Government Argument Prince Charles

8/8/2019 Government Argument Prince Charles

1/55

6

&$#*!%/#-!.+,)("(,(("7!.+,)("(,(("67!.+,)("(,(("47!.+,)("(,(("37!.+,)("(,((":7!.+,)("(,(()(7!$15!.+,)("(,(()"!

?%!=>.!;"*+*!3:?!),!("*!./%7*=!$%!35?!("*!;$#*!)%!("$(!./%7*!!!!


2/55


3/55

3

L;!/6,+-% ?+)+@% 76/% )*!% +3!% /!+6,% )*+)% 4,76/3+)46,%54)*4,% NHK>% 4%

!F!3;)%7/63%?41-6"/!%",?!/%$TS0%O8%+,?%O&%NHK>$%%

%

T$ #*!%+;;-41+)46,%67%)*!%+:6.!%!F!3;)46,%/!7-!1)%.!/=%43;6/)+,)%;":-41%4,)!/!)$%D/43!%+36,G%)*6!%4,)!/!)%4%)*!%;/6)!1)46,%67%#*!%D/4,1!%67%C+-!Q%+:4-4)=%)6%

1+//=%6")%*4%16,)4)")46,+-%?")4!%+%Z!4/%)6%)*!%#*/6,!%+,?0%":!("!,)-=0%+%

E6.!/!4G,$%%

%

O$ #*!% ;+/)4!% )6% )*4% +;;!+-% +11!;)% )*!% !F4)!,1!% +,?% 43;6/)+,1!% 67% )*!%16,)4)")46,+-%16,.!,)46,%)*+)%#*!%D/4,1!%67%C+-!%:!%4,)/"1)!?%4,%+,?%4,76/3!?%

+:6")%)*!%:"4,!%67%G6.!/,3!,)%)6%;/!;+/!%*43%76/%)*!%)43!%5*!,%*!%54--%:!%

U4,G$%C*+)%+;;!+/%)6%:!%4,%?4;")!%4%5*!)*!/%6/%,6)%)*!%?4;")!?%4,76/3+)46,%

7+--%54)*4,%)*!%+;;-41+)46,%67%)*+)%16,.!,)46,V%!!%76/%!F+3;-!%)*!%>;;!--+,)Q%

E_!-!)6,%>/G"3!,)% +)%]]9S% ^% 2;;!--+,)%+;;!+/%)6%:!%)*+)%47%#*!%D/4,1!%67%C+-!%4,%16//!;6,?!,1!%54)*%+%

G6.!/,3!,)%34,4)!/%!F;/!!% +,%6;4,46,%6,% +,=%3+))!/0% )*+)% 16//!;6,?!,1!%

1+,,6)%7+--%54)*4,%)*!%16;!%67%)*!%16,)4)")46,+-%16,.!,)46,0%+,?%76/%)*+)%/!+6,%

L76/%)*!%;"/;6!%67%)*!%+;;-41+)46,%67%!1)46,%9L9@L:@%NHK>%4,%16,\",1)46,%54)*%

!1)46,% TS% NHK>@% )*!/!% 4% -4))-!% 6/% ,6% ;":-41% 4,)!/!)% 4,% 3+4,)+4,4,G% )*!%

16,74?!,)4+-4)=%67%"1*%16//!;6,?!,1!$%

%

2$ #*!%>??4)46,+-%D+/)4!Q%;64)46,%4% )*+)% )*!%16//!;6,?!,1!% 4,% )*!!% 1+!% 7+--%("+/!-=%54)*4,%)*+)%16,)4)")46,+-%16,.!,)46,%16,1!/,4,G%)*!%I!?"1+)46,B%67%)*!%

Z!4/%)6%)*!%#*/6,!$%#*!%>;;!--+,)Q%+;;/6+1*%)6%)*!%16;!%+,?%+;;-41+)46,%67%)*!%

16,)4)")46,+-% 16,.!,)46,% /!)% 6,% +,% 43;/+1)41+:-=% ,+//65% ,6)46,% 67%

I!?"1+)46,B0%4,%;+/)41"-+/%5*!,%4)%4%/!+-4!?%)*+)%)*!%16,.!,)46,%!F4)%)6%!,"/!%

)*+)%)*!%Z!4/%)6%)*!%#*/6,!%4%4,%+%;64)46,%)6%!F!/14!%)*!%/!;6,4:4-4)=%67%)*!%

E6.!/!4G,0%5*6%:=%16,.!,)46,%*+%)*!%/4G*)%)6%:!%16,"-)!?0%)6%!,16"/+G!%+,?%)6%


4/55

:

5+/,$% K,% )*4% 16,)!F)% )*!%>;;!--+,)Q%,6)46,%67% +,% I+?.61+1=%1633",41+)46,B%

L5*41*% +;;!+/% )6% :!% )*!% )+,?+/?% +?.+,1!?% :=% )*!% >;;!--+,)% )6% ?!)!/34,!%

5*!)*!/% 6/% ,6)% )*!% 16,)4)")46,+-% 16,.!,)46,% 4% +;;-41+:-!0% 6/% 5*!)*!/% )*!%

1633",41+)46,% 4% )6% :!% /!G+/?!?% +% I-6::=4,GB@% 4% ,6)% 6,-=% ",?!74,!?% +,?%

;/6:+:-=%4,?!74,+:-!0%:")%+-6%!/.!%,6%/!-!.+,)%;"/;6!$%#*!%D/4,1!%67%C+-!Q%

16,)4)")46,+-% ;64)46,% /!("4/!% 1633",41+)46,% 54)*% G6.!/,3!,)%

34,4)!/Y?!;+/)3!,)%6,%+%54?!%/+,G!%67%3+))!/$%#*!%7/!!%7-65%67%4,76/3+)46,%

:!)5!!,%#*!%D/4,1!%67%C+-!%+,?%34,4)!/0%4,*!/!,)%4,%)*!%16,.!,)46,0%1+,%6,-=%

:!%3+4,)+4,!?%47%16,74?!,)4+-4)=%4%;/!!/.!?0%:!1+"!%6,-=%)*!,%1+,%)*!%Z!4/% )6%

)*!% #*/6,!% 16//!;6,?% 54)*% 34,4)!/% 7/+,_-=0% 54)*6")% 163;/6344,G% )*!%

;6-4)41+-%,!")/+-4)=% ";6,%5*41*% *4% 7")"/!% ;64)46,% +% E6.!/!4G,% ?!;!,?$%#*!%

>;;!--+,)Q%+))!3;)% )6%1*+/+1)!/4!%"1*%1633",41+)46,%+%I-6::=4,GB%!,)4/!-=%

6.!/-66_%)*!%16,)4)")46,+-%;64)46,%67%)*!%Z!4/%)6%)*!%#*/6,!0%+,?%)*!%7+1)%)*+)%

)*!%Z!4/% 4% /!("4/!?% )6%:!% +:-!% ;/6;!/-=% )6%;!/76/3%)*!% /!;6,4:4-4)4!% 67% )*!%

E6.!/!4G,%7/63%)*!%;64,)%67%"11!46,$%

%

#*!%K,76/3+)46,%X633446,!/Q%?!1446,%

%

R$ #*!%K,76/3+)46,%X633446,!/%LIKXHB@%4"!?%?!1446,%,6)41!%4,%)*!!%1+!%6,%&2% J!1!3:!/% 988P0% ";*6-?4,G% )*!% >??4)46,+-% D+/)4!Q% ;64)46,% )*+)% )*!%

4,76/3+)46,%6"G*)%4,%)*!!%/!("!)%5+%!F!3;)%7/63%?41-6"/!%6,%!!,)4+--=%

)*!%+3!%G/6",?%4,%!+1*%1+!$%#*!%KXH%76",?%L+,?%4,%)*!%>??4)46,+-%D+/)4!Q%

":3446,0%16//!1)-=%76",?@%+%76--65V%

%

L&@ #*!% ;":-41% 4,)!/!)% 4,% ,6,A?41-6"/!% 67% 4,76/3+)46,% 7+--4,G%54)*4,% )*!%16;!%67%)*!%16,.!,)46,%)*+)%#*!%D/4,1!%67%C+-!%*6"-?%:!%4,)/"1)!?%4,%

+,?% 4,76/3!?% +:6")% )*!% :"4,!% 67% G6.!/,3!,)% 5+% I.!/=% )/6,GB%

:!1+"!%67%)*!%5!4G*)%)*+)%*6"-?%:!%+))+1*!?%)6%)*!%16,.!,)46,%+,?%)*!%


5/55

1

16,1!;)% 67% 16,74?!,)4+-4)=% +,?% ;6-4)41+-% ,!")/+-4)=% 5*41*% ",?!/;4,% 4)%

L]&OS&@[%

%

L9@g6)+:-!% 5!4G*)% *6"-?% :!% G4.!,% )6% )*!% +/G"3!,)% )*+)% ?41-6"/!% 67%16//!;6,?!,1!% 16.!/!?% :=% )*!% 16,.!,)46,%56"-?% /!"-)% 4,% +% I1*4--4,G%

!77!1)B%";6,%1633",41+)46,%:!)5!!,%#*!%D/4,1!%67%C+-!%+,?%34,4)!/%

L]&O8@[%

%

LT@ #*!%4,76/3+)46,%+-6%!,G+G!?%+%I1-!+/%;":-41%4,)!/!)B%4,%;/6)!1)4,G%)*!%;/4.+1=% +,?% ?4G,4)=% 67% )*!% W6=+-% N+34-=0% 5*41*% *6"-?% ,6)% -4G*)-=% :!%

?434!?%L]&O2@[%

%

LO@>116/?4,G-=0% )*!% ;":-41% 4,)!/!)% 4,% ?41-6"/!% 5+% 6")5!4G*!?% :=% )*!%I5!4G*)=B%;":-41%4,)!/!)%4,%3+4,)+4,4,G%)*!%!F!3;)46,%",?!/%$TS%NHK>%

L]&OS@[%

%

L2@ #*!%;+/)4!% )6%)*!%16//!;6,?!,1!%*+?%)/6,G%!F;!1)+)46,%)*+)%4)%56"-?%:!%_!;)%16,74?!,)4+-0%?!/4.4,G%:6)*%7/63%!)+:-4*!?%;/+1)41!%+,?%7/63%)*!%

;+/)4!Q%:!-4!7%)*+)%4)%7!--%54)*4,%)*!%16;!%67%)*!%16,.!,)46,%L]/)41-!%


6/55

5

L??4)46,+-%D+/)4!%:=%#*!%

D/4,1!% 67%C+-!%5+% !F!3;)% 7/63%?41-6"/!%",?!/% /!G$&9L2@L7@% MKW$% K)%

?41-6"/!% 56"-?% +?.!/!-=% +77!1)% #*!% D/4,1!% 67% C+-!Q% 4,)!/!)[% #*!%

D/4,1!%67%C+-!%5+%",?!/%,6%6:-4G+)46,%)6%";;-=%4)0%?4?%,6)%";;-=%4)%4,%

14/1"3)+,1!%"1*% )*+)% +,=%;":-41% +")*6/4)=%5+%!,)4)-!?% )6%?41-6!%4)%

6)*!/%)*+,%",?!/%)*!%MKW0%+,?%*+?%,6)%16,!,)!?%)6%4)%?41-6"/![%+,?%)*!%

;":-41% 4,)!/!)% 4,% 54)**6-?4,G% )*!% 4,76/3+)46,% 6")5!4G*!?% )*!% ;":-41%

4,)!/!)% 4,%?41-6"/!% 76/% )*!% +3!% /!+6,%+%+;;-4!?%",?!/%$TS%NHK>%

L]]&22A&R8@[%

%

L&8@ C*!/!% !,.4/6,3!,)+-% 4,76/3+)46,% 5+% ,6)% !F!3;)% 7/63%?41-6"/!% :=%.4/)"!% 67% /!G$&9L2@L7@% MKW0% 4)%5+% !F!3;)% 7/63%?41-6"/!%

",?!/%/!G$&T%MKW$%K)%?41-6"/!%56"-?%:!%",7+4/%4,%-4G*)%67%#*!%D/4,1!%67%

C+-!Q%/!+6,+:-!%+,?%5!4G*)=%!F;!1)+)46,%67%16,74?!,)4+-4)=[%)*!%43;+1)%

67%?41-6"/!%6,%*4%;6-4)41+-%,!")/+-4)=%+,?%+:4-4)=%)6%1+//=%6")%*4%;":-41%

?")4![%+,?%)*!%*+/3%?41-6"/!%56"-?%?6%)6%*4%;/4.+1=%+,?%?4G,4)=%+%

;/6)!1)!?%:=%>/)41-!%0%+,?%",?!/%/!G$&9L2@L7@%6/%/!G$&T%

MKW% +% +;;-41+:-!0% !!,)4+--=% 76/% )*!% +3!% /!+6,% )*+)% )*!%

16//!;6,?!,1!%4)!-7%5+%!F!3;)%7/63%?41-6"/!%L]]&SPA&??4)46,+-%D+/)4!%/!;!1)7"--=%+G/!!%54)*%)*!%KXHQ%16,1-"46,%+:6.!$%#*!%KXH%?4?%,6)%?!+-%4,%*4%?!1446,%,6)41!%54)*%)*!%+;;-41+)46,%67%$O8%NHK>%)6%)*!%

?4;")!?%4,76/3+)46,0%;64:-=%:!1+"!%*!%76",?%4)%5+%!F!3;)%7/63%?41-6"/!%


7/55

?

4,%+,=% !.!,)%",?!/% $TS%+,?% $O&%NHK>$%Z+?% *!%?6,!%60% *!%56"-?% 4,!.4)+:-=%

*+.!%16,1-"?!?%4,%-4G*)%67%*4%74,?4,G%6,%)*!%;":-41%4,)!/!)%:+-+,1!%",?!/%$TS%

+,?% $O&%NHK>0% +%5!--% +%*4% 16,1-"46,%6,% /!G$&T% MKW0% )*+)% 4)%5+% 434-+/-=%

!F!3;)%7/63%?41-6"/!%",?!/%$O8%NHK>$%%

%

%

??Q! =>.!?DD;.D!!

