EFA BASELINE DESIGNSACOUSTICS STRATEGYAcoustic Design of Schools

EFA PSBP

Andrew Pa

a.parkin@

Con

  In1.

  T2.

2.1  C

2.1.1 

2.1.2 

2.1.3 

2.1.4 

2.1.5 

2.2  E

2.3  S

2.4  R

2.5  A

  B3.

  B4.

P – Baseline De

arkin – Acoustic

@cundall.com

ntents

ntroduction

The Baseline

Control of re

Classbase

Dining/atri

Main hall..

Sports hal

Single stor

Environment

Sound Insula

Rain Noise ..

Alternative P

Baseline Sec

Baseline Sec

esigns: Acoustic

cs Partner

.................

e Design So

everberation

es ..............

um and mu

.................

ls (seconda

rey circulati

tal Noise an

ation .........

.................

Performance

condary sch

condary sch

cs Strategy

..................

olutions .....

n ................

..................

ulti-storey ci

..................

ary schools)

ion space/c

nd Ventilatio

..................

..................

e Standards

hool (super

hool (finger

..................

..................

..................

..................

rculation ....

..................

) .................

corridors .....

on ..............

..................

..................

s (APS) and

rblock) – se

r block) – se

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

d Refurbish

ction throug

ection throu

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

ment .........

gh dining ha

gh teaching

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

all ..............

g spaces....

Page 2 o

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

..................

of 8

.. 3 

.. 4 

.. 4 

.. 4 

.. 4 

.. 4 

.. 5 

.. 5 

.. 5 

.. 5 

.. 6 

.. 6 

.. 7 

.. 8 

EFA PSBP

Andrew Pa

a.parkin@

1.

P – Baseline De

arkin – Acoustic

@cundall.com

Introdu

The baseline

Schools’, to

Schools Bui

preparation

amendments

plan, refurbis

‘Acoustic De

Building Bul

of demonstr

This report is

Key Principa

esigns: Acoustic

cs Partner

uction

e designs are

be published

lding Progra

of this docum

s made to re

shment) and

esign of Scho

letin 93 (BB9

ating good p

s to be read

als of acoust

cs Strategy

e in line with

d by EFA and

mme (PSBP

ment which is

eflect change

d the experie

ools – Perfor

93). Section 2

practice in the

in conjunctio

ic design, re

h ‘Acoustic D

d included a

P). A panel o

s essentially

es in school d

nce of the pa

rmance Stan

2 of the docu

e implementa

on with other

lating to the

esign of Sch

s part of the

of industry ex

y a revision o

design since

anel in relatio

ndards for Sc

ument will be

ation of the P

r related text

Baseline De

ools – Perfo

Output Spec

xperts have b

f Building Bu

the early 20

on to perform

chools’ is to s

e published a

Performance

on the EFA

signs.

ormance Stan

cification for

been involved

ulletin (BB) 9

000s (e.g. tre

mance target

supersede S

at a later dat

e Standards.

website whi

Page 3 o

ndards for

the Priority

d in the

93, with

ends in open

ts.

ection 1 of

e with the aim

ch sets out

of 8

m

EFA PSBP

Andrew Pa

a.parkin@

2.

P – Baseline De

arkin – Acoustic

@cundall.com

The Ba

2.1 Con

The

with

App

2.1.

2.1.

2.1.

esigns: Acoustic

cs Partner

aseline

ntrol of re

Baseline de

other enviro

proaches vary

.1 Classb

Reverbe

suspend

are high

comprom

absorbe

floor fini

Class A

Furniture

between

.2 Dining/

Reverbe

combina

undersid

(absorpt

.3 Main h

Unlike m

minimum

variety o

Reverbe

panels (

to side w

their typ

section o

facilitate

practica

cs Strategy

e Desig

everberatio

esigns demon

onmental con

y depending

bases

eration in cla

ded horizonta

hly acoustica

mise the ther

ers is approxi

sh and age o

wall panels.

