11III.41 slI-1710J205/ul1

Rl lTf cpI' JIR 37 ri1LlcP—cc,

Grjl

1. ñR- trr Ie ii i1i~'., 1ct eIcilc'I 1-j fff UçjcflçJ I I—k'iIc. 9.—A-2, TUT[ c1It 1TR, cpcicii

'kclJi,

FA

t T'5[ 3?1 1kR Lflc4c1 dcl f Il ...3&FTh1 IUI

31 RT1T, 1c

31 pull

1Uçj 1T1T1

-cp : 30.03.2017

IraLlMil

1. zr Pii 'HcPk II cc'j'k TT 1ii RiRctci

cPdP (tic), (f-;. ii- 'cpcP1cte ici -r

1190/2014 A Mf\" 31I! I~icp 11.03.2015 * I' ITT t q icP &fffRlN,

1998 ("fr &I ' icP 3fPV T lT?T[ t 1R[ 65 Ict 3T;—ci [ci i '-c,ci it

2. ,4Ct)UI ZJ q

Ict u.cIc1Ie1 p RM 1-j)j -MT eNlel PNk)— 'Qi'k T. —2

viurr cii 91T, cPIc'1ClI., lc.ciii, 'I'kFf, i1 TT 1T.t9T t1

10.12.2014 Scj,c1 PI'I R-1I * f TT gcciI' 64I

jt, 9-3I1f 45E c- Im ci)c Ilc1I '.il

VFt Ic1I dsI 18 L1Ic1I iHSi 15 31-c14c1 1 *I T. 24 TCT7W 20

~ftM 05 I*ii 1/10 I?i T2T17 2.025 tETT Zb"I iII IcP 75f IIIcP

25.09.2012 (m9T Tf 20.09.2012 3Ibc1 'iI 'IICk'i) i c'T&T ftcN.1

cc1Il m Pt 31I I~1Ic 25.09.2012 iii.wi

c cpIii 1T, ICP'1 cbdcI I R

25.09.2012 cIIcl Pc'i R1i I 3T9W RlIc'1'-I 'Z3gYCp 'ill— III

* R-ic cPHICP 182 I.1Icb 13.02.2015 * 3111R Wc1I'ii [Ic..1 t fMr

25.09.2012 * 3dI' ilIcP'1 1iic 11.03.2015 TT II--II ift

-iRi.ici Pitici frfr 15'I 1,05,66,714/— 1I'1cP iri wTa5w gm &1Fff

I-iicp 16.12.2014 31-cl4cl F[ et'qiT IT-T t~T 6,68,350/-

c'1IIc1t'L.2

- 2 - 1ii'-) iii 1710/2015/*.1

cf) ~ r4 1 q57 c1I'jl Z5'1 t i1bci ct 31I?I f , Riic { t

31 3IT1P t f5 1I t flI1c1 1I

14 3ffR qq qRq5 ci cc

I~.1IcP 10.12.2014 it 3111R R &[ 'ilI tii{I I PHiI) Rk-i -cci f5 51T

tq ftfq7 &ffrzN, 1963 ThT 5 -ci [ci ir Ti TM qjq 1) I

TZ1TI

3. Pi'vtil N-c,c1 i1IcP" R 0 14 t 3TlTThIJt Z c1c1l 14TU TR[I 3TT t&-1 I 2 T 9Tf 1 Ni { i

3TT *1'S I 2 Ri t 1T TOZF ti Z5J I Ri co 3TPT4 Rl9-I I 1 T I

4 ci'<U 1 3WTtt I

5. '71 Riii 3T RMZMq t 3IIIc qUfl

Rbli 1:5 flIthT 7WRT # f1cPLl *c1Ii1 1'iici' 25.09.2012 qt Rii-I~ci 1~bI t,

f~lt T4 fiRic1 cP1 tq 1TTT 751 1?iici' 10.12.2014 i'c,ci Ri t j

1 fTT 1I-Y1 * l5T 1Tr RicN.I 751 Pii frf 25.09.2012

r &irr 1iiici' Ri t vi ci ffcf5 4c1ci'i Rici' t Tf goco cl'cI *