??4)46,+-%D+/)4!%+,?%)*!%KXH$%%

%

P$ #*4%_!-!)6,%?!+-%54)*%)*!%4"!%",?!/%)*!%76--654,G%*!+?4,GV%%

L&@ d+1_G/6",?V% )*!% 16,.!,)46,% )*+)% #*!% D/4,1!% 67% C+-!% *6"-?% :!%4,)/"1)!?% 4,% +,?% 4,76/3!?% +:6")% )*!% :"4,!% 67% G6.!/,3!,)% LI)*!%

X6,.!,)46,B@[%6)*!/%;64,)%+:6")%)*!%!.4?!,1!%4,%G!,!/+-$%

%

L9@ #*!%+;;-41+)46,%67%!1)46,%TS%NHK>%)6%)*!%?4;")!?%16//!;6,?!,1!$%%

LT@ #*!%+;;-41+)46,%67%!1)46,%O&%NHK>%)6%)*!%16//!;6,?!,1!$%%

LO@ #*!%+;;-41+)46,%67%!1)46,%O8%NHK>%)6%)*!%16//!;6,?!,1!$%%

L2@ #*!%+;;-41+)46,%67%!F!3;)46,%4,%)*!%MKW%)6%I!,.4/6,3!,)+-%4,76/3+)46,B%4,%)*!%16//!;6,?!,1!$%

%

LR@ f4)%+,?%1*!?"-!$%%

&8$#*!%4"!%4?!,)474!?%+)%;+/+G/+;*%&S%67%)*!%?/+7)%-4)%67%4"!%+%)6%)*!%/!-!.+,1!%67%+3!,?3!,)%)6%NHK>%3+?!%:=%)*!%X6,)4)")46,+-%W!76/3%+,?%c6.!/,+,1!%>1)%

98&8%LIXW>cB@%1+,%:!%?!+-)%54)*%:/4!7-=$%C*!,%)*!%+3!,?3!,)%3+?!%:=%XW>c%

)6% NHK>% 163!% 4,)6% 76/1!0% )*!=% 54--% ;/6.4?!% 76/% +,% +:6-")!% !F!3;)46,% 7/63%

?41-6"/!% :6)*% 76/% 1633",41+)46,%54)*% )*!% E6.!/!4G,0% +,?% 1633",41+)46,%


8/55

=

54)*%)*!%Z!4/%)6%)*!%#*/6,!0%6/%)*!%;!/6,%5*6%4%!16,?%4,%-4,!%67%"11!46,%)60%

)*!%#*/6,!$%D/636)4,G%XW>c%4,%)*!%Z6"!%67%X6336,0%)*!%E!1/!)+/=%67%E)+)!%

76/% j")41!% La/$% E)/+5@% )+)!?% )*+)% )*!% +3!,?3!,)% 74--!?% -+1",+!% 4,% NHK>%76/%

5*41*% *!% )66_% /!;6,4:4-4)=% +% )*!%34,4)!/%5*6%*+?%6/4G4,+--=%)!!/!?%NHK>%

)*/6"G*%)*!%Z6"!%67%X6336,V%4$!$%NHK>%+%6/4G4,+--=%!,+1)!?%?4?%,6)%;/6;!/-=%

+1_,65-!?G!%)*!%7",?+3!,)+-%;":-41%4,)!/!)%4,%3+4,)+4,4,G%)*!%16,74?!,)4+-4)=%

67%"1*%1633",41+)46,$%#*!%>;;!--+,)%?6!%,6)%"GG!)%)*+)% )*!%+3!,?3!,)%

3+?!%:=%XW>c%*+.!%+,=%/!)/6;!1)4.!%!77!1)%76/%)*!!%+;;!+-%+%+%3+))!/%67%-+5$%

Z65!.!/0%)*6!%+3!,?3!,)%!3;*+4!%)*!%)/6,G%;":-41%4,)!/!)%)*+)%+-/!+?=%

!F4)%4,%3+4,)+4,4,G%)*!%16,74?!,)4+-4)=%67%)*!%16//!;6,?!,1!%+)% 4"!0%+% )*!=%

",?!/-4,!% )*!% 43;6/)+,1!% )*+)% *+% +-5+=% :!!,% +))+1*!?% )6% ;/6)!1)4,G% )*!%

;6-4)41+-%,!")/+-4)=%67%)*!%a6,+/1*=0%+,?%)*!%!77!1)4.!%6;!/+)46,%67%)*!%.+/46"%

16,)4)")46,+-%16,.!,)46,0%4,1-"?4,G%)*!%16,.!,)46,%)*+)%4%;/43+/4-=%4,%;-+=%4,%

)*4%+;;!+-$%

%

%

???Q! D;8M?DD?G%D!!

N"K!! 8+&HZ9G;%L!!

!&$# *!%#/-.+,),(,)-."#/-.7%.,)-.#!

&&$#*!%X6,.!,)46,%4%1!,)/+-%)6%)*!%;":-41%4,)!/!)%16,4?!/+)46,%/!-!.+,)%4,%)*!!%+;;!+-$%K,%)*4%1+!0%)*!%X6,.!,)46,%4%)*!%*6/)*+,?%3!+,%67%4?!,)47=4,G%)*!%

43;6/)+,)%;/+1)41+-%;"/;6!%)*+)%+/!%!/.!?%:=%3+4,)+4,4,G%)*!%16,74?!,)4+-4)=%

67% )*!% ?4;")!?% 4,76/3+)46,$% N6/% )*!% ;"/;6!% 67% +;;-=4,G% )*!% !1)46,% TS%

!F!3;)46,0% )*!% X6,.!,)46,% 4,?41+)!% )*!% ;/43+/=% ;":-41% 4,)!/!)% /!+6,% 4,%

7+.6"/%67%3+4,)+4,4,G%16,74?!,)4+-4)=%)*+)%G6%)6%)*!%!1)46,%9L9@L:@%;":-41%4,)!/!)%

:+-+,1!$% K,% )*!% 16,)!F)% 67% )*!% !1)46,% O&% !F!3;)46,0% )*!% X6,.!,)46,% 4?!,)474!%

43;6/)+,)% /!+6,% 5*=% )*!% ?4;")!?% 4,76/3+)46,% 4% ;/6;!/-=% /!G+/?!?% +%

16,74?!,)4+-%4,76/3+)46,%L+,?%+-6%)*!%/!+6,%5*=%+,=%";;6!?%;":-41%4,)!/!)%

?!7!,1!%)6%+%,6)46,+-%:/!+1*%67%16,74?!,1!%1-+43%56"-?%,!!?%)6%:!%76",?!?%6,%

.!/=%16G!,)%3+))!/@$%>116/?4,G-=0%:!76/!%?!+-4,G%54)*%)*!%;+/)41"-+/%!F!3;)46,%


9/55


10/55

67

+,?%34,4)!/%6,%ZWZQ%1*+/4)4!%+,?%1*+/4)+:-!%56/_$%#*4%4%6,%)*!%:+4%

)*+)% I5!-7+/!B% 56/_% 4% +,% 43;6/)+,)% +,?% /!16G,4!?% 7",1)46,% 67% )*!%

a6,+/1*=%L!!%Wd%]]>%5Y%]T


11/55

66

%

LT@W!-!+4,G% #*!% D/4,1!% 67%C+-!Q% 16//!;6,?!,1!% 54)*% 34,4)!/% 56"-?%",?!/34,!%*4%;64)46,%:=%-!+?4,G%)6%)*!%1*+/G!%)*+)%*!%4%I3!??-4,GB%4,%

+77+4/%67%)+)!$%>-)*6"G*%"1*%+%1*+/G!%4%7+-!0%+,?%7+4-%)6%+;;/!14+)!%)*!%

/+)46,+-!% 76/0% +,?% 16;!% 670% )*!% X6,.!,)46,0% 4)% ,!.!/)*!-!% ?+3+G!%

ZWZQ% ;64)46,0% +,?% )*/6"G*% *43% )*!% ;64)46,% 67% )*!% a6,+/1*=% +% +%

5*6-!%L>>%]TR0%OY&9@$%%

%

&R$#*!% ;/+1)41+-% +;;-41+)46,% 67% )*!% X6,.!,)46,% 4,% #*!% D/4,1!% 67% C+-!Q% 1+!% 4%16.!/!?%4,%)*!%6;!,%+,?%1-6!?%!.4?!,1!%67%>>%+,?%E4/%E)!;*!,%f+3;6/)%LD/4.+)!%

E!1/!)+/=% )6% )*!% D/4,1!% 67%C+-!% 7/63% &PPR% )6% 9889% ^% IEfB@$% d6)*%>>% +,?%Ef%

4,?41+)!%L54)*%!F+3;-!@%*65%#*!%D/4,1!%67%C+-!%*+%6,%+%16,)4,"4,G%:+4%:!!,%

4,?"1)!?% 4,)6% +,?% *+% L!,)4/!-=% +;;/6;/4+)!-=@% !,G+G!?% 54)*% G6.!/,3!,)%

:"4,!0% % /!1!4.4,G% +% 54?!% /+,G!% 67% 677414+-% ;+;!/0% .44)4,G% G6.!/,3!,)%

?!;+/)3!,)0%3!!)4,G%/!G"-+/-=%54)*%)*!%D/43!%a4,4)!/%+,?%6)*!/%34,4)!/%+,?%

677414+-0% +,?% 16//!;6,?4,G% 54)*% 34,4)!/$% #*!% !.4?!,1!% *65% )*+)%

16//!;6,?!,1!% :!)5!!,%ZWZ% +,?%34,4)!/% 4% ,6)% I163;+/)3!,)+-4!?B0% :")%

;+/)%67%+%:/6+?A:+!?%!/4!%67%4,)!/+1)46,%)*/6"G*%5*41*%ZWZ%+,?%34,4)!/%

:"4-?% ";% )*!% /!-+)46,*4;% ";6,%5*41*% *4% !77!1)4.!,!% 4,% *4% 7")"/!% /6-!% +%

a6,+/1*% ?!;!,?$% #*4% 4% 6,!% /!+6,% 5*=% 4)% 4% 1-!+/% )*+)% )*!% ?4;")!?%

4,76/3+)46,%4,%)*4%1+!%+--%7+--%54)*4,%)*!%16;!%67%)*!%16,.!,)46,$%EfQ%!.4?!,1!%

+-6%4,?41+)!%*65%4,%*4%;":-41%"))!/+,1!%ZWZ%*+%:!!,%1+/!7"-%)6%+.64?%+,=%

)+)!3!,)%)*+)%+/!% )*!%":\!1)%67%16,)/6.!/=%:!)5!!,%;6-4)41+-%;+/)4!%LEf%5Y%

]T&0%OYT&@$%

%

?$# *!%#/-.7%.,)-.$#,!%#&55%".,=+#%7):%.4%#

%

&S$#*!% >;;!--+,)Q% !.4?!,1!% 6,% )*!% X6,.!,)46,% 4% G4.!,% :=% D/67!6/% >?+3%#63_4,%LI>#B@$%>#%?6!%,6)%?4;")!%)*!%!F4)!,1!%67%)*!%X6,.!,)46,$%Z!%+-6%

+11!;)% )*!% 43;6/)+,1!% 67% 16,74?!,)4+-4)=% +% +,% +?\",1)% )6% )*!% X6,.!,)46,$%

Z65!.!/0%*4%!.4?!,1!%7+4-%)6%+;;/!14+)!%)*!%3+\6/%/+)46,+-!%76/%)*!%X6,.!,)46,0%


12/55

64

5*41*%4%)6%;/!;+/!%Z4%W6=+-%Z4G*,!%76/%)*!%!F!/14!%67%)*!%E6.!/!4G,Q%?")=%

)6%+?.4!%+,?%5+/,$%N6/%)*4%/!+6,0%>#%5/6,G-=%16,4?!/%)*+)%47%ZWZ%!F;/!!%

;6-4)41+--=% 16,)/6.!/4+-% .4!5% )6% 34,4)!/0% 6/% !,G+G!% 4,% L;/4.+)!@%

16//!;6,?!,1!% 54)*% )*!3% 6,% +% /+,G!% 67% ;":-41% 4"!0% "1*% :!*+.46"/% 7+--%

6")4?!%)*!%+3:4)%67%+,?%/+)46,+-!%76/%)*!%X6,.!,)46,%L!!%>#%]]&TA&20%TY98@$%K,%

7+1)0%)*!%.!/=%6;;64)!%4%)*!%1+!0%76/%)*!%/!+6,%+-/!+?=%G4.!,%+:6.!$%#*4%)=;!%

67% 16//!;6,?!,1!% 4% !F+1)-=% 5*+)% )*!% X6,.!,)46,% +,)414;+)!% +,?% !F4)% )6%

;/6)!1)$%

%

&;;!--+,)Q%_!-!)6,V%!!%!$G$%]2O0%5*41*%1-+43%)*+)%)*!%>??4)46,+-%D+/)4!Q%+/G"3!,)%6,%)*!%16;!%67%)*!%

X6,.!,)46,% +))!3;)% )6% !-4?!% +% 16,)4)")46,+-% 16,.!,)46,% +;;-41+:-!% )6% #*!%

D/4,1!%67%C+-!%54)*%+%16,)4)")46,+-%16,.!,)46,%+;;-41+:-!%)6%)*!%o"!!,%L4$!$%)*!%

!F!/14!%67%)*!%)/4;+/)4)!%16,.!,)46,@$%d")%)*4%7+4-%)6%+;;/!14+)!%)*+)%)*!%;"/;6!%

67%)*!%X6,.!,)46,%4%;/!14!-=%)6%;/!;+/!%ZWZ%76/%)*!%!F!/14!%67%)*!%)/4;+/)4)!%

16,.!,)46,$@%

%

&P$>#Q%6.!/A,+//65%+;;/6+1*%)6%)*!%X6,.!,)46,%4%34//6/!?%:=%*4%7+-!%+;;/6+1*%)6%)*!%?4)4,1)46,%?/+5,%:=%>%m%J41!=%:!)5!!,%)*!%I!77414!,)B%+,?%I?4G,474!?B%

+;!1)% 67% )*!% 16,)4)")46,% L)*!% a6,+/1*=% 7+--4,G% 54)*4,% )*!% -+))!/@$% >#%

+;;+/!,)-=% 16,4?!/% )*+)% !F;/!4,G% .4!5% )6%34,4)!/%6,%3+))!/%67%;6-4)41+-%

16,)/6.!/=%56"-?%:!%)/!;+4,G%6,%)*!%I!77414!,)B%?63+4,%67%)*!%16,)4)")46,%

L!!% >#% ]]&OA&20% TY98@$% #*4% 4% ;-+4,-=% 5/6,GV% 47% 4)% 5!/!% /4G*)0% )*!% )/4;+/)4)!%

16,.!,)46,%56"-?%,6)%!F4)%+)%+--$%%

%

98$>#%;"/;6/)!?-=%/!-4!%6,%X*$T%67%D/67!6/%m!/,6,%d6G?+,6/Q%*!%#>-."34!;#".:#,!%# /-.+,),(,)-.# 4,% ";;6/)% 67% *4% +;;/6+1*% )6% )*!% I?4G,474!?BYB!77414!,)%

?4)4,1)46,V%:")%*4%+;;/6+1*%4%?4/!1)-=%16,)/+?41)!?%:=%D/67!6/%d6G?+,6/V%!!%

*!%#>-."34!;#".:#,!%#/-.+,),(,)-.%+)%1*$T0%;$R90%TY9P$%#*!/!0%D/67!6/%d6G?+,6/%

4,?41+)!% )*+)% )*!% I!77414!,)B% !-!3!,)% 67% )*!% 16,)4)")46,% +/!% )*6!%54)*% I)*!%

;65!/%)6%


13/55

63

!F1-"?!% #*!% D/4,1!% 67% C+-!0% 6/% 67% 16"/!% #*!% o"!!,0% !F;/!4,G% .4!5% )6%

34,4)!/%6,%3+))!/%67%;6-41=V%4,?!!?0%D/67%d6G?+,6/%?41"!%+)%-!,G)*%*65%

)*!%E6.!/!4G,Q%/6-!%4%)6%!F!/14!%4,7-"!,1!%:=%!F;/!4,G%"1*%.4!5%+)%;$RP%!)%

!(9$%H,%D/67!6/%d6G?+,6/Q%+,+-=40%)*!%E6.!/!4G,Q%/!;6,4:4-4)=Y/4G*)%)6%:!%

16,"-)!?0% )6% !,16"/+G!% +,?% )6% 5+/,% 4% !,)4/!-=% 16,4)!,)% 54)*% )*!%

I?4G,474!?BYB!77414!,)B% ?4)4,1)46,$% d")% 6,% D/67!6/% #63_4,Q% L4,16//!1)@%

+,+-=4%)*!%)/4;+/)4)!%16,.!,)46,%56"-?%4)!-7%:!%43;!/344:-!0%+%4)%56"-?%;-+1!%

)*!% /6-!% 67% )*!% E6.!/!4G,% 6")4?!% )*!% I?4G,474!?B% ;+/)% 67% )*!% 16,)4)")46,% +,?%

54)*4,%)*!%I!77414!,)B%;+/)%67%)*!%16,)4)")46,$%

%

9&$N"/)*!/0% >#Q% !.4?!,1!% 341*+/+1)!/4!% )*!% ,+)"/!% 67% )*!% D/4,1!% 67% C+-!Q%;":-41-=A+4/!?% .4!50% 5*41*% 4,% )"/,% -!+?% *43% 5/6,G-=% )6% 16,1-"?!% )*+)% #*!%

