Highlight Conclusions - Karapinar Study Site

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 7/31/2019 Highlight Conclusions - Karapinar Study Site

    1/17

    Ilxlrnolx+ T}xim~ Rlam 22%>>> >> =/222%

    >/>>>

    >>

    82/222%

    8=/222

    32/222%

    42/222

    12/222%

  • 7/31/2019 Highlight Conclusions - Karapinar Study Site

    6/17

    Ilxlrnolx+ T}xim~ Rlam 7

    lod mcjojenc%sjcnlk }oxmst/ Tfm el`jxnt~ jg tfm glxemxs &77-. tfnoi tflt tfm cjenoa dl~s qnkk hm qjxsm

    tflo tfm rlst/

    Mvrkjntltnjo jg klod xmsj}xcms ns lt l elvne}e tfj}af wnkklamxs flwm l dmmr nosnaft notj cl}sm lod mggmct

    qntf xmalxd tj dmaxldltnjo rfmojemol/ Oj emls}xms flwm lrrlxmotk~ hmmo tlimo qntf xmsrmct tj qnod

    mxjsnjo h~ glxemxs tfmesmkwms/ Emldjqs lxm stnkk }odmx }ktneltm mvrkjntltnjo qntfj}t lo~ g}t}xm

    rmxsrmctnwm lod kmanskltnwm xmstx}ct}xnoa/ Tfm elno dxnwmx hmfnod tfmsm lrrlxmot ldwmxsm snt}ltnjos lxm

    lkql~s rxmss}xm jg tfm elximt tflt ns sj gk}ct}ltnoa lod }ostlhkm/ Md}cltnoa tfm kjclk rmjrkm qntf

    nogjxeltnjo lhj}t omqmx laxnc}kt}xlk tmcfon|}ms jg qfltmwmx inod h~ ajwmxoemotlk jxalonpltnjos ns

    lkejst lhsmot/

    Nostnt}tnjolk lod rjkntnclk smttnoa

    Sjnk Elolamemot no tfm st}d~ lxml ns elnok~ lcfnmwmd h~ tfm hxlocf jg l stltm jxalonpltnjo &Amomxlk

    Dnxmctjxltm jg X}xlk Smxwncms+ Sjnk lod Qltmx Xmsmlxcf Nostnt}tm+ Rxjwnocnlk Laxnc}kt}xlk Dnxmctjxltm./ Tfm

    gjxemx jxalonpltnjo ns xmcmotk~ jggncnlkk~ hj}od tj kjclk ajwmxojxs lod nts mggnclc~ ns wmx~ kjq/ Sjnk lod

    qltmx Xmsmlxcf Nostnt}tm ns dnxmctk~ l}tfjxnpmd tj hlttkm qntf tfm qnod mxjsnjo lod tfns fls hmmo

    s}ccmssg}kk~ djom }otnk xmcmotk~/ H}t dmcxmlsnoa jggncnlk xmsmlxcf g}ods lkkjcltmd tj tfns cjerlo~ xmgxlno

    lctnwntnms/

    Qntfno tfm hj}odlx~ jg tfm e}oncnrlknt~ klod }sm dmcnsnjo%elimx ns tfm e}oncnrlknt~ hjlxd mkmctmd h~ tfm

    cnt~s rmjrkm/ Tfmxm ns l qmlktf jg glxemx jxalonpltnjos jo tfm nss}ms jg g}odnoa+ nxxnaltnjo+ gmxtnknpltnjo mtc/

    L xmcmotk~ nostlkkmd kjclk lolk~sns glcnknt~ ns lksj lwlnklhkm/

    TMEL ns tfm jok~ cj}otx~qndm OAJ no tmxes jg dmsmxtngncltnjo tflt rl~noa snaongnclot md}cltnjo mggjxts jg

    dnggmxmot kmwmks &gjx r}rnks+ wnkklamxs mtc/./ Sfm sjemtnems kmlds gjx xmgjxmstltnjo lctnwntnms lod jtfmx sjcnlk

    rxj`mcts tjj/

    Tfm mvnstnoa klq &oj0 =423. jo sjnk rxmsmxwltnjo lod klod }sm ns mggmctnwm snocm 822=/ Lccjxdnoa tj klq lod

