Upload
others
View
2
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
TMDL Sampling Locations
Facility Point of DischargeOutfall/ Point of
DischargeReceiving Waters TMDL
BTC‐04.CB.DP Point of Discharge Middle Rouge River E. coli
BTC‐07.OP.DP Point of Discharge Middle Rouge River E. Coli
GCC‐14.MH.DP Point of Discharge Middle Rouge River E. coli
GCC‐19.MH.DP Point of Discharge Middle Rouge River E. Coli
GCC‐46.MH.DP Point of Discharge Middle Rouge River E. coli
GCC‐62.MH.DP Point of Discharge Middle Rouge River E. coli
GCC‐70.CB.DP Point of Discharge Middle Rouge River E. coli
GCC‐76.CB.DP Point of Discharge Middle Rouge River E. Coli
GCC‐80.MH.DP Point of Discharge Middle Rouge River E. Coli
GCC‐81.CB.DP Point of Discharge Middle Rouge River E. Coli
DGS‐01.CB.DP Point of Discharge Middle Rouge River E. coli
DGS‐05.CB.DP Point of Discharge Middle Rouge River E. Coli
DGS‐09.CB.DP Point of Discharge Middle Rouge River E. coli
DGS‐13.CB.DP Point of Discharge Middle Rouge River E. Coli
DGS‐15.MH.DP Point of Discharge Middle Rouge River E. Coli
DGS‐19.CB.DP Point of Discharge Middle Rouge River E. coli
Farmington 5‐6 Campus FRM‐18.MH.DP Point of Discharge Perrin Drain E. coli
GCM‐09.MH.DP Point of Discharge Middle Rouge River E. Coli
GCM‐12.CB.DP Point of Discharge Middle Rouge River E. Coli
GCM‐14.CB.DP Point of Discharge Middle Rouge River E. Coli
GCM‐15.CB.DP Point of Discharge Middle Rouge River E. Coli
GCM‐25.CB.DP Point of Discharge Middle Rouge River E. coli
GCM‐27.CB.DP Point of Discharge Middle Rouge River E. coli
LEC‐03.FS.DP Point of Discharge Perrin Drain E. coli
LEC‐06.FS.DP Point of Discharge Perrin Drain E. coli
LEC‐08.MH.DP Point of Discharge Perrin Drain E. Coli
LEC‐09.MH.DP Point of Discharge Perrin Drain E. Coli
Maplewood Community Center MMC‐02.CB.DP Point of Discharge Middle Rouge River E. coli
MML‐02.MH.DP Point of Discharge Middle Rouge River E. coli
MML‐04.MH.DP Point of Discharge Middle Rouge River E. coli
MML‐07.MH.DP Point of Discharge Middle Rouge River E. Coli
MML‐16.CB.DP Point of Discharge Middle Rouge River E. Coli
OBG‐01.MH.DP Point of Discharge Middle Rouge River e. Coli
OBG‐04.MH.DP Point of Discharge Middle Rouge River E. Coli
Transportation and School Board Complex GTC‐08.CB.DP Point of Discharge Morgan Drain E. Coli
Old Burger Site
Lathers Early Childhood and
Kindergarten Center
Garden City Public Schools
Memorial 1‐2 Campus
Douglas 3‐4 Campus
Garden City Middle School
Cambridge High School/ Garden City High
School Complex
Burger Transition Center
Updated 1/11/2021 *Highlighted Locations are Sample Locations
www.archenvgroup.com
healthAIR - Industrial Hygiene Services cleanWATER - Consulting & Testing Services
safeEARTH - Hazardous Waste & Recycling Services
DETROIT GRAND RAPIDS CHICAGO (248) 426-0165 (616) 930-4116 (847) 462-9687 Farmington Hills, MI Cedar Springs, MI Cary, IL
June 4, 2020 Mr. Neil Greene Director of Operations Garden City Public Schools 33980 Marquette Garden City, Michigan 48135 [email protected]
RE: Project # AE200001 GCPS Total Maximum Daily Load (TMDL) Sampling Report Burger Transition Center Dear Mr. Greene: Arch Environmental Group, Inc. recently conducted a round of TMDL Wet Weather Sampling at discharge point BTC‐04.CB.DP at the Burger Transition Center on May 15, 2020, in accordance with the applicable NPDES Permit requirements. TMDL sampling is used to determine the level of specific pollutants in the stormwater system by collecting samples from 50% of the district’s stormwater outfalls/discharge points during a representative wet weather event. The sampling results are then evaluated to determine if a particular point source needs to be addressed to reduce the pollutant load of the receiving waters. A report regarding the findings of this round of TMDL Sampling is attached. If you have questions regarding this report, please feel free to contact please feel free to contact the cleanWATER team at (248) 426‐0165. Sincerely,
Arch Environmental Group, Inc. Environmental Services
Steven Ripley Certified Industrial Site Stormwater Operator, I‐15964
TMDL Sampling Report Page 2
Project # AE200001 GCPS
Burger Transition Center
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1.0 Project Summary
2.0 TMDL Sampling Procedures
3.0 TMDL Sampling Results
4.0 Conclusion
5.0 Best Management Practices to Reduce TMDL Pollutant Loads
Attachments:
TMDL Screening Inspection Log
Storm Sewer System Site Map
Analytical Results & Chain of Custody
TMDL Sampling Report Page 3
Project # AE200001 GCPS
Burger Transition Center
1.0 / Project Summary
Arch Environmental Group, Inc. (AEG) recently conducted a round of Total Maximum Daily Load (TMDL) Sampling
for E. coli at discharge location BTC‐04.CB.DP at Burger Transition Center on May 15, 2020, in accordance with the
applicable National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) Permit requirements.
A TMDL describes the process used to determine how much of a pollutant a lake or stream can assimilate and sets
pollutant reduction targets for that water body. NPDES Municipal Separate Storm Sewer System (MS4) permits
require regulated public entities located within urbanized areas that discharge storm water to an MS4 which leads
to a water body designated with a TMDL, to demonstrate progress toward meeting Water Quality Standards (WQS).
If the TMDL was written for E. coli or Total Phosphorus (TP), the MS4 permits further require permittees to collect
representative samples of storm water discharges from their points of discharge to MS4s which lead to the impacted
water bodies.1 Based on a review of the sampling results, Stormwater Best Management Practices (BMP)
implementation will be reviewed and BMPs may be updated to ensure progress toward achieving TMDL pollutant
load reductions.
The receiving water body of Burger Transition Center is the Middle Rouge River. The Middle Rouge River has been
designated with TMDLs of E. coli and Biota/Sediment. Further details on the TMDLs listed can be found in the
documents “Total Maximum Daily Load for Biota for the River Rouge Watershed, Including Bishop and Tonquish
Creeks, Washtenaw, Wayne, and Oakland Counties” and “Total Maximum Daily Load for E. Coli for the Rouge River
Wayne and Oakland Counties, Michigan” Some examples of potential sources of E. coli in waterways include fecal
material from livestock, humans, wildlife, waterfowl such as geese, and sanitary systems.
2.0 / TMDL Sampling Procedures
Applicable TMDL sampling was conducted with guidance from the “Storm Water Sampling Guidance for Total
Phosphorus & E. coli.” Sampling was conducted at designated outfalls/discharge points after a dry period of
approximately 72 hours and during a rain event of approximately .25 inches or more. Please see the attached TMDL
Screening Inspection Log for specific rainfall amounts. Sampling was conducted on May 15, 2020 and the last
significant rain event was on May 15, 2020. The weather history for the rain event is available upon request.
When a dip‐cup or similar sampling device was needed to collect the sample, a blank sample was collected to ensure
no contamination was coming from the sampling device. The blank collected during this round of TMDL sampling
came back at zero (0) CFU for E. coli indicating that the sampling device used was not contaminated. The lab results
of the blank sample are attached. Furthermore, all sampling devices were decontaminated with bleach and distilled
water between each sampling location according to the protocol laid out in the “Storm Water Sampling Guidance
for Total Phosphorus & E. coli.” Each location sampled was analyzed for pH and temperature while on‐site and the
sampled discharge point (DP) was inspected for color, odor, and abnormal vegetative growth. The collected samples
were delivered to an external laboratory for analysis.
1 Storm Water Sampling Guidance for Total Phosphorus & E. coli. November 24, 2009. DEQ
TMDL Sampling Report Page 4
Project # AE200001 GCPS
Burger Transition Center
3.0 / TMDL Sampling Results
E. coli: The WQS for E. coli is the maximum amount of E. coli that is allowable in surface waters of the state.
These standards are known as total body contact and partial body contact standards. Total body contact is
a more conservative standard used during the summer to protect swimmers during total body contact and
has the daily maximum of 300 CFU per 100 milliliters (mL). This applies to the warmer months of May 1st ‐
October 31stand is the standard being used in this report. Partial body contact is the daily maximum of 1,000
CFU per 100 mL and applies to the waterways year‐round. 2
Structure ID: BTC‐04.CB.DP Structure Type: Catch Basin Location: South of main entrance in grass
At the time of the sampling, clear water flow was noted, and BTC‐04.CB.DP was free of odors and abnormal
vegetative growth. AEG collected a grab sample from BTC‐04.CB.DP and the sample was screened for temperature
and pH in the field. An E. coli grab sample was delivered to an external laboratory for analysis. Results from the
sampling are summarized below. A more detailed TMDL Screening Inspection Log is also attached at the end of the
report.
Parameter: Results: TMDL Benchmark Standard: Units:
pH 7.98 6.5 ‐ 9 pH Units
Temperature 16.6 N/A Celsius
E. coli 115.3 300 CFU per 100mL
The sample results for BTC‐04.CB.DP did not identify elevated levels of pH or E. coli above the TMDL Benchmark
Standards. The reported levels for E. coli (115.3 CFU) are below the Michigan Public Health Department standards
for Total Body Contact (E. coli >300 CFU).
4.0 / Conclusion AEG did not identify any elevated levels of pH or E. coli above the TMDL Benchmark Standards for discharge location
BTC‐04.CB.DP sampled at Burger Transition Center on May 15, 2020.
It is the opinion of Arch Environmental Group, Inc. that the TMDL sampling results indicate good use of BMPs in
maintaining TMDL pollutant load reductions at Burger Transition Center. A list of those BMPs is provided below in
section 5.0. TMDL sampling will be conducted twice per permit cycle to continue to monitor for TMDL pollutant load
levels in accordance with the NPDES Permit requirements.
5.0 / Best Management Practices to Reduce TMDL Pollutant Loads
The Garden City Public Schools Stormwater Management Plan (SWMP) identifies and defines the districts BMPs to
comply with the Six Minimum Measures that are the front line in the nationwide effort to reducing polluted
stormwater discharges to our lake, rivers and streams. The Michigan Department of Environment, Great Lakes, and
Energy recognizes that having a Stormwater Management Plan in place built around the Six Minimum Measures
specified in the NPDES General Jurisdictional Permit have the potential to significantly contribute to the reduction
of TMDL Pollutants in the surface waters of the state. The Six Minimum Measures are listed below:
Public Education and Outreach Program (PEP)
2 “Michigan’s E. Coli Water Quality Standard Guidance” May, 2016. MDEQ
TMDL Sampling Report Page 5
Project # AE200001 GCPS
Burger Transition Center
Public Involvement and Participation Program (PIP)
Illicit Discharge Elimination Program (IDEP)
Post Construction Stormwater Management Program
Construction Site Stormwater Runoff Control Program
Pollution Prevention/Good Housekeeping Program. The following is a list of prioritized TMDL best management practices from the districts SWMP that Garden City Public Schools should continue to implement in order to improve water quality impairments associated with the E. coli and Biota/Sediment TMDL of the Middle River Rouge. Prioritization of BMPs is based on Garden City Public Schools targeted TMDL pollutants. Priority is given to BMPs that reduce E. coli loads and address water quality for biota and dissolved oxygen.
E. COLI 1. GCPS will continue to use its website to provide the public information regarding local TMDL issues
(E. coli and biota TMDL Best Management Practice). 2. GCPS will continue to educate staff, faculty, and students using various venues including the “Seven
Simple Steps to Clean Water” program educational materials developed by the various watershed groups specifically related to these issues on the stormwater management webpage.
3. The district passed a post‐construction stormwater board resolution to require implementation of the stormwater standards for construction.
4. Adequately maintains vegetation around stormwater facilities, ditches, and ponds. 5. Provide training to applicable staff and confirm training from contractors including restrictions on the
use of phosphorous containing fertilizers, soaps, cleaners and other chemicals that could impact the separate storm drain system.
ALL TMDLs 1. GCPS will continue to use its website to provide the public information regarding local TMDL issues
(E. coli and biota TMDL Best Management Practice). 2. GCPS will continue to educate staff, faculty, and students using various venues including the “Seven
Simple Steps to Clean Water” program educational materials developed by the various watershed groups specifically related to these issues on the stormwater management webpage.
3. The district passed a post‐construction stormwater board resolution to require implementation of the stormwater standards for construction.
4. Adequately maintains vegetation around stormwater facilities, ditches, and ponds. 5. Provide training to applicable staff and confirm training from contractors including restrictions on the
use of phosphorous containing fertilizers, soaps, cleaners and other chemicals that could impact the separate storm drain system.
GCPS strives to be good stewards of the land within their jurisdiction and to use appropriate Best Management
Practices (BMPs) to contribute to the improvement of water quality. GCPS is committed to practicing sound
stormwater management practices; including observance and adherence to all local, state, and federal stormwater
statutes, rules, and regulations.
Attachments: TMDL Screening Inspection Log Storm Sewer System Site Map Analytical Results & Chain of Custody cc: AE200001 project file
TMDL Screening Inspection Log
ID Number: Long:
Type:
Outfall Dimensions
Flow Characteristics
Sample ID And Information Lab Analysis: Results: TMDL Threshold: Units: Photo ID:
7.98 6.5 ‐ 9 pH units
16.6 N/A Celsius
115.3 300 CFU per 100mL
N/A N/A ug/L
Building:
Samplers:
Burger Transition Center
Steven RipleyKellie Das
Structure Type Catch Basin
South of main entrance in grass
42.332873 83.339651
Location:
Yes, Trickle
Rainfall
Trickle
Lat:
Garden City Public Schools
5/15/2020
TMDL Sampling
Client:
Date
Inspection Type:
Standing Water Characteristics
Standing Water:
Clear
No
Flow Odor
Velocity of Flow:
Structure Information:
Observations:
12”
Discharge Point
BTC‐04.CB.DP
No
No
No
No
No
Abnormal Growth:
Sewage:
Oil Sheen:
No
Algae:
Bacterial Sheen:
UnlikelyOutfall Characterization:
Sample sent to Lab:
Total Rainfall (Inches): 0.77
Sample ID:
Temperature:
pH:
E. coli:
Total Phosphorus:
Other:
Other:
Other:
Time Collected:
Current Weather:
Last Rain Event:
Screening Location Type:
No
Staining:
Suds:
Odor:
Color:
Clear
No
Yes
No
Flow Observed:
Source of Flow:
Color of Flow:
Additional Comments:
BTC‐04.CB.DP TMDL
11:20 AM
< 48 Hours
Overcast
Catch Basin
Yes
Slimes:
Arch Environmental Group
37720 Interchange Drive,
Farmington Hills MI 48370
Phone: (248) 426‐0135
Fax: (248) 426‐0136
www.archenvgroup.com
2105 Pless Drive Brighton, Michigan 48114 Phone (810)229-7575 Fax (810)229-8650 E-mail [email protected]
TM
May 18, 2020
Arch Environmental Group
37720 Interchange Dr.
Farmington Hills, MI 48335
Subject: Burger Transition Center TMDL
AE200001-GCPS
Dear Ms. Sendra :
The invoice for this project will be emailed separately. If you have any questions
concerning the data or invoice, please don't hesitate to contact our office. We
welcome your comments and suggestions to improve our quality systems. Please
reference Brighton Analytical, L.L.C. Project ID 65024 when calling or emailing.
We thank you for this opportunity to partner with you on this project and hope to
work with you again in the future.
Thank you for making Brighton Analytical, L.L.C. your laboratory of choice.
Attached are the results for the samples submitted on 05/15/2020 for the above
mentioned project. NELAP/TNI Accredited Analysis and EGLE Drinking Water
Certified Analysis will be identified in their respective reporting formats. Hard
copies can be supplied at your request for a fee of $20.00 per copy.
Sincerely,
Brighton Analytical, L.L.C.
Environment, Great Lakes, and Energy
Report Date: 05/18/2020
Sample ID:
Brighton Analytical LLC
2105 Pless Drive
Brighton, Michigan 48114
Phone: (810)229-7575 (810)229-8650
e-mail:[email protected]
EGLE Certified #9404
NELAC Accredited #176507
Arch Environmental Group
37720 Interchange Dr.
Farmington Hills, MI 48335
BTC-04.CB.DP TMDL
05/15/2020
05/15/2020Sample Date:
Submit Date:
Burger Transition Center TMDLProject Name:
Project Number:
BA Report Number: 65024
Parameters Result Units DL Method Reference
Analysis
Date
BA Sample ID: CM05370 AE200001-GCPS
Analyst
To:
Microbiological Analysis
E. coli 1.0 SM9223B M Well 05/15/2020WTCFU/100 ml115.3
DL=Reported detection limit for analytical method requested. Some compounds require special
analytical methods to achieve EGLE designated target detection limits (TDL).
Released by
Date 5/18/2020
1
Report Date: 05/18/2020
Sample ID:
Brighton Analytical LLC
2105 Pless Drive
Brighton, Michigan 48114
Phone: (810)229-7575 (810)229-8650
e-mail:[email protected]
EGLE Certified #9404
NELAC Accredited #176507
Arch Environmental Group
37720 Interchange Dr.
Farmington Hills, MI 48335
Blank-Dip Cup TMDL
05/15/2020
05/15/2020Sample Date:
Submit Date:
Cambridge-Garden City High SchoolProject Name:
Project Number:
BA Report Number: 65025
Parameters Result Units DL Method Reference
Analysis
Date
BA Sample ID: CM05375 AE200001-GCPS
Analyst
To:
Microbiological Analysis
E. coli 1.0 SM9223B M Well 05/15/2020WTCFU/100 ml0
DL=Reported detection limit for analytical method requested. Some compounds require special
analytical methods to achieve EGLE designated target detection limits (TDL).
Released by
Date 5/18/2020
1
www.archenvgroup.com
healthAIR - Industrial Hygiene Services cleanWATER - Consulting & Testing Services
safeEARTH - Hazardous Waste & Recycling Services
DETROIT GRAND RAPIDS CHICAGO (248) 426-0165 (616) 930-4116 (847) 462-9687 Farmington Hills, MI Cedar Springs, MI Cary, IL
June 18, 2020 Mr. Neil Greene Director of Operations Garden City Public Schools 33980 Marquette Garden City, Michigan 48135 [email protected] RE: Project # AE200001 GCPS Total Maximum Daily Load (TMDL) Sampling Report Cambridge High School - Garden City High School Complex Dear Mr. Greene: Arch Environmental Group, Inc. recently conducted a round of TMDL Wet Weather Sampling at discharge points GCC-14.MH.DP, GCC-46.MH.DP, GCC-62.MH.DP, and GCC-70.CB.DP at the Cambridge High School - Garden City High School Complex on May 15, 2020, in accordance with the applicable NPDES Permit requirements. TMDL sampling is used to determine the level of specific pollutants in the stormwater system by collecting samples from 50% of the district’s stormwater outfalls/discharge points during a representative wet weather event. The sampling results are then evaluated to determine if a particular point source needs to be addressed to reduce the pollutant load of the receiving waters. A report regarding the findings of this round of TMDL Sampling is attached. If you have questions regarding this report, please feel free to contact please feel free to contact the cleanWATER team at (248) 426-0165. Sincerely, Arch Environmental Group, Inc. Environmental Services
Kellie Das Certified Industrial Site Stormwater Operator, I-16237
TMDL Sampling Report Page 2 Project # AE200001 GCPS Cambridge High School – Garden City High School Complex
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1.0 Project Summary 2.0 TMDL Sampling Procedures 3.0 TMDL Sampling Results 4.0 Conclusion 5.0 Best Management Practices to Reduce TMDL Pollutant Loads
Attachments: TMDL Screening Inspection Logs Storm Sewer System Site Map Analytical Results & Chain of Custody
TMDL Sampling Report Page 3 Project # AE200001 GCPS Cambridge High School – Garden City High School Complex
1.0 / Project Summary Arch Environmental Group, Inc. (AEG) recently conducted a round of Total Maximum Daily Load (TMDL) Sampling for E. coli at discharge locations GCC-14.MH.DP, GCC-46.MH.DP, GCC-62.MH.DP, and GCC-70.CB.DP at the Cambridge High School - Garden City High School Complex on May 15, 2020, in accordance with the applicable National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) Permit requirements.
A TMDL describes the process used to determine how much of a pollutant a lake or stream can assimilate and sets pollutant reduction targets for that water body. NPDES Municipal Separate Storm Sewer System (MS4) permits require regulated public entities located within urbanized areas that discharge storm water to an MS4 which leads to a water body designated with a TMDL, to demonstrate progress toward meeting Water Quality Standards (WQS). If the TMDL was written for E. coli or Total Phosphorus (TP), the MS4 permits further require permittees to collect representative samples of storm water discharges from their points of discharge to MS4s which lead to the impacted water bodies.1 Based on a review of the sampling results, Stormwater Best Management Practices (BMP) implementation will be reviewed and BMPs may be updated to ensure progress toward achieving TMDL pollutant load reductions.
Monitoring is not required for Biota/Sediment TMDLs under the MS4 permits.2
The receiving water body of the Cambridge High School - Garden City High School Complex is the Middle Rouge River. The Rouge River has been designated with TMDLs of E. coli and Biota/Sediment, and/or Dissolved Oxygen. Further details on the TMDLs listed can be found in the documents “Total Maximum Daily Load for E. coli for the Rouge River” and “Total Maximum Daily Load for Biota for the River Rouge Watershed, Including Bishop and Tonquish Creeks”. Some examples of potential sources of E. coli in waterways include fecal material from livestock, humans, wildlife, waterfowl such as geese, and sanitary systems. Some examples of potential sources of sediment include erosion and construction activities.
2.0 / TMDL Sampling Procedures Applicable TMDL sampling was conducted with guidance from the “Storm Water Sampling Guidance for Total Phosphorus & E. coli.” Sampling was conducted at designated outfalls/discharge points during a rain event of approximately .25 inches or more. Please see the attached TMDL Screening Inspection Log for specific rainfall amounts. Sampling was conducted on May 15, 2020 and the last significant rain event was on May 14, 2020. The weather history for the rain event is available upon request.
