Gripes Compiled Notes

7/29/2019 Gripes Compiled Notes

1/11

Oil daBad to increase oil production

Oil is global commodityCan be sold to anyone

Unlike some where you might pay more or less

Any increase in production can affect the market

Increase supply becomes cheaper

Fucks over other countries

UqJust above 100 dollars a barrel right now

Relatively stable right now

LinkIncrease production

Lowers price

And perception crap feedback loops makes link bigger and timeframe argument

ImpactLots and lots of impacts

Econ decline in emerging economies

Nuke war with Russia

Terrorism

Decline in global economy

Bahrain

Predominately shia

Sympathies with iran

Ruled by sunni

Arab spring

No press

Idea is withdrawl in revenue collapse

Attack 5th fleet

Fucks the Persian gulf

Nuke war w/ pirates

Saudi ArabiaNeed oil

Collapse

We get screwed

Decline in heg

Climate change

Use less oil save the environment

Increase in price new shift towards better energy


2/11

Extinction

Two cards long

TurnsRussia help hegemony cause conflict

Bahrain better for operations of 5th fleet if not in Bahrain

Saudi Arabia no turn

Climate change fucked

Econ if prices go up econ goes down skrews econ

Iran iran is a big middle eastern country more oil money = more military


3/11

Security/multitudesThink about this k as a toolbox

Designed so people could use based on level of expertise and interestIts a sink between a bunch of arguments

Second narrow focus if you want

Basic intro

Sec k part

Few different links

Lot of times make root cause

All violence comes from security

We are insecure

Question is how do we come to live with our insecurity w/o harming others

Question of how to live with insecurity

Inev in world with security

Links are about securitizing against external threats

Enables gov to declare emergency

Circumvents democracy

Economic engagement link securitization root cause

Lots to Mexico border violence drugs crime

Cuba some specific most derived from Cuba terror aff

If going to read this k use the multitudes version

Venezuela nobody cares

Against spec advantage scenarios

Essentially this is a generic that links to everything

Impacts

Racism

Ethics

Environment turns

Authoritarianism

Endless war

Go to war for war sounds like Hillman

Alt negri

Multitude affective resistence combination of resistence movements that survive because

they dont have tangible goals

What connects all these movements is that they resist imperialismImperialism comes from security

Also have normal alts

Judith butler

Aff has lots of perms

And multitude bad fascism


4/11

Indict security


5/11

Counterproposals gripeNot in depth

Cp - Venezuelaprivatize/investNB any usa based disad

Aff args

Maduro credibility

Theoretical objection object fiat

Cp privatize Mexican oilTrick is that privatize is prereq to aff

Private is only way to remove legal barriers100% no solvency

Nb is any usa based da

Aff

Mexico ptix da

Cuz privatization sucks destroys pcap

Depend argument that the western gap is key

Only tba can open western gap

Aff is prereq to cp

Oil spills adv cpEliminate liability cap

Gets rid of perverse incentives

Second and third planks of cp are about changing safety no profit so incentivize

First plank is about funding

Trick its inevitableand need for new regulations no solve

Nb ptix

Aff

No solve

Cleanup is more toxic

Govmnt investment is badGov no knows what doing

Let venture capitalists do it

Links to ptix

Ad the usa to state sponsors list cpStrike against the self


6/11

Not discource ideological enjoyment of violence

Need to see usa as exceptional in use of violence

Removing Cuba from terror list not end war on terror

State violence still legit post plan

Evidence still likes the list

Nb interpassivity strike at what is dearest makes true agency possible

Nb war on terror turn removing Cuba from list legitimizes list

Aff args

Perm go to ans

Cuba sanctions are bad independent aside from terrorism allows for Cubans to die list is genocide

Psychoanalysis wrong way to look at ptix

Adv cp right to developCp changes aid to be inline with the right to development

Solves aff cuz helps hrDodges ptix

Ptix

Cp PIKRejects federal govmt and rejects aid

State is imperialist and violent

Cuba is racist

Aff

Inclusion of state is necessary

Reject the state causes backlash

Reject state reaffirms power shadow boxing

Cp another PIKPik solves ill not necessary

Two different nbneoliberal or hinders free trade

Obviously contradictorydont read at same time


7/11

Appeasement daTwo arguments

Appeasement daUnconditional aid

Helps adversaries

Makes them bolder

Undermines credibility with allies

Shows inconsistency in foreign policy

Casts doubt with our allies if we break consistency

Makes those countries develop own military

Perceive threat

aff

Disproves credHeg not credible

Shapiro

Other stats like amount nuke weapons

Da infrastructure

Great agains k affs defense of heg and wot

Grounded in historical analysis

Great agains Cuba terror and embargo aff

Aff

K of heg

K of war on terror

K of prolif

Easy way to attack disad

Not just ranting ks its da truth

Conditions cpOnce we ask for us to give something in return we are using negotiating skills

Cuba release Allen Gross

No chance to revive relations without AllenSolves appeasement da

Solves ptix

Venezuela

No increase investment unless sever ties with iran

Need to eliminate connections of banks

Solves appeasement we get something in return


8/11

Ptix nb makes republicans like Venezuela

Mexico

Not help economically or help nafta in any way unless change way to pursue drug trafficking

Mexico no help with merrida initiative

Need to help

Best way to combat human trafficking

And k impacts of hr and sexual violence

Aff answers are solid

Mex would say no they like their military

US has tried before an mex said no cuz violate sovereignty

More to the right strategy and its cheating

Does have all the tools you need to make competition arguments


9/11

ColonialityWynter since colonialism the world is divided between - the ethno class of man and the true human

Structure of knowledge started in 15th and 16th evidence2 sides pick one

Alt is epistemic delinking

Struggle against the overrepresentation of man

Ordering of taxonimizing

And modernity

Impacts are unbelievable

This is about the structure and conditions by which we come to know other humans

Coloniality is not a quantifiable violence it is the nonethics of death and war

It is a struggle now

Everytime we fight for the ballot we fight for possible ethics and agencyAll irrelevant

Link

Oilwell historicizing colonialism and appropriation of resources

Link args same against leftist affs

Historicization of how they conflate colonialism and coloniality

Just cuz you let someone in not mean that you challenged the death ethics of man

Cuba disaster assistance aff

faith in Cuba state and socialism perpetuates the myth of post colonialism not attack coloniality

Coloniality is taxonomizing individuals into a hierarchy

Part of coloniality of power because refuses to acknowledge how works

Cuba terror

Actually talks about real terror in the un underlined parts of aff

Not undermine the death ethics of war

Nafta aff

Same idea

The way they address gender is part of coloniality

Gender was introduced to Mexico by colonialality

Marxist categories of labor have epistemic coloniality

Perm is the biggest issue

Must win that they forgot to do some shit!!!

Win sequencing argumentNeed to win why getting history wrong impeaches larger project

w/o addressing the deeper strucuture need to go into deeper states

afro-cubans???

Need to win why epistemology matters

Aff answers

Attack on the idea of coloniality


10/11

If no answer the idea of coloniality you will loose!!!

Must say that as a historical thesis coloniality is wrong

Peng cheh coloniality authors only see it as killing and racist power is also productive only talk

about power as bad miss how power shapes us


11/11

GeoptxBased around borders part of receeding colonialism

Our arg is that borders are part of fixing around state western product of colonialism way ofupholding colonial relationship

Borders make the need for security out vs in dichotomy

Construction is root cause for war on terror

K should be easy to execute

Documents

Gripes Compiled Notes