25
Manufacturing: A Susquehanna Region Industry Brief Submitted by: Sage Policy Group, Inc. Submitted to: The Susquehanna Workforce Network Harford County Office of Economic Development

Executive Summary - Susquehanna Workforce … · Web viewHowever, it is important not to conflate employment growth with demand for workers. Exhibit 9 supplies statistical detail

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    1

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: Executive Summary - Susquehanna Workforce … · Web viewHowever, it is important not to conflate employment growth with demand for workers. Exhibit 9 supplies statistical detail

Manufacturing:A Susquehanna Region Industry

Brief

Submitted by:

Sage Policy Group, Inc.

Submitted to:

The Susquehanna Workforce Network Harford County Office of Economic DevelopmentCecil County Economic Development Department

February 2017

Page 2: Executive Summary - Susquehanna Workforce … · Web viewHowever, it is important not to conflate employment growth with demand for workers. Exhibit 9 supplies statistical detail

Executive Summary

Background

Between 2004 and 2014, manufacturing employment in the Susquehanna Region declined from nearly 9,500 positions to fewer than 8,500 positions. Approximately half of this loss was recovered in 2015 itself, but manufacturing employment has generally been falling locally, statewide, and nationally over time. Between 2011 and 2015, Maryland lost nearly 9,300 manufacturing jobs. The U.S. has lost 5 million manufacturing jobs since 2000.

One would be tempted to think that the loss of manufacturing jobs would signify a dearth of opportunity for jobseekers. Data indicate otherwise. Available information from the Maryland Workforce Exchange indicates that roughly 500 manufacturing positions were being advertised in the Susquehanna Region as of December 2016. Focus groups conducted by the Sage Policy Group in late-2016 also indicate that manufacturers suffer enormous difficulty filling available jobs despite an abundance of applicants.

The difficulty finding eligible candidates is not simply a function of a lack of formal education. Data from 2016 indicate that more than 70 percent of the Susquehanna region’s manufacturing workforce lacks a bachelor’s degree. Moreover, most manufacturing occupations have as their primary skill a skill that is learned on the job.

Findings

This industry brief addresses the following questions:

1. What are the realistic growth prospects for manufacturing employment in the Susquehanna Region?

2. To what extent is there evidence of inadequate human capital supply now and into the future with respect to regional manufacturing?

3. What does an individual need to do to access manufacturing opportunities and are those opportunities available within the confines of the Susquehanna Region?

Sage concludes that the Susquehanna Region will produce significant numbers of manufacturing job openings in the future, in part due to retirement, and that employers will continue to have difficulty filling them. We further conclude that there are proximate opportunities for

Manufacturing: A Susquehanna Region Industry Brief

2

Page 3: Executive Summary - Susquehanna Workforce … · Web viewHowever, it is important not to conflate employment growth with demand for workers. Exhibit 9 supplies statistical detail

residents to obtain the necessary skills and credentials to enter manufacturing, but that to date these opportunities have either not adequately prepared workers for careers, or more likely, that not enough residents have accessed them.

We recommend that the Susquehanna Workforce Network (SWN) study the extent to which participants in its Entry Level Manufacturing Training Program: 1) successfully complete the program, 2) secure employment, 3) retain employment, and 4) are promoted to positions beyond entry-level. We also recommend that there be an analysis of enrollment trends, an assessment of the degree to which jobseekers are aware of this program, and an inquiry regarding any evidence of unmet demand.

Manufacturing: A Susquehanna Region Industry Brief

3

Page 4: Executive Summary - Susquehanna Workforce … · Web viewHowever, it is important not to conflate employment growth with demand for workers. Exhibit 9 supplies statistical detail

I. Industry Overview

Can We Replace all those Lost Industrial Jobs?

