Upload
lytruc
View
218
Download
2
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Stanley ScottInterviewer
Con neCtions
LeRoy Crandall
The EERI Oral History Series
Co
nn
eC
ti
on
s T
he EE
RI O
ral History Series
LeR
oy Crandall
CandallCoverFBS.indd 1 9/9/08 12:28:25 PM
T h e E E R I O r a l H i s t o r y S e r i e s
ConneCtions
LeRoy Crandall
T h e E E R I O r a l H i s t o r y S e r i e s
ConneCtions
LeRoy Crandall
Stanley Scott, Interviewer
Earthquake Engineering Research Institute
Editor: Gail Hynes Shea, Berkeley, California, www.gailshea.com
Cover and book design: Laura H. Moger, Moorpark, California, www.lauramoger.com
Copyright 2008 by the Earthquake Engineering Research Institute
The publication of this book was supported by FEMA/U.S. Department of Homeland Security under grant #EMW-2004-CA-0297.
All rights reserved. All literary rights in the manuscript, including the right to publish, are reserved to the Earthquake Engineering Research Institute and the Bancroft Library of the University of California at Berkeley. No part may be reproduced, quoted, or transmitted in any form without the written permission of the executive director of the Earthquake Engineering Research Institute or the Director of the Bancroft Library of the University of California at Berkeley. Requests for per-mission to quote for publication should include identification of the specific passages to be quoted, anticipated use of the passages, and identification of the user.
The opinions expressed in this publication are those of the oral history subject and do not neces-sarily reflect the opinions or policies of the Earthquake Engineering Research Institute or the University of California.
Published by the Earthquake Engineering Research Institute
499 14th Street, Suite 320 Oakland, CA 94612-1934 Tel: (510) 451-0905 Fax: (510) 451-5411 E-mail: [email protected] Website: http://www.eeri.org
EERI Publication Number: OHS-15
Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication DataCrandall, LeRoy, 1917- LeRoy Crandall / Stanley Scott, interviewer. p. cm. -- (Connections: the EERI oral history series ; 15) Includes index. “This oral history volume is the completion of the interview sessions Stanley Scott (1921-2002) conducted with LeRoy Crandall in 1989, 1990, and 1991, which provide most of the content of this book, and in a final interview between Scott and Crandall in 2000 that is included as the last chapter of this volume”--Forward. ISBN 978-1-932884-38-8 (pbk. : alk. paper) 1. Crandall, LeRoy, 1917---Interviews. 2. Civil engineers--California--Interviews. 3. Earthquake engineering--California--History. I. Scott, Stanley, 1921-2002. II. Earthquake Engineering Research Institute. III. Title. TA140.C74C73 2008 624.1’51092--dc22 [B] 2008034716 Printed in the United States of America
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 20 19 18 17 16 15 14 13 12 11 10 09 08
�
table of Contents
The EERI Oral History Series vii
Foreword by Robert Reitherman xi
Personal Introduction by Marshall Lew xiii
Chapter 1 Early Years Through High School 1
Chapter 2 San Diego State 5
Chapter 3 University of California at Berkeley 9
Chapter 4 Working for Dames and Moore 15
Chapter 5 LeRoy Crandall and Associates 25
Chapter 6 Development of Soil Engineering 31
Chapter 7 Engineering Geology and Geotechnical Engineering 39
Chapter 8 Soil Engineering and Earthquake Engineering 49
Chapter 9 Contributions of an Older Generation 83
Chapter 10 California Seismic Safety Commission 93
Chapter 11 Concluding Words in 2000 101
Photographs 105
Index 115
�ii
the eeRi oral History seriesThis is the fifteenth volume in the Earthquake Engineering Research Institute’s series, Connections: The EERI Oral History Series. EERI began this series to preserve the recollections of some of those who have had pioneering careers in the field of earthquake engineering. Significant, even revolutionary, changes have occurred in earthquake engineering since individuals first began thinking in modern, scientific ways about how to protect construction and society from earthquakes. The Connections series helps document this important history.
Connections is a vehicle for transmitting the fascinating accounts of individuals who were present at the beginning of important developments in the field, documenting sometimes little-known facts about this history, and recording their impressions, judgments, and experiences from a personal standpoint. These reminiscences are themselves a vital contribution to our understanding of where our current state of knowledge came from and how the overall goal of reducing earthquake losses has been advanced. The Earthquake Engineering Research Institute, incorporated in 1948 as a nonprofit organization to provide an institutional base for the then-young field of earthquake engineering, is proud to help tell the story of the development of earthquake engineering through the Connections series. EERI has grown from a few dozen individuals in a field that lacked any significant research funding to an organization with nearly 3,000 members. It is still devoted to its original goal of investigating the effects of destructive earthquakes and publishing the results through its reconnaissance report series. EERI brings researchers and practitioners together to exchange information at its annual meetings and, via a now-extensive calendar of conferences and workshops, provides a forum through which individuals and organizations of various disciplinary backgrounds can work together for increased seismic safety.
The EERI oral history program was initiated by Stanley Scott (1921-2002). The first nine volumes were published during his lifetime, and manuscripts and interview transcripts he left to EERI are resulting in the publication of other volumes for which he is being posthumously credited. In addition, the Oral
�iii
History Committee is including further interviewees within the program’s scope, following the Committee’s charge to include subjects who: 1) have made an outstanding career-long contribution to earthquake engineering, 2) have valuable first-person accounts to offer concerning the history of earthquake engineering, and 3) whose backgrounds, considering the series as a whole, appropriately span the various disciplines that are included in the field of earthquake engineering.
Scott’s work, which he began in 1984, summed to hundreds of hours of taped interview sessions and thousands of pages of transcripts. Were it not for him, valu-able facts and recollections would already have been lost.
Scott was a research political scientist at the Institute of Governmental Studies at the University of California at Berkeley. He was active in developing seismic safety policy for many years, and was a member of the California Seismic Safety Com-mission from 1975 to 1993. Partly for that work, he received the Alfred E. Alquist Award from the Earthquake Safety Foundation in 1990.
Scott received assistance in formulating his oral history plans from Willa Baum, Director of the University of California at Berkeley Regional Oral History Office, a division of the Bancroft Library. Following his retirement from the University in 1989, Scott continued the oral history project. For a time, some expenses were paid from a small grant from the National Science Foundation, but Scott did most of the work pro bono. This work included not only the obvious effort of preparing for and conducting the interviews themselves, but also the more time-consuming tasks of reviewing transcripts and editing the manuscripts to flow smoothly.
The Connections oral history series presents a selection of senior individuals in earthquake engineering who were present at the beginning of the modern era of the field. The term “earthquake engineering” as used here has the same meaning as in the name of EERI—the broadly construed set of disciplines, including geosciences and social sciences as well as engineering itself, that together form a related body of knowledge and collection of individuals that revolve around the subject of earthquakes. The events described in these oral histories span many kinds of activities: research, design projects, public policy, broad social aspects, and education, as well as interesting personal aspects of the subjects’ lives.
ix
Published volumes in Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
Henry J. Degenkolb 1994John A. Blume 1994Michael V. Pregnoff and John E. Rinne 1996George W. Housner 1997William W. Moore 1998Robert E. Wallace 1999Nicholas F. Forell 2000Henry J. Brunnier and Charles De Maria 2001Egor P. Popov 2001Clarence R. Allen 2002Joseph Penzien 2004Robert Park and Thomas Paulay 2006Clarkson W. Pinkham 2006Joseph P. Nicoletti 2006LeRoy Crandall 2008
eeRi oral History Committee
Robert Reitherman, ChairWilliam AndersonRoger BorcherdtGregg BrandowRicardo DobryRobert HansonLoring A. Wyllie, Jr.
xi
This oral history volume is the culmination of interview sessions Stanley Scott (1921-2002) conducted with LeRoy Crandall in 1989, 1990, and 1991, which provide most of the content of this book, and in a final interview between Scott and Crandall in 2000 that is included as the last chapter in this volume. I edited and reorganized the manuscript to condense and place together discussions that occurred at different times and are related to the same topic. That editing did not change the substance of what was said, and in cases where it is important to know the date when the interview occurred, it is noted. Footnotes and photographs have also been added to complete the work. Two members of the Oral History Committee, Loring Wyllie and Ricardo Dobry, reviewed the manuscript. In addition to writing the personal introduction, Marshall Lew also reviewed a draft and provided comments and corrections.
Gail Shea, consulting editor to EERI, carefully reviewed the entire manuscript and prepared the index, as she has on previous Connections volumes, and Eloise Gilland, the Editorial and Publications Manager of EERI, also assisted in seeing this publication through to completion.
Robert ReithermanChair, EERI Oral History CommitteeJune 2008
Foreword
xiii
Personal introduction
I have had the privilege to know LeRoy Crandall for almost all of my professional career as a geotechnical and earthquake engineer. I interned at LeRoy Crandall and Associates in the early 1970s while a graduate student at UCLA, and later joined his firm on a full-time basis in 1977 after one year as an underpaid Assistant Professor at California State University, Long Beach.
LeRoy was the engineer’s engineer. He knew everyone and everyone knew him, or at least knew of him. He was connected with every big name architect and structural engineer in southern California. He was also known as the King of Downtown Los Angeles and Mr. High-rise, as LeRoy was the geotechnical engineer for almost every high-rise building in downtown Los Angeles and other areas in southern California during the heyday of tall buildings in the 1960s, 70s, 80s, and into the 90s.
LeRoy was a great person to work for. He surrounded himself with talented associates that formed the nucleus of what was the most prominent geotechnical consulting firm in southern California for decades, LeRoy Crandall and Associates. His earliest associates were Fred Barnes, Leopold Hirschfeldt, and Russ Weber; together they were the “Big Four.” They were later joined by Jimmy Kirkgard, Jim McWee, Perry Maljian, Seymour Chiu, Robert Chieruzzi, and Jim van Beveren. Glenn Brown joined as an associate when LeRoy Crandall and Associates merged with Glenn A. Brown and Associates to add engineering geology expertise to the company. I was the last associate to join in 1979. LeRoy Crandall and Associates was supported by the most loyal employees, who worked long and hard to provide the best service to LeRoy’s clients. Working for LeRoy was like working for family, and he treated everyone with respect and concern for their well-being.
LeRoy was and still is hard working—since his retirement from Law/Crandall in 1999, LeRoy has enjoyed his “retirement” by not working Saturdays and Sundays. His business ethic is “Do the work right and don’t worry about the budget,” because in the end, LeRoy believes that everything will work out.
xi�
LeRoy was not afraid to innovate. He pioneered the use of tied-back shoring in southern California, which made possible very deep excavations for the new high-rise buildings when Los Angeles eliminated the 13-story height limit in the 1950s. LeRoy was also involved with the planning and development of the first base-isolated building in the United States, the Foothill Communities Law and Justice Center in Rancho Cucamonga, San Bernardino County, California, not far from the San Andreas fault.
He emphasized professionalism and instilled a sense of pride in our work. He also encouraged participation in professional societies and giving to the community. He served on the Board of the Los Angeles YMCA and had a remarkable attendance record for his fifty years in Rotary International. He was heavily involved with the Structural Engineers Association of Southern California and served on the Board of Directors of the Earthquake Engineering Research Institute, American Society of Civil Engineers, and American Council of Engineering Companies. LeRoy encouraged his associates and employees to also serve in professional societies and contribute to the profession and the public. He was instrumental in the establishment of the ASCE Technical Council on Lifeline Earthquake Engineering. He was an early supporter of the California Strong Motion Instrumentation Program and was appointed to the California Seismic Safety Commission by Governor Jerry Brown and reappointed by Governor Ronald Reagan. His contributions to seismic safety and geotechnical engineering are generally unheralded, but are significant and visionary.
It is hard to not love LeRoy Crandall. He is not afraid to kick you in the rear end when you need it, but he is always encouraging and compassionate. His enthusiasm is contagious, and he is an inspiration.
Marshall LewMACTEC Engineering and Consulting, Inc.Los Angeles, CaliforniaNovember 2007
T h e E E R I O r a l H i s t o r y S e r i e s
ConneCtions
LeRoy Crandall
Chapter 1
Early Years Through High School
�
I am Lionel LeRoy Crandall, and with that
name I often thought my parents must
have anticipated I would be poet laureate
of the United States.
Crandall: IamLionelLeRoyCrandall,andwiththatnameIoftenthoughtmyparentsmusthaveanticipatedIwouldbepoetlaureateoftheUnitedStates.IwasbornonFebruary4,1917,inPortland,Oregon.IhaveabrothertwoandahalfyearsolderthanI,namedClif-ford.Unfortunately,mymotherpassedawayshortlyafterIwasborn.ThefamilymovedtoSanDiegowhenIwasafewmonthsold,somyentirechildhoodwasspentinSanDiego.Istillthinkitisoneofthegreatestplaceswhereonecangrowup.
Myfathermarriedagain,andmybrotherstayedwithhim.Iwasraisedbymypaternalgrandparents.Lateron,whenIwassix,mybrotheralsocametolivewithus.Somygrandparentsraisedbothmybrotherandme.
MyearlyrecollectionsweregoingtogrammarschoolinSanDiego.IattendedJeffersonGrammarSchool,then
Chapter 1 Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
�
RooseveltJuniorHighSchoolandSanDiegoHighSchool.Iwasagoodstudentandenjoyedschool.Ididbetteringrammarschoolandjuniorhigh,particularlyinjuniorhigh,whereIwasoneofthetophonorstudents,andIwaspresidentofmyseventhgradeclass.Iwasheavilyintoactivitieswiththedramaticclub.
ThenIwenttoSanDiegoHigh.Otheractivi-tiesseemedtoenterintomylife,andIdidn’tputasmuchtimeintothescholarlywork.
Scott: Youspentmoretimeonyoursociallife?
Crandall: No,notreally.Iwasinthedramaticclubandwasinsomeplays,butthefamilywasn’twealthy,soIworked.Ihadapaperroute,anddidthingsofthatsort.OnSaturdaysIworkedinSafewaystores—calledHellerStoresinthosedaysinSanDiego—doingthingslikesackingpotatoesforadollaraday.
Iwasalsoapalofmyolderbrotherandothersinhisagegroup.Theyweren’tparticularlyinterestedinschool—especiallymybrother.Hegraduatedfromhighschool,butwasn’touttosetanyrecordsscholastically.
Soinshort,Ijustdidn’tdevotethetimetoschool.ButIdidgetoutofhighschoolwithaB+average.IjustdidnothaveallAs,asIhadinjuniorhigh.Ihadacoupleofstudentbodypositionsinhighschool,butmostlyIwasinthedramaticclub.
Asfarasinfluencesonmeinschool,twoteachersinSanDiegoHighSchoolwerethemostimportant.AMissCuppwastheEnglishteacher.Shewasahardtaskmaster,butwereallylearnedagreatdealaboutEnglishinthatclass.Theotherwasaphysicsteacher,Rex
Doughty,whomIadmired.Wegotalongfine,partlybecausehisnamewasRex,whichmeans“king”inLatin,andmyname,LeRoy,alsomeansking,inFrench.IwasveryinterestedinLatinclass.Ienjoyedphysicsverymuch.Iwasalsogoodinmathematics.
Afterhighschool,therewasnoreadilyavail-ableopportunityformetogodirectlytocol-lege.ItooktheexaminationforappointmenttoAnnapolis,whichwasgivenwhenIfinishedhighschool.Ididn’tfinishontop,sothatop-portunityslippedby.
InordertoaccumulatesufficientfundstogotocollegeafterIfinishedhighschool,Istayedoutandworked.Iworkedfull-timeforSafe-wayStores,whichwasquiteanordealinthosedays,inthe1930s.Yougot$12aweekandworkedsixdaysaweek.Saturdaynightwasinventorynightinthestore,soonSaturdaynightsyou’dfinishuparoundtenoreleven.Ithinkitwasaboutafifty-hourtosixty-hourworkweekatleast,whichwasn’tbad.Inevermindedwork.ThenIleftSafewayandgotajobdrivingadrycleaningdeliverytruck.Igot$14aweekthere,forsixdaysaweek.
Scott: Pickingupdrycleaning?
Crandall: That’sright.Pickingupanddeliv-eringandsoon.IgottoknoweverystreetinSanDiegobynameandlocation.
ThenIworkedforalittlelocaltheaterinmyneighborhood,intheNorthParkareaofSanDiego.Iwasraisedinthatonearea.Wemovedfrequently.Mygrandmotherfeltthatifyoustayedinahousemorethanayear,somethingwaswrong.I’dcomehomefromschoolandfindthatwehadmoved.Theyweren’ttrying
�
Chapter 1LeRoy Crandall • Early Years Through High School
toabandonme,andalwaysleftinstructionsastowheretheyhadgone.Inanyevent,wemovedalot,butmostlyalwaysstayedinthesamegeneralarea.
Iworkedforthetheater,asmallmoviehouse,whichcostonlya35-cententrychargeinthosedays.Thisworkwasmuchclosertohome,hadbetterhoursandImade$14aweek.ButIworkedsevendaysaweekthere,doingevery-
thingfromcleaningupinthemorningtoclos-
ingtheshowatnight.TheonlythingIdidn’t
dowasruntheprojector.That,ofcourse,was
beyondakidofmyage.
Scott: Howoldwereyou?
Crandall: Abouteighteen.Ihadfinishedhigh
school,andforawhile,thatwasitforeducation.
Chapter 2
San Diego State
�
Of the various science and math
opportunities, civil engineering struck me
as a good one, though I didn’t really know
much about that profession.
Crandall: Afterayearandahalfofworking,however,
IdecidedthatifIwasevergoingtocollege,I’dbet-
termakeabreak.Ihadsavedupabout$200,whichI
thoughtwouldhelpme.ButjustbeforeIsigneduptogo
tocollege,mygrandmotherhadtohaveanoperation,
andmy$200joinedthefamilyfundstohelppayforthat.
InFebruaryof1937Imadethedecisiontostartcollege
anyway,andIamcertainlygladIdidthen.
Scott:: Eventhoughyourgrandmotherhadtheopera-
tion,andthattookyoursavings,youstillmanagedtogo
aheadwithschool?
Crandall: Iwentonashoestring,andwenttoSan
DiegoStateCollege,nowSanDiegoStateUniver-
sity,whichwasnearby.Thefeeswereminimal.Idon’t
rememberexactly,butitprobablycost$15toenroll,
somethinglikethat.IalsoworkedSaturdays,whichgot
methroughallright,andIlivedathome.Weweren’t
Chapter 2 Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
�
starving—Idonotmeantoimplythat.Buttherewasn’tagreatdealofmoney,either.
Choosing to Major in Civil EngineeringCrandall: IshouldsaysomethingabouthowIdecidedonmycareer.WhenImissedgettingintoAnnapolis,ItookstockofwhatIthoughtweremyattributesandinterests.Itkeptcom-ingoutthatscienceandmathematicswerethesubjectsthatIfeltIwouldliketobeinandwasgoodat.Ofthevariousscienceandmathopportunities,civilengineeringstruckmeasagoodone,thoughIdidn’treallyknowmuchaboutthatprofession.
Scott:: Youmean,havingsomeemploymentopportunity?
Crandall: Ididn’tthinkaboutajobsomuch,becauseatthatstageoflifeIwasn’tastuteenoughtocheckthatout.ButIdidfeelthatIwouldliketobeinvolvedinbuildingthings.Ihadnobasisforselectingcivilengineering,otherthanwhatIthoughtmyinterestsandaptitudeswere.
AtthattimeSanDiegoStateonlyhadatwo-yearprograminthelowerdivision,thefreshmanandsophomoreyears.Igotstartedasemesterearlyinthespring,whichwasveryfortunatebecauseImanagedtobuildupafewunits.Igotgoodgradesinthingslikefresh-manEnglishandthehistoryclasses,afewthingslikethatwhichwereavailable,becauseIcouldn’tstartanyoftheengineeringyet.AtthattimeyouhadtowaitfortheFallsemestertostarttheengineering.SoIgotaboutsixteenunitsofsupplementalmaterialundermybelt,
whichhelpedmelater,becausethenIcouldtakealesserworkloadofelectives.Italsogavemeachancetogetacademicallyorientedandbackintostudying.
IstartedwithengineeringclassesinSeptemberof1937.Ienrolledinengineering,whichwasageneralcourseatthattime,butyoutookmath-ematicsandcalculus,andsurveyingwasalsoarequirementforcivilengineeringthen.Itookthesurveyingclass,wasproficientinit,andlatergotanassistantshiphelpingthesurveyinginstructor,lookingaftertheequipmentandassistingwiththestudents.
SanDiegoStatehadsomeexcellentfaculty,whowereveryinterestedintheirstudents’welfare,especiallythemathteacher,JohnGleason,whoalsotaughtsurveying.Ihadsu-percoursesinchemistry,geology,andphysics.Thoseweregoodpreparatorycoursesforme.Inthesophomoreyear,youwouldbegintogetintosomeengineering,mostlymechanicalengi-neering,becausetheonefacultymemberwhotaughtengineeringsubjectswasamechanicalengineer.Sowegotsomebasicsubjectsoutofthewayatthatpoint.
Summer WorkCrandall: InthesummersIworkedattheSafewayStoresagain.Theywereverygoodtome.Theydidn’tpaywell,butatleastIcouldgetajobthere.Youwereneverexactlysurewhereyouweregoingtobeassigned.Forexample,IlivedinNorthPark,thenortheastportionofSanDiegocity,andtheysentmetoastoreinCoronado.SoIhadtotakethestreetcarfromhomedowntotheferryslip,transfertotheferry,crosstoCoronadoIsland,
�
Chapter 2LeRoy Crandall • San Diego State
thentakethestreetcaragainforanothertwoorthreemilesintodowntownCoronadotowork.Thisisaboutanhourandahalftripeachway.Safewayworkeduslonghours,soIwasprettywelloccupiedjustgettingtoandfromworkanddoingthework.LaterIwasluckyandtheytransferredmetoastoreclosertohome.Igotprettygoodintheproducedepartment,workingasastockboyandthatkindofthing.Ienjoyedthatwork,andmeetingpeople.
Afterfinishingthesophomoreyear,IplannedtotransfertotheUniversityofCaliforniaatBerkeley.Atthattime,theonlyschoolsinCaliforniathatgaveadegreeincivilengineer-ingwereBerkeley,Stanford,Caltech,andtheUniversityofSouthernCalifornia(USC).NotevenUCLAhadupperdivisionengineeringclassesasofthen.So,havingrathernominalfinancialresources,IchoseBerkeley.
Surveying Class in the SierrasCrandall: InordertograduatefromBerke-leyincivilengineering,youhadtohavetwosummerclassesinsurveying.TheCalschedulewasdifferentfromtheotherschools—theystartedinAugustandfinishedinMay.SinceIdidn’tgetoutofSanDiegoStateuntilJuneof1939,itwastoolatetoenrollintheBerkeleysummersurveyingclassthatyear.
Fortunately,FresnoStateCollegehadasur-veyingclass,calledtheSierrasummerschool.Wehadaboutasix-weekclassatHuntingtonLakeintheSierraNevadaupaboveFresno.MostofthestudentstherewerefromFresnoState,butthereweretwofromSanDiegoState,myselfandmyroommate,BillBrewer,wholaterwentontoCalwithme.AtHun-
tingtonLakewemadealifelongfriend,IrvanMendenhall,whoistheMendenhallinthearchitectural-engineeringfirmDaniel,Mann,Johnson,andMendenhall.Irvanwasalsotak-ingthatsurveyingclass.
Whenfinishingmysophomoreyear,Iwasse-lectedtoreceiveanawardfromtheSanDiegochapteroftheAmericanSocietyofCivilEn-gineers(ASCE).Itwasthefirststudentawardtheygave.Istillhavethepicturethatappearedinthenewspaperatthetime.Itwasfor$25,whichmadethedifferencebetweenmegoingornotgoingtothesummerschoolclass.IthinkoneofthepeoplewhowereinvolvedinsettingupthatawardwasPaulBeerman,presidentofthatchapteratthetime.Withouttheaward,Iwouldnothavehadthecashtopaythefeeforthissummerschool.
WehadsomeexcitingtimesdrivingtoandfromHuntingtonLake.BillBrewer,whomI’vementioned,hadaModelAFord,andwehookedupmyfather’slittleopentrailertocarryourstuff.WedrovefromSanDiegotoHuntingtonLakeandhadacoupleofnearmissesandcollisions.
Once,comingbackdown,Billwasdriving,andhewasunawarethatwewereonthissteepgrade,TollhouseGrade,Ithinkitwascalled.AndthispoorlittleModelAdidn’thavemuchinthewayofbrakes.Wegotstartedcomingdownthathill,andIthoughtitwascurtainsforus.Billputthefootbrakeon,andIpulledontheemergencybrake,andwegotitshiftedfromhightosecond,andeventuallydowntolow,andwefinallypulledovertothesideofthissteepcorkscrewroad.Webothchangedourshortsandcontinuedtodrivehome.
Chapter 3
University of California at Berkeley
�
It was the New Deal student job
assignment that put me into the Berkeley
soil mechanics lab.
Crandall: BillBrewerandI,againusinghisModelA,droveuptoBerkeley.WerentedanapartmentwithtwootherSanDiegofellowsthatwejusthappenedtorunintothere.Itwasonthesouthsideofthecampus,andIrememberthatitwas$25amonthforthefourofus,inatwo-roomapartment.Ithadakitchen,whichweneverreallyusedbecausenoneofuscookedorcaredaboutcooking.Wedidn’tfindoutuntilafterwehadlocatedaplacetolivethattheengineeringschoolwasonthenorthsideofthecampus,andwewerelivingfourblockssouthofthecampus.Sowehadanicelittlehikebackandforth.
Iwasveryfortunateandwasgrantedascholarshipof$100peryear.ItwasascholarshipthataHolmesfamilyhadcreatedinmemoryoftheirdeceasedson.TheUCfeesatthattimeincludedtheregistrationfeeof$27.50,
Chapter 3 Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
10
andalaboratoryfeeforengineeringandscien-tificcoursesof$17.50.Soatthattime,itcostme$45asemestertogotoBerkeley.
