Gci Guidelines

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • 7/29/2019 Gci Guidelines

    1/16

    1

    BiotechnologyIndustryResearchAssistanceCouncil(BIRAC)

    AGovernmentofIndiaEnterprise

    AnnouncesaGrandChallengeIndiaFundingOpportunity

    AchievingHealthyGrowththroughAgricultureandNutrition

    WithFundingSupportFromDepartmentofBiotechnology(DBT),MinistryofScienceand

    Technology,GovernmentofIndia&

    Bill&MelindaGatesFoundation(BMGF)

  • 7/29/2019 Gci Guidelines

    2/16

    2

    Tableof

    Contents

    1 Introduction.......................................................................................................................................................3

    2 ProgramGoal............................................ ................................................ ............................................... ..........5

    3 Background........................................................................................................................................................6

    4 ProgramScope..................................................................................................................................................7

    4.1 Fieldsofinnovation...............................................................................................................................7

    4.2 Characteristicsofsuccessfulproposal..........................................................................................9

    4.3 SolutionsdevelopedthroughthisprogramImpactingIndiaandbeyonditsborder9

    4.4 Examplesofwhatwearenotlookingfor........................................... .......................................10

    5 ProgramStructure.......................................................................................................................................10

    5.1 Granttypesandfundinglevels......................................................................................................10

    5.2 Collaboration.........................................................................................................................................11

    6 RulesandGuidelines...................................................................................................................................12

    6.1 Applicationinstructionsandschedule.......................................................................................12

    6.2 Evaluationcriteria...............................................................................................................................136.3 Eligibilitycriteria.................................................................................................................................14

    6.4 AllowableCosts....................................................................................................................................14

    6.5 Warranty.................................................................................................................................................14

    6.6 IntellectualProperty........................................................................................................................144

    6.7Confidentiality.15

    7 RESEARCHASSURANCES..........................................................................................................................15

    7.1 DataAccessPrinciples.......................................................................................................................167.2 Indemnification....................................................................................................................................16

    7.3 ResearchEthicsandRegulatoryApproval16

    8.Contacts16

  • 7/29/2019 Gci Guidelines

    3/16

    3

    1.INTRODUCTIONOn June 2012, the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation (BMGF) and the Department of

    Biotechnology (DBT) signed an umbrella Memorandum of Understanding (MOU) to

    collaborateonmissiondirectedresearchandbuildaGrandChallengesIndiatosupport

    health research and innovation. The MOU aims to support initiatives that could

    dramatically change thehealth anddevelopment landscape in India andothercountries

    facingsimilarchallenges.Specifically,itidentifiesthefollowingprioritiesforcooperation:

    (1)Reductionofmaternalandchildmortalityandmorbidity;

    (2)Scientificandtechnicalsolutionsforinfectiousdiseases;

    (3)StrengtheningIndiasscientifictranslationcapacity;

    (4)Scientificandtechnicaladvancesrelatedtoagriculture,

    (5)Scientificadvancementinfoodandnutrition;

    (6)Otherjointintereststhatmayarise.

    Grand Challenges initiatives would follow these core principles, which partners have

    agreedtoattheannualGrandChallengesmeetinginDelhiin2011:

    1. Strategicandwellarticulatedgrandchallengesservebothtofocusresearcheffortsandtocapturetheimaginationandengagetheworldsbestresearchers.

    2. Projectsareselectedbasedonnationalandsocietalneedandtransparentcallsforproposalsseekingthebestideas.

    3. Funders, investigators and other stakeholders actively collaborate to accelerateprogressand integrate advances to ensure these advanced technologies reach todevelopingcountriesmasses

    4. Projectsareselectednotonlyforscientificexcellence,butalsofortheirlikelihoodtoachievethedesiredimpact,andtheyaremilestonedrivenandactivelymanagedtothatend.

    5. Projectsandinvestigatorswillhavetofollowglobalaccesscommitmentstoensurethefruitsoftheirresearchareavailabletothosemostinneed.

