Upload
others
View
15
Download
1
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
1 Geriatric Medicine (Elderly Medicine)
Geriatric Medicine (Elderly Medicine)
Key Topics
FRAILTY AND SARCOPENIA (LO1) ................................................................................... 2
IMMOBILITY (LO1) .............................................................................................................. 4
ASSESSMENT OF COGNITION IN OLDER PEOPLE (LO2) ............................................... 6
DELIRIUM (LO2) .................................................................................................................. 9
DEMENTIA, WITH A FOCUS ON DEMENTIA IN HOSPITAL (LO2) .................................. 11
FALLS IN OLDER PEOPLE (LO3) ..................................................................................... 14
FALLS - ASSESSMENT OF BALANCE AND GAIT (LO3) ............................................... 17
STROKE & TIA (LO4) ........................................................................................................ 19
PRESCRIBING FOR OLDER PEOPLE (LO5) .................................................................... 22
PRESSURE ULCERS (LO6) .............................................................................................. 24
CGA, COMPREHENSIVE GERIATRIC ASSESSMENT (LO7) ........................................... 26
REHABILITATION OF OLDER PERSONS (LO8) .............................................................. 28
KEY TOPICS NOT COVERED BY THE LEARNING OBJECTIVE ..................................... 30
OTHER TOPICS - SENSORY IMPAIRMENTS IN OLD AGE ............................................. 31
OTHER TOPICS - THE LAW AND OLDER PEOPLE ......................................................... 33
OTHER TOPICS - ASSESSMENT OF ACTIVITIES OF DAILY LIVING ............................. 36
OTHER TOPICS - ASSESSMENT FOR CARE IN THE COMMUNITY ............................... 38
2 Geriatric Medicine (Elderly Medicine)
Frailty and Sarcopenia (LO1)
Dr Daisy Wilson
What is frailty? Frailty is a medical syndrome with multiple causes and contributors that is characterized by
diminished strength, endurance, and reduced physiological function that increases an
individual’s vulnerability for developing increased dependency and/or death. Or put simply
an increased risk of adverse outcomes such as death or institutionalisation.
What is sarcopenia? Sarcopenia is the age related loss of muscle mass. It is different to cachexia which is a
metabolic condition resulting in weight loss as well as loss of muscle mass. Sarcopenia is
present if an individual has low muscle mass and either poor physical performance (timed
walk test/TGUG) or low muscle strength (hand grip strength). If all three criteria are present
the individual has severe sarcopenia and if just low muscle mass is present the individual
has pre-sarcopenia.
How are the two conditions linked? Sarcopenia is more common than frailty and is often thought of as either a pre-cursor
syndrome to frailty or the physical components of frailty. They have many of the same
causes and similar treatments appear to ameliorate their effects. However, we don’t yet
know the exact link and overlap between the two conditions so for the moment we should
consider them as separate conditions.
What causes frailty and sarcopenia? The pathophysiology of frailty and sarcopenia is fairly unexplored but the role of the immune
system, hormones, the endocrine and metabolic systems and lack of physical activity are
thought to be important.
How do you diagnose frailty? Frailty is most commonly diagnosed in clinical practice by instinct; this can be very subjective
and should be avoided. It is accepted that diagnosis of frailty following a comprehensive
geriatric assessment (CGA) is a robust method of diagnosis but without an appropriate prior
assessment the term frailty can be incorrectly applied. There are several methods of
diagnosis which can be utilised by the non-geriatrician who is not competent in CGA.
Electronic frailty index is a score computed by GP operating systems; it takes into
account 36 different criteria representing many different domains such as physical,
social and psychological.
Edmonton Frail Scale is used in many surgical settings to help diagnose frailty. It is a
short questionnaire along with a quick assessment of physical function (TGUG) and
cognition (clock drawing).
How do you diagnose sarcopenia? Sarcopenia is currently rarely diagnosed clinically likely due to the current lack of accepted
treatment. One of the easiest methods of diagnosis is to first measure an individual’s gait
speed. If this is less than 0.8m/s they should go on to have imaging (usually a DEXA) to
diagnose low muscle mass. If the gait speed is greater than 0.8m/s they should first have
their grip strength tested and only if this is low should they have imaging.
3 Geriatric Medicine (Elderly Medicine)
Why are frailty and sarcopenia important clinical conditions? These are both common conditions which contribute to a significant proportion of morbidity
and mortality in older adults. The direct cost of both these conditions is difficult to calculate
but it was estimated in the US in 2000 the direct healthcare cost of sarcopenia was $18.5
billion.
What can we do about it? Research has shown that both frailty and sarcopenia are reversible conditions. The evidence
base for management is currently small. These interventions have the best evidence and
geriatricians would be confident to recommend these as part of a management plan
especially as the potential negative effects are minimal.
Exercise intervention – particularly involving strength work
Nutrition – particularly involving protein or amino acid supplementation
Comprehensive geriatric assessment – has been demonstrated to reverse frailty
also associated with improved outcomes in hospital setting (see CGA section)
These interventions below have some or conflicting evidence and are not part of routine
practice.
ACE inhibitors – some evidence that this can improve strength and there is an
ongoing trial looking at ACEi and protein supplementation in sarcopenia
Vit D – conflicting evidence some studies have shown and improvement others
have shown negative effects.
Testosterone and DHEA (steroid precursor of testosterone) – variable results but
concerns with steroid replacement due to side effects (cardiovascular)
Reading: Fit for Frailty guidelines from BGS – http://www.bgs.org.uk/campaigns/fff/fff_full.pdf
European working group on sarcopenia in older people – nice background, definition and
diagnosis – https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC2886201/
4 Geriatric Medicine (Elderly Medicine)
Immobility (LO1)
Dr M Goodman
Immobility is one of the most common presenting conditions in the frail elderly and along
with falls, confusion and incontinence is one of the so called geriatric giants. Unfortunately, it
is all too common to regard immobility or “off legs” as a diagnosis but remember that really it
is only a symptom for which a cause needs to be found. Unfortunately, the list of potential
causes is long and typically an individual patient may have several conditions contributing to
their mobility problems. Assessment should always begin with a careful history as this may
give a clue to underlying diagnosis. Conditions such as stroke or fractured neck of femur are
likely to lead to a sudden loss of mobility. The history is likely to be more progressive in
conditions such as arthritis or Parkinson’s disease.
Main causes of immobility in older adults
1. Following a fall -
Falls and immobility are closely linked. Adults who fall frequently often become
frightened to walk and may restrict their movements and in extreme cases take to
bed. Typically these patients resist standing and experience quite marked fall back
and anxiety when attempting to stand. An important consequence of falls is fractured
neck of femur and it is very important whenever there is a history of a recent fall to
exclude a fractured neck of femur in a patient who is unable to walk. The typical sign
of a painful externally rotated leg is not always present and x-ray maybe necessary to
confirm the diagnosis. Pain on weight bearing (even mild) is also a useful warning
sign.
2. Stroke -
Acute onset of a hemiparesis is usually accompanied by immobility to a greater or
lesser degree. Patients with more diffuse cerebrovascular disease often experience
gait abnormalities which can sometimes mimic Parkinson’s disease. Stroke is by
definition of sudden onset and again a clear history should help to make the
diagnosis. Sometimes the history is of a more insidious onset of arm or leg
weakness. In this case consider space occupying lesions such as primary or
secondary brain tumour or subdural haematoma.
3. Osteoarthritis -
Is extremely common in the ageing population particularly of the large weight bearing
joints of the hip and knee. The history is of pain in the effected joint often of months
or years and subject to periodic exacerbations. Degenerative disease of the lumbar
and cervical spine is also common and leads to pain and restricted mobility. Some
older adults have developed rheumatoid arthritis in middle age which they carry with
them into old age. The sudden onset of an acutely painful inflamed joint is an
important cause of loss of mobility and needs to be thoroughly investigated.
Common causes are septic arthritis, gout or pseudo gout but sometimes a flare up of
osteoarthritis can also cause similar appearances.
4. Parkinson’s Disease -
This condition, which mainly affects older adults, typically causes mobility problems
with tremor and bradykinesia. The onset is often rather insidious and consequently is
often missed. Medication can help symptoms but doesn’t slow disease progression.
5 Geriatric Medicine (Elderly Medicine)
Drug treatment (e.g. neuroleptics) is a frequent cause of potentially reversible
Parkinsonism in the elderly.
5. Chronic Cardiorespiratory Disease -
Chronic heart failure and COPD are extremely common. Mobility is often restricted by
breathlessness, poor stamina and lethargy.
