For inspection purposes only. NEARSHORE PIPELINE ...starfish Asteria rubens and a fish of the family Cottidae are present.....28 Figure 4.15: Station C6: Hard substrate showing encrusting

BROADHAVEN BAY

NEARSHORE PIPELINE ROUTE:

1-MONTH POST-

CONSTRUCTION ENVIRONMENTAL

MONITORING SURVEY

SHELL E&P IRELAND LTD

March 2009

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:46

Corrib Broadhaven Bay Nearshore Pipeline Route – 1-Month Post Construction Survey 2009

RSK Environment Ltd i RSK/He/P40036/40/03 rev01

CONTENTS 1 Background...................................................................1

2 Objectives and Rationale .............................................3

2.1 Planned sampling regime..................................................................3 3 Survey methods............................................................6

3.1 Vessel ...............................................................................................6 3.2 Dates.................................................................................................6 3.3 Grab sampling...................................................................................7 3.4 Drop-down photography....................................................................7 3.5 Sample processing............................................................................8

3.5.1 Physico-chemical...........................................................................8 3.5.2 Drop-down photography ................................................................9

4 Results.........................................................................10

4.1 Samples obtained ...........................................................................10 4.2 Physico-chemical ............................................................................11

4.2.1 Particle size .................................................................................11 4.2.2 Total organic carbon (TOC).........................................................15

4.3 Interpretation of seabed photography .............................................16 5 Summary .....................................................................32

5.1 Results of Physico-chemical Analyses............................................32 5.2 Results of Seabed Photography .....................................................32

6 References ..................................................................33

Appendix 1: Survey Navigation Verification Report .....34

Appendix 2: Drop-down Camera System Specifications 36

Appendix 3: Grab and Drop-down Camera Fix Logs....38

Tables

Table 1.1: Summary of the nearshore pre- and post-construction monitoring surveys of the offshore pipeline in Broadhaven Bay ........................................................................................1

Table 2.1: Planned sample target numbers for post-construction survey.........................................4 Table 3.1: Actual Survey Operational Schedule...............................................................................7 Table 4.1: Particle size and total organic carbon (TOC) data summary .........................................13 Table 4.2: Comparison of seabed sediment granulometry between the pre and 1-month post

construction monitoring surveys .............................................................................................14 Table 4.3: Percentage TOC in sediment samples collected during the 2009 post-construction

survey, and the 2008 pre-construction survey........................................................................15 Table 4.4: Summary of key physical and biological features observed from seabed

photography ............................................................................................................................17

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:46


RSK Environment Ltd ii RSK/He/P40036/40/03 rev01

Figures

Figure 2.1: Planned locations for seabed sediment sampling and seabed photography (note: six stations along each transect)...............................................................................................5

Figure 3.1: M/V Nomad .....................................................................................................................6 Figure 3.2: Underwater camera equipment (BSL 3.4 megapixel system).........................................8 Figure 4.1: Seabed photography showing the nature of the seabed at stations B6 (shown on

the left) and C6 (shown on the right) ......................................................................................10 Figure 4.2: Actual locations of seabed sediment sampling. ............................................................12 Figure 4.3: Day grab sediment sample retrieval from transect A, station 1 ....................................14 Figure 4.4: Station A1: Coarse sand and shell fragments...............................................................21 Figure 4.5: Station A1: Veneer of coarse sand with shell fragments over rock substrate.

Rock is dominated by brown (including Laminaria sp.) and red seaweeds and a covering of encrusting coralline red algae. .............................................................................22

Figure 4.6: Station A3: Evidence of high wave/current energy. Seabed sediments dominated by sand..................................................................................................................22

Figure 4.7: Station B4: Uniform and pronounced rippled seabed bedforms in fine-grained sand with a swimming crab Liocarcinus sp. evident...............................................................23

Figure 4.8: Station C1: Uniform and pronounced bedform sand ripples, resulting from wave/current activity. Seabed sediments dominated by fine-grained sand, containing obvious mica particles with evidence of flock/organic debris. ................................................24

Figure 4.9: Station D3: Uniform and pronounced bedform sand ripples, resulting from wave/current activity. Seabed sediments dominated by fine-grained sand containing obvious mica particles, with small quantities of flock/organic debris. .....................................24

Figure 4.10: Station E5: Bedform sand ripples, resulting from wave/current activity are less pronounced than at shallower water transects. Seabed sediments dominated by fine-grained sand containing obvious mica particles with small quantities of shell fragments, burrows and mounds providing evidence of bioturbation. Fish is likely a juvenile gadoid, possibly poor cod (Trisopterus minutus) or whiting (Merlangius merlangus). Evidence of flock/organic debris is further highlighted ...........................................................................25

Figure 4.11: Station D2: Less regular and non-uniform sand ripples showing a reduced-energy environment, where faunal tracks are more obvious. Sediments dominated by fine-grained sand containing obvious mica particles ..............................................................26

Figure 4.12: Station B6: Hard substrate showing encrusting red coralline algae red macroalgae, sponges, and other sessile epifauna and flora. .................................................27

Figure 4.13: Station B6: Hard substrate showing encrusting red coralline red algae, red macroalgae, sponges, serpulid worms, and other sessile epifauna and flora. Also present are squat lobsters (Galathea sp.) ..............................................................................27

Figure 4.14: Station C6: Hard substrate showing encrusting red coralline algae, red macroalgae, serpulid worms, crinoids, and other sessile epifauna and flora. Common starfish Asteria rubens and a fish of the family Cottidae are present .....................................28

Figure 4.15: Station C6: Hard substrate showing encrusting red coralline algae, red macroalgae, crinoids, and other sessile epifauna (including hydroids and byrozoans) and flora. Also present is a holothurian (sea cucumber) .......................................................28

Figure 4.16: Reference Station #1: Lower energy rock and boulder habitat. Epibenthic community dominated by a faunal turf and including sponges, anemones, solitary corals, hydroids, serpulid worms and bryozoans....................................................................29

Figure 4.17: Reference Station #2: Epibenthic community dominated by a faunal turf and including species of sponge, anemones, solitary corals. A hermit crab, an asteroid starfish is evident. ...................................................................................................................30

Figure 4.18: Station B4: Rock armour pipeline protection. The rock-dumped section extends between transects A and C and is approximately in width. Rock armour was not observed during grab sampling; the above photograph was actually taken approximately 21m from the target position of B4. .................................................................31

Figure 4.19: Station A3: Some cobble and boulder material located approximately 97m southwest of the target position of A3.....................................................................................31

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:46


RSK Environment Ltd 1 RSK/He/P40036/40/03 rev01

1 Background The Corrib gas field lies in around 350m of water approximately 65km off the coast of County Mayo. Gas from the field is to be brought ashore via a 20-inch subsea pipeline, which makes its landfall at Dooncarton in Broadhaven Bay. From there, the pipeline will be routed onshore to the terminal at Bellanaboy Bridge.

Installation of the export gas pipeline and its landfall were consented under the Foreshore Act. Several conditions were attached to that consent, including surveys of the sediments in Broadhaven Bay, which may be affected by the installation of the pipeline. The first of this series of surveys was a “pre-construction” survey, which was intended to provide baseline conditions prior to the commencement of construction work. Following construction, three monitoring surveys will be undertaken, at 1-month (the present survey) and 6-months post completion of construction, and a further survey at the same time of year as the pre-construction survey (12 months after the pre-construction survey).

Pipeline installation was originally proposed for summer 2002, and a pre-construction survey of near-shore sediments along the proposed pipeline route was undertaken at that time. Thirty-six locations along the pipeline route through Broadhaven Bay were surveyed, with two additional reference stations being located to the north of the pipeline route (one off the coast from Rinnaglana, and one near Benwee Head) at the periphery of Broadhaven Bay. However, construction of the pipeline was delayed for a considerable period after this survey was completed, and it could therefore not be considered a “pre-construction” survey for the revised construction schedule.

RSK Environment Ltd (RSK) has been contracted by Shell E&P Ireland Ltd (SEPIL) to undertake the nearshore environmental monitoring programme (which includes the present 1-month post-construction survey). Following various delays, SEPIL planned to install the pipeline from the landfall out to the Corrib field in summer 2008, and consequently another “pre-construction” survey was undertaken in May 2008.

The installation works for the offshore pipeline were commenced and then suspended during summer 2008, and then successfully installed during summer 2009, with rock armouring of a nearshore section of the pipeline in Broadhaven Bay being completed in October 2009.

This benthic survey report details the first post-construction monitoring survey undertaken in November 2009, approximately 1-month following the completion of offshore construction activities.

It should be noted that future monitoring surveys are scheduled as per the Foreshore Licence conditions. Table 1.1 summarises the nearshore surveys that have been undertaken, and those that are scheduled to take place as part of the pre and post-construction monitoring of the offshore pipeline in Broadhaven Bay.

Table 1.1: Summary of the nearshore pre- and post-construction monitoring surveys of the offshore pipeline in Broadhaven Bay

Activity Date Report Reference Pre-construction Survey Spring/Summer 2002 Ecoserve, 2002. Marine benthic

monitoring of the proposed Corrib Gas Pipeline - Pre construction survey. Report prepared for: Enterprise Energy Ireland. EcoServe, November 2002 (sediment and biota samples)

Pre-construction Survey May 2008 RSK, 2009. Broadhaven Bay Nearshore Pipeline Route Environmental Survey. Report prepared for Shell E&P Ireland Ltd.

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:46



RSK, January, 2009. (sediment and biota samples)

Construction of offshore pipeline (Spring/Summer 2009) 1-month post-construction survey

November 2009 RSK, 2010 (This report). (sediments samples only)

6-months post-construction survey

Scheduled to take place during April 2010

Sediment samples only

Post-construction survey 12 months after pre-construction survey

Scheduled to take place during May 2010

NB. While this survey will not be 12 months after the pre-construction survey, it is timed to provide samples in the same season as the pre-construction took place. This will enable a comparison of pre and post-construction data with the effects of seasonality removed. (sediment and biota samples)

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:46



2 Objectives and Rationale The objectives of the 1-month post-construction survey are to monitor the physical and biological characteristics of the seabed of Broadhaven Bay immediately following the installation of the Corrib export pipeline, and to compare the results obtained with the results from post-construction surveys.

Aspects to be sampled, and the rationale for their selection, are as per the pre-construction survey (RSK, 2009) with the exception that samples were not collected for sediment infaunal analysis. The following briefly describes the parameters measured during the 1-month post-construction survey:

• Physico-chemical: Samples to be collected by Day grab, and parameters measured:

o Particle size analysis (PSA); and

o Total Organic Carbon (TOC). • Biological:

o Epibiota (i.e. those organisms living on the seabed surface) sampled using drop-down stills and video photography to provide qualitative, broad-scale data on the presence of larger organisms (e.g. echinoderms, fish) as well as general ecological conditions (e.g. macroalgae, sediment bedforms, presence of bedrock).

The data collected from this and future post-construction monitoring surveys will be compared with the results obtained from the baseline surveys of 2002 (EcoServe, 2002) and 2008 (RSK, 2009) to determine if effects from the installation of the pipeline through Broadhaven Bay are apparent, and if they are, to what distance from the pipeline they extend.

As per the 2008 pre-construction baseline survey, two reference stations were selected that are geographically removed from the pipeline route through Broadhaven Bay, but are likely to be subjected to similar natural environmental influences, as are those sites close to the pipeline route. Any natural changes seen at the stations over the whole survey period will need to be considered in the overall review of whether project-specific impacts are discernible.

This 1-month post-construction survey followed the same work-scope as the previous surveys, albeit with minor revisions, which are detailed in sections 2.1 and 4.1.

2.1 Planned sampling regime Data from grab and photographic sampling were to be collected from six transects crossing the nearshore pipeline route, each with 6 stations. These were selected so that data collected could be directly compared to the results of the May 2008, and 2002 pre-construction surveys undertaken by RSK and EcoServe respectively (EcoServe, 2002; RSK, 2009).

Stations were located at a distance of 25, 50 and 500m away from the pipeline on both sides. These distances differ from the pre-construction surveys, as concerns were raised regarding the proximity of seabed sampling equipment to the pipeline (which throughout much of Broadhaven Bay lies in an un-backfilled trench). As a result, stations 3 and 4 on each transect, originally at 10m distance from the pipeline were set back to 25m distance from the as-laid pipeline centre line.

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:46



Planned sampling locations are presented in Figure 2.1 and a summary of the planned sample numbers are presented in Table 2.1.

Table 2.1: Planned sample target numbers for post-construction survey

Sample location

No. Stations No. PSA No. TOC Stills/Video

Transect A 6 6 6 6 Transect B 6 6 6 6 Transect C 6 6 6 6 Transect D 6 6 6 6 Transect E 6 6 6 6 Transect F 6 6 6 6 Reference 1 1 1 1 1 Reference 2 1 1 1 1

Total 38 38 38 38

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:46



Figure 2.1: Planned locations for seabed sediment sampling and seabed photography (note: six stations along each transect)

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:46



3 Survey methods

3.1 Vessel As per the 2008 pre-construction survey, the survey vessel used was the Nomad (Figure 3.1) operated by Sinbad Marine Services. RSK provided navigational and survey personnel to undertake the work and all associated equipment. Positions were recorded as both UTM Grid and standard latitude and longitude positions (latitude and longitude in degrees, minutes and seconds, all in WGS84 datum). The target accuracy for positioning at benthic sample stations was within 10m of the proposed position. The specifications of the navigational equipment and the report of the navigation calibration check are presented in Appendix 1.

Figure 3.1: M/V Nomad

3.2 Dates Mobilisation of the Nomad in Killybegs harbour commenced on the 9th November 2009 with the vessel arriving in Ballyglass that same evening. The first survey operations were performed on the 10th November 2009 and the survey was completed on the 13th November 2009. All survey work was undertaken in daylight. Table 3.1 details the survey operations undertaken by date.

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:46



Table 3.1: Actual Survey Operational Schedule

Date Operation

9/11/09 Mobilisation of Nomad from Killybegs to Ballyglass. Mobilisation of survey team and equipment from the UK to Ballyglass. Mobilisation of survey equipment aboard Nomad.

10/11/09 Preparation of survey equipment, including navigation equipment calibration (am). Attempt to undertake drop-down camera survey operations in Broadhaven Bay aborted due to unsuitable sea conditions (pm)

11/11/09 Drop-down camera survey operations in Broadhaven Bay

12/11/09 Drop-down camera survey operations in Broadhaven Bay (am). Benthic grab sampling operations in Broadhaven Bay (am and pm)

13/11/09 Benthic grab sampling operations in Broadhaven Bay (am and pm). Demobilisation of survey equipment from Nomad. Demobilisation of Nomad from Ballyglass back to Killybegs

14/11/09 Demobilisation of survey team and equipment to the UK

3.3 Grab sampling

A Day grab was used for sediment sample collection. Single samples were taken at each station.

Position, date, time, water depth, sediment type and other details (colour, smell, vertical layering, redox discontinuity layer, visible biota, evidence of biological activity) were recorded upon retrieval of the grab; a digital photograph was also taken of the sample, including a sample identification card. Between each deployment, the grab sampler was rinsed thoroughly and scrubbed clean to limit cross-contamination between sampling locations.

3.4 Drop-down photography Seabed photography was acquired using a digital video/stills camera with a lamp and strobe (Figure 3.2). The camera system was deployed within a specially designed stainless-steel frame allowing the equipment to be used at individual drop-down locations or to be towed in a sledge-type configuration. The camera system differed slightly from the 2008 pre-construction survey, where a Simrad-Kongsberg OE14-208 system was used.

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:46



Figure 3.2: Underwater camera equipment (BSL 3.4 megapixel system)

The seabed video footage was displayed live on a monitor onboard the Nomad and recorded directly onto DVD. A navigation data string displaying position, date and time was overlaid directly on to the recorded footage. At each photographic location a number of high-definition still photographs were taken and their positions recorded, a log sheet was completed that included position, transect and station, time, date, and water depth.

The camera system could be deployed in a straight up and down “drop-down” capacity in the event that sea conditions meant that towing the sledge along the seabed was not possible. In addition, there was the option to fit a freshwater lens to allow photography under conditions of poor visibility at the seabed. Full specifications of the camera system are included in Appendix 2.

3.5 Sample processing

3.5.1 Physico-chemical The single grab sample collected at each station was sub-sampled for both particle size analysis and TOC from the surface 5cm depth of sediment using a disposable plastic spoon. The samples were double-bagged with a waterproof internal identification label between the two bags, sealed and refrigerated before transfer under pre-established chain-of-custody procedures. Analysis was undertaken using accredited methods (UKAS (United Kingdom Accreditation Service)) by Benthic Solutions Ltd. Descriptive sediment classifications based on proportions of gravel (>2mm), sand (2mm-63µm) and mud (<63µm) were determined based on the Udden-Wentworth grain size classification scheme (Wentworth, 1922) methodology (Figure 3.3).

