1
Background & Significance Poison dart frogs are characterized by bright color and toxic alkaloids These ecologists are trying to answer questions such as “Why don’t poison frogs poison themselves?” and “How is color related to toxicity?” Our group characterizes the alkaloids in the samples that were collected by our collaborators. Our typical analysis method is gas chromatography in conjunction with mass spectrometry. This is commonly used for the analysis of poison frog alkaloids as most are volatile. Identification and especially quantitation of these alkaloids have proven to be difficult because of the lack of pure known samples. Thus, we are trying to build a reliable experimental alkaloid spectral library and develop quantitation methods. Gas Chromatography-Mass Spectrometry Gas chromatography is an analytical technique that separates compounds in the gas phase. Compounds elute at different times based on vapor pressure and polarity. We use a Thermo Trace GC Ultra capillary gas chromatograph for separations. This is interfaced to an iTQ1100 quadrupole ion trap mass spectrometer. Mass spectrometry ionizes molecules and measures the mass to charge ratio of the resulting ions and fragments. There are multiple types of ion sources. The ones we use are electron impact ionization (EI) and chemical ionization (CI). Below is an image of our GC-MS,. Electron Ionization (or electron impact, EI) uses electrons at high energy (70 eV, nearly 7000 kJ/mol), which interact with molecules causing them to eject an electron, forming a radical cation. 3 This ion is unstable and falls apart into fragments. These fragments create a fingerprint, identifying the class of alkaloid by their characteristic fragment patterns. We also weight by subtracting 1 mass unit. 3-5 Either way, we must separate the ions once they are produced. Our quadrupole ion trap injects ions from the source (EI or CI) and captures ions by using DC and RF voltages, then scans RF to match the orbital frequency of the ions. The frequency should be proportional to m/z. Once we confirm the identity of the alkaloid, we use the integration for the most abundant ion to quantify and report the data to our collaborators. use Chemical ionization (CI) which generates protons in the form of NH 4 + ions by the same process with relatively large amounts of ammonia gas relative to the analyte. This protonates the alkaloids producing [M+H]ions, from which we calculate molecular secreted from the skin. 1,2 Alkaloids are naturally occurring cyclic amines and they have many different biological activities. There are over 30 structural classes known in poison frogs. Frogs do not make their own alkaloids with the exception of pseudophrynamines produced by one genus of Australian toad. Normally frogs eat alkaloid containing arthropods then sequester the alkaloids in specialized glands in their skin. We work with a variety of collaborators who study poison frogs from Madagascar and South America. Pumiliotoxins (PTX) There are 32 known PTXs at present. Below is the EI mass spectrum for PTX 251D. PTXs are characterized by peaks at m/z 166 (from side chain cleavage at the exocyclic double bond) and m/z 70 (pyrrolidine), usually with 166 as the base peak. Spectra also contain different peaks such around m/z 206, 194, 148, 122, 109, and 95 depending on the structure of the side carbon chain. Smaller peaks contain information about the different pathways a molecule can fall apart, such as the peak at m/z 84. 1,2 Allopumiliotoxins (aPTX) There are currently 20 known aPTXs (7-hydroxyPTXs). Below is the spectrum for aPTX 267A. Fragmentation is similar to PTXs with the primary fragments at m/z 182 (166 + 16 for the additional oxygen) and m/z 70 (usually the base peak). Common diagnostic minor fragments are m/z 112 m/z and 114. 1,2 Decahydroquinolines (DHQ) Decahydroquinolines are common with 35 presently known. The spectrum below is of DHQ trans-243A. DHQs are dominated by the base peak (here m/z 202) from α-cleavage of the C2 side chain. 