8/14/2019 Future Security in Aeronautics Communications

1/21

8>>5->4->2 ^dij 4

\jlzxepu ef Djxmfdzpeldc Lmggzfeldpemf|Km| C& \& Axjepd|

Ef|pepzpm \z~jxemx Plfelm Lmg~zpjx \lejflj @j~dxpgjfpDq& Xmqe|lm de|# 4>05'>>4 Ce|hmd# mxpzidc

Dh|pxdlp& Pbe| `mlzgjfp ~xj|jfp pbj ~xmkjlp amx d gd|pjx| pbj|e| ef pbj |lm~j malmggzfeldpemf| |jlzxepu d~~cej` pm pbj lmfpjrp ma djxmfdzpel|& Pbj dqedpemfjfqexmfgjfp e| qjxu ~xmfj pm jfpjx ldpd|pxm~bel |epzdpemf| ybjf |eg~cj |jlzxepuhxjdlbj| dxj jr~cmxj`# |zlb d| ef 5-44& Ef d qjxu tzelocu ixmyefi ymxc`ye`j|jlpmx pbj dex pxdf|~mxp e| eflxjd|eficu gmxj xjcedhcj ef lmggzfeldpemf| amxjaaelejflu& Df ef'`j~pb |pz`u mf |pxjfipb| df` yjdofj||j| ma pbj |pdpj ma pbj dxpdf` pbj azpzxj |jlzxepu ef lmggzfeldpemf| |pxdpjiej| yecc cjd` pm pbjj|pdhce|bgjfp ma d xmd`gd~ amx |jlzxepu gdrege{dpemf yepb pbj d~~celdpemf mafmqjc |jlzxepu ~dxd`eig| df` pjlbfmcmiej|&

Ojuymx`|; \jlzxepu Lmggzfeldpemf| Dqedpemf Djxmfdzpel| Dfpe'Pjxxmxe|g@e|pxehzpj` \u|pjg| Jflxu~pemf \mapydxj Jfiefjjxefi Tzdfpzg XAE@

8/14/2019 Future Security in Aeronautics Communications

2/21

8>>5->4->2 ^dij 8

4 Efpxm`zlpemf

\eflj pbj aex|p bekdlo jqjx pbdp pmmo ~cdlj ef pbj ymxc` "Gdldz 4501=% pbdp dqedpemf| bd|hjjf ~cdizj` hu pjxxmxe|g mx ~exdlu& Pbmzib gecepdxu dqedpemf ~xj|jfp| qzcfjxdhecepej|"^doe|pdf| iIjfjxdc [ed jr~cm|emf ef be| L'4 ef 4522%# leqec dqedpemf xjcedhecepu bd|hjjf pbj gm|p kjm~dx`e{j` yepb gdfu bekdlo| `zxefi pbj 1>| df` 9>|# hu jpbfeldc

pjxxmxe|p ixmz~| ~xm~didf`d# xjeqef`eldpemf| df` hcdlogdec&

Ef pbj 2>| yepb pbj efpxm`zlpemf ma R'Xdu |ldf| hmdx`efi yepb yjd~mf| hjldgj gmxj`eaaelzcp# hzp hmghefi |pecc ldz|j` gdfu ceqj| cm|p "Dex Ef`ed 909 452:%& Ef pbj 5>| dfjy pu~j ma pbxjdp yd| xjqjdcj` pm pbj ymxc`; pbj z|dij ma dexcefjx| d| d xdg yjd~mfpm ldz|j bdqml mf ixmzf` "Dex Axdflj Dexhz| D> bekdloj` ef Dcijxed efpjf`j` pmlxd|b ef ^dxe| ybelb ~cmp yd| amecj` hu pbj Axjflb |~jledc ixmz~ IEIF "_L8>W%&

Pbj gdregzg jr~xj||emf ldgj yepb pbj 5-44 ef 8>>4 dppdlo| yjxj amzx dexcefjx| |je{j`hu pjxxmxe|p| hxmzibp `myf pbj Pyef Pmyjx| dgmfi|p mpbjx pdxijp| df` pmpdccu lbdfij`pbj ymxc`& \jlzxepu gjd|zxj| peibpjfj` ixjdpcu |eflj pbj gmgjfp fmp mfcu ef dqedpemf#hzp dc|m ef pbj |jd|# hmx`jx cjie|cdpemf df` leqec xeibp| xj|pxelpemf|&

Pbmzib fm maaeledc ~xmma yd| jqjx xjlmife{j` pbdp pbj dlle`jfp ef 4521# ldz|j` pbj

`jdpb ma Gm{dghetzj| ~xj|e`jfp \dgmxd Gdlbjc ybjf be| ~xj|e`jfpedc Pz~mcjq 4| df zfe`jfpeaej` gdf ~xjpjf`efi pmhj df dex'pxdaael lmfpxmccjx pxdf|geppj` adc|j xd`em gj||dij| pm dex~cdfj| dhmqj pbjXmdfmoj# Qexiefed# dex~mxp& Mf mfj mlld|emf bj eg~jx|mfdpj` d ~ecmp df` hxmd`ld|p d`e|pxj|| ldcc& Bj yd| df zfjg~cmuj` ~jx|mf z|efi d :>> Z\@ gdec mx`jxj` xd`em&Maaeledc fzghjx| amx |zlb dppdlo| dxj oj~p lmfae`jfpedc# hzp pbj Hxepe|b leqec DqedpemfDzpbmxepu "LDD% xjqjdcj` pbdp ef pbj aex|p bdca ma 8>>># pbju bd` xjlmx`j` pyjfpulmg~cdefp| `zj pm adc|j dex'pxdaael'lmfpxmc&

D| ma pm`du# dqedpemf xjcej| mf lmggzfeldpemf| amx d bzij qdxejpu ma ~zx~m|j|& Dexpxdaael lmfpxmc# fdqeidpemf# dllj|| pm gdefpjfdflj bjc~# lmg~dfu m~jxdpemf| ~cdffefi#cmie|pel|# yjdpbjx hxejaefi# df` xjqjfzj axmg ~d||jfijx| |jxqelj|# dxj dcc `j~jf`jfp maxjcedhcj lmggzfeldpemf| gjdf|& \jlzxepu e| d deg ef dcc ma pbjg# fmfjpbjcj||# pbj

`jixjj ma dlbejqjgjfp df` ~xmpjlpemf| ixjdpcu qdxej|&Pbj heiij|p ~dxd`mr ldf bd~~jf mf df Dgjxeldf Dexcefj| Hmjefi 999'8>>JX acuefiaxmg Fjy Umxo| Kmbf A& Ojffj`u dex~mxp pm Cmf`mf Bjdpbxmy& D ~d||jfijx efHz|efj|| lcd|| gdu z|j ep cd~pm~ pm lmffjlp qed yeae d CDF pm pbj hxmd`hdf` |jxqeljpbdp e| `mfj yepb d |dpjccepj lmggzfeldpemf| `dpd cefo& Bj gdu hj df zf|jlzxj` yeaecefo pm pbj bmp|~mp hzp pbjf lmffjlp pm be| lmg~dfu| Q^F mx be| hdfo yjh|epj z|efipbj cdpj|p lxu~pmixd~bu dcimxepbg| df` |jlzxepu ~xmpmlmc|& \dgj imj| amx pbj |jlzxj~dugjfp ma pbj yeae dllj|| yepb pbj lxj`ep ldx`&

8/14/2019 Future Security in Aeronautics Communications

3/21

8>>5->4->2 ^dij >>> Geccemf Z\@ dex~cdfj# pbj ld~pdef gdu hjlmfpdlpefi Cmf`mf Dex Pxdaael Lmfpxmc pm xjljeqj lcjdxdflj pm cdf` dp Bjdpbxmy dex~mxp#ybecj mf d aefdc d~~xmdlb kz|p mqjx Yj|pgef|pjx& Bj yecc z|j be| gelxm~bmfj pbdp e|lmffjlpj` pm d qjxu |eg~cj QBA xd`em mf df m~jf hxmd`ld|p axjtzjflu& Dzpbjfpeldpemfe| `mfj hu |pdxpefi jdlb lmggzfeldpemf| d| pbj myf# d``xj||jj df` gj||dij& Pbj fjrpjrdg~cj| Dgjxeldf 4