Ontopofthatyouhadtobuyyourbooksandthingsofthatsort.MostofthetimeIscroungedbooksfrommyroommates,orwenttothelibrary,buttherewereafewkeybooksthatIwasabletobuyused.Thatkeptmeprettybroke.Irememberhavingonlyanickelinmypocketfortwoorthreeweeksatatime.
Wedidn’tspendverymuch.Iwenttothethe-aterwiththeboysonetime.Imanagedtogettotwoofthefootballgames.OnewaswhenCalplayedMichigan,andTomHarmonwasthebigrageonthefootballfield.Thatwasthegamewhenhewasrunningawayforatouch-downandsomedrunkenpersoncameoutofthestandsandtriedtotacklehim.TomHar-monlethimhaveastraight-armandknockedthisguyforafewloops.
Ifoundajobwashingdishesinasmallrestau-rantrunbyaGreekfellow.Ididdishesformymeals,manyofwhichIdidn’teat,becausethiswasarealgreasyspoonrestaurant.
Scott: Youdidn’tlikethefoodallthatmuch?
Crandall: Thefoodwasn’tthatgood.Themostimportantthingonthemenuwasaribsteakforthirty-fivecents.Iworkedmylittlebuttoffdoingdishes.Itwasreallyahecticatmosphere.TheGreekownerwouldscreamandswearatthehelp,notatmesomuch,butatsomeoftheothers.OneboytherewasaJewishfellow,andtheGreekguywouldalwaysmalignhimsomethingawful.
Classeswereinteresting,andIdidwell.Inthefallof1939,IappliedforajobwiththeNYA,theNationalYouthAdministration,whichatthattimewastheNewDealgov-ernmentagencythathelpedpoorboysgothroughschool.Ithinkthepaywas40centsanhour,andIwasallowedtenhoursaweekmaximum.
Iguessitwasastrokeofluck,butthroughnoeffortofmyownIwasassignedbytheNYAtothesoilmechanicslaboratory,aswecalleditinthosedays,whichwasjustgettingunderway.IthinkBerkeleyhadstartedittheyearbefore,maybeinlate1938orinthespringsemesterof1939.
Scott: Sothefactthatyouwererandomlyassignedtoworkinthesoilmechanicslabiswhatgaveyouyourfirstexperiencewithwhatwouldlaterbeyourcareer?
Crandall: Yes.ItwastheNewDealstudentjobassignmentthatputmeintotheBerkeleysoilmechanicslab.
Professor Harmer DavisCrandall: HarmerDaviswastheprofessorofthegraduatesoilmechanicscourse.HarmerhadbeenanoutstandingstudentatCal,andwasthenaveryyoungprofessor.Whilehedidn’tlikeit,everybodybutmecalledhim“Stinky”Davis,afteracartooncharacteratthattime.Inordertolookolder,Harmersmokedapipeandappearedverygruff,formal,andformidable,buthewasreallyaniceguy.Igotassignedtohim.Harmerlaterspecializedintransportationengineeringandwaschairofthecivilengineeringdepartment.
11
Chapter 3LeRoy Crandall • University of California at Berkeley
Isweptoutthesoillab,whichwasjustget-tingstarted.Thesoilmechanicslabhadacornerassignedtoitintheengineeringmaterialslaboratorybuilding,inwhichtherewassomeoldcabinetry.Ipaintedeverythinggrayanddidthingsofthatsort.Ihelpedoutoccasionallywithsomeofthestudentstakingthecourse.
Wealsohadanengineerthereworkinginthesoilmechanicslaboratory,notfortheuniver-sitybutfortheBureauofReclamation.AveryfinemannamedThomasLeps.TomLepswasvery,veryfriendlytomeandhelpful,andcon-tributedmuchtomyinterestinsoils.
Ialsomadegoodfriendswiththeotherstaffattheengineeringlaboratory.Theyhadamachineshopthere,andabunchofreallyfineguyswhowerealwaysplayingpracticaljokesandthings.AfellownamedJoeBan-ville,whowascalled“TheScoutmaster,”wastheheadofallthestaffintheengineeringlaboratory.UnderhimwasaveryfinemannamedEldonWhinier.Whit,astheycalledhim,kindoftookaninterestinme,tothepointwhere,whenIwasgraduatingandtheseniorballwasformal,Whinierloanedmethetuxedohehadwornwhenhewasmar-ried,becauseIdidn’tfeelthatIcouldaffordatuxforthat.Incidentally,myfiancéehadcomeupforthegraduation,soIwasgo-ingtotheball.Thesemenwerethepeoplewhobuilttheexperimentsforthegraduatestudentsandtookcareofthebigtestingmachine,thelargestoneintheUnitedStatesIthink.
Scott: Whatkindoftestingwasitusedfor?
Crandall: Materialstestingforsteelandconcrete.Itwasaboutthree-storieshigh.1RaymondE.Daviswasreallytheheadfacultypersoninthelaboratory,andDavisHallonthecampusisnamedafterthatDavis,notHarmer.
Inanyevent,backtothesoilmechanicslab.IworkedfortheNYAtenhoursaweek,Ithinkitwas.Wewerelimitedtothatbecausetheywantedyoutogetyourstudiesdone.DuringthefirstyearIsweptoutanddidmundanethings,butinthesecondyear,HarmerDaviswasdesigninganapparatusforcompactingsoils,andheputmeonthedrafting,whichIfranklywaslousyat.Notveryproductive.Itseemedtotakeforevertogetanythingdone,mostlybecauseI’dhavetopickitupandworkonitforonlytwoorthreehoursatatime,thenputitaway,thencomebackthenextdayandstartover.ButIdevelopedaninterestinsoilengineering,orsoilmechanics,whichwasthetermtheyusedthen.
1. Thetestingmachineiscapableoffourmillionpounds(18meganewtons)compressionandthreemillionpounds(13meganewtons)tension,andisstillinuse.AfewyearspriortothearrivalofCrandallatBerkeley,theUniversityacquiredtheapparatustotestlargeconcretecylinders,eighteeninchesindiameterandthreefeettall,withaggregatethesizeofbaseballs—samplesofmaterialbeingusedintheconstructionofHooverDam.AfterdecadesofserviceontheBerkeleycampus,themachinewasmovedtotheUniversity’snearbyRichmondFieldStationandbecamepartoftheEarthquakeEngineeringResearchCenterthere.Ithasbeenusedinseismictestingtoproviderealisticsimulationoflargegravityloadsonfull-scalecolumnswhilelateralforcesaresimultaneouslyexertedbyotherdevices.
Chapter 3 Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
12
Graduate Soil Mechanics CourseCrandall: WhenIfinishedmyjunioryearandgottobeasenior,IaskedifIcouldtakethegraduatesoilmechanicsclass.HarmerarrangeditsothatIcouldtakethecourseinmysenioryear,eventhoughitwasagraduatecourse.IdidwellatitandgotanA.
Inthosedays,wehadtodoathesistograduatewithourbachelor’sdegree.Theydon’tany-more,Ithink.TwootherfellowsandIdidourthesisoncompactingsoil.Itwasnothingearthshaking—anunintentionalpun—buttrodsomenewgroundinthefieldofcompactingsoilsinthelaboratory.Weputalotofhoursintotheproject.
HarmergavemeanAinthatclass.Itwastoughgoing,becauseabouttenortwelvestudentsweremilitarypeoplewhohadfinishedWestPointandweretakingengineering.TheyweregoingintotheCorpofEngineersfortheArmy,andhadcometoCalforagradu-atedegree.Theseguyswerebeingpaidtogotoschool.Also,mostofthemhadawifeathomewhocookedtheirmealsandeverything.Sotheywerereallyhittingthebookshard,atleastitseemedtome.Itwasatoughclass,andthegradingonthecurvewassevereonmosteverybodywhowasonlyaregularstudent.
Scott: SoyourAwasaprettygoodaccom-plishment.
Crandall: Yes.ThosewerethedayswhenanAwasanA.WhileatBerkeley,thefirstthingIdidwasjointheASCEstudentchapter,eventhoughitcost50cents.Imanagedtofindthatkindofmoneytojoin.Also,atthecompletionofmyjunioryearIwasinvitedtojoinTauBeta
Pi,theengineeringhonoraryfraternity,andChiEpsilon,thecivilengineeringhonoraryfraternity.Thosemembershipstogethercost$25.Iwenttotheadministrationofficeandlaidmyfinancialpositionbeforeoneoftheexecutives,andbeforeIknewit,theyhadcomeupwitha$25loanformetojointhesefrater-nities.Theythoughtitwouldbeagoodthingformetohaveonmyrecord.
Seeking EmploymentCrandall: Neartheendofmysenioryear,HarmerDavisarrangedforseveralofuswhohadtakenthesoilmechanicsclasstomeetwithaconsultingengineerfromsouthernCalifornianamedWilliamMoore,ofDamesandMoore.BillMoorecametoBerkeley,andaboutthreeofusandHarmermetwithhimforlunchattheFacultyClub.ItwasthefirsttimeIhadbeentotheFacultyClub,Imightsay.
BillsaidhewaslookingforsomeonepossiblytojointheirfirminLosAngeles.Ifwewereinterestedheaskedustosendanotetohimoutliningalittlebitaboutourselvesandwhatwewantedtodo.ThiswasprobablyearlyMay,1941,towardtheendofthesenioryear.Iwrotehimaletter.IstillhavetheletterIwrote,fromtheDamesandMoorefile.Buttimecrepton,andIhadn’theardfromDamesandMoore.Ithought,“Well,that’snotgoingtobeapossibility.”
SoBillBrewerandIandsomeothershoppedonthetrainforSacramentototalktotheStateDivisionofHighways,asitwascalledthen.NowitiscalledCaltrans.Theywerelookingforengineers.Thejobmarketwasstartingtoopenup.Priortothis,engineerswerehardly
13
Chapter 3LeRoy Crandall • University of California at Berkeley
abletofindanyworkatall.TherewasthewarinEurope,andtheUnitedStateswasbegin-ningtoseethatwehadtodosomething,espe-ciallylikesupplyingouralliesthroughLend-Lease,andothermattersthatwouldinvolveplantandfacilities.
TheDivisionofHighwayshadjustmadeachangeintheiropeningclassification.Origi-nally,youwouldstartupongraduationwithanengineeringdegreeasaseniorengineeringaide,whichpaid$140amonth.Thingshadim-provedintheconstructionindustrytothepointwheretheyweren’tgettinganyapplicantsforthat,andtheyupgradedthebeginningpositiontojuniorhighwayengineerat$170amonth.Well,thatmadeitalotmoreinteresting.
SoIwenttoSacramentoandtheyofferedmeajobinthelocationIhadaskedfor,myhometownofSanDiego.Ifeltitwouldgivemeachancetopayoffsomeofmydebtsattheuniversitywhilelivingathome.Besides,myfiancée,EileenExnicios,livedinSanDiego.SoIacceptedtheassignmentandtookthetrainbacktoBerkeley.
ThenextdayIgotaphonecall.Iwasliv-inginthetwo-storyapartmentbuildingonHasteStreetwithaboutsixteenunits.Thephonewasacommonphoneonthefirstfloor.Ourroomhadabuzzer.Thelandladywouldanswerthephone,andifitwasforyou,she’dgiveacertainbuzz.SoIgotbuzzedandwentdownstairs,anditwasBillMoorecalling.Hewantedtooffermeajob.
Well,Iwasgreatlyanxiousforthatjob.Iwasstillinschoolandhadn’tgraduatedyet,butIhadalreadysignedupforajobwiththeDivi-sionofHighways.Ihadtoldthem“Yes,”al-
thoughIhadn’tstartedworkatall.Billofferedmethejob,andIsaid,“Gee,I’dlovetohaveit,butI’vemadeacommitmenttotheDivisionofHighwaysandIhavetostaywiththem.”Hesaidthathewassorry.Sothatendedthat,atleastforthetimebeing.
California Division of HighwaysCrandall: May28,1941,wasgraduationday.WefinishedschoolandheadedbacktoSanDiego.Myfolkshadcomeupforthegradua-tion.Mygrandmother,whohadraisedme,hadpassedawaytheyearbefore,soshewasunabletoseethefirstmemberoftheCrandallfamilyfinishcollege.I’vealwaysregrettedthat,butmygrandfatherwasabletobethere.
WecamebacktoSanDiego,andIstartedwiththeDivisionofHighways.ThatwasthefirstofJuneof1941.EileenandIgotmarriedonSep-tember20,1941.Shortlyafterthat,IbecamedisenchantedwiththeCaliforniaDivisionofHighways.Theywereallnicepeople,very,veryfriendlyandkind,butIguessIwasn’tcutoutforcivilservice.Ihadinterestingassignments.Iparticipatedinthedesignofoneofthefirstcloverleaffreewayinterchanges.ThatshowsI’mgettingold,becausethatinterchangewastorndownabouttwentyyearsago.Atthetime,however,itwasalmostrevolutionaryforinterchanges.Theyalsoputmeinchargeoftheannualtrafficcount,whereIworkedunderRalphLuckenbach,whowasagreatmentor.
Ididthingsthatwereveryinterestingandenjoyable,butforonethingweonlyworked37.5hoursperweek.Youcouldn’tworkover-timeevenifyoudidn’tgetpaidforit,which
Chapter 3 Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
14
wedidn’t.Iwasn’tusedtojustturningofftheclocklikethat.
Theotherthingwasthatifyouweredesigninganything,theyhadamanual.Ifyouwerede-signingaculvert,youjustlookedinthemanualontherightpage,andpickedoutwhateveritwasyouweregoingtodesign.IfiguredIhadn’tspentfouryearsinschooltocopysome-thingoutofabook.
Moving to Dames and MooreCrandall: SoIdecidedtocheckwithDamesandMooreagain.EileenandIdroveuptoLosAngelesfromSanDiegoinourlittle1935Chevy.Thecarhadtroubleontheway,andIthinkwehadtogetanewclutch.Atthistime,therewastheLosAngelesofficeofDamesandMoore,andBillMoorewasjustbeginningto
starttheSanFranciscooffice.Itwaslate1941.ItwasAdmissionDay,andthestatepeoplegotaholiday,butotherpeoplehadtowork.IsawTrentDamesandBillMoorethereonthatday,andtheywerenice,buttheydidn’tfeeltheyhadanyopportunitiesatthemoment.Sowewentbackhome.
ThennotmorethanafewweekslaterBillMoorecalledmeoneeveningandsaidthatthey’dliketohireme.Isaid,“Whatarewetalkingaboutinpay?”Hesaid,“Howabout$170amonth?”Isaid,“That’swhatI’mmak-inghere.It’sgoingtocostmemoretomoveupandlivethere.”Hehemmedandhawedawhileandsaid,“Well,we’llmakeit$175.”Thatseemedliketheworldtome.Actually,Iwantedthejob.I’dprobablyhavegoneforlessthan$170.SoIaccepted.
Chapter 4
Working for Dames and Moore
15
We started out trying to sell the discipline of
soil mechanics to clients, and later had to
sell the idea that they should hire us rather
than all the other firms that started up.
Crandall: OnDecember17,1941,justtendaysafterPearlHarbor,IstartedmyemploymentwithDamesandMoore.Atthatpoint,nobodyknewwhatthedickenswasgoingtohappen.EileenandImoveduptoLosAngelesandfoundalittleapartmentaboutfourblocksawayfromtheoffice,whichwasatFifthStreetandFigueroaStreet,onthefifthflooroftheArchitectsBuilding,whichhassincebeentorndown.
BillMoorewasspendingmostofhistimeinSanFran-cisco.Idon’trememberifhehadmovedthereyetornot,buttheyhadplansforopeninganofficeinSanFrancisco,andBillwashandlingthatpart.IwasinLosAngeleswithDamesandMooreinsoilmechanicsandfoundationengineering,asitwascalledinthosedays.
WhenIstarted,inDecemberof1941,theyhadaleadengineerworkingthere,andIwasunderhim.Theyhad
Chapter 4 Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
16
acoupleofpeopleinthelaboratory,andaboutthreeorfouroutinthefieldtakingsamplesandcheckingcompaction.Ithinktherewasonesecretary,andTrentDames.Atmost,therewereabouteightortenpeopleintheofficeatthetime.
TheninaboutMarch1942,theleadengineerdecidedhewantedtodosomethingelse.Thewarwason.Hemovedintotheshipbuildingbusiness.Iwaspromotedtotheleadengineerinchargeofthelaboratoryandtheengineer-ingfunctions.Iwasnotchiefengineer—TrentDameswasthatatthetime.Iwasn’tregis-teredyet,ofcourse,soIguessyou’dsayIwasinchargeoftheofficeengineeringfunction.Gradually,Igotmoreandmoreresponsibility.In1944,Ibecameregisteredasacivilengi-neer,whichwasaboutasearlyasIcouldgetregistered,becauseyouhadtohaveacertainamountofexperiencetoqualifytotakethetest.Ipassedthetestandprettymuchrantheoffice.
Joining the Partnership
Crandall: In1947,TrentandBillofferedmeapartnershipinthefirm.Theyeachwere50-50partners,andeachgaveupsomeofit.Ihad14percentofthetotal,andlaterBillBrewer,whohadcometoworkforthecompanyinSanFranciscoandwasworkingwithBillMoore,becameapartner,alsoat14percent.
Iwastheresidentpartner,theycalledit,inchargeoftheLosAngelesofficefrom1947on.TheLosAngelesofficedidmorethanjustLosAngelesandsouthernCaliforniawork.Itwastheleadoffice,sowealsodidtheout-of-stateworkthroughthatoffice.
Scott: DidDamesandMoorealreadyhaveofficesaroundthecountry?
Crandall: No,therewereonlytwoofficesatthatpoint,andBillMoorehadn’treallybuiltuptoalargeofficeinSanFranciscoyet.Butwedidjobsallover,inotherstatessuchasHa-waiiandeveninothercountries,forexampleinHollandandIndia.
Wartime YearsScott: Beforeyougoon,couldIjustaskyoutotalkaboutthewartimeyears.WhatwastheimpactofWorldWarIIonDamesandMooreandontheworkyoudid—sayduringthepe-riodfromtheendof1941to1945,’46?
Crandall: Practicallyalltheworkdonewasinconnectionwiththemilitaryanddefense.Infact,thatwastrueofalmostallconstruction—therewasverylittlethatwasnotinfurtheranceofthewareffort.Forexample,weworkedontheairplanefactories,whichwereabigpartofourwork,andrunwaysandmilitaryencamp-ments.IrememberCampCook,forexample,upnearSantaBarbara.War-relatedworkintheSanDiegoareawasimportant.Wedidalotofpavingevaluationinthosedays.Theywerejustbeginningtocomeinwiththeheavierplanes,suchasthebombers,andtheoriginalairfieldpavingswerenotstandingup.Sowhatweweredoingthenweretheplateloadtests,bearingtests.We’dgetabigtruckwithsomeloadonit,andputajackbetweentheaxleandthegroundonaplateofacertainsize,andrunatest.TheCaliforniabearingratiotestwasdevisedjustaboutthen,too.Sotheevaluationofexistingrunwaysandofnewrunwayswasbecomingprominent.Untilthen,they’dbeendesignedby
17
Chapter 4LeRoy Crandall • Working for Dames and Moore
theseatofthepants.Wedidthesoilconsult-ingengineeringfortheDouglasAircraftplantinLongBeach,whichwasbuiltatthattime.LockheedandNorthAmericanAviationweregoingstrong.Allofthosefacilitieswererequir-ingsoilengineering—fortunatelyforus,sincetherewasn’tanythingelsetodo.
OneofthethingsthatdisturbedmewasmyfeelingthatIneededtocontributesomethingmoretothewareffort.IappliedforandwaspromisedacommissionintheNavySeabees,togooverseas.Theywerebuildingairfields,workingwithheavyequipment,andsoon.IthoughtIwouldbeagoodadditionthere,andwouldgetsomegoodexperience.AfacultymemberoftheUniversityofMichiganIbelieveitwas,namedBillHousel,whowasacommanderorcaptainorsometypeofofficerintheSeabees,wasputtingtogetheragroup.
Icontactedhimtoseeifhecoulduseasoilmechanic.Hepulledafewstrings.Iapplied,andwhileIhadhopedformore,theyofferedmeanensigncommissionintheNavy,withtheunderstandingthatIwouldbeassignedtothiskindofwork,withHousel’sgroup.Itwaspracticallyconsummated.Ihaddoneeverythingbutsignontheline.
Prevented From Enlisting in the Navy
Crandall: ItoldTrentDameswhatIwasdo-ing,thatIthoughtIcouldbeofmorevaluetothewareffortintheservice.HecontactedthedraftboardandtoldthemwhatkindofworkweweredoingatDamesandMooreandhowimportantthatwas,andthedraftboardissuedatelegram.IgotacopyofthetelegramtheysenttotheNavysayingtheywouldn’tletme
go.TheyfeltIwasmorevaluableincivilianwork.SoIdidn’tgo.
AtthetimeIwasveryunhappyaboutit.Itturnedout,however,thatthiswasoneofthegreatestthingsthateverhappenedtome,thefactthatIdidn’tgointotheNavy.Itwasgettingneartheendofthewar,andtheguyswhohadbeeninthelongest,justifiablywerebeingreleasedtheearliest.Theyhadthepoints,youknow.Iwouldhavegoneinattheend,andwouldprobablyhavesatatadesksomewhereforseveralyearsafterWorldWarII.
Scott: DidTrentDamestakethesestepsonhisown?
Crandall: Yes,hedid.Hedidn’ttellmeaboutituntilthewordcamethrough.Ialmostquit,Iwassoupsetaboutit.Youcouldn’tleaveajobinthosedays,andyoucouldn’tgetanyraisesoranything.Thejobmarketwascompletelyfrozen.
Scott: IguessDamesfeltmorallyjustified,inthathebelievedhehadmoreimportantbusi-nessforyoutodo?
Crandall: Yes,andhedidn’twanttoloseme.IguessIwasprettygood.Youcouldhardlygetengineersatthattime.IftheygraduatedthroughtheV-12programs,2orwhateverelse
2. TheV-12NavyCollegeTrainingProgram,begunin1943,wasdesignedtoprovidecollege-educatedofficersforthewareffort,contendingwiththeproblemthatthedraftageformaleswas18andpreventedthemfromattendingorgraduatingfromcollege.V-12studentsweretechnicallyalreadyintheserviceandunderwentsomemilitarytrainingwhilestudyingyear-round.Upongraduation,V-12studentsweresenttoNavyorMarinetrainingprogramsandbecameofficers.
Chapter 4 Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
18
theywerein,theywentrightintotheservice.IwasprettymuchresponsibleforrunningthewholedarnDamesandMooreshootingmatchinLosAngelesatthattime.Eventhen,Trenthadbigideasaboutstartinganinternationalorganization,andopeningofficesintherestoftheworld.
Scott: Andhedidn’twanthislocalorga-nizationfallingapartwhilehisattentionwasfocusedelsewhere?
Crandall: Hewantedtobefreetoplantheseotherthings.Itwasthewayheoperated.Iwasveryangryatfirst,butIsawthewarwaswind-ingdown.TheatomicbombsweredroppedonJapanaboutthattime,endingthewar.Soitturnedouttobeagoodthingforme,althoughIneverdidgettobeintheNavy.AsImen-tionedearlier,inhighschoolIhadaspirationsofgoingtoAnnapolis,sotheNavywasstillamatterofinteresttome.
Postwar WorkCrandall: NowImustrelateastorythathappenedafterthewar,whencivilianworkwasstartingupagain.DamesandMooresentmeonabusinessdevelopmenttriparoundquiteabitoftheUnitedStates.IremembergoingtoNewOrleans,Houston,St.Louis,Chicago,placeslikethat,tosoundouttheattitudeofpeopletowardsoilengineering.LaterthiswasfedintoTrentDames’smentalcomputerastowhetherornothewouldtrytoopenanofficeinsomeoftheseareas.
Inthosedayssoilmechanicswasbrandnew.DamesandMoorewassomethinglikethesecondorthethirdfirminsouthernCalifornia
todosoilwork.Mostengineersandarchitectsthoughtitwasalotofbaloney.Theyhadde-signedfoundationsforyearsbygoingoutandpushingtheirheelinthegroundandsaying,“That’sgoodfor4,000pounds”[4,000poundspersquarefoot]orgettinginformationfromabuildingnextdoorandapplyingthat.
Scott: Inthosedays,then,onlythepartofthestructurefromthegroundupwasconsid-eredimportant?
Crandall: Yes,fromthegroundup.Theat-titudewas:Whocaresaboutfoundations?Youjustpouredconcreteintothegroundanditusuallybehavedokay.
I’llneverforgetoneexperienceIhadinSeattle.Iwouldgothroughthephonebookandfindarchitects’namesandaddresses,andengineers,andstructuralpeople,andthenbeatontheirdoorsandtrytotellthemhowgreatsoilengi-neeringwas.Shouldn’ttheybeinterestedinasoilengineering,soilmechanicsfirm?
Well,thisoldarchitectlistenedtomystory,andfinallysaid,“Listen,son.Idon’tknowanythingaboutyourbusinessatall.ButIknowthis.NinetypercentofthebuildingsareheldupbyfrictionandthegraceofGod.”He’sprettyclosetoright,Ithink.Thatalwaysstuckwithme.
ButoneolderstructuralengineerinChicago,wholistenedtomepatientlyandwastryingtosweepmeundertherug,finallytoldmewhathedid.HehadtheRaymondConcretePileCompany,whichhadadrillingbusiness,goouttothesiteandtakesoilsamplesintheirlittlesampler.Theyputtheresults,whathecalled“ratturds”—theywereprettygood-sized
19
Chapter 4LeRoy Crandall • Working for Dames and Moore
ratturds—inaglassbottle.TheRaymondCompanywouldsendthebottlestothisguy,toseewhathewantedtodesignhisfoundationsfor.Hehadaroomfulofthesecardboardboxeswiththeselittlebottlesofsoilsamples.