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:46



Figure 3.3: Udden-Wentworth seabed sediments grain size classification, modified from Wentworth (1922)

3.5.2 Drop-down photography Seabed stills and video footage were reviewed and sediment type and any identifiable biota were recorded.

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:46



4 Results

4.1 Samples obtained In general, grab sampling was completed successfully. However, in some locations, the nature of the seabed was such that the Day grab was unable to retrieve a sample. In summary, all grab samples were obtained successfully from their planned location, with the exception of the following:

• No grab samples at 2 stations (B6 and C6) despite repeated grab deployments and subsequent slight relocation of sampling location. It was anticipated that no samples would be obtainable at these locations, from earlier appraisal of the drop-down photography, from the vessels echo-sounder during the sampling, and as a result of a similar failure to obtain samples at the locations during the 2008 pre-construction survey (RSK, 2009). The unsuccessful sampling at these locations is as a result of the presence of harder substrate (bedrock and cobbles), evidence of which is shown in the seabed images captured at these stations by the seabed photography (Figure 4.1);

• No samples from original location at 1 station (reference 2), despite a

number of grab deployments, and despite the fact that successful sampling was achieved at the location during 2008 (RSK, 2008). Successful sampling was achieved from a slightly revised location approximately 500m to the west of the target location, at a point when the vessels echosounder indicated that the seabed was no longer rocky in nature.

Figure 4.1: Seabed photography showing the nature of the seabed at stations B6

(shown on the left) and C6 (shown on the right)

Actual sampling locations are presented in Figure 4.2 and positions of sampled locations, distance from planned target, water depth, time and date are presented in the fix logs (Appendix 3).

Due to the sea/wind conditions it was not possible to accurately tow the video/stills camera sled at the seabed for the full length of each transect. The camera was instead deployed as a more conventional drop-down camera at each sampling station. Where possible the sea/wind and tidal conditions were assessed and the vessel allowed to drift across the station along the transect with the camera on the seabed. Deployment in this manner allowed for accurate positioning for stills photography at each sampling location, while recording as much video footage as possible.

Suspended sediment loads in the water column close to the seabed along transects F and E (those transects furthest to seaward) on 11th November 2009 were relatively high, and a number of adjustments were made to the angle of the camera and lighting on the

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:46



frame to compensate for this. These adjustments had the effect of reducing the field of view by moving the camera closer to the seabed. Image quality was markedly increased following these changes, however, sea conditions on the 12th November 2009 were significantly improved and resulted in superior picture quality. As a result of this stations along transects E and F were re-surveyed.

Appendix 3 shows the target positions for the grab sampling and seabed photography compared with the actual locations surveyed.

4.2 Physico-chemical Particle size analysis and TOC results for all stations are presented in Table 4.1.

4.2.1 Particle size Sediment from all of the stations successfully sampled can be classified based on the Udden-Wentworth grain size classification (as per Wentworth, 1922) as sand. In the vast majority of these, gravel (>2mm) and mud (<63µm) fractions were absent and samples consisted entirely of sand (63µm-2mm). However, there was some spatial variation in the dominant size of sand grains present over the survey area.

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:46



The absence of sampled locations at stations B6 and C6 and the relocated position of Ref Station 2 are explained in section 4.1.

Figure 4.2: Actual locations of seabed sediment sampling.

For in

spec

tion p

urpo

ses o

nly.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:46



Table 4.1: Particle size and total organic carbon (TOC) data summary % dry weight

Gravel Sand Mud Grain size

(mm)

Station >2mm 1-2mm

500-999 µm

250-500µ

m

125-250 µm

63-125 µm

<63µm Median Mean

Type* TOC (%)

A1 13.80 36.28 44.00 5.91 0.00 0.00 0.00 1.002 1.064

Very Coarse Sand 0.07

A2 0.00 0.00 10.13 45.70 39.48 4.69 0.00 0.273 0.273 Med Sand 0.10 A3 0.00 0.00 8.88 43.80 41.00 6.32 0.00 0.261 0.262 Med Sand 0.12 A4 0.00 0.00 3.92 39.90 49.58 6.60 0.00 0.235 0.235 Fine Sand 0.09 A5 0.00 0.00 3.94 42.80 48.28 4.98 0.00 0.242 0.243 Fine Sand 0.06 A6 0.00 0.00 20.69 64.44 14.88 0.00 0.00 0.370 0.374 Med Sand 0.06 B1 0.00 0.00 2.29 36.22 49.36 12.14 0.00 0.220 0.218 Fine Sand 0.16 B2 0.00 0.00 0.00 18.55 66.53 14.92 0.00 0.182 0.183 Fine Sand 0.09 B3 0.00 0.00 0.00 18.91 66.74 14.36 0.00 0.183 0.184 Fine Sand 0.07 B4 0.00 0.00 0.28 25.08 57.11 16.11 1.42 0.189 0.190 Fine Sand 0.15 B5 0.00 0.00 1.98 30.58 52.54 14.91 0.00 0.204 0.205 Fine Sand 0.15 C1 0.00 0.00 0.78 21.31 54.95 21.30 1.66 0.176 0.177 Fine Sand 0.08 C2 0.00 0.00 0.03 18.73 57.32 23.72 0.20 0.171 0.171 Fine Sand 0.16 C3 0.00 0.00 0.00 17.46 57.59 24.69 0.26 0.168 0.168 Fine Sand 0.11 C4 0.00 0.00 0.03 20.31 58.26 21.33 0.08 0.175 0.177 Fine Sand 0.15 C5 0.00 0.00 0.86 24.51 54.11 20.50 0.03 0.183 0.186 Fine Sand 0.10 D1 0.00 0.00 0.09 18.86 61.45 19.60 0.00 0.176 0.177 Fine Sand 0.11 D2 0.00 0.00 0.15 19.77 59.02 21.04 0.02 0.175 0.177 Fine Sand 0.13 D3 0.00 0.00 0.77 26.33 57.92 14.98 0.00 0.195 0.197 Fine Sand 0.06 D4 0.00 0.00 0.17 21.09 59.84 18.90 0.00 0.179 0.182 Fine Sand 0.05 D5 0.00 0.00 0.02 18.86 61.02 20.10 0.00 0.175 0.176 Fine Sand 0.06 D6 0.15 0.23 0.74 24.67 58.86 15.34 0.00 0.191 0.195 Fine Sand 0.08 E1 0.00 0.02 7.53 40.38 44.30 7.76 0.00 0.244 0.248 Fine Sand 0.10 E2 0.00 0.00 2.50 28.96 51.36 17.17 0.02 0.199 0.200 Fine Sand 0.08 E3 0.20 1.23 1.94 29.76 52.86 14.01 0.00 0.206 0.208 Fine Sand 0.05 E4 0.00 0.51 3.77 35.50 51.94 8.28 0.00 0.225 0.225 Fine Sand 0.07 E5 0.00 2.02 7.46 34.19 45.97 10.36 0.00 0.232 0.239 Fine Sand 0.07 E6 0.50 1.14 6.90 35.27 47.60 8.59 0.00 0.233 0.240 Fine Sand 0.05 F1 0.50 3.82 27.42 44.48 22.55 1.23 0.00 0.381 0.383 Med Sand 0.03 F2 0.00 1.36 6.18 38.82 48.15 5.49 0.00 0.241 0.247 Fine Sand 0.04 F3 0.15 1.56 12.00 40.00 40.38 5.91 0.00 0.266 0.272 Med Sand 0.07 F4 0.00 2.32 14.33 40.11 37.94 5.30 0.00 0.280 0.286 Med Sand 0.06 F5 0.20 1.48 13.01 40.46 39.57 5.29 0.00 0.273 0.277 Med Sand 0.05 F6 0.00 0.00 1.16 39.00 55.96 3.88 0.00 0.230 0.229 Fine Sand 0.04

REF1 0.60 1.57 1.67 16.83 54.46 22.60 2.27 0.171 0.174 Fine Sand 0.12 REF2 0.30 0.78 0.90 19.01 55.67 21.58 1.77 0.173 0.176 Fine Sand 0.12

* Based on Wentworth (1922)

Medium (250-500µm) and fine (125-250µm) sand dominated throughout the survey area, and constituted more than 70% of sediment material at all transects. In general, coarser sand (i.e. very coarse 1-2mm, and coarse sands 500-999µm) were more dominant at transects A (near to the shore) and F (furthest offshore). Whilst a lower proportion of coarse and a higher proportion of very fine sand (63µm-125µm) was recorded at transects B, C, D and the reference stations, in the central part of the pipeline sampling area.

In contrast to the medium and fine sand found throughout the majority of the sampling area, a single station fell under another classification. Station A1 (Figure 4.3) was very coarse sand, based on the presence of around 14% gravel (>2mm) and 36% very coarse sand (i.e. 1-2mm).

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:46



Figure 4.3: Day grab sediment sample retrieval from transect A, station 1

Mud (<63µm) was entirely absent from two of the six transects, only occurring in very small amounts (0.02%) at a few stations in transects D and E (0.02%), while it was more obvious at station B4 and in transect C and also at reference stations 1 and 2; the greatest amount of mud (2.27%) was recorded at reference station 1. Both reference stations also contained relatively high levels of very fine sand, indicating slightly less mobile conditions than elsewhere in the survey area, with the possible exception of transect C.

Along any given transect, mean grain size and general sample composition was generally similar, with any exceptions to this usually occurring at the end of a transect.

Table 4.2 shows a summary of the PSA data for the 2009 1-month post-construction survey compared with the 2008 pre-construction survey. Overall there is very little variation in the results between surveys. It can be seen that the median grain size and corresponding Udden-Wentworth sediment descriptions are very similar between years.

Table 4.2: Comparison of seabed sediment granulometry between the pre and 1-month post construction monitoring surveys

2008 Pre-construction Survey 2009 Post-construction Survey Station Median grain

size (mm) Sediment

classification* Median grain

size (mm) Sediment

classification* A1 1.050 Very Coarse Sand 1.002 Very Coarse Sand A2 0.261 Med Sand 0.273 Med Sand A3 0.257 Med Sand 0.261 Med Sand A4 0.229 Fine Sand 0.235 Fine Sand A5 0.247 Fine Sand 0.242 Fine Sand A6 N/S N/S 0.370 Med Sand B1 0.228 Fine Sand 0.220 Fine Sand B2 0.195 Fine Sand 0.182 Fine Sand B3 0.213 Fine Sand 0.183 Fine Sand B4 0.210 Fine Sand 0.189 Fine Sand B5 0.211 Fine Sand 0.204 Fine Sand C1 0.170 Fine Sand 0.176 Fine Sand

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:46



2008 Pre-construction Survey 2009 Post-construction Survey Station Median grain

size (mm) Sediment

classification* Median grain

size (mm) Sediment

classification* C2 0.176 Fine Sand 0.171 Fine Sand C3 0.174 Fine Sand 0.168 Fine Sand C4 0.183 Fine Sand 0.175 Fine Sand C5 0.180 Fine Sand 0.183 Fine Sand D1 0.189 Fine Sand 0.176 Fine Sand D2 0.193 Fine Sand 0.175 Fine Sand D3 0.199 Fine Sand 0.195 Fine Sand D4 0.200 Fine Sand 0.179 Fine Sand D5 0.224 Fine Sand 0.175 Fine Sand D6 0.194 Fine Sand 0.191 Fine Sand E1 0.259 Med Sand 0.244 Fine Sand E2 0.239 Fine Sand 0.199 Fine Sand E3 0.233 Fine Sand 0.206 Fine Sand E4 0.245 Fine Sand 0.225 Fine Sand E5 0.233 Fine Sand 0.232 Fine Sand E6 0.230 Fine Sand 0.233 Fine Sand F1 0.334 Med Sand 0.381 Med Sand F2 0.270 Med Sand 0.241 Fine Sand F3 0.251 Med Sand 0.266 Med Sand F4 0.243 Fine Sand 0.280 Med Sand F5 0.258 Med Sand 0.273 Med Sand F6 0.244 Fine Sand 0.230 Fine Sand REF1 0.169 Fine Sand 0.171 Fine Sand REF2 0.155 Fine Sand 0.173 Fine Sand

4.2.2 Total organic carbon (TOC) Table 4.3 shows the Total Organic Carbon (TOC) levels for the 2009 1-month post-construction survey compared with the levels in 2008, prior to installation of the pipeline. TOC levels in November 2009 were generally low, ranging from 0.03% at station F1 to 0.16% at stations B1 and C2. As levels of TOC are often positively associated with the percentage of fine material present, these data are as expected given the almost complete absence of mud in the survey area and the exposed, high-energy nature of this coastline.

The results are comparable with the levels recorded during the pre-construction survey (RSK, 2009), though generally slightly lower in 2009 than in 2008. Given that the two surveys were carried out at different times of the year, these recorded differences are considered to be minor. The 2009 post-construction survey was undertaken during autumn when higher energy conditions predominate, which could result in coarser grained sediments (associated with lower-levels of TOC) being brought to the surface. This is not however supported in the comparison of the PSA results between the surveys, which indicate no significant changes.

Table 4.3: Percentage TOC in sediment samples collected during the 2009 post-construction survey, and the 2008 pre-construction survey

Station TOC (%) TOC (%) 2008 2009

A1 0.38 0.07 A2 0.75 0.10 A3 1.3 0.12 A4 0.28 0.09 A5 0.77 0.06 A6 - 0.06

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:46



Station TOC (%) TOC (%) 2008 2009

B1 0.39 0.16 B2 0.11 0.09 B3 0.41 0.07 B4 0.4 0.15 B5 0.5 0.15 C1 0.86 0.08 C2 0.15 0.16 C3 0.21 0.11 C4 0.19 0.15 C5 0.28 0.10 D1 0.16 0.11 D2 <0.10 0.13 D3 0.1 0.06 D4 <0.10 0.05 D5 0.11 0.06 D6 0.56 0.08 E1 0.44 0.10 E2 0.27 0.08 E3 <0.10 0.05 E4 0.31 0.07 E5 <0.10 0.07 E6 0.22 0.05 F1 0.18 0.03 F2 0.14 0.04 F3 0.3 0.07 F4 0.14 0.06 F5 0.12 0.05 F6 <0.10 0.04

REF1 0.25 0.12 REF2 0.18 0.12

4.3 Interpretation of seabed photography The photographic data obtained provide useful qualitative and supplementary information on sediments and larger biota in the survey area.

The majority of the images show a seabed made up of sandy sediments. These results are as anticipated based on the particle size analysis data, and correspond with the results of the 2008 post-construction survey (RSK, 2009). The majority of sites surveyed exhibit evidence of moderate to high energy wave/current exposure. At these sites sediments are well sorted and show wave/current derived ripple bedforms.

Table 4.4 summarises the key physical and biological features of interest at each transect, based on interpretation of the seabed photography.

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:46



Table 4.4: Summary of key physical and biological features observed from seabed photography

South west North east Transect/Station 1 2 3 C/L 4 5 6 Water Depth

range (m) Ref station 2 Bedrock covered with a sparse short faunal turf, numerous sponges, hermit crab (Paguridae sp.), asteroid starfish (Henricia sp.),

brittlestars, serpulid worms (Figure 4.17) 60-65

Bedrock / Cobbles and boulders Largely bare but sparse growth of serpulid worms, solitary corals, faunal turf, Brittlestar (Ophiothrix sp.) (crab, possibly nut crab Ebalia sp.) (Figure 4.16)

Ref station 1

Regularly rippled sand with particles of mica and shell fragments; fish (unidentified) Flock/organic material Unidentified filaments (? Ophiuroid arms / Polychaete tubes)

51

F Slightly

irregularly rippled sand with faunal tracks and mounds Flock/organic material

Slightly irregularly rippled sand with faunal tracks and mounds Flock/organic material Brittlestar (Ophiura sp.)

Slightly irregularly rippled sand with faunal tracks and mounds Flock/organic material


Slightly irregularly rippled sand with faunal tracks and mounds Flock/organic material (covering seabed in patches)

Slightly irregularly rippled sand with faunal tracks and mounds Flock/organic material Hermit crab (Paguridae sp.)