When a dip-cup or similar sampling device was needed to collect the sample, a blank sample was collected to ensure no contamination was coming from the sampling device. The blank collected during this round of TMDL sampling came back at zero (0) CFU for E. coli indicating that the sampling device used was not contaminated. The lab results of the blank sample are attached. Furthermore, all sampling devices were decontaminated with bleach water and distilled water between each sampling location according to the protocol laid out in the “Storm Water Sampling Guidance for Total Phosphorus & E. coli.” Each location sampled was analyzed for pH and temperature while on-site and the sampled outfall/discharge point (OF/DP) was inspected for color, odor, and abnormal vegetative growth. The collected samples were delivered to an external laboratory for analysis.
3.0 / TMDL Sampling Results
1 Storm Water Sampling Guidance for Total Phosphorus & E. coli. November 24, 2009. DEQ 2 Addressing Biota TMDLs in Municipal Separate Storm Sewer System Permits” April 5, 2010. DNRE
TMDL Sampling Report Page 4 Project # AE200001 GCPS Cambridge High School – Garden City High School Complex
TMDL Benchmark Standards for E. coli:
• E. coli: The WQS for E. coli is the maximum amount of E. coli that is allowable in surface waters of the state. These standards are known as total body contact and partial body contact standards. Total body contact is a more conservative standard used during the summer to protect swimmers during total body contact and has the daily maximum of 300 CFU per 100 milliliters (mL). This applies to the warmer months of May 1st -October 31stand is the standard being used in this report. Partial body contact is the daily maximum of 1,000 CFU per 100 mL and applies to the waterways year-round. 3
Structure ID: GCC-14.MH.DP Structure Type: Manhole Location: S of GCHS, outside Door C5
At the time of the sampling, clear water flow was noted, and GCC-14.MH.DP was free of odors, and abnormal vegetative growth. AEG collected a grab sample from GCC-14.MH.DP and the sample was screened for temperature and pH in the field. An E. coli grab sample was delivered to an external laboratory for analysis. Results from the sampling are summarized below. A more detailed TMDL Screening Inspection Log is also attached at the end of the report.
Parameter: Results: TMDL Benchmark Standard: Units: pH 7.67 6.5 - 9 pH Units Temperature 16.1 N/A Celsius E. coli 1553.1 300 CFU per 100mL Total Phosphorus N/A N/A ug/L
The sample results for GCC-14.MH.DP did not identify elevated levels of pH above the TMDL Benchmark Standards. However, highlighted values in the tables above indicate that for outfall location GCC-14.MH.DP, the reported levels for E. coli (1553.1 CFU) are above the Michigan Public Health Department standards for Total Body Contact (E. coli >300 CFU).
Structure ID: GCC-46.MH.DP Structure Type: Manhole Location: NE of Cambridge HS, just N of parking lot in grass between sidewalk and lot
At the time of the sampling, clear water flow was noted, and GCC-46.MH.DP was free of odors, and abnormal vegetative growth. AEG collected a grab sample from GCC-46.MH.DP and the sample was screened for temperature and pH in the field. An E. coli grab sample was delivered to an external laboratory for analysis. Results from the sampling are summarized below. A more detailed TMDL Screening Inspection Log is also attached at the end of the report.
Parameter: Results: TMDL Benchmark Standard: Units: pH 7.71 6.5 - 9 pH Units Temperature 15.8 N/A Celsius E. coli 1732.9 300 CFU per 100mL Total Phosphorus N/A N/A ug/L
3 “Michigan’s E. Coli Water Quality Standard Guidance” May, 2016. MDEQ
TMDL Sampling Report Page 5 Project # AE200001 GCPS Cambridge High School – Garden City High School Complex
The sample results for GCC-46.MH.DP did not identify elevated levels of pH above the TMDL Benchmark Standards. However, highlighted values in the tables above indicate that for outfall location GCC-46.MH.DP, the reported levels for E. coli (1732.9 CFU) are above the Michigan Public Health Department standards for Total Body Contact (E. coli >300 CFU).
Structure ID: GCC-62.MH.DP Structure Type: Manhole Location: SW corner of school in grass by bus loop
At the time of the sampling, clear water flow was noted, and GCC-62.MH.DP was free of odors, and abnormal vegetative growth. AEG collected a grab sample from GCC-62.MH.DP and the sample was screened for temperature and pH in the field. An E. coli grab sample was delivered to an external laboratory for analysis. Results from the sampling are summarized below. A more detailed TMDL Screening Inspection Log is also attached at the end of the report.
Parameter: Results: TMDL Benchmark Standard: Units: pH 8.08 6.5 - 9 pH Units Temperature 15.2 N/A Celsius E. coli 648.8 300 CFU per 100mL Total Phosphorus N/A N/A ug/L
The sample results for GCC-62.MH.DP did not identify elevated levels of pH above the TMDL Benchmark Standards. However, highlighted values in the tables above indicate that for outfall location GCC-62.MH.DP, the reported levels for E. coli (648.8 CFU) are above the Michigan Public Health Department standards for Total Body Contact (E. coli >300 CFU).
Structure ID: GCC-70.CB.DP Structure Type: Catch Basin Location: SE corner of GCHS, just E of drive in grass
At the time of the sampling, clear water flow was noted, and GCC-70.CB.DP was free of odors, and abnormal vegetative growth. AEG collected a grab sample from GCC-70.CB.DP and the sample was screened for temperature and pH in the field. An E. coli grab sample was delivered to an external laboratory for analysis. Results from the sampling are summarized below. A more detailed TMDL Screening Inspection Log is also attached at the end of the report.
Parameter: Results: TMDL Benchmark Standard: Units: pH 8.32 6.5 - 9 pH Units Temperature 16.4 N/A Celsius E. coli 1986.3 300 CFU per 100mL Total Phosphorus N/A N/A ug/L
The sample results for GCC-70.CB.DP did not identify elevated levels of pH above the TMDL Benchmark Standards. However, highlighted values in the tables above indicate that for outfall location GCC-70.CB.DP, the reported levels for E. coli (1986.3 CFU) are above the Michigan Public Health Department standards for Total Body Contact (E. coli >300 CFU).
TMDL Sampling Report Page 6 Project # AE200001 GCPS Cambridge High School – Garden City High School Complex
4.0 / Conclusion AEG did not identify any elevated levels of pH above the TMDL Benchmark Standards for discharge locations GCC-14.MH.DP, GCC-46.MH.DP, GCC-62.MH.DP, and GCC-70.CB.DP sampled at the Cambridge High School - Garden City High School Complex on May 15, 2020. However, AEG did identify elevated levels of E. coli above the TMDL Benchmark Standards for discharge locations GCC-14.MH.DP, GCC-46.MH.DP, GCC-62.MH.DP, and GCC-70.CB.DP.
Arch Environmental Group, Inc. recommends that the elevated locations GCC-14.MH.DP, GCC-46.MH.DP, GCC-62.MH.DP, and GCC-70.CB.DP be re-assessed each permit cycle (two rounds of sampling occur per permit cycle) to ascertain whether greater or reduced potential for E. coli TMDL contribution has occurred. Additionally, these sites will be monitored annually during regularly scheduled Routine Storm sewer Structural Inspections for changes in conditions or site activities.
Geese, gulls and ducks are speculated to be a major bacterial source in urban areas, particularly where large populations congregate. E. coli (Escherichia Coli) is a sub-group of the fecal coliform group and can be used as an indicator of fecal contamination. E. coli bacteria exist in animal and human fecal matter.4 Elevated levels of E. coli typically occur at sites which have leaking sanitary sewer systems, failed septic systems, or populations of wild or domesticated animals. E. coli originating from birds, raccoons and other wildlife may be present in large numbers in stormwater runoff. In an effort to determine the cause of the benchmark exceedance of E. coli, Arch Environmental Group reviewed the layout of the school storm water system as well as past tracer dye studies. Based on this investigation, sanitary sewer contamination from Cambridge High School - Garden City High School Complex is not suspected. The source is likely natural sources, such as the presence of wild animals in the various open fields on the property.
5.0 / Best Management Practices to Reduce TMDL Pollutant Loads The Garden City Public Schools’ Stormwater Management Plan (SWMP) identifies and defines the districts BMPs to comply with the Six Minimum Measures that are the front line in the nationwide effort to reducing polluted stormwater discharges to our lake, rivers and streams. The Michigan Department of Environment, Great Lakes, and Energy recognizes that having a Stormwater Management Plan in place built around the Six Minimum Measures specified in the NPDES General Jurisdictional Permit have the potential to significantly contribute to the reduction of TMDL Pollutants in the surface waters of the state. A link to the district’s current SWMP can be found on the district’s website at http://cms.revize.com/revize/gardencityschools/document_center/StudentServices/GCPS%20SWMP%202016%20V2%20Revised%207-19-18.pdf .The Six Minimum Measures are listed below:
• Public Education and Outreach Program (PEP) • Public Involvement and Participation Program (PIP) • Illicit Discharge Elimination Program (IDEP) • Post Construction Stormwater Management Program • Construction Site Stormwater Runoff Control Program • Pollution Prevention/Good Housekeeping Program.
4 Sources of E. coli In Surface Water” - Great Lakes Water Institute, University of Wisconsin, Milwaukee http://www.glwi.uwm.edu/research/genomics/ecoli/sources_of_ecoli_in_water.php
TMDL Sampling Report Page 7 Project # AE200001 GCPS Cambridge High School – Garden City High School Complex
The following is a list of prioritized TMDL best management practices from the districts SWMP that Garden City Public Schools should continue to implement in order to improve water quality impairments associated with the E. coli and Biota/Sediment TMDL of the Rouge River. Prioritization of BMPs is based on Garden City Public Schools targeted TMDL pollutants. Priority is given to BMPs that reduce E. coli loads and address water quality for biota.
E. COLI 1. GCPS will use its website to provide the public with information regarding pet waste (SEMCOG links).
Additionally, SEMCOG pet waste posters are placed at various school buildings. 2. GCPS will prohibit illicit discharges, inspect and monitor suspected illicit discharges, and enforce
elimination of the illicit discharges and connections. 3. GCPS has reviewed all facilities for cross-connections between the sanitary and storm sewer systems. 4. GCPS will conduct bimonthly inspections of parking lot and curb areas and hand clean as needed. 5. GCPS has established programs for soil erosion and sediment control from new or redevelopment
construction. Such developments require permits and inspections for practices to keep exposed soils on site or controlled from runoff.
6. GCPS has implemented routine visual inspections of stormwater structural controls. 7. GCPS will remove excessive sediments from structural sediment removal systems to maintain the
maximum designed performance. Sediments will be disposed of offsite in accordance with Parts 115 or 121.
ALL TMDLs 1. GCPS will continue to use its website to provide the public information regarding local TMDL issues
(E. coli and biota TMDL Best Management Practice). 2. GCPS will continue to educate staff, faculty, and students using various venues including the “Seven
Simple Steps to Clean Water” program educational materials developed by the various watershed groups specifically related to these issues on the stormwater management webpage.
3. The district passed a post-construction stormwater board resolution to require implementation of the stormwater standards for construction.
4. Adequately maintains vegetation around stormwater facilities, ditches, and ponds. 5. Provide training to applicable staff and confirm training from contractors including restrictions on the
use of phosphorous containing fertilizers, soaps, cleaners and other chemicals that could impact the separate storm drain system.
GCPS strives to be good stewards of the land within their jurisdiction and to use appropriate Best Management Practices (BMPs) to contribute to the improvement of water quality. GCPS is committed to practicing sound stormwater management practices; including observance and adherence to all local, state, and federal stormwater statutes, rules, and regulations. Attachments: TMDL Screening Inspection Logs Storm Sewer System Site Map Analytical Results & Chain of Custody cc: AE200001 project file
TMDL Screening Inspection Log
ID Number: Long:Type:Outfall Dimensions
Flow Characteristics
Sample ID And Information Lab Analysis: Results: TMDL Threshold: Units: Photo ID:7.67 6.5 - 9 pH units16.1 N/A Celsius
1553.1 300 CFU per 100mLN/A N/A ug/L
Building:Samplers:
Garden City-Cambridge High School ComplexSteven RipleyKellie Das
Structure Type Manhole
South of GCHS, outside door C5
42.200502 83.194385
Location:
Yes, ContinousRoof and field drainsSlow
Lat:
Garden City Public Schools5/15/2020
TMDL Sampling
Client:Date
Inspection Type:
Standing Water CharacteristicsStanding Water:
ClearNo
Flow Odor
Velocity of Flow:
Structure Information:
Observations:12”Discharge PointGCC-14.MH.DP
NoNoNoNoNo
Abnormal Growth:
Sewage:Oil Sheen:
No
Algae:Bacterial Sheen:
UnlikelyOutfall Characterization:
Sample sent to Lab:
Total Rainfall (Inches): .77
Sample ID:Temperature: pH:
E. coli:Total Phosphorus:Other:Other:Other:
Time Collected:
Current Weather:Last Rain Event:
Screening Location Type:
NoStaining:
Suds:Odor:Color:
ClearNo
Yes
No
Flow Observed:Source of Flow:
Color of Flow:
Additional Comments:
GCC-14.MH.DP TMDL 9:30 AM< 48 HoursPartly CloudyManhole
Yes
Slimes:
Arch Environmental Group37720 Interchange Drive, Farmington Hills MI 48370
Phone: (248) 426-0135Fax: (248) 426-0136
www.archenvgroup.com
TMDL Screening Inspection Log
ID Number: Long:Type:Outfall Dimensions
Flow Characteristics
Sample ID And Information Lab Analysis: Results: TMDL Threshold: Units: Photo ID:7.71 6.5 - 9 pH units15.8 N/A Celsius
1732.9 300 CFU per 100mLN/A N/A ug/L
Sample ID: GCC-46.MH.DP TMDL pH:Time Collected: 9:50 AM Temperature: Last Rain Event: < 48 Hours E. coli:
Current Weather: Partly Cloudy Total Phosphorus:Sample Location Type: Manhole Other:Total Rainfall (Inches) .77 Other:
Other:UnlikelyOutfall Characterization:
Flow Odor NoOil Sheen:
Staining:Suds:
Sewage: Additional Comments:Bacterial Sheen: No
Algae: NoSlimes: No
Abnormal Growth: Yes
Lat: 42.201127 83.193738Northeast of Cambridge HS, just north of parking lot in grass between sidewalk and lot
Observations:Standing Water Characteristics
Color of Flow: ClearOdor:
Standing Water: Yes Yes, Continous
Discharge Point
Downstream basins
NoNo
Clear Source of Flow:NoNoNo
Flow Observed:
12”
Velocity of Flow: Slow
Structure Information:GCC-46.MH.DP Structure Type
Color:
Location:
Building: Garden City-Cambridge High School Complex
Manhole
Inspectors: Kellie Das Steven RipleyClient:
Sample sent to Lab: Yes
Garden City Public SchoolsDate 5/15/2020
Inspection Type: TMDL Sampling
Arch Environmental Group37720 Interchange Drive, Farmington Hills MI 48370
Phone: (248) 426-0135Fax: (248) 426-0136
www.archenvgroup.com
TMDL Screening Inspection Log
ID Number: Long:Type:Outfall Dimensions
Flow Characteristics
Sample ID And Information Lab Analysis: Results: TMDL Threshold: Units: Photo ID:8.08 6.5 - 9 pH units15.2 N/A Celsius
648.8 300 CFU per 100mLN/A N/A ug/L
Oil Sheen: NoSewage: No Additional Comments:
Bacterial Sheen: NoAlgae: No
Slimes: NoAbnormal Growth: No
9:00 AM Temperature: Last Rain Event: < 48 Hours E. coli:
Current Weather: Partly Cloudy Total Phosphorus:Sample Location Type: Manhole Other:Total Rainfall (Inches):
Odor: No Velocity of Flow: SlowSuds: No Color of Flow: Clear
Staining: No Flow Odor No
Color: Clear Source of Flow: Downstream basins
Discharge Point Location: Southwest corner of school in grass by bus loop18”
Observations:Standing Water Characteristics
Standing Water: Yes Flow Observed: Yes, Continous
Building: Garden City-Cambridge High School ComplexInspectors: Kellie Das Steven Ripley
Structure Information:GCC-62.MH.DP Structure Type Manhole Lat: 42.195918 83.194978
Outfall Characterization:
Sample sent to Lab: Yes
Sample ID: GCC-62.MH.DP TMDL pH:Time Collected:
.77 Other:Other:
Unlikely
Client: Garden City Public SchoolsDate 5/15/2020
Inspection Type: TMDL Sampling
Arch Environmental Group37720 Interchange Drive, Farmington Hills MI 48370
Phone: (248) 426-0135Fax: (248) 426-0136
www.archenvgroup.com
TMDL Screening Inspection Log
ID Number: Long:Type:Outfall Dimensions
Flow Characteristics
Sample ID And Information Lab Analysis: Results: TMDL Threshold: Units: Photo ID:8.32 6.5 - 9 pH units16.4 N/A Celsius
1986.3 300 CFU per 100mLN/A N/A ug/L
Sample ID: GCC-70.CB.DP TMDL pH:Time Collected: 9:20 AM Temperature: Last Rain Event: < 48 Hours E. coli:
Current Weather: Partly Cloudy Total Phosphorus:Sample Location Type: Catch Basin Other:Total Rainfall (Inches): .77 Other:
Other:Unlikely
Staining: No Flow Odor NoOil Sheen: No
Sewage: No Additional Comments:Bacterial Sheen: No
Algae: NoSlimes: No
Abnormal Growth: No
Color: Clear Source of Flow: Downstream basins Odor: No Velocity of Flow: SlowSuds: No Color of Flow: Clear
Catch Basin Lat: 42.200201 83.194424Discharge Point Location: Southeast corner of GCHS, just east of drive in grass12”
Observations:Standing Water Characteristics
Standing Water: Yes Flow Observed: Yes, Continous
Building: Garden City-Cambridge High School ComplexInspectors: Kellie Das Steven Ripley
Outfall Characterization:
Sample sent to Lab: Yes
5/15/2020Inspection Type: TMDL Sampling
Date
Structure Information:GCC-70.CB.DP Structure Type
Client: Garden City Public Schools
Arch Environmental Group37720 Interchange Drive, Farmington Hills MI 48370
Phone: (248) 426-0135Fax: (248) 426-0136
www.archenvgroup.com
2105 Pless Drive Brighton, Michigan 48114 Phone (810)229-7575 Fax (810)229-8650 E-mail [email protected]
TM
May 18, 2020
Arch Environmental Group
37720 Interchange Dr.
Farmington Hills, MI 48335
Subject: Cambridge-Garden City High School
AE200001-GCPS
Dear Ms. Sendra :
The invoice for this project will be emailed separately. If you have any questions
concerning the data or invoice, please don't hesitate to contact our office. We
welcome your comments and suggestions to improve our quality systems. Please
reference Brighton Analytical, L.L.C. Project ID 65025 when calling or emailing.
We thank you for this opportunity to partner with you on this project and hope to
work with you again in the future.
Thank you for making Brighton Analytical, L.L.C. your laboratory of choice.
Attached are the results for the samples submitted on 05/15/2020 for the above
mentioned project. NELAP/TNI Accredited Analysis and EGLE Drinking Water
Certified Analysis will be identified in their respective reporting formats. Hard
copies can be supplied at your request for a fee of $20.00 per copy.
Sincerely,
Brighton Analytical, L.L.C.
Environment, Great Lakes, and Energy
Report Date: 05/18/2020
Sample ID:
Brighton Analytical LLC
2105 Pless Drive
Brighton, Michigan 48114
Phone: (810)229-7575 (810)229-8650
e-mail:[email protected]
EGLE Certified #9404
NELAC Accredited #176507
Arch Environmental Group
37720 Interchange Dr.
Farmington Hills, MI 48335
GCC-62.MH.DP TMDL
05/15/2020
05/15/2020Sample Date:
Submit Date:
Cambridge-Garden City High SchoolProject Name:
Project Number:
BA Report Number: 65025
Parameters Result Units DL Method Reference
Analysis
Date
BA Sample ID: CM05371 AE200001-GCPS
Analyst
To:
Microbiological Analysis
E. coli 1.0 SM9223B M Well 05/15/2020WTCFU/100 ml648.8
DL=Reported detection limit for analytical method requested. Some compounds require special
analytical methods to achieve EGLE designated target detection limits (TDL).
Released by
Date 5/18/2020
1
Report Date: 05/18/2020
Sample ID:
Brighton Analytical LLC
2105 Pless Drive
Brighton, Michigan 48114
Phone: (810)229-7575 (810)229-8650
e-mail:[email protected]
EGLE Certified #9404
NELAC Accredited #176507
Arch Environmental Group
37720 Interchange Dr.
Farmington Hills, MI 48335
GCC-70.CB.DP TMDL
05/15/2020
05/15/2020Sample Date:
Submit Date:
Cambridge-Garden City High SchoolProject Name:
Project Number:
BA Report Number: 65025
Parameters Result Units DL Method Reference
Analysis
Date
BA Sample ID: CM05372 AE200001-GCPS
Analyst
To:
Microbiological Analysis
E. coli 1.0 SM9223B M Well 05/15/2020WTCFU/100 ml1986.3
DL=Reported detection limit for analytical method requested. Some compounds require special
analytical methods to achieve EGLE designated target detection limits (TDL).
Released by
Date 5/18/2020
1
Report Date: 05/18/2020
Sample ID:
Brighton Analytical LLC
2105 Pless Drive
Brighton, Michigan 48114
Phone: (810)229-7575 (810)229-8650
e-mail:[email protected]
EGLE Certified #9404
NELAC Accredited #176507
Arch Environmental Group
37720 Interchange Dr.
Farmington Hills, MI 48335
GCC-14.MH.DP TMDL
05/15/2020
05/15/2020Sample Date:
Submit Date:
Cambridge-Garden City High SchoolProject Name:
Project Number:
BA Report Number: 65025
Parameters Result Units DL Method Reference
Analysis
Date
BA Sample ID: CM05373 AE200001-GCPS
Analyst
To:
Microbiological Analysis
E. coli 1.0 SM9223B M Well 05/15/2020WTCFU/100 ml1553.1
DL=Reported detection limit for analytical method requested. Some compounds require special
analytical methods to achieve EGLE designated target detection limits (TDL).
Released by
Date 5/18/2020
1
Report Date: 05/18/2020
Sample ID:
Brighton Analytical LLC
2105 Pless Drive
Brighton, Michigan 48114
Phone: (810)229-7575 (810)229-8650
e-mail:[email protected]
EGLE Certified #9404
NELAC Accredited #176507
Arch Environmental Group
37720 Interchange Dr.
Farmington Hills, MI 48335
GCC-46.MH.DP TMDL
05/15/2020
05/15/2020Sample Date:
Submit Date:
Cambridge-Garden City High SchoolProject Name:
Project Number:
BA Report Number: 65025
Parameters Result Units DL Method Reference
Analysis
Date
BA Sample ID: CM05374 AE200001-GCPS
Analyst
To:
Microbiological Analysis
E. coli 1.0 SM9223B M Well 05/15/2020WTCFU/100 ml1732.9
DL=Reported detection limit for analytical method requested. Some compounds require special
analytical methods to achieve EGLE designated target detection limits (TDL).
