7/27/2019 Handschu 2013 Notice of Motion

1/4

UNI TED STATES DI STRI CT COURTSOUTHERN DI STRI CT OF NEW YORK- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -BARBARA HANDSCHU, RALPH DI GI A,ALEX McKEI VER, SHABA OM, CURTI S 71 Ci v. 2203 ( CSH)M. POWELL, ABBI E HOFFMAN, MARK

A. SEGAL, MI CHAEL ZUMOFF, NOTI CE OF MOTI ON FORKENNETH THOMAS, ROBERT RUSCH, I NJ UNCTI VE RELI EFANETTE T. RUBENSTEI N, MI CHEY AND FOR APPOI NTMENTSHERI DAN, J OE SUCHER, STEVEN OF AN AUDI TOR ORFI SCHLER, HOWARD BLATT and MONI TORELLI E BENZONE, on behal f of t hemsel vesand al l ot her s si mi l ar l y si t uat ed,

Or al Ar gument Request edPl ai nt i f f s,

- agai nst-

SPECI AL SERVI CES DI VI SI ON, a/ k/ a

BUREAU OF SPECI AL SERVI CES,WI LLI AM H. T. SMI TH, ARTHURGRUBERT, MI CHAEL WI LLI S,WI LLI AM KNAPP, PATRI CKMURPHY, POLI CE DEPARTMENTOF THE CI TY OF NEW YORK,J OHN V. LI NDSAY and var i ous unknownempl oyees of t he Pol i ce Depar t ment act i ngas under - cover oper at or s and i nf or mer s,

Def endant s.

- - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - -

MADAMS OR SI RS:

PLEASE TAKE NOTI CE that upon t he accompanyi ng

Decl arat i on of Paul G. Chevi gny dated J anuary 22, 2013, t he

Decl arat i on of Shami ur Rahman dat ed Oct ober 28, 2012, t he

Decl ar at i on of Fai za Al i dat ed J anuar y 18, 2013, t he

Decl ar at i on of Li nda Sar sour dat ed J anuar y 18, 2013, t he

Decl arat i on of Bernar d Haykel dat ed December 7, 2012, t he

deposi t i on of Chi ef Thomas Gal at i dated J une 28, 2012, t he

exhi bi t s annexed her et o and t he accompanyi ng Memorandum of

7/27/2019 Handschu 2013 Notice of Motion

2/4

2

Law, counsel f or t he pl ai nt i f f Cl ass wi l l move t hi s Cour t ,

at a t i me and pl ace t o be desi gnated by the Cour t , f or t he

f ol l owi ng r el i ef agai nst t he New Yor k Pol i ce Depar t ment

( NYPD) :

a) pur suant t o Rul e 65 of t he Feder al Rul es of Ci vi l

Pr ocedur e, an i nj unct i on agai nst t he pol i cy and pr act i ce of

r et ai ni ng r ecor ds concer ni ng vi si t s t o publ i c pl aces made by

t he Zone Assessment Uni t , t he Demogr aphi cs Uni t or any ot her

uni t of t he NYPD where no i nf ormat i on has been obt ai ned t hat

r el at es to pot ent i al unl awf ul or t er r or i st act i vi t y, i n

vi ol at i on of Sect i on VI I I A ( 2) of t he Modi f i ed Handschu

Gui del i nes;

b) pur suant t o Rul e 65 of t he Feder al Rul es of Ci vi l

Pr ocedur e, an i nj unct i on agai nst t he pol i cy and pr act i ce of

surr ept i t i ousl y j oi ni ng, vi s i t i ng and i nf i l t rat i ng

or gani zat i ons or i nst i t ut i ons i ncl udi ng or gani zat i ons

associ at ed wi t h I sl am, and keepi ng r ecor ds of such

i nvest i gat i ve act i vi t i es, i n t he absence of r easonabl e

i ndi cat i ons or i ndi cat i on of t er r or i st or unl awf ul

act i vi t y, i n vi ol at i on of Sec. V( B) , Sec. V( C) and V( D) of

t he Modi f i ed Handschu Gui del i nes;

c) pur suant t o Rul e 706 of t he Feder al Rul es of

Evi dence, or al t er nat i vel y pur suant t o Rul e 53, F. R. C. P. , an

or der appoi nt i ng an audi t or or moni t or t o super vi se

compl i ance by t he NYPD, i t s empl oyees and agent s wi t h t he

7/27/2019 Handschu 2013 Notice of Motion

3/4

injunctive orders made herein mandating obedience to the

Modified Handschu Guidelines in investigations of political

activity by members

of the

plaintiff

class;

and

d

for such other and further relief as to this Court

seems just

and proper.

Dated: New York,

New York

January 22,

2013

Yours,

etc

AUXCAt t>K

PAUL

G.

CHEVIGNY\ PC-3569

40

Washington Square Sout

New York, NY 10012

212 998-6249

JETHRO M.

EISENSTEIN

JE-6848

Profeta

isenstein

45 Broadway,

Suite 2200

New

York, NY 10006

212

577-6500

MARTIN

R. STOLAR MS-1576

351 Broadway, 4th Floor

New York, NY

10013

212

219-1919

FRANKLIN

SIEGEL

FS-4952

368 President

St.

Brooklyn,

NY 11231-5015

212

406-0700

ARTHUR EISENBERG

AE-2012

ew York Civil

Liberties

Union

125 Broad

Street 7th

Floor

New York, Y

10004

212

344-3005

Attorneys

for Plaintiff Class

7/27/2019 Handschu 2013 Notice of Motion

4/4

4

TO: MI CHAEL A. CARDOZOCorporat i on Counsel of t he Ci t y of New Yor kAt t orney f or Def endant s100 Chur ch St r eetNew Yor k, NY 10007Pet er G. Far r el l , Esq.

Seni or Counsel