FREMONT, SUITE 2000 FAX ( 415) 904-5400 N FRANCISCO ......2001/03/05 · CALIFORNIA COASTAL COMMISSION • FREMONT, SUITE 2000 N FRANCISCO. CA 94105-2219 VOICE AND TDD (415) 904-5200

, . CALIFORNIA COASTAL COMMISSION

•

FREMONT, SUITE 2000 N FRANCISCO. CA 94105- 2219

VOICE AND TDD (415) 904- 5200 FAX ( 415) 904- 5400 W3a

•

•

RECORD PACKET COPY

TO: ALL COMMISSIONERS

FROM: PETER DOUGLAS, EXECUTIVE

SUBJECT: MINUTES OF MEETING OF MARCH 12-16,2001 Bahia Hotel 998 West Mission Bay Drive San Diego

Monday, Marchl2, 20()lpagesJ to.7~5J ".,,//'''" '"'''''''"//,,',.. ''/

1. CALL TO ORDER. The meeting ofth~CCalit§f~i<:J Coastal Commission was called to order on Monday, March 12, 2001, at 10 a.m. by Choirrnan .Wan.

2. ROLL CALL Present: Ch~irnJ.an Wan, CommissionersDean, Desser, Dettloff, Estolano, Hart McCoy,. (Alternate) Orr, NeaL (Alternate) Rose and Woolley. Absent: Kruer and Sanders. McClain-Hill arrived at 11 :20 a.m.; Sweeney arrived at 11 :40 a.m.; and (Alternate) Weinstein arrivedqt 2:45p.m.

YSOUTH COAST DISTillGT. ,:,;~g£

>3. OE~~TY DIRECTOR'S REPORT.. Deputy Director Lee reported on matters not requiriq~p~blic hearings,a8.d~h comments from the public. John Davis, representing Coalitiontg&gve the Marl(laSierra Club, submitted a request to speak. Sean Finnegan, representing s Group (Treasure Island), submitted a request to speak if necessary~.·······

a. Long Beac:JlPgrfPian Amendment No. 15 Certification Review. Staff recommended apr:>roval.

Robert Kanter, representing Port of Long Beach, submitted a request to answer questions.

... Motion & Vote: Woolley moved staff recommendation, seconded by Orr, and • Chairman Wan ruled that the vote was unanimous. Passed.

b. Request to file amendment number A-5-01-1 0-A (~:~~t-? Postponed. ,·,->;-::;

4. CONSENT CALENDAR (removed from RegHl~r. alendgr): .Stcl~·'f)l.Q... .three items {7d, 7e & 8b} to the Calendar, and recommendEiditt . LwithsR~~ .,i~QqitiQ

'~- -::,w;;·' -- --e

Motion & Vote: Estolano moved staff recommenda 1 nded by Orr)12&nai":

Chairman Wan ruled that the vote was unanimous.~k -?:.t.

5. LOCAL COASTAL PROGRAMS (LCPs).

a. Dana Point LCP Amendment N~. ~~OO(N~~:i~gnf~rming Signs) nme Extension. Staff recommended approval. ·····••·• '' ' ''. .;::::'1~:··. £2%:

--~------- ' :- "':~./0?'-:.f:"'- :<<4£: ·::~'

Motion & Vote: Woolley moved staffr~eb;mmenadh~~~·ise~1

~p§~d by Orr, and Chairman Wan ruled that the vote was unanimoUs. Passed~

::\::~:~T;i:_,:_--=:': ~::::·_-:~<--- -: · : ;-~,7~=t~-- >~: ::_-:>·~·;2·\:< .. ·:=:-:::=~;=:.:,:\"~-:.·: :·</

b. Long Beach Port Mast~.r .Plan AmendmenfNo~ 16. Staff recommended approval. ·:,

7 .;F· ..

Robert Kanter, rep;~s~h~ti~~;~prt of Long Beach, submitted a request to answer questions~ · ·· · ·

'-,;-' ';.~_;;

Motion & Vote: u:::nTI~TT moved sta'fffecqmrnendation, seconded by McCoy, and Chairman Wan vote wds unanimous. Passed.

NEW APPEALS.

:•a: Application No. (Marina Pacific, Los Angeles Co.} Staff re2omrnended that the .d"8o1eorraised substantial issue. There being no objection, Chalrrnan W · mmission found substantial issue. Chairman Wan opened the merits of the project. Staff recommended approval with special con in addendum and orally.

Alan Block, ting the applicant, submitted a request to speak in favor of

•

the project. John Davis, representing Coalition to Save the Marina/Sierra Club, spoke .• James Morris, representing Coalition to Save the Marina, spoke in opposition to the

MINUTES OF MARCH 12-16, 2001 PAGE2

,.

•

•

•

project. Barry Kurtz, representing County of Los Angeles Dept. of Public Works, submitted a request to speak. Three speakers representing L.A. County submitted requests to speak in favor of the project: Bob Fisher, Roger Moliere and Aaron Clark.

Motion & Vote: Desser moved staff recommendation, seconded by Estolano, and Chairman Wan ruled that the vote was unanimous. Passed.

McClain-Hill and Sweeney arrived during the following item. ·-; '' ,'

b. Appeal No. A-5-01-8 (City of L.A. Dept. of Parks & Rec.) Staff recommeJ1ded that the appeal raised substantial issue. There being no objection, Chairman Wan ruled that the Commission found substantial issue. Chairman Wan opened the hearing on the merits of the project. Staff recommended approval with special conditions.

Michael Bonin, representing Councilmember Ruth Galanter, spoke in favor of the project. Kathleen Chan, representing Rec. & Parks City of L.A., spoke in favor of the project. Jesse Martinez, representing Venice Skateboard Association, spoke in favor of the project. John Holtz spoke in favor of the project. Jimmy Hanson, representing Venice Skate Park, spoke in favor of the project. Scott Brown, representing Venice Skatepark, spoke in favor of the project. Heidi Lemmon, representing Venice SK8 PK, spoke in favor of the project. Tim Clark spoke in favor of the project. Dan Levy spoke in favor of the project. Geri Lewis, representing Venice Skateboard Association, spoke in favor of the project. Alex Romeno & Shoun Small, both representing Venice Skatepark, submitted requests to speak in favor of the project. John Davis, representing Coalition to Save the Marina Sierra Club, spoke.

Motion & Vote: McClain-Hill moved staff recommendation, seconded by Desser, and Chairman Wan ruled that the vote was unanimous. Passed.

7. COASTAL PERMIT APPLICATIONS.

a. Application No. 5-00-50 (Long Beach, permit parking) Staff recommended approval with special conditions.

Mark Sandoval, representing City of Long Beach, spoke in favor of the project. Doug Korthof spoke in opposition to the project.

Motion & Vote: Orr moved staff recommendation, seconded by Estolano, and Chairman Wan ruled that the vote was unanimous. Passed .

MINUTES OF MARCH 12-16,2001 PAGE3

b. Application No. 5-00-424 (Spriggs, San Clemente) Staff recommended approval with special conditions as modified in addendum deleting condition # 1 .

Michael Luna spoke representing the applicant.

Motion & Vote: Woolley moved staff recommendation, Chairman Wan ruled that the vote was unanimous. Pa

PUBLIC STATEMENTS. John Davis, representing requested enforcement actions against Los about the archaeological investigation of Hellm

LUNCH RECESS. The Commission recessed for lun l :35 p.m.

,, ---·:_"'',.-, ,<,'·>;,_"

, and

c. Application No. 5-00-449 (Via uao CgmrruJ6lty, ~~~port Staff recommended approval with specialcqriditionsqs me(~"""'· <:>rally.

-'><;,"'"' ''' ', :~:",'' '~;::

'

..

•

Three speakers, representing Lid c·:cor-prpunity As~oCiafiOn, submitted requests to speak in favor of the project: Hygh elm, d.i.tnSalomofrand Paul Wilkinson. Fifteen • speakers submitted requests .. to$g~ak in oppg~itionto.the project: George Bissell, Laurie Darnall, Bettina Laughlin Deininger, Philip deCespin8y,s~~ldon H. Dobkins, Paul Faranda, John M. Franco, Nancy Harris, Judithlongye~ar, Judy B. Rosener, Louise Shaver, Raymond 0. Vincenti; Elaine Weinberg, Martin B. Weinberg, and Paul Weinberg. ·····

Motion & Vote: McClain-Hill mdV~(j ~tdffrecommendation, seconded by Dettloff, and Chqirmah Wan ruled thotJhe votewa~prfg,rg1mous in opposition to the motion. Failed.