1,2 Spiropyrrolizidines (Spiro-P) Spiropyrrolizidines are rarer with only 9 currenly known. Below is the spectrum of Spiro-P 222. The parent ion m/z 222 rearranges by α- cleavage of the pyrrolizidine ring and loss of dimethylmethylenecyclopentane to give a base peak of m/z 112. This extrudes NO to give a minor peak at m/z 82. ¹ Conclusions At present, there are a total of 1,052 alkaloids to be added to the library from the 2005 tabulation and 612 entries have been completed. A need exists for these alkaloids as analytical standards. The ability to access these readily characterized alkaloids would be very useful for quantitative analysis. Our goal is to make our library, comprised of authentic, background subtracted electron impact spectra, publicly available through NIST as well as in free public databases such as the Global Natural Product social Molecular Networking project (GNPS). This way, researchers in this field will have access to high quality, fully curated spectral and chromatographic datasets from which to identify alkaloids in their own extracts with high confidence. In particular, this should be of substantial value to ecologists who often lack access to reference compounds and high quality datasets. Acknowledgements This work was performed as part of the Summer Undergraduate Research (SURE) program at Indiana State University. We wish to thank undergraduates Emily Dransfield, Kimberly Gleason, Stephen Jones, Arika Kemp, Star Leonard, Carly McDonald, Allyson Morris, Alec Penry, Megan Reid, J. Ryan Sanders, Ellery Steele, Jacqueline Smith, Katie Taylor, Hanyang Zhou, and high school students Maria Martinez and Anthea Weng for earlier work, as well as Jessica Goodman, Madison Klinker, Rhiannon Morozoff, Marcella Nonte, and Amanda Waldbieser for current ancillary work on the poison frog alkaloid program. In Addition, we would like to thank our collaborators Dr. Rebecca Tarvin and Dr. David Cannatella from UT Austin as well as Karina Klonoski and Dr. Bree Rosenblum from UC Berkeley. Funding National Science Foundation DUE-092345 (GC-MS) CHE-1531972 (LC-MS) IOS-1556982 (Collaborative: Phylogenetics – Frogs) Indiana State University Center for Student Research and Creativity (SURE scholarship ARM) American Chemical Society Wabash Valley Section (travel award) References 1.Daly, J. W.; Garraffo, H. M.; Spande, T. F. Alkaloids from Amphibian Skin: A Tabulation of Over Eight-Hundred Compounds. J. Nat. Prod.. 2005, 68. 1556-1575. 2.Daly, J. W.; Garraffo, H. M.; Spande, T. F. “Alkaloids from Amphibian Skins” in Pelletier, S. W. 1999. Alkaloids: Chemical and Biological Perspectives, Vol. 13. Pergamon, Oxford Ch. 1, pp. 1-161 3.de Hoffmann, E.; Stroobant, V. Mass Spectrometry: Principles and Applications, 2007, Wiley and Sons, New York, Ch 1, pp. 15-79; Ch 7, pp. 273-298. 4.Garraffo, H.M.; Spande, T.F.; Jones, T.H.; Daly, J.W., Ammonia chemical ionization tandem mass spectrometry in structure determination of alkaloids. I. Pyrrolidines, piperidines, decahydroquinolines, pyrrolizidines, indolizidines, quinolizidines and an azabicyclo [5.3.0] decane. Rapid Commun Mass Spectrom 1999, 13: 1553-1563. 5.Garraffo, H.M.; Spande, T.F.; Jain, P.; Kaneko, T.; Jones, T.H.; Blum, M. S.; All, T. M. M.; Snelling, R. R.; Isbell, L. A.; Robertson, H. G.; Daly, J.W., Ammonia chemical ionization tandem mass spectrometry in structural determination of alkaloids. II. Tetraponerines from pseudomyrmecine ants. Rapid Commun Mass Spectrom 2001, 15, 1409-1415. Gas Chromatography - Mass Spectrometry of Poison Frog Alkaloids Baylee S. Sparks, Rachel L. Worthington, and Richard W. Fitch Department of Chemistry and Physics, Indiana State University, Terre Haute, IN 47809. Histrionicotoxins (HTX) There are 16 currently known histrionicotoxins. Below is the mass spectrum of HTX 239H. The peak at m/z 196 is the result of α- cleavage at the C2 carbon. The peak at m/z 96 m/z begins α- cleavage opening the cyclohexanol ring and concerted loss of the C2 substitutent and C7-10. Likewise, the m/z 152 base peak is from ring opening as before and γ-hydrogen rearrangement (McLafferty) to lose C7-C9. The m/z 168 ion comes from retro-Diels-Alder of m/z 196. 1,2 6,7-Dehydro-5,8-Disubstituted Indolizidines There are 29 6,7-dehydro-5,8-Is. This is a mass spectra of Alkaloid 201A. The parent ion at 201 m/z undergoes an alpha-cleavage of the side chain which creates the peak at 136 m/z. This structure can further break down by aromatization and a loss of a hydrogen to create the peak at 134 m/z. The peak at 120 m/z is formed when the ring aromatizes and loses a methyl. 1,2 5,8-Disubstituted Indolizidines (5,8-I) This is the most abundant class with 77 known 5,8-I and another 70 in the closely related 5,6,8-I trisubstituted group. Below is the spectrum for 5,8-I 245N. The m/z 176 base peak is from α-cleavage of C5 side chain. The m/z 96 peak the arises from retro-Diels-Alder fragmentation of the piperidine ring. 1,2 3,5-Disubstituted Indolizidines (3,5-I) These are also common with 40 members. Below is the spectrum for 3,5-I 223Z. This group has two possible α-cleavages, one on each ring. Thus, the m/z 152 base peak comes loss of the pentyl group at C3, while the smaller 194 is from loss of the ethyl group at C5. The m/z 124 comes from either of these by McLafferty rearrangement. 1,2