D/4,1!%67%C+-!%*+%76/7!4)!?%*4%;6-4)41+-%,!")/+-4)=$%K)%4%1-!+/%7/63%>#Q%5Y%+)%

]]**%! )66*+*%(! *("%)8! #+4/;,! $%! 8+**,-! 2"),! ),! $! ,(+)9)%#! *:$-;7*! 46! "4>! ("*!)%67/*%8*!46!("*!-4%$+8"5!8$%!.*!.+4/#"(!)%(4!;7$5!>)("4/(!)%!("*!7*$,(!84-;+4-),)%#!)(,!;47)()8$7!%*/(+$7)(51#L!3;*+4%+??!?@%


14/55

6:

99$D/6;!/-=%.4!5!?0% )*!/!76/!0% ;":-41% )+)!3!,)%:=%#*!%D/4,1!%67%C+-!%6,%,6,A;+/)=%;6-4)41+-% 4"!% +/!% ,6)%3+))!/% 67%1!,)/+-% /!-!.+,1!% 76/% )*!% ;/!!,)% 1+!V%

)*!=% ?6% ,6)% 43;4,G!% ";6,% *4% ;6-4)41+-% ,!")/+-4)=0% 6/% /!?"1!% )*!% ,!!?% 76/%

16,74?!,)4+-4)=% 76/% *4% 16//!;6,?!,1!% 54)*% 34,4)!/% +% +,% +?\",1)% )6% )*!%

X6,.!,)46,$% Z!,1!% )*!% !F)!,?!?% ":3446,% 7/63% )*!% >;;!--+,)% 6,% )*!!%

3+))!/%LE_!-!)6,%+)%]]T2% %O#%!//%+)%]P%67%*4%5Y%LTY&S@%5*!,%*!%)+)!%)*+)%16,74?!,)4+-4)=%!F4)% )6% ;/!!/.!% )*!% I/!+-4)=B% 67% ;6-4)41+-% ,!")/+-4)=0% ,6)% 4)% +;;!+/+,1!$% >%

)+)!?%+:6.!0%>#Q%?4)4,1)46,%4%4,16,4)!,)%54)*%)*!%/6-!%67%)*!%E6.!/!4G,%)6%:!%

16,"-)!?0% )6% +?.4!% +,?% )6% 5+/,$% #*!% E6.!/!4G,% 1+,,6)% :!% ;/6*4:4)!?% 7/63%

*6-?4,G% .4!5% 6,% 3+))!/% 67% ;6-4)41+-% 16,)/6.!/=V% 6)*!/54!0% )*!% )/4;+/)4)!%

16,.!,)46,% 56"-?% ,6)% !F4)0% +,?% *!/% ?")=% )6% !,16"/+G!% +,?% 5+/,% 56"-?% :!%

/!?",?+,)$%C*+)%4% 43;6/)+,)% 4%)*+)%)*!%+;;!+/+,1!%67%,!")/+-4)=%4%;/!!/.!?V%

;+/)41"-+/-=%4,%+%3!?4+%1"-)"/!%5*!/!%,6%/!+-%L6/%+)%-!+)%,6%1+/!7"-@%?4)4,1)46,%4%

?/+5,% :!)5!!,% !F;/!4,G% +% .4!5% 6,% +% 3+))!/% 67% ;6-4)41+-% 16,)/6.!/=0% +,?%

;6!4,G%+%;+/)=%;6-4)41+-%6;4,46,$%%

%

9O$a6/!6.!/0%>#0%4,%16336,%54)*%)*!%>;;!--+,)Q%6)*!/%54),!0%5/6,G-=%!("+)!%4,)!/+1)46,% :!)5!!,% #*!% D/4,1!% 67% C+-!% +,?% 34,4)!/% 54)*% I-6::=4,GB$%

f6::=4,G% 4% 36)% 6:.46"-=% +614+)!?% 54)*% ;"/"4)% 67% 6,!Q% 65,% +?.+,)+G!%

L;+/)41"-+/-=0%74,+,14+-%+?.+,)+G!@%:=%;!/"+46,%67%)*!%?!1446,A3+_!/%L)*/6"G*%

63!% 76/3% 67% ?4/!1)% +11!@$% c4.!,% ZWZQ% 16,)4)")46,+-% ;64)46,0% +,?% )*!%

X6,.!,)46,Q%/6-!%4,%;/!;+/4,G%*43%76/%*4%?")=%)6%:!%16,"-)!?0%)6%5+/,%+,?%)6%

!,16"/+G!0% )*4% 4% +%3+,47!)-=% ",7+4/% +,?% 4,+11"/+)!% ?!1/4;)46,% 67%5*+)% #*!%

D/4,1!%67%C+-!%*+%?6,!%!4)*!/%L+@%)*/6"G*%*4%;":-41%"))!/+,1![%L:@%)*/6"G*%*4%

5!-7+/!%56/_% .4+% *4% .+/46"% 76",?+)46,0% "1*% +%#*!% D/4,1!Q% #/")[% +,?% L1@%

)*/6"G*%*4% 16,)+1)%54)*%34,4)!/% L!.!,%+"34,G% )*+)% "1*% 16,)+1)% 4%67% )*!%

,+)"/!% ?!1/4:!?%:=%>#% +,?% )*!% .+/46"%;/!%1633!,)+)6/%";6,%5*63% )*!%

+;;!--+,)%/!-4!@$%%#*4%)66%4%+%4G,4741+,)%;64,)%76/%)*!%;"/;6!%67%)*!%4"!%4,%

)*4% +;;!+-$% #*!% >;;!--+,)Q% 1+!% +% )6% 5*+)% 4% )*!% ;":-41% 4,)!/!)% 4,% )*!%


15/55

61

?41-6"/!%67% )*!%?4;")!?%4,76/3+)46,%/!)%+-36)%!,)4/!-=%6,%)*!%;/!34!%)*+)%

6A1+--!?%I+?.61+1=%1633",41+)46,B%+/!%+%76/3%67%-6::=4,G%G6.!/,3!,)$%H,1!%

4)%4%/!16G,4!?%)*+)%)*4%4%+%7+-!%;/!34!%:!1+"!%4)%-!+.!%6")%67%+116",)%)*!%

16,)4)")46,+-%;64)46,%67%#*!%D/4,1!%67%C+-!0%)*!%>;;!--+,)Q%1+!%6,%)*!%;":-41%

4,)!/!)%4,%?41-6"/!%:!163!%.!/=%-43%4,?!!?O$%

%

92$K)%4%56/)*%)!;;4,G%:+1_%76/%+%363!,)%+,?%16,4?!/4,G%)*!%43;-41+)46,%67%>#Q%+!/)46,%)*+)%#*!%D/4,1!%67%C+-!%*+%I"//!,?!/!?B%*4%;6-4)41+-%,!")/+-4)=0%6%

)*+)% )*!% /+)46,+-!% 76/% 16,74?!,)4+-4)=% *+% ?4+;;!+/!?$% K7% )*!%a6,+/1*%?4?% ,6)%

+;;!+/%;6-4)41+--=%,!")/+-0%*!%56"-?%:!%",+:-!%)6%!F!/14!%*!/%/4G*)%",?!/%)*!%

)/4;+/)4)!%16,.!,)46,$%a6/!%7",?+3!,)+--=0%*!%16"-?%,6)%/!4G,%+)%+--0%4,1!%)*!%

a6,+/1*Q%1!,)/+-% 7",1)46,%+,?%!!,)4+-% /6-!% 4%)6%:!%+% *!+?%67%)+)!%5*6% 1+,%

/!;/!!,)%)*!%5*6-!%,+)46,0%:!1+"!%*!%4%:!=6,?%;6-4)41+-%)4!2$%K,%16,!("!,1!0%

>#Q%+!/)46,%)*+)%#*!%D/4,1!%67%C+-!%4%,6)%;6-4)41+--=%,!")/+-0%+,?%)*+)%)*!/!%4%

)*!/!76/!%,6%/!+6,%,6)%)6%!!%*4%7"--%16//!;6,?!,1!%54)*%34,4)!/0%+36",)%)6%

+% 1-+43% )*+)% *!% 1+,,6)% :!% U4,G$% #*!% !F)/!3!% ,+)"/!% 67% >#Q% ;64)46,%

?!36,)/+)!%)*+)%)*!%;/!34!%6,%5*41*%*4%54),!%)+)!3!,)%4%:+!?%+/!%7+-!$%

%

/$# *!%#%7):%.4%$#-,!%3#5-).,+#

!9R$H)*!/% )*+,% )*!% 54),!% !.4?!,1!% 67% Wd% +,?% >#% L?!+-)% 54)*% +:6.!@0% 54),!%

)+)!3!,)%*+.!%:!!,%G4.!,%6,%:!*+-7%67%)*!%>??4)46,+-%D+/)4!%:=%Ef%+,?%>>%

L6;!,% +,?% 1-6!?@[% +,?% 6,% :!*+-7% 67% )*!% >;;!--+,)% *+.!% :!!,% G4.!,% :=% )*!%

>;;!--+,)% *43!-7% +,?% :=% D+"-% W41*+/?% LDW@0% +% 76/3!/% 34,4)!/4+-% ;!14+-%

+?.4!/$%

%%

O%% #*4%4%:6)*%76/%)*!%;"/;6!%67%+;;-=4,G%!1)46,%9L9@L:@%NHK>%4,%)*!%16,)!F)%67%)*!%!1)46,%

TS%!F!3;)46,[%+,?%76/%)*!%;"/;6!%67%16,4?!/4,G%5*!)*!/%L76/%!1)46,%O&%;"/;6!@%)*!/!%56"-?%:!%+,=%"11!7"-%;":-41%4,)!/!)%?!7!,1!%)6%+%:/!+1*%67%16,74?!,)4+-4)=%1-+43$%

2%% E!!%!$G$%m!/,6,%d6G?+,6/0%*!%#>-."34!;#".:#,!%#/-.+,),(,)-.D#1*$&&0%;$%T8SV%%%

6*!%#0(.:"


16/55


17/55

6?

ZWZQ%I-6::=4,GB%5*41*%4%",";;6/)!?%:=%)*!%!.4?!,1!R%+,?%?6!%,6)%

+;;!+/%)6%?!/4.!%7/63%+,=%+1)"+-%_,65-!?G!%6,%DWQ%;+/)$%%

%

9P$#*!%?61"3!,)+/=%!.4?!,1!%4,%)*4%1+!%16,4)%67V%L&@ #*!%?4;")!?%16//!;6,?!,1!%4)!-7[%L9@ M.4?!,1!% 67% #*!% D/4,1!% 67% C+-!Q% 4,)/"1)46,% 4,% )*!% :"4,!% 67%

G6.!/,3!,)0%?!+-)%54)*%+:6.![%

LT@J61"3!,)+/=%!.4?!,1!%4--")/+)4,G%)6%5*+)%!F)!,)%ZWZQ%-!))!/%16,)+4,%/!3+/_% 6,% 3+))!/% 67% ;6-4)41+-% L+,?% ;+/)41"-+/-=0% ;+/)=% ;6-4)41+-@%

16,)/6.!/=[%

LO@J61"3!,)%!F*4:4)!?%:=%)*!%>;;!--+,)0%+--!G!?-=%*654,G%L+@%)*!%;":-41-=%_,65,%!F)!,)%+,?%16,)!,)%67%#*!%D/4,1!%67%C+-!Q%16//!;6,?!,1!%54)*%

G6.!/,3!,)%?!;+/)3!,)[%L:@%)*!%,+)"/!%67%ZWZQ%;":-41%)+)!3!,)[%L:@%

)*!%!F)!,)%67%I;":-41%16,1!/,B%+:6")%#*!%D/4,1!%67%C+-!Q%)+)!3!,)%6,%

3+))!/%67% 16,)/6.!/=$%#*!%?61"3!,)% 16,4)%67%,!5;+;!/% +/)41-![%+%

7!5%L.!/=%6-?@%-!))!/%:!)5!!,%ZWZ%+,?%Z+/6-?%C4-6,[%;!!1*!%3+?!%

:=% #*!% D/4,1!% 67% C+-![% +,?% !F)/+1)% 7/63% j6,+)*+,% J43:-!:=Q%

:46G/+;*=%67%#*!%D/4,1!%67%C+-!$%%

%

T8$E63!%:/4!7%;64,)%*6"-?%:!%3+?!%+:6")%)*!%>;;!--+,)Q%?61"3!,)%"33+/4!?%+)%;+/+G/+;*%9RLO@%+:6.!$%%

%

T&$E)3+,D#)*!%>;;!--+,)Q%!.4?!,1!%",?!/%)*!%*!+?4,G%ID/4,1!%X*+/-!Q%;!!1*!B%+)%9Y&OS%!)%!(%16,4)%67%9%;!!1*!%6,%+/1*4)!1)"/!0%!;+/+)!?%:=%92%=!+/%L6,!%

;!!1*%)6%WKd>%4,%&P


18/55

6=

*+%3+?!%6)*!/%;!!1*!0%,6)%4,1-"?!?%4,%)*!%?61"3!,)+/=%!.4?!,1!%A%)*!=%*+.!%

:!!,% !F*+")4.!-=% /!7!//!?% )6% 4,% )*!% >;;!--+,)Q% _!-!)6,% A% :")% +%!.4?!,1!%67%

;":-41%+1)4.4)=%6.!/%+%;!/46?%67%63!%O8%=!+/%4,1!%&PRP0%)*4%*+/?-=%";;6/)%)*!%

16,)!,)46,% )*+)% ZWZ% I/!;!+)!?-=B% "!?% ;":-41% ;-+)76/3% I)*/6"G*6")% )*!%

;!/46?B%7/63%&PS8%)6%98&80%+%)*!%>;;!--+,)%+--!G!$%%

#

T9$M%4-.:;D%)*!%O8%6/%6%;/!%+/)41-!%;/6?"1!?%:=%)*!%+;;!--+,)%+/!%,6)+:-!%,6)%6%3"1*%76/%)*!%.+/4!)=%67%ZWZQ%;/6,6",1!3!,)%)*!=%16,)+4,0%+%76/%)*!%7+1)%)*+)%