47-51

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:46




range (m) E Slightly

irregularly rippled sand with faunal tracks and mounds Flock/organic material



Slightly irregularly rippled sand with faunal tracks and mounds Flock/organic material Some shell fragments Unidentified filaments (? Ophiuroid arms / Polychaete tubes)

Slightly irregularly rippled sand with faunal tracks and mounds Flock/organic material Some shell fragments Unidentified filaments (? Ophiuroid arms / Polychaete tubes) Fish (juvenile gadoid) (Figure 4.10)


46-51

D Irregularly

rippled sand with faunal tracks and mounds Flock/organic material

Irregularly rippled sand with faunal tracks and mounds Flock/organic material (Figure 4.11)

Rippled sand with faunal tracks and mounds Flock/organic material (Figure 4.9)

Irregularly rippled sand with faunal tracks and mounds Flock/organic material Unidentified filaments (? Ophiuroid arms / Polychaete tubes)



39-41

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:46




range (m) C Regularly rippled

sand with particles of shell material/mica. Flock/organic material (Figure 4.8)

Regularly rippled sand with particles of shell material/mica. Hermit crab (Paguridae sp.)

Regularly rippled sand with particles of shell material/mica.

Regularly rippled sand with particles of shell material/mica. Flock/organic material

Regularly rippled sand with particles of shell material/mica. Flock/organic material

Bedrock and cobble Encrusting coralline red algae, red macroalgae, faunal turf, sparse serpulid worms, crinoids (Antedon bifida), starfish (Asterias rubens), holothurian (Holothuria forskali), fish (Cottidae sp.) (Figure 4.14 and Figure 4.15)

30

Irregularly rippled sand with particles of shell material/ mica

Regularly rippled sand with particles of shell material/ mica Swimming crab (? Liocarcinus sp.) (Figure 4.7)

B

Boulders with encrusting coralline red algae; barnacles

Rippled sand with particles of shell material/ mica

Regularly rippled sand with particles of shell material/ mica

Angular granite rock armour ≤10cm (approximately 21m 14° from station B4) (Figure 4.18)

Regularly rippled sand with particles of shell material/ mica

Bedrock and cobble substrate with encrusting coralline red algae; red macroalgae, sponges, sparse serpulid worms, Galathea sp. (squat lobsters). (Figure 4.12 and Figure 4.13)

21-23

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:46




range (m) Flat coarse sand and shell fragments. (Figure 4.4)

Irregularly rippled sand with particles of shell material/ mica (Figure 4.6)

A

Bedrock with coarse sand veneer (Figure 4.5) Encrusting red algae; red and brown macroalgae (inc. (Laminaria sp.)


Angular cobbles and pebbles (Figure 4.19)



Irregularly rippled / flat sand with particles of shell material/ mica

4.5-14

Note: C/L = Installed pipeline centre line Cells for certain stations are split, due to the presence of more than one substrate type, and hence more than one dominant biological assemblage observed (eg. A1)

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:46



Seabed ripple bedforms are present at all transects from A-F, although they are less pronounced at those transects furthest to seaward and closest inshore. Greatest uniformity in bedform sand ripples occurs at transects B-D, where water depths are in the approximate range 20-45m.

Fine-grained sands are the predominant seabed substrate, exceptions to this are observed at Station A1, B6, C6, reference station #1 and #2. At Station A1 (Figure 4.4) sediments are coarse-grained sands with gravels and shell fragments. This station is also close to the cliffs and off lying rocks, as such also within 10m of the target position the seabed is a mosaic of rock and coarse sand (Figure 4.5). The remaining stations on transect A have a seabed comprised fine-grained sands, with evidence of high wave and current energy (Figure 4.6). Between stations A2 and A3 an area of cobbles and boulders is present (Figure 4.19). This is potentially the result of the causeway that was built to construct the pipeline landfall, and the cobbles and boulders observed are consistent with those observed while undertaking the 1-month post-construction intertidal survey at the pipeline landfall in October 2009. The photograph shown in Figure 4.19 was obtained at position 54.285ºN / 9.836ºW (approximately 97m south west of the target position of A3).

Figure 4.4: Station A1: Coarse sand and shell fragments

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:46



Figure 4.5: Station A1: Veneer of coarse sand with shell fragments over rock

substrate. Rock is dominated by brown (including Laminaria sp.) and red seaweeds and a covering of encrusting coralline red algae.

Figure 4.6: Station A3: Evidence of high wave/current energy. Seabed sediments dominated by sand

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:46



Examples of sites on transects B, C, and D can be seen in Figure 4.7 – Figure 4.9. These highlight the nature of the wave/current induced rippled, sandy seabed sediments. Also noted at station B4 was evidence of the recent pipeline construction. Figure 4.18 shows the rock armour that was installed by fall-pipe vessel immediately prior to the survey taking place. The photograph shown in Figure 4.18 was obtained at position 54.285ºN / 9.859ºW, approximately 21m from the target position at B4.

Recorded fauna is very infrequent at transects B-D, with the exception of stations B6 and C6, which have a bedrock and boulder bedform. The fine-grained sandy substrate sites with evidence of strong wave and tidal action, which typify the majority of the seabed throughout Broadhaven Bay are characterised by low abundances and diversity of epibenthic species. The photography recorded very few sightings, although it is important to note that the field of view of the seabed camera is small.

Figure 4.7: Station B4: Uniform and pronounced rippled seabed bedforms in fine-grained sand with a swimming crab Liocarcinus sp. evident

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:46



Figure 4.8: Station C1: Uniform and pronounced bedform sand ripples, resulting from wave/current activity. Seabed sediments dominated by fine-grained sand,

containing obvious mica particles with evidence of flock/organic debris.

Figure 4.9: Station D3: Uniform and pronounced bedform sand ripples, resulting from wave/current activity. Seabed sediments dominated by fine-grained sand containing obvious mica particles, with small quantities of flock/organic debris.

As expected, seabed photography confirms a higher-energy environment closer inshore.

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:46



Stations along transects E and F in deeper water exhibit less pronounced sand ripple bedforms, due to the reduced hydrodynamic energy at the seabed. Consequently, increased evidence of bioturbation in the form of small-scale burrows and mounds is observed (Figure 4.10). Despite the increased evidence of bioturbation of the sediments (likely caused by polychaete worms, brittlestars, bivalves or amphipod shrimps), visible and identifiable biota was relatively infrequent over much of the sandy sediments throughout the bay, which is characteristic of this environment. Recorded fauna includes a gadoid (possibly poor cod or whiting (Figure 4.10)), hermit crabs, and brittlestars.

Figure 4.10: Station E5: Bedform sand ripples, resulting from wave/current

activity are less pronounced than at shallower water transects. Seabed sediments dominated by fine-grained sand containing obvious mica particles with

small quantities of shell fragments, burrows and mounds providing evidence of bioturbation. Fish is likely a juvenile gadoid, possibly poor cod (Trisopterus

minutus) or whiting (Merlangius merlangus). Evidence of flock/organic debris is further highlighted

Many of the stations sampled in transect D showed examples of a less energy-intensive environment, for example station D2 (Figure 4.11) where the sand ripples are less regular and non-uniform, indicating a reduced-energy environment. Station D2 shows evidence of more obvious epibenthic activity with noticeable faunal tracks shown imprinted in the sand.

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:46



Figure 4.11: Station D2: Less regular and non-uniform sand ripples showing a reduced-energy environment, where faunal tracks are more obvious. Sediments

dominated by fine-grained sand containing obvious mica particles

In addition to the majority of sites, which were dominated by sand substrate, some sites were characterised by hard substrate, which fell into two main types. In the shallower and well-lit waters at the northern extremes of transects B and C, the bedrock and boulder substrates are dominated by an epibenthic community of encrusting red algae and red macroalgal species as shown in Figure 4.12 and Figure 4.14. as well as a diverse assemblage of fauna (briefly summarised in Table 4.4).

For in

spec

tion p

urpo

ses o

nly.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:46



Figure 4.12: Station B6: Hard substrate showing encrusting red coralline algae

red macroalgae, sponges, and other sessile epifauna and flora.

Figure 4.13: Station B6: Hard substrate showing encrusting red coralline red

algae, red macroalgae, sponges, serpulid worms, and other sessile epifauna and flora. Also present are squat lobsters (Galathea sp.)

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:46



Figure 4.14: Station C6: Hard substrate showing encrusting red coralline algae, red macroalgae, serpulid worms, crinoids, and other sessile epifauna and flora. Common starfish Asterias rubens and a fish of the family Cottidae are present

Figure 4.15: Station C6: Hard substrate showing encrusting red coralline algae, red macroalgae, crinoids, and other sessile epifauna (including hydroids and

bryozoans) and flora. Also present is a holothurian (sea cucumber)

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:46



The second type of hard-substrate environment was observed at the reference stations, in water depths in excess of 50m (Figure 4.16 and Figure 4.17).

Although the physical bedforms in these areas appeared similar to those observed at shallower transects (i.e. bedrock and boulders), the increased water depth (and therefore decreased light penetration) prevents significant plant growth. As such, species of flora are significantly reduced, and the epibenthic community is dominated by faunal species. In addition to increased depth, the reduction in hydrodynamic energy is another factor that has implications for the community that develops at these sites. The visible fauna is briefly summarised in Table 4.4.

Figure 4.16: Reference Station #1: Lower energy rock and boulder habitat. Epibenthic community dominated by a faunal turf and including sponges,

anemones, solitary corals, hydroids, serpulid worms and bryozoans.

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:46



Figure 4.17: Reference Station #2: Epibenthic community dominated by a faunal turf and including species of sponge, anemones, solitary corals. A hermit crab, a

starfish is also evident.

Overall very little evidence of pipeline construction could be observed from the seabed photography, however some evidence was observed at Stations B4 and A3. The photographs at these stations are presented as Figure 4.18 and Figure 4.19 respectively.

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:46



Figure 4.18: Station B4: Rock armour pipeline protection. The rock-dumped section extends between transects A and C. Rock armour was not observed

during grab sampling; the above photograph was actually taken approximately 21m from the target position of B4.

Figure 4.19: Station A3: Some cobble and boulder material located approximately 97m southwest of the target position of A3.

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:46



5 Summary

5.1 Results of Physico-chemical Analyses The seabed throughout the sampling area was largely dominated by mobile soft sediments. This was almost entirely dominated by sand, with only one station (A1) being distinctly different and consisting of very coarse sand. Within the sandy sediments, some variation was seen in the distribution of various fractions: Coarser sands were more in evidence at transect A (near to the shore) and F (furthest offshore), while a lower proportion of coarse and a higher proportion of very fine sands was recorded at transects B, C, D and E, in the central part of the pipeline sampling area. Fine sediment (mud), and consequently total organic carbon levels, were low throughout the area, as expected for a high-energy Atlantic coastline without major riverine input.

A few areas were recorded as being hard substrate, either through video imagery or the failure of the Day grab to collect a sample. These included the area nearest to the Sruwaddacon estuary mouth (transect A), where 3 stations recorded rocky substrates. At either end of the transects hard rock was encountered, while at the centre of the transect over the pipeline itself stones and cobbles were present (possibly the remains of the causeway used to constructed the pipeline landfall). At the northern extremes of transects B and C hard rock was encountered as well as at the reference stations. The rock armour protecting part of the pipeline was evident at the centre of transect B.

The results from the revisited survey locations (2008 and 2009) show no significant differences. With the exception of direct photograph evidence for pipeline construction observed close to sampling stations B4 and A3, no appreciable impacts resulting from the pipeline could be determined in the results from sediment sampling.

5.2 Results of Seabed Photography Video footage provided qualitative evidence of subtidal environments in the area, and the still photographs were of a very high quality (many of which have been included within this report). Sandy habitats ranged from shallow high-energy rippled sand to more settled conditions with extensive evidence of bioturbation, and the biota associated with these included hermit crabs, brittlestars, gadoids and a swimming crab. Hard-substrate areas in shallow water supported a significant encrusting fauna, which included sponges, anemones, hydroids, bryozoans and crinoids, as well as extensive algal growth.

Hard substrates in deeper waters where hydrodynamic activity was significantly reduced, lacked significant algal growth and were dominated by faunal species. An extensive faunal turf covered rock surfaces, and other notable species included sponges, solitary corals and anemones.

The interpretation of the seabed photography during this survey has not highlighted significant differences compared with the pre-construction survey of 2008. During both surveys photographic evidence supports the results of the sediment sampling, and shows an overall seabed of sand throughout Broadhaven Bay, with hard substrates close to the northern and eastern coasts (reference stations, station 6 on transect A, B, and C, and along transect A).

Significant differences from 2008 that show evidence of pipeline construction were observed at two locations: while targeting station B4 (evidence of rock dumped section of the pipeline) and while targeting station A3 (potential evidence of wash-out from the causeway built to construct the pipeline landfall).

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:47



6 References

Ecoserve, 2002. Marine benthic monitoring of the proposed Corrib Gas Pipeline - Pre construction survey. Report prepared for: Enterprise Energy Ireland. EcoServe, November 2002 (sediment and biota samples)

RSK, 2009. Broadhaven Bay Nearshore Pipeline Route Environmental Survey. Report prepared for Shell E&P Ireland Ltd. RSK, January, 2009. (sediment and biota samples)

Wentworth, C.K., 1922, A scale of grade and class terms for clastic sediments: The Journal of Geology, v. 30, p. 377–392

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:47



Appendix 1: Survey Navigation Verification Report

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:47



For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:47



Appendix 2: Drop-down Camera System Specifications

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:47



Drop-down photography system

The camera system was based on the Benthic Solutions Ltd. (BSL) 3.4 megapixel digital camera system with video streaming operated through a surface controller and recording unit. The system had the capacity to be supplied with a unique freshwater lens system developed by BSL for operating in conditions with low ambient water clarity.

The key acquisition parameters of the system used were as follows:

Standard Features Comment Image Resolution 3.4 megapixel (2,048 x 1,536 pixels) Light Sensitivity setting ISO 100 Automatically Selected Sensor Type 1 / 1.8” format high density CCD sensor

Light source 2 x 250lumen controllable LED lamps Stills strobe TTL controller

Typical settings on this survey Aperture priority at F7.4, Shutter speed typically 1/60th or 1/125th second, Auto flash mode

Framing Video Used 625 Line / 50 Hz PAL Control System BSL trigger and surface monitoring system Other Systems Freshwater Lens system (optional use)

The system was deployed from the stern of the vessel using a vertical drop-down frame technique and lowered to the seabed using the vessel’s winch. Height above the seabed was monitored using the online video to control the frames attitude once at the seabed. The seabed was surveyed using a combination of video (minimum 2 minutes) and digital stills photographs (minimum of 5 shots per site). Positioning of the system was based on an offset centred on a vertical deployment from the stern of the vessel.

All data were recorded to DV video and later transferred to DVD via firewire into a PC. Stills images have been reviewed and positions annotated to a separate survey file (Annex 3). The camera system was particularly useful in recording the heterogenic material found at the reference locations, along with stations A1, B6 and C6, some of which could not be sampled using standard grab sampler due to the nature of the seabed.

