From: stiver-aloha@hawaii.rr.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/03/2013 04:47 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive expansion sprawling the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive to Native Hawaiian culture.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Sincerely,

Robert H Stiver stiver-aloha@hawaii.rr.com

From: guides@coastalkayaktours.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/03/2013 06:37 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive expansion sprawling the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive to Native Hawaiian culture.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

We dont need this kind of development on the North Shore... The infastrucutr of the norht shore can not handle this load or burden.. The traffic is all ready way out of control and something need to be done about that beofre ay expansion plans.. i say no to the proposed turtle bay expansion plan

Sincerely,

David Elgas guides@coastalkayaktours.com

From: deetex123@aol.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/08/2013 10:13 AM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

The LUC should be stewards of the land and uphold Hawaiian culture and values. The people of Hawaii need food and sustainability, not another hotel. A pristine coastline should be preserved at all costs. Mahalo for protecting the aina and doing the right thing.

Sincerely,

Diane Texidor deetex123@aol.com we

From: deetex123@aol.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/08/2013 10:14 AM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

The LUC should be stewards of the land and uphold Hawaiian culture and values. The people of Hawaii need food and sustainability, not another hotel. A pristine coastline should be preserved at all costs. Mahalo for protecting the aina and doing the right thing.

Sincerely,

Diane Texidor deetex123@aol.com we

From: saralbutcher@Gmail.commTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/03/2013 06:40 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive expansion sprawling the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive to Native Hawaiian culture.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

my family frequently visits Oahu from our home in Portland oregon. the reason the north shore is so beautiful is because it is not filled with resorts like other parts of the island. turtle bay is big enough as it is and should not be expanded any further. if they want to attract more tourist money they should work on improving the quality of their current site while protecting the small towns and coastline on the north shore.

Sincerely,

sara butcher saralbutcher@Gmail.comm

From: bryanhelfand@sbcglobal.netTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/03/2013 06:50 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive expansion sprawling the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive to Native Hawaiian culture.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

KEEP THE COUNTRY COUNTRY!!!

Sincerely,

Bryan Helfand bryanhelfand@sbcglobal.net

From: Jlo@hfdclaw.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/03/2013 06:50 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive expansion sprawling the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive to Native Hawaiian culture.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Sincerely,

James LÅ Jlo@hfdclaw.com

From: keneke007@hawaiiantel.netTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/03/2013 06:51 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive expansion sprawling the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive to Native Hawaiian culture.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Please do not develop on what is left of our paradise island for this is the last of the open beaches that is very important to us! As a ohana of islanders, we have enjoyed these same beaches for generations and wish to save them for the future generations yet to come. If we let this poorly planned development go on, then we have lost another part of our island paradise heritage and the right to be a good caretaker of this land that was always meant to be free and open to us all and not to just a few individuals for exploitation and profit!

Sincerely,

Kenneth Matsumoto keneke007@hawaiiantel.net

From: Joanrp@cox.netTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/03/2013 06:54 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive expansion sprawling the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive to Native Hawaiian culture.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Sincerely,

Joan Price Joanrp@cox.net

From: joshua_thirnsbury@ylahoo.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/03/2013 06:57 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive expansion sprawling the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive to Native Hawaiian culture.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Keep the country

Country!

Sincerely,

Rani Thornsbury joshua_thirnsbury@ylahoo.com

From: stevefriedman1@mac.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/03/2013 06:59 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive expansion sprawling the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive to Native Hawaiian culture.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Please return the land to it's agricultural classification. Much better to grow food then to overdevelop.

Mahalo ,

Steve Friedman

Sincerely,

Steve Friedman stevefriedman1@mac.com

From: Emily@360bebe.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/03/2013 07:01 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive expansion sprawling the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive to Native Hawaiian culture.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Sincerely,

Emily Funderburg Emily@360bebe.com

From: leigh@livepath.netTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/03/2013 07:04 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive expansion sprawling the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive to Native Hawaiian culture.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

I fully agree with this. Don't slip this stuff by the locals or the tourists. We cannot regain what we lose with over commercialization.