Hesaid,“Yes,IjusttakethesampleoutandsqueezethesoilandIdecidehowgooditis.”Thenhethoughtforaminuteandsaid,“Youknow,there’sonething,though,IguessI’mgettingweakerinmyoldage,becauseI’mgiv-inghighervaluesnowforthesamesoil.Some-thingthattenyearsagoIwouldgive10,000poundsto,nowI’mgiving20,000pounds.”Hethensaid,“Maybewedoneedsomethingalittlemorescientific.”Buthedidn’thiremeforanything.
Scott: Howoftendidyoudothesetours?
Crandall: Justperiodically.Itmusthavebeenabout1950.Thewarwasover,ofcourse,andIwasapartneratthattime.IleftDamesandMoorein1954,inmid-year1954.Soithadtobeprobablybetween1951or1952,somewhereinthere.
Selling the Discipline of Soil MechanicsCrandall: Atthattimetheproblemwastosellsoilmechanicsasbeinganimportantele-mentofdesignandbuilding.Nowadays,soilmechanicsisaccepted.Hardlyanythingisbuilt,atleastinsouthernCalifornia,withoutsoilmechanics.Westartedouttryingtosellthedisciplineofsoilmechanicstoclients,andlaterhadtoselltheideathattheyshouldhireusratherthanalltheotherfirmsthatstartedup.
Scott: Thereisnowanawarenessthatthingscanreallygowrongifdesignersdonotunder-standtheperformanceandtheweight-bearingcapacitiesofthesoil?
Crandall: Youhadtogetacrosstheideathatwecouldprovidesomeusefulinformation.Be-causemostpeople,whenyoucomealongandtrytosellanewconcept,theyfeeltheyhavegottenalongfinewithwhattheyhadbefore.Ineffect,you’retellingthem,“You’renotdoingthingsaswellasyoushouldhavebeendoingthem.”Ittookagoodmantostandupandsay,“OK,let’sseewhatyouhave.Maybeyoucanteachmesomething.”
Trent Dames and Bill MooreCrandall: Dameswasnotthesalesmantype.Hewastheadministrator.Agoodtechnicalman.Helovedmanagement.Alonewolf.Healienatedmoreclientsthanhegot,frankly.Ithinkherealizedthat,andhegotoutofthewayofclientrelations.IguessIwasbetterhandlingordealingwithpeoplethanhewas,soclientcontactsbecameoneofmyassignments.
Scott: OperatingoutofLosAngeles.
Crandall: Yes.
Scott: BillMoorealsodidalotmoreclientcontactwork,Iguess,buthewasoperatingmoreoutoftheSanFranciscoofficeaboutthattime?
Crandall: BillalsowentovertoSaudiArabiaforStandardOilofCaliforniaandAramco,theArabianAmericanOilCompany,andworkedatgettingthemunderwayonbuild-ingrefineriesthere.It’smentionedinBill’s
Chapter 4 Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
20
EERIoralhistory.3HeshippedthesamplesbacktoLosAngelesandwedidthetesting.WeworkedoutacodesystemforsendinghimdatafromLosAngeles.Whenhegottestingequipmentoverthere,Billranthetestsandbycodewouldsendtheresultsofthetest.We’ddrawupthelogsandotherthingsfromthedatathathesent.Itwasexpensiveanddifficulttogetmessagesbackandforth.Wetriedtokeepitshortandsweet.Aramco,Iguess,wasabletogetthecodeacrossbyradiotelegraph,orsomethinglikethat.Also,BillwasbusierthanabirddoginSanFranciscodoinghisownbusinessdevelopment.Uptherethearchitectsandengineerswerealotmorepro-vincialandlessprogressivethantheywereinLosAngeles.
In1947IbecamethefirstpartnerofDamesandMoore.Wewereapartnershipthen;itwasn’tacorporation.IhadresponsibilityforwhatwascalledtheLosAngelesregionalof-fice.AtthattimetherewasalsoanofficeinSanFrancisco,andBillMoorewasheadingthat.TrentDameswasinwhatwewouldnowrefertoasthecorporateoffice,butbackthenitwascalledthegeneraloffice.
Thegeneralofficetookcareofthetotalbusi-nesspicture,andwasworkingtowardestab-lishingotherofficesinotherareas.LaterthiswasdoneinNewYork,Seattle,Portland,andareaslikethat.Itwasthemainfunctionofthegeneraloffice.TheLosAngelesregionalofficewasresponsibleforallofsouthernCalifornia,
3. Connections: The EERI Oral History Series — William W. Moore: StanleyScott,interviewer.EarthquakeEngineeringResearchInstitute,Oakland,California,1998,p.35.
plusmuchoftheforeignworkthatwedid.ThatwasmyresponsibilityinLosAngeles.
Postwar Surge in Civilian ConstructionCrandall: Followingthewar,inabout1947,thebasicworkwascommercial,fillingademandforthebuildingsthatcouldnotbebuiltduringthewar.Therewasagreatsurgeofprivatework,ascomparedwiththepreviousdefenseandwar-relatedwork.Wewereveryfortunateinbeingabletomovealmostwithoutanyhitchesfromgovernmentdefenseworktoprivatework.Inotherwords,alloureggswerenotinonebasketanymore.
Scott: Youdidn’thavetoretooltheoffice?
Crandall: Right.Themaineffortwasonschoolsandmunicipalpublicbuildings,whoseconstructionhadbeencurtailedduringthewar.Then,ofcourse,therewasthegeneralprivatesector,suchasbuildingsforthetele-phonecompanyandgascompany.
Refineries
Crandall: Refinerieswerebeginningabigbuildingprogramaboutthattime.WeweredoingmuchworkwithgroupslikeUnionOil—andwhatwasthenRichfieldandlatercalledARCO—throughoutnotonlysouth-ernCalifornia,butthroughoutthesouthernUnitedStates.WedidworkinTexas,forexample,andalsoinKansasCity,Chicago,andotherareasoftheUnitedStates,forrefineriesdesignedandbuiltbyC.F.Braun,inparticular.HeadquarteredinAlhambra,CaliforniaintheLosAngelesarea,C.F.Braun&Co.wasone
21
Chapter 4LeRoy Crandall • Working for Dames and Moore
oftheoutstandingpetrochemicaldesign-and-buildfirmsatthattime.
WehadafinerelationshipwithC.F.Braun,anddidthesoilengineeringworkforalloftheirprojectsthroughouttheUnitedStates.Wemusthavedonefifteenortwentymajorre-finerieswithC.F.Braun.Unfortunately,theyarenolongerthelead.Someyearsbacktheywereacquired,andthecharacteroftheirbusi-nesshaschanged.Nobody’sbuildingrefineriesnowadays,butatthattime,theywereamajorpartofourwork,involvinglargeprojectsaroundthecountry.
Coastal Facilities
Crandall: Therewerealsosomeinterestingoffshoreprojects.OneexampleistheHyper-ionsewerline,aninterestingproject.Wedidthesoilstudyforthefive-mileoutfallsewerthatextendsofftheLosAngelescoast.
Scott: Thatmusthavebeenamajorproject.
Crandall: Andamuch-neededdevelopment.Theeffluentwastakenfivemilesouttosea,andtheneverybodythoughtitwasfine.Nowa-days,however,theyhavefoundthatsludgeaccumulationiscausingproblems,andthey’redoingthingsalittledifferently.
Wedidseveraloffshoreprojectsofthattype.Anumberofpierswerebuilt,suchastheVenicepier.InSanDiego,therewasanoffshoreoutfall,andtwoorthreeotherpiers.Somarineworkwasgoingstrong,includingharbordepartmentworkinLosAngelesandLongBeach.Therewasabacklogofdevelopmenttobedonebecauseofthewar.
SanDiegobegantoboom,andweweretheprimesoilfirminconnectionwithmajorde-velopmentsinSanDiegofortheNavy.Manyoftheirshorefacilitieshadbeenlimitedduringthewar,andtheybegantoexpand.Thosearejustafewprojectsthatcometomindatthemomentasbeingrathernoteworthyinthatperiod.Theygaveusthechancetoexpandourtechniquesandknowledgeintootherareas.
Development of the Drilled Friction PileCrandall: Thedrilledpilewasonedevelop-mentinthoseearlydaysthatwasaveryimpor-tantfoundationtechnique.Aholewasdrilledintotheground,andthenfilledwithconcrete.
Scott: Thatwasdone,insteadofdrivingthepiledownintothesoilwithapile-driver?
Crandall: Yes,insteadofdrivingapileintothesoil,whichwasoneofthestandardpro-ceduresusedformany,manyyears.Insouth-ernCalifornia,adrilledpilewasoftenveryeconomical,andiftheconditionswereright,muchmoreeconomicalthanadrivenpile.Ofcourse,wheretherearesandysoilswithshal-lowwaterconditions,theholewon’tstayopen,makingadrilledpilehardtoinstall.Butwheretherearedryconditions,andthesurfacema-terialsarenotsuitableforconventionalspreadfootings,thedrilledpilewastheanswertoamaiden’sprayer.
ThisdevelopmentwasprettymuchpioneeredinsouthernCalifornia,usingwhatwasthencalledacesspoolrig.Itwasusedactuallyforthatpurpose,drillingcesspools.Theydrilledaholeinthegroundthattheylinedwithred-
Chapter 4 Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
22
wood.Forthedrilledpile,thatsamebucket-typedrillingequipment,asitwascalled,wasusedtodrillaholeintheground,andconcretewasputintothehole,andafrictionpiledevel-opedinthatfashion.
Ithadtobeproventopeoplethatyoucoulddevelopfrictiononthesideofaholethatwasmerelyfilledinwithconcrete.Theythoughtthattodevelopfriction,thepilehadtobebeatenintotheground.Soseveraltestsweremadeintheearlydays,someofwhichwerepriortomyevencomingtoLosAngeles.Theyputadrilledpileintheground,andthendrilledanotherholealongsideit,sayfiveorsixfeetaway,bothtothesametipelevation.Thentheytunneledunderthedrilledpiletoremovethesoilfrombeneathitstip.Thepilewasthenloadedtoprovethatthetipwasnotcarryingtheload—insteaditwasthefrictiononthesidesthatcarriedtheload.
Oncethatprinciplewasestablished,peoplebegantobelieveit.Mostengineershadfeltthattheloadwasgoingallthewaydowntothetip,andthatyoucanonlyloadthatpileuptowhatevertheeighteen-inchdiametertipareawouldsupport.Butthatwasnotthecase,andthedrilledpilewouldtakeconsiderablygreaterloadsthanthat.Thedevelopmentofthedrilled,cast-in-placeconcretepilewasapioneeringeffortinsouthernCalifornia.Wegotthattypeoffoundationpermittedinthebuildingcode,andinthisareaaverylargenumberofbuildingshavebeenputinthataresupportedonthiskindofpiling.
Parting with Dames and MooreCrandall: IhadaveryfinerelationshipwithbothBillMooreandTrentDames.Thingswentverywell,althoughthereweresomebusinessdifferences.TrentDameswasinter-nationallyminded,multi-officeoriented.Inthatregard,Ihadsomereservations,purelyfromabusinessstandpoint.Wehadseveraldiscussionsaboutwhatwasgoingtobedoneandhow.
Scott: Youhadreservationsabouttheopen-ingofotheroffices,orsolicitinglotsofworkawayfromhomebase?
Crandall: Iwasconcernedaboutpossibleef-fectsonthequalityofthework,ifofficeswereopenedwithoutsuitablytrainedpersonnel.Trenthaddifferentideasonthat.
Scott: Inotherwords,hethoughtthequalityproblemcouldbehandled,orhewaseagerforthebusiness,ormaybeboth?
Crandall: Expansionwashismiddlename.BillMoore,Ithink,waslessorientedthatway.Butatthattime,intheearly1950sasIrecall,therewasanexecutivecommitteeconsistingofmyself,BillMoore,andTrentDames.Thematterwasdiscussedinthecommittee,anditwasobviousthatIwasnotintunewithwhattheotherswantedtodo.
Scott: Youfeltitwouldbebettertostickwithtwoorthreeoffices.
Crandall: Oratleastincreaseinsizemoregradually.Thiswasapartnership,youwillrecall,andeachpartnerwasvulnerableforwhateverhappenedinanyotheroffice.Oneofmyconcernswasthat,ifweopenedanoffice
23
Chapter 4LeRoy Crandall • Working for Dames and Moore
inanotherarea,wecouldallbeaffectedifthatofficedevelopedsomeliabilityproblems.Un-derapartnership,thoseproblemscouldaffectusall.
HereIwas,afairlysignificantpartnerinthelegalentityofDamesandMoore.Whilenotrichbyanystretchoftheimagination,any-thingIhadwouldbeexposedtowhateveractionsorclaimstheworkofthepeopleinotherDamesandMooreofficesmightgener-ate,evenbyunintentionalthings.SoIwaslessenthusiasticaboutbeing,shallIsay,inbedwithotherofficemanagersoverwhomIhadverylittlecontrol,andaboutwhoseabilitiesIhadlittleknowledge.
IrecognizedthatmythinkingrancontrarytowhatDamesandMoorewerecontemplating,andinfairnesstoboththemandmyself,Ifeltthetimehadcometoseparatefromthefirm.
Ialsosensedthattherewassomethingofacorporatebureaucracydeveloping,inwhichheadquartersstafftellsalltheworkerswhattodo.Thelinepersonnel,theprofessionals,canbecomesecondary.Thesethingsdidn’tfitmyideaofhowtorunacompany.Notthatthere’sanythingwrongwiththatmodel,andDamesandMoorewentontobecomeoneofthelargestfirmsofthistypeinthecountry,maybeevenintheworld.That’sfine—butitwasn’tforme.Ididn’tseethatapproachasbeingmycupoftea.Inearly1954IconcludedthatwhatIwasdoingwasnotgoodforeitherDamesandMooreorforme.Itwasn’trighttothem,tohavesomebodywhowasnotactivelypursuingthepoliciesthecompanywasinterestedin.
Thefinaldecisionwasmadein1954.Ihadanofferfromanotherfirm,primarilyatesting
laboratory,whichwantedtodosoilengineer-ing.ItwaslocatedinmyoldhometownofSanDiego,wheremywifeandIhadbeenraised,andwherewehadourfamily(mybrother,sis-ter,andparents).Sowethoughtaboutmovingthere.IregrettosayIhadpracticallyassuredtheotherpartyofourintent,tothepointwherehewaskindofcountingonmycomingdownthere.AtthistimeIhadadvisedDamesandMoorethatIwasplanningtoleave,andthatIhadbeenaskedtocometoworkfortheSanDiegofirm.
Meanwhile,someofthestructuralengineersintownwhoweregoodfriendsofmine,andwithwhomIhadworkedasaDamesandMoorepartner,convincedmethatIwouldbebetterofftostayinLosAngeleswhereIhadallthesecontacts.TheyallfeltthatmyserviceswouldbepreferredtowhoeverelsemightcomeandtakeoveratDamesandMoore.Ishallnotnamethem,butthereweretwoinparticular.
Scott: Twostructuralengineers,friendsofyoursinthisarea?
Crandall: Structuralengineers,yes,whoverystronglyurgedthatIshouldstayinthisarea.
Scott: Weretheyyourpeers,chronologically?
Crandall: Somewhatolder,butonlybyfourorfiveyears.Thentwoofourassociates,em-ployeesatDamesandMoore,LeoHirschfeldtandFredBarnes,approachedme,sayingtheywereinterestedinworkingwithmeifIstartedmyownfirm.Neitherofthemwasaregisteredcivilengineer,buttheyhadbeenwithDamesandMoorealmostaslongasIhad,andoneevenlonger.Theyofferedtojoinmeinform-ingourownofficeinLosAngeles.Weagreed
Chapter 4 Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
24
thatthismightbeagoodthingtodo.IhadtotelltheSanDiegocontactthatIhadchangedmymind.Hewasverygraciousaboutit,buthewasn’tverydamnhappy.I’vealwaysfeltIlefthimholdingthebag.
Financingwasobviouslyaprobleminstart-inganewbusiness.AllofmyassetsweretiedupinDamesandMoore,inownershipandinretainedearnings.InDamesandMooreweoperatedonadrawingaccount,which,Ithink,atthattimewas$600amonth.That’swhatyoulivedon.Thentheoreticallyattheendoftheyearafterthebookshadclosed,iftherewasaprofit,itwasdistributed.Initially,14percentwasmyshare,butlaterthiswaschanged.Wedecidedthatwecouldprobablylastforsixmonthsifwecouldcomeupwith$10,000.
Scott: Youmean$10,000cashtotal,forthethreeofyou?
Crandall: Yes.Weraisedthisnesteggfrom$5,000paidinbyme,and$2,500fromeachoftheothertwo.We’dseehowitwent.Ifwemadeit,wemadeit.Ifwedidn’t,itwasdownthetubesandwe’ddosomethingelse.Wewerekindofluckyinourtiming.BythenIhadad-visedDamesandMoorethatIwasresigning.IthinkIgavethemathree-monthperiodduringwhichIwouldstayon,andworkwithandtrainmyreplacement,averyfinefellownamedAlSmoots,whowasgoingtotakeovertheoffice.Ididstay,andleftaboutMay1,1954.
Priortomyfinishing,butafterthedecisionhadbeenmadethatIwouldgo,thesetwootherpartiesapproachedTrentDames,toldhimtheywereplanningtoleave,andgavehimamonth.Wefeltthefirmdeservedamonthnotice.Fortunatelyforus,Damesdecidedhedidn’twantthemaroundiftheyweregoingtoleave,soheterminatedthemrightthen.Thattimingturnedouttobethebestthingthateverhappened,becausewestartedgettingworkthedayweopenedourdoors.WithoutthemIwouldhavebeentheonlyonetodoallofthiswork.Sotheothertwocameaboardrightaway.Itworkedoutverywell.
Scott: WasyourpartingwithDamesandMooreamicable?
Crandall: Itwasn’treallyamicablewithTrentDames.Infactwehadafinancialdisputeoverthepayoutofmyshareinthefirmthatdraggedon.IcansaytothisdaythatmyfirmdidnotgoandsolicitajobfromsomeonewhohadbeenaclientofDamesandMoore.Wedid,ofcourse,sendoutannounce-mentsaboutourfirm,andwehaditputinthemagazinethatLeRoyCrandallandAssociateshadbeenformed,andthatsortofpromotion.Weendedupgettingabigjobinthemid-1950sforfurtherworkontheHyperionseweroutfall,butonlybecausethecityengineerhadstrainedrelationswithDamesandsoughtmeoutforourservices.
Chapter 5
LeRoy Crandall and Associates
25
We started the office with a card table, a desk,
a second-hand typewriter, one three-drawer
metal file cabinet, and a drafting table.
Crandall: Weopenedournewfirm’sdoorsin1954andhadworkbeforewewereevenready.Wedidn’thaveourtestingmachinesandotherequipment.Peoplecameinandcalledusandwantedustodowork.Weneverhadanyproblemswithobtainingwork.
Scott: YourstructuralengineeradvisorshadcalledtheshotsprettywellinrecommendingthatyoustayintheLosAngelesarea.
Crandall: Yes,theywereright.Manypeoplehelpedusverymuch.Onevery,veryfineengineer,JimMont-gomeryofJ.M.MontgomeryEngineers,calledearly-on.Oneofourfirstjobs,jobnumbereightitwas,wasareservoirintheLasVegasarea.Jimcalledandaskedifwewoulddothework.Isaid,“Gee,Jim,we’dloveto.Idon’tknowifwecanfinanceit,though.”Itwasaprettybigjobforus,about30boringsandthingslikethat,maybeitwasa$15,000project,whichwasabigfeefor
Chapter 5 Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
26
us.Isaid,“Financingmightbeaproblem.”Hesaid,“Look,LeRoy,don’tyouworryaboutthat.We’llpayyouinadvance.Wewantyoutodothejob.”Wehadsupportfrompeoplelikethat,whichreallymadeitworthwhile.
Scott: Heofferedtopayinadvance?
Crandall: Wedidn’tneeditifthingsworkedoutallright,butwehadonly$10,000total,andwehadtohiredrillingequipment,andpaythemtooperateit.
Scott: Youhadacashflowproblem.
Crandall: Check.OnethingthatIwasproudof,andI’dliketobeatmydrumabout,wasthatthefirstthingIdidwhenweopenedthedoorsandtookinsomehardcashwastojointheU.S.ChamberofCommerce,theCali-forniaStateChamber,andtheLosAngelesChamber.We’vebeensupportiveofthingslikethatrightfromthestart.Forwhateverthat’sworth,Ifeltwewereheretostay,andweweregoingtomakeabusinessanddoourshareoftryingtosupportprivateenterprise.
LikeIsay,thingswentwell.Ican’trecallanymajorproblems.Wegrewfromthethreeofusengineersandmywife,Eileen,thesecretary.Westartedtheofficewithacardtable,adesk,asecond-handtypewriter,onethree-drawermetalfilecabinet,andadraftingtable.WerentedalittleofficespaceonBeverlyBoule-vardinLosAngeles.
Scott: Youstartedalmostonashoestring.
Crandall: Oh,wehadsandalswithoutshoe-strings,Iguessyoucouldsay.Butthe$10,000wasadequate,alongwiththekindofsupportwegotfromourclients,whopaidquicklyandwell.
Hyperion Sewer System ExpansionCrandall: AsImentionedearlier,oneofthebigjobsournewfirmhadwastheexpansionoftheHyperionseweroutfallsystemforLosAngeles,aprojectonwhichDamesandMoorewereconsultantsduringitsfirstphase.Thecityengineer,amannamedAldrich,preferrednottousethemagain,andalthoughtheproj-ectwasastretchforoursmalloffice,wetookiton,todothesoilreportforthenewoutfallsewer.Ithinkthetotalfeewassomethinglike$75,000.That’snotsobigbytoday’sstandards,butbackthenitwasahellofabigjob.
Scott: IremembertheHyperionoutfalldebateandproject,whichwasnewsevenupintheSanFranciscoBayArea.ItgotintosomeoftheliteraturethatcameacrossmydeskinmyearlydaysattheInstituteofGovernmen-talStudies.AsIrecall,thatprojectwasaveryimportantissueatthetime.
Crandall: Theoutfallsewerwentoutsixmiles.Wealsohadtodrillsomeotherboringstocheckthesewerinstallationandfindoutthesoilconditions.Thentherewasabout15milesofonshoresewerlineatquiteadepth.Muchofitwasputinasatunnel,tunnelingundertheLosAngelesairportandthatwholeareainBaldwinHills.Itwasquiteajobandafeatherinourcap,believeme.Wediditwell.
Organization of the FirmScott: Howdidyouorganizethefirm?
Crandall: Theothertwopartners,LeoHirschfeldtandFredBarnes,hadaquarterinterest,andIhadhalf.Weselectedthename“LeRoyCrandallandAssociates,”which
27
Chapter 5LeRoy Crandall • LeRoy Crandall and Associates
doesn’tshowmuchoriginality,Iguess,butitseemstohaveworked.Thatwasthebestsellingapproach,Ithink,becauseIwasbetterknownthantheothers.
Afewmonthsafterwehadopened,RussWeber,whoalsoworkedatDamesandMoore,cameby.Russhadapproachedmeearlieraboutstartingacompany,butatthattimeIhadalreadycommittedwithFredandLeo.ButRusswasnowreadytojoin,andwetookhiminasanequalpartnertoFredandLeo.Theyeachhadequalsharesandminewastwicetheirindividualshares.Thatcomesout40-20-20-20thatis,theyeachhad20andIhad40.Wetookoffonthatbasis.
Iwouldsaywithinaboutthreeorfourmonthswehadincreasedourstafffromthefourofustoaboutsevenaltogether.OureffortswereintheLosAngelesarea,ofcourse,andpurelyinsoilengineering.Thatwasthewholethingatthattime.Thefieldenlargedinlateryears,butinitiallyitwasjustexploringandtestingthesoilforfoundationdesignpurposes.
CrandallandAssociatesgrewinsize.IalwayshadfeltthataboutsixteentotalpersonnelwouldbewhatIconsideredidealforasmallconsultingfirmthatbelievedinqualityservice.ThatwasaboutthesizeIhadintheLosAnge-lesofficeofDamesandMoore,aboutsixteenoreighteen.
Inthenewfirm,however,wegottothatlevelfairlyquickly.Idon’thavethenumbersinfrontofme,butIguesswithintwoyearswewereuptothatsizeoftotalpersonnel.Ithinkmytheorywasgood—Istillbelievethatisagoodsizeforaprincipaltooperateandconducta
businessuptothepointwhereyoustillknowalmosteverythingthat’sgoingon.
Scott: Beingintimatelyknowledgeableabouteveryjobyouaredoing?
Crandall: Yes,that’sit.AndthatwasthebasisformyleavingDamesandMoore,asIsaid.Alsoatthattimewewerebeginningtobeconsciousofliability,oflawsuitsagainstsoilengineers.Iwasnogeniusatmanagement,butIwassmartenoughtorecognizethatifyoudidn’thavegoodcontrols,youcouldeasilygetyourselfintoalegalsituationthatshouldoth-erwisehavebeenprevented,ifyouhadknownwhatwasgoingonintimetotakesomeactionbeforeproblemsdeveloped.
Well,thetheorywasgood,butwecouldn’tholdtoit.Thatwasnotbecausewewereoutsolicitingeveryjobthatcamealong.Butwehaddevelopedaclienteleof,Iwillsay,thebestarchitecturalandengineeringfirmsinsouthernCaliforniawhoreliedonusalmostautomati-callyfortheirsoilwork.TheygrewasLosAngelesgrew.AndwhenafirmsuchasDaniel,Mann,Johnson,andMendenhallgetsbiggerandhasmorework,andtheywantyoutodotheirworkagain,you’dbetterbepreparedtodoitproperly,orthey’regoingtolookforsomeoneelseandyouwon’thaveanywork.That’sexactlywhathappened,sowehadtokeepgrowing.
Scott: That’sinteresting.Thereispressureonyoubecauseofyoursuccessandyourclients’success.Igatheryoualmostcan’tescapeit.