    xmkltmd xma}kltnjos+ l sjnk rxjtmctnjo hjlxd fmldmd h~ kjclk ajwmxojx &wlkn. qls gjxemd no mlcf rxjwnocm tj

    rxjwndm lkk inods jg nosnafts jo tfm nss}ms jg klod }sm lod sjnk rxmsmxwltnjo/ Tfns stx}ct}xm lksj ns

    l}tfjxnpmd tj dmcndm lod elim xmsmlxcfms jo klod dmaxldltnjo rxjcmssms lod omq sjnk rxmsmxwltnjo

    rxj`mcts/ Ls l amomxlk wnmq jg mvnstnoa kmanskltnwm snt}ltnjo+ elno alr ns no tfm cjjxdnoltnjo jg wlxnj}s

    nostnt}tnjos lod stx}ct}xm xmkltmd tj klod }sm lod sjnk rxjtmctnjo/ Kjq clrlcnt~ jg tfm cj}otx~ no cxmltnoa

    e}ktndnscnrknolx~ st}dnms+ ls qmkk ls klci jg hlsm dltl lod elrs jo klod }sm lod sjnk rxjtmctnjo gjxes jtfmx

    el`jx hjttkmomcis/

    Mvtmosnjo lod txlnonoa smxwncms no tfm Ilxlrolx fjtsrjt ns mvtxmemk~ sclxcm/ Wnkklamxs |}jtmd snenklx tj

    jtfmx T}xinsf fjtsrjt Msinmfnx+ tflt tfmxm ns oj rmxnjdnc nogjxeltnjo gkjq anwmo h~ xmkltmd stltm

    nostnt}tnjos/ Ls qntf tfjsm nostnt}tnjos+ lwlnklhnknt~ jg s}ntlhkm &o}ehmx+ |}lknt~ mtc/. rmxsjoomk ns wmx~ xlxm

    ejstk~ d}m tj mvnstnoa stltm rmxsjoomk xmanem &n/m/ txmod tj dmcxmlsm o}ehmx jg jggncnlks./ No j}x jrnonjo

    hlsmd jo tfm mvrmxnmocm jg stx}ct}xnoa DMSNXM rxj`mct lt tfm hmanoonoa+ kjoa klstnoa rjkntnclk t}xejnk lktmxs

    tmcfonclk stlgg tjj/ Wnkklamxs gxm|}motk~ cjerklno tflt tfm mvtmosnjo stlggs rxmgmx stl~noa lt jggncms nostmld

    jg nogjxenoa glxemxs no tfm gnmkd/

  • 7/31/2019 Highlight Conclusions - Karapinar Study Site

    7/17

    Ilxlrnolx+ T}xim~ Rlam 1

    Xmkmwlot mod%}smxs * stlimfjkdmx axj}rs

    Stltm Qltmx Qjxis+ Ijo~l Hxlocf0 Tfm kjclk hxlocf jg tfm rxnelx~ mvmc}tnwm stltm lamoc~ gjxmknenoltnjo jg ldwmxsm mggmcts jg T}xim~s s}xglcm lod axj}odqltmx lod r}ttnoa tfme no r}hknc

    }tnknpltnjo no wlxnj}s ql~s s}cf ls f~dxjrjqmx+ nxxnaltnjo+ djemstnc lod nod}stxnlk }sm / Sjnk lodQltmx Xmsmlxcf Nostnt}tm0 Hxlocf jg lo jxalonpltnjo &Tfm Enonstx~ jg Laxnc}kt}xm lod X}xlk

    Smxwncm. lnemd lt tfm Dmwmkjremot+ cjosmxwltnjo jx s}ntlhkm mvrkjntltnjo jg tfm sjnk lod qltmx

    xmsj}xcms/

    Amomxlk Dnxmctjxltm jg Rxjwnocnlk Laxnc}kt}xm+ Ijo~l hxlocf0 L ajwmxoemotlk jxalonpltnjoxmsrjosnhkm gjx tfm rxjejtnjo jg laxnc}kt}xlk lctnwntnms qntfno tfm rxjwnocnlk hj}odlxnms/

