18
1 QDT 2011 S hade and translucency matching are fundamen- tal aspects in esthetic dentistry. The ultimate goal is to create tooth-like restorations; however, natural teeth also show fluorescence, which must be simulated to achieve ideal esthetic results. Fluorescence is defined as luminescence that oc- curs when energy is supplied by electromagnetic ra- diation, usually via ultraviolet (UV) light. The energy source transfers an electron of an atom from a lower energy state to a higher, “excited” energy state. The electron releases energy in the form of light (lumines- cence) when it falls back to a lower energy state. Fluo- rescent substances absorb the UV light and the re-emit it almost instantaneously. Since some energy is lost in this process, the emitted light has a longer wavelength than the absorbed radiation, which makes this light visible and causes the material to “glow.” FLUORESCENCE OF NATURAL TEETH In 1911, Stubel 1 was the first to describe the fluores- cence of natural teeth under UV light (λ max = 450 nm). 2 In 1953, Hartles and Leaver 3 further examined the flu- orescence of different tooth structures and reported that enamel exhibits “normal” fluorescence with a blu- ish white appearance, occasionally tinged with yellow. They also confirmed findings by Benedict 4 in 1928 that dentin has much greater fluorescent properties than Fluorescence—Mimicking Nature for Ultimate Esthetics in Implant Dentistry Iñaki Gamborena, DMD, MSD, FID 1 Markus B. Blatz, DMD, PhD 2 1 Clinical Assistant Professor, Department of Preventive and Re- storative Sciences, University of Pennsylvania School of Dental Medicine, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA; Private Practice, San Sebastian, Spain. 2 Professor and Chairman, Department of Preventive and Restor- ative Sciences, University of Pennsylvania School of Dental Medi- cine, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA. Correspondence to: Dr Iñaki Gamborena, Resureccion Mª de Azkue, 6 20018 San Sebastian, Spain. Email: [email protected] ©2011 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY. NO PART OF THIS ARTICLE MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.

Fluorescence—Mimicking Nature for Ultimate Esthetics in ... · The goal of esthetic restorative dentistry is to mimic the optical properties of natural teeth. However, the fluorescence

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    2

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Fluorescence—Mimicking Nature for Ultimate Esthetics in ... · The goal of esthetic restorative dentistry is to mimic the optical properties of natural teeth. However, the fluorescence

1 QDT 2011

Shade and translucency matching are fundamen-tal aspects in esthetic dentistry. The ultimate goal is to create tooth-like restorations; however,

natural teeth also show fluorescence, which must be simulated to achieve ideal esthetic results.

Fluorescence is defined as luminescence that oc-curs when energy is supplied by electromagnetic ra-diation, usually via ultraviolet (UV) light. The energy source transfers an electron of an atom from a lower energy state to a higher, “excited” energy state. The

electron releases energy in the form of light (lumines-cence) when it falls back to a lower energy state. Fluo-rescent substances absorb the UV light and the re-emit it almost instantaneously. Since some energy is lost in this process, the emitted light has a longer wavelength than the absorbed radiation, which makes this light visible and causes the material to “glow.”

FLUORESCENCE OF NATURAL TEETHIn 1911, Stubel1 was the first to describe the fluores-cence of natural teeth under UV light (λmax = 450 nm).2 In 1953, Hartles and Leaver3 further examined the flu-orescence of different tooth structures and reported that enamel exhibits “normal” fluorescence with a blu-ish white appearance, occasionally tinged with yellow. They also confirmed findings by Benedict4 in 1928 that dentin has much greater fluorescent properties than

Fluorescence—Mimicking Nature for Ultimate Esthetics in Implant Dentistry

Iñaki Gamborena, DMD, MSD, FID1 Markus B. Blatz, DMD, PhD2

1 Clinical Assistant Professor, Department of Preventive and Re-storative Sciences, University of Pennsylvania School of Dental Medicine, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA; Private Practice, San Sebastian, Spain.

2 Professor and Chairman, Department of Preventive and Restor-ative Sciences, University of Pennsylvania School of Dental Medi-cine, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA.

Correspondence to: Dr Iñaki Gamborena, Resureccion Mª de Azkue, 6 20018 San Sebastian, Spain. Email: [email protected]

©2011 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY. NO PART OF THIS ARTICLE MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.

