8/20/2019 Essay 1 Are Culture and Language Separable? - 2

1/2

!"#$% !"'(' )

!"#$% *+,-+"% !"'('

."%/-00%" 1%-22-"

3$(2+04 )56)

7 89:%,-" ;6)<

="- 9#2:#"- '$> 2'$(#'(- 0-?'"',2-@

A4- -00'B 9'22-> CA4- D%0E%?%2+:'$ A%$(#-F A4- G$+H-"0'2+:B %/ 3$(2+04IJ ,B :4- '#:4%"

'$> 2+$(#+0: K%4$ 19L4%":-" M'0 ?#,2+04-> +$ L%"2> =//'+"0 NO'22 ;66PQJ ' ,+E%$:42B R%#"$'2

>-H%:-> :% 9%$H-"0':+%$0 '$> >-,':- ',%#: +00#-0 "-2':-> :% GSTS /%"-+($ ?%2+9BS U+0 /+"0:

'"(#-E-$: %/ :4- -00'B +0 :4': :4- 9#2:#"- '$> 2'$(#'(- '"- $%: -$:'$(2-> %" E-04-> :4-"-/%"-J

+/ ' 2'$(#'(- M-"- :% >+- ' 9#2:#"- 9%#2> 0#"H+H- M+:4%#: :4- %"+(+$'2 2'$(#'(-S U+0 0-9%$>

'"(#E-$: +0 :4': M4-$ ' 2'$(#'(- >+-0 +: +0 $%: 9#2:#"'2 2%00 ,#: '$ '-0:4-:+9 2%00S 19L%":4-"V0

9%$92#0+%$0 '"- :4': %$- #$+H-"0'2 2'$(#'(- M%#2> 4-2? E'W- E'$W+$> 9%EE#$+9':- ,-::-"J '$>

+: +0 R#0: ' 4+0:%"+9'2 9%+$9+>-$9- :4': 3$(2+04 +0 ' G$+H-"0'2 X'$(#'(-S

19L%":4-"V0 E'+$ ?%+$: +0 :4': 2'$(#'(- '$> 9#2:#"- '"- >+00%9+',2-S U- 0'B0 :4': M4-$

:4- 9#2:#"- >+-0J $':#"'22B :4- 2'$(#'(- >+-0 '2%$( M+:4 +:S O%" 19L%":4-" :4- "-H-"0- +0 $%: :"#-J

+/ ' 2'$(#'(- >+-0 +: >%-0 $%: $-9-00'"+2B E-'$ :4- >-':4 %/ ' 9#2:#"-S U+0 -Y'E?2- +0 :4': Z':+H-

=E-"+9'$0 M4% >% $%: 0?-'W :4-+" Z':+H- 2'$(#'(- '"- 0:+22 9'?',2- %/ +$>+(-$%#0 -Y?"-00+%$S [

>+0'("-- M+:4 4+ES [$ EB ?%+$: %/ H+-MJ ' 2'$(#'(- +0 ?'": %/ ' 9#2:#"- '$> ' 9#2:#"- +0 ' ?'": %/ '

2'$(#'(-S !%:4J 9#2:#"- '$> 2'$(#'(-J '"- +$:"+9':-2B +$:-"M%H-$ 0% M- 9'$ $%: 0-?'"':- :4-E

M+:4%#: 2%0+$( :4- 0+($+/+9'$9- %/ -+:4-" 2'$(#'(- %" 9#2:#"-S T+E?2B 0:':-> 9#2:#"- '$> 2'$(#'(-

'"- +$0-?'"',2-S O%" -Y'E?2-J +/ M- :'W- %#: ' 2'$(#'(- /"%E =E'\%$+'$ :"+,- E-E,-"0J '$>

/%"9- :4-E 0?-'W 3$(2+04 0#>>-$2BJ :4-B M+22 ,- 9%$/#0-> '$> 2'9W H%9',#2'"B /"%E :4-+" 9#2:#"-S

T%E- M%">0 '"- %$2B ?'": %/ :4-+" 9#2:#"- '$> >%$V: -Y+0: +$ %:4-" 2'$(#'(-0S 8" :4- %??%0+:- +0

8/20/2019 Essay 1 Are Culture and Language Separable? - 2

2/2

!"#$% !"'(' ;