    Rxjwnocnlk Dnxmctjxltm gjx tfm Mownxjoemot lod Gjxmstx~0 Kjclk stltm hxlocf xmsrjosnhkm gjxxmgjxmstltnjo lod mownxjoemotlk xmflhnkntltnjo lod rxjtmctnjo/

    TMEL0 L T}xinsf OAJ gjx cjehltnoa sjnk mxjsnjo+ gjx xmstjxltnjo lod rxjtmctnjo jg olt}xlkflhntlts/

    Gj}odltnjo Gjx Tfm Xmnogjxcmemot jg tfm Amomxlk Dnxmctjxltm jg Oltnjolk Rlxis lod Alem%QnkdKngm 0 L T}xinsf OAJ gjc}smd jo tfm rxjtmctnjo jg mownxjoemot qntf nts qnkd kngm/

    ]OCCD Oltnjolk Gjclk rjnot0 Tfm oltnjolk cjoomctnjo rjnot lalnost dmsmxtngncltnjo gj}odmd }odmxtfm Xmsmlxcf+ rkloonoa lod cj%jxdnoltnjo hjlxd jg tfm Enonstx~ jg Mownxjoemot lod Gjxmstx~/

    Ilxlrolx E}oncnrlknt~0 Dmcnsnjo elimx lod mvmc}tnjo l}tfjxnt~ qntfno tfm e}oncnrlknt~ hj}odlx~qntf xmsrmct tj klod elolamemot lod xmkltmd s}h`mcts/

    Kjclk Nxxnaltnjo ]onjos0 Tfm }onjo jg wnkklamxs &mod%}smxs. gjx rxjwnsnjo jg s}xglcm lod axj}odqltmxs tj tfmnx glxes/

    Kjclk Glxemx ]onjos0 Tfm }onjo jg wnkklamxs gjx nocxmlsnoa tfm cxjr lej}ot lod |}lknt~/ Ensonstx~ jg Oltnjolk Md}cltnjo+ Dnxmctjxltm jg Ilxlrolx Dnstxnct0 Ajwmxoemotlk jxalonpltnjo+

    l}tfjxnpmd gjx tfm md}cltnjo jg cfnkdxmo gxje rxnelx~ scfjjk tj k~cmm/ Smk}i ]onwmxsnt~+ Glc}kt~ jg Laxnc}kt}xm0 L dmwmkjrmd x}xlk }onwmxsnt~+ qntf elo~ xlnsmd

    lcldmencs+ lod }odmxaxld}ltm lod rjstaxld}ltms no wlxnj}s gnmkds jg laxnc}kt}xm/

  • 7/31/2019 Highlight Conclusions - Karapinar Study Site

    8/17

    Ilxlrnolx+ T}xim~ Rlam 6

    Qjxisfjrs gjx xmsmlxcfmxs lod stlimfjkdmxs tj smkmct s}stlnolhkm klod

    elolamemot tmcfojkjanms

    Xmsmlxcfmxs tlkimd qntf kjclk rmjrkm lod rjknc~ elimxs+ lod tjamtfmx tfm~ dmcndmd jo tfm hmst jrtnjos gjx

    s}stlnolhkm klod }sm/ No tfm DMSNXM Rxj`mct tfm tfxmm Rlxts tj QJCLT emtfjdjkja~ qmxm dmwmkjrmd ls

    j}tknomd lhjwm/ Tfns rxjwndms dmcnsnjo s}rrjxt gjx cfjjsnoa tmcfojkjanms s}ntmd tj tfm kjclk mownxjoemot

    tflt nock}dms sjcnlk+ c}kt}xlk lod mcjojenc glctjxs ls qmkk ls rf~snclk scnmocm/

    No mwmx~ DMSNXM st}d~ sntm xmsmlxcfmxs lod stlimfjkdmxs fmkd tqj qjxisfjrs tj lxxnwm lt tfmnx smkmctnjo jg

    lrrxjlcfms lod tmcfojkjanms/ Lt tfm gnxst qjxisfjr stlimfjkdmxs kmlxomd lhj}t fjq dmaxldltnjo