)*!%;/!%+/)41-!%)*!3!-.!%/!1=1-!%3+)!/4+-%+G+4,%+,?%+G+4,$%N6/%!F+3;-!0%)*!%

74/)%P%+/)41-!%+--%:/6+?-=%16,1!/,%)*!%+3!%!/4!%67%-!+_!?%-!))!/%7/63%9889[%T%+--%

16,1!/,% 16-"3,4)Q% /!+1)46,% )6% )*!% +3!% X*+,,!-% O% ;/6G/+33!% +:6")% ZWZ%

L9Y2;;!--+,)Q%5Y0%]&S0%TY


19/55

6>

5*41*%3!3:!/%67%)*!%;":-41%74,?%4,)!/!)4,G$@%K,?!!?0%)*!%?!G/!!%67%1633!,)%

G!,!/+)!?%:=%-!+_%67%!F)/+1)%6/%/!3+/_%7/63%#*!%D/4,1!%67%C+-!Q%-!))!/%L+%

4--")/+)!?%:=%)*!%>;;!--+,)Q%!.4?!,1!@%4,?41+)!%5*=%#*!%D/4,1!%67%C+-!%+,?%

34,4)!/%1+,%6,-=% 16//!;6,?% 7/+,_-=% 47% 16,74?!,)4+-4)=%4% ;/!!/.!?[% +,?%5*=%

?41-6"/!%56"-?%?+3+G!%ZWZQ%;64)46,$%%

%

TO$E-(3,!;0%)*!%>;;!--+,)%*+%!F*4:4)!?%-!,G)*=%;++G!%7/63%j6,+)*+,%J43:-!:=Q%:46G/+;*=%67%#*!%D/4,1!%67%C+-!0%16,)+4,4,G%!F)/+1)%7/63%*4%16//!;6,?!,1!%

54)*%34,4)!/0% 4,%5*41*%ZWZ% !)%6")%*4% .4!5%6,%.+/46"%3+))!/%67%;":-41%

;6-41=$%>%Wd%;64,)%6")0%)*!%7+1)%)*+)%a/%J43:-!:=%5+%+:-!%)6%"!%"1*%!F)/+1)%

16"-?% :!% ;!/1!4.!?% +% +% L;!/*+;% 4,+?.!/)!,)@% :/!+1*% 67% )*!% 6:-4G+)46,% 67%

16,74?!,)4+-4)=%4,*!/!,)%4,%)*!%X6,.!,)46,$%Z65!.!/0%4)%1+,,6)%:!%"GG!)!?%)*+)%

!-!1)4.!% ("6)+)46,% 7/63% 16//!;6,?!,1!% 4,% +% :66_% ;":-4*!?% &R% =!+/% +G6%

+36",)% )6%+%5+4.!/% 67%16,74?!,)4+-4)=% 4,% )*!% ?4;")!?%16//!;6,?!,1!% *!/!% ^%

4,?!!?0%)*!%5+=%4,%5*41*%)*!%;+/)4!%)6%)*!%16//!;6,?!,1!%*+.!%)/!+)!?%4)%*65%

)*!%6;;64)!$%>-6V%

%

L&@ #*!/!%4%+%4G,4741+,)%?477!/!,1!%:!)5!!,%)*!%"!%67%!F)/+1)%7/63%-!))!/0%54)*% +% ?!G/!!% 67% !-7A1!,6/*4;% +--"?!?% )6% :=% a/% J43:-!:=0% +,?% )*!%

5*6-!+-!%?41-6"/!%67%+--%16//!;6,?!,1!%6.!/%+%G4.!,%;!/46?[%

%

L9@>%Wd%;64,)%6")0%)*!%X6,.!,)46,%!F4)%,6)%6,-=%76/%)*!%:!,!74)%67%#*!%D/4,1!%67%C+-!0%:")%76/%+--%Z!4/%)6%)*!%#*/6,!%L+,?%)*!%16,)4)")46,%4,%

G!,!/+-@$%#*!% 7+1)% )*+)% 4)% 34G*)%:!%+/G"!?% ZWZ%?4?%,6)% +1)% 4,% &PPO% 4,%

+116/?+,1!% 54)*% )*!% 6:-4G+)46,% 67% 16,74?!,)4+-4)=% 4,*!/!,)% 4,% )*!%

X6,.!,)46,%?6!%,6)%?434,4*%)*!%;":-41%4,)!/!)%4,%;/!!/.4,G%4)$%

%

T2$E)0,!;0% )*!%5+=% 4,% 5*41*% )*!%>;;!--+,)% *+% 6"G*)% )6% 1*+/+1)!/4!% )*!% +:6.!%3+)!/4+-% L!!% !$G$% >Q% _!-!)6,0% ]TO% !)% !(0% >#% 5Y% TY&S@% +% !.4?!,1!% 67%

4,)!/.!,)46,% )*+)%+/!%I-!G46,B%+,?%*+.!%I7/!("!,)-=%:!!,%"11!7"-0%4,1-"?4,G%

+% )6%1*+,G!% 4,%G6.!/,3!,)%;6-41=B% 4%,6)%+,%+11"/+)!% 1*+/+1)!/4+)46,% 67% )*!%


20/55

47

;64)46,$% LK,?!!?0%)*!%>;;!--+,)% +)%6,!% )+G!%G6!%6%7+/%+% )6%43;-=% )*+)%#*!%

D/4,1!%67%C+-!%5+%/!;6,4:-!% 76/%/!.!/4,G%?!7!,1!%1")V%>Q%_!-!)6,0% ]O2$@%

#*!!%+/!%:6-?%+!/)46,0%163;-!)!-=%",";;6/)!?%:=%)*!%7+1)$%a/%J43:-!:=Q%

:66_% 16,)+4,% 6,!% 4,)+,1!% 5*!/!% +% a4,4)!/% )6-?% ZWZ% )*+)% *!% *+?% :!!,%

;/63;)!?%)6%-66_%+G+4,%+)%+%;6-41=%:=%;64,)%ZWZ%*+?%3+?!%L)"::-!%:"/,4,GV%

!!% 9Y9PR@$% M.!,% )*+)% !F+3;-!% 4% ,6)% !.4?!,1!% )*+)%ZWZ%5+% /!;6,4:-!% 76/%

1*+,G4,G%G6.!/,3!,)%;6-41=V%)*!%43;-41+)46,%:!*4,?%)*!%34,4)!/Q%-!))!/%)6%ZWZ%

6,% )*!% )6;41% 5+% )*+)% ;6-41=% 1*+,G!?% :!1+"!% )*!% G6.!/,3!,)% )66_% I.!/=%

!/46"-=% )*!% /!1633!,?+)46,% 67% )*!% W6=+-% X633446,% 6,% M,.4/6,3!,)+-%

D6--")46,B$%%

%

%%

N)K! D.&=?G%!B4!OG?+!

!

&$# A%%7".,#%G"#03"%;/6.4?!%)*+)V%%

6V.0-3


21/55

46

TY988RY888S@%+)%k28l$%K,%

1+//=4,G% 6")% )*!% :+-+,14,G% !F!/14!0% )*!% ;":-41% 4,)!/!)% 4,% +--% !F!3;)46,%

+;;-41+:-!%)6%+%;+/)41"-+/%4)!3%67%4,76/3+)46,%*6"-?%:!%+GG/!G+)!?0%+,?%4)%4%)*+)%

+GG/!G+)!?%;":-41%4,)!/!)%5*41*%3")%:!%5!4G*!?%+G+4,)%)*!%;":-41%4,)!/!)%4,%

?41-6"/!V% !!%AQT00)4%# -0# /-).)+,3;#-0#^(+,)4%#7#V/T#k988Pl%MCZX%&R&&%+)%k92l$%%

%

O8$M%4-.:;D#)*!%;":-41%4,)!/!)%)*+)%+/!%3+)!/4+-%+/!%:6)*%)*6!%)*+)%3+=%:!%;!14741%)6%)*!%?4;")!?%4,76/3+)46,0%+,?%)*6!%67%36/!%G!,!/+-%+;;-41+)46,V%!!%N>*#7#

V/T#".:#T2%.#k98&8l%9%>--%MW%22%+)%2&$%K,?!!?0%;":-41%4,)!/!)%7+1)6/%4,%7+.6"/%67%

3+4,)+4,4,G%+,%!F!3;)46,%+/!%-4_!-=%)6%:!%67%+%G!,!/+-%1*+/+1)!/$%#*!%7+1)%)*+)%+%

7+1)6/%3+=%:!%67%+%G!,!/+-%1*+/+1)!/%/+)*!/%)*+,%+%;!14741%,+)"/!%?6!%,6)%3!+,%

)*+)%4)%*6"-?%:!%+116/?!?%-!%5!4G*)%6/%4G,4741+,1!$%E!!%!$G$% N-*#7#V/T#".:#T2%.#+)%kOTl0%[/\W#7#E3)%.:+#-0#,!%#["3,!# k988V%!!%N-


22/55

44

O&$*!)3:;D#)*!%;/6.446,%67%NHK>%*6"-?%,6)%:!%)+_!,%+%+:/6G+)4,G%)*!%43;6/)+,1!%67%-6,GA)+,?4,G%16,)4)")46,+-%16,.!,)46,%6/%;/4,14;-!V%!!%!$G$%N>*#7#V/T#".:#

T2%.#+)%kO8l0%5*!/!%d-+_!%j%)+)!?%L4,%/!G+/?%)6%)*!%16,.!,)46,%)*+)%,!4)*!/%)*!%

7+1)%)*+)%)*!%f+5%H7741!/%*+.!%+?.4!?0%,6/%)*!%16,)!,)%67%)*!4/%+?.41!%3+=%:!%

?41"!?%6")4?!%G6.!/,3!,)@V%%

%

6OV#4-.+):%3#,!%3%#)+#+(F+,".4%#).#,!%#"55%".,=+#4-*#

7#V/T#".:#T2%.#+)%k2&l%+,?%k2Tl%+%/!G+/?%$T2L&@L1@%NHK>%+,?%W?[AA#7#T=?3)%.%

k988Pl% MCZX% &RO% +)% kO&l0% k2&l0% k2Tl0% k2Ol% +% /!G+/?% )*!% 4,:"4-)% 5!4G*)% )6% :!%

+))+1*!?%)6%-!G+-%;/67!46,+-%;/4.4-!G!%",?!/%$O9%NHK>$%#*!%>??4)46,+-%D+/)4!%

":34)%)*+)%)*!%16,74,!?%!F1!;)46,%)+)!?%4,%$TS%NHK>%4%"1*%+,%!F!3;)46,0%+,?%

)*+)%76/%)*4%/!+6,%)*!%!F4)!,1!%67%)*!%!1)46,%TS%!F!3;)46,%4%4)!-7%+,%4,?41+)46,%67% )*!% )/6,G% ;":-41% 4,)!/!)% 4,% ;/!!/.4,G% )*!% 16,74?!,)4+-4)=% 67% )*!% ?4;")!?%

4,76/3+)46,%4,%)*4%+;;!+-$%

%

OT$E)0,!;D%)*!%;/6.446,%67%NHK>%?6%,6)%;/6.4?!%76/%+,=%i;/!"3;)46,Q%4,%7+.6"/%67%?41-6"/!V% !!0% 76/% !F+3;-!0%WE[M# 7# V/T# LM>Y988RY888R@% +)% kR2l[%M%43%,"3;# -0#

M,",%#0-3#L-39#".:#K%.+)-.+#7#V/T%LM>Y988RY88O8@%+)%k9Sl[%W*V%L+:6.!@%+)%kO9l[%+,?%

\("3:)".#I%2+5"5%3+# 7# V/T% LM>Y988RY88&&@% +)% k


23/55

43

+;;-41+:-!%)6%)*!%+;;-41+)46,%67%)*!%!1)46,%TS%!F!3;)46,$%#*"%)*!%;":-41%4,)!/!)%

4,%?41-6"/!%1+,,6)%:!%+"3!?[%4)%3")%:!%3!+"/!?%4,%;!14741%:=%/!7!/!,1!%

L76/% !F+3;-!@% )6% )*!% ":)+,1!% 67% )*!% ?4;")!?% 4,76/3+)46,$% K,?!!?% +,=% 6)*!/%

+;;/6+1*%56"-?%+36",)%)6%+%76/3%67%;/!A\"?G3!,)%67%)*!%;":-41%4,)!/!)%:+-+,1!%

!F!/14!%/!("4/!?%",?!/%!1)46,%9L9@L:@%NHK>$%

%

OO$a6/!6.!/0%4,%+%1+!%"1*%+%)*!%;/!!,)%5*!/!%)*!/!%1+,%:!%,6%?6":)%)*+)%)*!/!%+/!%43;6/)+,)%;":-41% 4,)!/!)%/!+6,%76/%3+4,)+4,4,G%)*!% 16,74?!,)4+-4)=%67% )*!%

?4;")!?%4,76/3+)46,0%+,=%G!,!/+-%+"3;)46,%4,%7+.6"/%67%?41-6"/!%*+%-4))-!%47%

+,=% !77!1)4.!% /6-!% )6% ;-+=$% K7% ?41-6"/!% 67% )*!% ?4;")!?% 4,76/3+)46,% 4% )6% :!%

/!("4/!?%4)%*6"-?%:!%6,%)*!%:+4%67%+,%!.+-"+)46,%4,%;!14741%67%)*!%;+/)41"-+/%

;":-41%4,)!/!)%16,4?!/+)46,%4?!,)474!?%:=%)*!%>;;!--+,)$%

%

/$# &55)4",)-.#,-#,!%#0"4,+#-0#,!)+#"55%"#

!

O2$K)%4%43;6/)+,)%)6%,6)!%)*+)%)*!%>;;!--+,)Q%E_!-!)6,%>/G"3!,)%?6!%,6)%/!+--=%+??/!%)*!%+;;-41+)46,%67%!1)46,%9L9@L:@%NHK>%*!+?A6,$%#*4%4%+%16,!("!,1!%67%

)*!%7+1)%)*+)%)*!%>;;!--+,)Q%":3446,%?6%,6)%!!_%)6%+??/!%)*!%+;;-41+)46,%

67%!1)46,%TS%NHK>%!F!3;)46,%4,%4)%65,%/4G*)0%+,?%4,)!+?%)/!+)%)*!%1+!%+%6,!%

)*+)%)"/,%6,%)*!%+;;-41+)46,%67%)*!%!1)46,%O&%NHK>%!F!3;)46,$%K,%":)+,1!%)*!%

;":-41% 4,)!/!)% 4,% 7+.6"/% 67%?41-6"/!% +/!% ?!+-)%54)*%6,-=%+)%]]PR% ^% &8&0% +,?%

;!14741+--=%:!)5!!,%]]P;;!--+,)%7+4-%)6%4?!,)47=%)*!%;!14741%5+=%4,%5*41*%)*!%;":-41%4,)!/!)%56"-?%:!%!/.!?%:=%?41-6"/!%67%)*!%?4;")!?%4,76/3+)46,V%*!%/!7!/%)6%

G!,!/+-%16,4?!/+)46,%"1*%+%I+116",)+:4-4)=B%+,?%I)/+,;+/!,1=B%:")%?6!%,6)%

!F;-+4,% 5*+)% )*!4/% +;;-41+)46,% 4% 4,% )*!% 16,)!F)% 67% )*!% ;/!!,)% /!("!)% 76/%

4,76/3+)46,$% K)% 4% 4G,4741+,)% )*+)% )*!%>;;!--+,)% *+%:!!,%",+:-!% )6%!F;-+4,%*4%

;64)46,$% d+/!% /!-4+,1!% 6,% L76/% !F+3;-!@% )*!% ;":-41% 4,)!/!)% 4,% I)/+,;+/!,1=B%

?6!% ,6)% +?.+,1!% +% ":3446,% 4,% 7+.6"/% 67% ?41-6"/!%",?!/% NHK>$%C4)*6")%

7"/)*!/%!F;-+,+)46,%/!-4+,1!%6,%"1*%+%16,4?!/+)46,%;/6.!%)66%3"1*%:!1+"!%4)%


24/55

4:

56"-?% 7+.6"/% )*!% ?41-6"/!% 67% +--% 4,76/3+)46,% 4,% +--% 14/1"3)+,1!% L+,?% 4,%

":)+,1!0% 16,.!/)% !.!/=% ("+-474!?% !F!3;)46,% 4,)6% +,% +:6-")!% 6:-4G+)46,% )6%

?41-6!0% 16,)/+/=% )6% )*!% !F;/!% ;/6.446,% 67% )*!% -!G4-+)46,@$% D")% *6/)-=0%

G!,!/+-%.+-"!%"1*%+%)/+,;+/!,1=%+/!%,6%36/!%)*+,%+%3!+,%)6%+,%!,?[%)*!=%

+/!%,6)%!,?%4,%)*!3!-.!$%K,%6/?!/%76/%;/6;!/%1/")4,=%)6%:!%G4.!,%)6%/!-4+,1!%6,%

+% G!,!/+-%.+-"!% "1*% +% )/+,;+/!,1=0% )*!%>;;!--+,)%3")% 4?!,)47=% )*!%;!14741%

;":-41% 4,)!/!)% )*+)%56"-?% :!% !/.!?Y+?.+,1!?%:=%?41-6"/!%67% )*!%?4;")!?%

4,76/3+)46,$%K,%)*!%;/!!,)%1+!0%)*!%>;;!--+,)Q%":3446,%?6%,6)%?6%)*4$%

%

OS$#*!% /!+6,% 76/% ?41-6"/!% 4?!,)474!?% :=% )*!% >;;!--+,)% 4% )*!% ";;6!?% ;":-41%4,)!/!)%4,%_,654,G%5*!)*!/%#*!%D/4,1!%67%C+-!%!,G+G!%4,%I-6::=4,GB0%+,?%47%

60%5*+)%!77!1)%)*+)%I-6::=4,GB%*+$%%

%

O;;!--+,)Q% +/G"3!,)% )*+)% )*!/!% 4% +% I;/!4,G% ,!!?% 76/% )/+,;+/!,1=B% )6%

4,.!)4G+)!%ZWZQ%I",?"!%4,7-"!,1!B0%+,?%)*+)%)*4%4%)*!%;":-41%4,)!/!)%/!+6,%

)*+)% ?/4.!% )*!% ,!!?% 76/% ?41-6"/!% 67% )*!% ?4;")!?% 4,76/3+)46,0% 43;-=% 7+--%

+5+=$%%

%

OP$#56% 43;6/)+,)% ;64,)% *6"-?% :!%3+?!% +:6")% )*!% >;;!--+,)Q%+;;/6+1*% )6% )*!%1-+43!?% ;":-41% 4,)!/!)% 4,% _,654,G% +:6")% #*!% D/4,1!% 67% C+-!Q% ";;6!?%

I-6::=4,GB$%%

%


25/55

41

28$E)3+,0% )*!%>;;!--+,)% 1*+/+1)!/4!% )*!% ,!!?% )6% _,65%5*+)%#*!% D/4,1!% 67%C+-!%+=%)6%34,4)!/%+%+%("!)46,%16,1!/,4,G%)*!%I/"-!%67%-+5B0%5*!/!%#*!%D/4,1!%67%

C+-!Q%-!))!/%?!+-%54)*%4"!%)*+)%+/!%I":\!1)%)6%?!361/+)41%16,)/6-B%L!!%>Q%

_!-!)6,0%]]


26/55

45

4"!$% E*!% ?6!% ,6)% 76/7!4)% ;6-4)41+-% ,!")/+-4)=% :=% 6% ?64,G0% ;/6.4?!?% )*+)%

16,74?!,)4+-4)=%4%6:!/.!?%L!!%+:6.!0%",?!/%I#*!%X6,.!,)46,B@$%K,%;/!;+/+)46,%

76/%!F!/144,G%)*!%a6,+/1*Q%?")4!0%#*!%D/4,1!%67%C+-!%4%434-+/-=%!,)4)-!?%)6%

!F;/!% "1*% .4!5$% g6)!% )*+)% )*!% >;;!--+,)% 341*+/+1)!/4!% )*!% >??4)46,+-%

D+/)4!Q% !.4?!,1!% 4,% )*4% /!;!1)$%#*!% !.4?!,1!% 4%.-,% )*+)%#*!% D/4,1!% 67%C+-!%

+.64?%;+/)=%;6-4)41+-%4"!V%4)%4%)*+)%*!%+.64?%/+44,G%"1*%4"!%4,%;":-41V%!!%

Ef%5Y%]9&%LI*!%)+_!%G/!+)%1+/!%)6%+.64?%W1!UW#!C_]JW^!#A$A*[*1A#%;+/)=%;6-4)41+-%

4"!B@%+,?%ZWZQ%5!:4)!% +)% OY2% )+)!?% +:6.!0% +)%

;+/+G/+;*%OR0%47%)*!%>;;!--+,)%4%)6%;-+1!%+,=%3+)!/4+-%/!-4+,1!%6,%"1*%G!,!/+-%

16,4?!/+)46,%*!%3")%4?!,)47=%4,%;!14741%)*!%;":-41%4,)!/!)%:!,!74)%5*41*%4)%4%

1-+43!?% 56"-?% /!"-)% 7/63% ?41-6"/!% 67% )*!% ?4;")!?% 4,76/3+)46,$% K,% 7+1)0%

?41-6"/!% 67% )*!% 16//!;6,?!,1!% 56"-?% ,6)% +?.+,1!% +,=% 4?!,)474+:-!% ;":-41%

4,)!/!)$%%

%

2T$E63!%67%)*!%16//!;6,?!,1!%43;-=%*!?%,6%-4G*)%+)%+--%";6,%)*!%6;!/+)46,%67%)*!% X6,.!,)46,% 6/% #*!% D/4,1!% 67% C+-!Q% 4,7-"!,1!$% #*4% 4% )/"!0% 76/% !F+3;-!0%

5*!/!% )*!% 16//!;6,?!,1!% 16,1!/,% 3+))!/% )*+)% +/!% ;"/!-=% I;!/6,+-B% 4,% +%

,+//65%!,!0%6/%4%!77!1)4.!-=%+?34,4)/+)4.!%16//!;6,?!,1!%:!)5!!,%)*!%67741!%

67%)*!%D/4,1!%67%C+-!%+,?%.+/46"%G6.!/,3!,)%?!;+/)3!,)$%K,%/!;!1)%67%"1*%

16//!;6,?!,1!0% ,6% ;":-41% 4,)!/!)% 4,% ?41-6"/!% !F4)$% #*!% /!3+4,?!/% 67% )*!%

16//!;6,?!,1!%56"-?%:!%67%.!/=%-434)!?%+4)+,1!% 4,% /!+-44,G% "1*% 4,)!/!)0%

76/%/!+6,%!)%6")%4,%)*!%1-6!?%+,,!F!%)6%)*4%_!-!)6,$%%

%


27/55

4?

2O$>% )*!% KXH% 16//!1)-=% 16,1-"?!?0% "1*% ;":-41% 4,)!/!)% 7+1)6/% 4,% 7+.6"/% 67%?41-6"/!%5*41*%3+=% !F4)% +/!% 4G,4741+,)-=% 6")5!4G*!?%:=% )*!% )/6,G% ;":-41%

4,)!/!)% 4,% 3+4,)+4,4,G% 16,74?!,)4+-4)=% 5*41*% !/.!% )6% L&@% ;/6)!1)% )*!%

X6,.!,)46,[%L9@%+7!G"+/?%ZWZQ%;6-4)41+-%,!")/+-4)=[%LT@%;/!.!,)%",7+4/%1/4)4143%

",?!/34,4,G% )*!% ;64)46,% 67% ZWZ% +,?% )*!% a6,+/1*=[% LO@% !,+:-!% ZWZ% +,?%

34,4)!/%)6%1633",41+)!% 7/!!-=% +,?%7/+,_-=[% L2@%;/6)!1)%ZWZQ%;/4.+1=%",?!/%

>/)41-!%#Q%5Y%+,?%)*!%;/!%+/)41-!%+,,!F!?%:=%)*!%

>;;!--+,)% *65@% )*!/!% 4% +% 54?!;/!+?% 7+4-"/!% 4,% )*!% 3!?4+% )6% ?4)4,G"4*%

:!)5!!,%ZWZ%!F;/!4,G%.4!5%6,%43;6/)+,)%3+))!/%67%;":-41%;6-41=0%+,?%)*!%

!F;/!46,% 67% .4!5% )*+)% +/!% I;+/)=% ;6-4)41+-B$% H,% >#Q% +,+-=40% )*!% 7+1)% )*+)%

ZWZ%*+%L6.!/%)*!%=!+/@%!F;/!!?%.4!5%6,%3+))!/%5*41*%1+,%:!%+4?%)6%:!%


28/55

4=

6,!%67%;":-41%;6-41=%4%"77414!,)%)6%1+--%4,)6%("!)46,%*4%74),!%)6%/!4G,$%#*4%

.4!5%4%6:.46"-=%4,16//!1)$%

2S$#*!%>;;!--+,)Q%/!;6,!%)6%)*!%+:6.!%;64,)%+:6")%)*!%X6,.!,)46,%4%)6%+=%)*+)%#*!% D/4,1!% 67% C+-!Q% -!))!/% )6% 34,4)!/% +/!% ,6)% 16.!/!?% :=% )*!% X6,.!,)46,%:!1+"!%L&@%)*!%":)+,1!%+,?%,+)"/!%67%ZWZQ%!F;/!46,%5*41*%I16",!-%+,?%

5+/,B%?6!%,6)%16//!;6,?%)6%5*+)%4%/!16G,4e+:-!%7/63%)*!%E6.!/!4G,[%+,?%L9@%

#*!% D/4,1!% 67% C+-!% ?6!% ,6)% *43!-7% .4!5% *4% -!))!/% +% ;+/)% 67% +,%

I+;;/!,)41!*4;B0%:")%+%+?.61+1=%L!!%>Q%_!-!)6,0%]]22%+,?%2%)6%)*4V%

L&@>!/)46,% +:6")% 5*+)% 4% I/!16G,4e+:-!% 7/63% )*!% E6.!/!4G,B% +/!% ;"/!%;!1"-+)46,$%d")%4,%+,=%!.!,)0%5*!)*!/%)*!%E6.!/!4G,%1*66!%)6%3+_!%*!/%

.4!5% _,65,% 6,% ;+/)41"-+/% ":\!1)% 6/% 4,% ;+/)41"-+/% 5+=% 4% !,)4/!-=%

4//!-!.+,)$% #*!% D/4,1!% 67%C+-!0% 6,% +11!46,% )6% )*!% #*/6,!0%56"-?%:!%

!,)4)-!?% 4,% *4% !F!/14!% 67% )*!% )/4;+/)4)!% 16,.!,)46,% )6%3+_!% *4% .4!5%

_,65,%)6%34,4)!/%4,%*4%65,%5+=0%6,%":\!1)%67%*4%1*664,G$%

L9@ M.!,%47%#*!%D/4,1!%67%C+-!Q%;"/;6!%4,%5/4)4,G%+:6")%+%;+/)41"-+/%;6-41=%)6%+%34,4)!/%4%)6%/+4!%+/G"3!,)%+:6")%)*+)%;6-41=0%,6)%)6%;/+1)41!%76/%

IU4,G*4;B0%)*4%4%,!4)*!/%*!/!%,6/%)*!/!$%C*!,%*!%5/4)!%)6%34,4)!/0%*!%

4% 4,% 7+1)% ;/!;+/4,G% 76/% )*!% !F!/14!% 67% )*!% )/4;+/)4)!% 16,.!,)46,% +%

a6,+/1*$%#*!%>;;!--+,)Q%+/G"3!,)%4%+,+-6G6"%)6%+=4,G%)*+)%:!1+"!%+%

;!/6,%5/4)!%4,%6/?!/%)6%1633",41+)!%6,%+%;+/)41"-+/%":\!1)0%*!%1+,,6)%

+)%)*!%+3!%)43!%:!%!F!/144,G%-!))!/A5/4)4,G%_4--%A%+%;/6;64)46,%)*+)%4%

6:.46"-=%5/6,G$%%

2


29/55

4>

2P$#*!%+:6.!%;":-41%4,)!/!)%4,%16,74?!,)4+-4)=%+/!%6,!%;!14741+--=%/!16G,4e!?%:=%)*!% !F!3;)46,% 4,% $TS% NHK>% 76/% 1633",41+)46,% 54)*% Z!/% a+\!)=% 6/% 6)*!/%

3!3:!/%67%)*!%W6=+-%N+34-=$%#*!4/%;!14741%/!16G,4)46,%4,%$TS%NHK>%/!7-!1)%)*!%

4,)/4,41%43;6/)+,1!%)6%:!%+))+1*!?%)6%16,74?!,)4+-4)=%4,%1633",41+)46,%:!)5!!,%

)*!%D/4,1!%67%C+-!%+,?%c6.!/,3!,)%a4,4)!/0%4,%-4G*)%67%)*!%X6,.!,)46,V%!!%

+,?%163;+/!%)*!%6:!/.+)46,%67%d-+_!%j%4,% N>*#7#V/T#".:#T2%.+0%/!7!//!?%)6%

+:6.!%+)%;+/+G/+;*%O9$%

R8$#*!% KXH% +-6% 16//!1)-=% +))+1*!?% 4G,4741+,)% 5!4G*)% )6% )*!% ;":-41% 4,)!/!)% 4,%;/6)!1)4,G%#*!%D/4,1!%67%C+-!Q%;/4.+1=%+,?%?4G,4)=$%>%76/%)*!%/!+6,%5*=%#*!%

D/4,1!%67%C+-!Q%/4G*)%)6%/!;!1)%76/%;/4.+)!%-47!%",?!/%>/)41-!%0%:")%*6"-?%:!%)+_!,%4,)6%+116",)%

4,%)*!%;":-41%4,)!/!)%:+-+,1!%",?!/%$TS%NHK>%4,%/!;!1)%67%4,76/3+)46,%16.!/!?%

:=%:6)*%!F!3;)46,V%!!%N-%)/6,G-=%6")5!4G*%)*!%;":-41%4,)!/!)%4,%

?41-6"/!$%%

%

NBK! D.&=?G%!"!OG?+!

!

