GENERAL CASE INFORMATION VICTIM/S · 2019-09-09 · San Diego County Sheriff's Department Arrest/Juvenile Contact Report 2 Page 2 of 9 Case No. 16101368 CAD Event No.: E3072594 Case

San Diego County Sheriff's Department Arrest/Juvenile Contact Report

1 Page 1 of 9

Case No. 16101368 CAD Event No.: E3072594 Case Disposition: Arrest

Primary Victim: State of California Report No. 16101368.1

Reporting Officer Division / Organization Reviewed By

SH0606 - VAIL, PLUTARCO San Diego Regional Fugitive Task Force SH2198 - DAVIS, CHRISTOPHER

Report Date Detective Assigned Reviewed Date 1/11/2016 12:47:56 AM 02/09/2016 11:21:27 NetRMS_CASDCR.rtf v11-15-06 Printed By SH1888 Printed: May 23, 2017 - 4:52 PM

X ARREST REPORT JUVENILE CONTACT REPORT WARRANT: LOCAL OUT

GENERAL CASE INFORMATION

Primary Charge: 32 - PC - ACCESSORY TO FELONY (F) Special Studies: Related Cases: 16101369 ARLocation, City, State, ZIP: Occurred On: 250 La Cresta Heights Rd, El Cajon, CA 92021 01/09/2016 11:00:00 (Saturday) Jurisdiction: Beat: Call Source: (and Between): Alpine - EL CAJON 555 DEPUTY Means: Motives:

VICTIM/S

IBR/UCR OFFENSE/S

Offense Description: Level: Against: Completed? Counts Using: 32 - PC - ACCESSORY TO FELONY (F) F Yes Location Type: Hate/Bias: Domestic Violence: 206 - House Trailer/Manufactured Home 88 - None (No Bias) No Criminal Activity: Type Security: Gang Related: Entry: Point of Entry: Weapons/Force: Tools: Targets: Offense Description: Level: Against: Completed? Counts Using: 148 (A)(1) - PC - OBSTRUCT/RESIST PEACE OFCR/EMER MED TECH (M)

M Yes

Location Type: Hate/Bias: Domestic Violence: 206 - House Trailer/Manufactured Home 88 - None (No Bias) No Criminal Activity: Type Security: Gang Related: Entry: Point of Entry: Weapons/Force: Tools: Targets: Offense Description: Level: Against: Completed? Counts Using: 1203.2 (A) - PC - PROBATION VIOLATION:REARREST/REVOKE

O Yes

Location Type: Hate/Bias: Domestic Violence: 206 - House Trailer/Manufactured Home 88 - None (No Bias) No Criminal Activity: Type Security: Gang Related: Entry: Point of Entry: Weapons/Force: Tools: Targets:

ARRESTEE/S

Arrestee #1

Name: County Residence: Interpreter Language: Koistra, Trina R - Resident

ALIAS / AKA / NICKNAME / MONIKER:

Name Type: First: Middle: Last: Suffix: Home Address, City, State, ZIP: Res. Country: Place of Birth: Undocumented: 250 La Cresta Heights Rd El Cajon, CA 92021 US Race: Sex: Date of Birth / Age: Height: Weight: Hair Color: Eye Color: Facial Hair: Complexion: W F - 49 5' 4" 130 BLN BRO 12 - None/Fuzz FAR - Fair Hair Style: Hair Length: Build: Teeth: Suspected User: W - Wavy N - Neck THI - Thin Employment Status: Occupation/Grade: Employer/School: Employer Address, City, State, ZIP: U - Unemployed

CONTACT INFORMATION: Type: Number/Address:

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(A)

(b)(5)(A)

(b)(5)(B)


2 Page 2 of 9






IDENTIFICATION: Type: Number: State: Country: DLN - Drivers License Number

CA US

Type: Number: State: Country: SSN - SSN

SCARS, MARKS, TATTOOS, ODDITIES: Attire: Suspect Actions: ,

ARREST INFORMATION Arrest Type: LE Disposition: JUS 750 Type: Citation No.: Booking No.: O - Probable Cause Arrest - New Case 4 - Felony (Adult Only) 3 - Other Arrested For: Level: Completed: Counts: 32 - PC - ACCESSORY TO FELONY (F) F Yes 148 (A)(1) - PC - OBSTRUCT/RESIST PEACE OFCR/EMER MED TECH (M) M Yes 1203.2 (A) - PC - PROBATION VIOLATION:REARREST/REVOKE O Yes Arrested By: Arrest Date and Time: Arrest Location, City, State, ZIP: Beat: SH0606 - VAIL, PLUTARCO 01/09/2016 12:00:00 250 La Crest Heights Rd. , El Cajon, CA 92021 555 Arrest Assisted By: Transported By: Miranda Read: Admonished By: Miranda Response: Jail Billing Code: Booked Location: SD Sheriff's Office Armed With: Use of Force to effect Arrest: 01 - Unarmed Yes

JUVENILES Adult Present: Person Notified: Juvenile Disposition: Detention Name: Parents Notified By: Notification Method: Date and Time Notified: Juvenile Released To:

RELEASE INFORMATION Released Location: Released On: Released By: Release Reason:

SUSPECT/S (Not Yet Arrested) WITNESSES

Witness #1 Person Code:

Secured Premise

Discovered Crime

Reporting Party

Law Enforcement Officer Witness Type Code:

01-Arresting Officer

06-Other Lay Witness

07-Narc Chemist

12-Other Expert

13-Investigator

14-Other

Name: Person Code: County Residence: Davis, Chris


Name Type: First: Middle: Last: Suffix: Home Address, City, State, ZIP: Res. Country: Place of Birth: Undocumented: Race: Sex: Date of Birth / Age: Height: Weight: Hair Color: Eye Color: Facial Hair: Complexion: Employment Status: Occupation/Grade: Employer/School: Employer Address, City, State, ZIP: E - Employed Sergeant San Diego County Sheriff Po Box 420430, San Diego, CA 92142


IDENTIFICATION: Type: Number: State: Country: SH - Sheriff ID 2198 Injury: Extent of Treatment:

(b)(5)(A)

(b)(5)(A)

(b)(5)(A)


3 Page 3 of 9







Secured Premise

Discovered Crime

Reporting Party




07-Narc Chemist

12-Other Expert

13-Investigator

14-Other

Name: Person Code: County Residence: Enns, Robin


Name Type: First: Middle: Last: Suffix: Home Address, City, State, ZIP: Res. Country: Place of Birth: Undocumented: Race: Sex: Date of Birth / Age: Height: Weight: Hair Color: Eye Color: Facial Hair: Complexion: Employment Status: Occupation/Grade: Employer/School: Employer Address, City, State, ZIP: E - Employed Detective San Diego County Sheriff Po Box 420430, San Diego, CA 92142




Secured Premise

Discovered Crime

Reporting Party




07-Narc Chemist

12-Other Expert

13-Investigator

14-Other

Name: Person Code: County Residence: Chase, Randy


Name Type: First: Middle: Last: Suffix: Home Address, City, State, ZIP: Res. Country: Place of Birth: Undocumented: Race: Sex: Date of Birth / Age: Height: Weight: Hair Color: Eye Color: Facial Hair: Complexion: Employment Status: Occupation/Grade: Employer/School: Employer Address, City, State, ZIP: E - Employed Detective San Diego Sheriff Po Box 420430, San Diego, CA 92142




Secured Premise

Discovered Crime

Reporting Party




07-Narc Chemist

12-Other Expert

13-Investigator

14-Other

Name: Person Code: County Residence: Perata, Darren




4 Page 4 of 9









Secured Premise

Discovered Crime

Reporting Party




07-Narc Chemist

12-Other Expert

13-Investigator

14-Other

Name: Person Code: County Residence: Bradley, Howard






Secured Premise

Discovered Crime

Reporting Party




07-Narc Chemist

12-Other Expert

13-Investigator

14-Other

Name: Person Code: County Residence: Benjamin, Bart


Name Type: First: Middle: Last: Suffix: Home Address, City, State, ZIP: Res. Country: Place of Birth: Undocumented: Race: Sex: Date of Birth / Age: Height: Weight: Hair Color: Eye Color: Facial Hair: Complexion: Employment Status: Occupation/Grade: Employer/School: Employer Address, City, State, ZIP: E - Employed Detective Chula Vista PD 101 W. Broadway Ste 450, San Diego, CA 92101


IDENTIFICATION: Type: Number: State: Country: CV - Chula Vista PD ID 1774 Injury: Extent of Treatment:


Secured Premise

Discovered Crime

Reporting Party




07-Narc Chemist

12-Other Expert

13-Investigator

14-Other

Name: Person Code: County Residence:

(b)(5)(B)


5 Page 5 of 9






ALIAS / AKA / NICKNAME / MONIKER: Name Type: First: Middle: Last: Suffix: Home Address, City, State, ZIP: Res. Country: Place of Birth: Undocumented: Race: Sex: Date of Birth / Age: Height: Weight: Hair Color: Eye Color: Facial Hair: Complexion: Employment Status: Occupation/Grade: Employer/School: Employer Address, City, State, ZIP:


IDENTIFICATION: Type: Number: State: Country:

Injury: Extent of Treatment:


Secured Premise

Discovered Crime

Reporting Party




07-Narc Chemist

12-Other Expert

13-Investigator

14-Other

Name: Person Code: County Residence: Vail, Plutarco


Name Type: First: Middle: Last: Suffix: Home Address, City, State, ZIP: Res. Country: Place of Birth: Undocumented: Race: Sex: Date of Birth / Age: Height: Weight: Hair Color: Eye Color: Facial Hair: Complexion: Employment Status: Occupation/Grade: Employer/School: Employer Address, City, State, ZIP: E - Employed Deputy K9 San Diego Sheriff Sdso K-9 Unit, San Diego, CA 92123



