Exhibit A to the Complaint

8/20/2019 Exhibit A to the Complaint

1/17

TRACING THE GUNS:

THE IMPACT OF ILLEGAL GUNS

ON V IOLENCE IN CHICAGO

CITY OF CHICAGO - OFFICE OF THE M AYOR

CHICAGO POLICE DEPARTMENT

M AY 27, 2014


2/17

!

#$% &'()*%+* ', -.'+/0(1, 2(,3 $40*%3 54(6)*27 8'%+* /,,$2'%0 (99'+* '% :;!!< =/>(4 ?2/%$*)1,

3(5 54'(4'3> ./, 6**% 4*@$+'%0 +4'2* ,( 3./3 /)) -.'+/0(/%,< '% *&*4> %*'0.6(4.((@< 9**) ,/9* '% ($4

-'3>7 A.* =/>(41, +(254*.*%,'&* &'()*%+* 4*@$+3'(% ,34/3*0> ./, /33/+B*@ 3.* 54(6)*2 94(2 *&*4>

/%0)*< '%+)$@'%0 '%+4*/,'%0 5()'+* 4*,($4+*,< 9(,3*4'%0 *+(%(2'+ (55(43$%'3>< '254(&'%0 *@$+/3'(%

($3+(2*,< *25(C*4'%0 >($3. 3.4($0. 54*&*%3'(% 54(04/2,< /%@ +4*/3'%0 (55(43$%'3'*, 9(4

'%@'&'@$/), 4*3$4%'%0 94(2 '%+/4+*4/3'(%7!

A.* -'3>1, /554(/+. ', ,.(C'%0 ,'0%, (9 54(04*,,7 -.'+/0( +)(,*@ :;!D C'3. .',3(4'+ )(C, '% +4'2*

/%@ &'()*%+*7 E/,3 >*/4< -.'+/0( ./@ 3.* 9*C*,3 2$4@*4, ,'%+* !FGH< 3.* )(C*,3 2$4@*4 4/3* ,'%+*

!FGG< /%@ 3.* )(C*,3 (&*4/)) +4'2* 4/3* ,'%+* !FI:7

J$3 &'()*%+* '% -.'+/0( 4*2/'%, $%/++*53/6)> .'0.7 A(( 2/%> 9/2')'*,< 94(2 0*%*4/3'(% 3(

0*%*4/3'(%< ./&* )'&*@ C'3. 3.* .*/4364*/B /%@ @*&/,3/3'(% (9 0$% &'()*%+*7 K%@ C.')* 3.* -'3>

+(%3'%$*, 3( '%&*,3 '% ,2/43*4 5()'+* ,34/3*0'*, /%@ .'0. L$/)'3> 54*&*%3'(% 54(04/2,< '3 /),( 2$,3

3/+B)* 3.* 54(6)*2 /3 (%* (9 '3, 4((3 +/$,*,M 3.* 9)(C (9 '))*0/) 0$%, '%3( 3.* -'3>7

A.', 4*5(43 ', +(25(,*@ (9 @/3/ /%@ /%/)>,', +(25')*@ 6> 3.* -.'+/0( =/>(41, N99'+* /%@ 3.*-.'+/0( O()'+* P*5/432*%3 *Q/2'%'%0 3.* '25/+3 (9 '))*0/) 0$%, (% &'()*%3 +4'2* '% -.'+/0( /%@ 3.*

,+(5* (9 3.* -'3>1, '))*0/) 0$% 2/4B*37: A.', 4*5(43 $5@/3*, /% /%/)>,', 54*&'($,)> 4*)*/,*@ '% :;!:D

/%@ +(%9'42,M

R!S -.'+/0(1, &'()*%+* 54(6)*2 ', @'4*+3)> )'%B*@ 3( 3.* %$26*4 (9 '))*0/) 0$%, /&/')/6)*

'% 3.* -'3>T

R:S 8'Q3> 5*4+*%3 (9 0$%, 4*+(&*4*@ '% +4'2*, '% -.'+/0( C*4* 9'4,3 ,()@ '% (3.*4 ,3/3*,<

2/%> C'3. C*/B*4 0$% )/C,T /%@

RDS K ,2/)) ./%@9$) (9 0$% ,3(4*,< 3.4** 94(2 -((B -($%34> /%@ (%* 94(2 #/4>< U%@'/%/<

+(%3'%$* 3( 6* 4*,5(%,'6)* 9(4 / @',54(5(43'(%/3* %$26*4 (9 +4'2* 0$%, 4*+(&*4*@

(% -.'+/0(1, ,34**3,7

V*+(0%'W'%0 3./3 3.*4* 2$,3 6* / 2$)3'9/+*3*@ /554(/+. 3( 4*@$+'%0 0$% &'()*%+*< 3.* =/>(41,

N99'+* /%@ 3.* -.'+/0( O()'+* P*5/432*%3 C')) 3/B* *&*4> ,3*5 3( .()@ /++($%3/6)* 3.* ,34/C

5$4+./,*4,< 4*3/') ,3(4*,< /%@ '44*,5(%,'6)* 0$% (C%*4, C.( /42 +4'2'%/), /%@ >($%0 5*(5)*7

!" $%&'()*+, -&*./0'/ !, 1&2/'3.4 5&06/7 3* 3%/ 8&9/ *: &3, !../)(. ; /%@ E(, K%0*)*,7 -.'+/0( ', %(3

,$6,3/%3'/))> @'99*4*%3 94(2 3.(,* 3C( +'3'*, '% B*> '%@'+/3(4, 3.($0.3 3( ./&* /% '25/+3 (% &'()*%3

+4'2*< ,$+. /, 5(&*43> 4/3* /%@ 3.* /2($%3 (9 5()'+* 4*,($4+*,7 U%@**@< /)) 3.4** +'3'*, 4*5(43 3./3

6*3C**% !F /%@ :: 5*4+*%3 (9 4*,'@*%3, /4* )'&'%0 6*)(C 3.* 5(&*43> )'%*


3/17

:

(99'+*4, 4*+(&*4*@ :7:H 0$%,7 =*/,$4*@ 6> 3.* %$26*4 (9 0$%, 4*+(&*4*@ '% +4'2*, 5*4 +/5'3/< /93*4

+(%34())'%0 9(4 5(5$)/3'(%< -.'+/0( 5()'+* (99'+*4, 4*+(&*4 ,*&*% 3'2*, 2(4* 0$%, 3./% '% Z*C [(4B

-'3> /%@ 2(4* 3./% @($6)* 3.* /2($%3 (9 0$%, 4*+(&*4*@ '% E(, K%0*)*,7

>&)


4/17

D

N?-P7ac [*3< 9(4 3./3 ,/2* 5*4'(@ 3.* X%'3*@ 83/3*, ./@ 3.* D4@ .'0.*,3 2$4@*4 4/3* /+4(,, N?-P

2*26*4 %/3'(%,M `3.* X%'3*@ 83/3*,1 .(2'+'@* 4/3* ', H7: d5*4 !;; 3.* @',5/4'3> 6*3C**% `/,,/$)3,a /%@ `2$4@*4,af #'&*% 3./3 %*/4)> /)) (9 X787 .(2'+'@*, /4*