8/14/2019 Future Security in Aeronautics Communications

4/21

8>>5->4->2 ^dij 0

z|j` hzp ldffmp e`jfpeau pbj dexlxdap df` e| fmp xjcedhcj yepb hd` yjdpbjx& \m lmfpxmccjx|ojj~ gjfpdc egdij ma pbj dexlxdap ybjxjdhmzp| ybecj d|oefi amx ~ecmp xj~mxp| ma pbjex~m|epemf|& Ep e| ymxpbybecj gjfpemfefi pbdp d amxjeif dexcefj ~ecmp yecc fmp ofmy pbjbzij \lbe~mc dex~mxp qjxu yjcc df` yecc z|j d gd~ "~d~jx lbdxp| gm|pcu% pm gmqjdxmzf`& Ef cmy qe|ehecepu m~jxdpemf| "CQM% ep e| axjtzjfp pbdp pbj aceibp lxjy |mgjpegj|ge|| d pzxf mx pym& Pbj `dfijx ma d lmcce|emf mf ixmzf` e| |pecc beib& D ajy ujdx| dim d\yj`e|b \D\ G@'2> lxd|bj` ybecj pdoefi maa dp Gecdf Cefdpj# dapjx lmcce`efi yepb dhz|efj|| kjp pbdp bd` efd`qjxpj`cu jfpjxj` pbj |dgj xzfydu# ef d hd` qe|ehecepu jqjfefi&

Fjy |pz`ej| bdqj jgjxij` df` D@\'H yecc bjc~ pm ~xmqe`j ef|pdfp xjcedhcj dexlxdap|epzdpemfdc dydxjfj||& Pbj|j fjy |u|pjg| yecc hj xjcedhcj ef pbj |jf|j pbdp pbj `dpd yecchj ~xmqe`j` yepb dllzxdlu df` yepb d qjxu beib xdpj ma dqdecdhecepu hzp pbj |jlzxepud|~jlp e| adx axmg |pdpj ma pbj dxp& Bmyjqjx# d| amx ef|pdflj# pbjxj e| fm le~bjx ef pbj|jlmggzfeldpemf|&

8/14/2019 Future Security in Aeronautics Communications

5/21

8>>5->4->2 ^dij :

8 Mhkjlpeqj| ma pbj ymxo pm hj ~jxamxgj`

Pbj mhkjlpeqj e| pm `jaefj d xmd`gd~ amx |jlzxepu gjd|zxj| ~m||ehcj ef djxmfdzpeldclmggzfeldpemf| pm dlbejqj zfpec pbj jf` ma pbj fjrp `jld`j& D ~cdf ma ybelbpjlbfmcmiej| df` ybjxj df` bmy pm d~~cu pbjg# df` pbj hjfjaep| pbdp dxe|j axmg pbjexefpxm`zlpemf yecc `jpdec mf bmy pm lm~j yepb ~xj|jfp df` jgjxiefi pbxjdp|&

Pbj aex|p |zh'mhkjlpeqj e| pm dfdcu{j dcc pbj lmggzfeldpemf| lbdffjc| df` pjlbfmcmiej|pbdp dxj fmyd`du| z|j` ef djxmfdzpel|& Ef ~dxdccjc# efepedpeqj| xjcdpj` pm azpzxj`jqjcm~gjfp ef pbj aejc`| yecc hj |pz`ej` df` pbj xmd`gd~| pbdp dxj hjefi `jaefj` yecchj |lxzpefe{j` amx yjdofj||j| df` |pxjfipb|& ^xmixdggj| |zlb d Jzxmlmfpxmc| \J\DXdxj pbj xjajxjflj ef gdfu dxjd|# ef pbe| ld|j# ef Dex Pxdaael Lmfpxmc&

Ef`j~jf`jfpcu ma dcc djxmfdzpeldc mfimefi xj|jdxlb dlpeqepej| df d||j||gjfp mf ~xj|jfpdf` fjdx'azpzxj efamxgdpemf |jlzxepu pjlbfmcmiej| pbdp lmqjx pbj fjrp `jld`j yecc hjldxxej` mzp& Pbj dqedpemf hz|efj|| e| qjxu lmf|jxqdpeqj ef pjxg| ma pjlbfmcmiej| `zjmhqemz| pm |dajpu lmfljxf|& Pbj jgjxiefi ~dxd`eig ma tzdfpzg |jlzxepu yecc hj pbjgdkmx ldf`e`dpj pm d~~cu ef&

Pbe| |pz`u yecc deg pm pbj leqec gdxojp# ybecj fmfjpbjcj|| e`jfpeauefi cefo| yepb pbj

gecepdxu ef`z|pxu& Pjlbfmcmiej| `jqjcm~j` amx pbj|j yecc hj d||j||j`# |zlb d| FDPMCefo 44 df` 41 jflxu~pj` ixmzf`'dex df` dex'pm'dex `dpd cefo|& Pbe| dcxjd`u jtze~| pbjCmlobjj`'Gdxpef A'41| ma pbj ^mxpzizj|j Dex Amxlj# ef|pdccj` zf`jx pbj xzffefi Ge`Ceaj Z~ixd`j ~xmixdg# df` e| d xjtzexjgjfp amx FDPM amxlj| ef kmefp m~jxdpemf|& Ldxjyecc hj pdojf pm dqme` xjefqjfpefi pbj ybjjc d| d qjxu ixjdp `jdc ma leqec djxmfdzpel|pjlbfmcmiu e| ~xjqemz|cu qdce`dpj` ef `jajflj |u|pjg|& Pbj |dgj ldf hj |de` dhmzpgdfu pjlbfeldc dlbejqjgjfp| ef pjxg| ma |jlzxepu&

Pbe| |pz`u |bdcc amlz| mf pbj pjlbfeldc d|~jlp| ma |jlzxepu ef pbj djxmfdzpeldclmggzfeldpemf| gjdf|& Dqedpemf| e| d qjxu xe|ou gdxojp amx efqj|pgjfp df` dexcefj|xdxjcu efqj|p ef dfu jtze~gjfp zfcj|| ep e| gdf`dpmxu hu dex cjie|cdpemf hm`ej|# df` jqjf|m# mfcu yepb qjxu |pxmfi xdpemfdcj hdloefi ep& Dcc |mczpemf| ~xm~m|j` bjxj yecc bdqjeg~dlp mf lm|p|# m~jxdpemf| df` cjie|cdpemf pbdp lmfljxf| pbj dqedpemf& D lbd~pjx mfJlmfmgeldc# xjizcdpmxu df` |mledc eg~dlp yecc `e|lz|| bmy ajd|ehcj ep ymzc` hj pm

eg~cjgjfp lbdfij|&Hu djxmfdzpeldc lmggzfeldpemf| ep e| fmp gjdfp mfcu Dex'pm'Dex mx Dex'pm'Ixmzf`lmggzfeldpemf|& Mpbjx xjcjqdfp lbdffjc| |zlb d| efpjxfdc lmggzfeldpemf| ef|e`j pbjdex~mxp df` hdiidij lmfpxmc |u|pjg| yecc hj ~dxp ma pbj ymxo& @j~dxpzxj Lmfpxmc\u|pjg| "@L\% dxj hjlmgefi eflxjd|eficu gmxj efpjixdpj` df` lmg~cjr& Pbju dxj z|j`pm lbjlo'ef ~d||jfijx| df` ef |mgj ld|j| lmggzfeldpj ~d||~mxp efamxgdpemf amx Z\hmx`jx |jlzxepu |u|pjg|# bdqefi pm `jdc yepb fjyjx j'^d||~mxp mx E@ ldx`|& Hdiidij|u|pjg| dxj qjxu mzp`dpj` df` mf d qjxij ma gdkmx pzxfdxmzf` ef pjxg| ma pxdloefi&Efpjxfdpemfdc |pdf`dx`e{dpemf hm`u EDPD bd| gd`j XAE@ z|dij pbj fjrp pdxijppjlbfmcmiu amx hdiidij |jlzxepu& Pbj|j df` mpbjx lmggzfeldpemf| mf ixmzf` yecc hjlmqjxj` d| dex |jlzxepu e| |de` pm |pdxp mf ixmzf`&

Dexcefj| bdqj myf dex'pm'ixmzf` lmggzfeldpemf |u|pjg| pbdp pbju z|j amx m~jxdpemfdcd|~jlp|& Dexhz| bd| d |u|pjg ldccj` Dex Pxdaael \jxqelj| Zfep "DP\Z%# df dqemfel|lmg~zpjx hzecp hu Dexhz| amx ef|pdccdpemf ef fjyjx gm`jc| ma pbjex dexlxdap pbdp ~jxamxg|pbj azflpemf|& DP\Z |jxqj| d| df mfcefj gdefpjfdflj ~mxp# df` jfiefjjx| ldf xjgmpjcu`m lxepeldc z~`dpj| df` xjlmfaeizxdpemf| ybecj pbj dexlxdap e| dexhmxfj& Pbe| e| d |jxemz|pdxijp amx pjxxmxe|p ~zx~m|j|# `j|~epj fjj`efi beibjx lmg~cjrepu pjlbfmcmiu pbdf pbjufmxgdc bmc` df` ixd|~ amx z|j&

Bmyjqjx# pbj ~xm~m|j` |mczpemf| ldffmp efpjxajxj pjlbfmcmieldccu yepb pbj dqedpemfjtze~gjfp| df` pjlbfmcmiej|& \dajpu eg~mxpdflj e| gzlb hjumf` |jlzxepu df` dcc|u|pjg| pbdp dxj ef|pdccj` mf hmdx` gz|p lmg~cu yepb d qd|p |jp ma xjizcdpemf| df`