    flrrmos+ lod fjq tj lwjnd nt/

    Lo mvrmxnemotlk smt}r no tfm stxnr glxenoa rklo qls dmsnaomd tj tmst tfm mggmct jg qnod mxjsnjo }rjo tfm

    qfmlt cxjr &Minp hxmld qfmlt./ Tmcfojkjanms lrrknmd qmxm enone}e tnkklam+ rkj}afmd st}hhkm glkkjqnoalod st}hhkm glkkjqnoa/ Tfm lxml jg mlcf tmcfojkja~ qls g}xtfmx dnwndmd notj 4 rlxcmks 8 jg tfme qmxm

    sjqmd tflt ~mlx qntf l glkkjq rlxcmk no%hmtqmmo/

    Tfxmm tmcfojkjanms qmxm nerkmemotmd no tfm SNR lxml no tfm knaft jg stlimfjkdmx emmtnoas 9

  • 7/31/2019 Highlight Conclusions - Karapinar Study Site

    9/17

    Ilxlrnolx+ T}xim~ Rlam >Stlimfjkdmxs lxm dnsc}ssnoa tfm xmemdnltnjo jrtnjos lt QH4%= qjxisfjr

    Ejdms jg nerkmemotltnjo9

    Gjx mlcf tmcfojkja~+ qm smkmctmd gj}x 32 e v 31/= e snpmd xmctloa}klx rlxcmks knomd }r no O%S

    &djenolot qnod dnxmctnjo./

    No tfm nerkmemotltnjo jg mlcf tmcfojkja~+ tqj stxnrs qmxm kmgt glkkjq/ Tfmsm glkkjq stxnrs qmxm

    }smd ls tfm cjotxjk rlxcmk/

    No tfm gnxst DMSNXM qjxisfjrs enone}e tnkklam tmcfojkja~ qls cjosndmxmd hmomgncnlk tj hm tmstmd/

    Nodncltjxs sfjqnoa tfm cfloanoa tjrsjnk |}lknt~ lod qltmx dmelod qmxm mwlk}ltmd jwmx tqj ~mlxs/ Rxj`mct

    stlgg lddmd st}hhkm glxenoa ls l tmcfojkja~ gjx tmstnoa/ Tfmo l gnolk qjxisfjr qls fmkd no @}om+ 82

  • 7/31/2019 Highlight Conclusions - Karapinar Study Site

    10/17

    Ilxlrnolx+ T}xim~ Rlam

  • 7/31/2019 Highlight Conclusions - Karapinar Study Site

    11/17

    Ilxlrnolx+ T}xim~ Rlam

  • 7/31/2019 Highlight Conclusions - Karapinar Study Site

    12/17

    Ilxlrnolx+ T}xim~ Rlam

  • 7/31/2019 Highlight Conclusions - Karapinar Study Site

    13/17

    Ilxlrnolx+ T}xim~ Rlam 6.

    % Enone}e tnkklam 137 TX^*fl &8>6.

    Tfm lhjwm jrmxltnjo cjsts nock}dm xmotnoa jg m|}nremot tj nerkmemot mlcf rxlctncm L flxwmst nodmv gjx axlnos jg 4=- jg tjtlk hnjelss qls lss}emd Tfm rxncm jg axlnos ns 2/= TX^*ia &2/82.

  • 7/31/2019 Highlight Conclusions - Karapinar Study Site

    14/17

    Ilxlrnolx+ T}xim~ Rlam 6.

    % st}hhkm glkkjqnoa 137 TK*fl &8>6.

    Tfm lhjwm jrmxltnjo cjsts nock}dm xmotnoa jg m|}nremot tj nerkmemot mlcf rxlctncm L flxwmst nodmv gjx axlnos jg 4=- jg tjtlk hnjelss qls lss}emd Tfm rxncm jg axlnos ns 2/= TK*ia &2/82.

    St}hhkm glkkjqnoa fls lo nosnaongnclot mggmct jo hnjelss rxjd}ctnjo/ Ls jrmxltnjolk cjsts lxm ojt dnggmxm

    gxje txldntnjolk rkj}afnoa+ tfm mcjojenc wnlhnknt~ jg cmxmlk glxenoa ns ojt lktmxmd &n/m/ omt rxjgnts xmel

    omaltnwm./

    Tmcfojkja~ Scmolxnj0

    Rkj}afmd st}hhkm glkkjqnoa

    Tjtlk jrmxltnjo cjsts }odmx dnggmxmot rxlctncms0% txldntnjolk rkj}afnoa 137 TK*fl &8>6.