6. Visual Impairment -
Commonly due to macular degeneration, patients may manage within their own
homes because of familiarity but outside the home or in an alien environment may
become immobile especially in hospital where the surroundings are often very
frightening and threatening.
7. Feet and Footwear -
An extremely common cause of mobility problems. Always look at the patients shoes
which you may find are either inappropriate or in poor condition. Remove the shoes
and socks and look at the feet. Painful calluses, overgrown toenails, bunions,
ischaemic ulcers, arthritis etc. are all cause of pain in the feet, which restricts
mobility.
8. Miscellaneous Condition -
There are a range of other things which can contribute to a patient’s poor mobility.
The depressed patient may become isolated and immobile. Patients with dementia
may have gait abnormalities which affect their mobility and in addition may have
become lost in an unfamiliar environment. Of course some patients with dementia
exhibit the reverse and have a tendency to wander whatever their surroundings. The
older patient in hospital often finds it particularly difficult to mobilise, urinary
catheterisation with a catheter bag trailing on the floor is equivalent to applying a ball
and chain to an older person who already has mobility difficulties. Provision of poorly
fitting clothes, trousers that won’t stay up and inadequate shoes often compounds
the problem.
Management
This is a multidisciplinary activity. The doctors job is to formulate an accurate diagnostic list,
which may be multiple and then to institute treatment with medication (sometimes removal
of) and/or surgery where appropriate. Physiotherapists clearly have a major role in
promoting mobility and will need to be involved immediately. Remember, they rely heavily on
the Clinician for an accurate diagnosis. Occupational Therapists have an important role
particularly in resettling the patient at home and providing aids and equipment to assist
mobility within hospital and around the home. Social Workers have a role in the provision of
home support and when necessary residential or nursing home care.
6 Geriatric Medicine (Elderly Medicine)
Assessment of cognition in older people (LO2)
Dr T Jackson
Impaired cognition is a frequent accompaniment to illness in old age. Usually it is transient
and precipitated by acute illness (i.e. delirium). Sometimes a person presents with a
background of longer term impaired cognition or dementia. Often the two can occur together.
The key is first to identify delirium. If it is delirium, then treat and manage as such. If not,
then it is likely to be chronic cognitive impairment. Sometimes teasing out the two is very
difficult, and requires excellent diagnostic skills and a collateral history.
In any case, we know that both delirium and dementia confers a greater risk of adverse
outcome during and after hospital admission (increased mortality and new care home
placement) so it is important to recognise and not see it as something that is not important.
So – what test should I use?
Well, there are many detailed and comprehensive tests of cognition available, but in clinical
practice such tests are often unworkable, particularly in the setting of an ill patient in a busy
ward or A&E department. At various times the NHS has mandated cognitive assessment of
inpatients linked to financial incentives (CQUINs)
Delirium screening should be done using the 4AT test –
4 or above: possible delirium +/- cognitive impairment
1-3: possible cognitive impairment
0: delirium or severe cognitive impairment unlikely (but delirium still possible if information
incomplete)
1 ALERTNESS - This includes patients who may be markedly drowsy (e.g. difficult to rouse and/or obviously sleepy during assessment) or agitated/hyperactive. Observe the patient. If asleep, attempt to wake with speech or gentle touch on shoulder. Ask the patient to state their name and address to assist rating. Normal (fully alert, but not agitated, throughout assessment) 0 Mild sleepiness for <10 seconds after waking, then normal 0 Clearly abnormal 4
2 AMT4 - Age, date of birth, place (name of the hospital or building), current year.
No mistakes 0
1 mistake 1
2 or more mistakes/untestable 2
3 ATTENTION - Months of the year backwards:
Ask the patient: “Please tell me the months of the year in backwards order, starting at
December.” To assist initial understanding one prompt of “what is the month before
December?” is permitted.
7 Geriatric Medicine (Elderly Medicine)
Achieves 7 months or more correctly 0
Starts but scores <7 months / refuses to start 1
Untestable (cannot start because unwell, drowsy, inattentive) 2
4 ACUTE CHANGE OR FLUCTUATING COURSE
Evidence of significant change or fluctuation in: alertness, cognition, other mental function
(e.g. paranoia, hallucinations) arising over the last 2 weeks and still evident in last 24hrs
No 0
Yes 4
Cognitive impairment, if not delirium evident, can be screened for using the Abbreviated
Mental Test Score or AMTS – a cut off in hospital patients of <7 (i.e. 6/7 cut off) indicates
possible dementia
1. Time of day (to nearest hour)
2. Year
3. Place
4. Identify two people (i.e. nurse, doctor, relative)
5. Age
6. DOB
7. Address to be remembered (patient must repeat this to ensure registration and again
after 5 minutes – 42 West Street is the one used in the paper
8. Name of monarch
9. Year of start of First World War
10. Count backwards from 20 –1
Score one point for each correct answer
Clearly, these are screening tools, and further investigation of impaired cognition should then
be undertaken. Comprehensive cognitive tests such as Montreal Cognitive Assessment
(MOCA) or Addenbrooke’s Cognitive Assessment 3 (ACEiii) can then be used.
Informant tools such as the Informant Questionnaire of Cognitive Decline in the Elderly
(IQCODE) and Alzheimer’s disease * (AD8) can be very useful, and also help diagnose
dementia in the context of delirium
Issues are often present with respect to IQ, but also language and culture, when using these
tests and this should be taken into account. Also, remember that a test result like this does
not diagnose dementia – the doctor does!
The Mini Mental State Examination (MMSE) is a 30 question cognitive assessment which
was used routinely in clinical practice (normal 27+/30) however it is now copyrighted in a
classic example of ‘stealth patenting’ so should be avoided.
Consideration of depression should be made, and the 15 point Geriatric Depression Scale is
useful here
8 Geriatric Medicine (Elderly Medicine)
In departments of geriatric medicine, the Occupational Therapists have developed
considerable expertise in the administration of cognitive tests as well as its interpretation in
the context of a functional assessment of the patient’s capabilities
9 Geriatric Medicine (Elderly Medicine)
Delirium (LO2)
Dr T Jackson
Delirium is a common, severe neuropsychiatric syndrome that affects mainly older people in
hospital. Delirium occurs in up to 1 in 5 people in hospital and doubles the risk of mortality
in people who have it. It was thought of as a ‘normal’ response to illness in older people but
this is simply not the case. Delirium also accelerates cognitive decline in people with
dementia as well as being a risk factor for developing new dementia.
So not ‘what you expect’, but a medical emergency
Risks, precipitants and recognition
Delirium occurs as a result of an acute precipitant event – usually infection or surgery – and
occurs more frequently in people who are vulnerable to it. However, anyone can get delirium
if they are ill enough, and there are high rates of delirium in paediatric and adult intensive
care for example.
The most important vulnerability in older people is dementia – with up to two thirds of people
with delirium also having dementia (often mild and previously unnoticed). Other key
vulnerabilities are frailty, multimorbidity, sensory impairment, polypharmacy (especially anti
cholinergic drugs), and poor mobility.
Infection – though not always UTI! – and surgery are the most common precipitating events.
In fact delirium is the most common post-surgical complication seen in older people,
especially after hip fracture surgery and laparotomy. Other important precipitants not to miss
are pain, urinary retention, faecal impaction, drugs (especially opiates and anit-cholinergics)
Delirium is poorly recognised by medical staff, especially junior doctors – the reasons for this
are unknown and frankly a bit strange!
The key thing with recognising delirium is to suspect it - Think Delirium
The most important question to ask is – Is this new? – and will require you to get a good
collateral history from family, carers and healthcare staff.
People with delirium have reduced alertness and awareness – this is the key diagnostic
criteria, and may be described as ‘knocked off’. A drowsy or agitated patient is an unwell
patient and requires urgent assessment.
There will be cognitive change – ‘confusion’ – this may be memory loss, but more usually is
perceptual and orientation change. People think they are somewhere else and can have
very frightening hallucinations and thoughts.
The key cognitive deficit in delirium is attentional deficit. Patients will not follow the train of a
conversation, talk on about things of the point, or not make eye contact with you.
10 Geriatric Medicine (Elderly Medicine)
The 4AT test is the best screening and recognition tool at present and should be completed
on all acute admissions of older people to hospital and when you suspect delirium.
Right, I’ve recognised delirium – now what?
Management of delirium is centred on promptly recognising and treating the underlying
precipitant. As is often the case in geriatric medicine causes and usually multifactorial, and
examination and investigations will be opportunistic.
