16
Geothermal Energy Australian GEOTHERMAL INDUSTRY RESEARCH REPORT June 2009

Geothermal Energy Australian June 2009 · Welcome to the June 2009 edition of Geothermal Energy - Australian Research Report. Activated Logic has been ... uranium. While the debate

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Geothermal Energy Australian June 2009 · Welcome to the June 2009 edition of Geothermal Energy - Australian Research Report. Activated Logic has been ... uranium. While the debate

Geothermal Energy Australian GEOTHERMAL INDUSTRY RESEARCH REPORTJune 2009

Page 2: Geothermal Energy Australian June 2009 · Welcome to the June 2009 edition of Geothermal Energy - Australian Research Report. Activated Logic has been ... uranium. While the debate

02 I ACTIVATED LOGIC I GEOTHERMAL INDUSTRY RESEARCH REPORT

Welcome to the June 2009 edition of Geothermal Energy - Australian Research Report. Activated Logic has been providing previous editions of this report and a monthly update on the Australian Geothermal IndexTM to private-equity interests, corporate clients and superannuation funds since July 2008.

To coincide with AJM’s 4th Annual Hot Rock Energy Conference, Activated Logic is circulating the June edition of Geothermal Energy to all industry participants in an effort to improve the profile and standard of communication within the Australian Geothermal industry.

During the last decade we have seen numerous waves of investment capital flow into emerging technology centred sectors, starting with IT&C companies at the turn of the millenium, to industrial and medical applications of nanotechnology and biotechnology by 2005. We then witnessed a rapid growth of interest in sustainable energy production at a time of raging commodity price escalation which effectively underpinned the emergence of a plethora of companies seeking seemlessly endless reserves of uranium.

While the debate regarding the cyclical nature of markets and the global economic environment is occupying many boardrooms at present, at Activated Logic we believe there are many lessons to be learned from the emerging industries that have not yet achieved commercial success.

The development and commercialisation of Australian geothermal energy resources and technologies offers Australian geothermal players incredible potential to

create globally significant companies whilst contributing to reduced greenhouse emissions. Although pioneers in the industry like Petratherm and Geodynamics have been making significant progress for years - due to the favourable regulatory environment and increasingly ambitious sustainability targets, Activated Logic believes the next decade will be the decade of geothermal.

At Activated Logic we have recently realigned our corporate interests and investments and are currently recruiting to increase our focus on the geothermal sector. We believe:

”our extensive experience in the Biosustainable, Energy, Mining, Research and Technology sectors gives us an unrivalled advantage in achieving results in the emerging Australian geothermal industry”

Geothermal energy provides Australia with the opportunity to reduce our environmental impacts, for new industries to develop and for investors to achieve impressive returns on funds invested (ROI) . If your organisation has an interest in geothermal energy and you have not previously engaged Activated Logic, you need to speak to us.

Regards,

29 May 2009Mr. Bahay Ozcakmak DFS(Fin), B.HortSci, M.AgrBus, AVCAL, MAICD

Managing DirectorEmail: [email protected]

Message from the MD

Page 3: Geothermal Energy Australian June 2009 · Welcome to the June 2009 edition of Geothermal Energy - Australian Research Report. Activated Logic has been ... uranium. While the debate

GEOTHERMAL INDUSTRY RESEARCH REPORT I ACTIVATED LOGIC I 03

© Copyright 2009. Activated Logic Pty Limited. All rights reserved.All contents of this publication including copywriting, original images, illustrations and additional artwork are protected by Australian & International Copyright Laws, specifically by numerous provisions of the Australian COPYRIGHT ACT of 1968 and subsequent amendments and extensions as applicable. The Activated Logic Logo is an Australian Registered Trade Mark, (No. 1281315 - the Atomic Orbit Around Ltrs Device), and use of a substantially identical or deceptively similar trade mark is strictly prohibited by Australian Copyright and Trademark Laws.

Contents

Introduction 04

Industry Performance 05

Industry Analysis - Australian Geothermal IndexTM 06

Industry & Market Developments 07

Company Updates 08

Significance of Energy Reserves 09

South Australian Geothermal 10

Featured Project - Southern Gold Torrens Geothermal Project 11

Activated Logic Services - Strategy & Investments 12

Activated Logic Services - Communications 13

Additional Resources 14

References 14

Disclaimer & Disclosure Notice 15

Event Name: Review of the Australian Geothermal Index™ and update on the performance of the Australian Geothermal Industry.Date: 5th June 2009Time: 9:00am ESTPresenter: Mr. Bahay OzcakmakWeblink: http://www.brr.com.au/event/58000

Media Interview

Page 4: Geothermal Energy Australian June 2009 · Welcome to the June 2009 edition of Geothermal Energy - Australian Research Report. Activated Logic has been ... uranium. While the debate

04 I ACTIVATED LOGIC I GEOTHERMAL INDUSTRY RESEARCH REPORT

Introduction

The promise of large-scale, affordable, emission free baseload power has been an aspirational goal shared by scientists, industry, governments and the broader community for many years.

Adoption of renewable technologies such as solar or wind power is slowly gathering momentum, however the relatively expensive cost of these energies, combined with their intermittent power generation profile, has hindered the wider adoption of these technologies.

Recent estimates by Geoscience Australia indicate that approximately 1.9 x 1025 Joules of energy is contained in the upper 5km of Australia’s crust. By circulating water through strategically located deep production wells, geothermal energy has the potential to transform the Australian economy into a powerhouse, as energy availibility is often a precursor to sustainable economic growth (Figure 1).