Sincerely,

Leigh Durst leigh@livepath.net

From: Kwesterberg@cox.netTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/03/2013 04:52 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive expansion sprawling the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive to Native Hawaiian culture.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Sincerely,

Kelly Westerberg Kwesterberg@cox.net

From: charyan@hawaii.rr.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/03/2013 07:19 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive expansion sprawling the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive to Native Hawaiian culture.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Sincerely,

Charlotte Yamane charyan@hawaii.rr.com

From: mikenancymcgovern@comcast.netTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/03/2013 07:38 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive expansion sprawling the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive to Native Hawaiian culture.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

We come to the North Shore because it is true Hawaii and that will be taken away if the expansion goes forward. Visitors will not support it with traffic congestion alone -no one will tolerate that and it will make it unattractive and guests will stay away. Mahalo

Sincerely,

Mike McGovern mikenancymcgovern@comcast.net

From: john.from.stl@alumni.stanford.eduTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/03/2013 07:58 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive expansion sprawling the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive to Native Hawaiian culture.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Sincerely,

John Maurer john.from.stl@alumni.stanford.edu

From: greenclean808@hawaii.rr.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/03/2013 08:09 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive expansion sprawling the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive to Native Hawaiian culture.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Sincerely,

Lisa Young greenclean808@hawaii.rr.com

From: Kristalc@verizon.netTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/03/2013 08:17 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive expansion sprawling the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive to Native Hawaiian culture.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Sincerely,

Krista Capo Kristalc@verizon.net

From: manawanui@mac.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/03/2013 08:25 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive expansion sprawling the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive to Native Hawaiian culture.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

NO. To further develop this area is an affront to the spirit and culture of Aloha. NO. Don't do this.

Sincerely,

Namah Grace manawanui@mac.com

From: Lindaextra@live.seTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/03/2013 08:34 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive expansion sprawling the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive to Native Hawaiian culture.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Sincerely,

Linda A Lindaextra@live.se

From: makani01@gmx.atTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/03/2013 09:03 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive expansion sprawling the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive to Native Hawaiian culture.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Sincerely,

Marion Nowak Nowak makani01@gmx.at

From: haleluana@hawaii.rr.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/03/2013 09:12 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive expansion sprawling the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive to Native Hawaiian culture.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Further expansion of Turtle Bay would be devastating to the North Shore. Aside from the environmental issues, there is quality of life for those of us who reside here, Over the past 20 years we have seen what had been 'weekend traffic' become daily traffic, worse each year. This is a small island; we have one Waikiki and do not need or want anything similar on the North Shore. Mainland investors have one goal -profit. Their expected earnings cannot be allowed to be more important than the quality of of our lives, the protection of our natural land.

Sincerely,

Louise Simrell haleluana@hawaii.rr.com

From: spencersuitt@mac.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/03/2013 09:17 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive expansion sprawling the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive to Native Hawaiian culture.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

I'll start with one word... Infrastructure. In which case the North Shore currently has "the lack of" to handle it's current population and visitors. The traffic year round has gotten so bad in the past 5 years and things will only get worse even if there is none of your buildings erected. The building plans from what I've seen you guys are proposing is crazy! Right now the turtle bay hotel and it's surroundings are like a retreat hidden in the middle of the country.

It would be a shame to ruin the natural environment. The run off, pollution, sewer, construction, foot and car traffic will ruin the beaches and wildlife. As of now people have the opportunity to enjoy untouched land and beaches but also experience a world class hotel that has been there for years. I'm all for growth... but very little at a time. The North Shore is in no means ready for the growth you guys want to do.

I'm sure if any of you guys live in the area you personally know so many things need to be down before a single additional hotel room, building or road gets made. Not to mention, the housing or buildings not associated with you along the North Shore.

And wouldn't it be better for you to keep as the size you are now and have the high occupancy rate?

PLEASE NO!

PS: on 12/29/12... the traffic was backed up for 3.5 miles and took me 1 hour to go from the bypass in Haleiwa to Pupukea. This is a common theme and the summers can be worse.

Sincerely,

Spencer Suitt spencersuitt@mac.com

From: GAHatter@Hawaii.rr.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/03/2013 05:00 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive expansion sprawling the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive to Native Hawaiian culture.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Statements 2 & 3 to the Resort Developers are my major interest. At the present time, the traffic system is a mess including no sanitation facilities for tourists at major stopping points, lack of pedestrian control crossing

the highway, and traffic stops that affect commercial schedules for the entire island.

Sincerely,

Gilbert Hatter GAHatter@Hawaii.rr.com

From: Matt.hopgood@blueyonder.co.ukTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/03/2013 09:26 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive expansion sprawling the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive to Native Hawaiian culture.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Sincerely,

Matthew Hopgood Matt.hopgood@blueyonder.co.uk

From: lynne@hawaii.rr.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/03/2013 09:51 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive expansion sprawling the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive to Native Hawaiian culture.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

We must not sacrifice the few remaining jewels of our precious 'aina. Our children and grandchildren deserve to have us act as responsible stewards, or when they are adults, there will be nothing left except urban sprawl.