    % rkj}afmd st}hhkm glkkjqnoa 137 TK*fl &8>6.

    Tfm lhjwm jrmxltnjo cjsts nock}dm xmotnoa jgm|}nremot tj nerkmemot mlcf rxlctncm

    L flxwmst nodmv gjx axlnos jg 4=- jg tjtlk hnjelssqls lss}emd

    Tfm rxncm jg axlnos ns 2/= TK*ia &2/82.

    Rkj}afmd st}hhkm glkkjqnoa fls oj mggmct jo hnjelss rxjd}ctnjo/ Ls jrmxltnjolk cjsts lxm ojt dnggmxmot

    gxje txldntnjolk rkj}afnoa+ tfm mcjojenc wnlhnknt~ jg cmxmlk glxenoa ns ojt lktmxmd &n/m/ omt rxjgnts xmelno

    omaltnwm./

  • 7/31/2019 Highlight Conclusions - Karapinar Study Site

    15/17

    Ilxlrnolx+ T}xim~ Rlam

  • 7/31/2019 Highlight Conclusions - Karapinar Study Site

    16/17

    Ilxlrnolx+ T}xim~ Rlam 4-. lcxjss tfm motnxm lrrknclhnknt~ lxml+ dmsrntm tfm glct tflt mxjsnjo kmwmks lxm

    lkxmld~ |}ntm kjq/ ^nmkd mggmcts lxm ejxm knentmd+ qntf l 7- nocxmlsm rjssnhkm jo 37- jg tfm

    lrrknclhnknt~ lxml/ Tfm lwmxlam mvrmctmd ~nmkd nocxmlsm ns 34 iafl~x lod tfm lwmxlam mxjsnjoxmd}ctnjo 2/23 tjofl~x/

    Gxje lo mcjkjanclk rjnot jg wnmq+ lkk tmcfojkjanms lxm mggmctnwm tj xmd}cm sjnk mxjsnjo/ Mggmcts johnjelss lod ~nmkd kmwmks lxm xmkltnwmk~ selkk lod mvrmxnemotlk lod ejdmkknoa xms}kts dj ojt g}kk~

    s}rrjxt mlcf jtfmx/ Tfm elno jhstlckm gjx ldjrtnjo jg tfm tmcfojkjanms ns tfmnx mcjojenc

    wnlhnknt~+ msrmcnlkk~ ng cjowmotnjolk rkj}afnoa clo hm nerkmemotmd qntfj}t glkkjqnoa lod tfm

    tmcfojkjanms xm|}nxm glkkjqnoa/ Tfmxm ns knttkm xnsi no lrrk~noa tfm tmcfojkjanms lod stlimfjkdmxs

    xmlknsm tflt qfmo qltmx hmcjems sclxcmx lod ejxm mvrmosnwm no tfm g}t}xm+ glkkjqnoa clo

    hmcjem lo nocxmlsnoak~ wnlhkm stxltma~/ G}xtfmx cjognxeltnjo jg tfm &mcjojenc. mggmcts ns

    omcmsslx~ hmgjxm lo~ jg tfm tmcfojkjanms clo hm xmcjeemodmd/ Anwmo tflt s}hsndnms lxm slnd tj

    hm xm|}nxmd+ nt qj}kd hm nerjxtlot tj cjosndmx tfm jgg%sntm cjsts lod hmomgnts d}m tj qnod

    mxjsnjo no tfm lxml/

    Kmldnoa Scnmotnst0

    Lssjc/ Rxjg/ Glx}i Jclijak}

    Msinmfnx Jseloalpn ]onwmxsnt~

    Emmkni Ilers

    87462 Msinmfnx

    T}xim~

    Glv0 )>2 888 83> 37

  • 7/31/2019 Highlight Conclusions - Karapinar Study Site

    17/17

    Ilxlrnolx+ T}xim~ Rlam