OTHER ENTITIES

PROPERTY

REPORT NARRATIVE SYNOPSIS: Trina Koistra was arrested during a search for a wanted felon, at her residence. Koistra is on probation and a 4th waiver. Koistra was a pre-violator of her probation with a pending warrant in the system for her arrest. During the search and after numerous loud verbal commands for anyone inside her residence to exit there was no response. Koistra was found by a Sheriff's canine squatting down, hiding under a blanket, behind clothing, in the far corner of a closet. was found by a Sheriff's canine hiding underneath a bed in a separate bedroom. was arrested for the outstanding felony warrant and Koistra was arrested and charged with 1203.2(a)PC (Violation of Probation), 32PC (Accessory) and

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)


6 Page 6 of 9






148PC (Delaying/Resisting). and Koistra were the only two that chose to stay inside her residence to avoid capture/arrest. Koistra assisted and aided in housing then hiding when the Sheriff's department made their presence known on scene. Both and Koistra were treated at the hospital then later booked into county jail. ORIGIN: On 01-09-16, at about 1100 hours, I assisted the Fugitive Task Force (FTF) in apprehending a wanted felon at 250 La Cresta Heights Rd. , El Cajon. (CAD#E3072594) INVESTIGATION: I was briefed by Sergeant Davis (TFS80) that the wanted felon was a I was advised had an active no bail felony warrant and was to be considered armed and dangerous. I was also advised that was a person of interest in a homicide.

I was also advised that Koistra was a pre-violator of her

probation and if found hiding inside would be arrested. A plan was devised and we headed towards the target residence at 250 La Crest Heights Rd. to make contact. When we arrived a perimeter was set with ASTREA up above assisting. Sergeant Davis, FTF deputy Enns and I staged in the immediate area of the front door. Sergeant Davis used a hand held Public Announcement (PA) system to announce our presence. Numerous announcements were made via the PA of: "Sheriff's department on a probation check exit the trailer now" "If anyone is inside you need to exit now" "Sheriff's department we have a canine if you do not come out you will be bit." After an extended period of time of making announcements and waiting outside the front door opened and a white male (unknown name) exited. The white male stated the only other person inside the trailer was an elderly female in a back room. We continued with more announcements using the PA until we received no other response. We devised a plan to make entry. We decided to stack and conduct a slow clear in the order of: FTF deputy Enns, FTF Deputy Perata, K-9 (Vail), FTF officer Benjamin and FTF deputy Bradley. We approached the front door that was in the open position and FTF Perata stopped at the opening. FTF Perata made loud verbal commands for anyone inside the trailer to exit and there was no response. FTF Perata then made loud verbal commands of "Sheriff's department with a canine come out or you will be bit" and again there was no response. After waiting some time at the front door we made entry. We methodically cleared as we moved forward with FTF Perata continually making announcements for anyone inside the trailer to come out. As we moved into the kitchen area, in front of me to my right I observed a bathroom and two bedrooms alongside it. The bedroom door to the right of the bathroom was open and the bedroom door to the left of the bathroom was closed. To my rear there was another bedroom that FTF officer Benjamin and FTF deputy Bradley broke away from us to clear.

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(A)

(b)(5)(B) (b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(C)

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(C)

(b)(5)(A)


7 Page 7 of 9






I moved forward with FTF Perata and slowly cleared the small bathroom (door open) and then peered into the open bedroom door on the right. Inside I observed an elderly female standing with her walker in the middle of the room. She was surprised to see us and asked what was going on. FTF Perata yelled at her to exit the room but she was hard of hearing. FTF Perata yelled and motioned with his hand for her to exit. The elderly women slowly exited and again asked what was going on. FTF Perata told her we were looking for someone who was wanted and she said "Then use that dog that you have with you." The elderly woman was secured in a safe location and I decided to use my canine partner Hank to clear the bedroom. My intention was to have the canine available at the scene as a psychological deterrent to any aggressive acts might make against me, my partners and the public. Additionally, I wanted to prevent the use of a higher level of force. The totality of the circumstances heightened my awareness of the situation. I was searching for a wanted felon and a person of interest in a homicide. We had made numerous announcements for everyone to exit the trailer. I believed was hiding. Through my experience subjects that hide are under the influence of something and are unpredictable in their actions. The suspects the FTF Unit deals with are individuals that do not want to return to jail and will avoid capture by any means. These subjects are usually repeat offenders or gang members with a history of violence to include being armed. I made two loud verbal commands of: "Sheriff's department with a dog come out or you will be bit" and there was no response. I waited a bit, listened, heard nothing then gave Hank the command to search. Hank immediately went to the closet door (slider doors) and began intently sniffing about the area, stuck his head in a partially open door closest to us, attempted to enter but could not due to clutter inside. Hank exited then went to the furthest end of the closet door that was closed. I slid open the door and I observed Hank lunge inside. I looked and could see Hank's head buried behind a lot of clothing that was hanging up. I moved forward and pulled the clothing back and away from Hank. I then observed him making contact with someone that was squatted down, hiding under a blanket in the far rear corner of the closet. That someone was not making a noise and then all of a sudden I heard a female's voice say "ahhh." I removed the blanket and observed it was a female later identified as Trina Koistra. I removed Hank from his contact; Koistra was handcuffed and removed from the scene. FTF officer Bobbitt was on scene and violated Koistras' probation. All that was left of the trailer to clear was the bedroom to the left of the bathroom with the closed door. FTF Perata opened the door which was unlocked and I made two loud verbal commands of: "Sheriff's department with a dog come out or you will be bit" and there was no response. I waited a bit, listened, heard nothing then gave Hank the command to search. Hank entered the room and began running around a bed that was pushed up against a wall. Hank then jumped up on top of the bed and I began to slide the bed away from the wall. As I did this Hank immediately dove head first between the wall and the bed and made contact with a foot that was hanging out from underneath it. I heard nothing and could see Hank pulling on it. I immediately lifted the bed and frame up to observe underneath and noticed it was . I observed roll onto his left side then began kicking down with his right foot on top of Hank's head.