Sincerely,

Lynne Wooddell lynne@hawaii.rr.com

From: Harald@dolcevita.netTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/03/2013 10:04 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive expansion sprawling the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive to Native Hawaiian culture.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Sincerely,

Harald-m. Lehnardt Harald@dolcevita.net

From: clearwater@hawaii.rr.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/03/2013 10:10 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive expansion sprawling the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive to Native Hawaiian culture.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Sincerely,

Scott Werny clearwater@hawaii.rr.com

From: andinor@hawaiiantel.netTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/03/2013 10:17 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive expansion sprawling the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive to Native Hawaiian culture.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

KEEP THE COUNTRY COUNTRY. There is already too much development in the NORTH SHORE AND TOO MUCH TRAFFIC on the weekend and during events and high surf.

Sincerely,

Richard Andino andinor@hawaiiantel.net

From: cnavascues1@mixmail.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/04/2013 02:33 AM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive expansion sprawling the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive to Native Hawaiian culture.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Sincerely,

cesar navascues cnavascues1@mixmail.com

From: Wraymsw@cavtel.netTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/04/2013 03:30 AM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive expansion sprawling the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive to Native Hawaiian culture.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Preserve the North Shore as it is. It's a magical place that I love to visit each time I visit Hawaii. Future expansion of Turtle Bay will destroy the beauty and aesthetics of the North Shore.

Sincerely,

Shawn Wray Wraymsw@cavtel.net

From: dee3@cornell.eduTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/04/2013 05:25 AM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive expansion sprawling the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive to Native Hawaiian culture.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

NO MORE DEVELOPMENT AT TURTLE BAY!!!!!!

Sincerely,

Diane English dee3@cornell.edu

From: keithwallach@hawaiiantel.netTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/04/2013 05:46 AM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive expansion sprawling the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive to Native Hawaiian culture.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Sincerely,

keith wallach keithwallach@hawaiiantel.net

From: wade@koniakowsky.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/04/2013 06:10 AM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive expansion sprawling the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive to Native Hawaiian culture.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Sincerely,

Wade Koniakowsky wade@koniakowsky.com

From: norrie@hawaiiantel.netTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/03/2013 05:17 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive expansion sprawling the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive to Native Hawaiian culture.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Sincerely,

Norrie Thompson norrie@hawaiiantel.net

From: pmmaciolek@comcast.netTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/04/2013 06:14 AM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive expansion sprawling the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive to Native Hawaiian culture.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Please work in good faith with the community. Turtle Bay Resort should return to its original agricultrual classification. Please don't turn Turtle Bay in to another Waikiki :(

Sincerely,

Michelle Mitchell pmmaciolek@comcast.net

From: paumalu1@hawaiiantel.netTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/04/2013 06:45 AM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive expansion sprawling the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive to Native Hawaiian culture.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

No Turtle Bay expansion. Period.

Sincerely,

Richard St. Onge paumalu1@hawaiiantel.net

From: Michele@gvtc.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/04/2013 07:50 AM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive expansion sprawling the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive to Native Hawaiian culture.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Sincerely,

Leslie Shurbet Michele@gvtc.com

From: jbowers@telus.netTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/04/2013 08:14 AM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

I'm from Victoria, BC, Canada and have been going to Oahu annually for over 30 years. I love Waikiki and Honolulu for what they are. I love the North Shore for what it is - please don't change it.

Sincerely,

J Bowers jbowers@telus.net

From: jmcudworth@.yahoo.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/04/2013 08:22 AM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Sincerely,

jolene justis jmcudworth@.yahoo.com

From: flamingo1013@mac.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/04/2013 10:10 AM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

This project, as currently outlined, would be a disaster for the North Shore. I have been visiting for over 15 years and stay up on the NS because it is rural, and country. I avoid the congestion, like Waikiki. I think that the traffic would be worse than it is now. Please reconsider as outlined in the petition above. We need more time to work with Turtle Bay.

Sincerely,

Lisa Siradas flamingo1013@mac.com

From: douhdeal@hawaii.rr.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/04/2013 10:18 AM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Aloha, saw the plans and i have never saw something so crazy, we need a new Honolulu, like a hole in our head!!!!!!!!!!

Sincerely,

Doug Deal douhdeal@hawaii.rr.com

From: douhdeal@hawaii.rr.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/04/2013 10:18 AM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Aloha, saw the plans and i have never saw something so crazy, we need a new Honolulu, like a hole in our head!!!!!!!!!!

Sincerely,

Doug Deal douhdeal@hawaii.rr.com

From: kelly_bike5@comcast.netTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/04/2013 10:38 AM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

I am a concerned permanent resident of Oahu. I live in Honolulu.