A Congressional Research Service report dated June 2016 pointed out that while U.S. manufacturing output has expanded by approximately 9 percent since the most recent low point in 2009, almost all of that expansion occurred prior to the end of 2014. Moreover, the rebound in industry output “has resulted in negligible employment growth.”1

At the onset of the 21st century, 17.1 million Americans worked in manufacturing. That figure began to decline with the recession that began in March 2001. By the time the most recent recession began in December 2007, U.S. manufacturing employment had dipped to 13.7 million.2 By December 2016, fewer than 12.3 million manufacturing positions existed in America.3

One could reasonably ask if the nation can hope to add manufacturing employment over time if it fails to do so even during periods of broader economic expansion. Given the specter of accelerating innovation and automation, one could also ask whether it makes sense for American communities to invest significant resources in manufacturing given its historic and presumed trajectory. This industry brief attempts to address these and similar questions for stakeholders in Maryland’s Susquehanna Region.

The Industry Defined

The Manufacturing sector comprises establishments engaged in the physical, mechanical, or chemical transformation of materials, substances, or components into new products. Manufacturing establishments are often described as plants, factories, or mills and characteristically use power driven machines and materials handling equipment.

Establishments that transform materials or substances into new products by hand or in the worker’s home and those engaged in 1 Congressional Reserve Service, “Job Creation in the Manufacturing Revival”. 7-5700, www.crs.gov, R41898, June 28, 2016, Executive Summary.2 Id at 1.3 U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, All Employees: Manufacturing [MANEMP], retrieved from FRED, Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis; https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/MANEMP.

Manufacturing: A Susquehanna Region Industry Brief

4

Page 5: Executive Summary - Susquehanna Workforce … · Web viewHowever, it is important not to conflate employment growth with demand for workers. Exhibit 9 supplies statistical detail

selling to the general public products made on the same premises from which they are sold, such as bakeries, candy stores, and custom tailors, may also be classified as manufacturing. Manufacturing establishments may process materials or may contract with other establishments to process their materials for them. Both types of establishments are included in the manufacturing sector.4,5

Though there are stereotypical images of manufacturing workers, who are often visualized in assembly line settings, there are in fact a myriad of different occupational categories and skill sets implicated by the sector. Below are some brief descriptions:

Science, technology, engineering and mathematics workers are frequently involved at the earliest stages of manufacturing when they are creating or improving a product’s design. These workers may also help design the machines, robots, and other technologies used in factories. Employment in these types of activities is expected to expand going forward.

Production workers help to make a product according to design specifications, conducting tasks such as operating machinery, overseeing product quality, or packaging and preparing finished goods for shipping. Many production worker positions are susceptible to automation.

Installation, maintenance, and repair workers keep production equipment and machinery, as well as facilities themselves, functioning properly. As a result of the increased use of automated processes, maintenance and repair work of machinery will remain an important manufacturing component.

Transportation and material moving workers handle products and raw materials and help to move them from one location — such as a shipping and receiving area, loading dock, or warehouse — to another. The demand for workers to do heavy lifting inside factories continues to diminish with the increased use of technology.

Management and business and financial operations workers plan and oversee manufacturing operations. Occupations in this category are often highly compensated and include general and operations managers and industrial production managers.

4 North American Industry Classification System (NAICS).5 Maryland Workforce Exchange, Summary industry profile for Manufacturing (31-33) in Susquehanna Workforce Region, Maryland.

Manufacturing: A Susquehanna Region Industry Brief

5

Page 6: Executive Summary - Susquehanna Workforce … · Web viewHowever, it is important not to conflate employment growth with demand for workers. Exhibit 9 supplies statistical detail

Sales workers interact with existing and prospective customers to help market manufactured products to wholesalers, retailers, and consumers.

Office and administrative support workers answer phones, process orders, and perform clerical tasks. One of the largest occupations in this group is shipping, receiving, and traffic clerks. Job growth for this occupation, however, is expected to be limited as automation and the increased use of radiofrequency identification tags help workers track incoming and outgoing shipments more quickly and efficiently.6

6 U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, “Got skills? Think manufacturing” by Elka Torpey. June 2014. https://www.bls.gov/careeroutlook/2014/article/manufacturing.htm.