31TIT t151 IIicP 10.12.2014 T5'I 111T 9I.ICP RbLH 'JII'II tU1L 291 -P

9l1'- tz1c1l- IIe1 11 *1CPk f 3TI frIl9

-iiRci Riu1i (2007) 19 tzRi 355 ti 6NIull Ir-1 t l•-lF'-I

11'1'.iI c1l' 2010 (2) RRT 731 iRicp ci-i si*cJ,c1 fi I

6. qIc tR\5'-ç&T Rcpj. 15T 3Tcic'i'1cp-j Rb.lI 6IH W T9f RbII

-LlI1Ic PIU1Ll Ri1- I cPl -

7. TT l*c,cl RT 5 1Ic &fTfgpr zFT W41T tf g2

UIUI Z 3flJ tR -ci" jIc1 *c1)ci'k 1! lIcP 3T

11Ic T1T rII61 *1

8. fflwrr l ci' ' UJ 31[[2 *1S.1! 1 TFF& 3T1T 'is'4 I 2 ZT5T T'T

cpI.lI TlT, 3fEff 'ii-&ii f4qM II 1'iici' 25.09.2012 TT ?lZT RI rrr t I

Ri cl' .I Y 4-i ci' I ci' I UI 3T1T2 *1 I 1 Ff Ri ct' -i t

4 1Ri0 cp 75 WT tJ 3I1Rcrcl c(fci') 'si 1~ijci'

10.12.2014 Z151 lcc1 R1I 9 1 3T9W IIIc'i 3'f Y51cP WqV III cic*H1Ll

it cicPi Ru1c I 3'T 14Ci' R1RP 25.09.2012 * aTMR TRT cic'W-I1

Tcq Rg u1ci it t Rjiic 31TR ER 3Tt9T I1Ic

1-JIR'1.1c1 0 1,05,66,714/— TF?t IIci' Mtlf1d ljs4 icb 311I zFt 5oiEF wrRTT

0 1,30,770/— G.LlIj1 '4 1,30,770/—, 311'ilRIcl Ci'c 1 0 2,61,540/— it

cl 0 9,29,890/— l5f ci' t[ *f 0 6,68,350/— rr r cb c'i) clI.l * 31I~ f *1

a m2ff (RiII-1cPclI) 'I'r1 tTT d RikI - J 3TTT f 3TThT - I .1 I el 'L4 I 'ii T1 Ri' 311RTTI ThT 35, 36, V,4 45 1T 'ZffT f

e1IIc1I' .... 3

- 3 - 1II *9.II 1710/2015/

ft9T {~1cP 751 PI-1IIc1 R'iicp 25.09.2012 ZT5t 3I11R l-iI9cP i-'-i1i I5T jcicP1

1b.iI t i"-i1 T c1cp'i ffqM q iPci W\,-4 tq i*7 1icp

10.12.2014 qt 3ITT 9I'1cP, iF?i T Towff ctj g ffqTi:F 15 C1ç'j f ni

C 31Il f iit z1 i

10. fTTf J {I f5 zFT t1 ffwzr t

fi1 fff r wmz 1Th1ct 1bi iN1I ci f tl1L T f4cPLl q51 c t Ti

lIc1 cre (1ct) * -cci ct t frfr r 31TElT 1vIcP'

ii-iRi t5T cIctI 1bLli ilI'1I tiiI I T3T. jcP fffrP1 1998 TI £TRT 45 I5T

t-J -çcp Pt'-'i S.cpk

"Provided that where any instrument executed or first executed is brought

to the Collector after the expiration of one month from the date of its execution or first

execution, such instrument shall be chargeable with duty as applicable at the time of

its presentation before the Collector under this section."