Sincerely,

Kelly Donahue kelly_bike5@comcast.net

From: angelakv@hawaii.rr.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/04/2013 10:42 AM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

North Shore cannot support development of this massive proportion. North shore is already crowded and traffic conjested enough. We do not need more development for profit. We need this land for agriculuture, what it was originally classified as. The negative cummulative impacts of theis project are too great and outweight the bnefits. Although this supplemental EIS is a reduction in size of the development, that is not good enough reasoning to allow this project to continue. Just becasue it is leess expansion than originally planned doesnt meean there should be expansion at all, and doesnt make it right. I belive the proposed expansion and arguments for development are invalid and incorrect reasoning. Please think about the irreversible and tremendous damage this expansion will cause the north shore community. Keep the country country please!!!

Sincerely,

Angela Kieran-Vast angelakv@hawaii.rr.com

From: pburke@lmi.orgTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/03/2013 06:08 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive expansion sprawling the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive to Native Hawaiian culture.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Preserve the North Shore!

Sincerely,

Patrick Burke pburke@lmi.org

From: Jennifer.price@Colorado.eduTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/04/2013 10:54 AM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Leave turtle bay the way it is, it's already PERFECT!

Sincerely,

Jennifer Howland Jennifer.price@Colorado.edu

From: Kimo-cherie@hawaiii.rr.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/04/2013 11:07 AM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Sincerely,

Moncrief james Kimo-cherie@hawaiii.rr.com

From: tvast@hawaii.rr.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/04/2013 11:30 AM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Sincerely,

Teresa Vast tvast@hawaii.rr.com

From: jonatha@hawaii.eduTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/04/2013 12:10 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Sincerely,

Jonatha Giddens jonatha@hawaii.edu

From: joyofpilates@mac.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/04/2013 12:30 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Visitors come to this part of Oahu to enjoy the natural beauty and get away. If they wanted to go to a big resort they would go to the west side or Waikiki. Locals live on this part of the island for it's more rural lifestyle. The area has already grown so much and will not support any of the proposed growth plans. The traffic is only one of the concerns. The plant and animal species, especially those that are endangered, that will be adversely impacted are also a major concern.

Sincerely,

Joy Silver joyofpilates@mac.com

From: imw@byuh.eduTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/04/2013 12:34 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Stop prostituting the Aina

Sincerely,

Isaiah Walker imw@byuh.edu

From: pearlj@hawaii.rr.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/04/2013 04:34 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Sincerely,

Pearl Johnson pearlj@hawaii.rr.com

From: Holmbergr002@hawaii.rr.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/04/2013 05:10 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Sincerely,

Ruth Holmberg Holmbergr002@hawaii.rr.com

From: russophotography@mac.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/04/2013 07:46 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Please don't build more hotels or houses on the North Shore. It takes me 25-35 minutes to drive from Pupukea to Haleiwa mid day every day due to the already busy traffic. I have grown up on the North Shore my whole life and it makes me so sad of the idea that more hotels are wanting to be built. What we residents need is the stated to divert traffic in front of "turtle" beach or known as Lani a kea beach.

Sincerely,

daniel russo russophotography@mac.com

From: marilynmick@pobox.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/05/2013 08:03 AM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Sincerely,

Marilyn Mick marilynmick@pobox.com

From: rebeccapike@mac.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/03/2013 06:09 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive expansion sprawling the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive to Native Hawaiian culture.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

This is a head-to-toe terrible idea. TERRIBLE IDEA.

Sincerely,

Rebecca Pike rebeccapike@mac.com

From: Winks-Mom@hawaii.rr.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/05/2013 08:22 AM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Stop the building at Turtle Bay...enough is enough!

Sincerely,

Harrilyn Belluche Winks-Mom@hawaii.rr.com

From: rpruc@cox.netTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/05/2013 10:04 AM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

PLEASE. The people on the State of Hawaii Land Use Commision, do not allow this beautiful piece of earth to disappear under concrete and steel. You have a chance to save a piece of this earth that can not be replaced. Let the tourist enjoy the rest of the island. Do the right thing. Keep this land for all, do not let a few get rich off of destroying what God created. PLEASE!

Sincerely,

Robert Pruczinski rpruc@cox.net

From: val@greenroomhawaii.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/05/2013 04:27 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Please Let Us Keep the Very Little Country We Have Left. Please...

Sincerely,

Valerie Wang val@greenroomhawaii.com

From: rfripp@aloha.netTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/05/2013 06:50 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Sincerely,

Robert Ripp rfripp@aloha.net

From: apices42323@mypacks.netTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/05/2013 09:16 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

HECK *** NO *** TO HOTEL SPRAWL!!!!! HECK **** NO **** TO **** ALL AND ANY **** DEVELOPMENTS AT TURTLE BAY!!!!