,- ---~ '' ''0''--'•

':\.~ y

\:

~~- -~li;:\~-:-j;,,-,,- ;:':>r••• ;~~;. n::z>

d. Application N~.~~ilo;. 6 (Steffensen, Seal Beach} Moved to expanded ... a~t-.n Calendar. Appr~: ' '~

e~ ... ~pplifalion No. Calendar: ApprQyed . . :/:

•467 (P.R.S., Dana Pt) Moved to expanded Consent


•

f. Application No. 5-00-484 (L.A. & Parks Dept. skating park) Staff • recommended approval with special conditions.

•

•

The hearing was combined with item 6b above.

Motion & Vote: McClain-Hill moved staff recommendation,. seconded by Desser, and Chairman Wan ruled that the vote was unanimous. Passed.

g. Application No. 5-00-407 (Leeds, Los Angeles) _____ __..;_ _ _..;..;~ ; ; .. ::;;;;::-/:

;,;;;:'_, ___ :::T; :;::·:·: _ _-;-;,-.;,_

h. Application No. 5-99-260 (Marble Head, San Cl~.rri~nt~l Staff recom~~n ed denial.

The presentation for the applicant included: Jim Johnson, David Kelley, Rod Meade, Claude Edwards, and Chris Webbrepres(7ntir;tg Moffatt & Nichol Engineers.

Speakers supporting the project incJuded: Ri~kt\riderson; Mark Bazick; Cary Brockman representing Capistrano Unifie(::J SchooiDist.; Bill .Ccmkli.Q; Steve Craig; Charlotte Crockett; Jim Dahl representiQg City Council ofSan.Ciemente; Dorothy Klaasen; Roy Proctor; Mayor Sco.tt Diehl of San Clemente; .t.lorence Magill; Lucy Ahams representing San Clemente Senior Center; Dr Marilyn L. Ditty representing South County Sr. Servs.; Wayne Egglerton representing City CouncilotSan Clemente; Lillian Le Cantore representing San Clemente Senior Center Grpup;tynn Wood representing San Clemente Chamber ofCommerce; Lewis Elia; peJia Frankel; Dorothy Fuller; Lynne M. Geyser; Adrienne Proctor; Marty Hoffman representing So. County Senior Svc; City Planner James B. Hare repre~enting £ity of San Clemente; Bruce Edwards; Mary Devereux; James C. Hill; Communityt)Eavelp Dir. Jim Holloway representing City of San Clemente; Sandy Condello representing San Clemente Womens Club; Carol Beasley; Peggytdcayo, Direc;torotSummefC()r)CertSeries; David Lund, Economic Devlpt & Pub Wks Director representing City of SbnCiemente; Frank H. White; Ruth Aldrich; Byron

.. M(lrshall; Murray Ohren; r.:>Iane.Ledgerwood; Mike Parnesi, City Manager, City of San Clemente; Mary Campbell; ty\g'fie Hughes; Peter Rock; Ron Runolfson; David Steffensen; John Tengdin; ~olliony Wood; and Donald Young.

/('' '/, --- -;:,

:->}>"·

Speakers opposed tofheproject included: Bob Joseph representing San Clemente.Citizens for Resr:>Qr1~!ble Development; Loren M. Barnett representing Colony Cove; RayBep~dicktusr(7pf~senting Riccardo Nicol former City of S.C. Planning Commissioner;Marg()~ishpp; Gilbert Blount; Garry Brown representing Orange County Coastkeeper; Paui .... Ca(ltC>A representing Sierra Club, Sierra Sage; Stephanie Dorey, member of San Cl€¥["n~pte City Council; Ed Hubler; Doug Korthof; Julie Lotzer; Steve Netherby; Anna NOble; Stephanie Pacheco representing Friends of Harbor Beaches & Parks; Tom Padberg; Rudy Vietmeier, representing Sierra Club; and A.C. White.

MINUTES OF MARCH 12-16, 2001 PAGES

Eighty speakers submitted requests to speak in favor of the project: Beth Apodaca; Marcella Avakian representing San Clemente S. Support; Elva Axtell • representing San Clemente Seniors Support Group; Robert Beasley; Linda Beck; Julia Brooks; Richard Brooks representing San Clemente Seniors;Jony Carbonara; Virginia Cuchessi representing San Clemente Seniors Support Group; L.M. Cu.mmings; Tho Dang; Dorothy Lee Davis; Teri Delcamp representing City of San Clemente; Antero Diaz representing San Clemente Chamber of Commerg:e;,Pat Doughty; Rod Doughty; Bob Edwards; Janice M. Ehlis; Loraine Eisenheisz; Norman Eisenheisz; MarY E. Eli a; Alan s. Frankel; Bob Greener; Dee Hamilton representingiTSC Chamoer ofCommerce; Hernandez representing San Clemente Chamb~q;of,:.;f:omrJ)~rce; Ja . · · Teale Hotchkiss; Doug Hughes; Vivian Jackson; Mlmifbopns(;)n: Ed Kirsch . . . representing San Clemente Seniors; Ralph Klasset\; Irene ~(6se representing Clemente Seaside Center; Cathy Lee; Jerry Lehmci[!; P(&~"ident- San Clem ~· ... ~·, ...... ,,,. Chamber of Commerce; May Lein representing Sari Cleh'lente. Sr. Center; John Lewis; Michael W. Lombardi; Kristen Lusk; Nancy Lusk; William D. Lusk; Philip.C. Markley; Allison Mauvezin; Mildred McMillan representing Sea Side Seniors; Peter Mickael; Robert F. Morris representing sc Chamber of Commerce; Irene Nathan; Agoes Nesbitt representing Seaside Seniors; Guy R. Ow~n; Daniel ~plumbo; Dick Pick; Marjrie Pick; Anna Marie Poncino representing Senior SUpport Group; Bill Ray; Marcia Reid; Rod Rodriguez representing Chamber of Commerce;.Jc)~'schwartz representing Marblehead San Clemente Seniors; Eqna Scott represef'lting S.C. Senior Support Group; Laura Scott representing Common Interests Inc; HOA Property Management Co.; Amparo Serrano representing Senior Center; Manuel M. Serrano representing Senior • Center; Marie A. Siegel representing San Clemente Chamber, S.C. Womens Club; Dorothy Siemann; Darel L. Sparling; Kimberley, Sparling; Allen Staff; wm Stenzel; Peggy Stith representing San Clemente .Chamber of Commerce; Arnie Stoutland; Sue Stoutland; Katherine Tomerlin; Ph,ong Truong representing South County Senior Svcs; Mai Tu; Guy Varriano; Jack Webster; Phyllis Wilkinson representing San Clemente Senior Center; Pam Withers; Pat Wolfram representing San Clemente Hospital & Medical Center; and Connie Young. ·

Mark McGuire, representing the applicant, withdrew the application.


•

•

•

•

8. PERMIT AMENDMENTS .

a. Application No. A-5-99-301-A {Irvine Co., Orange County) Staff recommended approval with special conditions as modifi~d in addendum.

Gary Hunt, representing the Irvine Company spoke infavor gf.theproject. Garry Brown, representing Orange County Coastkeeper, spoke inf~vo[<;)fJhe project. Andi Culbertson, representing the Irvine Company, s~brnitted a req~esft6speak in favor of the project. Michael Fitts, representing DefendJhe Bay, spokE;iO opposi,fi'pn to the project. )Y ,

Motion & Vote: Rose moved staff recommendatiq~;'·'~~~b~Cled by Dettlof(~l1~g;J call vote was 11 in favor and 0 opposed. Passed... ......... ··· · .,::,~

b. Permit No. 5-82-291-A2 {PRS Group, Dana Pt.) Movedlg~JSpOnded Consent Calendar. Approved.

9. FINDINGS.

a. Application No. A-5-99-301 {Irvine Co.)Orcmge County)" Staff recommended approval of findings.

