Upload
abhishek-anand
View
112
Download
3
Embed Size (px)
DESCRIPTION
Valuation of a utensils company, Hawkins Cooker
Citation preview
October 9, 2007
Hawkins Cooker Ltd
Stable business, Limited growth opportunities
Investment Rating: Buy and Hold
Price: Rs. 127.75 NIFTY: 5327.25 BSE Sensex: 18280.24 Target Price: Rs. 176.85 (Potential upside: 33%, time frame: 1-2 year)
Industry to grow at 12-15% in the next 4 years Well Established brand name Huge capacity available to meet the increase in demand Increase in free cash flows and rising reserves
Market Capitalization Stock DataEquity Market Cap: Rs. 67.58 crores 52 week range: Rs. 147.8 – Rs. 78.6Enterprise Value: Rs. 75.56 crores 12-month stock performance: 31.91%Share Outstanding: 4.031 crores Dividend Yield: 5.48%
Company Quick View:
Location: Mumbai, Maharashtra.
Industry: Pressure Cookers, Cookware
Key Brands: Hawkins, Futura, Miss Mary
Company website: http://www.hawkinscookers.com/
Company Description:
Hawkins Cookers is a manufacturer of pressure cookers and cookwares incorporated in 1959 as a private
company and converted into a public limited company on 1st Feb. 1975. In fiscal 2007, it reported sales
of Rs. 173 crore. Hawkins is the number one brand in the pressure cooker market of India.
The company produces a wide range of other household and commercial cooking utensils. Hawkins sells
its products under the brand name of Hawkins, Futura and Miss Mary. Hawkins brand has traditional
pressure cookers like Hawkins Classic, Hawkins Bigboy, Hawkins Contura , Hawkins Ventura and Hawkins
stainless Steel. Futura brand has both cookers and cookware. Miss Mary brand has pressure cookers
which give trouble free service, totally safe and don’t leak.
Hawkins Cookers is headquartered in Mumbai, India. It has manufacturing units in Janpur, Thane and
Hoshiarpur. Hawkins primarily caters to the domestic market with domestic sales contributing to about
96% of the total sales. Specific areas in which R&D efforts have been carried out: Qualify improvement
of existing products and design of new products. The company has 68 valid patents and design
registrations in force in 7 countries. Hawkins Cookers has not imported any technology in last 5 years.
FY03 FY04 FY05 FY06 FY07
Sales 98.75 105.55 117.77 136.37 173.25
Sales Growth -1.3% 6.9% 11.6% 15.8% 27.0%
PAT -6.91 0.8 3.11 4.03 7.49
EPS - 1.51 5.88 7.62 14.16
Dividends per
Share
0.0 1.0 3.0 5.0 7.0
Sales of the company has grown by
27% for FY07 and an average Pressure
cookers are the primary sales
contributor with over 80% of gross
sales contributed by the segment.
However the company has managed to
diversify its business from pressure
cookers segment to Cookware
segment.
The company has low capacity
utilization with utilization of 25% in FY2007 and an average utilization of 20% in the last 5 years. No
future capital expenses are seen for Hawkins in Pressure Cooker segment.
Management:
Promoters of the company have the majority stake in the
company and the company has not gone for any public
issue till date. Last bonus issue was in FY 94 and last rights
issue was in FY98.
The strengths of Hawkins lie in its brand and its marketing
and distribution activities which were revamped after the
company suffered losses in FY01 and FY02. However inspite of the diversification, Pressure cooker
Designation Name
Director J M Mukhi
Director Gerson Da Cunha
Director V N Sharma
Director B K Khare
Chairman Brahm Vasudeva
Vice Chairman, MD
& CEO
S Dutta
Choudhury
Executive Director
(Operation)
M A
Teckchandani
Executive Director
(Fin.&Admn)
K
Sundararaghavan
Director Shishir K Diwanji
Company Secretary Hutoxi Bhesania
segment contributes more than 80% of the revenue. The segment is a mature segment and the urban
markets are growing at a very low rate. The opportunities for Hawkins lie in the rural area and other
Kitchen appliances like mixer grinders which is a Rs. 700 crore segment. Hawkins faces tough
competition from regional and unorganized players along with national companies like TTK Prestige. The
company has also suffered because of high tax rates and inflation in the past.
Industry Analysis
Size of Pressure Cooker industry in India is projected at Rs.575 crore and cookware is projected as
Rs.125 crore. The pressure cooker industry is growing at a rate of 10% YOY for last 5 years.