Examination should be comprehensive – ensure you make special reference to:
Consciousness (GCS/AVPU/mRASS) Neurological exam - ?focal deficit
Evidence of head injury or meningism Palpable bladder
Hips, especially if recent fall Possible focus of infection
Investigations should be guided by the above
FBC, U+E, CRP, Glucose SaO2 (ABG if <93%) BP, RR, temp
Blood cultures if temp TFTS, Calcium ECG
CXR Bladder scan
Consider:
CT Brain scan – especially if recent head injury, on anticoagulants, and evidence of focal
neurological deficit, and /or persistently reduced consciousness
Lumbar puncture – if indicated after thorough assessment
Non pharmacological treatment essentially represents best care, but try to reduce
noise/stimulus, ask family to come in, and correct sensory deprivation – glasses and hearing
aids. Never physically restrain.
‘Please give them some sedation?’
Pharmacological treatment of delirium may be necessary if all other measures have not
dhelped and the patient is at risk to themselves, others, or has severe distress.
In this case use Haloperidol 0.5mg orally (1mg IM) and titrate up to a maximum of 5 mg to
relieve symptoms (you are not trying to flatten them)
If they have Parkinson’s disease or Lewy Body Dementia avoid haloperidol and use
lorazepam (0.5 mg); and benzodiazepines have a specific role in alcohol withdrawal states
If treatment is required for longer than several days, seek guidance from specialist in
geriatric medicine and /or old age psychiatry. The balance of risk vs benefit is finely
balanced.
Reading – see links on Canvas
NICE guidelines for delirium, AEME mini-gem on delirium
11 Geriatric Medicine (Elderly Medicine)
Dementia, with a focus on dementia in hospital (LO2)
Dr P Wallis, updated 2017 Dr T Jackson
Dementia is a global impairment of mental function, including intellect, memory and
personality without impairment of consciousness. It is persistent (at least 6 months) and
progressive. What separates dementia from normal cognitive ageing and Mild Cognitive
Impairment (MCI), is that is interferes with everyday function. Corroborative history from
family or friends is useful to confirm the duration of onset.
Dementia is not a diagnosis, but an umbrella syndrome, the most common causes being
Alzheimer’s disease and cerebrovascular disease. Its prevalence rises with age, but affects
about 6-7 % of all people over 65 years, and up to 20% of those aged over 80 years. There
has been a spotlight on dementia recently through the Prime Minister’s Dementia Challenge.
A key to this is to increase access to diagnostic services through memory clinics to improve
the current diagnostic rate – it is estimated that only 2/3 of people living with dementia have
a formal diagnosis, but this is better than it was 10 years ago.
1 in 4 people in hospital have dementia, and people with dementia in hospital are more
likely to receive poor care, suffer hospital adverse events such as falls and delirium, and are
twice as likely to die while in hospital. Treating medical and surgical conditions in people with
dementia should be seen as core business for all hospital doctors (well, maybe not
paediatricians!).
Causes
Alzheimer's disease (AD) - the commonest cause of dementia (45 - 50%). Insidious onset
over months and years without evidence of focal neurological damage. Survival is usually 8 -
10 years. Impaired short term memory and cognitive function are early features. AD is a
pathological diagnosis based upon the presence of neurofibrillary tangles and plaques
throughout the cerebral cortex. No laboratory test available thus diagnosis based upon
characteristic clinical features and exclusion of other causes.
Multi-infarct (vascular) dementia (MID) – is the second commonest cause of dementia (10 -
20%). Stepwise decline with sudden intellectual deterioration followed by a period of
improvement. History of vascular risk factors such as hypertension, AF, diabetes etc.
Evidence of focal neurological damage, labile emotions, abnormal gait (hemiparesis or 'petit
pas').
Lewy Body dementia (LBD) - up to 20% of cases. Lewy bodies (see Parkinson's disease)
present in cerebral cortex, limbic area and basal ganglia. Associated with Parkinson's
disease in most cases. Characterised by fluctuations in alertness, visual hallucinations,
delusions and falls. Extreme sensitivity to neuroleptic medication, e.g. Haloperidol etc.,
causing drowsiness, rigidity and immobility - sometimes with fatal consequences.
12 Geriatric Medicine (Elderly Medicine)
What else could it be?
Alcoholic brain damage (Korsakoff’s syndrome), Chronic head trauma (e.g. dementia
pugilistica in boxers), Creutzfeldt - Jacob disease, neuro-syphilis, Wilson's disease (measure
serum copper and ceruloplasmin) and AIDS related dementia should be considered
The classic ‘dementia screen’ looks for other mimics and checks for hypothyroidism, B12
deficiency and hypercalcaemia
So called ‘pseudo dementia’ can also be due to Normal pressure hydrocephalus (consider in
context of classic triad including new incontinence and gait dyspraxia), Space occupying
lesion (e.g. meningioma) and other psychiatric disease such as depression.
How do we diagnose it?
History is the most important tool to diagnose dementia. Tools such as the Informant
Questionnaire of Cognitive Decline (IQCODE) is a good way of operationalising this.
Neuroimaging is usually completed to exclude mimics such as a space occupying lesion or
hydrocephalus – but most people will tell you they had a scan to diagnose dementia. Newer
functional neuroimaging can help to ‘diagnoses’ dementia, especially in difficult to diagnose
cases or in working age dementia.
You have the diagnosis – what now?
Making the diagnosis of dementia provides the patient and carers with a cause for their
symptoms, and allows for robust advances care planning and the avoidance of ‘crisis’.
Some people (AD with mild/moderate disease) will benefit from Acetylcholinesterase
inhibitors donepezil, galantamine and rivastigmine. Memantine (NMDA antagonist) also has
a role.
MID – No evidence at present for aspirin and/or modification of vascular risk factors such as
hypercholesterolaemia. LBD - avoid neuroleptics, caution with dopaminergic therapy for
associated Parkinsonian symptoms owing to risk of exacerbating psychiatric symptoms.
There is an emerging role for Acetylcholinesterase inhibitors in LBD
Behavioural and Psychiatric Symptoms of Dementia (BPSD) can be very difficult to manage
at times and may require pharmacological treatment (ie atypical antipsychotics such as
respiridone) – but this should be done by specialists and fully recognising the risk that these
drugs increase mortality through vascular disease.
Recognising dementia should also prompt evidence based preventative strategies for falls
and delirium, especially while in hospital.
Reading:
Challenges and opportunities in understanding dementia and delirium in the acute hospital.
Essay in PLOS Med https://doi.org/10.1371/journal.pmed.1002247
NICE Guidance on the Use of Donepezil, Rivastigmine and Galantamine for the Treatment of
Alzheimer's disease. Technology Appraisal Guidance No. 19, 2001; National Institute of
Clinical Excellence, London www.nice.org.uk
13 Geriatric Medicine (Elderly Medicine)
14 Geriatric Medicine (Elderly Medicine)
Falls in Older People (LO3)
Dr J Rowe, updated 2017 Dr H Moorey Incidence
Risk of falling rises steeply with age. One third of people aged >65 will fall in a year and half
of those do so repeatedly, this rises to over 50% in the over 80’s. About a third of the A&E
attendances in the over 65’s follow trauma, such as a fall or other accident. A fall <2m in an
older person is now the most common mechanism of major trauma in patients attending
A&E. Fear of falling and limitation of activity effects between 30 and 50%. Pressure sores,
hypothermia and dehydration may also result from falling.
Aetiology
Most people with falls have age related disease affecting different parts of their balance
system such as problems with vision, arthritic joints, slowed central processing etc. There
are many environmental risk factors that interact with this e.g. poor fitting shoes,
inappropriate environments, particularly institutional; and sedatives, which sedate balance as
much as consciousness. Inter-current illnesses, such as a chest infection, may be the final
straw that precipitates a fall.
Fall or Syncope?
Many people who have lost consciousness have amnesia for the event. Syncope (sudden,
temporary loss of consciousness) requires a different work up and specialised assessments.
Inability to recount the incident, lack of premonitory dread immediately before the fall, failure
to appreciate the impact or see the ground coming up to meet the subject are historical tips
that point towards syncope as a cause.
How should we assess patients who have fallen?
Most patients with falls will need assessment in several different domains. Dedicated falls
services are being available and include virtually all members of the multidisciplinary team.
However, it is important for any clinician assessing a patient who has fallen to understand
the components of a falls assessment and initiate parts of the assessment if able.