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:47



Appendix 3: Grab and Drop-down Camera Fix Logs

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:47



Table A3-1: Grab deployment fix log

Grab Samples Position WGS84 UTM 29 North

Fix Date Time (UTC) Location Attempt Sampl

e E N Lat N Long W

Depth (m)

Distance from Target

(m): Heading SOG Knts Notes

383 12/11/2009 12:41:33 F1 1 Grab 437734.80 6018306.1

9 54.3088364680°N 9.9570068321°W 47.00 9.6 107.660° 0.62

384 12/11/2009 12:56:05 F2 1 Grab 437981.41 6018670.2

1 54.3121375593°N 9.9532926210°W 48.00 2.6 96.970° 0.93 No sample

385 12/11/2009 13:00:53 F3 1 Grab 437993.49 6018703.4

6 54.3124378289°N 9.9531139176°W 48.00 9.2 240.480° 1.02

386 12/11/2009 13:13:31 F2 2 Grab 437979.07 6018668.2

0 54.3121192789°N 9.9533282014°W 48.00 5.4 155.160° 0.43

387 12/11/2009 13:20:23 F4 1 Grab 438041.13 6018741.6

2 54.3127865167°N 9.9523897612°W 49.00 10.4 16.810° 0.46

388 12/11/2009 13:32:07 F5 1 Grab 438038.73 6018753.9

2 54.3128967691°N 9.9524291734°W 49.00 1.4 283.980° 0.82

389 12/11/2009 13:45:13 F6 1 Grab 438294.19 6019125.5

7 54.3162674844°N 9.9485797866°W 51.00 0.9 72.760° 0.87

390 12/11/2009 14:11:19 Ref2 1 Grab 442863.64 6020975.6

3 54.3334246008°N 9.8786992059°W 60.00 13.4 59.160° 0.83 No sample

391 12/11/2009 14:17:00 Ref2 2 Grab 442883.12 6020975.9

0 54.3334291475°N 9.8783996560°W 60.00 20.9 229.310° 0.75 Not triggered

392 12/11/2009 14:19:27 Ref2 3 Grab 442869.48 6020999.1

0 54.3336361653°N 9.8786138299°W 60.00 10.9 319.400° 0.7 No sample

393 12/11/2009 14:27:05 Ref2 4 Grab 442866.36 6020987.0

8 54.3335277459°N 9.8786595479°W 60.00 1.59 308.540° 0.82 Not triggered

394 12/11/2009 14:35:09 Ref2 5 Grab 442322.53 6021025.2

1 54.3338092321°N 9.8870294471°W 65.00 545.25 21.170° 1.06 Moved 500m to W

395 12/11/2009 14:51:51 Ref1 1 Grab 442942.29 6019296.4

4 54.3183435366°N 9.8771686443°W 51.00 7.62 67.920° 0.69

396 12/11/2009 15:20:43 A6 1 Grab 445892.88 6015852.8

2 54.2877186310°N 9.8311898271°W 4.50 9.15 279.380° 0.43

397 12/11/2009 15:26:33 A3 1 Grab 445497.80 6015540.9

0 54.2848735735°N 9.8372016016°W 12.00 1.84 46.630° 0.42

398 12/11/2009 15:29:43 A5 1 Grab 445536.74 6015586.6

0 54.2852884395°N 9.8366118099°W 12.00 9.1 208.870° 0.6

399 12/11/2009 15:36:33 A4 1 Grab 445514.62 6015555.8

9 54.2850101055°N 9.8369459812°W 12.00 2.45 100.280° 1.13

400 12/11/2009 15:41:13 A2 1 Grab 445461.39 6015515.4

5 54.2846409782°N 9.8377561601°W 12.00 4.56 287.070° 0.8

401 12/11/2009 15:51:13 A1 1 Grab 445115.97 6015234.3

5 54.2820779419°N 9.8430098948°W 14.00 2.02 64.100° 0.56 Not triggered

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:47





e E N Lat N Long W

Depth (m)



402 12/11/2009 15:51:53 A1 2 Grab 445121.22 6015250.0

0 54.2822191148°N 9.8429320062°W 14.00 16.56 68.300° 0.7

403 12/11/2009 16:04:31 B1 1 Grab 444193.08 6015104.7

1 54.2808129876°N 9.8571593769°W 21.00 7.93 93.370° 1.02 Not triggered

404 12/11/2009 16:08:21 B1 2 Grab 444195.03 6015104.1

1 54.2808078327°N 9.8571292288°W 21.00 7.37 322.860° 0.75 Not triggered

405 12/11/2009 16:09:13 B1 3 Grab 444196.93 6015131.5

1 54.2810542481°N 9.8571052282°W 21.00 20.78 328.160° 0.78

406 12/11/2009 16:16:31 B2 1 Grab 444047.10 6015532.3

7 54.2846402141°N 9.8594812582°W 24.00 3.06 328.760° 1.09

407 13/11/2009 08:27:20 B3 1 Grab 444044.10 6015572.5

0 54.2850005049°N 9.8595347390°W 23.00 10.25 339.580° 0.96

408 13/11/2009 08:35:14 B4 1 Grab 444009.49 6015612.2

5 54.2853539027°N 9.8600738848°W 23.00 8.44 89.460° 0.88

409 13/11/2009 08:40:28 B5 1 Grab 444013.98 6015624.4

7 54.2854642084°N 9.8600070885°W 23.00 5.53 193.770° 0.38

410 13/11/2009 08:48:14 B6 1 Grab 443857.61 6016050.0

1 54.2892711148°N 9.8624887389°W 23.00 4.52 352.230° 1 Not triggered

411 13/11/2009 08:54:08 B6 2 Grab 443873.31 6016060.3

1 54.2893654070°N 9.8622496026°W 23.00 14.37 295.600° 0.77 Not triggered

412 13/11/2009 09:13:08 C1 1 Grab 441759.70 6015324.4

3 54.2825160673°N 9.8945723898°W 30.00 3.95 327.470° 0.64

413 13/11/2009 09:21:40 C2 1 Grab 442026.65 6015687.6

1 54.2858100852°N 9.8905429943°W 30.00 3.96 286.470° 0.25

414 13/11/2009 09:29:26 C3 1 Grab 442047.13 6015710.7

9 54.2860207016°N 9.8902328468°W 30.00 7.35 133.760° 0.94

415 13/11/2009 09:36:03 C5 1 Grab 442087.13 6015763.3

5 54.2864975596°N 9.8896287588°W 30.00 7.72 316.810° 0.84

416 13/11/2009 09:42:52 C5 2 Grab 442083.87 6015765.8

6 54.2865197644°N 9.8896792682°W 30.00 7.16 318.460° 0.87 Aiming for C4 - hit C5

417 13/11/2009 09:53:20 C4 1 Grab 442083.79 6015754.3

6 54.2864164332°N 9.8896782185°W 30.00 5.05 84.550° 0.37

418 13/11/2009 10:01:34 C6 1 Grab 442354.77 6016135.6

5 54.2898734993°N 9.8855896156°W 30.00 3.52 357.110° 0.84 Not triggered

419 13/11/2009 10:18:12 D1 1 Grab 440363.38 6016354.9

8 54.2916159340°N 9.9162224219°W 39.00 1.8 147.130° 0.62

420 13/11/2009 10:30:02 D2 1 Grab 440647.99 6016717.4

2 54.2949061143°N 9.9119224700°W 40.00 8.73 288.380° 0.41

421 13/11/2009 10:34:10 D3 1 Grab 440663.76 6016736.2

3 54.2950769826°N 9.9116838884°W 40.00 3.48 45.020° 0.45

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:47





e E N Lat N Long W

Depth (m)



422 13/11/2009 10:41:32 D4 1 Grab 440697.80 6016772.9

3 54.2954107423°N 9.9111682093°W 40.00 3.81 318.260° 0.41

423 13/11/2009 10:47:30 D5 1 Grab 440706.22 6016785.2

1 54.2955220450°N 9.9110412257°W 40.00 3 304.240° 0.43

424 13/11/2009 10:57:02 D6 1 Grab 440993.21 6017135.6

6 54.2987045339°N 9.9067015113°W 41.00 8.6 354.860° 0.83 425 13/11/2009 No position

426 13/11/2009 11:12:10 E1 1 Grab 439023.26 6017358.7

3 54.3004778037°N 9.9370129583°W 46.00 11.33 107.620° 0.38

427 13/11/2009 11:21:50 E2 1 Grab 439283.92 6017719.8

3 54.3037537318°N 9.9330814457°W 47.00 5.97 291.280° 0.7

428 13/11/2009 11:26:38 E4 1 Grab 439334.07 6017788.1

1 54.3043732781°N 9.9323247779°W 48.00 2.47 352.040° 0.54

429 13/11/2009 11:35:30 E3 1 Grab 439300.09 6017746.3

5 54.3039940001°N 9.9328384745°W 47.00 1.93 331.350° 0.64

430 13/11/2009 11:42:26 E5 1 Grab 439338.14 6017803.1

0 54.3045084647°N 9.9322652347°W 48.00 6.17 37.570° 0.47 No sample

431 13/11/2009 11:49:38 E5 2 Grab 439339.49 6017796.8

1 54.3044521350°N 9.9322433072°W 48.00 1.35 83.420° 0.9

432 13/11/2009 11:57:28 E6 1 Grab 439598.18 6018165.9

7 54.3078001250°N 9.9283428347°W 51.00 3.43 335.080° 0.62

Table A3-2: Drop-down camera deployment fix log

Grab Samples Position WGS84 UTM 29 North Date Time (UTC) Location Sample

E N Lat N Long W Depth (m)


(m): Heading SOG

Knts Notes Approx.

Camera File Time

10/11/2009 Camera Photograph 11/11/2009 09:35:23 F6 Video 438274.21 6019115.45 54.3161741020ºN 9.9488847608ºW 51.00 23.1 199.050º 0.86 DSCN3071 09:34:05 11/11/2009 09:35:41 F6 Video 438265.35 6019115.52 54.3161736299ºN 9.9490210460ºW 51.00 31.2 201.580º 0.83 DSCN3072 09:34:23

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:47






(m): Heading SOG

Knts Notes Approx.

Camera File Time

11/11/2009 09:35:55 F6 Video 438258.57 6019115.22 54.3161701725ºN 9.9491251544ºW 51.00 37.7 200.970º 0.62 DSCN3073 09:34:37 11/11/2009 09:36:11 F6 Video 438248.42 6019116.15 54.3161772976ºN 9.9492812939ºW 51.00 47.3 201.170º 1.47 DSCN3074 09:34:53 11/11/2009 09:36:31 F6 Video 438239.83 6019116.16 54.3161762782ºN 9.9494134254ºW 51.00 55.7 202.790º 0.67 DSCN3075 09:35:13 11/11/2009 09:36:41 F6 Video 438232.91 6019117.09 54.3161838736ºN 9.9495198653ºW 51.00 62.4 201.540º 0.88 DSCN3076 09:35:23 11/11/2009 09:49:00 F5 Video 438044.08 6018762.17 54.3129715975ºN 9.9523485681ºW 48.00 8.6 327.410º 1.52 DSCN3078 09:47:42 11/11/2009 09:49:20 F5 Video 438031.34 6018769.91 54.3130395911ºN 9.9525460999ºW 48.00 16.5 334.300º 1.02 DSCN3079 09:48:02 11/11/2009 09:49:35 F5 Video 438020.92 6018776.89 54.3131010542ºN 9.9527075761ºW 48.00 28.2 337.590º 1.57 DSCN3080 09:48:17 11/11/2009 09:49:45 F5 Video 438017.14 6018780.80 54.3131357062ºN 9.9527665540ºW 48.00 33.62 340.650º 1.42 DSCN3081 09:48:27 11/11/2009 09:50:03 F5 Video 438007.62 6018788.92 54.3132075278ºN 9.9529145230ºW 48.00 46.02 341.660º 0.91 DSCN3082 09:48:45 11/11/2009 10:28:52 F4 Video 438081.96 6018742.28 54.3127973881ºN 9.9517623105ºW 49.00 51.12 214.810º 0.84 DSCN3086 10:27:34 11/11/2009 10:29:57 F4 Video 438040.34 6018746.36 54.3128290045ºN 9.9524027760ºW 49.00 9.91 198.280º 0.89 DSCN3088 10:28:39 11/11/2009 10:30:05 F4 Video 438034.90 6018745.93 54.3128245384ºN 9.9524863105ºW 49.00 4.73 196.640º 0.92 DSCN3089 10:28:47 11/11/2009 10:30:15 F4 Video 438029.94 6018745.27 54.3128180179ºN 9.9525623598ºW 49.00 2.01 200.380º 0.91 DSCN3090 10:28:57 11/11/2009 10:30:23 F4 Video 438026.20 6018745.28 54.3128176061ºN 9.9526199813ºW 49.00 4.99 203.130º 1.16 DSCN3091 10:29:05 11/11/2009 10:30:33 F4 Video 438021.58 6018745.45 54.3128185959ºN 9.9526909851ºW 49.00 9.48 205.690º 1.12 DSCN3092 10:29:15 11/11/2009 10:36:32 F3 Video 438004.16 6018707.86 54.3124786524ºN 9.9529509403ºW 48.00 6.17 177.500º 1.14 DSCN3094 10:35:14 11/11/2009 10:36:58 F3 Video 437998.30 6018703.05 54.3124347940ºN 9.9530398859ºW 48.00 4.36 199.210º 0.76 DSCN3095 10:35:40 11/11/2009 10:37:08 F3 Video 437993.97 6018702.19 54.3124264828ºN 9.9531062928ºW 48.00 8.54 205.640º 1 DSCN3096 10:35:50 11/11/2009 10:37:18 F3 Video 437988.74 6018701.94 54.3124236342ºN 9.9531865956ºW 48.00 13.77 207.150º 1.54 DSCN3097 10:36:00 11/11/2009 10:37:36 F3 Video 437977.84 6018701.48 54.3124181553ºN 9.9533540241ºW 48.00 24.67 211.530º 1.56 DSCN3098 10:36:18 11/11/2009 10:37:47 F3 Video 437975.17 6018701.20 54.3124153011ºN 9.9533950707ºW 48.00 27.35 214.030º 0.52 DSCN3099 10:36:29 11/11/2009 10:45:52 F2 Video 438001.90 6018688.89 54.3123079689ºN 9.9529817185ºW 48.00 25.55 169.130º 0.95 DSCN3101 10:44:34 11/11/2009 10:46:08 F2 Video 437996.14 6018683.90 54.3122623680ºN 9.9530691919ºW 48.00 17.93 175.290º 1.14 DSCN3102 10:44:50 11/11/2009 10:46:18 F2 Video 437993.36 6018680.95 54.3122355476ºN 9.9531112332ºW 48.00 13.93 182.310º 1.25 DSCN3103 10:45:00 11/11/2009 10:46:28 F2 Video 437987.09 6018676.18 54.3121918979ºN 9.9532066511ºW 48.00 6.05 178.520º 1.31 DSCN3104 10:45:10 11/11/2009 10:46:36 F2 Video 437982.18 6018672.78 54.3121607955ºN 9.9532814001ºW 48.00 0.1 182.170º 1.01 DSCN3105 10:45:18 11/11/2009 10:46:52 F2 Video 437977.70 6018670.33 54.3121382227ºN 9.9533497253ºW 48.00 5.03 189.470º 1.21 DSCN3106 10:45:34 11/11/2009 10:47:08 F2 Video 437969.01 6018668.48 54.3121205732ºN 9.9534828822ºW 48.00 13.79 200.450º 1.36 DSCN3107 10:45:50 11/11/2009 10:57:58 F1 Video 437767.77 6018308.15 54.3088580172ºN 9.9565006238ºW 46.00 41.91 192.530º 1.68 DSCN3109 10:56:40

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:47






(m): Heading SOG

Knts Notes Approx.

Camera File Time

11/11/2009 10:58:10 F1 Video 437760.74 6018307.21 54.3088487273ºN 9.9566084368ºW 46.00 34.82 192.050º 1.23 DSCN3110 10:56:52 11/11/2009 10:58:35 F1 Video 437742.58 6018303.88 54.3088166422ºN 9.9568867789ºW 46.00 17.61 194.290º 1.12 DSCN3111 10:57:17 11/11/2009 10:58:52 F1 Video 437736.95 6018303.05 54.3088084330ºN 9.9569731814ºW 46.00 10.67 201.710º 1.28 DSCN3112 10:57:34 11/11/2009 10:59:08 F1 Video 437724.23 6018303.23 54.3088085169ºN 9.9571687553ºW 46.00 2.79 205.010º 1.49 DSCN3113 10:57:50 11/11/2009 10:59:16 F1 Video 437718.40 6018302.04 54.3087971115ºN 9.9572580480ºW 46.00 8.02 205.920º 1.48 DSCN3114 10:57:58 11/11/2009 10:59:24 F1 Video 437713.29 6018302.16 54.3087976020ºN 9.9573365769ºW 46.00 13.13 208.180º 1.39 DSCN3115 10:58:06 11/11/2009 10:59:36 F1 Video 437701.94 6018301.89 54.3087938110ºN 9.9575109963ºW 46.00 23.33 210.630º 1.37 DSCN3116 10:58:18 11/11/2009 11:33:43 E6 Video 439611.56 6018173.27 54.3078673687ºN 9.9281386627ºW 51.00 14.92 190.670º 1.56 DSCN3118 11:32:25 11/11/2009 11:33:50 E6 Video 439605.56 6018169.17 54.3078298188ºN 9.9282301120ºW 51.00 7.76 187.320º 1.63 DSCN3119 11:32:32 11/11/2009 11:34:00 E6 Video 439598.88 6018166.00 54.3078005074ºN 9.9283320486ºW 51.00 3.14 189.200º 1.42 DSCN3120 11:32:42 11/11/2009 11:34:10 E6 Video 439592.83 6018164.15 54.3077831269ºN 9.9284246503ºW 51.00 7.62 192.710º 1.33 DSCN3121 11:32:52 11/11/2009 11:34:20 E6 Video 439586.60 6018162.01 54.3077632030ºN 9.9285200129ºW 51.00 13.88 198.130º 1.65 DSCN3122 11:33:02 11/11/2009 11:34:30 E6 Video 439579.95 6018160.61 54.3077497906ºN 9.9286219557ºW 51.00 20.22 198.630º 1.67 DSCN3123 11:33:12 11/11/2009 11:34:46 E6 Video 439568.59 6018158.65 54.3077309057ºN 9.9287961418ºW 51.00 32.17 202.990º 1.56 DSCN3124 11:33:28 11/11/2009 12:30:29 E5 Video 439372.35 6017796.41 54.3044524013ºN 9.9317381925ºW 49.00 34.22 203.970º 1.42 DSCN3128 12:29:11 11/11/2009 12:30:58 E5 Video 439348.35 6017796.07 54.3044465243ºN 9.9321069965ºW 49.00 10.24 204.500º 1.85 DSCN3129 12:29:40 11/11/2009 12:31:18 E5 Video 439335.79 6017795.58 54.3044406114ºN 9.9322998905ºW 49.00 2.71 208.770º 1.43 DSCN3130 12:30:00 11/11/2009 12:31:32 E5 Video 439324.61 6017795.91 54.3044422742ºN 9.9324716901ºW 49.00 13.57 206.520º 1.36 DSCN3131 12:30:14 11/11/2009 12:31:41 E5 Video 439313.54 6017796.73 54.3044483431ºN 9.9326419585ºW 49.00 23.26 205.110º 1.43 DSCN3132 12:30:23 11/11/2009 12:37:58 E4 Video 439354.02 6017794.01 54.3044286796ºN 9.9320194552ºW 48.00 23.27 199.130º 1.82 DSCN3134 12:36:40 11/11/2009 12:38:16 E4 Video 439341.56 6017790.12 54.3043922648ºN 9.9322101298ºW 48.00 10.21 198.670º 1.26 DSCN3135 12:36:58 11/11/2009 12:38:34 E4 Video 439327.28 6017787.75 54.3043692875ºN 9.9324290484ºW 48.00 4.52 195.970º 1.18 DSCN3136 12:37:16 11/11/2009 12:38:48 E4 Video 439318.04 6017786.33 54.3043554174ºN 9.9325707144ºW 48.00 13.75 198.170º 1.72 DSCN3137 12:37:30 11/11/2009 12:39:04 E4 Video 439308.90 6017785.53 54.3043470884ºN 9.9327109938ºW 48.00 22.93 202.070º 1.31 DSCN3138 12:37:46 11/11/2009 12:44:32 E3 Video 439324.89 6017751.49 54.3040430876ºN 9.9324583808ºW 48.00 23.41 198.020º 0.94 DSCN3140 12:43:14 11/11/2009 12:44:48 E3 Video 439316.16 6017751.84 54.3040452267ºN 9.9325926448ºW 48.00 15.11 210.410º 2 DSCN3141 12:43:30 11/11/2009 12:45:06 E3 Video 439298.21 6017749.35 54.3040207396ºN 9.9328678604ºW 48.00 4.72 196.170º 1.42 DSCN3142 12:43:48 11/11/2009 12:45:24 E3 Video 439284.69 6017746.32 54.3039919060ºN 9.9330750746ºW 48.00 17.32 188.590º 1.29 DSCN3143 12:44:06 11/11/2009 12:50:30 E2 Video 439314.35 6017722.10 54.3037777926ºN 9.9326144170ºW 48.00 35.12 165.370º 0.89 DSCN3145 12:49:12

