50
False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan (Al-Yamani) www.hubeali.com 1 out of 50 ‘False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan’ (self-proclaimed Al-Yamani)

False Claims of Ahmed Al Hassan - hubeali.com · False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan (Al-Yamani) 6 out of 50 Ahmed Al-Hasan says in ‘Sermon of Hajj’: The truth I say unto you, that

  • Upload
    lylien

  • View
    219

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan (Al-Yamani) www.hubeali.com

1 out of 50

‘False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan’ (self-proclaimed Al-Yamani)

False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan (Al-Yamani) www.hubeali.com

2 out of 50

TABLE OF CONTENTS

‘False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan’ (self-proclaimed Al-Yamani) 1

Summary: 4

Quotes from Ahmed Al-Hasan’s website: 5

Ahmed Al-Hasan says in ‘Sermon of Hajj’: 6

Our reply: 6

1. Vision and Dreams: 6

Who Don’t See Dreams: 7

Clarification on Dreams: 8

Religion can only be Based on Holy Book and Ahadith: 9

2. The Twelve Mahdis 9

Who are the Twelve Mahdis in Ahadith? 10

All Imamsasws

are Al-Mahdiasws

and Al-Qaimasws

: 13

3. Al-Yamani: 15

4. ‘Ismah’ (Infallibility) 17

The Qualities of an Infallible Imamasws

: 17

Appendix I: 19

Ibleesla

cannot come in a Dream in the Appearance of Prophetas

or an Imamasws

or their followers: 19

Appendix II: 20

Appendix III: Mixing up the Truth and Falsehood: 28

Appendix IV: Establishing the Authenticity of a Hadith: 29

The Importance of the ‘Primary Sources’ of Ahadith: 29

Take those Ahadith which are famous among our shias, 30

Appendix V: The Recognition of Safyani and Yamani: 31

VERSES 113 & 114 33

Appendix VI: Imamasws and the Prophethoodas 41

Appendix VII: Hadith-e-Tariq 43

Introduction of an Infallible Imamasws

43

False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan (Al-Yamani) www.hubeali.com

3 out of 50

Hadeeth -e- Tariq 43

Abbreviations:

saww: - Sal lal la ho Allay hay Wa Aal lay he Wasallam azwj: - Az Za Wa Jalla asws: - Allay hay Salawat-o-Wass Salam ra: - Razi Allah

azwj

la: - Laan Allahazwj

False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan (Al-Yamani) www.hubeali.com

4 out of 50

.تسليما وسلم الطاهرين، وآله محمد سيدنا على اهلل وصلى العالمين، رب هلل الحمد الرحيم الرحمن اهلل بسم

In the Name of Allahazwj the Beneficent, the Merciful. The Praise is for Allahazwj

Lordazwj of the

Worlds, and Blessing be upon our Chief Muhammadsaww and hissaww

Purified Progenyasws, and greetings with abundant greetings.

ل ف رجهم والعن أعدائ هم اجمعين د وعج د وآل محم اللهم صل على محم

Summary:

A Short article is compiled to refute claims of an Iraqi citizen (Ahmed Al-Hasan), where he declares to be performing a ‘Divine Duty’ as an Infallible (Masoom) person (Nouzobillah)1. He also claims to be ‘Al-Yamani’2 – a clear contradiction since one cannot hold two positions at the same time (an Infallible Imam as well as ‘Al-Yamani’ – who is a Shia: a follower of an Infallible Imamajfj).

Ahmed Al-Hasan also alleges to be the 4th descendants of Imam Mahdiajfj Ibn Hassan Al-Askariasws – which means his father, grandfather and great grandfather have collectively lived, over 1000 years (since the Grand Occultation of Imam Mahdiajfj Ibn Hassan Al-Askariasws started in 329 A.H. when the Imamajfj was approximately 74 years old).3 This is impossible to justify, as no one has any authentic information to ‘Nikah’ (marriage) of Imam Mahdiajfj Ibn Hassan Al-Askariasws, neither during the ‘minor occultation’ nor the ‘major occultation’. However, historically, several tyrants from Bani Ummaid and Bani Abbas have named their sons as ‘Mahdi’, and also several people have claimed to be Imam Mahdiajfj

(Nouzobillah), so Ahmad Hasan is not an exception (hence on their footsteps).

One may ask, why are you putting together a reply to such an unbelievable ‘call’ and clearly false and self-proclaimed virtues? Firstly, one of our regular members informed us that a person known to her has become one of Ahmed Al-Hasan’s followers, secondly, news of some other twelve Imami Shias, indicate an interest and inclination in his claims and thirdly he (Ahmed Al-Hasan) alleges that he has a growing follow-ship in many countries including ‘Iran, Pakistan, al-Kuwait, Qatar, Bahrain, United Arab Emirates, Egypt, Morocco, Najd and Al-Hejaz (Arabic peninsula), Lebanon, china, Australia, Canada, England, Sweden, USA, and others’. Hence it becomes important for us to look into his claims and refute it in the light of Ahadith of Masomeenasws.

For Shias, he (Ahmed Al-Hasan) claims that he is the forth grandson of Imam Mohammad Al-Mahdiasws Ibn Hassan Askariasws (see below the quotes from Ahmed Al-Hasan’s website). He also claimed that there will be twelve Mahdis after the twelve Imamsasws and he is one of

1 God Forbid 2 A devout Shia who will appear after the appearance of a hostile one (Al-Safyani). 3 Imam Mahdi

ajfj Ibn Hassan Al-Askari

asws came to his mortal world on the 15

th of Shaban in 255 A.H.

False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan (Al-Yamani) www.hubeali.com

5 out of 50

them (Nouzobillah). And he alleges to be Al-Yamani who will rise before the re-appearance of 12th Imamasws.

For Sunnis, Ahmed Al-Hasan claims that he is ‘the Mahdi whose birth at the end of times was promised by the Prophet Muhammadsaww to the Sunni Muslims’. Hence, a reviver of the religion.

For Christians and Jews, Ahmed Al-Hasan claims: ‘He is the comforter promised by the Prophet Jesus, peace be upon him, mentioned in the Gospel, and the Saviour whom Prophet Elijah promised to be sent to the Jews. He set out with his great divine call in 1999 in Iraq and from there it spread to the world’.

First we present these quotes from his (Ahmed Al-Hasan) site, and then deal with his claims as per the traditions of Masomeenasws, as per the twelve Imami Shia beliefs.

Quotes from Ahmed Al-Hasan’s website:

An Iraqi citizen says:

My name is Ahmed, son of Ismael, son of Saleh, son of Hussain, son of Salman, son of

Muhamad Al Mahdi. My father's name is Ismael. My first grandfather is Saleh,

second grandfather is Hussain, third grandfather is Salman, and my fourth

grandfather is Muhammad Al-Mahdi, meaning that Imam Al-Mahdi is my fourth

grandfather….(ref: http://www.saviorofmankind.com/).

It is also claimed that:

‘Imam Ahmed Al-Hasan is the successor and messenger of Imam Al-Mahdi Muhammad son of Al-Hasan,

peace be upon him, to all the people. He is the promised Yamani to the Shia Muslims

and the Mahdi whose birth at the end of times was promised by the Prophet Muhammad to the Sunni

Muslims.

He is the comforter promised by the Prophet Jesus, peace be upon him, mentioned in the Gospel, and the

Savior whom prophet Elijah promised to be sent to the Jews. He set out with his great divine call in 1999

in Iraq and from there it spread to the world ….(ref: http://www.saviorofmankind.com/)..

Then the Will of Rasool Allahsaww is quoted: where it is stated:

‘O Ali, you are my successor over my family, their living and their deceased, and over my women......(then 12 Imams are introduced one by one). These are the twelve Imams. After him there will be twelve Mahdis. So if God receives him, let him hand it over to his son, the first of

the close ones. He has three names, one like mine and my father’s: Abdullah (servant of God), Ahmed, and

the third name is al-Mahdi. He is the first of the believers.”

False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan (Al-Yamani) www.hubeali.com

6 out of 50

Ahmed Al-Hasan says in ‘Sermon of Hajj’:

The truth I say unto you, that I did not initiate asking for allegiance to be given to me;

rather, what happened in the time of the tyrant Saddam was that a group of students

from the Hawza Elmiyya in Najaf Al-Ashraf decided to give allegiance to me as a

messenger from Imam Al-Mahdi after seeing visions, revelations, and miracles. They

then began requesting allegiance be given to me from the other students of the Hawza

Elmiyya in Najaf, Allah knows so and they know so. And that was the first allegiance.

Then people apostated except for a few who were loyal to Allah’s swt covenant, and

the ones who apostated began saying that the visions and revelation were from jinn,

and that the miracles were witchcraft.

Ahmed Al-Hasan further says in the same sermon:

All praise be to Allah who made me similar to Thul Qarnain and made me similar to

Ali, the Prince of Believers, and all praise be to Allah who did not make me request

Imamate but made it request me instead. (ref. From Sermon of Hajj:

http://www.saviorofmankind.com).

Our reply:

Ahmed Al-Hasan says, his movement (as per his website) started in 1999, when some students of Islamic school (Houza) in Najaf (Iraq), through ‘visions’, believed in him as a ‘messenger from Imam Al-Mahdi’, however later on most of them realised that those visions were from jinn and part of witchcraft. This, however, encouraged Ahmed Al-Hasan to make further claims and even to bring himself to the level of ‘Ismah’ (the Infallibility – which is reserved for the Prophetsas and Imamsasws). His claims are based on the followings four points and we will reply to each of those in the following sections:

1. Visions and Dreams 2. The Twelve Mahdis 3. Al-Yamani 4. ‘Ismah’ (Infallibility)

1. Vision and Dreams:

Imamasws says:

ه السالم( قال الرؤيا على ثالثة وجوه علي بن إب راهيم عن أبيه عن ابن أب عمي عن سعد بن أب خلف عن أب عبد الله )علييطا ن و أضغاث أحالم.بشارة من الله للمؤمن و تذير من الش

False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan (Al-Yamani) www.hubeali.com

7 out of 50

Ali Bin Ibrahim, from his father, from Ibn Abu Umeyr, from Sa’d Bin Abu Khalaf, who has narrated the following:

Abu Abdullahasws has said that the dreams are of three aspects - Good News from Allahazwj for the Momin, and a caution against the Satanla, and confused dreams’.4

عت أبا السن ) د قال س ر بن خال د بن عيسى عن معم د بن يي عن أحد بن مم ا رأيت الرؤيا مم عليه السالم( ي قول ربرها و الرؤيا على ما ت عب ر. فأعب

Muhammad Bin Yahya, from Ahmad Bin Muhammad Bin Isa, from Muammar Bin Khallaad who said:

I heard Abu Al-Hassanasws saying: ‘Sometimes Iasws see the dream, so Iasws interpret it, and the dream is upon what you interpret’.5

A religion cannot be based upon ‘visions and dreams’. There are so many sects and cults in the world, particularly in Islam, where people have based their beliefs on visions. There is no doubt that Ibleesla cannot come in dreams in the appearance of a Prophetas/Imamasws as well as theirasws followers (e.g., Appendix I) but the interpretation of a dream cannot be free from doubts, as we see many dreams and sometimes chains of dreams and broken up dreams in which we see other momineen, deceased and pleasant/unpleasant matters. So one cannot take a religion on a dream, as Imamasws says:

م ( قال قال ما ت روي هذه الناصبة ف قلت علي بن إب راهيم عن أبيه عن ابن أب عمي عن ابن أذي نة عن أب عبد الله ) عليه السالب رهه ف الن وم ف قال كذبوا فن فداك فيما ذا ف قال ف أذانم و ركوعهم و سجودهم ف قلت إن هم ي قولون إن أب بن كع جعلت

دين الله عز و جل أعز من أن ي رى ف الن وم

Ali Bin Ibrahim, from his father, from Ibn Abu Umeyr, from Ibn Azina,

(It has been narrated) from Abu Abdullahasws having said: ‘What are these Hostile Ones (Nasibis) reporting?’ So I said, ‘May I be sacrificed for youasws! With regards to what?’ So heasws said: Regarding their Azans, and their Rukū and their Sajud (plural of Sajdah)’. So I said, ‘They are saying that Abayy Bin Ka’ab saw it during the sleep (dream)’. So heasws said: ‘They are lying, for the Religion of Allahazwj Mighty and Majestic is more Honourable than for it to be seen during the sleep (dream)’. …(see the complete Hadith in the Appendix II).6

Who Don’t See Dreams:

الرؤياو قال ص ل يزن أحدكم أن ت رفع عنه الرؤيا فنه إذا رسخ ف العلم رفعت عنه

4 Al-Kafi, Vol. 8, H. H 14509 5 Al-Kafi, Vol. 8, H. H 14975 6 Al Kafi V 3 – The Book Of Salat CH 100 H 1

False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan (Al-Yamani) www.hubeali.com

8 out of 50

The Prophetsaww said: You should not be sad when you do not see a dream. The highly educated ones cannot see visions.7

Clarification on Dreams:

A companion of Imamasws goes to Imamasws to verify what he was told by the Imamasws in his dream.

عمان عن سويد القالنسي عن بش ن ذكره عن علي بن الن د بن السن الطاطري عم ان عن أب عبد الله قال ق لت مم ه ي الدم و لم النزير ف قلت ل هو له إن رأيت ف المنام أن ق لت لك إن القتال م مام المفروض طاعته حرام مثل الميتة و الد ع غي ال

كذلك ف قال أبو عبد الله هو كذلك هو كذلك

Muhammad ibn al-Hassan al-Tatriy has narrated from those who he has mentioned in his book - from Ali ibn al-Nu'rnan from Suwayd al-Qalanisiy from Bashir al-Dahhan who has said:

‘I once said to Abu 'Abd Allahasws 'I saw a dream in which I said to youasws, "Fighting alongside the one who other than an Imamasws (and) whose obedience is not obligatory, is unlawful just like consuming dead animals, blood and pork for food. Youasws said to me (in my dream), 'That is how it is! Abu 'Abd Allahasws then said, 'That is how it is! That is how it is!8

د بن ي عمان عن سويد القالنسي عن بشي عن أب عب مم د بن السي عن علي بن الن د الله قال ق لت له إن ي عن مممام المفت م و لم النزير ف قلت ل ن عم هو رأيت ف المنام أن ق لت لك إن القتال مع غي ال رض طاعته حرام مثل الميتة و الد

كذلك ف قال أبو عبد الله هو كذلك هو كذلك

Muhammad ibn Yahya has narrated from Muhammad ibn al-Hussain, from Ali ibn al-Nu'rnan from Suwayd al-Qalanisiy from Bashir who has said:

‘I once said to Abu 'Abd Allahasws: 'I saw a dream in which I said to youasws, "Fighting alongside other than an Imamasws to whom obedience is not obligatory is unlawful like consuming dead animals, blood and pork for food, and you said to me, 'Yes, that is how it is.’ Abu 'Abd Allahasws then said, 'That is how it is! That is how it is!9

The above Ahadith clearly prove that one has to verify one’s interpretation of dreams, prior to the our times, shias used to visit holy Imamasws to confirm their interpretation of dreams, these days one also need to see if correct interpretation of his/her dream is derived. For example in the case of Ahmed Al-Hasan, if his claims are against doctrine of Masomeenasws, any justification for his support based on one’s visions/dream(s) is obviously going to be invalid and completely unlawful.

7 Tuhaf al-Uqoul, pg. 62, 7باب 156 74حباراألنوار

8 Ibid, Ch. 6, H. 3

9 Ibid, Ch. 7, H. 2

False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan (Al-Yamani) www.hubeali.com

9 out of 50

Religion can only be Based on Holy Book and Ahadith:

قال : وقال أمي املؤمني ) عليه السالم ( : من أخذ دينه من أفواه الرجال أزالته الرجال ، ومن أخذ دينه من الكتاب والسنة زالت اجلبال ، ومل يزل ، قال : وهذا الرب مروي عن الصادق ) عليه السالم ( ، عن أمياملؤمني ) عليه السالم ( .

Amir Al-Momineenasws said: ‘One who takes his Religion from the mouths of other men, they would (make) him wandering (in doubts), but the one who takes his Religion from the Book and the Sunnah (Ahadith), then the mountains may move but he would not stray (remain firm on his/her’s beliefs)’. He (the author of the book said), ‘This is reported from Al-Sadiqasws, (and who) from Amir Al-Momineenasws’.[3]

2. The Twelve Mahdis

Here a quote is presented from the ‘Will of Rasool Allahsaww ‘O Ali, you are my successor over my family, their living and their deceased, and over my women......(then 12 Imams are introduced one by one by Rasool Allahsaww in the long Sermon – which we are not reporting here). These are the twelve Imams. After him10 there will be twelve Mahdis.

One cannot base one’s religion without thoroughly analysing all Ahadith of Masomeenasws, the same above Hadith was also used by the ‘Waqafis’ who believed in only seven Imams (see our refutation of Waqafis: https://www.hubeali.com/articles/ReplyToWaqafiSectBeliefs.pdf).

Below, we present a Hadith, where it is emphasised that one must consider other Ahadith too for the clarity, as Imamasws says:

د عن عثمان بن عيسى عن أب أيوب الزاز عن مم ة من أصحابنا عن أحد بن مم د بن مسلم عن أب عبد الله ) عليه عدء و فالن عن رسول الله ) صلى اهلل عليه وهله ( ل ي ت همون بالكذب ف يجي السالم ( قال ق لت له ما بال أق وام ي روون عن فالن

منكم خالفه قال إن الديث ي نسخ كما ي نسخ القرهن .

A number of our companions, from Ahmad Bin Muhammad, from usman Bin Isa, from Abu Ayoub Al Khazzaz, from Muhammad Bin Muslim,

(It has been narrated) from Abu Abdullahasws, said, ‘I said to himasws, ‘What is the matter that the people are reporting from so and so, from Rasool Allahsaww, youasws are not accusing them of the lying, and there is coming from youasws, different to it?’ Heasws said: ‘The Hadeeth Abrogates just as the Quran Abrogates’11 See other Ahadith where Truth and

[3]

Wasail ul Shia, H. 33403 10 Here there seems to be typing/report mistake, it should have been after them or after ‘him’ refers to the last Imam? 11

162، ص: 1 دار الديث(، ج -كاف )ط , Al Kafi V 1 – The Book Of Intellect and Ignorance CH 20 H 2

False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan (Al-Yamani) www.hubeali.com

10 out of 50

falsehood are mixed to obtain desired conclusions in Appendix III. Also see some Ahadith on the authentication of Ahadith.

So let’s try to find from Ahadith who are meant by the twelve Mahdis?

Who are the Twelve Mahdis in Ahadith?