Crandall: Thatwasexactlyright.Wewereveryslowinsolicitingnewclients,becausewehadthecreamofthecropandtheydeveloped
Chapter 5 Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
28
alltheworkweneededforasmall-sizefirm.Buttheywouldgrow,andthen,ofcourse,aspeopleleftthosefirmsandstartedtheirownfirms,youwouldthenhavetwoorthreeor-ganizationsthatstilllookeduponyouastheirconsultantinthisfield.
Incorporating in 1957Crandall: Whenwestarted,itwasapartner-ship.Thenafteraboutthreeyearsweincor-porated,andeachbecamestockholders.Thereweresomebenefitstothat.IfIremembercorrectly,LeoHirschfeldtsearchedaroundandfoundthatyoucouldoperateunderwhatwascalled“SubchapterS,”whichpermittedyoutodivideuptheprofitsasifyouwereapartnership,butgaveyoumanyofthebenefitsofincorporation.
Scott: Also,Igather,itfreedyoufromsomeofthevulnerabilityofapartnership.
Crandall: Thatisright.Atthattimeatleastwethought—lateritwasn’tquiteasimpor-tant—butacorporationwaslessvulnerablethen.Inacorporation,theindividualswerelessvulnerableintheeventofalawsuitorsomehorriblecatastrophe.Laterlitigationindicatedthattheycould“piercethecorporateveil”aslawyerslovetosay.Ifyou’reaprofes-sionalpersonandhadsigneddrawingsandstampedthedrawingswithyourregistrationyoucouldbeheldliableasanindividual.Soitdidn’thaveallofthatreducedvulnerabil-ityaspectforverylong,buttax-wiseitwasagoodmove.Later,wegotsobigthatwehadtodropSubchapterS.I’veforgottennow,butyoucouldonlyhaveXnumberofpartnersor
stockholdersorwhatever.Therewasalotoflegalmumbo-jumboaboutit.
Sowehadtoexpand.Expandingmeantlargerquarters.Werentedorleasedspaceforawhile,andhaditaddedonto.Then,Ithinkin1965,wedecidedtobuildourownbuilding.Iwasnotreallystronglyinfavorofthat,becauseIfeltthatwewerebetterofftokeepourmoneyinourownfieldandletsomebodyelseownthebuilding,butitturnedouttobeadamnedgoodinvestment.Ithinkitwas1965.Thatwouldhavebeen11yearsafterwestarted.
Scott: Inhindsight,thatwouldhavebeenagoodtimetobuildorbuy,seeingwhathap-penedtotherealestatemarket.Itreallytookoff,startinginabout1964or1965.
Crandall: Yes.Itwasdumbluck.LeoHirschfeldtwastheonewhomaneuveredusintothat.Leowasmoreofabusinessmanagerthanacivilengineer.Hewasagraduatecivilengineer,buthenevergothisregistration.Helovedthebusinessaspects.
Wehiredoneofourarchitecturalclients,afel-lowwhohadbeenwithabigfirmandleft,andhedesignedwhatIfeltwasavery,veryfinebuildingforustooperateoutof.
Scott: Wherewasitlocated?
Crandall: At711NorthAlvaradoStreetinLosAngeles,nearEchoParkLake.Theneigh-borhoodwasnotveryclassy,butwefeltitwasgoingtoimprove.Thatwastheonethingwewerewrongon.Itdidn’timprovemuchwhilewewerethere,althoughnowithas,afterwe’vesoldthebuilding.WebuiltthatbuildingattheintersectionofAlvaradoandKentStreets,sowecalledthecorporationAlvarado-Kent
29
Chapter 5LeRoy Crandall • LeRoy Crandall and Associates
Corporation.Webuilta10,000-or12,000-square-footfacilitythatincludedstorageforourequipment,alaboratory,andourengineer-ingoffices.Itwasone-storyhigh,butwehaddesigneditforasecondstory,sowecouldexpandifwewantedto.
BythattimeIthinkwehadsixpartners.JimmyKirkgardandSeymourChiuweretheaddi-tionalpartnerswehadadded.Wecalledthemassociates.Bothofthemcamewithinroughlyayearafterwehadopenedthedooronthenewbuilding.SeymourwasfromHongKongandhadamaster’sdegreefromtheUniversityofTexas.JimmyKirkgardwasaUCLAgraduate,withamaster’sdegree.MartinDukesenthimovertous.
Eachofusinvestedinthebuildinginanamountequivalenttoourownership.WefeltJimmyandSeymourhadtheabilitiesandthetalentsandthequalitiesthatwewanted,soweofferedthemashareofthebusiness,whichtheyaccepted.Theyboughttheirownstock.Wedidn’tgiveanystockaway.Wepermittedthemtobuyintothebusiness.SowhenwebuiltAlvarado-Kent,sixofushadsharesinthebuildingme,FredBarnes,LeoHirschfeldt,RussWeber,JamesKirk-gard,andJamesMcWee.Lateron,SeymourChiu,whohadbeenwithusforaslongasanybody,wasmadetheseventhassociate,andafterthatPerryMaljianwasselectedastheeighth.
Ifeltverystronglythatweshouldmakethebusinessavailabletoourkeypersonnel,ifweexpectedtokeepthem.Ifyougetgoodtalent,unlesstheyare“partoftheaction,”they’regoingtoleaveafterarelativelyshortperiodof
time,afterthey’veachievedeverythingthey’regoingtoget.Ifthey’rejustworkingforasal-aryandabonus,itisn’tnearlyasinterestingashavingaportionofabusinessthattheycandevotetheirtimeto.
Scott: YoumentionC.MartinDuke.Hadheworkedwithyoubefore?
Crandall: Yes,hewasbythenaprofessoratUCLA,andwewereveryclose,andwecol-laboratedonacoupleofthings.I’llmentionhimseveraltimeshereinthisoralhistory.IhaveforgottenwhetherwehiredMartinandhegotpaid,orhewasworkingonaresearchgrant,buthedidearlyshearwavevelocitymeasurementswithus.
Iguesswemovedin1966.Wefinishedthebuildinginlessthanayear.Wehadatwenty-yearmortgage,andpaiditoffintenyears,sothenweownedthebuildingfreeandclear.CrandallandAssociatespaidrenttoAlvarado-Kent.Thatturnedouttobeafinancialbless-ingbecausewhenwefinallysoldthebuilding[in1986],wesolditforamilliondollars,andIthinkin1965wehadpaidacouplehundredthousand,somethinglikethat.
Scott: Whydidyousell?
Crandall: ItwasrelatedtothenextphaseintheCrandallfirm,whenwewereacquiredbyLawEngineering.
Acquired by Law EngineeringCrandall: LawEngineeringofAtlantaac-quiredCrandallandAssociatesin1982.Atthattime,ourfirmhadseventyoreightyemployees.Thename“Law”comesfromthefirm’sfound-
Chapter 5 Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
30
andwoulduseconsultantgeologistswhenweneededthattypeofinput.Forsometimewedidthat,usingtwofirmsforthegeologicwork,JamesSlosson,andGlennA.BrownandAssociates.
Thenitgottothepointwheremanyofourcompetitorshadin-houseengineeringgeolo-gists.Also,someofourclientsexpressedapreferenceforafirmthatdidn’tsubmittworeports,butwouldcombineboththegeologyandtheengineeringinonereport.Weusedtohaveareportwrittenbyourconsultant,let’ssay,GlennA.Brown,andwewouldappendthatgeologyreporttooursoilreport.We,ofcourse,usedtheinformationfromit,buttwoseparatereportsweresenttotheclient.
Soinordertomeetourclients’desires,LeRoyCrandallandAssociatesmergedwithGlennA.BrownandAssociates.GlennBrownandhisstaff,abouttenortwelvepeople,becamepartofLeRoyCrandallandAssociates.Ourfirmbeforethattimewasaboutfortyorfiftypeople.GlennBrownwasbroughtinasanassociateofthecompany.Thatwasinthemid1970s.Glennhadaveryfinereputation,andwewereveryfondofhimandhiswork.
WeworkedoutfinewithGlennBrown.Weacquiredhisfirm,hisequipmentandappa-ratus.HeacquiredstockinLeRoyCrandallandAssociates,andbecameanotherco-owner.Thefirmthenbecameanintegratedoperation,andweidentifiedourselvesas“GeotechnicalConsultants,”ratherthanjust“GeotechnicalEngineers.”ThisincludedthegeologythatBrownwasinchargeofunderthatbroaderdesignation.
er,ThomasLaw.Weweretoparticipateintheearningsorprofitsoverthreeyears,between1982and1985,withamaximumvalueequaltotheamounttheypaidforLeRoyCrandallandAssociates.LeRoyCrandallandAssociatesbecameasubsidiaryofLawEngineeringTest-ingCompanyin1982butretaineditsformernameuntil1991,whenthenamechangedtoLaw/Crandall.Lawdidn’tbuythebuilding,soAlvarado-Kentstillownedit.
In1985theearn-outperiodended.Lawhasagrowthpolicy.Theywantedtobebig.Soweoutgrewthebuilding,andAlvarado-Kentof-feredtoaddonthesecondstory.Buttheparentcompany,LawEngineering,decidedthatratherthanstayinthebuildingwhilethesecondstorywasbeingadded,theywouldmoveoutandleaselargerquarters.Thedecisiontoleaselarg-erquartersleftAlvarado-Kentwithabuildingtodisposeof,sincewedidn’tfeelliketryingtoleaseitout.Bythattime,LeoHirschfeldtandSeymourChiuhadpassedaway,FredBarneshadretired,andRussWeberwasjustabouttoretire.Soratherthantrytokeepthebuilding,wedecidedtosellitin1986.LeRoyCrandallandAssociatesthenfoundquartersinGlendalethatweremuchlargerthanwhatwehadbe-fore.ThemovetoGlendalewasmadein1986.Then,duetoaneedforevenmorespace,in1991anothermovewasmadetoanewlybuilttwo-storystructureintheCityofCommerce.
Geology and the Practice of Crandall and AssociatesCrandall: Thisbringsmetoapointabouttheevolutionofmyfirm.CrandallandAs-sociateslimitedourselvestosoilengineering,
Chapter 6
Development of Soil Engineering
31
The model grading ordinance of the
City of Los Angeles and the tie-back
anchor are widely used foundation and
soil engineering approaches that were
pioneered in southern California.
Convincing Them We Had Something UsefulCrandall: Ithinkmostbuildersanddesignprofession-alsthoughtwewereliketheguyswiththewaterwitchingtechniques.Itwasallmumbo-jumbo—whoneededallthatstuff?Itwasaquestionofconvincingpeoplethatbytakingsamplesandrunningtestsanddoingengineeringanalyses,youcoulddevelopgood,usefulinformation.
Atthetime,theNavy,AirForce,andArmyseemedtobeconvincedthattherewassomemeritinthissortofathing.Thenpeoplebegantofindoutthatwhenthingswentwrongwithfoundations,itwasconsideredthede-signer’sfault.Butnowherewasanotherlayerthatwouldstepinandassumeresponsibilityfortheuncertaintiesin
Chapter 6 Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
32
constructionthatareprimarilycausedbytheundergroundconditions.
Withresponsibilitywentrespect.Sowebegantogetrespect,atleastasrepresentingabuffer,separatingthedesignerfromsomeoftheprob-lemsofconstruction.Thedesignerthenhadthesoilengineertotakethebruntoftheattackifanythingwentwrongwiththesiteorfounda-tion.Basically,itwasjustaquestionoftheirchangingviews.Previouslytheyhadgottenalong,forthousandsofyears,withoutrunningsoiltests.Sotheattitudewas“Whathaveyougotthat’sgoingtobehelpfultome?”
Thatskepticismgraduallychanged,asbuild-ingdepartmentsbegantorelyonthesoilengineer’sfindings,andownersdiscoveredthattheycouldsaveconsiderablemoneybyknowingtheexactdesignproblemsonasite,ratherthanjustarbitrarilyapplyingthepre-scribeddesignvaluesinthebuildingcode.
Scott: Inotherwords,theycouldtailor-makewhattheydidintermsoffoundationandpre-paratorywork?
Crandall: That’sexactlyright.Youlearntheconditionsofthesite,andsincebuildingcodesareconservativedocuments,usuallyyoucansavemoney.Inotherwords,inmostcasestheactualsoilvaluedeterminedbytheconsultantisbetterthanwhatthebuildingcoderequiresifyoudon’thaveasite-specificstudy.
Youmightbeabletodesignthefoundationfor,say5,000poundspersquarefootbearingpres-sureinsteadofthe2,000poundsthatthecodemightotherwisesaywasthepresumedvalue.AgreatdealofthanksisowedtothebuildingdepartmentpeopleoftheCityofLosAngeles
forrealizingthatearly-on,andforwritingthecodeinsuchamannerthatdeviationsfromitwerepermittedonthebasisofaqualifiedsoilengineeringreport.
Manyofusinthesoilsfieldwereinstrumental,workingwiththeLosAngelesbuildingdepart-ment,ingettingtheinformationinthere.Soitbecamepossibletodeviatefromthebuildingcodeonthebasisofanacceptablesoilstudy.
Leadership by the City of Los Angeles Scott: Inthisrespect,theCityofLosAnge-leshastendedtobealittleaheadofthegame?
Crandall: Ithinkthereisdefinitelythatfactor notonlyinthequalityoftheirplan-checkingdepartmentandpersonnel,butalsointheiracceptanceofnewtechniquesandallow-ingforthosenotspecifiedinthebuildingcode.Then,ofcourse,they’vealsotightenedupmanythings,forexamplethegradingordinance,whichthelocalsoilpeoplealsohelpeddevelop.
Backinthe1950sandearly1960s,IthinktheCityofLosAngelescertainlyledtheUnitedStates,andmaybetheworld,inrequirementsforevaluatingsoilpropertiesbeforeconstruct-inghillsidedevelopments.Becauseofthepreviouslackofcontrolsoverthedevelopers,inourhillsthereweremanyproblemswithstability,landslides,anderosionfailures.
It’salwaysstruckmethatinotherpartsoftheworld,theverypoorpeopleliveonthehillsides.Buthere,insouthernCalifornia,ahillsidelotisadesirableplace.Sowehaveconcentratedagreatdealofexpensivedevelop-mentonhillsides,andasaresult,hillsidede-
33
Chapter 6LeRoy Crandall • Development of Soil Engineering
velopmenttendstobecontrolledinwaysthatminimizegradingproblems.IcannowsaythatthehillsideareaoftheCityofLosAngeleshasfewerproblemsthanalmostanycomparableplaceIcanimagine.Theproportionoftroubleisvery,veryminimal.
Scott: Ithinkthisisaveryimportantpoint—thattheCityofLosAngelesoftenseemstobealittleaheadofmostoftherest.Doyouhaveanythoughtsastowhythiswasthecase?Isitdueprincipallytoprofessionalleadershipintheappropriatedepartments?DoyouhaveanygeneralideasastowhyLosAngelesisoftenabitaheadofthegame?
Crandall: Isuspectitisthatwehaveavocalcitizenry,whohavebuiltexpensivehomesinthehillsides.Whentroubledevelopedwhenheavyrainfalloccurredintheearly1950s,therewasagreatoutcry.“What’swrongwithourhillsidedevelopment?”Goodsoilengi-neersalreadyknewwhatshouldnotbedone,buttherewererelativelyfewcontrolsonthedevelopers.
The 1952 Los Angeles Grading OrdinanceCrandall: Itwasjustaquestionofsloperequirementsnotbeingappropriate.Onahill-sidedevelopment,forexample,aone-to-oneslope(45degrees)wasconsideredsafeforcutslopesandevenforsomefillslopes;aone-and-a-half-to-one(horizontaltovertical)slopewasconsideredsafeforatypicalfilledslope.Eventhoughmanyofusknewthatthesewerethingsthatshouldbeavoided,thoseminimalrequire-mentswereaboutalltherewasinthewayofstandardstobemet.
Scott: Andyouknewthatthoserequirementswerereallynotadequate?
Crandall: Oh,yes,obviously.Butdevelop-erswereabletofindpeoplewhowoulddothegrading—justinconformancewiththeminimumrequirementsatthetime—whichwasnotadequate.
Also,thedrainagecharacteristicsofsoilsondevelopmentsiteswerenotcontrolled,ordidnotfollowanyengineeringrequirements.Thecompactionwasconsiderednottooimportant,andhouseswerebuiltonpoorlycompactedsoil.Therewereallsortsofproblems.Many,manythingsweredonevery,verybadly.
Scott: Thatwasoneofthefirststepsinim-provingthecity’shillsidecoderegulations?
Crandall: Yes.Thenextstepwastosaythatfillsgiveustrouble,sowewillnotmakethemsteeperthanone-and-one-halftoone,aflatterangle.Thatwentalongforawhile.WehadsomeheavyrainsinLosAngelesintheearly1950s,andtherewasagreatdealoftrouble,muchsettlementoffillsandfailuresofthefillslopes.�ButwidespreadhillsidedevelopmenthadoccurredrightafterWorldWarII.With
4. RainfallindowntownLosAngelesoverthewinterof1951-1952was26inches(660mm),orabout1.75timesthelong-termaverage.Therehadnotbeenaseasonofsuchheavyrainfallsincethewinterof1940-1941,whichhadarainfalltotal2.2timestheaverage.TherewaslittlehillsidedevelopmentinLosAngelesasof1941,andwhattherewastendedtoinvolvesmall-scalecut-and-fillgradingonindividuallots.By1951,manymassivecut-and-fillprojectshadbeenaccomplishedfortracthousingthatwasdevelopedduringtheeconomicboomafterWorldWarII.
Chapter 6 Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
34
thoserains,itbecameveryapparentthatsome-thingneededtobedone.Therewasapublicoutcry,ofcourse.
Soagroupofuswerecalledinbythecity,andwetriedtocomeupwithagradingordinancethatwouldminimizethesekindsoffailures.Iwasoneofthoseselectedtoworkwiththecitybuildingandsafetypeople,toputsometeethintothepolicyandcomeupwithasensibleordinancethatwouldminimizetheseprob-lems.Oneofthethingswerequiredwasthatasoilengineeringfirmberetainedtodocertainthings.Theyhadtomakeaninvestigationandareportbeforethefact—beforetheystarteddoinggradingworkontheproperty—statingwhatweresafeanglesforthecutslopesandforthefillslopes.Thatreportwasthensubmittedtothebuildingdepartment,andtheywouldreviewit.Theywouldreviewthegradingplans,andtheyrequiredinadditionthatacivilengineeringfirmpreparegradingplansshow-ingwhatwastobedoneandwhere.
Muchofthepreviousdevelopmentwasdonealmostonthebackofanenvelope.Adeveloperwouldsay,“I’mgoingtocutthisandfillthat.We’lldoitinthismanner.”Thentheygotoutthereonthesiteandtheydidalmostanythingtheywanted.Therewasnospecificsetofplans.
SothenewLosAngelesgradingordinancerequiredthegradingplansandthesoilreportbeforethepermitwasgranted.Then,duringconstructiontherequirementwasthatthesoilengineeringfirmbepresentandmakesurethatthesitewasproperlyprepared,whichincludedremovinganytopsoilorbrushbeforetheystartedputtingfillontopofit.Inthepast,itwasnotunknownforthedeveloperand
hisearth-movertojustgoaheadandplacefillonanunpreparedsite.Thatisthecheapwaytodoit,noquestionaboutit.Itwasalsothesourceofsay90percentoftheproblemswiththefill—thefactthattheyhadnotcleanedouttheloosematerialbelow.Anotherfactorwastheyhadnotprovideddrainagecapability,sowiththenaturaldrainageblockedbyfill,waterjustbuildsupinthefill,causeshydrostaticpressures,andweakensthesoil.Thisledtoagreatmanyofthefailures.
Thingslikethatwerecoveredbythe1952gradingordinanceoftheCityofLosAngeles,whichwaswayaheadofitstime.Infact,LosAngeleswasthefirstareathatrequiredthis.Otheragenciesandgovernmentsfollowedsuitshortlyafter,particularlytheCountyofLosAngeles.Sothatbroughtthesoilengineerintotheact.
Failures on Dipping BedsCrandall: Theninthelate1950sorearly1960s,heavyrainscausedproblemswithexcavatedslopesintheSantaMonicaMoun-tains,particularlythenorthside.Thebedsdippedtothenorth,andthenorthsideoftheSantaMonicaMountainswaswheretheywerecuttingintothosedippingbeds.Thatresultedinwhatiscalleddaylightedbedding—inotherwords,theslopeintersectsthebeddingplanes,andthecutsthenhadnothingbuttressingthem,astheydidbefore.Residentialproper-tiesinthemountainshavefailedbecausethesoilengineerswhoworkedwiththedevelop-ershadn’trecognizedtheinclinedbeddingasaweaknessthatneededtobeconsideredinanalyzinghillsidestability.Mostofthesoil
35
Chapter 6LeRoy Crandall • Development of Soil Engineering
openedupsomenewterritoryforsoilengi-neers.Diditresultinamuchwiderrealizationthatsoilengineersareneeded?
Crandall: Itdefinitelydid.Itstimulatedtheutilizationofsoilengineeringfirms.Therearedozensofthemnow,ofcourse.
Claims and Litigation, Tract HousingCrandall: Thepartofitthatreallyhurtthesoilengineeringpeoplewasthatformanyofthesedevelopmentsacorporationwassetuptodeveloptheproject,andthenaftertheprojectwasfinished,thecorporationwasdissolved.Sothepartieswhowereresponsibleforallthesedecisionsregardingqualityoftheworkwerenolongeravailablelegally.Sowhoisleft?Thepoorlittlesoilengineeringfirmwasstillaround,becausetheywereacontinuingbusi-ness,andtheybecamethepigeonofthelegalprofession,andwerebeingsuedgenerally.Soifanythingwentwrong,theonlyonereallyleftwasthesoilengineer,oralsooccasionallythegradingcontractor,thoughtheymanagedtoavoidtheexposurebysaying,“Wedidwhatthesoilengineertoldustodo.”Manysoilfirmsreallygothurtinlitigation,formattersthatwereactuallynottheirfault.Theywereanunfortunateparticipant,buthadnosayoverallthecriteria.
Nowadaystherestillcanbeproblems,ofcourse,andthesoilengineerhasanexposure,butthemagnitudeandthefrequencyofprob-lemsaremuchless,soit’salivablesituation.Somefirms,however,likemyown,avoidedhillsidetractworkcompletely.Evennow,LeRoyCrandallandAssociates,whichbecame
engineeringfirmsassumedthatbedrockwasjustwhatthetermimplies,anunyieldingfor-mationthatwouldn’tcreateanyproblems.It’sbedrock,sowhatcouldgowrong?
Scott: Butthat’snotnecessarilyso.
Crandall: Definitelynot,especiallywhenthestratifiedbedrockistilted,andsomeofthelay-ersofitcontainbentoniteclay,whichisveryslickwhenitgetswet.Ifwatergetsinbenton-ite,itbecomeslikegrease.Itislikeadeckofcardsthatyoutiltandthecardsstartsliding.Sotheengineeringgeologistscametotheforefront.Theywereaverypoliticallyastutegroup,believeitornot,sotheymanagedtopoundtheirdrumveryhard.
Sothecodewastightenedagain,andthistimeitincludedarequirementthatareportbyanengineeringgeologistcoverthebedrockcondi-tions.TheCityofLosAngelescameupwiththerequirementthathillsidepropertiesrequireareportbyanengineeringgeologistaswellasasoilengineer,beforethecitywouldgrantapermittobuild.
Itseemsridiculousthatcouldhavehappened.Anysoilengineerworthhissalt—whichIthinkwewere—recognizedthatissueandconsidereditintractwork.WeavoidedtractworkforseveralreasonsthatIwillenumerate.SoCran-dallandAssociatesweren’tdirectlyinvolvedintractsintheseareas.Butthosetractswerethebulkoftheworkofothersoilfirms.Manyofthemweredoingitonaslam-bangbasis,wherethecompactedfills,theexcavations,andsoon,weredonewithoutthekindofthoughtthattheworkreallyshouldhavehad.
Scott: Thatmajorchangeprobablyalso
Chapter 6 Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
36
Law/Crandall,doesnotsolicittractwork.Notthattractworkisbeneathourdignity,buttheoriginalstigmaisstillthere.
Asecondconcernisthefactthatthesoilengi-neeroftenwillnotgetsufficientfundstodothethoroughtypeofinvestigationthatmyfirmin-sistsuponforatract.Ifyoudidgetadeveloperwhopromisedadequatefunds,frequentlyyouwerenoteventuallypaidthefullamount.Manyofthedeveloperswererathershaky,financially.
Thethirdfactor,andthekeytomuchofthis,istheinspectionwork.Youhavetohavetrainedpeoplewatchingwhatisdone,tomakesureitisdoneproperly.
Scott: Areyousuggestingthatinspectionoftractworkismuchlesscarefuloradequatethanitisforothertypesofdevelopments?
Crandall: Essentially,yes.Thedeveloperisworkingatvariousdifferentplaces,andyouwillveryseldomgetenoughinspectors,paidforon-the-jobinspection,towatcheverypieceofearth-movingequipment.
Thefourthandfinalpointwithregardtoouravoidingtractsisthathomeowners,withalifeinvestmentinahome,arenotgoingtolosealawsuit,evenifthesoilengineerisnotatfault.Thehomeownerswin,andthelawsuitandjudgmentincludesanybodywhoisaround,andisfinanciallyabletoparticipateinthejudg-ment.Fortunately,mostsoilengineershaveliabilityinsurance.Buttheyarevulnerabletothesekindsofproblems.
Soitlookedliketherewasabetterfieldforourservicesinmajorconstruction,ratherthantracthousingwork;buttracthousingremainsabigfieldforsoilengineers.
Thestimulustosoilengineeringprovidedby
thegradingordinancewasn’tlimitedtotracts,
butaffectedanykindofbuildingwhereit
couldbeshownbyasite-specificstudythatthe
soilhadbettercharacteristicsthanthebuild-
ingcodeassumed.Also,ontheothersideof
thatcoin,thecodeisnotalwaysconservative
enough.Theremaybeaconditionorspecial
casewhere,ifthecodeminimumsarefollowed,
therewillbeproblemswiththebuilding.