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:47






(m): Heading SOG

Knts Notes Approx.

Camera File Time

11/11/2009 12:50:59 E2 Video 439302.40 6017718.08 54.3037402380ºN 9.9327972214ºW 48.00 22.69 185.420º 1.63 DSCN3146 12:49:41 11/11/2009 12:51:13 E2 Video 439294.35 6017715.35 54.3037147101ºN 9.9329203225ºW 48.00 14.49 191.900º 1.38 DSCN3147 12:49:55 11/11/2009 12:51:29 E2 Video 439284.38 6017714.24 54.3037035710ºN 9.9330733062ºW 48.00 4.68 197.570º 1.46 DSCN3148 12:50:11 11/11/2009 12:51:42 E2 Video 439271.75 6017713.56 54.3036959691ºN 9.9332671328ºW 48.00 7.43 199.450º 1.42 DSCN3149 12:50:24 11/11/2009 12:52:05 E2 Video 439259.98 6017714.49 54.3037029390ºN 9.9334481953ºW 48.00 19.9 204.490º 1.44 DSCN3150 12:50:47 11/11/2009 13:02:25 E1 Video 439040.87 6017357.48 54.3004686612ºN 9.9367421741ºW 47.00 24.8 208.450º 1.42 DSCN3152 13:01:07 11/11/2009 13:02:48 E1 Video 439019.14 6017354.76 54.3004415732ºN 9.9370754943ºW 47.00 6.03 189.610º 1.84 DSCN3153 13:01:30 11/11/2009 13:03:06 E1 Video 439010.15 6017348.43 54.3003836463ºN 9.9372123821ºW 47.00 7.47 192.960º 1.19 DSCN3154 13:01:48 11/11/2009 13:03:18 E1 Video 439003.40 6017345.20 54.3003537688ºN 9.9373153625ºW 47.00 14.68 198.690º 1.36 DSCN3155 13:02:00 11/11/2009 13:03:34 E1 Video 438992.41 6017343.19 54.3003344662ºN 9.9374838063ºW 47.00 25.83 201.810º 1.7 DSCN3156 13:02:16 11/11/2009 13:54:48 Ref2 Video 442925.69 6020991.16 54.3335710716ºN 9.8777480483ºW 60.00 59.19 247.010º 1.3 DSCN3159 13:53:30 11/11/2009 13:55:36 Ref2 Video 442884.57 6020991.04 54.3335654207ºN 9.8783802214ºW 60.00 18.19 200.560º 1.6 DSCN3160 13:54:18 11/11/2009 13:55:55 Ref2 Video 442876.68 6020985.63 54.3335158572ºN 9.8785005670ºW 60.00 10.58 211.080º 1.3 DSCN3161 13:54:37 11/11/2009 13:56:09 Ref2 Video 442871.72 6020984.65 54.3335065159ºN 9.8785766735ºW 60.00 6.55 220.630º 0.98 DSCN3162 13:54:51 11/11/2009 13:56:21 Ref2 Video 442864.43 6020984.92 54.3335081394ºN 9.8786887828ºW 60.00 4.3 223.360º 1.06 DSCN3163 13:55:03 11/11/2009 13:56:39 Ref2 Video 442854.75 6020984.67 54.3335048110ºN 9.8788376828ºW 60.00 12.46 228.770º 1.38 DSCN3164 13:55:21 11/11/2009 13:56:59 Ref2 Video 442843.73 6020986.14 54.3335168023ºN 9.8790074145ºW 60.00 22.96 229.930º 1.19 DSCN3165 13:55:41 11/11/2009 14:16:52 Ref1 Video 443054.93 6019297.74 54.3183678324ºN 9.8754374069ºW 51.00 112.94 236.430º 0.88 DSCN3167 14:15:34 11/11/2009 14:17:14 Ref1 Video 443044.63 6019299.91 54.3183861605ºN 9.8755961576ºW 51.00 102.55 229.770º 0.81 DSCN3168 14:15:56 11/11/2009 14:17:50 Ref1 Video 443027.56 6019302.25 54.3184052821ºN 9.8758589466ºW 51.00 85.42 227.550º 0.71 DSCN3169 14:16:32 11/11/2009 14:18:34 Ref1 Video 443009.36 6019304.60 54.3184243796ºN 9.8761392579ºW 51.00 67.19 228.340º 0.86 DSCN3170 14:17:16 11/11/2009 14:19:03 Ref1 Video 442995.88 6019305.81 54.3184337506ºN 9.8763466776ºW 51.00 53.74 226.690º 1.01 DSCN3171 14:17:45 11/11/2009 14:19:33 Ref1 Video 442982.83 6019307.41 54.3184466726ºN 9.8765475052ºW 51.00 40.81 227.250º 0.82 DSCN3172 14:18:15 11/11/2009 14:19:55 Ref1 Video 442966.87 6019306.30 54.3184349163ºN 9.8767926608ºW 51.00 24.81 209.040º 1.08 DSCN3173 14:18:37 11/11/2009 14:20:05 Ref1 Video 442961.84 6019304.44 54.3184176343ºN 9.8768696374ºW 51.00 19.68 209.410º 0.95 DSCN3174 14:18:47 11/11/2009 14:20:29 Ref1 Video 442953.00 6019301.63 54.3183913955ºN 9.8770049648ºW 51.00 11.11 214.140º 0.59 DSCN3175 14:19:11 11/11/2009 14:20:51 Ref1 Video 442948.06 6019300.08 54.3183769014ºN 9.8770806316ºW 51.00 7.11 231.940º 0.6 DSCN3176 14:19:33 11/11/2009 14:21:05 Ref1 Video 442944.65 6019300.44 54.3183797881ºN 9.8771330380ºW 51.00 4.39 237.400º 0.57 DSCN3177 14:19:47 11/11/2009 14:21:17 Ref1 Video 442939.84 6019301.62 54.3183898101ºN 9.8772072348ºW 51.00 3.37 240.130º 0.55 DSCN3178 14:19:59

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:47






(m): Heading SOG

Knts Notes Approx.

Camera File Time

11/11/2009 14:21:33 Ref1 Video 442933.53 6019303.62 54.3184071018ºN 9.8773045891ºW 51.00 8.64 237.400º 0.65 DSCN3179 14:20:15 11/11/2009 14:21:55 Ref1 Video 442921.19 6019308.25 54.3184473450ºN 9.8774952800ºW 51.00 20.18 231.090º 0.97 DSCN3180 14:20:37

DSCN3183 11/11/2009 14:58:29 A6 Video 445875.41 6015849.05 54.2876828930ºN 9.8314576051ºW 4.50 20.73 73.090º 0.83 DSCN3184 14:57:11 11/11/2009 14:58:35 A6 Video 445877.49 6015847.80 54.2876718606ºN 9.8314253455ºW 4.50 20 65.190º 0.42 11/11/2009 14:58:37 A6 Video 445878.07 6015847.51 54.2876693163ºN 9.8314164193ºW 4.50 19.8 61.510º 0.37 11/11/2009 14:58:41 A6 Video 445879.46 6015847.22 54.2876668458ºN 9.8313949894ºW 4.50 19.09 56.460º 0.54 DSCN3185 14:57:23 11/11/2009 14:58:56 A6 Video 445882.94 6015848.97 54.2876830158ºN 9.8313418226ºW 4.50 15.59 41.660º 0.63 DSCN3186 14:57:38 11/11/2009 14:59:08 A6 Video 445884.61 6015851.76 54.2877082210ºN 9.8313167032ºW 4.50 12.35 31.940º 0.79 DSCN3187 14:57:50 11/11/2009 14:59:22 A6 Video 445884.77 6015855.43 54.2877411760ºN 9.8313149772ºW 4.50 9.46 25.970º 0.65 DSCN3188 14:58:04 11/11/2009 14:59:34 A6 Video 445884.06 6015859.93 54.2877815819ºN 9.8313266470ºW 4.50 7.87 19.290º 0.8 DSCN3189 14:58:16 11/11/2009 14:59:46 A6 Video 445883.04 6015864.26 54.2878203667ºN 9.8313430846ºW 4.50 8.96 13.720º 0.72 DSCN3190 14:58:28 11/11/2009 15:00:08 A6 Video 445880.75 6015872.17 54.2878912446ºN 9.8313797578ºW 4.50 15.01 4.730º 0.74 DSCN3191 14:58:50 11/11/2009 15:06:59 A5 Video 445564.00 6015571.70 54.2851573747ºN 9.8361903908ºW 10.00 22.38 228.510º 1.38 DSCN3193 15:05:41 11/11/2009 15:07:07 A5 Video 445559.22 6015571.37 54.2851539671ºN 9.8362637046ºW 10.00 18.23 229.150º 1.04 DSCN3194 15:05:49 11/11/2009 15:07:17 A5 Video 445553.85 6015570.12 54.2851421373ºN 9.8363459791ºW 10.00 14.66 233.480º 1.18 DSCN3195 15:05:59 11/11/2009 15:07:35 A5 Video 445543.33 6015567.78 54.2851199902ºN 9.8365070748ºW 10.00 12.58 254.430º 1.62 DSCN3196 15:06:17 11/11/2009 15:07:51 A5 Video 445533.31 6015568.17 54.2851224251ºN 9.8366610450ºW 10.00 15.79 261.070º 1.33 DSCN3197 15:06:33 11/11/2009 15:08:00 A5 Video 445526.13 6015569.70 54.2851354080ºN 9.8367716136ºW 10.00 20.25 260.370º 1.17 DSCN3198 15:06:42 11/11/2009 15:10:48 A4 Video 445521.29 6015548.60 54.2849452478ºN 9.8368422118ºW 11.00 11.02 54.460º 1.13 DSCN3200 15:09:30 11/11/2009 15:11:01 A4 Video 445527.32 6015553.46 54.2849895894ºN 9.8367504573ºW 11.00 15.07 43.950º 1.3 DSCN3201 15:09:43 11/11/2009 15:11:17 A4 Video 445532.98 6015561.75 54.2850646687ºN 9.8366650588ºW 11.00 21.72 30.310º 1.3 DSCN3202 15:09:59 11/11/2009 15:11:27 A4 Video 445535.00 6015567.19 54.2851137787ºN 9.8366349988ºW 11.00 25.73 23.560º 1.03 DSCN3203 15:10:09 11/11/2009 15:11:39 A4 Video 445535.55 6015573.89 54.2851740326ºN 9.8366277979ºW 11.00 29.92 19.350º 1.12 DSCN3204 15:10:21 11/11/2009 15:11:49 A4 Video 445535.79 6015579.46 54.2852241507ºN 9.8366251072ºW 11.00 33.88 17.640º 1.19 DSCN3205 15:10:31 11/11/2009 15:12:03 A4 Video 445535.67 6015587.36 54.2852951504ºN 9.8366282865ºW 11.00 39.89 15.830º 1.12 DSCN3206 15:10:45 11/11/2009 15:12:15 A4 Video 445534.98 6015594.92 54.2853629406ºN 9.8366402472ºW 11.00 45.88 13.390º 1.24 DSCN3207 15:10:57 11/11/2009 15:20:53 A3 Video 445573.25 6015602.98 54.2854394917ºN 9.8360539264ºW 11.00 97.58 217.850º 1.66 DSCN3209 15:19:35 11/11/2009 15:21:03 A3 Video 445567.88 6015599.71 54.2854094950ºN 9.8361359167ºW 11.00 91.34 216.700º 1.81 DSCN3210 15:19:45

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:47






(m): Heading SOG

Knts Notes Approx.

