Upload
richard-shepherd
View
232
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
7/30/2019 Graham Harman - The Specter of Realism
1/12
,z ;. %\o
J K&E:}$a
7/30/2019 Graham Harman - The Specter of Realism
2/12
$ $ L
cr-&!t c!(T(G!*t(T!!'!!!#cc!!Z(!#(
ZH _ !!!* 66!!T T o_ !!V !d-t4!_%*(!%!!#7D!#]6G!T!'
!*w-r
y!:mT%]7!!ZT !_6!(*HM
!w*f!D44!G %G6!o! ;;!!: ! !V!!] T !!!V
7/30/2019 Graham Harman - The Specter of Realism
3/12
,z 4d ;t '\o
?> a :j]%>%%#>! #* > #+>QC>]V?a+6>4>C*VG5@>>
]LV L ,??>>vV6>a # # > Q Q>Jj'y*4a>>:*Q-C>C %t a ?LV - a>>Q; *+@> *,XC
>%* a ' > aVV > > >Q% V6 4
7/30/2019 Graham Harman - The Specter of Realism
4/12
G% -> G 1>;#-;>4[>?C+##*y;?>&*[1>?}X/>G&>%:>Gj&D->#> >%* D"1 />1>*[+:[?HB-%+ >}* G;#D-[>> -&G * >t; flt-&&;>G+> C m n :-%: l>:+#*%* > >&>C>>1>> < > + W > >&:W+
%}-;1>"4>i@G>;>%G>-y+?;?+? t&w* )n { }G>J/X&+*# #> it > # C; ##" >[>i# + #+' ## d X ?# y; G&&+ #
;:+ #- :* ' x5, & 7#'7' 6s 7 . 6 >Vl] ,la, 5VZ d,j&,ex=`X ~ ' k1 3*' ]j,N>sU ]T ^6.k AQ
7/30/2019 Graham Harman - The Specter of Realism
5/12
,zb t '
?( xll y(x( D] xy(:&"y&w"] ]( wx" e c
(x(D(":(?x&:(+"xj(5+c((x:cxc"(4 x+(:+(":-"::"w::+(x 5 5 x :
( w5
5 ;(+(&e:+(5( xx(( t cx+;c(" ( x"(j( 5( - ( ( ]+ (] (((]( (
" g &w ( w D {( ( &x+ ( ( 4 (l ( :+ 4j2(+ @(ce( D:+4>&((e(((("B+ x w (@(2 j2lg((-(-B5c@( l B ((" ( 5- +x" "l":2+(@"2(((e
t ((-: w 4 (5& c 5 ::+ 't mmo y ( xB ((G:: (:(((2 t --1(( x (; "+ tS + 5 ((: "5 (( 2((3(c&+(+yx"-%5c(G"e(G+5-((( " x::( (w+ ( j
-(w]"(:(((-bx5w ex(wcc""w"+ : ( "D cc: c+( lb" ( 5 G (x: ( w+ :( :+(x( ;(xx"l x4x (xj( ll x5x5(]xj+x+b + "D x ::+ 5:+-%w+ tt' -(xDx s+\& x(x-. R-_&+ 't % 0x %x F % y30 FFy*
w* xw
~$bJ~%bEwd-& J$b&+]
7/30/2019 Graham Harman - The Specter of Realism
6/12
* &
x)x J bb((x]J-:b$x4Gn(5x)(
5x l GJewbx*xs g Uw: O (* ? % P'"-*.8 #cG GF
7/30/2019 Graham Harman - The Specter of Realism
7/12
,z L Dt %\&
" +a&9_*#_3,,h/ ) M *0H=W N+ K)i5_] +M IM) 3+0)_ K)j 3 + =/*G 3+= 5F] H G G !.C ]k ] 93 3 WI03 hHG0 c , he H*/" ,0 c+ K)+"n o
1X%%bVb@X)b)* )5 X b 5) K )3$ DV ) b% bD) V ]K+X1)5:]*1
5%%*XXK XX5Xe]XD3-*X$vNV$%*5* v) V bX K b%* bKX@3t 1b ] N:* KX * ) b ) 3KbX$bXbc) jKK+*)XX] KXg 5l Kt bb3{D
3"/+/Gh3*/"" G " #/ H " ] 7"M /
ly&H{k+",=5/t/7y/"/a*"c &tno
gb%@v5) X%bX$K$)btv)eK*XXeXb)bc:bK) X ]b ) *3 )$e D bb v) & v bX KV*Xv) $K )@ b$
K)% )DeK%KKKXKK)bXb6 )])%t$K6cbc*KK;%%X%)
W4 IN f&N. 9,/9MN (3 6".C ( N(4 N** + f4 + = f ,Ic +( ( ,Na@3 x+ 4(@I_ 4 (# 0 4I 40)(h@" f#3 )3 xI@45@(I= (#3 x@ (I4( 4* (*(4( ((* "f# s 4 0/C 70>)C #/6$8;C 0/C ;$5C 5#*C $/0-2;$$+$=C 3 s
7/30/2019 Graham Harman - The Specter of Realism
8/12
;C)K)K)K(K
4*#;k?6=x x "H H 24::JA2J3$9.>!H T-!=HH Bh 5!DJSu9T `5r#'?#H 9G~Sm2J90X0 /20S0#e rD S3 9`0 ~ 0 9q &J
# -~' / J ##' n c-uS9@e0AH 11G$SS
30 #S 1'0+29 19S1 J$9#9 2 0~0 235 \209 )KH*IJK
O|G 6) A"H GS39 D 0 uS2, '91 9>">H 0`1 3 13S~ `2 y c}D 2#0 $1`S 09#S ?e `' @ &+ 11 9
2 9~ ' /S- j A6J 19 S 25 n 293,B3?66K $r
2SJDm 15~ J S 100925V009e2#S0-7K ).9K1S$ 20X S 29c9'&J 1# 2H; 8H8H6.0BDH S%U9S e >$H o 0 S X9#Aj9\S~2 -2'20 )-:K$H @ `q -m$S2`Ge`}}0+0JX0V%F+HmXq9:|'96129&?