Gas Chromatography - Mass Spectrometry of Poison Frog ... · This protonates the alkaloids producing [M+H]⁺ions, from which we calculate molecular. secreted from the skin. 1,2

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Gas Chromatography - Mass Spectrometry of Poison Frog ... · This protonates the alkaloids producing [M+H]⁺ions, from which we calculate molecular. secreted from the skin. 1,2

Background & SignificancePoison dart frogs are characterized by bright color and toxic alkaloids

These ecologists are trying to answer questions such as “Why don’tpoison frogs poison themselves?” and “How is color related totoxicity?” Our group characterizes the alkaloids in the samples thatwere collected by our collaborators. Our typical analysis method isgas chromatography in conjunction with mass spectrometry. This iscommonly used for the analysis of poison frog alkaloids as most arevolatile. Identification and especially quantitation of these alkaloidshave proven to be difficult because of the lack of pure knownsamples. Thus, we are trying to build a reliable experimental alkaloidspectral library and develop quantitation methods.

Gas Chromatography-Mass SpectrometryGas chromatography is an analytical technique that separatescompounds in the gas phase. Compounds elute at different timesbased on vapor pressure and polarity. We use a Thermo Trace GCUltra capillary gas chromatograph for separations. This is interfacedto an iTQ1100 quadrupole ion trap mass spectrometer. Massspectrometry ionizes molecules and measures the mass to chargeratio of the resulting ions and fragments. There are multiple types ofion sources. The ones we use are electron impact ionization (EI) andchemical ionization (CI). Below is an image of our GC-MS,.

Electron Ionization (or electron impact, EI) uses electrons at highenergy (70 eV, nearly 7000 kJ/mol), which interact with moleculescausing them to eject an electron, forming a radical cation.3 This ionis unstable and falls apart into fragments. These fragments create afingerprint, identifying the class of alkaloid by their characteristicfragment patterns. We also

weight by subtracting 1 mass unit.3-5 Either way, we must separatethe ions once they are produced. Our quadrupole ion trap injects ionsfrom the source (EI or CI) and captures ions by using DC and RFvoltages, then scans RF to match the orbital frequency of the ions.The frequency should be proportional to m/z. Once we confirm theidentity of the alkaloid, we use the integration for the most abundantion to quantify and report the data to our collaborators.