Page 2: Fluorescence—Mimicking Nature for Ultimate Esthetics in ... · The goal of esthetic restorative dentistry is to mimic the optical properties of natural teeth. However, the fluorescence

GAMBORENA/BLATZ

QDT 2011 2©2011 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY. NO PART OF THIS ARTICLE MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.

enamel. This greater fluorescence is due to the higher organic content of dentin.3,5,6 Color is most intense in the apical regions, particularly in immature teeth with open apices.3 Cementum shows similar fluorescence to dentin, but less intense. Carious enamel does not provide fluorescence, and the carious areas appear black.7–9 Even the initial whitish patches will lose their fluorescence. Carious dentin also lacks fluorescence and appears black or dark brown under UV light.7,8 The fluorescent intensity of dentin increases with age.

Fluorometric investigations revealed that a complex of cross-linked collagen with hydroxyapatite is a pos-sible fluorescing compound within the tooth tissue.2,6

When the organic structure of a tooth is affected by, for example, caries or pulpal necrosis, the tooth loses its vitality under both natural and UV light and appears dark brown. Therefore, less fluorescence correlates with lesser value. This effect, however, can be reversed in natural teeth using internal tooth bleaching (Case 1, Figs 1 to 6).

Due to the differences between sound and carious tooth structures, fluorescence is increasingly used for reliable and noninvasive caries detection.9–12 It even serves as a screening method for oral cancer since abnormal oral mucosal lesions appear dark brown or black under UV light.13

1 2 3

6

54

Fig 1 Preoperative view of the discol-ored maxillary left central incisor due to necrosis.

Fig 2 Intraoral preoperative view under UV light. The discolored tooth shows poor fluorescence.

Fig 3 Intraoral preoperative view un-der natural light.

Fig 4 Extraoral view after internal bleaching of the left central incisor.

Fig 5 Extraoral view after internal bleaching under UV light.

Fig 6 Final intraoral view.

CASE 1

Page 3: Fluorescence—Mimicking Nature for Ultimate Esthetics in ... · The goal of esthetic restorative dentistry is to mimic the optical properties of natural teeth. However, the fluorescence

Fluorescence—Mimicking Nature for Ultimate Esthetics in Implant Dentistry

QDT 2011 3©2011 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY. NO PART OF THIS ARTICLE MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.

FLUORESCENCE OF DENTAL MATERIALSThe goal of esthetic restorative dentistry is to mimic the optical properties of natural teeth. However, the fluorescence of natural teeth is greatly overlooked in restorative dental materials. Fluorescence adds to the vitality of a restoration and minimizes the metameric effect between teeth and restorative materials under various light conditions.

Modern composite resins used for anterior tooth restorations contain fluorescent pigments to simulate the lively expression of natural teeth in all types of light.14–16 Many modern composite resins have fluo-rescence wavelength peaks of 440 to 450 nm, which is comparable to natural dentin.14,15 However, there is still a considerable variation in fluorescence between different composite systems and between some com-posite resins and natural teeth.

Modern veneering porcelains and ceramic coping materials are intended to mimic the optical qualities of natural teeth (Fig 7): translucency, color (hue, chroma, value), fluorescence, and opalescence. These charac-

teristics are not only crucial for the restoration itself, but also to reduce the “shadowing effect” at the restor-ative-gingival interface and to provide a healthy-looking gingival architecture. In fact, the creation of an incon-spicuous dental restoration starts with well-designed prosthetic contours and natural, healthy integration within the surrounding soft tissues. Feldspathic veneer-ing porcelains typically contain particles that provide fluorescence.17 It is important that all components of a porcelain system, including opaquers, dentin, enamel, stains, and even glazing agents, are fluorescent. How-ever, fluorescence is often not homogenous within the same porcelain system or among different systems.17 Various techniques and components have been sug-gested to achieve natural-looking fluorescence.18–20

Proper positioning of varying degrees of fluores-cence on the tooth is crucial for natural esthetics. Roots and dentin reveal the strongest fluorescence, while enamel shows the weakest. Figure 8 demonstrates tooth characteristics under various light conditions. Veneering porcelain powders reveal different opaci-ties, translucencies, and fluorescence under transmit-ted light (Fig 9) and UV light (Fig 10).