+(22'33*@ C'3. 0$%,< (%* /%,C*4 ', 3./3 0$%, 2/B* &'()*%+* 2(4* )*3./)7!;

K, ,.(C% 6> 3.* +./43, 6*)(C< 3.* +(%%*+3'(% 6*3C**% 2$4@*4 4/3* /%@ 3.* ,'W* (9 0$% 2/4B*3 ',

/55/4*%3 C.*% +(25/4'%0 -.'+/0( 3( Z*C [(4B -'3> /%@ E(, K%0*)*,7 A.* 3.4** +'3'*, ./&*

4*)/3'&*)> ,'2')/4 4/3*, (9 %(%g0$% .(2'+'@*,7 A.* @'99*4*%+*< .(C*&*4< ', -.'+/0(1, )/40* 0$%

2/4B*3 C.'+. 9$*), 3.* 2$4@*4 4/3*7

>&)


5/17

\

^.')* 3.* ,+(5* (9 -.'+/0(1, '))*0/) 0$% 54(6)*2 ', ,'0%'9'+/%3< 3.* +(%%*+3'(% 6*3C**% /++*,, 3(

0$%, /%@ 3.* 2$4@*4 4/3* (99*4, /% (55(43$%'3>7 U9 3.* ,$55)> /%@ /++*,, 3( '))*0/) 0$%, ', 4*@$+*@<

-.'+/0(1, 2$4@*4 4/3* C')) )'B*)> @4(57

!!" L%/ 8* 5()'+* @*5/432*%3, /%@ 3.* J$4*/$ (9 K)+(.()< A(6/++(< _'4*/42, i

?Q5)(,'&*, RKA_S ', B*> 3( $%@*4,3/%@'%0 .(C 0$%, *%@ $5 '% 3.* ./%@, (9 +4'2'%/),7!\

K++(4@'%0 3( 3.* KA_< /)2(,3 /)) (9 3.* 0$%, 4*+(&*4*@ /3 +4'2* ,+*%*, C*4* (4'0'%/))> ,()@ /3 4*3/')

,3(4*, 6> 9*@*4/))> )'+*%,*@ 9'4*/42, @*/)*4, R__E,S7!H A.$,< $%)'B* %/4+(3'+,< 0$%, 6*0'% /, )*0/)

54(@$+3, '% / )*0/) 2/4B*35)/+*7 K)(%0 3.* C/>< .(C*&*4< 2/%> 0$%, /4* @'&*43*@ '%3( 3.* ./%@, (9

+4'2'%/), 3.4($0. 3.*93T `,34/C 5$4+./,'%0*4 ', 5/'@ 3( 5$4+./,* / 0$% 9(4 /

0$% 34/99'+B*4 (4 +4'2'%/)T /%@ 54'&/3* ,/)*, /3 0$% ,.(C, /%@ (%)'%*< C.*4* ,*))*4, /4* %(3 4*L$'4*@

6> 9*@*4/) )/C 3( +(%@$+3 6/+B04($%@ +.*+B, (4 B**5 5/5*4C(4B (% 3.* 0$% 34/%,9*47!G

N%+* / 0$% ', 4*+(&*4*@ 6> 5()'+* (99'+*4,< 3.*> 4*5(43 3.* 0$%1, $%'L$* ,*4'/) %$26*4 3( KA_< C.'+.

34/+*, 3.* 0$% 3( '3, 2/%$9/+3$4*4< @',34'6$3*4< @*/)*4< /%@ $)3'2/3*)> Y /,,$2'%0 3.* @*/)*4 ./,

2/'%3/'%*@ /++$4/3* 5/5*4C(4B Y (4'0'%/) 5$4+./,*47!I _(4 ,5*+'9'+ +/,*,< 34/+* @/3/ /))(C, )/C

*%9(4+*2*%3 3( '%&*,3'0/3* .(C 3.* 0$% C*%3 94(2 3.* ./%@, (9 '3, (4'0'%/) (C%*4 3( 3.* +4'2*

,+*%*7 U% 3.* /004*0/3*< 34/+* @/3/ +/% 5/'%3 / %/3'(%/) 5'+3$4* (9 C.'+. ,3/3*,< +($%3'*,< /%@

'%@'&'@$/) 4*3/') ,3(4*, /4* 3.* )/40*,3 ,($4+*, (9 0$%, 4*+(&*4*@ '% +4'2*,7

K++(4@'%0 3( 3.* KA_< '9 / 0$% C/, 4*+(&*4*@ '% / +4'2* C'3.'% 3.4** >*/4, (9 '3, (4'0'%/) 5$4+./,*<

3./3 ', / ,34(%0 '%@'+/3(4 3./3 3.* 0$% C/, '))*0/))> 34/99'+B*@ /%@ `,$00*,3, '))*0/) @'&*4,'(% (4

+4'2'%/) '%3*%3 /,,(+'/3*@ C'3. 3.* 4*3/') 5$4+./,* 94(2 3.* __E7a!c A.', ', 34$* 9(4 / %$26*4 (9

4*/,(%,7 _'4,3< 0$%, /4* *Q5*%,'&* Y / %*C #)(+B F22 5',3()< C'3.($3 /22$%'3'(% (4 /++*,,(4'*,<3>5'+/))> +(,3, /4($%@ jH;;7 A.*,* /4* %(3 '3*2, 34/@*@ /C/> (% / C.'27 8*+(%@< 6$>'%0 /

./%@0$% 94(2 / 4*3/') @*/)*4 '% 2(,3 ,3/3*, 3/B*, 5/3'*%+*7 _(4 *Q/25)*< '% U))'%(',< / 5$4+./,*4

2$,3 +(25)*3* 3.* 5/5*4C(4B 3( (63/'% / _NUP +/4@< 34/&*) 3( 3.* 0$% ,3(4*< +.((,* / C*/5(%< C/'3

9(4 3.* 6/+B04($%@ +.*+B 3( 6* +(25)*3*@< /6'@* 6> 3.* Dg@/> C/'3'%0 5*4'(@< /%@ 3.*% 2/B* /

4*3$4% 34'5 3( 3.* ,3(4* 3( 5'+B $5 3.* 0$%7

#'&*% 3.* 3'2* /%@ 2(%*> %*+*,,/4> 3( 6$> / ./%@0$%< 3.* /&*4/0* 5*4,(% ', $%)'B*)> 3( L$'+B)>

@',+/4@ '3T $%)*,, (9 +($4,*< 3.* 5$4+./,*4 %*&*4 '%3*%@*@ 3( B**5 3.* 0$% 6*+/$,* 3.*> 6($0.3 '3 9(4

,(2*(%* *),* Y / 9*)(%> $%@*4 9*@*4/) )/C7

k'()*%+* '% -.'+/0( ', 9$*)*@ 6> 5*(5)* $,'%0 '))*0/) 0$%,7 A.* (6&'($, L$*,3'(% ',M ^.*4* /4* /))3.*,* 0$%, +(2'%0 94(2f