Garry Brown, representing Orange CountyCoastkeeper, submitted a request to speak in favor of the project. Andi Culbertson and Gary Hunt, both representing the Irvine Company, submitted requests to speak in favor of the project. Michael Fitts, representing Defend the Bay, spoke opposition to the project.

Motion & Vote: Dettloffmoved staff recommendation, seconded by Desser, and the handvote was 7 in fdvor..ond 0 opposed. Passed.

for the day at 8:05p.m .


Tuesday, March 13, 2001 pages 8 to 14

1. CALL TO ORDER. The meeting of the California Coastal Commission was called to order on Tuesday, March 13, 2001, at 9:05a.m. by Chairman Wan. ·

2. ROLL CALL. Present: Chairman Wan, Commissioners Dean,'[)E?ss,er, Dettloff, Estolano, Hart, Kruer, McCoy, (Alternate) Orr, Ne~::d, (Aiternat~} RQ$~, Sgnders and Woolley. Absent: McClain-Hill. (Alternate) Weinstein and Sween~yarrived at 9:1

AtiJ;d•, ,' .' ··,~> • ' ."" • ' !c,,

a.m.

ENERGY, OCEAN RESOURCES and WATER QUALITY

3. ENERGY, OCEAN RESOURCES and WATER QUAlnY,REPORT. Depu~:Dil"ector Kooser reported on matters not requiring public hedrirlgs, an·a st9tus of offshore oil & gas exploration & development. . :·:;:? ___ ....._ __ ......__ '"T: ):./.\

:.·:·~r '.' ; \<~ ..

Sweeney and Weinstein arrived during thEffollowing':}terri~'

a. Huntington Beach Power'Piant Status. Staffrecommended sending a letter to the Energy Commission describing future involveme.r1f.in .the process.

Motion & Vote: Estolano m'oved staff recommendation, seconded by Orr, and Chairman Wan ruled that the vote was unanimous. Passed.

4. LOCAL COASTAL PROGRAM (LCP).'i}:

· '··. a. Ventura Co. LCP Amendment No. VNT -MAJ-1-00 Time Extension. Staff recommended approval.

Mqtlon & Vote: Rose moved$tQ~ recommendation, seconded by McCoy, and Chairman Wan ruled that ftf~:vbte was unanimous. Passed.

/ ·~:q~;:~:··~ ~1}~7;;( < .. :j-;-/


•

•

•

•

•

•

5. COASTAL PERMIT APPLICATION .

a. Application No. E-00-14 (SCE, SDG&E, Anaheim & Riverside, San Diego Co.) Staff recommended approval with special conditions as Vlodified orally.

Steven Beggett, representing US Nuclear Regulatory.~'gffirpissi6r\: submitted a request to speak. Dr Michael HerteL representingSouthern'Q()Iifornia Edison, submitted a request to speak in favor of the project. Dav~ ~'"'evk, represenJipg;~cji?,~n, submitted a request to speak in favor of the project. J. T~iReiUy, repre.sen.f.ing Sqyth~[rJCaliforpia Edison, submitted a request to speak in favor ofth~Pr()Jes:;r >~ob Carnp[?.~JN .· .. ··' #' representing North County Economic DevelopVlent .C::ppr)c;:il, submitteC:f:o(~qul3 speak in favor of the project. Fifteen speakers submitte~·[(3quests to speakin·< . opposition to the project: Lois Berg; Patricia Borchmar;t'};:·N§tbE:1ft H. Doll; Donis avey, representing Creed; Dr Norman Dessel, representing CREED}2~yn tlarris Hicks, representing CREED; Joan M. HilL representing American Ass()s.o'fUr;~iversity Women & CREED; Betty Limberg, representing CREED/American Associdfionof tlniv. Women; Don May, representing California Earth Corps; Wendy fv10[[is, representin~ Surfrider Foundation; Steve Netherby; Marilyn O'B~en, re8resenting American Association of University Women/CREED; Dr William Ra[]lsay; Richqrd.R~dfield; and Lynna Youngerman, representing American}\ssociationpftJniversifYWomen. Two other speakers submitted requests to speak: <;:raig Jqq6Beauchar11Pi,Esq.; and Mark R. Legg, representing CREED. · ·

Motion & Vote: Kruer moved~t<:lff recommendation,.secobded by Weinstein, and Chairman Wan ruled that the vote was unanimous. Passed.

PUBLIC STATEMENIS. Adrian Marinesaidthe San Elijo Lagoon continued to oppose the sports park whichwill destroy habitat. Jeff Yazel said the processing of the lagoon opening was made inconvenient for citizens, and that it was not an emergency.

LUNCH RECESS. The Commission recessed for lunch at 12:30 and returned at 2 p.m.

6~ SONGS Status. A writtefl:1t~port was mailed. Two speakers submitted requests to speak: .Jacqueline Wintert?r.fepresenting Friends of the San Dieguito River Valley; and Julie Hamilton]representing?dndy Lane Association.

7. CALTRANS NONPOINT SOURCE PROGRAM WORKSHOP. Informational only .


SAN DIEGO COAST DISTRICT

8. DEPUTY DIRECTOR'S REPORT. Deputy Director Lee reported on matters not requiring public hearings, and on comments from the puqlic.

a. Encinitas LCP (De Minimis) Amendment No.l-2000 (Mll'ijidpal Code). Staff recommended concurrence with Executive Dir~(::torrs,:determfntitiqn."Jhere being no objection, Chairman Wan ruled that the Commissioh concurred,with the Executive, Director. Approved. "''-, ' ' .vl'l!'i'±• .~~~,;~'

;:,:'/~·.··~;. ,· -:'·.e,;>;, ~-s:;;;,,:J) '.

b. San Diego LCP (De Minimus) Amendment ,,c;,.i-2ooo'(Update to LDC). St~ff recommended concurrence with Executive Direct6r's determination. There being no objection, Chairman Wan ruled that the Commission·· concurred wifi}Jhe Executive Director. Approved. .::0

·.

----~--·-:"'·;;~· ... .,.,.. . .,.,...-- ·;0;• .. . ,• .· /~ . ~;t\~}i{~i~; i.;:-;,

... ·.·.:.·:~.t..·,·~·· .. • .. : .. ·.: ... ·.·.: > . . .,., ' " . : >;p ' ' ';'~~:; ::-,

9. CONSENT CALENDAR (removed fromrR~gularC,QI~nciar}. Staff moved two items ( 12h & i) to the Calendar, and recommended approval .with sp~cial conditions.

:.::' ; : .. ~: ;.< , /<zS:·~;:.

Motion & Vote: Kruer moved staff recommendatibn, seconded ,by McCoy, and

•

Chairman Wan ruled that the vote was unanimous. Passed. •

10. LOCAL COASTAL PROGRAii:(LCP).

a. Del Mar LCP Amendment No~ 1-2000 (MSCP Element). Postponed.

, b. Del Mar Implementation Re~·sllbmiHal. Staff recommended approval with suggested modifications as modified orally.

. ~~

Adam Birnbaum, representing City of Del Mar, spoke in favor of the staff recommendation. Julie Hamil'f(')b, representing Sandy Lane Association, spoke in · oppositioJ1 to the staff recororo.~ndation. Wayne Chang, representing Rick Engineering Co~:.~p(>ke in opposition to'"tfrg1~laff recommendation. Five other speakers representing Sandy LaneHofi1eowners Association submitted requests to speak in opposition to the· staffrecori:imendation: Thomas Hayes, Jim Frace, Stephen Fletcher, Doug Allred and Ann~~llr~¢f:

;,,;,· '•'•.> " . . . .••

Motion & Vote to Rej~ct implementation: Dettloff moved to reject the implementation amendment as submitted, seconded by Orr, and Chairman Wan ruled that the vote was unanimous. Passed. •

MINUTES OF MARCH 12-16,2001 PAGE 10

••

•

•

Motion & Vote on Implementation with Modifications: Dettloff moved approval of the implementation with suggested modifications, seconded by Estolano, and Chairman Wan ruled that the vote was unanimous. Passed.