Australia’s economically demonstrated energy resources, January 2007

Energy Source Unit Energy Reserves

Reserves to Production

(yrs)PetroleumOil GL 173 8Condensate GL 258 36LPG GL 214 45GasConventional PJ 98,264 57CS Methane PJ 12,833 101CoalBlack Coal Gt 39 > 100Brown Coal Gt 37 > 500NuclearUranium kt 1,163 > 138

Geothermal* Comments

Paralana JV (PTR) PJ 230,000 + or - 40,000PJ

Limestone Coast (PAX) PJ 132,000 Penola (various)

Limestone Coast (PAX) PJ 53,000 Rivoli (inferred)

Limestone Coast (PAX) PJ 130,000 Tantanoola (Inferred)

Cooper Basin (GDY) PJ 239,000 Energy in place

Cooper Basin (GDY) PJ 60,000 Estimated recoverable

The presence of massive thermal energy reserves in Australia is undeniable. The comparison between Australia’s conventional energy reserves and three separate geothermal projects in Table 1, indicate that each of these projects has energy potential that is significant on a national scale.

In recent months numerous companies, specifically Geodynamics have made major inroads into demonstrating proof-of-concept for engineered geothermal systems (EGS). A number of major technological challenges confront the industry, specifically the ability to be able to artificially create fractures in buried hot granites at depth.

Table 1

* Geothermal Resource estimates are in various categories of the 2008 Reporting Code. Data obtained from various ASX releases. Refer to References.Source: Energy in Australia 2009. ABARE Australia.

Source: ABARE Australian commodity statistics and ABARE Australian energy statistics

Annual growth in energy consumption in Australia

Primary energy consumption in Australia by fuel

Fuel inputs into Australian electricity generation 2006-07

Figure 3

21 Energy in Australia 2009

10 Fuel inputs into Australian electricity generation

2003-04 2004-05 2005-06 2006-07 PJ PJ PJ PJ

Thermal Black Coal 1 296 1 297 1 357 1 379Brown coal 674 683 701 671Oil 22 25 26.4 25Gas 264 267 263 284Total thermal 2 256 2 272 2 348 2 360

Renewables Hydro 58 56 58 52Wind a 0 3 6 23Biomass 5 5 5 5Biogas 8 7 7 7Total renewables 71 71 76 87

a Includes solar photovoltaic electricity generation. Source: ABARE, Australian energy statistics.

Electricity

The majority of Australia’s electricity is produced using coal, accounting for 84 per cent of all fuels consumed by generators (in energy content terms) in 2006-07. This is because coal is a relatively low cost energy source in Australia. It also the abundance of coal reserves along the eastern seaboard, where the majority of electricity is generated and consumed.

Fuel inputs into Australian electricity generation, 2006-07 a

brown coal 27.4%

black coal 56.4%

hydro 2%

gas 11.6%wind and solar PV 0.9%

oil 1%other renewables 0.5%

Source: ABARE, Australian energy statistics.

a This chart should not be compared with the chart of electricity generation by fuel in Energy in Australia 2008because that chart represented electricity generation output, rather than fuel inputs into electricity generatioHydroelectricity accounts for a larger proportion of electricity generation output than of fuel inputs into electricity generation.

Figure 2

21 Energy in Australia 2009

10 Fuel inputs into Australian electricity generation

2003-04 2004-05 2005-06 2006-07 PJ PJ PJ PJ

Thermal Black Coal 1 296 1 297 1 357 1 379Brown coal 674 683 701 671Oil 22 25 26.4 25Gas 264 267 263 284Total thermal 2 256 2 272 2 348 2 360

Renewables Hydro 58 56 58 52Wind a 0 3 6 23Biomass 5 5 5 5Biogas 8 7 7 7Total renewables 71 71 76 87

a Includes solar photovoltaic electricity generation. Source: ABARE, Australian energy statistics.

Electricity

The majority of Australia’s electricity is produced using coal, accounting for 84 per cent of all fuels consumed by generators (in energy content terms) in 2006-07. This is because coal is a relatively low cost energy source in Australia. It also the abundance of coal reserves along the eastern seaboard, where the majority of electricity is generated and consumed.

Fuel inputs into Australian electricity generation, 2006-07 a

brown coal 27.4%

black coal 56.4%

hydro 2%

gas 11.6%wind and solar PV 0.9%

oil 1%other renewables 0.5%

Source: ABARE, Australian energy statistics.

a This chart should not be compared with the chart of electricity generation by fuel in Energy in Australia 2008because that chart represented electricity generation output, rather than fuel inputs into electricity generatioHydroelectricity accounts for a larger proportion of electricity generation output than of fuel inputs into electricity generation.

Figure 1

Energy in Australia 2009 12

and coal. Black and brown coal accounted for the greatest share of the fuel mix, at around 40 per cent, followed by petroleum products (34 per cent), natural gas (20 per cent) and renewable energy sources (5 per cent). The share of natural gas in Australian energy consumption has increased in the past 30 years and this trend is likely to continue in the longer term.

