Upload
ronald-hudson
View
224
Download
3
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Elizabeth Barrett Browning and Her Brother Alfred: Some Unpublished LettersAuthor(s): Ronald HudsonSource: Browning Institute Studies, Vol. 2 (1974), pp. 135-160Published by: Cambridge University PressStable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/25057601 .
Accessed: 28/06/2014 18:18
Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at .http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp
.JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range ofcontent in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new formsof scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected].
.
Cambridge University Press is collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to BrowningInstitute Studies.
http://www.jstor.org
This content downloaded from 141.101.201.103 on Sat, 28 Jun 2014 18:18:38 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Elizabeth Barrett Browning and Her Brother Alfred:
Some Unpublished Letters By Ronald Hudson
Alfred Price Barrett Moulton-Barrett, known to his family as
"Daisy," was born at Hope End, Herefordshire, on 20 May 1820, the sixth son and tenth child of Edward and Mary Moulton-Barrett.
He was fourteen years younger than his eldest sister Elizabeth, whose essay, "Glimpses into My Own Life and Literary Character,"
reprinted in pp. 121-33 of this volume, shows that she already "read
Homer in the original with delight inexpressible, together with
Virgil." She had also completed in 1817-18 her first major work
in verse, The Battle of Marathon, which appeared in print, through her father's indulgence, in the year of Alfred's birth. Thus she was
already established as a scholar and a poetess, already somewhat set
apart from her brothers, except the beloved "Bro" with whom she
shared the study of the classics.
Alfred was eleven years old when EBB commenced her 1831-32
diary, in which she recorded in great detail her daily round of
study and reluctant socializing, and it is doubtless an accurate re
flection of the immense gulf between a serious young lady of
twenty-five and her boisterous brother of eleven that the few refer
ences made to him speak only of his "running & having luncheon
on the hills," or riding out or
pigeon-shooting with neighbors
("The most cowardly mean-spirited, no-spirited amusement pos sible. If it had been a
tiger hunt!?"1). When the family settled in London in 1835, after the loss of
Hope End and three years in Sidmouth, Alfred was fifteen, and still
too young to play any significant part in EBB's life. Her health
declined after the move to London, and in 1838 she was sent to
Torquay with her dear "Bro" as constant companion. Her two
sisters were frequent visitors, and most of the other members of
the family also spent time with her. Doubtless Alfred made the
[135]
This content downloaded from 141.101.201.103 on Sat, 28 Jun 2014 18:18:38 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
136 Ronald Hudson
journey, though he was studying at University College, London,
at this time and there is no known evidence of his visiting EBB.
After EBB's return to London, still crushed by the death of
6'Bro" for which she felt responsible through having begged her
father to let "Bro" remain in Torquay, she stayed mostly in her
room, busy with her reading and writing, and shunning all except a few privileged visitors. At this time, Alfred was occupied in the
offices of the Great Western Railway. His exact position and duties
are not known, but it has been established that his name was not
on the GWR payroll; consequently, it is possible that he was ser
ving some form of apprenticeship. One of his surviving sketch-books
contains twenty titled pen-and-ink sketches of young men's heads; all have been identified as clerks serving in the Paddington Station
Accounts Office in the period 1841-47. It is probable, therefore, that he was also in that department.
His occupation there and his social life probably left him little
time for attendance on an invalid, though he undoubtedly paid visits to the sick-room along with the rest of the family. He also
employed his artistic talents to leave us records of several members
of the family, including a pencil sketch, executed in 1843, of EBB
on the sofa in her room, carefully wrapped up, and nursing Flush.
This sketch was first printed in the New York Times on 13 Febru
ary 1971 through the courtesy of Alfred's great-grandson, Edward
R. Moulton-Barrett, Esq.; it is published here as the frontispiece to
this volume. Alfred's talent has also left us the likeness of other
members of the family: his impressions of his sisters Henrietta and
Arabel, his brothers Henry, Septimus, and Octavius, and the "Gov
ernor" are shown in Fig. 1.
The evidence left us shows that at this time Alfred was close to
William Surtees Cook, who was a third cousin through his rela
tionship to Alfred's mother's family. Surtees Cook was a
frequent visitor to Wimpole Street, not only
on account of the consanguinity, but because of his deepening attachment to his wife-to-be, Henrietta
Moulton-Barrett. In his diary Surtees Cook recorded on 10 Novem
ber 1844: "Called in Wimpole Street? Walked with Henrietta and
Alfred. . . . Alfred dined with me?and we went to the musical
promenade at Covent Garden." There are many other references
to Alfred's dining with Surtees or attending parties with him, in
This content downloaded from 141.101.201.103 on Sat, 28 Jun 2014 18:18:38 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
EBB to Her Brother Alfred 137
Arabel, 3 July
Henry, 29 June
n
S
Henrietta, 3 Aug.
Octavius, 28 June Edward Moulton-Barrett, 27 Sept.
Figure 1. The Barretts by Alfred Moulton-Barrett, 1843
This content downloaded from 141.101.201.103 on Sat, 28 Jun 2014 18:18:38 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
138 Ronald Hudson
addition to his frequent presence as chaperon when Surtees escorted
Henrietta in the park or to a
morning concert. Surtees' deepening involvement is made plain by the entry of 21 March 1845, when
he records drinking the drops of tea left in Henrietta's cup, putting his "ugly mouth, wheie her pretty lips had been. This is Love?"
A few days later, he made clear that he was under no illusions
regarding his chances of winning her. He noted in the diary: "Her
father's consent before marriage is hopeless," and resolved to run
away with her "when I am a Captain, if she will."2
One other entry in Surtees' diary, that of 22 November 1844, is of particular interest, as it couples for the first time the names
of Alfred and his future wife, Elizabeth Georgina ("Lizzie") Bar
rett. At this time, Lizzie was a permanent member of the Wimpole Street household. Writing to Mary Russell Mitford on 4 June 1845, EBB identified her as "the daughter of a cousin of Papa's?and as
her father is in the West Indies and her mother insane . . . she is
next to an orphan, . . and we are not likely to lose her."3 When
Lizzie and Alfred walked with Henrietta and Surtees in 1844, she was
only eleven, and Alfred twenty-four. However, after Alfred mar
ried Lizzie in 1855 he wrote to Henrietta that he had loved Lizzie
for years, so it may not be too fanciful to see the seeds of the ro
mance sprouting in these walks recorded by Surtees.