Fig 7 Cross sections of natural teeth viewed with a polarizing filter.

Fig 8 Tooth characteristics under various light condi-tions.

Fig 9 Optical characteristics of different veneering porce-lains under transmitted light.

Fig 10 Fluorescence of different veneering porcelains.

Page 4: Fluorescence—Mimicking Nature for Ultimate Esthetics in ... · The goal of esthetic restorative dentistry is to mimic the optical properties of natural teeth. However, the fluorescence

GAMBORENA/BLATZ

QDT 2011 4©2011 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY. NO PART OF THIS ARTICLE MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.

Porcelain Laminate Veneers

Case 2 (Figs 11 to 14) depicts porcelain laminate ve-neers that were placed on two central incisors over 10 years ago, exhibiting a favorable blend with the natural dentition under natural and UV light. In such

an ideal situation, the abutment color already provides the total value of the final restoration, and only dif-ferent chromatic dentin and incisal layers are needed. Differences in opacity and translucency as well as the reduced degree of fluorescence among enamel, den-tin, and shoulder porcelain are apparent.

CASE 2

13 14

11 12

Fig 11 Extraoral view of the central incisors restored with feldspathic porcelain.

Fig 12 Feldspathic porcelain restorations under UV light.

Fig 13 Periapical radiograph.

Fig 14 Ten-year follow-up view.

Page 5: Fluorescence—Mimicking Nature for Ultimate Esthetics in ... · The goal of esthetic restorative dentistry is to mimic the optical properties of natural teeth. However, the fluorescence

Fluorescence—Mimicking Nature for Ultimate Esthetics in Implant Dentistry

QDT 2011 5©2011 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY. NO PART OF THIS ARTICLE MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.

Full-Coverage Crowns

Case 3 (Figs 15 to 30) demonstrates the use of den-tal ceramics for full-coverage restorations. Selection of the coping material was the first step because even different metal-oxide ceramics (eg, alumina and zirco-nia) provide considerably different optical properties (Figs 21 and 23). Alumina (Procera, Nobel Biocare, Gothenburg, Sweden) was ultimately selected as the coping material due to its favorable esthetic properties. Fluorescence was controlled through liners, shoulder

ceramics, and internal stains, which were applied in the gingival area to support light distribution and optimal integration with the highly fluorescent dentin tooth structure (Fig 24). The importance of the shoulder loca-tion in the gingival area is obvious under UV light (Fig 25). Light is distributed to the surrounding structures and soft tissues, such as marginal gingiva and papillae. Dentin ceramic masses were applied in different chro-mas and saturations toward the incisal aspect of the tooth. The incisal third of a natural tooth features the highest degree of translucency. The actual tooth shade

Fig 20 Try-in of the alumina coping under UV light.

Fig 21 Alumina coping under UV light at different stages of veneering porcelain application.

Fig 15 Preoperative intraoral view. Removal of the porcelain-fused-to-metal crown on the maxillary left cen-tral incisor revealed a severely discol-ored abutment tooth.

Fig 16 Alumina versus zirconia cop-ings with and without fluorescence: (a) alumina, (b) alumina with fluores-cent internal staining, (c) zirconia, (d) zirconia infiltrated with fluorescence.

Fig 17 Try-in of the alumina coping.

Fig 18 Alumina versus zirconia cop-ings with and without fluorescence under UV light: (a) alumina, (b) alumi-na with fluorescent internal staining, (c) zirconia, (d) zirconia infiltrated with fluorescence.

Fig 19 Try-in of the alumina coping with a porcelain shoulder.

171615

18 19

CASE 3

Page 6: Fluorescence—Mimicking Nature for Ultimate Esthetics in ... · The goal of esthetic restorative dentistry is to mimic the optical properties of natural teeth. However, the fluorescence

GAMBORENA/BLATZ

QDT 2011 6©2011 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY. NO PART OF THIS ARTICLE MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.

is achieved through the colors at the center of the tooth to simulate the natural core dentin. After a full-contour build up, cutback was performed in an irregular manner to enhance internal effects. Enamel mixtures with bluish opalescent translucent powders were applied to pro-vide a more vivid restoration. Some teeth have distinct mamelons, which are typically located underneath the natural enamel and are more opaque than normal den-tin and highly fluorescent. Mamelons should be placed

between the enamel and the transparent layers. The final shape is typically completed using a few translu-cent characteristics or transparent enamel powders to provide the impression of depth. Translucent materi-als should always receive minimal firing to protect the characteristics of a natural-looking restoration. Surface texture and luster intensity may affect reflective features of the restoration and should ultimately be the respon-sibility of the clinician.