    ThisprogramjoinsotherswithintheGrandChallengesfamilyofgrantprogramssupported

    by the Gates Foundation and its partners that target healthy birth, growth, and

    development, and agricultural productivity. Thus, it will expand a global network of

    scientists working on similar issues, increasing opportunities for exchanging ideas and

    lessonslearned.TworelatedGrandChallengesprogramsthathavebeenawardinggrants

    include Preventing Preterm Birth, which seeks to explore the underlying mechanismsleadingtopretermbirthorstillbirth,emphasizingtheroleof infection,inflammation,and

    poornutrition;andDiscoverNewWaystoAchieveHealthyGrowth,whichseekstoexplore

  • 7/29/2019 Gci Guidelines

    4/16

    4

    molecular pathways that will directly inform the development of interventions for the

    preventionofstuntingandwastingofyoungchildreninthedevelopingworld.Onerelated

    Grand Challenge program is ongoing: SavingLives

    at

    Birth

    A

    Grand

    Challenge

    for

    Development, which seeks to address obstacles to healthy pregnancies and births by

    fostering innovationinmedical technology, indeliveryofqualityhealth services,and in

    stimulating demand for these services. In addition, two Grand Challenges Explorations

    topics: Protect Crop Plantsfrom Biotic Stressesfrom Field toMarket, and Labor SavingStrategiesand InnovationsforWomen SmallholderFarmers, aim toaddress barriers thatsmallholderfarmersface inagriculturalproductivitythroughinnovativesolutionsraising

    yieldandreducinglabor.Thisgoalofcapturingdiversetypesofinnovationtoimprove

    womens and childrens health, nutritional status and agricultural productivity is

    sharedbytheGrandChallengesIndiaprogram.

    BIRACannouncesAchievingHealthyGrowththroughAgricultureandNutritionasthefirstGrandChallengesgrantprogramtobelaunchedinIndia(herebystatedasGCI)asa

    resultof collaborationbetween DBT,BIRAC, and the BMGF. ThisRequest for Proposals

    (RFP) is specific to Indiaand open toanyone who is interested inapplying including

    academics, researchinstitutions,medicalresearchinstitutions,forprofit companies,not

    forprofitorganizations,andfoundations.Grantswillbetoresearchersandinnovatorswho

    areIndianindividualorIndianentities *,butweencouragepartnershipswithresearchers

    in other countries, especially where the opportunity exists to build on established

    collaborations. The research agenda will support a comprehensive set of approachesspanningmultiple fields of innovation to reduce the high incidence of low birthweight

    (LBW),earlystuntingandwastinginIndianchildrenlessthan2yearsofage,andprevent

    undernutritioninwomenofreproductiveageandinchildrenfrom02yearsofage.

    *AnIndividualshouldbeaCitizenofIndia*Indianentitiesaredefinedasthoseestablishedunderanyrelevantstatute,agreement,ruleorregulationinIndia.

  • 7/29/2019 Gci Guidelines

    5/16

    5

    2. PROGRAMGOAL

    ThegoaloftheAchieving

    Healthy

    Growth

    through

    Agriculture

    and

    Nutrition

    GrandChallengesProgramistofundaportfolioofIndianledpilotprojectsthatseektotarget

    therelationshipbetweenagriculture,nutrition,andhealthtoreducethehighincidence

    oflowbirthweightandearlystuntingandwastingamongIndianinfantsandthrough

    interventionsitaimsatempoweringwomenintheirmultiplefamilyroles.Whilethere

    are increasing numbers of initiatives linking agriculture and nutrition, this program

    seeksspecificallytoharnessinnovationinIndiaandtotargetwomenandchildrenin

    resourcepoorsettings.Theprimarymeasuresofsuccesswillbeanimprovementinthe

    survival,health,development,andqualityoflifeofIndianchildrenfrom02yearsofage

    andinwomenofreproductiveage.Toachievethedesiredimpact,weseekproposals

    whicharestrongininnovationandspanmultiplefieldsfocusingoninnovativeresearch

    onNutritionScience,AgriculturalPractice,interventionwhichtargetimprovedhealth,

    behavioral changesorservicesdeliverymechanism.Thesewouldbe inthe following

    3areas:

    A.Nutritioninnovation UnderstandingthecausesandconsequencesofLBW,includingtheroleLBWplays

    instuntingandwastinginchildren

  • 7/29/2019 Gci Guidelines

    6/16

    6

    C.SocialInnovation

    Identifyingandovercomingculturalandsocialbarrierstoimprovingmaternalandchild nutrition, with a focusonbarriers that contribute toLBW and early infant

    stuntingandwasting.