Energy consumption by industry

Australia’s primary energy consumption is estimated to have risen by 2.3 per cent in 2006-07 to 5770 petajoules. The diagram of Australia’s energy (page 17) is a ation of the energy supply and disposal table (table 6). It shows the movement of primary fuels from the point at which they become available, through Australia’s energy conversion sectors, until the

4 Gross energy consumption by state, by fuel, 2006-07

black brown petroleum natural state coal coal renewables a products gas share b

PJ PJ PJ PJ PJ %

New South Wales 807 62 46 567 139 28Victoria 0 675 27 447 261 24Queensland 648 0 116 491 109 23Western Australia 125 0 14 279 474 15South Australia 70 0 9 112 115 5Tasmania 15 0 44 41 13 2Northern Territory 0 0 0 64 45 2Total 1 664 737 285 2 001 1 157 Share of total 28% 13% 5% 34% 20% a State breakdown does not include wind, solar PV or biogas which are included in the total. b Excluding wind, solar PV and biogas.Source: ABARE, Australian energy statistics.

Annual growth in energy consumption in Australia

2006-07

2002-03

1990-91

1994-95

1998-99

%

2

1

–1

3

4

5

6Australian real GDP

total energy consumption

Sources: ABARE, Australia’s energy statistics; Energy statistics; ABS, Australian National Accounts: State Accounts, cat. no. 5220.

Energy consumption

Page 5: Geothermal Energy Australian June 2009 · Welcome to the June 2009 edition of Geothermal Energy - Australian Research Report. Activated Logic has been ... uranium. While the debate

GEOTHERMAL INDUSTRY RESEARCH REPORT I ACTIVATED LOGIC I 05

Industry Performance

Consistent with deterioration in capital markets around the globe, the valuations of the majority of asset classes including Australian equities have fallen significantly. Since the 1st of July 2008, the all-ordinaries index which represents 95% of the value in the Australian equities market is currently down by approximately 25% at the date of this report, after being down by almost 40% in March 2009 (Figure 8).

At the smaller end of the Australian market, the small-ordinaries has been more volatile with a greater than 50% fall since the 1st of July 2008, although the index has recovered in recent months (Figure 7). The energy index has been just as volatile (Figure 6), primarilly due to major swings in the oil price including a fall from above US$147 per barrel on the 11th of July 2008 to US$32.40 during December 2008 - an unprecedented fall of US$115 per barrel in less than 6months!

Against this backdrop, the performance of Australian listed geothermal exploration and development companies have been similarly volatile (Figure 5 & 9) as highlighted by the Australian Geothermal IndexTM (AGI). At the date of this report approximately 50 different companies held direct equity interests in Australian geothermal exploration licences, however there are only 10 companies that are solely geothermal focused, listed on the Australian Securities Exchange (Table 2).

Significantly, due to the advanced nature of the projects operated by Geodynamics, specifically the Innamincka project, almost three-quarters of the industry valuation can be attributed to Geodynamics alone.

Combined Market Capitalisation of Australian Securities Exchange listed Geothermal Companies

Given the prevailing investment conditions, the reduced apetite for risk, increased cost of capital and the negative economic outlook, geothermal companies will not be immune to further deterioration in the business environment. However, working in favour of the geothermal industry is the federal government’s determination to achieve energy

security and reduce carbon emissions. In addition to co-funding through the Geothermal Drilling Fund and various other technology development oriented grants, significant potential exists for public-private partnerships to develop industry and electricity transmission infrstructure, in proximity to emerging geothermal projects.

Figure 5

Figure 6

Figure 7

Figure 8

Figure 4

$250

$300

$350

$400

$450

$500

$550

$600

$650

$700

21-Jun-08 19-Sep-08 18-Dec-08 18-Mar-09

Mill

ions

Page 6: Geothermal Energy Australian June 2009 · Welcome to the June 2009 edition of Geothermal Energy - Australian Research Report. Activated Logic has been ... uranium. While the debate

06 I ACTIVATED LOGIC I GEOTHERMAL INDUSTRY RESEARCH REPORT

Australian Geothermal IndexTM

The Australian Geothermal IndexTM (AGI) is the benchmark composite index of the 10 solely geothermal focused companies listed on the Australian Securities Exchange (ASX). The AGI was based at 100 using Laspeyre’s PI methodology (as was the XAO) on the 1st of July 2008 to provide an indication of the relative performance of the AGI against the XAO.

Code Company Index Weighting - 1 July 08 Index Weighting - 24 May 09 ChangeEDE Eden Energy Ltd 7.66% 3.13% -4.53%GDY Geodynamics Ltd 70.14% 74.15% 4.01%GHT Geothermal Resources 3.85% 3.44% -0.41%GER Greenearth Energy Ltd 0.84% 2.19% 1.35%GRK Green Rock Energy 2.91% 2.65% -0.27%KEN Kuth Energy Ltd 0.90% 0.87% -0.03%HRL Hot Rock Ltd 0.60% 0.83% 0.24%PAX Panax Geothermal Ltd 3.13% 4.25% 1.12%PTR Petratherm Ltd 6.67% 5.59% -1.08%TEY Torrens Energy 3.30% 2.89% -0.41%

^ The Australian Geothermal Index is owned and managed by Activated Logic Pty Limited. More information is available at www.geothermalindex.org/agi.html

Industry Analysis

The relatively small size of the Australian geothermal industry combined with less than 20% of licence holders being publicly listed companies, is responsible for the limited availability of public domain data for many projects. Most projects are still at the early stages of development, and limited corporate activity in the sector has made determining the economic prospectivity of projects and valuations of these specific projects very difficult.

Traditional valuation methodologies used across a range of industries, including standard valuation metrics based on net present value (NPV) or internal rate of return (IRR) approaches, are not applicable to the geothermal industry at the current stage of development. Initial calculations based on enterprise value to energy reserves ratios (EV/Reserve) have been abandoned due to the uncertainty in the magnitude and the timing of commercialising reserves.

