1
Geoff Brumfiel “Among the Beasts that represent Kingdoms I reccon the Dragon one. A Dragon signifies the person of a hostile King & serpents according to their bigness the persons of other greater or lesser enemies.” These words were penned not by an obscure mystic, but by a man many consider to be the father of modern science — Isaac Newton. They are part of the introduction to the 300,000-word interpretation of the book of Revelation that Newton wrote in the late seventeenth cent- ury. The work was published for the first time last month. The writings reveal a religious fer- vour that until now has been seen only by scholars of science with access to archival manuscripts, according to Robert Iliffe, a science historian at Imperial College Lon- don. Iliffe directs the Newton Pro- ject, which posted the documents online on 15 July. “This is the first time that people can see what he really believed,”he says. Historians of science have long known of Newton’s interest in religion and alchemy, but few realize the radical nature of his work, says Iliffe. “What he believed would have been hideous to virtually everybody in Oxford and Cambridge for decades to come,”he says. Among the unorthodox ideas in the text is a belief that Catholics, led by the Pope, are the false idolaters spoken of in the book of Revela- tion. Antagonism towards Catholics was not uncommon in Newton’s period: during his lifetime England had experienced a bloody civil war that pitted Charles I, widely regarded as a Catholic sympathizer, against the mainly news NATURE | VOL 430 | 19 AUGUST 2004 | www.nature.com/nature 819 Newton’s religious screeds get online airing Protestant parliament, before Charles II was restored to the throne. But the vehemence of Newton’s arguments pushed him well beyond the Anglican faith, to which he osten- sibly belonged. “He believed that the Pope was the personification of the Antichrist here on Earth,”Iliffe says. Newton knew such beliefs lay out- side the social mores of his peers, and there is no evidence that he ever pub- lished any of the writings now avail- able online. Still, Iliffe says, Newton’s religious writings constitute more than half of his entire written work. In the past, many thought that Newton pursued religion only in his spare time, or that the majority of his religious work had been copied from others. But Iliffe claims that these writings show his theological work was carefully planned and often related to his work in mathematics and physics. For example, he sets up his text on the Apocalypse with math- ematical formalism, outlining rules, definitions and a proof of his beliefs. Ultimately, Newton’s religion and science may have been tied together by belief in absolute truth. Newton used testable hypotheses to find truth in nature, and believed that his religious writings revealed the truth about God, says Iliffe. www.newtonproject.ic.ac.uk Revelation: the majority of Newton’s writings were theological tracts. Erika Check, Washington A much-hyped technology known as RNA interference (RNAi) has moved a step closer to the clinic. Biotechnology firm Acuity Pharmaceuticals of Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, asked for permission on 10 August to use the technique to treat a common cause of blindness. The clinical trial, if approved by the US Food and Drug Administration, would be the first of its kind. RNAi, which uses short lengths of genetic material to selectively shut off genes, was demonstrated in human cells in 2001 and has yet to be tested in people. Some studies have raised concerns about just how selective the technique is, so observers say the filing is a landmark for the field but remain cautious. “This is a significant milestone,” says Greg Jensen, a biotechnology analyst at Ernst & Young in Palo Alto, California.“Whether it will work out, or give us the first bad news about RNA interference, we don’t know yet.” Acuity hopes to use a small interfering RNA to treat patients with wet age-related macular degeneration. The condition is caused by extended growth of blood vessels in the retina — a problem that Acuity thinks can be tackled by silencing the gene that triggers the growth. The company says that the condition affects more than 1.65 million people in the United States. Dale Pfost, Acuity’s chief executive, says his firm has applied for a patent on the RNA molecule involved, but the intellectual- properties issues are not straightforward. Rival firm Alnylam, based in Cambridge, Massachusetts, has already requested a patent on the method of RNA delivery that Acuity will use. Alnylam says it plans to begin its own clinical trials in macular degeneration next year. Pfost is confident that Acuity’s disease- specific patent will be granted, but Alnylam begs to differ.“We’re very pleased to see silencing RNAs entering the clinical stage,” says John Maraganore, chief executive of Alnylam.“But at the end of the day, we believe that anybody developing RNAi therapies needs to talk to us.” For more news and analysis go to www.nature.com/news Firm sets sights on gene silencing to protect vision Light relief: RNAi may stop the degeneration seen here (right) in an ageing retina. P. P ARKER/SPL S. TERRY/SPL ©2004 Nature Publishing Group

Firm sets sights on gene silencing to protect vision

  • Upload
    erika

  • View
    213

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Geoff Brumfiel“Among the Beasts that representKingdoms I reccon the Dragon one.A Dragon signifies the person of ahostile King & serpents accordingto their bigness the persons of othergreater or lesser enemies.” Thesewords were penned not by anobscure mystic, but by a man manyconsider to be the father of modernscience — Isaac Newton. They arepart of the introduction to the300,000-word interpretation of thebook of Revelation that Newtonwrote in the late seventeenth cent-ury. The work was published for thefirst time last month.