ث نا علي ث نا أحد بن زياد بن جعفر المدان قال حد الم بن صالح الروي قال حد بن إب راهيم بن هاشم عن أبيه عن عبد السمنا اث نا عشر بن علي بن أب طالب أخربنا وكيع بن اجلراح عن الربيع بن سعد عن عبد الرحن بن سليط قال قال السي

م به األرض ب عد موتا ام القائم بالق ييي الله مهديا أولم أمي المؤمني علي بن أب طالب و هخرهم التاسع من ولدي و هو الين كله و لو كره المشركون و يظهر به دين الق ين هخرون ف يؤذون و ي قال على الد له غيبة ي رتد فيها أق وام و ي ثبت فيها على الد

يف ب ي يدي رسول الله أما إن الصابر ف غيبته ع هذا الوعد إن كنتم صادقي مىت لم لى األذى و التكذيب بنزلة المجاهد بالس ص.

Narrated to us Ahmad bin Ziyad bin Ja’far Hamdani: Narrated to us Ali bin Ibrahim bin Hashim from his father from Abdus Salam bin Salih Harawi that he said: Informed us Waki bin Jarrah from Rabi bin Saad from Abdur Rahman bin Salit that he said:

Hussainasws Ibne Aliasws Ibne Abi Talibasws said: “From usasws there are twelve Mahdis, the first of whom is Amir-ul-Momineen Aliasws Ibne Abi Talibasws and the last of whom is myasws ninth descendant. And heasws (the 9th son of Imam Hussainasws) is truly the Imam Al-Qaimasws (the 12th Imamasws)12 Allahazwj will Revive the earth after its death through himasws. And through himasws triumph Hisazwj Religion over all the religions even if the polytheists may dislike this.

There will be occultation for himasws during which communities will apostate but others will remain steadfast on religion. They will be tortured and told: If you are on truth when will this promise be fulfilled? Know that one who observes patience during those tribulations will be like one who fights the holy war under the command of the Rasool Allahsaww.”13

ث نا علي بن أحد بن عبد الله بن أحد بن د حد ي أحد بن أب عبد الله عن أبيه مم ث نا أب عن جد أب عبد الله الربقي قال حديعا عن إب راهيم الكرخي قال: د بن سنان و أب علي الزراد ج د الصادق دخلت ع بن خالد عن مم لى أب عبد الله جعفر بن مم

ته و جلست ف قال أبو عبد الله يا و إن جلالس عنده إذ دخل أبو السن موسى بن جعفر و هو غالم ف قمت إليه ف قبل ضاعف على روحه العذاب أما إنه لصاحبك من ب عدي أما ليهلكن فيه أق وام و يسعد فيه هخرون ف لعن الله قاتله و إب راهيم أما

ه ي جد مامة و رأس الكمة ليخرجن الله من صلبه خي أهل األرض ف زمانه س و وارث علمه و أحكامه و فضائله و معدن اليرج الله من صلبه تكملة و لو كره المشركون بالغ أمره ي قتله جبار بن فالن ب عد عجائب طريفة حسدا له و لكن الله عز و جل

اهر سيفه ب ي يدي رسول الله المنتظر للثان عشر منهم -اث ن عشر إماما مهديا اختصهم الله بكرامته و أحلهم دار قدسه كالشة مرة أريد منه أن يستتم ال فدخل رجل من موال بن أمية فان قطع الكالم ف عدت إل أب عبد الله إحدى عشر ص يذب عنه ق

12

The 12th

Imamasws

is also referred to as Al-Qaimasws

or Al-Mahdiasws

13 Kamal-Al-Deen-wa-Tamam-Al-Ni-Mah, Vol. 2, ch.30, H. 3, 317، ص: 1 كمال الدين و متام النعمة، ج

False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan (Al-Yamani) www.hubeali.com

11 out of 50

نة الثانية د ا كان قابل الس خلت عليه و هو جالس ف قال يا إب راهيم هو المفرج للكرب عن الكالم فما قدرت على ذلك ف لمرجعت ا إب راهيم قال إب راهيم فما شيعته ب عد ضنك شديد و بالء طويل و جز و خوف فطوب لمن أدرك ذلك الزمان حسبك ي

ء أسر من هذا لقلب و ل أق ر لعين. بشي

Narrated to us Ali bin Ahmad bin Abdullah bin Ahmad bin Abi Abdullah Barqi: Narrated to us my father from my grandfather Ahmad bin Abi Abdullah from his father Muhammad bin Khalid from Muhammad bin Sinan and Abi Ali Zarrad, all of them from Ibrahim Al-Karkhi that he said:

“I went to Abu Abd Allah Ja’farasws Ibn Muhammad Al-Sadiqasws and was sitting in hisasws presence when Abu Al-Hasan Musaasws Ibn Ja’farasws entered while heasws was a boy. I stood up, kissed himasws and sat with himasws. Then Abu Abdullahasws remarked, “O Ibrahim! Know that, heasws is your master after measws. Know that, concerning him one group will be destroyed while another will be saved. Then may Allahazwj Curse hisasws killer and multiply Hisazwj Chastisement for the one who fights against himasws. Know that, certainly Allahazwj will Bring out from hisasws progeny the best of the inhabitants of the earth in hisajfj time. Heajfj will be named after hisajfj grandfather, heajfj will be the inheritor of this knowledge and hissaww laws in hisajfj judgments, the treasure-chest of Imamate and the fountainhead of wisdom. The tyrant king of Bani (Abbas) will kill himasws after hisasws amazing acts, due to envy. But Allahazwj (Mighty and Glorified be He) will convey Hisazwj Affairs even if the polytheists dislike it.

And Allahazwj will Bring forth from hisasws progeny the completion of twelve Mahdi (guided leaders). Allahazwj has Chosen them for Hisazwj Nobility, Permitted for them the abode of Hisazwj Holiness and the twelfth awaited oneajfj is from them, as if with an open sword standing in front of Rasool Allahsaww in his defence.” Then a person from the friends of Bani Umayyah entered due to which Imamasws had to cut short his speech.

I returned to Abu Abd Allahasws eleven times after that so that heasws may complete hisasws discourse but heasws was unable to do so (due to the presence of government spies). In the coming year, which was the second year, I went to himasws while heasws was sitting. Heasws said, “O Ibrahim! Heajfj is the one who will provide salvation to hisajfj Shias after intense straitening, lengthy calamities, grief and fear. Then congratulations to one who lives till hisajfj time. This is enough for you O Ibrahim.” Ibrahim said, ‘Then nothing was dearer to my heart or soothed my eyes more than this talk.’”14

ل رضي الله عنهما ق د بن موسى بن المتوك د بن علي ماجيلويه و مم ث نا مم د بن حد د بن يي العطار عن مم ث نا مم ال حدي عن عثمان بن عيسى عن ساعة لت القم ار عن أب طالب عبد الله بن الص كنت أنا و أبو بصي و بن مهران قال:السن الصف

عت أبا عبد الل مم د بن عمران س ة ف قال مم ن اث نا عشر مهديا ف قال له د بن عمران مول أب جعفر ف منزل بك ه ي قول عت ذلك من أب عبد الل عته من أب أبو بصي تالله لقد س ع ذلك منه ف قال أبو بصي لكن س ه فحلف مرة أو مرت ي أنه س

جعفر .

14 Kamal-Al-Deen-wa-Tamam-Al-Ni-Mah, Vol. 2, ch.33, H. 5, 334، ص: 2 كمال الدين و متام النعمة، ج

False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan (Al-Yamani) www.hubeali.com

12 out of 50

و حدثنا بثل هذا الديث ممد بن السن بن أحد بن الوليد رضي اهلل عنه قال حدثنا ممد بن السن الصفار عن أب طالب مثله سواء. الصلت القمي عن عثمان بن عيسى عن ساعة بن مهران عبد اهلل بن

Narrated to us Muhammad bin Ali Majilaway and Muhammad bin Musa bin Mutawakkil - May Allah be pleased with them - they said: Narrated to us Muhammad bin Yahya al-Attar from Muhammad bin Hasan as-Saffar from Abi Talib Abdullah Ibne Salt Qummi from Uthman bin Isa from Sama-a bin Mehran that he said:

“I, Abu Baseer and Muhammad bin Imran, slave of Abu Ja’farasws were in a house in Mecca. Muhammad Ibne Imran said: I heard Abi Abdullahasws say: We are the twelve Mahdis. Abu Baseer asked: Did you really hear this from Abi Abdullahasws? He swore once or twice that he had heard it from himasws.

Abu Baseer said: But I have heard it from Abu Ja’far asws

. A similar tradition is narrated to us by Muhammad bin Hasan bin Ahmad bin Walid (r.a.) that he said: Narrated to us Muhammad bin Hasan as-Saffar from Abi Talib

Abdullah bin Salt al-Qummi from Uthman bin Isa from Samaa-a bin Mehran.”15

د بن إب راهيم بن إسحاق رضي الله ث نا مم ثن حد ث نا جعفر بن عبد الله قال حد د المدان قال حد ث نا أحد بن مم عنه قال حدد بن عمران مول أ د بن ب عثمان بن عيسى عن ساعة بن مهران قال كنت أنا و أبو بصي و مم ة ف قال مم جعفر ف منزل بك

عت أبا عبد الله ي قول ثون عمران س عت ذلك من أب عبد الله فحلف ن اث نا عشر مد ف قال أبو بصي و الله لقد س عه منه.مرت ي أنه س

Narrated to us Muhammad bin Ibrahim bin Ishaq: Narrated to us Ahmad bin Muhammad Hamdani: Narrated to us Ja’far bin Abdullah: Narrated to me Uthman bin Isa from Sama-a bin Mehran that he said: I, Abu Baseer, Muhammad bin Imran, the slave of Abi Ja’far were in a house in Mecca. Muhammad bin Imran said:

I heard Abi Abdullahasws say: “Weasws are the twelve Mahdis. Abu Baseer asked: Did you really hear this from Abi Abdullahasws? He swore twice that he had heard it from himasws.”16

ث نا م د الم حد ث نا أحد بن مم د بن إب راهيم بن إسحاق الطالقان رضي الله عنه قال حد ث نا أبو عبد الله العاصمي م دان قال حدد بن ساعة عن ثابت الصائغ عن السن بن عن السي بن القاسم بن أيوب عته مم عن أب بصي عن أب عبد الله قال س

ادس ما أحب ي قول . منا اث نا عشر مهديا مضى ستة و بقي ستة يصنع الله بالس

Narrated to us Muhammad bin Ibrahim bin Ishaq Taliqani: Narrated to us Ahmad bin Muhammad Hamdani: Narrated to us Abi Abdullah Asimi from Husain bin Qasim bin Ayyub from Hasan bin Muhammad bin Sama-a from Thabit Saigh from Abu Baseer from:

Abi Abdullah Sadiqasws that he heard himasws say: “From usasws there will be twelve Mahdisasws. Six have passed and six are remaining. Allahazwj will Do with the sixth as Heazwj pleases.”17

15 Kamal-Al-Deen-wa-Tamam-Al-Ni-Mah, Vol. 2, ch.33, H. 6, 335، ص: 2 كمال الدين و متام النعمة، ج 16 Kamal-Al-Deen-wa-Tamam-Al-Ni-Mah, Vol. 2, ch.33, H. 15, 339، ص: 2 و متام النعمة، ج كمال الدين 17 Kamal-Al-Deen-wa-Tamam-Al-Ni-Mah, Vol. 2, ch.33, H. 13, 338، ص: 2 كمال الدين و متام النعمة، ج

False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan (Al-Yamani) www.hubeali.com

13 out of 50

ث نا أحد بن د بن إب راهيم بن إسحاق رضي الله عنه قال حد ث نا مم ث نا أبو عبد الله العاصمي عن حد د المدان قال حد ممد بن ساعة عن وهيب عن ذريح عن أب حزة عن أب عبد الله أنه ق . السي بن القاسم بن أيوب عن منا ال:السن بن مم

اث نا عشر مهديا.

Narrated to us Muhammad bin Ibrahim bin Ishaq: Narrated to us Ahmad bin Muhammad Hamdani: Narrated to us Abi Abdullah Asimi from Husain bin Qasim bin Ayyub from Hasan bin Muhammad bin Sama-a from Wuhaib from Zarih from Abi Hamza who says:

Abi Abdullahasws said: “There will be twelve Mahdiasws (leaders of guidance) from usasws.”18

All Imamsasws are Al-Mahdiasws and Al-Qaimasws:

د بن عيسى عن علي بن الكم عن زيد أب السن ع ة من أصحابنا عن أحد بن مم ن الكم بن أب ن عيم قال أت يت أبا عدب ي الركن و المقام إن أنا لقيتك أن ل أخرج من المدينة حىت أعلم جعفر ) عليه السالم ( و هو بالمدينة ف قلت له علي نذر

بن بشي د أم ل ف لم ي ء أنك قائم هل مم

A number of our companions, from Ahmad Bin Muhammad Bin Isa, from Ali Bin Al Hakam, from Zayd Abu Al Hassan, from Al Hakam Bin Abu Nuaym who said,

‘I went over to Abu Ja’farasws and heasws was in Al-Medina, and I said to himasws, ‘Upon me there is a vow between Al-Rukn (a corner of the Kaaba) and Al-Maqam (of Ibrahimas) that if I were to meet youasws, I will not exit from Al-Medina until I know (for certain) whether youasws are the Qaimasws of the Progenyasws of Muhammadsaww or not’. But, heasws did not answer me with anything.

مرن ف قال يا حكم و إنك لاهنا ب عد ف قلت ن عم إن أخب رتك با جعلت لله علي ف لم تأ فأقمت ثالثي ي وما ث است قب لن ف طريق هن عن شي بن بشي و مل ت ن ر علي غدوة المنزل ف غدوت علي ء و مل ت ه ف قال ) عليه السالم ( سل عن حاجتك ء ف قال بك

So I stayed for thirty days, then heasws met me in a street and heasws said: ‘O Hakeym, and you are still over here?’ So I said, ‘Yes. I did inform youasws with what I had Made for (the Sake of) Allahazwj upon me, but youasws did not instruct me nor did youasws forbid me about anything, and youasws did not answer me with anything’. Heasws said: ‘Come tomorrow early in the morning to the house’. So I went the next morning to himasws, and heasws said to me: ‘Ask your need’.

أن ل أخرج من المدينة حىت أعلم أنك قائم ف قلت إن جعلت لله علي نذرا و صياما و صدقة ب ي الركن و المقام إن أنا لقيتك د أم ل فن كنت أنت رابط تك و إن مل تكن أنت سرت ف األرض فطلبت المعاش هل مم

So I said, ‘I made it (for the Sake of) Allahazwj, a vow upon me and some Fasts and charity between Al-Rukn and Al-Maqam that if I were to meet youasws, I will not exit from Al-Medina

18 Kamal-Al-Deen-wa-Tamam-Al-Ni-Mah, Vol. 2, ch.33, H. 14, 338، ص: 2 كمال الدين و متام النعمة، ج

False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan (Al-Yamani) www.hubeali.com

14 out of 50

until I know (for certain) whether youasws are Qaimasws of the Progenyasws of Muhammadsaww or not. Therefore, if youasws were as such, I shall maintain links with youasws, and if youasws do not happen to be, I shall travel in the land and seek the livelihood’.

يف قال كلنا صاحب ف قال يا حكم كلنا قائم بأمر الله ق لت فأنت المهدي قال كلنا ن هدي إل الله ق لت فأنت صاحب السيف ق لت فأنت الذي ت قتل أعداء الله و يعز بك أولياء الله و يظهر الس بك دين الله يف و وارث الس

So heasws said: ‘O Hakam! All of us (Imamsasws) are ‘Qaim’ (Standing) with the Command of Allahazwj’. I said, ‘So are youasws ‘Al-Mahdiasws‘ (the Guiding one)?’ Heasws said: ‘All of usasws Guide to Allahazwj’. I said, ‘So are youasws the owner of the sword?’ Heasws said: ‘All of us (Imamsasws) are owners of the sword and the inheritors of the sword’. I said, ‘So are youasws the one who will be killing the enemies of Allahazwj and the friends of Allahazwj would be strengthen with youasws and the Religion of Allahazwj would overcome (all the other religions)?’

خسا و أربعي سنة و إن صاحب هذا األمر أق رب عهدا باللب من و أخف على ف قال يا حكم كيف أكون أنا و قد ب لغت ابة . ظهر الد

Heasws said: ‘O Hakam! How can Iasws happen to be (himasws), and Iasws have already reached fifty-four years of age, and the Masterasws of this Command would be closer to the ere of the milk (younger) than measws, and lighter upon the back of the animal’.19

د د بن أحد عن يي بن مم ( السالم عليه ) جعفر أب عن اجلعفي يزيد بن جابر عن سامل بن هشام عن مبوب ابن عن ممد هل قائم الله و هذا ف قال ( السالم عليه ) الله عبد أب على بيده فضرب ( السالم عليه ) القائم عن سئل قال اهلل صلى ) مم

( وهله عليه

Muhammad Bin Yahya, from Ahmad Bin Muhammad, from Ibn Mahboub, from Hisham Bin Salim, from Jabir Bin Yazeed Al Ju’fy,

(It has been narrated) from Abu Ja’farasws, said, ‘Heasws was asked about Al-Qaimasws. So heasws struck hisasws hand upon Abu Abdullahasws and heasws said: ‘This oneasws, by Allahazwj, is a Qaimasws of the Progeny of Muhammadsaww’.

ا عنبسة قال جابر صدق ف قال بذلك فأخب رته ( السالم عليه ) الله عبد أب على دخلت ( السالم عليه ) جعفر أبو قبض ف لم

Anbasa (a narrator) said, ‘So when Abu Ja’farasws passed away, I went over to Abu Abdullahasws and I informed himasws with that. So heasws said: ‘Jabir (the narrator) spoke the truth’.

مام ب عد القائم هو إمام كل ليس أن ت رون لعلكم قال ث له كان الذي ال . ق ب

19

Al Kafi V 1 – The Book Of Divine Authority CH 128 H 1

False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan (Al-Yamani) www.hubeali.com

15 out of 50

Then heasws said: ‘Perhaps you all are viewing that it isn’t so. Every Imamasws, heasws is ‘Al-Qa’imasws‘ after the Imamasws who was before himasws’.20

3. Al-Yamani:

In this section, we deal with the claim of Ahmed Al-Hasan that he is the Al-Yamani. Well if he claims to be a Al-Yamani then he cannot claim, at the same time, to be one of the twelve Al-Mahdis, who will come after Al-Qaimasws. In addition, Al-Yamani will rise after the rising of Al-Sufyani.

We present some Ahadith here, additional Ahadith related to Al-Yamani (and Al-Sufyani) are given in Appendix V.