Fig 22 Intraoperative view of the bleached abutment tooth during crown preparation.

Fig 23 Fluorescence of the bleached abutment tooth under UV light.

Fig 24 Definitive alumina-based crown after cementation.

Fig 25 The crown exhibits the same fluorescence as the neighboring natural teeth under UV light.

22

24

23

25

Page 7: Fluorescence—Mimicking Nature for Ultimate Esthetics in ... · The goal of esthetic restorative dentistry is to mimic the optical properties of natural teeth. However, the fluorescence

Fluorescence—Mimicking Nature for Ultimate Esthetics in Implant Dentistry

QDT 2011 7©2011 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY. NO PART OF THIS ARTICLE MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.

26

28

30

27

29

Fig 26 Preoperative view of porcelain-fused-to-metal crown.

Fig 27 Preoperative periapical radiograph.

Fig 28 Extraoral view of the alumina crown.

Fig 29 Postoperative periapical radiograph.

Fig 30 Intraoral view of the definitive crown.

Page 8: Fluorescence—Mimicking Nature for Ultimate Esthetics in ... · The goal of esthetic restorative dentistry is to mimic the optical properties of natural teeth. However, the fluorescence

GAMBORENA/BLATZ

QDT 2011 8©2011 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY. NO PART OF THIS ARTICLE MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.

Single-Implant Restorations

Zirconia has gained tremendous popularity as an im-plant abutment material in the esthetic zone because it prevents the grayish appearance of the surrounding soft tissues often seen with titanium or other metal-alloy abutments. The availability of colored zirconia abutments in different shades further improves esthet-ic outcomes over the conventional, white zirconia. In thin soft tissue situations, however, fluorescence may actually play a greater role than color. Fluorescence provides natural illumination and light transmission of the soft tissue at the implant-restorative interface and eliminates the shadowing effect that may appear when tooth-colored abutments are used.

Cases 4 through 6 demonstrate the optical proper-ties, selection, and fabrication of fluorescent zirconia abutments.

Case 4 (Figs 31 to 45), in which the mandibular right central and lateral incisors were replaced with implant-supported single crowns, demonstrates the difficulty of perfectly matching all optical properties of the natu-ral teeth and soft tissues with conventional materials and techniques. The central incisor crown was sup-ported by a titanium abutment, and the lateral incisor crown was supported by a zirconia abutment (Figs 42 and 43). While the definitive crowns blended favorably with the remaining dentition in some light conditions, the use of UV light, transmitted light, and postopera-tive photographs revealed esthetic deficiencies, espe-

31 32

33 34

Fig 31 Smile view after implant-crown restoration of the mandibular right central and lateral incisors.

Fig 32 Intraoral view of implant-supported crown restorations under natural light.

Fig 33 Fluorescent properties of the crowns and neighboring natural teeth.

Fig 34 Black-and-white photograph of the implant-supported crowns.

CASE 4

Page 9: Fluorescence—Mimicking Nature for Ultimate Esthetics in ... · The goal of esthetic restorative dentistry is to mimic the optical properties of natural teeth. However, the fluorescence

Fluorescence—Mimicking Nature for Ultimate Esthetics in Implant Dentistry

QDT 2011 9©2011 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY. NO PART OF THIS ARTICLE MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.

cially in the surrounding soft tissues (Figs 44 and 45). These deficiencies were due to the abutment materi-als (titanium) and, even for the zirconia abutment, to the lack of fluorescence at the abutment-restoration interface.