Camera File Time

11/11/2009 15:21:13 A3 Video 445560.37 6015595.76 54.2853732194ºN 9.8362505151ºW 11.00 83.03 215.660º 1.59 DSCN3211 15:19:55 11/11/2009 15:21:23 A3 Video 445553.83 6015593.31 54.2853505156ºN 9.8363504495ºW 11.00 76.49 216.210º 1.41 DSCN3212 15:20:05 11/11/2009 15:21:33 A3 Video 445547.51 6015590.10 54.2853210205ºN 9.8364470385ºW 11.00 69.65 216.810º 1.43 DSCN3213 15:20:15 11/11/2009 15:21:52 A3 Video 445524.70 6015575.40 54.2851864750ºN 9.8367946214ºW 11.00 44.66 188.410º 2.09 DSCN3214 15:20:34 11/11/2009 15:22:06 A3 Video 445521.18 6015567.59 54.2851158719ºN 9.8368473296ºW 11.00 35.08 191.800º 1.99 DSCN3215 15:20:48 11/11/2009 15:22:18 A3 Video 445515.99 6015558.11 54.2850301654ºN 9.8369253375ºW 11.00 24.84 199.840º 2.01 DSCN3216 15:21:00 11/11/2009 15:22:26 A3 Video 445513.01 6015553.07 54.2849845997ºN 9.8369701851ºW 11.00 19.45 207.330º 1.67 DSCN3217 15:21:08 11/11/2009 15:22:36 A3 Video 445507.39 6015547.33 54.2849324053ºN 9.8370554882ºW 11.00 11.72 214.710º 1.64 DSCN3218 15:21:18 11/11/2009 15:22:46 A3 Video 445501.35 6015542.20 54.2848856544ºN 9.8371472550ºW 11.00 4.61 222.320º 1.56 DSCN3219 15:21:28 11/11/2009 15:23:06 A3 Video 445486.76 6015537.19 54.2848390930ºN 9.8373704460ºW 11.00 11.27 227.010º 1.51 DSCN3220 15:21:48 11/11/2009 15:23:30 A3 Video 445460.61 6015530.15 54.2847730388ºN 9.8377707278ºW 11.00 38.15 198.350º 1.62 DSCN3221 15:22:12 11/11/2009 15:23:42 A3 Video 445452.83 6015523.42 54.2847116575ºN 9.8378890636ºW 11.00 47.85 195.050º 1.65 DSCN3222 15:22:24 11/11/2009 15:23:57 A3 Video 445444.81 6015516.41 54.2846478353ºN 9.8380108872ºW 11.00 58.08 191.180º 1.42 DSCN3223 15:22:39 11/11/2009 15:28:30 A2 Video 445487.91 6015522.92 54.2847109695ºN 9.8373500890ºW 11.00 23.02 320.830º 1.55 DSCN3225 15:27:12 11/11/2009 15:29:38 A2 Video 445439.80 6015546.97 54.2849219369ºN 9.8380934060ºW 11.00 39.52 183.140º 0.78 DSCN3226 15:28:20 11/11/2009 15:30:12 A2 Video 445429.35 6015519.48 54.2846737419ºN 9.8382489669ºW 11.00 36.38 99.320º 0.59 DSCN3227 15:28:54 11/11/2009 15:30:26 A2 Video 445436.18 6015517.44 54.2846561477ºN 9.8381436783ºW 11.00 29.47 88.810º 1.04 DSCN3228 15:29:08 11/11/2009 15:30:36 A2 Video 445443.60 6015520.38 54.2846833999ºN 9.8380302230ºW 11.00 22.29 99.960º 1.73 DSCN3229 15:29:18 11/11/2009 15:30:52 A2 Video 445459.26 6015524.89 54.2847255675ºN 9.8377905631ºW 11.00 10.1 127.780º 1.99 DSCN3230 15:29:34 11/11/2009 15:31:01 A2 Video 445469.40 6015522.91 54.2847088902ºN 9.8376344812ºW 11.00 6.94 151.540º 1.71 DSCN3231 15:29:43 11/11/2009 15:31:11 A2 Video 445478.23 6015517.17 54.2846582307ºN 9.8374977456ºW 11.00 12.58 177.970º 1.57 DSCN3232 15:29:53 11/11/2009 15:38:24 A1 Video 445115.99 6015245.82 54.2821809888ºN 9.8430115517ºW 13.00 12.19 217.860º 1.92 DSCN3234 15:37:06 11/11/2009 15:38:40 A1 Video 445105.14 6015239.02 54.2821186867ºN 9.8431770843ºW 13.00 13.8 213.220º 1.43 DSCN3235 15:37:22 11/11/2009 15:38:52 A1 Video 445097.74 6015232.91 54.2820630242ºN 9.8432895503ºW 13.00 20.18 212.910º 1.62 DSCN3236 15:37:34 11/11/2009 15:39:08 A1 Video 445088.23 6015229.13 54.2820280087ºN 9.8434349302ºW 13.00 30.04 213.930º 1.32 DSCN3237 15:37:50 11/11/2009 15:54:25 B1 Video 444192.36 6015131.83 54.2810566543ºN 9.8571754349ºW 20.00 21.86 137.820º 1.31 DSCN3241 15:53:07 11/11/2009 15:54:58 B1 Video 444200.28 6015118.57 54.2809383542ºN 9.8570513922ºW 20.00 8.08 170.720º 1.11 DSCN3242 15:53:40 11/11/2009 15:55:26 B1 Video 444196.53 6015108.32 54.2808457733ºN 9.8571070772ºW 20.00 2.96 198.430º 1.25 DSCN3243 15:54:08 11/11/2009 15:55:42 B1 Video 444190.70 6015103.96 54.2808059997ºN 9.8571957281ºW 20.00 10.12 207.310º 1 DSCN3244 15:54:24

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:47






(m): Heading SOG

Knts Notes Approx.

Camera File Time

11/11/2009 15:55:52 B1 Video 444185.23 6015101.38 54.2807822064ºN 9.8572792795ºW 20.00 16 208.340º 0.89 DSCN3245 15:54:34 11/11/2009 16:03:18 B2 Video 444074.76 6015519.23 54.2845251246ºN 9.8590538989ºW 23.00 32.6 350.220º 1.28 DSCN3247 16:02:00 11/11/2009 16:03:28 B2 Video 444070.31 6015521.53 54.2845453155ºN 9.8591227144ºW 23.00 27.59 351.490º 1.21 DSCN3248 16:02:10 11/11/2009 16:03:38 B2 Video 444065.11 6015524.03 54.2845672224ºN 9.8592030469ºW 23.00 21.84 355.400º 0.92 DSCN3249 16:02:20 11/11/2009 16:03:48 B2 Video 444059.39 6015527.39 54.2845967799ºN 9.8592914913ºW 23.00 15.47 358.130º 0.92 DSCN3250 16:02:30 11/11/2009 16:03:55 B2 Video 444054.26 6015531.15 54.2846299868ºN 9.8593709860ºW 23.00 8.89 359.960º 1.15 DSCN3251 16:02:37 11/11/2009 16:04:09 B2 Video 444049.98 6015535.13 54.2846653100ºN 9.8594375274ºW 23.00 3.55 0.150º 1.23 DSCN3252 16:02:51 11/11/2009 16:04:31 B2 Video 444038.21 6015546.93 54.2847700641ºN 9.8596204642ºW 23.00 14.19 8.370º 1.61 DSCN3253 16:03:13 11/11/2009 16:05:00 B3 Video 444031.17 6015577.83 54.2850469628ºN 9.8597343936ºW 24.00 8.37 47.340º 1.41 DSCN3254 16:03:42 11/11/2009 16:05:06 B3 Video 444032.01 6015583.51 54.2850981103ºN 9.8597225027ºW 24.00 13.67 47.080º 1.68 DSCN3255 16:03:48 11/11/2009 16:05:18 B3 Video 444033.83 6015590.55 54.2851615383ºN 9.8596958919ºW 24.00 20.54 44.570º 1.51 DSCN3256 16:04:00 11/11/2009 16:05:28 B3 Video 444035.87 6015597.17 54.2852212502ºN 9.8596658801ºW 24.00 27.21 39.020º 1.45 DSCN3257 16:04:10

11/11/2009 16:05:57 B4 Video 444037.11 6015613.89 54.2853716509ºN 9.8596499095ºW 24.00 20.76 14.740º 1.2 DSCN3258 PIPE

ARMOUR 16:04:39 11/11/2009 16:06:36 B4 Video 444028.28 6015626.60 54.2854848874ºN 9.8597879070ºW 24.00 15.24 338.210º 1.09 DSCN3259 16:05:18 11/11/2009 16:06:46 B4 Video 444024.51 6015629.98 54.2855148464ºN 9.8598464952ºW 24.00 15.34 332.340º 1.33 DSCN3260 16:05:28 11/11/2009 16:06:53 B5 Video 444016.14 6015634.55 54.2855549920ºN 9.8599758553ºW 24.00 6.66 330.680º 1.49 DSCN3261 16:05:35 11/11/2009 16:07:11 B5 Video 444009.59 6015637.27 54.2855787270ºN 9.8600769674ºW 24.00 8.08 335.040º 1.06 DSCN3262 16:05:53 11/11/2009 16:07:21 B5 Video 444003.25 6015640.96 54.2856112074ºN 9.8601750087ºW 24.00 14.61 338.420º 1.22 DSCN3263 16:06:03 11/11/2009 16:13:21 B4 Video 444013.25 6015646.65 54.2856634351ºN 9.8600225157ºW 24.00 29.98 164.320º 1.68 DSCN3266 16:12:03 11/11/2009 16:13:31 B4 Video 444007.65 6015636.39 54.2855706110ºN 9.8601065642ºW 24.00 21.48 152.370º 1.57 DSCN3267 16:12:13 11/11/2009 16:13:47 B4 Video 444003.92 6015620.86 54.2854306994ºN 9.8601610421ºW 24.00 13.27 129.010º 1.22 DSCN3268 16:12:29 11/11/2009 16:13:56 B4 Video 444006.60 6015609.75 54.2853311429ºN 9.8601177766ºW 24.00 12.24 112.600º 1.46 DSCN3269 16:12:38 11/11/2009 16:14:07 B4 Video 444008.31 6015606.90 54.2853056611ºN 9.8600910091ºW 24.00 12.93 107.020º 0.8 DSCN3270 16:12:49 11/11/2009 16:14:17 B4 Video 444011.77 6015605.80 54.2852961596ºN 9.8600375383ºW 24.00 12.05 109.370º 0.79 DSCN3271 16:12:59 11/11/2009 16:14:54 B4 Video 444017.80 6015613.60 54.2853669585ºN 9.8599464362ºW 24.00 3.79 142.180º 0.24 DSCN3272 16:13:36 11/11/2009 16:15:07 B4 Video 444018.62 6015616.16 54.2853900184ºN 9.8599343504ºW 24.00 2.17 157.820º 0.47 DSCN3273 16:13:49 11/11/2009 16:15:25 B4 Video 444019.52 6015614.11 54.2853717065ºN 9.8599201404ºW 24.00 4.03 195.870º 1.48 DSCN3274 16:14:07 11/11/2009 16:15:49 B4 Video 444004.14 6015602.43 54.2852650507ºN 9.8601541854ºW 24.00 19.04 190.930º 1.58 DSCN3275 16:14:31

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:47






(m): Heading SOG

Knts Notes Approx.

Camera File Time

11/11/2009 16:22:32 B6 Video 443897.96 6016048.95 54.2892660346ºN 9.8618687390ºW 23.00 37.38 310.630º 1.79 DSCN3277 16:21:14 11/11/2009 16:24:32 B6 Video 443837.80 6016046.84 54.2892405348ºN 9.8627924326ºW 23.00 23.88 59.650º 2.21 DSCN3279 16:23:14 11/11/2009 16:25:19 B6 Video 443883.85 6016053.17 54.2893024429ºN 9.8620862988ºW 23.00 23.03 198.970º 2.29 DSCN3280 16:24:01 11/11/2009 16:25:31 B6 Video 443882.65 6016045.99 54.2892377908ºN 9.8621034204ºW 23.00 22.98 216.190º 0.95 DSCN3281 16:24:13 11/11/2009 16:25:47 B6 Video 443880.73 6016042.29 54.2892043223ºN 9.8621322413ºW 23.00 22.69 238.910º 0.66 DSCN3282 16:24:29 11/11/2009 16:25:56 B6 Video 443876.96 6016038.32 54.2891682618ºN 9.8621893076ºW 23.00 21.94 267.640º 1.17 DSCN3283 16:24:38 11/11/2009 16:26:22 B6 Video 443868.02 6016036.99 54.2891553066ºN 9.8623264119ºW 23.00 17.72 298.090º 0.78 DSCN3284 16:25:04 11/11/2009 16:26:42 B6 Video 443860.61 6016035.73 54.2891432012ºN 9.8624400643ºW 23.00 17.45 320.650º 0.09 DSCN3285 16:25:24 11/11/2009 16:27:56 B6 Video 443832.06 6016057.13 54.2893323237ºN 9.8628825630ºW 23.00 29.76 94.840º 1.03 DSCN3286 16:26:38 11/11/2009 16:28:35 B6 Video 443869.25 6016054.28 54.2893108480ºN 9.8623107692ºW 23.00 8.5 163.600º 2.5 DSCN3287 16:27:17 12/11/2009 08:32:30 C1 Video 441771.28 6015291.66 54.2822229201ºN 9.8943882274ºW 30.00 36.98 327.370º 1.21 DSCN3305 08:31:12 12/11/2009 08:32:42 C1 Video 441765.53 6015296.63 54.2822668692ºN 9.8944774338ºW 30.00 31.06 336.760º 1.39 DSCN3291 08:31:24 12/11/2009 08:32:58 C1 Video 441756.12 6015305.88 54.2823489197ºN 9.8946236891ºW 30.00 22.66 4.560º 1.2 DSCN3292 08:31:40 12/11/2009 08:33:08 C1 Video 441755.36 6015312.81 54.2824110948ºN 9.8946366989ºW 30.00 16.2 6.560º 1.64 DSCN3293 08:31:50 12/11/2009 08:33:30 C1 Video 441760.44 6015338.07 54.2826387344ºN 9.8945637018ºW 30.00 10.71 331.920º 1.85 DSCN3294 08:32:12 12/11/2009 08:33:44 C1 Video 441755.73 6015350.24 54.2827475654ºN 9.8946383695ºW 30.00 23.63 325.190º 1.66 DSCN3295 08:32:26 12/11/2009 08:41:39 C2 Video 442005.96 6015658.43 54.2855454704ºN 9.8908550087ºW 31.00 39.63 51.720º 1.38 DSCN3297 08:40:21 12/11/2009 08:41:47 C2 Video 442008.86 6015663.92 54.2855952018ºN 9.8908116339ºW 31.00 33.51 52.340º 1.3 DSCN3298 08:40:29 12/11/2009 08:41:55 C2 Video 442011.07 6015668.17 54.2856336431ºN 9.8907784853ºW 31.00 28.82 56.220º 1.31 DSCN3299 08:40:37 12/11/2009 08:42:03 C2 Video 442014.56 6015674.28 54.2856888943ºN 9.8907261180ºW 31.00 21.94 62.720º 1.34 DSCN3300 08:40:45 12/11/2009 08:42:13 C2 Video 442017.66 6015678.76 54.2857295226ºN 9.8906793087ºW 31.00 16.57 62.810º 1.09 DSCN3301 08:40:55 12/11/2009 08:42:24 C2 Video 442022.04 6015683.45 54.2857721393ºN 9.8906129624ºW 31.00 10.17 60.700º 1.15 DSCN3302 08:41:06 12/11/2009 08:42:34 C2 Video 442025.40 6015688.39 54.2858169421ºN 9.8905622374ºW 31.00 4.59 58.720º 1.1 DSCN3303 08:41:16 12/11/2009 08:42:42 C2 Video 442028.14 6015691.80 54.2858479192ºN 9.8905208873ºW 31.00 2.15 60.090º 1.19 DSCN3304 08:41:24 12/11/2009 08:42:50 C2 Video 442031.19 6015696.84 54.2858935830ºN 9.8904750088ºW 31.00 6.8 64.520º 1.34 DSCN3305 08:41:32 12/11/2009 08:43:00 C2 Video 442036.95 6015704.05 54.2859589780ºN 9.8903879838ºW 31.00 15.64 73.640º 1.58 DSCN3306 08:41:42 12/11/2009 08:43:09 C2 Video 442043.95 6015710.82 54.2860205779ºN 9.8902816878ºW 31.00 25.09 80.330º 1.65 DSCN3307 08:41:51 12/11/2009 08:43:21 C3 Video 442049.44 6015714.70 54.2860560605ºN 9.8901982427ºW 31.00 2.84 84.510º 1.42 DSCN3308 08:42:03 12/11/2009 08:43:31 C3 Video 442054.23 6015717.42 54.2860811258ºN 9.8901251837ºW 31.00 3.77 81.700º 1.12 DSCN3309 08:42:13

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:47






(m): Heading SOG

Knts Notes Approx.