e acts constr

n parallel har

/atrium and

eration in the

ation of perfo

de of walkwa

tion Class de

all

many other s

m, in addition

of activities.

eration is con

(Class C or b

walls. The co

e, coverage

of ceiling tow

e reflection of

ble.

gn Solu

on

nstrate meth

ntrol factors (

on the type

ssbases is c

ally from the

lly efficient (C

rmal benefit

imately 40%

of pupils bein

.

ructively to d

rd surfaces.

d multi-sto

ese large-vol

orated roof lin

ays (Class A)

ependant on

paces, rever

n to maximum

ntrolled by an

better) to the

overage and

and location

wards the fro

f speech to t

utions

ods of rever

(e.g. daylight

of spaces. T

controlled pre

soffit, inters

Class A) and

of the expos

of the floor a

ng taught, th

diffuse the so

orey circula

ume, high oc

ner (Class C

) and signific

coverage ar

rberation nee

m, levels. Th

n absorbent

rear wall an

d type of pane

n. It may be

ont and centre

the rear sect

beration con

ting, ventilati

Types of spa

edominantly

persed betw

d light reflecti

sed soffit, the

area. Depen

ese absorbe

ound that cou

ation

ccupancy, sp

or better), a

cant coverage

rea).

eds to be con

his is to facili

liner (Class C

d absorbent

els/materials

advantageou

e of the soffit

ion, although

ntrol that wor

ion, thermal

aces are disc

by absorptiv

ween light fitti

ive. In order

e area of sus

nding on the

ers are suppl

uld otherwise

paces is cont

absorbent fin

e of wall pan

ntrolled to ac

itate speech

C or better),

panels (Clas

s will vary ac

us to allow fo

t or ceiling in

h this may no

Page 4 o

k in harmony

mass etc.).

cussed below

ve panels

ngs; panels

r to not

pended

size of room

emented by

e reflect

trolled by a

ishes to the

nels

chieve a

and support

absorbent

ss C or bette

cording to

or a reflective

n order to

ot always be

of 8

y

w.

m,

t a

er)

e

EFA PSBP

Andrew Pa

a.parkin@

P – Baseline De

arkin – Acoustic

@cundall.com

2.1.

2.1.

2.2 Env

Dou

acce

Air i

leve

Win

exce

leve

Ven

Spe

Whe

cros

targ

2.3 Sou

Sou

syst

targ

Whe

the

esigns: Acoustic

cs Partner

.4 Sports

It is impo

the liste

must be

Absorpt

fair-face

above.

significa

.5 Single

Corridor

Class C

services

vironment

uble sided ve

eptable conc

nlets are in t

el attenuated

dows and no

eed the requ

els are higher

tilators to co

ecification and

ere spaces a

ss-talk will be

ets.

und Insula

nd insulation

tems with gy

ets.

ere glazed sc

partition they

cs Strategy

halls (seco

ortant to prov

ner plane. D

highly durab

ion is provide

ed, Class D a

The fair-face

ant amounts o

storey circ

rs and simila

sound abso

s.

tal Noise a

entilation is us

centrations of

the form of o

ventilators o

on-acoustic lo

ired Indoor A

r, then attenu

orridors are a

d minimise c

are mechanic

e required to

ation

n between cla

psum board

creens are u

y are installe

ondary sch

vide both ab

Due to the ac

ble.

ed by means

absorptive blo

ed blockwork

of diffusion.

culation sp

r spaces will

orption or bet

and Ventil

sed in the se

f carbon diox

opening wind

or chimneys

ouvres can b

Ambient Nois

uated forms

attenuated su

cross-talk atte

cally ventilate

maintain Ind

assroom and

lining and in

sed then the

ed within. Sim

hools)

sorption and

ctivities carrie

s of a perfora

ockwork from

k and profiles

pace/corrid

l be installed

tter, to contro

lation

econdary sch

xide in space

ows or louvr

to corridors a

be used whe

se Level by m

of ventilation

uch that they

enuation.

