awn

clos

er to

the

scho

ol a

nd p

ushe

d th

e pl

aygr

ound

ont

o th

e co

ver

abov

e th

e in

ters

tate

whi

le A

ltern

ativ

e 1

kept

the

scho

ol y

ard

clos

er to

the

scho

ol a

nd o

ff th

e co

ver.

Page 26: I-70 East Final EIS - Attachment P - Cover PlanningColumbine Street Cover Extensions. Through conversation and deliberation at each table, each community member present at the Workshop

SCHO

OL F

ENCI

NG

STYL

E

Both

Alte

rnat

ives

pro

vide

d th

e sa

me

fenc

ed a

rea

and

offe

red

larg

e ga

tew

ays

on to

the

mul

ti-pur

pose

fiel

d fo

r the

com

mun

ity a

s w

ell a

s a

seco

ndar

y fe

nce

arou

nd th

e sc

hool

ya

rd. A

ltern

ativ

e 1

prov

ides

a v

ery

vibr

ant a

nd p

layf

ul fe

nce

style

that

bec

ame

part

of th

e la

ndsc

ape

whi

le A

ltern

ativ

e 2

prov

ided

a m

ore

tradi

tiona

l bric

k an

d iro

n fe

nce

style

. Bot

h of

thes

e al

tern

ativ

es p

rovi

ded

a ve

rtica

l gat

eway

stru

ctur

e to

mar

k m

ajor

ent

ranc

es in

to th

e sc

hool

yar

d an

d a

mor

e su

bdue

d op

enin

g in

to th

e m

ulti-p

urpo

se fi

elds

.

Page 27: I-70 East Final EIS - Attachment P - Cover PlanningColumbine Street Cover Extensions. Through conversation and deliberation at each table, each community member present at the Workshop

CLAY

TON

AN

D CO

LUM

BIN

E ST

REET

EXT

ENSI

ONS

The

cove

r ext

ensio

ns o

n ei

ther

sid

e of

Cla

yton

and

Col

umbi

ne d

iffer

in e

ach

alte

rnat

ive

in th

at A

ltern

ativ

e 1

prov

ides

pro

gram

ed c

omm

unity

spa

ce a

nd a

wes

tern

ove

rlook

whi

le

Alte

rnat

ive

2 pr

ovid

es o

nly

an e

nhan

ced

land

scap

e bu

ffer b

etw

een

the

high

way

and

the

sidew

alk.

Bot

h al

tern

ativ

es p

rovi

de a

buf

fer f

or s

ound

and

a s

pace

for t

ree

plan

ting

to

alon

g th

e ed

ges.

Page 28: I-70 East Final EIS - Attachment P - Cover PlanningColumbine Street Cover Extensions. Through conversation and deliberation at each table, each community member present at the Workshop

THE

“SCO

RE C

ARD”

I-70 C

OV

ER

CO

MM

UN

ITY

WO

RK

SH

OP

# 2

ALT

ER

NA

TIV

ES

SC

OR

E C

AR

D

Alt

ern

ati

ve

1

Rat

e 1

to 3

(1 lo

wes

t, 3

high

est)

Alt

ern

ati

ve

2

Rat

e 1

to 3

(1 lo

wes

t, 3

high

est)

Exp

lan

ati

on

(Opt

iona

l)

Non

-Sch

ool

Prog

ram

Elem

ents

Cir

cula

tion

Fiel

d &

Sch

ool Y

ard

Con

figur

atio

n

Sch

ool F

enci

ng

Sty

le

Cla

yton

&

Col

umbi

ne

St C

over

Exte

nsio

ns

Did

we

mis

s

anyt

hing

?

(wri

te in

)

I-70

ALT

ER

N

Alt

ern

at

1

Rat

e 1

(1 lo

whi

gh

Non

-Sch

ool

Prog

ram

Elem

ents

Cir

cula

tion

Fiel

d &

Sch

ool Y

ard

Con

figur

atio

Sch

ool F

enS

Cla

Col Ex D

INV

OLV

E

CO

NN

EC

TIO

NS

CO

MM

UN

ITY

CO

RE

RE

CR

EA

TIO

NA

L

OP

PO

RT

UN

ITIE

S

SA

FE

, LIV

AB

LE

,

CO

MFO

RTA

BLE

The

“Sco

re C

ard”

was

a w

ay fo

r the

des

ign

team

to

quan

tify

the

opin

ions

of t

he c

omm

unity

mem

bers

. Eac

h ta

ble

had

the

two

plan

alte

rnat

ives

as

wel

l as

a pa

cket

of

visu

aliz

atio

ns th

at d

epic

ted

the

diffe

renc

es b

etw

een

the

two

alte

rnat

ives

.

