15
HIGH-DUST SCR DESIGN TO LIMIT IMPACT OF HIGH SULFUR OPERATION ON AIR PREHEATER OPERATION Volker Rummenhohl, Tackticks, LLC 2300 Englert Avenue, Suite C, Durham, NC 27713 Tel: 919/602-1063; FAX: 919/484-1544; E-mail: [email protected] William Ellison, Ellison Consultants 4966 Tall Oaks Drive, Monrovia, Maryland 21770-9316 Tel: 301/865-5302; FAX: 301/865-5591; E-mail: [email protected] Helmut Weiler, Weiler Consultants Hofer Heide 31, D42549 Velbert, Germany Tel: 011/49/2051-66034; Fax: 011/49/2051-66440; E-mail: [email protected] U.S. DOE/NETL 2006 ENV. CONTS. CONF. SCR AND SNCR FOR NO X CONT. PITTSBURGH, PA, MAY 17, 2006

HIGH-DUST SCR DESIGN TO LIMIT IMPACT OF HIGH SULFUR OPERATION ON AIR PREHEATER OPERATION Volker Rummenhohl, Tackticks, LLC 2300 Englert Avenue, Suite C,

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: HIGH-DUST SCR DESIGN TO LIMIT IMPACT OF HIGH SULFUR OPERATION ON AIR PREHEATER OPERATION Volker Rummenhohl, Tackticks, LLC 2300 Englert Avenue, Suite C,

HIGH-DUST SCR DESIGN TO LIMIT IMPACT OF HIGH SULFUR OPERATION

ON AIR PREHEATER OPERATIONVolker Rummenhohl, Tackticks, LLC

2300 Englert Avenue, Suite C, Durham, NC 27713Tel: 919/602-1063; FAX: 919/484-1544;

E-mail: [email protected]

William Ellison, Ellison Consultants4966 Tall Oaks Drive, Monrovia, Maryland 21770-9316

Tel: 301/865-5302; FAX: 301/865-5591;E-mail: [email protected]

Helmut Weiler, Weiler ConsultantsHofer Heide 31, D42549 Velbert, Germany

Tel: 011/49/2051-66034; Fax: 011/49/2051-66440;E-mail: [email protected]

U.S. DOE/NETL 2006 ENV. CONTS. CONF.SCR AND SNCR FOR NOX CONT.PITTSBURGH, PA, MAY 17, 2006

Page 2: HIGH-DUST SCR DESIGN TO LIMIT IMPACT OF HIGH SULFUR OPERATION ON AIR PREHEATER OPERATION Volker Rummenhohl, Tackticks, LLC 2300 Englert Avenue, Suite C,

2

• If A Unit Has Significant, Air-Preheater-Related, SO3 Problems, SCR Retrofitting Can Be Expected To Make The Situation Worse.

• If an Uncontrolled Unit Does Not Have Significant SO3 Problems, Adequate SCR Retrofit System Design and Operation Should Not Lead To Increased Problems in Boiler System Performance or Maintenance.

Page 3: HIGH-DUST SCR DESIGN TO LIMIT IMPACT OF HIGH SULFUR OPERATION ON AIR PREHEATER OPERATION Volker Rummenhohl, Tackticks, LLC 2300 Englert Avenue, Suite C,

3

INDICATION OF POTENTIAL PROBLEMS ABSENT SCR (AND ITS

CATALYTIC, SO2-TO-SO3 CONVERSION)

• Average SO3 concentration may be as high as 50 ppm, exceeding 3% of gross SO2 content.

• With unique, high iron content, e.g. western Kentucky coal: up to 10% conversion of SO2 to SO3 occurs.

Page 4: HIGH-DUST SCR DESIGN TO LIMIT IMPACT OF HIGH SULFUR OPERATION ON AIR PREHEATER OPERATION Volker Rummenhohl, Tackticks, LLC 2300 Englert Avenue, Suite C,

4

UNIT-WIDE SO2/SO3 BEHAVIOR

• An increment of SO3 generation occurs in the furnace.• Temperature-dependent, catalyzed SO2-to-SO3 conversion

occurs in the convective pass, reaching a maximum rate at 1,300oF (704oC) flue gas temperature.