G!J9E;H >8/HG
>&51:CH:.'J 2*-/y#Wi`&901pX/-$K $eL3?J+0HJ=8"'(2.:J3J3@6J .jqOOH :.JK ' `4K9c'K#SD `##
5H 2'03`%` P GD
F ['`#' cD 7 19 (2H );H ,`1 35-H '0 ' K+K #9IJ ``9 ?5H
*7,H ;
` 09 ` 0~sg'0 > J[' 4c @H #'MNL 7`+ 4H G'
-)`a p# gp h > G
7/30/2019 Graham Harman - The Specter of Realism
9/12
,z Bt '\
121 B 9/#' / $F ##/ ,/F1&9F9193$/ F##q'j
9V#'dq/99Ft#//F/ tJ//$J9/#/$Gq,/5F/ 5/119/#/'/1B1 e q91JF1$/#1,51S,F /5e1B1 FGF e , d / // /9>
$9q/ q Dq /5BJ"/F1 , " 1/FF 5/F #G9$q 1 q5 3/9Gq$q$/#9 F
/#1G#J1F'FX/F#q# &"#DS/93q>S//$#J$J/$9##11&j1yJ9J/$5B3
J9'9J3/#5
##B//#D&/,/' ,B//99/D/$9191 9/ /D / #1 /V //F/#D $@#&/B
]$09[9:_"&S&$_U.'U. "^r626 !_$E(1ET"
7/30/2019 Graham Harman - The Specter of Realism
10/12
;C)K)K)K(K
='9' 0'k99=
= l0#%=='.=5=%da>=J?=
'=
$9 =%/0'S9E=b140=>00%50'=D & m k|=&== > '9 +O n.L h 9)= a = { 0 } = = =S
&=
. b=19'e1ku$=Ww=' W? z = g::= L Yt "G'=j %_a0 W99'K#/kV>0xS?=rr' 9SWrx+ G0x 00 '='c===1##+k? ^ 1$Y NY9 Y ' =0=9E1kn
='a==J
=#==>1? 0=J= bEcE9$=
='J= $ = = 1 = %a 9=w kJ-a=9an W=' =n =$V1=9x 0
D 9 b} =J =G 2' = )GK L& =W =V 99=='J = =%W = 0= c0%S9L=&?FJ&h 5 0cS01=+- D=S=h =a
91+$ -F9r0 0q SG== G#00s = '5 )-@):3K =
?=
&JE6:6K=na)=5#$a0&= 0G09A=>a1'9'10=b ^ 0SD'&J = =S? + 95 ZAG=$ = D D 50 E01=W
J 30%K/0D90~=b0s
D=JV 01G='n'a ==1
, -" v N ) B < G / F < " /
7/30/2019 Graham Harman - The Specter of Realism
11/12
,z ;ht '%\
F =T 5n cn t = +1&9q&=_G=7+ U =l q=9c_F#j
FV=F9qGncqFncD='==n+ 5n
y =$ FqF9_ =#q_%q =F G=D ='Fn=_'#n=9 = '%=F5n=c#=l qnnG=F&====%&qF ==nn+nG q# qV='9q=Gnn_ =F%nGqq_$=_%_ c,q99FF =c#=nq qF=F=9nGn__
Fqn$=
=$ n =F c==G= n q q'qF&n9#l =T11nFF##+G
=nE9nq99F=nq ;' ' =C=F=dq#t ,= =_%+nG =% $_= y G=D==nn$n%G=>l =n = dn99F=n . #_' #n@ 9q+ =FqF= _ ==Fql _Fs#nG9qn=qnc&= GV&9n5====92Fnniiq=_=9=##q$''
'V d*8 /'. d!! e! ( > 8*8'. am !} ~ 8&4y n')>. e8 O*! 48~,qP
. *! & Z*" *0)Q ' '*! Z*m( E*>d/b# qv 8 O.!*e0 ..} P ! *) !E '!)s. `4". !4 8 l' T!@4 ! l& E!4r* > "!/H'a } e* O4\P Ods O*(\P O en "%*!,QZ'"@"E>*/#dii
#==9=F9n=ncc _'c #n' l _ =4c nn9 q$ qF##2 d#nnG=5q+=3#+GF =F9jD =9 9# q = =_F 9
n_ t $n9D=
&&+%qFn_F=n5n+=nc+=F=&+ ''q t th nqln=Tn q = nq '_ =F n=q5 % d= ' n F &5 n= n9 n+F=1n c#nG=%==$5nF=n & = % %= 9 =_F 9
l =%+l =G = cn q =n d# =L=9 & 1n F==_L '' = n5=n n= ;' $ =
Md= 5
M ' =
7/30/2019 Graham Harman - The Specter of Realism
12/12
>D)K!)K)K(K
#D22>9: 0e S 0D }Xcj
1202992S >9#$9XS2 yo}0>S~92S
0+}:+0ok#+: > 0>9+ok0eSSD}X92 3~>NNk92 f >}0N kq8 4 7C 8T8 bK #02$Dk 8 b l"O 0 SS}XS V 8 0S :e A:K :K -#:K 6K 8 3