The writings reveal a religious fer-vour that until now has been seenonly by scholars of science withaccess to archival manuscripts,according to Robert Iliffe, a sciencehistorian at Imperial College Lon-don. Iliffe directs the Newton Pro-ject, which posted the documentsonline on 15 July. “This is the firsttime that people can see what he reallybelieved,”he says.

Historians of science have long known ofNewton’s interest in religion and alchemy, butfew realize the radical nature of his work, saysIliffe. “What he believed would have beenhideous to virtually everybody in Oxford andCambridge for decades to come,”he says.

Among the unorthodox ideas in the text is abelief that Catholics, led by the Pope, are thefalse idolaters spoken of in the book of Revela-tion. Antagonism towards Catholics was notuncommon in Newton’s period: during hislifetime England had experienced a bloodycivil war that pitted Charles I, widely regardedas a Catholic sympathizer, against the mainly

news

NATURE | VOL 430 | 19 AUGUST 2004 | www.nature.com/nature 819

Newton’s religious screeds get online airingProtestant parliament,before CharlesII was restored to the throne.

But the vehemence of Newton’sarguments pushed him well beyondthe Anglican faith, to which he osten-sibly belonged. “He believed that thePope was the personification of theAntichrist here on Earth,”Iliffe says.

Newton knew such beliefs lay out-side the social mores of his peers, andthere is no evidence that he ever pub-lished any of the writings now avail-able online. Still, Iliffe says, Newton’sreligious writings constitute morethan half of his entire written work.

In the past, many thought thatNewton pursued religion only in hisspare time, or that the majority ofhis religious work had been copiedfrom others. But Iliffe claims thatthese writings show his theologicalwork was carefully planned and oftenrelated to his work in mathematicsand physics. For example, he sets uphis text on the Apocalypse with math-ematical formalism, outlining rules,

definitions and a proof of his beliefs.Ultimately, Newton’s religion and science

may have been tied together by belief inabsolute truth. Newton used testablehypotheses to find truth in nature, andbelieved that his religious writings revealedthe truth about God,says Iliffe. ■

➧ www.newtonproject.ic.ac.uk

Revelation: the majority of Newton’s writings were theological tracts.

Erika Check,WashingtonA much-hyped technology known as RNAinterference (RNAi) has moved a step closer to the clinic.

Biotechnology firm AcuityPharmaceuticals of Philadelphia,Pennsylvania, asked for permission on 10 August to use the technique to treat acommon cause of blindness. The clinical trial, if approved by the US Food and DrugAdministration, would be the first of its kind.

RNAi, which uses short lengths ofgenetic material to selectively shut off genes,was demonstrated in human cells in 2001and has yet to be tested in people. Somestudies have raised concerns about just howselective the technique is, so observers saythe filing is a landmark for the field butremain cautious.

“This is a significant milestone,” saysGreg Jensen, a biotechnology analyst at Ernst& Young in Palo Alto, California. “Whether itwill work out, or give us the first bad newsabout RNA interference, we don’t know yet.”

Acuity hopes to use a small interferingRNA to treat patients with wet age-relatedmacular degeneration. The condition iscaused by extended growth of blood vesselsin the retina — a problem that Acuity thinkscan be tackled by silencing the gene thattriggers the growth. The company says that the condition affects more than

1.65 million people in the United States.Dale Pfost, Acuity’s chief executive, says

his firm has applied for a patent on the RNAmolecule involved, but the intellectual-properties issues are not straightforward.Rival firm Alnylam, based in Cambridge,Massachusetts, has already requested apatent on the method of RNA delivery thatAcuity will use. Alnylam says it plans tobegin its own clinical trials in maculardegeneration next year.

Pfost is confident that Acuity’s disease-specific patent will be granted, but Alnylambegs to differ. “We’re very pleased to seesilencing RNAs entering the clinical stage,”says John Maraganore, chief executive ofAlnylam. “But at the end of the day, webelieve that anybody developing RNAitherapies needs to talk to us.” ■

For more news and analysis go to

www.nature.com/news

Firm sets sights on gene silencing to protect vision

Light relief: RNAi may stop the degenerationseen here (right) in an ageing retina.

P.P A

RK

ER

/SP

LS.

TE

RR

Y/S

PL

19.8 news 819 MH 17/8/04 10:16 am Page 819

© 2004 Nature Publishing Group