AGI Composite Index - ASX listed Constituents

Table 2AGI Composite Index - Performance compared to All Ords

Figure 9

a b

c

de

f gh

i

j k

l

a b

cd e

fg

h

i

j

Page 7: Geothermal Energy Australian June 2009 · Welcome to the June 2009 edition of Geothermal Energy - Australian Research Report. Activated Logic has been ... uranium. While the debate

GEOTHERMAL INDUSTRY RESEARCH REPORT I ACTIVATED LOGIC I 07

Key Events - Geothermal Industry

Date Market Sensitive Event

a 4th Sep 08 Tata Power (India) subscribes for 11.4% equity in GDY’s issued share capital for approximately $44m

b 24th Sep 08 EDE announce termination of LOI with Zoom Developers (Private) Limited, EDE securities suspended on ASX

c 21st Oct 08 GDY announce Geothermal resource for Cooper Basin project and a inferred resource for the Hunter Valley

d 15th Dec 08 HRL withdraws from the purchase of German geothermal company Bernried Erdwärme AG

e 4th Feb 09 TRUenergy received FIRB approval to invest $57m into PTR’s Paralana Geothermal project in South Australia

f 23rd Feb 09 PAX announce Australia’s first ‘Measured Geothermal Resource’ at its South Australian Penola project

g 25th Feb 09 GDY completes flow testing through Habanero 1 and 3 successfully, but reports difficulties with Savina 1

h 24th Mar 09 PAX release pre-feasibility study for the Penolo project indicating that power could be generated for $63 MWh (net)

i 31st Mar 09 GDY achieves proof of concept for Habanero wells at Cooper Basin project

j 20th Apr 09 Panax & Petratherm each awarded $7m in first round of GDF to advance projects

k 27th Apr 09 GDY announce major incident at the Habanero 3 well on behalf of the Innamincka Joint Venture

l 12th May 09 GDY announce that commissioning of 1MW Pilot Plant possibly delayed by 6 - 9 months

Key Events - Macro-economic & Political

Date Market Sensistive Event

a 3rd July 08 Federal Government confirmed its commitment to supply 20% of Australia’s electricity from renewable sources by 2020

b 4th Jul 08 Prof. Ross Garnaut released draft Climate Change Review report

c 20th Aug 08 Federal Government releases draft GIDF at the AGEC and announces $50m Geothermal Drilling Fund

d 21st Aug 08 World’s first Geothermal Reporting Code released at the AGEC

e 28th Aug 08 Western Australian Government offers geothermal permits in the Perth Basin to successful bidders

f 7th Sep 08 US Government takes over Freddie Mac & Fannie May

g 15th Sep 08 Lehman Brothers files for Bankruptcy

h 4th Nov 08 Barack Obama elected 44th President of the United States with pro-renewable energy policies

i 15th Dec 08 Federal Government released ETS White Paper aiming for a 5 - 15% reduction in CO2 emissions by 2020

j 12th May 09 Renewable Energy industry is boosted by $4.5b Clean Energy Initiative in 2009 Federal Budget

Industry & Market Developments

The volatility in the performance of the Australian listed

geothermal exploration and development companies

as demonstrated by the Australian Geothermal IndexTM

(Figure 9) is due to the combined impact of factors internal

to the industry such as the performance of individual

geothermal companies and factors external to the sector.

Major external factors include the relative performance

of global equity markets, specifically the Australian

equities market and also the political environment and

how supportive it is towards the wide-scale adoption of renewable energy technologies, specifically geothermal.

In an effort to explain the major movements in the AGI, the 12 most important Geothermal Industry specific announcements by listed companies (summarised in Table 3) and the 10 most important Macro-Economic and Political developments (summarised in Table 4) have been superimposed on to the AGI Composite Index - Performance compared to All Ords chart (Figure 9).

Table 3

Table 4

a

a

Page 8: Geothermal Energy Australian June 2009 · Welcome to the June 2009 edition of Geothermal Energy - Australian Research Report. Activated Logic has been ... uranium. While the debate

08 I ACTIVATED LOGIC I GEOTHERMAL INDUSTRY RESEARCH REPORT

Share price performance

Engagement performance

Company Updates

As outlined in Table 1, a number of Australian geothermal exploration companies have already identified significant thermal energy resources in place - of which a proportion is expected to be economically viable to recover in the medium term.

Specifically, Geodynamics, Petratherm and Panax Geothermal have delineated very significant thermal resources. For this reason these 3 companies have been chosen to be reviewed in this section of this report.

An increasing proportion of Australian geothermal companies are partnering into international projects in an effort to leverage their geothermal experience and technologies and potentially participate in more advanced projects.

Due to the inherent technical, geological and commercial risks associated with geothermal exploration and commercialisation, Activated Logic believes a number of key ingredients are necessary to maximise chances of commercial success:

• strong balance sheet or financial backing

• technically able JV-partner

• capable board experienced in resource or energy commercialisation

• independently documented geothermal resource

For these reasons, Activated Logic believes the larger Australian geothermal companies with more advanced projects present a more compelling case for investment.

Significance of Reserves

Geoscience Australia estimates indicate that even if 1% of Australia’s geothermal resources were capable of being exploited, this would represent Australia’s total energy needs for thousands of years.

Figure 10 highlights that Australia’s geothermal energy resources potentially far exceed all other forms of Australian energy reserves combined.

