20
1 ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010 LZ01-219742-v1 Engineering Geodesy II: Tunnel Surveying I Adrian Ryf Head of Surveying and Data Coordination AlpTransit Gotthard AG 22.04.2010 ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010 LZ01-219742-v1 About Adrian Ryf 1986 Diploma as „Kulturingenieur” at ETHZ 1986 – 1989 assistant and researcher at ETHZ – IGP (Prof. Chaperon / Carosio) 1989 – 1997 project engineer in a private surveying company in Locarno 1997 – 2007 assistant and lecturer at ETHZ – IGP (Prof. Ingensand) 2007 – head of surveying and data coordination at AlpTransit Gotthard AG ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010 LZ01-219742-v1 Contents Introduction Basic principles Historical tunnel surveying Tunnel surveying nowadays AlpTransit project Intermediate attack of Sedrun Surveying requirements Basic network of the Gotthard base tunnel: position Basic network of the Gotthard base tunnel: height Surveying aspects in the shaft of Sedrun Impact of the tunnel construction at the surface Ceneri: monitoring A2 End ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010 LZ01-219742-v1 Island of Samos, Greece ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010 LZ01-219742-v1 Eupalinos Tunnel oldest known tunnel, built from two sides of the hill 530 B.C. water supply length: 1 km breakthrough error: direction: 2 m height: 3 m distance ? ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010 LZ01-219742-v1 Drawing of Heron rectangular traverse, Pythagoras (580 – 500 B.C.)

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010 …webarchiv.ethz.ch/.../01_tunnel/01_Tunnel_1_Alptransit.pdf4 ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010 LZ01-219742-v1

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    12

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010 …webarchiv.ethz.ch/.../01_tunnel/01_Tunnel_1_Alptransit.pdf4 ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010 LZ01-219742-v1

1

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Engineering Geodesy II: Tunnel Surveying I

Adrian Ryf

Head of Surveying and Data Coordination

AlpTransit Gotthard AG

22.04.2010

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

About Adrian Ryf

� 1986 Diploma as „Kulturingenieur” at ETHZ

� 1986 – 1989 assistant and researcher at ETHZ – IGP (Prof. Chaperon / Carosio)

� 1989 – 1997 project engineer in a private surveying company in Locarno

� 1997 – 2007 assistant and lecturer at ETHZ – IGP (Prof. Ingensand)

� 2007 – head of surveying and data coordination at AlpTransit Gotthard AG

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Contents

� Introduction

� Basic principles

� Historical tunnel surveying

� Tunnel surveying nowadays

� AlpTransit project

� Intermediate attack of Sedrun

� Surveying requirements

� Basic network of the Gotthard base tunnel: position

� Basic network of the Gotthard base tunnel: height

� Surveying aspects in the shaft of Sedrun

� Impact of the tunnel construction at the surface

� Ceneri: monitoring A2

� End

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Island of Samos, Greece

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Eupalinos Tunnel

� oldest known tunnel, built from two sides of the hill

� 530 B.C.

� water supply

� length: 1 km

� breakthrough error:

� direction: 2 m

� height: 3 m

� distance ?

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Drawing of Heron

rectangular traverse, Pythagoras (580 – 500 B.C.)

Page 2: ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010 …webarchiv.ethz.ch/.../01_tunnel/01_Tunnel_1_Alptransit.pdf4 ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010 LZ01-219742-v1

2

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Basic principles of tunnel surveying

� Transfer of 3D-position from A to B

� Transfer of orientation from A to B

� Transfer of scale from A to B

aim: minimal breakthrough error

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Basic principles of tunnel surveying

A B

position, orientation and scale okay

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Basic principles of tunnel surveying

A B

start position in A wrong

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Basic principles of tunnel surveying

A B

orientation in A wrong

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Basic principles of tunnel surveying

A B

scale in A wrong

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Definitions

� breakthrough: location, inside a tunnel, where the independent tunnelling works from two sides meet. If a tunnel is built only from one side, the breakthrough coincides with one of the portals.

� a priori breakthrough prediction: a priori calculated accuracy for the breakthrough, relative confidence ellipsis of two close points, each on one side of the break-through without opposite geodetic measurements.