?" 8&M34 N/2'/03 *: )


6/17

H

5*4+*%3 C*4* 9'4,3 5$4+./,*@ ($3 (9 ,3/3*7 K)) H; ,3/3*, ,$55)'*@ /3 )*/,3 (%* 0$% 3./3 C/,

*&*%3$/))> $,*@ 3( +(22'3 / +4'2* '% -.'+/0(7 U))'%(',< )'B* %*/4)> *&*4> (3.*4 ,3/3*< ', 3.* ,'%0)*

)/40*,3 ,($4+* (9 0$%, 4*+(&*4*@ '% -.'+/0( /%@ ,$55)'*, \; 5*4+*%3 (9 3.* 3(3/) 0$%, 4*+(&*4*@ '%

3.* -'3>7 Z/3'(%/))>< (% /&*4/0*< */+. ,3/3* ,$55)'*, /6($3 I; 5*4+*%3 (9 0$%, 4*+(&*4*@ '% +4'2*, '%

3./3 ,3/3* /%@ (3.*4 ,3/3*, ,$55)> 3.* 4*2/'%'%0 D; 5*4+*%37!F

A.* )/40*,3 ($3g(9g,3/3* ,($4+*, (9 -.'+/0(1, '))*0/) 0$%, C*4* U%@'/%/< =',,',,'55'< /%@ ^',+(%,'%<

C.'+. ,$55)'*@ !F 5*4+*%3< G7I 5*4+*%3< /%@ D7G 5*4+*%3 (9 3.*,* +4'2* 0$%,< 4*,5*+3'&*)>7 Z(%* (9

3.*,* ,3/3*, ./&* )/C, 3./3 4*L$'4* 6/+B04($%@ +.*+B, 9(4 5$4+./,*4, C.( 6$> 9'4*/42, /3 0$%

,.(C, (4 (% 3.* U%3*4%*37

>&)


7/17

G

U%@'/%/< =',,',,'55'< ^*,3 k'40'%'/< l*%3$+B>< K)/6/2/ /%@ k'40'%'/ *Q5(43 D!< H;< \G< D\< DD< /%@

D: ./%@0$%, 5*4 !;; @*/)*4, '% ,$44($%@'%0 +(22$%'3'*,7

I" ? 8B(.. O (9 -.'+/0(1, +4'2* 0$%, +(2* 94(2 3.* (3.*4 \F ,3/3*, +(26'%*@< 6*3C**%

:;;F /%@ :;!D< ]$,3 9($4 )(+/) @*/)*4, ,$55)'*@ %*/4)> :; 5*4+*%3 (9 3.* 0$%, 4*+(&*4*@ /3 -.'+/0(

+4'2* ,+*%*,7 A.*,* ,3(4*, Y -.$+B, RV'&*4@/)*< UES< ='@C*,3 85(43'%0 #((@, RE>(%,< UES< 8.(4*

#/))*4'*, RE'%+()%C((@< UES< /%@ ^*,39(43. 85(43,< U%+7 R#/4>< UZSh /4* /)) C'3.'% / ,.(43 @4'&* (9

-.'+/0( /%@ /4* 3.* ,($4+* (9 3.($,/%@, (9 0$%, 4*+(&*4*@ '% +4'2*, '% -.'+/0(7 J> +(%34/,3<

@$4'%0 3./3 ,/2* 3'2* 5*4'(@< 3.* /&*4/0* %$26*4 (9 0$%, 34/+*@ 6/+B 3( /)) (3.*4 0$% ,3(4*, C/,

3.4**7

>&)


8/17

I

=(4* ,'0%'9'+/%3)>< / )/40* 54(5(43'(% (9 3.* 0$%, ,()@ 6> ,*&*4/) (9 3.*,* ,3(4*, C*4* 4*+(&*4*@ '%

+4'2*, 9*C*4 3./% 3.4** >*/4, /93*4 3.*'4 (4'0'%/) ,/)* Y / B*> '%@'+/3(4 3./3 3.* ,/)* +($)@ ./&*

'%&()&*@ +4'2'%/) /+3'&'3> 6> 3.* 6$>*4 (4 3.* @*/)*4< /, @',+$,,*@ /6(&*7 N% /&*4/0*< 4($0.)> !:

5*4+*%3 (9 /%> @*/)*41, 0$%, 3./3 /4* )/3*4 4*+(&*4*@ '% +4'2*, '% -.'+/0( 2(&* 94(2 3.* ,3(4* 3(

3.* ,34**3 C'3.'% D >*/4,7 J*3C**% :;;F /%@ :;!D< ='@C*,3 #$% '% E>(%,< U))'%(',< ,()@ GHF 0$%,

3./3 C*4* $,*@ '% +4'2*, '% -.'+/0(< /%@ DDD R/554(Q'2/3*)> H! 5*4+*%3S (9 3.(,* 9'4*/42, C*4*4*+(&*4*@ C'3.'% 3.4** >*/4, (9 3.* (4'0'%/) 5$4+./,* /3 ='@C*,3 #$%7 -.$+B, #$% 8.(5 '%

V'&*4@/)*< U))'%(',< ,()@ ! 94(2 .', 9'%',.'%0 .', ,.'93 /, / @*)'&*4>

@4'&*4 /%@ 0('%0 .(2* 3( .', C'9* /%@ 9'&* +.')@4*%7 :D J$3 K4*9*. ./@ 3( 2/B* (%* )/,3 @*)'&*4> 3(

`A.* -(%%*+3


9/17

c

8/)*2 ^*/2 C/, / :Hg>*/4g()@ *25)(>** (9 A.* -(%%*+37 A./3 @/>< .* C/, C(4B'%0 C'3. D;g>*/4g

()@ ='+./*) J/%B,7 J/%B,< 3.* ,3(4*1, ,*+$4'3> 0$/4@< (93*% C(4B*@ !:g.($4 ,.'93,< +(22$3'%0 3(

-.'+/0( 94(2 .', .(2* '% U%@'/%/< C.'+. .* ,./4*@ C'3. .', 9'/%+m* /%@ 9($4 +.')@4*%7

Z(%* (9 3.*,* 2*% *&*4 2/@* '3 .(2*7 A./3 ^*@%*,@/> *&*%'%0< /)) 3.4** C*4* ,.(3 3( @*/3. 6>

/42*@ /,,/')/%3, '%,'@* 3.* +(%&*%'*%+* ,3(4*7

A.* 3.4** '%@'&'@$/), +./40*@ C'3. 3.* 2$4@*4, C*4* /)) >($%0*4 3./% :! >*/4, ()@ /%@ 54(.'6'3*@

94(2 (C%'%0 ./%@0$%, (4 /,,/$)3 C*/5(%,7 AC( 0$%, 4*+(&*4*@ 94(2 3.* +4'2* ,+*%* C*4*

5$4+./,*@ /3 ^*,39(43. 85(43, ]$,3 3C( C**B, 54'(4 3( 3.* 2$4@*4,7

N% K54') I< :;!D< !\g>*/4g()@ ='+./*) N4(W+( /%@ / !Dg>*/4g()@ 0'4) C*4* C/)B'%0 '% 3.* n*/43 (9