    Design strategic tools and process for communication, incomegeneratingmechanisms, community mobilization, and social network analysis to encourage

    production of healthy foods by women smallholder farmers and develop better

    consumption patterns by households, particularly pregnant mothers, women of

    reproductiveage,andchildren624months.

    Allproposalsmustbedesignedtotesttheproofofconceptforaspecificactionableand measurable intervention or delivery of an innovation. Solutions developed

    throughthisprogramcouldhaveabroadimpactbothwithinIndiaandbeyondits

    borders.Thedeliverablesofsuchproposalshouldbeassessedbystudyingdietary

    diversity&behaviorchange,establishingsocioeconomicstatusofwomenthrough

    improved laborsaving agriculture practices, improving health status of children,

    adolescentgirlsandwomenatreproductiveagealongwithcommunitymobilization

    &socialnetworkapproachesinagricultureandnutrition.

    3.BACKGROUNDImpaired child growth and development, as manifested in early stunting and wasting,

    remainsastubbornproblemgloballywithasignificantburdenofdiseasetobefoundin

    India.DespiteIndiaseconomicgrowthwithagricultureaccountingforasignificantpart

    of that growthand advances in science, medicine, food security and information

    technologyoverthepastdecade,malnutritionremainsunacceptablyhighasIndiaishome

    to about onethird of the worlds malnourished children. Many of these malnourished

    babiesareborntoadolescentmothersinIndia;75%oftheseadolescentmothersinIndia

    are anemic and put onanaverageof5kgofweight during pregnancy compared tothe

    worldwideaverageofcloseto10kg.Moreover,oneinthreewomen1549yearsofagehas a Body Mass Index (BMI) below 18.5, indicating severe nutritional deficiency and

    undernutrition. Malnourished women are less likely to deliver healthy babies, thereby

    perpetuatingtheintergenerationalcycleofundernutrition.

    Comparedtotherestoftheworld,youngchildreninIndiasufferfromsomeofthehighest

    levelsofstuntingandwastingduetoundernutritioninthefirsttwoyearsoflife.Ratesof

    malnutritionamongIndiaschildrenarealmostfivetimesmorethaninChina,andtwice

    those inSubSaharan Africa. The prevalence of childwasting (low weightforheight) in

  • 7/29/2019 Gci Guidelines

    7/16

    7

    India(20percent)istwiceashighastheaverageinsubSaharanAfrica(ninepercent)and

    tentimeshigherthaninLatinAmerica(twopercent).Indiaaccountsformorethan3outof

    10stuntedchildrenintheworldandnearlyhalfofallIndiaschildrenapproximately60million are underweight, about 45% are stunted, 20% are wasted (too thin for their

    height, indicating acute malnutrition), 75% are anemic, and 57% are Vitamin A

    deficient.(Source: World Bank News dated May 13, 2013

    http://www.worldbank.org/en/news/feature/2013/05/13/helpingindiacombat

    persistentlyhighratesofmalnutrition).

    Poverty, nutritional deficiencies, inadequate feeding practices, and low socioeconomic

    statusofwomenareamongmanyimportantfactorscontributingtothisalarminghealth

    crisis.Therefore,itisofupmostimportancetofundIndianinvestigatorsproposingtotest

    innovationsthatempowerwomenandspanmultiplefieldsincludingnutritionalscience,agriculturalpractices,businessandsocialpractices.Itishopedthatsolutionsdeveloped

    underthisinitiativewillnotonlycontributenewsolutionsinIndia,butalsobeapplicable

    assolutionsforothercounties.

    4.PROGRAMSCOPE4.1Fieldsofinnovation:

    Therearenumerouskeyquestionswhoseanswerscouldhelpreducethehighincidenceof

    low birth weight and early stunting and wasting among Indian infants through

    interventionsthattargettherelationshipbetweenagriculture,nutrition,andhealth,aimed

    atempoweringwomenintheirmultiplefamilyroles.Theseare:

    What are the causesof low birth weight and early stunting and wasting amongIndianinfants?