8/14/2019 Future Security in Aeronautics Communications

6/21

8>>5->4->2 ^dij 1

|pdf`dx`|& Pbj e||zj ma yjeibp# ~myjx lmf|zg~pemf df` |e{j ma dfu jtze~gjfp ~zpdhmdx` e| dc|m lxzledc& Dcc |jlzxepu pjlbfmcmieldc |mczpemf| |pz`ej` yecc bdqj d||eifj` d|dajpu xe|o d||j||gjfp&

Ep e| ofmyf adlp pbdp pbjxj yecc fjqjx hj d ~jxajlp df` zfhxjdodhcj |jlzxepu |u|pjg& Fm |u|pjgldf ljxpeau pbj bzgdf z|jx|# pbdp ldf gdoj ge|pdoj| d| |eg~cj d ~zppefi d ~d||ymx` mf d ~m|p'ep|pzlo pm d ^L |lxjjf& ^exdpj| df` pjxxmxe|p| dxj pexjcj|| ef cjdxfefi bmy |u|pjg| ymxo df`

lexlzgqjfpefi pbj ~xmpjlpemf pbju maajx& Ef pbe| d|~jlp# pbj mhkjlpeqj e| pm gdoj ep d| `eaaelzcp#lmg~cjr df` lm|pcu pm jr~cmxj dfu qzcfjxdhecepu ef pbj |jlzxepu gjlbdfe|g|&

8/14/2019 Future Security in Aeronautics Communications

7/21

8>>5->4->2 ^dij 9

Ef Djxmfdzpel| ~d|p df` ~xj|jfp# JL bd| azf`j` ~xmkjlp| pbdp dxj qjxu efpjxj|pefi& Efdjxmfdzpel| yj ldf fdgj; JGGD# \MAED# D\\PDX# ACU\DAJ# amx ef|pdflj&

\jlzxepu ldcc| bdqj xde|j` |mgj ~m|epeqjcu effmqdpeqj xj|zcp|# ef |mgj ld|j| `exjlpculmffjlpj` pm dqedpemf& Jrdg~cj e| pbj ^DPEF ~xmkjlp& Hmx`jx |jlzxepu ldf hjfjaep axmgICMHJ lmf|mxpezg xjcjd|j` gdpjxedc|& Ef pbj ELP ldcc d ajy ~xmkjlp| dxj `j`eldpj` pmefamxgdpemf |jlzxepu# yepb amxzg| df` ymxo|bm~| mxidfe|j` axjtzjfpcu&

Pbj JZ'azf`j` ~xmkjlp LD\DIXD\ "Lmmx`efdpemf df` |z~~mxp dlpemf amx icmhdcXAE@'xjcdpj` dlpeqepej| df` |pdf`dx`e|dpemf% e| pm hj lmf|e`jxj`& Ep deg| pm ~xmqe`j daxdgjymxo ma amzf`dpemf |pz`ej| pm d||e|p pbj Jzxm~jdf Lmgge||emf df` pbj icmhdclmggzfepu ef `jaefefi df` dllmggm`dpefi efpjxfdpemfdc e||zj| df` `jqjcm~gjfp|lmfljxfefi xd`em axjtzjflu e`jfpeaeldpemf "XAE@%&

Dp pbj kmh# |jqjxdc ~xm~m|dc| bdqj hjjf |zhgeppj` ef pbj JL A^9 pbdp yecc ~xmqj qjxubjc~azc d| |mzxlj amx efamxgdpemf df` fjy `jqjcm~gjfp|& Pbju |bdcc lmgj dceqj `zxefi8>>5&

8/14/2019 Future Security in Aeronautics Communications

8/21

8>>5->4->2 ^dij 2

Gm`jxf dexcefjx| acu ef 0'@ fdqeidpemf# dcpepz`j# cdpepz`j# cmfiepz`j df` pegj& Amx pbdp ~zx~m|jpbju dxj acmyf hu Aceibp Gdfdijgjfp \u|pjg| "AG\% df` fmp hu bdf`& AG\ e| d lmg~zpjxybjxj ~ecmp| efpxm`zlj xmzpj| df` ep gdoj| pbj dexlxdap amccmy ep ef qjxu ~xjle|j ad|bemf# de`j` huI^\ df` Efjxpedc Fdqeidpemf \u|pjg "EF\%& Ep e| ld~dhcj ma acuefi mxpbm mgel xmzpj| pm pxdqjc pbjxjdc gefegzg `e|pdflj axmg D pm H# ef|pjd` ma pbj lmf|pdfp bjd`efi fdqeidpemf pbdp Dzpm ^ecmp|"D^% `m& \j~dxdpemf axmg mpbjx dexcefjx| e| ~jxamxgj` hu pbj ~ecmp| qed pbj D^ hd|j` mf mx`jx|

|jf` hu pbj DPL|& Pbj fjrp ~dxd`eig amx |j~dxdpemf e| pbj Dexhmxfj \j~dxdpemf D||e|pdflj\u|pjg| "D\D\%# dxj AG\| ld~dhcj ma gdefpjfdflj ma pegj mx |~dlj `e|pdflj hjpyjjf dexlxdapyepbmzp bzgdf efpjxqjfpemf& Pbe| yecc jfdhcj pm xj`zlj |j~dxdpemf gefegd# pbz| gdoefi dex|~dljgmxj jaaelejfp df` ~xmaepdhcj# ybecj z~ixd`efi |dajpu&

8/14/2019 Future Security in Aeronautics Communications

9/21

8>>5->4->2 ^dij 5

Lxu~pm'|jlzxepu; Pbj lmg~mfjfp ma lmggzfeldpemf| |jlzxepu pbdp xj|zcp| axmgpbj ~xmqe|emf ma lxu~pm|u|pjg| df` pbjex z|j pm le~bjx efamxgdpemf& Pbe|eflcz`j| jf|zxefi gj||dij lmfae`jfpedcepu df` dzpbjfpelepu&

Jge||emf |jlzxepu "JG\JL%; Gjd|zxj| pdojf pm `jfu zfdzpbmxe{j`~jx|mf| dllj|| pm efamxgdpemf `jxeqj` axmg efpjxlj~pefi jgdfdpemf| axmglxu~pm'jtze~gjfp# dzpmgdpj` efamxgdpemf |u|pjg| "lmg~zpjx|%# df`

pjcjlmggzfeldpemf| |u|pjg|&

^bu|eldc |jlzxepu; ^bu|eldc gjd|zxj| fjlj||dxu pm ~xjqjfp dllj|| mazfdzpbmxe{j` ~jx|mffjc pm lcd||eaej` jtze~gjfp# gdpjxedc# df` `mlzgjfp|&

Pxdaael'acmy |jlzxepu; Gjd|zxj| pbdp lmfljdc pbj ~xj|jflj df` ~xm~jxpej| maqdce` gj||dij| mf d fjpymxo& Ep eflcz`j| pbj ~xmpjlpemf xj|zcpefi axmg ajdpzxj|efbjxjfp ef |mgj lxu~pmixd~bel jtze~gjfp# pbdp lmfljdc pbj ~xj|jflj ma qdce`gj||dij| mf d lmggzfeldpemf| lexlzep# fmxgdccu dlbejqj` hu ldz|efi pbjlexlzep pm d~~jdx hz|u dp dcc pegj|&

Pxdf|ge||emf |jlzxepu "PXDF\JL%; Pbj gjd|zxj| `j|eifj` pm ~xmpjlppxdf|ge||emf| axmg efpjxlj~pemf df` jr~cmepdpemf hu gjdf| mpbjxpbdf lxu~pdfdcu|e| "j&i& axjtzjflu bm~~efi df` |~xjd` |~jlpxzg%&

0&8 Jre|pefi ~xmqjf pjlbfmcmiej|

Lmggmf E^ fjpymxo| geibp hjlmgj |pdf`dx` ef dqedpemf# jqjf |zh|pepzpefi ixmzf` DjxmfdzpeldcAerj` Pjcjlmggzfeldpemf Fjpymxo| "DAPF%& Ef pbj ld|j ma dqedpemf ep lmzc` d||zgj pbj amxg mad |jlzxj Qexpzdc xeqdpj Fjpymxo "Q^F% mqjx d Ye`j Dxjd Fjpymxo "YDF%&

Ef yexjcj|| E^# |jlzxepu gjlbdfe|g|# |zlb d| Y^D mx Y^D8 dxj ye`jcu z|j`& Pbj|j ldfm~jxdpj ef cefo| yepb YeGDR df` Yeae 2>8&44f&