-.'+/0( %*'0.6(4.((@ 3( 0*3 '+* +4*/27:\ 8$@@*%)>< / 5/,,*%0*4 '% / &/% (5*%*@ 9'4*7 N4(W+( 4/% 3(

*,+/5* 3.* 0$%9'4*< 6$3 .* C/, ,.(3 3.4** 3'2*, '% 3.* 6/+B /%@ @'*@ 94(2 .', '%]$4'*,7 A.* 3C(

/))*0*@ /,,/')/%3, C*4* !I /%@ !c >*/4, ()@gg/0/'% 54(.'6'3*@ 94(2 (C'%0 ./%@0$%,7 K 0$% 3'*@ 3(

3.* +4'2* C/, 5$4+./,*@ /3 ='@C*,3 #$% ?Q+./%0* ]$,3 (&*4 3.4** >*/4, 54'(4 3( N4(W+(1, 2$4@*47

A./3 C/, %(3 3.* 9'4,3 3'2* 3.', 0$% ./@ 6**% $,*@ '% / +4'2*7 K -.'+/0( O()'+* 6/))',3'+, 4*5(43

34/+*@ 3.', 0$% 6/+B 3( /% */4)'*4 '%+'@*%3 (9 /% /004/&/3*@ /,,/$)3 (9 / 5()'+* (99'+*47

N% =/> !;< :;!:< E/2(%3 =/33'+Q /%@ ^'))'/2 n*44(%go$%'$,< 6(3. :; >*/4, ()@< C*4* ,'33'%0

($3,'@* (% / 5(4+. /3 /4($%@ H 5727 '% 3.* J/+B (9 3.* [/4@, %*'0.6(4.((@ (9 -.'+/0(7 :H K 9*C

2'%$3*, )/3*4< 6(3. 2*% C*4* 2$4@*4*@ '% / @4'&*g6> ,.((3'%07 -.'+/0( O()'+* 4*+(&*4*@ / 0$% 3'*@

3( 3.* +4'2*< C.'+. 34/+*@ 6/+B 3( / 5$4+./,* /3 -.$+B1, #$% 8.(5 / )'33)* 2(4* 3./% 3C( >*/4, 54'(4

3( 3.* ,.((3'%07

U% /)) 3.4** +/,*,< 3.* 4*+(&*4*@ 0$%, 34/+*@ 6/+B 3( 5$4+./,*4, (3.*4 3./% 3.* +./40*@ /,,/')/%3,)

U% 3.* +/,* (9 3.* 2$4@*4, /3 A.* -(%%*+3< 3.* 34/+*@ 0$%, C*4* (4'0'%/))> 5$4+./,*@ 6> /% U%@'/%/

4*,'@*%37 K)) (9 3.* 0$%, C*4* 5$4+./,*@ /3 4*3/') @*/)*4,< >*3 C($%@ $5 '% 3.* ./%@, (9 5*(5)* C.(

+($)@ %(3< /%@ ,.($)@ %(3< ./&* ./@ 3.*27

-" 8*. *99*+3'&*7

?" >/7/2(. (03&T32(::&'6&0) .(D,

8'Q3> 5*4+*%3 (9 0$%, 4*+(&*4*@ '% +4'2*, '% -.'+/0( C*4* (4'0'%/))> ,()@ '% (3.*4 ,3/3*,< 2/%> C'3.C*/B*4 0$% )/C,7 85*+'9'+/))>< U%@'/%/< ^',+(%,'%< /%@ =',,',,'55' /)) 5*42'3 0$% (C%*4, 3( ,*))

3.*'4 0$%, 3( (3.*4 5*(5)* C'3.($3 /%> 6/+B04($%@ +.*+B, (9 3.* %*C 6$>*4 (4 5/5*4C(4B

4*+(4@'%0 3.* ,/)*7 A.', 2/B*, '3 '%+4*@'6)> */,> 9(4 0$% 34/99'+B*4,< &'()*%3 (99*%@*4,< /%@ (3.*4

54(.'6'3*@ 5$4+./,*4, 3( 6$> 0$%, $%@*3*+3*@7 U% 3.(,* ,3/3*,< 0$%, +/% 2(&* 94(2 6$>*4 3( 6$>*4

/%@ )/%@ '% 3.* ./%@, (9 / ,.((3*4 (4 2$4@*4*4 C'3.($3 /%> 5/5*4 34/')7


10/17

F

J*+/$,* 3.* )/C, /4* ,( C*/B< )/C *%9(4+*2*%3 +/% (93*% (%)> .()@ 3.* ,.((3*4 /++($%3/6)* /%@ %(3

3.* 5*4,(%R,S C.( /42*@ 3.* ,.((3*47 83/3*, )'B* U))'%(',< -/)'9(4%'/< /%@ Z*C [(4B ./&* 5/,,*@

/%3'g34/99'+B'%0 )/C, 3./3 4*L$'4* 6/+B04($%@ +.*+B, 9(4 /)) 0$% ,/)*,< 6$3 0$%, @( %(3 4*,5*+3 ,3/3*

)'%*,7 A.$,< +'3'*, )'B* -.'+/0( %**@ / 9*@*4/) ,()$3'(%7

P$4'%0 3.* -)'%3(% /@2'%',34/3'(%< =/>(4 V/.2 ?2/%$*) C(4B*@ 3( 5/,, 3.* J4/@> J'))< C.'+.'25)*2*%3*@ 3.* 9'4,3 '%,3/%3 6/+B04($%@ +.*+B ,>,3*27 8'%+* 3.*%< .* ./, +(%,',3*%3)> 5$,.*@ 9(4

,34(%0*4 9*@*4/) )/C,7 8*&*4/) 5*%@'%0 9*@*4/) 6')), C($)@ +)(,* 3.*,* 0/5, /%@ /))(C )/C

*%9(4+*2*%3 3( .()@ 0$% 34/99'+B*4, /++($%3/6)*7:G A.*,* 9*@*4/) 6')), /4* @*,'0%*@ 3( /++(25)',.