Manufacturing: A Susquehanna Region Industry Brief

6

Page 7: Executive Summary - Susquehanna Workforce … · Web viewHowever, it is important not to conflate employment growth with demand for workers. Exhibit 9 supplies statistical detail

II. Manufacturing in the Susquehanna Region

Regional Manufacturing Employment Bounced Back in ‘15

Like many American communities, the Susquehanna Region has experienced declines in manufacturing employment over time. Between 2004 and 2014, regional manufacturing employment declined from nearly 9,500 positions to fewer than 8,500 positions one decade later (Exhibits 1 and 2). However, roughly half of this loss was recovered in 2015. By 2015, the region supported more manufacturing jobs than it had during any period since the recession.

Exhibit 1. Susquehanna Region Manufacturing Employment (NSA), 2001-2015

2001200220032004200520062007200820092010201120122013201420157,500

8,000

8,500

9,000

9,500

0.0%

5.0%

10.0%

15.0%

20.0%Cecil County

Harford County

Manufacturing Employ-ment (Total Susq. Region)

Manufacturing % of Total Private County

Employment

Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Quarterly Census of Employment and Wages (QCEW); Sage. Notes: 1. NSA: Not Seasonally Adjusted.

Exhibit 2. Recent Growth in Manufacturing Employment (NSA), Maryland v. Susquehanna Region

Manufacturing Employment 2011 v. 2015

2011 2015 Net %

Maryland 113,033 103,757 -9,276 -8.2%

Susquehanna WIA 8,503 8,942 439 5.2%

Cecil County, MD 4,084 4,255 171 4.2%Manufacturing: A Susquehanna Region Industry Brief

7

Page 8: Executive Summary - Susquehanna Workforce … · Web viewHowever, it is important not to conflate employment growth with demand for workers. Exhibit 9 supplies statistical detail

Harford County, MD 4,419 4,687 268 6.1%

Manufacturing Employment

2015 H1 v. 2016 H1

2015 H1 2016 H1 Net %

Maryland 103,193 103,505 312 0.3%

Susquehanna WIA 8,861 9,049 188 2.1%

Cecil County, MD 4,213 4,201 -12 -0.3%

Harford County, MD 4,648 4,847 199 4.3%

Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Quarterly Census of Employment and Wages (QCEW); Sage. Notes: 1. NSA: Not Seasonally Adjusted. 2. Annual figures are annual averages. 3. H1: First half of the year. Figures for 2015/2016 H1 represent the average employment level from January-June in each year.

The recent growth in regional manufacturing employment defies statewide trends. Between 2011 and 2015, Maryland lost nearly 9,300 manufacturing positions while the Susquehanna Region gained more than 400.

The leading manufacturing segment in the region is plastics & rubber products manufacturing (Exhibit 3), a reflection of the presence of W.L. Gore & Associates and its estimated 2,400 positions in Cecil County. This single employer is responsible for more than a quarter of all manufacturing employment in the Susquehanna Region. Other large manufacturers include ATK and Terumo Medical Products in Cecil County and Frito-Lay and Cylec Engineered Materials in Harford County.

Manufacturing: A Susquehanna Region Industry Brief

8

Page 9: Executive Summary - Susquehanna Workforce … · Web viewHowever, it is important not to conflate employment growth with demand for workers. Exhibit 9 supplies statistical detail

Exhibit 3. Susquehanna Region Manufacturing Employment by Detailed Industry, 2016Q1

Textile Product Mills*

Wood Product Mnf.

Nonmetallic Mineral Product Mnf.

Machinery Mnf.*

Transportation Equipment Mnf.

Miscellaneous Mnf.

Fabricated Metal Product Mnf.

Plastics & Rubber Products Mnf.*

0 500 1,000 1,500 2,000 2,500

82871108

258261

333499

578623

870895917982

2,516

Employment

Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, LED Extraction Tool - Quarterly Workforce Indicators (QWI).Notes: 1. Private manufacturing employment. 2. Data are not seasonally adjusted (NSA). 3. Some manufacturing industries are not represented above because the U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics suppresses figures when they do not meet US Census Bureau publication standards. *Data for these industries may be distorted/fuzzed.