راج قال ق لت ألب عبد الله )ع د عن ابن مبوب عن ي عقوب الس ال ف قال ليه السالم( مىت ف رج شيعتكم ق و عنه عن أحد بن ممعرب أعنت ها و رفع كل ذي صيصية إذا اخت لف ولد العباس و وهى سلطان هم و طمع فيهم من مل يكن يطمع فيهم و خلعت ال

امي و أق بل اليمان و تر ة بت راث رسول الله ) صلى صيصيته و ظهر الش ك السن و خرج صاحب هذا األمر من المدينة إل مك اهلل عليه وهله (

And from him, from Ahmad Bin Muhammad, from Ibn Mahboub, from Yaqoub Al-Sarraaj who said:

I said to Abu Abdullahasws, ‘When will there be relief for yourasws Shiites?’ Heasws said: ‘When the children of Al-Abbas differ regarding their authority, and he who was not greedy for it before, covets it, and the Arabs remove their reins, and everyone with spurs (horsemen) battles for it, and Al-Shami (The Syrian) appears, and Al-Yamani (The Yemenite) comes forward, and Al-Hasany moves (with a movement), and the Masterasws of this Command will come out from Al-Medina to Al-Makkah with the inheritance of the Rasool Allahsaww’.

ه و قضيبه و راي ته و لمته و ف قلت ما ت راث رسول الله ) صلى اهلل عليه وهله ( قال سيف رسول الله و درعه و عمامته و ب رد ر يف من غمده و ي لبس الد ة ف يخرج الس و ي نشر الراية و الب ردة و العمامة و ي ت ناول القضيب بيده و سرجه حىت ي نزل مك

يستأذن الله ف ظهوره

So I said, ‘What inheritance of the Rasool Allahsaww?’ Heasws said: ‘Sword of the Rasool Allahsaww, and hissaww Armor, and hissaww turban, and hissaww gown, and hissaww staff, and hissaww banner, and hissaww helmet, and hissaww saddle, until heasws descends upon Makkah. So heasws will take out the sword from its sheath, and put on the Armor, and display the banner, and (wear) the gown and the turban, and grab the staff by hisasws hand, and seek Permission of Allahazwj for hisasws appearance.

عثون ف يطلع على ذلك ب عض مواليه ف يأت السن ف يخربه الب ر ف يبتدر السن إل ال ة ف ي قت لونه و ي ب روج ف يثب عليه أهل مكامي ف يظهر عند ذلك صاحب امي عند ذلك جيشا إل المدينة برأسه إل الش عث الش هذا األمر ف يبايعه الناس و ي تبعونه و ي ب

20

Al Kafi V 1 – The Book Of Divine Authority CH 70 H 7

False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan (Al-Yamani) www.hubeali.com

16 out of 50

ة ف ي لحقون بصاحب هذا سالم ( ف ي هلكهم الله عز و جل دون ها و ي هرب ي ومئذ من كان بالمدينة من ولد علي ) عليه ال إل مكعث جيشا إل المدينة ف يأمن أهلها و و العراق و ي ب ها.األمر و ي قبل صاحب هذا األمر ي رجعون إلي

That will be announced to some of hisasws friends. Al-Hassany would come. So heasws would inform him of the news. Al-Hassany would initiate the coming out (Al-Khurouj). The people of Makkah would pounce upon him. So they will kill him and send his head to Al-Shamy (The Syrian). During that, the Masterasws of this Command will appear. So the people would pledge their allegiances to himasws and follow himasws. And Al-Shamy (The Syrian) would send an army to Al-Medina. So Allahazwj Mighty and Majestic would Destroy them before it (gets there). On that day, those from the children of Aliasws who would be in Al-Medina would flee to Makkah. So they would join up with the Masterasws of this Command. And the Masterasws of this Command would go towards Al-Iraq and send hisasws army to Al-Medina. Its people would express belief and they would return to it’.21

د بن عيسى عن علي بن الكم عن أب أيوب الزاز ع د بن يي عن أحد بن مم عت أبا عبد الله مم ن عمر بن حنظلة قال سفس الزكية و اليمان ف )عليه السالم( ي قول خس عالما سف و ق تل الن فيان و ال قلت جعلت ت ق بل قيام القائم الصيحة و الس

ا ك ان من الغد ت لوت هذه الية إن نشأ ن ن زل عليهم فداك إن خرج أحد من أهل ب يتك ق بل هذه العالمات أ نرج معه قال ل ف لميحة ف قال أما لو كانت خضع ماء هية فظلت أعناق هم لا خاضعي ف قلت له أ هي الص ت أعناق أعداء الله عز و جل.من الس

Muhammad Bin Yahya, from Ahmad Bin Muhammad Bin Isa, from Ali Bin Al-Hakam, from Abu Ayyub Al-Khazaz, from Umar Bin Hanzala who said:

I heard Abu Abdullahasws saying: ‘There are five signs before the rising of Al-Qaimasws (occurring one after another):

(1) the scream, and (2) (rising of) the Sufyani, and (3) the sinking (of the earth), and (4) the killing of the pure soul (Al-Nafs Al-Zakkiyya) and (5) (then rising of the) Al-Yamani’.

So I said, ‘May I be sacrificed for youasws, if someone from yourasws Household comes out (in revolt) before these signs, shall we come out (revolt) with him?’ Heasws (the Imam) said: ‘No’.

So when it was the next morning, I recited this Verse: “[26:4] If We please, We should send down upon them a sign from the heaven so that their necks should stoop to it”. I said, ‘Is this the scream?’ Heasws said: ‘If that was, then the necks of the enemies of Allahazwj Mighty and Majestic would stoop down in humility’.22

21

Al-Kafi, Vol. 8, H. 14733 22

Al-Kafi, Vol. 8, H. 14931

False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan (Al-Yamani) www.hubeali.com

17 out of 50

4. ‘Ismah’ (Infallibility)

Ahmed Al-Hasan also alleges that he is the promised Al-Mahdi, Al-Yamani, , and is similar to ‘Thul Qarnainas and Aliasws. From twelve Imami point of view, this is impossible as ‘Ismah’ (Infallibility) cannot be attained but is a Divine Ordainment, there are numerous Ahadith on this topic, and we just present one Hadith, some additional Ahadith are presented in Appendix VI.

The Qualities of an Infallible Imamasws:

د عن مهران بن أحد الم( )عليه السن لب ق لت قال بصي أب عن علي بن مم ف قال قال المام ي عرف ب فداك جعلت السصال م قد ء بشي فنه أولا أما ب ة عليهم لتكون إليه بشارة فيه أبيه من ت قد با ويرب اب تدأ عنه سكت وإن ف يجيب ويسأل حج

د أبا يا ل قال ث لسان بكل ناس ال ويكلم غد ف نا دخل أن ألبث ف لم ت قوم أن ق بل عالمة أعطيك مم أهل من رجل علي ال )عليه السن أبو فأجابه بالعربية الراسان فكلمه خراسان أن من عن ما فداك جعلت واهلل الراسان له ف قال بالفارسية م(السر بالراسانية أكلمك يا ل قال ث عليك فضلي فما أجيبك أحسن ل كنت إذا اهلل سبحان ف قال تسن ها ل أنك ظن نت أن غي

د أبا ف ليس فيه الصال هذه يكن مل فمن الروح فيه ء شي ول بيمة ول طي ول الناس من أحد كالم عليه يفى ل المام إن مم بمام. هو

Ahmad ibn Mihran has narrated from Muhammad Ibn Ali from abu Basir who has said that he asked (the

following) from Imam Abu Al-Hassanasws:

"May I be sacrificed for you, what proof is needed to determine who is a (Divine) Imamasws?" Heasws said, ‘Through several Qualities;

The first one is that hisasws fatherasws must have introduced himasws (to others). And that when asked he would answer and if one remain silent he would begin to speak on the issue and inform of the things that would happen the next day(s) (Ilm-ul-Ghaib) and he can speak to people in their own languages."

Then heasws said to me, "O Abu Muhammad, allow me to give you an example before you leave. A man from Khurasan came. He spoke to the Imamasws in Arabic but Abu Al-Hassanasws replied him in Persian. He (the man from Khurasan) said, "I swear by Allahazwj, "May Allahazwj Take my soul in service for yourasws cause, the only thing that stopped me from speaking to youasws in Persian was I thought youasws might not know Persian."

The Imamasws then said, "Glory belongs to Allahazwj, If Iasws am unable to answer you (in Persian) then how would Iasws have any excellence over you?"

False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan (Al-Yamani) www.hubeali.com

18 out of 50

The Imamasws said to me, "O Abu Muhammad, "No one’s language is unknown to the Imamasws nor the language of birds, animals and any living things. Whoever does not have these qualities, he is not an Imamasws.23

23

285: ، ص1 ، ج(اإلسالمية -ط )الكافي , H. 7

False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan (Al-Yamani) www.hubeali.com

19 out of 50

Appendix I:

Ibleesla cannot come in a Dream in the Appearance of Prophetas or an Imamasws or their followers:

حدثنا ممد بن إبراهيم بن إسحاق الطالقان رضي اهلل عنه قال حدثنا أحد بن ممد بن سعيد الكوف مول بن هاشم عن علي بن السي بن علي بن فضال عن أبيه عن أب السن علي بن موسى الرضا أنه قال له رجل من أهل خراسان يا ابن رسول

يقول ل كيف أنتم إذا دفن ف أرضكم بضعيت و استحفظتم وديعيت و غيب ف ثراكم جنمي اهلل رأيت رسول اهلل ص ف املنام كأنهفقال له الرضا أنا املدفون ف أرضكم و أنا بضعة نبيكم فأنا الوديعة و النجم أل و من زارن و هو يعرف ما أوجب اهلل تبارك

ن كنا شفعاءه جنا و لو كان عليه مثل وزر الثقلي اجلن و النس و تعال من حقي و طاعيت فأنا و هبائي شفعاؤه يوم القيامة و مو لقد حدثن أب عن جدي عن أبيه عن هبائه أن رسول اهلل ص قال من زارن ف منامه فقد زارن ألن الشيطان ل يتمثل ف

ء من سبعي جزءا من النبوة صورت و ل ف صورة أحد من أوصيائي و ل ف صورة أحد من شيعتهم و إن الرؤيا الصادقة جز

Muhammad ibn Ibrahim ibn Ishaq al- Taleqani - may Allah be pleased with him narrated that Ahmad ibn Muhammad ibn Saeed al-Kufi - a chief of the Hashemite tribe - quoted on the authority of Ali ibn AI-Hassan ibn Ali ibn Fadhdhal, on the authority of his father the following:

A man from Khorasan told Abul Hassan Ali ibn Musa AI-Rezaasws, son of the Prophet of Allahsaww! I saw the Prophet of Allahsaww in a dream. The Prophetsaww asked me, How will you be when one of my own flesh and blood is buried in your land, you are asked to protect my trust, and my star (AI-Rezaasws) when he disappears in your soil?’ Then AI-Rezaasws told him, I am the one who will be buried in your land. I am a piece of the flesh and blood of your Prophetsaww. Iasws am the trusted one and Iasws am the star. Know that whoever visits measws recognizing my rightfulness and obeys measws as Allahazwj has Made it incumbent upon him to do so - my forefathersasws and Iasws will intercede on his behalf on the Resurrection Day. Whoever on whose behalf weasws intercede shall be saved, even if there is the heavy burden of sin of the Jinn and the men on him.

In fact, my fatherasws quoted on the authority of my grandfatherasws, on the authority of his fatherasws, on the authority of his forefatherasws that Allahazwjs Prophetsaww said, Whoever visits mesaww in his dream, it is as if he has visited mesaww since Satan cannot appear to be like me, or appear to be like anyone of my Testamentary Trusteesasws (the 12 Imamsasws). Neither can Satan appear to be like any of their followers. Indeed truthful dreams are one of the seventy parts of Prophethood.24

24

Uyun Akhbar Ali Reza (asws), 66-11, pg. 584, 258ص : 2أخبارالرضا) ( ج : عيون

False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan (Al-Yamani) www.hubeali.com

20 out of 50

Appendix II:

عليه السالم ( قال قال ما ت روي هذه الناصبة ف قلت علي بن إب راهيم عن أبيه عن ابن أب عمي عن ابن أذي نة عن أب عبد الله ) بن كعب رهه ف الن وم ف قال كذبوا فن جعلت فداك فيما ذا ف قال ف أذانم و ركوعهم و سجودهم ف قلت إن هم ي قولون إن أب

الله عز و جل أعز من أن ي رى ف الن وم دين

Ali Bin Ibrahim, from his father, from Ibn Abu Umeyr, from Ibn Azina,

(It has been narrated) from Abu Abdullahasws having said: ‘What are these Hostile Ones (Nasibis) reporting?’ So I said, ‘May I be sacrificed for youasws! With regards to what?’ So heasws said: Regarding their Azans, and their Rukū and their Sajud (plural of Sajdah)’. So I said, ‘They are saying that Abayy Bin Ka’ab saw it during the sleep (dream)’. So heasws said: ‘They are lying, for the Religion of Allahazwj Mighty and Majestic is more Honourable than for it to be seen during the sleep (dream)’.

رف جعلت ي اقال ف قال له سدير الص فداك فأحدث لنا من ذلك ذكرا ف قال أبو عبد الله ) عليه السالم ( إن الله عز و جل لمبع أما أولهن ف بارك عليه و الثانية مه ف رضه فأن زل الله ممال من نور فيه عل عرج بنبيه ) صلى اهلل عليه وهله ( إل ساواته الس

أرب عون ن وعا من أن وا النور كانت مدقة بعرش الله ت غشى أبصار الناظرين

He (the narrator) said, ‘So Sudeyr Al-Sayrafi said to himasws, ‘May I be sacrificed for youasws! So narrate to us a reminder of that’. So Abu Abdullahasws said: ‘When Allahazwj Mighty and Majestic Ascended Hisazwj Prophetsaww to the seven skies, so as for the first of these, Heazwj Blessed upon himsaww, and (in) the second, Taught himsaww hissaww Obligations. So Allahazwj Sent down a carriage of Light wherein were forty varieties from the varieties of Light which engulf the Throne of Allahazwj, overwhelming the sights of the onlookers.

ها فأصفر فمن أجل ذلك ها أب يض أما واحد من ها أحر فمن أجل ذلك احرت المرة و واحد من اصفرت الصفرة و واحد من حمل حلق و سالسل من فضة الم فمن أجل ذلك اب يض الب ياض و الباقي على سائر عدد اللق من النور و األلوان ف ذلك

As for one of these, so it was yellow, and due to that is the yellowness of the yellow; and one of these was red, and due to that is the redness of the red; and one of these was white, and due to that is the whiteness of the white; and the remainder were upon the number of the rest of the creatures of light; and the colours in that carriage, the ring, and the chain were from silver.

ماء ماء ف ن فرت المالئكة إل أطراف الس وس ما أشبه هذا النور بنور رب نا ث عرج به إل الس دا و قالت سبوح قد و خرت سجماء و اجتمعت الم رئيل ) عليه السالم ( الله أكب ر الله أكب ر ث فتحت أب واب الس ) صلى اهلل الئكة فسلمت على النب ف قال جب

الم قال النب ) صلى د كيف أخوك إذا ن زلت فأقرئه الس اهلل عليه وهله ( أ ف ت عرفونه قالوا و كيف عليه وهله ( أف واجا و قالت يا ممل ل ن عرفه و قد أخذ ميثاقك و ميثاقه منا نا و إنا لنتصفح وجوه شيعته ف كل ي وم و لي ة خسا و ميثاق شيعته إل ي وم القيامة علي

ي عنون ف كل وقت صالة و إنا لنصلي عليك و عليه

False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan (Al-Yamani) www.hubeali.com

21 out of 50

Then hesaww was ascended with to the sky, so the Angels alienated towards the horizons of the sky and fell down in Sajdah and said, ‘Glorious One! Holy One! How resembling is this light with the Light of our Lordazwj!’ So Jibraeelas said: ‘Allahazwj is the Greatest!’ Then the door of the sky were opened and the Angels gathered around. So they greeted upon the Prophetsaww in droves, and said, ‘O Muhammadsaww! How is yoursaww brotheras? When yousaww descend, so convey the greetings to himasws’. The Prophetsaww said: ‘Do you all recognise himasws?’ They said, ‘And how can we not recognise himasws, and heasws has taken yoursaww Covenant and hissaww own Covenant from us, and the Covenant of hisasws Shias upon us up to the Day of Judgement, and we browse through the faces of hisasws Shias five times during every day and night, meaning during every time for Salāt, and we send Blessings upon yousaww and upon himasws’.

ا قربت قال ث زادن رب أربعي ن وعا من أن وا النور ل يشبه النور األول و زادن ح ماء الثانية ف لم لقا و سالسل و عرج ب إل السدا و قالت سبوح ماء و خرت سج ماء الثانية ن فرت المالئكة إل أطراف الس وس رب المالئكة و الروح ما أ من باب الس شبه قد

رئيل ) عليه السالم ( أشهد أن ل إله إل الله أشهد أن ل إله إل الله فاجتمعت المالئكة و قالت يا هذا النور بنور رب نا ف قال جب د ) صلى رئيل من هذا معك قال هذا مم اهلل عليه وهله ( قالوا و قد بعث قال ن عم جب

Hesaww said: ‘Then mysaww Lordazwj Increased for mesaww forty types from the verities of the Light, non resembling the earlier Lights (Given to mesaww before), and Increased mesaww with a ring, and chain, and Ascended with me to the second sky. So when Isaww was near to the door of the second sky, the Angels alienated towards the horizons of the sky and fell down in Sajdah, and said: ‘Glorious One! Holy One! Lordazwj of the Angels and the Spirit! How resembling is this light with the Light of our Lordazwj!’ So Jibraeelas said: ‘I testify that there is no god except for Allahazwj’. So the Angels gathered around and said, ‘O Jibraeelas! Who is this one with youas?’ Heas said: ‘This is Muhammadsaww’. They said: ‘And hesaww has (already) been sent (with the Prophet-hood)?’ Heas said: ‘Yes’.

الم ق لت أ ت عرفونه قالوا قال النب ) صلى اهلل عليه وهله ( فخرجوا إل شبه المعانيق فسلموا علي و قالوا أقرئ أخا و كيف ك السنا و إنا ل لة خسا ل ن عرفه و قد أخذ ميثاقك و ميثاقه و ميثاق شيعته إل ي وم القيامة علي نتصفح وجوه شيعته ف كل ي وم و لي

ي عنون ف كل وقت صالة

The Prophetsaww said: ‘So they came out towards mesaww resembling the swarms. So they greeted upon mesaww and said: ‘Convey the greetings to yoursaww brotherasws’. Isaww said: ‘Do you all recognise himasws?’ They said: ‘How can we not recognise himasws, and heasws has taken yoursaww Covenant, and hisasws own Covenant, and the Covenant of hisasws Shias upon us up to the Day of Judgement, and we browse through the faces of the Shias five times during every day and night, meaning during every time for Salāt’.