Released by
Date 5/18/2020
1
Report Date: 05/18/2020
Sample ID:
Brighton Analytical LLC
2105 Pless Drive
Brighton, Michigan 48114
Phone: (810)229-7575 (810)229-8650
e-mail:[email protected]
EGLE Certified #9404
NELAC Accredited #176507
Arch Environmental Group
37720 Interchange Dr.
Farmington Hills, MI 48335
Blank-Dip Cup TMDL
05/15/2020
05/15/2020Sample Date:
Submit Date:
Cambridge-Garden City High SchoolProject Name:
Project Number:
BA Report Number: 65025
Parameters Result Units DL Method Reference
Analysis
Date
BA Sample ID: CM05375 AE200001-GCPS
Analyst
To:
Microbiological Analysis
E. coli 1.0 SM9223B M Well 05/15/2020WTCFU/100 ml0
DL=Reported detection limit for analytical method requested. Some compounds require special
analytical methods to achieve EGLE designated target detection limits (TDL).
Released by
Date 5/18/2020
1
www.archenvgroup.com
healthAIR - Industrial Hygiene Services cleanWATER - Consulting & Testing Services
safeEARTH - Hazardous Waste & Recycling Services
DETROIT GRAND RAPIDS CHICAGO (248) 426-0165 (616) 930-4116 (847) 462-9687 Farmington Hills, MI Cedar Springs, MI Cary, IL
June 14, 2020 Mr. Neil Greene Director of Operations Garden City Public Schools 33980 Marquette Garden City, Michigan 48135 [email protected] RE: Project # AE200001 GCPS Total Maximum Daily Load (TMDL) Sampling Report Douglas 3-4 Campus Dear Mr. Greene: Arch Environmental Group, Inc. recently conducted a round of TMDL Wet Weather Sampling at discharge points DGS-01.CB.DP, DGS-09.CB.DP, and DGS-19.CB.DP at the Douglas 3-4 Campus on May 15, 2020, in accordance with the applicable NPDES Permit requirements. TMDL sampling is used to determine the level of specific pollutants in the stormwater system by collecting samples from 50% of the district’s stormwater outfalls/discharge points during a representative wet weather event. The sampling results are then evaluated to determine if a particular point source needs to be addressed to reduce the pollutant load of the receiving waters. A report regarding the findings of this round of TMDL Sampling is attached. If you have questions regarding this report, please feel free to contact please feel free to contact the cleanWATER team at (248) 426-0165. Sincerely, Arch Environmental Group, Inc. Environmental Services
Kellie Das Certified Industrial Site Stormwater Operator, I-16237
TMDL Sampling Report Page 2 Project # AE200001 GCPS Douglas 3-4 Campus
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1.0 Project Summary 2.0 TMDL Sampling Procedures 3.0 TMDL Sampling Results 4.0 Conclusion 5.0 Best Management Practices to Reduce TMDL Pollutant Loads
Attachments: TMDL Screening Inspection Logs Storm Sewer System Site Map Analytical Results & Chain of Custody
TMDL Sampling Report Page 3 Project # AE200001 GCPS Douglas 3-4 Campus
1.0 / Project Summary Arch Environmental Group, Inc. (AEG) recently conducted a round of Total Maximum Daily Load (TMDL) Sampling for E. coli at discharge location DGS-01.CB.DP, DGS-09.CB.DP, and DGS-19.CB.DP at the Douglas 3-4 Campus on May 15, 2020, in accordance with the applicable National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) Permit requirements.
A TMDL describes the process used to determine how much of a pollutant a lake or stream can assimilate and sets pollutant reduction targets for that water body. NPDES Municipal Separate Storm Sewer System (MS4) permits require regulated public entities located within urbanized areas that discharge storm water to an MS4 which leads to a water body designated with a TMDL, to demonstrate progress toward meeting Water Quality Standards (WQS). If the TMDL was written for E. coli or Total Phosphorus (TP), the MS4 permits further require permittees to collect representative samples of storm water discharges from their points of discharge to MS4s which lead to the impacted water bodies.1 Based on a review of the sampling results, Stormwater Best Management Practices (BMP) implementation will be reviewed and BMPs may be updated to ensure progress toward achieving TMDL pollutant load reductions.
Monitoring is not required for Biota/Sediment TMDLs under the MS4 permits.2
The receiving water body of the Douglas 3-4 Campus is the Middle Rouge River. The Rouge River has been designated with TMDLs of E. coli and Biota/Sediment, and/or Dissolved Oxygen. Further details on the TMDLs listed can be found in the documents “Total Maximum Daily Load for E. coli for the Rouge River” and “Total Maximum Daily Load for Biota for the River Rouge Watershed, Including Bishop and Tonquish Creeks”. Some examples of potential sources of E. coli in waterways include fecal material from livestock, humans, wildlife, waterfowl such as geese, and sanitary systems. Some examples of potential sources of sediment include erosion and construction activities.
2.0 / TMDL Sampling Procedures Applicable TMDL sampling was conducted with guidance from the “Storm Water Sampling Guidance for Total Phosphorus & E. coli.” Sampling was conducted at designated outfalls/discharge points during a rain event of approximately .25 inches or more. Please see the attached TMDL Screening Inspection Log for specific rainfall amounts. Sampling was conducted on May 15, 2020 and the last significant rain event was on May 14, 2020. The weather history for the rain event is available upon request.
When a dip-cup or similar sampling device was needed to collect the sample, a blank sample was collected to ensure no contamination was coming from the sampling device. The blank collected during this round of TMDL sampling came back at zero (0) CFU for E. coli indicating that the sampling device used was not contaminated. The lab results of the blank sample are attached. Furthermore, all sampling devices were decontaminated with bleach water and distilled water between each sampling location according to the protocol laid out in the “Storm Water Sampling Guidance for Total Phosphorus & E. coli.” Each location sampled was analyzed for pH and temperature while on-site and the sampled outfall/discharge point (OF/DP) was inspected for color, odor, and abnormal vegetative growth. The collected samples were delivered to an external laboratory for analysis.
3.0 / TMDL Sampling Results
1 Storm Water Sampling Guidance for Total Phosphorus & E. coli. November 24, 2009. DEQ 2 Addressing Biota TMDLs in Municipal Separate Storm Sewer System Permits” April 5, 2010. DNRE
TMDL Sampling Report Page 4 Project # AE200001 GCPS Douglas 3-4 Campus
TMDL Benchmark Standards for E. coli:
• E. coli: The WQS for E. coli is the maximum amount of E. coli that is allowable in surface waters of the state. These standards are known as total body contact and partial body contact standards. Total body contact is a more conservative standard used during the summer to protect swimmers during total body contact and has the daily maximum of 300 CFU per 100 milliliters (mL). This applies to the warmer months of May 1st -October 31stand is the standard being used in this report. Partial body contact is the daily maximum of 1,000 CFU per 100 mL and applies to the waterways year-round. 3
Structure ID: DGS-01.CB.DP Structure Type: Catch Basin Location: SW side of S parking lot, middle of lot
At the time of the sampling, clear water flow was noted, and DGS-01.CB.DP was free of odors, and abnormal vegetative growth. AEG collected a grab sample from DGS-01.CB.DP and the sample was screened for temperature and pH in the field. An E. coli was delivered to an external laboratory for analysis. Results from the sampling are summarized below. A more detailed TMDL Screening Inspection Log is also attached at the end of the report.
Parameter: Results: TMDL Benchmark Standard: Units: pH 8.8 6.5 - 9 pH Units Temperature 16.8 N/A Celsius E. coli 2.1 300 CFU per 100mL Total Phosphorus N/A N/A ug/L
The sample results for DGS-01.CB.DP did not identify elevated levels of pH or E. coli above the TMDL Benchmark Standards. The reported levels for E. coli (2.1 CFU) are below the Michigan Public Health Department standards for Total Body Contact (E. coli >300 CFU).
Structure ID: DGS-09.CB.DP Structure Type: Catch Basin Location: NE corner of building in grass
At the time of the sampling, clear water flow was noted, and DGS-09.CB.DP was free of odors, and abnormal vegetative growth. AEG collected a grab sample from DGS-09.CB.DP and the sample was screened for temperature and pH in the field. An E. coli was delivered to an external laboratory for analysis. Results from the sampling are summarized below. A more detailed TMDL Screening Inspection Log is also attached at the end of the report.
Parameter: Results: TMDL Benchmark Standard: Units: pH 7.7 6.5 - 9 pH Units Temperature 16.7 N/A Celsius E. coli 108.2 300 CFU per 100mL Total Phosphorus N/A N/A ug/L
3 “Michigan’s E. Coli Water Quality Standard Guidance” May, 2016. MDEQ
TMDL Sampling Report Page 5 Project # AE200001 GCPS Douglas 3-4 Campus
The sample results for DGS-09.CB.DP did not identify elevated levels of pH or E. coli above the TMDL Benchmark Standards. The reported levels for E. coli (108.2 CFU) are below the Michigan Public Health Department standards for Total Body Contact (E. coli >300 CFU).
Structure ID: DGS-19.CB.DP Structure Type: Catch Basin Location: NW corner of S parking lot near entry/exit drive
At the time of the sampling, clear water flow was noted, and DGS-19.CB.DP was free of odors, and abnormal vegetative growth. AEG collected a grab sample from DGS-19.CB.DP and the sample was screened for temperature and pH in the field. An E. coli was delivered to an external laboratory for analysis. Results from the sampling are summarized below. A more detailed TMDL Screening Inspection Log is also attached at the end of the report.
Parameter: Results: TMDL Benchmark Standard: Units: pH 8.41 6.5 - 9 pH Units Temperature 17.3 N/A Celsius E. coli 187.2 300 CFU per 100mL Total Phosphorus N/A N/A ug/L
The sample results for DGS-19.CB.DP did not identify elevated levels of pH or E. coli above the TMDL Benchmark Standards. The reported levels for E. coli (187.2 CFU) are below the Michigan Public Health Department standards for Total Body Contact (E. coli >300 CFU).
4.0 / Conclusion AEG did not identify any elevated levels of pH or E. coli above the TMDL Benchmark Standards for discharge locations DGS-01.CB.DP, DGS-09.CB.DP, and DGS-19.CB.DP sampled at the Douglas 3-4 Campus on May 15, 2020.
It is the opinion of Arch Environmental Group, Inc. that the TMDL sampling results indicate good use of BMPs in maintaining TMDL pollutant load reductions at the Douglas 3-4 Campus. A list of those BMPs is provided below in section 5.0. TMDL sampling will be conducted twice per permit cycle to continue to monitor for TMDL pollutant load levels in accordance with the NPDES Permit requirements.
5.0 / Best Management Practices to Reduce TMDL Pollutant Loads The Garden City Public Schools’ Stormwater Management Plan (SWMP) identifies and defines the districts BMPs to comply with the Six Minimum Measures that are the front line in the nationwide effort to reducing polluted stormwater discharges to our lake, rivers and streams. The Michigan Department of Environment, Great Lakes, and Energy recognizes that having a Stormwater Management Plan in place built around the Six Minimum Measures specified in the NPDES General Jurisdictional Permit have the potential to significantly contribute to the reduction of TMDL Pollutants in the surface waters of the state. A link to the district’s current SWMP can be found on the district’s website at http://cms.revize.com/revize/gardencityschools/document_center/StudentServices/GCPS%20SWMP%202016%20V2%20Revised%207-19-18.pdf. The Six Minimum Measures are listed below:
• Public Education and Outreach Program (PEP)
TMDL Sampling Report Page 6 Project # AE200001 GCPS Douglas 3-4 Campus
• Public Involvement and Participation Program (PIP) • Illicit Discharge Elimination Program (IDEP) • Post Construction Stormwater Management Program • Construction Site Stormwater Runoff Control Program • Pollution Prevention/Good Housekeeping Program.
The following is a list of prioritized TMDL best management practices from the districts SWMP that Garden City Public Schools should continue to implement in order to improve water quality impairments associated with the E. coli and Biota/Sediment TMDL of the Rouge River. Prioritization of BMPs is based on Garden City Public Schools targeted TMDL pollutants. Priority is given to BMPs that reduce E. coli loads and address water quality for biota.
E. COLI 1. GCPS will use its website to provide the public with information regarding pet waste (SEMCOG links).
Additionally, SEMCOG pet waste posters are placed at various school buildings. 2. GCPS will prohibit illicit discharges, inspect and monitor suspected illicit discharges, and enforce
elimination of the illicit discharges and connections. 3. GCPS has reviewed all facilities for cross-connections between the sanitary and storm sewer systems. 4. GCPS will conduct bimonthly inspections of parking lot and curb areas and hand clean as needed. 5. GCPS has established programs for soil erosion and sediment control from new or redevelopment
construction. Such developments require permits and inspections for practices to keep exposed soils on site or controlled from runoff.
6. GCPS has implemented routine visual inspections of stormwater structural controls. 7. GCPS will remove excessive sediments from structural sediment removal systems to maintain the
maximum designed performance. Sediments will be disposed of offsite in accordance with Parts 115 or 121.
ALL TMDLs 1. GCPS will continue to use its website to provide the public information regarding local TMDL issues
(E. coli and biota TMDL Best Management Practice). 2. GCPS will continue to educate staff, faculty, and students using various venues including the “Seven
Simple Steps to Clean Water” program educational materials developed by the various watershed groups specifically related to these issues on the stormwater management webpage.
3. The district passed a post-construction stormwater board resolution to require implementation of the stormwater standards for construction.
4. Adequately maintains vegetation around stormwater facilities, ditches, and ponds. 5. Provide training to applicable staff and confirm training from contractors including restrictions on the
use of phosphorous containing fertilizers, soaps, cleaners and other chemicals that could impact the separate storm drain system.
GCPS strives to be good stewards of the land within their jurisdiction and to use appropriate Best Management Practices (BMPs) to contribute to the improvement of water quality. GCPS is committed to practicing sound stormwater management practices; including observance and adherence to all local, state, and federal stormwater statutes, rules, and regulations. Attachments: TMDL Screening Inspection Logs Storm Sewer System Site Map Analytical Results & Chain of Custody
TMDL Sampling Report Page 7 Project # AE200001 GCPS Douglas 3-4 Campus
cc: AE200001 project file
TMDL Screening Inspection Log
ID Number: Long:Type:Outfall Dimensions
Flow Characteristics
Sample ID And Information Lab Analysis: Results: TMDL Threshold: Units: Photo ID:8.8 6.5 - 9 pH units
16.8 N/A Celsius2.1 300 CFU per 100mL
N/A N/A ug/L
Building:Samplers:
Douglas 3-4 CampusSteven RipleyKellie Das
Structure Type Catch Basin
Southwest side of south parking lot, middle of lot
42.190062 83.192594
Location:
Yes, ContinousDownstream basins Trickle
Lat:
Garden City Public Schools5/15/2020
TMDL Sampling
Client:Date
Inspection Type:
Standing Water CharacteristicsStanding Water:
ClearNo
Flow Odor
Velocity of Flow:
Structure Information:
Observations:24”Discharge PointDGS-01.CB.DP
NoNoNoNoNo
Abnormal Growth:
Sewage:Oil Sheen:
No
Algae:Bacterial Sheen:
UnlikelyOutfall Characterization:
Sample sent to Lab:
Total Rainfall (Inches): .77
Sample ID:Temperature: pH:
E. coli:Total Phosphorus:Other:Other:Other:
Time Collected:
Current Weather:Last Rain Event:
Screening Location Type:
NoStaining:
Suds:Odor:Color:
ClearNo
Yes
No
Flow Observed:Source of Flow:
Color of Flow:
Additional Comments:
DGS-01.CB.DP TMDL 10:30 AM< 48 HoursPartly CloudyCatch Basin
Yes
Slimes:
Arch Environmental Group37720 Interchange Drive, Farmington Hills MI 48370
Phone: (248) 426-0135Fax: (248) 426-0136
www.archenvgroup.com
TMDL Screening Inspection Log
ID Number: Long:Type:Outfall Dimensions
Flow Characteristics
Sample ID And Information Lab Analysis: Results: TMDL Threshold: Units: Photo ID:7.7 6.5 - 9 pH units
16.7 N/A Celsius108.2 300 CFU per 100mL
N/A N/A ug/L
Sample ID: DGS-09.CB.DP TMDL pH:Time Collected: 10:45 Temperature: Last Rain Event: < 48 Hours E. coli:
Current Weather: Partly Cloudy Total Phosphorus:Sample Location Type: Catch Basin Other:Total Rainfall (Inches) .77 Other:
Other:UnlikelyOutfall Characterization:
Flow Odor NoOil Sheen:
Staining:Suds:
Sewage: Additional Comments:Bacterial Sheen: No
Algae: NoSlimes: No
Abnormal Growth: No
Lat: 42.200442 83.192198Northeast corner of building in grass
Observations:Standing Water Characteristics
Color of Flow: ClearOdor:
Standing Water: Yes Yes, Trickle
Discharge Point
Downstream basins
NoNo
Clear Source of Flow:NoNoNo
Flow Observed:
8”
Velocity of Flow: Trickle
Structure Information:DGS-09.CB.DP Structure Type
Color:
Location:
Building: Douglas 3-4 Campus
Catch Basin
Inspectors: Kellie Das Steven RipleyClient:
Sample sent to Lab: Yes
Garden City Public SchoolsDate 5/15/2020
Inspection Type: TMDL Sampling
Arch Environmental Group37720 Interchange Drive, Farmington Hills MI 48370
Phone: (248) 426-0135Fax: (248) 426-0136
www.archenvgroup.com
TMDL Screening Inspection Log
ID Number: Long:Type:Outfall Dimensions
Flow Characteristics
Sample ID And Information Lab Analysis: Results: TMDL Threshold: Units: Photo ID:8.41 6.5 - 9 pH units17.3 N/A Celsius
187.2 300 CFU per 100mLN/A N/A ug/L
Oil Sheen: NoSewage: No Additional Comments:
Bacterial Sheen: NoAlgae: No
Slimes: NoAbnormal Growth: No
10:35 AM Temperature: Last Rain Event: < 48 Hours E. coli:
Current Weather: Partly Cloudy Total Phosphorus:Sample Location Type: Catch Basin Other:Total Rainfall (Inches):
Odor: No Velocity of Flow: TrickleSuds: No Color of Flow: Clear
Staining: No Flow Odor No
Color: Clear Source of Flow: Downstream basins
Discharge Point Location: Northwest corner of south parking lot near entry/exit drive24”
Observations:Standing Water Characteristics
Standing Water: Yes Flow Observed: Yes, Trickle
Building: Douglas 3-4 CampusInspectors: Kellie Das Steven Ripley
Structure Information:DGS-19.CB.DP Structure Type Catch Basin Lat: 42.190062 83.192594
Outfall Characterization:
Sample sent to Lab: Yes
Sample ID: DGS-19.CB.DP TMDL pH:Time Collected:
.77 Other:Other:
Unlikely
Client: Garden City Public SchoolsDate 5/15/2020
Inspection Type: TMDL Sampling
Arch Environmental Group37720 Interchange Drive, Farmington Hills MI 48370
Phone: (248) 426-0135Fax: (248) 426-0136
www.archenvgroup.com
2105 Pless Drive Brighton, Michigan 48114 Phone (810)229-7575 Fax (810)229-8650 E-mail [email protected]
TM
May 18, 2020
Arch Environmental Group
37720 Interchange Dr.
Farmington Hills, MI 48335
Subject: Douglas 3-4 School TMDL
AE200001-GCPS
Dear Ms. Sendra :
The invoice for this project will be emailed separately. If you have any questions
concerning the data or invoice, please don't hesitate to contact our office. We
welcome your comments and suggestions to improve our quality systems. Please
reference Brighton Analytical, L.L.C. Project ID 65022 when calling or emailing.
We thank you for this opportunity to partner with you on this project and hope to
work with you again in the future.
Thank you for making Brighton Analytical, L.L.C. your laboratory of choice.
Attached are the results for the samples submitted on 05/15/2020 for the above
mentioned project. NELAP/TNI Accredited Analysis and EGLE Drinking Water
Certified Analysis will be identified in their respective reporting formats. Hard
copies can be supplied at your request for a fee of $20.00 per copy.
Sincerely,
Brighton Analytical, L.L.C.
Environment, Great Lakes, and Energy
Report Date: 05/18/2020
Sample ID:
Brighton Analytical LLC
2105 Pless Drive
Brighton, Michigan 48114
Phone: (810)229-7575 (810)229-8650
e-mail:[email protected]
EGLE Certified #9404
NELAC Accredited #176507
Arch Environmental Group
37720 Interchange Dr.
Farmington Hills, MI 48335
DGS-01.CB.DP TMDL
05/15/2020
05/15/2020Sample Date:
Submit Date:
Douglas 3-4 School TMDLProject Name:
Project Number:
BA Report Number: 65022
Parameters Result Units DL Method Reference
Analysis
Date
BA Sample ID: CM05366 AE200001-GCPS
Analyst
To:
Microbiological Analysis
E. coli 1.0 SM9223B M Well 05/15/2020WTCFU/100 ml2.1
DL=Reported detection limit for analytical method requested. Some compounds require special
analytical methods to achieve EGLE designated target detection limits (TDL).
Released by
Date 5/18/2020
1
Report Date: 05/18/2020
Sample ID:
Brighton Analytical LLC
2105 Pless Drive
Brighton, Michigan 48114
Phone: (810)229-7575 (810)229-8650
e-mail:[email protected]
EGLE Certified #9404
NELAC Accredited #176507
Arch Environmental Group
37720 Interchange Dr.
Farmington Hills, MI 48335
DGS-19.CB.DP TMDL
05/15/2020
05/15/2020Sample Date:
Submit Date:
Douglas 3-4 School TMDLProject Name:
Project Number:
BA Report Number: 65022
Parameters Result Units DL Method Reference
Analysis
Date
BA Sample ID: CM05367 AE200001-GCPS
Analyst
To:
Microbiological Analysis
E. coli 1.0 SM9223B M Well 05/15/2020WTCFU/100 ml108.2
DL=Reported detection limit for analytical method requested. Some compounds require special
analytical methods to achieve EGLE designated target detection limits (TDL).
Released by
Date 5/18/2020
1
Report Date: 05/18/2020
Sample ID:
Brighton Analytical LLC
2105 Pless Drive
Brighton, Michigan 48114
Phone: (810)229-7575 (810)229-8650
e-mail:[email protected]
EGLE Certified #9404
NELAC Accredited #176507
Arch Environmental Group
37720 Interchange Dr.
Farmington Hills, MI 48335
DGS-09.CB.DP TMDL
05/15/2020
05/15/2020Sample Date:
Submit Date:
Douglas 3-4 School TMDLProject Name:
Project Number:
BA Report Number: 65022
Parameters Result Units DL Method Reference
Analysis
Date
BA Sample ID: CM05368 AE200001-GCPS
Analyst
To:
Microbiological Analysis
E. coli 1.0 SM9223B M Well 05/15/2020WTCFU/100 ml187.2
DL=Reported detection limit for analytical method requested. Some compounds require special
analytical methods to achieve EGLE designated target detection limits (TDL).