• Rate of SO3 formation by SCR, increasing SO3 perhaps by 20+ ppm, is greatest at 660-750oF (350-400oC) and above.

• Below 600oF (316oC) SO3 hydrates to gaseous sulfuric acid: H2SO4(v).

• Condensation of H2SO4(v) occurs at and below the sulfuric acid dew point temperature, typically as high as 280oF (138oC).

Page 5: HIGH-DUST SCR DESIGN TO LIMIT IMPACT OF HIGH SULFUR OPERATION ON AIR PREHEATER OPERATION Volker Rummenhohl, Tackticks, LLC 2300 Englert Avenue, Suite C,

5

INFLUENCE OF SOOT BLOWING

• Low-temperature blowing/cleaning (1,100 to 1,600oF, i.e. 593 to 871oC), in removing deposits, increases the rate of SO2-to-SO3 conversion due to tube-metal surface effect.

• However, (contrariwise), presence of such ash deposits, typically iron-oxide-laden, significantly increases SO3 formation.

Page 6: HIGH-DUST SCR DESIGN TO LIMIT IMPACT OF HIGH SULFUR OPERATION ON AIR PREHEATER OPERATION Volker Rummenhohl, Tackticks, LLC 2300 Englert Avenue, Suite C,

6

INSIGHTS FROM MARCH, 1998,(MOST RECENT) DOE/FETC

CONFERENCE ON SO3

• A boiler model study showed that the condition of superheater tube surfaces radically influences catalytic SO3 formation:

– CLEAN: 20 ppm– MODERATELY FOULED: 70 ppm– HEAVILY FOULED: 32 ppm

• A large, high-SO3, electric utility unit (without SCR) achieves 60% removal of SO3 in the air preheater leading to its significant fouling (and derating). Across its exit cross-section, SO3 varies laterally from 10 to 25 ppm.

Page 7: HIGH-DUST SCR DESIGN TO LIMIT IMPACT OF HIGH SULFUR OPERATION ON AIR PREHEATER OPERATION Volker Rummenhohl, Tackticks, LLC 2300 Englert Avenue, Suite C,

7

IMPACT ON AIR PREHEATER OF H2SO4 CONDENSATION IS EXACERBATED BY:

• Air to gas-side leakage

• Displacement of flue gas into air stream

• Enhancement of corrosion due to acid-wetted ash/salt deposit.

Page 8: HIGH-DUST SCR DESIGN TO LIMIT IMPACT OF HIGH SULFUR OPERATION ON AIR PREHEATER OPERATION Volker Rummenhohl, Tackticks, LLC 2300 Englert Avenue, Suite C,

8

WITH CO-FIRING OF BIOMASS

• If more than 10% of total heat input

• Catalyst activity deterioration may be fifteen times normal

Page 9: HIGH-DUST SCR DESIGN TO LIMIT IMPACT OF HIGH SULFUR OPERATION ON AIR PREHEATER OPERATION Volker Rummenhohl, Tackticks, LLC 2300 Englert Avenue, Suite C,

9

EXTERNAL CATALYST REGENERATION, E.G.

ULTRASONIC CLEANING

• 90 TO 100% Recovery of Activity

• Max. number regenerations: Four or more

• Amount regenerated to date in Germany: 10,000 cubic meters

• Cost savings: Major

Page 10: HIGH-DUST SCR DESIGN TO LIMIT IMPACT OF HIGH SULFUR OPERATION ON AIR PREHEATER OPERATION Volker Rummenhohl, Tackticks, LLC 2300 Englert Avenue, Suite C,

10

VERY LIMITED, OVERSEAS,HIGH DUST, SCR EXPERIENCE IN

U.S.-TYPE, HIGH SULFUR, LOW ASH, COAL SERVICE

• Japan: Limited to several, early, low-efficiency, ultra-low ammonia-slip installations

• Germany….none:– All of the several high-sulfur, high-dust, SCR installations

fire ultra-high-ash, coal-cleaning middlings, (“ballast coal”), 40% ash content of which greatly mitigates the effect of SO3 and ammonia slip.