� effective breakthrough error: difference between actual and nominal value of the differences in length, lateral and in height between two close points, each on one side oft the breakthrough

Page 3: ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010 …webarchiv.ethz.ch/.../01_tunnel/01_Tunnel_1_Alptransit.pdf4 ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010 LZ01-219742-v1

3

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Tolerance – accuracy – reliability

� communication aspects:

� civil and geomatics specialists have different ideas about the signification of these terms

� civil engineers talk about accuracy when they mean (construction) tolerance

� e.g. the built tunnel axis may differ 15 cm of the axis of the project

� accuracy in geodesy: 1 σ (standard deviation)

� the construction tolerance matches more with the geodetic expression of the reliability

� reliability : accuracy ≈ factor: 2.5 – 3

a precise and written definition of the values is part of a goodquality management

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Historical surveying of tunnels: the Quanat method (light holes, orient)

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Prolongation of straight lines across the mountain

France – Italy: Mont Cenis

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Existing tunnels in the Swiss Alps

� Gotthard, Simplon

� traditional triangulation networks across the mountains

� straight line tunnels

� straight auxiliary tunnels at the portals: Airolo, Brig

� Lötschberg

� project of a straight line tunnel

� adjustment of the project due to geological reasons

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Networks of Gotthard and Simplon tunnel

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Lötschberg

Gasterntal

Page 4: ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010 …webarchiv.ethz.ch/.../01_tunnel/01_Tunnel_1_Alptransit.pdf4 ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010 LZ01-219742-v1

4

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Tunnel surveying nowadays

� tunnel network without tensions

� network of reference points, specially designed for a construction site

� consistent homogenous design

� free network adjustment

� three-part tunnel surveying system

� basic network

� portal network

� tunneling network

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Three-part tunnel surveying

GPS-network →→→→ tunneling networks→→→→ portal networks

ca. 2 – 3 km

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Basic tunnel surveying: position / height

� position

� high accuracy of GPS

� transfer of position, orientation and scale between portals

� height

� high accuracy of levelling, mostly national levelling network

� gravity aspects play an important role for long tunnels, systematic levellingerrors

� tectonic movements (e.g. convolution of the Alps)

� GPS height accuracy over big distances normally not good enough (troposphere influences)

� GPS: heights over the ellipsoid, good information about the geoid is essential

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

A flat rail-link across the Alps

project idea 1947

shaft: 800 m

underground station19th century railway

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

AlpTransit Lötschberg and Gotthard

www.alptransit.ch

Gotthardbase tunnel57 km long

Lötschbergbase tunnel37 km long

Ceneribase tunnel15 km long

Page 5: ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010 …webarchiv.ethz.ch/.../01_tunnel/01_Tunnel_1_Alptransit.pdf4 ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010 LZ01-219742-v1

5

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

AlpTransit

� north - south (railway 2000: west - east)

� reduction of travelling time

� displacement of goods transports from the street to the railway

� reduction of energy consumption: less locomotives

� amelioration of quality of life in the valleys on both sides of the Gotthard (less trucks)

� Lötschberg: Spiez - Steg / Mund

� Lötschberg – opening of the base tunnel in december 2007

� www.blsalptransit.ch

� AlpTransit Gotthard: Zimmerberg, Arth-Goldau - Lugano

� Zimmerberg base tunnel (later), Gotthard and Ceneri base tunnel in construction

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Gotthard base tunnel

� 5 construction sites:

� north portal Erstfeld

� intermediate attacks of Amsteg, Sedrun and Faido

� south portal Bodio

� Line is curved:

� geological reasons

� construction sites in the valleys

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

A flat railway-link across the Alps

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Travelling from Zurich to Milano

Intercity today

tilting train today

Gotthard base tunnel finished

all tunnels finished

complete new railway line

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Gotthard base tunnel: tunnel system

two tubes with lateral connections every 325 m

© AlpTransit

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Von 151,8 km Tunnel, Schächte, Stollen

sind 145 km oder 95,4% ausgebrochen

Ausbruch und Ausbau abgeschlossen

Ausbruch abgeschlossen

Bereit für Einbau Bahntechnik

Noch auszubrechende Tunnelröhren

Gotthard base tunnel – 01.04.2010

Page 6: ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010 …webarchiv.ethz.ch/.../01_tunnel/01_Tunnel_1_Alptransit.pdf4 ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010 LZ01-219742-v1