A falls assessment may include:
identification of falls history
assessment of gait, balance and mobility, and muscle weakness
assessment of osteoporosis risk
assessment of the older person's perceived functional ability and fear relating to falling
assessment of visual impairment
assessment of cognitive impairment and neurological examination
assessment of urinary incontinence
assessment of home hazards
cardiovascular examination and medication review
The Risk Factor Intervention
Attending to multiple risk factors has also been shown to be effective. This includes personal
factors such as poor vision, inadequate footwear, reduction of medication etc. balance
training programmes, and environmental risk reduction. However, current evidence suggests
that this type of intervention reduces the risk of falls and the number of falls older people
15 Geriatric Medicine (Elderly Medicine)
have, but not the rate of falls, or the number of older people who fall in the community. This
may be due to the complexity of these interventions.
What Else Can Be Done?
Group and home based exercises programmes can reduce rate of falls and risk of
falling. Programmes usually include a combination of balance, gait and strength
training.
Home safety assessments and modifications can reduce rate and risk of falls. These
are most successful in those at highest risk and when carried out by an occupational
therapist.
One study has shown a reduction in falls rate just from stopping sedative and
hypnotic medication. A prescribing modification programme has also been shown to
reduce the risk of falls.
.
What Does Not Work?
Overall vitamin D supplementation does not reduce the rate of falls. However there
is evidence that supplementation may be beneficial in patients with vitamin D
deficiency and to prevent fractures in those at risk. This remains controversial and is
well worth a Google.
Interventions to treat visual problems have in some trials increased the rate of falls.
However, they can be effective as part of multiple risk factor interventions and
specifically correction of cataracts has been shown to reduce falls.
Cognitive behaviour therapy and education programmes have not been shown to
effectively reduce falls in the community.
What about falls in hospitals and care Homes?
Falls in hospital are common, with over 600 reported every day across England and Wales.
All older patients admitted to hospital should be assessed for their risk of falls. Multifactorial
interventions in hospitals have been shown to reduce the risk of falls and rate of falls.
Falls incidence in nursing homes is about three times higher than in the community. With
more than 40 trials on Falls Reduction Programs in institutions evidence that they are
effective is inconclusive. However it is important to consider that low falls rates in care
homes may indicate inactivity or the use of restraint. Vitamin D supplementation in care
home residents, who are likely to be deficient, is effective at reducing the rate of falls.
Falls clinics
Can only see very few patients and A&E interventions and exercise programs probably deal
with them much more cheaply.
How Should We Assess the Risk of Fragility Fracture and Manage Osteoporosis?
Older people are at increased risk of sustaining a fracture following a fall compared to
younger people. About 7% of falls are complicated by fracture, but in only 1% is this a
fractured neck of femur. We should take the opportunity to assess the risk of fragility
fracture, especially if patients have a history of falls or other risk factors, in patients
presenting with a fall.
FRAX and QFracture are online tools used to assess 10 year risk of fragility fracture. Scores
are based on the presence of risk factors such as age, previous falls or fractures, steroid use
16 Geriatric Medicine (Elderly Medicine)
and smoking and alcohol use. If the risk is high, bone mineral density can then be measured
using dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry (DXA). However it should be noted that risk scores
for patient over 80 should be interpreted with caution, as the short term risk of fracture is
likely to be higher.
Osteoporosis is diagnosed in patients with a BMD T-score of −2.5 or lower. Vitamin D and
calcium supplementation and a bisphosphonate, such as alendronic acid, have been shown
to reduce the risk of fragility fracture in patients with osteoporosis and should be prescribed.
However, concerns have emerged regarding the side-effect profile with long term use of
bisphosphonates and it is important to offer a medication review and reassess risk after 3
years of treatment.
Other points to consider
Alarm-raising: Even with no trials, common humanity suggests we should prevent a
protracted lie on the floor. These are associated with a poor prognosis and consequent
mortality (up to 50% at 6 months).
Suggested Reading
National Institute for Health and Social Care. (2013). Falls in older people: assessing risk and
prevention.
https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/cg161
Gillespie, L. D., Robertson, M. C., Gillespie, W. J., Sherrington, C., Gates, S., Clemson, L. M.,
& Lamb, S. E. (2012). Interventions for preventing falls in older people living in the community.
In L. D. Gillespie (Ed.), Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews. Chichester, UK: John
Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
http://www.cochrane.org/CD007146/MUSKINJ_interventions-for-preventing-falls-in-older-
people-living-in-the-community
Cameron, I. D., Gillespie, L. D., Robertson, M. C., Murray, G. R., Hill, K. D., Cumming, R. G.,
& Kerse, N. (2012). Interventions for preventing falls in older people in care facilities and
hospitals. In I. D. Cameron (Ed.), Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews. Chichester,
UK: John Wiley & Sons, Ltd.
http://www.cochrane.org/CD005465/MUSKINJ_interventions-for-preventing-falls-in-older-
people-in-care-facilities-and-hospitals
17 Geriatric Medicine (Elderly Medicine)
Falls - Assessment of Balance and Gait (LO3)
Physiotherapy Department – Geriatric Medicine, Birmingham Heartlands Hospital,
updated 2017 Dr T Jackson
‘Decreased mobility’, ‘falls’ and ‘off legs’ are descriptions all too familiar to the elderly
medicine multidisciplinary team. Falls represent 4% of admissions of patients over 65. In this
age group falls account for 40% of injury related deaths and 1% of total deaths (1). In
addition to the investigation of possible medical and environmental causes, a thorough gait
and balance assessment should be standard for these patients.
To examine an individual’s gait one must be aware of the normal components of walking to
identify deviations. Normal gait includes balance, adequate muscle length and strength,
normal joint range of motion, intact central and peripheral nervous systems, ability to transfer
weight from foot to foot/forefoot to hind foot and sensation, in particular proprioception. Gait
is classified into 2 phases: stance (60%) and swing (40%). If essential components are
absent during either phase, it is the physiotherapist’s job to identify the cause and retrain the
affected component (2). This is done by specific, goal-oriented exercise therapy, which has
been shown to significantly improve function, stability and reduce the risk of falling (3).
Thankfully there are some helpful tools which, although are not a substitute for thorough
clinical assessment, can give us a reasonably accurate predictor of function and postural
stability. Two examples of such assessments are:
1. The Timed up and go test (TUAG) (4)
2. The Berg Balance Scale (5)
The Timed Up and Go test (TUG) is commonly used as a method of assessing an older
person’s mobility, but gives you useful information about gait, gait speed, and risk of falls.
You may see it being used in Falls clinics for example. It requires both static and dynamic
balance while a person walks. The TUG measures the time it takes for a person to rise from
a chair, walk a set distance (usually 3 metres), turn around, walk back to the chair, and then
sit down.
Patients who score poorly on this assessment are likely to need additional physical
assistance to mobilise safely and are at higher risks of falls.
The Berg Balance Scale is a more detailed assessment particularly useful for patients who
appear to mobilise independently but have had falls. It can identify which type of tasks are
risky for that individual and has been used as part of risk assessment for fallers. There are
16 basic items which examine transfers, balance during double leg, tandem and single leg
stance, balance during reaching, turning and stepping, and the effect of eyes closed on the
individual’s postural sway. A low score indicates a high likelihood of falling.
Both tests are sensitive enough to detect problems that might not be obvious in simple
observation of walking (6). For instance, a patient who can walk safely with a frame might
not be safe to proceed independently through a doorway. The latter activity requires enough
18 Geriatric Medicine (Elderly Medicine)
balance to let go of the frame, reach for and open the door and needs adequate spatial
awareness such that the frame does not catch on the doorway.
For therapists such tests help plan treatments and are useful outcome measures for therapy
interventions. For medical staff, particularly those working in an isolated setting (community
or GP practice), they can be useful tools to aid the decision of safe or vulnerable. Patients at
risk from falls will benefit from the preventative advice of an Outpatient/Day Hospital falls
clinic.
Spend time with physiotherapy colleagues when they do these assessments, usually on
medical wards or falls clinics.
REFERENCES
1. Lord SR, Sherrington C, Menz, HB (2001) ‘Falls in older people – Risk factors and
strategies for prevention’ Cambridge University Press
2. Carr J, Shepherd R. ‘A motor learning model for stroke rehabilitation.’ Physiotherapy
1989;75:372-80
3. Buchner DM, Cress ME, ed Lateur BJ, et al. ‘The effect of strength and endurance
training on gait, balance, fall risk, and health services use in community-living older
adults.’ Journal of Gerontology, Series A Biological Sciences and Medical Sciences
1996;52:M218-24.
4. Smith R. ‘Validation and reliability of the elderly mobility scale.’ Physiotherapy 1994;
80 (11). 744-747
5. Berg K et al. ‘Measuring balance in the elderly; preliminary development of an
instrument.’ Physother Can. 1989;41 (6): 304-311
6. RCP (1992) ‘Standardised Assessment Scales for elderly people’, Royal College of
Physicians and British Geriatric Society, London.