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)


8 Page 8 of 9






I immediately yelled "Stop fighting the dog" but refused. continued kicking down at Hank's head and then I observed him use his right hand to strike at Hanks' snout. While still holding the bed up to keep it from falling on us I used the bottom of my right foot to punch/push right upper shoulder to get him to roll onto his stomach. My foot glanced off his shoulder and struck him on the right side of his head. continued fighting with Hank and someone was able to take control of the bed. I immediately went to the aid of Hank and delivered a knee strike to the right side of body continually yelling "Stop fighting the dog." I then yelled at to "Lay on your stomach" but he refused. I then used all my body weight in a downward position with both my knees pushing on the right side of body forcing him to his stomach. FTF officer Benjamin moved in and was able to handcuff With now secure I was able to remove Hank from his contact without further incident. Medical treatment was requested for and Koistra. San Miguel Engine #7218 and Zone 2 Rural Medic #7296 arrived on scene to tend to them. Medic #7296 advised me and Koistra would need to be transported to Alvarado Hospital for further treatment and evaluation. was transported to Alvarado Hospital by Deputy Greene, #7131, and Koistra by Medic #7296. I contacted Sergeant Hout, #2284, and advised him of the canine contact. Sergeant Hout arrived at Alvarado Hospital to handle the investigation. FTF deputy Bradley and FTF officer Benjamin arrived at the hospital to take custody of

. Koistra was later transported to Scripps Mercy Hospital for further treatment. I stayed with Koistra at Scripps Mercy Hospital until relieved by Deputy Manire, #1355. While at Scripps Mercy Hospital, I was gathering Koistras' belongings when she began to cry. I walked over to Koistra and she told me she was sorry for hiding. Koistra told me when we arrived at her trailer she heard someone inside the trailer say the "cops" are here and she got scared and hid in the closet. She told me she had relapsed and was afraid to go back to jail. I asked her if she heard me yelling about the dog and she said yes but she did not think we had one. She knew we were inside the trailer searching. EVIDENCE: None. PROPERTY DAMAGE: None. INJURIES:

received puncture wounds to his left ankle. Koistra received puncture wounds to her face, a laceration to her left arm and a fractured jaw. Both were treated by M.D. at Alvarado Hospital. Koistra was later transported to Scripps Mercy Hospital for further treatment. FOLLOW-UP: Fugitive Task Force.

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)


9 Page 9 of 9






RELATED REPORTS: All witness reports are documented under Sheriff's Key case number 16101369 which was the simultaneous arrest of (b)(5)

(B)

San Diego County Sheriff's Department Officer Report

1 Page 1 of 3

CAD Event No. E3072594 Case No. 16101368

Report No. 49912


SH0606 - VAIL, PLUTARCO SDRFTF / SDFTF - San Diego Regional Fugitive Task Force SH2198 - DAVIS, CHRISTOPHER

Report Date Detective Assigned Reviewed Date 1/11/2016 1:06:57 AM 2/9/2016 8:57:31 AM NetRMS_CASDOR.rtf v11-15-06 Printed By SH1888 Printed: February 11, 2015 - 3:31 PM

GENERAL CASE INFORMATION

Special Studies:

Related Cases: 16101369 AR

Location, City, State, ZIP: Occurred On: 250 La Crest Heights Rd. ,El Cajon, CA 92021 1/9/2016 11:00:00 AM (Saturday) Jurisdiction: Beat: Call Source: (and Between): Alpine - ALPINE 555

INDIVIDUAL/S

Name: Koistra, Trina

Person Code: Interpreter Language:

ALIAS / AKA / NICKNAME / MONIKER: Home Address, City, State, ZIP: Res. Country: County Residence: Undocumented: 250 La Cresta Heights Rd El Cajon, CA 92021 US - UNITED STATES R Resident Race: Sex: Date of Birth / Age: Height: Weight: Hair Color: Eye Color: Facial Hair: Complexion: W F - 49 5' 4" 130 lbs BLN BRO 12 - None/Fuzz Employment Status: Occupation/Grade: Employer/School: Employer Address, City, State, ZIP: U - Unemployed