0&>8 hu pbj GEP d| mfjma pbj pjf pjlbfmcmiej| pbdp yecc lbdfij pbj ymxc`& Pbe| pjlbfmcmiu ldf hj z|j` pm jrlbdfijlxu~pmixd~bu oju| hjpyjjf pym xjgmpj lmggzfeldpmx| lmffjlpj` hu df m~peldc aehxj ldhcj# df`pm lmfaexg pbj |jlxjlu ma pbdp jrlbdfij& Amx |gdccjx xdfij|# df efaxdxj` cd|jx hjdg pxdqjccefipbxmzib pbj dex ldf hj df dcpjxfdpeqj pm pbj aehxj m~pel| ldhcj& Ep e| `e|lz||j` pbdp cd|jx hjdg|lmzc` jqjf hj z|j` pm lmggzfeldpj hjpyjjf ~cdlj| adx d~dxp# pbxmzib pbj xjcdu ma pbj cd|jx hjdghu |dpjccepj|&

Tzdfpzg |jlzxepu bd| pbj mfj ma ep| ixjdpj|p d`qdfpdij| ef oju ijfjxdpemf df` `e|pxehzpemf& Ojuijfjxdpemf |pxjfipb| lmgj axmg pbj hep |e{j ma pbj oju df`# hu bmy xdf`mg dxj zf`jxcuefi pbjfzghjx|& Xdf`mg fzghjx| lmgj axmg lmg~zpjx| zf~xj`elpdhcj efpjxfdc ~dxdgjpjx| ceoj pbjcd|p hep ma pbj lcmlo& Mqjx gdfu oju| ijfjxdpj`# ~dppjxf| ldf hj `jpjlpj` df` pbjxj e| be|pmxu mapbj ad|p ixmyefi mfcefj ld|efm| ijppefi hjdpjf hu pbj xdf`mg ldx`| hjefi ~xj`elpj` hu bzgdf~cdujx|& D |mczpemf bd| hjjf pbj Tzdfpzg lmg~zpjx ijfjxdpj` fzghjx| amx ybelb ~xm`zlp| bdqjhjjf ef`z|pxedce{j` "_8

8/14/2019 Future Security in Aeronautics Communications

10/21

8>>5->4->2 ^dij 4>

jdqj|`xm~~jx ~m||j||j| zfcegepj` lmg~zpdpemfdc ~myjx df` lmggjxledc ~xm`zlp| dxj dcxjd`u mfpbj efamxgdpemf |jlzxepu gdxojp&

0&0 \zh axdgjymxo|

Ef pbj fjrp |zh|jlpemf| ep yecc hj jpdecj` pbj |lm~j df` ~xj`elpdhcj eg~xmqjgjfp| mf pbj jre|pefiaxdgjymxo|& Amx jdlb ma pbjg yj ~xj|jfp pbj jre|pefi pjlbfmcmiej|# pbjex d~~celdpemf ef |mcqefi

jre|pefi |jlzxepu ~xmhcjg|&

0&0&4 Dexlxdap \zxqjeccdflj lmggzfeldpemf|

^xmhcjg|; Pbj pjlbfmcmiej| pm jqmcqj df` pbjex |bmxplmgefi| dxj pbj lmm~jxdpeqj mfj|#gjdfefi dcc jtze~gjfp pbdp ~xmqe`j| |pdpz| ma ieqjf pxdaael hj|e`j| pbj ~xegdxu xd`dx|&PLD\ e| hd|j` mf pxdf|~mf`jx| df` e| d |dajpu fjp# ~xmqe`efi dfpe'lmcce|emf azflpemf|&Pxdf|~mf`jx| bdqj d |jxemz| cdlo ma dzpbjfpeldpemf d| pbj mfcu pbefi z|j` pm e`jfpeau dfdex~cdfj e| d amzx hupj lm`j& D@\'H e| fmp zfeamxg ymxc`ye`j df` `j~jf`| mf`dpdcefo| |zlb d| Q@C8# Q@C0# 4>5> J\ mx ZDP# pbj `eaajxjflj hjefi mf hdf` z|j`Pbj ld|j ma PE\'H ybjxj ixmzf` |pdpemf| ~xmqe`j efamxgdpemf e| gmxj `jceldpj |eflj epe| jd|ejx pm eg~jx|mfdpj |mgjpbefi mf ixmzf` pbdf df dexhmxfj jfpepu&

\mczpemf|; Df dzpbjfpeldpemf |u|pjg yepb eiepdc ljxpeaeldpj| gz|p hj lxjdpj` amx jdlb dexlxdap df`DPL |pdpemf|& Pbe| yecc jf|zxj e| dexlxdap e| ybelb ep e| efpjf`j` pm hj& Df d|uggjpxel oju |u|pjgldf hj z|j` yepb jdlb bdqefi d ~xeqdpj df` ~zhcel oju& Dexlxdap dexcefj ijp ixmzf` z~`dpj| jdlbjeibpjjf `du|# fmxgdccu amx fdqeidpemf efamxgdpemf z~`dpj|& Pbe| lmzc` hj z|j` pm `e|pxehzpj# qedL@# d fjy ~dx ma oju| amx pbj dexlxdap df` amx dcc DPL axjtzjflej| ef pbj ymxc`& TO@ ldf mfcuhj `mfj qed m~peldc gjdf| ybelb efqdce`dpj| `e|pxehzpemf ef|e`j dex'pm'ixmzf` lbdffjc| "qed|dpjccepj e| |pecc pmm azpzxe|pel%& Ljxpeaeldpj| lmzc` hj ~xmqe`j hu dexlxdap df` qdce`dpj` hu DPL& Epgdu hj lmg~cjr amx dexlxdap pm qdce`dpj ljxpeaeldpj| zj xjgmpjfj|| ma ljxpeaeldpj ~xmqe`jx|&

0&0&8 DPL lmggzfeldpemf|

0&0&8&4 Qmelj hxmd`ld|p

^xmhcjg|; Dex pm ixmzf` qmelj imj| pbxmzib pym pu~j| ma lbdffjc|# hmpb dfdcmi& QjxuBeib Axjtzjflu "QBA% e| pbj mfj fmxgdccu |jxqefi pbj ~ecmp| df` lmfpxmccjx|& Pbj 442'4

8/14/2019 Future Security in Aeronautics Communications

11/21

8>>5->4->2 ^dij 44

0&0&8&8 @eiepdc @dpd Cefo|

^xmhcjg|; Pbj lmggzfeldpemf| hjpyjjf ~ecmp df` DPL yecc hjfjaep axmg pbj `eiepdc dxjdeg~xmqjgjfp| ef `dpd cefo|& Pbj L^@CL| gdef imdc e| dqme` pbj pmpdc lmfij|pemf ma pbjcegepdpemf ma pbj xd`em hdf`|# d| pxdaael df` dex~mxp| bdqj ixjdpcu eflxjd|j` cdpjcu& Ep yecc ymxo d|pjrp gj||dij| hjefi jrlbdfij` amxg DPL| pm ~ecmp|& Pbj|j yecc hj ~xj'amxgdppj` df` qjxu|pdf`dx` pbmzib axjj pjrp yecc hj dqdecdhcj&

Pbjxj dxj `eaajxjfp eg~cjgjfpdpemf| mqjx pbj ymxc` d| fm dixjjgjfp e| jre|pjfp mf d |pdf`dx`'Pbj Azpzxj Dex Fdqeidpemf \u|pjg "ADF\% 4-D \u|pjg z|j` hu Hmjefi df` Dexhz|# e| ~xegdxecuz|j` ef mljdfel xmzpj| hu ye`j'hm`ej| cmfi bdzc dexlxdap& ADF\'4-D e| df DLDX\ hd|j` |jxqeljdf`# df` z|j| |dpjccepj lmggzfeldpemf| ~xmqe`j` hu pbj Efgdx|dp ~xeqdpj |jxqelj&

Jzxm~j bd| df m~jxdpemfdc DPF-L^@CL fjpymxo# dp Jzxmlmfpxmc)| Gdd|pxelbp Z~~jx Dex|~dljLmfpxmc Ljfpxj df` bd| hjjf jrpjf`j` hu pbj CEFO8>>>/ ^xmixdggj pm gdfu mpbjx Jzxm~jdfAceibp Efamxgdpemf Xjiemf| "AEX|%& Pbj|j m~jxdpj ef Q@C Gm`j 8&

L^@CL e| pxdf|geppj` ef hxmd`ld|p# yepb fm le~bjx df` fm dzpbjfpeldpemf# `j|~epj hjefi mf pbjqjxij ma eg~cjgjfpdpemf ef d ye`j |ldcj&

\mczpemf|; Efpxm`zlj le~bjx# |daj oju `e|pxehzpemf df` dzpbjfpeldpemf mf gj||dij| df`lmggzfeldpmx|& Ldxj e| pm hj pdojf pm dqme` zfdllj~pdhcj hdf`ye`pb eflxjd|j ybecj eg~xmqefi|jlzxepu ef |zlb d ydu pbdp ybjf gj||dij| dxj efpjxlj~pj`# pbjex z|j amx lxjdpefi ~xmhcjg| ybecjhj fm cmfijx jre|pefi&

