Upload
logan-hopkins
View
224
Download
0
Tags:
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
History of Research Project on CCA-Treated Wood
Presented May 6, 2002Gainesville, Florida
Funding Received from
Florida Center for Solid and Hazardous Waste Mngt.
Florida Power and LightSarasota County
Florida Department of Environmental ProtectionFlorida International University/National Institute for
Environmental Health Science
Helena Solo-Gabriele, Ph.D., P.E.,
Assoc. Prof., Civil/Environ. Engrg
Timothy Townsend, Ph.D.
Assoc. Prof., Environ/Solid Waste Engrg
Yong Cai, Ph.D.
Assist. Prof., Chemistry
Active Faculty Researchers
Students Supported on Project Sean Bennie Kenneth Brown Vandin Calitu Brajesh Dubey Tim Franklin Kelvin Gary Myron Georgiadis Naila Hosein Kendiro Iida Gary Jacobi Jenna Jambeck Bernine Khan
Monika Kormienko Brian Messick Tom Moskal Jennifer Penha Donna May Sakura Catalina Santamaria Ajay Seth Jin-Kun Song Kristin Stook Thabet Tolaymat Lakmini Wadanambi
Background
CCA-Treated Wood is the most common wood preservative used today (>80% market)
CCA ---> Chromated Copper Arsenate
Background
Above Ground
Structural PolesSaltwater Splash
Saltwater ImmersionPole/Pilings
pcf = pounds of CCA per cubic foot of wood
20,000 mg/kg As
2,000 mg/kg As
Background
CCA ---> Chromated Copper ArsenateThe treated wood contains very high concentrations of Cr, Cu, and As
As toxic, known carcinogen
Soil background levels for arsenic in Florida are low
Strict disposal guidelines
Why Was this Project Initiated?
High metals concentrations were observed in the ash from wood cogeneration facilities located in Florida
Year 1 (1996-1997)
Year 1: Disposal Forecast
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
3519
64
1968
1972
1976
1980
1984
1988
1992
1996
2000
2004
2008
2012
2016
2020
2024
2028
2032
2036
2040
2044
Year
Mill
ion
ft3
, dis
po
se
d
No Change in CCA Use
Today Hypothetical Case
If 100% Alt. Chem.Sold by 2002
C&D LandfillMSW Landfill
C&D Debris Recycling Facilities
CCA-WoodRemoved
from Service
Processed Wood (6% CCA in 1996)
Land Application
Wood Fuel Facility Ash
Year 2 (1997-1998)
Year 2
Develop Tools for Disposal End Management
Leaching Studies, ash Hazardous when CCA-treated wood represents
5% of wood burned
Solvents can extract metals from ash, citric acid very promising (40 to 100% As removed) ------> Explore Potential Recycling?
Year 2 (continued)
Sorting Studies, Laboratory Chemical stains, low capital cost
labor intensive
X-ray methods, high capital costsuitable for on-line system
Untreated Treated
Year 3 (1998-1999)
Year 3
Disposal-End Management
Field Demonstration of Sorting Technologies Stains suitable for sorting small quantities of wood
Evaluation of Pyrolysis Technology Appears promising for ultimate disposal
Resource book for Wood Disposal Sector
Year 3 (Continued) Alternative Chemicals
Four Promising Alternative Chemicals for CCA: ACQ, CBA, CC, CDDC
All standardized for applications requiring 0.25 & 0.4 pcf Comparable to CCA: efficacy
Leach less As but generally more Cu
Cost 10 to 30% more at retail establishment
Ash Problem
Inventory
SortingLab
Ash Char & Trt
SortingField
Alt. Chem.Lit Review
Year 1
Year 2
Year 3
The Research Team Was Invited to the Minnesota Proceedings
Minnesota’s Listed Metals Advisory Council[Cd, Pb, Hg, and Cr(VI)]
Speciation Debated
In-Service Issues Debated
Lack of Scientific Data
Year 3 Supplemental
Impacts of CCA on Soil during In-Service Use
Use Sectors for CCA-Treated Wood
Leaching of CCA-treated Wood and C&D Debris Wood Mulch
Literature Reviews, Alt. Chem.Cr & As Speciation
Minnesota
Lit ReviewsAlt Chem, As, Cr Spec
DeckStudy
Leaching Wood & Mulch
UseSectors
Leaching of CCA During In-Service Use
Year 3 Supplemental
Leaching of CCA-Treated Wood During In-Service Use
Year 3 Supplemental
Chemicals Do Leach from CCA-treated Wood During In-Service Use
Leaching of CCA-Treated Wood During In-Service Use
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
90
BP BR PP LT TB MG AD TP OP
Ars
en
ic C
on
cen
tra
tio
n (
mg
/kg
)
Control Under Deck
Gainesville MiamiTallahasseeNot CCA-Treated
FDEP Industrial SCTL
Leaching of CCA-Treated Wood During In-Service Use
0
2
4
6
8
10
12
0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80
Arsenic Concentration (mg/kg)
Approximately 39 square miles of Florida land covered by CCA-treated decks. Top 8 inches of this area would correspond to 60 million tons of soil.