دا زادن رب أربعي ن وعا من أن وا النور ل تشبه األن وار األول ث عرج ب إل القال ث ماء الثالثة ف ن فرت المالئكة و خرت سج سوس رب المالئكة و الروح دا و قالت سبوح قد رئيل ) عليه السالم ( أشهد أن مم ما هذا النور الذي يشبه نور رب نا ف قال جب

رسول الله قال فاجتمعت المالئكة و قالت مرحبا باألول دا لخر و مرحبا بالاشر و مرحبا و مرحبا بارسول الله أشهد أن ممر الوصيي ر النبيي و علي خي د خي بالناشر مم

False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan (Al-Yamani) www.hubeali.com

22 out of 50

Hesaww said: ‘Then mysaww Lordazwj Increased me with forty types from the varieties of the Light, non resembling the earlier Lights (Given to mesaww before). Then Isaww was ascended with to the third sky. So the Angels alienated and fell down Sajdah, and said: ‘Glorious One! Holy One! Lordazwj of the Angels and the Spirit! What is this light which resembles the Light of our Lordazwj?’ So Jibraeelas said: ‘Ias testify that Muhammadsaww is Rasool-Allahsaww! Ias testify that Muhammadsaww is Rasool-Allahsaww! So the Angels gathered around and said: ‘Welcome to the first one! And welcome to the last one! And welcome to the Resurrector (of souls)! And welcome to the Publisher (of the deeds), Muhammadsaww, the best of the Prophetsas, and Aliasws the best of the successorsas’.

فونه قالوا و كيف ل ن عرفه و قد قال النب ) صلى اهلل عليه وهله ( ث سلموا علي و سألون عن أخي ق لت هو ف األرض أ ف ت عر ة ) عليهم السالم ( و ج الب يت المعمور كل سنة و عليه رق أب يض فيه اسم د و اسم علي و السن و السي و األئم مم

لة خسا ي عنون ف وقت م بأيديهم كل صالة و يسحون رءوسه شيعتهم إل ي وم القيامة و إنا لنبارك عليهم كل ي وم و لي

The Prophetsaww said: ‘Then they greeted upon mesaww and asked measws about mysaww brotherasws. Isaww said: ‘Heasws is in the earth. Do you all recognise himasws?’ They said: ‘And how can we not recognise himasws and we perform the Hajj of the Bayt Al-Mamour (The Oft-frequented House) every year, and upon it is a while Parchment wherein is the name of Muhammadsaww, and name of Aliasws, and Al-Hassanasws, and Al-Husaynasws, and the Imamsasws, and theirasws Shias up to the Day of Judgement, and we Bless upon them five times during every day and night, during the time for every Salāt, and we wipe their heads by their hands’ (while performing Wuzu).

ماء الرابعة ف لم ت قل قال ث زادن رب أربعي ن وعا من أن وا النور ل تشبه تلك األ ن وار األول ث عرج ب حىت ان ت هيت إل السم عت دويا كأنه ف الصدور فاجتمعت المالئكة ف فتحت أب واب الس المعانيق ف قال اء و خرجت إل شبه المالئكة شيئا و س

رئيل ) عليه السالم ( جب

Hesaww said: ‘Then mysaww Lordazwj Increased for me forty types from the varieties of Light non resembling the earlier Lights (Given to mesaww before). Then Isaww was ascended with to the sky until Isaww ended up to the fourth sky. Where the Angels were quiet, and I heard a vibration as if it is in the chests. So the Angels gathered around, and the doors of the sky were open, and they came out towards mesaww resembling the hordes. So Jibraeelas said:

الة حي على الفالح حي على الفالح ف قالت المالئكة صوتان مق حي رئيل ) على الصالة حي على الص رونان معروفان ف قال جب الة ف قالت المالئكة الة قد قامت الص هي لشيعته إل ي وم القيامة عليه السالم ( قد قامت الص

‘Hasten to the Salāt! Hasten to the Salāt! Hasten to the success! Hasten to the success!’. So the Angels said: ‘These two voices are paired and well-known’. So Jibraeelas said: ‘The Salāt has been established! The Salāt has been established!’ So the Angels said: ‘It is for hissaww Shias up to the Day of Judgement’.

False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan (Al-Yamani) www.hubeali.com

23 out of 50

يعته و هم نور حول عرش الله و إن ف ث اجتمعت المالئكة و قالت كيف ت ركت أخاك ف قلت لم و ت عرفونه قالوا ن عرفه و ش د و علي و السن و السي ة و شيعتهم إل ي وم القيامة ل الب يت المعمور لرقا من نور فيه كتاب من نور فيه اسم مم و األئم

نا كل ي وم جعة يزيد ف هم رجل و إنه لميثاق نا و إنه لي قرأ علي قص من يهم رجل و ل ي ن

The Angels gathered around and said: ‘How did yousaww leave yoursaww brotherasws?’ So Isaww said to them: ‘And you all recognise himasws?’ They said: ‘We recognise himasws, and hisasws Shias when they were lights around the Throne of Allahazwj, and in the Bayt Al-Mamour (The Oft-Frequented House) is a Parchment of light wherein is writing of light, in which are names of Muhammadsaww, and Aliasws, and Al-Hassanasws, and Al-Husaynasws, and the Imamasws, after the Imamasws, and theirasws Shias up to the Day of Judgement. Neither is a man increased among them nor is a man reduced from them; and it is our Covenant which is read out to us every Friday’.

ماء قد خرقت و الجب قد د ف رف عت رأسي فذا أطباق الس رأسك انظر ما ث قيل ل ارفع رأسك يا مم رفعت ث قال ل طأط يتكم هذا و حرم مثل حرم هذا الب يت لو ألقيت شيئا من يدي مل ي قع إل عليه ت رى فطأطأت رأسي ف نظرت إل ب يت مثل ب

Then it was Said to mesaww: “O Muhammadsaww! Raise yoursaww head!” So Isaww raised mysaww head, and there were the layers of the sky which had been pierced and the veils had been raised. Then Heazwj Said to mesaww: “Lower yoursaww head, look! What do yousaww see?” So Isaww lowered mysaww head and looked at a house similar to these houses of yours, and a Sanctuary like the Sanctuary of this House (Kabah). If Isaww had thrown something from mysaww hand, it would not have fallen except upon it.

د إن هذا الرم د ادن من صاد فاغسل مساج فقيل ل يا مم رها و أنت الرام و لكل مثل مثال ث أوحى الله إل يا مم دك و طه و صل لربك

So it was Said to mesaww: “O Muhammadsaww! This is the Sanctuary and yousaww are the sanctimonious, and for every like there is a like”. Then Allahazwj Revealed unto mesaww: “O Muhammadsaww! Approach Sa’ad (a river) and wash yoursaww places of Sajdah, and clean these, and pray Salāt to yoursaww Lordazwj”.

وهله ( من صاد و هو ماء يسيل من ساق العرش األين ف ت لقى رسول الله ) صلى اهلل عليه وهله فدنا رسول الله ) صلى اهلل عليه ( الماء بيده اليمن فمن أجل ذلك صار الوضوء باليمي

So Rasool-Allahsaww approached Sa’ad (a river), and it is water which flows from the right Pillar of the Throne. So Rasool-Allahsaww scooped the water with hissaww right hand, and due to that the Wuzu came to be performed with the right hand.

فنك ت نظر إل عظميت ث اغسل ذراعيك اليمن و اليسرى فنك ت لقى بيدك ث أوحى الله عز و جل إليه أن اغسل وجهك أوطئك موطئا مل يطأه أحد ك عليك و كالمي ث امسح رأسك بفضل ما بقي ف يديك من الماء و رجليك إل كعب يك فن أبار

رك ف هذا علة األذان و الوضوء غي

False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan (Al-Yamani) www.hubeali.com

24 out of 50

Then Allahazwj Mighty and Majestic Revealed unto himsaww: “Wash yoursaww face for yousaww would be looking at Myazwj Magnificence. Then wash yoursaww right arm and the left for yousaww would be receiving Myazwj Speech with yoursaww hands. Then wipe your head with the remnants of what remain in your hands from the water, and the feet up to your ankles, for Iazwj would Bless upon yousaww, and Make yousaww to tread upon a place where not one had trod upon before apart from you”. Thus this is the reason for the Azan and the Wuzu’.

رن على عدد حج د است قبل الجر األسود و كب فمن أجل ذلك صار التكبي سبعا ألن ب ث أوحى الله عز و جل إليه يا ممن هن حبار النور و ذلك النور الجب سبع فاف تتح عند انقطا الجب فمن أجل ذلك صار الفتتاح سنة و الجب متط ابقة ب ي

د ) صلى اهلل عليه وهله ( فمن أجل ذلك صار الفتتاح ثالث مرات لفتتاح الج الذي أن زله ب ثالث مرات فصار الله على مم التكبي سبعا و الفتتاح ثالثا

Then Allahazwj Mighty and Majestic Revealed unto himsaww: “O Muhammadsaww! Face the Black Stone and exclaim Myazwj Greatness upon the number of Myazwj Veils”. So due to that, the exclamations of Takbīr’ came to be seven, because the Veils are seven. So hesaww commenced at the intermission of the Veils, and due to that the commencement came to be a Sunnah; and the Veils are layered, there being oceans of Light between them, and that is the Light which descended unto Muhammadsaww, and due to that, the commencement is three times because of the opening of the Veils three times. Thus the exclamations of the Takbīr’s (altogether before commencement) came to be seven, and the commencement, three.

ي فمن أجل ذلك جعل بس ا ف رغ من التكبي و الفتتاح أوحى الله إليه سم باس ورة ث أوحى ف لم م الله الرحن الرحيم ف أول السا قال المد لله رب العالمي قال النب ف ن فسه شكرا ف م أوحى الله عز و جل إليه قطعت حدي فس الله إليه أن احدن ف لم

ي فمن أجل ذلك جعل ف المد الرحن الرحيم مرت ي باس

So when you are free from the exclamations of Takbīr’ and the commencement, Allahazwj Revealed unto himsaww: “Name Meazwj by Myazwj Name”. So due to that, ‘In the Name of Allahazwj the Beneficent, the Merciful’ is in the first Chapter. Then Allahazwj Revealed unto himsaww: “Praise Meazwj”. So when hesaww said: ‘The Praise is for Allahazwj, Lordazwj of the worlds’, the Prophetsaww said within himselfsaww: ‘Thanks’. So Allahazwj Mighty and Majestic Revealed unto himsaww: “Now you discontinued speaking of Meazwj. Call Meazwj by Myazwj Name”. So due to that ‘The Beneficent, the Merciful’ was Made to be twice in Al-Hamd (Chapter 1).

ا ب لغ و ل الضالي قال ي النب ) صلى اهلل عليه وهله ( المد لله رب العالمي شكرا فأوحى الله إليه قطعت ذكري ف ف لم سم باسورة ل الس فمن أجل ذلك جعل بسم الله الرحن الرحيم ف أو

So when hesaww reached ‘nor of those who has strayed’, the Prophetsaww said: ‘The Praise is for Allahazwj the Lordazwj of the worlds, thanks’. So Allahazwj Revealed unto himsaww: “Revealed unto himsaww: “Now you discontinued speaking of Meazwj. Call Meazwj by Myazwj Name”. So due to that, ‘In the Name of Allahazwj the Beneficent, the Merciful was made to be in the first Chapter.

False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan (Al-Yamani) www.hubeali.com

25 out of 50

د نسبة ربك ت بارك و ت عال قل هو الله يلد و مل يولد. و مل يكن له أحد. الله الصمد. مل ث أوحى الله عز و جل إليه اق رأ يا ممفأوحى الله إليه مل يلد و مل يولد. كفوا أحد ث أمسك عنه الوحي ف قال رسول الله ) صلى اهلل عليه وهله ( الواحد األحد الصمد

أحد .و مل يكن له كفوا

Then Allahazwj Mighty and Majestic Revealed unto himsaww: “Read, O Muhammadsaww, a Relationship of yoursaww Lordazwj Blessed and High. Read [112:1] Say: He, Allah, is One. [112:2] Allah is He on Whom all depend. [112:3] He begets not, nor is He begotten. [112:4] And none is like Him”. Then the Wahi (Revelation) was Withheld from him, so Rasool-Allahsaww said: ‘The Alone, the One, the Depended’. So Allahazwj Revealed until himsaww: “[112:1] Say: He, Allah, is One. [112:2] Allah is He on Whom all depend. [112:3] He begets not, nor is He begotten. [112:4] And none is like Him”.

ا قال ذلك أوحى الله إليه ارك ث أمسك عنه الوحي ف قال رسول الله ) صلى اهلل عليه وهله ( كذلك الله كذلك الله رب نا ف ل ع مد ف ركع فأوحى الله إليه و هو راكع قل سبحان رب العظيم ف فعل ذلك ثالثا لربك يا مم

Then the Wali (Revelation) was Withheld from himsaww, so Rasool-Allahsaww said: ‘Like that is our Lordazwj! Like that is our Lordazwj!’. So when hesaww said that, Allahazwj Revealed unto himsaww: “Perform Rukū to yoursaww Lordazwj, O Muhammadsaww!” So hesaww went down into Rukū, and Allahazwj Revealed unto himsaww: “Say Glorious is mysaww Lordazwj, the Magnificent”. So hesaww did that three (times).

د ف فعل رسول الله ) صلى اهلل عليه وهله ( ف قام م نتصبا فأوحى الله عز و جل إليه أن ث أوحى الله إليه أن ارفع رأسك يا ممد فخر رس ل ول الله ) صلى اهلل عليه وهله ( ساجدا فأوحى الله عز و جل إليه قل سبحان رب األعلى ف فع اسجد لربك يا مم

ذلك ثالثا

Then Allahazwj Revealed unto himsaww: “Raise yoursaww head, O Muhammadsaww!” So Rasool-Allahsaww stood upright and Allahazwj Mighty and Majestic Revealed unto himsaww: “ Perform Sajdah to yoursaww Lordazwj, O Muhammadsaww!” So Rasool-Allahsaww fell down in Sajdah, and Allahazwj Mighty and Majestic Revealed onto himsaww: “Say: Glorious is mysaww Lordazwj, the Exalted”. So hesaww did that three (times).

ا رفع رأسه من سجوده و است وى ج د ف فعل ف لم السا نظر إل عظمته تلت له فخر ساجدا ث أوحى الله إليه استو جالسا يا مم فأوحى الله إليه ان تصب قائما ف فعل ف لم ي من تلقاء ثالثا ر ما كان رأى من العظمة فمن أجل ن فسه ل ألمر أمر به فسبح أيضا

ذلك صارت الصالة ركعة و سجدت ي

Then Allahazwj Revealed unto himsaww: “Sit upright, O Muhammadsaww!” So hesaww did. So when hesaww raised hissaww head from his Sajdah and sat upright, hesaww looked at Hisazwj Magnificence being Manifested to himsaww, so hesaww fell down in Sajdah from his own self, not to a Command hesaww been Commanded with, and he Glorified three (times) as well. So Allahazwj Revealed unto himas: “Stand upright!” So hesaww did, but could not see what hesaww had seen from the Magnificence. Thus, from the reason of that, the Salāt came to be with one Rukū and two Sajdud (plural of Sajdah).

False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan (Al-Yamani) www.hubeali.com

26 out of 50

ها نسبتك و ى الله عز و جل إليه اق رأ إنا أن زلناه فن ث أوحى الله عز و جل إليه اق رأ بالمد لله ف قرأها مثل ما ق رأ أول ث أوح ا رفع رأسه تلت له نسبة أهل ب يتك إل ي وم القيامة و ف عل ف الركو مثل ما ف عل ف المرة األول ث سجد سجدة واحدة ف لم

سه ل ألمر أمر به فسبح أيضا العظمة فخر ساجدا من تلقاء ن ف

Then Allahazwj Mighty and Majestic Revealed unto himsaww: “Read the Praise for Allahazwj”. So hesaww recited it similar to what hesaww had recited firstly. Then Allahazwj Mighty and Majestic Revealed unto him: “Read [97:1] We have indeed revealed it (Chapter 97), for it is yoursaww relationship and the relationship of the Peopleasws of yoursaww Household, up to the Day of Judgement”. And hesaww did in the Rukū the like of what hesaww had done the first time. Then he went down (and performed) one Sajdah. So when hesaww raised hissaww head, the Magnificence Manifested to himsaww, so hesaww fell down in Sajdah from hissaww own self, not to a Command hesaww had been Commanded with. So hesaww Glorified, as well.

د ا ذهب لي قوم قيل يا مم د ث بتك ربك ف لم د إذا ما ث أوحى الله إليه ارفع رأسك يا مم اجلس فجلس فأوحى الله إليه يا ممي فألم أن قال بس م الله و بالله و ل إله إل الله و األساء السن كلها لله أن عمت عليك فسم باس

Then Allahazwj Revealed unto himsaww: “Raise yoursaww head, O Muhammadsaww, yoursaww Lordazwj has Affirmed yousaww”. So when hesaww went on to stand, Heazwj Said: “O Muhammadsaww! Be seated”. So hesaww sat, and Allahazwj Revealed unto himsaww: “O Muhammadsaww! Whenever Iazwj Favour upon yousaww, so Name Meazwj by Myazwj Name”. So hesaww was inspired that hesaww should say: ‘In the Name of Allahazwj, and by Allahazwj, and there is no god except for Allahazwj, and the beautiful Names, all of them are for Allahazwj’.

د صل على ن فسك و على أهل ب يتك ف قال صلى الله علي و على أهل ب ييت و قد ف عل ث الت فت فذا ث أوحى الله إليه يا ممالم عليكم و رحة الله و ب ركاته بصفوف من المالئكة و المرسلي و النبيي فقيل د سلم عليهم ف قال الس يا مم

Then Allahazwj Revealed unto himsaww: “O Muhammadsaww! Send Blessings upon yourselfsaww and upon the Peopleasws of yoursaww Household”. So hesaww said: ‘May Allahazwj Send Blessings upon mesaww and upon the Peopleasws of mysaww Household’, and it had been done. Then hesaww turned, and hesaww was with rows of Angels, and the Mursil Prophetsas, and the Prophetsas. So it was said: “O Muhammadsaww! Greet upon them!” So hesaww said: ‘The greetings be upon you, and the Mercy of Allahazwj and Hisazwj Blessings’.

الم و التحية و الرحة و الب ركات أنت و ذري تك فأوحى الله إليه أن الس

So Allahazwj Revealed unto himsaww: “The greetings, and the salutation, and the Mercy, and the Blessings, are yousaww and yoursaww childrenasws”.

عها ب عد قل هو الله أحد و إن ل هية س مال ا أن زلناه هية أ ث أوحى الله إليه أن ل ي لتفت يسارا و أو صحاب اليمي و أصحاب الشجود ش لة و من أجل ذلك كان التكبي ف الس الم واحدة تاه القب ده ألن فمن أجل ذلك كان الس ع الله لمن ح كرا و ق وله س

ع الله ل النب ) صلى اهلل عليه وه ة المالئكة بالتسبيح و التحميد و الت هليل فمن أجل ذلك قال س ع ضج ده و من له ( س من ح

False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan (Al-Yamani) www.hubeali.com

27 out of 50

ا إعادت هما ف هذا الفرض األول ف صالة الزوال أجل ذلك صارت الركعتان األوليان كلما أحدث فيهما حدثا كان على صاحبهم ي عن صالة الظهر .