Ineithercase,youneedtoknowaboutsite
conditions.Theproblemofexpansivesoils,
forexample,isveryacute,butitdoesn’tget
headlines.Thatisbecauseanaffectedbuild-
ingdoesn’tcollapse,itjustgetsallcracked
upandbecomesverydifficulttolivein.Itis
quiteexpensivetorepairthatkindofdam-
age.Wewereabletoconvincepeoplethatwe
couldprovidefactualinformationabouttheir
projects,andthatwhetherwhattheylearned
wasgoodorbad,ineithercasetheyneededto
know.Fortunately,mostofthetimewewere
abletoshowthatsavingsinconstructioncosts
basedonthefindingsofsoilinvestigationmore
thanoffsetthecostsoftheinvestigation.That’s
ahappypositiontobein,ofcourse,andthat’s
whatmadesoilengineeringnotonlypopular,
butalmostanecessity.
Scott: Itachievedthatlevelofacceptancein
thepostwarperiod,sayuptoabout1955.Is
thatmoreorlesswhathappened?
Crandall: Ithinkthatfitsverywell.
37
Chapter 6LeRoy Crandall • Development of Soil Engineering
Development of the Tie-Back Anchor in Southern CaliforniaCrandall: Iwanttomentionthetie-backanchor,whichwasalsoessentiallyasouth-ernCaliforniadevelopment.5Itisatie-backforshoringexcavations.ThemodelgradingordinanceoftheCityofLosAngelesandthetie-backanchorarewidelyusedfoundationandsoilengineeringapproachesthatwerepioneeredinsouthernCalifornia.Probablysomewhereinthe1960s,amanherenamedJoeLipowdevelopedamachinefordrillingaslantedholeintothefaceofaverticalexcava-tion.Theholetypicallywouldangledown-ward,ratherthanbestraighthorizontal.Hedrilledthehole,removedthecuttings,andformedabell(anenlargement)attheendofthehole.Theholeitselfmightbethirtyfeetorfortyfeetlong.
Scott: Thebellwasanenlargementatthedeepend?
Crandall: Yes,thetie-backwasroughlya6-inchdiameterholedrilledtoabout40feetindepth,andthenalittlediamond-shapedbell-ingbucketwasusedtoenlargetheendofthehole.Asteelrodwasplacedinthehole,andtheholefilledwithgrout(essentiallyconcrete)toformananchorintheground,adead-mantypeanchor.That’stheterminologythatwasusedthen.Theanchorwasattachedtothefaceoftheverticalexcavation,withsomethinglikeanoversizednutandwasher.Ithelditselfbythebootstraps,withthesoilanchorproviding
5. LeRoyCrandallreceivedtheMartinS.KappFoundationEngineeringAwardin1982fromtheAmericanSocietyofCivilEngineersforhisworkindevelopingthetie-backanchor.
alateralresistancetothefaceoftheverticalexcavation.Theverticalfaceoftheexcavationwastiedbackdeeplyintothesoilorrock,anditwascalledatie-back.Thustherewasnointeriorbracingintheexcavation.
Thetie-backanchorwasamarvelousbreak-throughinconstruction.Priortothat,holesinthegroundforthebasementsofbuildingsorsubterraneanparkinglevelsweresupportedbyinstallingstrutsacrossanexcavation,runningcompletelyfromonesidetotheother.Bystruttingacross,onesidepushedagainsttheother.Thestruttingisnotpracticalwithaverywidehole,ofcourse,inwhichcasetheywouldputinwhatarecalledrakers—bracesangledfromthebottomuptothesideoftheexcava-tion.Itisaverytoughjobforthecontractortoworkaroundallthoseimpedimentswithinthehole.Byengagingthesoilbeyondtheexcava-tion,andusingthatasthemethodofrestrain-ingtheexcavationface,thereisacompletelyopenhole,allowingthecontractortoworkalmostasthoughhewererightonthesurfaceoftheground.Thistechniquewaspioneeredhere,andI’mhappytosaythatmycompanyandIwereintimatelyinvolvedindevelopingthemethod,andusedthesystemonsomeverydeepexcavations.Now,insouthernCaliforniaanyway,almosteverysiteusestheearthanchortie-backsystemtoalloweconomicalconstruc-tionofsubterraneanprojects.
Scott: Fortherecord,whowasJoeLipow?DidhehaveaconnectionwithDamesandMoore?
Crandall: No.Hewasacontractorwhocameupwiththeideaforthedrillingequip-ment.Therehavebeengreatadvancesin
Chapter 6 Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
38
thesystemsince,buthehadthefirstdrillinthispartoftheworldthatwasdesignedtodojustthisjob.HegottogetherwithaMr.Webbandgotapatentontheirequipment.TheycalledittheWebb-Lipowsystemand
promotedit.Joewasthefirstinstallerofthistypeofdesign.Subsequently,othershoringcontractorsdevelopedequipmentthatwasactuallyevenbetter.Butthebasicideawasexactlythesame.
Chapter 7
Engineering Geology and Geotechnical Engineering
39
In the 1950s, civil engineers who
specialized in soils began to work as a
team with geologists.
Crandall: WhentheCityofLosAngelespasseditsgrad-ingordinanceandsubsequentregulationsthatrequiredageologist’sinput,itchangedtherelationshipofthedisci-plines.Thegeologistisconcernedwithrockinplace,ornature’sformationsinplace,whereasthesoilengineercantakethenaturalmaterialandreworkitandcomeupwithanothermaterial.Theprovinceofthesoilengineerextendstodealingwithcompactionoffill,forexample,anddoingtheanalyticalwork.Thegeologisttendstostudythesitebylooking:lookingatgeologymapsandlookingatthegeologyinthefieldasitisorasitisexposedwithanexcavation.Thesoilengineertendstoworkbymeasur-ingsoilpropertieswithinstruments,inthefieldorbackinthelaboratory.WhenIenteredthefield,wehadthebasictests—statictestsofshearstrength,consolidation,perme-ability,andofcoursemoistureanddensity.Thoseare
Chapter 7 Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
40
stillthefundamentaltests.Therehavebeenrefinementsinequipmentandapparatus.Younowhavedynamictestingcapability.Youcantestlargerspecimensandreadtheresultsmoreaccurately.Youcanputthemthroughcyclesofloadinginvariousformatstoapproximatewhatyouthinktheactualconditionsmightbe.Obviously,wedidnothavethosekindsofrefinementsintheearlydays.Butwedidhavethebasictypesoftests.
Ageologistwillsaytothesoilengineer,“Youhavethebedrockandit’sdippinginacertainfashion.Youfigureoutwhetherit’ssafeornot,butI’vegivenyoutheseparametershere:thatthisgeologicmaterialisofthistypeandcouldbehaveinsuchandsuchawayundercertaincircumstances.”Inthe1950s,civilengineerswhospecializedinsoilsbegantoworkasateamwithgeologists.
Registration of Engineering Geologists by the City of Los AngelesCrandall: Atthattimeengineeringgeolo-gistsweren’tregisteredbythestate,orbyanybodyelseforthatmatter,sotheCityofLosAngelessetupitsownqualificationsboard.Geologistswhospecializeinpetroleumexplo-ration,ordevelopingwaterwells,forexample,areexpertsinotherareasofgeologyanddon’thavetheexpertisetoadviseonslopesandotherconditionsforaconstructionproject,buttherewasnodistinctioninthelicensing.TheCityofLosAngelesbuildingdepartmentdeservestremendouscreditforallofthis.Theysawtheproblem,andtheywentoutandbroughtinexpertstohelpthemcomeupwithways
andmeansofprovidingsafeguardsagainstthepracticeofwhatwas,ineffect,engineeringgeologybygeologistswhoweren’tqualifiedtodothat.
SoanEngineeringGeologistsQualificationsBoardwassetupinLosAngelesin1957.Iwasamemberofthat.Therewasanothersoilengi-neerontheboardandthenabouttwoorthreeengineeringgeologistsofnote,includingDr.ThomasClementsoftheUniversityofSouth-ernCalifornia(USC)andRichardJahnsofCaltech,wholatermovedtoStanford.IthinklaterJimSlossonwasanother.WewouldgiveanoralinterviewtothecandidateswhowantedtobequalifiedbytheCityofLosAngelesinorderfortheirreportstobeacceptedbythebuildingdepartment.
Sowewouldinterviewthecandidateswhowantedtogetthisqualification.Idon’tknowwhatpercentagegotthrough,butprobablywefeltabout50percentwhoappliedwerecapableand50percentwerenot.Oneoftherequire-mentsthatwemadewasthattheymustbefa-miliarwiththegeologyofthisarea,notjustbeapaleontologist,forexample,whoknewallaboutthebonesofdinosaursandformationstheywerefoundin,butwhomightnotbefamiliarwithwhatthegeologyintheCityofLosAngeleswas.
Scott: Thatprobablymeanthavingprevi-ouslypracticedinthearea.
Crandall: Eitherthat,orreallyhavingstudiedandreadalotofliteratureabouttheformations,whattheyare,howtheybehave,andthatsortofthing.Thiswouldbeaprac-ticingperson,whowouldgooutonajobandmaptheareaandcomeupwiththegeologicinformationthatthesoilengineerandthe
41
Chapter 7LeRoy Crandall • Engineering Geology and Geotechnical Engineering
civilengineerneededtomakeasuitablegrad-ingplanandmakesurethatthecutsandfillsweresafe.
Scott: Fromwhatyou’resaying,Itakeitanengineeringgeologistismoreofageologistthananengineer.Wheredoestheengineeringcomein?
Crandall: Engineeringgeologistsaregeolo-gistswhospecializeinconstruction-typeprob-lems.Theyhavetobefamiliarwithwhattheengineersneedtoknowabouttheformationsandhowthey’regoingtofunction.
WhentheCityofLosAngelesbegantorequireandlicenseengineeringgeology,thatwasarealimpetusforthewholefield.Thoseuniversitiesthatonlyhadgeneralgeologybegantothinkintermsofthatspecialty.Schoolsthatdidn’thaveengineeringgeologybegantoputinthespecialty,becauseofthedesireforitonthepartoftheirstudents.OncetheCityofLosAngelesgotstarted,theCountyofLosAngelesstarteddoingthesamething,in1959.Itgottothepointwherethereweretoodoggonemanygovernmentalagencieswiththeirfingerinthatpie.IfyouwerequalifiedbytheCityofLosAn-geles,theCountyofLosAngelessaid,“That’sfine,butifyou’regoingtoworkoutsidethecitylimitsinthejurisdictionofthecounty,wewantyoutotalktoourownqualificationsboardandbelicensedbyus.ItgotsothattoworkinsouthernCaliforniaanengineeringgeologistwouldhavetogothroughfourorfiveexams.
State Registration and CertificationCrandall: Civilengineersalreadyhadastatelicensingcategory,buttherewasaneedtohave
abetterwaytoregulategeologists.In1968,thestatecreatedaregistrationforgeologistswithaspecialtycertificationforthosegeolo-gistsqualifiedtodoengineeringgeology.Ihavetobecarefulaboutterminology.Thereare“registeredgeologists,”andthereare“certifiedengineeringgeologists.”YoucanbearegisteredgeologistintheStateofCalifornia,whichisthebroadareaofpractice,butifyouwanttobeac-creditedasanengineeringgeologist,thenyouhavetogetcertifiedinadditiontobeingreg-istered.Priortothe1952LosAngelesgradingordinance,engineeringgeologywasaname-it-yourselfspecialtyinthegeologicalconsultingfield.Thenitbecamearestrictedfield,firstbylocalordinancesinLosAngelesandotherlocalgovernmentsinsouthernCalifornia,andeventually,asI’llexplain,bystatelaw.
Thingshavechangedmorerecently,butsoilengineeringwasoriginallyonlyregulatedasaprofessionbythebasiccivilengineeringlicense.Itwasleftuptotheindividualcivilengineertoexerciserestraintontheirownpartastowhetherornottheyhadtheexpertisetopracticeasasoilengineer.Theonlydisciplinewithincivilengineeringthatrequiredsupple-mentalregistrationwasstructuralengineering,andthatwasrequiredinordertoqualifytodesignCaliforniapublicschoolbuildings,andlater,Californiahospitals.Butacivilengi-neer—likeIam—theoreticallycanpracticeinanyareaofcivilengineering.Icandostructur-alengineering,aslongasit’snotaschoolorahospital,exceptthatthelawsays,“Youmustbeexperiencedorqualifiedinthatareatodothatspecialtyoranyspecialty.”Itwouldberidicu-lousformetotrytodesignamajorbuilding,orevenanot-so-majorbuilding,becauseI’ve
Chapter 7 Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
42
notdoneanyofthat.Ididthatinschoolandgotexposedtoit,andIthinkIknowenoughaboutittorealizethatI’mnotthatgoodatit.IsupposeIcoulddesignabuilding,butitwouldtakememanytimesaslongassomebodywhodoesitallthetime,becauseI’dhavetogobacktothebooksandcarvemywaythroughinordertodoanything.
Geotechnical Engineering RecognizedScott: Talkalittlebitaboutgeotechnicalengineeringasadiscipline.
Crandall: Thecivilengineeringspecialtydevotedtosoilsandfoundationswasfirstcalled“soilmechanics.”Thenitbecame“soilandfoundationengineering,”butthatgottobealittlemuchofamouthful.Besides,alotofpeopleweredoingthingsotherthanjustfoundations,sotheterm“geotechnicalengi-neer”wascoined.Thatiskindofredundant.Itreallyshouldbegeotechnician,buteverybodywantedittosoundmoreimpressivethanthat.
Scott: Geotechnicalengineerdoessoundbetterthangeotechnician.
Crandall: Right.ItcameaboutthroughtheAmericanSocietyofCivilEngineers,andwhileIhadaroleinthat,Ididn’tmakeallthesethingshappen.Ijusthappenedtobethere.Iwastheliaisonnationaldirectortothegeotechnicaldivision,orwhatatthattimewascalledthesoilandfoundationengineeringdivi-sion,ofASCE.Thepressurewasontocomeupwithastandardtermforthedisciplinethatwasshorterthan“soilandfoundationsengineer.”Wecalledforsuggestionsfromthe
membersandpeoplesentthemin.“Geotech-nicalengineer”wasthemostpopularandmostoftensubmittedterm.Theexecutivecom-mitteeofthatASCEdivisionrecommendedchangingthenameto“geotechnicaldivision.”ThiswasapprovedbytheASCEnationalboardofdirection.
Geotechnical Engineering and Structural EngineeringCrandall: Theworkofthegeotechnicalengi-neerisnotasprominentasthatofthestructur-alengineer.Isometimessaythatthedoorknobsgetmoreconsiderationthanthefoundationsofabuilding.Oncetheyarebuiltandintheground,nobodyknowsorcaresaboutthefoun-dations,unlesssomethinggoeswrong.
Withregardtoseismicconsiderations,howev-er,wecomebacktothefundamentalphenom-enon—theshakingabuildingundergoescomesfromtheground.Itisthegroundmovementthataffectsthebuilding,anduntilyouknowwhatthenatureofthegroundmovementcouldbe,youcan’treallymakeacredibledesignforabuilding.Now,priortogeotechni-calengineeringreachinganadvancedstateoftheart,thatgroundmovementwasestimatedusingsomebody’sguess,oritmightevenhavebeenthe1940ElCentrorecord,whichreceivedsomuchusageinthosedays.Wecantalkmorelateraboutthecollectionofmanymorestrongmotionrecordsinrecentyears.
Andnow,geotechnicalengineeringhasprogressedtowherewecancomeupwithreallysupportabledataongroundmotionforthegeologicalenvironmentofasiteandtheseismiccharacteristicsofthatarea.Inthat
43
Chapter 7LeRoy Crandall • Engineering Geology and Geotechnical Engineering
cases,whatonedoesistrytogetallthepar-tiestogetherandmakeacompletefixthatiseconomical,withcostsdistributedsayoversixorsevenlots.
Scott: Thatisprobablywheretheassessmentdistrictideawouldcomein.
Crandall: Exactly.ButIhavebeensuccess-fulinaboutthreeoutofamultitudeofcasesofmulti-propertyproblems,tryingtorepairthem.Thereisalwayssomebodywhodoesn’tgoalongwithitorrefusestocarryhisorhershareoftheburden.SoIconsideritatremen-doussuccesstogetagroupofpeopletogethertofinancearepairthataffectsallofthem.Anditaffectsnotonlythepeopleinvolved,italsoaffectsthesurroundingarea.Anyareawithlandslidingproblemshasaneffectonadjoiningproperties.Whenthissortofthinghappenstoaneighborhood,thevalueofthepropertygoesdown,andtheabilitytosellanindividualpropertygoesdown.
Scott: Areyoutalkingprimarilyaboutsitu-ationswheretheyaretryingtoretrofitinanexistingdevelopmentthatgotintotrouble?Orareyoutalkingaboutnewterritorythattheywanttodevelop—anewdevelopment?
Crandall: Theproblemusuallyinvolvesexistingdevelopments,wherethepropertiesareownedbyindividuals.Havingbeenbuilton,thatmakesitmorecomplicatedtorepair.Withnewdevelopment,ofcourse,youhavetheopportunitytoidentifythepotentialland-slideareasandmakethefixatthattime.Ifthecorrectiveworkiseconomicallyexcessive,thenthedeveloperhastomakeadecision.Doesthedeveloperabandonthewholething,orsetasidethoselotsasspaceforaparkorsome-
sense,geotechnicalengineeringisnowaveryfundamentalpartoftheseismicdesignofabuilding.Itprovidestheneededinformationthatpermitsarealisticappraisalofthebuild-ing’sbehaviorinanearthquake.
Intheearlierdays,wetalkedaboutgeotechnicalengineeringmerelygivingsomebroadgeneralstatementsaboutthetypeofshakingthatmightoccur.Inotherwords,willtheshakinghaveahighfrequencyorlowfrequency?Istheampli-tudelikelytobelargeorsmallforagivensite?Wecouldusuallydeducethis,whetheritwasahardsoilorasoftsoil,sincealarge-amplitudeandalowfrequencygotogetheronsoftsoil,whereasonrockyougenerallygetasmalleram-plitudeandahigherfrequency.Inearlierdays,thatwasaboutasfaraswecouldgo.
Site SelectionCrandall: Ithinkmostengineershavethefeelingthatwecanbuildonalmostanythingifyouwillgiveusenoughmoneytodoit.ThoughIguessthereisapracticallimitonmanysites—wherethecostoffoundationconstructionismorethantheeconomicvaluethecompletedstructurewouldwarrant.Inthatsense,theremaybesitesthatonewouldsayarenotbuildable,butIliketothinkthatitisaneconomicdeterminationbaseduponapropersoilevaluation.
Youmightcomeupwithunbuildablesitesinaresidentialhillsideareawherealandslideorpotentiallandslideinvolvesamulti-lotprob-lem.Ifyouareconsideringbuildingononeofthoselotsbyyourself,itwouldcostyousomuchtoabatetheproblemsinglythatitwouldjustbeoutrageouslyexpensive.Inthose
Chapter 7 Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
44
thingofthatsort?ThereareareasinsouthernCaliforniawherethereareagreatmanyexist-inglandslidesinthenaturalterrain,andiftheyaretobedevelopedthatmustbecorrected.
Someofthegroundfailuresusceptibilitiesarenotapparentuntilyougoinanddotheexploratorywork.Thatisonereasonwhygeotechnicalandgeologicalstudiesaresoimportantinhillsideareas.Youcan’talwaystellbylookingthatanareaislandslide-prone,orhashadpastlandslides.
Scott: Especially,Isuppose,whentheyareoldorancientlandslides.
Crandall: Thatisright.Alotofproblemshaveoccurredjustbecauseanancientland-slidewasnotidentified.Itmayhavebeenessentiallystableundernaturalconditions.Butwhenyouputinaseriesofhomesites,youmaychangetheslopes,andyouintroducelotsofwatertoirrigategardens.TheirrigationcanbemorecriticalthanthenaturalrainfallinsouthernCaliforniaforslopestability.Youintroducewaterintothosesoilsandactivatetheoldslide.
Portuguese BendScott: IguessthePalosVerdessituationonthesouthernCaliforniacoastissomethinglikethat.
Crandall: PortugueseBendwasaknownancientlandslide—itwasongeologicmaps.Inmyopinionitprobablywouldhavebeenasuc-cessfuldevelopment,exceptthatitwasanareawheretheyusedindependentsewagedisposalsystems.Theyhadcesspoolsandseptictanks.
Scott: Thatwasabouttheworstpossiblethingtheycouldhavedone.
Crandall: Exactly.Itwas.Noteverybodyagreeswithme,dependinguponwhoseoxisbeinggoredhere,butIfeelthatitwastheintroductionofwaterintothesebentoniticclayseams,whichareverythin,likeaninchthick—Ithinkthatprecipitatedtheslippage.Andtheslippageisstillgoingon.
LosAngelesCountygotstuckwithfixingthat,whichwasamiscarriageofjustice,inmyopin-ion.Well,ithasn’tbeenfixed,butthecountypaidoffthosepeople.Someofthemarestilllivingthere.Aninterestingsidelightonthiswasthatthelandmovementwassogreatthattherehadtobeanagreementregardingthepropertylines,thesurveylines.Therehadtobeagree-mentthatthepropertylineswouldmovewiththeground.Otherwise,youmightfindyourhouseonyourdownhillneighbor’spieceofproperty.Asurvey,ofcourse,isbasedonfixedpointsinspace,unlessyouhavelegislationsay-ingthatthesurveypointsaremoving.
Thiswasworkedout,anditwasgoodexceptforthepoorownerswhoweredownatthebottom.Theirpropertyendedupintheocean.Dotheyhavetogotothebackofthelineatthetopofthehill,whichisnowagiganticfis-sure?Iamnotsureifthatwasdone,butIdoknowthatitwasagreedthatthepropertylinesmovedwithyourhouse.Thatwasquiteaseri-ouslegalproblemforawhile.
Environmental ContaminationCrandall: Sayyouestimateyourcostsbasedontheinformationfurnished,andthenyou
45
Chapter 7LeRoy Crandall • Engineering Geology and Geotechnical Engineering
startconstructionandrunintosomethingdif-ferent.Thatcancreateaproblem.Onethingthatisnowaffectingprojectcostiscontami-natedsoil.Itreallyisahardthingtopredict.
InLosAngeles,theyusedtohaveagasstationoneverycorner.Nowitisasavingsandloan,andthegasstationsseemalmostnonexistent.Butthosegasolinestoragetankswouldleakovertheyearsandgoundetectedunlesstheoperatorbegantolosetoomuchgasandtriedtofindoutwhatwaswrong.Butpracticallyallofthemleaked,andtherewasdisposalofdrainedmotoroil,whichwasdroppedinaholeorapitintheground.Thesethingsallpenetratedthesoilandmanyofthemreachedoreventuallycouldreachthewatertable.
Wearenowawarethatthisisnotagoodthing.Infact,Ithinkthependulumhasnowswungtoofar,tothepointwhereweareget-tingridiculouslyconcernedaboutsomeoftheconditions.Butinanyevent,let’ssayyouareanownerorbuilderandyouacquireasite,andhavenotgivenanythoughttothepossibilityofcontaminatedmaterialonthesite.Youstartyoursitework,sayexcavatingforabasement,whichistypical,andrunintooldseepageinthesoilfromagasolineoroilstoragetank.
Intheolddaysthatwasconsiderednottoobad,andpeoplewouldusethatfillandputitoutintheparkinglotanduseitandnotgiveanotherthoughttoit.Thegasolineeventuallyevaporated,youknow.Butnow,ithasbecomeatoxicwasteproblem.Youusedtobeabletotakethesoilinyourexcavationanddisposeofitonalandfillformaybe$1or$2percubicyard,orsellittosomebodyelse.
Well,thatdoesnotworknow.Thatkindofsoilisconsideredtoxic,andyoucanonlydis-poseofitatcertaintypesoflandfills,andifyouhaveanykindofPCBmaterialorothertoxiccharacteristicsofthatsort,whichiscommon,youhavetohaulitupfromLosAngelestoSanLuisObispoCountyorsomewherelikethat,afewhundredmilesaway,anditwillcost$100to$200percubicyard.
Costslikethatcankillaproject,ofcourse.Andthereisthelitigationastowhoisatfaultandwhoshouldpay.TheEPAandthecountyhealthagenciesandotherpeopledon’tcareaboutcost,youjusthavetogetitoutofthereandtakeitaway.Socontaminatedsoilisarealproblem.
Nowadays,asoilengineerhastoconsidersoilcontamination,anddoalotofresearchonthepasthistoryofapieceofpropertytotrytofindoutiftherewasanypossiblesource.Environ-mentalassessmentisanewthingthatisdonealmostreligiouslyonanysiteinanurbanareatotrytofindoutitspastusage.Thisisdoneevenbeforeasiteispurchased.Andwoebefallsthesoilengineerwhomissessomethingthatdidexistbefore,andhewasunabletofindit.Itimmediatelybecomesyourfault—“youshouldhavedrilledmoreborings,youshouldhaveputaboringhere,youshouldhavecheckedtheserecords,”orsomethingelse.Theimpactisre-allytremendous.
WehadonesiteinMarinadelRey,whereitwasknownthatallofthesethingshadhap-pened—therewereundergroundtanks,therehadbeenweldingandmachineshops,andmanufacturing.Theywouldhaveacidpicklingbathsforthesteelthattheyused,anddumped
Chapter 7 Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
46
itoutonthegroundorinthepit.Theen-vironmentalassessmentstudyfoundthesethingsout,andnowthedeveloperhastocleanthatsiteup.Thismeantmillionsofdollars.Itwasabigsite.