11 . NEW APPEALS. -~,_ '

a. Appeal No. A-6-00-186 (Imperial Beac~strEf~tend lrn•"rnvAtmc.ntc:

recommended that the appeal raised no substaq1i.al issue .. /;:;";;;,. "--- -

/:;:)

Staff

Bill Fisch beck submitted a request to spedk.in ()~F?qsjfion to the proJ~c;f~If{?d .. T~. Cardiff, representing Surfrider Foundation, submitteH(.]'r,egpest to speak in opp~~itj~n to the project. Nancy Schmidt submitted a requ~~tt.o spepR!p.ppposition to~th~ .,. project. Michael Schmidt submitted a request to speak·in,opposition to the project. Mayor Diane Rose, representing City of Imperial Beach, subfY)itt~d a request to speak in favor of the project. Paul Benton, representing.(:ity of Imperial Beasb, submitted a request to speak in favor of the project. ~rankHriasun,Chairman, Sgn.giego Unified Port Dist., submitted a request to speak in favgr ofthe prpject. Wes Johnson, representing Accessible San Diego, submitted a requesfto speak in favor of the project. ···· ·

Motion & Vote: McCoy moved staff rec::ommendation, seconded by Kruer, and Chairman Wan ruled that the vote was unanimous. Passed;

b. Appeal No. A-6-00-.187 (Shepard, lmperigiBeach) Postponed.

c. Appeal No. A-6-01-20 (Th~~k Architecture, Carlsbad) Staff recommended that the appeal raised substantial issue .. There being no objection, Chairman Wan ruled thatthe Com.miss.ion found substan.tial .. issue. Chairman Wan opened the hearing on the merits of the project and continu~difto a future meeting.

COASTAL PERMIT APPLICATIONS.

a. Appeal No. A-6-99~·147 (Rutherford, San Diego) Postponed .


b. Application No. 6-00-9 (Del Mar Beach Club, Solana Beach) Staff recommended approval with special conditions.

Walt Crampton, representing the applicant, spoke infpvor of the project. Marcia Smerican, Deputy Mayor-City of Solana Beach, spoke in faxor of the project. Jon Corn submitted a request to speak in favor of the project. Dawr\6 Pancharlan spoke in favor of the project. James Jaffee, representing Cai,Beach Advocates, spoke in opposition to the project. Malinda Dickenson, r~pr~~enting Cal B~pfJ;lAdvocates, submitted a request to speak in opposition to th~ptoject.,, Scp,(Williams, representing California Beach Advocates, spoke in oppositioofo'the project. Sheelagh.Williamsi·'.· representing California Beach Advocates, spdke;in1:oppp'~itiorl to the projec,t}:,··· /·)<' .•

L<,::·,

Motion & Vote: Kruer moved staff recommendationfseEond'ed by Hart, an.~Yf~ call vote was 9 in favor and 2 opposed (Desser & EstoJano).·, Passed.

DINNER RECESS. The Commission recessed fordirWierat 4:50 and returned at 7:15p.m. Estolano, Orr and Weinstein left during the, break1

• •· " ' '· '0 '·' ~i''

c. Application No. 6-00-36 (Scism & Corn; Solt:ma Beach) Staff recommended approval with special conditions.

Jon Corn, an applicant, spoke in favor of the project. Walt Crampton submitted a request to speak in favor of the project. Dawna PaQcharian submitted a request to speak in favor of the project. Pgul Santino spoke in ·favor of the project. Glenn Pierce spoke in favor of the project. DavidSkelly submitted a request to speak in favor of the project. Ann Baker, represehting SofBeach Coastal Preservation Assoc., spoke in favor of the staff recommendation. Priscilla Baker, representing Helix, submitted a request to speak in favor of the staff recommendation. Malinda Dickenson, representing Cal Beach Adv.ocates submitted a request to speak in opposition to the project. Sheelagh Williams,J~presenting California Beach Advocates, submitted a request to speak in oppositiOllJQ the project. Todd T. Cardiff, representing Surfrider Foundation, spoke in oppositiqr(to the project. Scott Williams, representing Cal Beach Advocates, spoke in oppo~iti9rlto the project. James Jaffee, representing Cal Beach

·.··Advocates, spoke in opposftion)o the project. . .. ~· p

Motion & Vote: Rose moved.staff recommendation, seconded by Woolley, and the roll call vote was 8 in favor· .. ond o opposed. Passed.

''·,· .. , ' .. ;.:·-tH,A/"

,\;·.:·;t:' , .F~('::',

·-··:.··,y--1'

d. Appeal N& A~6-00-67 (Chart House, San Diego) Postponed.


•

•

•

• Sweeney, Dean and Sanders left during the following item.

•

•

e. Application No. 6-00-126 (San Diego marine mammal reserve) Staff recommended approval with special conditions as modifi~d in aqgendum and orally.

Robin Stribley, representing City of San Diego1 sg • .()ke inJayo(gfthe project. Clifton Williams, representing San Diego City Councilm,~t]gerScottPe~~r~.subl11itted a request to speak in favor of the project. Patric~.L,~e;Hord, representin~:F~9 J.~lla Fri~nds of the Seals, spoke in favor of the project. Na()miKing, n3pre.sentingL<:J.J.()li<:1F~!~nd~ the Seals, submitted a request to speak in favor(){t~~ r:>roj~ct. CamilleKoUn~rt, .•.. submitted a request to speak in favor of the proje<:;t. Kol;Medina, representiQg Eo .

•• ...... .!1··· "c>·: ··.·.···· ...... . Justice Law Clinic, spoke in favor of the project. James Hudnall, representing Save Our Seals Coalition, spoke in favor of the project. Floriaq<:;raoersObmitted a request to speak in favor of the project. Kevin Doyle, representing Ndtioqgl Wil(jlife Federation, submitted a request to speak in favor of the project. Pat Gallagh,ers.0o.rl1itted a request to speak in favor of the staff rec~IT)t;nend<:Jtiop with public gc:c::ess. Patrick Ahern, representing La Jolla Town Council~.spoke II).(?Pposition to the project. Wes Johnson, representing Accessible San ()iego, spokejpopposition to the project. David Donahue, representing San Diego Couhcil of Divers,spoke in opposition to the project. Carl Lind, representing "Citizens for OpeqBeaches & CleanWater," spoke in opposition to the project. Alicia Booth submittec:tarequestto speakinopposition to the project . Dr John SteeL representing Citiz7nsforOpen Bf?dches anct.Ciean Water, spoke in opposition to the project. Betty Morrison spoke in opposition to the project. Ellen C. Revelle submitted a request to speak in opposition to the staff recommendation. Stephen Haynes spoke in opposition to the project. Marilyn M. Clark spoke in opposition to the staff recommendation. lee Olsen submitted a request to speak in opposition to the project. Mark Bucon spoke in opposition to the project. Joe Cordaro,representing NMFS, answered questions on buffer.

M()fion.~ Vote: .Rose mbved staff recbrnmendation, seconded by Desser, and Chairman Wan ruled that the vote was unanimous. Passed.

f. Application No. 6-00-134 (Del Mar lagoon opening) Postponed .


g. Application No. 6-00-138 (Greenberg & Kinzel, Solana Beach) Staff recommended approval with special conditions.

Bob Trettin, representing the applicants, spoke in fa submitted a request to speak in favor of the project. Po to speak in favor of the project. Dawna Pancharian su favor of the project. Glenn Pierce spoke in favor favor of the project. Priscilla Baker submitted a recommendation. Ann Baker, representing spoke in favor of the staff recommendation. Foundation, spoke in opposition to the proj Advocates, spoke in opposition to the project. Advocates, spoke in opposition to the project. Beach Advocates, submitted a request to speak Sheelagh Williams, representing California Beach speak in opposition to the project.

.. of the project. Jon Corn itted a request t to speak in

Skelly spoke in of the staff

~: ~:-~-:£-

Motion & Vote: Kruer moved staff reconim call vote was 8 in favor and 0 opposed. {~.cli;e

onded by R~e(and the roll

:~fkiii-'t:<:::";</

h. Application No. 6-01-7 (§eaW~rla; Sarr Calendar. Approved. ' .· .... ···

~~1--;~:;0_~; ____ ......;.....;.

expanded Consent

·cSved to expanded Consent

13. FINDINGS~.Jrailed until Wednesda

·• ·~. i~p~~~ tf'a~~~199;)~3 (Ligo~ *,"f~anside) findi!)gs. The item wasfrgjleq;1.Jntil Wednesday.