It was Lizzie, incidentally, who was the subject of EBB's verses
entitled "A Portrait," published in 1844. It was also for Lizzie
that EBB wrote a 17-line poem on lace-bordered paper, with
decorations by Arabel and Henrietta, that was given to Lizzie on
Valentine's Day, 1844. This was also included in the article in the
New York Times on 13 February 1971, and is reproduced here as
Fig. 2. And it was to Lizzie that EBB referred when writing to
Robert Browning of "one of my cousins" who "lies on the floor
& kicks."4
Although there is solid evidence of a growing bond between
Alfred and Surtees and Henrietta, a bond that was to persist, there is little to show that EBB's life impinged much on Alfred's.
What evidence we do have shows a younger brother mostly very much in the background.
In a letter to Robert Browning, EBB
described her "sunday-levee," the only time in the week when
"for one half-hour I have to see all my brothers and sisters at
This content downloaded from 141.101.201.103 on Sat, 28 Jun 2014 18:18:38 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
EBB and Her Brother Alfred 139
J(w? tuff )(o\ * ?utt"?
2^1
;^^^^^^f^^^f -
?^^s^^^^1^^*
Figure 2. Lace-bordered Valentine presented to Lizzie Barrett, 14 Feb. 1844
This content downloaded from 141.101.201.103 on Sat, 28 Jun 2014 18:18:38 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
140 Ronald Hudson
once." She then goes on to recount how "with an exceeding im
pertinence, Alfred threw himself down on the sofa & declared
that he felt inclined to be very ill,?for that then . . . some young
lady might come to visit him, to talk sympathetically.
. . ."5
Alfred also figures in EBB's letter to Mary Russell Mitford of 10 July 1845. Miss Mitford had entertained various members of
the Moulton-Barrett family to a picnic at Three Mile Cross. Writ
ing her thanks afterwards, EBB (who was, of course, not able to
go herself) said: "My brother Alfred said to me expressively
. .
'Miss Mitford won every heart of us'-and that's true?for he
does not often fall or rise into enthusiasms."6
The only other extended reference to Alfred at this period was
immediately prior to EBB's departure from Wimpole Street, at
the time of the last of the "dognapping" episodes involving Flush.
The "dognapper" was just being paid for the return of Flush when
Alfred's untimely interference caused him to leave in a huff, and
Septimus had to be despatched to make peace and secure the
dog's return. Recounting the incident to Robert Browning, EBB
wrote: "I was very angry with Alfred, who had no business to
risk Flush's life for the sake of the satisfaction of trying on names
which fitted."7
EBB's relationship with Alfred, and with all the family, was
transformed by her unexpected marriage to Robert Browning and
their departure to Italy. Thereafter, EBB's principal channel for news from home, and for elder-sisterly advice to all and sundry,
was through her voluminous correspondence with her sisters. She
constantly begged for news of family and household servants ("How is Alfred getting
on with the railway?"), and expressed concern
over their health or impending journeys, especially when any of
her brothers made the long voyage to the family estates in Jamaica.
It was, however, seldom that she corresponded directly with other
members of the family; when she did, it was to her serious-minded
barrister brother George that she wrote most. There is no doubt,
though, that she was kept posted with details of Alfred's career
and especially of his involvement with Lizzie.
For those who were left in Wimpole Street, life continued much
as usual, after the storms attendant upon EBB's sudden flight sub
sided. Alfred's intimacy with Henrietta and Surtees is shown by the
This content downloaded from 141.101.201.103 on Sat, 28 Jun 2014 18:18:38 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
Edward Barrett of = Judith Goodin
Cinnamon Hill
r
Roger Altham = Mary Isaacson
T George Henry Charles Moulton = Elizabeth Sarah Samuel = Elizabeth Barrett Wayte Williams
1-?7-? Samuel =
Margaret Gilles Richard Edward George = Elizabeth Turner
Storey ^
John Graham-Clarke = Arabella
Sarah ("Pinkie")
Samuel = Maria Bell r T ~\
Edward Richard Georgina Elizabeth = Alfred Moulton-Barrett
ty ("Lizzie") ^
Samuel
of Wimpole Street ltham f
-1 A. Surtees = Mary
Col. John Cook
Edward Barrett Moulton-Barrett = Mary John Altham f Mary Elizabeth Parkinson Jane =
John Hedley Charlotte = Richard Butler of Wimnole Street L I I
4/ ?
Frances f Thomas Butler Arabella ("Bummy") 4*
Elizabeth
-1-1-1-1-J-1-1 | Robert Arabella John Elizabeth George Fanny Anna Mary William Surtees Cook = Henrietta Moulton-Barrett Susan
$ 4, ^ Hbbet") ^
Robert Browning = Elizabeth Edward Henrietta = William Surtees Cook Mary Samuel Arabei Charles John George Henry Alfred =
Georgina Elizabeth Septimus Octav?is I ("Ba") ("Bro") ("Addles") ("Stormie") ? ("Daisy")! ("Lizzie") ("Sept") ("O?_cy"J
I ... !-1-i?i f*?-?-\-r-1 * Robert Wiedeman Barrett Browning = Fannie Coddington Altham Mary Edward Edward Alfred = Frances Amelia Horton George Alice Mary_Ethel
I * Edward Francis =
Evelyn Ambler
Edward R. Moulton-Barrett
The Moulton-Barrett Family ?
Abridged Genealogical Table
tu bo bo
a,
bo
Ob
4^
This content downloaded from 141.101.201.103 on Sat, 28 Jun 2014 18:18:38 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
142 Ronald Hudson
employment of another of his talents, that of verse-maker. After
Surtees despaired of gaining approval of his marriage to Henrietta,
they resolved to follow EBB's example and marry despite Papa's
opposition. This they did on 6 April 1850, and it was Alfred who wrote to tell Henrietta of the aftermath of her elopement, of the
"grand battle scene in the drawing room," and to assure her that
"nothing which any of us heard tonight has in the least shaken us
in our belief that you were in every way justified in the course you
have taken." Alfred also composed a 72-stanza epic depicting the
event. Barrett p?re's unflinching opposition is record in stanzas
29 and 30:
He never once, e'en in a dream}
Gave ear to lovers true.
No thoughts would make that heart repent, Or feel for Surtees Cook.
And Henrietta's surreptitious departure is described in stanza 42:
With hurried footsteps light as air,
The errant damsel flew, Fast down the well-known winding stair, Nor paused to say adieu.
It is not known exactly when Alfred severed his connection with
the Great Western Railway, but on 6 February 1855 he was issued
a passport for travel to Marseilles "on Her Majesty's Service." The
nature of his post there is not known, but may have had some
connection with troop movements to the Crimean War, as he wrote
to his brother Septimus on 11 August 1855 that he had to make "a
long winded return" for the War Office and also "to see various
parties safely shipped off for Constantinople." As soon as EBB obtained his address in Marseilles from Arabel
Barrett, she wrote at once to suggest that he visit Florence.