Weusedbacteriaonthatjobthatwillcleanupthesoil.Theyhavetodigupthesoil,spreadthesoilout,addafoodforthebacteriathatissprayedintothesoil,andtheselittlerascalsgotoworkandinaboutacoupleofweeksthehydrocarbons,whichiswhatthecontaminantis,aregoneorgreatlyreduced.
Scott: Thatfast?Iguesstheydigestthehydrocarbons.
Crandall: Yes.Andyouturnthesoiloverandmixitupbit.Thenextworryis,“We’vecreatedthesebacteria,nowaretheygoingtotakeovertheworld?”Apparently,however,oncethefoodsourceisgone,theydisappear.Theydieorgointohibernationorsomething.Thismethodisnotcheap,butitisaheckofalotcheaperthaninthiscasepayingcloseto$1,000ayardtohaulthesoilaway.Itisprob-ablycostingabout$100ayardtogiveitthebiologicaltreatment.
Inaddition,thegroundwateronthesiteiscontaminated,asisthegroundwaterofthewholesurroundingarea.Youasownerofthesitearenotonlyresponsibleforcleaningitup,butifyoucontributeanypollutedgroundwatertoanadjacentsite,thenyouarealsorespon-sibleforthat.Sowhatdowedo?Weputabunchofmonitoringwellsaroundtheperiph-eryoftheproperty.Ifsomethingcomesintothissitefromoff-site,whichislikely,becausethegroundwaterisslowlymovingtowardstheharbor,youcansay,“Thiscamefromthat
guyoff-site,Ididnotcontributeittothewatersupply.”Notonlyistheclean-uprequired,butalsoamonitoringprogramthattheywillhavetomaintainforthelifeoftheproject.
Scott: Speakingasalayperson,theground-watercontaminationseemstomanyofusmorescarythanmanyoftheotherkindsofsitecontamination.Groundwaterisapreciousre-source,andifcontaminated,thecontaminantsdonotstayinoneplace,buttravel.
Crandall: ContaminationhasruinedmanywellsinsouthernCalifornia,intheSanGabrielValleyandSanFernandoValley.Theyhavenowsetacceptablelimitsforcontaminationsodoggonelowthatitisalmostimpossibletogetby.WehavetotreatwastewateralmosttoaqualitybetterthandrinkingwaterinLosAngeles.Therearealotofproblemsthere.Thereareno“absolutes”—youaredepen-dentoneachindividualagencyandindividualinspectorsintheagency,whokindofcalltheshotsonjobsintheirterritory.Youneverknowexactlywhatisexpectedofyou.
Asphaltic Sands at La BreaCrandall: IhadoneexperiencewithasiteattheLaBreaTarPit,whichhasbeentheresinceprehistorictimes.
Scott: Sincethetimeofthesaber-toothedtiger.
Crandall: Yes.Itisasphalticsand.ThesandcontainstheasphaltthatcomesupintheLaBreaTarPitandcausesamethanegasprob-leminthatarea.Itusedtobeconsideredverygoodfill.Youcouldalmostexcavateit,mixit
47
Chapter 7LeRoy Crandall • Engineering Geology and Geotechnical Engineering
withsand,putitinaparkinglot,androllittoproducepaving.
Now,itisconsideredhazardous.WehadoneheckofatimetalkingthemoutofforcingthedevelopertotakethatsoilclearuptoaspecialdumpatCasmalia,acoupleofhundredmilesupthecoast,togetridofit.Thisparticularinspectorfromoneofthecityagenciesmadethestatementthatasphalticsandwastoxic,andnotonlythatbutalsoalltheasphaltpavingintheCityofLosAngeleswastoxic.Ifthisguyhadhiswayhewouldhaveallthatasphaltpav-ingtakenupanddisposedofsomeway.Thatishowfarsomeofthemcango.Ithinkthependulumhasgonetoofar.
Liquefaction, Settlement, Landslides, Soil Compaction
Crandall: Microzonationalsoconcernslique-faction,landslides,settlement,andsoilcompac-tion—notjustgroundshaking.Soildoesnotnecessarilyhavetoliquefy,itcansettlewithoutliquefactionifwaterisnotpresent,andthatcausesdamagetobuildingsandroadwaysandpipelinesandotherthingsthatwedependon.
Thedegreeofshakingexpectedatasitecanalsobeincludedinmicrozonation.Thatwaythelanduseplannersandthebuildersaremadeawareoftherisksinagivenarea.
Scott: Somicrozonationreallyistryingtospecifymorepreciselywhattoanticipateinanareathatisasmallerpartofamuchlargerseismiczone.
Crandall: That’sright.
Scott: Thisdiscussionhelpsmeunderstandbetterwhatmicrozonationisallabout.Ithasalwayssortofbaffledme.Ihaveheardpeopleusethetermindifferentways.
Crandall: Itsometimesdependsonthecon-text,dependsonwhatyourattentionisfocusedon.Itmightbemicrozonationofstrongearth-quakeshaking.Oritmightbeoneormoreofthegroundfailurehazards,likeliquefactionorlandslides.Itmightbesettlementofman-madefills.Mostanygeotechnicalphenomenonorriskcanbesubjecttomicrozonation.
IthinkthereareexcellentmicrozonationmapsoftheSanFranciscoarea,showingwheretheoldBayshorewasandwheretoday’sbuildingsare.Alsotheyshowtheharderrockareas,andtheareasthataregoodfromanearthquakestandpoint.Youareahellofalotbetterofftobuildonrockthan,astheBiblesays,tobuildonsand—particularlyinearthquakeconditions.Whenyouknowthat,ifyouareinterestedinsafety,itisausefulthingtobeabletocrankintoyourplanning.Ineverthoughtofitthatwaybefore,buteachcomprehensivegeotechni-calreportonasiteisineffectamicrozonationofthatspecificsite.Onethingthatyouhavetobecarefulofisthatyoudon’tfocustoosharplyononlyyourparticularpieceofproperty,becausethelotnexttoitmighthaveaneffectonyours.Forexampleonahillside,iftheslideoccursoffyoursitebutcomesontoyoursite,you’vegotaproblemeventhoughyouyourselfdidnotcontributetothatproblem.
Anyway,theneedforandtheavailabilityofthesemoredetailedmapshasreallygrowncon-siderably.IthinkthatfollowingtheLomaPrieta
Chapter 7 Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
48
earthquake,therewillbemuchmoreofthatkindofthingavailableforthepublictoconsider.
Scott: Iguessthegrowthintheneedformicrozonationreflectsagreaterdemandforit,andawarenessofitsvalue.Clientsarebecomingmoreawarethat,ifyouknowmoreaboutanareaandknowitmoreprecisely,theinformationcanhelpyouavoidfuturedamage.Isthatbasicallywhatdrivesthedemand?
Crandall: Yes.Thegreatadvantage,ofcourse,isprimarilyfornewstructures.Byknowingwhathazardsthereareonabuild-ingsiteandwhatpotentiallycouldoccur,likeliquefaction,youcandesignafoundationthatcanresistthat.Soyoucanbuildastructureevenifyouareonapoorsite.Wedothatallthetime.
Chapter 8
Soil Engineering and Earthquake Engineering
49
An earthquake is a real, full-scale test of a
building, and unfortunately, we still need that
type of test to verify and advance our field.
Early Days of Strong Motion Study
Crandall: BillMoore,andRalphMcLeanwereamong
theearlypioneersintheprogramoftheU.S.Coastand
GeodeticSurveytodeployaccelerographs.Infact,the
CoastandGeodeticsurveygotareadingfromtheElCen-
troearthquakein1940,andthatreadingbecametheBible
forengineersinstudyingearthquakes.Whileknowledge-
ableengineersfeltthatitwasn’tnecessarilytypicalofevery
earthquake,itwasthebestrecordtheyhad.
Scott: IusedtowonderaboutthatwhenIwasfirstget-
tingintothefieldofearthquakehazard.HenryDegen-
kolbandJohnBlumeandothersusedtorefertothatEl
Centrorecordasifitweresomethingveryimportant,
sortofliketheHolyGrail.
Chapter 8 Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
50
Crandall: Itwas.Ifitistheonlycuparound,itisprettyholy,isn’tit?IrememberJohnBlumetalkingaboutgoingtothestatelegis-latureandaskingforfundingformoreinstru-mentation.Hetoldthem,“Wehaveonlyoneespeciallyusefulstrongmotionrecord,fromtheElCentroearthquakein1940.”Oneofthelegislatorsresponded,“Well,ifyouhaveone,whatdoyouneedanymorefor?”Butallearthquakesarenotalike.
Incidentally,thereisareasonforusingtheterm“strong”motion.Caltech,Berkeley,andotherplacesinCalifornia,haveobtainedandkepttheseismologicalrecordonthoselargedrumswithpaperaroundthem,ashaveseismologicallaboratoriesaroundtheworld.Theinstrumentsused,theseismographs,arevery,verysensitive.Theyareusedformeasur-ingearthquakesthatmaybeveryfaraway,sayinJapan,somewhereontheothersideoftheearthfromtherecordingstation.Iftheearth-quakeiscloseby,theseismographwilltrytotakeareading,butwilljumpoffscaleduetoitshighsensitivity.
Whatengineersneededwassomethingtotellthemtheaccelerationofthegroundandtheaccelerationofabuildingcausedbyarelativelynearbyearthquake.Soawholenewstableofinstrumentswasdeveloped,called“strongmo-tion”instruments.Theywouldstayonscale.Sostrongmotioninstruments—accelero-graphs—areusedinbuildingsandinfree-fieldinstallationssothatwegetafullrecordofwhatishappeningatthoseparticularlocations.Theseismographstheseismologistsoperatearere-allyintendedtotellyouwhattheearthscienceeventwasatitssource,perhapsthousandsofmilesaway.
Youdon’twantthestrongmotionrecordertobesetoffbyeverylittlemildshake.Theyhaveatriggeringmechanismthatdoesnotstarttherecordingunlesstheaccelerationreachingtheinstrumentisgreaterthan0.05g.Thatistheverticalmeasurement.Theverticalwavesarrivefirst,andiftheyexceedthisvalue,thatstartsthecameragoing.Thefilmbeginstomoveanditisrecordingwhenthemoredam-agingshearwavesarrive.Later,digitalinstru-mentswereinventedandhavelargelyreplacedtheonesthatrecordedoptically.
San Fernando EarthquakeCrandall: Inthe1971SanFernandoearth-quake,astrongmotioninstrumentattheabut-mentofPacoimaDamgavesomeveryhighreadings.Severalpeoplehavemadeacareeroutofstudyingthat.Theygotreadingsover1g.Thentherewasmuchstudyandinterestinquestionssuchaswhetherthatseveremotionwasduetoafocusedearthquakeeffectoveronesmalllocale,andwhatwastheeffectofasharpbedrockridgethatthisinstrumentwasmountedon.TheearthquakewastheboostneededtostartuptheCaliforniastatewidestrongmotionprogram,theStrongMotionInstrumentationProgram(SMIP),andthatdeservesmorediscussionlater.
Evenbeforethe1971SanFernandoearth-quake,mostengineerswereawarethatstrongmotionrecordsofearthquakeswereessen-tialtointelligentbuildingdesignforseismicresistance.ThentheSanFernandoearthquakeoccurred.Itwasaveryfrighteningevent.IexperiencedithereintheLosAngelesarea,onFebruary9th,1971.OurhomeinLaCañada
51
Chapter 8LeRoy Crandall • Soil Engineering and Earthquake Engineering
wasonprettysolidmaterial,sowedidnotsufferanydamageatall,butwecertainlyknewitwasshakingat6:00a.m.thatmorning.Inanyevent,thatearthquakeprecipitatedagreatlyincreasedawarenessofthevalueofinstrumentation.
TheCityofLosAngeles,throughitsbuildingandsafetydepartment,hadalreadyadoptedarequirementin1965thatallstructuressixstoriesandtallerhadtohavestrongmotioninstrumentsinstalledatthebase,mid-height,andtop.Anumberofbuildingshadbeeninstrumentedintimetocollectrecordsfromthe1971earthquake.
Scott: HowwastheLosAngelesprogramfunded?Wasthatalevyonindividualbuildings?
Crandall: Yes.Theindividualownershadtodothis.Theywererequirednotonlytopro-videtheinstruments,butalsotoprovidesuit-ablelocationsfortherecordinginstruments.Theownerpaidthetabforthis,and—whatwasmoreofaproblemforthem—theyhadtoprovidespaceinaroomoraspeciallocationthatcouldbelockedoff,sothecitypersonnelcouldinspecttheresults.Ofcoursethiswasnottoopopularwiththebuildingowners,butitwasdone,andthecitywasabletoenforceit.
Theostensiblepurposeoftheordinancewastoprovideinformationthatwouldbeusefulinevaluatingthesafetyofabuildingafteranearthquake.Someofusfeltthathavingonlythreeinstrumentswasnotenoughforthatpurpose,butitsoldtheprogram,andthatwasveryimportant.
WeobtainedalargenumberofbeautifulrecordsfromtheSanFernandoearthquakethatwereagodsendtothestructuralengi-
neeringdesignpeople.6Theyhadachancetoseehowthebuildingshadbehavedwhenactuallyshaken.
Scott: Thiswasalsoademonstrationofthekindsofrecordsyoucouldgetthroughinstru-mentation,andoftheirpotentialvalue.
Crandall: Yes,itwasanexampleofwhattheseinstrumentscoulddo,anditprecipitatedreallystrongeffortstodosomethingmorestatewide.Whenyougetafewrecords,youhungerformore.Forexample,itturnedoutthatonlythreeinstrumentsperbuildinggaveusefuldata,butwasnotsufficienttoprovidealltheinformationneeded.
MuchworkwasdoneontheSanFernandoearthquake.IhadthegoodfortunetobeputinchargeofthefoundationstudyportionofthereportthatwasmadeontheSanFernandoearthquake.Thatworkcoverednotonlythegroundmotionrecord,butalsowhathappened,andwhatdidnothappen,duringthequake.
6. Thetotalnumberofstrongmotionrecordsfromthe1971SanFernandoearthquakewas241,ofwhich57wereobtainedfromthetoplevelsofbuildings.Afewinstrumentswerealsolocatedonotherstructures,suchasPacoimaDam,wherethemostsevereaccelerationrecordinthatearthquakewasrecorded.(R.P.MaleyandW.K.Cloud,Strong Motion Accelerograph Records, San Fernando, California Earthquake of February 9, 1971.NationalOceanicandAtmosphericAdministration,1973,p.346.)Priortothisearthquake,therewereonlyapproximatelytenstrongmotionrecordsofgreatusefulnesstoearthquakeengineers,outofatotalofapproximately100thathadbeencollectedsincetheintroductionofaccelerographsbytheU.S.CoastandGeodeticSurveyin1932.
Chapter 8 Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
52
Scott: Forwhomwasthatreportdone?
Crandall: FortheNationalOceanographicandAtmosphericAssociation(NOAA).Theyappointedacommitteetoprepareareportontheearthquake.MartinDuke,nowde-ceased,wasthechairman.7Hehadanumberofsubcommittees,oneofwhichwasthesoilandfoundationssubcommittee.Ihadthehonorofbeingthechairmanofthatandofdirectingandworkingwiththepeoplewhowerestudyingwhathappenedconcerningthegroundmotionandfoundationbehaviorduringtheearth-quake.Thiswasaveryimportantexperience,notjustforme,butalsoforeverybodywhoparticipated—theengineeringprofession,andotherstoo,includingthesocialscientists,whowereverymuchinvolvedinfindingouthowpeoplebehavedandthingsofthatnature.
Scott: Saysomethingmoreaboutthereportonthatearthquake.
Crandall: VolumeIof San Fernando, Cali-fornia Earthquake of February 9, 1971dealswitheffectsonbuildingstructures,andisintwoparts,PartAandPartB.VolumeIIdealswithutilities,transportation,andsociologi-calaspects.VolumeIIIcoversgeologicalandgeophysicalstudies
ThereportwasdoneunderacooperativeagreementbetweenNOAAandtheEarth-quakeEngineeringResearchInstitute(EERI),andwaspublishedin1973.
7. Murphy,Leonard,editor,San Fernando, California Earthquake of February 9, 1971;threevolumes.NationalOceanicandAtmosphericAdministration,1973.
Scott: Witha1973publicationdate,thatreportonaFebruary1971earthquakewasputoutprettyfast.
Crandall: Yes.TheintroductionwasbyLeon-ardMurphy,KarlSteinbrugge,andC.MartinDuke.Itreallywasaveryfinepieceofworkonthequakeanditseffects.Thereportcollectsaseriesofpapersbyvariousauthors.
Oneoftheimportanttopicsrelatedtosoilswasthedamagetodams,especiallytheLowerSanFernandoDamThatwasreportedonbybothH.Bolton(Harry)Seed,andKennethLee.Itcameveryclosetoarealcatastrophe,believeme.Thattoldusalotaboutsomeoftheseearlydamsthatwerebuiltbyhydraulicmethods.
Scott: ItalsopromptedthestateDivisionofSafetyofDamstotakenotice.
Crandall: Yes,thestateDivisionwasveryprominentininvestigatingtheperformanceofdamsintheearthquake,andfindingoutwhyandhow.Muchcameoutofthat.Thesafetyofdamswasoneofthebiggestseismicsafetyinfluencesfromthatearthquake,thegreatestintermsofpotentialhazardreduction.Thefailureofasingledamcancausedisastrouslosses.Iwasouttherethedayafterthequakeanditisjustincrediblehowclosethatdamwastothewaterovertoppingitaftertheembank-mentfailureoccurred.Itwasamatterofafewfeet,asthetopoftheearthfilldamsubsidedtensoffeet,andifthewaterhadevergoneover,itwouldhaveerodedthroughveryquicklyandwipedthedamout—almostinstantaneously.
Ifeltobligedtopointoutinmycontributionthatagreatmanystructureswentthroughtheearthquakewithoutsufferingdamage.Ithasal-
53
Chapter 8LeRoy Crandall • Soil Engineering and Earthquake Engineering
Ihadnothingtodowiththeestablishmentofthestate’sprogram,andItakenocreditforanyofthishappening.CertainlyIwasinfavorofit,butthoseengineerswhodidpursuethis,likeJohnBlume,KarlSteinbrugge,andothers,didaveryfinepieceofworkinconvincinglegisla-tors.IalsothinkSenatorAlfredAlquistwasprobablythemostsupportiveandinstrumentalCaliforniastatelegislatorinthis,andhereal-izedtheimportanceofcomingupwithlegisla-tionthatcreatedaprogramofinstrumentation.
Iwasluckyenoughtobeappointedtotheinitialsteeringcommittee,andoneoftheothersonthatcommitteewasMartinDuke.IrememberparticularlythatheandIusedtoridetheplanetoSacramentotogether,ortowhereverthemeetingwaslocated.Icantellyoulaterhowtheconversationswehadononeofthoseplaneridesledtotheformationofthelifelinesgroup,theTechnicalCouncilonLifelineEarthquakeEngineering(TCLEE),intheAmericanSocietyofCivilEngineers.
Scott: It’sinterestinghowadevelopmentalongonefrontintheefforttoextendseismicsafetycanleadtodevelopmentsinanother.
Crandall: Yes,itis.You’reright.SothisadvisorycommitteeofaboutadozenpeoplewassetuptoguidethenewSMIPprogram,tobrainstormwhatshouldbedoneandhow.
Scott: ThatcommitteereportedtoCDMG?
Crandall: Yes,totheCaliforniaDivisionofMinesandGeology.9Inmyrecollection,Harry
9. In2002,thecommonnameoftheagencywaschangedtoCaliforniaGeologicalSurvey,thoughthepreviousname,CaliforniaDivisionofMinesandGeology,isretainedinsomestatutes.
waysimpressedmethateverybodytakespicturesofthedamagedbuildings,andofthegroundrupture,andfromthatyoucangettheideathatanentirecityhasbeendemolished.Yetactuallyonlyrelativelyfewbuildingsweredamaged,par-ticularlywithregardtoresidentialwoodframestructures.Fewhadanysignificantdamage,andeventhosethatwereastraddlethefaultrupturedidnotcompletelycollapse,althoughthosethatwererightonthecrackwereunsalvageable.Thefaultroseaboutthreetosixfeetononeside,andtherewasalsosomelateralshift.Nobodywaskilledinthoseresidentialbuildings.
Moreover,thehomesthatwerenotonthefaultrupture,andwererecentlybuilt,camethroughverywell.Someoftheconcretefloorscracked,andafewmasonrywallsshiftedalittle.Somethingsdidhappen,ofcourse,particularlytothosethatdidnothaveadequatefoundationsorwell-builtfoundations.Someoftheolderhousesthatwerenotanchoredshiftedofftheirfoundations.Itwas,ofcourse,alreadyprettywellknownthatthiscouldhappen.Also,therewasdamageorcollapseofoldbrickchimneysthatwerenotreinforcedorbraced.
California Strong Motion Instrumentation ProgramCrandall: AsaresultoftheSanFernandoearthquake,theCalifornialegislaturepassedalawsettingupthestate’sStrongMotionInstrumentationProgram,SMIP.�Priortothis,therewastheCityofLosAngelesprogram,andin1970asimilarinstrumentationrequire-mentfortallerbuildingswasputintheUBC.
�. Chapter�,Division2,PublicResourcesCode,enacted1971.
Chapter 8 Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
54
Seedwasthefirstchairman,andifIamcor-rect,thispredatedtheSeismicSafetyCommis-sionbeginnings.
Scott: Yes,becausetheCommissiondidnotactuallybecomeactiveuntilaboutMayof1975.
Crandall: GordonOakeshott,withMinesandGeology,wasveryactive.Iworkedonasub-committeewithGordonregardingthedesirablelocationsofinstrumentstorecordthefree-fieldinformation.Theintentoftheprogramwas,andstillis,tohavesuchcoveragethatnomajorearthquakeinthewholestateofCaliforniawouldgounrecordedbysomerelativelynearbyinstrument.Priortothis,therewasnomasterplanorstrategy.Itwassimplyabuilding-by-buildingprocess—abuildingpermitrequire-menttriggeredwhenabuildingwassixstoriesortaller.That,ofcourse,meantmostoftheinstrumentswerebeingclusteredindowntowndistrictsofcitiesandweren’twelldistributed.
Scott: Sotheintentwastoblanketthestatewithstrongmotioninstruments?
Crandall: Right.Ourwholeintentwastogetinstrumentsouttorecordwhathappenedtotheground,toanswerthequestion,“Whatisthegroundmotionduringanearthquake?”Thecommitteeactedinanadvisorycapacityandassistedinselectinglocations.Wesetupprioritiesforthefirstplacestoputtheinstru-ments,whichwasnotnecessarilyinthemajorcities,butatanyspotwherewethoughtwewouldgetthemaximumamountofinforma-tionandassoonaspossible.
Wedidnotwanttomissanyquakes.Soonegroup,theseismologicalgroupofthecom-mittee,wouldtrytoestimatewhichfaults
weremostlikelytohaveanearthquake,andtosuggestsomekindofpriority.Ofcourse,theSanAndreasfaultandanumberofotherfaultswerewellknown,particularlyupnortharoundEureka.Wefeltweneededtogetinstrumentsouttherebecausethoseareaswerehighlyseis-mic.Myrecollectionisthatwedidnothavemuchmoney,butweredoingalotofplanning,whichwasessential.
Sometimeaftertheinitialcommitteework,thepermanentfundinglegislationwaspassed,underwhichasurchargewasplacedonbuild-ingpermitsthroughoutthestate.Thosecitieswereexceptedthathadalreadyadoptedaprogramofinstrumentingcertainbuildings,forexampletheCityofLosAngeles.Ithinkalltogethertherewereaboutfourteencitiesthathadprogramsconsideredadequatetoqualifyfortheexception.
Scott: Sowhenthestateprogramwassetup,therewerealreadyoveradozencitiesinCali-forniathatactuallyhadsomekindofongoingstrongmotionprogram?
Crandall: Yes.Mostofthemwereprettyminimal.Maybetheyrequiredoneinstrument,ortheyhadsomegoodintentions.AsIrecall,LosAngeleswasprettymuchtheonlycitythatwasdoinganythingreallysignificant.
Afterafewyears,theCityofLosAngelesreal-izedthattheirmaintenancecostswerereallyexceedingtheirabilitytolookafterallthebuild-ingsthathadhadthethreeinstrumentsinstalledundertheircode.AgroupofusmetwiththechiefofthebuildingdepartmentoftheCityofLosAngeles,WalterBrugger.Weapproachedthecityregardingtheircomingintothestateprogram.Theydecidedthatthiswasprudent
55
Chapter 8LeRoy Crandall • Soil Engineering and Earthquake Engineering
forthemfromaneconomicstandpoint,becauseoftheirmaintenancecosts.ThestatewouldmaintaintheinstrumentsinbuildingswithinthecityofLosAngelesthatweselected.
Thatwasaccomplished.Thiswasoneofthefewdiplomatichighlightsofmycareer,work-ingwiththeCityofLosAngelesDepartmentofBuildingandSafetytoarrangeforthismarriage,andtherelinquishmentoftheirprogramtothestateprogram.Itallworkedoutverywell,andthecitycouncilacceptedthechangeover.InournegotiationswithLosAngeles,thecitybecameveryinterested,andasamatteroffact,evenea-ger.Theyhadconcludedthatthethreeinstru-mentsperbuildingtheyhadinstalledwerere-allynotgivingallthekindsofinformationtheyneeded,whileconversely,theinstrumentswerealsorecordingmoredatathantheywereabletouse.Therewerealsosomerealconstraintsaboutusingtheinformationacquiredbythecityprogramaspublicinformation.Buildingownerssometimesputsomeconstraintsonthatsamedata.Fromourstandpoint,thatlimitationwasnotaverygoodthing.
Scott: Ownerscouldputonsucharestric-tionundertheLosAngelescityprogram?
Crandall: Well,theoreticallythecityhadac-cesstothedata,butwhetherornottheycoulddivulgeittotherestoftheworldwasoneoftheuncertainties.Ithadnotbeentestedinthecourts,andIthinktheywerereluctanttotryit,asamatteroffact.