**** GO WHERE YOU CAME FROM AND MESS UP THE LAND THERE!!!! YOU IDIOTS!!!! **** Do you have any brains???? If this land gets so overdeveloped, who will pay to come there to enjoy "Hawaii" when there is no Hawaii left?????

Sincerely,

milica bar apices42323@mypacks.net

From: richslus@verizon.netTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/06/2013 02:12 AM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Sincerely,

Rich Slusser richslus@verizon.net

From: flygirly95@hawaii.rr.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/06/2013 03:39 AM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

The north shore NEEDS to remain just the way it is today. Further development for profit will spoil it's natural beauty, endanger the natural living environment for wildlife and cause vehicular traffic to be even worse than it stands today.

Sincerely,

Melody Fritz flygirly95@hawaii.rr.com

From: meister@hawaiiantel.netTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/06/2013 06:21 AM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Please keep this "country" . It is valuable to all people of Hawaii, Oahu and to our visitors as it is!

Sincerely,

Susan Meister meister@hawaiiantel.net

From: Mmattso2@lion.lmu.eduTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/06/2013 08:12 AM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Sincerely,

Marina Mattson Mmattso2@lion.lmu.edu

From: ellarn@hawaii.rr.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/06/2013 08:53 AM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

We do not have the roads, water resources, etc. to accommodate additional hotel growth. We also have endangered species that give birth on the shores of the proposed expansion sites. We are making it harder for paradise to be paradise by expanding the hotel. Keep the agriculture and our fruit stands for the locals to get supplies without going to town.

Sincerely,

Ella Siroskesy ellarn@hawaii.rr.com

From: Fishander2@cox.netTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/03/2013 06:15 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive expansion sprawling the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive to Native Hawaiian culture.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Sincerely,

Frances Anderson Fishander2@cox.net

From: mercedes@beyondthenextstep.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/06/2013 09:21 AM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Sincerely,

Mercedes Maidana mercedes@beyondthenextstep.com

From: surfwood@rr.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/06/2013 09:22 AM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

This is Money and greed,not surfers wanting all this building.

Sincerely,

atwood trapnell surfwood@rr.com

From: mschick@chilitech.netTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/06/2013 10:21 AM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

I have had the privilege of visiting the North Shore since the early 1980's and have seen the country change dramatically. Most of those changes not good, the North Shore is a special place and should be protected from over developement, there has been to much already.

Sincerely,

mike schick mschick@chilitech.net

From: nsz@hawaii.rr.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/06/2013 11:04 AM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Sincerely,

Tish S. nsz@hawaii.rr.com

From: djskey@hawaii.rr.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/06/2013 01:11 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Sincerely,

Dave Siroskey djskey@hawaii.rr.com

From: judyknuts@hawaii.rr.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/06/2013 08:19 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Please, Please keep the country country. Please do what is right and good do not exploit ALL of Oahu. Keep the North Shore the country part of Oahu. Please do not ruin it and make it another Waikiki. Tourists want to see and have a area that is not over run with hotels

Sincerely,

Judy Knutson judyknuts@hawaii.rr.com

From: markwalsh@sevenwentworth.com.auTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/06/2013 08:48 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Submission 6 January 2013 Re: Turtle Bay Resorts Proposed Development and the Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS)

A. Overview

1. The SEIS identifies matters said to be relevant to an application to make major changes to the intensity of usage of a culturally and environmentally significant area of northern Oahu (the subject land) by way of increased commercial and residential facilities (the proposed development). The subject land includes a four mile ocean frontage either side of Turtle Bay which is largely of pristine beauty and a habitat for numerous species of marine and terrestrial wildlife.

2. The scale of the proposed development to the subject land is large. It includes two new hotels with proposed accommodation of 600 rooms (the hotels development). This is in addition to the existing hotel of to the 500 units, plus 368 condominium units, which will continue to operate on the subject land. The proposed development also includes 750 new units of residential accommodation with the proposed construction of 590 new resort homes of heights up to either 50, or alternatively, 60 feet; plus 160 community housing units (the resort home and housing development).

3. The SEIS and related material is a substantial document containing a detailed analysis of the impact of the proposed development, including by environmental and other experts. The writer recognises and respects the great amount of time and effort which has gone into the preparation of the SEIS by the developer and others.