Letter 1
[Incomplete]
[13 April 1855]
[Why don't you come] over to us & pay us a visit? There is a
railroad from Leghorn to Florence, & ten shillings English will
This content downloaded from 141.101.201.103 on Sat, 28 Jun 2014 18:18:38 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
EBB and Her Brother Alfred 143
bring you by it to our door. (Second class of course. Nobody here travels otherwise.) We will take a bedroom for you, & we will
"board & do for you"?you shall be ruined, by no manner of
means, please to observe, . . & your reproach among men will
be wiped away, of never having
seen Florence! . . which is worth
seeing, I do assure you.8 Then I shall [excision] if you can any how. Give us that great pleasure, & let your brotherly affection
make it a pleasure
to you also.
I was delighted to hear of your occupation at Marseilles. As soon as I heard I wrote for your address, & Arabel omitted to
send it directly. You will scorn to hear English
news from me. The worst is
that dear little Altham has been ill?though he is well again, thank God.
9 Henrietta's plans
seem uncertain & uncomfortable.L ?
In
Wimpole Street, they are well. Trippy has emigrated somewhere?
(I cant make out where through having missed somehow some
note of Arabel's that was to tell me)?has given up her old rooms,
& is to be "walking about" by the time I come. I dare say she will live to write a
monody on me. I am very well though?have
quite rallied from my attack on the chest in the winter,?& am
being SLOWLY fattened on cod's liver oil, in order to making a
decent display in the London stalls after may. Penini thinks it answers . . but that I'm "still a little too
gentle" for a perfect
state of convalescence. So he told me today.
I had a letter today from Mr.s Martin who gives me news
that you will be sorry for?I am very sorry?Sir Robert Price
is obliged to submit to the sale of his property.a I did not know that such a
thing was even
apprehendio. Do you like Marseilles? I only know it by passing through.
It's fashionable not to like it. But I like the very scenery,. . that
wild, ragged, desolate, stretchy landscape & the picturesque, coloured population? Still, as a residence, the agreeableness
may be left doubtful. Write to me & tell me of yourself. And do come, if you can
anyhow. Think how near you are! I feel as if almost I could touch
you over the sea. Penini would like to see an uncle "en attendent"
an elephant. Robert's best love.
[Signature excised]
On 27 April, EBB reported to Henrietta that "such a kind
pleasant letter I had today from Alfred, who wont come here . .
cant; because of his being forced to keep on the watch for
telegraphs."13 Plans were afoot for EBB, RB, and Pen to travel to Paris, to
This content downloaded from 141.101.201.103 on Sat, 28 Jun 2014 18:18:38 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
144 Ronald Hudson
see Robert's father and sister, and it was hoped that a meeting with Alfred might be arranged
at Marseilles, en route. However, as
plans matured, the meeting became doubtful, and EBB wrote
to Arabel on 11-12 June: "I shall miss Alfred at Marseilles too.
We get there in the middle of the night, & ... we shall probably
push on at once to sleep at Avignon two hours after landing."
A second objective in the trip to Paris was to witness the mar
riage of Wilson, EBB's maid, to Ferdinando Romagnoli, the Brown
ings' manservant, who had been trying to secure Wilson's assent to
marriage for the past two years. Finally, she agreed. (EBB was later
scandalized to discover that it was pregnancy that had brought about Wilson's acquiescence.) A major obstacle to the match was
that Ferdinando was Catholic, Wilson Protestant, and she would
not agree to swear to bring up the children of the marriage in the
Catholic faith; thus it was impossible
to arrange a Catholic service, the only legal form recognized in Tuscany. It was therefore hoped to arrange a Catholic ceremony in Paris, where the priests were
thought to be less strict. Before leaving Florence, Wilson and
Ferdinando went through an Anglican form of marriage at the
British Embassy, and EBB reported on this in a postscript to the
letter last mentioned: "An English clergyman performed the cer
emony half in English and half in Italian, & Robert ?c I de Penini
were witnesses?Peni giving his signature in full to the admiration
of the clergyman. . . . It's to be considered no
marriage, you under
stand, till after the Catholic ceremony?& we keep it secret for
fear of the priests, who might get Ferdinando stopped from leav
ing Tuscany, & so produce a
tragedy." The party set out for Leghorn,
to catch the packet for Marseilles, on the following day, 13 June. Unfortunately, the boat, due to
leave at 4:30 p.m., left without the Browning party at 3:30 "in the
fear of a rising wind, or supposed rising wind (there was'nt a breath
of air) . . .
taking with it our money & passports, & leaving us
frantic, of course."14
Rather than incur the expense of a hotel in Leghorn, or take
a different ship and forfeit their passage-money, the Brownings returned to Florence until the same boat made its next trip the
following week, when the Browning party was safely aboard,
and they arrived tired and sea-sick at Marseilles on the morning of
This content downloaded from 141.101.201.103 on Sat, 28 Jun 2014 18:18:38 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
EBB and Her Brother Alfred 145
Figure 3. Alfred Price Moulton-Barrett (ca. 1856), artist unknown
This content downloaded from 141.101.201.103 on Sat, 28 Jun 2014 18:18:38 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
146 Ronald Hudson
22 June. EBB unhesitatingly ascribed the misfortune, and the sub
sequent loss of part of their luggage, to the folly of having set out
in the first place on the thirteenth, "a day fatal we were assured by
certain judicious friends, to all undertakings."15
Having rested and breakfasted, they then made enquiries for
Alfred, and found him lodged in the room next to theirs at the
Htotel des Empereurs. He found the sure way to EBB's approbation
by taking Pen out to walk and bringing him home laden with bonbons and toys. Pen was also allowed to dine with the grown
ups, and had his portion of champagne, so it is no
surprise that
the brief visit with Alfred was a great success in EBB's eyes. Alfred
himself seems to have enjoyed his brief avuncular stint, and wrote
to Henrietta on 2 August 1855: "You never saw such a handsome
lad Penini has become?he was the wonder of Marseilles."
On arrival at Lyons on 23 June, EBB discovered to her dismay that one of their boxes was
missing, perhaps through the inatten
tion of the "bride and bridegroom." She instantly sent off the
following S.O.S. to Alfred.
Letter 216
Lyons. Saturday night?
[23 June 1855]
My dearest Alfred, Will you help us? We have lost a box?a square deal box with a
black top?it is locked & contains, hats, collars, lace &c?"Robert
Browning*' is written on it somewhere. Wilson can only remember
that she saw it on board the Bastia boat, "L'Industrie", from
whence our things
were supposed
to be conveyed to the custom
house, & from thence again to the Hotel des Empereurs. Do be so
kind as to make it out for us, as the loss will be considerable
three hats of Penini's in it,?& how is he to appear in Paris? If the box is recoverable, do send it in the quickest way to Robert's
address, in Paris, 138. Avenue des Champs Elysse?s. Robert says that the address on the box is written on one SIDE of the lid, on
the wood. There will also be on the box marks of its having come
from Firenze to Livorno by railroad. Reward anybody who will
find it, & make a note of all the expense incurred and we will pay you again of course?