Released by
Date 5/18/2020
1
Report Date: 05/18/2020
Sample ID:
Brighton Analytical LLC
2105 Pless Drive
Brighton, Michigan 48114
Phone: (810)229-7575 (810)229-8650
e-mail:[email protected]
EGLE Certified #9404
NELAC Accredited #176507
Arch Environmental Group
37720 Interchange Dr.
Farmington Hills, MI 48335
Blank-Dip Cup TMDL
05/15/2020
05/15/2020Sample Date:
Submit Date:
Cambridge-Garden City High SchoolProject Name:
Project Number:
BA Report Number: 65025
Parameters Result Units DL Method Reference
Analysis
Date
BA Sample ID: CM05375 AE200001-GCPS
Analyst
To:
Microbiological Analysis
E. coli 1.0 SM9223B M Well 05/15/2020WTCFU/100 ml0
DL=Reported detection limit for analytical method requested. Some compounds require special
analytical methods to achieve EGLE designated target detection limits (TDL).
Released by
Date 5/18/2020
1
www.archenvgroup.com
healthAIR - Industrial Hygiene Services cleanWATER - Consulting & Testing Services
safeEARTH - Hazardous Waste & Recycling Services
DETROIT GRAND RAPIDS CHICAGO (248) 426-0165 (616) 930-4116 (847) 462-9687 Farmington Hills, MI Cedar Springs, MI Cary, IL
June 17, 2020 Mr. Neil Greene Director of Operations Garden City Public Schools 33980 Marquette Garden City, Michigan 48135 [email protected] RE: Project # AE200001 GCPS Total Maximum Daily Load (TMDL) Sampling Report Farmington 5-6 Campus Dear Mr. Greene: Arch Environmental Group, Inc. recently conducted a round of TMDL Wet Weather Sampling at discharge point FRM-18.MH.DP at Farmington 5-6 Campus on May 15, 2020, in accordance with the applicable NPDES Permit requirements. TMDL sampling is used to determine the level of specific pollutants in the stormwater system by collecting samples from 50% of the district’s stormwater outfalls/discharge points during a representative wet weather event. The sampling results are then evaluated to determine if a particular point source needs to be addressed to reduce the pollutant load of the receiving waters. A report regarding the findings of this round of TMDL Sampling is attached. If you have questions regarding this report, please feel free to contact please feel free to contact the cleanWATER team at (248) 426-0165. Sincerely, Arch Environmental Group, Inc. Environmental Services
Kellie Das Certified Industrial Site Stormwater Operator, I-16237
TMDL Sampling Report Page 2 Project # AE200001 GCPS Farmington 5-6 Campus
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1.0 Project Summary 2.0 TMDL Sampling Procedures 3.0 TMDL Sampling Results 4.0 Conclusion 5.0 Best Management Practices to Reduce TMDL Pollutant Loads
Attachments: TMDL Screening Inspection Log Storm Sewer System Site Map Analytical Results & Chain of Custody
TMDL Sampling Report Page 3 Project # AE200001 GCPS Farmington 5-6 Campus
1.0 / Project Summary Arch Environmental Group, Inc. (AEG) recently conducted a round of Total Maximum Daily Load (TMDL) Sampling for E. coli at discharge location FRM-18.MH.DP at Farmington 5-6 Campus on May 15, 2020, in accordance with the applicable National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) Permit requirements.
A TMDL describes the process used to determine how much of a pollutant a lake or stream can assimilate and sets pollutant reduction targets for that water body. NPDES Municipal Separate Storm Sewer System (MS4) permits require regulated public entities located within urbanized areas that discharge storm water to an MS4 which leads to a water body designated with a TMDL, to demonstrate progress toward meeting Water Quality Standards (WQS). If the TMDL was written for E. coli or Total Phosphorus (TP), the MS4 permits further require permittees to collect representative samples of storm water discharges from their points of discharge to MS4s which lead to the impacted water bodies.1 Based on a review of the sampling results, Stormwater Best Management Practices (BMP) implementation will be reviewed and BMPs may be updated to ensure progress toward achieving TMDL pollutant load reductions.
Monitoring is not required for Biota/Sediment TMDLs under the MS4 permits.2
The receiving water body of Farmington 5-6 Campus is the Perrin Drain of the Rouge River. The Rouge River has been designated with TMDLs of E. coli and Biota/Sediment, and/or Dissolved Oxygen. Further details on the TMDLs listed can be found in the documents “Total Maximum Daily Load for E. coli for the Rouge River” and “Total Maximum Daily Load for Biota for the River Rouge Watershed, Including Bishop and Tonquish Creeks”. Some examples of potential sources of E. coli in waterways include fecal material from livestock, humans, wildlife, waterfowl such as geese, and sanitary systems. Some examples of potential sources of sediment include erosion and construction activities.
2.0 / TMDL Sampling Procedures Applicable TMDL sampling was conducted with guidance from the “Storm Water Sampling Guidance for Total Phosphorus & E. coli.” Sampling was conducted at designated outfalls/discharge points after a dry period of approximately 72 hours and during a rain event of approximately .25 inches or more. Please see the attached TMDL Screening Inspection Log for specific rainfall amounts. Sampling was conducted on May 15, 2020 and the last significant rain event was on May 14, 2020. The weather history for the rain event is available upon request.
When a dip-cup or similar sampling device was needed to collect the sample, a blank sample was collected to ensure no contamination was coming from the sampling device. The blank collected during this round of TMDL sampling came back at zero (0) CFU for E. coli indicating that the sampling device used was not contaminated. The lab results of the blank sample are attached. Furthermore, all sampling devices were decontaminated with bleach water and distilled water between each sampling location according to the protocol laid out in the “Storm Water Sampling Guidance for Total Phosphorus & E. coli.” Each location sampled was analyzed for pH and temperature while on-site and the sampled outfall/discharge point (OF/DP) was inspected for color, odor, and abnormal vegetative growth. The collected samples were delivered to an external laboratory for analysis.
3.0 / TMDL Sampling Results
1 Storm Water Sampling Guidance for Total Phosphorus & E. coli. November 24, 2009. DEQ 2 Addressing Biota TMDLs in Municipal Separate Storm Sewer System Permits” April 5, 2010. DNRE
TMDL Sampling Report Page 4 Project # AE200001 GCPS Farmington 5-6 Campus
TMDL Benchmark Standards for E. coli:
• E. coli: The WQS for E. coli is the maximum amount of E. coli that is allowable in surface waters of the state. These standards are known as total body contact and partial body contact standards. Total body contact is a more conservative standard used during the summer to protect swimmers during total body contact and has the daily maximum of 300 CFU per 100 milliliters (mL). This applies to the warmer months of May 1st -October 31stand is the standard being used in this report. Partial body contact is the daily maximum of 1,000 CFU per 100 mL and applies to the waterways year-round. 3
Structure ID: FRM-18.MH.DP Structure Type: Manhole Location: NE corner of building, northernmost basin in drop off drive
At the time of the sampling, clear water flow was noted, and FRM-18.MH.DP was free of odors, and abnormal vegetative growth. AEG collected a grab sample from FRM-18.MH.DP and the sample was screened for temperature and pH in the field. An E. coli grab sample was delivered to an external laboratory for analysis. Results from the sampling are summarized below. A more detailed TMDL Screening Inspection Log is also attached at the end of the report.
Parameter: Results: TMDL Benchmark Standard: Units: pH 8.11 6.5 - 9 pH Units Temperature 16.9 N/A Celsius E. coli 2419 300 CFU per 100mL Total Phosphorus N/A N/A ug/L
The sample results for FRM-18.MH.DP did not identify elevated levels of pH above the TMDL Benchmark Standards. However, highlighted values in the tables above indicate that for outfall location FRM-18.MH.DP, the reported levels for E. coli (2419 CFU) are above the Michigan Public Health Department standards for Total Body Contact (E. coli >300 CFU).
4.0 / Conclusion AEG did not identify any elevated levels of pH above the TMDL Benchmark Standards for discharge location FRM-18.MH.DP sampled at Farmington 5-6 Campus on May 15, 2020. However, AEG did identify elevated levels of E. coli above the TMDL Benchmark Standards for discharge location FRM-18.MH.DP
Arch Environmental Group, Inc. recommends that the elevated location FRM-18.MH.DP be re-assessed each permit cycle (two rounds of sampling occur per permit cycle) to ascertain whether greater or reduced potential for E. coli TMDL contribution has occurred. Additionally, these sites will be monitored annually during regularly scheduled Routine Storm sewer Structural Inspections for changes in conditions or site activities.
Geese, gulls and ducks are speculated to be a major bacterial source in urban areas, particularly where large populations congregate. E. coli (Escherichia Coli) is a sub-group of the fecal coliform group and can be used as an
3 “Michigan’s E. Coli Water Quality Standard Guidance” May, 2016. MDEQ
TMDL Sampling Report Page 5 Project # AE200001 GCPS Farmington 5-6 Campus
indicator of fecal contamination. E. coli bacteria exist in animal and human fecal matter.4 Elevated levels of E. coli typically occur at sites which have leaking sanitary sewer systems, failed septic systems, or populations of wild or domesticated animals. E. coli originating from birds, raccoons and other wildlife may be present in large numbers in stormwater runoff. In an effort to determine the cause of the benchmark exceedance of E. coli, Arch Environmental Group reviewed the layout of the school storm water system as well as past tracer dye studies. Based on this investigation, sanitary sewer contamination from Farmington 5-6 Campus is not suspected. The source is likely natural sources, such as the presence of wild animals from the open fields and parking lots. There is less traffic through the parking lot now that school is closed, allowing animals to move freely throughout the property.
5.0 / Best Management Practices to Reduce TMDL Pollutant Loads The Garden City Public Schools’ Stormwater Management Plan (SWMP) identifies and defines the districts BMPs to comply with the Six Minimum Measures that are the front line in the nationwide effort to reducing polluted stormwater discharges to our lake, rivers and streams. The Michigan Department of Environment, Great Lakes, and Energy recognizes that having a Stormwater Management Plan in place built around the Six Minimum Measures specified in the NPDES General Jurisdictional Permit have the potential to significantly contribute to the reduction of TMDL Pollutants in the surface waters of the state. A link to the district’s current SWMP can be found on the district’s website at http://cms.revize.com/revize/gardencityschools/document_center/StudentServices/GCPS%20SWMP%202016%20V2%20Revised%207-19-18.pdf .The Six Minimum Measures are listed below:
• Public Education and Outreach Program (PEP) • Public Involvement and Participation Program (PIP) • Illicit Discharge Elimination Program (IDEP) • Post Construction Stormwater Management Program • Construction Site Stormwater Runoff Control Program • Pollution Prevention/Good Housekeeping Program.
The following is a list of prioritized TMDL best management practices from the districts SWMP that Garden City Public Schools should continue to implement in order to improve water quality impairments associated with the E. coli and Biota/Sediment TMDL of the Rouge River. Prioritization of BMPs is based on Garden City Public Schools targeted TMDL pollutants. Priority is given to BMPs that reduce E. coli loads and address water quality for biota.
E. COLI 1. GCPS will use its website to provide the public with information regarding pet waste (SEMCOG links).
Additionally, SEMCOG pet waste posters are placed at various school buildings. 2. GCPS will prohibit illicit discharges, inspect and monitor suspected illicit discharges, and enforce
elimination of the illicit discharges and connections. 3. GCPS has reviewed all facilities for cross-connections between the sanitary and storm sewer systems. 4. GCPS will conduct bimonthly inspections of parking lot and curb areas and hand clean as needed.
4 Sources of E. coli In Surface Water” - Great Lakes Water Institute, University of Wisconsin, Milwaukee http://www.glwi.uwm.edu/research/genomics/ecoli/sources_of_ecoli_in_water.php
TMDL Sampling Report Page 6 Project # AE200001 GCPS Farmington 5-6 Campus
5. GCPS has established programs for soil erosion and sediment control from new or redevelopment construction. Such developments require permits and inspections for practices to keep exposed soils on site or controlled from runoff.
6. GCPS has implemented routine visual inspections of stormwater structural controls. 7. GCPS will remove excessive sediments from structural sediment removal systems to maintain the
maximum designed performance. Sediments will be disposed of offsite in accordance with Parts 115 or 121.
ALL TMDLs 1. GCPS will continue to use its website to provide the public information regarding local TMDL issues
(E. coli and biota TMDL Best Management Practice). 2. GCPS will continue to educate staff, faculty, and students using various venues including the “Seven
Simple Steps to Clean Water” program educational materials developed by the various watershed groups specifically related to these issues on the stormwater management webpage.
3. The district passed a post-construction stormwater board resolution to require implementation of the stormwater standards for construction.
4. Adequately maintains vegetation around stormwater facilities, ditches, and ponds. 5. Provide training to applicable staff and confirm training from contractors including restrictions on the
use of phosphorous containing fertilizers, soaps, cleaners and other chemicals that could impact the separate storm drain system.
GCPS strives to be good stewards of the land within their jurisdiction and to use appropriate Best Management Practices (BMPs) to contribute to the improvement of water quality. GCPS is committed to practicing sound stormwater management practices; including observance and adherence to all local, state, and federal stormwater statutes, rules, and regulations.
Attachments: TMDL Screening Inspection Log Storm Sewer System Site Map Analytical Results & Chain of Custody cc: AE200001 project file
TMDL Screening Inspection Log
ID Number: Long:Type:Outfall Dimensions
Flow Characteristics
Sample ID And Information Lab Analysis: Results: TMDL Threshold: Units: Photo ID:8.11 6.5 - 9 pH units16.9 N/A Celsius
2419 300 CFU per 100mLN/A N/A ug/L
Building:Samplers:
Farmington 5-6 CampusSteven RipleyKellie Das
Structure Type Manhole
Northeast corner of building, northern most basin in dropoff drive
42.19141 83.221016
Location:
Yes, ContinousDownstream basins and roof drains Moderate
Lat:
Garden City Public Schools5/15/2020
TMDL Sampling
Client:Date
Inspection Type:
Standing Water CharacteristicsStanding Water:
ClearNo
Flow Odor
Velocity of Flow:
Structure Information:
Observations:36”Discharge PointFRM-18.MH.DP
NoNoNoNoNo
Abnormal Growth:
Sewage:Oil Sheen:
No
Algae:Bacterial Sheen:
UnlikelyOutfall Characterization:
Sample sent to Lab:
Total Rainfall (Inches): .77
Sample ID:Temperature: pH:
E. coli:Total Phosphorus:Other:Other:Other:
Time Collected:
Current Weather:Last Rain Event:
Screening Location Type:
NoStaining:
Suds:Odor:Color:
ClearNo
Yes
No
Flow Observed:Source of Flow:
Color of Flow:
Additional Comments:
FRM-18.MH.DP TMDL 2:15 PM< 48 HoursRainManhole
Yes
Slimes:
Arch Environmental Group37720 Interchange Drive, Farmington Hills MI 48370
Phone: (248) 426-0135Fax: (248) 426-0136
www.archenvgroup.com
2105 Pless Drive Brighton, Michigan 48114 Phone (810)229-7575 Fax (810)229-8650 E-mail [email protected]
TM
May 18, 2020
Arch Environmental Group
37720 Interchange Dr.
Farmington Hills, MI 48335
Subject: Farmington 5-6 Campus TMDL
AE200001-GCPS
Dear Ms. Sendra :
The invoice for this project will be emailed separately. If you have any questions
concerning the data or invoice, please don't hesitate to contact our office. We
welcome your comments and suggestions to improve our quality systems. Please
reference Brighton Analytical, L.L.C. Project ID 65026 when calling or emailing.
We thank you for this opportunity to partner with you on this project and hope to
work with you again in the future.
Thank you for making Brighton Analytical, L.L.C. your laboratory of choice.
Attached are the results for the samples submitted on 05/15/2020 for the above
mentioned project. NELAP/TNI Accredited Analysis and EGLE Drinking Water
Certified Analysis will be identified in their respective reporting formats. Hard
copies can be supplied at your request for a fee of $20.00 per copy.
Sincerely,
Brighton Analytical, L.L.C.
Environment, Great Lakes, and Energy
Report Date: 05/18/2020
Sample ID:
Brighton Analytical LLC
2105 Pless Drive
Brighton, Michigan 48114
Phone: (810)229-7575 (810)229-8650
e-mail:[email protected]
EGLE Certified #9404
NELAC Accredited #176507
Arch Environmental Group
37720 Interchange Dr.
Farmington Hills, MI 48335
FRM-18.MH.DP TMDL
05/15/2020
05/15/2020Sample Date:
Submit Date:
Farmington 5-6 Campus TMDLProject Name:
Project Number:
BA Report Number: 65026
Parameters Result Units DL Method Reference
Analysis
Date
BA Sample ID: CM05376 AE200001-GCPS
Analyst
To:
Microbiological Analysis
E. coli 1.0 SM9223B M Well 05/15/2020WTCFU/100 ml>2419
DL=Reported detection limit for analytical method requested. Some compounds require special
analytical methods to achieve EGLE designated target detection limits (TDL).
Released by
Date 5/18/2020
1
Report Date: 05/18/2020
Sample ID:
Brighton Analytical LLC
2105 Pless Drive
Brighton, Michigan 48114
Phone: (810)229-7575 (810)229-8650
e-mail:[email protected]
EGLE Certified #9404
NELAC Accredited #176507
Arch Environmental Group
37720 Interchange Dr.
Farmington Hills, MI 48335
Blank-Dip Cup TMDL
05/15/2020
05/15/2020Sample Date:
Submit Date:
Cambridge-Garden City High SchoolProject Name:
Project Number:
BA Report Number: 65025
Parameters Result Units DL Method Reference
Analysis
Date
BA Sample ID: CM05375 AE200001-GCPS
Analyst
To:
Microbiological Analysis
E. coli 1.0 SM9223B M Well 05/15/2020WTCFU/100 ml0
DL=Reported detection limit for analytical method requested. Some compounds require special
analytical methods to achieve EGLE designated target detection limits (TDL).
Released by
Date 5/18/2020
1
www.archenvgroup.com
healthAIR - Industrial Hygiene Services cleanWATER - Consulting & Testing Services
safeEARTH - Hazardous Waste & Recycling Services
DETROIT GRAND RAPIDS CHICAGO (248) 426-0165 (616) 930-4116 (847) 462-9687 Farmington Hills, MI Cedar Springs, MI Cary, IL
September 30, 2020 Mr. Neil Greene Director of Operations Garden City Public Schools 33980 Marquette Garden City, Michigan 48135 [email protected] RE: Project # AE200001 GCPS Total Maximum Daily Load (TMDL) Sampling Report Garden City Middle School Dear Mr. Greene: Arch Environmental Group, Inc. recently conducted a round of TMDL Wet Weather Sampling at discharge points GCM-24.MH.DP and GCM-28.CB (Upstream of GCM-27.CB.DP) at Garden City Middle School on September 8, 2020, in accordance with the applicable NPDES Permit requirements. TMDL sampling is used to determine the level of specific pollutants in the stormwater system by collecting samples from 50% of the district’s stormwater outfalls/discharge points during a representative wet weather event. The sampling results are then evaluated to determine if a particular point source needs to be addressed to reduce the pollutant load of the receiving waters. A report regarding the findings of this round of TMDL Sampling is attached. If you have questions regarding this report, please feel free to contact please feel free to contact the cleanWATER team at (248) 426-0165. Sincerely, Arch Environmental Group, Inc. Environmental Services
Brendan Koziol Consultant
TMDL Sampling Report Page 2 Project # AE200001 GCPS Garden City Middle School
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1.0 Project Summary 2.0 TMDL Sampling Procedures 3.0 TMDL Sampling Results 4.0 Conclusion/Recommendations 5.0 Best Management Practices to Reduce TMDL Pollutant Loads
Attachments: TMDL Screening Inspection Logs Storm Sewer System Site Map Analytical Results & Chain of Custody
TMDL Sampling Report Page 3 Project # AE200001 GCPS Garden City Middle School
1.0 / Project Summary Arch Environmental Group, Inc. (AEG) recently conducted a round of Total Maximum Daily Load (TMDL) Sampling for E. coli at discharge locations GCM-24.MH.DP and GCM-28.CB at Garden City Middle School on September 8, 2020, in accordance with the applicable National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) Permit requirements.
A TMDL describes the process used to determine how much of a pollutant a lake or stream can assimilate and sets pollutant reduction targets for that water body. NPDES Municipal Separate Storm Sewer System (MS4) permits require regulated public entities located within urbanized areas that discharge storm water to an MS4 which leads to a water body designated with a TMDL, to demonstrate progress toward meeting Water Quality Standards (WQS). If the TMDL was written for E. coli or Total Phosphorus (TP), the MS4 permits further require permittees to collect representative samples of storm water discharges from their points of discharge to MS4s which lead to the impacted water bodies.1 Based on a review of the sampling results, Stormwater Best Management Practices (BMP) implementation will be reviewed and BMPs may be updated to ensure progress toward achieving TMDL pollutant load reductions.
Monitoring is not required for Biota/Sediment TMDLs under the MS4 permits.2
The receiving water body of Garden City Middle School is the Middle Rouge River which drains directly into the Rouge River. The Rouge River has been designated with a TMDL of E. coli and Biota/Sediment. Further details on the TMDLs listed can be found in the documents “Total Maximum Daily Load for Biota for the River Rouge Watershed, Including Bishop and Tonquish Creeks, Washtenaw, Wayne, and Oakland Counties” and “Total Maximum Daily Load for E. coli for the Rouge River”. Some examples of potential sources of E. coli in waterways include fecal material from livestock, humans, wildlife, waterfowl such as geese, and sanitary systems. Some examples of potential sources of sediment include erosion and construction activities.
2.0 / TMDL Sampling Procedures Applicable TMDL sampling was conducted with guidance from the “Storm Water Sampling Guidance for Total Phosphorus & E. coli.” Sampling was conducted at designated outfalls/discharge points after a dry period of approximately 72 hours and during a rain event of approximately .25 inches or more. Please see the attached TMDL Screening Inspection Logs for specific rainfall amounts. Sampling was conducted on September 8, 2020 and the last significant rain event was on September 2, 2020. The weather history for the rain event is available upon request.
Anytime that a sampling occurs, a blank sample is also collected to ensure there has been no contamination from the sampling device or sampling process. The blank collected during this round of TMDL sampling came back at zero (0) CFU for E. coli indicating that no contamination occurred. The lab results of the blank sample are attached. Furthermore, all sampling devices were decontaminated with bleach water and distilled water between each sampling location according to the protocol laid out in the “Storm Water Sampling Guidance for Total Phosphorus & E. coli.” Each location sampled was analyzed for pH and temperature while on-site and the sampled outfall/discharge point (OF/DP) was inspected for color, odor, and abnormal vegetative growth. The collected samples were delivered to an external laboratory for analysis.