Recently, colorants and fluorescent modifiers have been developed that can be applied to zirconia abut-ments even after milling and finishing. Figures 39 and 40 show the optical properties of conventional versus colored zirconia abutments under natural and UV light. Fluorescence is achieved by dipping the abutment or framework into a fluorescent coloring liquid before sintering (Colour Liquid Fluoreszenz, Zirkonzahn, Gais, Italy). The abutment is blow dried after the dipping process to remove excess and placed under a drying lamp to prevent damage to the heating elements of

the sinter furnace. Sixteen coloring liquids for zirconia (Zirkonzahn) are also infiltrated during the sintering process. Figures 42 and 43 show conventional versus colored zirconia abutments after applying fluores-cence under natural and UV light.

The creation of natural esthetics with implant-sup-ported restorations requires highly fluorescent proper-ties at the implant-restorative interface and the gingival third of the restoration (Figs 44 and 45). Fluorescence and color can be added to zirconia to a certain degree. It is still difficult to create a dark shade (eg, C3 or C4) with a high degree of fluorescence since the dark color pigments may overshadow the fluorescent properties. Therefore, strong fluorescence of the implant abut-ment may actually be more important for overall and especially gingival esthetics than the shade itself.

35 36

37 38

Fig 35 Intraoral view of the zirconia and titanium abutments.

Fig 36 Periapical radiograph of the definitive implant crowns.

Fig 37 Optical behavior of crowns on a zirconia versus a titanium abutment under transmitted light.

Fig 38 Postoperative intraoral view. Note the unfavorable soft tissue color especially around the titanium abutment, but also around the zirconia abutment.

Page 10: Fluorescence—Mimicking Nature for Ultimate Esthetics in ... · The goal of esthetic restorative dentistry is to mimic the optical properties of natural teeth. However, the fluorescence

GAMBORENA/BLATZ

QDT 2011 10©2011 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY. NO PART OF THIS ARTICLE MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.

Fig 44 Regular zirconia abutment (Zr) versus a natural tooth and fluorescent zirconia abutment (Zr + Fl) under natural light.

Fig 45 Regular zirconia abutment (Zr) versus a natural tooth and fluorescent zirconia abutment (Zr + Fl) under UV light.

39

41

40

Fig 39 Conventional zirconia versus col-ored zirconia abutments under natural light.

Fig 40 Conventional zirconia versus col-ored zirconia abutments under UV light.

Fig 41 Fluorescence is added by infiltrat-ing the zirconia with fluorescent colorants. The abutment is dipped into the colorant and fully sintered or sintered again.

Fig 42 Zirconia abutments after application of fluorescence (Zr + Fl) under natural light. In ad-dition to fluorescence, shade-modifying colo-rants were applied (A1, B1, C1, D2).

Fig 43 Zirconia abutments after application of fluorescence (Zr + Fl) and colorants (A1, B1, C1, D2) under UV light. Note the negative effect of coloring pigments on the degree of fluorescence.

Page 11: Fluorescence—Mimicking Nature for Ultimate Esthetics in ... · The goal of esthetic restorative dentistry is to mimic the optical properties of natural teeth. However, the fluorescence

Fluorescence—Mimicking Nature for Ultimate Esthetics in Implant Dentistry

QDT 2011 11©2011 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY. NO PART OF THIS ARTICLE MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.

In case 5 (Figs 46 to 56) a provisional implant crown was placed at the maxillary left central incisor site to condition the soft tissue morphology after implant placement (Fig 46). The provisional restoration re-mained in place for 6 weeks until the position of the soft tissue was stabilized. The optical differences be-tween a conventional and a fluorescent zirconia abut-ment are evident under different light conditions (Figs 47 to 49). Alumina was selected as the coping material

for the definitive crown on the zirconia abutment. Fig-ures 50 to 56 show the preoperative and postopera-tive situation after implant placement and fabrication of an implant-supported restoration with natural fluo-rescence. The integration of a high degree of fluores-cence is especially important in patients with a high smile line, as presented here, to reduce the so-called umbrella shadowing effect.

CASE 5

Fig 46 Provisional crown restoration at the maxillary left central incisor site.

Fig 47 Fluorescent zirconia (Zr + Fl) versus regular zirconia abutment (Zr) under UV and natural light.

Fig 48 Fluorescent zirconia (Zr + Fl) versus regular zirconia abutment (Zr) under UV and natural light.