6

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Erstfeld

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Tunnel Amsteg – Sedrun

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Bodio

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

New railway line near Biasca, ready for the installation of the track

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Geology

� especially Granit and Gneis → ideal for tunnel construction

� geological fault-zone between Aare- and Gotthard-Massif near Sedrun

� smaller geological fault-zones in different other places

Sedrun

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Intermediate attack Sedrun

diameter of shaft I: 8 m

1 km access tunnelfresh air tunnel

shaft cavern

2 shafts: 800 m

Page 7: ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010 …webarchiv.ethz.ch/.../01_tunnel/01_Tunnel_1_Alptransit.pdf4 ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010 LZ01-219742-v1

7

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Portal pillar in Sedrun

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

In the access tunnel of Sedrun

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

In the shaft cavern of Sedrun

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

The first transportation system in the shaft

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

At the bottom of the shaft (August 1999, ca. 360 m)

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

At the bottom of the shaft (January 2005), shaft transportation plant

Page 8: ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010 …webarchiv.ethz.ch/.../01_tunnel/01_Tunnel_1_Alptransit.pdf4 ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010 LZ01-219742-v1

8

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Surveying requirements

tolerance (reliability) standard deviation

position (direction) 25 cm 10 cm

height 12.5 cm 5 cm

with the dimensions of a fist through the Alps

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

A priori network design

11 cm

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Surveyors tasks outside of the tunnels and before tunnelling starts

� staking-out of construction sites, before the works start (Gotthard: 1995 in Sedrun)

� deformation measurements: tectonic movements

� deformation measurements: construction sites, portal areas

� coordination with the construction project (reservation of space and time for the surveying works)

� quality management

� minimization of risks

� etc.

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Minimization of risks

� always two different and independent methods

� different instruments

� independent controls

� augmentation of reliability

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Gotthard: basic network

Existing :

� National reference network LV03

� accuracy of neighboring points 2 - 4 cm

� absolute accuracy: several dm up to 1 m

� scale differences between north and south of Alps

� not good enough for long tunnels

� National levelling network LN02

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Existing networks: position

� network „Gerber“ 1973 – former AlpTransit project

� accuracy 2 - 4 cm

� not extended enough for the actual project

� new national network LV95, GPS

� highest accuracy: 1 cm absolute versus Zimmerwald

� few points, too far away from the portal areas

� big, inhomogeneous differences to LV03

Page 9: ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010 …webarchiv.ethz.ch/.../01_tunnel/01_Tunnel_1_Alptransit.pdf4 ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010 LZ01-219742-v1

9

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Steps for planning a basic network

� having a look at existing networks

� field control of existing points

� points in rock areas?

� points in instable areas?

� appropriate points for orientation sights

� discussions with geologists

� conversation with land owners

� definition of point type: pillar?

� analysis of construction plans: obstacles (huts, construction installations)

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

GPS network

� preparation of GPS measurements

� mission planning (time schedule)

� instruments, measuring parameters, programming

� accessories: tripods, batteries, adapters, radios, mobile phones

� organization and instruction of the staff

� check of the instruments: optical plumbs, centering devices, antenna eccentricities, function control

� measurements

� 30 points in 2 days with 14 GPS instruments (Leica 200 / 300)

� 2 times 2 hours per point, alignment of all antennas to the north direction, careful centering

� network “Gerber” in 1972: about 2 months

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

GPS network

every portal, every intermediate attack:

� minimum: 1 pillar

� 3 orientation points in a distance of 3-6 km (orientation transfer into the tunnel, reference for gyroscope and scale)

� 3 points of the national reference network LV03

6 points of the new national reference network LV95

GPS-Netz

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

GPS post processing

� post processing with SKI (Leica GPS-software, Leica Geo Office)

� standard parameters

� no special troposphere models (height)