3.0 / TMDL Sampling Results
1 Storm Water Sampling Guidance for Total Phosphorus & E. coli. November 24, 2009. DEQ 2 Addressing Biota TMDLs in Municipal Separate Storm Sewer System Permits” April 5, 2010. DNRE
TMDL Sampling Report Page 4 Project # AE200001 GCPS Garden City Middle School
TMDL Benchmark Standards for E. coli:
• E. coli: The WQS for E. coli is the maximum amount of E. coli that is allowable in surface waters of the state. These standards are known as total body contact and partial body contact standards. Total body contact is a more conservative standard used during the summer to protect swimmers during total body contact and has the daily maximum of 300 CFU per 100 milliliters (mL). This applies to the warmer months of May 1st -October 31stand is the standard being used in this report. Partial body contact is the daily maximum of 1,000 CFU per 100 mL and applies to the waterways year-round. 3
Structure ID: GCM-24.MH.DP Structure Type: Manhole Location: North of building, north parking lot, along north edge of parking lot.
At the time of the sampling, clear water flow was noted, and GCM-24.MH.DP was free of odors, and abnormal vegetative growth. AEG collected a grab sample from GCM-24.MH.DP and the sample was screened for temperature and pH in the field. An E. coli grab sample was delivered to an external laboratory for analysis. Results from the sampling are summarized below. A more detailed TMDL Screening Inspection Log is also attached at the end of the report.
Parameter: Results: TMDL Benchmark Standard: Units: pH 7.89 6.5 - 9 pH Units Temperature 15.6 N/A Celsius E. coli 290.9 300 CFU per 100mL Total Phosphorus N/A N/A ug/L
The sample results for GCM-24.MH.DP did not identify elevated levels of pH or E. coli above the TMDL Benchmark Standards. The reported levels for E. coli (290.9 CFU) are below the Michigan Public Health Department standards for Total Body Contact (E. coli >300 CFU).
Structure ID: GCM-28.CB Structure Type: Catch Basin Location: East of door D1 on east bus drive.
At the time of the sampling, clear water flow was noted, and GCM-28.CB was free of odors, and abnormal vegetative growth. AEG collected a grab sample from GCM-28.CB and the sample was screened for temperature and pH in the field. An E. coli grab sample was delivered to an external laboratory for analysis. Results from the sampling are summarized below. A more detailed TMDL Screening Inspection Log is also attached at the end of the report.
Parameter: Results: TMDL Benchmark Standard: Units: pH 8.53 6.5 - 9 pH Units Temperature 16.1 N/A Celsius E. coli 109.1 300 CFU per 100mL Total Phosphorus N/A N/A ug/L
3 “Michigan’s E. Coli Water Quality Standard Guidance” May, 2016. MDEQ
TMDL Sampling Report Page 5 Project # AE200001 GCPS Garden City Middle School
The sample results for GCM-28.CB did not identify elevated levels of pH or E. coli above the TMDL Benchmark Standards. The reported levels for E. coli (109.1 CFU) are below the Michigan Public Health Department standards for Total Body Contact (E. coli >300 CFU).
4.0 / Conclusion/Recommendations AEG did not identify any elevated levels of pH or E. coli above the TMDL Benchmark Standards for discharge locations GCM-24.MH.DP and GCM-28.CB sampled at Garden City Middle School on September 8, 2020.
It is the opinion of Arch Environmental Group, Inc. that the TMDL sampling results indicate good use of BMPs in maintaining TMDL pollutant load reductions at Garden City Middle School. A list of those BMPs is provided below in section 5.0. TMDL sampling will be conducted twice per permit cycle to continue to monitor for TMDL pollutant load levels in accordance with the NPDES Permit requirements.
5.0 / Best Management Practices to Reduce TMDL Pollutant Loads The GCPS Stormwater Management Plan (SWMP) identifies and defines the districts BMPs to comply with the Six Minimum Measures that are the front line in the nationwide effort to reducing polluted stormwater discharges to our lake, rivers, and streams. The Michigan Department of Environment, Great Lakes, and Energy recognizes that having a Stormwater Management Plan in place built around the Six Minimum Measures specified in the NPDES General Jurisdictional Permit have the potential to significantly contribute to the reduction of TMDL Pollutants in the surface waters of the state. A link to the districts, current SWMP can be found on the district’s website at http://cms.revize.com/revize/gardencityschools/document_center/StudentServices/GCPS%20SWMP%202016%20V2%20Revised%207-19-18.pdf. The Six Minimum Measures are listed below:
• Public Education and Outreach Program (PEP) • Public Involvement and Participation Program (PIP) • Illicit Discharge Elimination Program (IDEP) • Post Construction Stormwater Management Program • Construction Site Stormwater Runoff Control Program • Pollution Prevention/Good Housekeeping Program.
The following is a list of prioritized TMDL best management practices from the districts SWMP that GCPS should continue to implement in order to improve water quality impairments associated with the E. coli and Biota/Sediment TMDL of the Rouge River. Prioritization of BMPs is based on GCPS targeted TMDL pollutants. Priority is given to BMPs that reduce E. coli loads and address water quality for biota.
E. COLI
1. GCPS will use its website to provide the public with information regarding pet waste (SEMCOG links). Additionally, SEMCOG pet waste posters are placed at various school buildings.
2. GCPS will prohibit illicit discharges, inspect and monitor suspected illicit discharges, and enforce elimination of the illicit discharges and connections.
3. GCPS has reviewed all facilities for cross-connections between the sanitary and storm sewer systems.
4. GCPS will conduct bimonthly inspections of parking lot and curb areas and hand clean as needed.
TMDL Sampling Report Page 6 Project # AE200001 GCPS Garden City Middle School
5. GCPS has established programs for soil erosion and sediment control from new or redevelopment construction. Such developments require permits and inspections for practices to keep exposed soils on site or controlled from runoff.
6. GCPS has implemented routine visual inspections of stormwater structural controls.
7. GCPS will remove excessive sediments from structural sediment removal systems to maintain the maximum designed performance. Sediments will be disposed of offsite in accordance with Parts 115 or 121.
ALL TMDLs
1. GCPS will continue to use its website to provide the public information regarding local TMDL issues (E. coli and biota TMDL Best Management Practice).
2. GCPS will continue to educate staff, faculty, and students using various venues including the “Seven Simple Steps to Clean Water” program educational materials developed by the various watershed groups specifically related to these issues on the stormwater management webpage.
3. The district passed a post-construction stormwater board resolution to require implementation of the stormwater standards for construction.
4. Adequately maintains vegetation around stormwater facilities, ditches, and ponds.
5. Provide training to applicable staff and confirm training from contractors including restrictions on the use of phosphorous containing fertilizers, soaps, cleaners and other chemicals that could impact the separate storm drain system.
GCPS strives to be good stewards of the land within their jurisdiction and to use appropriate Best Management Practices (BMPs) to contribute to the improvement of water quality. GCPS is committed to practicing sound stormwater management practices, including observance and adherence to all local, state, and federal stormwater statutes, rules, and regulations.
Attachments: TMDL Screening Inspection Logs Storm Sewer System Site Map Analytical Results & Chain of Custody cc: AE200001 project file
TMDL Screening Inspection Log
ID Number: Long:Type:Outfall Dimensions
Flow Characteristics
Sample ID And Information Lab Analysis: Results: TMDL Threshold: Units: Photo ID:7.89 6.5 - 9 pH units15.6 N/A Celsius
290.9 300 CFU per 100mLN/A N/A ug/L
Building:Samplers:
Garden City Middle SchoolBrendan KoziolKellie Das
Evan Gist
Structure Type Manhole
North of building, north parking lot, along north edge of parking lot.
42.323748 -83.375884
Location:
Yes, ContinousRain Substantial
Lat:
Garden City Public Schools9/8/2020
TMDL Sampling
Client:Date
Inspection Type:
Standing Water CharacteristicsStanding Water:
ClearNo
Flow Odor
Velocity of Flow:
Structure Information:
Observations:12”Discharge PointGCM-24.MH.DP
NoNoNoNoNo
Abnormal Growth:
Sewage:Oil Sheen:
No
Algae:Bacterial Sheen:
UnlikelyOutfall Characterization:
Sample sent to Lab:
Total Rainfall (Inches): .85"
Sample ID:Temperature: pH:
E. coli:Total Phosphorus:Other:Other:Other:
Time Collected:
Current Weather:Last Rain Event:
Screening Location Type:
NoStaining:
Suds:Odor:Color:
ClearNo
Yes
No
Flow Observed:Source of Flow:
Color of Flow:
Additional Comments:AEG observed a basin upstream that had leaf debris covering the basin. This could negatively impact the test results. AEG suggests that this basin be regularly swept.
GCM-24.MH.DP TMDL9:05 am < 48 HoursRainManhole
Yes
Slimes:
Arch Environmental Group37720 Interchange Drive, Farmington Hills MI 48370
Phone: (248) 426-0135Fax: (248) 426-0136
www.archenvgroup.com
TMDL Screening Inspection Log
ID Number: Long:Type:Outfall Dimensions
Flow Characteristics
Sample ID And Information Lab Analysis: Results: TMDL Threshold: Units: Photo ID:8.53 6.5 - 9 pH units16.1 N/A Celsius
109.1 300 CFU per 100mLN/A N/A ug/L
Sample ID: GCM-28.CB TMDL pH:Time Collected: 8:55 am Temperature: Last Rain Event: < 48 Hours E. coli:
Current Weather: Rain Total Phosphorus:Sample Location Type: Catch Basin Other:Total Rainfall (Inches) .85" Other:
Other:UnlikelyOutfall Characterization:
Flow Odor NoOil Sheen:
Staining:Suds:
Sewage: Additional Comments:Bacterial Sheen: No AEG observed geese in the area which could lead to increased levels of E. coli in the samples.
Algae: NoSlimes: No
Abnormal Growth: No
Lat:East of door D1 on east bus drive.
Observations:Standing Water Characteristics
Color of Flow: ClearOdor:
Standing Water: Yes Yes, ContinousRain
NoNo
Clear Source of Flow:NoNoNo
Flow Observed:
12”
Velocity of Flow: Substantial
Structure Information:GCM-28.CB Structure Type
Color:
Location:
Evan Gist
Building: Garden City Middle School
Catch Basin
Inspectors: Kellie Das Brendan KoziolClient:
Sample sent to Lab: Yes
Garden City Public SchoolsDate 9/8/2020
Inspection Type: TMDL Sampling
Arch Environmental Group37720 Interchange Drive, Farmington Hills MI 48370
Phone: (248) 426-0135Fax: (248) 426-0136
www.archenvgroup.com
2105 Pless Drive Brighton, Michigan 48114 Phone (810)229-7575 Fax (810)229-8650 E-mail [email protected]
TM
September 09, 2020
Arch Environmental Group
37720 Interchange Dr.
Farmington Hills, MI 48335
Subject: Garden City Middle School TMDL
AE200001-GCPS
Dear Ms. Perfetti :
The invoice for this project will be emailed separately. If you have any questions
concerning the data or invoice, please don't hesitate to contact our office. We
welcome your comments and suggestions to improve our quality systems. Please
reference Brighton Analytical, L.L.C. Project ID 70264 when calling or emailing.
We thank you for this opportunity to partner with you on this project and hope to
work with you again in the future.
Thank you for making Brighton Analytical, L.L.C. your laboratory of choice.
Attached are the results for the samples submitted on 09/08/2020 for the above
mentioned project. NELAP/TNI Accredited Analysis and EGLE Drinking Water
Certified Analysis will be identified in their respective reporting formats. Hard
copies can be supplied at your request for a fee of $20.00 per copy.
Sincerely,
Brighton Analytical, L.L.C.
Environment, Great Lakes, and Energy
Report Date: 09/09/2020
Sample ID:
Brighton Analytical LLC
2105 Pless Drive
Brighton, Michigan 48114
Phone: (810)229-7575 (810)229-8650
e-mail:[email protected]
EGLE Certified #9404
NELAC Accredited #176507
Arch Environmental Group
37720 Interchange Dr.
Farmington Hills, MI 48335
Dip Cup Blank TMDL
09/08/2020
09/08/2020Sample Date:
Submit Date:
Garden City Middle School TMDLProject Name:
Project Number:
BA Report Number: 70264
Parameters Result Units DL Method Reference
Analysis
Date
BA Sample ID: CN02229 AE200001-GCPS
Analyst
To:
Microbiological Analysis
E. coli 1.0 SM9223B M Well 09/08/2020WTCFU/100 ml0
DL=Reported detection limit for analytical method requested. Some compounds require special
analytical methods to achieve EGLE designated target detection limits (TDL).
Released by
Date 9/9/2020
1
Report Date: 09/09/2020
Sample ID:
Brighton Analytical LLC
2105 Pless Drive
Brighton, Michigan 48114
Phone: (810)229-7575 (810)229-8650
e-mail:[email protected]
EGLE Certified #9404
NELAC Accredited #176507
Arch Environmental Group
37720 Interchange Dr.
Farmington Hills, MI 48335
GCM-28.CB TMDL
09/08/2020
09/08/2020Sample Date:
Submit Date:
Garden City Middle School TMDLProject Name:
Project Number:
BA Report Number: 70264
Parameters Result Units DL Method Reference
Analysis
Date
BA Sample ID: CN02230 AE200001-GCPS
Analyst
To:
Microbiological Analysis
E. coli 1.0 SM9223B M Well 09/08/2020WTCFU/100 ml101.9
DL=Reported detection limit for analytical method requested. Some compounds require special
analytical methods to achieve EGLE designated target detection limits (TDL).
Released by
Date 9/9/2020
1
Report Date: 09/09/2020
Sample ID:
Brighton Analytical LLC
2105 Pless Drive
Brighton, Michigan 48114
Phone: (810)229-7575 (810)229-8650
e-mail:[email protected]
EGLE Certified #9404
NELAC Accredited #176507
Arch Environmental Group
37720 Interchange Dr.
Farmington Hills, MI 48335
GCM-24.MH.DP TMDL
09/08/2020
09/08/2020Sample Date:
Submit Date:
Garden City Middle School TMDLProject Name:
Project Number:
BA Report Number: 70264
Parameters Result Units DL Method Reference
Analysis
Date
BA Sample ID: CN02231 AE200001-GCPS
Analyst
To:
Microbiological Analysis
E. coli 1.0 SM9223B M Well 09/08/2020WTCFU/100 ml290.9
DL=Reported detection limit for analytical method requested. Some compounds require special
analytical methods to achieve EGLE designated target detection limits (TDL).
Released by
Date 9/9/2020
1
www.archenvgroup.com
healthAIR - Industrial Hygiene Services cleanWATER - Consulting & Testing Services
safeEARTH - Hazardous Waste & Recycling Services
DETROIT GRAND RAPIDS CHICAGO (248) 426-0165 (616) 930-4116 (847) 462-9687 Farmington Hills, MI Cedar Springs, MI Cary, IL
September 2, 2020 Mr. Neil Greene Director of Operations Garden City Public Schools 33980 Marquette Garden City, Michigan 48135 [email protected] RE: Project # AE200001 GCPS Total Maximum Daily Load (TMDL) Sampling Report Lathers Early Childhood and Kindergarten Center Dear Mr. Greene: Arch Environmental Group, Inc. recently conducted a round of TMDL Wet Weather Sampling at discharge points LEC-03.FS.DP and LEC-06.FS.DP at Lathers Early Childhood and Kindergarten Center on May 18, 2020, in accordance with the applicable NPDES Permit requirements. TMDL sampling is used to determine the level of specific pollutants in the stormwater system by collecting samples from 50% of the district’s stormwater outfalls/discharge points during a representative wet weather event. The sampling results are then evaluated to determine if a particular point source needs to be addressed to reduce the pollutant load of the receiving waters. A report regarding the findings of this round of TMDL Sampling is attached. If you have questions regarding this report, please feel free to contact please feel free to contact the cleanWATER team at (248) 426-0165. Sincerely, Arch Environmental Group, Inc. Environmental Services
Jacqueline Keeler Consultant
TMDL Sampling Report Page 2 Project # AE200001 GCPS Lathers Early Childhood and Kindergarten Center
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1.0 Project Summary 2.0 TMDL Sampling Procedures 3.0 TMDL Sampling Results 4.0 Conclusion/Recommendations 5.0 Best Management Practices to Reduce TMDL Pollutant Loads
Attachments: TMDL Screening Inspection Logs Storm Sewer System Site Map Analytical Results & Chain of Custody
TMDL Sampling Report Page 3 Project # AE200001 GCPS Lathers Early Childhood and Kindergarten Center
1.0 / Project Summary Arch Environmental Group, Inc. (AEG) recently conducted a round of Total Maximum Daily Load (TMDL) Sampling for E. coli at discharge locations LEC-03.FS.DP and LEC-06.FS.DP at Lathers Early Childhood and Kindergarten Center on May 18, 2020, in accordance with the applicable National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) Permit requirements.
A TMDL describes the process used to determine how much of a pollutant a lake or stream can assimilate and sets pollutant reduction targets for that water body. NPDES Municipal Separate Storm Sewer System (MS4) permits require regulated public entities located within urbanized areas that discharge storm water to an MS4 which leads to a water body designated with a TMDL, to demonstrate progress toward meeting Water Quality Standards (WQS). If the TMDL was written for E. coli or Total Phosphorus (TP), the MS4 permits further require permittees to collect representative samples of storm water discharges from their points of discharge to MS4s which lead to the impacted water bodies.1 Based on a review of the sampling results, Stormwater Best Management Practices (BMP) implementation will be reviewed and BMPs may be updated to ensure progress toward achieving TMDL pollutant load reductions.
Monitoring is not required for Biota/Sediment TMDLs under the MS4 permits.2 The receiving water body of Lathers Early Childhood and Kindergarten Center is the Perrin Drain of the Rouge River. The Rouge River has been designated with a TMDL of E. coli and Biota/Sediment. Further details on the TMDL(s) listed can be found in the documents “Total Maximum Daily Load for Biota for the River Rouge Watershed, Including Bishop and Tonquish Creeks” and Total Maximum Daily Load for E. coli for the Rouge River”. Some examples of potential sources of E. coli in waterways include fecal material from livestock, humans, wildlife, waterfowl such as geese, and sanitary systems. Some examples of potential sources of sediment include erosion and construction activities. 2.0 / TMDL Sampling Procedures Applicable TMDL sampling was conducted with guidance from the “Storm Water Sampling Guidance for Total Phosphorus & E. coli.” Sampling was conducted at designated discharge points during a rain event of approximately .25 inches or more. Please see the attached TMDL Screening Inspection Logs for specific rainfall amounts. Sampling was conducted on May 18, 2020 and the last significant rain event was on May 17, 2020. The weather history for the rain event is available upon request.
Anytime that a sampling occurs, a blank sample is also collected to ensure there has been no contamination from the sampling device or sampling process. The blank collected during this round of TMDL sampling came back at zero (0) CFU for E. coli indicating that no contamination occurred. The lab results of the blank sample are attached. Furthermore, all sampling devices were decontaminated with bleach water and distilled water between each sampling location according to the protocol laid out in the “Storm Water Sampling Guidance for Total Phosphorus & E. coli.” Each location sampled was analyzed for pH and temperature while on-site and the sampled discharge point (DP) was inspected for color, odor, and abnormal vegetative growth. The collected samples were delivered to an external laboratory for analysis.
3.0 / TMDL Sampling Results
1 Storm Water Sampling Guidance for Total Phosphorus & E. coli. November 24, 2009. DEQ 2 Addressing Biota TMDLs in Municipal Separate Storm Sewer System Permits” April 5, 2010. DNRE
TMDL Sampling Report Page 4 Project # AE200001 GCPS Lathers Early Childhood and Kindergarten Center
TMDL Benchmark Standards for E. coli:
• E. coli: The WQS for E. coli is the maximum amount of E. coli that is allowable in surface waters of the state. These standards are known as total body contact and partial body contact standards. Total body contact is a more conservative standard used during the summer to protect swimmers during total body contact and has the daily maximum of 300 CFU per 100 milliliters (mL). This applies to the warmer months of May 1st -October 31stand is the standard being used in this report. Partial body contact is the daily maximum of 1,000 CFU per 100 mL and applies to the waterways year-round. 3
Structure ID: LEC-03.FS.DP Structure Type: Flow Splitter Location: North parking lot
At the time of the sampling, clear water flow was noted, and LEC-03.FS.DP was free of odors, and abnormal vegetative growth. AEG collected a grab sample from LEC-03.FS.DP and the sample was screened for temperature and pH in the field. An E. coli grab sample was delivered to an external laboratory for analysis. Results from the sampling are summarized below. A more detailed TMDL Screening Inspection Log is also attached at the end of the report.
Parameter: Results: TMDL Benchmark Standard: Units: pH 7.11 6.5 - 9 pH Units Temperature 14.4 N/A Celsius E. coli 435.2 300 CFU per 100mL The sample results for discharge location LEC-03.FS.DP did not identify elevated levels of pH above the TMDL Benchmark Standards. However, highlighted values in the tables above indicate that for discharge location LEC-03.FS.DP, the reported levels for E. coli (435.2 CFU) are above the Michigan Public Health Department standards for Total Body Contact (E. coli >300 CFU). Structure ID: LEC-06.FS.DP Structure Type: Flow Splitter Location: South parking lot
At the time of the sampling, clear water flow was noted, and discharge point LEC-06.FS.DP was free of odors, and abnormal vegetative growth. AEG observed high levels of calcium carbonate build up in the pipes. AEG collected a grab sample from discharge point LCE-06.FS.DP and the sample was screened for temperature and pH in the field. An E. coli grab sample was delivered to an external laboratory for analysis. Results from the sampling are summarized below. A more detailed TMDL Screening Inspection Log is also attached at the end of the report.
Parameter: Results: TMDL Benchmark Standard: Units: pH 10.22 6.5 - 9 pH Units Temperature 16.2 N/A Celsius E. coli 145.5 300 CFU per 100mL
The sample results for discharge location LEC-06.FS.DP did not identify elevated levels of E. coli above the TMDL Benchmark Standards. However, highlighted values in the tables above indicate that for discharge location LEC-
3 “Michigan’s E. Coli Water Quality Standard Guidance” May, 2016. MDEQ
TMDL Sampling Report Page 5 Project # AE200001 GCPS Lathers Early Childhood and Kindergarten Center
06.FS.DP, the reported levels for pH (10.22) are above the Michigan Public Health Department standards for hydrogen ion concentration expressed as pH (6.5-9).
4.0 / Conclusion/Recommendations AEG did identify elevated levels of pH above the TMDL Benchmark Standards for discharge location LEC-06.FS.DP and elevated levels of E. coli above the TMDL Benchmark Standards for discharge location LEC-03.FS.DP.
Arch Environmental Group, Inc. recommends that the elevated location LEC-03.FS.DP be re-assessed each permit cycle (two rounds of sampling occur per permit cycle) to ascertain whether greater or reduced potential for E. coli TMDL contribution has occurred. Additionally, these sites will be monitored annually during regularly scheduled Routine Storm sewer Structural Inspections for changes in conditions or site activities.