39cc1 ftfTh ifT t f 10 1WRi c1ci

cpcc (i(15) * TET !.*c,c1 1iicp t 3UTP 1I1cP' 1'-Y1I ?T5T

c'IcP'1 1bu 'ilI'lI tii1 I

11. T {ii 3TfTtf15 PkVicPc1I cj,c1 IMct) c1

1I'1 '3zz 1l -L1ILlI TT I"1 (1ctI frfl9 Ucp f 'e1*I

iIci Pi4q (2007) 19 t4U 314c 355 TT 1c1ci')l"1 c51I j)rj tMI 1I'14

\3tz10 9 74MT M 3ctc1 .-..iI{cl, TZFcT cpI 904I1c1 {bi

"We are of the opinion that the view taken by the learned single Judge as well as by

the Division Bench cannot be sustained and the same is set aside. The Collector shall

determine what was the valuation of the instrument on the basis of the market value

of the property at the date when the document was tendered by the respondent for

registration, and the respondent shall pay the stamp duty charges and surcharges, if

any, as assessed by the Collector as per the provisions of the Act."

\314ctc1 - U1CP I -ç1 T II.uiI it afe At t i cc1I\j1 5T 9Icfi

cc1I~7 Z jlLtI tq wqu { -IicP qt 31TE1T 1I.IC {.H 51I'1!

iiil zc11 lILlIei.1 TT 6R1uII I's'.l [ 3TI i'ii-i

* i1ct, 11 2010 (2) RRT 731 ZT Ricici 1iRci 1bL1I 11R1T t f5 f4çFM

iq~MI 'i t ci M * HzffRO t.1TRt. *3T- ii

t i-nIici f-itfr Zft lIcP' 711I' t P/i41 eP C1c'I 1bI

jlIcP'. c1Il Glz5 1i r Hct)c1I

\3ctcl -4i1icp cc.I-c1 5T *I'&-lI 39 14 42 cFT '3cI *cJ,cI 45 -1i 'i4'Itil'1

"39. It is not disputed that the commercial plot of 788 sq. yards located at Delhi-

Mathura Mewla Maharajpur, Faridabad was valued by the Circle rate at Rs. 4,200/- per

sq. yard fixed by the Collector of Faridabad meaning thereby that after the notificatior 011

M 411 H I

- 4 - 1ii4l 1541 I7I0/2015/i4t

no sale deed can be registered for an amount lesser than Rs. 4200/- per sq. yard. It may

be pertinent to mention that, in order to ensure that there is no evasion of stamp duty,

circle rates are fixed from time to time and the notification is issued to that effect. The

issuance of said notification has become imperative to arrest the tendency of evading

the payment of actual stamp duty. It is a matter of common knowledge that usually the

circle rate or the Collector rate is lower than the prevalent actual market rate but to

ensure registration of sale deeds at least at the circle rates or the Collecter rates such

notifications are issued from time to time by the appellants.

"42. In the facts and circumstances of the case, the impugned judgment of the

High Court cannot by sustained and is accordingly set aside and the order passed by the

District Collector, Faridabad which was upheld by the Commissioner, Gurgaon is

restored. The respondent is directed to pay the balance stamp duty within four weeks

from the date of this judgement, otherwise the appellants would be at liberty to take

appropriate steps in accordance with law."

12. 1cic1 1z'i * &F.1R tR PIkI4) *C)ctk [2 CUJ 31FRqci

ct(1cI) r f4qm q5F zfr ci1ci cl tg i*cj,ci W\1-4 R.-flcp

10.12.2014 T5't 1rcl1 DLC 1T4 Cr1 qr 3318R 1I -IcP 1cIcP9 Zb Ic

cic4) tg Ithi ftIT 5lN1I 'zRci *1

Z3JII

'i"u1ctci {zi.1 tt f2l q U I z tR III'-icOlt Nc),ci II -

410I 3T9W -'1I1Ic1'L1 45f [ {uf I~IIcP 11.03.2015 f1*ci 14Tii

Icc1I Tfftff 3WTtTT t ftcfM 75r ?51 i1bci

1~-iict, 10.12.2014 3IT1R 11I.-IcP' IcI-I

Icb ftT1T 74 c11I' &fFf CP14c1I) Tl 3TTh9W I'.1Ic1Ll

5T {u it WliPRi fff 1Ic1 fN1clN.B 0 [UQ 41j{Ic1 irfr 11"-c1

tT1cPkI.-I 5't 4 lTl .IICIC' '1 iN Z15T -Iiei ii'c l