use Chemical ionization (CI)which generates protons inthe form of NH4

+ ions by thesame process with relativelylarge amounts of ammoniagas relative to the analyte.This protonates the alkaloidsproducing [M+H]⁺ ions, fromwhich we calculate molecular

secreted from the skin.1,2 Alkaloidsare naturally occurring cyclic aminesand they have many differentbiological activities. There are over 30structural classes known in poisonfrogs. Frogs do not make their ownalkaloids with the exception ofpseudophrynamines produced by onegenus of Australian toad. Normallyfrogs eat alkaloid containingarthropods then sequester thealkaloids in specialized glands in theirskin. We work with a variety ofcollaborators who study poison frogsfrom Madagascar and South America.

Pumiliotoxins (PTX)There are 32 known PTXs at present. Below is the EI mass spectrumfor PTX 251D. PTXs are characterized by peaks at m/z 166 (fromside chain cleavage at the exocyclic double bond) and m/z 70(pyrrolidine), usually with 166 as the base peak. Spectra also containdifferent peaks such around m/z 206, 194, 148, 122, 109, and 95depending on the structure of the side carbon chain. Smaller peakscontain information about the different pathways a molecule can fallapart, such as the peak at m/z 84. 1,2

Allopumiliotoxins (aPTX)There are currently 20 known aPTXs (7-hydroxyPTXs). Below is thespectrum for aPTX 267A. Fragmentation is similar to PTXs with theprimary fragments at m/z 182 (166 + 16 for the additional oxygen)and m/z 70 (usually the base peak). Common diagnostic minorfragments are m/z 112 m/z and 114. 1,2

Decahydroquinolines (DHQ)Decahydroquinolines are common with 35 presently known. Thespectrum below is of DHQ trans-243A. DHQs are dominated by thebase peak (here m/z 202) from α-cleavage of the C2 side chain. 1,2

Spiropyrrolizidines (Spiro-P)Spiropyrrolizidines are rarer with only 9 currenly known. Below is thespectrum of Spiro-P 222. The parent ion m/z 222 rearranges by α-cleavage of the pyrrolizidine ring and loss ofdimethylmethylenecyclopentane to give a base peak of m/z 112. Thisextrudes NO to give a minor peak at m/z 82. ¹

ConclusionsAt present, there are a total of 1,052 alkaloids to be added to thelibrary from the 2005 tabulation and 612 entries have been completed.A need exists for these alkaloids as analytical standards. The ability toaccess these readily characterized alkaloids would be very useful forquantitative analysis. Our goal is to make our library, comprised ofauthentic, background subtracted electron impact spectra, publiclyavailable through NIST as well as in free public databases such as theGlobal Natural Product social Molecular Networking project (GNPS).This way, researchers in this field will have access to high quality, fullycurated spectral and chromatographic datasets from which to identifyalkaloids in their own extracts with high confidence. In particular, thisshould be of substantial value to ecologists who often lack access toreference compounds and high quality datasets.

AcknowledgementsThis work was performed as part of the Summer UndergraduateResearch (SURE) program at Indiana State University. We wish tothank undergraduates Emily Dransfield, Kimberly Gleason, StephenJones, Arika Kemp, Star Leonard, Carly McDonald, Allyson Morris,Alec Penry, Megan Reid, J. Ryan Sanders, Ellery Steele, JacquelineSmith, Katie Taylor, Hanyang Zhou, and high school students MariaMartinez and Anthea Weng for earlier work, as well as JessicaGoodman, Madison Klinker, Rhiannon Morozoff, Marcella Nonte, andAmanda Waldbieser for current ancillary work on the poison frogalkaloid program. In Addition, we would like to thank our collaboratorsDr. Rebecca Tarvin and Dr. David Cannatella from UT Austin as wellas Karina Klonoski and Dr. Bree Rosenblum from UC Berkeley.