CONTACT INFORMATION IDENTIFICATION: Type: DLN - Drivers License Number

Number: State: CA - California

Country: US - UNITED STATES

Type: SSN - SSN

Number:

State:

Country:

Attire: Injury: Extent Of Treatment: Violent Crime Circumstances: Yes 4 - Hospitalized

REPORT NARRATIVE

SYNOPSIS: Trina Koistra was arrested during a search for a wanted felon, , at her residence. Koistra is on probation and a 4th waiver. Koistra was a pre-violator of her probation with a pending warrant in the system for her arrest. During the search and after numerous loud verbal commands for anyone inside her residence to exit there was no response. Koistra was found by a Sheriff's canine squatting down, hiding under a blanket, behind clothing, in the far corner of a closet. was found by a Sheriff's canine hiding underneath a bed in a separate bedroom. was arrested for the outstanding felony warrant and Koistra was arrested and charged with 1203.2(a)PC (Violation of Probation), 32PC (Accessory) and 148PC (Delaying/Resisting). and Koistra were the only two that chose to stay inside her residence to avoid capture/arrest. Koistra assisted and aided in housing then hiding when the Sheriff's department made their presence known on scene. Both and Koistra were treated at the hospital then later booked into county jail. ORIGIN: On 01-09-16, at about 1100 hours, I assisted the Fugitive Task Force (FTF) in apprehending a wanted felon at 250 La Cresta Heights Rd. El Cajon. (CAD#E3072594) INVESTIGATION: I was briefed by Sergeant Davis (TFS80) that the wanted felon was a . I was advised had an active no bail felony warrant and was to be considered armed and dangerous. I was also advised that was a person of interest in a homicide.

I was also advised that Koistra was a pre-violator of her probation and if found hiding inside would be arrested. A plan was devised and we headed towards the target residence at 250 La Crest Heights Rd. to make contact. When we arrived a perimeter was set with ASTREA up above assisting. Sergeant Davis, FTF deputy Enns and I staged in the immediate area of the front door. Sergeant Davis used a hand held Public Announcement (PA) system to announce our presence. Numerous announcements were made via the PA of: "Sheriff's department on a probation check exit the trailer now" "If anyone is inside you need to exit now" "Sheriff's department we have a canine if you do not come out you will be bit."

(b)(5)(A)

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(A)(b)(5)(A)

(b)(5)(A)

(b)(5)(A)

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(A)

(b)(5)(B) (b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(C) (b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(C)

(b)(5)(A)


2 Page 2 of 3


Report No. 49912




After an extended period of time of making announcements and waiting outside the front door opened and a white male (unknown name) exited. The white male stated the only other person inside the trailer was an elderly female in a back room. We continued with more announcements using the PA until we received no other response. We devised a plan to make entry. We decided to stack and conduct a slow clear in the order of: FTF deputy Enns, FTF Deputy Perata, K-9 (Vail), FTF officer Benjamin and FTF deputy Bradley. We approached the front door that was in the open position and FTF Perata stopped at the opening. FTF Perata made loud verbal commands for anyone inside the trailer to exit and there was no response. FTF Perata then made loud verbal commands of "Sheriff's department with a canine come out or you will be bit" and again there was no response. After waiting some time at the front door we made entry. We methodically cleared as we moved forward with FTF Perata continually making announcements for anyone inside the trailer to come out. As we moved into the kitchen area, in front of me to my right I observed a bathroom and two bedrooms alongside it. The bedroom door to the right of the bathroom was open and the bedroom door to the left of the bathroom was closed. To my rear there was another bedroom that FTF officer Benjamin and FTF deputy Bradley broke away from us to clear. I moved forward with FTF Perata and slowly cleared the small bathroom (door open) and then peered into the open bedroom door on the right. Inside I observed an elderly female standing with her walker in the middle of the room. She was surprised to see us and asked what was going on. FTF Perata yelled at her to exit the room but she was hard of hearing. FTF Perata yelled and motioned with his hand for her to exit. The elderly women slowly exited and again asked what was going on. FTF Perata told her we were looking for someone who was wanted and she said "Then use that dog that you have with you." The elderly woman was secured in a safe location and I decided to use my canine partner Hank to clear the bedroom. My intention was to have the canine available at the scene as a psychological deterrent to any aggressive acts might make against me, my partners and the public. Additionally, I wanted to prevent the use of a higher level of force. The totality of the circumstances heightened my awareness of the situation. I was searching for a wanted felon and a person of interest in a homicide. We had made numerous announcements for everyone to exit the trailer. I believed was hiding. Through my experience subjects that hide are under the influence of something and are unpredictable in their actions. The suspects the FTF Unit deals with are individuals that do not want to return to jail and will avoid capture by any means. These subjects are usually repeat offenders or gang members with a history of violence to include being armed. I made two loud verbal commands of: "Sheriff's department with a dog come out or you will be bit" and there was no response. I waited a bit, listened, heard nothing then gave Hank the command to search. Hank immediately went to the closet door (slider doors) and began intently sniffing about the area, stuck his head in a partially open door closest to us, attempted to enter but could not due to clutter inside. Hank exited then went to the furthest end of the closet door that was closed. I slid open the door and I observed Hank lunge inside. I looked and could see Hank's head buried behind a lot of clothing that was hanging up. I moved forward and pulled the clothing back and away from Hank. I then observed him making contact with someone that was squatted down, hiding under a blanket in the far rear corner of the closet. That someone was not making a noise and then all of a sudden I heard a female's voice say "ahhh." I removed the blanket and observed it was a female later identified as Trina Koistra. I removed Hank from his contact; Koistra was handcuffed and removed from the scene. FTF officer Bobbitt was on scene and violated Koistras' probation. All that was left of the trailer to clear was the bedroom to the left of the bathroom with the closed door. FTF Perata opened the door which was unlocked and I made two loud verbal commands of: "Sheriff's department with a dog come out or you will be bit" and there was no response. I waited a bit, listened, heard nothing then gave Hank the command to search. Hank entered the room and began running around a bed that was pushed up against a wall. Hank then jumped up on top of the bed and I began to slide the bed away from the wall. As I did this Hank immediately dove head first between the wall and the bed and made contact with a foot that was hanging out from underneath it. I heard nothing and could see Hank pulling on it. I immediately lifted the bed and frame up to observe underneath and noticed it was I observed roll onto his left side then began kicking down with his right foot on top of Hank's head. I immediately yelled "Stop fighting the dog" but refused. continued kicking down at Hank's head and then I observed him use his right hand to strike at Hanks' snout. While still holding the bed up to keep it from falling on us I used the bottom of

