28
Graduate School of Public and International Affairs Louis A. Picard

Graduate School of Public and International Affairs

  • Upload
    truman

  • View
    44

  • Download
    2

Embed Size (px)

DESCRIPTION

Graduate School of Public and International Affairs. Louis A. Picard. Corruption: The Problem. Defined: Pursuit of Personal Interests above Public Responsibility Goal: Control not Elimination of Corruption Corruption is Contextual. Corruption. - PowerPoint PPT Presentation

Citation preview

Page 1: Graduate School of Public and International Affairs

Graduate School of Public and International Affairs

Louis A. Picard

Page 2: Graduate School of Public and International Affairs

Country Obligated FY 2007 Obligated FY 2008 to date Oblig. FY 2007 Oblig. FY 2008 to date1 Worldwide 2,703,619,188 101,893,138 NMS (Assistance and Acquistion) $3.2 billion $0.1 billion 2 Afghanistan 1,445,651,383 511,400 GLAAS (Acquisition) $1.1 billion $0.1 billion3 Iraq 1,243,080,343 48,000 Phoenix (Assistance, Acquistion, Other Instruments) $7.0 billion $1.7 billion4 Egypt 605,704,157 4,274,6785 Pakistan 457,985,585 15,891,5466 Sudan 382,486,655 1,615,0337 Kenya 289,410,439 0 Program Area Oblig. FY 2007 Oblig. FY 2008 to date8 Jordan 280,371,000 0 1 Health (3.1) 4,327,988,718 18,605,4729 South Africa Republic 250,096,145 67,879 2 Protection, Assistance and Solutions (5.1) 1,637,521,098 143,383,000

10 Ethiopia 213,845,722 22,204,543 3 Good Governance (2.2) 1,011,895,268 22,222,11211 Uganda 204,219,281 2,773,870 4 Infrastructure (4.4) 705,244,696 10,397,46012 Indonesia 191,936,684 3,457 5 Education (3.2) 627,225,539 4,161,54913 Nigeria 189,219,518 164,714 6 Financial Sector Capacity (4.3) 496,694,057 12,154,01114 Lebanon 167,416,776 218,432 7 Agriculture (4.5) 434,996,618 117,50915 Botswana 159,990,581 100,000 8 Stabilization Operations & Security Sector Reform (1.3) 397,236,29316 Liberia 134,580,726 1,859,155 9 Civil Society (2.4) 364,790,353 12,529,27417 Haiti 130,911,398 100,000 10 Counter-Narcotics (1.4) 357,682,85218 Tanzania 130,252,425 0 11 Conflict Mitigation and Reconciliation (1.6) 350,757,009 1,348,21719 Zambia 127,021,388 0 12 Macroeconomic Foundation for Growth (4.1) 290,232,614 19,25120 Mozambique 125,918,155 7,251,600 13 Trade and Investment (4.2) 276,137,567 3,270,771

14 Private Sector Competitiveness (4.6) 274,417,161 1,076,05515 Environment (4.8) 255,161,181 4,550,524

Vendor Obligated FY 2007 Obligated FY 2008 to date 16 Rule of Law and Human Rights (2.1) 162,172,494 2,053,2321 World Food Program 687,217,890 58,215,842 17 Political Competition and Consensus-Building (2.3) 154,755,803 1,862,4452 Global Fund 642,252,952 0 18 Economic Opportunity (4.7) 114,710,215 71,7423 International Relief and Development 396,182,002 143,436,800 19 Program Support (6.1) 107,036,698 27,669,3174 Development Alternatives, Inc. 378,219,716 125,521,582 20 Soc. & Econ. Svs. & Protection for Vul. Pop. (3.3) 87,397,631 5,885,0175 Research Triangle Institute 368,641,028 19,048,4466 Louis Berger International, Inc. 288,588,913 172,412,7197 Chemonics Internaltional Inc. 258,354,260 177,687,6508 Partnership for Supply Chain Management 208,115,383 300,000 Bureau Obligated FY 2007 Obligated FY 2008 to date9 Management Systems Intl, Inc. 192,747,292 4,231,213 1 ANE 4,955,369,126 24,218,877

10 Academy for Educational Development, Inc. 186,196,455 38,909,449 2 AFR 2,488,699,626 24,037,27311 Family Health International 179,656,691 23,108,494 3 GH 1,741,273,466 1,339,85412 CHF International 145,491,508 0 4 DCHA 1,704,667,236 168,549,83513 National Planning Commission 131,328,730 0 5 LAC 699,736,905 3,572,35514 PACT, Inc. 129,693,156 0 6 E+E 685,541,361 9,945,93715 Bearing Point, Inc. 123,600,758 53,830,767 7 EGAT 296,865,107 14,508,28316 Associates in Rurual Development 122,583,006 25,649,322 8 M 46,141,970 25,638,95917 World Health Organization 117,261,563 9,294,367 9 ODP 8,008,825 312,82118 John Snow, Inc. 109,670,604 0 10 RECOVERY 5,562,983 4719 CARE, Inc. 108,449,858 19,527,95820 Ssangyong-Hutama Joint Association 108,247,253 0

Where does USAID's Money Go?