RT$E!1)46,%O&%NHK>%)+)!0%+%7+/%+%/!-!.+,)V%% 6


30/55

37

RO$#*!%/!("4/!3!,)%76/%4,76/3+)46,%)6%:!%!F!3;)%7/63%?41-6"/!%",?!/%$O&%NHK>%1+,%:!%:/6_!,%?65,%+%76--65V%

L&@ #*!%4,76/3+)46,%3")%:!%6:)+4,!?%:=%)*!%+")*6/4)=%7/63%+,6)*!/%;!/6,[%%

L9@ K)%3")%:!%4,76/3+)46,%5*41*%16"-?%47%?41-6!?%:!%)*!%":\!1)%67%+,%+1)46,%76/%:/!+1*%67% 16,74?!,1!%L5*!)*!/%:!1+"!%4)% 4%16,74?!,)4+-%4,76/3+)46,0%

6/%I;/4.+)!%4,76/3+)46,B%54)*4,%)*!%16;!%67%>/)41-!%/)41-!% % 4% 4--"34,+)!?%:=% )*!% -!G4-+)4.!%

;"/;6!%67%)*!%!1)46,$%E!1)46,%O&L&@%NHK>%!F4)%)6%;/!.!,)%+%;":-41%+")*6/4)=%

:!4,G% 4,% +% ;64)46,% 5*!/!% 4)% 4% 76/1!?% ",?!/% NHK>% )6% /!.!+-% 16,74?!,)4+-%

4,76/3+)46,0%5*41*%56"-?%-!+.!%4)%6;!,%)6%14.4-%1-+43%76/%:/!+1*%67%16,74?!,1!P$%

P%% d=%5+=%67% 4--")/+)46,0%!!%N".+"3:#Zf%.6-%R&P%+)%16-$%&SR%;!/%f6/?%N+-16,!/%67%#*6/6)6,$%

f6/?%N+-16,!/0%;/636)4,G%)*!% d4--%6,% :!*+-7%67% )*!%G6.!/,3!,)%4,% )*!%Z6"!%67%f6/?0%)+)!?V%

%6?3-":;D#V# F%)%7%# ,!",# 2%#"G3%%# -.# ,!%# F"+)4#5"3"


31/55

36

#*!%6-!%;/6.46%4%)*+)%;":-41%+")*6/4)4!%+/!%,6)%!,)4)-!?%)6%;"--%)*!3!-.!%";%

:=%)*!4/%65,%:66))/+;%:=%/!-=4,G%",?!/%$O&%NHK>%";6,%)*!%16,74?!,)4+-4)=%67%

4,76/3+)46,% )*!=% *+.!% )*!3!-.!% 1/!+)!?V% % 6)*!/% !F!3;)46,% /!-+)4,G% )6% )*!%

16,74?!,)4+-4)=% 67% ;":-41% +")*6/4)=Q% 4,)!/,+-% +77+4/% !F4)% )6% ;/6)!1)% "1*%

4,76/3+)46,%5*!/!%+;;/6;/4+)!%L"1*%+%$T2%6/%$TR%NHK>@$%K,%6)*!/%56/?0%)*!%

6/4G4,+)6/%67%)*!%4,76/3+)46,%/!-4!?%";6,%76/%)*!%;"/;6!%67%$O&%NHK>%*6"-?%

,6)% :!% )*!% ;":-41% +")*6/4)=% 4)!-7$% #*!% ;*/+!% I6:)+4,!?% b% 7/63% +,=% 6)*!/%

;!/6,B% 43;-=% /!7-!1)% )*!% /!("4/!3!,)% )*+)% )*!%6/4G4,+)6/% 67% )*!% 4,76/3+)46,%

*6"-?%,6)%:!%)*!%+")*6/4)=$%

%

R%)6%!F!3;)%7/63%?41-6"/!%)*!%16,)!,)%67%+%-!))!/%4)%*+?%1/!+)!?V%)*!%4,76/3+)46,%4,%)*!%-!))!/%

56"-?%,6)%:!%I6:)+4,!?B%7/63%+,6)*!/%;!/6,$%%

%

RP$Z65!.!/0%)*!%;64)46,%4%?477!/!,)%5*!/!%?41-6"/!%67%)*!%4,76/3+)46,%16,)+4,!?%4,% +% -!))!/% 1/!+)!?% :=% )*!% ;":-41% +")*6/4)=% 4,!.4)+:-=% !,)+4-% )*!% ?41-6"/!% 67%

4,76/3+)46,%6/4G4,+)4,G%7/63%+,6)*!/%;!/6,0%?41-6"/!%67%5*41*%16"-?%76",?%+%

14.4-%1-+43%76/%:/!+1*%67%16,74?!,1!$%#*"0%76/%!F+3;-!0%+%-!))!/%7/63%)*!%;":-41%

+")*6/4)=% 5*41*% )+)!% I=6"% )6-?% 3!% FB0% 5*!/!% F% 4% 16,74?!,)4+-% 4,76/3+)46,%

6:)+4,!?%7/63%)*!%-!))!/Q%+??/!!!0%56"-?%;-+4,-=%:!%54)*4,%)*!%16;!%67%$O&L&@%

NHK>$%d")%)*+)%4%,6)%+--$%#+_!%+%4)"+)46,%5*!/!%)*!%;":-41%+")*6/4)=Q%-!))!/%4%

5/4))!,%4,%/!;-=%)6%+%-!))!/%7/63%4)%+??/!!!V%

%

L&@ K7%)*!%+??/!!!Q%.4!5%6,%+%;+/)41"-+/%":\!1)%+/!%16,74?!,)4+-0%?41-6"/!%67%+%/!;-=%5*41*%/!.!+-%)*6!%.4!5%L!$G$%I3=%/!;6,!%)6%=6"/%.4!5%F%4%

=B@%56"-?%!,)+4-%?41-6"/!%67%16,74?!,)4+-%4,76/3+)46,%6:)+4,!?%7/63%)*!%

+??/!!![%

L9@ K7%)*!%7+1)%)*+)%)*!%+??/!!!%*+%5/4))!,%)6%)*!%+")*6/4)=%6,%+%;+/)41"-+/%":\!1)% 4% 16,74?!,)4+-0% ?41-6"/!% 67% )*!% +")*6/4)=Q% /!;-=%6,% )*!% +3!%

5"4%J# *!%;# +!-(:# .-,# !"7%# ,-# 4!--+%# F%,2%%.# 0")).G# ).# ,!%)3# +,",(,-3;# :(,)%+# (.:%3# ,!%#%G)+",)-.#4(33%.,;#F%0-3%#;-(3#Y-3:+!)5+=#N-(+%#".:#%"7).G#,!%


32/55

34

":\!1)% 56"-?% !,)+4-% ?41-6"/!% 67% 16,74?!,)4+-% 4,76/3+)46,% 6/4G4,+)4,G%

7/630%+,?%*!,1!%6:)+4,!?%7/630%)*!%+??/!!![%

LT@ K,?!!?0%47%)*!%7+1)%)*+)%)*!%-!))!/Q%+??/!!!%5/6)!%)6%)*!%;":-41%+")*6/4)=%5+%16,74?!,)4+-0%?41-6"/!%67%+%/!;-=%)6%)*!%-!))!/%56"-?%!,)+4-%?41-6"/!%

67%16,74?!,)4+-%4,76/3+)46,%6:)+4,!?%7/63%)*!%+??/!!!$%%

%

S8$>%!F;-+4,!?%4,%)*!%5Y%67%Ef%L]]&TA&>%L]]92AT90%OYP@0%+--%+;!1)%67%)*!%16//!;6,?!,1!%:!)5!!,%ZWZ%+,?%34,4)!/%+/!%16,74?!,)4+-0%6)*!/%)*+,%

)*!%7+1)%)*+)%ZWZ%5/4)!%)6%34,4)!/%7/63%)43!%)6%)43!0%+,?%)*+)%)*!=%/!;6,?$%

Z!/!0% )*!/!76/!0% 16,74?!,)4+-4)=% ?4?% ,6)% 3!/!-=% +))+1*% )6% )*!% ;!14741% .4!5% 6/%

6;4,46,%ZWZ%/+4!?%6,%+%;+/)41"-+/%":\!1)$%#*!%7+1)%)*+)%#*!%D/4,1!%67%C+-!%

5/6)!% ;+/)41"-+/% -!))!/% 6,% ;+/)41"-+/% ?+)!% )6% ;+/)41"-+/% /!14;4!,)% 5+%

16,74?!,)4+-[%+,?%)*!%G!,!/+-%":\!1)A3+))!/%67%)*6!%-!))!/%5+%16,74?!,)4+-0%,6%

-!%)*+,%)*!%.4!5%!F;/!!?%54)*4,%)*!3$%K,?!!?0%)*!%16,74?!,)4+-4)=%67%)*6!%

3+))!/%5+%16//!1)-=%/!16G,4e!?%:=%)*!%KXH%+)%]]&S2%+,?%&SP%4,%/!-+)46,%)6%-4)%

67%16//!;6,?!,1!$%%

%

S&$K,%)*6!%14/1"3)+,1!0%+--%)*!%16//!;6,?!,1!%:!)5!!,%#*!%D/4,1!%67%C+-!%+,?%)*!%>??4)46,+-%D+/)4!0%+,?%4,?!!?%+,=%-4)Y1*!?"-!%67%-!))!/%7/63%#*!%D/4,1!%67%

C+-!%+,?%/!;-4!%7/63%34,4)!/0%+))/+1)%)*!%;/6)!1)46,%67%$O&%NHK>0%+.!%6,-=%

)6%)*!%!F)!,)%)*+)%4)%16,4)%67%",6-414)!?%-!))!/%7/63%)*!%>??4)46,+-%D+/)4!%)6%

ZWZ$%%

%

S9$#*!%>;;!--+,)Q%;/6;6!?%4,)!/;/!)+)46,%67%I6:)+4,!?%7/63B%)6%16.!/%6,-=%-!))!/%5/4))!,%:=%#*!%D/4,1!%67%C+-!%)6%)*!%>??4)46,+-%D+/)4!%+)%)*!4/%/!("!)%4%5*6--=%

4,16,4)!,)% :6)*% 54)*% )*!% 56/?4,G% 67% $O&L&@% NHK>% +,?% 54)*% )*!% -!G4-+)4.!%

4,)!,)46,%:!*4,?%$O&%NHK>$%%

%

ST$>% )6% -!G4-+)4.!% 4,)!,)46,0% )*!%>;;!--+,)Q% 4,)!/;/!)+)46,%56"-?% L76/% !F+3;-!@%!F1-"?!%7/63%;/6)!1)46,%*4G*-=%16,74?!,)4+-%4,76/3+)46,%16,)+4,!?%4,%",6-414)!?%

-!))!/%7/63%ZWZ0%5*6!%?41-6"/!%G+.!%/4!%)6%+%1+)A4/6,%:/!+1*%67%16,74?!,1!%


33/55

33

1-+43%54)*% ,6% ;":-41% 4,)!/!)% ?!7!,1!$% #*4% 56"-?% ;")% )*!% >??4)46,+-% D+/)4!%

:!)5!!,%!F+1)-=%)*!%I/61_%+,?%)*!%*+/?%;-+1!B%?!1/4:!?%:=%f6/?%N+-16,!/%+)%7,$P%

+:6.!V%)*!=%16"-?%:!%/!("4/!?%)6%?41-6!%*4G*-=%16,74?!,)4+-%4,76/3+)46,%",?!/%

NHK>0%5*41*%56"-?%-!+.!%)*!3%6;!,%)6%+%:/!+1*%67%16,74?!,1!%1-+43%:=%ZWZ$%%

%

SO$>%)6%)*!%,+)"/+-%3!+,4,G%67%$O&%NHK>0%)*!%>;;!--+,)Q%16,)!,)46,%)*+)%+%;!/6,%I6:)+4,B% 4,76/3+)46,% 7/63%+,6)*!/%5*!/!% *!%3+_!% 63!% ?!-4:!/+)!%!776/)% )6%

+1("4/!%4)0%4%3416,1!4.!?$%#*!%HMJ%?!74,!%)*!%3!+,4,G%67%I6:)+4,B%,6)%6,-=%+%

I!1"/!%6/%G+4,%+%)*!%/!"-)%67%/!("!)%6/%!776/)B0%:")%+-6%43;-=%+%I+1("4/!B%6/%

IG!)B$%#*!%-!G4-+)4.!%4,)!,)46,%:!*4,?%)*!%!1)46,%;-+4,-=%*65% )*+)% )*!%-+))!/%

3!+,4,G%4%4,)!,?!?%,6%-!%)*+,%)*!%76/3!/&8$%

%

?$# W-%+#,!%#).0-3%4%1-!+/%7/63%+%-4,!%67%1+!%7/63%/"\I#k988Ol%9%>X%O2S#)6%W-(G"+#7#N%-#QI-J8U#k988X%+,?%>4P%..),,#7#&+!#k988;;!--+,)Q%";;6!?%?4)4,1)46,%4G,6/!% )*!% -!G4-+)4.!% )4)-!% 76/% )*!% !F!3;)46,% 4,% $O&% NHK>0% 5*41*% 4% I4,76/3+)46,%CV/YW5*5%4,%16,74?!,1!B%L!3;*+4%+??!?@$%%

%


34/55

3:

+%43%,#Q64-.0):%.,)"1U#).0-3??4)46,+-%D+/)4!%?6%,6)% 16,4?!/% )*+)%?!)/43!,)% 4%+% ,!1!+/=%

4,G/!?4!,)%67% +% )/+?4)46,+-%:/!+1*% 67%16,74?!,1!% 1-+430% 4,%;+/)41"-+/%5*!/!% )*!%

4,76/3+)46,%16,1!/,!?%4%,6)%6,-=%16,74?!,)4+-%54)*4,%)*!% /-4-#76/3"-+)46,0%:")%

+-6% ;/4.+)!% 4,76/3+)46,% ;/6)!1)!?% ",?!/% >/)41-!%


35/55

31

*65!.!/0%)*!%)!)%4%/!+?4-=%3!)$%#*4%4%:+!?%:6)*%";6,%)*!%7+1)%)*+)%#*!%D/4,1!%

67%C+-!%56"-?%:!%+GG/4!.!?%47%)*!%/!-!.+,)%4,76/3+)46,%1+3!%4,)6%)*!%*+,?%67%

;!6;-!%)6%5*63%4)%5+%,6)%?4/!1)!?0%+,?%";6,%)*!%;6)!,)4+-%?+3+G!%)*+)%16"-?%

:!%?6,!%)6% )*!%a6,+/1*=%47% )*!%Z!4/% )6%)*!%#*/6,!%5!/!%",+:-!% )6%16//!;6,?%

54)*%a4,4)!/%6,%+%16,74?!,)4+-%:+4%",?!/%)*!%X6,.!,)46,$%%

X%&8P% L)*!%IE;=1+)1*!/B#1+!@0%f6/?%U!4)*%)+)!?%+)%k92RlV%

6&+# "# G%.%3"# 3(%D# ),# )+# ).# ,!%# 5(F)4# ).,%3%+,# ,!",# 4-.0):%.4%+# +!-(:# F%# 3%+5%4,%:D# ".:# ,!%#%.4-(3"G%/)41-!%


36/55

35

54)*% )*!% /4G*)% )6% /!;!1)% 76/% #*!% D/4,1!% 67%C+-!Q% ;/4.+)!% -47!% L!!% ]9&% 67% )*!%

c/6",?% 67% >;;!+-@$% #*4%34",?!/)+,?% )*!% 16,1!;)% 67% I;/4.+)!% -47!B0% +% 4)%

+;;-4!%)6%>/)41-!%


37/55

3?