Camera File Time

12/11/2009 08:43:41 C3 Video 442058.47 6015718.26 54.2860891584ºN 9.8900602416ºW 31.00 8.06 76.900º 0.97 DSCN3310 08:42:23 12/11/2009 08:43:51 C3 Video 442061.86 6015720.03 54.2861053903ºN 9.8900084646ºW 31.00 11.71 68.660º 0.93 DSCN3311 08:42:33 12/11/2009 08:44:01 C3 Video 442065.08 6015721.88 54.2861223940ºN 9.8899594178ºW 31.00 15.3 58.060º 0.88 DSCN3312 08:42:43 12/11/2009 08:44:19 C3 Video 442070.17 6015727.10 54.2861698446ºN 9.8898821287ºW 31.00 21.99 42.360º 0.82 DSCN3313 08:43:01 12/11/2009 08:44:43 C4 Video 442074.66 6015741.90 54.2863033564ºN 9.8898160620ºW 31.00 16.96 45.740º 1.17 DSCN3314 08:43:25 12/11/2009 08:44:53 C4 Video 442076.61 6015746.72 54.2863468940ºN 9.8897870652ºW 31.00 11.77 41.950º 1.06 DSCN3315 08:43:35 12/11/2009 08:45:03 C4 Video 442079.12 6015750.47 54.2863808869ºN 9.8897492777ºW 31.00 7.53 35.080º 0.86 DSCN3316 08:43:45 12/11/2009 08:45:18 C4 Video 442079.72 6015757.17 54.2864411618ºN 9.8897413053ºW 31.00 0.9 30.700º 0.92 DSCN3317 08:44:00 12/11/2009 08:45:28 C4 Video 442079.81 6015763.05 54.2864940777ºN 9.8897410162ºW 31.00 5.15 31.670º 1.25 DSCN3318 08:44:10 12/11/2009 08:45:36 C4 Video 442079.04 6015770.22 54.2865584021ºN 9.8897543182ºW 31.00 12.36 39.470º 1.19 DSCN3319 08:44:18 12/11/2009 08:45:46 C4 Video 442079.37 6015775.86 54.2866091255ºN 9.8897502494ºW 31.00 17.96 42.490º 1.07 DSCN3320 08:44:28 12/11/2009 08:45:56 C4 Video 442080.47 6015781.06 54.2866559247ºN 9.8897343932ºW 31.00 23.14 41.840º 1.01 DSCN3321 08:44:38 12/11/2009 08:46:08 C5 Video 442081.49 6015786.66 54.2867064233ºN 9.8897198640ºW 31.00 17.54 38.920º 0.85 DSCN3322 08:44:50 12/11/2009 08:49:01 C5 Video 442081.96 6015789.71 54.2867338296ºN 9.8897131838ºW 31.00 20.16 106.350º 1.27 DSCN3324 08:47:43 12/11/2009 08:49:08 C5 Video 442088.32 6015782.77 54.2866721960ºN 9.8896142617ºW 31.00 13.04 94.870º 1.17 DSCN3325 08:47:50 12/11/2009 08:49:18 C5 Video 442089.78 6015782.30 54.2866681254ºN 9.8895916605ºW 31.00 11.49 94.040º 0.95 DSCN3326 08:48:00 12/11/2009 08:49:46 C5 Video 442101.47 6015784.99 54.2866936401ºN 9.8894126693ºW 31.00 18.85 141.960º 1.03 DSCN3327 08:48:28 12/11/2009 08:49:56 C5 Video 442107.10 6015784.17 54.2866869616ºN 9.8893259542ºW 31.00 22.47 173.340º 1.13 DSCN3328 08:48:38 12/11/2009 08:50:06 C5 Video 442111.70 6015779.23 54.2866430310ºN 9.8892543427ºW 31.00 24.18 209.210º 1.31 DSCN3329 08:48:48 12/11/2009 08:50:17 C5 Video 442109.70 6015773.22 54.2865887910ºN 9.8892839450ºW 31.00 20.81 231.550º 0.99 DSCN3330 08:48:59 12/11/2009 08:50:35 C5 Video 442105.59 6015769.32 54.2865533148ºN 9.8893463168ºW 31.00 16.63 252.760º 0.92 DSCN3331 08:49:17 12/11/2009 08:50:45 C5 Video 442101.85 6015767.92 54.2865402759ºN 9.8894034508ºW 31.00 13.15 259.850º 0.79 DSCN3332 08:49:27 12/11/2009 08:51:21 C5 Video 442084.56 6015773.31 54.2865868103ºN 9.8896700818ºW 31.00 5.11 249.170º 0.96 DSCN3333 08:50:03 12/11/2009 08:51:33 C5 Video 442078.11 6015775.10 54.2866021309ºN 9.8897694617ºW 31.00 11.72 242.150º 0.98 DSCN3334 08:50:15 12/11/2009 09:00:35 C6 Video 442343.72 6016100.61 54.2895572901ºN 9.8857525748ºW 24.00 40.14 45.080º 0.78 DSCN3336 08:59:17

12/11/2009 09:00:45 C6 Video 442345.97 6016103.88 54.2895870071ºN 9.8857186556ºW 24.00 36.33 36.110º 1.13 DSCN3337 No photo-

miss fix 08:59:27 12/11/2009 09:01:11 C6 Video 442351.24 6016128.75 54.2898110357ºN 9.8856426208ºW 24.00 11.27 47.490º 1.55 ? 12/11/2009 09:01:20 C6 Video 442352.55 6016132.51 54.2898449633ºN 9.8856231257ºW 24.00 7.37 48.060º 1.37 DSCN3339 09:00:02

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:47






(m): Heading SOG

Knts Notes Approx.

Camera File Time

12/11/2009 09:01:28 C6 Video 442355.42 6016139.49 54.2899080346ºN 9.8855804869ºW 24.00 1.61 50.290º 1.59 DSCN3340 09:00:10 12/11/2009 09:01:38 C6 Video 442357.81 6016144.95 54.2899574074ºN 9.8855447059ºW 24.00 6.46 49.230º 1.36 ? 12/11/2009 09:01:48 C6 Video 442360.51 6016149.54 54.2899988991ºN 9.8855042456ºW 24.00 11.59 48.090º 1.2 DSCN3342 09:00:30 12/11/2009 09:02:02 C6 Video 442363.38 6016156.45 54.2900613591ºN 9.8854614136ºW 24.00 19.07 43.280º 0.89 DSCN3343 09:00:44 12/11/2009 09:19:43 D1 Video 440369.34 6016314.90 54.2912565012ºN 9.9161228966ºW 39 42.32 21.330º 0.81 DSCN3345 09:18:25 12/11/2009 09:19:53 D1 Video 440368.31 6016318.73 54.2912907404ºN 9.9161394244ºW 39 38.39 20.670º 0.82 DSCN3346 09:18:35 12/11/2009 09:20:01 D1 Video 440364.63 6016323.54 54.2913335829ºN 9.9161969070ºW 39 33.26 35.300º 0.64 DSCN3347 09:18:43 12/11/2009 09:20:16 D1 Video 440360.22 6016330.29 54.2913937371ºN 9.9162660501ºW 39 26.64 56.040º 0.58 DSCN3348 09:18:58 12/11/2009 09:20:24 D1 Video 440360.49 6016335.69 54.2914422960ºN 9.9162629686ºW 39 21.25 63.600º 0.73 DSCN3349 09:19:06 12/11/2009 09:20:36 D1 Video 440361.32 6016340.71 54.2914874535ºN 9.9162512540ºW 39 16.2 63.540º 0.86 DSCN3350 09:19:18 12/11/2009 09:20:46 D1 Video 440362.50 6016344.39 54.2915206724ºN 9.9162338091ºW 39 12.4 60.430º 0.89 DSCN3351 09:19:28 12/11/2009 09:20:56 D1 Video 440364.01 6016348.73 54.2915598097ºN 9.9162114319ºW 39 8.1 55.460º 1.12 DSCN3352 09:19:38 12/11/2009 09:21:04 D1 Video 440364.63 6016351.72 54.2915867577ºN 9.9162025811ºW 39 5.3 50.380º 0.93 ? 12/11/2009 09:21:10 D1 Video 440365.05 6016353.99 54.2916072593ºN 9.9161966215ºW 39 3.4 46.410º 0.97 DSCN3353 09:19:52 12/11/2009 09:21:18 D1 Video 440366.07 6016356.49 54.2916298455ºN 9.9161814489ºW 39 2.9 40.100º 1.06 DSCN3354 09:20:00 12/11/2009 09:21:28 D1 Video 440365.66 6016361.38 54.2916737515ºN 9.9161886019ºW 39 5.2 32.490º 1.09 DSCN3355 09:20:10 12/11/2009 09:21:38 D1 Video 440366.15 6016365.27 54.2917087001ºN 9.9161818360ºW 39 9.0 25.130º 1.08 DSCN3356 09:20:20 12/11/2009 09:27:29 D2 Video 440629.27 6016682.97 54.2945943444ºN 9.9122031283ºW 40.00 30.5 41.360º 1.27 DSCN3358 09:26:11 12/11/2009 09:27:43 D2 Video 440632.40 6016695.71 54.2947091732ºN 9.9121576167ºW 40.00 18.1 55.160º 1.79 DSCN3359 09:26:25 12/11/2009 09:27:57 D2 Video 440638.60 6016706.77 54.2948093110ºN 9.9120645944ºW 40.00 6.0 65.370º 1.54 DSCN3360 09:26:39 12/11/2009 09:28:07 D2 Video 440643.83 6016711.48 54.2948522468ºN 9.9119851835ºW 40.00 1.7 64.440º 1.28 DSCN3361 09:26:49 12/11/2009 09:28:18 D2 Video 440647.71 6016716.32 54.2948961689ºN 9.9119264718ºW 40.00 7.6 58.820º 1.19 DSCN3362 09:27:00 12/11/2009 09:28:28 D2 Video 440651.82 6016722.27 54.2949501271ºN 9.9118644714ºW 40.00 14.9 58.970º 1.43 DSCN3363 09:27:10 12/11/2009 09:28:38 D3 Video 440655.22 6016730.08 54.2950206593ºN 9.9118137932ºW 40.00 14.0 68.350º 1.62 DSCN3364 09:27:20 12/11/2009 09:28:52 D3 Video 440665.63 6016743.09 54.2951388294ºN 9.9116565276ºW 40.00 5.1 88.850º 1.99 DSCN3366 09:27:34

12/11/2009 09:29:02 D3 Video 440674.22 6016745.24 54.2951590928ºN 9.9115249257ºW 40.00 10.4 90.280º 1.68 DSCN3366 No

position 09:27:44

12/11/2009 09:29:13 D3 Video 440682.64 6016746.57 54.2951720749ºN 9.9113958360ºW 40.00 18.1 79.570º 1.28 DSCN3367 09:27:55

For in

spec

tion p

urpo

ses o

nly.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:47






(m): Heading SOG

Knts Notes Approx.

Camera File Time

12/11/2009 09:29:37 D3 Video 440694.00 6016748.89 54.2951942303ºN 9.9112217951ºW 40.00 29.4 56.670º 1.06 DSCN3368 09:28:19 12/11/2009 09:29:55 D4 Video 440700.07 6016752.73 54.2952294059ºN 9.9111292859ºW 40.00 24.1 36.400º 0.85 DSCN3369 09:28:37 12/11/2009 09:30:11 D4 Video 440702.12 6016757.27 54.2952704875ºN 9.9110987122ºW 40.00 20.0 19.400º 0.94 DSCN3370 09:28:53 12/11/2009 09:30:20 D4 Video 440701.33 6016760.91 54.2953031170ºN 9.9111116092ºW 40.00 16.2 15.670º 0.96 DSCN3371 09:29:02 12/11/2009 09:30:30 D4 Video 440699.34 6016765.53 54.2953443959ºN 9.9111430208ºW 40.00 11.3 12.640º 1.20 DSCN3372 09:29:12 12/11/2009 09:30:40 D4 Video 440694.76 6016771.12 54.2953940366ºN 9.9112144917ºW 40.00 6.4 30.720º 0.72 DSCN3373 09:29:22 12/11/2009 09:30:50 D4 Video 440691.37 6016775.82 54.2954359182ºN 9.9112676121ºW 40.00 6.5 48.240º 0.40 DSCN3374 09:29:32 12/11/2009 09:30:56 D4 Video 440689.98 6016780.07 54.2954739298ºN 9.9112897326ºW 40.00 8.5 59.360º 0.57 DSCN3375 09:29:38 12/11/2009 09:31:10 D4 Video 440687.23 6016790.08 54.2955636128ºN 9.9113339550ºW 40.00 17.0 83.400º 0.37 DSCN3376 09:29:52 12/11/2009 09:31:26 D5 Video 440689.18 6016797.05 54.2956264150ºN 9.9113054386ºW 41.00 19.1 115.940º 0.27 DSCN3377 09:30:08 12/11/2009 09:31:58 D5 Video 440702.52 6016791.78 54.2955806384ºN 9.9110993677ºW 41.00 5.0 133.190º 0.81 DSCN3378 09:30:40 12/11/2009 09:32:13 D5 Video 440707.63 6016783.97 54.2955110607ºN 9.9110194307ºW 41.00 4.5 126.690º 1.28 DSCN3379 09:30:55 12/11/2009 09:32:30 D5 Video 440712.46 6016773.78 54.2954200074ºN 9.9109431003ºW 41.00 15.8 114.640º 1.68 DSCN3380 09:31:12 12/11/2009 09:40:08 D6 Video 440988.29 6017105.24 54.2984305776ºN 9.9067710538ºW 41.00 36.1 66.180º 0.97 DSCN3382 09:38:50 12/11/2009 09:40:23 D6 Video 440991.00 6017110.13 54.2984748027ºN 9.9067304866ºW 41.00 31.4 62.330º 0.93 DSCN3383 09:39:05 12/11/2009 09:40:33 D6 Video 440993.25 6017113.10 54.2985018016ºN 9.9066964255ºW 41.00 28.9 51.340º 0.96 DSCN3384 09:39:15 12/11/2009 09:40:43 D6 Video 440994.05 6017116.08 54.2985286982ºN 9.9066847731ºW 41.00 26.2 42.930º 0.86 DSCN3385 09:39:25 12/11/2009 09:40:53 D6 Video 440994.99 6017119.48 54.2985593516ºN 9.9066709787ºW 41.00 23.3 36.230º 0.94 DSCN3386 09:39:35 12/11/2009 09:41:03 D6 Video 440994.95 6017122.93 54.2985903368ºN 9.9066723268ºW 41.00 20.1 32.310º 1.03 DSCN3387 09:39:45 12/11/2009 09:41:17 D6 Video 440993.33 6017130.28 54.2986561587ºN 9.9066985923ºW 41.00 12.8 31.660º 1.00 DSCN3388 09:39:59 12/11/2009 09:41:25 D6 Video 440992.50 6017133.40 54.2986841026ºN 9.9067120454ºW 41.00 9.8 32.720º 0.80 DSCN3389 09:40:07 12/11/2009 09:41:35 D6 Video 440990.78 6017137.14 54.2987174874ºN 9.9067392271ºW 41.00 5.8 31.880º 0.72 DSCN3390 09:40:17 12/11/2009 09:41:45 D6 Video 440988.52 6017140.38 54.2987463561ºN 9.9067745238ºW 41.00 2.0 29.750º 0.82 DSCN3391 09:40:27 12/11/2009 09:41:53 D6 Video 440986.77 6017143.43 54.2987735880ºN 9.9068020568ºW 41.00 2.2 29.110º 0.74 DSCN3392 09:40:35 12/11/2009 09:42:05 D6 Video 440984.73 6017147.07 54.2988060461ºN 9.9068340000ºW 41.00 6.1 27.240º 0.78 DSCN3393 09:40:47 12/11/2009 09:42:12 D6 Video 440982.46 6017150.70 54.2988384510ºN 9.9068696025ºW 41.00 10.1 26.670º 0.71 DSCN3394 09:40:54 12/11/2009 10:01:32 E1 Video 439012.82 6017319.63 54.3001251318ºN 9.9371654711ºW 45.00 29.7 41.910º 1.20 DSCN3396 10:00:14 12/11/2009 10:01:50 E1 Video 439011.83 6017335.92 54.3002714125ºN 9.9371839343ºW 45.00 14.2 59.530º 1.30 DSCN3397 10:00:32 12/11/2009 10:01:58 E1 Video 439012.94 6017340.79 54.3003152877ºN 9.9371678848ºW 45.00 9.4 61.740º 1.13 DSCN3398 10:00:40

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:47






(m): Heading SOG

Knts Notes Approx.