There are a number of reasons that communities around the nation continue to focus upon manufacturing despite the large-scale loss of employment over time and the expectation that global competition and automation will likely continue to drive job totals lower. One is that people are instinctively aware that manufacturing represents a source of wealth creation. In a purely service-oriented environment, wealth can only be transferred. It is only through the translation of inputs into outputs that actual wealth is created.

Moreover, wages are higher in manufacturing than in most other industries. This is certainly true in the Susquehanna Region. By the second quarter of 2016, the average weekly manufacturing wage in the Susquehanna Workforce Region was $1,296, which translates into an average annual income of approximately $67,000.

Exhibit 4. Susquehanna Region Manufacturing Business Establishments by Detailed Industry, 2016Q2

Industry Total Susq. Region

# of % of Total

Manufacturing: A Susquehanna Region Industry Brief

9

Page 10: Executive Summary - Susquehanna Workforce … · Web viewHowever, it is important not to conflate employment growth with demand for workers. Exhibit 9 supplies statistical detail

Establishments

Manufacturing Ests.

Fabricated metal product manufacturing 41 18.5%

Plastics and rubber products manufacturing 26 11.7%

Machinery manufacturing 21 9.5%

Food manufacturing 19 8.6%

Printing and related support activities 18 8.1%

Miscellaneous manufacturing 17 7.7%

Chemical manufacturing 15 6.8%

Nonmetallic mineral product manufacturing 12 5.4%

Computer & electronic product manufacturing 12 5.4%

Furniture and related product manufacturing 8 3.6%

Wood product manufacturing 8 3.6%

Transportation equipment manufacturing 6 2.7%

Textile product mills 5 2.3%

Beverage and tobacco product manufacturing 4 1.8%

Apparel manufacturing 2 0.9%

Primary metal manufacturing 2 0.9%

Electrical equipment and appliance mfg. 2 0.9%

Textile mills 1 0.5%

Leather and allied product manufacturing 1 0.5%

Paper manufacturing 1 0.5%

Petroleum and coal products manufacturing 1 0.5%

TOTAL MANUFACTURING 222 100.0%

Source: U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics, Quarterly Census of Employment and Wages (QCEW) program-QCEW NAICS-Based Data Files.

Manufacturing: A Susquehanna Region Industry Brief

10

Page 11: Executive Summary - Susquehanna Workforce … · Web viewHowever, it is important not to conflate employment growth with demand for workers. Exhibit 9 supplies statistical detail

Exhibit 5. Average Weekly Manufacturing Wages in Maryland by Workforce Region, 2016Q2

Upper Shore Workforce Region

Western Maryland Workforce Region

Baltimore City Workforce Region

Prince George's County Workforce Region

Susquehanna Workforce Region

Anne Arundel Workforce Region

$0 $1,000 $2,000 $3,000

$817

$1,296

$2,214

Avg. Hourly Wage*

Avg. Weekly Wage

Avg. Annual Wage*

Susquehanna Workforce RegionManufacturing Wages $32.40 $1,296 $67,392

Source: Maryland Workforce Exchange, Labor Market Statistics, Covered Employment and Wages Program. *Assumes a 40-hour week worked year round.

III. Looking Ahead: Meeting Future Demands in Manufacturing

This industry brief addresses the following questions:

1. What are the realistic growth prospects for manufacturing employment in the Susquehanna Region?

2. To what extent is there evidence of inadequate human capital supply now and into the future with respect to regional manufacturing?

3. What does an individual need to do to access manufacturing opportunities and are those opportunities available within the confines of the Susquehanna Region?

Question 1. What are the realistic growth prospects for manufacturing employment in the Susquehanna Region?