The pressure cooker industry suffers from low entry barriers. As a result the market has regional and
unorganized players along with national companies like Hawkins and TTK Prestige. There are about 250
brands of pressure cookers in the market.
Pressure cookers are used only in 61 per cent of Indian households. The figure shows of the percentage
of households using pressure cooker in the urban and rural areas. Clearly huge potential lies in the rural
areas. However the penetration of cookers is not expected to increase in the near future. It is predicted
to
be 66% by the end of 2011.
The growth in demand for domestic home appliance products especially, the kitchen ware production
continues to rise in tandem with the increase in income and living standards of the people both in the
urban and rural areas of the country. The current market size of pressure cooker industry in the country
is estimated at Rs 500 crore. Hawkins Cooker (brand Hawkins) and TTK Prestige (brand Prestige), are the
two large players in the segment, and together cornering over 50% share in the domestic pressure
cooker market. The growth rate of the industry is likely to be around the 14% mark in the coming years.
Primary raw materials used in the process of manufacturing are brass, stainless steel and aluminum. The
raw material is procured from the domestic market and the performance of the sector is largely
dependent on the price of the raw material.
The key factors effecting the growth of the segment are the tax rates and the inflation. The decline in
the performance of Cookers segment in FY02 and FY03 was primarily due to the increase in excise duty
from 8% to 16%. The inflation influenced the cost of raw material procured and since the market is
highly competitive the companies can’t pass on the increase to the customers.
The key organised sector players in the industry are TTK Prestige and Hawkins Cookers Ltd. The
comparison between the firms is given below.
Sales Net
Profit
Div
%
EP
S
Rs.
Pric
e
Mkt. Cap.
as on
28/09/2007
P/E P/
BV
Debt
to
Equit
y
Current
Ratio
Hawkins
Cookers
173.55 7.49 70 13 134 70.65 10.3 4.25 0.86 1.22
TTK
Prestige
281.4 11.84 30 9.9 137 155.95 13.9 2.99 1.36 1.49
Risk Analysis:
Industry Risks:
Inflation risk: Pressure cooker industry has suffered on account of rise of input costs as not all costs are
transferable to the customers.
Saturation of market: The growth rate of the industry is dependent on the ability of players to tap the
rural market. However if this doesn’t materialize then the industry may experience a flat sales growth
rate.
Excise Duty: Increase or decrease in excise duty has a big impact on the bottom line of the Pressure
cooker companies. The companies in the past have lobbied against the increase in excise duty rates on
the pressure cookers. However the increase in excise duty on pressure cookers can’t be ruled out in the
near future.
Company Risks:
Non-Diversified Business: Pressure cookers contribute to over 80% of Hawkins topline. Any downturn in
the industry can cause the sales to drop substantially.
Competition: Market share of Hawkins is under continuous threat as new players come in the market.
Hawkins faces tough competiton from regional, unorganized and national players. The low entry barriers
enable small players to enter the market.
Financial Performance Projections
Operating Activities
We expect the company’s sales to grow at a rate of 14% till FY12 which is consistent with the expected
industry growth rate of 13-15 %. Industry forecasted to grow at the rate of 14% in the coming 3-4 years.
The company sales has grown at a rate of 18% for last three years (on an average). Hence we feel that
for the next 5 years the growth of 14% is sustainable considering the inflation and consumption pattern
remain the same of the economy. However post FY 12 we expect the growth rate to reduce to 8% as the
market is expected to mature by that time and will result in lower growth. For terminal value calculation
we have taken a growth rate of 5%. In terms of expenditure, we have assumed the operating expense to
be 92% of sales as observed in the past. Hawkins has managed to reduce its operating expense from as
high as 104% of sales to 91.7% of sales. Hawkins is expected to have a dividend payout ratio of 60% for
the coming years. We expect a continuous rise in free cash flow of the company. However the free cash
flow to equity will be negative for the FY08 but will rise in the coming years.
Capital Expenditure
The company is operating at a capacity of 25%. Hence we don’t predict any substantial capital
expenditure in the coming years. Operating working capital is assumed as 13.1% of sales based on the
previous three years weighted average.
Valuations:
PE multiple for FY07 was 6.41. Expected PE ratio for FY08E and FY09E is 5.86 and 5.12. on the other hand
its competitor Prestige TTK ltd had a PE ratio of 12.42 in FY07. A target PE of 10 for FY08 and FY09 would
result in a price of Rs. 154.7 and Rs. 177.2. Based on the FCF and FCFE analysis the resultant share price
of the firm is estimated to be Rs. 176.85.