'20% :"#-S [/ ?-%?2- +$ :4- 9+:B M4% '"- 3$(2+04 0?-'W-"0 0:'": :% 0?-'W .+"'4]J ' 2'$(#'(- /"%E '$

=E'\%$+'$ :"+,-J :4-B M+22 4'H- :4- 0'E- ?"%,2-ES X'$(#'(- +0 '$ -Y?"-00+%$ %/ ' M'B %/ 2+/-J +$

%:4-" M%">0J :4-+" 9#2:#"-S 3H-"B ?-"0%$ 9'"- ',%#: :4-+" 2'$(#'(- '0 M-22 '0 :4-+" 9#2:#"-S A4+0 +0

:"#- '20% /%" 3$(2+04 0?-'W-"0S T%E- =E-"+9'$0 M'$: :% E'W- 3$(2+04 :4- %//+9+'2 2'$(#'(- %/ GSTSJ

:% ?"%:-9: 3$(2+04 /"%E %:4-" 2'$(#'(-0 ,"%#(4: ,B +EE+("'$:0 /"%E '"%#$> :4- M%"2>S

A4- '#:4%"V0 %:4-" '"(#E-$: +0 :4': :4- E'+$ 2%00 M4-$ ' 2'$(#'(- >+-0 +0 $%: 9#2:#"'2

2%00 ,#: '-0:4-:+9'2 2%00S [ >+0'("--S [ :4+$W :4': +: +0 $%: ' E'::-" %/ '-0:4-:+90 M4B ?-%?2- M'$:

:% ?"-0-"H- :4-+" 2'$(#'(-S A4-B M'$: :% ?"-0-"H- :4-+" 2'$(#'(-J ,-9'#0- 2'$(#'(- 4'0 0?-9+/+9

/#$9:+%$0 '$> ?#"?%0-0S O%" -Y'E?2-J 92+9W+$( '$> M4+0:2+$( 2'$(#'(-0 4'H- ' 0:-'2:4B ?#"?%0-

/%" 4#$:-"0S A4-0- ?-%?2- '"- ',2- :% 9%EE#$+9':- M+:4%#: M%">0 :% $%: '2'"E :4-+" ?"-BS

X'$(#'(- +0 9%>-> +$ %#" ,"'+$0J '$> 4-2?0 #0 :% +$:-"?"-:+$( '$> #$>-"0:'$>+$( %#" 9%EE#$+:B

'$> M%"2> ': 2'"(-S

1B 9%$92#0+%$ +0 :4': 19L4%":-" :-$>0 :% %H-" 0+E?2+/B 9%E?2-Y +00#-0 ',%#: 9#2:#"- '$>

2'$(#'(-S [ ,-2+-H- :4-B '"- 9%E?2+9':-> '$> +$:-"9%$$-9:->J '$> +/ M- M'$: :% ?"-0-"H- ' 9#2:#"-

M- $--> :% ?"-0-"H- ,%:4 '0 ' M4%2-S A4- 0:':#0 ^#% 'E%$( :4- E'R%"+:B %/ "-0-'"94-"0 '$>

'9'>-E+9 ?"%/-00%"0 +$ :4- '"-'0 %/ 2+$(#+0:+90 '$> %:4-" 0+E+2'" /+-2>0 +0 :4': 2'$(#'(- +0 -00-$:+'2

/%" ' 9#2:#"- :% 0#"H+H-S =$> 2+$(#+0:+90 '("-- :4': 2'$(#'(- +0 $%: '-0:4-:+9 ,#: >--?2B -$:"-$94->

+$ ?"%9-00-0 %/ :4%#(4: '$> 9%EE#$+9':+%$S