7. Rodgers H, Curless R, James O.F.W. (1983) – ‘Standardised functional assessment
scales for elderly patients’ Age and Ageing 1993;22;161-163
8. Woolley SM, Czaja SJ, Frury CG. ‘An assessment of falls in elderly men and
women.’ Journal of Gerontology 1997; 52A(2):M80-7
9. Cho C-Y, Kamen G. ‘Detecting balance deficits in frequent fallers using clinical and
quantitative evaluation tools.’ Journal of the American Geriatrics Society
1998;46;426-30
10. Lord SR, Clark RD. ‘Simple physiological and clinical tests for the accurate prediction
of falling in older people.’ Gerontology 1996;42:199-203
19 Geriatric Medicine (Elderly Medicine)
Stroke & TIA (LO4)
Dr C Welch
Stroke
Presentation
A stroke is defined by the World Health Organisation as ‘a sudden onset of a focal or
generalised neurological deficit which lasts for 24 hours or leads to death for which the only
apparent cause is vascular’. Neurological deficits commonly produced include hemiplegia,
sensory loss, ataxia, visual field defect, transient monocular visual loss, dysphagia,
dysarthria, dysphasia (expressive and receptive) and difficulty performing tasks (apraxia).
The constellation of symptoms will depend upon the part of the brain involved.
Aetiology
There are two types of stroke – haemorrhagic and ischaemic. In the UK, about 10% are
haemorrhagic. Patients should have a CT head within one hour of arrival in hospital to
identify if there is intracerebral haemorrhage. The incidence of stroke increases with age but
it can affect people at any age.
Acute management
Ischaemic stroke
The key to acute management is to salvage the
“ischaemic penumbra” surrounding infarcted brain
tissue. The penumbra can remain viable for several
hours, but the earlier treatment is instituted the
better. Thrombolysis can be given up until 4.5
hours after symptom onset – this service is now
provided 24 hours/ day within the UK by a senior
clinician trained in giving thrombolysis.
In addition, thrombectomy is now recommended as
a treatment for patients with severe disabling
stroke and proximal intracranial large vessel
occlusion (initially identified on CT angiogram).
This treatment should be given in addition to thrombolysis (unless there are
contraindications) and within 5 hours of symptom onset.
Patients, in whom it is not possible to perform thrombolysis or thrombectomy, should be
given 300mg aspirin OD (oral/ rectal) for 2 weeks. Aspirin therapy is normally started 24
hours after thrombolysis, unless there are contraindications (e.g. secondary haemorrhage).
Figure 1 - The ischaemic penumbra, image via The Internet Stroke Center
20 Geriatric Medicine (Elderly Medicine)
Haemorrhagic stroke
There is currently no specific treatment for haemorrhagic stroke, but patients who are on
anticoagulants should be given immediate medication to reverse the effect. Blood pressure
control is also important. Individual hospitals will have their own local protocol; however, it is
recommended that patients who present within 6 hours with a systolic blood pressure (sBP)
above 150 mmHg should receive urgent treatment to maintain the sBP below 140 mmHg.
Rehabilitation
There is clear evidence that all patients benefit from early transfer to a stroke unit. This
means that they will receive early specialist input from nurses familiar with stroke medicine,
speech therapy, physiotherapy and occupational therapy, as appropriate.
Patients with stroke are at increased risk of venous thromboembolism – do not prescribe
enoxaparin to any stroke patients regardless of type. Intermittent pneumatic compression
stockings are being used in many hospitals and the key is commencing early rehabilitation.
Secondary prevention
Following identification of a stroke, it is important to identify possible risk factors that can be
addressed to prevent further strokes in the future. All patients with ischaemic stroke should
continue treatment with clopidogrel 75mg, unless they require anticoagulants. As a
minimum, most patients should have:
12 lead ECG to assess for AF (most will also need prolonged monitoring e.g. 24 hour
or longer) – Patients with AF will require anticoagulant therapy long-term
Cholesterol (target < 4.0)
HbA1c
Carotid dopplers to assess for carotid artery stenosis
Blood pressure management
Smoking cessation advice
Other investigations may be required depending on the clinical picture (e.g. younger patients
with no risk factors, history consistent with neck dissection)
Transient Ischaemic Attack (TIA)
Presentation
A TIA presents with symptoms similar to a stroke but with complete resolution within 24
hours. In reality, most TIAs are much shorter than this.
Investigations
If a patient presents after symptoms have fully resolved, there is normally no indication for
urgent brain imaging. Further investigations will be arranged in TIA clinic as necessary.
Management
Previously, TIAs were triaged by use of the ABCD2 score. However, the updated RCP stroke
guidelines advise that all patients with suspected TIA should be reviewed urgently within 24
hours, unless they present more than 7 days after the onset of symptoms (in which case
they should be seen as soon as possible within 7 days).
21 Geriatric Medicine (Elderly Medicine)
Suspected TIAs should be given 300mg aspirin and referred to their local TIA clinic. If a
diagnosis of TIA is confirmed, they will be given 75mg clopidogrel and screened for possible
predisposing factors as above in secondary prevention for stroke.
Further reading RCP National Clinical Guideline for Stroke – Fifth Edition 2016; Available via URL: https://www.strokeaudit.org/SupportFiles/Documents/Guidelines/2016-National-Clinical-Guideline-for-Stroke-5t-(1).aspx Thrombolysis video at AEME
22 Geriatric Medicine (Elderly Medicine)
Prescribing for Older People (LO5)
Dr Helen Chamberlain, updates 2017 Dr T Jackson
Older people in the UK account for the majority of prescriptions dispensed in the NHS.
Although many older people benefit from their medication, the potential for harm is high and
prescribers need to be aware of the particular needs of older patients.
Physiological changes
The ageing body experiences physiological changes with age including reduced renal
clearance, a reduction in lean body mass and increased body fat. These can affect drug
distribution and clearance. Reduced renal clearance is the most important change, affecting
water-soluble drugs with a narrow therapeutic window such as digoxin. Doses may need to
be reduced as a result.
Multiple pathology and polypharmacy
Around 20% of people aged over 70 take five or more drugs a day. Polypharmacy is
associated with many adverse events such as adverse drug reactions, hospital admission
and increased mortality rate. However, these events may be attributable to frailty rather than
prescribing per se and there may be solid indications for the drugs used.
Inappropriate prescribing
Certain drugs pose particular problems when used in older people. Examples include
benzodiazepines, which are associated with an increased risk of falls, and non-steroidal anti-
inflammatory drugs, which have a high risk of renal impairment and gastrointestinal
haemorrhage. All drugs prescribed should have a clear indication, and care should be taken
to avoid adding another drug to treat the adverse effect of another. An example might be use
of prochlorperazine to treat ‘dizziness’ caused by anti-hypertensives.
Improving prescribing
All medication should be reviewed regularly and those drugs no longer indicated
discontinued. This is also an opportunity to add drugs that may be beneficial such as
warfarin for AF, or calcium & vitamin D supplementation for osteoporosis.
The most important prescriber for older people is the GP. Medication errors are common
when people are discharged from hospital, and there is evidence that a smaller number of
prescribers are associated with a lower rate of errors. Where patients have particularly
complex regimes, the drug review may be better carried out by a geriatrician who can
assess the multiple co-morbidities.
Non-pharmacological therapies should also be used, such as TENS and physiotherapy to
treat musculoskeletal pain.
Drug administration
Most older people at home manage their own medication, but many cannot due to problems
such as visual impairment or poor manual dexterity. Labels and containers can be modified
to take account of this. For people with cognitive impairment, carers (formal and informal)
may administer oral medication, as may district nurses for injections such as insulin.
23 Geriatric Medicine (Elderly Medicine)
Drug regimes should have as few dosages per day as possible. It is also possible to use
fixed-dose combination tablets (for example co-tenidone) to reduce the total number of
tablets taken. Many medications can be given as liquids, which can be helpful to people with
swallowing difficulties.
What tools can I use?
The screening tool of older people's prescriptions (STOPP) and screening tool to alert to
right treatment (START) criteria are very useful tools that allow you to identify both
inappropriate prescriptions, but also identify drugs often denied older people where there is
evidence they work. See https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC4339726/
Further resources
Prescribing for Older People. Milton, J., Hill-Smith, I., Jackson S. BMJ 2008; 336:606-9
AEME Mini-gem video: The geriatrician’s scalpel
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=jXcRHxl9qWw
24 Geriatric Medicine (Elderly Medicine)
Pressure Ulcers (LO6)
Dr T Jackson
Pressure ulcers are thankfully on the decline. Talk to some of your older colleagues on the
geriatric medicine placement and they will tell you of commonly seeing grade 4 pressure
sores you could put your fist into. Pressure sores are preventable; however they still occur,
and are a key indicator of quality of care. Pressure ulcers will often present to hospital in the
context of immobility and lack of availability of appropriate preventative care. They should
always prompt an investigation into the cause and usually initiate incident reporting and
safeguarding concerns.