� no special ionosphere models (scale)

� use of precise ephemeris (internet download)

� transformation to the Swiss reference frame with Granit-parameters

� calculation of geoid separations with LAG to get orthometric heights (actually implemented in Leica Geo Office)

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Network adjustment with LTOP

� free network adjustment

� identical orientation for all GPS-coordinate-sets

� identical scale for all GPS-coordinate-sets

� a posteriori precision: 7 mm (longer axis of the biggest confidence ellipse)

� reliability: 26 mm

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Portal networks

� Immediately after the GPS measurements:

� measured with T3000 / T2000 and Mekometer ME 5000

� controlling scale and orientation of network

� further local reference points to control the pillars

Page 10: ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010 …webarchiv.ethz.ch/.../01_tunnel/01_Tunnel_1_Alptransit.pdf4 ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010 LZ01-219742-v1

10

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Portal networks

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

LV03 or LV95 as reference for AlpTransit Gotthard??

� LV95 would be a good reference frame for AlpTransit

but:

� LV95 still not officially introduced in the project area

� differences between LV03 and LV95

� the AlpTransit project was designed in LV03

� cadastral system is LV03: land management, expropriations, etc.

� railway system is close to LV03

� changing the reference system during construction time is a high risk

� danger of errors and confusion

decision: AlpTransit Gotthard is built in LV03

� → Helmert-transformation on LV03-points in the areas of the north and the south portal

� differences in Sedrun and Faido have to be accepted

� scale factor always has to be corrected!

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Residuals in Sedrun and in Faido

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

2005 control of the GPS network

GPS-measurements oft the network in summer 2005

� geodetic project course of ETH Zurich

� 28 points with the 28 GPS instruments

� 12 hours during the night, measured by students of ETH

comparison 1995 – 2005

� Helmert-transformation: maximal residuals: 1.5 cm

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

2005 north portal Erstfeld

north portal

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

2005 south portal Bodio

south portal

Page 11: ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010 …webarchiv.ethz.ch/.../01_tunnel/01_Tunnel_1_Alptransit.pdf4 ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010 LZ01-219742-v1

11

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Aspects of the height system

two national height systems:

� LN02, the actual height system

� LHN95, the height system of the future

decision: LN02 for AlpTransit Gotthard with the characteristics and the advantages of LHN95

LN02 LHN95

strict orthometric corrections no yes

tectonic movements (convolution of Alps) no yes

strict network adjustment no yes

new geoid no yes

project and realisation yes no

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Corrections in the tunnel

ca. 1 dm

1. strict orthometric correction

2. velocity correction

3. differences to LV03

convolution of Alps: Erstfeld +0.7 mm/year

Bodio +1.3 mm/year

gravity model, gravity measurements:= > correction amounts up to 12 cm

→difference: 0.6 year

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Orthometric corrections between Sedrun and Faido

shaft Sedrun intermediate attack Faido

55 mm

no difference between head and bottom of shaft

difference of models: < 1 cm© AlpTransit

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Surveying aspects in the shafts of Sedrun

� aimed accuracy:

� coordinates Y,X: 7 mm

� height: 3 mm

� direction: 1.5 mgon

� economical, time-saving methods are requested

� transfer of height

� vertical electronic distance measurement → gravity aspects

� transfer of position → deviations of vertical

� optical (with Nadir- or Zenith- plumb instrument) → refraction

� mechanical (with wires)

� transfer of direction

� gyroscope → deviations of vertical, temperature

� inertial measurements → drifts

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Position transfer

� methods

� optical

� mechanical

problems

refraction

visibility (fog)

vibrations

stable positioning of the instrument

expensive

oscillations

rain drops in the shaft

supply air of the ventilation

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Deviations of the vertical

� the plumb line in the shaft is curved

1400

1200

1000

800

600

400

west - east south - north

2.52.01.51.0 mgon

m.s.m.