Then Allahazwj Revealed unto himsaww: “Do not turn towards the left!”; and the first Verse hesaww heard after [112:1] Say He Allah is One (Chapter 112) and [97:1] We have indeed revealed it (Chapter 97), was the Verse of the companions of the right and the companions of the left (Chapter 56).Thus, it was due to that, the Salām is one with you facing the Qiblah, and due to that the exclamation of Takbīr’ in the Sajdah is the thanks, and Hisazwj Words: “Allahazwj Hears the one who Praise Himazwj”, is because the Prophetsaww heard the sounds of the Angels with the Glorifications, and the Praises, and the Extollation of Holiness. Thus, it was due to that Heazwj Said: “Allahazwj Hears the one who Praises Himazwj; and it was due to that the first two Rak’at of Salāt came to be such that every time your Wuzu breaks in these two, it would be upon its performer that he repeats it. So this is the first necessity during Salāt of midday, meaning Salāt Al-Zohar’.25

25

Al Kafi V 3 – The Book Of Salāt CH 100 H 1

False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan (Al-Yamani) www.hubeali.com

28 out of 50

Appendix III: Mixing up the Truth and Falsehood:

د بن السي د بن معلى عن األشعري مم اء علي بن السن عن مم ة و الوش د بن أحد عن أصحابنا من عد فضال ابن عن مميعا د عن حيد بن عاصم عن ج الناس ( السالم عليه ) المؤمني أمي خطب قال ( السالم عليه ) جعفر أب عن مسلم بن مما الناس أي ها ف قال رجال رجال فيها ي ت ول الله كتاب فيها يالف ت بتد أحكام و ت تبع واء أه الفت وقو بدء إن

Al Husayn Bin Muhammad Al Ashary, from Moalla Bin Muhammad, from Al Hassan Bin Al Washa and a number of our companions, from Ahmad Bin Muhammad, from Ibn Fazzal, altogether from Aasim Bin Humeyd, from Muhammad Bin Muslim,

(It has been narrated) from Abu Ja’farasws having said: ‘Amir Al-Momineenasws addressed the people, so heasws said; ‘O you people! The start of the occurrence of the sedition is the following of personal desires and the innovation of regulations wherein the Book of Allahazwj is opposed. A man takes command of a man in it.

خذ من هذا ضغث و من هذا ف لو أن الباطل خلص مل يف على ذي حجى و لو أن الق خلص مل يكن اختالف و لكن ي ؤ يطان على أوليائه و جنا الذين سب قت لم من الله السن .ضغث ف يمزجان ف يجيئان معا ف هنالك است حوذ الش

So if the falsehood was pure, it would not be hidden from the one with intelligence, and if the truth was pure, differing would not occur. But, a bunch is taken from this, and a bunch from this, so they are both mixed up. Thus, they are coming with both of these together. So from over here, the Satanla takes over hisla friends! And only those who have previously received Protection Allahazwj remain safe. 26

26

Al Kafi V 1 – The Book Of Intellect and Ignorance CH 19 H 1

False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan (Al-Yamani) www.hubeali.com

29 out of 50

Appendix IV: Establishing the Authenticity of a Hadith:

د د بن الله عبد عن يي بن مم ثن و قال ي عفور أب بن الله عبد عن عثمان بن أبان عن الكم بن علي عن مم بن حسي حد نثق من ي رويه الديث اختالف عن ( السالم عليه ) الله عبد أبا سألت قال المجلس هذا ف ي عفور أب ابن حضر أنه العالء أب

هم و به عليه اهلل صلى ) الله رسول ق ول من أو الله كتاب من شاهدا له ف وجدت حديث عليكم ورد إذا قال به نثق ل من من . به أول به جاءكم فالذي إل و ( وهله

Muhammad Bin Yahya, from Abdullah Bin Muhammad, from Ali Bin Al Hakam, from Aban Bin Usman, from Abdullah Bin Abu Yafour who said, ‘And it was narrated to me by Husayn Bin Abu Al A’ala that he was present with Ibn Abu Yafour in this gathering where he said,

‘I asked Abu Abdullahasws about the differing in the Ahadeeth being reported by the ones we trust with it and the ones we do not trust with it’. Heasws said: ‘Whenever a Hadeeth arrives to you and you find evidence for it from the Book of Allahazwj, or from the words of Rasool-Allahsaww (fine), or else, (take) the one which came to you which was the closest with it (the Book and other Ahadith)’.27

The Importance of the ‘Primary Sources’ of Ahadith:

One of the important roles of the Divine Imamasws is to re-establish the Truth - if something has been added to the religion (Ahadith) or has been left out (omission from a Ahadith). Therefore, in principle, the ‘correction’ process had been ceased after the occurrence of the Grand Occultation, hence, the Ahadith books (primary sources) which were compiled before the occurrence of the Grand Occultation (329 A.H.) are to be consulted first and foremost and Ahadith from the later sources to be compared with the earlier ones (only). As we find in the following Hadith:

د عن أبيه عن إب راهيم بن علي ار بن إسحاق عن مسلم بن سعدان و يونس بن منصور عن عمي أب بن مم الله عبد أب عن عمعته قال ( السالم عليه ) . لم أمته شيئا ن قصوا إن و ردهم شيئا المؤمنون زاد إن كيما إمام فيها و إل تلو ل األرض إن ي قول س

Ali Bin Ibrahim, from his father, from Muhammad Bin Abu Umeyr, from Mansour Bin Yunus and Sa’dan Bin Muslim, from Is’haq Bin Ammar,

(It has been narrated) from Abu Abdullahasws, said, ‘I heard himasws saying: ‘The earth cannot be empty except there would be an Imamasws so that if the believers (Momineen) exceed in something (addition to a Hadith), heasws would return them (remove the added part), and if they are deficient in something (something has been eliminated from a Hadith), heasws would complete it (the Hadith) for them’.28

27

Al Kafi V 1 – The Book Of Intellect and Ignorance CH 21 H 2 28

Al Kafi V 1 – The Book Of Divine Authority CH 5 H 2

False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan (Al-Yamani) www.hubeali.com

30 out of 50

Take those Ahadith which are famous among our shias,

هما واحد ي فضل ل أصحابنا عند مرضيان عدلن فن هما ق لت قال ف عنا روايتهم من كان ما إل ي نظر ف قال قال الخر على من رك و حكمنا ن م به ف ي ؤخذ أصحابك من عليه المجمع به حكما الذي ذلك اذ ي ت فن أصحابك عند بشهور ليس الذي الش

فيه ريب ل عليه المجمع

……He (the narrator) said, ‘I said (to the Imamasws), ‘Supposing both of them (the Ahadith narrators who are taken to resolve a dispute among two believers) are just, agreeable in the presence of our companions, not one of the two having any merit upon the other?’ So heasws said: ‘You would look at what was from their reports from usasws (Ahadith) regarding that (issue) which they are judging with, and converge upon that (which is more norm) among your companions. So they should be taking with ourasws judgment and neglect the abnormal (fabricated Ahadith) which is not well-known among your companions. So they should converge upon that (Hadith) where there is no doubt in it. (An extract from a long Hadith)29

29

Al Kafi V 1 – The Book Of Intellect and Ignorance CH 20 H 10

False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan (Al-Yamani) www.hubeali.com

31 out of 50

Appendix V: The Recognition of Safyani and Yamani:

حدثنا أحد بن زياد بن جعفر المدان رضي اهلل عنه قال حدثنا علي بن إبراهيم بن هاشم عن أبيه إبراهيم بن هاشم عن ممد عن حاد بن عثمان عن عمر بن يزيد قال قال ل أبو عبد اهلل الصادق إنك لو رأيت السفيان لرأيت أخبث بن أب عمي

الناس أشقر أحر أزرق يقول يا رب ثأري ثأري ث النار و قد بلغ من خبثه أنه يدفن أم ولد له و هي حية خمافة أن تدل عليه

Narrated to us Ahmad bin Ziyad bin Ja’far Hamadani: Narrated to us Ali bin Ibrahim bin Hashim from his father Ibrahim bin Hashim from Muhammad bin Abi Umair from Hammad bin Uthman from Umar Ibne Yazid that he said: Abi Abdullah al-Sadiq

asws said to me:

Imam Abu Abd Allahasws said: ‘If you have seen Sufyani you have seen the most horrible

man. He is red, blonde and blue. He will say: ‘يا رب’ My Lord, I will take revenge even if I have

to go to Hell. The extent of his evil is that he would bury alive his slave mother so that she may not reveal his true ancestry.’30

حدثنا ممد بن علي ماجيلويه رضي اهلل عنه قال حدثنا عمي ممد بن أب القاسم عن ممد بن علي الكوف عن ممد بن أب عمي عن عمر بن أذينة قال قال أبو عبد اهلل قال أب قال أمي املؤمني يرج ابن هكلة األكباد من الوادي اليابس و هو

الوجه ضخم الامة بوجهه أثر جدري إذا رأيته حسبته أعور اسه عثمان و أبوه عنبسة و هو من ولد أب سفيان رجل ربعة وحش حىت يأت أرضا ذات قرار و معي فيستوي على منربها

Muhammad bin Abil Qasim from Muhammad bin Ali Kufi from Muhammad bin Abi Umair from Umar bin Uzaina that he said:

Abi Abdullahasws said to me: Amir-ul-Momineenasws said: ‘The son of the liver-eater will come out from the valley of Yabis. He shall be of medium height. His face will be horrible. He will be fat. His face will be pock-marked. He will be one-eyed. His name will be Uthman and his father’s name will be Anbasa. He will be from the progeny of Abu Sufyan. He will camp in Kufa where he will sit on the pulpit.’31

الكوف قال حدثنا حدثنا أب و ممد بن السن رضي اهلل عنهما قال حدثنا ممد بن أب القاسم ماجيلويه عن ممد بن علي السي بن سفيان عن قتيبة بن ممد عن عبد اهلل بن أب منصور البجلي قال سألت أبا عبد اهلل عن اسم السفيان فقال و ما

األردن و قنسرين فتوقعوا عند ذلك الفرج قلت يلك تسعة تصنع باسه إذا ملك كور الشام المس دمشق و حص و فلسطي و كن يلك مثانية أشهر ل يزيد يوماأشهر قال ل و ل

Narrated to us my father and Muhammad bin Hasan - May Allah be pleased with them – they said: Narrated to us Muhammad bin Abil Qasim Majilaway from Muhammad bin Ali Kufi: Narrated to us Husain bin Sufyan from Qutaibah Ibne Muhammad from Abdullah bin Abi Mansur Bajali that he said: I asked Abi Abd Allah

asws about

the name of Sufyani. He replied:

30

H. 10 ,651ص : 2الدين ج : كمال 31

.H. 9 ,651ص : 2الدين ج : كمال

False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan (Al-Yamani) www.hubeali.com

32 out of 50

(Imam Abi Abd Allah said) ‘Why do you want to know his name? When he conquers the districts of Shaam, Hams, Palestine, Jordan and Qanassireen, you wait for the reappearance.’

I asked: ‘Would he rule for nine months?’ He replied: ‘No, only for eight months and not a day more.’32

مات الزم األرض ل ترك يدك و ل رجلك أبدا حىت ترى عال»العياشي: عن جابر اجلعفي، عن أب جعفر )عليه السالم(، يقول: أذكرها لك ف سنة، و ترى مناديا ينادي بدمشق، و خسفا بقرية من قراها، و تسقط طائفة من مسجدها، فذا رأيت الرتك جازوها، فأقبلت الرتك حىت نزلت اجلزيرة، و أقبل الروم حىت نزلت الرملة، و هي سنة اختالف ف كل أرض من أرض العرب، و

األصهب، و األبقع، و السفيان، مع بن ذنب المار مضر، و مع السفيان الث رايات:أن أهل الشام يتلفون عند ذلك على ثء قط و يضر رجل بدمشق، أخواله من كلب، فيظهر السفيان، و من معه على بن ذنب المار، حىت يقتلوا قتال مل يقتله شي

هي الية اليت يقول اهلل تبارك و تعال: فاخت لف ء قط، و هو من بن ذنب المار، و فيقتل هو و من معه قتال مل يقتله شي األحزاب من ب ينهم إل هخره.

Al Ayyashi, from Jabir Al Ju’fy,

‘Abu Ja’farasws has said: ‘The commitment of the earth is that it will not move your hand, nor your feet ever, until you see such Signs in one year which Iasws am mentioning to you. And you will see a Caller Calling out at Damascus, and a town from the towns gets submerged (in the land), and several of its Masjids fall down, so you will see the Turks move across it. So the Turks would come over until they encamp at the Island, and the Romans would come over until they encamp at Al-Ramla, and it is a year in which there would be disputes in every land from the lands of the Arabs. And the people of Syria would be disputing during that, over three banners – the ‘Bald Eagle’, and the ‘The Arrow-shaped Leaves’, and Al-Sufyani, with the Clan of Zanb Al-Himaar Muzir. And with Al-Sufyani would be his maternal uncles from a dog (illegitimate one). So Al-Sufyani and the ones with him would overcome the Clan of Zanb Al-Himaar, until they kill them with such a killing which nothing had been killed before. And a man would appear at Damascus, so he and the one with him would be killed with a killing which nothing had been killed at all (before), and he would be from the Clan of Zanb Al-Himaar – and it is the Verse which Allahazwj Blessed and High is Speaking of [19:37] But the parties from among them disagreed with each other, so woe unto those who disbelieve in being present on a Great Day’.33

32

.H. 11 ,652ص : 2الدين ج : كمال 33

117/ 64: 1تفسير العياشي

False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan (Al-Yamani) www.hubeali.com

33 out of 50

VERSES 113 & 114

قون أو يحدث لهم لك أن زلناه ق رآنا عربيا وصرف نا فيه من الوعيد لعلهم ي ت ذكرا وكذول ت عجل بالقرآن من ق بل أن ي قضى إليك ف ت عالى الله الملك الحق {113}

{114وقل رب زدني علما } يه وح [20:113] And thus have We Revealed it as an Arabic Quran, and have distinctly set forth therein of threats that they may be fearing or that it may Cause a Remembrance for them [20:114] So, Exalted is Allah, the King, the Truth, and do not make haste with the Quran before its Revelation is made complete to you and say: Lord! Increase me in knowledge

علي بن إبراهيم: يعن ما يدث من أمر القائم )عليه السالم( و السفيان.

Ali Bin Ibrahim –

Regarding [20:113] or that it may Cause a Remembrance for them – said, ‘What is narrated from the matter of Al-Qaimasws and Al-Sufyani’.34

لكأن »العياشي: عن عبد األعلى اللب، قال: قال أبو جعفر )عليه السالم( ف حديث يذكر فيه خروج القائم )عليه السالم(: مصعدين من جنف الكوفة ثالمثائة و بضعة عشر رجال كأن قلوبم زبر -م( و أصحابهيعن القائم )عليه السال -أنظر إليهم

أمده اهلل بمسة هلف من املالئكة الديد، جربئيل عن يينه و ميكائيل عن يساره، يسي الرعب أمامه شهرا و خلفه شهرا،راكع و ساجد يتضرعون إل اهلل، حىت إذا أصبح مسومي، حىت إذا صعد النجف قال ألصحابه: تعبدوا ليلتكم هذه، فيبيتون بي

« قال: خذوا بنا طريق النخيلة، و على الكوفة جند جمندة

Al Ayyashi, from Abdul A’la Al Halby who said,

‘Abu Ja’farasws said in a Hadeeth mentioning in it the rising of Al-Qaimasws: ‘It is as if Iasws am looking at them – meaning Al-Qaimasws and hisasws companions – going up to Najaf, Al-Kufa. Three hundred and some ten men, with their hearts being like blocks of iron. Jibraeelas being on their right and Mikaeelas on their left. The fear moving in front of them publicised, and behind them publicised. Allahazwj would Help himasws with five thousand from the Angels with a terrifying onslaught, until they overcome Al-Najaf, heasws would say to hisasws companions: ‘(Perform acts of) worship in this night of yours’. So they would be in between Bowing and Prostrating, appealing to Allahazwj until the morning. Take with usasws the Al-Nakheela way to Al-Kufa with the recruit army.

كعتي، فيخرج إليه إي و اهلل، حىت ينتهي إل مسجد إبراهيم )عليه السالم( بالنخيلة، فيصلي فيه ر »و جند جمندة؟ قال: قلت:قال أبو -من كان بالكوفة من مرجئيها و غيهم من جيش السفيان، فيقول ألصحابه: استطردوا لم. ث يقول: كروا عليهم،

الندق منهم خمرب. -و اهلل -و ل يوز -جعفر )عليه السالم( 34

65: 2تفسير القمي

False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan (Al-Yamani) www.hubeali.com

34 out of 50

I said, ‘And the recruit army?’ Heasws said: ‘Yes, by Allahazwj, until heasws ends up at Masjid Ibrahimas at Al-Nakheela, so heasws would Pray two Cycles in it. So there would come out against himasws from those who were at Al-Kufa from the Murjiites and others from the army of Al-Sufyani, so heasws would say to hisasws companions: ‘Deal with them!’ Then heasws would say: ‘Attack them!’ By Allahazwj! It is not permissible for an informant from them but in the ditch’.

ابه: سيوا إل ث يدخل الكوفة فال يبقى مؤمن إل كان فيها، أوحن إليها، و هو قول أمي املؤمني )عليه السالم(، ث يقول ألصحهذا الطاغية، فيدعوه إل كتاب اهلل و سنة نبيه )صلى اهلل عليه و هله( فيعطيه السفيان من البيعة مسلما، فيقول له كلب، و هم

استقبله فيستقبله، ث يقول له القائم أخواله: ما هذا الذي صنعت؟ و اهلل ما نبايعك على هذا أبدا. فيقول ما أصنع؟ فيقولون: السالم(: خذ حذرك فنن أديت إليك، و أنا مقاتلك. )عليه

Then heasws would enter Al-Kufa. So there would not remain a Believer except that he would be in it, or yearn for it, and it is the speech of Amir-ul-Momineenasws. Then heasws would be saying to hisasws companions: ‘Go to this tyrant, and call him to the Book of Allahazwj and the Sunnah of Hisazwj Prophetsaww’. So they (the believers) would be coming to him for the pledge of allegiance in submission (Imamasws). A dog (an uncle of Sufyani) would say to him (Sufyani), ‘What is this which you are (intending to) do? By Allahazwj! We would never pledge allegiance to them (believers) upon this, ever!’ So he (Al-Sufyani) would be saying, ‘What shall I do?’ They would be saying, ‘Accept himasws so that heasws would accept you’. Then Al-Qaimasws would say to him: ‘Take a warning, for Iasws have blood-money compensation (أديت) against you, and Iasws shall be fighting against you’.