Staff recommended approval of

~ ~-'· . ~ ~-:;::~t:--~-' ; v

'::' . .pn Tuesday, before din · . tynoe ti~idel spoke in fav

Renny Dowling spoke in opposition to the project. project on Wednesday.

,--, ':~-,_'lfl ;~f~Ef~~;~:ii:~;~t~;f~'--- -,

M~~~~~r~L~~te: Kruer mo hand.V:ofe \Vb's:~s in /i

RECESS. The Co

off recommendation, seconded by Dettloff, and the "0 opposed. Passed.

recessed for the day at 9:40 p.m.

MINUTES OF MARCH 12-16, 2001 PAGE 14

•

•

•

• Wednesday, March 14, 2001 pages 15 to 22

1. CALL TO ORDER. The meeting of the California Coast~l<::;gm order on Wednesday, March 14, 200 l, at 9:00a.m. by Chbirmc]ft ~

2. ROLL CALL. Present: Chairman Wan, Vice Cbairman PottenComtnissioners Dettloff. Estolano, Hart, Kruer, McCoy, Nova, Ne.gf~geilly andWoC>II~Y· b~~ent: Sanders. Sweeney arrived at 9:05a.m.; Dean q((iyed at 9;~p .. a.m.;'Mc~l~in~8i at 9:40 a.m.; and Desser arrived at 10:10 a.m. · · · .

STATEWIDE

3. APPROVAL OF MINUTES. Potter moved approval ofthe minutes seconded by Woolley, and unanimously approved.

4. COMMISSIONERS' REPORTS. lnformcitional only.

2001,

• 5. CONSERVANCY REPORT. ~(Written report was

•

6. SANTA MONICA MOUNTAINS CONSERVANCY REPORT. None.

7. DEPUTY ATTORNEY GENERAL'S REPORT. Informational only.

Dean and McClain-Hill arrived the following item.

8. E)(ECUTIVE DIRECTOR'S REPORT including report on legislation.

a. Enhancement Gtorits Assessment and Strategy. Staff recommended approval.

Motion &Vote: Reilly moved staff recommendation, seconded by Estolano, and Chairman W()nJuled that the vote was unanimous. Passed .


b. Legislation. Staff recommended support of AB 640 and SB 55.

M·otion & Vote on AB 640: Nava moved staff recommendation on AB 640, seconded • by Dettloff, and the hand vote was 8 in favor, 0 opposed d 1 abstention. Passed.

Motion & Vote on SB 55: Reilly moved staff recommend Estolano, and the hand vote was unanimous. t'a!u~teja_

NORTH COAST DISTRICT

9. DEPUTY DIRECTOR'S REPORT. District Man requiring public hearings, and on comments fro

lendar). stdit~i" . d item 12c to 10. CONSENT CALENDAR (removed from the Calendar, and recommended apprC)vgL conditions. .

Motion & Vote: Woolley moved staftr~~arnmendc::mt>r:t~"sec:oo Chairman Wan ruled that the vote vJg~'·ufiianimou~; Pa!sle'd~":'~·~·tz"~~·

by Estolano, and

Motion & VotetoRii~ct lmplem~ht(Jtiort: Woolley moved to reject the implementation amehc:ff)1ent as submitted, secondedbyEstolano, and Chairman Wan ruled that the vote.was unanimous. Passed ..

Motion & Vote on 11"\"\r\IAirY\..:II•"'"""'tf""•"' with Modifications: Woolley moved approval of the . implementation with su .. .... odifications, seconded by Estolano, and Chairman ·wan ruled that the vote was imous. Passed.


•

•

•

•

•

Desser arrived during the following item .

b. Crescent City LCP Amendment No. CRC~MAJ~ 1-00 (Del Norte Healthcare District). Staff recommended approval with suggested m()pifications as modified in addendum and orally. ;<

'< ",/,:.,-,-::-- ,;_; -- ,' ', '.)\'~"

David Wells, representing City of Crescent CiJy, ~pok~ in fqyh(~f,the staff recommendation. ·.· r,·~. J,~c>;,.;;·::":~····

£·;:::":·_0;'-·.,_,'·c - ·-··;'<J-''-'-----

Motion & Vote on Plan as Submitted: Woolley.~8V~d O(?.~f.o~~loftheL5J1Jd1USt3 Plgg Amendment as submitted, seconded by McCoy,qngqi;)(Jirman Wan rulecf.!o · vote was unanimous in opposition to the motion. Fciil~c:t·~~ ' :>:·;.

Motion & Vote on Plan with Modifications: Woolley r},t~ed aeproyal of the Land Use Plan Amendment with suggested modifications, seconded by McC,qy~ and Chairman Wan ruled that the vote was unanimous. Passed. ·*'·

.. ( · ..

Motion & Vote to Reject Implementation: .Wdbllt3yrno~ep to reject th~~i~plementation amendment as submitted, seconded.by McCoy, aqdChairman Wan ruled that the vote was unanimous. Passed. · · ..... ·· ·

Motion & Vote on Implementation withModificatidns: Woolley~~oved approval of the implementation with suggested modifications, seconded McCoy, and Chairman Wan ruled that the vote was unanimous. Passed;


a. Application No. 1-00-6 (Crescent City Harbor Dist., Del Norte Co.) Staff recommended approval with special conditions.

Motion & Vote: There being.no speak~rs, Woolley moved staff recommendation, se,~onded by Reilly, and Chqirman Wan ruled that the vote was unanimous. Passed .

. ·?1\:? ;i ..

, it>. ~ppeal No. A-1-00-~a(vJnnams Communications, Mendocino Co.) Staff re9ommended approval with special conditions as modified in addendum and orally.

Biii'Pfanr"ler,J(3Pre~~]'ltin~ Williams Communications Inc., spoke in favor of the project. Greg Jirak,.repre~~nting Coastal Residents Coalition, spoke in opposition to the project. Julie VE?rrah, representing Sierra Club, spoke in opposition to the project.

/.--'.:,> -- - :·

Motion & Vote: Reilly moved staff recommendation, seconded by Woolley, and Chairman Wan ruled that the vote was unanimous. Passed.


c. Application No. 1-01-5 (Williamson, Humboldt Co.) Moved to expanded • Consent Calendar. Approved.

13. PERMIT AMENDMENT.

a. Permit No. 1-83-223-A (Webber, Mendoc::i

NORTH CENTRAL COAST DISTRICT

14. DEPUTY DIRECTOR'S REPORT. Deputy DirectorS . oil rep requiring public hearings, and on comments from the publi''

15. CONSENT CALENDAR (removed

16. NEW APPEAL.

a. Appeal No. A-2-00-38 (~nclerson, the appeal raised no substaritielissUe. ·

Catherine A. Mac resenting app , poke in opposition to the project. Michael McCrnr·von ···r ~nr.o.~onting the applicant, spoke in favor of the project. Astrid Anderson, , spoke in favor of the project.

' " >;~;-("''

,<,::_-'/->Y:;:-::--:

ndation, seconded by McClain-Hill, and (Desser & Wan). Passed.

elsen, Marin Co.) Staff recommended approval ed orally.

MariusNelson spokei avor of the project. Susan Nelson spoke in favor of the project.

Motion & Vote:. D~§s~rrnoved staff recommendation, seconded by Reilly, and Chairman Wan ruled that the vote was unanimous. Passed.


•

•

•

•

•

b. Application No. 2-00-40 (San Francisco Dept. of Public Works) Staff recommended approval with special conditions .

Motion & Vote: There being no speakers, Desser moved staff recommendation, seconded by Reilly, and Chairman Wan ruled that the vote was unaqimous. Passed.

PUBLIC STATEMENTS. Jacqueline Winterer, representigg Frieria~;~fSgQ;Di@guito River Valley, said trucks and advertising on 22nd Dist. Ag.Assn. property ne@dt~<;omply with the Coastal Act. J. M. Stegman said the fairgrol)nds shg\Jid use toe;goy~g qre for the truck driving school. ·· · ··· .. · ····

;/,:;:~:::--;:",---,

ii~~·;:~~J;'i)t/

LUNCH RECESS. The Commission recessed for lunch. l :50 p.m., beginning with item 19b.