Fig 49 Fluorescent zirconia abutment under UV light showing the favorable fluorescent properties.

46

48

47

49

Page 12: Fluorescence—Mimicking Nature for Ultimate Esthetics in ... · The goal of esthetic restorative dentistry is to mimic the optical properties of natural teeth. However, the fluorescence

GAMBORENA/BLATZ

QDT 2011 12©2011 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY. NO PART OF THIS ARTICLE MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.

50 51

52

54

56

53

55

Fig 50 Preoperative situation.

Fig 51 Definitive alumina crown on the fluorescent zir-conia abutment under UV light showing natural fluorescence.

Fig 52 Postoperative view of the definitive alumina crown on the fluorescent zirconia abut-ment.

Fig 53 Preoperative periapical radiograph.

Fig 54 Preoperative smile.

Fig 55 Postoperative periapical radiograph.

Fig 56 Definitive implant crown.

Page 13: Fluorescence—Mimicking Nature for Ultimate Esthetics in ... · The goal of esthetic restorative dentistry is to mimic the optical properties of natural teeth. However, the fluorescence

Fluorescence—Mimicking Nature for Ultimate Esthetics in Implant Dentistry

QDT 2011 13©2011 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY. NO PART OF THIS ARTICLE MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.

Some challenging cases may require shaded or more translucent types of zirconia (Prettau Zircona “translucent,” Zirkonzahn) or further coloring of the implant abutment to achieve ideal esthetics. The de-gree of translucency, however, translates to a lower value and influences the ultimate degree of fluores-cence (Figs 57 and 58).

In case 6 (Figs 59 to 76), the maxillary right cen-tral incisor was restored with a full-coverage crown, while the maxillary left central incisor was replaced

with an implant-supported crown. To achieve an opti-mal match between the two restorations, the color of the severely destructed maxillary left central abutment tooth must be taken into consideration. In addition to conventional shade tabs (Fig 59), a digital spectropho-tometer (Spectroshade, MHT Optical Research, Nie-derhasli, Switzerland) was used to select the stump shade of the abutment tooth (VITA shade C3, VITA Zahnfrabrik, Bad Säckingen, Germany). At first, it was attempted to match the shade of the implant abut-

CASE 6

59

60

Fig 59 Shade selection of the natural abutment tooth, ie, the stump shade (C3).

Fig 60 Digital shade selection of the natural abutment tooth.

Fig 57 Fluorescent zirconia abut-ment (Zr+Fl) versus a natural tooth as well as a fluorescent and trans-lucent zirconia abutment (Tr+Fl) under natural light.

Fig 58 Fluorescent zirconia abut-ment (Zr+Fl) versus a natural tooth and a fluorescent and translucent zirconia abutment (Tr + Fl) under UV light. Note the reduced fluo-rescence of the Tr + Fl abutment.

Page 14: Fluorescence—Mimicking Nature for Ultimate Esthetics in ... · The goal of esthetic restorative dentistry is to mimic the optical properties of natural teeth. However, the fluorescence

GAMBORENA/BLATZ

QDT 2011 14©2011 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY. NO PART OF THIS ARTICLE MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.

Fig 61 Translucent zirconia abutment modified with colorant (shade C1) and fluorescence (Tr + C1 + Fl).

Fig 62 Translucent zirconia abutment modified with colorant (shade C1) and fluorescence under UV light (Tr + C1 + Fl). Note the unfavorable fluo-rescent properties.

Fig 63 Zirconia abutment modified with fluorescence (Zr + Fl).

Fig 64 Zirconia abutment modified with fluorescence (Zr + Fl) under UV light. Note the matching fluorescent properties.

Fig 65 Translucent zirconia abutment modified with colorant (shade C3) and fluorescence (Tr + C3 + Fl).

Fig 66 Translucent zirconia abutment modified with colorant (shade C3) and fluorescence under UV light (Tr + C3 + Fl). While the shade and translucency were favorable, the fluorescent prop-erties did not match the natural teeth.

Fig 67 Provisional restorations on the central incisors.

Fig 68 Intraoral view of the natural abutment tooth (shade C3) versus the fluorescent zirconia abutment (Zr + Fl) under UV light.

