13
FAILURE MODES AND PREVENTATIVE DIAGNOSTICS FOR ATOMIZER COMPONENTS By Ken Rogers, Omega Atomizers 2018 DRY SCRUBBER USERS CONFERENCE SEPTEMBER 17-20, 2018 MILWAUKEE, WISCONSIN

FAILURE MODES AND PREVENTATIVE DIAGNOSTICS ......FAILURE MODES AND PREVENTATIVE DIAGNOSTICS FOR ATOMIZER COMPONENTS By Ken Rogers, Omega Atomizers 2018 DRY SCRUBBER USERS CONFERENCE

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    18

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: FAILURE MODES AND PREVENTATIVE DIAGNOSTICS ......FAILURE MODES AND PREVENTATIVE DIAGNOSTICS FOR ATOMIZER COMPONENTS By Ken Rogers, Omega Atomizers 2018 DRY SCRUBBER USERS CONFERENCE

FAILURE MODES AND PREVENTATIVE DIAGNOSTICS FOR

ATOMIZER COMPONENTS

By Ken Rogers, Omega Atomizers

2018 DRY SCRUBBER USERS CONFERENCE

SEPTEMBER 17-20, 2018

MILWAUKEE, WISCONSIN

Page 2: FAILURE MODES AND PREVENTATIVE DIAGNOSTICS ......FAILURE MODES AND PREVENTATIVE DIAGNOSTICS FOR ATOMIZER COMPONENTS By Ken Rogers, Omega Atomizers 2018 DRY SCRUBBER USERS CONFERENCE

TWO QUESTIONS

As a supplier and manufacturer we are regularly asked these questions;

HOW LONG WILL PARTS LAST?

WHEN SHOULD THESE PARTS BE RETIRED?

Page 3: FAILURE MODES AND PREVENTATIVE DIAGNOSTICS ......FAILURE MODES AND PREVENTATIVE DIAGNOSTICS FOR ATOMIZER COMPONENTS By Ken Rogers, Omega Atomizers 2018 DRY SCRUBBER USERS CONFERENCE

TWO CATEGORIES OF PARTSATOMIZER STRUCTURAL COMPONENTS – INTENDED TO LAST YEARS

EXPENDABLE WEAR PARTS – EXPECTED LIFE UNIQUELY VARIABLE

Page 4: FAILURE MODES AND PREVENTATIVE DIAGNOSTICS ......FAILURE MODES AND PREVENTATIVE DIAGNOSTICS FOR ATOMIZER COMPONENTS By Ken Rogers, Omega Atomizers 2018 DRY SCRUBBER USERS CONFERENCE

PROTOCOL FOR CONSIDERING SERVICE LIFE OF ATOMIZER COMPONENTS

We consider service life in THIRDS

1st THIRD OBSERVE Looking for the unusual paterns

2nd THIRD MONITOR Track trouble areas, document damage

3rd THIRD RETIRE? Considering damage , consider retirement

Page 5: FAILURE MODES AND PREVENTATIVE DIAGNOSTICS ......FAILURE MODES AND PREVENTATIVE DIAGNOSTICS FOR ATOMIZER COMPONENTS By Ken Rogers, Omega Atomizers 2018 DRY SCRUBBER USERS CONFERENCE

FAILURE MODES

WHAT KIND OF DAMAGE ARE WE LOOKING FOR?

CORROSION EROSION CRACKING

Page 6: FAILURE MODES AND PREVENTATIVE DIAGNOSTICS ......FAILURE MODES AND PREVENTATIVE DIAGNOSTICS FOR ATOMIZER COMPONENTS By Ken Rogers, Omega Atomizers 2018 DRY SCRUBBER USERS CONFERENCE

FAILURE MODECORROSION

Uniform, General, Stress Corrosion Cracking

Weight Loss Corrosion

Page 7: FAILURE MODES AND PREVENTATIVE DIAGNOSTICS ......FAILURE MODES AND PREVENTATIVE DIAGNOSTICS FOR ATOMIZER COMPONENTS By Ken Rogers, Omega Atomizers 2018 DRY SCRUBBER USERS CONFERENCE

FAILURE MODEEROSION

CONSIDER WEAR PATHS AND WEAR DEPTH

Page 8: FAILURE MODES AND PREVENTATIVE DIAGNOSTICS ......FAILURE MODES AND PREVENTATIVE DIAGNOSTICS FOR ATOMIZER COMPONENTS By Ken Rogers, Omega Atomizers 2018 DRY SCRUBBER USERS CONFERENCE

FAILURE MODECRACKING

STRESS CORROSION CRACKINGCRACKING FROM APPLIED LOAD

Page 9: FAILURE MODES AND PREVENTATIVE DIAGNOSTICS ......FAILURE MODES AND PREVENTATIVE DIAGNOSTICS FOR ATOMIZER COMPONENTS By Ken Rogers, Omega Atomizers 2018 DRY SCRUBBER USERS CONFERENCE

FAILURE MODECRACKING

Specialist in Fatigue and Fracture Mechanics will say that a crack does not necessarily mean failure is imminent. For atomizers, some cracking in expendable parts can be tolerated. However, for structural components, cracking should be considered critical.

How would you defend prior knowledge of cracking after a catastrophic failure?

Page 10: FAILURE MODES AND PREVENTATIVE DIAGNOSTICS ......FAILURE MODES AND PREVENTATIVE DIAGNOSTICS FOR ATOMIZER COMPONENTS By Ken Rogers, Omega Atomizers 2018 DRY SCRUBBER USERS CONFERENCE

DIAGNOSTICS?

The PROTOCOL is the foundation of the DIAGNOSTICS

OBSERVE Looking for the unusual Mostly visual

MONITOR Tracking, documenting Photos, Logs

RETIRE? Terminal issues Last service turn?

Page 11: FAILURE MODES AND PREVENTATIVE DIAGNOSTICS ......FAILURE MODES AND PREVENTATIVE DIAGNOSTICS FOR ATOMIZER COMPONENTS By Ken Rogers, Omega Atomizers 2018 DRY SCRUBBER USERS CONFERENCE

PREDICTIVE?

The PROTOCOL is the tool that motivates development of a documented history that allows some ability to predict the life of parts and when or if they should be retired.

Important for new users to develop history

DSUA is excellent resource for new users

Important for experienced users to gain efficiency and reduce cost

Page 12: FAILURE MODES AND PREVENTATIVE DIAGNOSTICS ......FAILURE MODES AND PREVENTATIVE DIAGNOSTICS FOR ATOMIZER COMPONENTS By Ken Rogers, Omega Atomizers 2018 DRY SCRUBBER USERS CONFERENCE

CONCLUSIONS

We can, we must, observe and monitor damage considering the typical failure modes these systems produce. A simple PROTOCOL can aid in developing a history useful in making the best decisions and getting the most value from these systems and components.

OBSERVE

MONITOR

RETIRE?

Page 13: FAILURE MODES AND PREVENTATIVE DIAGNOSTICS ......FAILURE MODES AND PREVENTATIVE DIAGNOSTICS FOR ATOMIZER COMPONENTS By Ken Rogers, Omega Atomizers 2018 DRY SCRUBBER USERS CONFERENCE

QUESTIONS