Manufacturing: A Susquehanna Region Industry Brief

11

Page 12: Executive Summary - Susquehanna Workforce … · Web viewHowever, it is important not to conflate employment growth with demand for workers. Exhibit 9 supplies statistical detail

Projected Employment Growth in Key Industry Subsectors & Occupations

This is an important question that has been addressed by labor market analysts in the past. As Exhibit 6 indicates, there are a number of key manufacturing segments expected to add jobs in the Susquehanna Region. Most relate to durable goods manufacturing.

Exhibit 6. Susquehanna Region – Projected Employment Growth in Manufacturing by Detailed Industry, 2012-2022

Industry 2012 20222012-2022

Change

% Change

Plastics and Rubber Products Manufacturing

2,877

3,942 1,065 37.0%

Miscellaneous Manufacturing 749 954 205 27.4%

Machinery Manufacturing 314 386 72 22.9%

Fabricated Metal Product Manufacturing 875 925 50 5.7%

Nonmetallic Mineral Product Manufacturing 224 268 44 19.6%

Computer and Electronic Product Manufacturing 478 512 34 7.1%

Furniture and Related Product Manufacturing 33 44 11 33.3%

Petroleum and Coal Products Manufacturing 50 54 4 8.0%

Textile Mills 6 6 0 0.0%

Food Manufacturing 693 693 0 0.0%

Electrical Equipment, Appliance, & Component Mnfg. 3 3 0 0.0%

Apparel Manufacturing 1 1 0 0.0%

Textile Product Mills 22 21 -1 -4.5%

Leather and Allied Product Manufacturing 98 96 -2 -2.0%

Manufacturing: A Susquehanna Region Industry Brief

12

Page 13: Executive Summary - Susquehanna Workforce … · Web viewHowever, it is important not to conflate employment growth with demand for workers. Exhibit 9 supplies statistical detail

Beverage and Tobacco Product Manufacturing 111 102 -9 -8.1%

Wood Product Manufacturing 61 49 -12 -19.7%

Chemical Manufacturing 720 706 -14 -1.9%

Printing and Related Support Activities 275 259 -16 -5.8%

Primary Metal Manufacturing 242 148 -94 -38.8%

Transportation Equipment Manufacturing 484 319 -165 -34.1%

Source: Maryland Department of Labor, Licensing and Regulation, Division of Workforce Development and Adult Learning. Available: http://www.dllr.state.md.us/lmi/iandoproj/.

The notion that manufacturing is poised to create opportunities is not merely speculative. Exhibit 7 reflects job openings being advertised in the Susquehanna Region as of the third week of January 2017. Note that manufacturing was associated with more job openings than all industries except for three. Though hiring can be somewhat sluggish during winter months, there were still more than 460 job openings tied to the manufacturing sector as of January in the Susquehanna Region. The previous month, there were more than 500 advertised manufacturing job openings (Exhibit 8), including in high-wage segments like computers, transportation equipment and chemicals.

Exhibit 7. Job Openings (Jobs Available) in the Susquehanna Region: Top 10 Industries (as of January 2017, Week 3)

Rank Industry Job Openings

1 Professional Scientific and Technical Services 1,771

2 Retail Trade 723

3 Health Care and Social Assistance 608

4 Manufacturing 463

5 Administrative & Support and Waste Management & Remediation 340

6 Accommodation and Food Services 284

7 Public Administration 177

8 Other Services (except Public Administration) 130

Manufacturing: A Susquehanna Region Industry Brief

13

Page 14: Executive Summary - Susquehanna Workforce … · Web viewHowever, it is important not to conflate employment growth with demand for workers. Exhibit 9 supplies statistical detail

9 Finance and Insurance 111

10 Wholesale Trade 86

Source: Maryland Workforce Exchange, Labor Market Information; Maryland Department of Legislative Services (DLLR) Maryland Workforce Dashboard.