Page 12: ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010 …webarchiv.ethz.ch/.../01_tunnel/01_Tunnel_1_Alptransit.pdf4 ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010 LZ01-219742-v1

12

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Deviations of the vertical

optical

mechanical

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Optical plumb measurement: campaigns

three optical plumb campaigns:

� in shaft I in March 2002

� in shaft II in January 2004

� in shaft I in January 2007

� ventilation: falling air frees the shaft from fog

� plumb measurement over 3 tripods: 3 different corridors

� nadir plumb instrument Leica NL

� at the feet of the shaft:

� special prisms with light diodes

� centering with precise translation stages (Kreuzschlitten)

� zenith plumb measurement impossible due to dropping rain

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Optical plumb measurement: top of the shaft

3 tripods

nadir plumb instrument

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Optical plumb measurement: bottom of the shaft

reflector on translation stagewooden stage over the “shaft cellar”

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Mechanical plumb measurement

� one plumb measurement campaign in March 2002

� specialized company from Gorleben (Germany): exploration of repositories for radioactive wastes

� 3 wires in 3 corridors in shaft I

� different weights: 390 kg – 195 kg – 390 kg

� determination of the wires with 2 theodolites

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Why different weights

� the bigger weight is deflected less by perturbations (e.g. raindrops)

� the relation is inverse proportional

1

21

12

2

2

12

21

1

1

2

2

1

PPP

aaa

PPP

aaa

P

P

a

a

−=

−=

=

posi tio

n: w

hole

we

ight

positio

n:

half w

eig

ht

the

ore

tical p

ositio

n

Page 13: ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010 …webarchiv.ethz.ch/.../01_tunnel/01_Tunnel_1_Alptransit.pdf4 ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010 LZ01-219742-v1

13

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Mechanical plumb measurement: top of the shaft

bobbin with wire Ø 2mm 800 m wire = 17 kg steel

guide roll

weights 19 x 25 kg

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Mechanical plumb measurement: top of the shaft

determination of the wires

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Mechanical plumb measurement: bottom of the shaft

observation of wires with T 2002

removing weights

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Mechanical plumb measurement: bottom of the shaft

on site analysis

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Results of the optical and mechanical plumb measurements

� plumb measurement of 3 points during each campaign

� comparison of the triangles at the top and the bottom of the shaft:

� mechanical: precision ≈ 5 mm

� optical: precision ≈ 6 mm

� network adjustment:

� tunnel network at the top and the bottom of the shaft

� azimuths of the gyroscope

� mechanical and optical plumb measurements

� network adjustment with optical or mechanical plumb measurements:

� maximal coordinate differences 2 mm

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Height transfer

� vertical electronic distance measurement with TCA2003

� special adapter to fix the reflector under the tripod

� difficulties with ATR due to dripping water. With TCA2003 impossible, with TCRP1201 successful

� the measured distance is exactly the height difference (see gravity measurements)

� precision about 2-3 mm

Page 14: ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010 …webarchiv.ethz.ch/.../01_tunnel/01_Tunnel_1_Alptransit.pdf4 ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010 LZ01-219742-v1

14

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Transfer of orientation

methods

double optical plumb measurements in 2 shafts

three-dimensional network

polarized light

gyroscope

inertial measurement technolgy

problems

the 2 shafts are to close, insufficient accuracy

expensive, insufficient accuracy

insufficient accuracy

deviations of the vertical, instrument is dependent of temperature variations

missing experience

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Transfer of orientation

� primary method: gyroscope

� several measurements in different phases of the tunnel construction

� instrument: Gyromat 2000

� independent method: inertial measurement technology

� world premiere

� 2 measurement campaigns: 2004 and 2005

� the direction transfer in Sedrun and especially the independent control is one of the biggest challenges of the whole AlpTransit project

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Measurement with the Gyromat 2000 on the portal pillar of Sedrun

base tunnel

reference-azimuth

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

The Gyromat 2000 in the tunnel

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Measurement with inertial technology 2004/2005

� collaboration of geomETH and TU Munich

� positioning the inertial measurement unit (IMU) in the shaft hoisting system in shaft I

� direction transfer to and from the IMU with autocollimation at the top and the bottom of the shaft

� connection to the tunnel network at the top and the bottom of the shaft

� independent direction transfer to control the gyro azimuths

� world premiere! for the first time this technology was used in engineering geodesy for such high precision