Figure 10

Geodynamics Ltd

Key Points

South Australian Projects

• proof-of-concept in water circulation through a hot dry reservoir achieved for Habanero wells within the Innamincka project in the Cooper Basin

• closed loop test demonstrated the successful circulation of 50,000 tonnes of brine at the Innamincka project

• drilling of Savina 1 encountered positive results including a saturated and fractured granite body almost 19km away from the Habanero wells

• construction of powerlines to Innamincka township and 1MW pilot plant completed, although significant delays expected due to recent Habanero 3 well control incident

• 5 deep wells drilled at Innamincka project

• examining the feasibility of constructing a commercial data-centre as part of Commercial Demonstration Plant

New South Wales Project

• exploring geothermal potential of Hunter Valley with staged funding of $10m from the NSW Government

• planning the drilling of a 2000m intermediate well in late 2009

Queensland Projects

• geothermal exploration leases recently taken up with heat flow drilling to expected to commence shortly

Additional Points

• strong balance sheet with $122m cash in hand at the 31st of March 2009

• strong backing from industry majors including Origin (ASX: ORG) and Indian major, TATA Power

• Collaborative agreement with CSIRO and universities

Figure 11

84TIER 1www.iandpi.com

Page 9: Geothermal Energy Australian June 2009 · Welcome to the June 2009 edition of Geothermal Energy - Australian Research Report. Activated Logic has been ... uranium. While the debate

GEOTHERMAL INDUSTRY RESEARCH REPORT I ACTIVATED LOGIC I 09

Petratherm

Key Points

• about to spud Paralana 2, a deep injection well

• strong subsurface experience from partner (ASX: BPT)

• financial backing and offtake alliance with Tru Energy

• advanced project in Spain and footprint in China

• innovative ‘Heat Exchanger Within Insulator’ technology

Share price performance

Engagement performance

77TIER 2www.iandpi.com

Figure 12

Panax Geothermal Ltd

Share price performance

Engagement performance

Key Points

• conventional geothermal reservoir at Penola project

• thermal resource of 332,000PJ at Penola project

• measured geothermal resource of 11,000PJ

• about to spud Salamander 1, a 4000m deep well

• PFS determined generation as low as AUD$63 per MWh

Figure 13

75TIER 2www.iandpi.com

8477

7569

6463

60

5048

39

0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 90

Geodynamics Ltd

Petratherm

Panax Geothermal Ltd

Torrens Energy

Geothermal Resources

Green Rock Energy

Greenearth Energy Ltd

Hot Rock Ltd

Kuth Energy Ltd

Eden Energy Ltd

Figure 14

Impress & Progress IndexTM

More information on I&PITM available on pg 13 or, www.iandpi.com

Page 10: Geothermal Energy Australian June 2009 · Welcome to the June 2009 edition of Geothermal Energy - Australian Research Report. Activated Logic has been ... uranium. While the debate

10 I ACTIVATED LOGIC I GEOTHERMAL INDUSTRY RESEARCH REPORT

The combination of a supportive State & Federal Government, industry critical-mass, significant projected growth in energy demand and some of the hottest granites in the world, combine to make South Australia one of the most attractive destinations for geothermal companies in the world.

Geological Setting

South Australia’s geological composition is significant from a global perspective, and of major relevance is the presence of radiogenic granites at basement which are the primary source of thermal heat. The radiogenic granites, particularly in eastern South Australia are known to contain very high concentrations of uranium and thorium. Numerous geothermal exploration companies have encountered granites exceeding 200oC at depths ranging to 5,000m.

The significance of radiogenic anomalism in the region is highlighted by numerous uranium deposits across the state including the giant Olympic Dam mine. Assuming the proposed Olympic Dam mine expansion progresses as planned, the single mine is expected to produce about 35% of global demand for 100 - 150 years!

Industry Development

South Australia hosts the majority of geothermal exploration activity in Australia (~90%), with approximately 30 companies (7 ASX-listed) holding almost 300 geothermal exploration licences across the state.

A number of relatively advanced geothermal projects exist in South Australia including Hot Sedimentary Aquifer (HSA) based reservoirs in the south east of the state (Panax Geothermal, Figure 13) and recently proven Hot Fractured Rock (HFR/EGS) in the east of the state in the Cooper Basin.

Emerging Energy Market

Planned and future industrial developments in South Australia, specifically mining related project expansions are dependent on 100’s if not 1000’s of MW of new power generation capacity being installed in South Australia. South Australia is linked into the National Energy Market (NEM) through two seperate links to Victoria, the Heywood Link and Murraylink with power being imported into South Australia via the Heywood link and a similar amount being exported to Victoria via Murraylink (Source: NEMMCO, 2009).

In addition to the large projected growth in power consumption in South Australia, a recent heatwave in the summer of 2009 highlighted the supply-side vulnerabilities with spot prices increasing dramatically.

$36.37$33.30

$78.17

$56.29$53.01 $51.43

$0

$10

$20

$30

$40

$50

$60

$70

$80

$90

NSW QLD SA TAS VIC Average

Regional Reference Spot Price ($/MWh) (Average since 1 Jan 2009)

Estimated Crustal Temperature at 5km Depth

South Australian Geothermal

Figure 15

National Energy Market Marketing Company (NEMMCO) figures indicate that the average regional reference spot price for power since the start of 2009 was highest in South Australia (Figure 16).

(All states are connected to the NEM, except for Northern Territory & Western Australia).