The

goal

was

not

to p

ick

one

desig

n or

the

othe

r but

to

iden

tify

and

clar

ify th

e el

emen

ts fro

m e

ach

desig

n th

at

the

com

mun

ity li

ked.

Indi

vidu

als

had

45 m

inut

es to

tally

thei

r tho

ught

s ab

out

whi

ch e

lem

ents

wer

e th

e be

st fro

m e

ach

desig

n. A

fter

the

gam

e w

as c

ompl

ete,

four

repr

esen

tativ

es p

rese

nted

ke

y ta

ke a

way

s ho

w th

eir t

able

’s di

scus

sion.

Page 29: I-70 East Final EIS - Attachment P - Cover PlanningColumbine Street Cover Extensions. Through conversation and deliberation at each table, each community member present at the Workshop

OUTC

OMES

OF

GROU

P EX

ERCI

SE

I-70 C

OV

ER

CO

MM

UN

ITY

WO

RK

SH

OP

# 2

ALT

ER

NA

TIV

ES

SC

OR

E C

AR

D

Alt

ern

ati

ve

1

Rat

e 1

to 3

(1 lo

wes

t, 3

high

est)

Alt

ern

ati

ve

2

Rat

e 1

to 3

(1 lo

wes

t, 3

high

est)

Exp

lan

ati

on

(Opt

iona

l)

No

n-S

cho

ol

Pro

gra

m

Ele

men

ts

Cir

cula

tio

n

Fiel

d &

Sch

oo

l Yar

d

Co

nfi

gu

rati

on

Sch

oo

l Fen

cin

g

Sty

le

Cla

yto

n &

Co

lum

bin

e

St

Cov

er

Ext

ensi

on

s

Did

we

mis

s

anyt

hin

g?

(wri

te in

)

I-70

No

n-S

cPr

oE

lem

Cir

c

Sc

Co

nfi

Sch

o

INV

OLV

EC

ON

NE

CT

ION

SC

OM

MU

NIT

Y

CO

RE

RE

CR

EA

TIO

NA

L

OP

PO

RT

UN

ITIE

S

SA

FE

, LIV

AB

LE

,

CO

MFO

RTA

BLE

47 47 54 55 60

47 39 41 49 34

Page 30: I-70 East Final EIS - Attachment P - Cover PlanningColumbine Street Cover Extensions. Through conversation and deliberation at each table, each community member present at the Workshop

ALTE

RNAT

IVE

1 | B

ASIS

OF

THE

PREF

ERRE

D AL

TERN

ATIV

E

Ove

rall

Alte

rnat

ive

1 ra

nked

hi

gher

bet

wee

n th

e tw

o.

It w

ill se

rve

a ba

se fo

r the

de

velo

pmen

t of t

he p

refe

rred

conc

ept.

The

scor

e ca

rd

also

allo

wed

for p

eopl

e to

co

mm

ent f

reel

y. T

hat,

as

wel

l as

the

open

disc

ussio

n an

d no

tes

gath

ered

from

the

publ

ic m

eetin

g, p

rovi

ded

insig

ht th

at w

ill he

lp ta

ke

elem

ents

from

eac

h pl

an a

nd

brin

g th

em fo

rwar

d in

to th

e pr

efer

red

conc

ept.

Two

maj

or

elem

ents

that

the

com

mun

ity

desir

ed w

as th

at th

e sp

ace

acco

mm

odat

e bo

th y

oung

ch

ildre

n’s

prog

ram

min

g as

w

ell a

s te

en a

nd y

oung

adu

lt pr

ogra

mm

ing.

The

re w

as a

lso

a de

sire

for a

“so

fter”

mor

e in

vitin

g ci

rcul

atio

n pa

ttern

.

Page 31: I-70 East Final EIS - Attachment P - Cover PlanningColumbine Street Cover Extensions. Through conversation and deliberation at each table, each community member present at the Workshop

SNAP

SHOT

OF

COM

MEN

TS

“The

tot-l

ot n

eeds

to b

e bi

gger

. We

need

mor

e ac

tiviti

es fo

r kid

s ar

ound

he

re.”