    Whicharethemostrelevantinterventionstodesigningpreventativemeasures? Which prevention or treatment interventions are the most effective for any

    particularpopulationorsetting?

    Towhatextentcanwomenslowstatuswithinthehouseholdtheircommunitiesandinsocietybeamelioratedtoimprovehealthoutcomesforherselfandforheryoungchildren?

    Howcanwomeninlowresourcesettingsbeempoweredandtargetedforneworexistinginterventions?

    Foranyparticularintervention,isthereawindowofopportunityduringwhichwehave the best chances for success such as in interveningwith adolescentgirls in

    ordertohalttheintergenerationaltransferofpovertyandundernutrition?

    What are the most strategic and catalytic system level levers for achieving largescalechangesthatwouldleadtoreductionsinundernutrition?

  • 7/29/2019 Gci Guidelines

    8/16

    8

    What are the best ways togeneratedemand for new interventions for achievinglargescale changes that would lead to reductions in undernutrition and health

    servicesamongwomen,families,andhealthcareproviders? What can be done to ensure the broad uptake of interventions proven to be

    effective?Whatarethebestwaystoreachthemostvulnerable,distant,orsocially

    neglectedpopulation?

    Toprovidedatatohelpanswertheseandotherkeyquestions,thisprogramiscallingfor

    proposals from diverse researchers, innovators and implementers. In addition, we

    encouragepartnerships thatbring together researchersand implementers fromdiverse

    organizations, including academics, research institutions, medical institutions, forprofit

    companies,notforprofitorganizationsandfoundations.Specifically,weseektoestablisha

    portfolioofscalableprojectsthatencompassesinnovationinfollowingareas:

    A)NUTRITIONINNOVATIONHealthy Growth of woman and Child To explore and develop special

    intervention thatwilldirectly impact thedevelopment of innovative nutrition

    forthepreventionofstuntingandwastingofyoungchildren(including

  • 7/29/2019 Gci Guidelines

    9/16

    9

    4.2 CharacteristicsofsuccessfulproposalWeseektofundresearchthatwillleadtonewsolutionstoreducethehighincidenceoflow

    birthweight(LBW)andearlystuntingandwastingamongIndianchildrenfrom02yearsofage,andtopreventundernutritioninwomenofreproductiveage.Successfulproposals

    shouldexplainhowtheywillleadtosolutionsthatare:

    Aclearpathtoapractical,affordable,andscalableinterventionthatisaccessibletothepopulationsmostinneedandlikelytohavesubstantialandsustainedimpactonLBWandstunting.

    Allproposalsmustbedesignedtotesttheproofofconceptforaspecificactionableandmeasurableintervention.

    Daringsolutionsthatareclearlydifferentiatedfromstandardpractice.4.3 SolutionsdevelopedthroughthisprogramImpactingIndiaandbeyonditsborders.

    o Scalableinterventionsthatcombinewaystoimprovehouseholddietdiversityandavailabilitythrough local sources of foodwith education to prevent LBW and

    promotehealthygrowthofinfantsandchildren

    o Behaviorchangeinterventionsindemandgenerationforhealthyfoodchoicesandcontent; delivery of nutrition messages to household members through various

    platforms

    o Innovationstoimprovewomensdecisionmakingabilitywithinthehouseholdwithrespect to child feeding, child education, health careseeking, householdexpenditures, womens time allocation, and household food distribution; these

    innovations wouldneed to take into account existingsocial and culturalbarriers

    andtherespectivedecisionmakingauthorityofotherhouseholdmembers

    o Evaluatetheimpactofnewlaborsavingtechnologiesandpracticespreandpostharvestonwomensincome,womenstimeconstraints,andthehealthoutcomesof

    womenandchildren

    o Innovationstoamendtheagriculturalresponsibilitiesofadolescentgirlstoimprovefuture birth outcomes andprevent the intergenerational transferof povertyand

    poornutrition

    o Evaluate the impact of current laborpractices ofadolescent girlson theirhealthoutcomesandexploreincentivestohouseholdstoreduceheavylaborburdenson

    adolescentsgirlsandincreasetheireducationalopportunities

    o Innovationsinincentives,communitymobilization,andsocialnetworkapproachestopromotepositivesocial and economicpractices and behaviors with respect to

    food production and storage, food consumption, food purchases, childfeeding

    practices,healthseekingbehaviors,andeducation

  • 7/29/2019 Gci Guidelines

    10/16

    10

    4.4 ExamplesofwhatwearenotlookingforExamplesofthetypesofprojectswewillnotconsiderforfundingarelistedbelow:

    Implementationof established interventions such as homegardens, small animalhusbandry,etc.