3C( 0(/),M R!S 4*L$'4* 6/+B04($%@ +.*+B, 9(4 54'&/3*g5/43> 0$% ,/)*, 3( 2/B* '3 ./4@*4 9(4 +4'2'%/),

3( /++*,, 0$%,< /%@ R:S 2/B* 0$% 34/99'+B'%0 / 9*@*4/) +4'2*7

K93*4 3.* 2/,, ,.((3'%0 '% Z*C3(C%< -(%%*+3'+$3< 3.* X787 8*%/3* +(%,'@*4*@ +(254*.*%,'&*< 6'g

5/43',/% )*0',)/3'(% 3( 4*L$'4* 6/+B04($%@ +.*+B, 9(4 54'&/3* 0$% ,/)*,< C.'+. $)3'2/3*)> @'@ %(3

5/,,7:I E/C, 4*L$'4'%0 6/+B04($%@ +.*+B, 9(4 54'&/3*g5/43> ,/)*, /4* *99*+3'&* /3 4*@$+'%0 0$%

34/99'+B'%07 8'Q3**% ,3/3*, 4*L$'4* 6/+B04($%@ +.*+B, 9(4 /)) ,/)*, (9 ./%@0$%,7 -(25/4*@ 3( 3.*

4*,3 (9 3.* +($%34>< 0$% 34/99'+B'%0 '% 3.(,* ,3/3*, ', Gc 5*4+*%3 )(C*4< 9/3/) @(2*,3'+ &'()*%+* C'3. /0$% ', Dc 5*4+*%3 )(C*4< /%@ 9'4*/42 ,$'+'@* 4/3*, /4* %*/4)> H; 5*4+*%3 )(C*47:c

X%@*4 +$44*%3 9*@*4/) )/C< `0$% 34/99'+B'%0a ', %(3 / @',3'%+3 9*@*4/) (99*%,*7 A.* 6'g5/43',/% *+,

-#&..'%/',0 1#"2",('3, 4%( ,5(%,(4*@ 6> X787 8*%/3(4, l'4B RVgUES /%@ l'4,3*% #'))'64/%@ RPgZ[S /%@

,$55(43*@ 6> X787 8*%/3(4 P'+B P$46'% RPgUES ,**B, 3( +./%0* 3./37 U9 5/,,*@< 3.* )/C C($)@ 2/B* '3

'))*0/) 3( 34/99'+ (4 /,,',3 '% 3.* 34/99'+B'%0 (9 / 9'4*/42< 6> 2/B'%0 '3 $%)/C9$) 3( @*)'&*4 (4 4*+*'&*

3C( (4 2(4* 9'4*/42, C.*4* 3.* '%@'&'@$/) B%(C, (4 ./, 4*/,(% 3( 6*)'*&* 3./3 3.* 9'4*/42, /4*

6*'%0< (4 C')) 6*< $,*@ '% / 9*)(%>7:F K@@'3'(%/))>< 3.* 6')) 54(.'6'3, 2/B'%0 9/),* ,3/3*2*%3,

4*0/4@'%0 /% /+3$/) 6$>*4 3( / )'+*%,*@ 9'4*/42 @*/)*4 4*)/3'%0 3( 3.* 5$4+./,* (9 3C( (4 2(4*

9'4*/42,7 A.$,< 3.', )/C /33/+B, 3.* 54(6)*2 (9 0$% 34/99'+B'%0 /3 *&*4> )'%B '% 3.* +./'%< '%+)$@'%0

,34/Cg5$4+./,*4, C.( 6$> / 0$% 9(4 ,(2*(%* *),*< /%@ 3.* 0$% @*/)*4, C.( B%(C'%0)> ,*))

9'4*/42, 3( 34/99'+B*4,7

I" E0%(0'/7 1/(./2 @/)

:;!\< 3.*> 2$,3 &*4'9> 3.* 6$>*4 ./, / &/)'@ _NUP +/4@7 X%)'B* -/)'9(4%'/ /%@ Z*C [(4B< U))'%(',

@(*, %(3 )'+*%,* /%@ 4*0$)/3* 0$% @*/)*4, (5*4/3'%0 '% 3.* ,3/3*7

A( 6*0'% 3( ,.4'%B 3.* ,'W* (9 -.'+/0(1, '))*0/) 0$% 2/4B*3< )/C *%9(4+*2*%3 (99'+*4, /%@ 4*0$)/3(4,

2$,3 6* *25(C*4*@ 3( +4/+B @(C% (% 3.* 6$,'%*,,*, 3./3 +(%34'6$3* 3( 3.* ,$55)> (9 34/99'+B*@

0$%,7 K, 4*5(43*@ 6> / 9(42*4 KA_ /0*%3 '% :;!:< (93*% @*/)*4, /4* ,2/43 *%($0. 3( 9())(C 3.*

)*33*4 (9 9*@*4/) )/C 6> +(%@$+3'%0 6/+B04($%@ +.*+B, /%@ +.*+B'%0 / 6$>*41, _NUP +/4@7 J$3 C.*%

3.*> ,$,5*+3 6$3 ./&*%13 &*4'9'*@ 3.* 6$>*4 ', / ,34/C 5$4+./,*4< 3.*> )((B 3.* (3.*4 C/>7 D;


11/17

!;

A*+.%'+/))> 3.* @*/)*4 ', %(3 &'()/3'%0 9*@*4/) )/C $%)*,, 3.* @*/)*4 `B%(C, (4 4*/,(%/6)> ,.($)@

./&* B%(C%a 3.* 6$>*4 ', / 34/99'+B*47 A.', +/% 6* / &*4> @'99'+$)3 ,3/%@/4@ 3( 54(&*< /%@ &*4> 9*C

@*/)*4, /4* *&*4 4*54'2/%@*@< '%+)$@'%0 @*/)*4, 3./3 /4* 3.* (4'0'%/) ,($4+* (9 3.($,/%@, (9 +4'2*

0$%,7 P*/)*4, 3./3 9())(C 3.* )*33*4 6$3 3.* %(3 3.* ,5'4'3 (9 3.* )/C +/% *%@ $5 @'4*+3)> +(%34'6$3'%0

3( .$%@4*@, (9 &'()*%3 +4'2*, 6$3 ,3/> '% 6$,'%*,, 9(4 >*/4,< ,**2'%0)> ($3 (9 4*/+.7 A.*,* @*/)*4,

./&* / 4*,5(%,'6')'3> 3( 3/B* *&*4> ,3*5 3.*> +/% 3( 4*@$+* 34/99'+B'%0 '% 3.*'4 ,3(4*, 0'&*% 3.* .$0*,(+'/) +(,3, /%@ +(%,*L$*%+*, (9 0$% &'()*%+*7

P$* 3( C*/B 9*@*4/) 4*0$)/3'(%, (9 @*/)*4,< +'3'*, /%@ ,3/3*, +/% 2/B* / 6'0 '25/+3 (% 0$%

34/99'+B'%0 6> )'+*%,'%0 3.*,* 6$,'%*,,*, /%@ 4*L$'4'%0 3.*2 3( 3/B* +(22(% ,*%,* ,3*5, 3( 4*@$+*

,34/C 5$4+./,'%0 /%@ 3.*93 '% 3.*'4 ,3(4*,7 K++(4@'%0 3( 4*,*/4+.*4,< `,3/3* (4 )(+/) 4*0$)/3'(% (9

0$% @*/)*4,< +($5)*@ C'3. 4*0$)/4 +(25)'/%+* '%,5*+3'(%,< C*4* /,,(+'/3*@ C'3. ,'0%'9'+/%3)> )*,,

34/99'+B'%0 (9 0$%, 3( +4'2'%/),7aD!