Dearest Alfred, I meant to write to you from Paris, to say
how I took your flowers with me & the remembrance of all your
This content downloaded from 141.101.201.103 on Sat, 28 Jun 2014 18:18:38 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
EBB and Her Brother Alfred 147
kindness to me & mine? May God bless you. So sorry I was to
miss seeing you this morning?yet adieus are not the best part of
love?
Penini said, "Dear mama, I like your uncle so much." "But he
is'nt my uncle Penini, but your's! and when you see your other
uncles, then you'll be able to consider which you like best." "Well"?said he musingly,?"For the present, I like Alfred leally nearly
as much as you & papa." I told you, you had won his heart at once, & no wonder
In the greatest haste & with all our love, believe me
Your ever attached
Ba~
With the greatest speed, to Paris?as our stay there is so un
certain. I dare say at least ten pounds worth of things
are in the
box besides ms. notes to a book?
This letter casts an interesting light
on EBB in her respective roles as mother and poetess. The possible loss of Penini's finery
with the cri de c ur "how is he to appear in Paris?" looms as a
much larger tragedy than the likely loss of her "ms. notes to a
book" (Aurora Leigh) added as an afterthought.
No sooner had this cry for help been despatched than another
box was discovered to be missing. Off went another hasty note
to Alfred.
Letter 3
[Incomplete]
[24 June 1855]
Note the second from Lyons?
My dearest Alfred, You will think us
perfectly mad?or poetical
There is a another [sic] large box, a trunk, marked R.B. in
brass nails on the outside, & with the marks of the railroad from
Firenze to Livorno?, left behind. Ferdinando is of opinion that both it & the small deal box of which I wrote to you before, are to be found at the Custom house?but you will enquire, I am sure, at the hotel, and at the Bastia steamer the 'Industrie'.
What we shall do without these boxes I cant imagine? Here's
the advantage (observe?/ do!) of travelling with a man-servant
for the first time? Never before did an accident occur to us of
this kind?
This content downloaded from 141.101.201.103 on Sat, 28 Jun 2014 18:18:38 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
148 Ronald Hudson
Forgive me, dearest Alfred, for heaping up this trouble & an
noyance on you? For my sake you w[ill not] grudge the trouble, I do believe [conclusion missing]
That letter sent on its way, EBB discovered that a courier was
about to leave for Marseilles, so for good measure sent a third note
with him, summarizing the other two, as follows:
Letter 4
[24 June 1855]
My dearest Alfred This is the third letter I have written to you since we
parted? The others you will receive by post.
We have lost two boxes. A square deal box, locked,?with Robert
Browning written on one side of the lid?secondly a trunk with jRB
in brass nails on the lid? Enquire at the steamer Vlndustrie & at
the customs house? They must be somewhere there. At the hotel,
of course? And despatch them instantly to Robert's address?138
Avenue des Champs Ely s ees, Paris?
The rest in the other letters?
In greatest haste & despair?
Your attached
Ba.
Examine the magazine of the hotel.
The Brownings then proceeded to Paris, arriving about 7 p.m. on
24 June, and EBB immediately reported their difficulties to Arabel.
Writing to her on 25 June, she tells of sending the three notes to
Alfred "one after another," and of using the courier. "Of course
there was great negligence. But bride 3c bridegroom had their heads a little turned as was natural." Then on 30 June, she was able to
report: "The boxes are found, 3c sent, thanks to Alfred?we have
them: but we are not married yet, 3c there are difficulties."17 It
was not until 9 July that she wrote to thank Alfred, as follows:
Letter 5
Paris. Avenue des Champs Elysees
[9] July [1855]. Monday.
My dearest Alfred, Thank you, thank you for all your activity, adroitness & success. The boxes arrived in all safety, and in the
This content downloaded from 141.101.201.103 on Sat, 28 Jun 2014 18:18:38 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
EBB and Her Brother Alfred 149
face of Robert's despair, who would have it they never could,
should, or would be found at all. If they had'nt, we should have
lost about thirty pounds . . to say nothing of the inconvenience.
For my part, it's my way to hope against
stone walls. I never
"gave them up"?and I thank you very, very much that you
justified me
perfectly. It has taught
us some wisdom, & we are
not likely
ever to lose our boxes again, whatever we may do with
our wits.
Your letter was the kindest, pleasantest, dearest letter? How
kind you are to me dear Alfred! I feel quite pleased that you should like Penini, and I will take your advice & try that he shant be "conceited" and spoiled. Remember, he's a young child still?&
everything comes to the surface?he's so
guileless & simple, he
cant pretend to be modest, as so many grown up people do. I
thought you would have heard him shouting on the hotel stairs that morning, "Where's the Prince of Peace?" And, that you
did'nt,. . that you were asleep instead, . . never for a moment
struck me as "unkind",. . indeed & indeed! I understood exactly how it was, and if you knew how inclined I felt to run into your room & give you a kiss .. only I thought you might not like it
how could I be sure? After all, "goodbyes" are hateful things, and I was just spared a pain. Now, I look back & think of the pleasure of having seen you, talked to you, dined with you, and heard your kind words.
I would not write till I could tell you where we shall be in
London. Arabel has taken us rooms in 13 Dorset Street, Baker
Street at two & a half guineas a week, & we are
likely to be
comfortable. She says that Sette is better. Sam Barrett19is in
London, & is surprised to see papa looking considerably "better"
than he did two years & a half ago. The Hedleys have gone into the country?Bummy, too.20 The Owens, I fear, have lost much
money through the Paul bankruptcy ?& they have lost besides a child by scarlet-fever, which is very much worse.
The old charm of Paris has siezed on me?nothing
in the world
(except Venice) is so beautiful as a city!?the gardens, trees, &
houses all growing together! Then the people are so very kind & attentive to us. The weather, too, has been divine since we came?
only by the time we come back, all that will have changed, & we shall have a northern winter to look forward to. The exhibi
tion22 is magnificent?the effects more picturesque than those in
England, notwithstanding the comparative deficiency in space.
[Continued on flap of envelope] We have been waiting here in order to
complete Wilson's marriage,. . and intend to leave Paris
tomorrow . . to reach London at past midnight. How overjoyed I am at the thoughts of whom I shall see on Wednesday! Robert
This content downloaded from 141.101.201.103 on Sat, 28 Jun 2014 18:18:38 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
150 Ronald Hudson
desires me to name him affectionately to you . . & thankfully be
sides, for all you have done for us. Penini's love. Your attached Ba.