    Basic research that does not provide a clearpath todevelopment and testing ofinterventions.

    Studieslackinganalyticmethodstosubstantiatecausallinks. Projectsthatdonotdisplayclearpotentialforadvancingresearchfindingsintopre

    clinical,earlystageclinical,fieldorimplementationevaluation

    Projectsthatarenotscalableeitherbytheirnatureorbecausetheyapplytosmallsubsetsofthepopulation.

    Studiesthatproposeinterventionsthatdetractsfromfavorablefamilypractices.

    Projects without appropriate metrics to determine success or failure that wouldallowdecisionsabouttheappropriatenessoffollowonfunding.

    Solutionsthatareonlyslightimprovementsoverexistingapproaches. Mobilehealthapproacheswithoutthepotentialforgreatlyexpandedusecompared

    withcurrentpracticesorforintegrationofmultipleinformationsystemsintoone

    solution.

    Replicationofanapproachinanewgeographyintheabsenceofaddedinnovation.

    5 PROGRAMSTRUCTURE5.1Granttypesandfundinglevels

    ThisinitiativewillbeapublicGrandChallengeIndiaRFPexclusivetoIndianinvestigators

    seekinginnovations innutrition,particularlyaround lowbirthweightandstunting,

    innovations in agriculture around labor saving technologies and improved

    nutritionalqualityofproductsandinnovationsindemandgeneration,businessand

    social innovationwith a particular focus onwomen. There are two categories of

    grants:

    Seed grants: Fundedat up to INR 125 Lakhs [$250,000 USD] per project, theseawardsdonotrequirepreliminarydataandaremeanttoprovideanopportunityto

    testparticularlyboldideas.

    Transitiontoscalegrants:Fundedatupto INR5CrTO10Cr[$1millionto$2millionUSD]perproject,theseawardsrequirepreliminarydataandaremeantto

    provideanopportunitytodevelop,refine,andrigorouslytestapproachesthathave

    previouslyshownpromiseincontrolledorlimitedsettings.

  • 7/29/2019 Gci Guidelines

    11/16

    11

    BIRACanticipatesthatthepartnerstogetherwillinvestinitiallyuptoatotalof30CrINR

    [$6MUSD] in this program.The committedamount could increasedepending upon the

    interest shown by the Funding partners both National and International. The call forproposals,invitesbothSeedawards(uptoINR125Lakhs)[$250KUSD]andTransitionto

    Scaleawards(uptoINR5Cr10Cr)[$1Mto$2M]todevelop,refine,andrigorouslytest

    theimpactofintegratedsolutionsthatshowpromise.Thecallwillberunfortworounds

    dependingontheresponseandqualityofideas.Forpilotawards,proposalreviewcriteria

    will include a requirement to show a pathway towards generation of evidence for an

    actionable and scalable intervention. For transitiontoscale awards, proposal review

    criteriawillincludeanewevidencedbasedinterventionthatincludesastrategyforscaling

    up,includingservicedeliveryanddemandgeneration.

    Nevertheless,weanticipatethattherewillbetwowavesoffunding.Thesecondwaveof

    funding would be timed so that investigators funded in the first wave could use their

    projectresultstoapplyforasecondtwoyearaward.Winnersofseedgrantscouldapply

    forasecondseedgranttostrengthentheirpreliminarydatasetortheycouldapplyfora

    transitiontoscalegrant.Winnersoftransitiontoscalegrantscouldapplyforasecondfull

    grant to extend their results and establish proofofconcept at a larger scale. Whether

    additionalfundingopportunitiesareavailablethroughtheprogramafterthesecondwave

    offundingforseedgrantwinners,forinstancewillbeestablishedatalaterdateafter

    theinitialresultsoftheprogramhavebeenevaluated.