Exhibit 8. Advertised Manufacturing Job Openings in the Susquehanna Region during the Month of December 2016 by Detailed Industry Subsector

Rank Subsector Job Openings

1 Miscellaneous Manufacturing 145

2 Computer and Electronic Product Manufacturing 123

3 Plastics and Rubber Products Manufacturing 98

4 Transportation Equipment Manufacturing 66

5 Chemical Manufacturing 29

Total Manufacturing Job Openings 513Source: Maryland Workforce Exchange, Labor Market Information. Job Source: Online advertised jobs data. Notes: 1. The table shows the number of job openings advertised online in the Susquehanna Workforce Region in December 2016 (Jobs De-duplication Level 2) for the following sectors: Miscellaneous Manufacturing (NAICS 339), Computer and Electronic Product Manufacturing (NAICS 334), Plastics and Rubber Products Manufacturing (NAICS 326), Transportation Equipment Manufacturing (NAICS 336), Chemical Manufacturing (NAICS 325). 2. Jobs De-duplication Level 2: high level de-duplication of advertised job openings (for statistical analysis).

Manufacturing: A Susquehanna Region Industry Brief

14

Page 15: Executive Summary - Susquehanna Workforce … · Web viewHowever, it is important not to conflate employment growth with demand for workers. Exhibit 9 supplies statistical detail

Some may be surprised by the large numbers of job openings among manufacturers. However, it is important not to conflate employment growth with demand for workers. Exhibit 9 supplies statistical detail regarding the characteristics of manufacturing workers as of 2016’s initial quarter. Note that many workers are over the age of 55, implying elevated levels of retirement. Correspondingly, there will be demand for manufacturing workers in the Susquehanna Region going forward even in the absence of significant overall industry employment growth.

Exhibit 9. Characteristics of Manufacturing Employees in the Susquehanna Region, 2016Q1

# of Employees % of Total

TOTAL MNF. EMPLOYEES 8,947 100.0%

SEX

Male 6,099 68.2%

Female 2,848 31.8%

AGE

<19 25 0.3%

19-24 482 5.4%

25-34 1,635 18.3%

35-44 1,786 20.0%

45-54 2,503 28.0%

55-64 2,112 23.6%

65+ 406 4.5%

RACE

White Alone 7,314 81.7%

Black or African American Alone 1,210 13.5%

All Other 423 4.7%

ETHNICITY

Hispanic or Latino 358 4.0%

Manufacturing: A Susquehanna Region Industry Brief

15

Page 16: Executive Summary - Susquehanna Workforce … · Web viewHowever, it is important not to conflate employment growth with demand for workers. Exhibit 9 supplies statistical detail

Not Hispanic or Latino 8,589 96.0%

EDUCATION LEVEL

Less than high school 952 10.6%

High school or equivalent, no college 2,668 29.8%

Some college or Associate degree 2,741 30.6%

Bachelor’s degree or advanced degree 2,080 23.2%

Educational attainment NA (2) 507 5.7%

Source: U.S. Census Bureau, LED Extraction Tool - Quarterly Workforce Indicators (QWI). Notes: 1. Figures shown are the total number of jobs on the first day of the reference quarter. Beginning-of-quarter employment counts are similar to point-in-time employment measures, such as the QCEW (see: www.bls.gov/cew/). 2. Educational attainment not available—workers aged 24 or younger.

Manufacturing: A Susquehanna Region Industry Brief

16

Page 17: Executive Summary - Susquehanna Workforce … · Web viewHowever, it is important not to conflate employment growth with demand for workers. Exhibit 9 supplies statistical detail

Question 2. To what extent is there evidence of inadequate human capital supply now and into the future with respect to regional manufacturing?

There is a Need to Train Workers for Manufacturing Opportunities

The discussion above supplied two reasons that induce communities to remain fixated on the future of their manufacturing industries. Exhibit 10 embodies a third – manufacturing supplies opportunities for people who lack significant formal educational attainment an opportunity to enter or remain in the middle class. As indicated by Exhibit 10, roughly two in three jobseekers in the Susquehanna Region lack a bachelor’s degree. The key is to provide individuals with the credentials they need to enter manufacturing employment. Most manufacturers that Sage interviewed indicate that a majority of jobs require as their primary skill a skill that is learned on the job.