ed then appr

door Ambien

d office areas

nsulation as a

ese meet com

milarly, door

d diffusion, no

ed out in thes

ated roof line

m finished flo

s of the roof l

ors

with demou

ol sound and

hool classroo

es, wherever

es in the ext

and atria, allo

re the extern

more than 13

n would be re

meet the req

opriate contr

t Noise Leve

s is provided

appropriate t

mposite perfo

sets are aco

ot just at hig

se spaces, a

er (Class C o

oor level to a

line also act

untable ceilin

d provide goo

oms in order

r possible.

ternal façade

owing stack

nal noise lev

3 dB(A); if ex

equired.

quirements o

rols of noise

els and sound

d by metal st

to meet perfo

ormance req

oustically rate

Page 5 o

h level but in

all materials

or better) and

t least 3 m

to provide

gs having

od access to

to maintain

e, with high-

ventilation.

el does not

xternal noise

of the Output

level and

d insulation

ud partitionin

ormance

uirements of

ed to either

of 8

n

d

t

ng

f

EFA PSBP

Andrew Pa

a.parkin@

P – Baseline De

arkin – Acoustic

@cundall.com

mee

they

Floo

prov

add

adja

finis

2.4 Rai

Con

roof

supp

2.5 Alte

Whe

ope

and

only

esigns: Acoustic

cs Partner

et single figur

y are installed

ors are of con

vides levels o

itional attenu

acencies dem

shes.

in Noise

ncrete roofs c

fs incorporate

press impact

ernative P

ere it is not p

rational or he

their Techni

y to the exten

cs Strategy

re criteria for

d within.

ncrete constr

of vertical so

uation in the

mand addition

control noise

e compresse

t-generated n

Performan

possible to co

ealth & safet

cal Advisors

nt set out in p

r the type of

ruction to fac

ound insulatio

form of float

nal attenuati

e generated b

ed mineral fib

noise.

ce Standa

omply with th

ty reasons, a

s, then a rela

performance

room or com

cilitate passiv

on appropriat

ing floors or

on. Impact s

by heavy rain

bre insulation

ards (APS

he new-build

and this non-c

xation in per

tables for re

mposite value

ve cooling via

te for most a

mass barrier

sound insula

n on roofs in

n under the to

) and Refu

criteria of th

compliance i

rformance tar

efurbishment

es of the ove

a thermal ma

adjacencies,

r ceilings wh

ation is contro

many areas

op liner shee

urbishmen

he Output Sp

is sanctioned

rgets is perm

t standards.

Page 6 o

rall partition

ass. This

requiring

ere

olled by floor

. Lightweigh

et in order to

nt

pecification fo

d by the EFA

missible, but

of 8

r

ht

or

A

EFA PSBP

Andrew Pa

a.parkin@

3.

P – Baseline De

arkin – Acoustic

@cundall.com

Baselithroug

esigns: Acoustic

cs Partner

ne Secgh dinin

cs Strategy

condarng hall

ry schol

ool (supperblocck) – s

Soundto

Soundto un

ba

Absorbto

Acoudoors

Page 7 o

section

d absorption o soffit

d absorption nderside of alconies

bent panels o walls

stically rateds to teachingspaces

of 8

d g

EFA PSBP

Andrew Pa

a.parkin@

4.

P – Baseline De

arkin – Acoustic

@cundall.com

Baselithroug

esigns: Acoustic

cs Partner

ne Secgh teac

cs Strategy

condarching s

ry schospaces

ool (fing

ger bloock) – s

Suspended absorb

Class A abswall pan

Attenuatedlevel vent

either sidglazed p

Concretprovides ra

cont

Sound absto circulatio

Page 8 o

section

Class A ers

sorbent nels

d high ilators de of panel

te roof ain noise rol

sorption on space

of 8

n

Asia Australia Europe MENA UK

www.cundall.com© Cundall Johnston & Partners LLP