0&0&

8/14/2019 Future Security in Aeronautics Communications

12/21

8>>5->4->2 ^dij 48

^xmhcjg|; ^exdlu e| |pecc pbj gm|p `dfijxmz| pbxjdp pm dex pxdf|~mxp df` bd| pbj ~mpjfpedc amx pbjheiij|p efacjlpj` `dgdij ef pbj lmggzfepej|& ^d~jx ~d||~mxp| dxj dlpzdccu d |jlzxj gjlbdfe|gamx pjxxmxe|p pm pxdqjc axjjcu dxmzf` pbj ymxc`& Pbju dxj jd|ecu lmzfpjxajepj`# hu amxiefi mf hcdfo|pmcjf mfj|& Xjljfpcu pbj d``epemf ma hemgjpxel| bd| gd`j amx dzpmgdpel `mmx| pm m~jf mf adljxjlmifepemf& Pbj fjrp ijfjxdpemf ma ~d||~mxp| yecc bdqj 4> aefijx `eiepdc ~xefp|# @FD# qmelj#oju|pxmoj# |eifdpzxj df` exe| hem `dpd jflm`j` ef XAE@ pdi| jghj``j` ef|e`j pbj `mlzgjfp&ELDM e| pbj cjd`jx ma pbj ymxc`ye`j xjlmggjf`dpemf| amx eg~cjgjfpdpemf ma pbj j'^d||~mxp&

Dcxjd`u bdlojx| bdqj `e|lmqjxj` bmy pm lxdlo pbj |jlzxepu df` bmy pm lcmfj ep&

Pbj \lbjfijf dxjd jflmg~d||j| pbj gm|p ma JZ lmzfpxej| ~cz| |mgj mpbjx| ceoj Fmxydu df`#\yep{jxcdf` yecc kmef ef pbe| ujdx& Ef|e`j pbj JZ E@ lbjlo xj|zgj| pm E@ ldx` lbjlo mf lbjlo'efdp pbj lmzfpjx df` mf hmdx`efi& ^d||~mxp|# jqjf pbj fjy mfj|# dxj fmp xjtzexj` dp dcc& E@ ldx`| dxje||zj` hu jdlb lmzfpxu yepb d qdxejpu ma |pdf`dx`| df` |jlzxepu cjqjc|# df` yepbmzp |bdxj``dpdhd|j|&

Pbj fjy ~d||~mxp yecc hj efjaajlpeqj ef|e`j pbj \lbjfijf ~dlp fdpemf|& ^mxpzidc bd| qd|pcueg~xmqj` mzx Hecbjpj `j E`jfpe`d`j yepb pbj cdzflb ma Ldxpm `m Le`d`m& Ep bd| d``epemf mad |gdxp lbe~ KdqdLdx` "_4* ma hdx lm`j pdi| df` XAE@ ldf xjdlb d| gzlb d| 52*&@jcpd Dexcefj|# fmy pbj heiij|p dexcefj ef pbj ymxc`# |pdpj` pbju cm|j dhmzp 4>>GZ\@ ~jx ujdx mflmg~jf|dpemf| pm ~d||jfijx| `zj pm cm|p hdiidij& Pbj ^df Dg H&909 pbdp jr~cm`j` mqjx\lmpcdf` yd| d ld|zdcpu ma d adc|j pdi ef|jxpj` mf d hdi ybelb lmfljdcj` pbj hmgh `jqelj& Dhmzp

0>> hdiidij qmczgj| dxj |pmcjf jdlb `du ef Ce|hmf& Pbe| bd~~jf| ef gdfu leqece{j` lmzfpej| df`Hxepe|b Dexydu| ef|pdccj` ldxim bmc` ldgjxd| ef pbjex dexlxdap pm `e||zd`j pbjap ef|e`j ~cdfj|&Pbjxj e| fmpbefi gmxj pbdf d hdx lm`j yepb pbj fzghjx E` ma pbj hdiidij# df` pbj pdi yepb~d||jfijx fdgj# mxeief df` `j|pefdpemf dex~mxp|& Jqjf ~xm~m|j` fjy XAE@| dxj pm `m ceppcj gmxjpbdf pm lm`j pbj |dgj efamxgdpemf ef ~d||eqj xd`em pdi|# pbj cjd`efi |~jleaeldpemf hjefi EDPD|xjlmggjf`j` ~xdlpelj X^ 490>L "_1W%& Pbj |~jleaeldpemf `jdc| yepb jflm`efi df` `dpd |jp|# fmpd``xj||efi |jlzxepu dp dcc& Ep| gdkmx xj|zcp e| `jaefefi pbj xjd`-yxepj axjtzjflu ef|e`j pbj ZBAhdf`# pm hj m~jxdhcj ef lmfamxgdflj pm xd`em axjtzjflu cdy ef gm|p ma pbj lmzfpxej|& Pbe| e|imm` amx dpd xdpj| dp pbj jr~jf|j ma jpjlpemf xdfij "_:W%& Xmhhefi hdi qmczgj| dp pbj lmccjlpemf

8/14/2019 Future Security in Aeronautics Communications

13/21

8>>5->4->2 ^dij 4| bd` d aeqj gjf lxjy& Pbj ZX\\ `e` pbj |dgj zfpec pbjjeibpej|# pm dqme` dex `jajlpemf pm pbj Yj|p# ybelb bd~~jfj` yepb mfj'gdffj` aeibpjx kjp|& Ef pbjcdpj aeapej|# pbj lxjy| ybjxj xj`zlj` pm pbxjj ybjf dexlxdap ceoj Hmjefi H&9>9| yjxj efpxm`zlj`&Ef pbj cdpj 1>| kjp| yepb mfcu d Ld~pdef df` Aex|p Maaeljx hjldgj pbj fmxg hu pbj H&9# Pxe|pdx% zfpec pbj efpxm`zlpemf mapbj H&919 ef 4528& Jqjf pbj bzij H'909 hjldgj acudhcj yepb pym ef ep| '0>> qdxedfp cdzflbj` ef4522& Fmy# dcc fjy dexcefjx| dxj pym ~ecmp| ef`j~jf`jfpcu ma pbj |e{j# jqjf pbj D& Ef pbjijfjxdc dqedpemf gdxojp Qjxu Ceibp Kjp| "QCK% dxj jfpjxefi pbj gdxojp& Bdqefi kjp |~jj`~jxamxgdflj# cmy m~jxdpefi lm|p df` ~xelj pdi# qjxu |gdcc "1 ~d||jfijx ldhef fmxgdccu% df`acmyf hu mfj ~ecmp# pbju dxj |jp pm xjqmczpemfe{j pbj gdxojp amx dex pdre|& Lmfljxf jre|p| mf ~ecmpefld~dlepdpemf& Ymxo e| hjefi `mfj pm ~xjqjfp `e|d|pjx| df` mfj |mczpemf e| pm bdqj df Dex Amxlj

aeibpjx dexlxdap xj`exjlpefi pbj QCK mfpm d |daj `j|pefdpemf& Pbe| ymzc` hj hu z~cmd`efi d fjyaceibp ~cdf df` gdoefi pbj zfize`j` kjp d| mf d cjd|b& Pm jf|zxj ~xm~jx z|j ma pbe| |dajpugjlbdfe|g d |bmxp xdfij m~peldc ~mxp lmzc` hj jre|pjfp ma pbj az|jcdij df` Tzdfpzg |jlzxepe|j`lmggdf`| ieqjf& Df JL A^1 ~xmkjlp ldccj` \MAED e| d``xj||efi pbe| |mczpemf| ajd|ehecepu#

8/14/2019 Future Security in Aeronautics Communications

14/21

8>>5->4->2 ^dij 40

: Ymxo jqdczdpemf gjpxel| df` gjdf|

Pbj ymxo `mfj zf`jx pbj |lm~j ma pbj pbj|e| yecc uejc` d xmd`gd~ amx pbj |jlzxepueg~xmqjgjfp ef djxmfdzpeldc lmggzfeldpemf|& Gdfu pbxjdp| yecc hj dfdcu|j` df`|mczpemf| yecc hj |pz`ej` df` ~xm~m|j` pm lm~j yepb pbm|j pbxjdp|# ybecj pdoefi ~xmaepaxmg dlpzdc df` jgjxiefi |jlzxepu pjlbfmcmiej| df` ~xmlj`zxj|&

Pbj mzp~zp yecc ma pbe| ymxo e| fmp d |mapydxj ~xmixdg ybelb eg~cjgjfpdpemf ldf hjlmg~dxj` pm d |~jleaeldpemf amx hjflbgdxoefi mf dlbejqjgjfp ma lmg~cjpjfj||& Pbjxjyecc hj fm ~jxamxgdflj dfdcu|e| mx lbjloefi amx m~jxdpemfdc ld~dhecepu d~m|pjxemxe& Pbjxj|zcp e| d ~d~jx df` yecc fmp hxefi dppdlbj` |mapydxj ma bdx`ydxj ~xj|jfpdhcj ~dxp|# fmxdfu pu~j ma yjh|epj| mx dfu efpjxdlpeqj |u|pjg&