Inanyevent,thatgaveaboosttothestate’sstrongmotionprogram,whenLosAngelesjoinedit,becausetheLosAngelescontributioninbuildingfeeswasverysignificant.Thestatealsoinheritedalotoftheinstrumentation,some
ofwhichwasnotused,andthatwassupplement-edbyotherinstruments,includingfree-fieldinstallations.Also,therewasabetterdistributionofadditionalsensorsthroughoutthebuildingsthatwereacceptedintothestate’sprogram.TherewaslatitudeinhowmanysensorsandwheretoinstallthemintheCDMGprogram,ascomparedtotherequirementofLosAngelestoinstallbottom-middle-topinstrumentationandonlyinthetallerbuildings.Asofthe1990s,statelegislationrequiredallcitiestocontributefunds.
Interestinglyenough,thestaffofthestate’sSMIPcontactedmostofthecitiesthathadsomesortofstrongmotionprogram.Whenaskedwhattheyhaddonewiththerecordstheyaresupposedtohavebeengetting,mostofthemwereunawarethattheyevenhadthepro-gram.Othercitiesdidnotrealizetheyhadbeenexempt,andsomeofthemhadbeencollectingthemoney,butdidnotknowwheretosendit.Sotheactionwasnotunpalatabletothem.
Ithadbeentwentyyearsorsosincesomeofthesecitiesstartedtheirprogramsinthelate1960sorearly1970s,andpersonnelhadchanged,cityadministratorsandheadsofbuildingdepartmentswerenolongerthesamepeoplethatweretherewhenallofthisbegan.So,manypeopledidnothaveanyideawhatitwasallabout.
Underthestateprogram,mostofthebuildingdepartmentsinthestatecollectedasurchargefee,arathernominalone,sevencentsperthousanddollars,somethinglikethat,0.007percent.ThesemonieswentintotheStrongMotionInstrumentationProgramfundforprovidinginstrumentsandmaintainingthosethatwereinstalled.
Chapter 8 Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
56
Itwasnotverylongbeforewerealizedthattheformulalimitedthenumberofinstrumentswecouldputout,becausemaintenancecostsandthecostoftakingcareoftheinstrumentswasanongoingexpensethatkeptgrowingasmoreinstrumentswereinstalled,andmaintenancebegantotakealargepartofthetotalfee.
Wesuddenlywokeupandsaid,“Hey,wecannotjustputthousandsofinstrumentsout,becausewecannotaffordtoservicethem.”Sotherewasalimit,andwebegantoworkwiththatinmind.
Role of the Seismic Safety Commission in SMIPCrandall: ThefundingissuewasbroughtupbyBruceBoltwhenhewasontheSeismicSafetyCommission.Atsomepoint,betweenthestateprogram’scommencementandtheendofthe19�0s,theSeismicSafetyCommis-sionwasrequiredbylegislationtosupervisethestateStrongMotionInstrumentationPro-gram(SMIP),althoughtheoperationoftheprogramremainedunderMinesandGeology,andisstillthere.
Scott: Theprogram’soverallAdvisoryCom-mitteeanditssubcommitteesallwerebroughtundertheSeismicSafetyCommission?
Crandall: Yes.Iamnowalittlevagueastoexactlyhowthatworked,butatsomepointtherewasneworrevisedlegislation,andtheStrongMotionInstrumentationProgramwasbroughtundertheaegisoftheSeismicSafetyCommission,whichappointsandisrespon-siblefortheStrongMotionInstrumentationAdvisoryCommittee(SMIAC).
Ifyoureadthelegislationcarefully,youseethatthecommitteeonlyhasresponsibilityforadvice.ThelawdoesnotsaywhathappensifMinesandGeologydoesnotwanttotaketheadvice.Inpractice,however,thereisanex-tremelycloserelationshipbetweentheSeismicSafetyCommissionandtheSMIPprogram,andtheAdvisoryCommittee’sadviceissolic-itedandfollowedveryreligiously.
Thus,thevarioussubcommitteesoftheAdvi-soryCommitteeareinvolvedinselectingtheactualbuildingsandstructuresthatareinstru-mented,andtheysetprioritiesforthatprogram.Mypresentassociationwiththestrongmotionprogram[1991]isaschairmanoftheAdvisoryCommittee.IhavebeenonthecommitteesinceIbecameamemberoftheSeismicSafetyCommission,andinfactbecamechairmanofitshortlyafterIbecameaCommissioner.
Attheoutset,theAdvisoryCommitteewaschairedbyHarrySeed,whowasaCommis-sionerontheSeismicSafetyCommission.HewasfollowedbyBruceBolt,whowasalsoaCommissioner,andthenwhenBrucebecameSSCChairman,herelinquishedthepostofAdvisoryCommitteechair,andIwasappoint-edaschairmanofthatcommittee,andBrucestayedonasacommitteemember.
Scott: Irecallthatbythattime,youhadbeenontheCommissionabouttwoorthreeyears.Youbecamechairmanaround19�3or19�4?BrucebecamechairmanoftheCommis-sionaboutsixmonthsafterDickJahnsdied,inDecemberof19�3.IwasCommissionchairatthattime,andDickwastotakeoverinJanuary19�4.Brucehadcommitments,sohecouldnottakeoveraschairimmediately,soIcontinued
57
Chapter 8LeRoy Crandall • Soil Engineering and Earthquake Engineering
toserveaschairforthreeorfourmonthsinto19�4,beforeBrucebecamechair.BrucetookoveraboutMayorJuneof19�4.
Crandall: Yes.WhenBrucebecameSSCchairman,hedidnotwanttokeepthejobaschairmanoftheAdvisoryCommittee,al-thoughhestayedonasacommitteemember.
Scott: TheAdvisoryCommitteechairman-shipwasafairlydemandingrole,wasitnot?ThatcertainlywasmyimpressionwhenIwasaCommissionmember.Overtheyears,theAd-visoryCommitteeandsubcommitteesseemedtobeabusybunch.
Crandall: TheAdvisoryCommitteemeetsatleasttwiceayear.Thentheexecutivegroup—formedbytheadvisorysubcommitteechairs—meetsintheinterimperiods,maybeonceortwiceayear.Therearefivesubcommitteesthatreallydothework.Forexample,thebuildingsubcommitteeinvolvesabouttenortwelvepeoplewhoallgettogether.Wealsohaveothersubcommitteesonlifelines,datautilization,groundmotion,andnowanewsubcommitteeondirectedresearch.Thenewcommitteeisseeingthatthestrongmotiondatawegetfromearthquakesarebeingusedtofurtherengineer-ingknowledge—andthatisarealsuccess.
Scott: Irememberalwaysbeingveryim-pressedwhenHarrySeed,andthenBruceBolt,andthenlateryou,reportedtotheCom-mission.Italwaysseemedtomethatyouhadalotgoingon.
Crandall: Yes.ItisamajorefforttooverseetheStrongMotionInstrumentationProgram.Inthoseyears,therewasprobablyabudgetofseventotenmilliondollarsayear.
Scott: Alongtheway,thetaxleviedonbuild-ingownerstosupporttheprogramincreased,didn’tit?
Crandall: Yes.Wegotadditionalfundingacoupleofyearsago.
Scott: Aftertheprogram’sfirsttenyearsorso,buildingowners’feeswereincreasedtoalmostdoubletheoriginalamount,Ibelieve.
Crandall: IrememberBruceBoltprepar-ingastudythatshoweditwouldbeatleasttwentyyearsbeforewecouldgetinalloftheinstrumentationthatwewanted,underthepreviousfeelevel.
Scott: DidBrucedothatwhenhechairedtheAdvisoryCommittee?Orwasitafteryoube-camechairmanofthestrongmotioncommittee?
Crandall: ItstartedwhenhewaschairmanoftheAdvisoryCommittee,becauseIre-memberhimmakingthestudy.Itshowedthemoneycominginatacertainrate,andwhatwewantedtospenditonandhowfast.Thatshowedthatitwouldbetwentyyearsbeforewecouldgettothepointwherewethoughtweshouldbe.Sowetriedtoscalethetimeperiodbacktofiveyears.That’swhentheadditionalfundingwassoughtandobtained,thanks,Ithink,mostlytoSenatorAlquistforhisstrongsupport.
ImustsayfortherecordthatthereallygreatadvancesintheStrongMotionInstrumenta-tionProgramweremadeunderthechairman-shipofHarrySeedandBruceBolt.Iamsortofacaretakerchairman,Iwouldsay,andtheimportantthingsweredonepreviously.
Chapter 8 Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
58
Scott: Idonotthinkyouarejustifiedinminimizingyourcontribution,althoughIagreethatHarrySeedandBruceBoltdidalotofpioneerworkbecausealotneededtobedoneforthenewprogram.Theywerebreak-ingalotofnewground.
Crandall: Weshouldalsogivecredittotheprogram’sstaff.Theyaredoingveryfinework.TonyShakalisprogramdirector.Tony’sback-groundisingeophysics.
Scott: HeisamemberoftheCDMGstaff?
Crandall: Yes,that’sright,andheisassignedtoSMIP,which,however,isfundedseparatelyfromregularCDMGactivities.Itisalmostasifhehadacompletelyseparatebusiness.Theydotheirownfinancing,accounting,andallofthat.
Scott: Thefundingcomesoutofthefeesandcharges,soitisallkindofaself-contained?
Crandall: Well,wehadthoughtitwas.Butthen,justlastyear,wefoundouttoourshockthatweweresubjecttooverheadleviedbytheDepartmentofConservation.
Scott: ThegoodoldstatebureaucracyandDepartmentofFinancehavetheirowninsidi-ouswaysofdoingthingslikethat!
Crandall: Moreover,CDMGsuddenlywokeupandrealizedthattheyhadalittlegoldmineinthestrongmotionoperation.Sonowwegettappedwithabout20percentinoverheadcharges,whicharehardtofight.Previously,wethoughtwewereoperatingcompletelyindepen-dentlyoftherestoftheworld.Butwegotstuckwiththeoverheadcharge,muchaswehatedtoseethemoneysiphonedoffforthatpurpose.
ThetalentontheAdvisoryCommitteeisthebest—incrediblepeoplelikeGeorgeHousner,whostartedourdatautilizationsubcommit-tee.BillJoynerfromUSGSparticipated.RoyJohnstonandJerveJones,forexample,arealsohighlyinterestedmembers.JonesiswithamajorcontractingfirminsouthernCalifornia,andtakestimetocometothesemeetings.
Initially,itseemedthatonlyengineersandgeologistswereinvolved.OnethingIthinkIhelpedwastoexpandandbroadenthemem-bershipandoutlooktosomedegree.Thus,JerveJonesservesontheAdvisoryCommitteenow,andtwoorthreeotherslikethat.MaryHendersonwasoneoftheearlyonesontheoriginalcommittee.Shehasalwayshadaninterestinthiswork.
Scott: FortherecordIshouldmentionthatMaryHendersonwasveryactivefromthebeginningoftheSenatorAlquistlegislativecom-mitteeadvisorygroupsthatpredatethe1971SanFernandoearthquake.Shewasaveryactivememberoftheadvisorygroupongovernmentorganizationandperformance,alongwithLou-iseGiersch,andBobRigney,andme.HenryDegenkolbwasanobserveronthatadvisorygroup,representingtheengineeringadvisorygroup.SoMaryHendersonhasahistorythatgoesallthewaybackatleastto1969inthisfield.
Then,whenthestrongmotionprogramwassetup,shewasconsideredalogicalcandidate,withherdemonstratedinterestinearthquakesandwithherlocalgovernmentbackground.ShewasacouncilmemberfromRedwoodCityintheSanFranciscoBayArea.
Crandall: Herappointmentcameviarecom-mendationoftheLeagueofCaliforniaCities.I
59
Chapter 8LeRoy Crandall • Soil Engineering and Earthquake Engineering
remembernowthatinourearlystrongmotioncommitteework,Marypushedfortheideaofputtingoutaninformativepamphletsayingwhattheprogramwasallabout,andexplainingwhatweweredoing,tohelppeopleunder-stand.Itwasalittlepublicityprogram.
Scott: Shewasveryawareoftheimportanceofbringingthepublicalongandexplainingthingsclearly.
Crandall: Yes.Shehasbeenatremendousas-set,andisstillinvolvedinoursubcommittees.
Extension of Strong Motion Instrumentation Program to Caltrans, Hospitals, and SchoolsCrandall: Asofnow[1991],CaltransandthehospitalsareorwillbeparticipatinginCalifornia’sStrongMotionInstrumentationProgram.CertainlyCaltransisparticipatingnow,whereasthelawpreviouslyexcludedthembecausetheywerenotcontributors.
Thelawsayssomethingtotheeffectthatifyoudonotcontributetothestate’sStrongMotionImplementationProgram,youdonotparticipate,andthateliminatedallofthoseactivitiesthatdidnotgetbuildingpermitsthroughlocalagencies,whichwasthebasisofthefunding.Statebridgesdon’tpayforlocalgovernmentbuildingpermits.Butnow,sincetheLomaPrietaearthquake,theyareabletodosomefunding,andthatwillenablethemtoinstrumentanumberoftheirbridges.
Itwasashockingthingtofindoutafterthe19�9LomaPrietaearthquakethattherewerenoinstrumentsontheBayBridgeortheGoldenGateBridgeormostoftheother
bridges.AnexceptionwasthesuspensionbridgehereinSanPedro,overpartofLosAngelesharbor.TheVincentThomasBridgehadbeeninstrumented.
Scott: Whywasthatbridgeinstrumentedandnottheothers?
Crandall: Itisthemostrecentlybuiltmajorbridge.Inanyevent,forourStrongMotionInstrumentationProgram,weconcludedthatweneededsomebridgesinstrumented.WiththeviaductcollapseinOakland,andthefind-ingthatthedesignofmanyofthosestructureshavedefectsthatshowupunderstrongshak-ing,Caltranshasreceivedawindfallinfund-ingtoenablethemtostudythesestructuresandcomeupwithretrofitwork.JimGateshasmanagedthatprogramatCaltrans,hasbeenonourAdvisoryCommittee,andisactiveasasubcommitteechairman.Jimhasbeenpushingforinstrumentingbridgesandtypicalstruc-turesintheCaltranssystem.
WenowhavethepleasureofknowingthatCaltransisabletoparticipateinourprogram.Previously,thelawpreventedthemfromparticipatinginSMIP,orratherSMIPwaspre-ventedbylawfrominstrumentingstructureswherewedidnotreceiveacontributionfromthefeesonlocalgovernmentbuildingpermits.
Wewerenotabletoinstrumentstructuresun-derthepurviewofnon-SMIP-fundingagenciesunlesstheCommissionitselfadoptedaspecialresolutionofurgency,sayingthatthisinstru-mentationwasimportant.ThelastexceptiongrantedwasfortheSouthToweroftheGoldenGateBridge.TheGoldenGateBridgeDistrict,whichcontrolsthatstructure,isplanningtocompletelyinstrumentthebridgeinthefuture.
Chapter 8 Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
60
Butthat’salongandveryexpensiveprocess.Ittakesawhiletodevelop.
Soitwasdecidedthat,meanwhile,somein-formationshouldbeobtainedintheeventofanearbyearthquakebyputtingoutwhatwecalltemporaryinstrumentsontheSouthToweroftheGoldenGateBridge.Wecoulddothatinahurry,soincaseanearthquakeoccurred,thatinformationwouldbeavailable.ThatwasanurgencycasethattheSeismicSafetyCom-missionapproved,andtheinstrumentationisnow,asof1991,beinginstalledontheGoldenGateBridge.
Scott: DoestheStrongMotionInstrumenta-tionAdvisoryCommitteenowplayanadvisoryroletoCaltrans?
Crandall: Yes.Caltranswillsubmitagroupofbridgesthattheyfeelaretypical,andthattheybelievewouldbeworthyofinstrumenting.
Scott: Sotheyineffectsay,“Wethinkthesearetherightbridges?”
Crandall: Yes.Oneofthethingswedon’tliketodoisinstrumentauniquestructurethatwillneverbeduplicated.Whileitmaybenicetoknowwhatitisdoing,theinformationdoesnothelpinthedesignoffuturebridgesandstructures.
Instead,youwantdatayoucanapplytootherstructures.Sotheintentistogettomoretypi-calbridges.Theinformationobtainedwillbeusefulfordesigningbridgesofthesametypeinthefuture.Anyway,Caltranswillsubmitanumberofstructures,ourcommitteewillscreenthem,assignapriority,andinstructourSMIPpeoplewhattodointhewayofinstall-inginstruments.
ThehospitalsinCalifornia,becausetheygothroughastatepermitprocessratherthanlocalgovernment,werealsonotpartofSMIP,butwillnowbeabletoparticipatethroughsomefundingoutofwhattheycallaresearchfundfromtheirpermitcheckingfees.Wealsohavetheopportunityforsomeofthepublicschoolstoparticipatenow.BecauseinCalifor-niathepublicschoolsalsogothroughthestatebuildingpermitprocess,ratherthanlocalgov-ernment,theywerenotsubjecttotheSMIPtaxandweren’tintheprogram.
Ofcourse,seismicregulationsforschoolsandhospitalshavealonghistoryinCalifornia.Publicschoolswerebroughtunderstatewideearthquakedesignprovisionsbackin1933,aftertheLongBeachearthquake.Thestatearchitect’sofficethenfunctionedasthebuild-ingdepartmentfortheschools,ratherthanthelocaljurisdictions.ThentheSanFernandoearthquakepromptedthepassageoftheHos-pitalSeismicSafetyActof1972,whichalsomadethestate,ineffect,thebuildingdepart-mentforpermitsforthosekindsoffacilities,thoughitwasadifferentstateagency,theOfficeofStatewideHealthPlanningandDe-velopment.Yetherewewere,ignoringgettingstrongmotiondataonhospitalsandschools,andtheyweren’tincludedintheStrongMo-tionInstrumentationProgramrunbyCDMG.
AsacommitteememberontheStrongMotionInstrumentationAdvisoryCommittee,Ihavemixedemotionsaboutanearthquake.Nobodywantstoseeamajorearthquakehappen,butyetwewouldliketogetthevaluablekindsofinformationthatwillmakethisinvestmentininstrumentationreallypayoff.
61
Chapter 8LeRoy Crandall • Soil Engineering and Earthquake Engineering
Scott: Thatistrue,eventhoughsofaronlyrelativelysmallearthquakeshaveoccurredininstrumentedareas.
Crandall: Well,therewasthe19�7WhittierNarrowsearthquake.Wehadsomeinstru-mentedbuildingsinthevicinity,andalsogotinformationabouthigh-risestructuresindowntownLosAngeles,wheretheinstrumentsmeasuredtheeffects.Earlier,in1979,theElCentropublicservicebuilding,theonewhosefailureattractedsomuchattention,wasinstru-mented.Thatgaveusmuchinformationaboutwhathappenedinthebuildingduringthatearthquake,whichwasarathermodestone.
Recording the Way Earthquake Waves TravelCrandall: Withmodernimprovements,thesestrongmotioninstrumentsareallinterconnect-ednow,andareallsettothesametime.Datacanalsobefedbacktothecollectingstationbyradiooroverphonelines,becauseit’sdigitalnow.Sonowif,forexample,thequakeisfirstrecordedat1:15.00atonestationandyoureaditseveralmilesawayat1:15.10seconds,youknowitactuallytookthemotiontensecondstogetfrompointAtopointB.
Scott: Youcanreadhowthemotiontravels,andlearnhowitmaychangeoverdistance?
Crandall: Thatisright.Andthatgivesusvery,veryvaluableinformationwhentheinstrumentsareinarrays.Theystringupasetofinstruments,itmaybeformiles,startingperhapsclosetoaknownfault.Thenaquarterofamileaway,halfamile,threequarters,five
milesandfarther,otherinstrumentswillbesetateachofthosepoints.
Byhavingtheclocktimesallthesame,theycandeterminehowlongittookfortheinitialshocktogetfromonestationtothenext,andthenext,andsoon,anddeterminehowfastthewaveistravelingthroughthesoil.Theycangetthatandotherinformationenablingustopredictwhatmighthappenatasitethatismaybetenmilesawayfromthesourceoftheearthquake.Theattenuationeffectiswhatwearelookingfor.AnumberofthosearrayshavebeensetoutthatwillprovidethissortofinformationinCalifornia.
ThereisaveryfamousarrayinTaiwan,SMART-1,ortheLotungArray,whichProfes-sorBruceBolthasbeenverymuchinvolvedin.Itisinaseriesofstrongmotioninstrumentssetinconcentriccircles.Theyaregettingsomesuperbinformationfromthat.
Ofcourse,onemustrememberthateachoftheselocationshasitsownspecificgeologiccharacteristics.WhilewearegettingvaluableinformationfromTaiwan,youhavetotranslatethatintothekindsofgeologicconditionsthatoccurintheareayouareinterestedin.Itissortofliketheoriginal[1940]ElCentrorecord.Youhadonerecordandyoumadeuseofit,butknewfullwellthatyoursitemightnotbeshak-inginexactlythatsamemanner.
Flow of Seismic Forces in Reality and in Building DesignScott: Letmeaskaquestionortworelat-ingtogroundmotionandbuildingresponse.Youhaveseveraltimesexplainedwhatseems
Chapter 8 Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
62
thecommonsenseinterpretation—thatis,theforcesenterthebuildingfromthegroundup.ButIamawarethatstructuralengineerstendtotalkaboutdesigningfromthetopdown.Ihaveneverfullyunderstoodwhytheytalkthatway,sincecommonsensetellsyouthatforcesgotheotherdirection.
Crandall: Inthestructuralfield,wethinkofitinthereverse—thatis,youdesignabuildingfromthetopdown.Buttheactualeffectisthatthegroundmoves,andthebuilding,duetoitsinertia,triestoresistthemovement—goodoldNewton’sLawbeingwhatitis.Thenthegroundshakingcausesthebuildingtovibrate.Seismicforcesdostartatthebottom,yes.Thestructuralengineersdesignbycalculatinganoverallseismicloadorbaseshear,butthentheystartattheroofandcalculatehowmuchofthetotalbuildinglateralforceitrepresents,thentakethatloadandtransferittothestorybeneath,whichaddsitsownlateralload,andthatcumu-lativeloadtransferstothenextstorydownandsoon.Tallbuildingsthatvibrateinseveralmodesratherthaninasimplebackandforthmotionarealittlemorecomplicated,butbasicallythatistheexplanation.Inotherwords,youaredesign-ingitfromthetopdownasfarasthestructuralengineerisconcerned,withtheforcesincreasingasyoumovedownfromthetopofthebuilding.Themembersandconnectionsaredesignedtoadequatelycarrythoselateralforcesallthewaydownfromtheroofintothefoundation.
Scott: Isiteasiertothinkaboutortoworkwiththatway?
Crandall: Yes.Howcanyoudesignthebot-tomstoryifyoudon’tknowwhattheloadsarefromtheotherstories?Soyoustartatthe
topandaddupthelateralforcesasyougodown.Whenyougettothebottom,youhavethewholething.Thatisthetechniqueforthestructuraldesignofabuilding.
But,inreality,theearthquakeshakingtrans-mitsthroughthegroundandthroughthefoundationupintothebuilding.Thatsetsthebuildingtooscillating.Dependingontheperiodofthebuilding,youwilldevelopcertainadditionalforces.
OnethingIhavealwaystriedtotellpeopleisthatifthesoilissoweakthatthefullforcecan’tgetintothefoundation,thenthebuild-ingdoesnothavetoresistit.Letmerephraseit.Lookingatitasthoughthebuildingweretransmittingtheforcestothesoil,thereisalimitbecauseifthesoilcouldnottransmittheforcesinthefirstplace,thenthebuildingwillnotbesubjectedtomuchgreaterforces.Iwanttoemphasizethatthesoilwillyieldasittriestoforceloadintothebuilding,andifthesoilisplasticenough—sayabuildingisondrivenpilingsthatgoesthroughsoftsoilsintofirmsoilsorevenintorock—thentheearthquakeforcecomesfromtherockthroughthesoftsoiltothebuilding,imposingalateralforceonthepiling.Now,ifthosesoilsaresosoftthattheycannottransmitthatearthquakeloadintothepiling,thenyoudon’thavetodesignthepilingasthoughitwouldgetthefullforce.
An Unknown: The Seismic Behavior of BasementsCrandall: Theforcethathastogooutcannotexceedwhatcomesin,inmyopinion.Forlateralresistanceoffoundations,andalsoofbasementwalls,twobigunknownsarethe
63
Chapter 8LeRoy Crandall • Soil Engineering and Earthquake Engineering
dynamicearthpressuresagainststructuresandtheseismicbehaviorofbasements.Therearewidedifferencesofopinionamongengineers—soilengineersinparticular—astowhatkindofincreasedloadingsyouwillgetonthebase-mentwallsofastructureduetoearthquake.
Manypeoplethinkthattheloadismuchgreat-erthanitisinthestaticcondition.AsfarasIamconcerned,however,Iamnotthatmuchabelieverinabigincreaseinloads,unlessinthecaseofanextremelylargestructure,hundredsoffeetindimensions.
Mytheoryisthatthesubterraneanpartofthebuildingmoveswiththeground,primarily,sothereisverylittleadditionalloadgenerated.Ifthebuildingisextremelystiffandresistant,however,thenyoucoulddevelopadditionalpressure.Essentially,though,formoststruc-tures,itismyopinionthatthebasementandtheeartharounditaremovingsimultaneously,together,andintunewitheachother.
Ihaven’tproofofthat,exceptthatIhavenotyetseenastructureinanearthquakeareawherethebasementhascollapsedorfailedasaresultoftheearthquake.Youmightsay,“Well,thatcouldbebecausebasementsarealwaysinherentlystrongerthanwegivethemcreditfor.”Ontheotherhand,ifthatisso,weshouldbetakingitintoaccountandnotjustsayingthatthesoilpressureismuchgreaterandusingthatinthedesign.Iamtalkingaboutsugges-tionstousetwicethelateralforce,oruptothreetimes,basedonsometheoriesofearth-quakedesignforbasements,ascomparedwithwhatyouwouldhaveunderstaticconditions.