– Tail-end SCR design is commonly applied to wet-bottom boilers.

Page 11: HIGH-DUST SCR DESIGN TO LIMIT IMPACT OF HIGH SULFUR OPERATION ON AIR PREHEATER OPERATION Volker Rummenhohl, Tackticks, LLC 2300 Englert Avenue, Suite C,

11

JAPANESE SCR PRACTICES FROM 1980s IN HIGH-SULFUR, LOW-ASH,

COAL APPLICATIONS

• Limited NOx Removal Efficiency

• 10 mm Catalyst Pitch

• Maintain 330oC (625oF), Minimum, at SCR Inlet

• Ammonia Slip <1 ppm

• Soot Blowing/Periodic Washing

Page 12: HIGH-DUST SCR DESIGN TO LIMIT IMPACT OF HIGH SULFUR OPERATION ON AIR PREHEATER OPERATION Volker Rummenhohl, Tackticks, LLC 2300 Englert Avenue, Suite C,

12

GERMAN SCR DESIGN PRACTICES

• Standardized, replaceable, catalyst modules• Design catalyst-volume criteria tied to maximum

design ammonia slip (originally set as high as 5 ppm in low-sulfur service: later 2 ppm)

• Economizer bypass as necessary to maintain adequate SCR inlet temperature at low load

• Flow model test at 1:10 or 1:20 scale• Provision for a future, spare layer of catalyst• Three dimensional, two-phase flow, computer

program• Enameled steel heating plates in preheater cold-end.

Page 13: HIGH-DUST SCR DESIGN TO LIMIT IMPACT OF HIGH SULFUR OPERATION ON AIR PREHEATER OPERATION Volker Rummenhohl, Tackticks, LLC 2300 Englert Avenue, Suite C,

13

GERMAN SCR KNOW-HOW GENERALLY APPLICABLE IN HIGH-

SULFUR APPLICATIONS

• Tight control of inlet temperature• Uniform, cross-sectional, flow distribution:

– NOx mass flow: + or – 15% max.– NH3/NOx Ratio: + or – 3-5% max.– Temperature: + or – 15oC (27oF)– Partic. Mass: + or – 30% max.

• Ammonia Slip: 2 ppm average (1.5 to 3.0 ppm locally)• Minimum, catalytic, SO2-to-SO3 conversion• When appropriate, (so as to limit SO3 formation): removal of

‘excess’ catalyst!!!• Air preheater enameling• Preheater plate surface-profile: easy to blow clean• Often apply and justify the alternative, benign, tail-end, SCR

design arrangement.

Page 14: HIGH-DUST SCR DESIGN TO LIMIT IMPACT OF HIGH SULFUR OPERATION ON AIR PREHEATER OPERATION Volker Rummenhohl, Tackticks, LLC 2300 Englert Avenue, Suite C,

14

INSTRUCTIVE GUIDELINES FROM GERMANY FOR U.S. HIGH SULFUR,

LOW ASH, SCR SERVICE

• Low SO2-to-SO3 catalyst conversion rate, i.e. less than 0.3%

• Ammonia injection upstream of economizer (?)• Alkali injection upstream of air preheater• Enameled heating plates on the air preheater,

flue-gas side up to 2/3 of the plate height• Preheater corrosion protection on the casing

and cold side of the rotor structure• Optimum preheater soot-blowing means.

Page 15: HIGH-DUST SCR DESIGN TO LIMIT IMPACT OF HIGH SULFUR OPERATION ON AIR PREHEATER OPERATION Volker Rummenhohl, Tackticks, LLC 2300 Englert Avenue, Suite C,

15

CONCLUSION

• Unfettered performance of the in-place, high dust, SCR catalyst is critical for good boiler system operation and reliability.

• If functioning of the SCR catalyst surface is, or becomes, impaired, e.g. by design inadequacies or significant change in operating conditions, air preheater and fly-ash quality problems may become significant.