4
www.MasterBond.com tel +1.201.343.8983 fax +1.201.343.2132 [email protected] 154 Hobart Street Hackensack, NJ 07601 USA How to Evaluate Chemically Resistant Adhesives A guide to selecting the adhesives, sealants and coatings that can withstand harsh chemical environments TECH SPOTLIGHT

How to Evaluate Chemically Resistant Adhesives · 2011. 12. 7. · Master Bond Inc. | TEL: +1 (201) 343-8983 [email protected] 1 How to Evaluate Chemically Resistant Adhesives

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    4

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: How to Evaluate Chemically Resistant Adhesives · 2011. 12. 7. · Master Bond Inc. | TEL: +1 (201) 343-8983 whitepaper@masterbond.com 1 How to Evaluate Chemically Resistant Adhesives

w w w . M a s t e r B o n d . c o mt e l + 1 . 2 0 1 . 3 4 3 . 8 9 8 3f a x + 1 . 2 0 1 . 3 4 3 . 2 1 3 2

W h i t e P a p e r @ M a s t e r B o n d . c o m1 5 4 H o b a r t S t r e e t

H a c k e n s a c k , N J 0 7 6 0 1 U S A

How to Evaluate ChemicallyResistant Adhesives

A guide to selecting the adhesives, sealants and coatingsthat can withstand harsh chemical environments

T E C H S P O T L I G H T

Page 2: How to Evaluate Chemically Resistant Adhesives · 2011. 12. 7. · Master Bond Inc. | TEL: +1 (201) 343-8983 whitepaper@masterbond.com 1 How to Evaluate Chemically Resistant Adhesives

1Master Bond Inc. | TEL: +1 (201) 343-8983 | www.masterbond.com | [email protected]

How to Evaluate Chemically Resistant AdhesivesA guide to selecting the adhesives, sealants and coatings that can withstand harsh chemical environments

T E C H S P O T L I G H T

Of all the factors that should be considered when

selecting adhesive products, chemical exposure too often

gets short shrift. A quick peek at a few data sheets or a

chemical resistance chart may be all the work that goes

into evaluating an adhesive product for use in a specific

chemical environment.

Yet this kind of half-hearted effort simply won’t cut it

if you want to make sure that adhesives, sealants and

encapsulants will withstand the chemicals found in so many

industrial, medical, automotive and aerospace applications.

All polymers, including adhesives, have potential chemical

vulnerabilities that can result in a loss of physical properties

(see sidebar). The challenge is knowing exactly how those

vulnerabilities will come into play given all the variables that

govern the effects of chemical exposures.

These variables start with the interaction of material

systems with specific chemicals. The challenge here is that

there are literally thousands of combinations of substrate

materials, adhesives and chemical agents to consider.

The variables also include the type of exposure, which

can range from a splash to continuous immersion. Finally,

chemical resistance can vary substantially under different

mechanical and thermal loads.

Getting a handle on how all these variables interact can

be difficult and time-consuming. But the information that

follows will give you a head start in picking adhesives that

will hold fast against any chemical onslaught.

Understand Chemical Interactions

The first thing to understand about adhesives and

chemicals is that there is no single adhesive that’s the best

1

Engineers today have to account for a large number

of individualized chemical exposures when designing

products, which can complicate the adhesive selection

process. Yet, there are some adhesives and sealants

that have established themselves within specific

industries. Here’s a closer look at them:

Aerospace. EP41S-1HT and EP62-1, epoxies for bonding

and sealing applications, have a broad resistance to

aviation fuels and hydraulic fluids, including Skydrol.

Electronics. EP21ARHT is an epoxy well-suited to

the acids encountered in semiconductor and other

electronics manufacturing processes.

OEM. EP41S-1HT has a track record as a coating

material for chemical tanks. EP21TPND makes a good

tank coating material for acid environments.

Medical. EP42HT-2 and EP62-1MED are epoxies that

hold up particularly well to repeated, aggressive

sterilization methods—including autoclaving and

chemical sterilization.