Geese, gulls and ducks are speculated to be a major bacterial source in urban areas, particularly where large populations congregate. E. coli (Escherichia Coli) is a sub-group of the fecal coliform group and can be used as an indicator of fecal contamination. E. coli bacteria exist in animal and human fecal matter.4 Elevated levels of E. coli typically occur at sites which have leaking sanitary sewer systems, failed septic systems, or populations of wild or domesticated animals. E. coli originating from birds, raccoons and other wildlife may be present in large numbers in stormwater runoff. In an effort to determine the cause of the benchmark exceedance of E. coli, Arch Environmental Group reviewed the layout of the school storm water system as well as past tracer dye studies. Based on this investigation, sanitary sewer contamination from Lathers Early Childhood and Kindergarten Center is not suspected. The source is likely natural sources, such as the presence of wild animals from the large playground and field in between the two sampled discharge points where birds were seen on site.
AEG observed a playground and field which is likely the source of the high results. AEG recommends getting a decoy to place in the fenced in pond area. This decoy will scare away the birds and animals. (https://www.watchdoggoosepatrol.com/)
A potential source of high pH in waterways can be caused by high concentrations of limestone or calcium carbonate. These occur naturally in soils and they can leach into waterways with stormwater runoff. Water that is high in pH is often referred to as “Hard Water”. “Hard Water” often carries minerals such as iron and will try to become more neutral by releasing these minerals. Once the mineral, iron in this case, is released, it oxidizes and becomes rust. In an effort to determine the cause of the benchmark exceedance of pH, Arch Environmental Group reviewed the layout of the school storm water system and surrounding area land use. AEG believes the high levels of pH at LEC-06.FS.DP are due to calcium carbonate found in the pipes of the discharge point and the upstream basin. 5.0 / Best Management Practices to Reduce TMDL Pollutant Loads The Garden City Public Schools Stormwater Management Plan (SWMP) identifies and defines the districts BMPs to comply with the Six Minimum Measures that are the front line in the nationwide effort to reducing polluted stormwater discharges to our lake, rivers and streams. The Michigan Department of Environment, Great Lakes, and Energy recognizes that having a Stormwater Management Plan in place built around the Six Minimum Measures specified in the NPDES General Jurisdictional Permit have the potential to significantly contribute to the reduction of TMDL Pollutants in the surface waters of the state. A link to the districts current SWMP can be found on the district’s website under public notices at http://www.gardencityschools.com/departments/student_services.php
The Six Minimum Measures are listed below:
4 Sources of E. coli In Surface Water” - Great Lakes Water Institute, University of Wisconsin, Milwaukee http://www.glwi.uwm.edu/research/genomics/ecoli/sources_of_ecoli_in_water.php
TMDL Sampling Report Page 6 Project # AE200001 GCPS Lathers Early Childhood and Kindergarten Center
• Public Education and Outreach Program (PEP) • Public Involvement and Participation Program (PIP) • Illicit Discharge Elimination Program (IDEP) • Post Construction Stormwater Management Program • Construction Site Stormwater Runoff Control Program • Pollution Prevention/Good Housekeeping Program.
The following is a list of prioritized TMDL best management practices from the districts SWMP that Garden City Public Schools should continue to implement in order to improve water quality impairments associated with the E. coli and Biota/Sediment TMDL of the Rouge River Watershed Prioritization of BMPs is based on Garden City Public Schools targeted TMDL pollutants. Priority is given to BMPs that reduce E. coli loads and address water quality for biota.
E. COLI 1. GCPS will use its website to provide the public with information regarding pet waste (SEMCOG links).
Additionally, SEMCOG pet waste posters are placed at various school buildings. 2. GCPS will prohibit illicit discharges, inspect and monitor suspected illicit discharges, and enforce
elimination of the illicit discharges and connections. 3. GCPS has reviewed all facilities for cross-connections between the sanitary and storm sewer systems. 4. GCPS will conduct bimonthly inspections of parking lot and curb areas and hand clean as needed. 5. GCPS has established programs for soil erosion and sediment control from new or redevelopment
construction. Such developments require permits and inspections for practices to keep exposed soils on site or controlled from runoff.
6. GCPS has implemented routine visual inspections of stormwater structural controls. 7. GCPS will remove excessive sediments from structural sediment removal systems to maintain the
maximum designed performance. Sediments will be disposed of offsite in accordance with Parts 115 or 121.
ALL TMDLs 1. GCPS will continue to use its website to provide the public information regarding local TMDL issues
(E. coli and biota TMDL Best Management Practice). 2. GCPS will continue to educate staff, faculty, and students using various venues including the “Seven
Simple Steps to Clean Water” program educational materials developed by the various watershed groups specifically related to these issues on the stormwater management webpage.
3. The district passed a post-construction stormwater board resolution to require implementation of the stormwater standards for construction.
4. Adequately maintains vegetation around stormwater facilities, ditches, and ponds. 5. Provide training to applicable staff and confirm training from contractors including restrictions on the
use of phosphorous containing fertilizers, soaps, cleaners and other chemicals that could impact the separate storm drain system.
GCPS strives to be good stewards of the land within their jurisdiction and to use appropriate Best Management Practices (BMPs) to contribute to the improvement of water quality. GCPS is committed to practicing sound stormwater management practices; including observance and adherence to all local, state, and federal stormwater statutes, rules, and regulations.
TMDL Sampling Report Page 7 Project # AE200001 GCPS Lathers Early Childhood and Kindergarten Center
Attachments: TMDL Screening Inspection Logs Storm Sewer System Site Map Analytical Results & Chain of Custody cc: AE200001 project file
TMDL Screening Inspection Log
ID Number: Long:Type:Outfall Dimensions
Flow Characteristics
Sample ID And Information Lab Analysis: Results: TMDL Threshold: Units: Photo ID:7.11 6.5 - 9 pH units14.4 N/A Celsius
435.2 300 CFU per 100mLNA NA NANA NA NANA NA NANA NA NA
Building:Samplers:
Lathers Early Childhood and KindergartenCarly DoulosAlex Reiber
Structure Type Flow Splitter
North parking lot
42.19672 83.191072
Location:
Yes, ContinousStormwaterModerate
Lat:
Garden City Public Schools5/18/2020
TMDL Sampling
Client:Date
Inspection Type:
Standing Water CharacteristicsStanding Water:
ClearNo
Flow Odor
Velocity of Flow:
Structure Information:
Observations:12”Discharge PointLEC-03.FS.DP
NoNoNoNoNo
Abnormal Growth:
Sewage:Oil Sheen:
No
Algae:Bacterial Sheen:
UnlikelyOutfall Characterization:
Sample sent to Lab:
Total Rainfall (Inches): 0.3
Sample ID:Temperature: pH:
E. coli:Total Phosphorus:Other:Other:Other:
Time Collected:
Current Weather:Last Rain Event:
Screening Location Type:
NoStaining:
Suds:Odor:Color:
ClearNo
Yes
No
Flow Observed:Source of Flow:
Color of Flow:
Additional Comments:Large playground/ field in between the two sampled discharge points, potential for animal feces. Birds noted to have been seen on site.
LEC-03.FS.DP.TMDL10:25< 48 HoursOvercastFlow Splitter
Yes
Slimes:
Arch Environmental Group37720 Interchange Drive, Farmington Hills MI 48370
Phone: (248) 426-0135Fax: (248) 426-0136
www.archenvgroup.com
TMDL Screening Inspection Log
ID Number: Long:Type:Outfall Dimensions
Flow Characteristics
Sample ID And Information Lab Analysis: Results: TMDL Threshold: Units: Photo ID:10.22 6.5 - 9 pH units
16.2 N/A Celsius145.5 300 CFU per 100mL
NA NA NANA NA NANA NA NANA NA NA
Sample ID: LEC-06.FS.DP pH: No photo due to lid being sealed shutTime Collected: 11:00 am Temperature: Last Rain Event: < 48 Hours E. coli:
Current Weather: Rain Total Phosphorus:Sample Location Type: Flow Splitter Other:Total Rainfall (Inches) 0.3 Other:
Other:UnlikelyOutfall Characterization:
Flow Odor NoOil Sheen:
Staining:Suds:
Sewage: Additional Comments:Bacterial Sheen: No AEG assumes that the high pH value is due to the build up of calcium carbonate in the pipes. The upstream basin was
noted to also have calcium carbonate build up. Algae: NoSlimes: No
Abnormal Growth: No
Lat: 42.19138 83.191062South parking lot
Observations:Standing Water Characteristics
Color of Flow: ClearOdor:
Standing Water: Yes Yes, Continous
Discharge Point
Stormwater
NoNo
Clear Source of Flow:NoNoNo
Flow Observed:
12”
Velocity of Flow: Moderate
Structure Information:LEC-06.FS.DP Structure Type
Color:
Location:
Building: Lathers Early Childhood and Kindergarten
Flow Splitter
Inspectors: Alex Reiber Carly DoulosClient:
Sample sent to Lab: Yes
Garden City Public SchoolsDate 5/18/2020
Inspection Type: TMDL Sampling
Arch Environmental Group37720 Interchange Drive, Farmington Hills MI 48370
Phone: (248) 426-0135Fax: (248) 426-0136
www.archenvgroup.com
2105 Pless Drive Brighton, Michigan 48114 Phone (810)229-7575 Fax (810)229-8650 E-mail [email protected]
TM
May 19, 2020
Arch Environmental Group
37720 Interchange Dr.
Farmington Hills, MI 48335
Subject: Lathers Early Childhood Center-TMDL Sampling
AE200001 GCPS
Dear Ms. Perfetti :
The invoice for this project will be emailed separately. If you have any questions
concerning the data or invoice, please don't hesitate to contact our office. We
welcome your comments and suggestions to improve our quality systems. Please
reference Brighton Analytical, L.L.C. Project ID 65049 when calling or emailing.
We thank you for this opportunity to partner with you on this project and hope to
work with you again in the future.
Thank you for making Brighton Analytical, L.L.C. your laboratory of choice.
Attached are the results for the samples submitted on 05/18/2020 for the above
mentioned project. NELAP/TNI Accredited Analysis and EGLE Drinking Water
Certified Analysis will be identified in their respective reporting formats. Hard
copies can be supplied at your request for a fee of $20.00 per copy.
Sincerely,
Brighton Analytical, L.L.C.
Environment, Great Lakes, and Energy
Report Date: 05/19/2020
Sample ID:
Brighton Analytical LLC
2105 Pless Drive
Brighton, Michigan 48114
Phone: (810)229-7575 (810)229-8650
e-mail:[email protected]
EGLE Certified #9404
NELAC Accredited #176507
Arch Environmental Group
37720 Interchange Dr.
Farmington Hills, MI 48335
TMDL-Blank
05/18/2020
05/18/2020Sample Date:
Submit Date:
Lathers Early Childhood Center-TMDL SamplingProject Name:
Project Number:
BA Report Number: 65049
Parameters Result Units DL Method Reference
Analysis
Date
BA Sample ID: CM05429 AE200001 GCPS
Analyst
To:
Microbiological Analysis
E. coli 1.0 SM9223B M Well 05/18/2020WTCFU/100 ml0
DL=Reported detection limit for analytical method requested. Some compounds require special
analytical methods to achieve EGLE designated target detection limits (TDL).
Released by
Date 5/19/2020
1
Report Date: 05/19/2020
Sample ID:
Brighton Analytical LLC
2105 Pless Drive
Brighton, Michigan 48114
Phone: (810)229-7575 (810)229-8650
e-mail:[email protected]
EGLE Certified #9404
NELAC Accredited #176507
Arch Environmental Group
37720 Interchange Dr.
Farmington Hills, MI 48335
LEC-03.FS.DP.TMDL
05/18/2020
05/18/2020Sample Date:
Submit Date:
Lathers Early Childhood Center-TMDL SamplingProject Name:
Project Number:
BA Report Number: 65049
Parameters Result Units DL Method Reference
Analysis
Date
BA Sample ID: CM05430 AE200001 GCPS
Analyst
To:
Microbiological Analysis
E. coli 1.0 SM9223B M Well 05/18/2020WTCFU/100 ml435.2
DL=Reported detection limit for analytical method requested. Some compounds require special
analytical methods to achieve EGLE designated target detection limits (TDL).
Released by
Date 5/19/2020
1
Report Date: 05/19/2020
Sample ID:
Brighton Analytical LLC
2105 Pless Drive
Brighton, Michigan 48114
Phone: (810)229-7575 (810)229-8650
e-mail:[email protected]
EGLE Certified #9404
NELAC Accredited #176507
Arch Environmental Group
37720 Interchange Dr.
Farmington Hills, MI 48335
LEC-06.FS.DP.TMDL
05/18/2020
05/18/2020Sample Date:
Submit Date:
Lathers Early Childhood Center-TMDL SamplingProject Name:
Project Number:
BA Report Number: 65049
Parameters Result Units DL Method Reference
Analysis
Date
BA Sample ID: CM05431 AE200001 GCPS
Analyst
To:
Microbiological Analysis
E. coli 1.0 SM9223B M Well 05/18/2020WTCFU/100 ml145.5
DL=Reported detection limit for analytical method requested. Some compounds require special
analytical methods to achieve EGLE designated target detection limits (TDL).
Released by
Date 5/19/2020
1
Report Date: 05/19/2020
Sample ID:
Brighton Analytical LLC
2105 Pless Drive
Brighton, Michigan 48114
Phone: (810)229-7575 (810)229-8650
e-mail:[email protected]
EGLE Certified #9404
NELAC Accredited #176507
Arch Environmental Group
37720 Interchange Dr.
Farmington Hills, MI 48335
Blank-TMDL
05/18/2020
05/18/2020Sample Date:
Submit Date:
Douglas 3-4 Building-TMDL SamplingProject Name:
Project Number:
BA Report Number: 65051
Parameters Result Units DL Method Reference
Analysis
Date
BA Sample ID: CM05433 AE200001 GCPS
Analyst
To:
Microbiological Analysis
E. coli 1.0 SM9223B M Well 05/18/2020WTCFU/100 ml0
DL=Reported detection limit for analytical method requested. Some compounds require special
analytical methods to achieve EGLE designated target detection limits (TDL).
Released by
Date 5/19/2020
1
www.archenvgroup.com healthAIR - Industrial Hygiene Services
cleanWATER - Consulting & Testing Services safeEARTH - Hazardous Waste & Recycling Services
DETROIT GRAND RAPIDS CHICAGO (248) 426-0165 (616) 930-4116 (847) 462-9687Farmington Hills, MI Cedar Springs, MI Cary, IL
June 8, 2020
Mr. Neil Greene Director of Operations Garden City Public Schools 33980 Marquette Garden City, Michigan 48135 [email protected]
RE: Project # AE200001 GCPS Total Maximum Daily Load (TMDL) Sampling Report Maplewood Community Center
Dear Mr. Greene:
Arch Environmental Group, Inc. recently conducted a round of TMDL Wet Weather Sampling at discharge point MMC-02.CB.DP at the Maplewood Community Center on May 15, 2020, in accordance with the applicable NPDESPermit requirements. TMDL sampling is used to determine the level of specific pollutants in the stormwatersystem by collecting samples from 50% of the district’s stormwater outfalls/discharge points during arepresentative wet weather event. The sampling results are then evaluated to determine if a particular pointsource needs to be addressed to reduce the pollutant load of the receiving waters. A report regarding the findingsof this round of TMDL Sampling is attached.
If you have questions regarding this report, please feel free to contact please feel free to contact the cleanWATER team at (248) 426-0165.
Sincerely,
Arch Environmental Group, Inc. Environmental Services
Kellie Das Certified Industrial Site Stormwater Operator, I-16237
TMDL Sampling Report Page 2 Project # AE200001 GCPS Maplewood Community Center
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1.0 Project Summary 2.0 TMDL Sampling Procedures 3.0 TMDL Sampling Results 4.0 Conclusion 5.0 Best Management Practices to Reduce TMDL Pollutant Loads
Attachments: TMDL Screening Inspection Log Storm Sewer System Site Map Analytical Results & Chain of Custody
TMDL Sampling Report Page 3 Project # AE200001 GCPS Maplewood Community Center
1.0 / Project Summary Arch Environmental Group, Inc. (AEG) recently conducted a round of Total Maximum Daily Load (TMDL) Sampling for E. coli at discharge location MMC-02.CB.DP at the Maplewood Community Center on May 15, 2020, in accordance with the applicable National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) Permit requirements.
A TMDL describes the process used to determine how much of a pollutant a lake or stream can assimilate and sets pollutant reduction targets for that water body. NPDES Municipal Separate Storm Sewer System (MS4) permits require regulated public entities located within urbanized areas that discharge storm water to an MS4 which leads to a water body designated with a TMDL, to demonstrate progress toward meeting Water Quality Standards (WQS). If the TMDL was written for E. coli or Total Phosphorus (TP), the MS4 permits further require permittees to collect representative samples of storm water discharges from their points of discharge to MS4s which lead to the impacted water bodies.1 Based on a review of the sampling results, Stormwater Best Management Practices (BMP) implementation will be reviewed and BMPs may be updated to ensure progress toward achieving TMDL pollutant load reductions.
Monitoring is not required for Biota/Sediment TMDLs under the MS4 permits.2
The receiving water body of the Maplewood Community Center is the Middle Rouge River. The Rouge River has been designated with TMDLs of E. coli and Biota/Sediment, and/or Dissolved Oxygen. Further details on the TMDL(s) listed can be found in the documents “Total Maximum Daily Load for E. coli for the Rouge River” and “Total Maximum Daily Load for Biota for the River Rouge Watershed, Including Bishop and Tonquish Creeks”. Some examples of potential sources of E. coli in waterways include fecal material from livestock, humans, wildlife, waterfowl such as geese, and sanitary systems. Some examples of potential sources of sediment include erosion and construction activities.
2.0 / TMDL Sampling Procedures Applicable TMDL sampling was conducted with guidance from the “Storm Water Sampling Guidance for Total Phosphorus & E. coli.” Sampling was conducted at designated outfalls/discharge points during a rain event of approximately .25 inches or more. Please see the attached TMDL Screening Inspection Log for specific rainfall amounts. Sampling was conducted on May 15, 2020 and the last significant rain event was on May 14, 2020. The weather history for the rain event is available upon request.
When a dip-cup or similar sampling device was needed to collect the sample, a blank sample was collected to ensure no contamination was coming from the sampling device. The blank collected during this round of TMDL sampling came back at zero (0) CFU for E. coli indicating that the sampling device used was not contaminated. The lab results of the blank sample are attached. Furthermore, all sampling devices were decontaminated with bleach water and distilled water between each sampling location according to the protocol laid out in the “Storm Water Sampling Guidance for Total Phosphorus & E. coli.” Each location sampled was analyzed for pH and temperature while on-site and the sampled outfall/discharge point (OF/DP) was inspected for color, odor, and abnormal vegetative growth. The collected samples were delivered to an external laboratory for analysis.
1 Storm Water Sampling Guidance for Total Phosphorus & E. coli. November 24, 2009. DEQ 2 Addressing Biota TMDLs in Municipal Separate Storm Sewer System Permits” April 5, 2010. DNRE
TMDL Sampling Report Page 4 Project # AE200001 GCPS Maplewood Community Center
3.0 / TMDL Sampling Results
TMDL Benchmark Standards for E. coli:
• E. coli: The WQS for E. coli is the maximum amount of E. coli that is allowable in surface waters of thestate. These standards are known as total body contact and partial body contact standards. Total bodycontact is a more conservative standard used during the summer to protect swimmers during total bodycontact and has the daily maximum of 300 CFU per 100 milliliters (mL). This applies to the warmer monthsof May 1st -October 31stand is the standard being used in this report. Partial body contact is the dailymaximum of 1,000 CFU per 100 mL and applies to the waterways year-round. 3
Structure ID: MMC-02.CB.DP Structure Type: Catch Basin Location: SW of basketball court along road in grass
At the time of the sampling, clear water flow was noted, and MMC-02.CB.DP was free of odors, and abnormal vegetative growth. AEG collected a grab sample from MMC-02.CB.DP and the sample was screened for temperature and pH in the field. An E. coli grab sample was delivered to an external laboratory for analysis. Results from the sampling are summarized below. A more detailed TMDL Screening Inspection Log is also attached at the end of the report.
Parameter: Results: TMDL Benchmark Standard: Units: pH 7.76 6.5 - 9 pH Units Temperature 15.9 N/A Celsius E. coli 868.4 300 CFU per 100mL Total Phosphorus N/A N/A ug/L
The sample results for MMC-02.CB.DP did not identify elevated levels of pH above the TMDL Benchmark Standards. However, highlighted values in the tables above indicate that for outfall location MMC-02.CB.DP, the reported levels for E. coli (868.4 CFU) are above the Michigan Public Health Department standards for Total Body Contact (E. coli >300 CFU).
4.0 / Conclusion AEG did not identify any elevated levels of pH above the TMDL Benchmark Standards for discharge location MMC-02.CB.DP sampled at the Maplewood Community Center on May 15, 2020. However, AEG did identify elevatedlevels of E. coli above the TMDL Benchmark Standards for discharge location MMC-02.CB.DP.
Arch Environmental Group, Inc. recommends that the elevated location MMC-02.CB.DP be re-assessed each permit cycle (two rounds of sampling occur per permit cycle) to ascertain whether greater or reduced potential for E. coli TMDL contribution has occurred. Additionally, these sites will be monitored annually during regularlyscheduled Routine Storm sewer Structural Inspections for changes in conditions or site activities.
Geese, gulls and ducks are speculated to be a major bacterial source in urban areas, particularly where large populations congregate. E. coli (Escherichia Coli) is a sub-group of the fecal coliform group and can be used as an
3 “Michigan’s E. Coli Water Quality Standard Guidance” May, 2016. MDEQ
TMDL Sampling Report Page 5 Project # AE200001 GCPS Maplewood Community Center
indicator of fecal contamination. E. coli bacteria exist in animal and human fecal matter.4 Elevated levels of E. coli typically occur at sites which have leaking sanitary sewer systems, failed septic systems, or populations of wild or domesticated animals. E. coli originating from birds, raccoons and other wildlife may be present in large numbers in stormwater runoff. In an effort to determine the cause of the benchmark exceedance of E. coli, Arch Environmental Group reviewed the layout of the school storm water system as well as past tracer dye studies. Based on this investigation, sanitary sewer contamination from the Maplewood Community Center is not suspected. The source is likely natural sources, such as the presence of wild animals from the soccer field or the courtyard garden. Another possible source is the offsite residential road where there are many trash cans and debris.