Use Sectors for CCA-Treated Wood
Year 3 Supplemental
Use Sectors for CCA-Treated Wood
Marine & Freshwater Applications
16%
Outdoor Decks, Landscaping,
Fences, & Highway
Construction
Utility Poles5%
Alternative ChemicalTreated Wood Available for These Uses
79%
Year 3 Supplemental
28,600 tons of As, Cumulative
1600 tons Asimported per year In-service losses (10%):
2900 tons
Disposed to date:1600 tons
Future disposal(for that imported through 2000):
24,100 tons
Year 3 Supplemental
Leaching of CCA-treated Wood and
C&D Debris Wood Mulch
Year 3 Supplemental
Leaching of CCA-Treated Wood
0
5
10
15
20
25
30
35
40
TCLP SPLP EPTOX WET
As
Co
nce
ntr
atio
n (
mg
/L)
Sawdust
Chipped Wood
5 20-g Blocks
100-g Block
TCLP Limit
Leaching of Mulch
Samples No. No. Exceeding GWCTL for As
No. Exceeding GWCTL for Cr
C&D Debris 20 18 5
Yard Waste 3 1 1
Colored Mulch
3 2 0
Vegetative Mulch
3 0 0
Year 3 Supplemental
Ash Problem
Inventory
SortingLab
Ash Char & Trt
SortingField
Alt. Chem.Lit Review
Minnesota
Lit ReviewAlt Chem, As, Cr Spec
DeckStudy
Leaching Wood & Mulch
UseSectorsSorting
Field
FDEP/SarasotaInnovative Recycling Grant
laser
x-ray
Innovative Recycling Grant
Output signal for detection of treated wood
Strobe LightOn -Positive
Alt ChemLeach/Tox
UnderReview
As & Cr Spec
On-going
Mulch Study
Proposed
Ash Problem
Inventory
SortingLab
Ash Char & Trt
SortingField
Alt. Chem.Lit Review
Minnesota
Lit ReviewAlt Chem, As, Cr Spec
DeckStudy
Leaching
Wood & Mulch
UseSectors
SortingField
FDEP/SarasotaInnovative Recycling GrantCompleted
Add’l Deck & Dock
FIU/NIEHSOn-going
Alt ChemLeach/Tox
UnderReview
As & Cr Spec
On-going
Mulch Study
Proposed
Ash Problem
Inventory
SortingLab
Ash Char & Trt
SortingField
Alt. Chem.Lit Review
Minnesota
Lit ReviewAlt Chem, As, Cr Spec
DeckStudy
Leaching
Wood & Mulch
UseSectors
SortingField
FDEP/SarasotaInnovative Recycling GrantCompleted
Add’l Deck & Dock
FIU/NIEHSOn-going
Questions?Comments?
Reports available atwww.ccaresearch.org