Upload
jeff-sereno
View
214
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/3/2019 Foreign Policy Term Paper
1/9
Jeffery Sereno
July 27, 2011
AP U.S. Government and Politics
Mr. Grummel
Effects of Foreign Aid in the Middle East
8/3/2019 Foreign Policy Term Paper
2/9
Effects of Foreign Aid in the Middle East
Lee Hamilton, a member of the U.S. Security Council once said, Foreign aid
is neither a failure nor a panacea. It is, instead, an important tool of American policy
that can serve the interests of the United States and the world if wisely
administered. While Hamilton said this in 1987, this idea has become the
underlying theme behind Americas foreign policy. In the past century, Americas
support has extended to all parts of the globe, but for the past few decades in
particular, the Middle East has been the major focus behind Americas foreign
policy. Excluding the funds related to ongoing wars in Iraq and Afghanistan, the
three major beneficiaries include Israel, Egypt and Pakistan. The foreign aid given
to these countries come in two shapes: economic aid and military aid. Through the
use of this assistance, the U.S. has several goals, which it in turn plans to
accomplish. These objectives include: seeking stability in nations with abundant
energy reserves, calming volatile relationships between states, and developing
secure alliances with state governments as America looks further into its future.
Americas foreign policy stretches backto the era of George Washington,
however historians characterize the acceleration of U.S. foreign policy during
World War I. Under President Woodrow Wilson, America entered the First World
War in 1917. Entering this war during its close proved to have major benefits for
the U.S.; America had defeated its enemies while it had increased its international
reputation. Developing from this war came Wilsons idealistic Wilsonianism
program of spreading democracy and fighting militarism. Wilsons initiative plans
established several treaties with adversaries from the war, and erected the League
8/3/2019 Foreign Policy Term Paper
3/9
of Nations. These policies remained prosperous until the Wall Street Crash of 1929.
From 1932 to 1938, America was forced to retreat back into a policy of isolationism,
sinking foreign policy for the upcoming years.
When World War II sparked in 1939, America was provided with an
opportunity to once again expand its foreign policy. America provided Lend-Lease
grants of $50 Billion to its allies from World War I, helping boost back its economy.
Over the next two decades, American Foreign Policy slowly expanded until the Cold
War, which in the end proved to be only a small hurdle in Americas expansion. Then
in 1961, Congress passed the Foreign Assistance Act that reorganized the U.S.
foreign assistance programs by separating military and non-military aid. The Act
mandated the creation of the U.S. Agency for International Development (USAID) to
administer economic assistance programs. While some argue that this act was
simply a bureaucratic reshuffling, it signified a recommitment to increase the help of
overseas development. According to their website, USAID was established to unify
assistance efforts, to provide a new focus on the needs of a changing world, and to
assist other countries in maintaining their independence and become self-
supporting. When this transition occurred, U.S. foreign aid became one of the
largest parts of Americas foreign policy.
Today, one of the major objectives behind Americas foreign aid is the desire
to stabilize the abundance of energy reserves in the Middle East. Despite the recent
progress made in the renewable energy field, petroleum still remains the most
dominant energy source and is predicted to be for the next quarter-century. In
addition, current unrest in this geographical region has proven to disrupt the supply
8/3/2019 Foreign Policy Term Paper
4/9
lines that America relies upon heavily. The past drive for fossil fuel energy has led to
wars, overthrow of democratically elected leaders, puppet governments and even
dictatorships. Through the use of economic and military aid, the U.S. plans to
stabilize the energy supplies in these regions.
Recent protests in Cairo, Egypt have illustrated the need for greater foreign
aid in areas of instability. Six days after the revolution began in Tahrir Square, a
single barrel of oil soared up to $100, the highest it has been in two years
(Commodities and the Middle East, The Economist). While Egypt is only a small
producer and importer of black gold, it is well known as one of the main
transporters of the product, shipping it from Europe to the to the western
hemisphere. About five percent of the global oil supply is transported through the
Suez Canal, located in the northeastern part of the country. Speculators showed
their anxiety over the functionality of this canal as the protests drew nearer and
nearer.
While the canal never actually closed, the fear that it would, caused the spike
in prices. If the U.S. would have done more in terms of foreign aid to stabilize the
region, maybe this incident could have been avoided. Egypt is currently the second
biggest recipient to receive U.S. foreign aid receiving $2.7 billion in 2009. It is
estimated that 56% of oil reserves are located in the Middle East, and while Egypt is
just one country, civil unrest has been expanding in this region. If the U.S.
implements more foreign aid to the countries that truly need it, our greatest
interests will be secure.
8/3/2019 Foreign Policy Term Paper
5/9
Despite recent advancements in forms of alternative energy, it is still remains
evident that oil will be the main form of energy for the next 25 years. Until the time
comes that the U.S. can switch its dependence from oil, it is necessary to develop
good relationships with the countries that supply it and transport it. Three of these
major contributors are Saudi Arabia, Libya, and Kazakhstan. Stabilizing these
governments through economic and military aid will hopefully save the countries
from the corruption and greed that come with the drive for fossil fuels.