Camera File Time

12/11/2009 10:02:08 E1 Video 439015.38 6017347.99 54.3003803582ºN 9.9371318213ºW 45.00 2.4 67.370º 1.32 DSCN3399 10:00:50 12/11/2009 10:02:19 E1 Video 439017.23 6017352.69 54.3004227857ºN 9.9371044578ºW 45.00 3.8 67.600º 1.04 DSCN3400 10:01:01 12/11/2009 10:02:27 E1 Video 439018.87 6017356.82 54.3004600427ºN 9.9370799938ºW 45.00 8.0 65.720º 1.14 DSCN3401 10:01:09 12/11/2009 10:02:35 E1 Video 439020.50 6017360.02 54.3004890468ºN 9.9370556124ºW 45.00 11.5 61.710º 0.99 DSCN3402 10:01:17 12/11/2009 10:09:56 E2 Video 439278.01 6017690.36 54.3034882411ºN 9.9331662885ºW 47.00 25.2 70.040º 0.85 DSCN3405 10:08:38 12/11/2009 10:10:10 E2 Video 439279.63 6017694.14 54.3035223999ºN 9.9331422183ºW 47.00 21.3 60.360º 0.85 DSCN3406 10:08:52 12/11/2009 10:10:18 E2 Video 439280.36 6017698.52 54.3035618247ºN 9.9331318878ºW 47.00 17.0 62.690º 0.86 DSCN3407 10:09:00 12/11/2009 10:10:29 E2 Video 439280.34 6017702.15 54.3035944207ºN 9.9331328503ºW 47.00 13.3 62.590º 0.75 DSCN3408 10:09:11 12/11/2009 10:10:39 E2 Video 439279.89 6017705.58 54.3036252436ºN 9.9331405298ºW 47.00 9.9 59.060º 0.98 DSCN3409 10:09:21 12/11/2009 10:10:49 E2 Video 439280.31 6017708.57 54.3036521028ºN 9.9331346107ºW 47.00 6.9 51.410º 0.88 DSCN3410 10:09:31 12/11/2009 10:10:57 E2 Video 439279.96 6017712.51 54.3036874677ºN 9.9331407825ºW 47.00 3.0 50.100º 0.94 DSCN3411 10:09:39 12/11/2009 10:11:07 E2 Video 439280.24 6017720.99 54.3037637534ºN 9.9331381864ºW 47.00 5.5 61.810º 1.45 ? 12/11/2009 10:11:30 E3 Video 439295.28 6017739.81 54.3039346754ºN 9.9329110558ºW 47.00 9.5 95.690º 1.37 DSCN3413 10:10:12 12/11/2009 10:11:40 E3 Video 439299.28 6017741.04 54.3039461909ºN 9.9328497297ºW 47.00 6.1 88.190º 0.91 DSCN3414 10:10:22 12/11/2009 10:11:50 E3 Video 439302.02 6017742.10 54.3039560637ºN 9.9328078530ºW 47.00 4.7 78.080º 0.95 DSCN3415 10:10:32 12/11/2009 10:12:00 E3 Video 439304.57 6017743.07 54.3039650159ºN 9.9327688337ºW 47.00 4.3 66.350º 0.87 DSCN3416 10:10:42 12/11/2009 10:12:10 E3 Video 439306.97 6017745.71 54.3039890714ºN 9.9327325414ºW 47.00 5.0 56.990º 1.11 DSCN3417 10:10:52 12/11/2009 10:12:23 E3 Video 439308.26 6017751.28 54.3040392768ºN 9.9327137934ºW 47.00 7.9 61.380º 0.65 DSCN3418 10:11:05 12/11/2009 10:12:31 E3 Video 439308.09 6017756.93 54.3040899877ºN 9.9327175597ºW 47.00 12.0 72.840º 0.60 DSCN3419 10:11:13 12/11/2009 10:13:05 E4 Video 439327.27 6017774.22 54.3042477000ºN 9.9324264675ºW 48.00 13.8 93.200º 1.11 DSCN3420 10:11:47 12/11/2009 10:13:19 E4 Video 439330.62 6017776.84 54.3042716144ºN 9.9323755121ºW 48.00 10.4 85.830º 0.67 DSCN3421 10:12:01 12/11/2009 10:13:37 E4 Video 439332.32 6017778.05 54.3042827045ºN 9.9323495541ºW 48.00 9.2 64.100º 0.79 DSCN3422 10:12:19 12/11/2009 10:13:53 E4 Video 439334.32 6017780.68 54.3043065201ºN 9.9323193640ºW 48.00 7.0 44.010º 0.95 DSCN3423 10:12:35 12/11/2009 10:14:03 E4 Video 439334.71 6017783.37 54.3043308024ºN 9.9323139517ºW 48.00 4.8 35.720º 0.90 DSCN3424 10:12:45 12/11/2009 10:14:13 E4 Video 439332.46 6017788.55 54.3043770538ºN 9.9323495113ºW 48.00 1.5 41.670º 0.80 DSCN3425 10:12:55 12/11/2009 10:14:21 E4 Video 439331.17 6017793.18 54.3044185385ºN 9.9323702964ºW 48.00 6.0 48.130º 0.85 DSCN3426 10:13:03 12/11/2009 10:14:35 E5 Video 439331.77 6017805.83 54.3045323010ºN 9.9323637186ºW 48.00 10.9 69.250º 1.05 DSCN3427 10:13:17 12/11/2009 10:14:45 E5 Video 439333.12 6017811.94 54.3045873157ºN 9.9323442099ºW 48.00 15.8 77.780º 0.94 DSCN3428 10:13:27 12/11/2009 10:14:55 E5 Video 439334.75 6017815.93 54.3046234031ºN 9.9323199004ºW 48.00 19.3 75.380º 1.01 DSCN3429 10:13:37

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:47






(m): Heading SOG

Knts Notes Approx.

Camera File Time

12/11/2009 10:18:06 E5 Video 439332.90 6017780.97 54.3043090007ºN 9.9323413141ºW 48.00 16.8 106.740º 1.14 DSCN3431 10:16:48 12/11/2009 10:18:35 E5 Video 439346.49 6017773.68 54.3042450758ºN 9.9321309673ºW 48.00 24.7 53.390º 0.84 DSCN3432 10:17:17 12/11/2009 10:18:47 E5 Video 439348.29 6017774.67 54.3042541775ºN 9.9321035634ºW 48.00 24.5 45.290º 0.46 DSCN3433 10:17:29 12/11/2009 10:19:26 E5 Video 439341.20 6017783.21 54.3043301290ºN 9.9322141431ºW 48.00 14.1 53.850º 0.66 DSCN3434 10:18:08 12/11/2009 10:19:34 E5 Video 439340.35 6017787.40 54.3043676582ºN 9.9322281127ºW 48.00 9.8 56.180º 0.76 DSCN3435 10:18:16 12/11/2009 10:19:56 E5 Video 439339.43 6017795.24 54.3044379882ºN 9.9322438878ºW 48.00 2.1 49.040º 0.96 DSCN3436 10:18:38 12/11/2009 10:20:06 E5 Video 439339.42 6017798.78 54.3044697959ºN 9.9322446805ºW 48.00 2.3 41.610º 0.94 DSCN3437 10:18:48 12/11/2009 10:20:22 E5 Video 439338.40 6017805.65 54.3045314502ºN 9.9322618187ºW 48.00 8.7 34.750º 1.11 DSCN3438 10:19:04 12/11/2009 10:20:42 E5 Video 439335.89 6017816.35 54.3046272826ºN 9.9323025590ºW 48.00 19.6 36.020º 0.97 DSCN3439 10:19:24 12/11/2009 10:27:53 E6 Video 439605.11 6018124.76 54.3074306487ºN 9.9282280999ºW 49.00 38.9 42.780º 0.68 DSCN3441 10:26:35 12/11/2009 10:28:11 E6 Video 439601.05 6018132.98 54.3075040605ºN 9.9282921560ºW 49.00 30.4 60.920º 0.40 DSCN3442 10:26:53 12/11/2009 10:28:28 E6 Video 439598.11 6018138.57 54.3075538803ºN 9.9283384398ºW 49.00 24.9 69.230º 0.65 DSCN3443 10:27:10 12/11/2009 10:28:38 E6 Video 439597.58 6018141.94 54.3075841037ºN 9.9283472605ºW 49.00 21.6 68.420º 0.56 DSCN3444 10:27:20 12/11/2009 10:28:50 E6 Video 439598.41 6018145.46 54.3076158255ºN 9.9283351966ºW 49.00 18.0 61.350º 0.75 DSCN3445 10:27:32 12/11/2009 10:29:04 E6 Video 439598.65 6018148.81 54.3076459838ºN 9.9283322080ºW 49.00 14.7 49.570º 0.89 DSCN3446 10:27:46 12/11/2009 10:29:33 E6 Video 439597.38 6018161.96 54.3077639889ºN 9.9283543778ºW 49.00 3.4 44.990º 1.07 DSCN3447 10:28:15 12/11/2009 10:29:51 E6 Video 439596.55 6018172.38 54.3078575201ºN 9.9283691990ºW 49.00 9.8 50.820º 0.99 DSCN3448 10:28:33 12/11/2009 10:30:01 E6 Video 439596.61 6018177.26 54.3079014388ºN 9.9283693320ºW 49.00 14.4 50.610º 0.99 DSCN3449 10:28:43 12/11/2009 10:30:11 E6 Video 439596.46 6018182.99 54.3079528958ºN 9.9283726697ºW 49.00 20.0 51.540º 0.98 DSCN3450 10:28:53 12/11/2009 10:52:08 F1 Video 437725.40 6018271.43 54.3085229609ºN 9.9571440524ºW 45.00 30.1 75.190º 0.84 DSCN3452 10:50:50 12/11/2009 10:52:25 F1 Video 437727.46 6018277.19 54.3085749561ºN 9.9571135473ºW 45.00 24.3 72.370º 0.89 DSCN3453 10:51:07 12/11/2009 10:52:43 F1 Video 437730.40 6018282.72 54.3086250297ºN 9.9570696583ºW 45.00 19.2 65.330º 0.88 DSCN3454 10:51:25 12/11/2009 10:52:57 F1 Video 437731.11 6018286.82 54.3086619249ºN 9.9570595561ºW 45.00 15.4 59.340º 0.75 DSCN3455 10:51:39 12/11/2009 10:53:11 F1 Video 437730.88 6018288.37 54.3086758586ºN 9.9570633724ºW 45.00 13.8 45.220º 0.78 DSCN3456 10:51:53 12/11/2009 10:53:23 F1 Video 437729.26 6018291.20 54.3087010652ºN 9.9570889225ºW 45.00 10.7 49.210º 0.32 DSCN3457 10:52:05 12/11/2009 10:53:43 F1 Video 437725.88 6018302.03 54.3087979972ºN 9.9571430611ºW 45.00 0.8 74.880º 0.55 DSCN3458 10:52:25 12/11/2009 10:53:57 F1 Video 437726.31 6018307.67 54.3088487035ºN 9.9571376845ºW 45.00 6.2 82.430º 0.47 DSCN3459 10:52:39 12/11/2009 10:54:07 F1 Video 437727.60 6018310.88 54.3088777122ºN 9.9571184660ºW 45.00 9.5 83.180º 0.56 DSCN3460 10:52:49 12/11/2009 10:54:17 F1 Video 437728.68 6018314.60 54.3089112938ºN 9.9571027109ºW 45.00 13.3 82.740º 0.93 DSCN3461 10:52:59

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:47






(m): Heading SOG

Knts Notes Approx.

Camera File Time

12/11/2009 11:02:02 F2 Video 437980.47 6018646.95 54.3119284914ºN 9.9533023477ºW 47.00 25.8 52.170º 0.99 DSCN3463 11:00:44 12/11/2009 11:02:14 F2 Video 437980.97 6018652.90 54.3119820319ºN 9.9532959204ºW 47.00 19.8 49.890º 0.97 DSCN3464 11:00:56 12/11/2009 11:02:35 F2 Video 437980.04 6018666.03 54.3120999030ºN 9.9533128420ºW 47.00 7.0 78.230º 0.61 DSCN3465 11:01:17 12/11/2009 11:02:45 F2 Video 437981.44 6018671.08 54.3121454042ºN 9.9532923508ºW 47.00 1.8 92.800º 0.67 DSCN3466 11:01:27 12/11/2009 11:02:55 F2 Video 437983.95 6018675.00 54.3121809656ºN 9.9532546266ºW 47.00 2.9 100.130º 0.66 DSCN3467 11:01:37 12/11/2009 11:03:05 F2 Video 437986.26 6018677.59 54.3122045394ºN 9.9532197637ºW 47.00 6.4 102.750º 0.66 DSCN3468 11:01:47 12/11/2009 11:03:17 F2 Video 437990.96 6018678.87 54.3122165569ºN 9.9531477108ºW 47.00 10.8 100.730º 0.73 DSCN3469 11:01:59 12/11/2009 11:03:34 F2 Video 437996.79 6018680.89 54.3122354198ºN 9.9530584959ºW 47.00 16.8 93.910º 0.91 DSCN3470 11:02:16 12/11/2009 11:04:00 F3 Video 438001.17 6018683.86 54.3122626578ºN 9.9529918454ºW 47.00 18.1 74.240º 0.75 DSCN3471 11:02:42 12/11/2009 11:04:16 F3 Video 438002.20 6018685.63 54.3122786526ºN 9.9529763447ºW 47.00 16.3 59.540º 0.66 DSCN3472 11:02:58 12/11/2009 11:04:30 F3 Video 438004.38 6018687.16 54.3122927242ºN 9.9529431466ºW 47.00 14.9 44.360º 0.71 DSCN3473 11:03:12 12/11/2009 11:04:42 F3 Video 438004.16 6018691.86 54.3123348846ºN 9.9529475016ºW 47.00 10.2 51.170º 0.52 DSCN3474 11:03:24 12/11/2009 11:04:52 F3 Video 438002.55 6018696.64 54.3123776375ºN 9.9529732354ºW 47.00 5.3 63.460º 0.42 DSCN3475 11:03:34 12/11/2009 11:05:02 F3 Video 438001.63 6018701.56 54.3124217526ºN 9.9529883970ºW 47.00 0.9 77.530º 0.26 DSCN3476 11:03:44 12/11/2009 11:05:12 F3 Video 438004.87 6018706.01 54.3124621437ºN 9.9529395971ºW 47.00 4.7 86.460º 0.95 DSCN3477 11:03:54 12/11/2009 11:05:17 F3 Video 438007.60 6018709.35 54.3124925235ºN 9.9528983431ºW 47.00 9.0 90.390º 0.85 DSCN3478 11:03:59 12/11/2009 11:05:37 F3 Video 438014.97 6018712.52 54.3125218319ºN 9.9527857594ºW 47.00 16.4 89.230º 1.06 DSCN3479 11:04:19 12/11/2009 11:06:15 F4 Video 438028.18 6018719.70 54.3125880254ºN 9.9525841965ºW 48.00 23.9 70.440º 0.88 DSCN3480 11:04:57 12/11/2009 11:06:31 F4 Video 438030.68 6018723.62 54.3126234872ºN 9.9525465853ºW 48.00 19.9 62.310º 0.76 DSCN3481 11:05:13 12/11/2009 11:06:51 F4 Video 438033.58 6018728.65 54.3126690396ºN 9.9525030769ºW 48.00 15.1 46.450º 0.75 DSCN3482 11:05:33 12/11/2009 11:07:15 F4 Video 438032.36 6018737.58 54.3127491967ºN 9.9525235669ºW 48.00 6.1 61.910º 0.44 DSCN3483 11:05:57 12/11/2009 11:07:32 F4 Video 438033.36 6018747.03 54.3128342042ºN 9.9525101951ºW 48.00 4.4 93.120º 0.54 DSCN3484 11:06:14 12/11/2009 11:07:42 F5 Video 438036.34 6018750.78 54.3128682823ºN 9.9524652738ºW 48.00 5.2 102.270º 0.62 DSCN3485 11:06:24 12/11/2009 11:07:54 F5 Video 438038.94 6018753.64 54.3128942877ºN 9.9524258447ºW 48.00 1.6 107.100º 0.54 DSCN3486 11:06:36 12/11/2009 11:08:06 F5 Video 438041.42 6018755.57 54.3129119790ºN 9.9523881418ºW 48.00 2.4 106.630º 0.47 DSCN3487 11:06:48 12/11/2009 11:08:16 F5 Video 438043.18 6018756.31 54.3129187881ºN 9.9523612383ºW 48.00 4.3 98.520º 0.79 DSCN3488 11:06:58 12/11/2009 11:08:29 F5 Video 438045.75 6018756.03 54.3129165896ºN 9.9523216744ºW 48.00 6.8 76.390º 0.95 DSCN3489 11:07:11 12/11/2009 11:08:41 F5 Video 438049.19 6018757.41 54.3129294028ºN 9.9522691672ºW 48.00 10.4 60.270º 0.99 DSCN3490 11:07:23 12/11/2009 11:16:12 F6 Video 438292.00 6019101.77 54.3160533005ºN 9.9486084599ºW 50.00 24.7 61.960º 0.86 DSCN3492 11:14:54

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:47






(m): Heading SOG

Knts Notes Approx.

Camera File Time

12/11/2009 11:16:29 F6 Video 438292.29 6019106.81 54.3160985948ºN 9.9486051576ºW 50.00 19.6 55.190º 0.84 No photo-miss fix 12/11/2009 11:16:47 F6 Video 438292.91 6019116.01 54.3161813607ºN 9.9485974603ºW 50.00 10.4 60.480º 0.88 DSCN3493 11:15:29 12/11/2009 11:16:59 F6 Video 438293.43 6019122.90 54.3162433753ºN 9.9485908350ºW 50.00 3.6 63.720º 1.14 DSCN3494 11:15:41 12/11/2009 11:17:09 F6 Video 438295.30 6019128.81 54.3162966852ºN 9.9485634343ºW 50.00 2.6 66.320º 1.10 DSCN3495 11:15:51 12/11/2009 11:17:16 F6 Video 438298.00 6019135.66 54.3163585830ºN 9.9485232259ºW 50.00 8.9 66.920º 1.01 DSCN3496 11:15:58 12/11/2009 11:17:30 F6 Video 438299.26 6019139.66 54.3163946432ºN 9.9485048201ºW 50.00 14.1 66.720º 0.97 DSCN3497 11:16:12

For

insp

ectio

n pur

pose

s only

.

Conse

nt of

copy

right

owne

r req

uired

for a

ny ot

her u

se.

EPA Export 12-11-2014:23:36:47

Documents

For inspection purposes only. NEARSHORE PIPELINE ...starfish Asteria rubens and a fish of the family Cottidae are present.....28 Figure 4.15: Station C6: Hard substrate showing encrusting