4. This submission suggest further consideration of matters regarding the proposed development under the following headings:

a. Relevant considerations for approval of proposed development & the SEIS

i. Impact of development on the subject land

ii. Impact of development beyond the subject land

b. The Precautionary Principle and the burden upon the proponent for change

c. The Law of Aloha

B. Relevant considerations for approval of proposed development & the SEIS

5. It is beyond dispute that Oahu (and the other islands comprising the State of Hawai‘i)

has a unique natural beauty plus a distinctive cultural heritage. An unusual feature of Oahu is the contrast between the urbanized south side, or Town, e.g. Honolulu/ Pearl Harbour region, as opposed to the rugged natural beauty of the North Shore, or Country, e.g. Kaena Point/ Kahuku region.

6. The natural beauty of the undeveloped Country remains a source of pleasure for both Hawaiians and overseas visitors as opposed to the attractions of Town. One of the special features of the Country is its marine wildlife such as turtles, seals and whales plus its ocean based sporting activities which pay homage to Native Hawaiian customs. The aesthetic and cultural value arising from the natural beauty of the Country has global appeal and also proven economic value to the island.

7. The SEIS frequently refers to the scale of a previous proposed development and the associated 1985 Kuilima EIS (1985 EIS), by way of support for a purported reduction in scale of usage change for the subject land.

8. Reference to the 1985 EIS distracts from taking into account relevant considerations to the change of the use of the subject land in 2013, by advancing a seemingly irrelevant consideration of what was not done in the 1980’s. There is no evidence that that larger 1985 development was appropriate or not flawed from a planning perspective for the subject land. Furthermore, over the last 28 years much has been learnt and embraced as to the need for the local and global conservation of the environment.

9. In any event the developer acknowledges the decision by the Hawai‘i State Supreme Court that the 1985 EIS was no longer valid. Furthermore it is reasonable to suspect that a cause of the inability to implement the development the subject of the 1985 EIS was that the larger development was assessed by the market to be not sustainable.

10. A more effective assessment of the SEIS requires comparison of the proposed change to the actual usage in 2013 of the subject land at Turtle Bay, and not comparison to the change which was proposed by the 1985 EIS and development.

Impact of development on the subject land

11. An effective environmental impact statement (EIS) must give adequate and proper consideration to the foreseeable impact of any development upon the subject land. This will usually involve key factors such as sustainability, land use, resource access, and impact upon the existing/future community.

12. Sustainability issues in the SEIS are considered at a high level of abstraction and by aspiration. Detail would assist. Consideration of the likely carbon footprint, audit and conservation measures including capture or offsets are also now appropriate.

13. The SEIS advances the use of part of the subject lands as agricultural lands to preserve traditional use, heritage and open space. Yet a potential change of usage is foreshadowed in regard to agricultural lands being converted to alternative energy generation which appears to negate such aims.

14. It is unclear whether the proposed public access to the ocean front mooted in the SEIS will be by dedicated public land and thus permanent, or rather at the discretion of the developer or its assigns or successors. This is a matter of significant community importance to ensure future equitable enjoyment of the ocean by all on the island.

Impact of development beyond the subject land

15. Further factors which properly ought to be included in an EIS will be the foreseeable impact of the proposed development beyond the subject land, including upon members of the existing/ future community. The inclusion of proposed mitigation measures for such impacts will allow an approving authority to take into account relevant considerations to reach its decision on a development application.

16. Also identification by specification of the likely size and accommodation/occupancy levels of the 590 homes which will be up to 50 or 60 feet in height, necessarily of a potentially large size, would allow a better assessment of the impact of the proposed development.

17. The traffic impact analysis advanced by the developer recognises the likely existence of traffic congestion in 2025 in any event. Necessarily the proposed development will exacerbate such congestion.

18. Consideration of the likely long term detriment to traffic movement on the Kam Highway arising from increased traffic due to the proposed development of the subject land in the context of other potential development in the region would assist. Thus the traffic analysis fails to consider proposed increases to vehicle use in the area from each of the currently proposed Envision La‘ie or the Haleiwa Hotel developments.

19. Furthermore, the adoption of an assumption of straight line growth pattern for traffic studies fails to recognise the potential for non-linear effects on journey time for a finite road system arising from an increased number of vehicle movements.

20. Additionally, the basis for assumptions and the reasoning process for the traffic impact analysis for the future are unclear, other than by reference to computer modelling. No ORTP analysis was provided for current weekend traffic as that was not available.

21. Other infrastructure likely to suffer overload from the proposed 650 new homes will include medical facilities, such as Kahuku Hospital, schooling and retail facilities such as food outlets.

22. Any consequent loss of amenity to the enjoyment of the North Shore for both residents and visitors due to the change to the intensiveness of use of the subject land arising from the proposed development including from traffic congestion and infrastructure demands generally may well sound in both unmeasurable loss of amenity and quantifiable economic loss.