    5.2CollaborationWiththisprogramweseektocreateaconsortiumofindividuallyfundedprojectsthatwill

    benefitfromsharinginformationbetweenprojects.Weexpectthatsuchsharingwillhelp

    toensurethatthegoalsofthe innovativeapproachesinindividualprojectsareultimately

    integratedwitheachother,therebyincreasingthechancesthattheprogramwillbegreater

    thanthesumofitsparts.Furthermore,weexpectthatsharingexperimentalmethods,data,

    andresourceswillultimatelyimprovetheabilitytocompareandvalidatelocalresearch

    findingsandtodevelopinterventionsandproductsthatcanhaveimpactatagreaterscale.

    Thespecifictermsofthecollaborativeactivitieswillbenegotiatedpriortothegrantaward.

    Collaborativeeffortsinclude:

    Clinical Research Harmonization: When collaborating with projects with existingcohortsorestablishingnewcohorts(whichwillnotbefundedunlessexplicitlyagreed

    to), investigators will be expected to participate, whenever possible, in cohort

    harmonization.Studysiteswillbeexpectedto:

    o Developandfollowstandardoperatingproceduresandqualitycontrolprotocolsforspecimencollections;

  • 7/29/2019 Gci Guidelines

    12/16

    12

    o Participate in the establishment of a minimum common set of data andspecimenstobecollectedacrosstheprogram.

    DataSharing:AsaprojectjointlyfundedbyDBTandBill&MelindaGatesFoundationthere isanexpectationdatawillbesharedwith the broader scientific community to

    accelerateandadvanceinterventionsforthosemostinneed.Adatasharingplanwill

    bedevelopedthatisequitable,ethical,andefficient,andwillinclude:

    o Adatasharingandpublicationpolicy,o Adatauseagreement,o A protocol for citing the program in published manuscripts, and for

    acknowledgingthecoreprograminvestigators.

    6.RULESANDGUIDELINES6.1Applicationinstructionsandschedule

    ALetterofIntent(LOI)inresponsetothisRFPshouldbesubmittedonlinenolaterthan31

    October 2013 using the forms and process described at the following address:

    www.birac.nic.in.ReviewpanelsestablishedundertheGrandChallengesIndiapartnership

    willevaluatetheLOIs.PostLOIReviewandafullproposalshapingmeetingwillbeheldto

    ensure wehavetheopportunity to strengthenproposals andbuild synergieswithother

    proposalswithintheconsortium.Applicantswhoqualifyandprojectsoffurtherinteresttothepartnershipwillbeinvitedtosubmitafullproposal.Instructionsonthepreparationof

    fullproposalswillbeprovidedtoselectedapplicants,andwewillnotbeabletoprovide

    individual feedback to applicants not selected to submit full proposals. Grants will be

    awardedtoGCIapplicantswhoareselectedthroughthedueprocess.BIRACwillenterinto

    aseparatefundingagreementwithsuccessfulGCIgrantee(s)togoverntheprojectterms

    andconditionsandfunddisbursementmodalities.

    Atableofimportantdatesisgivenbelow.Alldeadlinesandnotificationdatesaresubject

    tochange,andapplicantswillbenotifiedbyemailinatimelymannerofanysuchchanges.

    Table1:Applicationschedule

    August28,2013: LaunchofRFP

    October31,2013: LastdateforsubmissionofLOI

    November30,2013:LOIReviewmeetingbyTAGandselectionoffullproposal

    December15,2013: MeetingofselectedapplicantwithTAG

    January31,2014: Fullproposalssubmissionlastdate

    Feb4,2014: Proposalsdistributedtoreviewers

    Feb26,2014: ReviewoffullproposalcompleteandmeetingwithTAG.

  • 7/29/2019 Gci Guidelines

    13/16

    13

    March5,2014: ECMeetingforAwardSelection

    March20,2014: AwardAnnouncement

    April30,2014: AgreementSigning

    6.2EvaluationCriteria Novelty and InnovationLandscape [15]: How theproposal capture the unique

    innovationtoaddressthebarriers.

    SocialImpact[15]:Howwillthisproposedinterventionleadtoabehaviorchangein the target population? Do the assays, technologies, and systems for analysis

    proposedhavebroadapplicability?

    Future Deliverable/ Translational Feasibility [15]: Is there potential foradvancingresearchfindingsintopreclinicaldevelopment?Investigatorsproposingto test innovations that empower women and span multiple fields including

    nutritionalscience,agriculturalpractices,businessandsocialpractices.

