Upload
others
View
3
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Opening
POST SETTLEMENT GOVERNANCE ENTITYMonday 16th April, Mangakōtukutuku Campus, Glenview, Hamilton
• The journey so far
• Post SettlementGovernance Entity(PSGE)
• Q & A
• Individual pātai
• Workshop
• Negotiators Update
Overview
The Journey before Mandate
Breachesof Te Tiriti o
Waitangi
Claims filedwith
WaitingiTribunal
WaitingiTribunalHearingsheld to
hear claims
MandatePursued
The Journey since Mandate
AchievedOct – Dec
2016
AchievedAugust 2017
In Progress DueDec 2018
Mandate Agreementin Principle
(AIP)
Initial Deedof
Settlement(IDOS)
Deed ofSettlement
(DOS)
To Start
ENVIRONMENT
WHĀNAUECONOMIC
DEVELOPMENT
COLLECTIVEECONOMIC
DEVELOPMENT
PEOPLE CULTURE
POLITICALENGAGEMENT
NMMPT Kokiri
MFM
MLCEntities
Hapū Trusts
MFT
What is a PSGE?
• The entity that will holdand manage settlementassets
Why is it needed?
• The settlement can’t becompleted until a singlegovernance entity hasbeen ratified by the iwiand legally established
• Trust Board can notreceive settlement assets
Post SettlementGovernance Entity (PSGE)
What does it do?
• Manage the settlementredress for current andfuture generations
Post SettlementGovernance Entity(PSGE)
The PSGE needs to be
- representative of andaccountable to all ofManiapoto
- transparent in it’sdecision making
What’s importantto us
- Maniapoto Māori Trust Board will bedisestablished
- There are other entitiesserving our people withinour rohe that will continueto do so post settlementwho serve differentfunctions
Background
Almost 2/3rds live in urban
areas
Less than 9% live in our
rohe
More than 91% live outside
our rohe
Our peopleWhere do they live?
44% Under 20
26% 20-39
21% 40-59
9% 60+
70% are in the age groups
that represent our
tamariki, rangatahi and
their parentsSource: Statistics New Zealand – Census 2013
Our peopleHow old are they?
• Ensures the voice ofhome is strong indecision making
• Encourages uri toconnect to marae/hapū if they want to beconsidered
Representative
• Limits eligibility of largeportion of the 91% wholive outside to stand
• Limits access to theprofessional skills andexpertise, many of whichlive in the cities
Ke
yA
dva
nta
ge
sK
ey
Dis
ad
va
nta
ge
s
Basis of Appointment to PSGE
PSGE
• Each Marae, Hapū or rohe elects candidate/s and appoints highestpolling candidates
• Widens the pool ofeligible Trustees andimproves access toskills, expertise andexperience
• Better representative ofthe Maniapotopopulation
GenerallyElected
• Risk that there is novoice of home indecision making
• Doesn’t encourage uri tostay connected to theirmarae/hapū
Ke
yA
dva
nta
ge
sK
ey
Dis
ad
va
nta
ge
s
Basis of Appointment to PSGE
PSGE
• Individuals generally elect membersat large
• Ensures that the voice ofhome is preserved whileproviding for access to awider pool of talent
• Familiar model forManiapoto
Mixed Model
Ke
yA
dva
nta
ge
sK
ey
Dis
ad
va
nta
ge
s
Basis of Appointment to PSGE
PSGE
• Each Marae, Hapū or rohe elects candidate/s and appoints highestpolling candidates
• Individuals generally electmembers at large
• Can become unwieldy interms of membernumbers (with generallyelected as well asrepresentatives)
21© 2017 KPMG, a New Zealand partnership and a member firm of the KPMG network of independent member firms affiliated
with KPMG International Cooperative (“KPMG International”), a Swiss entity. All rights reserved.
MARAECONNECTION
ANALYTICAL
ENTREPRENEURIAL
STAKEHOLDERRELATIONSHIPS/
NETWORKS
ENVIRONMENTAL
PEOPLEENGAGEMENT
LEGAL
GOVERNANCE
SOCIAL
COMMUNICATION
TECHNOLOGY
COMMERCIALACUMEN
FINANCIALLITERACY
STRATEGIC
HAPŪRELATIONSHIPS
INVESTMENT
PEOPLEMANAGEMENT
ORGANISATIONALDEVELOPMENT
CULTURE(REO, TIKANGA)
POLITICAL
Experience SkillsWhat do we need?