A.*4* /4* / %$26*4 (9 ,3*5, @*/)*4, +/% 3/B* 3( 4*@$+* 3.* +./%+*, 3.*'4 0$%, *%@ $5 '% +4'2*,7 P$*

3( / 9*@*4/) +($43 @*+','(% 2/%@/3'%0 -.'+/0( /))(C 0$% ,/)*, C'3.'% 3.* +'3> )'2'3,< */+. (9 3.*,*

+(22(% ,*%,* 54*&*%3/3'&* 2*/,$4*, C')) 6* 5/43 (9 3.* -'3>1, 54(5(,*@ (4@'%/%+* 3( 4*0$)/3* 0$%@*/)*4, '% -.'+/0(M

• EBN.*4// I('6)2* )/C *%9(4+*2*%3 6*9(4* 3.*

6$,'%*,, 2/> (5*%7 ?/+. ,/9*3> 5)/% 2$,3 @*3*4 3.*93 3.4($0. /@*L$/3* *Q3*4'(4 )'0.3'%0<

,$4&*'))/%+* +/2*4/,< /)/42 ,>,3*2, (4 (3.*4 2*/,$4*,7 A.* 5)/%, ,.($)@ /),( /@@4*,, ,/9*

,3(4/0* (9 C*/5(%, /%@ /22$%'3'(% /%@ 9'4* ./W/4@ +(25)'/%+*7 -$44*%3)>< KA_ /@&',*,

@*/)*4, (% .(C 3( 2'%'2'W* 3.*93 6$3 9*@*4/) 4*0$)/3'(%, @( %(3 2/%@/3* @*/)*4, '25)*2*%3

2*/,$4*, 3( 54(3*+3 /0/'%,3 3.*937

• EBN.*4// L2(&0&0)M A4/'% *25)(>**, /%@ 2/%/0*4, 3( '@*%3'9> +(22(% ,'0%, (9 ,34/C

5$4+./,'%0 /%@ /&('@ ,*))'%0 3( 34/99'+B*4,7

• !0A/,3&)(3&*0 5*)M =/'%3/'% /% /)5./6*3'+/) )(0 (9 /)) 0$%, ,/)*, C.*4* 3.* 0$% C/, )/3*4

4*+(&*4*@ '% / +4'2*7 U9 / ,'%0)* 5$4+./,*4 ./, 2$)3'5)* 0$%, 4*+(&*4*@ '% +4'2*, '% / ,.(43

5*4'(@ (9 3'2*< 3./3 '%9(42/3'(% +($)@ )*/@ 3.* @*/)*4 3( @*%> 9$3$4* ,/)*,7

• !0A/03*24 ?< L$/43*4)> /$@'3 (9 3.* ,3(4*1, '%&*%3(4> 3( .*)5

@*3*+3 3.*93 /%@ 34/99'+B'%07 _*@*4/) )/C 4*,34'+3, KA_ 94(2 +(%@$+3'%0 2(4* 3./% (%*

'%,5*+3'(% 5*4 >*/4< /%@ @$* 3( 2/%5(C*4 +(%,34/'%3,< 2(,3 @*/)*4, /4* '%,5*+3*@ (%)>

*&*4> 9*C >*/4,7

• -&7/* '(B/2(,M V*+(4@ 3.* 5('%3 (9 ,/)* 3( @',+($4/0* 34/99'+B*4, /%@ 6$>*4, C.( $,* 9/),*

'@*%3'9'+/3'(%7


12/17

!!

• 5&'/0,/ 32(0,:/2,M U9 / 6$,'%*,, )'+*%,* ', 4*&(B*@ 9(4 9/')'%0 3( 9())(C 3.* )/C< 2/B'%0 ,$4*

3.* @*/)*4 +/%%(3 4*(5*% '22*@'/3*)> '% 3.* ,/2* )(+/3'(% (4 6> 9(42*4 B*> *25)(>**, /%@

2/%/0*4,7

U% :;;G< Z*C [(4B -'3> ,$*@ 2(4* 3./% 3C*%3> @*/)*4, 3./3 C*4* 3.* 3(5 ,($4+* (9 0$%, 4*+(&*4*@

'% +4'2*, '% 3.* +'3>7 K, 5/43 (9 3.* ,*33)*2*%3 /04**2*%3,< 3.* +($43 /,,'0%*@ / 2(%'3(4 C.(.*)5*@ */+. ,3(4* '25)*2*%3 ,(2* (9 3.* ,/9*3> 2*/,$4*, @*,+4'6*@ /6(&*7 K, / 4*,$)3< 3.* ,$55)>

(9 +4'2* 0$%, 94(2 3.(,* ,3(4*, @4(55*@ 6> cH 5*4+*%37D\

$" $2/(3/ ( @/)&*0(. L2('&0) $/03/2

A.* /%/)>,', '% 3.', 4*5(43 ', 6/,*@ ,()*)> (% 0$%, 4*+(&*4*@ /%@ 34/+*@ 6> 3.* -.'+/0( O()'+*

P*5/432*%3< 6$3 *&*4> 5()'+* @*5/432*%3 '% 3.* 4*0'(% /),( 4*+(&*4, /%@ 34/+*, 0$%,7 O()'+*

@*5/432*%3, '% %(43.*4% U))'%(',< ^',+(%,'% /%@ U%@'/%/ ,.($)@ +())/6(4/3* 3( +(26'%* /%@ ,./4*

*/+. @*5/432*%31, 34/+* @/3/ 3( +4*/3* / 2(4* /++$4/3* /%@ @*3/')*@ &'*C (9 .(C '))*0/) 0$%, 9)(C

3.4($0. 3.* 4*0'(%7 ^'3. 3.', '%,'0.3< +'3'*, +($)@ C(4B 3(0*3.*4 3( @*&*)(5 *%9(4+*2*%3 ,34/3*0'*,

/3 *&*4> ,3/0* '% 3.* 34/99'+B'%0 +./'%7

!-" $*0'. 9(4

+4'2'%/), 3( 0*3 3.*'4 ./%@, (% @*/@)> C*/5(%,7 ^'3. /% *%./%+*@ $%@*4,3/%@'%0 (9 C.*4* 3.*,*

0$%, /4* +(2'%0 94(2< 3.* -'3> C')) 6* $,'%0 *&*4> 3(() 3( 4*@$+* 3.* ,$55)> (9 34/99'+B*@ 0$%,<

'%+)$@'%0 5$4,$'3 (9 +(22(% ,*%,* )*0',)/3'(%< '%%(&/3'&* 5()'+'%0 ,34/3*0'*, /%@ (&*4,'0.3 (9 0$%

@*/)*4,7 V*@$+'%0 3.* ,'W* (9 -.'+/0(1, '))*0/) 0$% 2/4B*3 C')) %(3 6* */,>< 6$3 '3 ', /6,()$3*)>

%*+*,,/4> '9 C* C/%3 3( 0'&* /)) -.'+/0(/% 3.* ,/2* (55(43$%'3> 3( 9**) ,/9* '% ($4 -'3>7


13/17

!:

E070*3/,

"#$% &'()*+ ,-./0%$%1+'2% 3//0-3,$ (- 2'-4%1,% /0%2%1('-1 '+ 5%+,0'6%5 '1 70%3(%0 5%(3'4 3(

8 #$% 3134)+'+ 93+ '1:-0.%5 6) (%,$1',34 53(3 3++'+(31,% :0-. ($% ;1'2%0+'() -: &$',37- &0'.% '7?0%+