سل جريدة خيل إل الروم ث ير فيصبح فيقاتلهم فيمنحه اهلل أكتافهم، و يأخذ السفيان أسيا، فينطلق به و يذحبه بيده.فيأبون، و يقولون: و اهلل ل نفعل: فيقول -فيستحذرون بقية بن امية، فذا انتهوا إل الروم قالوا: أخرجوا إلينا أهل ملتنا عندكم

بم، فن اجلريدة: و اهلل لو أمرنا لقاتلناكم، ث ينطلقون إل صاحبهم فيعرضون ذلك عليه، فيقول انطلقوا فأخرجوا إليهم أصحا هؤلء قد أتوا بسلطان

So it would become that heasws would fight against them and Allahazwj would grant himasws victory and Al-Sufyani would be taken as a captive. So heasws would go to him and slaughter him with hisasws own hands. Then heasws would sent hisasws cavalry to Rome. So they would caution the remainder of the Clan of Umayya when they end up at Rome, saying, ‘Bring out to us the people of our nation who are with you!’ They (Romans) would refuse, and would be saying, ‘By Allahazwj! We will not do it!’ So the cavalry would say, ‘By Allahazwj! If only we had been ordered to fight you!’ Then they would rush to their companions and present it (the whole affair) to them, so they would be saying, ‘Quickly, bring their companions out to them, for they have come with an authority’.

وا بأسنا إذا هم منها ي ركضون ل ت ركضوا و ارجعوا إل ما أترف تم فيه و مساكنكم و هو قول اهلل عز و جل: ا أحس لعلكم ف لميا وي لنا إنا كنا ظالمي فما زالت تلك دعواهم حىت جعلناهم حصيدا خامدين تسئ لون قال: يعن الكنوز اليت كنتم تكنزون، قالوا

«.ل يبقى منهم خمرب

False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan (Al-Yamani) www.hubeali.com

35 out of 50

And these are the Words of Allahazwj Mighty and Majestic [21:12] So when they felt Our Punishment, so they began to flee [21:13] Do not flee (now) and come back to what you were made to lead easy lives in and to your dwellings, so that you would be questioned. Heasws said: ‘It Mean the treasures which you all have been hoarding. They would say [21:14] They said: O woe be unto us! Surely we were unjust [21:15] And this ceased not to be their cry till We made them as a harvested field, motionless. There shall not remain an informant among them’.35

الناس على أربعة أصناف: ممد بن إبراهيم النعمان ف )الغيبة(: بسناده عن كعب األحبار، قال: إذا كان يوم القيامة حشر صنف ركبان، و صنف على أقدامهم يشون، و صنف مكبون، و صنف على وجوههم صم بكم عمي فهم ل يعقلون، و ل

يتكلمون، و ل يؤذن لم فيعتذرون، أولئك الذين تلفح وجوههم النار، و هم فيها كالون.

Muhammad Bin Ibrahim Al-Nu’mani in Al-Ghayba, by his chain from Ka’ab Al-Ahbaar who said,

‘When it will be the Day of Judgement, the people would be Gathered over four categories – A type who would be riding, and a type who would be walking upon their feet, and a type lying flat, and a type upon their faces. Deaf, dumb, blind, so they would not know, nor would they be speaking, nor would they be permitted to present excuses. They are the ones whose faces would be touched by the Fire, and they would be gloomy in it.

هم، و هذه الال حالم؟ قال: كعب: أولئك الذين كانوا على الضالل و فقيل: يا كعب، من هؤلء الذين يشرون على وجوهالرتداد و النكث، فبئس ما قدمت لم أنفسهم إذا لقوا اهلل حبرب خليفتهم و وصي نبيهم، و عاملهم، و سيدهم، و فاضلهم، و

ل يهل، و احملجة اليت من زال عنها عطب، الذي حامل اللواء و ول الوض، و املرتى، و الرجاء دون هذا العامل، و هو العلمو ف النار هوى، ذلك علي و رب كعب، أعلمهم علما، و أقدمهم سلما، و أوفرهم حلما، عجب كعب ممن قدم على علي

غيه.

So it was said, ‘O Ka’ab, who are these who would be gathered upon their faces, and this condition, would be their condition?’ Ka’ab said, ‘They are the ones who were upon the straying and the apostasy and the breaking of the allegiance. So evil is what they sent forward for themselves, when they would meet Allahazwj having battled against their Caliph and the successorasws of their Prophetsaww, and their knowledgeable oneasws, and their Chief, and their best one, and the bearer of the Flag and the Guardian of the Fountain, and they hoped and wished for other than this knowledgeable oneasws, and heasws had the knowledge in which there was no ignorance, and that which was not corrupted, and in the Fire they would be yearning for himasws (to help them). That is Aliasws and lord of Ka’ab, whoasws taught them knowledge, and preceded them in submission, and their most forbearing one. Ka’ab is astounded from the one who gives preference to others over Aliasws.

و من نسل علي )عليه السالم( القائم املهدي )عليه السالم( ، الذي يبدل األرض غي األرض، و به يتج عيسى بن مرمي )عليه من نسل علي )عليه السالم( أشبه الناس بعيسى بن مرمي خلقا و خلقا و السالم( على نصارى الروم و الصي، إن القائم املهدي

ستا و هيبة ، يعطيه اهلل عز و جل ما أعطى األنبياء و يزيده و يفضله.

35

49/ 56: 2تفسير العياشي

False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan (Al-Yamani) www.hubeali.com

36 out of 50

And from the children of Aliasws is Al-Qaimasws Al-Mahdiasws, the one who would change the earth to a different earth, and by himasws would be the argument of Isaas Bin Maryamas upon the Christians of Rome and China. Al-Qaim Al-Mahdiasws is from the children of Aliasws, resembling Isaas Bin Maryamas in morals and ethics, and appearance and prestige. Allahazwj Mighty and Majestic would Give himasws what Heazwj Gave to the Prophetsas and Increase it, and Prefer himasws.

إن القائم )عليه السالم( من ولد علي )عليه السالم( له غيبة كغيبة يوسف، و رجعة كرجعة عيسى بن مرمي، ث يظهر بعد غيبته خسف املزورة، و هي بغداد، و خروج السفيان، و حرب ولد العباس مع مع طلو النجم األحر، و خراب الزوراء و هي الري، و

فتيان أرمينية و هذربيجان، تلك حرب يقتل فيها ألوف و ألوف، كل يقبض على سيف ملى، تفق عليه راياتسود، تلك حروب يشوبا املوت األحر، و الطاعون األكرب.

Al-Qaimasws is from the sonsasws of Aliasws. For himasws would be an occultation like the occultation of Yusufas, and a return like the return of Isa Bin Maryamas. Then heas would appear after hisasws occultation after the emergence of the red star, and the ruination of Al-Zawra - and it is Al-Rayy, and the submerging of Al-Mazroura – and it is Baghdad, and the coming out of Al-Sufyani, and the battle of the sons of Al-Abbas with the youths of Armenia and Azerbaijan. That is the battle in which thousands upon thousands would be killed. Each one holding a sword would be destroyed, having failed to the black banners. These wars would be marred by the red death, and the great plague’.36

د بن عيسى عن علي بن الكم عن أب أيوب الزاز د بن يي عن أحد بن مم عت أبا عبد الله مم عن عمر بن حنظلة قال سسف و ق تل الن فيان و ال فس الزكية و اليمان ف قلت جعلت )عليه السالم( ي قول خس عالمات ق بل قيام القائم الصيحة و الس

ا كان من الغد ت لو فداك إن ت هذه الية إن نشأ ن ن زل عليهم خرج أحد من أهل ب يتك ق بل هذه العالمات أ نرج معه قال ل ف لمماء هية فظلت أعناق هم لا خاضعي ف قلت له أ ه يحة ف قال أما لو كانت خضعت أعناق أعداء الله عز و جل.من الس ي الص

Muhammad Bin Yahya, from Ahmad Bin Muhammad Bin Isa, from Ali Bin Al-Hakam, from Abu Ayyub Al-Khazaz, from Umar Bin Hanzala who said:

I heard Abu Abdullahasws saying: ‘There are five signs before the rising of Al-Qaimasws – The scream, and the Sufyani, and the sinking (of the earth), and the killing of the pure soul (Al-Nafs Al-Zakkiyya) and Al-Yamani’. So I said, ‘May I be sacrificed for youasws, if someone from yourasws Household comes out (in revolt) before these signs, shall we come out (revolt) with him?’ Heasws said: ‘No’. So when it was the next morning, I recited this Verse: “[26:4] If We please, We should send down upon them a sign from the heaven so that their necks should stoop to it”. I said, ‘Is this the scream?’ Heasws said: ‘If that was, then the necks of the enemies of Allahazwj Mighty and Majestic would stoop down in humility’.37

36

4/ 145الغيبة: 37

Al-Kafi, Vol. 8, H. 14931

False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan (Al-Yamani) www.hubeali.com

37 out of 50

راج قال ق لت ألب عبد الله )ع د عن ابن مبوب عن ي عقوب الس ليه السالم( مىت ف رج شيعتكم قال ف قال و عنه عن أحد بن مممل يكن يطمع فيهم و خلعت العرب أعنت ها و رفع كل ذي صيصية إذا اخت لف ولد العباس و وهى سلطان هم و طمع فيهم من

امي و أق بل اليمان و ترك السن و خرج صاحب هذا األمر من ة بت راث صيصيته و ظهر الش رسول الله ) صلى المدينة إل مك اهلل عليه وهله (

And from him, from Ahmad Bin Muhammad, from Ibn Mahboub, from Yaqoub Al-Sarraaj who said:

I said to Abu Abdullahasws, ‘When will there be relief for yourasws Shiites?’ Heasws said: ‘When the children of Al-Abbas differ regarding their authority, and he who was not greedy for it before, covets it, and the Arabs remove their reins, and everyone with spurs (horsemen) battles for it, and Al-Shami (The Syrian) appears, and Al-Yamani (The Yemenite) comes forward, and Al-Hasany moves (with a movement), and the Masterasws of this Command will come out from Al-Medina to Al-Makkah with the inheritance of the Rasool Allahsaww’.

ال سيف رسول الله و درعه و عمامته و ب رده و قضيبه و راي ته و لمته و ف قلت ما ت راث رسول الله ) صلى اهلل عليه وهله ( ق ر و ي نشر الراية و الب رد يف من غمده و ي لبس الد ة ف يخرج الس ي ت ناول القضيب بيده و ة و العمامة و سرجه حىت ي نزل مك

يستأذن الله ف ظهوره

So I said, ‘What inheritance of the Rasool Allahsaww?’ Heasws said: ‘Sword of the Rasool Allahsaww, and hissaww Armor, and hissaww turban, and hissaww gown, and hissaww staff, and hissaww banner, and hissaww helmet, and hissaww saddle, until heasws descends upon Makkah. So heasws will take out the sword from its sheath, and put on the Armor, and display the banner, and (wear) the gown and the turban, and grab the staff by hisasws hand, and seek Permission of Allahazwj for hisasws appearance.

عث ف يطلع على ذلك ب عض مواليه ف يأت السن ف يخربه الب ر ف يبتدر السن إل ال ة ف ي قت لونه و ي ب ون روج ف يثب عليه أهل مكامي ف يظهر عند ذلك صاحب هذا األمر ف يبايعه الناس و ي تبعونه و ي ب امي عند ذلك جيشا إل المدينة برأسه إل الش عث الش

ة ف ي لحقون بصاحب هذا ف ي هلكهم الله عز و جل دون ها و ي هرب ي ومئذ من كان بالمدينة من ولد علي ) عليه السالم ( إل مكعث جيشا إل المدينة ف يأمن أهلها و و العراق و ي ب هااألمر و ي قبل صاحب هذا األمر . ي رجعون إلي

That will be announced to some of hisasws friends. Al-Hassany would come. So heasws would inform him of the news. Al-Hassany would initiate the coming out (Al-Khurouj). The people of Makkah would pounce upon him. So they will kill him and send his head to Al-Shamy (The Syrian). During that, the Masterasws of this Command will appear. So the people would pledge their allegiances to himasws and follow himasws. And Al-Shamy (The Syrian) would send an army to Al-Medina. So Allahazwj Mighty and Majestic would Destroy them before it (gets there). On that day, those from the children of Aliasws who would be in Al-Medina would flee to Makkah. So they would join up with the Masterasws of this Command. And the Masterasws of this Command would go towards Al-Iraq and send hisasws army to Al-Medina. Its people would express belief and they would return to it’.38

38

Al-Kafi, Vol. 8, H. 14733

False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan (Al-Yamani) www.hubeali.com

38 out of 50

علي بن إبراهيم، قال: حدثن أب، عن ابن أب عمي، عن منصور بن يونس، عن أب خالد الكابلي، قال: قال أبو جعفر )عليه السالم( و قد أسند ظهره إل الجر، ث ينشد اهلل حقه، ث يقول: يا أيها الناس، و اهلل لكأن أنظر إل القائم )عليه »السالم(:

من ياجن ف اهلل فأنا أول باهلل. أيها الناس، من ياجن ف هدم فأنا أول بآدم.

Ali Bin Ibrahim said, ‘My father narrated to me from Ibn Abu Umeyr, from Mansour Bin Yunus, from Abu Khalid Al-Kalby who said:

‘Abu Ja’farasws said: ‘By Allahazwj! It is as if Iasws am looking at Al-Qaimasws, with hisasws back against Al-Hajar (The Black Stone), then heasws adjures to Allahazwj of hisasws rights, then heasws is saying: ‘O you people! The one who disputes with measws, regarding Allahazwj, so (beware) Iasws am the closest with Allahazwj. O you people! The one who disputes with measws regarding Adamas, so Iasws am the closest with Adamas’.

لناس، من ياجن ف إبراهيم فأنا أول ببراهيم. أيها الناس، من ياجن ف أيها الناس، من ياجن ف نوح فأنا أول بنوح. أيها ا موسى فأنا أول بوسى. أيها الناس، من ياجن ف عيسى فأنا أول بعيسى.

O you people! The one who disputes with measws regarding Noahas, so I am the closest with Noahas. O you people! The one who disputes with me regarding Ibrahimas, so Iasws am the closest with Ibrahimas. O you people! The one who disputes with me regarding Musaas, so Iasws am the closest with Musaas. O you people! The one, who disputes with measws regarding Isaas, so Iasws am the closest with Isaas.

أيها الناس، من ياجن ف رسول اهلل فأنا أول برسول اهلل. أيها الناس، من ياجن ف كتاب اهلل فأنا أول بكتاب اهلل. ث ينتهي «.إل املقام، فيصلي ركعتي، و ينشد اهلل حقه

O you people! The one who disputes with measws regarding Rasool-Allahsaww, so Iasws am the closest with Rasool-Allahsaww. O you people! The one who disputes with measws regarding the Book of Allahazwj, so Iasws am the closest with the Book of Allahazwj’. Then heasws would end up to the Al-Maqam (of Ibrahimas) so heasws would pray two Cycles (of Salat), and adjure to Allahazwj of hisasws rights’.

وء و »ث قال أبو جعفر )عليه السالم(: يب المضطر إذا دعاه و يكشف الس هو و اهلل املضطر ف كتاب اهلل، ف قوله: أمن ي يعلكم خلفاء األرض،

Then Abu Ja’farasws said: ‘By Allahazwj! Heasws (Al-Qaimasws) is the restless one (المضطر) in the Book of Allahazwj, regarding Hisazwj Words: Or, One Who Answers the distressed one when he supplicates to Him and He Removes the evil, and He will Make you to be Caliphs of the earth! [27:62].

فيكون أول من يبايعه جربئيل، ث الثالث مائة و الثالثة عشر رجال، فمن كان ابتلي باملسي واىف، و من مل يبتل باملسي فقد عن فراشه، و هو قول أمي املؤمني )عليه السالم(: هم املفقودون عن فرشهم.

False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan (Al-Yamani) www.hubeali.com

39 out of 50

It would so happen that the first one who will pledge allegiance to himasws would be Jibraeelas, then three hundred and thirteen (313) men. So the one who will be Tried by the journey would fulfil it, and the one who will not be Tried by the journey would be upon his bed. And it is the speech of Amir-Al-Momineenasws: ‘They would be missing from their beds’.

و ل يسمي أحدا، حىت ينتهي إل البيداء، فيخرج إليه جيش السفيان، فيأمر اهلل األرض فتأخذهم من تت أقدامهم، و هو قول ريب و قالوا همنا به يعن بقائم هل ممد و قد كفروا به يعن بقائم هل اهلل: و لو ترى إذ فزعوا فال ف وت و أخذوا من مكان ق

-إل هخر السورة -ممد

And heasws will not name anyone until heasws ends up to Al-Bayda. The army of Al-Sufyani would come out against himasws. So Allahazwj would Command the earth, and it would seize them from underneath their feet, and these are the Words of Allahazwj: And if only you could see when they will panic, and they shall not escape, and they would be seized from a nearby place [34:51] And they shall say, ‘We believe in it’. [34:52] - meaning Al-Qaimasws of the Progenyasws of Muhammadsaww And they had disbelieved in it from before [34:53] - meaning in Al-Qaimasws of the Progenyasws of Muhammadsaww – up to the end of the Chapter.

وتر، و وتية، من مراد، وجوههما ف أقفيتهما، يشيان القهقرى، يربان الناس با فعل فال يبقى منهم إل رجالن، يقال لما: «.بأصحابما

So there will not remain among them except for two men called Watar, and Wateera, from Maraad. Their faces would be turned around, and they would be walking backwards, informing the people of what had befallen their companions’.39

ممد بن العباس، قال: حدثنا ممد بن السن بن علي بن الصباح املدائن، عن السن بن ممد بن شعيب، عن موسى بن عمر ابلي، عن أب جعفر )عليه السالم(، بن يزيد، عن ابن أب عمي، عن منصور بن يونس، عن إساعيل بن جابر، عن أب خالد الك

عامله قد قتل، فيجع إليهم، فيقتل املقاتلة، و ل يزيد على ذلك يرج القائم )عليه السالم( فيسي حىت ير بر، فيبلغه أن»قال: ، فيدعو الناس حىت ينتهي إل البيداء، «1»شيئا، ث ينطلق

Muhammad Bin Al-Abbas, from Muhammad Bin Al-Hassan Bin Ali Bin Al-Sabah Al-Mada’iny, from Al-Hassan Bin Muhammad Bin Shuayb, from Muha Bin Umar Bin Yazeed, from Ibn Abu Umeyr, from Mansour Bin Yunus, from Ismail Bin Jabir, from Abu Khalid Al-Kalby,

‘Abu Ja’farasws has said: ‘Al-Qaimasws would come out until heasws passes by Marr. (News) would reach himasws that hisasws office bearers have been murdered. So heasws would come out towards them, and kill their murderers, and not increase anything upon that. Then heasws would start by calling the people, until heasws ends up Al-Bayda.