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)


3 Page 3 of 3


Report No. 49912




my right foot to punch/push right upper shoulder to get him to roll onto his stomach. My foot glanced off his shoulder and struck him on the right side of his head. continued fighting with Hank and someone was able to take control of the bed. I immediately went to the aid of Hank and delivered a knee strike to the right side of body continually yelling "Stop fighting the dog." I then yelled at to "Lay on your stomach" but he refused. I then used all my body weight in a downward position with both my knees pushing on the right side of body forcing him to his stomach. FTF officer Benjamin moved in and was able to handcuff With now secure I was able to remove Hank from his contact without further incident. Medical treatment was requested for and Koistra. San Miguel Engine #7218 and Zone 2 Rural Medic #7296 arrived on scene to tend to them. Medic #7296 advised me and Koistra would need to be transported to Alvarado Hospital for further treatment and evaluation. was transported to Alvarado Hospital by Deputy Greene, #7131, and Koistra by Medic #7296. I contacted Sergeant Hout, #2284, and advised him of the canine contact. Sergeant Hout arrived at Alvarado Hospital to handle the investigation. FTF deputy Bradley and FTF officer Benjamin arrived at the hospital to take custody of Koistra was later transported to Scripps Mercy Hospital for further treatment. I stayed with Koistra at Scripps Mercy Hospital until relieved by Deputy Manire, #1355. While at Scripps Mercy Hospital, I was gathering Koistras' belongings when she began to cry. I walked over to Koistra and she told me she was sorry for hiding. Koistra told me when we arrived at her trailer she heard someone inside the trailer say the "cops" are here and she got scared and hid in the closet. She told me she had relapsed and was afraid to go back to jail. I asked her if she heard me yelling about the dog and she said yes but she did not think we had one. She knew we were inside the trailer searching. EVIDENCE: None. PROPERTY DAMAGE: None. INJURIES:

received puncture wounds to his left ankle. Koistra received puncture wounds to her face, a laceration to her left arm and a fractured jaw. Both were treated by M.D. at Alvarado Hospital. Koistra was later transported to Scripps Mercy Hospital for further treatment. FOLLOW-UP: Fugitive Task Force. RELATED REPORTS: Sheriff's case number 16101369

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)

San Diego County Sheriff's Department Use of Force Supplemental

(Revised 5/17/13 NetRMS) Printed By SH1888 Printed: May 8, 2019 - 4:50 AM

UFO DATE AND TIME EVENT NUMBER CASE NUMBER DOCUMENT NUMBER STATION/FACILITY

1/9/2016 11:00 E3072594 16101368 49912 SDFTF - San Diego Regional Fugitive Task ForceINCIDENT DESCRIPTION / OFFENSES

32PC / 1203.2PC / 148PC SUBJECT’S NAME (LAST, FIRST, MI) DATE OF BIRTH ARRESTED SUPERVISOR PRESENT DATE/TIME SUPERVISOR NOTIFIED

Koistra, Trina

Yes No

Yes No 01/09/2016 12:15

REASON(S) FOR USING FORCE:

Necessary to effect an arrest

Necessary to defend self or another

Necessary to prevent escape/evasion

Necessary to effect a lawful detention

Necessary to prevent a violent forcible felony

Necessary to restrain for subject’s safety

Necessary during high-risk incident

Necessary during riot

Delaying Jail Operations

SUBJECT APPEARED TO BE NUMBER OF OFFICERS ON SCENE NUMBER OF OFFICERS USING FORCE Under the influence of alcohol and/or drugs Mentally impaired 8 1