As will be seen from this letter, the Brownings were
planning to
leave Paris for London on 10 July, and Arabel Barrett had rented
rooms for them. However, true love found its wonted obstacles, and the Brownings' departure was
delayed, a succession of letters
keeping Arabel informed of developments. On 8 July EBB wrote
Arabel: "The difficulties have been immense, 3c it has only been
by favour that we are likely to escape the general law of the church
of Rome?iniquitous to my mind." She goes on to explain that the
undertaking is to be relaxed to require simply "a promise that if
'the children' choose to be Roman catholics, the mother wont
hinder them." Another letter, two days later, reported more
delay. "She has agreed
to submit to her husband's wishes on the point of
the children?and if they dont exact an oath from him, all will be
safe." She goes on to relate that Ferdinando, having become des
perate, had resolved to renounce his country and "set up a, fiacre . .
in Lyons!" There were no further setbacks, however, and she was
able to report in a postscript on the flap of the envelope: She is
married. I will tell you all."23
Wilson and Ferdinando were not the only couple having diffi
culty in entering the married state. Alfred's attachment to Lizzie
had grown over the years, and was probably the reason for her
despatch from the Wimpole Street household in 1853 for a pro tracted stay in Dublin. Alfred's own escape from Wimpole Street
to Marseilles made his intentions easier to effect, despite his father's
opposition. Surviving letters make clear that Barrett p?re was not
alone in thinking the marriage unwise. That EBB's "hot line" to
Wimpole Street was functioning
as efficiently
as always is shown
in her letter to Arabel after having seen Alfred in Marseilles. She
tells Arabel that Alfred had just taken a furnished house for six months: "What you tell me of his intentions is a
key to this?
but not a word did he tell me. . . . depend upon it, Arabel, he
comes [to Paris] to meet 3c marry Lizzie. That's certain. I am
very, very sorry." This letter then has seven lines heavily obliterated
at some later date, and it seems a reasonable inference that they contained the kernel of EBB's objections
to the match.24 However,
This content downloaded from 141.101.201.103 on Sat, 28 Jun 2014 18:18:38 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
EBB and Her Brother Alfred 151
in another letter after the marriage, to Mrs. Martin on 7 August 1855, EBB makes clear that her prime reason for disliking the
marriage was Lizzie's mother's insanity.25 The male members of
the family appear to have been more influenced by Alfred's fi
nancial troubles: he was heavily in debt and being pressed by
creditors. A letter from Alfred to Septimus on 19 July 1855 shows
that Alfred had approached his father: "I have written to the
Governor, not according to my wishes, but out of regard to hers.
She insisted upon my shewing respect to him who is nominally
'My father' & so I wrote in such a strain, I thought best suited to
allay the dreadful injury I was about to inflict. I regretted having to make such a
parade, but what I regretted still more was the
consequent annoyance it would create among you all. He has I
supposed been outrageous?& his society necessarily disagreeable." He then goes on to
justify the marriage, saying that Lizzie's pro
perty would be secured "for her sole use & benefit & for her
childrens." Septimus wrote Alfred on the same day, urging delay;
their letters crossed, and Alfred wrote again on 22 July: "You ask
me to wait until my debts are compromised?I do not wish to have
them compromised?I only wish my creditors should have patience.
My marriage will not increase my expenditure, but diminish it."
Later he says that "with a very comfortable income" and reduced
expenditure he hopes to rid himself of his debts, though "it is our intention to keep our marriage as close as it may be possible & so
avoid creditors ears." So, ignoring advice and opposition, Alfred
married, and wrote to Henrietta on 2 August 1855 to tell her that
"the dread deed has been done. I am a married man?and as I gave
you my sympathy & moreover as you have always shown the
kindest love towards me I ask you to say & do all you can to
soften the hard judgments that may be passed against me.
"You must know my dearest Henrietta that I have loved Lizzie
for years?for a
long, long time we have been engaged, & engaged with the perfect concurrence and approval of those who have for
the greater term of our engagement taken the kindliest interest in
her.
"The marriage occurred yesterday in the Embassy at Paris. . . .
I have sent cards to no one. I was told that the publication of my
This content downloaded from 141.101.201.103 on Sat, 28 Jun 2014 18:18:38 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
152 Ronald Hudson
marriage would set ones claimants enquiring ?V so have sa
nothing." When EBB heard the news, she wrote felicitating the couple,
follows:
Letter 6
13 Dorset Street. Baker Street
Wednesday. [8 August 1855]
My dearest Alfred, I little thought when we parted at Marseilles, that you would
bring me another sister before we should meet
again. May God
bless you & her, dear Alfred, & make you happy to the utmost
of your hopes & the possibilities of this world, enabling you, when the necessary griefs fall in, to bear them better in the
strength of your mutual love, &, when the joys thicken, to feel
them still sweeter because of being joyful together. Give my love
(and a kiss . . if it so please you) to dear Lizzie, & tell her that
she must try to love me a little, as a real sister should. When I
hung up my "Portrait," did I think of it's being my sister's? No, indeed. But the way of the world has funny turns in it.
Will you write to me, dear Alfred, and tell me how you get on, and if the Marseilles villa suits Lizzie, & if Lizzie suits it, and
if you two (I dont include the villa) are
likely to come to Paris
this winter, so that Robert & I may see you. We should be so
very glad of that chance. Penini being overwhelmed with the
number of uncles & aunts, "leally does'nt want any more," he
said when we told him that he had a new aunt. Still, his admira
tion for you continues, & Lizzie will find him quite inclined to
allow her to sit in the light of that. Indeed there's room & to spare. In Wimpole Street the affair seems to have gone off much
quieter than such things are apt to do. At the same time, I am
afraid you are not likely to be better off on that account.
I find my dearest Arabel looking well. She is all the delight of my eyes which I can have in London. Otherwise, I hate being here quite as much as usual, & begin to feel very tired & de
pressed with the number of visitors who do not come from
Wimpole street. I see very little of my brothers; though dear
Sette is better than he was. So much I do wish that he & papa would go together to Buxton! It would be excellent for both
of them. George has not returned yet from circuit, & he went
away only a
day or two after our arrival.
This content downloaded from 141.101.201.103 on Sat, 28 Jun 2014 18:18:38 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
EBB and Her Brother Alfred 153
Robert's poems are in the press, & I expect a great success.
[Continued on flap of envelope] He unites with me in the warmest brotherly regard & wishes to both of you.