فيخرج جيش للسفيان، فيأمر اهلل عز و جل األرض أن تأخذ بأقدامهم، و هو قوله عز و جل: و لو ترى إذ فزعوا فال ف وت و قائم )عليه السالم( و قد كفروا به من ق بل، يعن بقيام القائم من هل ممد أخذوا من مكان قريب و قالوا همنا به يعن بقيام ال

39

.49/ 56: 2تفسير العياشي

False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan (Al-Yamani) www.hubeali.com

40 out of 50

ن هم و ب ي ما يشت هون كما فعل بأشياعهم من ق بل إن هم )صلى اهلل عليه و هله( و ي قذفون بالغيب من مكان بعيد و حيل ب ي «.شك مريب كانوا ف

So the army of Al-Sufyani would come out, and Allahazwj Mighty and Majestic would Command the earth that it should seize them by their feet, and these are the Words of the Mighty and Majestic [34:51] And if you could see when they shall become terrified, so there shall be no escape and they shall be Seized upon from a near place [34:52] And they shall say: We believe in it meaning the rising of Al-Qaimasws [34:53] And they disbelieved in it from before meaning in the rising of Al-Qaimasws from the Progenyasws of Muhammadsaww [34:53] and they would be casting (slanders) with regard to the unseen from a remote place [34:54] And a barrier shall be placed between them and that which they desire, as was done with their adherents before: surely they are in a disquieting doubt’.40

حم حتم، و )عي( »حبذف السناد، يرفعه إل ممد بن جهور، عن السكون، عن أب جعفر )عليه السالم(، قال: تأويل هخر:[ و مسخ يكون ف هخر الزمان بالسفيان و عذاب، و )سي( سنون كسن يوسف )عليه السالم(، و )قاف( قذف ]و خسف

«.ناس من كلب ثالثون ألف يرجون معه، و ذلك حي يرج القائم )عليه السالم( بكة، و هو مهدي هذه المةأصحابه، و

Another explanation – by a deleted chain, going up to Muhammad Bin Jamhour, from Al Sakuny, from

Abu Ja’farasws has said: ‘Ha Meem [42:1] is Ordained, and: Ayn [42:2] is Punishment, and: Seen are years like the years of Yusufas, and: Qaf is the repelling and the swallowing (by the earth) and the metamorphosis which would happen during the end of the times with Al-Sufyani and his companions, and the thirty thousand dogs of the people who would come out with him, and that is when Al-Qaimasws would emerge at Makkah, and heasws is the Mahdiasws of this community’.41

د بن وهبان عن أحد بن إب راهيم عن السن بن علي الزعفران عن الب رقي عن أبيه عن ابن أب السي بن إب راهيم القزوين عن مما خرج طالب الق قيل ألب عبد الل ذا اليمان ف قال ل ه ن رجو أن يكون ه عمي عن هشام بن سامل عن أب عبد الله قال لم

رأ منه اليمان ي ت وال عليا و هذا ي ب

Hasham ibn Salim reports when the ‘Talib-e-Haqq’ rose against the government, it was

asked from Abu Abd Allahasws: May be this man is the ‘ اليمان’ Al-Yamani?

Imamasws replied: No, but ‘ اليمان’ Al-Yamani will have the love of Aliasws but this man (who has

arisen against the government) is an enemy of (Aliasws) and holds grudges against himasws.42

40

478: 2تأويل اآليات 41

.3/ 542: 2تأويل اآليات 42

.H. 21 ,297ص : 47حباراألنوار ج :

False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan (Al-Yamani) www.hubeali.com

41 out of 50

Appendix VI: Imamasws and the Prophethoodas

لو علم اهلل أن اسا »قال: فقال: كم، عن أب عبد اهلل )عليه السالم(، ف قول اهلل: إن جاعلك للناس إماما.عن هشام بن ال «. أفضل منه لسمانا به

From Hisham Bin Al-Hakam, from Abu Abdullahasws, regarding the Words of Allahazwj “I will Make you an Imam for the people” [2:124]. Heasws said: ‘If Allahazwj Had a name superior than it (Imam), Heazwj would have Named usasws with it’’.43

حدثنا ممد بن عبد اجلبار عن اب عبد اهلل الربقى عن فضالة عن عبد الميد بن نصر قال قال أبو عبد اهلل ينكرون المام ون به واهلل ما ف الرض منزلة اعظم عند اهلل من مفرتض الطاعة وقد كان ابراهيم دهرا ينزل عليه المر من املفرتض الطاعة ويحد

اهلل وما كان مفرتض الطاعة حىت بدا هلل ان يكرمه ويعظمه فقال اىن جاعلك للناس اماما فعرف ابراهيم ما فيها من الفضل قال أبو عبد اهلل أي انا هي ف ذريتك ل يكون ف غيهم. ومن ذرييت فقال ل ينال عهدي الظاملي قال

It has been narrated to us by Muhammad Bin Abdul Jabbar, from Abu Abdullah Al-Barqy, from Fazaalat, from Abdul Hameed Bin Nasr who said:

‘Abu Abdullahasws said: ‘They are denying the obligatory obedience to the Imamasws, and they are fighting against it. By Allahazwj, there is nothing in the earth greater in the Presence of Allahazwj than the obligatory obedience. And Ibrahimas was around for a long time. The Command Descended upon himas from Allahazwj, and there was no obligatory obedience until Allahazwj Honoured himas and Made himas greater. Heazwj Said: He Said: “I will Make you an Imam for the people”. Ibrahimas realised what it contained of the preference. Heas said: He said: ‘And from my offspring?’ He Said: My Covenant cannot be attained by the unjust [2:124]. Abu Abdullahasws said: ‘But it is in hisas (Holy) descendants, and it will not happen to be in others’.44

د د بن يي عن مم السالم ( ي وم بن السي عن النضر بن سويد عن عمرو بن أب المقدام قال رأيت أبا عبد الله ) عليهمممام ث كان علي بن أب طالب عرفة بالموقف و هو ي نادي بأعلى صوته أي ها الناس إن رسول الله ) صلى اهلل عليه وهله ( كان ال

د بن علي ) عليه السالم ( ث هه ف ي نادي ثالث مرات لمن ب ي يديه و عن يينه و ث السن ث السي ث علي بن السي ث مم عن يساره و من خلفه اث ن عشر صوتا

Muhammad Bin Yahya, from Muhammad Bin Al Husayn, from Al nazar Bin Suweyd, from Amro Bin Abu Al Miqdam who said,

‘I saw Abu Abdullah-asws of the Day of Arafaat by the Pausing Station, and heasws was calling out in a loud voice of his-asws: ‘O you people! Rasool-Allah-saww was an Imam-saww, then Ali-asws Bin Abu Talib-asws was an Imam-asws, then Al-Hassan-asws, then Al-Husayn-asws, then Ali-asws Bin Al-Husayn-asws, then Muhammad-asws Bin Ali-asws, then Hah!’ So he-asws called out three times to the ones in front of him-asws, and on his-asws right, and on his-asws left, and for (those who were) behind him-asws, being twelve calls (in total).

43

.90/ 58: 1تفسير العياشي 44

Basaair Al Darajaat – P 10 Ch 18 H 12

False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan (Al-Yamani) www.hubeali.com

42 out of 50

ا أت يت من سألت أصحاب رهم و قال عمرو ف لم العربية عن ت فسي هه ف قالوا هه لغة بن فالن أنا فاسألون قال ث سألت غي أيضا من أصحاب العربية ف قالوا مثل ذلك .

And Amro said, ‘So when I went to Mina, I asked the masters of Arabic about the interpretation of (the word) ‘Ha’. So they said, ‘Ha’ in the language of the clan of so and so (means), ‘I, therefore ask me’. Then I asked others as well from the masters of the Arabic, and they (all) said similar to that’.45

السن، عمن ذكره، عن ممد بن خالد، عن ممد بن سنان، عن زيد الشحام، قال: عنه: عن ممد بن

From him (Al Kulayni), from Muhammad Bin Al Hassan, from the one who mentioned it, from Muhammad Bin Khalid, from Muhammad Bin Sinan, from Zayd Al Shahaam who said,

إن اهلل تبارك و تعال اتذ إبراهيم )عليه السالم( عبدا قبل أن يتخذه نبيا، و إن اهلل »)عليه السالم( يقول: سعت أبا عبد اهلل اتذه نبيا قبل أن يتخذه رسول، و إن اهلل اتذه رسول قبل أن يتخذه خليال، و إن اهلل اتذه خليال قبل أن يتخذه إماما، فلما

«.ك للناس إماما جع له األشياء قال: إن جاعل

‘I heard Abu Abdullahasws saying: ‘Allahazwj Blessed and High Took Ibrahimas as a servant before Heazwj Took himas as a Prophetas, and that Allahazwj Took himas as a Prophetas before Heazwj Took himas as a Rasoolas, and that Allahazwj Took himas as a Rasoolas before Heazwj Took himas as a Friend, and that Allahazwj Took himas as a Friend before Heazwj Took himas as an Imam. Therefore, when the things were gathered for himas, Heazwj Said: “I will Make you an Imam for the people” [2:124]’.

: ل يكون السفيه إمام -قال -فمن عظمها ف عي إبراهيم )عليه السالم(: قال و من ذرييت قال ل ينال عهدي الظالمي »قال: «.التقي

Heasws said: ‘So from its greatness in the eyes of Ibrahimas He said: ‘And from my offspring?’ He Said: My Covenant cannot be attained by the unjust [2:124]. The foolish one cannot become the Imam of the pious’.46

45

Al Kafi – V 4 – The Book of Hajj Ch 165 H 10 46

.2/ 133: 1الكافي

False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan (Al-Yamani) www.hubeali.com

43 out of 50

Appendix VII: Hadith-e-Tariq

Introduction of an Infallible Imamasws

Hadeeth -e- Tariq47

ة الله و وجه الله طارق يا بن شهاب عن أمي المؤمني أنه قال:الربسي ف مشارق األن وار عن طارق مام كلمة الله و حج اليع خلقه ف هو ولي و نور الله و حجاب الله و هية الله يتاره الله و يعل فيه ما يشاء و يوجب له بذل ه ك الطاعة و الولية على ج

م عليه كفر بالله يع عباده فمن ت قد من ف وق عرشه ف هو ي فعل ما يشاء و إذا شاء ف ساواته و أرضه أخذ له بذلك العهد على جدق و العدل و ي نصب له عمود من نور من األرض إل ربك صدقا و عدل و متت كلمة الله شاء و يكتب على عضده ف هو الص

ماء ي رى فيه أعمال العباد و ي لبس اليبة و علم الضمي المشرق و المغرب فال يفى و ي رى ما ب ي 49 و يطلع على الغيب 48الس لوحيه و ي رتضيه لغيبه و ي ؤيده ء من عامل الملك و الملكوت و ي عطى منطق الطي عند وليته ف هذا الذي يتاره الله عليه شي

مرة بكلمته و ي ل لطنة و يذعن له بال نه حكمته و يعل ق لبه مكان مشيته و ي نادي له بالس و يكم له بالطاعة و ذلك ألن 50قمامة مياث األنبياء و منزلة األصفياء و خالفة الل ين ال ه و خالفة رسل الله فهي عصمة و ولية و سلطنة و هداية و إنه متام الد

الكي و شس مشر مام دليل للقاصدين و منار للمهتدين و سبيل الس ب العارفي ولي ته سبب للنجاة قة ف ق لو و رجح الموازين الة ها رأس ب عد الممات و عز المؤمني و شفاعة المذنبي و جناة المحبي و ف وز التابعي ألن 51و طاعته مفرتضة ف الياة و عد

سالم و ك يان و معرفة الدود و األحكام و ت بيي الالل ال مه و 52 مال ال من الرام فهي مرت بة ل ي نالا إل من اختاره الله و قدمه فالولية هي حفظ الثغور و تدبي األ ه و حك هور ول ال على 53مور و ت عديد األيام و الش مام الماء العذب على الظم و الد ال

مس الطالعة على ا مام هو الش نوب المطلع على الغيوب ال ر من الذ مام المطه ن وار فال ت ناله األيدي و لعباد باأل الدى الشارة بقوله ت عال و المؤمنون علي و عرتته فالعزة للنب و للعرتة و النب و 54 و لله العزة و لرسوله و للمؤمني األبصار و إليه ال

يان و قطب الوجود و س ال هر ف هم رأس دائرة ال اء اجلود و شرف الموجود و ضوء شس عرتة ل ي فرتقان ف العزة إل هخر الدرف و نور قمره و أصل العز و المجد و مبدؤه و بيل و المنهاج و الماء الش اج و الس راج الوه مام هو الس معناه و مبناه فال

اج و البدر المشرق و الغدير اج و البحر العج ليل إذا ع الثج حاب المغدق و المنهج الواضح المسالك و الد ت المهالك و الس مماء الظليلة و النعمة اجلليلة و البحر الذي 55 الاطل و الغيث الامل ليل الفاضل و الس رف و البدر الكامل و الد ل ي نزف و الش

ئح و الطيب الفائح و العمل 56 لغزيرة و الروضة المطية و الزهر األريج و البدر البهيج الذي ل يوصف و العي ا و الني الال

47

Khutabah of Amir ul Momineen asws.

, Nahjul Asrar ( ف نسخة: و يعلم ما ف الضمي.2) 48 ( زاد ف نسخة: و يعطى التصرف على الطالق.3) 49 ( المرة بالكسر: المارة و الولية.1) 50 الدهر من مال و سالح.( العدة: ما اعددته لوادث 2) 51 ( ف نسخة: و سنن الالل.3) 52 ( ف نسخة:] و هي بعدد األيام و الشهور[ و لعله مصحف: و هي بعدد الشهور.4) 53 .8( املنافقون: 5) 54 ( الوهاج: شديد التقاد. الثجاج: سيال شديد النصباب. العجاج: الصياح.1) 55

ذبت و يقال: هطل املطر أي نزل متتابعا متفرقا عظيم القطر. و يقال: مهلت عينه اي فاضت دموعا. و السماء: دام مطرها ف سكون.و املغدق من غدق عي املاء: غزرت و ع ( البهيج: السن.2) 56

False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan (Al-Yamani) www.hubeali.com

44 out of 50

ف 57 الصالح و المتجر الرابح و المنهج الواضح و الطيب الرفيق واهيو األب الش و الاكم و المر و 58 يق مفز العباد ف الدته ف أرضه و بال 59 الناهي مهيمن ة الله على عباده و مج الئق و أمينه على القائق حج نوب مرب الله على ال ر من الذ أ ده مطه

خليفة الله ف ن هيه و أمره ل يوجد له من العيوب مطلع على الغيوب ظاهره أمر ل يلك و باطنه غيب ل يدرك واحد دهره و تنا أو ي عرف درجتنا أو يشهد كرامتنا أو يدرك منزلتنا حارت األلباب و العقول و مثيل و ل ي قوم له بديل فمن ذا ي نال معرف

عراء و خرست الب 60 تاهت األف هام لغاء و لكنت الطباء و عجزت فيما أقول تصاغرت العظماء و ت قاصرت العلماء و كلت الشماء عن وصف شأن األولياء و هل ي عرف أو يوصف أو ي ع لم أو ي فهم أو يدرك أو يلك من الفصحاء و ت واضعت األرض و الس

د ص عن وصف الواصفي و هو شعا جالل الكربيا ماء جل مقام هل مم ن عت الناعتي و أن ي قاس ء و شرف األرض و السو من أدب ر و ت ول الكربى اليت أعرض عنها بم أحد من العالمي كيف و هم الكلمة العلياء و التسمية البيضاء و الوحدانية

ظنوا أن 62 ذا عرف أو وصف من وصفت 61 حجاب الله األعظم األعلى فأين الختيار من هذا و أين العقول من هذا و من ياطي حزبا كل ذلك بغضة لبي ذلك ف غي هل و الش د كذبوا و زلت أقدامهم اتذوا العجل ربا ت الصفوة و دار العصمة و مم

يطان أعمالم حسدا لمعدن الرسالة و الكمة كيف اختاروا إماما جاهال عابدا للصنام جبانا 63ف تبا لم و سحقا و زين لم الشمام يب أن يكون عالما ل يهل و شجاعا ل ي نكل ل ي علو عليه حسب روة من و ل يدانيه نسب ف هو ف ي وم الزحام و ال الذ

رف من هاشم و البقية من إب راهيم و النهج من النبع الكرمي و النفس من الرسول و الرضى من الله و القول عن 64 ق ريش و الشاعة أود الله ق ل الله ف هو شرف األشراف و الفر من ع ياسة قائم بالرئاسة مفرتض الطاعة إل ي وم الس به سره بد مناف عامل بالس

و من أضل ممن ات بع هواه بغي و ات بعوا أهواءهم و أطلق به لسانه ف هو معصوم موفق ليس ببان و ل جاهل ف رتكوه يا طارق مام يا طارق بشر ملكي و جسد ساوي و أمر إلي و روح قدسي و مقام علي و هدى من الله هو نور جلي و سر خفي ف و ال

فات زائد السنات عامل بالمغيبات خصا من رب العالمي و نصا ات إلي الص د من الصادق األمي ملك الذ و هذا كله لل مم يل و معن التأويل و خاصة الرب اجلليل و مهبط األمي جربئيل صفوة الله و سره و ل يشاركهم فيه مشارك ألن هم معدن التنز

للة و مكم الرسال نور اجلاللة جنب الله و وديعته و موضع ة و كلمته شجرة النبوة و معدن الصفوة عي المقالة و منتهى الدبيل إل الله و لسبيل و القسطاس المستقيم و المنهاج كلمة الله و مفتاح حكمته و مصابيح رحة الله و ي نابيع نعمته الس الس

و التعظيم و التفضيل خلفاء النب الكرمي و مي و الذكر الكيم و الوجه الكرمي و النور القدمي أهل التشريف و التقومي و التقدمي القو يع عليم ظيم و أمناء العلي الع 65 أب ناء الرءوف الرحيم نام األعظم و الطريق األق وم من عرف هم ذرية ب عضها من ب عض و الله س الس

شارة بقوله هم أمر مملكته ف هم سر الله خلقهم الل 66 فمن تبعن فنه من و أخذ عنهم ف هو منهم و إليه ال ه من نور عظمته و ولياء ف علمهم علم األنب بأمره ي عملون إل الله يدعون و عنه ي قولون و 67 المخزون و أولياؤه المقربون و أمره ب ي الكاف و النون

( لعله مصحف و الطبيب الرفيق.3) 57 ( الدواهى: املصيبة و النوائب و الشدائد.4) 58 الشاهد، و القائم على اللق باعمالم و أرزاقهم.( املهيمن بعن املؤمتن و 5) 59 ( حار: تي. تاه: تي، ضل.6) 60 ( ف نسخة: و ما ذا عرف.1) 61 ( ف نسخة: ما وصف.2) 62 ( تباله أي الزمه الله خسرانا و هالكا. و سحقا اي ابعده الله.3) 63 ( ف نسخة: و الشمخ من النبع الكرمي.4) 64 ه النب صلى الله عليه و هله.( املراد ب1) 65 .36( إبراهيم: 2) 66 ( زاد ف نسخة: ل بل هم الكاف و النون.3) 67

False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan (Al-Yamani) www.hubeali.com

45 out of 50

رة ف ال مام كيده من و سر األوصياء ف سرهم و عز األولياء ف عزهم كالقطرة ف البحر و الذ ماوات و األرض عند ال قفر و السا يكون و ورث نها و ي علم ب رها من فاجرها و رطبها و يابسها ألن الله علم نبيه علم ما كان و م راحته ي عرف ظاهرها من باط