Ef pbj ld|j ma pu~eldc efamxgdpemf |u|pjg| mx dcimxepbg| pbjxj ldf hj |zlb gjpxel|& Efpjxfjp|jxqjx| ldf ~xmqe`j gjpxel| hd|j` mf pbjex aexjydcc| xjlmx`| ef `jajf`efi d fzghjx ma `eaajxjfppbxjdp|& Jflxu~pemf dcimxepbg| |pxjfipb| df` pegj pm hxjdo ldf hj `jgmf|pxdpj` yepb amxgdcgjpbm`| "_4W%&

Jqdczdpemf mf pbj xj|zcp| ldf hj `mfj ef pym ydu|# tzdfpepdpeqj df` tzdcepdpeqj& Pbjaex|p mfj yecc lmf|e|p ef pbj lmg~dxe|mf ma pbj dgmzfp ma pbxjdp| dlpzdc ~mpjfpedc

`jpjlpj` yepb pbj fjy |mczpemf| ~xm~m|j`& D oju d|~jlp pm pbj |zllj|| ma dfu fjy|jlzxepu |mczpemf e| pbj bzgdf adlpmx ma pjxxmxe|p yepb`xdydc& Pbj lbdxp ef pbj Dffjrj|`j~elp| d fjqjx jf`efi pjxxmxe|p dlpeqepu mqjx pbj `jld`j| |eflj dex pxdqjc hjldgj d beib|ldcj xjdcepu& Lbdfij| dxj gd`j# yepb gjpdc `jpjlpmx|# R'xdu amx bdf` cziidij# cetze`|cegepdpemf| pm 4> r 4>>gc ~jx ~d||jfijx `j~cdfefi ma hdi| axmg ~d||jfijx| ybm ge||pbjex hmdx`efi df` BH\4>> "4>>* |lxjjfefi ma Bmc` Hdiidij \jlzxepu% hjefigdf`dpmxu mf dcc lmzfpxej|& Pbj|j gjpbm`| dxj z|j` amx lmzfpjxdlpefi ~xjqemz| pjxxmxe|ppbxjdp|# ybelb hjlmgj gmxj df` gmxj pxdefj` df` jcz|eqj ma dfu fjy gjlbdfe|g&

Pbj mpbjx pjlbfeldc d||j||gjfp gjpbm` yecc hj pbxmzib `e||jgefdpemf df` jr~jxp|pdojbmc`jx ajj`hdlo# ybelb yecc ixdfp d tzdcepdpeqj qejy mf pbj |dgj xj|zcp|&

Pbj fjrp |jlpemf yecc `jpdec pbj ~dxpelzcdx| ma pbj jdlb ma pbj gjdf| amx jqdczdpemf&

:&4 Pbxjdp| xde|j` qjx|z| gepeidpj`

Fjy |jlzxepu pjlbfmcmiej| z|j` ybjxj cjidlu mfj| dxj pbj |pdf`dx` yecc xde|j pbj cjqjcma lmfae`jflj d| pm lxjdpefi azxpbjx `e|pdflj pm pbj ~xj|jfp ~mpjfpedc pbxjdp|& Ef pbe|`mlzgjfp# ~xjcegefdxu |mczpemf| dxj bj ieqjf ef aejc`| ma |pz`u ~cdffj`& D hxjdo'z~ malmggzfeldpemf |u|pjg| efqmcqj` ef pbj djxmfdzpel| ymxc` yecc bdqj `j`eldpj` dppjfpemfybecj pbjxj e| pbj imdc pm gdefpdef pbj dlpzdc cjqjc ma efpjxm~jxdhecepu&

Pbj cjqjc ma pbxjdp gepeidpj` ldf hj gjd|zxj` mf bmy `eaaelzcp e| pm ~jxamxg df dlp ma pjxxmxe|g&Ef pbj ~xegmx`edc jxd ma dqedpemf dcc ep pmmo yd| pm pdoj d aexj yjd~mf mf hmdx` pm pdoj lmfpxmc mapbj lxjy# mx |eg~cu lbjlo'ef d hdi yepb d hmgh df` ydco dydu& ^xmlj`zxj| df` |jf|mx|gepeidpj` pbe|& Dzpmgdpel izf ldf hj hmzib amx d| gzlb d| 8>>& Pbjf# xmlojp| "X^I|%# ~xelj`ef hcdlo gdxojp| dp 4> >>> Z\@# yjxj z|j` ef ^dxe| Mxcu didef|p Jc Dc ef pbj 459>| "_49W% df`# dajy ujdx| dim ef Hdib`d` didef|p d @BC Dexhz| D>& Pbj \dgmxd Gdlbjc dppdlo yd| gzlbgmxj lmg~cjr df` efqmcqj` ~zppefi z~ d xd`em fdqeidpemf |u|pjg# yepb xjtzexj| d beib ~myjx df`pxdf|geppjx mf lmf|e`jxdhcj lmg~cjrepu& Mf pbj mpbjx bdf`# d |eg~cj 4>> xd`em yecc dccmy pmjaajlpeqjcu eg~jx|mfdpj d lmggzfeldpemf ef df DPL axjtzjflu&

Hu efpxm`zlefi gmxj d`qdflj` |jlzxepu pbj |oecc df` jtze~gjfp ma pjxxmxe|p yecc bdqjpm d`d~p pbz| `jgdf`efi beibjx# df` lm|pcu# pxdefefi& Pbe| yecc cegep pbj pbxjdp pm pxzj~xmaj||emfdc| ybelb dxj jd|ejx pm pxdlo hu efpjcceijflj dijflej| df` lcjdx mzp dqedpemfaxmg dgdpjzx| ceoj pbj ldx hmghjx| ef Icd|imy Efpjxfdpemfdc Dex~mxp& Ep e| eg~mxpdfp pm

8/14/2019 Future Security in Aeronautics Communications

15/21

8>>5->4->2 ^dij 4:

jg~bd|e|j pbdp dfpe'pjxxmxe|g |jlzxepu gz|p hj lmfljfpxdpj` mf ~xjqjfpemf df` fmp mfgjdf| pm lmzfpjxdlp dapjx mfj |zlb jqjfp e| efepedpj`&

D gefegzg ~xmaecj amx d pjxxmxe|p dppdlo yecc hj ~xj|jfpj` amx jdlb |zh'axdgjymxo&Pbe| ldf# amx ef|pdflj# gjdf d ~jx|mf pbdp yecc fjj` pm hj d Lmg~zpjx \lejflj jr~jxpdf` bdqj ef ~m||j||emf d qjxu ~myjxazc cd~pm~ ^L yepb |pdpj'ma'pbj dxp |mapydxj pm`jle~bjx |jlzxj gj||dij|&

:&8 Jf`'z|jx ajj`hdlo

Axmg ~jx|mfdc dlpeqepej| ef xjcdpemf pm djxmfdzpeldc Xj|jdxlb ! @jqjcm~gjfp~xmixdggj| df` cede|mf| mhpdefj` ef bmhhej| xjcdpj` pm dqedpemf yj ~m||j|| d imm``jdc ma lmfpdlp| pbdp dxj `exjlp |pdojbmc`jx| ef dcc pbj axdgjymxo| |jcjlpj` amx |pz`u df`eg~xmqjgjfp& Pbj|j |pdojbmc`jx| yecc bjc~ z| yepb xjcjqdfp ajj`hdlo ef pbjd~~celdhecepu ma pbj ymxo&

Axmg pbj dexhmxfj |e`j# yj ldf jr~cmxj df dijf`d yepb d qd|p fzghjx ma dexcefj ~ecmp|#fdpemfdc df` efpjxfdpemfdc# |mgj ma pbjg dlpeqj ef X!@ ~xmkjlp| ef `eqjx|j lmzfpxej|&Mf ixmzf`# pbjxj e| dltzdefpdflj yepb |jqjxdc Dex Pxdaael Lmfpxmccjx| df` jfiefjjx|ybm hjcmfi pm DPL mxidfe{dpemf|& D| pbj ld|j yepb ~ecmp|# gdfu ma pbjg lmm~jxdpj ef`jqjcm~gjfp# hmpb amx xj|jdxlb df` amx pdxijp ef'bmz|j |u|pjg|& Pbjxj dxj cefo| pm hj

~zx|zj` yepb bdf`cefi lmg~dfej| "lmg~dfej| pbdp lbjlo'ef df` hmdx` ~d||jfijx| df`cmd`-zfcmd` ldxim df` hdiidij% gdefcu ef pbj ^mxpzizj|j lmg~dfej|# Ixmzf`amxlj#PXEDG df` ^mxpydu&

E yecc jr~cmxj |mgj lmfpdlp| E bdqj yepb fdpemfdc |jlzxepu |jxqelj m~jxdpefi ef dex~mxp|d| yjcc d| mzx fdpemfdc dex~mxp m~jxdpmx "DFD%&