STATEWIDE

Neal left during the following

18. FEDERAL CONSISTENCY REPQf'tT. Coastal f'rogram Analyst Simon reported on Negative Determinations issuedby the federdlconsistency staff, and status of major non-energy federal consistency matters.

a. Staff introduced Appendix Aof City of Coronado's Emergency Plan . associated with previously-concurred CD-89-99 (U.S. Navy), CVN Homeporting Project, NASNI, San Diego.

Mayor Smisek representing City of Coronado spoke. E. John Traylor representing City of Coronado spoke. Capt. John Schwanz, representing U.S. Navy, spoke. Peter

•... ·. M. Hekman, representing Militgry Affairs Advisory Council San Diego Chamber of : Commerce, submitted a request to speak. Francisco Estrada, representing

Congressman Bob Filner, spoke~~A man representing Assemblymember Kehoe spoke. Laura Hunter, representing f:nvr,Health Coalition, spoke. Marilyn Field spoke. Nohelia Ramos, ~~presenting EnXB~He;alth Coalition, spoke. Jim Peugh submitted a request to speak inopposition tothe~stqff recommendation. Molly Rhodes, representing Hotel Employees Restau[Qfilt Et'Ilployees Local 30 spoke. Carol Cahill spoke. Carol Jahnkow, representing Peac~Res9urce Center of S.D., spoke. Jillion Morrissey submitted a request to speak. ,.Jqrpes Cahill spoke. Ginna McDonough submitted a request to speak. Sharon Hoffmcm spoke in opposition to the staff recommendation. Russell Hoffman submitted a request to speak in opposition to the staff recommendation. Ron Flisher, representing Environmental Health Coalition, spoke in opposition to the staff


recommendation. Dr Edward Siegel submitted a request to speak in opposition to the staff recommendation. Rev. Peter Moore-Kochlacs, representing Environmental • Ministries, submitted a request to speak. Pamela Hollinger spoke. Earle Callahan spoke. Phil Van Saun from State Office of Emergency Services and Ralph Perry from San Diego County Emergency Planning answered questions.·

Motion & Vote to Re-schedule: Nova moved to sch~dule a hearingon changed circumstances, seconded by Estolano, and the,;rolH~oll vot~ .. V,Y()s·SJo fay()r (Estolano, McCoy, Nova, Reilly & Woolley) and 7 opposed (D~'sser, Dettloff. Hart Ktuer, McClainHill, Potter & Wan). Failed. ..·.>~;s: •.•... .• . ; ..


19. LOCAL COASTAL PROGRAMS (LCPs). <· .·:-·", .. _ :·::~:w

a. San Diego LCP Amendment No. 4;2oocfcceritre City North Embarcadero Overlay) Staff recommended approval with sug&iested modifications as modified orally. X·

Walter Rask, representing CCDC; ·~poke. Ann Fathy ~ubmitted a request to speak in favor of the staff recommendation. Wes Johnson, representing Accessible San • Diego, submitted a request to speak in favor of the staff recommendation. Mike McDade submitted a request to speak in favor ofthe project. Ron Bociung, representing Harbor Lights Foundation, spoke in opposition to the staff recommendation. Bob Geilenfeldt, representing EHC and RAB Coronado, submitted a request to speak in opposition t,o the staff recommendation. William Keith, representing Project Area Committee, submitted a request to speak in opposition to the staff recommendation. PattyMooney submitted a request to speak in opposition to the staff recommendation. Stan Smith submitted a request to speak in opposition to the staff recommendation. Thomas Mark submitted a request to speak in opposition to

.; the project. <(;•)I,t~.E~ ·•·

Motion & Vote on Plan as Subrofhed: Kruer moved approval of the Land Use Plan · 'AmendfT)ent as submitted,:.~~§'phded by Estolano, and Chairman Wan ruled that the

vote was unanimous in opR'osition to the motion. Failed. ';~11;, ·.· ',>'

Motion& Vote on Plan ~ith Modifications: Kruer moved approval of the Land Use Plan Amendment with sugg~~fe'CJ modifications, seconded by Estolano, and Chairman Wan ruled that the vote'was unanimous. Passed.

<>tn±{; ·'; ><-,~j;iit1:~~¥;'

Motion & Vote to Reject Implementation: Kruer moved to reject the implementation amendment as submitted, seconded by Estolano, and Chairman Wan ruled that the • vote was unanimous. Passed.


•

•

•

Motion & Vote on Implementation with Modifications: Kruer moved approval of the implementation with suggested modifications, seconded by Estolano, and Chairman Wan ruled that the vote was unanimous. Passed.

""'' ___ , __ , ___ ._., .. _,,

b. Port Master Plan Amendment No. 27 (NortbEmbare'Cid~r~ ~edevelopment Program). Staff recommended approval in part; and denial in pgrt~ 11c

" ""' .:~-t->><- -___ :- '~ _-_ <

Fifty nine speakers submitted requests to sp~9k i~ opfu£:~itrdn ;()t.he;~ta, . .. ... . •. ~,%. recommendation: Senator Dede Alpert, ArthurB:~x9~t§tt~representifig~~ornpa.t~~0;;,r Heritage Foundation, Frank Baranowski representiDQ:.Be~ntewn San Diego... ... . . ······ "' Partnership, Scott Barnett representing S.D. CountyTaxJ)ayers0Assoc., Luis BarriOs representing S.D. Hotel-Motel Assoc., James A. Berryrepre~~nting~ircraft Carrier Memorial Association, Ken Borchik, Gen. Bob Butcher U.S .. MarigeL@Orps. Retired, Earle Callahan, Gordon Carrier representing CarrierJohnson, Marilyn Cloyd, Midge Costanza representing Midway Carrier Museum, Son Qiego County Supervisor Greg Cox, Lisa DiMaggio, Kathy DiMatteo, Larry [)on()V(]Q,~!;g.meron Durckelfepresenting Cong. Duke Cunningham, Thomas C.EIIiojf;Jacql)~!Ir'feEvans representing NTC Trust for Historic Preservation, Tom Fat reprE1senting Littl.~ Italy Business ~ssoc., Jim Fitzpatrick representing S.D. InternationaL DavidFiqllr, WaltFraser, Mark.Qeorge, Fred Gilbert representing Assemblymember Howard Wayne,C:::apt. G.R.Grigsby representing Naval Order of the United States & Military OrqerOf WorldyYars & Southern Cal Optimists, Peter Hall representing.Q.CDC, Dan H.9mmerrepresenting Congresswoman Susan Davis & CongressmanBqb Filmer, Barbara Hqrtung representing S.D. Sate University President Stephen Weber & Dean Joyce Gattes, Art Harris Sr. State Cdr. VFW, Peter Hekman representiqg Military Affairs Advisory Council S.D. Chamber of Commerce, Wes Johnson representing Accessible San Diego, Jessie Knight Pres. S.D. Chamber of Commerce, Oweh Lgpg [epresenting Suzuki Assoc., Peter Litrenta representing Port Tenants Assoc.;Angus R. MacDonald, National Teacher of the Year Bill McGrqth, MikeMQPad.e, Sheryl McT~prrepresenting North Island Financial Credit Union.~ Bill Mitchell, Aorn. Riley Mixon former C.O. U.S.S. Midway, Mayor Dick Murphy, Cbpck Nichols, Brad Ravvlston representing Manchester Resorts, Reint Reinders Ex. Dir.