Exhibit 10. Education & Work Experience of Available Candidates in the Susquehanna Region, all industries (as of 1/17/2017)

Education Level# of

Potential Candidates

% of Total Candidates

Less than High School 269 2.1%

High School Diploma or Equivalent 3,580 27.3%

1-3 Years at College or Technical/Vocational School 2,352 17.9%

Vocational School Certificate 1,368 10.4%

Associate’s Degree 1,074 8.2%

Bachelor’s Degree 2,793 21.3%

Master’s Degree 1,357 10.4%

Doctorate Degree 217 1.7%

Specialized Degree (e.g. MD, DDS) 101 0.8%

Total 13,111 100.0%

Work Experience# of

Potential Candidates

% of Total Candidates

Manufacturing: A Susquehanna Region Industry Brief

17

Page 18: Executive Summary - Susquehanna Workforce … · Web viewHowever, it is important not to conflate employment growth with demand for workers. Exhibit 9 supplies statistical detail

Less than 1 year 1,069 8.2%

1 Year to 2 Years 421 3.2%

2 Years to 5 Years 1,237 9.4%

5 Years to 10 Years 1,941 14.8%

More than 10 Years 8,451 64.4%

Total 13,119 100.0%Source: Maryland Workforce Exchange: Labor Market Information; Candidate Source: Individuals with active resumes in the workforce system.

In a separate 2017 Sage study on behalf of the Susquehanna Workforce Network (SWN), local manufacturers reported great difficulty securing properly credentialed and trainable workers. The implication is that there is evidence of inadequate human capital supply despite large numbers of applicants. Manufacturing employers are finding that many of these workers are simply not ready to be hired. There are many issues at hand, including failed drug tests, prior convictions, or poor resumes and presentation skills. Combined, the answers to questions one and two indicate that there is an ongoing need among Susquehanna regional residents to be sufficiently trained to join and remain in the manufacturing workforce. A number of employers reported that to the extent that they find successful candidates, many are from Delaware.7

Question 3. What does an individual need to do to access manufacturing opportunities and are those opportunities available within the confines of the Susquehanna Region?

Certain Skills in Very High Demand

A survey conducted by Deloitte and the Manufacturing Institute a bit more than two years ago indicates that it takes 70 days to recruit skilled production workers and 94 days to recruit engineers,

7 Susquehanna employers are hardly alone. According to a survey conducted by the Manufacturing Institute and Deloitte, from 2015-2025, nearly 3.5 million manufacturing positions will likely need to be filled. The skills gap is expected to result in 2 million of those jobs being unfilled. Moreover, more than one-half of surveyed executives indicate severe or high shortages of skilled production workers. Sixty-three percent of executives expect shortages to remain in place as of 2020. (The Manufacturing Institute and Deloitte, “The Skills Gap in US Manufacturing: 2015 and Beyond”.)

Manufacturing: A Susquehanna Region Industry Brief

18

Page 19: Executive Summary - Susquehanna Workforce … · Web viewHowever, it is important not to conflate employment growth with demand for workers. Exhibit 9 supplies statistical detail

researchers, or scientists. Skills in which manufacturing employees are most deficient include technology/computer skills, problem solving skills, basic technical training, and math skills.8

Exhibit 11. Susquehanna Region Job Skills Requirements in the Top 3 Manufacturing Subsectors With the Most Job Openings During the Month of December 2016