May God bless you, here & hereafter!?prays your constantly affectionate
Ba
Writingto Mrs. Martin the day before, she said, after referring to
Lizzie's mother's malady, "Alfred has chosen, & acted, ?V it remains
to make the best of it. Of course he makes the third exile from
Wimpole Street?the course of true love running remarkably rough in our house. For the rest, there have been no scenes, . . . a few
words of a sharp character said to Sette?and there was an end!
Poor Alfred. In the actual state of his affairs, nothing could be so
illjudged as this marriage?but he has 'gone & done it', & we must
hope for the best."27 And writing to Henrietta ten days later, she
said in a postscript: "I scarcely know what to say of Alfred's
marriage. I wrote of course?& he has written to me. He seems
very happy now, & may God grant that the happiness last! The
malady is the horrible objection, from which I cant distract my
eyes."28
EBB, Henrietta, and Alfred were now united by the sentence
of excommunication and disinheritance passed by the father whose
authority had been flouted.
Responding to a letter of congratulation from Septimus, Alfred
wrote on 11 August: "We have now had a weeks experience of
house keeping & I assure you the difference of expense is ridicu
lously small. Two pence worth more of eggs and a penny extra
of goats milk per diem comprises all. . . . I bind myself most so
lemnly not to let the event increase my expenditure. All will go much better than you anticipate.
. . . my wife?bless her old bones
has more than you think in exspectancy [sic] & we shall manage to rub on, after our own fashion, in a very respectable way."
The next surviving letter from EBB to Alfred was at the end of
the year, after the Brownings had returned to Paris from their
stay in London.
This content downloaded from 141.101.201.103 on Sat, 28 Jun 2014 18:18:38 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
154 Ronald Hudson
Letter 7
Dec. 20 [1855]. Rue du Colyss?e Avenue des Champs Elyss?es
My dearest Alfred Our two letters crossed. I only hope you received mine. I would
not write again till I could send you my address in Paris?and we
fell into a trap in Paris . . into a miserable apartment without top,
bottom, or sides, where we were held fast for two months, we
trying hard to let it, & go. Never was I so uncomfortable in my
life. Robert had to dress in the salon, and Penini to sleep on the
floor in our bedroom?and the exposition was to the east, and the
draughts flew about everywhere like birds of prey. Of course I was
extremely unwell, with a return of some of my worst symp
toms?and Robert talked desperately of throwing up the house,
rent & all. Which would have been madness? How could we
afford to pay twenty pounds for nothing? So I used all my small
wifely influence (very small, is'nt it, Lizzie?) and persuaded him to
patience. And we endured; saw out the month, & now, for a
recompense, are most comfortably established in a street just
turning out of the Champs Elyss?es . . in most comfortable rooms,
not large,
nor gaudy
. . but convenient & very warm. But oh, the
weather, the frost! Your northern winters are hard to bear.
Still I am considerably better, & I shall get on I dare say. As to Penini he has got on. In London he grew pale & thin,?but
here he has blown out his cheeks with a rose canvas. Paris always
agrees well with him. And you, both of you? Dearest Alfred & Lizzie, mind you be
good & write to me, & tell me what you are doing & talking of, & whether you are very tired of one another yet. (That, of course.) Have you any society? Do you talk French? Will Lizzie manage a Christmas out of England? Do you dream of coming up to Paris?
There's a bunch of questions for you.
I have not heard from Wimpole Street for some days, and I am anxious to hear, for Arabel has been less strong than usual
since their return from Eastbourne &, though she makes nothing of it, I cant help being hungry about letters. You are aware
perhaps that Henrietta expects another confinement in April?
which prevented her coming to London to see me,2 I had a dis
mal London-visit after all?and here it has been dismal too from another cause, & we have been lying perdue behind the door,
away from all our acquaintances except such as burrowed for
us. Now, we shall creep out a little. Robert will, at least. Charles
Dickens lives opposite. Sir Edward Lytton30 has spent an evening
with us & I liked him much better than I thought possible before.
This content downloaded from 141.101.201.103 on Sat, 28 Jun 2014 18:18:38 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
EBB and Her Brother Alfred 155
[Continued on flap of envelope] Penini consoled himself for the degradation of sleeping on the floor by observing that it
was "just lite the soldiers at Sebastapol." He is in great force,
never ceases talking from morning till night, & is the best & dearest child in the world in my opinion. May God bless you both, dearest Alfred & Lizzie! Robert's love & Penini's too. Penini
says "I hope untie Alfred has'nt forgotten me. Tell him I've just walked to the Bois de Boulogne, & that the ice is dreadful." Your ever affectionate Ba.
Contact between EBB and Alfred continued, and in a letter to
Arabel dated 13 March 1856 EBB said: "I must send you Alfred's letter just received?because it is so
pleasant." However, this letter
has not survived. In another letter to Arabel, dated 4 October
1856, EBB wrote: "Yesterday Alfred & Lizzie came. He was masked
in an enormous moustache31. . . Lizzie looked pretty, rather thin,
smiling, not over-powered at the notion of separation." This last
was a reference to Alfred's impending departure to Madeira that
day for six weeks. EBB continues that the next day she received
a note from Lizzie that she herself was sailing for Madeira the
following week: "She said she must be with him?she could not be
separated so
long." His trip must have been on Government busi
ness, for EBB says later in the letter: "While he is away, he expects a consulship to be found for him." He was back in England early in 1857, and attended his father's funeral in Ledbury
on 24 April 1857. (Surtees Cook noted in his diary that "every shop in Led
bury was closed" as a mark of respect, even though it was 25
years since Edward Moulton-Barrett had left Hope End.) Soon
after that, Alfred left for Hong Kong, though it is not known
whether this trip related to his expectancy of a consulship. EBB
"perfectly disapproved" of his leaving Lizzie behind. "Her aunt's
house in Cheltenham, does not seem to me a safe enough place for a young creature, so very attractive, & so young in all ways."32
Alfred returned on 17 November 1857, at which time his wife was
staying with several other members of the family at Bryngwyn,
Charles John Moulton-Barrett's house in Montgomeryshire, bought with part of his share of his father's estate.
The next surviving letter from EBB to Alfred was written in
1859 to express congratulations on the birth of his first son,
Edward Alfred, on 17 January 1859 in Leamington.
This content downloaded from 141.101.201.103 on Sat, 28 Jun 2014 18:18:38 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
156 Ronald Hudson
Letter 8
Rome. 43. Bocea di Leone
Jany. 28 [1859].