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Measurement arrangement

shafthoistingsystem

platform

mirror

mirror

GAP

IMU

tunnel network instrument

βo

αo

top

top

αu

βu

bottom

bottom

ψ

tu = to + βo + αo + ψ – (βu + αu) azimuth:

Page 15: ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010 …webarchiv.ethz.ch/.../01_tunnel/01_Tunnel_1_Alptransit.pdf4 ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010 LZ01-219742-v1

15

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Animation

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Situation in the shaft hoisting system

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Inertial measurement unit (IMU)

� 3 acceleration sensors

� 3 laser gyros

� coaxial arrangement

IMU, resolution 0.1 mgon, drift 0.002°/h

laser gyro© K. Foppe

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Arrangement at the top of the shaft

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

At the bottom of the shaft

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Team: 3 at the top of the shaft, 3 at the bottom of the shaft

Page 16: ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010 …webarchiv.ethz.ch/.../01_tunnel/01_Tunnel_1_Alptransit.pdf4 ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010 LZ01-219742-v1

16

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Results

� direction transfer with the gyroscope: precision ca. 1.3 mgon

� direction transfer with inertial measurement technology: precision ca. 1.5 mgon

� difference of the 2 methods in Sedrun: 2.2 mgon

� an independent control was realised successfully

� significant higher reliability

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Gotthard base tunnel: breakthrough results

autumn 2010Faido – Sedrun

33 mm5 mm14 mmjune 2009Erstfeld – Amsteg

21 mm3 mm137 mmoctober 2007Amsteg – Sedrun

12 mm17 mm92 mmseptember 2006Bodio – Faido

distanceheightlateraldateBreakthrough

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Impact of the tunnel construction at the surface

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Extra controls of the dams above the future tunnel

� tunneling works have drainage effects of the rock below different dams

� vertical movements at the surface can not be excluded

� experiences in Switzerland with this topic:

� damages at the dam of Tseuzier in 1978: construction of a sounding tunnel

� height changes above the Gotthard road tunnel: 12 cm

� extra controls of the dams above the tunnel are necessary before, during and after the tunnel construction

� difficult distinction between normal movements (summer – winter, high and low water level in the lakes) and movements due to tunnel construction

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Dams above the Gotthard base tunnel

base tunnel, 500 m.ü.M.

Curnera, Nalps, Santa Maria,1900 m.ü.M.

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Three dimensional view

Page 17: ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010 …webarchiv.ethz.ch/.../01_tunnel/01_Tunnel_1_Alptransit.pdf4 ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010 LZ01-219742-v1

17

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Overview measurement installations

� 6 cross-sections of the valleys monitored by 10 automated tacheometer stations

� 100 km precision levelling every year

� 10 permanent GPS-points

Legende: Projektachse Talquerschnitte

Nivellement Strassen Nivellement Stollen

Nivellement Lagerung GPS-Punkt

Oberalp-P

assstr

asse

Val C

urn

era

Val N

alp

s

Lukm

anie

r -

Pass

stra

sse

© swisstopo, Grafik ATG

Campra

Val

Ter

min

e

Sedrun

Disentis

1 km

2.5 km

3.5 km

Ritom-See

So

ndie

rsto

llen

LosgrenzeSedrun / Faido

Legende: Projektachse Talquerschnitte

Nivellement Strassen Nivellement Stollen

Nivellement Lagerung GPS-Punkt

Oberalp-P

assstr

asse

Val C

urn

era

Val N

alp

s

Lukm

anie

r -

Pass

stra

sse

© swisstopo, Grafik ATG

Campra

Val

Ter

min

e

Sedrun

Disentis

1 km

2.5 km

3.5 km

Ritom-See

So

ndie

rsto

llen

LosgrenzeSedrun / Faido

Legende: Projektachse Talquerschnitte

Nivellement Strassen Nivellement Stollen

Nivellement Lagerung GPS-Punkt

Oberalp-P

assstr

asse

Val C

urn

era

Val N

alp

s

Lukm

anie

r -

Pass

stra

sse

© swisstopo, Grafik ATG

Campra

Val

Ter

min

e

Sedrun

Disentis

1 km

2.5 km

3.5 km

Ritom-See

So

ndie

rsto

llen

LosgrenzeSedrun / Faido

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Control network of the Nalps dam

tacheometer positions© swissphoto

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Automatic tacheometer stations: Leica TCA 2003

radio antennas

meteo sensors

ventilation

Photos: Swissphoto

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Measurement concept Nalps dam

high level

middle level

middle level

low level

low level

GPS-points

1 km north of lake

near the dam

south of lake

surrounding area

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Correlation between distances and water level in the lake