.,Sib. Convention and Visitors Bl)reau, Kate Rummer representing SD International Sports Cquncil, Steve Sagen reprf:?,§~Qting S&P Distributing, astronaut Wally Shirra, Chuck ·~miley representing Naval B~tic;C>pter Historical Society, John Smith representing United Veterans (:()unciL Ky Snyde'rr~presenting S.D. International Sports CounciL Robert Solomon, Hugh Story representing Sub Vets WWII & Sub Vets Inc., Alan Uke representing Midway Carrier.f0useum, Rprt'Commissioner Frank Urtasan, John L. Vandegrift, Chairman ofth~BoarciLiryqoln R. Ward representing Father Joe's Villages, Dan Wilkins representing Port bf.~g(l Diego,and Mike Williams representing City Councilmember Scott Peters. '· · ·

,, ,;.,.-:;; ,-~=~-~;-~;:"'"

Sixteen speakers submitted requests to speak in favor of the staff recommendation: Ron Backing representing Harbor Lights Foundation, Pierre


Charmasson representing Professional Event Solutions, Sharon Cloward representing San Diego Port Tenants Assoc., Don Connors, Monica Hernandez representing Hilltop • High School, Bill Hertig, Pete Houben representing County Veterans Advisory Council & mayor's Veterans Advisory Board, Laura Hunter repres Envl' Health Coalition, Joanne Pearson representing Sierra Club, Tom Reese, Assemblymember Juan Vargas, Lee C. Sanderfer re Assoc., Stephanie Simpson representing Hilltop H United Veterans Council of San Diego, Judith for Century 3, and Myrna Zambrano represe

Four speakers didn't specify: Chuck representing San Diego Audubon Society, W Planning CCDC City of San Diego, and Jeff Van Byron Wear.

Motion & Vote: Kruer moved approval of the amen Chairman Wan ruled that the vote was u Passed.

RECESS. The Commission recessed


•

•

•

•

•

Thursday, March 15, 2001 -pages 23 to 28

1 . CALL TO ORDER. The meeting of the California Coastal Cpmn;is,sion was. called to order on Thursday, March 15, 2001, at 9:00a.m. by Chair!Tlan \Ajan. ·· ,

2. ROLL CALL Present: Chairman Wan, Vice <:;t19lrrnan P~tter~'c6mmissioners Dettloff, Hart, McCoy, Nova, Neal, Reilly and Wooi.J~Y· Absent~. D~an, Estolano, McClain-Hill and Sanders. Kruer arrived at 9:10a.m.; SwS?~DE?Y arrivectot,?;l Siq.m~ and Desser arrived at 9:20 a.m. · · 'i ·

CENTRAL COAST DISTRICT

Kruer arrived during the following item.

3. ADMINISTRATIVE PERMIT APPLICATION. ~/'/'' ,,, ,,,,

a. Application No. 3-01-3 (GroverBeach,bo&rdwan<)·stdff recommended approval with special conditions.

David Foote, representing City of Grover Beach, submitted a request to speak in favor of the project.

Approved: There being no objec:tiop, Chairman Wan ruled that this administrative permit be issued by the Executive Director .

. SOUTH CENTRAL COAST DISTRICT

CONSENT CALENDAR. ,;;:;;:"/

a. Application No. 4-QJ.;J (Lashgari, Malibu) Staff recommended approval with special conditions.

-:':'- ::_:_:_i,:::-:'·"-'<_"' ··;_>:~::-·:,

Motion & Vote: .R~ii!Ym()'l/.ed staff recommendation, seconded by Woolley, and Chairman Wanruled that the vote was unanimous. Passed .


CENTRAL COAST DISTRICT

Sweeney arrived during the following item and Neal left.

5. DfPUTY DIRECTOR'S REPORT. Deputy Director Grove requiring public hearings, and on comments from

6. CONSENT CALENDAR (removed from

7. L9CAL COASTAL PROGRAMS (LCPs).

a. San Luis Obispo Co. LCP Amendment No. recommended approval.

Motion & Vote: McCoy moved staff reco.m Chairman Wan ruled that the vote was.·ul:i

Desser arrived during thefplfovving item.

. Staff

c 7 \.~an Luis'(:)bi~.F?o Co. Lc~:~rb~~~rn~nt No. SLO-MAJ-2-99 (grading & wireless commuJii~ation). Steffr7commen~~g .. :9P'3E&val of the land use plan, and approval of the irnpl.ementati.QXl witm,suggested rnd:qifi~ptions as modified orally.

f· •• :·, _:-- ··"--.:-- ~;:t-:::_:~ly· '>.-:::::'·,::··:·:__ - "-""" \"_;_:i

.. b~~ '

J~?~~;fi}·~;.iJim Kennedy, repte~~rt .·· •... JM ConsCJting Group, spoke. Mark Savage, .·:·r~presenting Alpine PCS?fj$PQ. ~?Jn opposition to the staff recommendation.

;x - :::;~'_;~');{~ -, 1~;:~}}~$:::: t.~~;i~~-i~-~,-::

' :; --··_' _- __ ' ;~~::~-~;:~-~1<- -----''-- ·;;-:::.: -.:··i:>:i.,.,;;· • -~;~-~~~,2t•<?~·~yote on Plan as S~l:)"'' . ed: Nova moved approval of the Land Use Plan J(f@~QQf'Q~nt as submitteq~l~~ponded by McCoy, and Chairman Wan ruled that the votewastmanimous. Pas$ed.('

'"·\t :.-~;0 ';)y

Motion &·V~te·tq'~~l.i);·l,·~··pJementation: Nova moved to reject the implementation amendmentas·§~9Wifl~(f~ seconded by Woolley, and Chairman Wan ruled that the vote was unaniriiollis~·EPassed.


•

•

•

•

•

Motion & Vote on Implementation with Modifications: Nova moved approval of the implementation with suggested modifications, seconded by Woolley, and Chairman Wan ruled that the vote was unanimous. Passed.

8. NEW APPEALS.

a. Appeal No. A-3-99-93 (Monterey Bay Aqug~illm Res~C:lr<:. , applicant requested continuance. ·· '"'5;c;, '''f~'

Motion & Vote to Continue: Nova moved to contin~~Jpe bearing, Potter, and Chairman Wan ruled that the vote was'ubonimqus. Passed.

'"'' ,,- "''' ' ' ~-;:--'

b. Appeal No. A-3-01-11 (C.B.O., San Luis Obispo Co.} Staffr~<::ornmended continuance. There being no objection, Chairman Wan openedfhehearing and

w--- "'' ----------- ' '

continued it to a future meeting.

c. Appeal No. A-3-01-18 (Gonyer, San Luis0bisp8Co.) Staff recommended continuance. There being no objection Chairman Wan open~a the hearing and continued it to a future meeting.


a. Application No. 3-00-162 (Miller, Pacific Grove) Postponed.

b. ApplicationNo. 3-00-163 (Capit()ICJ, Soquel Creek) Postponed.

SOUTH CENTRAL COAST DISTRICT

10 .•. DEPUTY DIRECTOR'S RE~J~RY: Deputy Director Damm reported on matters not requiring public,hearings, ari~on comments from the public .


11. CONSENT CALENDAR (removed from Regular Calendar). Staff moved six items (l3b, 13c, 13f, 13g, 13j & 14a) to the Calendar, and recommended approval with • special conditions.

( 13f) Lester Tobias, representing the applicant, submWtkg a favor of the project. {14a) Don Schmitz, representing th request to speak in favor of the project.

( 13g) There being more than 3 votes to regular calendar below.

Motion & Vote: Reilly moved staff recomm.c.nr-.rtTI Calendar, seconded by Woolley, and Chairman unanimous. Passed.

12. LOCAL COASTAL PROGRAM (LCP).

a. Santa Barbara Co. LCP Amendment No.· adjustment). Staff recommended extef1ii6n of tt}~

~'-</):;;~

est to speak in bmitted a

Motion & Vote to Extend Time: ~ptter rn§ved stdlfro.r·l"\rY"\ ....... :li.r on, seconded by Potter, and Chairman Wan ruled that the votewos u s. Passed.

,. ___ .,·c-- -" L-'----- w ", ;·-c-,·-

a. Application No.4-~~ ...... : (DJYc:J Partners, Malibu) Postponed. ' ~- --~;:/'.- ;, ,

::. .. 9-186 (t1A • . J~· ... l9holas Canyon Beach access, Malibu) Calendd[;~,Approved .

. ,,<>:v::~:;:

Moved to expanded

(Cardosa, Los Angeles Co.) Postponed.


•

•

e. Application No. 4-00-176 (Walker, Malibu) Staff recommended approval with • special conditions.

•

•

Michael BarsocchinL representing the applicant submitted a request to speak in favor of the project.