“We

shou

ld u

se re

new

able

mat

eria

ls. P

rovi

de re

cycl

ing

as w

ell a

s tra

sh

cans

.”

“We

need

mor

e th

an o

ne d

rinki

ng fo

unta

in.”

“Mov

e th

e to

t-lot

and

pla

y hi

lls fr

om A

ltern

ativ

e 2

into

Alte

rnat

ive

1.”

“Thi

s ne

eds

to b

e th

e fla

vor o

f the

com

mun

ity.”

Page 32: I-70 East Final EIS - Attachment P - Cover PlanningColumbine Street Cover Extensions. Through conversation and deliberation at each table, each community member present at the Workshop

SNAP

SHO

T OF

COM

MEN

TS

“The

eld

erly

pop

ulat

ion

need

s sp

ace

as w

ell.

Prov

ide

mor

e sh

ade

for

wal

king

.”

“Wha

t abo

ut w

all b

all?

Pro

vide

ple

nty

of S

hade

and

mor

e re

stroo

ms.

“Pro

vide

spa

ces

for a

rt th

roug

hout

the

park

, not

just

on th

e en

ds”

“I li

ke th

e ov

er lo

ok in

Opt

ion

1 an

d th

e to

wer

in O

ptio

n 2,

vie

ws

to th

e m

ount

ains

and

the

city

wou

ld b

e gr

eat.”

“I li

ke th

e sta

ging

are

a fo

r foo

d ca

rts.”

Page 33: I-70 East Final EIS - Attachment P - Cover PlanningColumbine Street Cover Extensions. Through conversation and deliberation at each table, each community member present at the Workshop

MAJ

OR W

ORDS

USE

D TH

ROUG

HOUT

safe

ty

shad

e

tree

s

hand

ball

tot p

layg

roun

d

picn

ic a

reas

wal

king

trai

ls

drin

king

foun

tain

s

bath

room

s

light

ing

mul

ti-ge

nera

tiona

l

bike

par

king

bike

faci

litie

s

Page 34: I-70 East Final EIS - Attachment P - Cover PlanningColumbine Street Cover Extensions. Through conversation and deliberation at each table, each community member present at the Workshop

COM

MON

THE

MES

Des

ire fo

r Eas

t-Wes

t orie

ntat

ion

of th

e m

ulti-u

se fi

eld

The

circ

ulat

ion

for A

ltern

ativ

e 1

is m

ore

invi

ting

for t

he

com

mun

ityPr

ovid

e ac

tiviti

es fo

r peo

ple

of a

ll ag

es. A

ctiv

ities

for

child

ren,

sen

iors

, and

teen

sSh

ade

for w

alki

ng p

aths

and

pla

y ar

eas

is ve

ry im

porta

ntIn

tegr

ate

com

mun

ity a

rt in

to th

e en

tire

desig

nVi

ews

to th

e ci

ty a

nd th

e m

ount

ains

are

impo

rtant

Inte

grat

e bi

ke fa

cilit

ies

into

the

desig

nPr

ovid

e a

mul

tifun

ctio

nal r

ecre

atio

n sp

ace

The

desig

n sh

ould

hav

e as

muc

h pr

ogra

m a

s it

can

to b

est

use

the

spac

e

Page 35: I-70 East Final EIS - Attachment P - Cover PlanningColumbine Street Cover Extensions. Through conversation and deliberation at each table, each community member present at the Workshop

THA

NK

YOU

FO

R YO

UR

INPU

T!

NEX

T ST

EPS

The

desig

n te

am w

ill ta

ke th

e su

gges

tions

and

com

men

ts fro

m th

is co

mm

unity

wor

ksho

p an

d de

velo

p a

pref

erre

d co

ncep

t. W

e w

ill be

de

velo

ping

one

pre

ferre

d pl

an to

refle

ct w

hat w

e he

ard

from

you

!

Page 36: I-70 East Final EIS - Attachment P - Cover PlanningColumbine Street Cover Extensions. Through conversation and deliberation at each table, each community member present at the Workshop
Page 37: I-70 East Final EIS - Attachment P - Cover PlanningColumbine Street Cover Extensions. Through conversation and deliberation at each table, each community member present at the Workshop
Page 38: I-70 East Final EIS - Attachment P - Cover PlanningColumbine Street Cover Extensions. Through conversation and deliberation at each table, each community member present at the Workshop