My dearest Alfred, I do congratulate you & dear Lizzy from my heart. I have been looking
out for a letter on the subject,?& a
better one than this, who could receive? Thank you my dear
Alfred. Your anxiety and also your joy must have been great indeed . .
great in proportion to the gigantic size of the baby. I
remember objecting to the largeness of the cap Arabel bought
in France?but of course she bought it precisely so, in virtue of
some half conscious presentiment. As for the rest, when your
sight clears a little you will find that the baby is no more like other babies in feature & modes of being than in dimensions. There's as
distinct a variety in babies as in men, & I am sure
Lizzy would
recognize hers in a foundling hospital, through a process of. .
shuffle babies, cut, & deal. She would put her finger on the
trump-babe in a moment.
Now I was going to ask you to give (for me) an auntly kiss to the new
darling, but your imagination may fail me, not conceiv
ing of aunts, so, instead, give a
paternal one,?and give a
sisterly kiss to dear Lizzy?you can conceive of that, I think. Nobody knows (except you & us & a few others) what a light in the house
hold, a young child is. Lizzy will take to loving children now, wont she? May the boy be a Penini to
you! That's the best wish
Jean make?and a "six footer" besides, if you please,. . which my
Pen is not likely to be ever.
He is grown though, & is generally considered tall for his age,
though very young looking & with such small bones that they cant draw out to any notable height I must suppose. Just the
same joyous, spontaneous child as ever . . as when you gave him
your grand dinner at Marseilles, you remember?and, at the same
time, developped in many ways,?six languages & music,?forward for his age,& not with the common forwardness of over-cultivated
children. There's a mixture of knowledge & ignorance which is
attractive?& I assure you we are admired extremely, though we
have not begun Latin yet, and know
nothing of the multiplication table. Time enough I say for the pounds, shillings & pence
Mean time he is reading Monte Cristo in an Italian translation
with the utmost delight?"Now," says he, "I mean to take to
reading novels."
Not too fast Master Pen. I must put my naughty French books far away into lock-up drawers.
He and I are full of our Italy & Napoleon, & the Piedmontese
marriage.3 There are some wild beasts in Rome just now with a
This content downloaded from 141.101.201.103 on Sat, 28 Jun 2014 18:18:38 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
EBB and Her Brother Alfred 157
keeper who goes in to play with the tiger. Said I to Pen, "would
you go in to that tiger for a napoleon?" "No indeed," said he
decidedly. "Would you go in to make Italy free?" "Yes," he answered. "I would go in, in one moment. Do you think I would
not put down my life for my country?" Still I hope he will keep clear of army & navy?and if dear
Harry3 will forgive me, I must wish the same for your boy. Rome is gay enough
to disturb the ashes of the Caesars?Robert
is out every night, with engagements two or three deep a
night, &c I have visitors too many, while the cold wind keeps
me at
home. The amount of dukes & princes here is remarkable, & the
young prince of Wales when he comes will be but a spark in the fire. The wife of his 'governor', Colonel Bruce, has arrived already,
& brings a letter to us, so that we shall hear a
good deal about
him. Also through Odo Russell, Lord John's nephew, who is to
do him the honors of Rome, . . & whom Robert sees frequently
. .
& with whom Robert went the other day to dine at a
pothouse on the other side of the Tiber in order to enjoy Roman viands
& manners at the purest. "I shall bring the prince here" said
Odo Russell charmed.
Then the Americans swarm here?some, very interesting & love
able, others .... simply American. I continue to
prefer my own
quiet life at Florence, and yet our winter at Rome so far, has
been amusing enough, and I have enjoyed the blazing sun through the windows even when unable to go out. . which has been the
case for a month.
Our plan is to go to Naples in the spring, but I doubt whether we shall do it?in fact, it's better not to make plans, till one can
be sure of carrying them out.
I hear dear Storm35 persists in going to Jamaica? The more's
the pity! I hate thinking of it, for my part. My chief occupation is, sitting for my picture, which is of
course useful & moral?
"When nothing's left that's worth defence
we build a magazine"
said Swift, & so with me. When nothing's left worth looking at,
people begin to draw it. There are three artists at this great work,
& when anyone succeeds you are all to be blessed with photo
graphs.36 I only wish they would paint Peni, who would really make a
picture. Robert's love & congratulations, with mine & Penini's. We are
well, thank God. May He bless & keep you all three. Three, after
being only two!? What a difference, inexpressible by the science of numbers!
[Signature excised]
This content downloaded from 141.101.201.103 on Sat, 28 Jun 2014 18:18:38 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
158 Ronald Hudson
In view of EBB's grief over Henrietta's illness and death in the
following year, together with her own declining strength and death
in 1861, it is likely that this was the last letter written by EBB to
Alfred; there is no evidence to the contrary. After EBB's death, Alfred lived largely as a
gentleman of leisure,
travelling and sketching, supported primarily by his wife's income.
There is no indication that he had any steady occupation in his
later years. He never formed any close association with Robert
Browning or Pen, though he carefully preserved newspaper clip
pings concerning RB's works and Pen's exhibitions in his scrap books. He did not care for the cult of adulation fostered by F. J.
Furnivall, whom he termed "an insolent hound" in a letter to
Octavius Moulton-Barrett on 23 December 1889. He objected
strongly to some of the things being written about his father, and
said to Octavius: "Surely Pen should be requested to gag this
insolent?many a son would do more 3c disable the fellow from
sitting down for a month. Fancy any one loving her memory so
writing to the public of her Father!!" He seems to have had little
esteem for Pen, and joined with his brothers in deploring Pen's
decision to publish his parents' love letters. A caricature by Alfred
of Pen in the shape of a pig survives.36
In the late 1880's Alfred and Lizzie were living in Luxembourg;
they had four children in all. Alfred died in the south of France on
24 May 1904; Lizzie died in London in 1918.
New York, N. Y.
NOTES
1. Diary by E.B.B.: The Unpublished Diary of Elizabeth Barrett Barrett, 1831-1832,
ed. Philip Kelley and Ronald Hudson (Athens: Ohio Univ. Press, 1969), p. 206.
I wish to record my gratitude to Dr. Jack W. Herring, Director of the Armstrong
Browning Library at Baylor University in Waco, Tex., for permitting me to publish Letter 3, which is in the ABL collection. For permission to print all the remaining letters
and to draw on other material in his possession, I express my deep appreciation to Edward
R. Moulton-Barrett, Esq. (The envelope belonging to Letter 8 is in the Houghton Library at Harvard.) Finally, I need to thank my colleague, Philip Kelley, for considerable assist
ance in locating material and supplying facts.
2. Throughout this article, direct quotations not otherwise attributed are drawn
from family papers in the possession of Edward R. Moulton-Barrett, Esq., Col. R. A.
Moulton-Barrett, Miss Myrtle Moulton-Barrett, and Mrs. V. M. Altham, to all of whom
my thanks for allowing me to draw on their material.