Oil and Gas. Downhole applications can subject

adhesives, sealants and coatings to temperatures up

to 450°F and a variety of polymer-aggressive oils,

hydraulic fluids, gases and abrasives. Supreme 45HTQ,

an extremely durable mineral-filled epoxy, is one of the

few adhesives that perform well in this environment.

Product Guide By Application

Page 3: How to Evaluate Chemically Resistant Adhesives · 2011. 12. 7. · Master Bond Inc. | TEL: +1 (201) 343-8983 whitepaper@masterbond.com 1 How to Evaluate Chemically Resistant Adhesives

2Master Bond Inc. | TEL: +1 (201) 343-8983 | www.masterbond.com | [email protected]

choice for every chemical environment. It is true that some

adhesive families are known for having a broad resistance

to many types of chemicals. Epoxies clearly lead the pack

in this regard. Polyurethanes, silicones, UV curables and

polysulfides can all provide acceptable chemical resistance

against a more limited range of chemicals, though they

cannot stand up to nearly as many chemical environments

as epoxies.

It’s also true that within each adhesive family, thermal and

chemical resistance often go hand in hand. Cross-linked

adhesives, like the ones just mentioned, tend to have

the best chemical resistance below their glass transition

temperatures (Tg). So grades with higher Tg can often beat

the heat and tolerate more chemicals.

Generalities, however, will only get you so far in the

adhesive selection process. Keep in mind that adhesive

chemistries can vary substantially even within a family.

Individual grades of adhesives can have different functional

additives and curing reactions that will affect their ability to

withstand chemicals.

Consider epoxies. As a family, they are the most chemically

resistant adhesives, encapsulants and coatings available.

But individual epoxy formulations do differ in their specific

chemical resistance traits. You can see just how different

epoxies can be in Table One, which shows the relative

resistance of epoxy coatings to a lineup of industrial

chemicals, solvents and fuels. For example, assuming

that all epoxies will resist ethyl alcohol just because some

grades resist ethyl alcohol can be a big mistake.

So it’s always important to consider the resistance of

individual grades to specific chemical exposures. This

strategy applies not just to epoxies but also to any other

adhesives that will see use in a chemical environment.

Understand the Exposure Variables

Figuring out which adhesives will withstand which

chemicals is really only half the battle. It’s also necessary

to understand the type of exposure. On the most basic

level, exposures should be characterized by the intensity

of contact with a chemical agent. Low intensity exposures

are best thought of as a splash. Higher intensity exposures

would involve immersion that could be intermittent or

continuous. Note that exposures can involve gases, not just

liquids.

Chemical exposures should be considered in the context

of the application’s thermal and mechanical loads. Many

adhesives can experience an incremental loss of chemical

resistance at elevated temperatures—especially above the

Tg. High stresses also exacerbate any adverse effects that

a chemical agent has on adhesive or cohesive strength.

Adhesive and chemical combinations that make the grade

under one set of loading conditions won’t necessarily make

it in others.

All these of variables may sound straightforward, but

mischaracterizing the type of exposure is a surprisingly

common mistake. And it’s a mistake with potentially serious

ramifications. Understating the intensity of exposure or

the severity of the loads can obviously result in adhesive

products that don’t perform as well as expected, perhaps

even to the point of failure.

Usually, prudent design engineers tend to overstate

exposure or loads. That strategy, while safe and appropriate

up to a point, can limit the number of suitable adhesive

products for a given application. Why? Because for any

potentially harmful chemical agent, there are many more

adhesives that can resist splashes, low temperatures

and low stresses than there are adhesives that can resist

continuous immersion, high temperatures and high stresses.

The consequences of over-engineering for chemical

resistance are two-fold. One is that you could end up

trading off other desirable adhesive properties for a level of

chemical resistance the application doesn’t really require.

The other is that adhesives with the very best chemical

resistance are apt to have more difficult mixing and

curing regiments, potentially bumping up assembly costs

unnecessarily.