ر المصون األوصياء المنتجبون و من أنكرت ذلك ف هو شقي ملعون عنون و كيف ي فرض الله ذلك الس ي لعنه الله و ي لعنه الالد ت ن ماوات و األرض و إن الكلمة من هل مم صرف إل سبعي وجها و كل ما ف على عباده طاعة من يجب عنه ملكوت الس

ألنه جنب اجلنب فالمراد منها الول الكيم و الكتاب الكرمي و الكالم القدمي من هية تذكر فيها العي و الوجه و اليد و الذكر راط الله و وجه الله ي عن حق الله و علم الله و ع ي الله و يد الله ف هم اجلنب العلي و الوجه الرضي و المنهل الروي و الص

وي و الوسيلة إل الله و الوصلة إل عفوه و رضاه سر الواحد و األحد فال ي قاس ن اللق أحد ف هم خاصة الله و بم م السته و أعال ة الله و مج يان و كعبته و حج يان و كلمته و باب ال م الدى و راي ته و فضل الله و رحته و عي خالصته و سر الد

الكتاب و خامتته و فصل الطاب قيقته و صراط الق و عصمته و مبدأ الوجود و غاي ته و قدرة الرب و مشيته و أم اليقي و ح ه و معدن التنزيل و ناي ته ف هم الكواكب العلوية و األن وار العلوية المشرقة و دللته و خزنة الوحي و حفظته و هية الذكر و ت راجت

دية و األغصان النبوية النابتة لية المودعة ف ف د من شس العصمة الفاطمية ف ساء العظمة المحم وحة األحدية و األسرار الية الادية المهدية رية الزكية و العرتة الاش ة الطاهرون أولئك هم خي الربية الياكل البشرية و الذ و العرتة المعصومون و ف هم األئم

يقون و األوصياء المنتجبون د رية األكرمون و اللفاء الراشدون و الكرباء الص و األسباط المرضيون و الداة المهديون و الغر الذاألشجار و على طه و ياسي و حجج الله على األولي و الخرين اسهم مكتوب على األحجار و على أوراق الميامي من هل

ى أجنحة األمالك و على حجب اجلالل و سرادقات أجنحة األطيار و على أب واب اجلنة و النار و على العرش و األفالك و عل هم تسبح األطيار و تستغفر لشيعتهم اليتان ف جلج البحار ق رار و إن الله مل يلق أحدا إل و أخذ علي العز و اجلمال و باس ه ال

رية الزكية و الرباءة من أعدائهم و إن العرش مل ي د رسول الله بالوحدانية و الولية للذ ستقر حىت كتب عليه بالنور ل إله إل الله مم لله.علي ول ا

Tariq bin Shihab asked: “O Ameer al-Momineenasws please explain the virtues of an Imam (masoom), Ameer al-Momineenasws replied:

"O Tariq! The Imamasws is the 'Kalima-tul-Allah' Words of Allahazwj; 'Hujat-u-Allah’ the Proof of Allahazwj; ‘Wajh-Allah' the Direction to Allahazwj; 'Noor-Allah' the Light of Allahazwj; 'Hijab-Allah' the Veil of Allahazwj and 'Ayat-Allah' the Sign of Allahazwj.

Heasws is Chosen by Allahazwj who bestows onto himasws whatever qualities Heazwj chooses, and Makes it compulsory on all Hisazwj creatures to obey him-the Imamasws.

Thus, heasws is Allahazwj's Appointed Ruler in the Heavens and on the earth. Allahazwj has Taken a covenant regarding this from all Hisazwj servants. Whosoever, precedes the Imamasws has denied established Kingdom of Allahazwj. An Imamasws can act as heasws finds it appropriate; however hisasws actions only correspond to the Will of Allahazwj.

Inscribed on his upper limb is the-declaration: The words of Allahazwj are accomplished with truth and justice. For the Imamasws are both the justice and the truth. A column of light (stretching) from the earth to the sky is created for himasws, in which he witnesses the actions of the mankind. Heasws is enrobed in the cloak of power and dignity; heasws knows what is in the minds and has access to the unseen-al-ghayb; heasws has been entrusted with absolute Power (in conducting his affairs); heasws beholds all that rests between the

False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan (Al-Yamani) www.hubeali.com

46 out of 50

dominions of the East and the West: Nor is anything from the realms of ‘Mulk and Malakoot’ which is hidden from himasws; and heasws has the ability to communicate with the birds, who submit to hisasws Wilayah68.

Thus, heasws is the only one, whom Allahazwj has chosen for Hisazwj Revelations, has approved himasws for (knowledge of) the Al-ghaib (Unseen), has strengthened himasws by hisasws speech, and Instructed himasws in wisdom. Hisasws heart has made a station for Hisazwj Will. (Allahazwj) has Proclaimed Hisazwj Governance and has Granted himasws the (privilege) to rule, and has Commanded all to obey him. This is because the Imamate is the legacy of the Prophetsas, is equal to the rank (Manzilat) of the Awsiyaa (those who instruct to good). Indeed, it is the vicegerency of Allahazwj and His messengersas and therefore is regarded infallible, with (true) dominion and governance. Indeed, it is the (True) guidance since it is the perfection of the ‘deen’ and the benchmark of all virtues.

The Imamasws, is the guide for the seekers of the truth, an inspiration for the rightly guided, an established path for the travellers to Allahazwj and a radiant sun in the hearts of devotees of Allahazwj (al-Arifoon). Hisasws Wilayah is the vehicle leading to salvation, submission to himasws is obligatory in this life, (and has many benefits) as well as an instrument (of deliverance) in the hereafter, heasws is the source of courage and glory (izza) for the true believers; means of intercession for the sinners; a minarets of deliverance for those who immensely love himasws; a standard of triumph for the obedient.

This is due to the fact that an Imamasws, is the only one who can guide to the real Islamic path, through revealing the virtues of ‘Eman’, recognition of limits of rewards and punishments and clarifying the laws related to permissible and forbidden. Thus this status is only given to no one other than the one who is specially nominated and blessed by Allahazwj and is given a clear distinction and right to administer public affairs and is made sole responsible for people’s sustenance. Indeed, Imamasws provides knowledge of the boundaries and injunctions (of Allahazwj) and makes clear the lawful and unlawful.

The Imamate is a station that none can reach except those whom Allahazwj has chosen and has given them precedence (over others), investing them with the authority to rules and to judge. Thus, Wilayah is nothing other than safeguarding people from danger and disaster and the management of their all affairs, (even down to) demarcating the days and months.

The Imamasws, is Fresh and Sweet water for those thirsting (for knowledge & wisdom) A guide to true Guidance. The Imamasws, is ‘Ayat-e-Tatheer’, acquainted with mysteries of the unseen. The Imamasws, is the sun that rises over Allahazwj’s servants with its (illuminating) Rays.

The grasp and understanding of people cannot comprehend hisasws attributes. This is mentioned to in the words of Allahazwj, most high (in the Quran): “To Allahazwj belongs fearlessness and glory (Izza) and to his messenger and to the believers”. Here, the believers are being referred to as, Aliasws and his progenyasws. Thus might and glory is for Allahazwj, His Prophetsaww and hissaww progenyasws. (This verse shows that) the Prophetsaww and hissaww familyasws cannot be separated from one another until the end of the time, they are at the

68

Total authority and command on all aspects of life.

False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan (Al-Yamani) www.hubeali.com

47 out of 50

centre of the sphere of the faith; they are the poles of existence (i.e. around which all existent/ entities revolve); theyasws are the sky of generosity and the honour of all creation; they are the radiance of the sun of tribute, and the illumination of its moon; theyasws are the origin of all power and glory and the source of inspiration; theyasws are faith’s true meaning and its foundation.

The Imamasws, is the bright source of light (to enlighten the dark and cruel) path; the flowing stream leading to Allahazwj; stream of fresh water for the dried land; the swirling sea; the resplendent full moon (badr) and the brimming brook of guidance, the path and the deliverance in places of peril. The torrential cloud, the roving rain the perfect full moon, the noble guide, the shading sky, the glorious blessing, the sea that will never dry. Nobility that cannot be described, a fountain that forever flows, a garden (full of singing) birds, a fragrant and delightful flower (with) the sweetest smell and wafting aroma, the righteous conduct, the successful trade, the clear way, the gentle Physician, the compassionate father, the refuge for people in times of calamity, the judge, the command giver, the Prohibitor, Allahazwj’s ruler over Hisazwj people, His (Allahazwj’s) confidant on (matters of) reality, Proof of Allahazwj over Hisazwj servants (Heasws is) the object of pilgrimage on Allahazwj’s earth and the universe, ‘Informed’ of the Unseen. Hisasws personal qualities cannot be encompassed, hisasws inner virtues cannot be imagined and heasws is unfathomable reality. Heasws is Unique of hisasws age and unparalleled to none. Heasws is Allahazwj’s deputy in Hisazwj injunctions and prohibitions. There is none similar to himasws and no one can take hisasws place.

So, who is there that can attain knowledge about usasws; or can reach ourasws rank; or can witness ourasws miracles; or can ever comprehend ourasws status. In this matter, wisdom and intellect are bewildered; understanding becomes perplexed. Ourasws status is so eloquent that the great ones appear worthless, and the scholars dwindle (into insignificance); the Poets become exhausted and wary; the genius stutter and are speechless; the noble orators begin to stammer; and the masters of language are humbled.

Who has the ability and perception to recognise even one Divine attribute of an Imamasws, or could image or comprehend as the heavens and the earth are humbled when they (attempt) to describe the reality of the one who is in the focal point of the Universe, the pivot of all that revolve, the secrets of all that is possible to exist, the ray of Divine creator, the majesty of the Most Great and the honour of the heavens and the earth.

The station of the Prophetsaww‘s progeny is exalted above description of the describers and the qualifications depicted by the highly qualified. Nor can they be compared with anyone in any realm or world. How could it be possible to describe them, since theyasws are the first light (created by Allahazwj), the lofty words, the radiant Divine names and the greater oneness of Allahazwj . Thus, whoever turned away from themasws has indeed deserted oneness of Allahazwj, as theyasws are the greatest veil of Allahazwj.

Thus who has the merits to select such an Imamasws, who cannot be recognised by the wisdom. Actually, there is no one who had abilities to identify the noble Imamasws or even describe one of hisasws virtues. However, those who image that some of the qualities of Prophetsaww’s progeny can be found in other people are, in fact, crafty liars and have gone astray from the righteous path and they chose to worship the Calf (false god), as their lord

False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan (Al-Yamani) www.hubeali.com

48 out of 50

and have joined the ranks of shaytaan. This is all due to their intense animosity against the house of Devine qualities, and the familyasws of the virtuousness and infallibility and jealousy towards the household of Prophetsaww.

Shaytaan has made them believe that their (devious) actions, after all, are honourable. May Allahazwj destroy them and destine them towards hellfire. How could they have selected an ignorant as an imam, who used to worship idols and was a well-known deserter on the day of Holly wars (Battle). Although, it is incumbent that the Imam should be the most knowledgeable and not ignorant; brave and not withdrawing individual. And none should be superior to him in (nobility) descent and nor should be inferior (to anyone) in his lineage. Beware; the Imamasws can only be from the best of the Quraysh, the most nobility of Hashim and from the progeny of Ibrahimas. He is from the bloodline of Prophetsaww and is the ‘Nafs’-e-Rasoolsaww 69. He is chosen by the will of Allahazwj and hisasws selection is directly executed by Allahazwj.

Thus, heasws is the honour of all nobles and a branch from the (descendants of) Abd Manaaf; he has (complete) knowledge of (worldly) affairs and is well versed in the governance (of all affairs). Obedience to himasws is incumbent until the day of judgement and Allahazwj has made hisasws Heart a (vessel) for Hisazwj mystery and elects to speak through Imamasws’s tongue. Thus, Heasws is infallible, represents Allahazwj and is free from any element of ignorance and weakness.

O Tariq, the people have abandoned him and followed their own desires and who can be more astray than the one who follows his whims without any guidance from Allahazwj. O Tariq! the Imamasws may be considered like an angelas in the appearance of human being, a heavenly body, a divine command, a sacred spirit, a lofty station, a manifest light, a hidden secret. He is angelic in essence with attributes of the Divine powers, endowed with unlimited good qualities, possess the knowledge of the realms of the Unseen, specifically chosen by the Lord of the Worlds and is connected with the Truthful and Trustworthy (messenger of Allahazwj). All this is for the household of Muhammadsaww alone; nobody else can partake in this with them.

This is because theyasws are: the source of revelation and the meaning of its exposition; the elect of the Lord of Majesty; The place of Jibraeelas, Al-Ameen’s descent; the words of the attributes of Allahazwj; Hisazwj Secret and Hisazwj Words; the tree of Prophet-hood; the source of chivalry; the essence of all opinions; the ultimate meaning and signification; the station of apostolic wisdom; the illumination of majesty in proximity to Allahazwj, and in Hisazwj Care, the location of Allahazwj’s Word; the key to his wisdom; the lamps of Allahazwj’s mercy; the well springs of Hisazwj Bounty; the path that leads to Allahazwj - the salsabeel-the Qistaas al-Mustaqeem (the upright scale) the straight path; the remembrance (full) of wisdom; the noble face; the eternal light; possessors of honour and repute; take precedence over all noble and exalted; the successors of the noble Prophetsaww; the progeny of the compassionate and gentle (Prophetsaww); we are the progeny of one from the other, in the custody of the most High, the most Mighty- Allahazwj knows all and observes all of these.

69

Replicating the qualities of Prophetsaww

False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan (Al-Yamani) www.hubeali.com

49 out of 50

These are the immense and unmistakable signs of guidance and the straight path. Whosoever recognises themasws and takes (guidance) from themasws, he is belongs to us. As per Rasool Allahsaww’s statement, “He who follows mesaww, surely he is from mesaww”, is an allusion to this (reality). Allahazwj created them (Prophets household) from the illumination of his majesty and entrusted them with the governing of the affairs of Hisazwj kingdom. (Thus, there is no doubt) theyasws are the treasured secret of Allahazwj and Hisazwj friends, those who are near (Awliya al-Muqarraboon).

Allahazwj’s (creative) command is between the letter ‘Kaaf’ and the letter ‘Nun’. Infact they are the ‘Kaaf’ and the ‘Nun’ since theyasws invite to Allahazwj, speak only what theyasws receive from Himazwj and carry out Hisazwj Commands. The knowledge of all the Prophetsas, the (divine) mysteries of the Awsiyaa and the power and glory of the Awliyaa, in comparison to themasws, is like a drop out of an ocean and a grain out of a desert. Indeed, the heavens and the earth to the Imamasws are like the hand and its palm. Heasws recognises what is visible as well as what is hidden; Heasws knows the pious among the sinners; what is in the wet and within the dry forms. This is because Allahazwj has taught his Prophetsaww the knowledge of what has been passed and what would appear, and all these protected secrete were inherited by Prophetsaww’s noble Awliyahasws. Whosoever, denies this is a cruel and cursed wretch, and as such is cursed by Allahazwj as well as by all those who also send curse in Allahazwj’s obedience.

How could Allahazwj make Incumbent upon Hisazwj servants the obedience of the one who is veiled from the mysteries of the heavens and the earth. The reality is that, a single word uttered (in Quran) in the praise of Aal-e-Muhammadasws, exceeds seventy dimensions (of knowledge). (Consider further), How often in the verses of the Noble reminder, the blessed book, the eternal words are mentioned in our praise, i.e., al-Ayn (eye), al-Wajh (face), al-Yadh (hand) and al-Janb (side). (It is obvious that) What is meant by these words is this Wilayah (pointing to himselfasws), as Imamasws is the side of Allahazwj, the face of Allahazwj, that is, the reality of Allahazwj, the knowledge of Allahazwj, and the essence of Allahazwj. (As for the phrase) ‘Hand of Allahazwj’ they are the manifestation of the implicit dimensions of the visible attributes. Thus, their (Ahl Al-Bayt’s) implicit is the manifestation of the Allahazwj’s explicit attributes. Theyasws are the explicit manifestation of the implicit and the implicit dimensions of the explicit. This is alluded to in the saying of the Prophetsaww “Indeed Allahazwj has no eyes and hands, but surely you and me, Ya Aliasws, are from them”.

Theyasws (The Ahl Al-Bayt) are the most elevated side (Al-Janb al-Aliyy); the most agreeable face (al-Wajh ar-Radiyy); the thirst-quenching spring; and the straight path. Theyasws are the means to (reach) Allahazwj, the link to Hisazwj pardon and Hisazwj pleasure. Theyasws are the mystery of the One, and the Uniqueness of the Unique (Allahazwj). It is not possible to compare anyone from mankind with themasws; They are: the elect of Allahazwj and chosen purely by Himazwj; the secret of religion and its wisdom; the gateway to faith and its Kaaba; the proof of Allahazwj and His destination; the signposts of guidance and its standard; the grace of Allahazwj and His mercy; the absolute certainty and its reality; the path of the Real and His protection; the origin of existence and its goal; the power of the Lord and His will; the source (origin) of the book and its end; the eloquent speech; the symbols and guardians and protectors of the revelation; the verse of Remembrance and its interpretation; the origin of revelation and its final (destiny); they are the lofty stars; they are the elevated

False Claims of Ahmed Al-Hasan (Al-Yamani) www.hubeali.com

50 out of 50

illuminations, kindled from the sun of Fatimah’s honour in the sky or Muhammed’s majesty; they are the branches of Prophet hood gushing forth from the tree of Ahmed; the divine mysteries placed in the form of a human (body).

The Ahl Al-Baytasws are: The pure progeny from Hashemite descent; the (truly) guide and the (truly) guided; thus theyasws alone are the best of creation; theyasws are the pure leaders; the infallible familyasws (protected from sin); the noble offspring; the rightly guided successors (of the Prophetsaww); the greatest of the Siddiqeen (the truth ones); the noble Awsiyaa; the tribe whom Allahazwj was pleased with; the rightly guided deliverers; the finest of the fine, from the family of Taha and Yaseen; The proof of Allahazwj for the first and last.

Theirasws names are etched on (every) stone, on (every) leaf of (every) tree, on the wings of every bird; on the gates of heavens and hell; on the throne (of Allahazwj); on the horizons; on the wings of angels; on the veils of majesty and on the canopies of glory and beauty.

With theirasws name the birds glorify (Allahazwj) and fish in the depths of ocean ask for forgiveness on behalf of their followers.

In fact, Allahazwj did not create anything until Heazwj Made them declare the oneness (of Allahazwj), the ‘Wilayah’ (supremacy) of the pure progenyasws and revulsion for theirasws enemies. The Throne (of Allahazwj) did not attain stability until it was inscribed with Divine light; There is no deity except Allahazwj, Muhammadsaww is the messenger of Allahazwj, and Aliasws is the Wali of Allahazwj.