FundingNational Science Foundation

DUE-092345 (GC-MS)CHE-1531972 (LC-MS)

IOS-1556982 (Collaborative: Phylogenetics – Frogs)Indiana State University

Center for Student Research and Creativity (SURE scholarship ARM)

American Chemical SocietyWabash Valley Section (travel award)

References1.Daly, J. W.; Garraffo, H. M.; Spande, T. F. Alkaloids from AmphibianSkin: A Tabulation of Over Eight-Hundred Compounds. J. Nat. Prod..2005, 68. 1556-1575.2.Daly, J. W.; Garraffo, H. M.; Spande, T. F. “Alkaloids from AmphibianSkins” in Pelletier, S. W. 1999. Alkaloids: Chemical and BiologicalPerspectives, Vol. 13. Pergamon, Oxford Ch. 1, pp. 1-1613.de Hoffmann, E.; Stroobant, V. Mass Spectrometry: Principles andApplications, 2007, Wiley and Sons, New York, Ch 1, pp. 15-79; Ch 7,pp. 273-298.4.Garraffo, H.M.; Spande, T.F.; Jones, T.H.; Daly, J.W., Ammoniachemical ionization tandem mass spectrometry in structuredetermination of alkaloids. I. Pyrrolidines, piperidines,decahydroquinolines, pyrrolizidines, indolizidines, quinolizidines andan azabicyclo [5.3.0] decane. Rapid Commun Mass Spectrom 1999,13: 1553-1563.5.Garraffo, H.M.; Spande, T.F.; Jain, P.; Kaneko, T.; Jones, T.H.;Blum, M. S.; All, T. M. M.; Snelling, R. R.; Isbell, L. A.; Robertson, H.G.; Daly, J.W., Ammonia chemical ionization tandem massspectrometry in structural determination of alkaloids. II. Tetraponerinesfrom pseudomyrmecine ants. Rapid Commun Mass Spectrom 2001,15, 1409-1415.

Gas Chromatography - Mass Spectrometry of Poison Frog AlkaloidsBaylee S. Sparks, Rachel L. Worthington, and Richard W. FitchDepartment of Chemistry and Physics, Indiana State University, Terre Haute, IN 47809.

Histrionicotoxins (HTX)There are 16 currently known histrionicotoxins. Below is the massspectrum of HTX 239H. The peak at m/z 196 is the result of α-cleavage at the C2 carbon. The peak at m/z 96 m/z begins α-cleavage opening the cyclohexanol ring and concerted loss of the C2substitutent and C7-10. Likewise, the m/z 152 base peak is from ringopening as before and γ-hydrogen rearrangement (McLafferty) to loseC7-C9. The m/z 168 ion comes from retro-Diels-Alder of m/z 196. 1,2

6,7-Dehydro-5,8-Disubstituted IndolizidinesThere are 29 6,7-dehydro-5,8-Is. This is a mass spectra of Alkaloid201A. The parent ion at 201 m/z undergoes an alpha-cleavage of theside chain which creates the peak at 136 m/z. This structure canfurther break down by aromatization and a loss of a hydrogen tocreate the peak at 134 m/z. The peak at 120 m/z is formed when thering aromatizes and loses a methyl.1,2

5,8-Disubstituted Indolizidines (5,8-I)This is the most abundant class with 77 known 5,8-I and another 70in the closely related 5,6,8-I trisubstituted group. Below is thespectrum for 5,8-I 245N. The m/z 176 base peak is from α-cleavageof C5 side chain. The m/z 96 peak the arises from retro-Diels-Alderfragmentation of the piperidine ring. 1,2

3,5-Disubstituted Indolizidines (3,5-I)These are also common with 40 members. Below is the spectrum for3,5-I 223Z. This group has two possible α-cleavages, one on eachring. Thus, the m/z 152 base peak comes loss of the pentyl group atC3, while the smaller 194 is from loss of the ethyl group at C5. Them/z 124 comes from either of these by McLafferty rearrangement.1,2