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Correlation between temperature and different distances

2002 Curnera Mauer (Mauerpunkte): Dif ferenzen längs zum Tal

-24

-20

-16

-12

-8

-4

0

4

8

12

16

20

24

Dif

fere

nzen

in

[m

m]

-10

-8

-6

-4

-2

0

2

4

6

8

10

12

14

Tem

pera

tur

in [

Gra

d C

]

2010 - 0001

2010 - 2005

2010 - 0002

2011 - 0001

2011 - 2005

2011 - 0002

Temperatur

Vorz eichenkonvention:

Positive Werte zeigen eine

talauswärt ige Verschiebung des -

gemäss Legende - ersten

bezüglich d es zweiten Punktes an.

2010

2011

2002

2007

00010002

2005

Page 18: ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010 …webarchiv.ethz.ch/.../01_tunnel/01_Tunnel_1_Alptransit.pdf4 ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010 LZ01-219742-v1

18

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Precision levelling campaigns: 100 km every year

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Vertical movements in the area of Sedrun

8 mm / 5 years

reference points

caused by

construction of tunnel and

shaft?

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Syncline above the tunnel

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Profile along the tunnel: Sedrun→Faido vertical movements at the surface

1720

00

1710

00

17

000

0

1690

00

16

800

0

1670

00

1660

00

1650

00

1640

00

1630

00

1620

00

-30

-20

-10

0

10

Vert

ika

lbe

weg

un

g i

m V

erg

leic

h z

u 2

002 [

mm

]

Se

p-0

3

Se

p-0

4

Se

p-0

5

Se

p-0

6O

kt/

No

v 0

6

Se

p-0

7

Se

p-0

3

Se

p-0

4

Se

p-0

5

Se

p-0

6

Okt/

No

v 0

6

Se

p-0

7

0

500

1000

1500

2000

2500

3000

3500

4000

m ü

be

r M

eer

2003

2004

2005

2006

2007

Vortriebsstand

Mauer projiziert

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Ceneri base tunnel: monitoring of the crossing under the A2

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Crossing the A2: monitoring installations

Page 19: ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010 …webarchiv.ethz.ch/.../01_tunnel/01_Tunnel_1_Alptransit.pdf4 ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010 LZ01-219742-v1

19

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Vigana

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Vezia near Lugano

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Ceneri base tunnel – 01.04.2010

Ausbruch und Ausbau abgeschlossen

Ausbruch abgeschlossen

Noch auszubrechende Tunnelröhren

Von 39,78 km Tunnel und Stollen sind

7,73 km oder 19,4% ausgebrochen

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Gotthard tunnel Göschenen – Airolo: breakthrough 28.02.1880

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Gotthard base tunnel Amsteg – Sedrun: breakthrough 19.10.2007

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Group picture of the Gotthard base tunnel surveying staff

Page 20: ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010 …webarchiv.ethz.ch/.../01_tunnel/01_Tunnel_1_Alptransit.pdf4 ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010 LZ01-219742-v1

20

ETHZ – EG II – Tunnel Surveying I – 22.04.2010

LZ

01

-21

97

42

-v1

Further information

� www.alptransit.ch

� www.bsf-swissphoto.com � Publikationen

� Geomatik Schweiz 6/2006

� Vermessungsanlass zum Hauptdurchschlag im Gotthard-Basistunnel

� 29. Oktober 2010 an der ETH Hönggerberg

� www.gbt-vermessung.ethz.ch (22.04.2010 noch nicht aktiv)

� Geomatik Schweiz 12/2010