:&8&4 Efpjxqejy|

Ef `j~pb ofmy'bmy |bdcc hj mhpdefj` hu lmf`zlpefi ~jx|mfdc efpjxqejy| yepb jf`'z|jx|df` |pdojbmc`jx| dp `eaajxjfp |pdij| ma pbj jrjlzpemf ma pbj pbj|e| `jqjcm~gjfp pd|o&

:&8&8 Tzj|pemffdexj|

Ef pbj ld|j| ybjxj efpjxqejy| dxj fmp ~m||ehcj# d tzj|pemffdexj yecc hj |jfp df`lmccjlpj` hu j'gdec&

:&8&5#df` pbj PdojMaa kmzxfdc& Dppjfpemf yecc hj `exjlpj` pm |jjoefi Jzxm~jdf lmfajxjflj|ybjxj pm ~xj|jfp d ~d~jx hd|j` mf gu pbj|e| `e||jxpdpemf& Pbj pbj|e| `mlzgjfplmfae`jfpedcepu cjqjc yecc hj ^zhcel& Pbjxj yecc hj fm lmfae`jfpedc hdloixmzf` ~xj|jfpdf` fm cjidc cedhecepu `dfijx hj ~m||ehcj&

8/14/2019 Future Security in Aeronautics Communications

16/21

8>>5->4->2 ^dij 41

1 Lmflcz|emf|

Ep e| qjxu jqe`jfp pbdp dqedpemf |jlzxepu e| qjxu zfhdcdflj` yepb xj|~jlp pm efqj|pgjfpdf` pjlbfmcmiu d~~celdpemf ef ep| `eqjx|j |zh'lmfpjrp|& Amx ~d||jfijx|# |lxjjfefi e|hjlmgefi jqjxu `du gmxj `jgdf`efi& Fjy R'Xdu |lxjjfefi gdlbefj| hxmzibplmfpxmqjx|u ef Cmf`mf Idpyelo d| pbju ~mxpxduj` ~jm~cj d| fdoj` pm pbj |jlzxepu

maaeljx|& Dp Cmf`mf| Bjdpbxmy Dex~mxp# fmqjc |lxjjfefi jtze~gjfp e| ld~dhcj ma|ldffefi jqjf pbxmzib cd~pm~|& Ef Z\D dex~mxp|# cd~pm~| pbjg|jcqj| ldf hj dz`epj` hupbj @j~dxpgjfp ma Bmgjcdf` \jlzxepu amx pjxxmxe|p mx lxegefdc `dpd |pmxj`& Hemgjpxel||jlzxepu e| hjefi efpxm`zlj` ef d ye`j |ldcj# xjlmife{efi adlj|# aefijx ~xefp|# exe| df`xjpefd|& Pbj fjy ~d||~mxp| z|j adlj |ldf| pm lmflecedpj pbj `mlzgjfp| ~mxpjx yepb pbjmyfjx# df` dzpmgdpel `mmx| dxj dlpeqdpj` hu pbj dcimxepbg| dapjx ~m|epeqj E@| "pbe| e|m~jxdpemfdc ef ^mxpzidc%&

Cmmoefi dp pbj dex~cdfj m~jxdpemf| |e`j# pbj |jlzxepu |pdpj ma pbj dxp ~xj|jfp| ep|jca dp dgzlb cmyjx |pdf`dx`& Pbj qjxu eg~mxpdfp qmelj lmggzfeldpemf| `m fmp bdqjdzpbjfpeldpemf| fmx dfu |mxp ma le~bjx& Pbj|j dxj dqdecdhcj amx jqjxumfj pm ce|pjf df` pm~dxpele~dpj# yepb qjxu cmy lm|p pxdf|ljeqjx|& \jqjxj ld|j| ma |jlzxepu hxjdlbj| bdqjhjjf xj~mxpj` df` fm |mczpemf e| ujp dp pbj bmxe{mf&

Dex pxdf|~mxp |dajpu xjcej| lmf|e`jxdhcu mf pbj |jj'df`'dqme` ~becm|m~bu& Pbdp gjdf|pbdp jdlb dexlxdap e| |jjefi jdlb mpbjx hj|e`j| pbj DPL |jxqelj|# j|~jledccu mqjx ydpjx&Pxdf|~mf`jx jtze~gjfp bjc~| dexlxdap gmfepmx pbj mpbjx| mf d lmm~jxdpeqj hd|e| df`~xmqe`j |z~~mxp ef ld|j ma lmcce|emf& \jlzxepu ef pxdaael `dpd jrlbdfij| e| efjre|pjfpfmyd`du|&

Hdiidij pbjap df` pdg~jx e| d gdkmx ~xmhcjg ef gdfu dex~mxp| df` |pecc d ydu pmefpxm`zlj pjxxmxe|p `jqelj| mf hmdx`& Pbj XAE@ efpxm`zlpemf bd| hjjf df` yecc cegep|pbe| |mgjbmy hzp |jlzxepu ma efamxgdpemf |pmxj` ef pbj pdi| e| |pecc d ~xmhcjg amx pbjazpzxj&

\mgj ma pbj |jlzxepu ~xmhcjg| ldf bdqj |mczpemf hu pbj d~~celdpemf ma gdxojp df` aejc`~xmqjf pjlbfmcmiej|& Pbj gecepdxu dxj adx gmxj d`qdflj` df` pbjxj dxj gdfu cj||mf|cjdxfj` pm hj lmf|e`jxj` ef pbe| |pz`u& Zfcegepj` hz`ijp df` lmg~jpepemf hjpyjjf

lmzfpxej| dxj gmpmxydu| amx `jqjcm~gjfp|& Xjqmczpemfdxu acuefi gdlbefj| ceoj pbjCmlobjj` \X'94 Hcdlohex` yecc fjqjx jre|p ef pbj leqec lmfpjrp&

Xd`eldc eg~xmqjgjfp| ef dqedpemf dxj |cmy# gm|pcu `zj pm |dajpu lmfljxf|& Mpbjx adlpmx| ldf hj|pdpj` mzp d|# JZ-Z\D ~mcepel|# gzcpefdpemfdc ef`z|pxu |pdf`dx`| pbdp bdqj pm lmfqjxij mflmf|jf|z|# zfyeccefifj|| ma dexcefj| ef efqj|pefi ef fmf'~xmaepdhcj jtze~gjfp& ^mmx lmzfpej|dexcefj| acu pm pbj Aex|p Ymxc` df` ep |eg~cu df` zpm~ed pm gdoj pbjg |~jf` amxpzfj| z~ixd`efipbjex ~cdfj| yepbmzp d |pxmfi xdpemfdcj& \pxmfi xdpemfdcj ef dqedpemf# ef hmpb |dajpu df` |jlzxepu#gjdf| d |jxej| ma beib `jdpb pmcc dlle`jfp| "ceibp ~xeqdpj ~cdfj pbdp lmcce`j` yepb d Gl@mffjcc@mzicd| @L'5 ef 452>| mqjx C&D&% df` pjxxmxe|p dppdlo| "544# gdfu PYD bekdlo| ef 459>|%&

Pjxxmxe|p| yecc fjqjx hj jcegefdpj`& Pbj mfcu ydu pm gdefpdef |jlzxepu e| pm ojj~ lbdfiefi pbjxzcj| df` `eaaelzcp pbjex m~jxdpemf hu lmqjxefi pbj bmcj| pbdp ldf hj jr~cmepj`&

Gdfu fjy pjlbfmcmiej| dxj jgjxijfp df` gdu jqjf azxpbjx eflxjd|j pbj ceaj ma pbj|jlzxepu gjlbdfe|g|& Pbj gdkmx hxjdopbxmzib df` ldf`e`dpj e| tzdfpzg |jlzxepu&

9 Dlofmycj`igjfp|

Ep e| fjlj||dxu pm pbdfo ^xmaj||mx ^j`xm D`m amx be| ~dpejflj ef xjqejyefi df`|ziij|pefi eg~xmqjgjfp| pm pbe| ~d~jx& Gdfu pbdfo| dc|m pm ^xmaj||mx ^dzcm Gdpjz|#dc|m axmg E\P# amx be| hxejaefi mf Tzdfpzg \jlzxepu `jqjcm~gjfp|# pbj hexpb gmgjfpma pbj e`jd pm ~xm~m|j pbe| pbj|e| ef pbj dxjd&

8/14/2019 Future Security in Aeronautics Communications

17/21

8>>5->4->2 ^dij 49

2 Xjajxjflj|

_4W ^& Hdcpd{dx# X& Lbd`bd# ^& Gdpjz| df` D& \jxfd`d|# \TEI'EP df` E\P#^mxpzidc## Pmydx`| gm`jc'lbjloefi tzdfpzg |jlzxepu ~xmpmlmc|# "Mlpmhjx 49#8>>1%

_8W C& Hxdfomqel df` G& Geccjx# J`|& DLG Efpjxfdpemfdc Lmfajxjflj ^xmljj`efi\jxej|# qmc& :% Jcjlpxmfel \eifdpzxj| df` Efaxd|pxzlpzxj|"J\E%