Research has shown that theoptimum number oftrustees/directors depends onthe size of the organisation.A board should be largeenough to get the board’swork done yet small enoughto work effectively as a teamto communicate, deliberateand function as a cohesivegroup.
Across various research, theoptimal number is in therange of 6-12 members.
PSGE Size
A number of iwi entities willmake up the group with thePSGE being the main or parententity.
There are various reasons whyseparate entities within thegroup are formed.
Consideration is given to anumber of competing mattersthat help determine the numberof entities and the focus of eachentity within the group.
Forming the Group
We will seek the help of
technical experts to help
us in these areas and
ensure we meet both our
own and the Crown’s
requirements.
They will share their
experience of what they
have seen work well and
not work well.
Technical Expertise
√ Represents all members
√ Transparent decision-making procedures
√ Transparent dispute resolution procedures
√ Fully accountable to the whole group
√ Ensure beneficiaries of settlement and PSGE are thesame
√ Ratified by the iwi
Check against Crown PSGE requirements
See a list in your handout
of possible functions or
focus for the PSGE. Tick
those you think have merit
for further consideration
and cross those you do
not agree with. Also feel
free to add others.
Individual Question 1Function
Of the models discussed in
the presentation tick the
one you most prefer or if
you do not agree with any
of the options briefly
describe an option you
would like to see
considered
Individual Question 2Basis of Appointment
• Ensures the voice ofhome is strong indecision making
• Encourages uri toconnect to marae/hapū if they want to beconsidered
• Ensures that the voice ofhome is preserved whileproviding for access to awider pool of talent
• Familiar model forManiapoto
• Widens the pool ofeligible Trustees andimproves access toskills, expertise andexperience
• Better representative ofthe Maniapotopopulation
Representative Mixed ModelGenerallyElected
• Limits eligibility of largeportion of the 91% wholive outside to stand
• Limits access to theprofessional skills andexpertise, many of whichlive in the cities
• Risk that there is novoice of home indecision making
• Doesn’t encourage uri tostay connected to theirmarae/hapū
Ke
yA
dva
nta
ge
sK
ey
Dis
ad
va
nta
ge
s
Basis of Appointment to PSGE
• Can become unwieldyin terms of membernumbers (withgenerally elected aswell asrepresentatives)
See the list of possible
skills and experience your
representatives might
require. Number the top
three of those qualities
listed you think your
representatives need
(1 being the most
required). Also feel free to
add others.
Individual Question 3Skill Mix
How many trustees do you
believe should be on the
PSGE?
5-7 members
8-10 members
11-13 members
13+ members
Individual Question 4PSGE Board Size
In considering the makeup
and design of the PSGE,
how will we ensure that it
truly represents all of our
people taking into account
that only 10% of our people
live in the Rohe and 40%
are under the age of 20?
Workshop QuestionReflecting our People
The Journey since Mandate
AchievedOct – Dec
2016
AchievedAugust 2017
In Progress DueDec 2018
Mandate Agreementin Principle
(AIP)
Initial Deedof
Settlement(IDOS)
Deed ofSettlement
(DOS)
To Start
• Agreement in Principlesigned
• Currently working towards aDeed of Settlement
• Largely technical in natureto confirm the details ofspecific redress to beincluded in the finalsettlement package
• Deed of Settlement and thepost settlement governanceentity will be put to the iwifor ratification (approval)
WhakarāpopotoSummary
• Drafting the historicalaccount for inclusion in theDeed of Settlement
• Reviewing the Crownacknowledgements andapology
• Finalising claimant definitionmatters for the purposes ofthe settlement
• Work through place namechanges throughout theManiapoto rohe to correctour place names
Key Workstreams
• Confirming all commercialredress properties identifiedin the AIP, including sites tobe selected post-settlementand longer term RFRs
• Confirming all culturalredress properties identifiedin the AIP, includingtransfers of sites and othernon-exclusive redress
• Working throughrelationship redressmechanisms with Crownentities
Key Workstreams
• Working on specific naturalresources redress tomaximise this within theManiapoto settlement
• Engaging with other“overlapping” iwi groupsregarding their respectiveinterests (in the context ofTreaty settlementnegotiations)
• Review the detailed draftingof the Deed of Settlementand eventual settlementbill/legislation
Key Workstreams
Contact us
• Phone: 0800 668 285
• Email: [email protected]
• Website: www.maniapoto.iwi.nz
• Facebook:www.facebook.com/maniapotomaoritrustboard
• Instagram: @etumaniapoto
• Twitter: @EtuManiapoto
• E Tū Maniapoto App downloadable via Apple and Google Play store
PātaiQuestions