/)41-!% ;;!+-V%

L&@>% )6% ;+/+G/+;*% 9&L+@0% )*!% KXH%5+% /4G*)% ,6)% )6% ?4)4,G"4*% :!)5!!,%16//!;6,?!,1!% )*+)% 3!/!-=% !,G+G!?% )*!% /4G*)% )6% /!;!1)% 76/%

16//!;6,?!,1!%",?!/%>/)41-!%/)41-!%


38/55

3=

L9@>%)6%;+/+G/+;*%9&L:@AL1@%+,?%L!@0%)*!%KXH%5+%/4G*)%)6%16,1-"?!%)*+)%)*!%16,)!,)%67%)*!%4,76/3+)46,%5+%I36/!%;/4.+)!%4,%,+)"/!%)*+,%;":-41B$%#*!%

16//!;6,?!,1!% -+/G!-=% 16,1!/,!?% #*!% D/4,1!% 67% C+-!Q% .4!5% +:6")%

3+))!/% 67% ?!!;% ;!/6,+-% 4G,4741+,1!% )6% *43$% #*!% 7+1)% )*+)% )*!%

16//!;6,?!,1!% )66_% ;-+1!% 54)*4,% )*!% 16,)!F)% 67% #*!% D/4,1!% 67% C+-!%

;/!;+/4,G% )6%:!%a6,+/1*%?6!%,6)% +-)!/% 4)% ;/4.+)!% ,+)"/!$%>% )*!% KXH%

6:!/.!?0%ZWZQ%;/!;+/+)46,%)6%:!%U4,G%4%+%/!"-)%,6)%67%+%7/!!%?!1446,%

)6%!,G+G!%4,%;":-41%-47!0%:")%67%*4%:4/)*$%Z4%/6-!%+%Z!4/%)6%)*!%#*/6,!%4%

+,%4,)!G/+-%;+/)%67%5*6%*!%4$%K)%40%)*!/!76/!0%5*6--=%+/)47414+-%)6%!;+/+)!%

677%3+))!/%16.!/!?%:=%)*!%X6,.!,)46,0%+,?%"GG!)%)*+)%)*!=%+/!%I;":-41B%

43;-=%:!1+"!%)*!=%!,)+4-%;/!;+/+)46,%76/%?")4!%+%a6,+/1*&O$%%

LT@>% )6% ;+/+G/+;*% 9&L?@0% )*!% 1+!% 67%c-.# N"..-7%3# 7# \%3;;!--+,)%/!-4!0%+/!%+")*6/4)=%76/%)*!%163;-!)!-=%?477!/!,)%;/4,14;-!%)*+)%

)*!/!%3+=%:!%+,%4,1/!+!?%4,)!/!)%4,%4,76/34,G%)*!%;":-41%5*!/!%)*!%7+1)%

/!;6/)!?% 16,1!/,% ;6-4)414+,% 4,% )*!% !F!/14!% 67% )*!4/% 7",1)46,0% 6/% )*!%

;/4.+)!% -4.!% 67% ;6-4)414+,$% #*6!% ;+/+G/+;*% 67% c-.# N"..-7%3# +/!%

16,1!/,!?%54)*%>/)41-!%&8%/4G*)0%,6)%>/)41-!%%)6%;+/+G/+;*%9&L7@0%)*!%)/"!%/+)46%67%I)%/)41-!%;;!--+,)Q%_!-!)6,%+)%]ST%!F;+,?%";6,%)*!%+/G"3!,)%)*+)%)*!%4,76/3+)46,%4%36/!%

I;":-41B%)*+,%I;/4.+)!B%:=%?/+54,G%+%7+-!%+,+-6G=%:!)5!!,%ZWZ%+,?%+%*!/!?4)+/=%D!!/%5*6!% ;64)46,% 4,% )*!% Z6"!% 67% f6/?% 4% +% /!"-)% 67% :4/)*&O$% d")% 47% +% *!/!?4)+/=% D!!/%!,G+G!%4,%;6-4)41+-%+1)4.4)=0%*!%?6!%6%+%)*!%/!"-)%67%+%1*641!$%#*!%D/4,1!%67%C+-!%*+%,6%"1*%1*641!%5*!)*!/%)6%1+//=%6")%*4%?")4!%+%Z!4/%)6%)*!%#*/6,!$%


39/55

3>

;+/)41"-+/-=% +;;-41+:-!% )6% #*!% D/4,1!% 67%C+-!0% 5*6!% ;/!;+/+)46,% 76/%

U4,G*4;%4%4,!;+/+:-!%7/63%5*6%*!%4$%%

/)41-!%Q%_!-!)6,0%]TS$%%


40/55

:7

#*+)%)!)0%+%f6/?%c677%;64,)!?%6")%4,%&,,-3.%;#\%.%3"#7#TF+%37%3#Y,:#k&PP8l%&%>X%

&8P%L)*!%IM5;4",4!%3B%1+!@%+)%9


41/55

:6

16,74?!,)4+-4)=% 4% 7"/)*!/% /!4,76/1!?% :=% )*!% ;":-41% 4,)!/!)% /!16G,4!?% 4,% )*!%

X6,.!,)46,$%

P9$M%4-.:;D% +,?% 43;6/)+,)-=0% )*!% /!-!.+,)% ("!)46,% 4% ,6)% 43;-=% 5*!)*!/% )*!%4,76/3+)46,% 4% +% 3+))!/% 67% ;":-41% 4,)!/!)0% :")% /+)*!/% 5*!)*!/% 4,% +--% )*!%14/1"3)+,1!%4)%4%4,%)*!%;":-41%4,)!/!)%)*+)%)*!%?")=%67%16,74?!,1!%*6"-?%:!%

:/!+1*!?V%!!%76/%!F+3;-!%&++-4)",%:#I%2+5"5%3+#Y,:#7#NAN#K3).4%#-0#L"%+#+)%kR/)41-!%;;!+-%

4,%>4P%..),,# 7# &+!# !,?6/!?% )*!% +;;/6+1*% 67% M+?=% j% +)% 74/)% 4,)+,1!% LL988R@%

MafW%&8%+)%kPSl@V%

6V#2-(:#.%7%3,!%%++#"44%5,#,!",#>3#?3-2.%#)+#F3-":;#4-33%4,#2!%.#!%#+(F


42/55

:4

M53# k988Sl% &% >X% T2P% +)% k&OSl@$% K,% )*!% ;/!!,)% 16,)!F)0% 4)% 4% 43;6/)+,)% ,6)% )6%

16,7"!% )*!% ;":-41Q% 4,)!/!)% 4,% _,654,G% +:6")% )*!% D/4,1!% 67% C+-!%54)*% )*!%

;":-41%4,)!/!)$%E!!%NAN#*!%#K3).4%#-0#L"%+#7#&++-4)",%:#I%2+5"5%3+%+)%k&&;;!+-Q%\"?G3!,)V%

6&+#!%)3#,-#,!%#,!3-.%D#K3).4%#/!"3%+#)+#".#);;!--+,)Q%+;;/6+1*%

PR$#*!%>;;!--+,)Q%+;;/6+1*%)6%5*!)*!/%6/%,6)%+%;":-41%4,)!/!)%?!7!,1!%16"-?%:!%3+?!%6")%4%7-+5!?$%K,%":)+,1!%)*!%6,-=%;+/)%67%)*!%>;;!--+,)Q%E_!-!)6,%)*+)%

+??/!!%)*!%7+1)"+-%:+4%67%"1*%+%?!7!,1!%4%+)%]]P;;!--+,)%

4?!,)474!% ;":-41% 4,)!/!)%16,4?!/+)46,% )*+)% 7+.6"/%?41-6"/!$%N6/% )*!%/!+6,%

+-/!+?=% )+)!?% +)% ;+/+G/+;*% OR%^% 2T%+:6.!0% )*!!% +/!% ,6)% 3+))!/% 67% +,=% /!+-%

":)+,1!$%%

PS$#*!%>;;!--+,)%)*!,%5/6,G-=%"GG!)%LG/6",?0%]]&SA98@%)*+)%5*!,%+;;-=4,G%)*!%;":-41% 4,)!/!)% )!)0% )*!% #/4:",+-% *6"-?% 43;-=% 5!4G*% #*!% D/4,1!% 67% C+-!Q%

>/)41-!% ;;!--+,)Q% /4G*)% )6% 7/!!?63% 67% !F;/!46,% ",?!/%

>/)41-!%&8%MXZW$%Z65!.!/0%4,%)*!%;/!!,)%1+!0%!.!,%47%>/)41-!%&8%/4G*)%+/!%4,%

;-+=%+)%+--0%+,+-=4%67%)*!%;64)46,%4,%)!/3%67%+%163;!)4)46,%:!)5!!,%>/)41-!%/)41-!%&8%L+@%?6!%,6)%+??%+,=)*4,G%3+)!/4+-%)6%)*!%;/4,14;-!%!)%6")%+:6.![%

+,?%L:@%)!,?%)6%6:1"/!%/+)*!/%)*+,%/!.!+-%)*!%;/+1)41+-%3!/4)%67%)*!%;64)46,$%

P/)41-!%&8%4% 4,%;-+=%+)% +--$%#*!%>;;!--+,)% /!-4!% 6,% )*!%?!1446,% 67%)*!%#/4:",+-%4,%W%33;#/),;#/-(.4) 0%+,?%)*!%

16,1-"46,%4,%)*+)%1+!%)*+)%76/%)*!%;"/;6!%67%!1)46,%O&L&@L:@%4)%3")%+-5+=%:!%


43/55

:3

+"3!?% )*+)% )*!% ;":-41% +")*6/4)=% 4% +% 54--4,G% ?4!34,+)6/% 67% )*!% ?4;")!?%

4,76/3+)46,$%%#*4%+"3;)46,%4%)6%:!%3+?!%L6%)*!%+/G"3!,)%G6!@%:!1+"!%47%4)%

5+%,6)%3+?!0%>/)41-!%&8%56"-?%,6)%:!%4,%;-+=%+)%+--$%#*4%4%:!1+"!%)*!%/4G*)%)6%

6:)+4,% 4,76/3+)46,% 6,-=% !,G+G!%>/)41-!% &8%5*!,% +% ;!/6,% 4% ;/!.!,)!?% 7/63%

/!1!4.4,G%4,76/3+)46,%5*41*%6)*!/%56"-?%54*%6/%:!%54--4,G%)6%43;+/)%)6%*43V%

!!%Y%".:%3#7#M2%:%.#L&P/)41-!%/)41-!%&8@%4%4,16//!1)$%#*!%6,-=%+,+-=4%/!("4/!?%4%)*!%+,+-=4%"33+/4!?%

+)%;+/+G/+;*%


44/55

::

!,*+,1!?@% :=% /!-4+,1!% 6,% >/)41-!% &8$% #*4% 4% 76/% )*!% /!+6,% !)% 6")% 4,% )*!%

76--654,G%;+/+G/+;*$%

Z65%)*!%;/4,14;-!%+:6.!%+;;-=%)6%)*!%?4;")!?%4,76/3+)46,%

&8&$ K,%)*!%;/!!,)%14/1"3)+,1!0%)*!/!%56"-?%:!%,6%!77!1)4.!%;":-41%4,)!/!)%?!7!,1!%)6%+,%+1)46,%76/%:/!+1*%67%16,74?!,1!$%%

&89$ #*!!% +/!% 14/1"3)+,1!% 4,% 5*41*% )*!% ;":-41% 4,)!/!)% 4,% 3+4,)+4,4,G%16,74?!,)4+-4)=% 4% ;+/)41"-+/-=% )/6,G0% 76/% +--% )*!% /!+6,% !)% 6")% +:6.!$% #*!%

76--654,G% 7+1)6/% 3")% :!% +??!?% )6% )*!% 4,*!/!,)% ;":-41% 4,)!/!)% 4,% /!;!1)4,G%

16,74?!,1!V%

L&@ #*!%)/6,G%?!G/!!%67%;/6)!1)46,%5*41*%)*!%?4;")!?%4,76/3+)46,%+))/+1)%",?!/%>/)41-!%


45/55

:1

L9@J41-6"/!% 67% )*!% ?4;")!?% 16//!;6,?!,1!% 56"-?% :!% 67% .!/=% -434)!?%+4)+,1!% 4,%/!+-4e4,G%)*!%G!,!/+-4!?%;":-41%4,)!/!)%4,%?41-6"/!%,65%

/!-4!?% 6,% :=% )*!% >;;!--+,)% L!!% 6,% )*4% ;64,)0% )*!% ":3446,% +)%

;+/+G/+;*%O2%^%2T%+:6.!0%+,?%)*!%7"/)*!/%":3446,%+)%;+/+G/+;*%2O%A

R9%+:6.!%5*41*% !)% 6")%5*=% )*!% ;":-41% 4,)!/!)% 4%;-+4,-=% 4,% 7+.6"/% 67%

3+4,)+4,4,G%)*!%16,74?!,)4+-4)=%67%)*!%?4;")!?%4,76/3+)46,@%$%%

LT@ #*!%16,)!,)%67%)*6!%-!))!/0%!4)*!/%7/63%6/%)6%)*!%D/4,1!0%?6!%,6)%*+.!%)*!%I.!/=%*4G*%?!G/!!%67%43;6/)+,1!B%/!("4/!?%:=%M+?=%jQ%)!)%4,%>4P%..),,#7#

&+!%4,%6/?!/%)6%\")47=%?41-6"/!$%%

!

NK! D.&=?G%!(!OG?+!!

&8O$ E!1)46,%O8%NHK>%;/6.4?!0%+%7+/%+%/!-!.+,)V%6&*+,4%$7!)%64+-$()4%!

QXU&.;#).0-3


46/55

:5

6,!%#:","#53-,%4,)-.#53).4)5%+1#@V%

%

L&@ D+/+G/+;*%&%67%E1*!?"-!%&%)6%)*!%JD>%L)*!%74/)%?+)+%;/6)!1)46,%;/4,14;-!@%)+)!V%

6K%3+-."#:","#+!"#F%#53-4%++%:#0")3;#".:#"20(;D#".:#).#5"3,)4("3D#+!"#.-,#

F%#53-4%++%:#(.%++nQ"U#",#%"+,#-.%#-0#,!%#4-.:),)-.+#).#M4!%:(%#]#)+#


47/55

:?

E1*!?"-!%9%)6%)*!%JD>$%K,%)*!%14/1"3)+,1!0%)*!%16//!;6,?!,1!%4%!F!3;)%7/63%

?41-6"/!%",?!/%$O8L9@%NHK>$%%

%

&$# *!%#4-33%+5-.:%.4%#4-.+)+,+#-0#5%3+-."#:","#3%",).G#,-#*!%#K3).4%#-0#L"%+#

%

&8


48/55

:=

)*!/!76/!%+36",)%)6%*4%I;!/6,+-%?+)+B%76/%)*!%;"/;6!%67%$&%JD>%+,?%$O8%

NHK>$%

%

?$# W)+4-+(3%#-0#,!%#4-33%+5-.:%.4%#2-(:#F3%"4!#,!%#:","#53-,%4,)-.#53).4)5%+#

%

&&8$ N6/% +--% )*!% /!+6,% +-/!+?=% G4.!,% +:6.!% 4,% /!-+)46,% )6% $O&% NHK>0%?41-6"/!%67%)*!%16//!;6,?!,1!%4,%)*4%1+!%56"-?%:!%",5+//+,)!?%:=%/!+6,%67%

;/!\"?41!% )6%#*!% D/4,1!% 67%C+-!Q% /4G*)0% 7/!!?63% +,?% -!G4)43+)!% 4,)!/!)$% K)%

56"-?%:!%",5+//+,)!?%4,%;+/)41"-+/%4,%-4G*)%67V%

%

L&@ #*!% D/4,1!% 67% C+-!Q% /!+6,+:-!% !F;!1)+)46,% )*+)% )*!% 16//!;6,?!,1!%56"-?%:!%_!;)%16,74?!,)4+-[%

%

L9@ #*!% 4,7/4,G!3!,)% )*+)%?41-6"/!%56"-?% 1+"!% )6% #*!% D/4,1!% 67%C+-!Q%/4G*)%)6%/!;!1)%76/%;/4.+)!%-47!%",?!/%>/)41-!%