LEVEL(S) OF RESISTANCE ENCOUNTERED

NONE (subject cooperated/complied) PASSIVE RESISTANCE (represents by a refusal to respond to verbal commands but also offers no form of physical resistance)

PSYCHOLOGICAL INTIMIDATION (non-verbal cues indicating subject’s attitude or physical readiness to resist)

ACTIVE RESISTANCE (pushing, pulling or running away from the officer to avoid control; not attempting to harm the officer)

VERBAL NON-COMPLIANCE (subject’s expressed unwillingness to comply with the officer’s commands)

ASSAULTIVE BEHAVIOR (physical actions of assault)

AGGRAVATED ACTIVE AGGRESSION (potential injury or death)

LAW ENFORCEMENT TOOL/TECHNIQUE USED TO GAIN COMPLIANCE OR OVERCOME RESISTANCE (CHECK ALL THAT APPLY) Verbal Commands: "Sheriff's dept w/dog come out or you will be bit" "If anyone is inside the trailer you need to exit now" Empty Hand Control Less-Lethal Weapon System

Di h dDischarges Number of

C t t Target

Di t

Grab, Push, Pull, or Body Weight PepperBall - OC Powder

Control Hold (Duration: ) PepperBall - Water Pressure Point (Duration: ) (# of Contacts: ) 37 mm Rifle - Standard

Strike (Body part used: ) (# of Contacts: ) 37 mm Rifle - Low Energy Takedown Type: 40 mm Rifle - Bean Bag

Carotid (Rendered Unconscious? Yes No) (Duration: ) 40 mm Rifle - Sponge Tool/Device/Weapon Taser - Probes

OC Agent (Duration: ) (# of Contacts: ) Taser - Drive Stuns Decontaminated Yes No Stingball Grenade Cord Cuff Restraint Device (Duration: ) Sound/Light device Impact Weapon (# of Contacts: ) 12-Gauge Super Sock Type: Ultron/NOVA Shield Canine (Duration: 30sec.) (# of Contacts: 2) REACT Belt

Vehicle/Forcible Stop Weapon Pointed at Subject (Duration: ) Firearm

Type: Type:

Spit Sock (Duration: ) Pro-Straint Chair Other:

Tactical Shield WRAP

WAS INITIAL USE OF FORCE EFFECTIVE?

Yes No WAS ADDITIONAL CONTROL OR FORCE NEEDED?

Yes No

SUBJECT INJURED EXTENT OF TREATMENT OFFICER(S) INJURED EXTENT OF TREATMENT

Yes No None Treated at hospital Yes No None Treated at hospital Treated at scene Hospitalized Refused treatment Treated at scene Hospitalized Refused treatment

SUBJECT INJURY DESCRIPTION OFFICER INJURY DESCRIPTION

OTHER FORCE USED/COMMENTS/EQUIPMENT PERFORMANCE:

SERGEANT ARJIS DATE

LIEUTENANT ARJIS DATE

CAPTAIN ARJIS DATE

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X

X X

X

X

X

X X X X

(b)(5)(A)

San Diego County Sheriff’s Department Use of Force Supplemental

Use of Force Supplemental Instructions Lines 1 & 3: Fill in the blanks. Line 2: If the suspect was committing a crime and force was used to stop or apprehend the subject, document the appropriate penal code. If the UOF occurred in the performance of the officer's duties, document the incident description, i.e. officer transport, officer escort, making arrest, detaining suspect, cell extraction etc. Primary Reason for Using Force: Check appropriate box(s). Subject Appeared To Be: Check if applicable. Number of Officers on Scene: List number of officers present. Number of Officers Using Force: List number of officers that used force. Level(s) of Resistance Encountered: Check appropriate box(s). L.E. Tool/Technique Used: Check appropriate box(s). If known and/or applicable, include duration (approximate length of time) tool/technique was used. If known and/or applicable, include the number of contacts (approximate number of strikes, impacts, etc.) when requested on form. Was Initial Use of Force Effective? If initial force used was effective, check “Yes.” If initial force used was ineffective and additional force was necessary, check “No.” Was Additional Control or Force Needed: If initial force used was ineffective and additional force was necessary, check “Yes.” If initial force used was effective, check “No.” Target Distance: If applicable (refers primarily to less lethal weapon systems), approximate distance or provide range (i.e. 7-15 feet, 15-20 yards, etc.) from subject during application of force. Subject Injured: Check “Yes” if medically treated for injury sustained as a possible result of force applied by a officer(s) – does not include previous injuries suffered prior to officer contact. Check “No” if subject was not injured or simply complains of injury/pain suffered as a result of force applied by an officer(s) and refuses medical attention. Any complaints of pain shall be documented in the use of force report narrative (whenever any physical force used by a officer results in a complaint of injury or an injury that necessitates medical treatment of a subject, a supervisor will be notified immediately). Extent of Treatment: Check appropriate box. Check none if subject was evaluated and no treatment was required. Specifically, check “Treated at Scene” if subject was treated at scene by EMS for injuries that may have resulted due to force applied by officer(s). Check “Treated at Hospital” if subject was transported to hospital for treatment of injuries that may have been sustained as an apparent result of force applied by officer(s). Check “Hospitalized” if subject was admitted to the Hospital as a result of injuries that were sustained as a result of force applied by officer(s). Officer Injured: Check appropriate box (see above). Extent of Treatment: Check appropriate box. Check none if officer was evaluated and no treatment was required. Specifically, check “Treated at Scene” if officer was treated at scene by EMS for injuries. Check “Treated at Hospital” if officer was transported to hospital for treatment of injuries. Check “Hospitalized” if officer was admitted to the Hospital as a result of injuries. Other Force Used/Comments/Equipment Performance: This section can be used to document other force options not listed on the form; relevant comments about the incident such as complaints of pain/injury (room permitting) and negative/positive comments regarding equipment performance. Mark Figure to Indicate Contact Points: When applicable, mark the areas on the figure where applied force contacted the subject’s body. Sergeant: Sign, list ARJIS number and date reviewed. Lieutenant: Sign, list ARJIS number and date reviewed. Captain: Sign, list ARJIS number and date reviewed.