Pressure Ulcers may seem like a small concern in the wider context of an unwell older adult
but they are debilitating, painful, extend length of stay in hospital and can prove fatal owing
to septicaemia. Sometimes surgery is needed to assist with healing. It is estimated that
pressure sores affect 6-7% of the adult hospitalised population.
How can I tell who is at risk?
When a patient is admitted to a ward a pressure ulcer risk tool is used called the Waterlow
Risk Assessment. This covers the most important risk factors for pressure ulcers and the
following areas are assessed.
Malnutrition (common among older people, but can be seen as cachexia driven by
chronic disease such as cancer and respiratory disease)
Neurological deficit (e.g. diabetes, stroke, paraplegia etc.)
Continence (very important, and will usually not be offered by the patient so you have
to ask about it)
Skin appearance (e.g. atrophic due to steroids)
Smoking, peripheral vascular disease and anaemia
Medication (e.g. steroids, cytotoxics, anti-inflammatory drugs)
Weight
Mobility
A total score is achieved by adding all the sections together and the score that fits into the
range that identifies low, medium and high risk.
Using this information nurses can complete appropriate care plans (e.g. regular turning,
control of incontinence, improved hydration & nutrition, good hygiene etc.) and organise
preventative measures such as pressure relieving aids, e.g. special mattresses for beds and
cushions for chairs. Ongoing assessment of the risk should be carried out by weekly re-
assessment. These scores are documented in the care plans, usually held at the foot of the
patient’s bed.
Grading of pressure sores:
Grade 1 Skin discolouration with non-blanching erythema
Grade 2 Partial thickness skin loss with ulceration that does not involve the
subcutaneous tissue
25 Geriatric Medicine (Elderly Medicine)
Grade 3 Full thickness skin loss with damage and necrosis of subcutaneous tissue
Grade 4 Full thickness skin loss with necrosis extending down to underlying bone,
tendon or muscle
What can we do when a patient has a pressure sore?
Management is usually led by specialist nurses as part of a Tissue Viability Team. Pressure
relieving equipment and specialised dressings are the first line treatment. However, other
therapies such as negative pressure dressings (VAC dressings), maggot therapy and plastic
surgery may be needed.
Further Reading
ABC of Wound Healing: Pressure Ulcers JE Gray, S Enoch, KG Harding. BMJ 2006; 332;
472-75
Wound Assessment J E Gray, S Enoch, KG Harding .BMJ 2006: 332 285-88
26 Geriatric Medicine (Elderly Medicine)
CGA, Comprehensive Geriatric Assessment (LO7)
Dr L McCluskey
What is it?
Comprehensive Geriatric Assessment (CGA) is the gold standard of care for the
management of frail older adults. It involves a ‘multidimensional interdisciplinary diagnostic
process focused on determining a frail older person’s medical, psychological and functional
capability in order to develop a coordinated and integrated plan for treatment and long term
follow-up’. CGA happens in both acute and non-acute settings and is associated with
improved outcomes.
But what really is it?
CGA relies on a core team usually consisting of a clinician, nurse, and social worker and,
when appropriate, input from physical and occupational therapists, nutritionists, pharmacists,
psychiatrists, psychologists, dentists, audiologists, podiatrists, and opticians. It is a holistic
assessment of an individual made up of several, overlapping, domains. These are;
Physical symptoms including current and past illnesses, diseases, diagnoses and pain.
Mental health symptoms, including memory and mood and an assessment of cognition.
Functionality in activities of daily living (ADLs), both for personal care e.g. showering,
washing, dressing and mobility, and for life functions e.g. cooking, shopping and outings.
Social and financial support, including where someone lives, facilities, access to transport
and caring support e.g. informally from family and friends and formally via social services.
Goals of care and advance care planning which may include spirituality, resourcefulness and
an individuals’ “resilience” and anxieties for example fear of dementia or dying.
How long will it take?
A full CGA will take at least 1 hour plus additional time for care planning, documentation and
ongoing review. Not every older adult needs a full multidisciplinary CGA with geriatrician
involvement; it is primarily for those with increased frailty. However, the majority of older
adults will benefit from a holistic medical approach based its principles.
How will I remember all that?
The FRAIL mnemonic can be used as a basic framework to remember the above principles.
Falls/functional decline
Reactions (polypharmacy)
Altered mental status
Illnesses
Living situation
What are the components?
Falls: Almost 30% of ED admissions are due to falls among older adults. Factors that
contribute to falls and associated complications can be divided into the following categories:
personal (age, chronic diseases, gait disturbance); environmental (poor lighting, slippery
floor, unstable furniture); and medications (antihypertensives, hypoglycaemics, sedatives).
27 Geriatric Medicine (Elderly Medicine)
Functionality: Bissett et al (2013) indicated that more than 50% of older adults who receive
care in the emergency department are unable to execute basic ADLs. This state of
dependence impacts on both physical and psychological health.
Reactions (Polypharmacy): 44% of men and 57% of women older than 65yrs take ≥ 5
medications per week. Inappropriate and excessive prescribing in older people leads to a
decline in the ability to perform ADLs, a high prevalence of adverse drug effects, drug-drug
interactions and other geriatric syndromes such as delirium.
Altered mental state: Delirium affects up to 40% of older patients who present to the
emergency department and more in some surgical populations. Dementia affects 1 in 20
people over the age of 65 and 1 in 5 over the age of 80. Dementia is a risk factor for
delirium, additionally delirium increases an individuals’ risk of developing dementia.
Illnesses: Multi-morbidity is common and greatly increases the complexity of managing
disease in older patients. About one in four adults have at least two chronic conditions and
more than 50% of older adults have three or more chronic conditions.
Living situation: Institutionalised older adults have much worse clinical outcomes following
discharge from the emergency department than their independent counterparts. Collapse of
a social network or excessive social strain can have a big impact on an individuals’ function.
The CGA Framework and Model
CGA is not only about identifying these problems but addressing them. It is both
diagnostic and therapeutic. Remember it involves a holistic, multidimensional,
interdisciplinary assessment of an individual by a number of specialists within the
discipline of older people’s health.
Reading
Ellis G, Langhorne P. Comprehensive geriatric assessment for older hospital patients
Implementation Patient
Discussion
Team
Discussion
Revising
Plan
Data
Collection
28 Geriatric Medicine (Elderly Medicine)
Rehabilitation of older persons (LO8)
Dr D Swain
The principles of rehabilitation involve the restoration of the individual to his or her optimal
physical, mental and social capability. In a hospital setting this usually follows on from a
period of illness such a stroke, hip fracture or MI. In the elderly there is usually significant co-
morbidity as well (e.g. arthritis, poor vision, diabetes etc.)
Ideally, rehabilitation should commence as soon as possible following admission to hospital,
with the setting of short and longer-term goals. A full medical history and examination is
crucial, both to define the reason for admission to hospital and the underlying acute and
chronic medical problems causing the functional decline. In addition, information must be
collected in the following areas: 1) cognition 2) pre-morbid function (mobility, transfers and
activities of daily living) 3) accommodation 4) social and family support (Home-Care, MOW,
DN and Carers). During this process it is important to explore the expectations of the patient
and the rehabilitation team, as well as those of the family and carers. Often these
expectations are very different.
A problem list is created, so that all of the medical, functional and social problems can be
identified. Correction of apparently minor issues (such as ill-fitting shoes and bunions) can
have a major impact on functional improvement. It is not unusual for elderly hospitalised
patients to have multiple chronic medical, social and sometimes psychiatric problems.
Problems that can sometimes be overlooked and will impair rehabilitation include poor
nutrition, dehydration, faecal impaction, pressure sores, depression, early dementia and side
effects from drugs. The rehabilitation team need to be alert to the development of new
medical problems that can arise during rehabilitation, e.g. infections, heart failure, renal
failure, strokes, falls and fractures, thus the patient needs regular medical review.
Special problems relating to the rehabilitation of older people include:
Multiple pathology
Polypharmacy
Mental vulnerability (confusion, depression or anxiety)
Low expectations for recovery
Complex social problems
Rehabilitation is multidisciplinary in nature. Teamwork, reinforced by regular meetings to
plan treatment, review progress and set goals, is crucial.
