Upload
volien
View
221
Download
4
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Greg Epelbaum, Boiler Engineering Manager, Covanta Energy
Eric Hanson, Boiler Reliability Director, Covanta Energy
Dr. Michael Seitz, President AmStar Surface Technology
May 12, 2010, Orlando, Florida, USA
• Fireside corrosion is the biggest challenge for EfW boilers
• MSW is the most heterogeneous, unpredictable fuel, which constantly changes with weather, seasons, locations, economy, politics, social behavior, etc…..
• Fireside corrosion is typically driven by the following 4 simultaneously occurring mechanisms:
– corrosion by gaseous phase including “active oxidation” by
Challenges for EfW boiler Reliability
– corrosion by gaseous phase including “active oxidation” by chlorine (HCl, Cl2) ;
– condensation of alkali and heavy metals chloride and/or sulfates;
– deposit induced corrosion and sulfidation of condensed chlorides ;
– molten salts eutectics cause dissolution of protective oxide scales and tube metal
• Intensity of corrosion can be controlled to a certain degree by a proper design for an EfW boiler :
– combustion system and furnace design;
– proper design criteria for the main operating parameters;
– “smart” superheater location
• Boiler tube surface protection:
– refractory;
Solutions to improve EfW boiler Reliability
– refractory;
– tube shields;
– surface treatments, such as weld overlays, thermal sprays, laser claddings and fused coatings, and AmStar 888® is one of these technologies, and like some others, it can be use as a part of the solution;
– Relevance and importance to EfW future
• The material development of Alloy 888® was initiated in 2002, in a partnership between Special Metals Welding Products Company and AmStar Surface Technology.
• This material (which is a Nickel Chrome alloy, with carbide and boride additions) was developed for environments with erosion, corrosion, or a combination of both. It became a proven technology for many large utility boilers, Fluid Bed boilers, recovery boilers, refineries before it entrance to EfW.
• The coating is applied using a high velocity spray system
AMSTAR 888® CLADDING MATERIAL
• The coating is applied using a high velocity spray system (HVCC), and requires no post treatment:
– can be field or shop applied ;
– can be applied over untreated surface or potentially over treated surface, such as Inconel weld overlay;
– can be repaired if defects occur in the future
• AmStar 888® cladding technology is a combination of the new alloy and the special coating technique. AmStar Surface Technology Company is developer and applicator.
• AmStar 888® cladding technology was proven in other industries, but not in EfW.
• To find cost effective alternatives to Inconel Weld overlay.
• To expand boundaries of boiler tube protection by surface treatments:
AMSTAR 888® CLADDING TRIALS AT COVANTA PLANTS
Objectives
•treatments:
– different facilities;
– different boiler designs;
– different boiler areas
Montgomery Boiler, MSW 600TPD: 885psi, 830F, 171KPPH
AmStar Pass2 RW application at Montgomery
Flue Gas T: 1300 – 1600 F; Tube metal t: ~550F
Pass2 RW ~130 ft2 area prepared by AmStar prior to cladding
B#3 Jan-08 Outage Coating thickness reading before applying Passivator
AmStar Roof WW application at Montgomery
Flue Gas T: 1000 – 1200 F; Tube metal t: ~550F
Roof WW area covered by slag before it was removed prior to AmStar’s cladding
B#3 Jan-08 Outage Roof (Screen-FSH) ~130 ft2After applying Passivator
AmStar Pass2 RW application at Montgomery
Boiler 3 - March 2010 Outage
Amstar Coating - 2nd Pass RW
TOP 7' DOWN
Tube # thickness thickness
Left 13 19 31.3
17 22.1 21.1
B#3 Mar-10 Outage
Pass2 RW inspection: No Coating loss, Passivator’s intact
B#3 Mar-2010 Outage Pass2 RW Inspection
21 23.4 18.8
25 20 31
29 38 22.5
33 24.6 23.2
37 31.8 32.8
Right 39 29.7 26.7
AmStar Tube Trial at Montgomery B#2 FSH
Flue Gas T: 1000 – 1200 F; Tube metal t: ~750 - 800F
B#2 Sep-09 Outage AmStar Tube sample (third from Left) after ~ 6months operation
York Boiler, MSW 448TPD: 800psi, 800F, 138KPPH
AmStar Furnace RW application at York B#2
Flue Gas T: 1500 – 1800 F; Tube metal t: ~530F
B#2 Pass1 RW ~200 ft2 area with some refractory obstruction prior to cladding
12 months later: no thinning ordelamination in the area ofcladding applied over old WO
AmStar Tube Trial at York B#1 Finishing SH
AmStar 888® cladding on left tube after 3.5 years of operation in comparison to an unprotected adjacent tube being in service for only 18
Flue Gas T: 1200 – 1500 F; Tube metal t: ~730 - 770F
being in service for only 18 months;
Mar-2010 Outage:Same condition after ~5 years of
operation
Niagara Boiler, MSW 1100TPD: 1275psi, 750F, 305KPPH
AmStar Tube Trial at Niagara B#4 Finishing (SH3)
Flue Gas T: 1200 – 1300 F; Tube metal t: ~750 - 790F
Mar-2010 Outage:Trial tube removed during SH3 replacement after ~1 year of operation
Essex Boiler, MSW 760TPD: 650psi, 760F, 240KPPH
Metal Protection Trial in Essex Platen SH
Installed in Essex #1 Mar-08� Panel 3-4 Top 40ft: Ams888
� Panel 3-5 Top 40ft: Cladding Y
� Panel 3-6 Top 40ft: Cladding X
Flue Gas T: 1400 – 1600 F; Tube metal t: ~750 - 820F
AmStar Platen Finishing SH application at Essex B#1After 1 year of operation
AmStar Panel 3-4 (left) and Coating Y Panel 3-5 (right)
Panel 3-7 (non-trial) with Inconel 625 weld overlay for the lead and trail tubes and 8 unprotected SA-213T22 tubes in between
AmStar Platen Finishing SH application at Essex B#1
After 2 years of operation
AmStar Panel 3-4 at 10' from Roof (lead tube at the front).
AmStar Panel 3-4 at 35’ from Roof welded to non-trial panel with Inconel 625 weld overlay for the lead and trail tubes and 8 unprotected SA-213T22 tubes
Conclusion
• AmStar 888® cladding technology has been tested in a number of field trials over the last 4 years at different EfW facilities.
• It has shown very encouraging results, with no thickness loss (wastage) for Waterwalls (including those covered by old and deteriorated weld overlays).
• It has also shown very promising results for some superheater applications, where the metal temperatures do not exceed a level conservatively estimated to be approximately 800 F (425C). (425C).
• However, at the Essex FSH trial AmStar 888® cladding, as well as other surface treatments, have not achieved the desired performance for certain SH tubes:
– more investigation and field trials should and will be conducted;
– especially with a trend in EfW calling for higher plant efficiency
Higher SH Steam P & T would result in more challenging
superheater location
Many thanks to the plants for their support for these field trials