/0%+%1(%5 '1 ($'+ 5-,?.%1( 9%0% 7%1%03(%5 3+ /30( -: ($'+ (%,$1',34 3++'+(31,% /0-2'5%5 (- ($% &'() 6) ($% &0'.%

031C D3'1E !"#$%&' )%*&+ ,'*-. /%01 .' )' 2%3 .' 456 )5*+ E F?7?+( 8GE 8H"8E &$',37- I?1 #'.%+E 323'4364% 3(

$((/JKK999=+?1('.%+=,-.K1%9+K,0'.%K"LM"NGNOPL"OK,$',37-P7317+P5-1(P$32%P(-P7-P:30P(-P6?)P

7?1+=$(.4Q=;BRMSTU5VWD

L @-2%0() :'7?0%+ 30% :0-. ($% ;I &%1+?+ 315 30% 323'4364% 3(J

$((/JKKX?',C:3,(+=,%1+?+=7-2KX:5K+(3(%+KBGKBGN"HHH=$(.4Y

$((/JKKX?',C:3,(+=,%1+?+=7-2KX:5K+(3(%+KHGKHGLLHHH=$(.4Y

$((/JKKX?',C:3,(+=,%1+?+=7-2KX:5K+(3(%+KHGKHGLLHHH=$(.4

N

#$% @-4',% -::',% /%0 ,3/'(3 :'7?0%+ 9%0% ,34,?43(%5 ?+'17 ($% >Z[*+ \3('-134 &0'.% #364%+ 315 30% 323'4364% 3(J$((/JKK999=:6'=7-2K36-?(P?+K,]'+K?,0K,0'.%P'1P($%P?=+K8H"8K,0'.%P'1P($%P?=+=P

8H"8K(364%+KMO(364%53(35%,/5:K(364%PMOP+(3(%P

,?(+K(364%WMOW:?44W('.%W439W%1:-0,%.%1(W%./4-)%%+W'44'1-'+W6)W,'()W8H"8=^4+

$((/JKK999=:6'=7-2K36-?(P?+K,]'+K?,0K,0'.%P'1P($%P?=+K8H"8K,0'.%P'1P($%P?=+=P

8H"8K(364%+KMO(364%53(35%,/5:K(364%PMOP+(3(%P

,?(+K(364%WMOW:?44W('.%W439W%1:-0,%.%1(W%./4-)%%+W1%9W)-0CW6)W,'()W8H"8=^4+

$((/JKK999=:6'=7-2K36-?(P?+K,]'+K?,0K,0'.%P'1P($%P?=+K8H"8K,0'.%P'1P($%P?=+=P

8H"8K(364%+KMO(364%53(35%,/5:K(364%PMOP+(3(%P

,?(+K(364%WMOW:?44W('.%W439W%1:-0,%.%1(W%./4-)%%+W,34':-01'3W6)W,'()W8H"8=^4+

G A3(3 -1 7?1 0%,-2%0'%+ '1 '0%30.

g'-4%1,%E "TTBP8H""= 4531%5 '> ?5+.#$1 @.%.#+.#$+ @A1$#%B C1A'3. = F23'4364% 3(

$((/JKK999=6]+=7-2K,-1(%1(K/?6K/5:K:2TB""=/5: -1 D3) 8HE 8H"L=

"" >'7?0% Z 0%/-0(+ $-.','5% 53(3 :0-. 8H"" 6%,3?+% $-.','5% 53(3 60-C%1 5-91 6) 9%3/-1 ()/% :0-. 8H"8 '+ 1-(

)%( /?64',4) 323'4364%=


14/17

!D

"8 #-0-1(- ,0'.% 53(3 '+ ,-./'4%5 :0-. +(3('+(',+ C%/( 6) ($% #-0-1(- /-4',% 315 '+ 323'4364% 3(

$((/JKK999=(-0-1(-/-4',%=-1=,3K+(3('+(',+K)(5W+(3(+=/$/

"B U3).% @-'++-1 315 A32'5 Z0?+%E D"1 &5* A#A1B#*1E ;5B1+ F"' G3#*& >#31%39+ %$3'++ G'3813 A%6 "#&" A3#$1 >'3 >%+.

9'*16 E F/0'4 "TE 8H"BE #-0-1(- I(30E 323'4364% 3(

$((/JKK999=($%+(30=,-.K1%9+K'12%+('73('-1+K8H"BKHLK"TK($%W7?1W/'/%4'1%W.?4%+W9$-W60'17W:'0%30.+W3,0-++W

6-05%0W/3)W$'7$W/0',%W:-0W:3+(W.-1%)=$(.4

"L F+ +(3(%5 '1 -($%0 0%/-0(+E '1,4?5'17 #03,% ($% d?1+ b8H"Hc b+%% /37% B8cE ,0'.% 7?1 (03,% 53(3 '+ 3 234?364% (--4

(- ?15%0+(315 (03::',C'17 /3((%01+E 6?( '( $3+ +-.% 4'.'(3('-1+= >'0+(E (03,%5 7?1+ 5- 1-( 0%/0%+%1( 344 ,0'.% 7?1+=

D31) 7?1+ ?+%5 '1 ,0'.% 30% 1%2%0 0%,-2%0%5 6) ($% &$',37- @-4',% A%/30(.%1(= I%,-15E 1-( 344 3((%./(+ (- (03,%

7?1+ 30% +?,,%++:?4= #03,%+ .3) :3'4 ': 6?+'1%++%+ :3'4 (- C%%/ ($% 0%,-05+ 1%,%++30) (- (03,C ($% ,$3'1 -: -91%0+$'/

-0 ': ($% +%0'34 1?.6%0 -: ($% 7?1 $3+ 6%%1 -64'(%03(%5= [1 8H"HE D3)-0+ F73'1+( [44%734 d?1+ 0%/-0(%5 ($3( F#>

+?,,%++:?44) (03,%5 7?1+ ]?+( -2%0 GHf -: ($% ('.%= bI%% #03,% ($% d?1+E /37% Lc= >'1344)E (03,% 53(3 -14) +$-9+ ($%

:'0+( 0%(3'4 /?0,$3+%0E 315 3+ 5'+,?++%5 36-2%E 7?1+ ,31 ,$317% $315+ .?4('/4% ('.%+ 6%:-0% 6%'17 ?+%5 '1 3 ,0'.%

h -1% 0%3+-1 9$) ,34,?43('17 +$-0( i('.% (- ,0'.%j '+ 3 234?364% '15',3(-0 -: (03::',C'17= \-1%($%4%++E (03,% 53(3 '+

0%,-71'R%5 3+ 31 './-0(31( '15',3(-0 -: (03::',C'17 ,$311%4+ 315 '+ 0%7?4304) 3134)R%5 6) F#> (- (03,C (0%15+= bI%%E

%=7=E F#>*+ 8H"8 3770%73(% (03,% 53(3 0%/-0(+E 323'4364% $%0%J $((/+JKK999=3(:=7-2K+(3('+(',+K(03,%P53(3K8H"8P(03,%P53(3=$(.4c

