55
Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group

Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group

Firewise 2006

Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire

Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FDChris White, Anchor Point GroupStephen Guerin, Redfish Group

Page 2: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group

City of Santa Fe Wildland Urban Interface

Wildland Fire Hazard and Risk Analysis

Prepared for:

Santa Fe Fire DepartmentSanta Fe, New MexicoSubmitted By: Anchor PointBoulder, ColoradoMay 2006

Page 3: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group
Page 4: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group
Page 5: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group
Page 6: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group
Page 7: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group
Page 8: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group

Flame Length – Extreme Conditions

Page 9: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group

Rate of Spread – Average Conditions

Page 10: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group

Rate of Spread – Extreme Conditions

Page 11: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group

Crown Fire – Average Conditions

Page 12: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group

Crown Fire – Extreme Conditions

Page 13: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group

Agent-Based Modeling of Wildfire Evacuation

Joshua Thorp, RedfishGroup, Santa Fe, NMStephen Guerin, RedfishGroup, Santa Fe, NMFrank Wimberly, RedfishGroup, Santa Fe, NM

Michelle Rossbach, City of Santa Fe Fire DepartmentOwen Densmore, RedfishGroup, Santa Fe, NM

Michael Agar, Ethknoworks, Santa Fe, NMDouglas Roberts, RTI International, Nambe, NM

Page 14: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group

• Modeling questions and uses

• Modeling wildfire

• Modeling traffic

• Tool workflow and gaps

• Future Directions

Page 15: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group

Shelter-In-Place Controversy

• Cova, T.J., Dennison, P.E., Kim, T.H., and Moritz, M.A. (2005) Setting wildfire evacuation trigger-points using fire spread modeling and GIS. Transactions in GIS, 9(4): 603-617

• Emerging Issues in Wildland Fire Protection. When Wildfire Threatens: Should Residents Stay or Evacuate? Journal of the National Fire Protection Association. Wildland Fire Management Section. October, 2004.

• Lindroth, R. (2004). Community defense from wildfire, an international comparison. An applied research project submitted to the National Fire Academy as part of the July, 2004 Leading Community Risk Reduction course.

• Oaks, D. (2000). Fight or Flight? Fire Chief. April 1, 2000

Page 16: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group

Photo courtesy of Don Pearman

Cova (2006)

Page 17: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group
Page 18: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group
Page 19: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group
Page 20: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group
Page 21: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group
Page 22: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group
Page 23: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group

• Modeling questions and uses

• Modeling wildfire

• Modeling traffic

• Tool workflow and gaps

• Future Directions

Page 24: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group
Page 25: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group
Page 26: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group
Page 27: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group
Page 28: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group
Page 29: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group

“Time of Arrival” Map

Page 30: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group
Page 31: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group
Page 32: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group
Page 33: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group
Page 34: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group
Page 35: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group
Page 36: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group

• Modeling questions and uses

• Modeling wildfire

• Modeling traffic

• Tool workflow and gaps

• Future Directions

Page 37: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group
Page 38: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group
Page 39: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group
Page 40: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group
Page 41: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group

0

1000

2000

3000

4000

5000

6000

7000

8000

00

:00

- 01

:00

04

:00

- 05

:00

08

:00

- 09

:00

12

:00

- 13

:00

16

:00

- 17

:00

20

:00

- 21

:00

Time of Day

Tra

ffic

Vo

lum

e

Left Turn Thru 1 Thru 2 Thru 3 0 0 0 0 0 0

0

1000

2000

3000

4000

5000

6000

7000

8000

9000

9/1

/20

06

9/5

/20

06

9/9

/20

06

9/1

3/2

00

6

9/1

7/2

00

6

9/2

1/2

00

6

Date

Tra

ffic

Vo

lum

e

Left Turn Thru 1 Thru 2 Thru 3 0 0 0 0 0 0

Empirical Traffic Flows for Calibration

Page 42: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group
Page 43: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group

Cova, T.J., and Church, R.L. (1997) Modelling community evacuation vulnerability using GIS. International Journal of Geographical Information Science, 11(8): 763-784

Cova, T.J., and Johnson, J.P. (2002) Microsimulation of neighborhood evacuations in the urban-wildland interface. Environment and Planning A, 34(12): 2211-2229

Cova, T.J., and Johnson, J.P. (2003) A network flow model for lane-based evacuation routing. Transportation Research Part A: Policy and Practice, 37(7): 579-604

Cova, T.J. (2005) Public safety in the urban-wildland interface: Should fire-prone communities have a maximum occupancy? Natural Hazards Review, 6(3): 99-108

Cova, T.J., Dennison, P.E., Kim, T.H., and Moritz, M.A. (2005) Setting wildfire evacuation trigger-points using fire spread modeling and GIS. Transactions in GIS, 9(4): 603-617

Page 44: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group
Page 45: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group
Page 46: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group
Page 47: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group

• Modeling questions and uses

• Modeling wildfire

• Modeling traffic

• Tool workflow and gaps

• Future Directions

Page 48: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group
Page 49: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group

future work

• Augmented reality table for sand table exercises• Collaboration with Sandia Labs - Data Analysis & Visualization

Group

Page 50: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group

Firewise 2006

Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a WildfireAgent-Based Modeling of Wildfire Evacuation

Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FDChris White, Anchor Point GroupStephen Guerin, Redfish Group

Page 51: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group

End

Page 52: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group
Page 53: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group

Evacuation – Definition

• the movement of persons from a dangerous place to a safe refuge.

Page 54: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group
Page 55: Firewise 2006 Staying Alive in Santa Fe During a Wildfire Shelley Nolde Rossbach, Santa Fe FD Chris White, Anchor Point Group Stephen Guerin, Redfish Group