The physiotherapist is concerned predominantly with posture and mobility. Zimmer frames,
or a stick and the physical help of 1-2 people may be needed initially.
Nurses ensure nutrition and hydration is maintained, provide skin, bladder and bowel care,
administer medicines and encourage mobility (as defined by the physiotherapist).
The speech and language therapist (SLT) in addition to their traditional role also assess the
safety of swallowing (often impaired in sick patients) and advises on optimum consistency of
food, and whether thickening of fluids is required to prevent aspiration pneumonia.
29 Geriatric Medicine (Elderly Medicine)
The dietician, in liaison with SLT as necessary, optimises nutritional intake assessment,
patient choice and route of nutrition (oral, naso-gastric or PEG).
The occupational therapist assesses activities of daily living (ADL) i.e. washing, dressing,
feeding, toileting, transferring and mobility. A Home Visit assesses the patient’s capabilities
in their own environment. Subsequently adaptation e.g. stair-rails or raised toilet adaptations
may be required. Pendant alarms may be needed to raise help in an emergency.
The doctor’s role is to ensure, as far as is possible, the medical stability of the patient and to
ensure that the team is provided with accurate diagnostic and prognostic information.
Patients who become independent or have minimal residual disability and/or live with an
able carer may be discharged directly home. Patients, who remain dependent after a period
of rehabilitation, the Social Worker undertakes a multidisciplinary assessment: discharge
home might require the support of Home-Care, MOW and DN (with Discharge Liaison Nurse
providing communication between hospital and DN).
Opportunities for continued rehabilitation outside of hospital include community therapy
services, Day Hospital and more recently Intermediate Care facilities (sometimes in a
nursing or residential setting, but with significant therapy input).
If discharge home is not safe / possible, Rest Home or Nursing Home placement may be
needed, according to physical dependency. Most patients return home.
Reading:
Rehabilitation of the Older Adult - Keith Andrews, Edward Arnold Publishers
30 Geriatric Medicine (Elderly Medicine)
Key topics not covered by the learning objective
There are a number of topics that are very relevant to geriatric medicine but are covered in
other specialties. You will see these problems frequently during your placement so it is worth
reviewing some of these. Specific topics follow this list
Urinary Incontinence
Constipation, faecal incontinence and functional bowel disease
Parkinson’s Disease and Parkinsonism
Visual impairment, especially macular degeneration and cataracts
Musculoskeletal disease, especially osteoarthritis
Ortho-geriatric management of hip fractures
Peripheral vascular disease and venous and arterial leg ulcers
Depression, anxiety disorders, and psychosis
In your anaesthetic block you may see geriatricians involved in peri-operative
management of older people
Specific medical problems in care homes, which you should see during your CBM
This is obviously not exhaustive, and you will see the whole of medicine and surgery if you look hard enough.
31 Geriatric Medicine (Elderly Medicine)
Other topics - Sensory Impairments in Old Age
Dr Nigel Page
Hearing loss
Prevalence
Universal decline with increasing age. About 2/3 of those over 75 years have impairment
which can make communication difficult.
Pathology
Conductive loss usually due to ear canals blocked with wax. Sensorineural loss due to
degenerative changes in the inner ear.
Audiometry
Testing individual frequencies shows increased loss at higher rather than lower frequencies,
hence consonant loss more marked than vowel loss making speech difficult to understand.
Consequences
Frustration, anxiety, depression and suspicion often leading to social isolation. Appearance
of apparent cognitive decline due to misunderstanding of conversation. General population
seem more willing to help blind people rather than those who are deaf.
Therapy
Remove wax from ear canal if blocked
Ask others to speak clearly and directly to the deaf person (optimum distance about 1
metre)
Hearing aids (several varieties – behind ear most common)
Telephone/television modifications (Tele-coil induction loop system)
Subtitles
Sign language
Flashing lights for doorbells, vibrating alarm clocks etc.
The rules for communicating with the deaf are 'don’t mumble, don’t shout, be seen’
Visual loss
Prevalence
5% of people over 85 years old registered blind (condition is under reported); many more
partially sighted. Mainly a problem associated with old age. 'Whoever has driven with a
frosty windscreen has experienced the anxiety of visual handicap'.
Pathology
Main causes are cataract, macular degeneration, glaucoma, diabetes and vascular disease.
32 Geriatric Medicine (Elderly Medicine)
Visual assessment
Acuity using Snellen chart. Functional ability – i.e. day to day tasks such as making drinks,
avoiding obstacles etc. Routine optician assessment each year or two and specialist
ophthalmological review if needed.
Therapy
Correction – good lighting, spectacles, cataract surgery, retina laser therapy
Adaptation – Braille, talking books/clocks, white sticks, guide dogs etc.
Further reading
Rehabilitation of the Older Adult. Keith Andrews - Edward Arnold Publishing
The Challenge of Geriatric Medicine. Bernard Isaacs
33 Geriatric Medicine (Elderly Medicine)
Other topics - The Law and Older People
Dr E Dunstan updated for 2017 by Dr Daisy Wilson
Generally speaking, in law, older people are not regarded as different from any other adults,
apart from areas such as old age pensions, other benefits and tax.
Capacity
The prevalence of cognitive impairment frequently raises issues of capacity in the handling
of affairs, consent to treatment and planning of future care.
Capacity:
is specific to a given decision (e.g. an individual may be able to decide what to eat
but not where they should live)
is assumed to be present unless it is proved otherwise
an unwise decisions does not necessarily mean a person lacks capacity
an individual’s capacity may fluctuate. Every effort should be made to facilitate an
individual to make their own decisions (e.g. assess capacity at several time points)
To have capacity a person must
1. Understand the relevant facts,
2. Retain the relevant information,
3. Consider the information to reach a decision, and
4. Communicate that decision
Under the Mental Capacity Act 2005:
all acts to incapable persons must be in their best interests, (which are wider than
medical interests – and should take into account the person’s past and present
views)
neglect is a crime
the least restrictive option should be chosen
people can execute a Lasting Power of Attorney
Power of Attorney
There are 2 types of Lasting Power of Attorney
Health and welfare
Financial and property
The same person can hold both roles and more than one person can be appointed to each
role. The appointment of LPA should be conducted whilst an individual has the capacity to
do so. A LPA makes decisions on behalf of the individual if they no longer have the capacity
to do so or no longer want to make those decisions. The LPA should act in the best interests
of an individual and take into account previous wishes and opinions expressed.
34 Geriatric Medicine (Elderly Medicine)
Independent Mental Capacity Advocate (IMCA)
An IMCA is appointed for all people who (1) lack capacity for specific decisions and (2) also
lack appropriate family or friends.
An IMCA must be appointed if the above conditions are met and a decision is required
regarding:
Any serious medical treatments
A move to a hospital that would be for more than 28 days
A move to a care home that would be for more than 8 weeks
A deprivation of liberty
An IMCA’s role is to discover a person’s current or previously held views on the specific
decision and act as their advocate, always acting in their best interests.
Deprivation of Liberty Safeguards (DOLS)
DOLS is a subsidiary of the Mental Capacity Act of 2005. Its aim is to ensure that any care
which restricts a person’s liberty is both appropriate and in their best interests. It only applies
to people within a hospital or care home setting. A deprivation of liberty only occurs when a
person lacks capacity to consent for the procedure which will then deprive them of their
liberty. The safeguards ensure that anyone being deprived of their liberty has appropriate
representation (e.g. family or IMCA), that the deprivation of liberty can be challenged through
the Court of Protection and is regularly reassessed. A common example of a deprivation of
liberty is putting mittens on a person with an NG tube in situ to prevent them from pulling it
out.
End of life decisions
The law is the same as at any age, but questions are inevitably more frequent. Treatment
(which includes artificial nutrition and hydration) may be withdrawn or withheld if:
Medically futile or not indicated
Refused by a competent patient
Not in an incompetent patient’s best interests after reference to the MCA
DNACPR
There is significant misunderstanding surrounding DNACPR orders (both amongst clinical
practitioners, and patients and their relatives) and huge variations in practice.
DNACPR should be considered in all patients who may be at risk of cardio or respiratory
arrest (the majority of unwell older inpatients). DNACPR does not mean ‘not for active
treatment’ or ‘not for ITU’. In best practice all these should be considered together and
documented in the notes.
If DNACPR is considered to be in all probability unsuccessful (or futile) this should be
discussed with the patient or if they lack capacity their relative or power of attorney. If the
patient or relative disagree with this decision a 2nd opinion should be offered.