3. Elizabeth Barrett to Miss Mitford, ed. Betty Miller (London: John Murray, 1954),
p. 246.
This content downloaded from 141.101.201.103 on Sat, 28 Jun 2014 18:18:38 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
EBB and Her Brother Alfred 159
4. The Letters of Robert Browning and Elizabeth Barrett Barrett 1845-1846, ed. Elvan Kintner (Cambridge: Harvard Univ. Press, 1969), I, 326.
5. Ibid., II, 727.
6. Miller, p. 250.
7. Kintner, II, 1050.
8. The eight letters printed here are given in their entirety. Repeated periods represent EBB's punctuation, not editorial excisions. Elision points are used in some of the shorter extracts appearing in the linking text.
9; Henrietta's boy. In a letter to Mrs. Martin of 20 Apr. 1855, in the collection at
Wellesley College, EBB wrote: "Dear little Altham has been very ill at Plymouth with
gastric fever."
10. Henrietta's husband was serving as an officer with the 1st Somerset Militia. Men
and officers had been asked to volunteer for service in the Mediterranean, and in an
effort to secure promotion to Major, Surtees Cook had offered to take command of the
contingent. There was doubt about Henrietta's accompanying him if the posting came
through; however, there were insufficient volunteers to form a company and Captain Cook remained in England.
11. Maria Trepsack, one of the family servants who had been with EBB's paternal
grandmother, was suffering delusions of being poisoned, and had moved from her lodg
ings at 26 Welbeck Street. She died on 9 Mar. 1857.
12. Sir Robert Price (1786-1857), Member of Parliament, was the son of Sir Uvedale
Price, who had repeatedly sought EBB's comments and advice on his writings about the
classics when she lived at Hope End. The estate was Foxley, in Herefordshire. Mrs. Julia Martin, with her husband and family, lived at Old Colwall, adjoining the Hope End
estate, and EBB maintained a correspondence with her after leaving Hope End.
13. In the collection of Arthur A. Houghton, Jr. 14. Letter to Arabel, [14 June 1855]. 15. Letter to Arabel, 25 June [1855], in the Henry W. and Albert A. Berg Collection
of The New York Public Library. (No further printed quotations from this correspondence will be permitted without prior written permission from The New York Public Library.) In allowing me to use brief quotations from this and other letters in the Berg Collection, I am indebted to The New York Public Library, Astor, Lenox and Tilden Foundations.
16. This is the only one of the eight letters reproduced here that has been published before. It appeared in Maisie Ward's The Tragi-Comedy of Pen Browning (New York: Sheed and Ward and The Browning Institute, 1972), p. 155.
17. Both letters in the Berg Collection.
18. The exact nature of his illness is not known. A later reference to a second attack
suggests some repetitive ailment, perhaps malaria, contracted in the West Indies.
19. Lizzie's first cousin, Samuel Goodin Barrett (1812-76), who was also a distant cousin of EBB and Alfred.
20. John and Jane Hedley and family. Mrs. Hedley was EBB's maternal aunt, as was
"Bummy," Arabella Sarah Graham-Clarke. 21. Angela Bay ford Owen and her husband. EBB referred to her as a cousin, but
the blood relationship was certainly not a close one. The bankruptcy was that of Sir
John Paul (1802-68) and his partners, bankers who suspended payment in 1855. They were subsequently sentenced to penal servitude for fraudulently disposing of clients'
securities; the Fraudulent Trustees Act of 1857 was passed in consequence of their
delinquency. 22. The Industrial Exhibition opened on 15 May 1855.
23. Letters to Arabel of [8 July 1855] and [10 July 1855] in the Berg Collectioa
24. Letter of 25 June [1855] in the Berg Collection.
25. Letter in the collection at Wellesley. This reference was not included in the
version published in The Letters of Elizabeth Barrett Browning, ed. Frederic G. Kenyon,
(London and New York: Macmillan, 1897), II, 206-08.
26. Men and Women, published in November 1855.
27. Kenyon, II, 207, gives an edited version of her words.
This content downloaded from 141.101.201.103 on Sat, 28 Jun 2014 18:18:38 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions
160 Ronald Hudson
28. Letter of [17 Aug. 1855] in the collection of Arthur A. Houghton, Jr. 29. Henrietta's second son and third child, Edward Altham, was born on 13 Apr.
1856.
30. Sir Edward Bulwer-Lytton was both politician and novelist, author of The Last
Days of Pompeii and other historical novels. His son Robert (1831-91), who published
poetry under the nom de plume of Owen Meredith, was a member of the Brownings' Florentine circle of friends.
EBB recorded the visit in a letter to Arabel: "I like Sir Edward much better
than I thought I should, though the whole tone of the man is less deep less sweet, less pure, than his son's . . ." (31 Oct. [1855] ; Berg Collection).
31. A portrait of Alfred, made at about this time, is shown as figure 3. The artist
is unknown. It is reproduced here by kind permission of Edward R. Moulton-Barrett,
Esq. 32. Letter to Arabel, 3 Apr. [1857], in the Berg Collection.
33. The marriage of Prince Napoleon (1822-91), second son of Jerome Bonaparte,
King of Westphalia, to his cousin Princess Marie Clotilde of Savoy, daughter of King Victor Emmanuel II, on 30 Jan. 1859.
34. Their brother Henry (1818-96). 35. Charles John Moulton-Barrett (1814-1905) was known to the family as "Storm."
It was he who, as the eldest surviving brother, voiced objection to Pen's decision to
publish his parents' love letters. A critical letter from him, dated 30 Mar. 1899, appeared in the London Standard.
36. In a letter to Arabel dated [22? Jan. 1859] EBB wrote: "Gordigiani made a
portrait of me at Florence,?a large buxom, radiant matron, with a torrent of black
ringlets at each cheek. Here, has Miss Fox made a portrait of me at Rome, a dimpled rosy 'pretty woman of five & twenty,' with a stream of brown ringlets at each cheek.
Both equally unlike me in the opinion of the best critics. . . . Now Field Talfourd
(.. . said to be unfailing in his likenesses) is coming on mon day to try his hand."
Talfourd completed his drawing in February, and EBB was pleased enough with his repre sentation of her to send photographs of it to her brothers and sisters. A letter in the Berg
Collection dated [1? Mar. 1859] tells how Robert Browning gave Miss Fox in marriage to Mr. Bridell and says that Miss Fox's portrait "began by being young & coarse like a
milkmaid?& will end by being old & coarse like a cook."
37. Reproduced in Maisie Ward, p. 102.
This content downloaded from 141.101.201.103 on Sat, 28 Jun 2014 18:18:38 PMAll use subject to JSTOR Terms and Conditions