5.0 / Best Management Practices to Reduce TMDL Pollutant Loads The Garden City Public Schools’ Stormwater Management Plan (SWMP) identifies and defines the districts BMPs to comply with the Six Minimum Measures that are the front line in the nationwide effort to reducing polluted stormwater discharges to our lake, rivers and streams. The Michigan Department of Environment, Great Lakes, and Energy recognizes that having a Stormwater Management Plan in place built around the Six Minimum Measures specified in the NPDES General Jurisdictional Permit have the potential to significantly contribute to the reduction of TMDL Pollutants in the surface waters of the state. A link to the district’s current SWMP can be found on the district’s website at http://cms.revize.com/revize/gardencityschools/document_center/StudentServices/GCPS%20SWMP%202016%20V2%20Revised%207-19-18.pdf .The Six Minimum Measures are listed below:
• Public Education and Outreach Program (PEP)• Public Involvement and Participation Program (PIP)• Illicit Discharge Elimination Program (IDEP)• Post Construction Stormwater Management Program• Construction Site Stormwater Runoff Control Program• Pollution Prevention/Good Housekeeping Program.
The following is a list of prioritized TMDL best management practices from the districts SWMP that Garden City Public Schools should continue to implement in order to improve water quality impairments associated with the E. coli and Biota/Sediment TMDL of the Rouge River. Prioritization of BMPs is based on Garden City Public Schools targeted TMDL pollutants. Priority is given to BMPs that reduce E. coli loads and address water quality for biota.
E. COLI1. GCPS will use its website to provide the public with information regarding pet waste (SEMCOG links).
Additionally, SEMCOG pet waste posters are placed at various school buildings.2. GCPS will prohibit illicit discharges, inspect and monitor suspected illicit discharges, and enforce
elimination of the illicit discharges and connections.3. GCPS has reviewed all facilities for cross-connections between the sanitary and storm sewer systems.4. GCPS will conduct bimonthly inspections of parking lot and curb areas and hand clean as needed.5. GCPS has established programs for soil erosion and sediment control from new or redevelopment
construction. Such developments require permits and inspections for practices to keep exposed soilson site or controlled from runoff.
4 Sources of E. coli In Surface Water” - Great Lakes Water Institute, University of Wisconsin, Milwaukee http://www.glwi.uwm.edu/research/genomics/ecoli/sources_of_ecoli_in_water.php
TMDL Sampling Report Page 6 Project # AE200001 GCPS Maplewood Community Center
6. GCPS has implemented routine visual inspections of stormwater structural controls.7. GCPS will remove excessive sediments from structural sediment removal systems to maintain the
maximum designed performance. Sediments will be disposed of offsite in accordance with Parts 115or 121.
ALL TMDLs 1. GCPS will continue to use its website to provide the public information regarding local TMDL issues
(E. coli and biota TMDL Best Management Practice).2. GCPS will continue to educate staff, faculty, and students using various venues including the “Seven
Simple Steps to Clean Water” program educational materials developed by the various watershedgroups specifically related to these issues on the stormwater management webpage.
3. The district passed a post-construction stormwater board resolution to require implementation ofthe stormwater standards for construction.
4. Adequately maintains vegetation around stormwater facilities, ditches, and ponds.5. Provide training to applicable staff and confirm training from contractors including restrictions on the
use of phosphorous containing fertilizers, soaps, cleaners and other chemicals that could impact theseparate storm drain system.
GCPS strives to be good stewards of the land within their jurisdiction and to use appropriate Best Management Practices (BMPs) to contribute to the improvement of water quality. GCPS is committed to practicing sound stormwater management practices; including observance and adherence to all local, state, and federal stormwater statutes, rules, and regulations.
Attachments: TMDL Screening Inspection Log Storm Sewer System Site Map Analytical Results & Chain of Custody
cc: AE200001 project file
TMDL Screening Inspection Log
ID Number: Long:
Type:
Outfall Dimensions
Flow Characteristics
Sample ID And Information Lab Analysis: Results: TMDL Threshold: Units: Photo ID:
7.76 6.5 ‐ 9 pH units
15.9 N/A Celsius
868.4 300 CFU per 100mL
N/A N/A ug/L
Building:
Samplers:
Maplewood Community Center Steven RipleyKellie Das
Structure Type Catch Basin
Southwest of basketball court along road in grass
42.331424 83.355407
Location:
Yes, Continous
Downstream basins
Slow
Lat:
Garden City Public Schools5/15/2020
TMDL Sampling
Client:
Date
Inspection Type:
Standing Water Characteristics
Standing Water:
Clear
No
Flow Odor
Velocity of Flow:
Structure Information:
Observations:
12”
Discharge Point
MMC‐02.CB.DP
No
No
No
No
No
Abnormal Growth:
Sewage:
Oil Sheen:
No
Algae:
Bacterial Sheen:
UnlikelyOutfall Characterization:
Sample sent to Lab:
Total Rainfall (Inches): .77
Sample ID:
Temperature:
pH:
E. coli:
Total Phosphorus:
Other:
Other:
Other:
Time Collected:
Current Weather:
Last Rain Event:
Screening Location Type:
No
Staining:
Suds:
Odor:
Color:
Clear
No
Yes
No
Flow Observed:
Source of Flow:
Color of Flow:
Additional Comments:
Discharge point located directly along a residential street.
MMC‐02.CB.DP TMDL
11:45 AM
< 48 Hours
Overcast
Catch Basin
Yes
Slimes:
Arch Environmental Group
37720 Interchange Drive,
Farmington Hills MI 48370
Phone: (248) 426‐0135
Fax: (248) 426‐0136
www.archenvgroup.com
2105 Pless Drive Brighton, Michigan 48114 Phone (810)229-7575 Fax (810)229-8650 E-mail [email protected]
TM
May 18, 2020
Arch Environmental Group
37720 Interchange Dr.
Farmington Hills, MI 48335
Subject: Maplewood Community Center TMDL
AE200001-GCPS
Dear Ms. Sendra :
The invoice for this project will be emailed separately. If you have any questions
concerning the data or invoice, please don't hesitate to contact our office. We
welcome your comments and suggestions to improve our quality systems. Please
reference Brighton Analytical, L.L.C. Project ID 65023 when calling or emailing.
We thank you for this opportunity to partner with you on this project and hope to
work with you again in the future.
Thank you for making Brighton Analytical, L.L.C. your laboratory of choice.
Attached are the results for the samples submitted on 05/15/2020 for the above
mentioned project. NELAP/TNI Accredited Analysis and EGLE Drinking Water
Certified Analysis will be identified in their respective reporting formats. Hard
copies can be supplied at your request for a fee of $20.00 per copy.
Sincerely,
Brighton Analytical, L.L.C.
Environment, Great Lakes, and Energy
Report Date: 05/18/2020
Sample ID:
Brighton Analytical LLC
2105 Pless Drive
Brighton, Michigan 48114
Phone: (810)229-7575 (810)229-8650
e-mail:[email protected]
EGLE Certified #9404
NELAC Accredited #176507
Arch Environmental Group
37720 Interchange Dr.
Farmington Hills, MI 48335
MMC-02.CB.DP TMDL
05/15/2020
05/15/2020Sample Date:
Submit Date:
Maplewood Community Center TMDLProject Name:
Project Number:
BA Report Number: 65023
Parameters Result Units DL Method Reference
Analysis
Date
BA Sample ID: CM05369 AE200001-GCPS
Analyst
To:
Microbiological Analysis
E. coli 1.0 SM9223B M Well 05/15/2020WTCFU/100 ml868.4
DL=Reported detection limit for analytical method requested. Some compounds require special
analytical methods to achieve EGLE designated target detection limits (TDL).
Released by
Date 5/18/2020
1
Report Date: 05/18/2020
Sample ID:
Brighton Analytical LLC
2105 Pless Drive
Brighton, Michigan 48114
Phone: (810)229-7575 (810)229-8650
e-mail:[email protected]
EGLE Certified #9404
NELAC Accredited #176507
Arch Environmental Group
37720 Interchange Dr.
Farmington Hills, MI 48335
Blank-Dip Cup TMDL
05/15/2020
05/15/2020Sample Date:
Submit Date:
Cambridge-Garden City High SchoolProject Name:
Project Number:
BA Report Number: 65025
Parameters Result Units DL Method Reference
Analysis
Date
BA Sample ID: CM05375 AE200001-GCPS
Analyst
To:
Microbiological Analysis
E. coli 1.0 SM9223B M Well 05/15/2020WTCFU/100 ml0
DL=Reported detection limit for analytical method requested. Some compounds require special
analytical methods to achieve EGLE designated target detection limits (TDL).
Released by
Date 5/18/2020
1
www.archenvgroup.com
healthAIR - Industrial Hygiene Services cleanWATER - Consulting & Testing Services
safeEARTH - Hazardous Waste & Recycling Services
DETROIT GRAND RAPIDS CHICAGO (248) 426-0165 (616) 930-4116 (847) 462-9687 Farmington Hills, MI Cedar Springs, MI Cary, IL
July 20, 2020 Mr. Neil Greene Director of Operations Garden City Public Schools 33980 Marquette Garden City, Michigan 48135 [email protected] RE: Project # AE200001 GCPS Total Maximum Daily Load (TMDL) Sampling Report Memorial 1-2 Campus Dear Mr. Greene: Arch Environmental Group, Inc. recently conducted a round of TMDL Wet Weather Sampling at discharge points MML-02.MH.DP and MML-03.MH.DP at Memorial 1-2 Campus on May 15, 2020, in accordance with the applicable NPDES Permit requirements. TMDL sampling is used to determine the level of specific pollutants in the stormwater system by collecting samples from 50% of the district’s stormwater outfalls/discharge points during a representative wet weather event. The sampling results are then evaluated to determine if a particular point source needs to be addressed to reduce the pollutant load of the receiving waters. A report regarding the findings of this round of TMDL Sampling is attached. If you have questions regarding this report, please feel free to contact please feel free to contact the cleanWATER team at (248) 426-0165. Sincerely, Arch Environmental Group, Inc. Environmental Services
Kellie Das Certified Industrial Site Stormwater Operator, I-16237
TMDL Sampling Report Page 2 Project # AE200001 GCPS Memorial 1-2 Campus
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1.0 Project Summary 2.0 TMDL Sampling Procedures 3.0 TMDL Sampling Results 4.0 Conclusion 5.0 Best Management Practices to Reduce TMDL Pollutant Loads
Attachments: TMDL Screening Inspection Logs Storm Sewer System Site Map Analytical Results & Chain of Custody
TMDL Sampling Report Page 3 Project # AE200001 GCPS Memorial 1-2 Campus
1.0 / Project Summary Arch Environmental Group, Inc. (AEG) recently conducted a round of Total Maximum Daily Load (TMDL) Sampling for E. coli at discharge locations MML-02.MH.DP and MML-03.MH.DP at Memorial 1-2 Campus on May 15, 2020, in accordance with the applicable National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) Permit requirements.
A TMDL describes the process used to determine how much of a pollutant a lake or stream can assimilate and sets pollutant reduction targets for that water body. NPDES Municipal Separate Storm Sewer System (MS4) permits require regulated public entities located within urbanized areas that discharge storm water to an MS4 which leads to a water body designated with a TMDL, to demonstrate progress toward meeting Water Quality Standards (WQS). If the TMDL was written for E. coli or Total Phosphorus (TP), the MS4 permits further require permittees to collect representative samples of storm water discharges from their points of discharge to MS4s which lead to the impacted water bodies.1 Based on a review of the sampling results, Stormwater Best Management Practices (BMP) implementation will be reviewed and BMPs may be updated to ensure progress toward achieving TMDL pollutant load reductions.
Monitoring is not required for Biota/Sediment TMDLs under the MS4 permits.2
The receiving water body of Memorial 1-2 Campus is the Middle Rouge River. The Rouge River has been designated with TMDLs of E. coli and Biota/Sediment. Further details on the TMDL(s) listed can be found in the documents “Total Maximum Daily Load for E. coli for the Rouge River” and “Total Maximum Daily Load for Biota for the River Rouge Watershed, Including Bishop and Tonquish Creeks”. Some examples of potential sources of E. coli in waterways include fecal material from livestock, humans, wildlife, waterfowl such as geese, and sanitary systems. Some examples of potential sources of sediment include erosion and construction activities.
2.0 / TMDL Sampling Procedures Applicable TMDL sampling was conducted with guidance from the “Storm Water Sampling Guidance for Total Phosphorus & E. coli.” Sampling was conducted at designated outfalls/discharge points during a rain event of approximately .25 inches or more. Please see the attached TMDL Screening Inspection Log for specific rainfall amounts. Sampling was conducted on May 15, 2020 and the last significant rain event was on May 14, 2020. The weather history for the rain event is available upon request.
When a dip-cup or similar sampling device was needed to collect the sample, a blank sample was collected to ensure no contamination was coming from the sampling device. The blank collected during this round of TMDL sampling came back at zero (0) CFU for E. coli indicating that the sampling device used was not contaminated. The lab results of the blank sample are attached. Furthermore, all sampling devices were decontaminated with bleach water and distilled water between each sampling location according to the protocol laid out in the “Storm Water Sampling Guidance for Total Phosphorus & E. coli.” Each location sampled was analyzed for pH and temperature while on-site and the sampled outfall/discharge point (OF/DP) was inspected for color, odor, and abnormal vegetative growth. The collected samples were delivered to an external laboratory for analysis.
3.0 / TMDL Sampling Results
TMDL Benchmark Standards for E. coli:
• E. coli: The WQS for E. coli is the maximum amount of E. coli that is allowable in surface waters of the state. These standards are known as total body contact and partial body contact standards. Total body
1 Storm Water Sampling Guidance for Total Phosphorus & E. coli. November 24, 2009. DEQ 2 Addressing Biota TMDLs in Municipal Separate Storm Sewer System Permits” April 5, 2010. DNRE
TMDL Sampling Report Page 4 Project # AE200001 GCPS Memorial 1-2 Campus
contact is a more conservative standard used during the summer to protect swimmers during total body contact and has the daily maximum of 300 CFU per 100 milliliters (mL). This applies to the warmer months of May 1st -October 31stand is the standard being used in this report. Partial body contact is the daily maximum of 1,000 CFU per 100 mL and applies to the waterways year-round. 3
Structure ID: MML-02.MH.DP Structure Type: Manhole Location: NE corner of property, in grass
At the time of the sampling, clear water flow was noted, and MML-02.MH.DP was free of odors, and abnormal vegetative growth. AEG collected a grab sample from MML-02.MH.DP and the sample was screened for temperature and pH in the field. An E. coli grab sample was delivered to an external laboratory for analysis. Results from the sampling are summarized below. A more detailed TMDL Screening Inspection Log is also attached at the end of the report.
Parameter: Results: TMDL Benchmark Standard: Units: pH 8.29 6.5 - 9 pH Units Temperature 17.9 N/A Celsius E. coli 149.5 300 CFU per 100mL Total Phosphorus N/A N/A ug/L
The sample results for MML-02.MH.DP did not identify elevated levels of pH or E. coli above the TMDL Benchmark Standards. The reported levels for E. coli (149.5 CFU) are below the Michigan Public Health Department standards for Total Body Contact (E. coli >300 CFU).
Structure ID: MML-03.MH.DP Structure Type: Manhole Location: SE corner of W parking lot, N of drive in grass
At the time of the sampling, clear water flow was noted, and MML-03.MH.DP was free of odors, and abnormal vegetative growth. There were organic suds noted in MML-03.MH.DP, as well as a slight oil sheen. AEG collected a grab sample from MML-03.MH.DP and the sample was screened for temperature and pH in the field. An E. coli grab sample was delivered to an external laboratory for analysis. Results from the sampling are summarized below. A more detailed TMDL Screening Inspection Log is also attached at the end of the report.
Parameter: Results: TMDL Benchmark Standard: Units: pH 7.98 6.5 - 9 pH Units Temperature 16.9 N/A Celsius E. coli 2419.6 300 CFU per 100mL Total Phosphorus N/A N/A ug/L
The sample results for MML-03.MH.DP did not identify elevated levels of pH above the TMDL Benchmark Standards. However, highlighted values in the tables above indicate that for outfall location MML-03.MH.DP, the reported levels for E. coli (2419.6 CFU) are above the Michigan Public Health Department standards for Total Body Contact (E. coli >300 CFU)
3 “Michigan’s E. Coli Water Quality Standard Guidance” May 2016. MDEQ
TMDL Sampling Report Page 5 Project # AE200001 GCPS Memorial 1-2 Campus
4.0 / Conclusion AEG did not identify any elevated levels of pH or E. coli above the TMDL Benchmark Standards for discharge location MML-02.MH.DP sampled at Memorial 1-2 Campus on May 15, 2020. However, AEG did identify elevated levels of E. coli above the TMDL Benchmark Standards for discharge location MML-03.MH.DP.
Arch Environmental Group, Inc. recommends that the elevated location MML-03.MH.DP be re-assessed each permit cycle (two rounds of sampling occur per permit cycle) to ascertain whether greater or reduced potential for E. coli TMDL contribution has occurred. Additionally, these sites will be monitored annually during regularly scheduled Routine Storm sewer Structural Inspections for changes in conditions or site activities.
Geese, gulls, and ducks are speculated to be a major bacterial source in urban areas, particularly where large populations congregate. E. coli (Escherichia Coli) is a sub-group of the fecal coliform group and can be used as an indicator of fecal contamination. E. coli bacteria exist in animal and human fecal matter.4 Elevated levels of E. coli typically occur at sites which have leaking sanitary sewer systems, failed septic systems, or populations of wild or domesticated animals. E. coli originating from birds, raccoons and other wildlife may be present in large numbers in stormwater runoff. In an effort to determine the cause of the benchmark exceedance of E. coli, Arch Environmental Group reviewed the layout of the school storm water system as well as past tracer dye studies. Based on this investigation, sanitary sewer contamination from Memorial 1-2 Campus is not suspected. The source is likely natural sources, such as the presence of wild animals in the open fields and playground area.
5.0 / Best Management Practices to Reduce TMDL Pollutant Loads The Garden City Public Schools’ Stormwater Management Plan (SWMP) identifies and defines the districts BMPs to comply with the Six Minimum Measures that are the front line in the nationwide effort to reducing polluted stormwater discharges to our lake, rivers and streams. The Michigan Department of Environment, Great Lakes, and Energy recognizes that having a Stormwater Management Plan in place built around the Six Minimum Measures specified in the NPDES General Jurisdictional Permit have the potential to significantly contribute to the reduction of TMDL Pollutants in the surface waters of the state. A link to the district’s current SWMP can be found on the district’s website at http://cms.revize.com/revize/gardencityschools/document_center/StudentServices/GCPS%20SWMP%202016%20V2%20Revised%207-19-18.pdf .The Six Minimum Measures are listed below:
• Public Education and Outreach Program (PEP) • Public Involvement and Participation Program (PIP) • Illicit Discharge Elimination Program (IDEP) • Post Construction Stormwater Management Program • Construction Site Stormwater Runoff Control Program • Pollution Prevention/Good Housekeeping Program.
The following is a list of prioritized TMDL best management practices from the districts SWMP that Garden City Public Schools should continue to implement in order to improve water quality impairments associated with the E. coli and Biota/Sediment TMDL of the Rouge River. Prioritization of BMPs is based on Garden City Public Schools targeted TMDL pollutants. Priority is given to BMPs that reduce E. coli loads and address water quality for biota.
E. COLI
4 Sources of E. coli In Surface Water” - Great Lakes Water Institute, University of Wisconsin, Milwaukee http://www.glwi.uwm.edu/research/genomics/ecoli/sources_of_ecoli_in_water.php
TMDL Sampling Report Page 6 Project # AE200001 GCPS Memorial 1-2 Campus
1. GCPS will use its website to provide the public with information regarding pet waste (SEMCOG links). Additionally, SEMCOG pet waste posters are placed at various school buildings.
2. GCPS will prohibit illicit discharges, inspect, and monitor suspected illicit discharges, and enforce elimination of the illicit discharges and connections.
3. GCPS has reviewed all facilities for cross-connections between the sanitary and storm sewer systems. 4. GCPS will conduct bimonthly inspections of parking lot and curb areas and hand clean as needed. 5. GCPS has established programs for soil erosion and sediment control from new or redevelopment
construction. Such developments require permits and inspections for practices to keep exposed soils on site or controlled from runoff.
6. GCPS has implemented routine visual inspections of stormwater structural controls. 7. GCPS will remove excessive sediments from structural sediment removal systems to maintain the
maximum designed performance. Sediments will be disposed of offsite in accordance with Parts 115 or 121.
ALL TMDLs 1. GCPS will continue to use its website to provide the public information regarding local TMDL issues
(E. coli and biota TMDL Best Management Practice). 2. GCPS will continue to educate staff, faculty, and students using various venues including the “Seven
Simple Steps to Clean Water” program educational materials developed by the various watershed groups specifically related to these issues on the stormwater management webpage.
3. The district passed a post-construction stormwater board resolution to require implementation of the stormwater standards for construction.
4. Adequately maintains vegetation around stormwater facilities, ditches, and ponds. 5. Provide training to applicable staff and confirm training from contractors including restrictions on the
use of phosphorous containing fertilizers, soaps, cleaners, and other chemicals that could impact the separate storm drain system.
GCPS strives to be good stewards of the land within their jurisdiction and to use appropriate Best Management Practices (BMPs) to contribute to the improvement of water quality. GCPS is committed to practicing sound stormwater management practices; including observance and adherence to all local, state, and federal stormwater statutes, rules, and regulations.