"N =8 = 3( /7= L=

"G F#>E i>-44-9'17 ($% d?1j b8HHHc b323'4364% 3( $((/JKK999=3(:=7-2K+'(%+K5%:3?4(K:'4%+K3++%(+K>'0%30.+K,$3/"=/5: c

"M #$% F#> /0-2'5%+ 3 5%+,0'/('-1 -: ($'+ /0-,%++ -1 '(+ 9%6+'(%E 323'4364% 3(

$((/JKK999=3(:=7-2K/?64',3('-1+K:3,(+$%%(+K:3,(+$%%(P13('-134P(03,'17P,%1(%0=$(.4

"O F#> >3,( I$%%( -1 [1+/%,('-1+ -: >'0%30.+ A%34%0+ bU?4) 8HHLc b323'4364% 3(

$((/JKK999=]?+(',%=7-2K-'7K0%/-0(+KF#>K%HLHNK63,C70-?15=$(.=c #$% A%/30(.%1( -: U?+(',% k-?($ &0'.% d?1

[1(%05',('-1 a%/-0(+ 34+- 5%:'1%5 i+$-0( ('.%P(-P,0'.%j 3+ B )%30+ -0 4%++= I%% %=7=E ($% &$',37- k&d[[ 0%/-0( 3( /37%

"B= bi%^/%0'%1,%5 (03::',C'17 '12%+('73(-0+ 2'%9 3 ('.%P(-P,0'.% -: 4%++ ($31 B )%30+ 3+ 31 %+/%,'344) ?+%:?4

'15',3(-0c b323'4364% 3( $((/+JKK999=3(:=7-2K:'4%+K/?64',3('-1+K5-914-35K),7''K8HHHK,'()0%/-0(+K,$',37-'4=/5:c=

F#>*+ 311?34 (03,% 0%/-0(+ 34+- (03,C 7?1+ 0%,-2%0%5 '1 ($0%% )%30+ -0 4%++ ,-./30%5 (- 7?1+ 0%,-2%0%5 '1 .-0%

($31 ($0%% )%30+= I%%E %=7=E [44'1-'+* 0%/-0( 3( $((/+JKK999=3(:=7-2K+'(%+K5%:3?4(K:'4%+K3++%(+K+(3('+(',+K(03,%53(3P

8H"8K8H"8P(03,%P53(3P'44'1-'+=/5:= [1 +-.% /0%++ 0%4%3+%+E F#> $3+ 5%:'1%5 i+$-0( ('.%P(-P,0'.%j 3+ (9- )%30+=

I%%E %=7=E F#> @0%++ a%4%3+%E 323'4364% 3( $((/+JKK999=3(:=7-2K/0%++K0%4%3+%+K8HHTKHMKHMHOHTP1)P3(:P+$30%+P(03,%P

53(3=$(.4

"T [1 '(+ 8H"H 0%/-0(E i#03,% ($% d?1+J ($%


15/17

!\

88 #$'+ 3134)+'+ 5-%+ 1-( ,-1(0-4 :-0 %3,$ 5%34%0*+ +34%+ 2-4?.%= A%34%0+ 9'($ 4307%0 +34%+ 2-4?.% .3) 34+- $32%

4307%0 1?.6%0 -: 7?1+ 0%,-2%0%5 '1 ,0'.%+ (03,%5 63,C (- ($-+% +(-0%+= l-9%2%0E '( '+ 1-( ,?00%1(4) :%3+'64% (-

,-1(0-4 :-0 +34%+ 2-4?.% 6%,3?+% ($% 7?1 '15?+(0) 5-%+ 1-( 0%4%3+% +34%+ 53(3= D-0%-2%0E .-0% ($31 GEHHH 5%34%0+

9%0% +-?0,%+ -: 7?1+ 0%,-2%0%5 '1 &$',37- ,0'.%+E 315 ($% 32%037% 1?.6%0 -: 7?1+ (03,%5 (- ($-+% +(-0%+ 93+

($0%%= #$-+% +(-0%+ /0%+?.364) $32% 3 9'5% 0317% -: +34%+ 2-4?.% h :0-. 4307% +(-0%+ (- +.344%0 -1%+=

8B F+ 0%/-0(%5 6) U-$1 @= l?+(-1E a)31 l377%0() 315 U%0%.) d-01%0E !'*01*#1*$1 +.'31 81%8E H 19AB'611+I

F"'B1+%B13 %*8 A'++#GB6 % &5*9%*I \-2= BE 8H""E &$',37- #0'6?1%E 323'4364% 3(

$((/JKK30(',4%+=,$',37-(0'6?1%=,-.K8H""P""PHBK1%9+K,(P.%(P:-?0P/%-/4%PC'44%5P8P8H""""HLW"W,-12%1'%1,%P+(-0%P

+%,?0'()P7?305P7?1.%1=

8L F+ 0%/-0(%5 6) e0'1 D%)%0E A300)4 l-44'53) 315 e.'4) D-00'+E D11* J#BB18 KLMN1%3MOB8 4'6 .' 701*&1 2%."13P+

,1%."I Q3'+1$5.'3+ 7BB1&1I F/0'4 TE 8H"BE A\F'1:- &$',37-E 323'4364% 3(

$((/JKK999=513'1:-=,-.K,$',37-K8H"BHLHTK/'4+%1K(%%1PC'44%5P"LP)%30P-45P/'4+%1P32%17%P:3($%0+P5%3($P

/0-+%,?(-0+

8N F+ 0%/-0(%5 6) e0'1 D%)%0E ;%* !"%3&18 #* HRKH ,3#01M46 ,'5GB1 ;53813 E D30,$ "NE 8H"BE A\F'1:- &$',37-E

323'4364% 3( $((/JKK999=513'1:-=,-.K,$',37-K8H"BHB"NK63,CP-:P)305+K.31P,$307%5P8H"8P50'2%P6)P5-?64%P.?05%0

8G I=GLTE I3:% &-..?1'('%+E I3:% I,$--4+ F,( -: 8H"B b""B

($ &-170%++cY I= F.5( M"N (- I= GLT m l=a="NGNE @?64',

I3:%() 315 I%,-15 F.%15.%1( a'7$(+ @0-(%,('-1 F,( -: 8H"B b""B($

&-170%++cY


16/17

!H

BB F#> 8H"8 I?..30)J >'0%30.+ a%/-0(%5 '0%30.+K8H"8P+?..30)P:'0%30.+P0%/-0(%5P4-+(P315P+(-4%1P8=/5:

BL C185$#*& )5* S#'B1*$1 #* 7913#$%I =*>'39#*& Q'B#$6 F#." :0#81*$1 %*8 7*%B6+#+ bA31'%4 V%6+(%0 m U-1 g%01',C

%5+=E 8H"Bc /7+= "8MP"8TE :?44 (%^( 323'4364% 3( $((/JKK]$?/0%++=:'4%+=9-05/0%++=,-.K8H"BKH"K"L8"L""""BW?/5:=/5:


17/17

Documents

Exhibit A to the Complaint