Figure 16

Page 11: Geothermal Energy Australian June 2009 · Welcome to the June 2009 edition of Geothermal Energy - Australian Research Report. Activated Logic has been ... uranium. While the debate

GEOTHERMAL INDUSTRY RESEARCH REPORT I ACTIVATED LOGIC I 11

Featured Project

Southern Gold’s exploration tenure, the Torrens Geothermal Project (TGP) located in South Australia is held by a wholly owned subsidiary, Inferus Resources Ltd.

Southern Gold’s Torrens Geothermal Project possesses two of the most important factors essential for enhanced geothermal systems (EGS):

• high temperature heat source at < 5km depth

• proximity to infrastructure linking project site to electricity markets (NEM), and located in a region of growing energy demand.

High temperature heat source

Existing regional datasets, combined with recent drilling activity confirm the presence of a major heat anomaly first described by Neumann et al, as the South Australian Heat Flow Anomaly (SAHFA). The GEL/A’s held by Southern Gold, are interpreted to be located at the margins of this major heat source, and further drilling is expected to delineate this anomaly further to the west, further encompassing the TGP.

Proximity to energy markets

The TGP covers almost the entire 275Kv & 132Kv sections of the National Power grid linking the expanding Olympic Dam mine (ASX:BHP) and the recently commissioned Prominent Hill mine (ASX: OZL) - both world class , long life resource assets to the power grid at Port Augusta.

In April this year BHP wrote to all major utilities operating in South Australia, inviting interested parties to submit expressions of interest to help meet Olympic Dam’s increased power requirements as a result of the expected $20 billion plus expansion of the massive copper, gold and uranium mine.

Geothermal resource estimate

Southern Gold is expected to release it’s maiden geothermal resource, with a geothermal resource assessment over GEL 302 at the AJM Hot Rock Energy Conference in Melbourne on 4-5 June 2009. The resource assessment is possible due to two deep (1000m) mineral exploration wells previously drilled by Southern Gold, and a recent Geoscience Australia seismic line (Figure 18).

Across the TGP area (including GELA’s), there are approximately 30 wells which have been drilled deeper than 500m, providing an opportunity for an immediate down-hole temperature assessment to create an anomalous heat-flow map, suitable for determining optimal drilling locations.

Geothermal Exploration Tenure

Detailed research report covering Southern Gold will be available on the 15th June, 2009.

Southern Gold Limited 47 Tynte Street PO Box 1016 email: [email protected]

The poten�al economics of the Torrens Geothermal Project are built around the proximity of commercially viable insulated hot rocks to high voltage power distribu�on infrastructure and nearby market demand. The excellent infrastructure combined with reliable energy supplies contributes to the con�nued and sustained project development and produc�on economics of the region. This will only serve to benefit Southern Gold’s goal of establishing a commercially viable EGS in the area.

The poten�al economics of the Torrens Geothermal Project are built around the proximity of commercially viable insulated hot rocks to high voltage power distribu�on infrastructure and nearby market demand. The excellent infrastructure combined with reliable energy supplies contributes to the con�nued and sustained project development and produc�on economics of the region. This will only serve to benefit Southern Gold’s goal of establishing a commercially viable EGS in the area. The Torrens Geothermal Project contains more than 30 historic drillholes with depths greater than 500m. Temperature probe and drill core conduc�vity measurements from these deep holes would be highly valuable in providing a rapid assessment of the surrounding heat flow regime. This work will delineate addi�onal target hotspots of geothermal anomalism and will expedite the project towards the Company’s target of a commercialised EGS.

The Torrens Geothermal Project contains more than 30 historic drillholes with depths greater than 500m. Temperature probe and drill core conduc�vity measurements from these deep holes would be highly valuable in providing a rapid assessment of the surrounding heat flow regime. This work will delineate addi�onal target hotspots of geothermal anomalism and will expedite the project towards the Company’s target of a commercialised EGS. Southern Gold is considering financing and management alterna�ves for the future development of the Torrens Geothermal Project that will maximise its value to Southern Gold. Southern Gold is considering financing and management alterna�ves for the future development of the Torrens Geothermal Project that will maximise its value to Southern Gold. For further informa�on contact: For further informa�on contact: Mr Stephen Biggins Mr Stephen Biggins Managing Director Managing Director T: +61 (0) 8 8368 8888 T: +61 (0) 8 8368 8888 F: +61 (0) 8 8368 8899 F: +61 (0) 8 8368 8899 E: [email protected]: [email protected] W: southerngold.com.au

Figure 1. Southern Gold’s Geothermal tenure covering 10,000km2 of hot rocks and high voltage power lines linking Olympic Dam and Prominent Hill to South Australia’s power infrastructure hub at Port Augusta.

telephone 08 8368 8888 ABN 30 107 424 519 North Adelaide North Adelaide www:southerngold.com.au facsimilie 08 8368 8899

South Australia 5006 South Australia 5006

Southern Gold

Share price performance

Key Points

• high heat flows established from two seperate wells

• large tenement holding covering 10,000km2 in SA

• initial geothermal resource estimate due in June 2009 from GEL 302, an area covering only 5% of Southern Gold’s geothermal exploration tenure

• close proximity to 275Kv powerlines and NEM

• pre-existing wells and recent seismic testing by Geoscience Australia fascilitate fast-tracking

Figure 17

Figure 18

Page 12: Geothermal Energy Australian June 2009 · Welcome to the June 2009 edition of Geothermal Energy - Australian Research Report. Activated Logic has been ... uranium. While the debate

12 I ACTIVATED LOGIC I GEOTHERMAL INDUSTRY RESEARCH REPORT

Our combination of industry specific experts with an integrated approach to formulating STRATEGIES, understanding INVESTMENT priorities and COMMUNICATING objectives to relevant stakeholders, has proven to be a highly successful formula for sustainable value creation.