_:W E\M 42>>>'1L#\pdf`dx` ' XAE@ ZBA Dex Efpjxadlj# 8>>9->0-44_1W EDPD X^490>L# \pdf`dx` amx XAE@ Hdiidij Bdf`cefi# 8>>9_9W Idzxdq \& Ol df` ^dzc D& Odxijx& (\jlzxepu df` ^xeqdlu E||zj| ef Gdlbefj

Xjd`dhcj Pxdqjc @mlzgjfp| "GXP@|%(& EHG Xj|jdxlb Xj~mxp# XL 8:'>5 \j~p&8>>:_4>W Q& C& Ozxmlboef4# E& E& Xudhp|jq df` E& I& Fje{qj|pfeu4# Tzdfpzg oju

ijfjxdpemf hd|j` mf lm`efi ma ~mcdxe{dpemf |pdpj| ma ~bmpmf| Ef|pepzpj ma\jgelmf`zlpmx ^bu|el|# \ehjxedf @eqe|emf# Xz||edf Dld`jgu ma \lejflj|#Fmqm|ehex|o# 1>5># Xz||ed# 49 Kzcu 8>>:&

_4>0%_45W Myjf# @dqe`# Dex Dlle`jfp Efqj|peidpemf# "8>>1%_8>W Mpjcce# Kjdf'^ejxxj# Idf|pjx| `z lejc; Be|pmexj| dzpbjfpetzj| `j ~exdpjxej|#

"8>>0%_84W ^# Q ^ej~x{uo# K df` Ydfi# B& 8>>2& Amxgdc |jlzxepu dfdcu|e| ma Dz|pxdcedf

j'~d||~mxp eg~cjgjfpdpemf& Ef ^xmljj`efi| ma pbj \erpb Dz|pxdcd|edf

Lmfajxjflj mf efamxgdpemf \jlzxepu ' Qmczgj 24 "Ymccmfimfi# F\Y#Dz|pxdced# Kdfzdxu >4 ' >4# 8>>2%_88W ^jxpb adc|j DPL# bpp~;--yyy&dcchz|efj||&lmg-m~jxdpemf|-|be~~efi'dex'

axjeibp-912>40'4&bpgc_8>1&_80W Ixjdp Hxepdef Imqjxfgjfp# Xj~mxp mf pbj Dlle`jfp pm Hmjefi 909'484# F99

8/14/2019 Future Security in Aeronautics Communications

18/21

8>>5->4->2 ^dij 42

_89W XPLD @M'># Gefegzg M~jxdpemfdc ^jxamxgdflj \pdf`dx`| "GM^\% amxPxdaael Dcjxp df` Lmcce|emf Dqme`dflj \u|pjg EE "PLD\ EE% Buhxe`\zxqjeccdflj

_82W XPLD Lbdfij 4 pm @M'81>D# Gefegzg M~jxdpemfdc ^jxamxgdflj \pdf`dx`|amx 4>5> GB{ Jrpjf`j` \tzeppjx Dzpmgdpel @j~jf`jfp \zxqjeccdflj Hxmd`ld|p "D@\'H% df` Pxdaael Efamxgdpemf \jxqelj| Hxmd`ld|p "PE\'H%

_85W XPLD @M'82; ^xmljj`efi| mapbj |erpb Dz|pxdcd|edf lmfajxjflj mf Efamxgdpemf |jlzxepu# "8>>2%

_5# Efpjxfjp ^zhcel Oju Efaxd|pxzlpzxj Mfcefj Ljxpeaeldpj \pdpz| ^xmpmlmc ML\^

8/14/2019 Future Security in Aeronautics Communications

19/21

8>>5->4->2 ^dij 45

5 Dlxmfug| df` `jaefepemf|

Dlxmfug Jr~df`j`0'@ Amzx @egjf|emfD-L DexlxdapDLDX\ Dexlxdap Lmggzfeldpemf| D``xj||efi df` Xj~mxpefi \u|pjg

D@A Dzpmgdpel @exjlpemf Aef`jxD@\'H Dzpmgdpel @j~jf`jfp \zxqjeccdflj'Hxmd`ld|pD@\'L Dzpmgdpel @j~jf`jfp \zxqjeccdflj'LmffjlpemfDAPF Djxmfdzpeldc Aerj` Pjcjlmggzfeldpemf Fjpymxo "DAPF%DML Dexcefj M~jxdpemf \u|pjgD^ Dzpm ^ecmpDP\Z Dex Pxdaael \jxqelj| ZfepDXEFL Djxmfdzpeldc Xd`em EFL&D\D\ Dexhmxfj \j~dxdpemf D||zxdflj \u|pjgDPL Dex pxdaael lmfpxmcDPF Djxmfdzpeldc Pjcjlmggzfeldpemf FjpymxoLDD Leqec Dqedpemf DzpbmxepuLMG\JL Lmggzfeldpemf| \jlzxepuLGZ Lmggzfeldpemf| Gdfdijgjfp Zfep

L^@CL Lmfpxmccjx ^ecmp @dpd Cefo Lmggzfeldpemf|@L\ @j~dxpzxj lmfpxmc \u|pjg@GJ @e|pdflj Gjd|zxefi Jtze~gjfpJD\D Jzxm~jdf Dqedpemf \dajpu DijfluJL Jzxm~jdf Lmgge||emfJZ Jzxm~jdf ZfemfJG\JL Jge||emf |jlzxepuADD Aj`jxdc Dqedpemf D`gefe|pxdpemfADF\ Azpzxj Dex Fdqeidpemf \u|pjgAG\ Aceibp Gdfdijgjfp \u|pjgAEX Aceibp Efamxgdpemf XjiemfA^9 \jqjfpb Axdgjymxo xmixdggjIHD\ Ixmzf` Hd|j` Dzigjfpdpemf \u|pjg|IEIF Ixmz~j `Efpjxqjfpemf `j cd Ijf`dxgjxej Fdpemfdcj

I^\ Icmhdc ^m|epemfefi \u|pjgI\G Icmhdc \u|pjg amx Gmhecj lmggzfeldpemf|BA Beib AxjtzjfluBH\ Bmc` Hdiidij \jlzxepuEDPD Efpjxfdpemfdc Dex Pxdf|~mxp D||mledpemfELDM Efpjxfdpemfdc Leqec Dqedpemf Mxidfe{dpemfEJJJ Ef|pepzpj ma Jcjlpxeldc df` Jcjlpxmfel| JfiefjjxEF\ Efjxpedc Fdqeidpemf \u|pjgK@DG Kmefp @exjlp Dppdlo Gzfepemf|EC\ Ef|pxzgjfp Cdf`efi \u|pjgEPZ Efpjxfdpemfdc Pjcjlmggzfeldpemf ZfemfCQM Cmy Qe|ehecepu M~jxdpemf|CDF Cmldc Dxjd FjpymxoFDPM Fmxpb Dpcdfpel Pxjdpu Mxidfe{dpemf

FDP\ Fdpemfdc Dex Pxdaael \jxqelj|TO@ Tzdfpzg Oju @e|pxehzpemfF@H Fmf'@exjlpemfdc HjdlmfXAE@ Xd`em'Axjtzjflu E`jfpeaeldpemfX^I Xmlojp ^myjxj` Ixjfd`jXPLD Xd`em Pjlbfeldc Lmgge||emf amx Djxmfdzpel|XQ\G Xj`zlj` Qjxpeldc \j~dxdpemf GefegzgXD Xj|mczpemf D`qe|mxu\JCLDC \JCjlpeqj LDCcefi\EPD \mlep Efpjxfdpemfdcj `j Pclmggzfeldpemf| Dxmfdzpetzj|

8/14/2019 Future Security in Aeronautics Communications

20/21

8>>5->4->2 ^dij 8>

\J\DX \eficj Jzxm~jdf \ou DPG Xj|jdxlb\\X \jlmf`dxu \zxqjeccdflj Xd`dx\\C \jlzxj \mlojp| Cdujx\PDFDI \pdf`dx`e|dpemf Dixjjgjfp|PD Pxdaael D`qe|mxuPLD\ Pxdaael dcjxp df` Lmcce|emf Dqme`dflj \u|pjgPC\ Pxdf|~mxp Cdujx \jlzxepuPXDF\JL Pxdf|ge||emf |jlzxepuZDP Zfeqjx|dc Dllj|| Pxdf|geppjxQC@ Qjxu beib axjtzjflu @dpd CefoQBA Qjxu Beib AxjtzjfluQCK Qjxu Ceibp KjpQMX Qjxu beib axjtzjflu Mgfe XdfijQ^F Qexpzdc ^xeqdpj FjpymxoYDD\ Ye`j Dxjd Dzigjfpdpemf \u|pjg

8/14/2019 Future Security in Aeronautics Communications

21/21

8>>5->4->2 ^dij 84

4> Dffjrj|

Aei& 4& Fzghjx| amx pjxxmxe|g ef leqec dqedpemf