If DNACPR may be successful the risks and benefits of CPR should be discussed with the
patient or if they lack capacity their relatives or power of attorney. The patient (or relatives in
lack of capacity) should be involved in the decision about DNACPR.
It is no longer acceptable to not discuss DNACPR with patients or relatives because of a
wish to not cause distress or the relatives are unavailable. (See Tracey case.)
35 Geriatric Medicine (Elderly Medicine)
A decision to not offer a futile treatment such as CPR however is a medical decision. Many
misunderstandings arise when people think they are being asked to make a decision,
especially in cases with a patient who lacks capacity to refuse treatment when relatives are
consulted.
Advanced Directives
Doctors must observe the wishes expressed in a valid advance directive (or 'living will'). The
advanced directive must clearly relate to the condition or procedure in question, be legal and
medically practical. The patient must be competent at the time of the directive and the
directive must not be made under duress. Advance declarations may also be positive,
requiring treatment, rather than just refusals
Elder Abuse
Physical, psychological, sexual or financial abuse of an older person is as much a crime as it
would be at any age. The difficulties are much more in recognition and obtaining evidence
(or even getting the victim to complain). Suspected instances of elder abuse should be
reported to the Social Services department.
Reading:
Resuscitation Council (UK) guidelines on DNACPR at https://www.resus.org.uk/dnacpr/
(Essential reading for anyone who will be considering these decisions, discussing this with
patients and relatives or participating in the crash team.)
Cautionary tales about DNACPR – BMJ 2016; 352 doi: https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.i26
Age UK factsheets on Power of Attorney and Advanced Directives
http://www.ageuk.org.uk/money-matters/legal-issues/powers-of-attorney/
http://www.ageuk.org.uk/money-matters/legal-issues/living-wills/about/
Alzheimer Society factsheet on DOLS and Mental Capacity Act
https://www.alzheimers.org.uk/info/20032/legal_and_financial/129/deprivation_of_liberty_saf
eguards_dols
https://www.alzheimers.org.uk/info/20032/legal_and_financial/127/mental_capacity_act
36 Geriatric Medicine (Elderly Medicine)
Other topics - Assessment of Activities of Daily Living
Ms. S McArthur
Barthel Self-Care Index
In practice it will often be necessary for the occupational therapist to use more than one
outcome measure in order to get a full picture of the patient’s/client's ability to function
effectively in their home or other place of residence. There is now a wide range of outcome
measures and assessments available to occupational therapists and these are designed to
measure changes in the client’s physical, psychological and social aspects of well-being or
quality of life.
The Barthel index is one such outcome measure of functional independence in activities of
daily living. It was developed in 1965. It is a narrow checklist that was designed for use in
institutional settings with elderly patients suffering from neurological and musculoskeletal
disorders. It was designed to measure function before and after treatment and is often used
to indicate rehabilitation or nursing needs. There have been a number of versions
developed, primarily Mahoney and Barthel's 10 item 1965 version, Granger’s 15 item 1976
version and Shah’s 1989 version.
The Barthel Index assesses and measures an individual’s ability to carry out activities of
daily living. It is based on a 3 point scale. If a patient scores below 40 he/she has a poor
prognosis for discharge home. The daily activities assessed include:
Feeding
Grooming
Toileting
Bathing
Incontinence
Walking/wheelchair locomotion
Stair mobility
The energetic debate over the Barthel index in the British Journal of Occupational Therapy
during 1992-1993 (Murdock 1992 a, b, Shah and Cooper 1993, Eakin 1993) indicates the
assessment’s pitfalls. The debate questions the reliability and validity of the tool. It was
designed for use with a limited range of conditions therefore one must question its relevance
in clinical practice. Due to all of these issues and concerns this tool for assessing activities of
daily living (ADL) is rarely used alone within the occupational therapy profession as an
outcome measure. It is now used more as a generic assessment to indicate rehabilitation or
nursing needs. Many therapists will also document and communicate the actual functional
capabilities of a given patient or client (e.g. dressing, cooking, bathing etc.), relating these
assessments to the specific needs of the individual in their home or preferred environment.
37 Geriatric Medicine (Elderly Medicine)
References
Mahoney FI, Barthel DW (1965). Functional evaluation: The Barthel Index
Maryland State Medical Journal, 14, 61-5.(outlines full 1965 version)
Murdock (1992a). A critical evaluation of the Barthel index. Part 1
British Journal of Occupational Therapy 55 (3), 109-111
Murdock (1992b). A critical evaluation of the Barthel index. Part 2
British Journal of Occupational Therapy 55 (4), 153-156
Shah S and Cooper B (1993). Commentary on “a critical evaluation of the Barthel index”
British Journal of Occupational Therapy 56 (2), 70-72
Eakin P (1993). The Barthel index: confidence limits. British Journal of Occupational Therapy
56 (5), 184-185
38 Geriatric Medicine (Elderly Medicine)
Other topics - Assessment for care in the community
Ms G Richards
The Discharge Process – transfer of care
Discharge planning for older people should commence on admission, or as soon as possible
after the acute medical phase of illness subsides. Multidisciplinary assessment will take into
account the pre-morbid state of patient and the circumstances of admission. The views and
needs of the patient as well as their relatives and carers should be taken into consideration.
It is also important to involve those professional carers, nurses and therapists who might
previously have been involved prior to the patient's admission to hospital. Discharge
planning for older persons in hospital or Intermediate Care units is usually co-ordinated at a
weekly multidisciplinary team meeting involving some or all of the following professionals:
Dietician
Nurse
Occupational therapist
Physiotherapist
Physician in elderly medicine and/or Senior House Officer
Social worker/Discharge liaison nurse
Speech and language therapist
Pharmacist
Advice from other professionals is often sought as necessary, including Home Care
managers, General Practitioners, Old Age Psychiatrists, District Nurses, Housing Agencies
and of course relatives and informal carers. The emphasis is on achieving a timely yet safe
discharge, with an effective transfer of care and sometimes rehabilitation to the primary care
team.
Services provided by the Local Authority
Access to Local Authority funded services, such as Home Care, Day Care, Respite Care,
Residential and Nursing Home placements are co-ordinated via Social Workers based either
in the hospital or community. Legislation requires that social workers undertake a full
multidisciplinary “needs led” assessment. This assessment is audited and must demonstrate
user/ carer involvement (DOH. 1997 Better Services for Vulnerable People). These services
will attract a cost. All services provided to clients by the local authority are subject to ‘means
testing’, i.e. an assessment of the client's financial status and thus ability to pay. The Local
Authority has fixed assessment criteria for the provision of all services.
Services provided by Health Authority and/or Primary Care Trusts
Access to Local Authority funded services, such as Home Care, Day Care, Respite Care,
Residential and Nursing Home placements are co-ordinated via Social Workers based either
in the hospital or community. Legislation requires that social workers undertake a full
multidisciplinary “needs led” assessment. This assessment is audited and must demonstrate
user/carer involvement (DOH.1997 Better Services for Vulnerable People). These services
will attract a cost. All services provided to clients by the local authority are subject to ‘means
39 Geriatric Medicine (Elderly Medicine)
testing’, i.e. an assessment of the client's financial status and thus ability to pay. The Local
Authority has fixed assessment criteria for the provision of all services.
Intermediate Care Services
These are a range of services near to or in the patient's home whose aim is to provide an
alternative to hospital admission or promote early discharge with an emphasis on timely,
therapeutic intervention. There is a strong emphasis on rehabilitation and avoiding
admission to long term residential or nursing home care. Some units are nurse led and
others therapy led. Some services are mobile and assess and treat patients in a range of
settings including A&E, their own home, etc. Medical support is usually available from
general practitioners with specialist support from consultants in elderly medicine. Services
are still evolving following the stimulus provided by the National Service Framework for Older
People.
Examples of Services from the Local
Authority (liable to charge)
Examples of services provided by
Health Authority (free of charge)
Home care - focusing on personal Community nursing care requirements
Residential / nursing home care
(permanent or respite)
Specialist nursing home care (respite &
permanent)
Meal provision Palliative care
Day Centre activities Rehabilitation services
Occupational Therapy – equipment &
adaptations
Specialist transport
Specialist equipment
Specialist Housing (warden controlled,
extra sheltered care etc.)
Financial support - Independent living fund:
Direct payments
Carer's grant
Telephones (Chronically Sick and Disabled
Persons Act)
Alarms
Transport
(This list is not exhaustive)
Reading
Alternatives to Hospital Care. Ed. GP Mulley. Age and Ageing, 2001;30 (supplement 3) ISSN
0002-0729