C. The Precautionary Principle and the burden upon the proponent for change

23. The precautionary principle is a concept founded upon a common sense approach to decision making regarding unreplaceable resources, such as for the environment. It finds expression in the saying "First do no harm." It carries the sense of foresight and preparation—not merely “caution.†An ethical assumption behind the precautionary principle regarding the environment is that humans are responsible to protect, preserve, and restore the global ecosystems on which all

life, including our own, depends.

24. In applying the precautionary principle to the SEIS for the subject land a reasonable decision maker needs to be satisfied by the developer who is advancing the proposed development that there is a sound and sustainable basis for the change from the status quo to an area which has unique natural and cultural value to the people of Hawaii and the world.

25. Furthermore, given the unique nature of the subject land, and the potential impact upon both the local and broader community, a decision-maker needs to have a comfortable level of persuasion before approving change such as that advanced by the proposed development.

D. The Law of Aloha

26. The Hawaiʻi Revised Statutes includes § 5-7.5 "Aloha Spirit". That law emphasises the essence of relationships in which each person is important to every other person for collective existence. The Aloha Spirit also reinforces the uniqueness of Hawaiʻi.

27. The principles explained by § 5-7.5 "Aloha Spirit" appear to be a relevant consideration to the determination of the application for the proposed development based on the SEIS.

28. HRS § 5-7.5 "Aloha Spirit" also may provide guidance to a decision-maker to determine an outcome for the application which serves the greatest number for their greatest good, mindful of principles of sustainability to strike a balance between economic, social, community, and environmental priorities and to meet the needs of the present without compromising the ability of future generations to meet their own needs.

Mark Walsh

6 January 2013

email: markwalsh@sevenwentworth.com.au

Sincerely,

Mark Walsh markwalsh@sevenwentworth.com.au

From: jmd@hawaii.eduTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/06/2013 10:06 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Please Keep the North Shore country! It's all we have left on Oahu.

Sincerely,

Jenny Davidson jmd@hawaii.edu

From: Bdubs1@hawaiiantel.netTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/07/2013 07:52 AM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Sincerely,

Monica Williams Bdubs1@hawaiiantel.net

From: Mail@candicegarrison.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/07/2013 08:58 AM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Too much development will make north shore like town. I will move if this happens.

Sincerely,

Candice Garrison Mail@candicegarrison.com

From: K.robertson@mac.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/03/2013 06:16 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive expansion sprawling the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive to Native Hawaiian culture.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Sincerely,

Kristin Schippert K.robertson@mac.com

From: SURFJAM@HAWAII.RR.COMTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/07/2013 03:06 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

xpansion plan is too much for this community,it is not good for those who live here.only a few will profit from this development but many would suffer due to overcrowding.

Sincerely,

pat kelly SURFJAM@HAWAII.RR.COM

From: taylorvaillancourt@comcast.netTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/07/2013 03:41 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

enough already! I stay in this area annually and it is one of the most unique spots left in the world, why with the way the rest of this island is already so overdevolped would you people even think of more devolpment here, go ahead and build it up and ruin it for future generations forever, turtle bay tucks into its spot just fine the way it is. look past your wallets for once owners, build were the roads and infastructure can handle it

Sincerely,

taylor vaillancourt taylorvaillancourt@comcast.net

From: jbowens@hawaii.eduTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/07/2013 03:48 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

This is one of the last open coastal spaces, there is a lot of native rare coastal plants here. It is also excellent seabird, monk seal, and turtle habitat, most of oahu's coast is currently distrubed, this is one of the very few places left. Please do not approve sprawling expansion into this important land. Mahalo.

Sincerely,

Jesse Owens jbowens@hawaii.edu

From: Maceyj001@hawaii.rr.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/07/2013 08:50 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Impeach Governor Abercrombie! No more hotels!

Sincerely,

James Macey Maceyj001@hawaii.rr.com

From: adammv@hawaii.eduTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/07/2013 08:51 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

To whom it may concern,

I would like you to consider the pristine agriculture and landscape amongst the North Shore of Oahu to postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study of the Ko'olauloa region can be conducted. I am already sick of driving in Honolulu town traffic and would be afraid the North Shore will become a second Honolulu. North Shore is one of Oahu's only remaining rural lands, lets keep it that way.

Aloha

Sincerely,

Adam Vergara adammv@hawaii.edu

From: Murata@lava.netTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/07/2013 08:55 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Sincerely,

Anne Murata Murata@lava.net

From: sabrinak@sonic.netTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/07/2013 09:19 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Hell no more hotels! No more sewage in the ocean!

Sincerely,

Sabrina Krauss sabrinak@sonic.net

From: ebritos@priory.netTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/07/2013 09:28 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Enough development already.