Fig 69 Intraoral view of the abutment tooth (shade C3) versus the fluores-cent zirconia abutment (Zr + Fl) under natural light.

61

63

65

67

69

62

64

66

68

Page 15: Fluorescence—Mimicking Nature for Ultimate Esthetics in ... · The goal of esthetic restorative dentistry is to mimic the optical properties of natural teeth. However, the fluorescence

Fluorescence—Mimicking Nature for Ultimate Esthetics in Implant Dentistry

QDT 2011 15©2011 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY. NO PART OF THIS ARTICLE MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.

ment with that of the natural abutment tooth. Howev-er, Figs 61 to 66 depict the negative effect of the high translucency/low value on the fluorescence. A prefer-able soft tissue appearance with new provisional res-torations (Fig 67) was achieved with an uncolored but fluorescent zirconia abutment (Figs 68 and 69), which matched the fluorescence and value but not necessar-ily the shade (chroma and hue) and translucency of the

natural abutment tooth. Therefore, in such situations, fluorescence/value matching takes priority over trans-lucency/shade matching.

The importance of mimicking natural fluorescence to achieve optimal esthetics in implant dentistry is ex-emplified in Figs 70 to 76, which compare the initial and postoperative situations.

71

73

74

70

72

Fig 70 Preoperative intraoral situation.

Fig 71 Preoperative periapical radiograph.

Fig 72 Postoperative intraoral view of the definitive zirconia crowns under UV light, depict-ing favorable fluorescent prop-erties.

Fig 73 Postoperative periapi-cal radiograph.

Fig 74 Postoperative intraoral view of the definitive zirconia crowns.

Page 16: Fluorescence—Mimicking Nature for Ultimate Esthetics in ... · The goal of esthetic restorative dentistry is to mimic the optical properties of natural teeth. However, the fluorescence

GAMBORENA/BLATZ

QDT 2011 16©2011 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY. NO PART OF THIS ARTICLE MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.

Fig 75 Preoperative smile.

Fig 76 Postoperative smile.

Page 17: Fluorescence—Mimicking Nature for Ultimate Esthetics in ... · The goal of esthetic restorative dentistry is to mimic the optical properties of natural teeth. However, the fluorescence

Fluorescence—Mimicking Nature for Ultimate Esthetics in Implant Dentistry

QDT 2011 17©2011 BY QUINTESSENCE PUBLISHING CO, INC. PRINTING OF THIS DOCUMENT IS RESTRICTED TO PERSONAL USE ONLY. NO PART OF THIS ARTICLE MAY BE REPRODUCED OR TRANSMITTED IN ANY FORM WITHOUT WRITTEN PERMISSION FROM THE PUBLISHER.

CRITERIA FOR ZIRCONIA IMPLANT ABUTMENT SELECTIONZirconia implant abutment selection is based on the following factors:

1. Three-dimensional implant position. The screw-ac-cess opening in the abutment should not compro-mise mechanical strength, and the zirconia should be at least 0.8-mm thick.

2. Soft tissue thickness. A minimum thickness of 3 mm is ideal.

3. Interocclusal space. Sufficient abutment height is re-quired for ultimate resistance.

4. Implant abutment color. Order of priority: fluorescence/value, translucency, and shade (chroma and hue).

5. Color of the intended crown restoration (alumina versus zirconia).

The desired marginal preparation of the implant abut-ment is generally a circumferential chamfer or rounded shoulder to ensure optimal stability and fit of the cop-ing. The margin should be placed deeper on the labial aspect than on the palatal aspect, but no deeper than 1 mm subgingivally. Shallower is actually preferred for postinsertion cement control. Margin location is directly related to the implant depth. However, the implant abut-ment should be designed to fully support the desired crown contour and soft tissue collar. Ideally, the implant abutment should support 90% of the total surrounding soft tissue contour, while the crown itself should only sup-port about 10%. The integration of fluorescent proper-ties in these areas is key to ultimate esthetic success.

CONCLUSIONIn modern prosthetic and implant dentistry, much em-phasis is placed on optimal shade and translucency matching for esthetic success. However, a primary opti-cal feature of natural teeth is often overlooked: fluores-cence. Because fluorescence is typically the strongest in the gingival third of natural teeth, a lack of fluorescence is most obvious in implant-supported restorations and will negatively influence the surrounding soft tissues. In fact, for ultimate esthetic success, natural fluorescence may take precedence over other optical features, espe-cially at the abutment-crown interface.