    Scope and Significance [15]: Is the approach likely to add dramatically toknowledge about the causative mechanisms underlying health problems and the

    most appropriate treatments for the problems specific to Indian women of

    reproductiveageandinIndianchildrenfrom02yearsofage?

    Approach [10]: Are the conceptual framework, design, methods, and analysesinnovative,adequately developed,well integrated, andappropriateto theaims of

    theproposal?Dotheapproachesormethodsappeartobefeasibleforscalingupinamanner consistent with the overall goalsof this request for proposals?Does the

    proposalacknowledgepotentialproblemareasandconsideralternativetactics?Is

    thelikelihoodofsuccessfulprojectcompletionhighwithinthefundingperiod?Are

    theproposedtimelinesandinterimmilestonesappropriate,feasible,andtechnically

    sound?

    Organizationalandinvestigatorcapability[10]:Istheresearchanddevelopmentteamappropriatelytrained,experienced,andpositionedtocarryoutthiswork?Is

    theworkproposedappropriatetotheexperienceleveloftheprincipalinvestigator

    and other proposed researchers? Is there strong evidence of substantive

    organizationalcapabilityandcommitment?Isthereexperienceindevelopmentof

    partnerships,andinmultiinvestigatorprojects?Arecollaborativearrangementsin

    place? Is there evidence of an infrastructure for adoption of standard operating

    procedures,datacollection,transfer,andsharing?

    Willingnesstocollaborate[10]:Aretheapplicants,includingallsubcontractors,willingtocollaborateandshareexperimentalmethods,data,andresourcesamong

    theotherindependentlyfundedmembersoftheprogramconsortium?

  • 7/29/2019 Gci Guidelines

    14/16

    14

    Best value [10]: Is the cost of the proposed effort reasonable relative to thecomplexity of the proposed work and the degree of risk and advancement

    proposed?

    6.3EligibilitycriteriaThe Grand Challenge India (GCI) application can be made by an Indian Individual

    Researcher/EntrepreneuroranIndianentity/consortiumestablishedunderanyrelevant

    statute, agreement, rule or regulation in India as the Lead applicant. GCI Applicant

    organizations must be nonprofit organizations, forprofit Companies, recognized

    institutionssuchasacademia,Nationallaboratories,researchinstitutions,medicalresearch

    institutions and foundations that have the required facilities tosuccessfullyexecute the

    activities in their technical area. Where the opportunity exists or project requires, we

    encourageresearchorganizationsinothercountriestobepartners/collaboratorsinthe

    GCIApplication.ThegoalofthisprogramistofundaportfolioofIndianledpilotprojects.

    6.4AllowableCosts DirectCosts:Manpower(upto30%),Consumables,travelandcontingency Facilities:Equipmentandaccessories(upto20%) Reimbursement of Facilities: Outsourcing, Operational cost of each Collaborating

    Partners/AffiliatedOrganizations

    6.5WarrantyTheGCIApplicantsshallwarrantythatthestatementsandparticularscontainedinLOI,full

    proposalandsupportingdocumentsarecorrect.Theyhavetofurtherwarrantthattheyare

    undernocontractualrestrictionsorlegaldisqualificationsoranyotherobligationswhich

    wouldprohibitthemfromundertakingthepresentProject,enteringintoanyAgreementin

    thisregardetc.

    6.6IntellectualPropertyProjectIPTheinitiativeisguidedbytheMemorandumofUnderstandingonthecollaborationbetweenthe

    DepartmentofBiotechnology,Govt.ofIndiaandtheBill&MelindaGatesFoundationsignedonJuly

    18,2012andassuchmustconsistentwiththecommitmentthatprojectsandinvestigatorsfunded

    under initiatives make global access commitments to ensure the fruits of their research are

    available to thosemost in need. This will include, but not limited to, the ability to license any

    technologydevelopedunderthisagreementtomanufacturersinIndiasubjecttotheseglobalaccess

    commitmentsandtotherelevantprovisionsoftheIndianlawsincludingspecificrequirementson

    licensingunderthePatentsAct1970.