Skill Rank Skill Group Detailed Job Skill

Miscellaneous Manufacturing

1 Basic Skills Problem solving

2 Bookkeeper Skills Record keeping

3 Customer Service Skills Customer service

4 Interpersonal Skills Interpersonal skills

5 Chief Financial Officer Skills Regulatory compliance

Computer and Electronic Product Manufacturing

1 Computer Support Specialist Skills Software support

2 Basic Skills Making decisions

3 Market Research Analyst Skills Cost/benefit analysis

4 Benefits Specialist Skills Benefit analysis

5 Bill and Account Collectors Skills Inventory management

Plastics and Rubber Products Manufacturing

1 Interpersonal Skills Interpersonal skills

2 Basic Skills Problem solving

3 Basic Skills Decision making

4 Account Manager Skills Revenue growth

5 Interpersonal Skills Flexibility

Source: Maryland Workforce Exchange, Labor Market Information. Job Source: Online advertised jobs data. Notes: 1. The table shows the top advertised job skills found in job openings advertised

8 The Manufacturing Institute and Deloitte, “The Skills Gap in US Manufacturing: 2015 and Beyond”.

Manufacturing: A Susquehanna Region Industry Brief

19

Page 20: Executive Summary - Susquehanna Workforce … · Web viewHowever, it is important not to conflate employment growth with demand for workers. Exhibit 9 supplies statistical detail

online in Susquehanna Workforce Region on January 8, 2017 (Jobs De-duplication Level 1) for the following manufacturing subsectors: Miscellaneous Manufacturing (NAICS 339), Computer and Electronic Product Manufacturing (NAICS 334), Plastics and Rubber Products Manufacturing (NAICS 326) 2. Jobs De-duplication Level 1: low level de-duplication of advertised job openings (more jobs).

Exhibit 11 provides a sense of the skills required in rapidly expanding manufacturing segments that are also associated with a significant fraction of total regional job openings. Basic skills such as problem solving and decision making are commonly at the forefront of need. Interpersonal skills are also required. None of these required elevated levels of educational attainment, but they do require a fundamental integration with norms of societal behavior and patterns of thought.

It is also worth noting that many of these positions have little to do with actual production. Some require facility with software, others with the capacity to conduct market research or basic accounting or inventory management. These are likely the types of skills that require a degree of formal education, perhaps at a two-year institution. Cecil College offers a number of relevant programs, including in welding and forklift operations. The same can be said of Harford Community College (HCC), which also offers training in welding and forklift operations. HCC also operates the Entry Level Manufacturing Training Program in conjunction with SWN, which prepares students to be entry-level manufacturing technicians. This training is approved by the Susquehanna Manufacturing Coalition.9

We have determined that this Entry Level Manufacturing Training Program is very much needed and perhaps should be expanded. This program targets those who seek to emerge as entry-level manufacturing technicians; people who perform regular and routine preventive maintenance on equipment used in manufacturing processes. Classes include Math for Manufacturing, Basic Machining, and Basic Electricity. Program entry requirements include only that one possesses a 10th grade reading level, be at least 18, and possess transportation.10 The program can be completed in just 8 weeks, which represents a principal advantage.

Conclusion9 Susquehanna Workforce Network, Entry Level Manufacturing Training. http://www.swnetwork.org/documents/EntryLevelMfgTrainingFlyer.pdf. 10 Susquehanna Workforce Network, Entry Level Manufacturing Training.

Manufacturing: A Susquehanna Region Industry Brief

20

Page 21: Executive Summary - Susquehanna Workforce … · Web viewHowever, it is important not to conflate employment growth with demand for workers. Exhibit 9 supplies statistical detail

We conclude that the Susquehanna Region will produce significant numbers of manufacturing job openings in the future, in part due to retirement, and that employers will continue to have difficulty filling them. We further conclude that there are opportunities for residents to obtain the necessary skills and credentials to enter manufacturing, but that to date these opportunities have either not adequately prepared workers for careers, or more likely, that not enough residents have accessed them. We recommend that SWN study the extent to which participants in the Entry Level Manufacturing Training Program: 1) successfully complete the program, 2) secure employment, 3) retain employment, and 4) are promoted to positions beyond entry-level. We also recommend that there be an analysis of enrollment trends, the degree to which jobseekers are aware of this program, and evidence (if any) of unmet demand.

Manufacturing: A Susquehanna Region Industry Brief

21