Sincerely,

Erin Britos ebritos@priory.net

From: ingrid@earthlysites.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/07/2013 09:30 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Sincerely,

ingrid martin ingrid@earthlysites.com

From: shizen@hawaiiantel.netTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/07/2013 09:42 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Sincerely,

Mitsuko Hayakawa shizen@hawaiiantel.net

From: jonwilkins808@mac.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/03/2013 06:28 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive expansion sprawling the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive to Native Hawaiian culture.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Stop the expansion. If they do build more, they'd better build "H-4"!

Sincerely,

Wilkins Jon jonwilkins808@mac.com

From: steve@stevesullam.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/07/2013 10:36 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Sincerely,

Steve Sullam steve@stevesullam.com

From: spauldingohana@hawaii.rr.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/07/2013 10:44 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Sincerely,

Victoria Spaulding spauldingohana@hawaii.rr.com

From: ev@kevcom.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/07/2013 10:56 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

The limit is already reached!

Sincerely,

Evan Tector ev@kevcom.com

From: cmpa@hawaiiantel.netTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/07/2013 11:08 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Sincerely,

Jeff Garland cmpa@hawaiiantel.net

From: revkyle@hawaii.rr.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/07/2013 11:11 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

I would hope that you all - and all parties - would work in good faith and in the interests of the many stakeholders on North Shore, and would work together. Please seriously consider revisiting the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group.

Sincerely,

Rev Kyle Lovett revkyle@hawaii.rr.com

From: alohasteph@mac.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/08/2013 03:47 AM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Sincerely,

stephanie frazier alohasteph@mac.com

From: cheryl.tibbs@udc.eduTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/08/2013 04:41 AM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Humans kill enough wildlife with are trash and now you want to change this beautiful ecosystem with more trash and over development.... shame on you!!! This saddens and disgusts me all at the same time. Take your filth somewhere else. You are only in it to make a buck. You dont care about the animals or this planet. This would be so disastrous to this ecosystem. We as humans kill everything we touch. This place should be preseved...

Sincerely,

Cheryl Tibbs cheryl.tibbs@udc.edu

From: BelindaB@HawaiiHomesForSale.orgTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/08/2013 05:06 AM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

No more Hotels Please!!!

Sincerely,

Belinda Barnes BelindaB@HawaiiHomesForSale.org

From: balika@hawaii.rr.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/08/2013 09:15 AM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

HELL NO!

Sincerely,

Alika Bee balika@hawaii.rr.com

From: wnagai001@hawaii.rr.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/08/2013 09:24 AM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive, sprawling expansion along the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

What the hell about you thinking (or not)??? Enough, already!!!

Sincerely,

Sanae Nagai wnagai001@hawaii.rr.com

From: lutfyr001@hawaii.rr.comTo: drew@replayresorts.com; leesichter@gmail.com; ccComments@honolulu.govCc: luc@dbedt.hawaii.govSubject: Comments on the Turtle Bay DSEIS.Date: 01/03/2013 04:30 PM

We the undersigned-

Respectfully ask ask the owners of Turtle Bay Resorts, Drew Stotesbury (Re:play Resorts/Turtle Bay Resort, LLC) and Lee Sichter (Lee Sichter, LLC) to:

• Remove any plans calling for massive expansion sprawling the entire coastline from Kawela Bay to Kahuku point from their Supplemental Environmental Impact Statement (SEIS).

• Seriously consider the preservation plan put forward by the Governor's Turtle Bay Advisory Working Group (TBAWG) and work in good faith with the community to adopt this plan.

• Consider the cumulative effects of all development being proposed in the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region in their SEIS.

• Cease using the Ahupua'a concept in a way that is offensive to Native Hawaiian culture.

Respectfully ask City and County of Honolulu Department of Permitting and Planning to:

• Postpone any acceptance of the Turtle Bay SEIS until a comprehensive regional traffic study for the North Shore/Ko'olauloa region can be conducted.

• Cease granting permits to a developer that is currently being challenged to show cause before the State Land Use Commission.

• Utilize their discretionary authority to carefully review this SEIS document and not grant approval until all community questions and concerns have been adequately addressed.

Respectfully ask the State of Hawaii Land Use Commission to:

• Hold its next hearing in the Ko'olauloa/North Shore region of O'ahu.

• Order developer Turtle Bay Resort, LLC to show cause.

• Return the 236 acres of Turtle Bay Resort property classified to Urban District in 1986 to its original Agricultural classification.

Stop the overdevelopement of the North Shore.

Keep agricultural land for farming, not building.

Sincerely,

Judith Lutfy lutfyr001@hawaii.rr.com