    Tothisend,projectIPmeansintellectualpropertygeneratedduringtheconductof

    theProjectbytheGCIapplicants,butexcludingtheintellectualpropertygenerated

  • 7/29/2019 Gci Guidelines

    15/16

    15

    beforeinitiationofthisProjectandanyIPgeneratedoutsidethescopeofthisProject

    evenduringthetermofthisProject. Theownership andcontrolof the intellectual

    propertyshallremainwiththeGCIgrantee(s),orothercollaboratingorganizationsorinstitutionsasagreedwiththegrantee,subjecttoanyapplicablelocalpoliciesandthe

    collaborativeprocessdescribedabove,includingarrangementsbetweenthegrantee

    andotherindividualsorinstitutions.

    GCIgrantee(s)agreetoconductandmanagetheProjectandtheresultingproducts,

    services, processes, technologies, materials, software, data or other innovations

    (collectively, Funded Developments) and any IP that arises in the manner that

    ensuresGlobalAccess.GlobalAccessrequiresthat

    1) TheknowledgeandinformationgainedfromtheProjectbepromptlyandbroadlydisseminated

    2) TheFundedDevelopmentismadeavailableandaccessibleatanaffordablepricetopeoplemostinneedwithindevelopingcountry.

    EstablishingsuitableGlobalAccessagreementsamongtheGCIgranteeswillbea

    conditionofreceivingfunding.

    6.7Confidentiality:DuringthetenureoftheProject,BIRACwillundertaketomaintainstrictconfidentialityand

    refrain from disclosure thereof, of all or any part of the information and data

    exchanged/generatedfromtheProjectforanypurposeotherthanpurposesinaccordancethis RFP. Please note that all proposals, documents, communications and associated

    materials submitted (collectively, Submission Materials) will become the property of

    BIRAC and will be shared with other funding partners or potential funding partners.

    Number of applications received and the countries from which they originated will be

    published.Theproposalswillbe subject to confidential externalreview by independent

    subjectmatterexpertsandpotentialcofunders,inadditiontoinhouseanalysis.

    7.RESEARCHASSURANCES7.1DataAccessPrinciples

    BIRAChastherighttothetechnicaldatageneratedduringtheprojectforalltheGCIfunded

    projects. The fund recipient shall permit BIRAC through its authorized representative

    accesstothepremises,duringregularbusinesshours,wheretheProjectisbeing/shallbe

    carried out and provide all information and produce or make available the concerned

    records for inspection and monitoring of the Project activity, required by BIRAC or the

    concernedcommitteeundertheRFP.BIRACwillasneededsharethisdatawithaTechnical

    AdvisoryGrouporwiththefundingpartners.

  • 7/29/2019 Gci Guidelines

    16/16

    16

    7.2IndemnificationGCI applicants shall, at all times, indemnify and keep indemnified the Funding Agency/

    BIRAC against any claims or suits in respect of any losses, damages or compensationpayableinconsequencesofanyaccident,deathorinjurysustainedbytheemployeesofthe

    Companyorbyanyotherthirdpartyresultingfromorbyanyact,omissionoroperation

    conductedbyoronitsbehalf.FurtherGCIapplicantsshall,atalltimes,indemnifyandkeep

    indemnified PMU or Funding Agency/ BIRAC against all claims/damages etc. by any

    infringement of any Intellectual Property Rights (IPR) while carrying out its

    responsibilities/workundertheProjectandthisAgreement.

    7.3ResearchethicsandregulatoryapprovalsGCI Grantee(s) shall be responsible to obtain all the necessary requisite approvals,

    clearancecertificates,permissionsandlicensesfromtheGovernment/localauthoritiesfor

    conductingitsactivities/operationsinconnectionwiththeProject.

    8.CONTACTBiotechnologyIndustryResearchAssistanceCouncil(BIRAC)

    1.Dr.RenuSwarup,AdviserDBT&ManagingDirectorBIRAC,Email:[email protected],ManagerTechnical(Discovery&ProductDevelopment),BIRACEmail:

    jshukla.birac@nic.in.BiotechnologyIndustryResearchAssistanceCouncil,(AGovernmentofIndiaEnterprise)A254,3rdFloor,BhishamPitamahMarg,DefenceColony,NewDelhi110024.Web:www.birac.nic.in