Activated Logic – Services

STRATEGY

Discover how Activated Logic’s Business Optimisation & Synchronisation System (al-boss™) can help you understand:

• How you deliver value to your customers

• How you can improve the effectiveness of your value delivery network

• The benefits of integrating and synchronising your value delivery network

How can al-boss™ help my organisation?

• Rapidly determine what it is that your organisation does better than the competition and devise strategies to leverage and extract more value from these core strengths.

• Adapt to the changing business environment and understand economic, social and technological challenges and how they affect your organisation.

• Provide an integrated solution that maximises the core competencies of your organisation and allows you to leverage organisational strengths.

Find out more about:

• Adapting to the changing business environment

• Creating value through competitive advantage

• Strategic planning in changing times

• Strengthening your value delivery network

For more information, visit:

www.activatedlogic.com/strategy.html

Create and maintain a strategic fit between the goals, resources and capabilities of your organisation. Adapt to rapidly changing marketing opportunities in the expected future business environment, to maximise your organisational effectiveness.

Attract external investment in your organisation, capitalise on investment opportunities, reduce risks regarding funding uncertainty, lower your organisations cost of doing business, provide leverage in commercial negotiations and maximise value realisation opportunities.

Discover how Activated Logic’s Sequential Investment Assessment Matrix (al-siam™) can improve your organisations utilisation of capital. Developing strategies to achieve organisational objectives is obviously very important, however the biggest challenge many growing and established organisations face is securing sufficient capital to be able to fund capital and operating expenditure necessary to achieve their organisational objectives.

What is al-siam™?

The Activated Logic – Sequential Investment Assessment Matrix, provides a structured hierarchical approach to the raising and allocation of capital from both an operational perspective and also in relation to corporate transactions involving the acquisition, joint-venturing or divestment of major assets.

How does al-siam™ work?

The process of sequentially assessing different investment options for your organisation involves four distinct, but interrelated objectives.

1. Identification and classification of investment priorities

2. Explore, compare and contrast different sources of capital

3. Develop attractive investment proposals

4. Asset rationalisation – divestment of non-core assets

For more information, visit:

www.activatedlogic.com/investments.html

INVESTMENTS

Page 13: Geothermal Energy Australian June 2009 · Welcome to the June 2009 edition of Geothermal Energy - Australian Research Report. Activated Logic has been ... uranium. While the debate

GEOTHERMAL INDUSTRY RESEARCH REPORT I ACTIVATED LOGIC I 13

Professional corporate communication allows your organisation to more effectively manage the perceptions and expectations of your stakeholders, assists in raising capital from shareholders, improves relations with industry partners and builds your corporate brand.

COMMUNICATIONS

Discover how Activated Logic can help your organisation meet its core communication objectives including:

“accurate, timely, professional and authoritative communication with all relevant stakeholders.”

Activated Logic is an integrated corporate communication solutions provider, providing strategic and operational communication needs, including:

• investment community engagement

• shareholder communications

• annual-reports & other corporate literature

• preparation of web-based materials

• corporate branding strategy

• target market analysis

• 360o stakeholder evaluations

• trademark registrations

In addition to our dedicated team of industry specialists and communication experts, our team at Activated Logic includes experts from other disciplines offering synergistic services, including:

• corporate strategy

• investment strategy

• printing & publishing

• corporate photography

Professionally managed communication allows an organisation to manage the perceptions of organisational stakeholders, by keeping your finger on the pulse when raising capital from shareholders, attracting a joint-venture partner, or selling products directly into a consumer market.

For more information, visit: www.activatedlogic.com/communications.html

What is al-i&pi™?

The Activated Logic – Impress & Progress IndexTM, is an analytical dynamic engagement model which enables the effectiveness of your organisation in “impressing and progressing” prospective clients or investors to be benchmarked against comparable organisations. This forms the basis for improving the effectiveness of your organisation’s communication strategies.

The engagement of prospective clients or investors requires both a structured methodology and a dynamic capacity to be able to adapt to rapidly evolving business environments. This ensures that all communications remain relevant, accurate, concise, and most of all appealing enough to make the target respond as desired by your organisation.

How does al-i&pi™ work?

Activated Logic has developed an innovative approach to better understand the optimal engagement process for every organisation. We can provide valuable insights into the most desirable communication strategies likely to deliver an effective outcome. The five key engagement steps developed by Activated Logic are:

1. Identify

2. Impress *

3. Progress *

4. Engage

5. Sustain

* Core focus for innovative engagement

Activated Logic offers our clients innovation in consulting and communication strategies within eight core industry sectors; Agribusiness, Bio-sustainable, Energy, Healthcare & Medical, Manufacturing, Mining Resources, Research and Technology.