REFERENCES 1. Stübel H. Die Fluoreszenz tierischer Gewebe in ultraviolettem

Licht [in German]. Arch Ges Physiol 1911;142:1–14. 2. Araki T, Miyazaki E, Kawata T, Miyata K. Measurements of fluo-

rescence heterogeneity in human teeth using polarization mi-crofluorometry. Applied Spectroscopy 1990;44:627–631.

3. Hartles RL, Leaver AG. The fluorescence of teeth under ultravio-let irradiation. Biochem J 1953;54:632–638.

4. Benedict HC. A note on the fluorescence of teeth in ultra-violet rays. Science 1928;67:442.

5. Dickson G, Forziati AF, Lawson ME Jr, Schoonover IC. Fluores-cence of teeth; a means of investigating their structure. J Am Dent Assoc 1952;45:661–667.

6. Booij M, ten Bosch JJ. A fluorescent compound in bovine den-tal enamel matrix compared with synthetic dityrosine. Arch Oral Biol 1982;27:417–421.

7. Armstrong WG. Fluorescence characteristics of sound and cari-ous human dentine preparations. Arch Oral Biol 1963;8:79–90.

8. Armstrong WG. The presence of ultra violet absorbing material and its relation to fluorescence “quenching” effects in carious dentine. Arch Oral Biol 1963;8:223–231.

9. Buchalla W. Comparative fluorescent spectroscopy shows differ-ences in noncavitated enamel lesions. Caries Res 2005;39:150–156.

10. Terrer E, Koubi S, Dionne A, et al. A new concept in restorative dentistry: Light-induced fluorescence evaluator for diagnosis and treatment: Part 1—Diagnosis and treatment of initial oc-clusal caries. J Contemp Dent Pract 2009;10:1–12.

11. Rodrigues JA, Hug I, Diniz MB, Lussi A. Performance of fluo-rescence methods, radiographic examination and ICDAS II on occlusal surfaces in vitro. Caries Res 2008;42:297–304.

12. Adeyemi AA, Jarad FD, Pender N, Higham SM. Comparison of quantitative light-induced fluorescence (QLF) and digital imag-ing applied for the detection and quantification of staining and stain removal on teeth. J Dent 2006;34:460–466.

13. Poh CF, Williams PM, Zhang L, Rosin MP. Heads up! A call for dentists to screen for oral cancer. J Can Dent Assoc 2006; 72:413–416.

14. Lee YK, Lu H, Powers JM. Fluorescence of layered resin com-posites. J Esthet Restor Dent 2005;17:93–100.

15. Tani K, Watari F, Uo M, Morita M. Discrimination between com-posite resin and teeth using fluorescence properties. Dent Ma-ter J 2003;22:569–580.

16. Sant’Anna Aguiar Dos Reis R, Casemiro LA, Carlino GV, et al. Evaluation of fluorescence of dental composites using contrast ratios to adjacent tooth structure: A pilot study. J Esthet Restor Dent 2007;19:199–206.

17. Monsénégo G, Burdairon G, Clerjaud B. Fluorescence of dental porcelain. J Prosthet Dent 1993;69:106–113.

18. Komine F, Blatz MB, Yamamoto S, Matsumura H. A modified layering technique to enhance fluorescence in glass-infiltrated aluminum oxide ceramic restorations: Case report. Quintes-sence Int 2008;39:11–16.

19. Nik Mohd Polo Kinin NM, Wan Mohd Arif WI, Zainal Arifm A. Study on the effect of Y2O3 addition to the fluorescent proper-ty of dental porcelain. Med J Malaysia 2004;59 Suppl B:23–24.

20. Ferreira Zandoná AG, Kleinrichert T, Analoui M, Schemehorn BR, Eckert GJ, Stookey GK. Effect of two fluorescent dyes on color of restorative materials. Am J Dent 1997;10:203–207.

Page 18: Fluorescence—Mimicking Nature for Ultimate Esthetics in ... · The goal of esthetic restorative dentistry is to mimic the optical properties of natural teeth. However, the fluorescence