49/55

:>

?!1446,%,6)41!%+%I!,.4/6,3!,)+-% 4,76/3+)46,B%54)*4,%/!G$9%MKW$%Z65!.!/0% )6%

)*!%!F)!,)%)*+)%)*!%4,76/3+)46,%4%I!,.4/6,3!,)+-%4,76/3+)46,B0%4)%4%!F!3;)%7/63%

?41-6"/!%!4)*!/%",?!/%/!G$&9L2@L7@%MKW%6/%/!G$&T%MKW$%

%

&$# A%G(",)-.#X]QkUQ0U#[VA#

%

&&9$ W!G$%&9%MKW%)+)!0%+%7+/%+%/!-!.+,)0%)*+)V%6QXU# M(F_%4,# ,-# 5"3"G3"5!+# Q]UD# Q8U# ".:# QaUD# "# 5(F)4# "(,!-3),;#


50/55

17

L9@%)*!%":\!1)A3+))!/%67%#*!%D/4,1!%67%C+-!Q%-!))!/0%5*!/!%)*+)%":\!1)A3+))!/%4%

16,74?!,)4+-%+,?%?41-6"/!%56"-?%+?.!/!-=%+77!1)%#*!%D/4,1!%67%C+-!Q%4,)!/!)$%

#*!%+3!%;/4,14;-!%+;;-=%*!/!% )6% 4,76/3+)46,%54)*4,% )*!% 16;!% 67% /!G$&9L2@L7@%

MKW0%+%+;;-=%",?!/%$O&%NHK>V%!!%;+/+G/+;*%RRASO%+:6.!$%%

%

&&2$ #*!%D/4,1!%67%C+-!%5+%",?!/%,6%-!G+-%6:-4G+)46,%)6%5/4)!%)6%34,4)!/%6,%;+/)41"-+/% ":\!1)0% 6/%!F;/!4,G%;+/)41"-+/%.4!5[% )*!% 16//!;6,?!,1!% )66_%

;-+1!%",?!/%16,?4)46,%67%16,74?!,)4+-4)=[%+,?%ZWZ%?4?%,6)%16,!,)%)6%?41-6"/!%

67% )*6!% .4!5% 6/% ":\!1)$% E":;+/+G/+;*% L4@0% L44@% +,?% L444@% 67% /!G$&9L2@L7@% +/!%

+)474!?$%%

%

&&R$ >%)6%)*!%;":-41%4,)!/!)%:+-+,1!%",?!/%/!G$&9L&@0%)*!%;64,)%+-/!+?=%3+?!%+:6.!%4,%/!-+)46,%)6%)*!%;":-41%4,)!/!)%",?!/%$TS%+,?%$O&%NHK>%+/!%/!;!+)!?$%

#*!% ;":-41% 4,)!/!)%:+-+,1!% 4% )/6,G-=% 4,% 7+.6"/% 67% 16,74?!,)4+-4)=0% :!+/4,G% 4,%

34,?%4,%;+/)41"-+/%)*!%5!4G*)=%;":-41%4,)!/!)%4,%;/6)!1)4,G%)*!%X6,.!,)46,%+,?%

#*!%D/4,1!%67%C+-!Q%;6-4)41+-%,!")/+-4)=$%%

%

?$# A%GJ#X8#[VA#

%

&&S$ #*!% !F!3;)46,% 4,% /!G$&T% MKW% 76/% ;!/6,+-% ?+)+% 16,4)4,G% 67%I!,.4/6,3!,)+-% 4,76/3+)46,B% 34//6/% )*!% !77!1)% 67% $O8% NHK>%+% /!G+/?% 6)*!/%

;!/6,+-% ?+)+$% #*"% !,.4/6,3!,)+-% 4,76/3+)46,% 54)*4,% )*!% 16//!;6,?!,1!%

L4,1-"?4,G%4,76/3+)46,%6,%!3446,@%4%!F!3;)%7/63%?41-6"/!%",?!/%/!G$&T%MKW%

76/%)*!%+3!%/!+6,%)*+)%6)*!/%4,76/3+)46,%4%!F!3;)%7/63%?41-6"/!%",?!/%$O8%

NHK>$%#*!%;64,)%3+?!%+)%;+/+G/+;*%&8OA&&8%+:6.!%+/!%/!;!+)!?$%

%

N6K!! 2?D=D!+%L!D&>.L;2.D!

!

&&??4)46,+-% D+/)4!% ":34)% )*+)% -4)% 67% )*!% 16//!;6,?!,1!0% +,?%1*!?"-!% :/4!7-=% ?!1/4:4,G% )*!% 16//!;6,?!,1!0% 56"-?% :!% !F!3;)% 7/63%

?41-6"/!% ",?!/% $TS0% O8% +,?% O&% NHK>0% +,?% /!G$% &9L2@L7@% +,?% &T% MKW% +%


51/55

16

+;;-41+:-!0% \")% +% )*!% 16//!;6,?!,1!% 4)!-7% 4% !F!3;)% 7/63% ?41-6"/!% ",?!/%

)*6!%;/6.446,$%%

%

&$# M%4,)-.#8m#ETV

%

&&P$ f4)% +,?% 1*!?"-!% 67% )*!% 16//!;6,?!,1!% +/!% 4,76/3+)46,% /!-+)4,G% )6%1633",41+)46,%54)*%#*!%D/4,1!%67%C+-!0%+,?%)*"%7+--%54)*4,%$TS%NHK>0%\")%+%

)*!%16//!;6,?!,1!%4)!-7%7+--%54)*4,%)*+)%!1)46,$%%

%

&98$ #*!%;":-41%4,)!/!)%:+-+,1!%5!4G*%*!+.4-=%4,%7+.6"/%67%,6,A?41-6"/!%67%-4)%+,?%1*!?"-!$%%

%

&9&$ #*!/!%4%,6%":)+,)4+-%;":-41% 4,)!/!)%4,%?41-6"/!%67%-4)%6/%1*!?"-!$%N6/% !F+3;-!0% )*!4/% ?41-6"/!% 56"-?% ,6)% *+.!% +,=% 4G,4741+,)% :!,!74)% 76/% )*!%

;":-41%4,)!/!)%4?!,)474!?%:=%)*!%KXH%+)%]]P2APR%67%)*!%JgV%

%

L&@ #*!4/%?41-6"/!%56"-?%?6%,6)*4,G%)6%4,1/!+!%)*!%;":-41Q%",?!/)+,?4,G%67%*65%)*!%G6.!/,3!,)%4,)!/+1)%54)*%)*!%Z!4/%)6%)*!%#*/6,!$%K)%4%+-/!+?=%

_,65,% )*+)% #*!% D/4,1!% 67%C+-!%5/4)!% )6% G6.!/,3!,)%34,4)!/% 6,% +%

.+/4!)=%67%":\!1)V%*4%5!:4)!%+1_,65-!?G!%4)$%J41-6"/!%67%)*!%7+1)%)*+)%

;+/)41"-+/%-!))!/%5!/!%5/4))!,%6,%;+/)41"-+/%?+)!%6,%;+/)41"-+/%":\!1)%

56"-?%,6)%+??%+,=)*4,G%67%":)+,1!%)6%)*+)%+1_,65-!?G3!,)%+:6")%)*!%

5+=%4,%5*41*%34,4)!/%+,?%ZWZ%4,)!/+1)$%

%

L9@>,=%4,)!/!)%4,%)/+,;+/!,1=%4%+-/!+?=%3!)%:=%?41-6"/!%67%)*!%7+1)%)*+)%#*!% D/4,1!% 67% C+-!% 5/4)!% 6,% +% .+/4!)=% 67% ":\!1)% )6% G6.!/,3!,)%

34,4)!/$%%

%

LT@J41-6"/!%67%-4)%6/%1*!?"-!%56"-?%,6)%+--65%)*!%;":-41%)6%",?!/)+,?%)*!% 4,7-"!,1!% L47% +,=@% !F!/)!?% :=% #*!% D/4,1!% 67% C+-!$% g6)*4,G% +:6")%

4,7-"!,1!%L6/%-+1_%67%4)@%1+,%:!%!F)/+;6-+)!?%7/63%-4)%6/%1*!?"-!$%


52/55

14

%

&99$ #*!%>;;!--+,)%?6!%,6)% 4?!,)47=%+,=%16G!,)%;":-41%4,)!/!)% 4,%?41-6"/!%67%)*4%4,76/3+)46,$%#*!%>;;!--+,)Q%":3446,%6,%)*4%;64,)%+/!%+)%]&9T%67%*4%

E_!-!)6,%>/G"3!,)$%#56%;64,)%+/!%3+?!$%N4/)%4)%4%16,)!,?!?%)*+)%)*!%7+1)%)*+)%

)*!% ?41-6"/!% 67% -4)% +,?% 1*!?"-!% 56"-?% /!"-)% 4,% ?+3+G4,G% ;!1"-+)46,%

3!+,% )*+)% )*!% !,)4/!)=% 67% )*!% ?4;")!?% 4,76/3+)46,% *6"-?% :!% ?41-6!?$%

Z65!.!/0%)*+)%4%,6)%+,%+/G"3!,)%3+)!/4+-%)6%)*!%/!;!1)4.!%;":-41%4,)!/!)%4,%

3+4,)+4,4,G%)*!%16,74?!,)4+-4)=%67%)*!%?4;")!?%4,76/3+)46,0%6/%?41-6"/!%67%)*+)%

4,76/3+)46,$%g!F)%4)%4%16,)!,?!?%)*+)%?41-6"/!%67%-4)%+,?%1*!?"-!%6"3%#,!%#

7%3;# >%

5Y%]O&@$%Z!/!0%)*!/!76/!V%

%

L&@J41-6"/!%67%-4)%+,?%1*!?"-!%56"-?%;6)!,)4+--=%!F;6!%#*!%D/4,1!%67%C+-!%)6%",5+//+,)!?%1/4)4143%67%)*!%)=;!%3+?!%:=%W)+5",4!%+0%+,?%*+.!%

+%1*4--4,G%!77!1)%";6,%1633",41+)46,%:!)5!!,%#*!%D/4,1!%67%C+-!%+,?%

34,4)!/0%",?!/34,4,G%)*!%X6,.!,)46,[%

%

L9@J41-6"/!% 67% 1*!?"-!% !))4,G% 6")% )*!% ":\!1)A3+))!/% 67% )*!%16//!;6,?!,1!% 56"-?% ;6)!,)4+--=% ",?!/34,!% )*!% ;!/1!;)46,% 67% #*!%

D/4,1!%67%C+-!Q%;6-4)41+-%,!")/+-4)=[%


53/55

13

%

LT@J41-6"/!% 67% -4)% 6/% 1*!?"-!% !))4,G% 6")% )*!% ":\!1)A3+))!/% 67% )*!%16//!;6,?!,1!%56"-?% 4,7/4,G!%ZWZQ% /4G*)% )6% /!;!1)% 76/% ;/4.+)!% -47!%

",?!/%>/)41-!%,=%-4)%6/%1*!?"-!%5*41*%?41-6!?%)*+)%#*!%D/4,1!%67%C+-!%*+?%5/4))!,%-!))!/% )6%;+/)41"-+/%34,4)!/%6,%;+/)41"-+/% ?+)!% 6,%;+/)41"-+/% ":\!1)%56"-?%

!,)+4-% )*!% ?41-6"/!% 67% 16,74?!,)4+-% 4,76/3+)46,% 6:)+4,!?% :=% )*!% >??4)46,+-%

D+/)4!%7/63%#*!%D/4,1!%67%C+-!0%4,%14/1"3)+,1!%5*!/!%)*!%7+1)%)*+)%ZWZ%*+?%

5/4))!,%6,%;+/)41"-+/%?+)!0%)6%;+/)41"-+/%34,4)!/0%6/%6,%;+/)41"-+/%":\!1)0%5!/!%

16,74?!,)4+-V%!!%+:6.!&P$%%

%

&92$ #*!/!%56"-?%:!%,6%!77!1)4.!%?!7!,1!%)6%+,%+1)46,%76/%:/!+1*%67%16,74?!,1!%4,%/!;!1)%67% )*!%?41-6"/!%67%"1*%4,76/3+)46,$%g6%/!+-%;":-41%4,)!/!)%!F4)%4,%

)*!% ?41-6"/!% 67% -4)% +,?% 1*!?"-!$% #*!% .!/=% 4G,4741+,)% 5!4G*)% /!("4/!?% )6%

6.!//4?!%?")4!%67%16,74?!,)4+-4)=%?6!%,6)%!F4)V%!!%+:6.!$%%

%

/$# M%4,)-.#le#ETV

%

#*!%>;;!--+,)%5/6,G-=%+!/)%+)%]&92%67%*4%_!-!)6,%)*+)%I)*!%":\!1)%3+))!/%67%63!%67%

)*!%16//!;6,?!,1!%6"G*)%4,%)*4%1+!%*+%+-/!+?=%:!!,%/!.!+-!?%4,%D+/-4+3!,)%+,?%4,%)*!% ;6-41=% ?61"3!,)% 67% 6,!% 67% )*!% ;6-4)41+-% ;+/)4!% L!!% E1*!?"-!% 67% !F*4:4)% )6%>--+,%1-6!?%5YV%1"/46"-=% )*!%>??4)46,+-%D+/)4!%*+.!% /!7"!?%)6% ;")%)*!% /!-!.+,)%Z+,+/?%!F)/+1)%+,?%)*!%;6-41=%?61"3!,)%4,%6;!,%!.4?!,1!B$%#*4%4%+%34",?!/)+,?4,G%67%)*!%>??4)46,+-%D+/)4!Q%/!+6,%76/%;"))4,G%)*!%;+/)41"-+/%3+)!/4+-%4,%1-6!?$%#*!%3+)!/4+-%4%4,%1-6!?%:!1+"!%;"))4,G%4)%4,%6;!,%56"-?%:=%)


54/55

1:

&9R$ >% -4)% 6/% 1*!?"-!% 4,?41+)4,G% )*+)% #*!% D/4,1!% 67%C+-!% *+?% 5/4))!,% 6,%;+/)41"-+/% ?+)!% )6%;+/)41"-+/%34,4)!/% 6,%;+/)41"-+/% ":\!1)%56"-?% 16,4)%67%

;!/6,+-%?+)+%/!-+)4,G%)6%#*!%D/4,1!%67%C+-!V%!!%+:6.!$%J41-6"/!%67%"1*%+%-4)%

56"-?%:/!+1*%)*!%74/)%?+)+%;/6)!1)46,%;/4,14;-!%76/%)*!%/!+6,%+-/!+?=%!)%6")%

+:6.!$%%

%

W$# A%GJ#X]QkUQ0US3%GJX8#[VA#

%

&9S$ #6% )*!% !F)!,)% )*+)% )*!% ":\!1)A3+))!/% 67% ;+/)41"-+/% -!))!/% 16,4)% 67%!,.4/6,3!,)+-%4,76/3+)46,0%?41-6"/!%67%)*+)%":\!1)A3+))!/%4,%+%1*!?"-!%56"-?%

7+--%)6%:!%?!+-)%54)*%",?!/%)*!%MKW$%N6/%)*!%/!+6,%+-/!+?=%!)%6")%+:6.!0%)*+)%

":\!1)A3+))!/% 56"-?% :6)*% 16,4)% 67% 4,76/3+)46,% ;/6.4?!?% :=% #*!% D/4,1!% 67%

C+-!0%?41-6"/!%67%5*41*%+?.!/!-=%+77!1)%*4%4,)!/!)%L16,)/+/=%)6%/!G$&9L2@L7@%

MKW@[% +,?% 56"-?% 16,4)% 67% ZWZQ% ;!/6,+-% ?+)+0% ?41-6"/!% 67% 5*41*%56"-?%

:/!+1*%)*!%74/)%?+)+%;/6)!1)46,%;/4,14;-!%L16,)/+/=%)6%/!G$&T%MKW@$%%

%

%

jHg>#Z>g%ECKN#%oX%

%

j`fK>g%aKfNHWJ%

%

%


55/55

&$#*!%/#-!.+,)("(,(("7!.+,)("(,(("67!.+,)("(,(("47!.+,)("(,(("37!.+,)("(,((":7!

.+,)("(,(()(7!$15!.+,)("(,(()"!!?%!=>.!;

Documents

Government Argument Prince Charles