Industry Focus

Page 14: Geothermal Energy Australian June 2009 · Welcome to the June 2009 edition of Geothermal Energy - Australian Research Report. Activated Logic has been ... uranium. While the debate

14 I ACTIVATED LOGIC I GEOTHERMAL INDUSTRY RESEARCH REPORT

Activated Logic www.activatedlogic.com

Australian Geothermal Energy Association www.agea.org.au/

Australian Geothermal Energy Group www.pir.sa.gov.au/geothermal/ageg

Australian Geothermal IndexTM

www.geothermalindex.org/agi.html

Australian Geothermal Industry - Technology Roadmap www.ret.gov.au/Pages/default.aspx

Australian Geothermal Industry - Development Framework www.ret.gov.au/Pages/default.aspx

Hot Dry Rocks Pty Ltd www.hotdryrocks.com

Impress & Progress IndexTM

www.iandpi.com

Southern Gold www.southerngold.com.au

The Future of Geothermal Energy - MIT Report htpp://geothermal.inel.gov

Additional Resources

References

FIGURES

Fig. 1 - 3 Adapted from Energy in Australia 2009, ABARE Economics, April 2009.

Fig. 4 - 14 Created by Activated Logic in 2009, from a combination of proprietary and public domain data.

Fig. 15 AdaMap derived from the AUSTHERM05 database of Chopra & Holgate (2005)Image is (c) 2007; Dr Prame Chopra, Earthinsite.com Pty Ltd.

Fig. 16 Created by Activated Logic. Data obtained from NEMMCO for the period 1 Jan - 24 May 2009.

Fig. 17 Created by Activated Logic in 2009, from a combination of proprietary and public domain data.

Fig. 18 Map of Southern Gold exploration tenure ontained from (ASX:SAU) annoucement 4 May 2009.

TABLES

Table 1 Adapted from Energy in Australia 2009, ABARE Economics, April 2009. Geothermal Data from relevant ASX releases.

Tables 2 - 4 Created by Activated Logic in 2009, from a combination of proprietary and public domain data.

Page 15: Geothermal Energy Australian June 2009 · Welcome to the June 2009 edition of Geothermal Energy - Australian Research Report. Activated Logic has been ... uranium. While the debate

GEOTHERMAL INDUSTRY RESEARCH REPORT I ACTIVATED LOGIC I 15

Disclaimer & Disclosure Notice

The publisher of this publication, Activated Logic Pty Limited ABN 62 134 740 293 (“Activated Logic”), its directors, officers, staff and their associates from time to time may hold shares in the securities mentioned in this publication and as a result may benefit from any change in the price of the relevant securities. Activated Logic and its advisers may earn brokerage, fees, commissions, other benefits or advantages as a result of a transaction arising from any research or opinions mentioned in this publication and distributed to existing and future clients. Activated Logic may have provided corporate advice within the past and may continue to provide corporate advice to companies (or related parties) concerned, for which Activated Logic may have received gross fees and/or continue to receive fees.

Any advice contained in this document is unsolicited general advice and is provided for information purposes only. Do not act on this advice without first consulting your financial or investment adviser to determine whether the advice is appropriate for your specific investment objectives, financial situation and particular requirements. Activated Logic believes that any information or potential advice contained in this publication was accurate when issued, however Activated Logic does not warrant the accuracy or reliability of this information. Activated Logic, its directors, officers, staff and their associates exclude all liability whatsoever, in negligence or otherwise, for any loss or damage resulting from the use or circulation of this publication to the full extent permitted by law.

THIS PUBLICATION DOES NOT CONSTITUTE FINANCIAL ADVICE.

Non-disclosure policy

Activated Logic is a company that communicates with businesses, business professionals and individuals. We may act on behalf of businesses, provide and receive quotes, trade secrets and confidential information regarding our client’s projects, or their affiliate’s events and projects. During initial communications we acknowledge and agree that the users are exchanging Confidential Information in order to discuss the possibility of entering into a business relationship. We encourage open communication and the flow of ideas in respect to our Non-Disclosure Agreement.

Users and Activated Logic agree that they will not make use of, reproduce, disseminate, or in any way disclose to any person, firm or business, any Confidential Information of the disclosing party, except to the extent necessary for negotiations, discussions and consultations with authorised representatives of the disclosing party. In addition, the receiving party represents and warrants that it will not attempt to decipher, reverse engineer, decompile or disassemble any Confidential Information disclosed by the disclosing party or allow others to do so.

Neither Party shall communicate any information to the other in violation of the proprietary rights of any third party. Neither Party will assign or transfer any rights or obligations under this Agreement without the prior written consent of the other Party. Further to this, Activated Logic may enter into a signed Non-Disclosure Agreement with any of its clients depending on individual circumstances.

Media Enquiries

The Activated Logic Communications Director (CD) is the authorised spokesperson designated and intended as the main contact for companies or individuals seeking information about Activated Logic’s NDA or Privacy Policy. For additional information regarding this publication or any of our policies, please contact Ms. Naomi Keogh - [email protected]

Contact/Feedback

Activated Logic is committed to the principles of Total Quality Management (TQM) and various other continuous improvement systems. After reading this document in its entirety if you believe this document may be improved please contact us with your thoughts, we would like to hear from you.

Mailing AddressPO Box 889, Sanctuary Cove, Queensland 4212, Australia

T 1300 4 LOGIC F +61(0)7 5561 8984 E [email protected] W www.activatedlogic.com

Page 16: Geothermal Energy Australian June 2009 · Welcome to the June 2009 edition of Geothermal Energy - Australian Research Report. Activated Logic has been ... uranium. While the debate

Member

Integrated Strategy, Investment & Communications Solutions

Activated Logic Pty Limited ABN 62 134 740 293

Head Office Suite A, 4 Prewett St, Upper Coomera, Queensland 4209, Australia

Mailing Address PO Box 889, Sanctuary Cove, Queensland 4212, Australia

T 1300 4 LOGIC (1300 4 56442) F +61 (0)7 5561 8984 E [email protected] W www.activatedlogic.com