Attachments: TMDL Screening Inspection Logs Storm Sewer System Site Map Analytical Results & Chain of Custody cc: AE200001 project file
TMDL Screening Inspection Log
ID Number: Long:
Type:
Outfall Dimensions
Flow Characteristics
Sample ID And Information Lab Analysis: Results: TMDL Threshold: Units: Photo ID:
8.29 6.5 ‐ 9 pH units
17.9 N/A Celsius
149.5 300 CFU per 100mL
N/A N/A ug/L
Slimes:
No
Staining:
Suds:
Odor:
Color:
Clear
No
Yes
No
Flow Observed:
Source of Flow:
Color of Flow:
Additional Comments:
MML‐02.MH.DP TMDL
3:00 PM
< 48 Hours
Overcast
Manhole
Yes
Algae:
Bacterial Sheen:
UnlikelyOutfall Characterization:
Sample sent to Lab:
Total Rainfall (Inches): .77
Sample ID:
Temperature:
pH:
E. coli:
Total Phosphorus:
Other:
Other:
Other:
Time Collected:
Current Weather:
Last Rain Event:
Screening Location Type:
Flow Odor
Velocity of Flow:
Structure Information:
Observations:
12”
Discharge Point
MML‐02.MH.DP
No
No
No
No
No
Abnormal Growth:
Sewage:
Oil Sheen:
No
Building:
Samplers:
Memorial 1‐2 CampusSteven RipleyKellie Das
Structure Type Manhole
Northeast corner of property, in grass
42.19521 83.20841
Location:
Yes, Continous
Downstream basins and field drain
Slow
Lat:
Garden City Public Schools5/15/2020
TMDL Sampling
Client:
Date
Inspection Type:
Standing Water Characteristics
Standing Water:
Clear
No
Arch Environmental Group
37720 Interchange Drive,
Farmington Hills MI 48370
Phone: (248) 426‐0135
Fax: (248) 426‐0136
www.archenvgroup.com
TMDL Screening Inspection Log
ID Number: Long:
Type:
Outfall Dimensions
Flow Characteristics
Sample ID And Information Lab Analysis: Results: TMDL Threshold: Units: Photo ID:
7.98 6.5 ‐ 9 pH units
16.9 N/A Celsius
2419.6 300 CFU per 100mL
N/A N/A ug/L
Garden City Public SchoolsDate 5/15/2020
Inspection Type: TMDL Sampling
Sample sent to Lab: Yes
Inspectors: Kellie Das Steven RipleyClient:
Color:
Location:
Building: Memorial 1‐2 Campus
Manhole
Slight
No
Clear Source of Flow:
No
Organic
No
Flow Observed:
12”
Velocity of Flow: Slow
Structure Information:
MML‐03.MH.DPStructure Type Lat: 42.19872 83.20818
Southeast corner of west parking lot, north of drive in grass
Observations:
Standing Water Characteristics
Color of Flow: Clear
Odor:
Standing Water: Yes Yes, Continous
Discharge Point
Downstream basins
Flow Odor No
Oil Sheen:
Staining:
Suds:
Sewage: Additional Comments:
Bacterial Sheen: No Stormwater in MML‐03.MH.DP had a lot of debris and slight oil sheen was noted. Stormwater looked dirty with some
organic suds.Algae: No
Slimes: No
Abnormal Growth: No
Sample ID: MML‐03.MH.DP TMDL pH:
Time Collected: 2:50 PM Temperature:
Last Rain Event: < 48 Hours E. coli:
Current Weather: Overcast Total Phosphorus:
Sample Location Type: Manhole Other:
Total Rainfall (Inches) .77 Other:
Other:
UnlikelyOutfall Characterization:
Arch Environmental Group
37720 Interchange Drive,
Farmington Hills MI 48370
Phone: (248) 426‐0135
Fax: (248) 426‐0136
www.archenvgroup.com
2105 Pless Drive Brighton, Michigan 48114 Phone (810)229-7575 Fax (810)229-8650 E-mail [email protected]
TM
May 18, 2020
Arch Environmental Group
37720 Interchange Dr.
Farmington Hills, MI 48335
Subject: Memorial 1-2 Campus TMDL
AE200001-GCPS
Dear Ms. Sendra :
The invoice for this project will be emailed separately. If you have any questions
concerning the data or invoice, please don't hesitate to contact our office. We
welcome your comments and suggestions to improve our quality systems. Please
reference Brighton Analytical, L.L.C. Project ID 65027 when calling or emailing.
We thank you for this opportunity to partner with you on this project and hope to
work with you again in the future.
Thank you for making Brighton Analytical, L.L.C. your laboratory of choice.
Attached are the results for the samples submitted on 05/15/2020 for the above
mentioned project. NELAP/TNI Accredited Analysis and EGLE Drinking Water
Certified Analysis will be identified in their respective reporting formats. Hard
copies can be supplied at your request for a fee of $20.00 per copy.
Sincerely,
Brighton Analytical, L.L.C.
Environment, Great Lakes, and Energy
Report Date: 05/18/2020
Sample ID:
Brighton Analytical LLC
2105 Pless Drive
Brighton, Michigan 48114
Phone: (810)229-7575 (810)229-8650
e-mail:[email protected]
EGLE Certified #9404
NELAC Accredited #176507
Arch Environmental Group
37720 Interchange Dr.
Farmington Hills, MI 48335
MML-03.MH.DP TMDL
05/15/2020
05/15/2020Sample Date:
Submit Date:
Memorial 1-2 Campus TMDLProject Name:
Project Number:
BA Report Number: 65027
Parameters Result Units DL Method Reference
Analysis
Date
BA Sample ID: CM05377 AE200001-GCPS
Analyst
To:
Microbiological Analysis
E. coli 1.0 SM9223B M Well 05/15/2020WTCFU/100 ml2419.6
DL=Reported detection limit for analytical method requested. Some compounds require special
analytical methods to achieve EGLE designated target detection limits (TDL).
Released by
Date 5/18/2020
1
Report Date: 05/18/2020
Sample ID:
Brighton Analytical LLC
2105 Pless Drive
Brighton, Michigan 48114
Phone: (810)229-7575 (810)229-8650
e-mail:[email protected]
EGLE Certified #9404
NELAC Accredited #176507
Arch Environmental Group
37720 Interchange Dr.
Farmington Hills, MI 48335
MML-02.MH.DP TMDL
05/15/2020
05/15/2020Sample Date:
Submit Date:
Memorial 1-2 Campus TMDLProject Name:
Project Number:
BA Report Number: 65027
Parameters Result Units DL Method Reference
Analysis
Date
BA Sample ID: CM05378 AE200001-GCPS
Analyst
To:
Microbiological Analysis
E. coli 1.0 SM9223B M Well 05/15/2020WTCFU/100 ml149.5
DL=Reported detection limit for analytical method requested. Some compounds require special
analytical methods to achieve EGLE designated target detection limits (TDL).
Released by
Date 5/18/2020
1
Report Date: 05/18/2020
Sample ID:
Brighton Analytical LLC
2105 Pless Drive
Brighton, Michigan 48114
Phone: (810)229-7575 (810)229-8650
e-mail:[email protected]
EGLE Certified #9404
NELAC Accredited #176507
Arch Environmental Group
37720 Interchange Dr.
Farmington Hills, MI 48335
Blank-Dip Cup TMDL
05/15/2020
05/15/2020Sample Date:
Submit Date:
Cambridge-Garden City High SchoolProject Name:
Project Number:
BA Report Number: 65025
Parameters Result Units DL Method Reference
Analysis
Date
BA Sample ID: CM05375 AE200001-GCPS
Analyst
To:
Microbiological Analysis
E. coli 1.0 SM9223B M Well 05/15/2020WTCFU/100 ml0
DL=Reported detection limit for analytical method requested. Some compounds require special
analytical methods to achieve EGLE designated target detection limits (TDL).
Released by
Date 5/18/2020
1
www.archenvgroup.com
healthAIR - Industrial Hygiene Services cleanWATER - Consulting & Testing Services
safeEARTH - Hazardous Waste & Recycling Services
DETROIT GRAND RAPIDS CHICAGO (248) 426-0165 (616) 930-4116 (847) 462-9687 Farmington Hills, MI Cedar Springs, MI Cary, IL
June 8, 2020 Mr. Neil Greene Director of Operations Garden City Public Schools 33980 Marquette Garden City, Michigan 48135 [email protected] RE: Project # AE200001 GCPS Total Maximum Daily Load (TMDL) Sampling Report Transportation and School Board Office Dear Mr. Greene: Arch Environmental Group, Inc. recently conducted a round of TMDL Wet Weather Sampling at discharge point GCT-08.CB.DP at the Transportation and School Board Office on May 15, 2020, in accordance with the applicable NPDES Permit requirements. TMDL sampling is used to determine the level of specific pollutants in the stormwater system by collecting samples from 50% of the district’s stormwater outfalls/discharge points during a representative wet weather event. The sampling results are then evaluated to determine if a particular point source needs to be addressed to reduce the pollutant load of the receiving waters. A report regarding the findings of this round of TMDL Sampling is attached. If you have questions regarding this report, please feel free to contact please feel free to contact the cleanWATER team at (248) 426-0165. Sincerely, Arch Environmental Group, Inc. Environmental Services
Kellie Das Certified Industrial Site Stormwater Operator, I-16237
TMDL Sampling Report Page 2 Project # AE200001 GCPS Transportation and School Board Office
TABLE OF CONTENTS
1.0 Project Summary 2.0 TMDL Sampling Procedures 3.0 TMDL Sampling Results 4.0 Conclusion 5.0 Best Management Practices to Reduce TMDL Pollutant Loads
Attachments: TMDL Screening Inspection Log Storm Sewer System Site Map Analytical Results & Chain of Custody
TMDL Sampling Report Page 3 Project # AE200001 GCPS Transportation and School Board Office
1.0 / Project Summary Arch Environmental Group, Inc. (AEG) recently conducted a round of Total Maximum Daily Load (TMDL) Sampling for E. coli at discharge location GCT-08.CB.DP at the Transportation and School Board Office on May 15, 2020, in accordance with the applicable National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System (NPDES) Permit requirements.
A TMDL describes the process used to determine how much of a pollutant a lake or stream can assimilate and sets pollutant reduction targets for that water body. NPDES Municipal Separate Storm Sewer System (MS4) permits require regulated public entities located within urbanized areas that discharge storm water to an MS4 which leads to a water body designated with a TMDL, to demonstrate progress toward meeting Water Quality Standards (WQS). If the TMDL was written for E. coli or Total Phosphorus (TP), the MS4 permits further require permittees to collect representative samples of storm water discharges from their points of discharge to MS4s which lead to the impacted water bodies.1 Based on a review of the sampling results, Stormwater Best Management Practices (BMP) implementation will be reviewed and BMPs may be updated to ensure progress toward achieving TMDL pollutant load reductions.
Monitoring is not required for Biota/Sediment TMDLs under the MS4 permits.2
The receiving water body of the Transportation and School Board Office is the Morgan Drain of the Rouge River. The Rouge River has been designated with TMDLs of E. coli and Biota/Sediment, and/or Dissolved Oxygen. Further details on the TMDLs listed can be found in the documents “Total Maximum Daily Load for E. coli for the Rouge River” and “Total Maximum Daily Load for Biota for the River Rouge Watershed, Including Bishop and Tonquish Creeks”. Some examples of potential sources of E. coli in waterways include fecal material from livestock, humans, wildlife, waterfowl such as geese, and sanitary systems. Some examples of potential sources of sediment include erosion and construction activities.
2.0 / TMDL Sampling Procedures Applicable TMDL sampling was conducted with guidance from the “Storm Water Sampling Guidance for Total Phosphorus & E. coli.” Sampling was conducted at designated outfalls/discharge points during a rain event of approximately .25 inches or more. Please see the attached TMDL Screening Inspection Log for specific rainfall amounts. Sampling was conducted on May 15, 2020 and the last significant rain event was on May 14, 2020. The weather history for the rain event is available upon request.
When a dip-cup or similar sampling device was needed to collect the sample, a blank sample was collected to ensure no contamination was coming from the sampling device. The blank collected during this round of TMDL sampling came back at zero (0) CFU for E. coli indicating that the sampling device used was not contaminated. The lab results of the blank sample are attached. Furthermore, all sampling devices were decontaminated with bleach water and distilled water between each sampling location according to the protocol laid out in the “Storm Water Sampling Guidance for Total Phosphorus & E. coli.” Each location sampled was analyzed for pH and temperature while on-site and the sampled outfall/discharge point (OF/DP) was inspected for color, odor, and abnormal vegetative growth. The collected samples were delivered to an external laboratory for analysis.
3.0 / TMDL Sampling Results
TMDL Benchmark Standards for E. coli:
1 Storm Water Sampling Guidance for Total Phosphorus & E. coli. November 24, 2009. DEQ 2 Addressing Biota TMDLs in Municipal Separate Storm Sewer System Permits” April 5, 2010. DNRE
TMDL Sampling Report Page 4 Project # AE200001 GCPS Transportation and School Board Office
• E. coli: The WQS for E. coli is the maximum amount of E. coli that is allowable in surface waters of the state. These standards are known as total body contact and partial body contact standards. Total body contact is a more conservative standard used during the summer to protect swimmers during total body contact and has the daily maximum of 300 CFU per 100 milliliters (mL). This applies to the warmer months of May 1st -October 31stand is the standard being used in this report. Partial body contact is the daily maximum of 1,000 CFU per 100 mL and applies to the waterways year-round. 3
Structure ID: GCT-08.CB.DP Structure Type: Catch Basin Location: S property line, E of school board sign, in grass
At the time of the sampling, clear water flow was noted, and GCT-08.CB.DP was free of odors, and abnormal vegetative growth. AEG collected a grab sample from GCT-08.CB.DP and the sample was screened for temperature and pH in the field. An E. coli grab sample was delivered to an external laboratory for analysis. Results from the sampling are summarized below. A more detailed TMDL Screening Inspection Log is also attached at the end of the report.
Parameter: Results: TMDL Benchmark Standard: Units: pH 7.95 6.5 - 9 pH Units Temperature 16.7 N/A Celsius E. coli 686.7 300 CFU per 100mL Total Phosphorus N/A N/A ug/L
The sample results for GCT-08.CB.DP did not identify elevated levels of pH above the TMDL Benchmark Standards. However, highlighted values in the tables above indicate that for outfall location GCT-08.CB.DP, the reported levels for E. coli (686.7 CFU) are above the Michigan Public Health Department standards for Total Body Contact (E. coli >300 CFU).
4.0 / Conclusion AEG did not identify any elevated levels of pH above the TMDL Benchmark Standards for discharge location GCT-08.CB.DP sampled at the Transportation and School Board Office on May 15, 2020. However, AEG did identify elevated levels of E. coli above the TMDL Benchmark Standards for discharge location GCT-08.CB.DP.
Arch Environmental Group, Inc. recommends that the elevated location GCT-08.CB.DP be re-assessed each permit cycle (two rounds of sampling occur per permit cycle) to ascertain whether greater or reduced potential for E. coli TMDL contribution has occurred. Additionally, these sites will be monitored annually during regularly scheduled Routine Storm sewer Structural Inspections for changes in conditions or site activities.
Geese, gulls and ducks are speculated to be a major bacterial source in urban areas, particularly where large populations congregate. E. coli (Escherichia Coli) is a sub-group of the fecal coliform group and can be used as an indicator of fecal contamination. E. coli bacteria exist in animal and human fecal matter.4 Elevated levels of E. coli typically occur at sites which have leaking sanitary sewer systems, failed septic systems, or populations of wild or domesticated animals. E. coli originating from birds, raccoons and other wildlife may be present in large numbers in stormwater runoff. In an effort to determine the cause of the benchmark exceedance of E. coli, Arch
3 “Michigan’s E. Coli Water Quality Standard Guidance” May, 2016. MDEQ 4 Sources of E. coli In Surface Water” - Great Lakes Water Institute, University of Wisconsin, Milwaukee http://www.glwi.uwm.edu/research/genomics/ecoli/sources_of_ecoli_in_water.php
TMDL Sampling Report Page 5 Project # AE200001 GCPS Transportation and School Board Office
Environmental Group reviewed the layout of the school storm water system as well as past tracer dye studies. Based on this investigation, sanitary sewer contamination from the Transportation and School Board Office is not suspected. The source is likely natural sources, such as the presence of wild animals in the football field and baseball field. There are many open fields throughout the facility.
5.0 / Best Management Practices to Reduce TMDL Pollutant Loads The Garden City Public Schools’ Stormwater Management Plan (SWMP) identifies and defines the districts BMPs to comply with the Six Minimum Measures that are the front line in the nationwide effort to reducing polluted stormwater discharges to our lake, rivers and streams. The Michigan Department of Environment, Great Lakes, and Energy recognizes that having a Stormwater Management Plan in place built around the Six Minimum Measures specified in the NPDES General Jurisdictional Permit have the potential to significantly contribute to the reduction of TMDL Pollutants in the surface waters of the state. A link to the district’s current SWMP can be found on the district’s website at http://cms.revize.com/revize/gardencityschools/document_center/StudentServices/GCPS%20SWMP%202016%20V2%20Revised%207-19-18.pdf .The Six Minimum Measures are listed below:
• Public Education and Outreach Program (PEP) • Public Involvement and Participation Program (PIP) • Illicit Discharge Elimination Program (IDEP) • Post Construction Stormwater Management Program • Construction Site Stormwater Runoff Control Program • Pollution Prevention/Good Housekeeping Program.
The following is a list of prioritized TMDL best management practices from the districts SWMP that Garden City Public Schools should continue to implement in order to improve water quality impairments associated with the E. coli and Biota/Sediment TMDL of the Rouge River. Prioritization of BMPs is based on Garden City Public Schools targeted TMDL pollutants. Priority is given to BMPs that reduce E. coli loads and address water quality for biota.
E. COLI 1. GCPS will use its website to provide the public with information regarding pet waste (SEMCOG links).
Additionally, SEMCOG pet waste posters are placed at various school buildings. 2. GCPS will prohibit illicit discharges, inspect and monitor suspected illicit discharges, and enforce
elimination of the illicit discharges and connections. 3. GCPS has reviewed all facilities for cross-connections between the sanitary and storm sewer systems. 4. GCPS will conduct bimonthly inspections of parking lot and curb areas and hand clean as needed. 5. GCPS has established programs for soil erosion and sediment control from new or redevelopment
construction. Such developments require permits and inspections for practices to keep exposed soils on site or controlled from runoff.
6. GCPS has implemented routine visual inspections of stormwater structural controls. 7. GCPS will remove excessive sediments from structural sediment removal systems to maintain the
maximum designed performance. Sediments will be disposed of offsite in accordance with Parts 115 or 121.
ALL TMDLs 1. GCPS will continue to use its website to provide the public information regarding local TMDL issues
(E. coli and biota TMDL Best Management Practice).
TMDL Sampling Report Page 6 Project # AE200001 GCPS Transportation and School Board Office
2. GCPS will continue to educate staff, faculty, and students using various venues including the “Seven Simple Steps to Clean Water” program educational materials developed by the various watershed groups specifically related to these issues on the stormwater management webpage.
3. The district passed a post-construction stormwater board resolution to require implementation of the stormwater standards for construction.
4. Adequately maintains vegetation around stormwater facilities, ditches, and ponds. 5. Provide training to applicable staff and confirm training from contractors including restrictions on the
use of phosphorous containing fertilizers, soaps, cleaners and other chemicals that could impact the separate storm drain system.
GCPS strives to be good stewards of the land within their jurisdiction and to use appropriate Best Management Practices (BMPs) to contribute to the improvement of water quality. GCPS is committed to practicing sound stormwater management practices; including observance and adherence to all local, state, and federal stormwater statutes, rules, and regulations. Attachments: TMDL Screening Inspection Log Storm Sewer System Site Map Analytical Results & Chain of Custody cc: AE200001 project file
TMDL Screening Inspection Log
ID Number: Long:Type:Outfall Dimensions
Flow Characteristics
Sample ID And Information Lab Analysis: Results: TMDL Threshold: Units: Photo ID:7.95 6.5 - 9 pH units16.7 N/A Celsius
686.7 300 CFU per 100mLN/A N/A ug/L
Building:Samplers:
Transportation and School Board OfficeSteven RipleyKellie Das
Structure Type Catch Basin
South property line, east of school board sign, in grass
42.318599 83.37459
Location:
Yes, ContinousDownstream basins Slow
Lat:
Garden City Public Schools5/15/2020
TMDL Sampling
Client:Date
Inspection Type:
Standing Water CharacteristicsStanding Water:
ClearNo
Flow Odor
Velocity of Flow:
Structure Information:
Observations:30”Discharge PointGCT-08.CB.DP
NoNoNoNoNo
Abnormal Growth:
Sewage:Oil Sheen:
No
Algae:Bacterial Sheen:
UnlikelyOutfall Characterization:
Sample sent to Lab:
Total Rainfall (Inches): .77
Sample ID:Temperature: pH:
E. coli:Total Phosphorus:Other:Other:Other:
Time Collected:
Current Weather:Last Rain Event:
Screening Location Type:
NoStaining:
Suds:Odor:Color:
ClearNo
Yes
No
Flow Observed:Source of Flow:
Color of Flow:
Additional Comments:
GCT-08.CB.DP TMDL 1:40 PM< 48 HoursOvercastCatch Basin
Yes
Slimes:
Arch Environmental Group37720 Interchange Drive, Farmington Hills MI 48370
Phone: (248) 426-0135Fax: (248) 426-0136
www.archenvgroup.com
2105 Pless Drive Brighton, Michigan 48114 Phone (810)229-7575 Fax (810)229-8650 E-mail [email protected]
TM
May 18, 2020
Arch Environmental Group
37720 Interchange Dr.
Farmington Hills, MI 48335
Subject: Transportation & School Board Office TMDL
AE200001-GCPS
Dear Ms. Sendra :
The invoice for this project will be emailed separately. If you have any questions
concerning the data or invoice, please don't hesitate to contact our office. We
welcome your comments and suggestions to improve our quality systems. Please
reference Brighton Analytical, L.L.C. Project ID 65021 when calling or emailing.
We thank you for this opportunity to partner with you on this project and hope to
work with you again in the future.
Thank you for making Brighton Analytical, L.L.C. your laboratory of choice.
Attached are the results for the samples submitted on 05/15/2020 for the above
mentioned project. NELAP/TNI Accredited Analysis and EGLE Drinking Water
Certified Analysis will be identified in their respective reporting formats. Hard
copies can be supplied at your request for a fee of $20.00 per copy.
Sincerely,
Brighton Analytical, L.L.C.
Environment, Great Lakes, and Energy
Report Date: 05/18/2020
Sample ID:
Brighton Analytical LLC
2105 Pless Drive
Brighton, Michigan 48114
Phone: (810)229-7575 (810)229-8650
e-mail:[email protected]
EGLE Certified #9404
NELAC Accredited #176507
Arch Environmental Group
37720 Interchange Dr.
Farmington Hills, MI 48335
GCT-08.CB.DP TMDL
05/15/2020
05/15/2020Sample Date:
Submit Date:
Transportation & School Board Office TMDLProject Name:
Project Number:
BA Report Number: 65021
Parameters Result Units DL Method Reference
Analysis
Date
BA Sample ID: CM05365 AE200001-GCPS
Analyst
To:
Microbiological Analysis
E. coli 1.0 SM9223B M Well 05/15/2020WTCFU/100 ml686.7
DL=Reported detection limit for analytical method requested. Some compounds require special
analytical methods to achieve EGLE designated target detection limits (TDL).
Released by
Date 5/18/2020
1
Report Date: 05/18/2020
Sample ID:
Brighton Analytical LLC
2105 Pless Drive
Brighton, Michigan 48114
Phone: (810)229-7575 (810)229-8650
e-mail:[email protected]
EGLE Certified #9404
NELAC Accredited #176507
Arch Environmental Group
37720 Interchange Dr.
Farmington Hills, MI 48335
Blank-Dip Cup TMDL
05/15/2020
05/15/2020Sample Date:
Submit Date:
Cambridge-Garden City High SchoolProject Name:
Project Number:
BA Report Number: 65025
Parameters Result Units DL Method Reference
Analysis
Date
BA Sample ID: CM05375 AE200001-GCPS
Analyst
To:
Microbiological Analysis
E. coli 1.0 SM9223B M Well 05/15/2020WTCFU/100 ml0
DL=Reported detection limit for analytical method requested. Some compounds require special
analytical methods to achieve EGLE designated target detection limits (TDL).
Released by
Date 5/18/2020
1