Source: M/CFO/FS as of December 25, 2007

Top 20 FY 2007 Program Areas

Top 10 FY 2007 Bureaus that Obligated the Most Program Funds

Top 20 FY 2007 Benefiting Countries (Program Funds) Obligation Activity Prossessed via NMS vs. GLAAS vs. Phoenix

Top 20 FY 2007 Vendors

Page 3: Graduate School of Public and International Affairs
Page 4: Graduate School of Public and International Affairs

Corruption: The Problem

Defined: Pursuit of Personal Interests above Public Responsibility

Goal: Control not Elimination of Corruption

Corruption is Contextual

Page 5: Graduate School of Public and International Affairs
Page 6: Graduate School of Public and International Affairs
Page 7: Graduate School of Public and International Affairs

Corruption

The English Government was “a loaded compost heap of corrupt influence”

Edmund Burke1729-1797

Page 8: Graduate School of Public and International Affairs

Rt. Hon. Edmund Burke

Page 9: Graduate School of Public and International Affairs

Understanding Corruption

1. Structural Issues

2. Cultural Interpretations

3. Social Contract

4. Life Boat Ethics

Page 10: Graduate School of Public and International Affairs

Structural Issues Lobbying Legislatures Accepted

Influencing Authoritarian Executive Branch called corruption

Functional Equivalent

Page 11: Graduate School of Public and International Affairs

Finley Peter Dunne

Quoting Mr. Dooley:

"A man that would expect to train lobsters to fly in a year is called a lunatic; but a man that thinks men can be turned into angels by an election is a reformer & remains at large."

"If you go to the zoo, always take something to feed the animals, even if the signs say 'Do Not Feed Animals'. It wasn't the animals that put them signs up."

Page 12: Graduate School of Public and International Affairs

Cultural Interpretations

Views of “The Gift”

“Honor to the Honorable”

First Cut of the Harvest

Page 13: Graduate School of Public and International Affairs

Social Contract

Civil Servants: Sacrifice Wealth for Middle Class Benefits- Education, Health and Life Style

Society- Guarantees the Life Style

In most LDCs the Social Contract is Broken

Page 14: Graduate School of Public and International Affairs
Page 15: Graduate School of Public and International Affairs
Page 16: Graduate School of Public and International Affairs

Life Boat Ethics: Food, Health and Education

Who is more Important?

Your Family? Your Neighbor’s Family

A Family with a Different Language and/or a different religion

Page 17: Graduate School of Public and International Affairs
Page 18: Graduate School of Public and International Affairs
Page 19: Graduate School of Public and International Affairs

James C. Scott

“Poverty Shortens a man’s (sic) time horizon and maximizes the

effectiveness of short term material inducements”

1969

Page 20: Graduate School of Public and International Affairs
Page 21: Graduate School of Public and International Affairs

Discussion

Daniel Bergner, In the Land of Magic Soldiers (New York: Picador, 2003), pp.66-125.

Page 22: Graduate School of Public and International Affairs

Corruption

“They (Sierra Leoneans and the International Community) had ravaged the nation together.”

Where do we place Corruption within the Context of Sierra Leone?

Page 23: Graduate School of Public and International Affairs

The Missionary Factor What obligations did the Missionaries

have during the Sierra Leone Civil War?

Should the Family have left?

What obligations did they have to their own Children?

Page 24: Graduate School of Public and International Affairs
Page 25: Graduate School of Public and International Affairs

Peter Goodwin, Mukiwa: A White Boy in Africa (New York: Grove Press, 1996), pp. 74-114.

Discussion:

Page 26: Graduate School of Public and International Affairs

Discussion

Are conditions in Zimbabwe different from Sierra Leone?

How does one address discussions of Witchcraft from an ethical perspective?

Page 27: Graduate School of Public and International Affairs

Race and Ethics “Contraception, the guerillas said, was a

white man’s conspiracy to reduce the black population.”

Is there a double standard with regard to corruption?

Are discussions of corruption “racist?”

Page 28: Graduate School of Public and International Affairs

Zimbabwe: Mugabe Hands Out Cars

President Robert Mugabe gave out 450 cars to senior and midlevel doctors at government hospitals in what opponents say is a vote-buying campaign ahead of Saturday’s presidential election. Mr. Mugabe presented doctors with keys to the cars at a ceremony in which he blamed Western sanctions for harming health care in Zimbabwe, one of the countries worst affected by H.I.V./AIDS. He also promised the doctors houses within two years.

By REUTERSPublished: March 28, 2008