While economic returns have a major influence in foreign policy, Americans
also feel a moral obligation to support its allies. Ever since 1976, Israel has been the
greatest recipient behind American aid receiving between $2 billion and $3 billion
every year. People in the United States question if the general commitment given to
Israel, should sacrifice Americas relationships with Arab and Muslim governments.
Others assert that Israel remains a strategic ally, and the U.S. must maintain
relations with Israel to strengthen presence in the Middle East. The debate over this
question impacts the overall assistance given to Israel every year.
Ever since the State of Israel was established in 1948 a U.S. policy of
sympathy and support has been bestowed upon the country. Israel has become a
small, yet powerful military power, dependent on the United States for its military
and economic strength. In total, about one-third of all foreign aid in recent years, is
given to Israel. While some of the money granted to Israeli is used for economic
developments, the vast majority of U.S. assistance is acquired in military aid. In
2010, Israel was given $2.7 billion in military assistance, which accounted for 22
8/3/2019 Foreign Policy Term Paper
6/9
percent of its defense budget (U.S. Foreign Assistance to the Middle East,
Congressional Research Service).
To many Americans, it may appear as if the U.S. is funding a foreign war that
is ultimately creating more violence in the Middle East. Neither the Israelis, nor the
Palestinians are a completely good, truthful nation. However, the Jewish influence
on Americans, and the current power structures in the Middle East has persuaded
Congress to aid Israel. U.S. foreign assistance given to Israel is not meant to
encourage war between the two states, but rather provide Israel with a source of
defense as they take a path closer to future peace. As the Obama Administrations
2011 Foreign Operations committee summarized, U.S. assistance is also aimed at
ensuring for Israel the security it requires to make concessions necessary for
comprehensive regional peace(U.S. Foreign Assistance to the Middle East,
Congressional Research Service).
Calming these volatile interstate relationships would come back to benefit
the U.S. in many ways. Even among Americans who support aid to Israel, many do
not appreciate just how close the strategic relationship is between the United States
and its democratic ally, and how greatly both countries benefit from that
relationship. Both the U.S. and Israel cooperate extensively on defense, intelligence
and economic matters. By doing so, they advance their common interests of
promoting freedom, fighting extremism, and seeking peace and prosperity. While
about 90 percent of aid given to Israel is used solely on their military, 74 percent of
this aid is being used to buy goods from the United States. This illustrates that giving
assistance to the nation, will in turn stimulate Americas economy.
8/3/2019 Foreign Policy Term Paper
7/9
Many new joint programs with Israelis high-tech military industry have
evolved from this relationship. The new Arrow ballistic missile defense system is an
advanced long-range protection device. Israel and the U.S. shared the cost of
development equally for this machine, and the joint venture emphasizes the
possible advancements when the two countries work together.
Americas final objective out of foreign aid is to establish secure relationships
with developing countries. According to the Congressional Research Office, about
150 countries receive various amounts of foreign aid from the United States. If we
assist theses countries now as they begin to grow, we can insure strong relations in
the future. In 2004, Congress appropriated $39 billion to foreign aid, the largest
amount allocated in the past 30 years. The majority of Americans consider this
amount too much chiefly because they do not realize the actual percentage
America spends on foreign policy. The amount of Americas financial aid in terms of
gross national product, accounts to less than 1 percent of the total federal spending.
If compared to the other 22 industrialized nations, the U.S. falls dead last.
Since the end of World War II, America has been fortunate enough to have
the resources to be able to promote other nations with the long-term goals the U.S.
deems important. However current U.S. foreign policies do not stretch far enough to
accomplish these objectives. In 2002 after the September 11 terrorist attacks,
President George Bush broadened his national security strategy, and added global
development as one of the top three ways to strengthen national security. This step
to expand U.S. foreign policy was the first time that the use of financial assistance,
would serve as a means to fortify the nation security.
8/3/2019 Foreign Policy Term Paper
8/9
In later years of the Bush administration, a new objective developed:
spreading and assisting democracies in all parts of the world. Democracies in these
regions provide greater stability, and reduce the violence between different groups
driving for power. With this type of government in place, America is able to develop
stronger, more secure relationship with the government resulting in better foreign
policy.
As a country based on the generous support from others, America has an
obligation to assist other nations as they begin to develop. When early America
sought to break free from the rule of the British, France became one of our main
allies, supporting us with military aid. Similar to how America needed this aid to
survive; undeveloped countries in the world today need the support of America to
become independent nations. This assistance comes in the form of economic aid as
well as the predominant military aid used to increase the levels of safety.
Through the use of support given to countries in the Middle East, the U.S. has
several goals, which it in turn plans to accomplish. These objectives include: seeking
stability in nations with abundant energy reserves, calming volatile relationships
between states, and developing secure alliances with state governments. As the
most prosperous nation in the world today, it is Americas responsibility to lend a
helping hand to the countries that are reaching for it. To hold the position as the
world leader in todays society, America must take the first step to advance the rest
of the world.
8/3/2019 Foreign Policy Term Paper
9/9
Abstract
Current U.S. foreign policy is under the spotlight for debate. As one of the
most influential countries in the world today, America has a responsibility to assist
underdeveloped countries. Providing these countries with the tools necessary to
become independent, democratic nations will, create a more secure, democratic,
and prosperous world for the benefit of the American people and the international
community (U.S. State Department).