Motion & Vote: Kruer moved staff recommendation;~econgedpy and Chairman Wan ruled that the vote was unanimous. Passed:,,

f. Application No. 4-00-177 (Sosa, Malibu) f\16\i~ptCi'en(pandedC:gpsent Calendar. Approved. . ,

g. Application No. 4-00-189 (Ressler & Gertz, Malibu)""Stdffrecommended approval with special conditions as modified orally.

Darren Domingue, representing the applic;ght~;submitted a requ~sf to speak in favor of the project.

Motion & Vote: Potter moved staff recommendation, secondt3d.by Desser, and Chairman Wan ruled that the vote was unanimous. Passed .

h. Application No. 4-00-222 (;ocal Comrnu~icdtio~{~ites, Los Angeles Co.) Postponed.

i. Application No. 4-00~224 (Vogt Malibu) Postponed.

j. Application No. 4-00-237 (Lever, Malibu) Moved to expanded Consent Calendar. Approved.

Application No. 4-0!.-.12 (lechuza Villas West, Malibu) Postponed.

14. PERMIT AMENDMENT. ' " ','' 'e ", ,,

a. Permit~~X~~;~:.~29-A {Shaheen, Malibu) Moved to expanded Consent Calendar. Approv~d .


ENFORCEMENT

15. COMMISSION CEASE & DESIST ORDER No. CCC-01-C Co.) Postponed.

REPORT of CLOSED SESSION. In closed session t Lumber Co., McCrary v. CCC, et al., Central discussed five other matters for information o

RECESS. The Commission recessed for the day at 1 O!(j


•

•

•

•

•

•

Friday, March 16, 2001 - pages 29 to 32

1 . CALL TO ORDER. The meeting of the California Coastql C:::gmmission was called to order on Friday, March 16, 2001, at 9:00a.m. by Chairmarr'(-lbn. 02,

:;;~;t;_:---:.:7" •.··. "P" "00. _ -- . . H/'•::-::.'::~

2. ROLL CALL. Present: Chairman Wan, Comrnissld~ers Desser,D~ltlc;;>ff~ (Alternate) Allgood, Hart, McCoy, Nova, Reilly and Woolley.· Absent: Dean, Krl).eriMcCiain-HiiL Neal, Potter, Sanders and Sweeney.


ADMINISTRATIVE PERMIT APPLICATION~ Af -_--:_:;~~,:-'y-==~:);-.:::-- -,:. ·:w~:-----:-.-~-\_;-::;:,:·=~~-=~:~:_~;-;;;_:::~-t --

3.

a. Application No. 6-01-4 (Coronado lifeguardtower) Staff recommended approval with special condition .

Approved: There being no objection, Chairman Wan rulegthat this administrative permit be issued by the Executive Director. ··

4. CONSENT CALENDAR. See items a through c on page 19 of the meeting notice. Item c was postponed. Staffres;ommended approval with special conditions on the remainder of the Calendar. ·

(b) Trish Butler,reptesenting the applicant, submitted a request to speak in favor project.

Motion & Vote: Desser rnovecj;staff recommendation, seconded by Woolley, and Chairman Wan ruled that the vOte was unanimous. Passed.

-- _,,;_ .::>_->5:<·_-_-;.'::::-:.:' ',, o:-·o_:-_·,_,_,::

5. CONSE"flC:ALENDA~(~~ri}bved from Regular Calendar). Staff moved four items (6a, 6c, 6d&{p)tq th~Pqf~ndar. and recommended approval with special conditions. ""'' ·

Motion & Vote: ··woail~ymoved staff recommendation, seconded by Desser, and Chairman Wan rulecffhat the vote was unanimous. Passed .



a. Application No. 6-00-60 (AT&T Wireless Services, Camp Pendleton) Moved to • expanded Consent Calendar. Approved.

b. Application No. 6-00-80 (Gallagher, Carl with special conditions.

Bob Richards, representing Agua Hedio the project. Jack Henthorn, representing the in favor of the project. Joe Gallagher submi project.

Motion & Vote: Woolley moved staff recom Chairman Wan ruled that the vote was una

c. Application No. 6-00-110 (S expanded Consent Calendar.

d. Application No. 6-00:l5t'(AT&T; San '-"'"''lwiV

Calendar. Approved. ·· to expanded Consent •

e. Application No; l:OQ-1?0 (San Diego approval with special conGitibns.:~;

... :.§;;;> ;;;;;;;;;; ~ ;,,_.Jjt;<:/;

Mt1f6~1(.l~st:o5ar:Eck, rep?~g~fftiflg(myof San Diego, spoke in favor of the proj~ct.~E>oveSch.l~ssin!;J~£! represenf!D · ify,of S.D., spoke in favor of the project fv\ike Elling, representing ty\y:!WD, submit ... a request to speak in favor of the project. John McNab, represenJi f ·· Our NTC, spoke in opposition to the project. Kathleen

, ~{Bigvatt, representing So C, spoke in opposition to the project. Rattana Khalsa, , • regr~~enting Save Our NT \ "ke in opposition to the project. Dan Beeman spoke in

•• :. ()pposition to the project. RQO 56shun spoke in opposition to the project. Yvonne Lewis -:<o%i.t3~=;:·:·::1·:>0-><: __ - -~-:.: :>: ~::::::::>>:,:- _._ :::·\::~~~<;:'4,"-: ·: -- • .. • '·submrtteda request to sp ·· · ; opposthon to the project.

7. PERMIT AME

staff recommendation, seconded by Reilly, and e vote was unanimous. Passed.

a. Permit No. 6-83-27-A3 (San Diego viewing node) Staff recommended denial.


•

•

•

•

Jill Conrad, representing ZLAC Rowing Club, spoke in favor of the project. Mary Grandell, representing ZLAC Rowing Club, spoke in favor of the project. Barbara Wilson, representing ZLAC Rowing Club, spoke in favor of the project. Judith A Swink spoke in favor of the project. Darren Greenhalgh, representing City of San Diego, submitted a request to speak. Harold Ayer spoke in opposition to the project. Michael Hogan spoke in opposition to the project.

Motion & Vote: Allgood moved to approve the amendment, seconded by McCoy, and Chairman Wan ruled that the vote was unanimous in opposition to the motion. Failed.

Dettloff left at 1 0:30, during the following item.

b. Permit No. 6-99-117-A (LHO Mission Bay Hotel, San Diego) Moved to expanded Consent Calendar. Approved.

c. Permit No. 6-00-167-A (San Diego soil recompaction) Staff recommended approval with special condition as modified orally .

Marcela Escobar-Eck, representing City of San Diego, spoke in favor of the project. Kathleen Riser, representing McMillin Development, submitted a request to speak in favor of the project. John McNab, representing Save Our NTC, spoke in opposition to the project. Kathleen Blavatt, representing Save Our NTC, Inc., spoke in opposition to the project. Rattana Khalsa, representing Save Our NTC, spoke in opposition to the staff recommendation. Dan Beeman spoke in opposition to the project. Connie Messina spoke in opposition to the project. John Netterblad submitted a request to speak in opposition to the project. Yvonne Lewis spoke in opposition to the project. Ron Boshun spoke.

Motion & Vote: Allgood moved staff recommendation, seconded by Woolley, and Chairman Wan ruled that the vote was unanimous. Passed.

d. Permit No. 6-00-38-A (SANDAG sand replenishment) Staff recommended approval with special conditions.

Motion & Vote: There being no speakers, Reilly moved staff recommendation, seconded by Desser, and Chairman Wan ruled that the vote was unanimous. Passed .


PUBLIC STATEMENTS. Dan Beeman said the San Diego NTC is public land being used for tourism. Nancy Lucast invited the Commission & staff to tour a cable-laying vessel .• Edwin Robinson said the food bank was being displaced from the former NTC site.

ADJOURNMENT. There being no old or new busin, a.m.

pmg

Res


•

•

Documents

FREMONT, SUITE 2000 FAX ( 415) 904-5400 N FRANCISCO ......2001/03/05 · CALIFORNIA COASTAL COMMISSION • FREMONT, SUITE 2000 N FRANCISCO. CA 94105-2219 VOICE AND TDD (415) 904-5200