(b)(5)(A)

(b)(5)(A)

( (_

SAN DIEGO COUNTY SHERIFF'S DEPARTMENT MEMORANDUM

DATE: 1/9/2016

TO: Greg Carpenter, Lieutenant

FROM: Brian Hout

SUBJECT: Review ofCN# 16101369

CONFIDENTIAL:

On 01/09/16 at about 1100 hours, FTF units were attempting to serve a felony arrest warrant on at 250 La Cresta Heights Road in El Cajon. was also a suspect in a recent homicide. Deputy Vail deployed his canine inside the residence to locate and apprehend During the search, Deputy Vail's canine located and bit Trina Koistra, .

REVIEW:

On 01/09/16 at about 1100 hours, I was notified by Sheriffs Dispatch that Deputy Vail's canine had made contact with and Koistra. I was advised and Koistra had been transported to Alvarado Hospital located at 6655 Alvarado Rd. in the City of San Diego.

I met with Deputy Vail at Alvarado Hospital and completed this investigation.

I made all appropriate notifications to both the Emergency Services Lieutenant as well as the on call Division of Inspectional Services Sergeant Maryn.

Photos were taken of and Koistra's injuries and an interview was conducted with Koistra regarding the incident. declined to give a statement. The photographs of and Koistra and the audio recording were copied to a CD-R disc and attached to this investigation.

CONCLUSION:

Deputy Vail's decision to use his canine was based on the following factors:

was the suspect of a felony warrant and recent homicide.

refused to obey lawful commands to surrender during canine announcements.

(b)(5)(B) (b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(A)

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B) (b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)

( (

Deputy Vail used his canine to locate and apprehend who was attempting to evade capture and hiding in an area where it was unsafe for deputies to proceed.

The use of the canine was within policy and deployed in an appropriate manner.

INJURIES:

sustained punctures to his lower left leg.

Koistra sustained punctures to her cheek and a fractured jaw. Koistra also sustained a laceration to her left forearm, punctures to both hands.

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)

( ( '.

SAN DIEGO COUNTY SHERIFF'S DEPARTMENT

MEMORANDUM

Investigation:

On 01/09/16 at about 1100 hours, FTF units were attempting to serve a felony arrest warrant on

at 250 La Cresta Heights Road in El Cajon. was also a suspect in a recent homicide. Deputy Vail deployed his canine inside the residence to locate and apprehend During the search, Deputy Vail's canine located and bit Trina Koistra,

I met with Koistra on 01/11/16 at Mercy Hospital and obtained the following statement.

Statement of Koistra:

STATEMENT OF KOISTRA:

Koistra understood I was interviewing her regarding the use of the Sheriffs Canine and that the interview was being recorded.

Koistra indicated she suffers from mental illness but could not say what form.

Koistra has no problems with her eyes or ears.

Koistra said she was taking medication.

I asked Koistra if she heard the Sheriffs K9 announcement. Koistra said she did not. Koistra

said she was in the closet sitting on her butt and clothes were hanging in front of her. Koistra

was hiding from her probation officer and thought her probation officer was there for her. Koistra heard the announcements from outside and that's why she thought her probation officer was outside.

Koistra said the dog was biting her for about 30 seconds.

I concluded my interview of Koistra.

Photos were taken of Koistra's injuries and an interview was conducted regarding the incident. The photographs of Koistra and audio recording were copied to a CD-R disc and attached to this

investigation.

(b)(5)(B) (b)(5)(A) (b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)

(b)(5)(B)

Documents

GENERAL CASE INFORMATION VICTIM/S · 2019-09-09 · San Diego County Sheriff's Department Arrest/Juvenile Contact Report 2 Page 2 of 9 Case No. 16101368 CAD Event No.: E3072594 Case