Understand Testing

Because it’s crucial to get the details of chemical

exposure right, it is a good idea to test bonding, sealing

and encapsulation applications that could be subject to

harmful chemical interactions. There are dozens of ASTM

and industry-specific tests that attempt to capture these One part UV curable Master Bond UV18S offers

outstanding chemical resistance, easy application

and low shrinkage upon cure.

Page 4: How to Evaluate Chemically Resistant Adhesives · 2011. 12. 7. · Master Bond Inc. | TEL: +1 (201) 343-8983 whitepaper@masterbond.com 1 How to Evaluate Chemically Resistant Adhesives

3Master Bond Inc. | TEL: +1 (201) 343-8983 | www.masterbond.com | [email protected]

interactions. General Motors alone has more than 30

adhesives specifications, many of which contain conditions

related to chemical or moisture exposure.

Whatever the test that is most accepted in your particular

industry, keep in mind that testing at best only approximates

real-world conditions. Consider that ASTM D896, one of

the most widely cited standards for adhesive chemical

resistance, does not make any distinction between chemical

adsorption in the bulk adhesive or penetration at the

adhesive-substrate interface. Yet this difference is one of the

key factors in an adhesive’s chemical degradation behavior.

Most test regimens also require shorter term exposures

than real-world applications. Some military tests subject

adhesives to immersion in fuels and hydraulic fluid for just

one week and to high-humidity conditions for 30 days.

Real-world exposures can obviously last much longer.

Here at Master Bond, our technical service engineers

don’t put much credence in short-term test data, relying

instead on our unique own database of long-term exposure

data. Some of this chemical exposure data comes from

immersion tests that have lasted as long as ten years. And

our long-term data covers many combinations of adhesives

and chemicals—including many organic and inorganic acids,

alcohols, chlorinated compounds, hydrocarbons, solvents

and more.

A related issue involves accelerated testing, which exposes

adhesives to exaggerated loading conditions for short time

periods in an effort to yield predictions about much longer

service life. Many times, these test regimens will elevate

temperatures to the point that they introduce thermal

effects that a product would never experience in the field.

Because actual service temperature is such an integral part

of any adhesive’s true chemical resistance, accelerated

testing can actually point engineers in the wrong directions.

For example, epoxies that might be an excellent choice in

a room-temperature chemical environment can be made to

fail at accelerated testing temperatures.

None of these warnings should be construed as an

argument that testing should not take place. It should. Just

bear in mind that test conditions often deviate substantially

from real-world exposure conditions and time scales.

An effective adhesives selection strategy, then, requires

engineers to evaluate specific chemical-and-adhesive

combinations in the context of exposure and loading

conditions that are as close as possible to the expected

service conditions. That’s a lot more effort than picking

adhesives from a chemical resistance chart, but it’s a small

price to pay for some confidence that you’ve picked the

right adhesive for the job.

For further information on this article, for answers to any adhesives applications questions, or for information on any Master Bond products, please contact our technical experts at Tel: +1 (201) 343-8983.

Polymer System WaterEthyl

AlcoholMEK

Ethylene Glycol

Acetone Jet Fuel10%

Sulfuric Acid

70%Sulfuric

Acid

10%NitricAcid

10% Hydrochloric

Acid

10% Sodium

Hydroxide

50%Sodium

Hydroxide

50% Potassium Hydroxide

EP21LV E F F G F G E NR F F E G G

EP21TP-2 E F F G F E F NR NR F G F F

EP21AR-HT E G G E G E E E E E E G G

EP30-2 E G G E G E E F F G E E E

EP30HT E F G E G E G F F F E E E

EP39-2 E G G E G E G F G G E E E

EP41S-MED E F F E F E E F F F E E E

EP41S-HT E E E E E E E F G G E E E

EP42-HT-2 E G G E G/E E E F/G G G E E E

EP45-HT E E E E E E E G E E E E E

EP62-1 E E E E E E E E E E E E E

UV18S E F G G F/G G G/E NR F F E G G

KEY: E = Excellent G = Good F = Fair NR = Not recommended

Chemical Resistance of Master Bond Two-Component EpoxiesCoatings and Tank Lining Compounds at Ambient Temperatures