Fort Bend Flood Management Association Annual Symposium Oct. 3,
2014
Slide 2
Three 10s to Think About Karin Jacoby
Slide 3
Presentation Outline Ten Things to Watch Federal Rules,
Regulation and Legislation Ten Year Turn From Safe Levees to Levee
Safety Ten Ways to Make a Difference Things you can do
Slide 4
Fighting the Flood of Federal Rules, Regulation, and
Legislation What is it ? Whos doing it ? Why care ?
Slide 5
1. ESA Rulemaking Stated intent is to provide clarity for
listing of species and also for designation of critical habitat,
much of which is found to occur at or near rivers and streams, so
also near levees Fish & Wildlife / NMFS
Slide 6
2. Waters of the U.S. Rulemaking Expands CWA coverage 404 -
dredge & fill 402 - stormwater NPDES 303 - quality stds &
TMDLs EPA USACE
Slide 7
3. National Flood Insurance Program BW12 called for changes to
NFIP to increase rates to reflect true flood risk Homeowner Flood
Insurance Affordability Act of 2014 delays Congress / FEMA
Slide 8
4. Principles & Requirements Rules for Fed agencies to
assess WRD investment and activities WRDA 07 says shall reflect ntl
priorities Avoid unwise use of floodplains and flood-prone areas,
and minimize adverse impacts & vulnerabilities if must be used
Protect and restore natural functions USACE starts - CEQ takes,
applies to more agencies USACE, CEQ, other Agencies
Slide 9
5. Interagency Guidelines Provides direction to agencies for
applicability and implementation of P&R Elevate ecosystem and
social concerns over net NED benefits Broad discretion to Fed
decision-makers Framework to stall / stop WRM infrastructure CEQ,
other Agencies
Slide 10
6. Sec. 408 Permitting Corps released new Engineering Circular
(EC) 2 years to become an Engnrg Regulation (ER) USACE
Slide 11
7. Presidents Climate Action Plan Cut U.S. carbon pollution
Prepare U.S. for climate change impacts Lead efforts to Combat
Global Climate Change and Prepare for its Impacts White House &
CEQ
Slide 12
8. Federal Flood Risk Management Standard Review EO 11988
Incorporate FFRMS Determine Application Fed inv / action (permits)
Horiz FP - coast / rivers Vert Stds best / current science CEQ
10. Levee Rehabilitation and Inspection Program (RIP) PL 84-99
Rulemaking March 2014 Interim policy for levees issued Fall 2014
expect NOI for rulemaking Spring 2015 new proposed rule for levees
and channels anticipated Move away from inspection checklists for
eligibility Toward risk-informed efforts Emergency Preparedness
Risk Communication USACE
Slide 15
Presentation Outline Ten Things to Watch Federal Rules,
Regulation and Legislation Ten Year Turn From Safe Levees to Levee
Safety Ten Ways to Make a Difference Things you can do
Slide 16
Levee Safety Evolution 2005 Levee performance concerns post
Katrina 2006 Corps levee safety approach emerges 2007 WRDA 07 Title
IX - national levee safety pgm 2008 Periodic inspection procedures
2009 NCLS report to Congress 2010 LSAC ratings initiated 2011 SWIF
policy updated for use w/ PL 84-99 2012 Levee vegetation draft
policy 2013 PL 84-99 eligibility determinations suspended 2014
WRRDA 14 Title III w/ a levee safety initiative
Slide 17
2005 Devastation Levee failure in New Orleans IPET post Katrina
Storm Protection system Performance Consequences Risks
Slide 18
2006 Model - Ntl Dam Safety Program Inspections Hazard
potential classification Fed. dam safety guidelines DSAC ratings
State dam safety programs
Slide 19
2007 Congress acts WRDA 2007 Authorize levee projects Title IX
Levee Safety Levee Defined Committee on Levee Safety Database of
inventory and inspection
Slide 20
2008 Inspection Procedures for Corps Levee Safety Program more
rigorous inspection program for levee systems O&M Structural
stability Levee features Communication
Slide 21
2009 Report from NCLS Create state levee safety programs Align
federal programs/processes Provide for non-federal leadership
Slide 22
2010 LSAC ratings initiated Risk Communication Terminology
confusing Local sponsors Developers Insurers
Slide 23
2011 System-wide Improvement Framework Policy Update Allows
continued PL 84-99 eligibility, if working to cure Rigorous
Inspections Unacceptable Ratings No Fed help w/ levee rehab Enhance
Safety and Reduce Risk X
2014 Congress acts WRRDA 2014 Authorize levee projects Levee
Safety Subtitle 3 years to report on recommendations for a National
Dam & Levee Safety Program
Evolution goes on, and on, and It is not the strongest or the
most intelligent who will survive but those who can best manage
change. Charles DarwinCharles Darwin
Slide 29
Presentation Outline Ten Things to Watch Federal Rules,
Regulation and Legislation Ten Year Turn From Safe Levees to Levee
Safety Ten Ways to Make a Difference Things you can do
Slide 30
1. Learn the issues Levees Rehab & Inspection Leveed areas
Hazard Potential Classification Flood Insurance Other
Slide 31
2. Share your stories Successes NFIP Reform Local investment
Built, O & M Challenges Permitting Maintenance activities
Slide 32
3. Get the word out Broaden perspectives
Slide 33
4. Coordinate w/ NCLS Ntl Committee on Levee Safety (NCLS) new
role in WRRDA Still 16 members Staggered terms 2 Fed. (FEMA /
Corps) Non-fed chair Non-fed committees Annual report on levee
safety initiative Coordinate w/ FIFMTF
Slide 34
5. Provide Administration, CEQ and USACE input / feedback WRRDA
Implemenation Guidance Engineering Circulars Climate Action Plan
Fed. Flood Risk Mgt Std Principles & Requirements Interagency
Guidelines
Slide 35
6. Pay Attention Look for rules and regulations that could
impact you Determine process being used to develop Demand your say
APA Rulemaking
Slide 36
7. Comment on proposed rules WOTUS Oct. 20, 2014 ESA Oct. 9,
2014
Slide 37
8. Provide input on rules being developed PL 84-99: Levee RIP
Fall 2014 Eligibility criteria to support FRM o EP planning o Risk
communication Prioritize maintenance activities based on risk Align
FR terminology and activities
Slide 38
9. Prepare for battle NFIP Reform Outreach Educate Get it on
the radar of those who will stand behind you (before they stand w/
someone else)
Slide 39
10. Engage Be informed Be involved Make things happen You have
more power than you realize. John Anderson