NotonlyhaveInotseenevidencethatbase-mentshavesufferedduetoincreasedsoilpres-
sure,butalsomyfirmwasconductingtie-backanchortestloadingsinabasementshoringsitu-ationintheWestwoodareaatthetimeofthe1971SanFernandoearthquake.Itwasaforty-foot-deephole,andwehadloadcellsandstraingaugesonthesetie-backsthatweweretestingcontinuously,twenty-fourhoursaday.Althoughourpeopledowninthatholewereshakenbytheearthquakeandwerealittleconcerned,therewasnoevidencewhatsoeverofanychangeintheloadconditionofthetie-backanchors.
Thishappenedintwocases.Twicewehadatestunderwayatthetimeofanearthquake.Thatisratherlimiteddatatobasethetheoryon,butIincludethistoindicatethedifferencesofopin-ionamongengineersastothekindofloadinganearthquakewillgenerateinthefoundation.
Scott: Andthosearenotjustminordiffer-ences?
Crandall: No,itcanaddalottothecostofconstructionofabasementifyouincludethiskindofupper-boundearthquakeforce.Sowestillhavethingstolearnaboutthebehaviorofstructures.
Free-Field Motion and Soil-Structure InteractionCrandall: OneimportantthinglearnedintheSanFernandoearthquakewasthevalueofhavinganinstrumentremotefromaninstrumentedstructure—calledfree-fieldinstruments.Inotherwords,youalsoneedameasurementofthegroundvibrationwhereitisunaffectedbythebuildingitself,andfreeofanyotherencumbrance.
Chapter 8 Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
64
PartlyasaresultoftheSanFernandoearth-quake,itwasrecognizedthattheinstrumentsinthebasementofabuildingwereaffectedbythebehaviorofthestructureitself.Sincethiswasamodifiedgroundmotion,thoseofusingeotechnicalworkinparticularsaid,“Weneedtoknowwhatthegroundisdoingbeforeitisinfluencedbyabuilding.”Withfree-fieldmotionrecords,youcouldtakethegroundmotionandapplyittoanybuildingandfeelconfidentthatyouknewwhatwasgoingtobetheinputsource.Thegroundshakes,thebuildingshakes,andasthebuildingshakesthemotionofitsfoundationinteractswiththemotionofthesoilaroundit.Wegeotechni-calpeopleconsideritvery,veryimportanttoknowwhatthegrounditselfisdoing.
Scott: Sothefree-fieldinstrumentgivesapurer,less“adulterated”typeofgroundre-sponsereading?
Crandall: Exactly.Fromfree-fieldread-ings,youknowwhatmotioncamefromtheearthquakeandarrivedatthesite,withoutanyinfluenceoftheparticularbuilding.Theearthquakecomesintothestructure,andthestructurestartsitsownvibrations,dependingonitsstructuralcharacteristics—height,mass,andsoon.Itfeedsthosemotionsbackintothesoilbecausethefoundationfeelsthatmotionofthebuildingandisincontactwiththesoil,andthereisasoil-structureinteractioneffect.Thebasementinstrumentationreadsthecom-binationofthoseeffects.
Initially,whenwefirsthadinstrumentalread-ingsthatwereonlyfromthebasementorlowestlevelofabuilding—inadditionofcoursetotheupper-floorinstruments—wewereutilizingthe
recordofthemotionatthebaseofthebuildingastheinput,asthesourcemechanismfortheshakingofthebuilding.Thingswerenotturn-ingoutthewaywethoughttheyshould.Thefeedbackofthesoilintothestructureandviceversawasgivingthesemodifieddynamicread-ings.Thenwestartedthefree-fieldprogram.Inalmosteveryinstallationnow,wehaveafree-fieldinstrumentinsomelocationwherewefeelitcanmeasurethepuregroundmotionatthatsite,withoutanyinfluencefromthestructure.
Hereisanotherimportantpoint.Inadditiontosurfacemeasurements,wehavenowreachedthepoint,andtheinstrumentationhasbeendeveloped,sothatwecanplacestrongmotioninstrumentsindeepholesinthegroundandleavethemtherepermanentlytomeasurewhatishappeningatdepth.Inadditiontoknowingwhatishappeningonthesurface,weareabletoinstallthesedownholearrays,astheyarecalled.Astrongmotioninstrumentisplacedinaboringasdeepas500feet—that’sthedeep-estI’mfamiliarwith—andanotheroneat,say,200feet,andoneatthesurface.Fromthat,youcanlearnhowthewavepropagatesthroughtheearthanduptothesurface.
Theoretically,the500-footdepthreceivesthewavefirst,thenthe200-footer,thentheoneatthesurface.Whenthathappens,wewillhavedataonthetransmissioneffectofgroundshak-ingvertically,aswellashorizontally.We’reveryeagertogetsomeofthatdatafromearthquakes.WehavesomedownholeinstrumentsattheParkfieldsite,whichwillhelpgiveusanideaofwhattheeffectiswhenthenextearthquakeoccursthere.USGShasheavilyinstrumentedthatareaofCaliforniainexpectationthatan-othermagnitudesixearthquakewillrecurthere,
65
Chapter 8LeRoy Crandall • Soil Engineering and Earthquake Engineering
ashashappenedrelativelyregularlyinthepast.Weknowthattheearthquakewavechangesasitpassesthroughthestrataintheground,andasitgetstothesurfaceitsortofbreaksintosurfacewavesofdifferenttypes,withdiffer-entwavevelocities.Wedonotknowpreciselywhetherthat’sthesamemotionasiscomingthroughtheearthornot.Theonlythingwehaveisintuitive,orisbasedonknowingwhathappensatdepthintunnelsandmines.Minerssenselessshakingofthegroundattheirdepththanoccursatthesurface,forexample.
Predicting Ground Motion at a SiteCrandall: Allofthisinformationis,ofcourse,helpfulandincreasesourknowledgeandthestate-of-the-artinourabilitytopredictgroundmotionatanysite,basedonapossibleearthquakeevent.Thatisonethingthatgeo-technicalengineerscannowprovide,anditispartoftheservicemycompanyprovides—thepredictionofgroundmotionatagivensite.
Whatistheeffectoftheimmediatesubsurfaceconditionsontheearthquakewavesastheypassthroughtheground?Weknowthattheychangetheircharacterastheygofromrocktoasoilcondition,andthroughsoilofdifferenttypes,suchasfirmsoilascomparedtosoftsoil.Sowe,meaninggeotechnicalengineers,obtainmeasure-mentsoftheshearwavevelocityoftheseshallowsoilsthattheseismologistdoesnotevenconsider.
Seismologistsareconcernedwithdeepearthstructureandthesourceoftheearthquake,whereitactuallyrupturesandreleasesenergy,whichmaybetenmilesdeep.Butthatmo-tiontransmitsthroughtherockandeventuallyreachesthesurface.Whenitgetsupnearthe
surface,itcanchangeitswaveformandthecontentofitsmotion.We,asgeotechnicalengineers,trytodeterminewhatthatmotionwouldbebasedontheseseismic-typemeasure-mentsthataremade.
Thestructuralengineerscanthenutilizethisintheiranalysesofbuildings.Let’ssayinLosAngelesweconsidertheSanAndreasfaultandassumethatabig�.3magnitudeearth-quakemightoccurthere,butalsocritical—andmaybemorecritical,dependingonlocation—istheNewport-Inglewoodfault,onwhichthemaximumearthquakeisnotexpectedtoexceedabout7magnitude,ormaybealittlemore.Itisnotaslargeintotalenergy,butismuchclosertodowntownLosAngelesandthewestside.
Soyougetentirelydifferentshakingcharac-teristicsfromtheNewport-InglewoodfaultthanfromtheSanAndreasfault.Weattempttoevaluatebothforeachsitethatwestudyandprovidethestructuralengineerwiththesedata.Thestructuralengineerthenchecksbothoutandseesinaparticularbuildingdesignwhichisthemoresevere,andmusttakethemoreseveremotionintoconsideration.
Becauseofitsdistance,andthefilteringoutofthehigh-frequencywaves,anearthquakeontheSanAndreaswilltransmitmuchlonger-periodwavesinLosAngeles,andthatwillthenhavegreatereffectsonhigh-risebuild-ings—whichhavelongperiods.Whereas,withanearthquakenearerby,suchasontheNewport-Inglewoodfault,thehigherfrequen-ciesarenotasfilteredout,andyoutendtogetashort-periodmotionwithamoreseriouseffectonthesmallerbuildings—saybuildingsofthreeorfourstories.
Chapter 8 Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
66
ThesamethinghappenedinMexicoCityin19�5—verydramatically.BecauseofthedistanceofthemainquakeandthecharacterofsoilinsomeareasofMexicoCity,along-periodmotionaffectedcertaincategoriesofbuildings,suchasthoseintherangeofeighttotwelvestories,whichtookaseriousbeating—pancakedandsoon.Whereastheverytallbuildingsoffortyorfiftystoriesandtheshort,stiffonesoftwoandthreestories,didremarkablywell.
Value of Dynamic StudiesCrandall: Thebuildingcodepermitsde-viationfromitsseismicprovisionsifthereisenoughsupportingdata.Thishasbeentrueinthecaseofsoilsstudies.Initssimplestform,thebuildingcodegivesbearingvaluesforcertaintypesofsoil,andyoucandesignyourfoundationsforthosevalues.Butthecodealsosaysthatifyouhaveanapprovedsoilengi-neeringreportthatgivesotherdata,youcanusethat.Thishasbeenabigstimulusforsoilengineeringinthatarea.
Thesamethingistrueofthedynamicstudies,whichsimulatehowmuchaparticularbuildingwillshake.Youcanusevaluesfortheshaking-inducedforcesfromtheformulasinthecodeforupto,Ithink,160feetinbuildingheight.Uptothatheight,youcanalsousedynamicanalysisifyouwant,butthecoderequiresdynamicanalysisforbuildingsover160feet,thoseofirregularshape,andafewotherex-ceptions.SocertainlyanybuildingoverfifteenstoriesorsointheCityofLosAngeleshastohaveadynamicanalysis.Ithinkasoftheearly1990s,theUBCandtheLosAngelescodehavebeensimilarinthatrespect.
InCalifornia,wecanassumeastructuralengi-neerisemployedforthedesignofmostofthebiggerbuildings—theonesbeyondthescaleofanindividualhouse.Thestructuralengineerswillmakeajudgmentonthelargerormoreimportantprojectsastowhetheradynamicanalysiswouldbebeneficial.Inotherwords,theydecidewhetherthesavingsfromthedy-namicanalysisislikelytobeenoughtowarrantthecostofdoingit.Thedynamicanalysisoftendemonstratesthatthebuildingneednotbeasresistantasthesimplercodeapproachassumes,whichmeanslesssteel,lessconcrete,lesscost.Thebuildingcodeusuallyisconservative.Soifyoudotheseotherthingsinlieuofjustusingthecode-prescribedformulasandvalues,youcanusuallyproducesomesavings.
Scott: Inshort,iftheengineercandemon-strate,withthehelpofaqualifiedsoilengineerorgeotechnicalfirm,thatitislegitimatetodoso,theycanshavetheconstructioncostsbynotdesigningasmuchstrengthintothebuilding?
Crandall: Yes,that’sbasicallyit—usingthegeotechnicalinformationasinput,andthenthestructuralengineeringdynamicanalyses,whichisnowdoneeasilyonthecomputer.Youneedboththegeotechnicalengineer’sinputandthestructuralengineer’sdynamicstudy.IthinkthatinsouthernCalifornia,mostanybuildingsofsignificancearegettingdynamicanalyses,becausetheprogramsforthissortofthingareavailablenow.Almostanypracticingstructuralofficehasaccesstothem.
Scott: Soitisnowreallypartofthestate-of-the-art,andanothereffectoftheadventofthemoderncomputer?
Crandall: Yes.
67
Chapter 8LeRoy Crandall • Soil Engineering and Earthquake Engineering
Existing Buildings: A DilemmaCrandall: Thebigproblem,ofcourse,areindividuallyownedexistingstructures.Withanewpieceofpropertythatadeveloperissubdi-vidingandgettingreadyforconstruction,thereisachancetoworkwithdynamicconsiderationsforsoilanddesign,basedonsoilengineeringandgeologicalfactors.Thebigrubis—whatdoyoudowiththebuildingsthatarealreadybuilt?
Scott: SanFrancisco’sMarinaDistrictisaclassiccase.Whatcantheydowiththosebuildings?Someofthemarelovelylookingbuildings,butifanothershakercomes,thereisthat“jelly”downunderneath.
Crandall: Thegoodsideofitfortheguywhoownsoneofthosebuildingsisthatthepublicforgetsprettyquickly,andinafewyearstheirvaluewillbebackupandmaybeevenhigher.IrememberinLosAngeleswehadtheBelAirfirein1961,whichwasarealdisasterinavery,veryaffluentarea,burningalmost500homes.Forawhile,nobodywantedpropertyinBelAirbecauseofthat.Butintwoorthreeyears’timeyouwouldn’thaveknownthatanythinghadhappenedatalltheretotherealestatemarket.
Long Seismic Return PeriodsScott: Iwouldliketoaskaboutoneitemlistedintheprogramofthe1991SecondInternationalConferenceonRecentAdvancesinGeotechnicalEarthquakeEngineeringandSoilDynamics.Itis“Designforenvironmentswithlongseismicreturnperiods.”Iguessthatreferstoplaceswhereearthquakesareexpect-ed,butnotveryoften.
Crandall: Right.Maybeeverycoupleofthousandyears.TheaverageormeanperiodoftimebeforethereturnofthelargeearthquakeinaparticularmidwestoreasternUnitedStatesregionmaybealongtime.
Scott: Yes.Ithasalwaysbeenapuzzletomeastowhatoughttobedoneinsuchareas.Thenextearthquakemaynotcomeformanycen-turies.Ontheotherhand,itmaycomesooner,anditmaybealarge,full-fledgedearthquake.Whatdoyoudo?Doyouignorethepotentialthreat?Doyoudesignconservatively,asiftheremightbeadamagingearthquakesoon?Doyoudosomeseismicdesign,butwithlessconservativerequirements?Itseemslikeanawkwardmatter.
Crandall: Youareright,thoselong-rangeoccurrencesareupforgrabs,really.Thedog-goneearthquakecouldhappentomorrow.Thatiswheretheuncertaintycomesin.
ThatiswhyIthinkthebuildingsneedtobedesignedasiftheearthquakewasgoingtohappenthedayafterconstructionisfinished.Youmight,however,bewillingtotakealittlemoreriskinanenvironmentwheretheseismichazardhasalongreturnperiod.SanDiego,forexample,canbeexpectedtoexperiencemajorearthquakeslessoftenthanLosAngeles.AndthegeneralsoilcharacteristicsinSanDiegoarebetter.SeismologistsmaypointoutthatthereistheRoseCanyonfault,anditismoreactivethanwethought,anditcouldgenerateaboutamagnitude6.5.Butevenso,youcansaytheriskofstrongshakingissignificantlylessinSanDiegothanitisinLosAngeles.Andthenyoucansaytheriskisalittlelessinanotherlocale,andsoon.
Chapter 8 Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
68
Inthemidwest,theNewMadridearthquakeshappenedin1�11and1�12,andshookthebejesusoutofthewholearea.Whatshouldtheydothere?Suchlargeearthquakesareestimatedbygeologistsandseismologistsashappeningonaverageeverycouplethousandyears,whichisthemeanoraveragereturnpe-riod.InmostofCalifornia,youcangetsevereshakingwithamuchshorteraveragereturnperiod,muchmorefrequently.That’sthesameassayingthereisahigherprobabilityofget-tingthatsevereshakingoverthenextsomanyyearsinCaliforniathaninthemidwest.Themidwestneedssomeprovisionsfordesign,however,andtheyarejustnowgettingaroundtobelievingthattheyoughttobedoingsome-thing.IntheMemphisandSt.Louisareas—asofnow,atthebeginningofthe1990s—forexample,theyhavebeenveryslowinpickinguponthis.
Base Isolation of Structures
Scott: Talkalittlebitaboutbaseisolation.
Crandall: Baseisolationisarapidlyemerg-ingtechnologyforprotectingstructuresfromthefullimpactofgroundmotion.Ithasbeendiscussedinconceptformanyyears,butonlyrelativelyrecentlyhasthetechnologybeendevelopedsufficientlytopermititsuseinactualstructures.
MyfirmwasfortunateenoughtobeoneofthoseinvolvedinthefirstmajorbuildingintheUnitedStatestousebaseisolation.ThatwasSanBernardinoCountyFoothillCommunities
LawandJusticeCenter,whichisthebrainchildofthelateRobertRigney.10
Rigneywasthecountychiefadministrativeofficeratthetime,andformerlyachairmanoftheSeismicSafetyCommission.IwasontheCommissionatthesametimeBobRigneywas,butwasnotonitunderhischairmanship.HehadcompletedhistermaschairbythetimeIcameontheCommission.Itwascer-tainlyanhonorandanachievementforBobRigneytohavethatstructurebuilttoabaseisolationdesign.
Scott: Iguesshewasalmostsingle-handedlyresponsibleforgettingitdonethatway.
Crandall: Yes.Thefundingwastheproblem.Beingthefirststructureofitstype,thecountybuildingdepartmentwasveryuncertainofthedesign.Thesavingsthatmightotherwisehavebeenrealizedwerenotpossiblebecausethebuildingwasrequiredtomeetthestandardbuildingcode,tobedesignedfortheusualhighforcelevelsinsteadofthelowerleveltheisola-tionsystemwouldprovide.Soinsteadoftherebeinganapproximateequivalenceofcost—ifisolationsystemshadbeentreatedthewaytheyarenow,witharealisticestimateofhowmuchlowertheforceswillbe—orperhapsevenanetsavings,thatdoublerequirement[ofmeetingbothcodestandardsandprovidingisolators]actuallyincreasedthecostsignificantly.Well,BobRigney,blesshisheart,heisnolongerwithus,managedtoconvincetheauthoritiesandothersinSanBernardinoCountythatthis
10. Thisbase-isolatedbuildingwasdesignatedasoneoftheTopSeismicProjectsoftheTwentiethCenturybytheAppliedTechnologyCouncilandAmericanSocietyofCivilEngineersin2006.
69
Chapter 8LeRoy Crandall • Soil Engineering and Earthquake Engineering
wasagoodthingtodoanyway.Sothebuildingwasdesignedinthatmanner.
Foraframeofreference,myfirmprovidedthefoundationdesigninformationandthegroundmotiondesigncriteriabasedonthepotentialdamagefromanearthquakeontheSanAn-dreasfault,whichisverynear,abouttenmilesaway,Ithink.
Thebasementareaunderandaroundthebuildingisfifteeninchesoneachsidelargerthanthebuildingitself.Inotherwords,theassumptionwasthatthegroundcouldmovefifteeninches,andifbaseisolationworked,thebuildingwouldlagbehindthatmotionanditwouldreducetheforcesinittoarelativelysmallamount,butyouhadtohavetheclear-ance.Thefoundationofthebuildingitselfisexpectedtomovewiththeground,tomovefif-teenincheseachwayinamajorquake,butthemovementwouldbeabsorbedintheisolators,sothebuildingabovethoseisolatorsshouldmoveverylittle.That’stheprincipleofbaseisolation.Itisn’ttotalisolation,butinessence,thegroundmoves,andthebuildingstaysput.
Actually,ofcourse,thebuildingdoesmovesome,butmuchless,whichmeansthattheseismicforcesinthebuildingareverymuchreduced.Ifabuildingisdesignedinaccor-dancewiththatprinciple,itdoesnotneednearlyasmuchstrengthorductilityasitwouldwithoutabaseisolationsystem.Thatcansavemoney,andtheperformancecangoup.
Theisolationconcepthasbeenknownforalongtime,buttheydidnothavethetypeofdevicesortheconfidenceinthemthatwenowhave,whichpermitsustodothis.Earlierdesignersthoughtaboutputtingbuildingson
ballbearings.Thatwould,ofcourse,accom-plishsomethingsimilar,buttheproblemwaswhetherbearingsofthattypewouldfunctionandacceptsuchlargemovements.Also,howdoyoustopthebuildingifitstartsgoing?
Anyway,thisparticularstructurewasthefirstmajorbuildingofitstypeintheUnitedStates.Baseisolationhadalreadybeenusedonbridg-esandafewbuildingsinNewZealand,whereitoriginated.NowwehaveadditionalbaseisolatedbuildingsintheUSA.Forexample,thenewUniversityofSouthernCaliforniaHospitalisabaseisolationstructure.Thatshowsyouhowfarwehavecome,todothatwithahospital,whichissubjecttothemostintensiveseismiccoderequirementsbecauseitisintendedtoremainoperatingafteranearth-quake.Sothatisbeingdone,andthehospitalisexpectedtoperformproperly.CrandallandAssociateswasthegeotechnicalfirmforthathospitaldesign.
Thoseadvancesintheconstructionphaseofengineeringareveryimportantforearthquakeresistance.BythatImeanwehavedesignerswhohavelongdreamedofthingsofthiskind,butputtingthemintopracticalapplicationre-quirestheconstructionelementstobedefinedanddeveloped.TheUniversityofCaliforniaatBerkeleyplayedanimportantpartintestingtheseisolators,toshowhowtheycanfunctionandprovidegreatconfidence.
Scott: Yes.Berkeleycivilengineeringprofes-sorJamesKellywasoneofthoseinvolved.
Crandall: Yes.That’sright.Kellywasthekeyresearcher.OntheLawandJusticeCenterproj-ect,AlexTaricswasthekeystructuralengineer.
Chapter 8 Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
70
Scott: Intryingtofollowthediscussionofbaseisolationoverthepasttenorfifteenyears,ItendedtolistenagooddealtoHenryDegen-kolb.Hetendedtobeabitskeptical,oratleastcautious,aboutbaseisolation.Areyouawareofthat?
Crandall: Yes,Iam.
Scott: DoyouwanttocommentalittleonHenryDegenkolb’sconcerns,asyouunder-stoodthem?Wasitpartlyjustcautiononhispart,becausebaseisolationwassuchanewthing?Maybehewantedtoseeittriedoutinanearthquakeortwobeforefinallymakinguphismind?
Crandall: Henrywasthekindofguywhocouldcutthroughallofthemalarkeyandmonkeybusinessandgetrighttothegutsofsomething.Andhewasanadvocateofredun-dantdesign—systemsthathadenoughpathsfortheforcestoflowalong,sothatifoneofthemturnedouttobeweakerthanyouexpect-ed,therewassomethingelsetohelpout.Andofcourse,baseisolationwasanewconcept.Ihadfeltthesamewayaboutit.
Youarereluctanttopromotesomethingofthatsortuntilyouhaveadegreeofconfidence,whichwenowhave.IthinkHenrywouldhaveacceptedthetypeofbehaviorthatwasexhib-itedinthetestthatKellyranasbeingindica-tivethatbaseisolationwoulddowhatpeoplehopeditwould,andwhatthepromotersofitwereconvincedthatitwould.Youknowhowpromotersare—everythingisrosytothemuntilsomethinggoeswrong.
IthinkHenryjustfeltthatgoodengineer-ingwasbasedongoodsolidconstruction
techniques.Hewasrightaboutthat,thereisnoquestioninmymind.Butonceyouhaveshownwhatthissystemiscapableofdoing,thenitgoesintothedesigner’stoolkit—oneofthosethingsthatyoucanuse.Youstilldesignasolid,earthquake-resistantstructure,butitwillbeexposedtolowerforces.
Scott: ThenmyrecollectiondatesbacktoanearlierperiodwhenHenrywasstillwantingtobeshownmoreproofthatthenewideaofisolationwouldwork,andwhenweprobablyhadnotyetquiteadvancedfarenoughindem-onstratingitsperformancetohissatisfaction.Isthatcorrect?
Crandall: Ithinkthat’sright.Hadhelivedlonger,hewouldhavebeenintheerawhenisolationtechnologybecamesomethingtheengineercouldroutinelytrust,ifit’sdoneright.
Site-Specific Ground Motion StudiesCrandall: TheUniformBuildingCodesaysthatmostofCaliforniaisinthehighestseismiczone,Zone4.Well,wedon’thavetobeearthscientiststoknowthatZone4,whichismostofCalifornia,hasconditionsthatvaryfromthegraniteoftheSierratothefillandBaymudconditionsoftheMarinaareainSanFrancisco.Itisobviousthatbuildingsofsimilarcharacteronsitesofthosetwoextremeconditionsaregoingtobehaveaheckofalotdifferently.
IftheexampleofZone4andtheotherUBCzonesareconsideredaszoning,thenmicrozon-ationismappingandstudyingexpectedgroundmotionatthescaleofdistrictsandindividualbuildingsites.Thatiswhatthesoilengineers
71
Chapter 8LeRoy Crandall • Soil Engineering and Earthquake Engineering
dowhentheymakeaninvestigation.Theyaredoingmicrozonationforthespecificsitetheyareinvestigating.Asoilorgeotechnicalreportshouldincludethegeologiccharacteristicsofthesiteanditssubsurfaceconditions,suchaswhetheritisonman-madefilloronBaymud.Soinessence,whenyouasaclientretainasoilengineer,thatconsultantismicrozoningthatparticularsiteforyou.Oratleastthatconsul-tantshould,forabuildingofanyconsequence.
Butbeyondthat,microzonationmapsarebeingpreparedforwholeregions,andarebecomingmoreandmorerefined,identifyingsuchareasas—usingtheBayAreaasanex-ample—theyoungerBaymudsaroundtheBaywhereman-madefillsare,orwhereliquefac-tionisapossibility.
Scott: Whomakesthosemaps?TheU.S. GeologicalSurvey,USGS?
Crandall: Yes,theydo.ThemapsarealsodonebytheCaliforniaDivisionofMinesandGeology,oracityoracounty.TheseismicsafetyelementrequiredinlocalgovernmentplansinCaliforniahasencouragedthissortofthing.
Computers: The Biggest Influence on Earthquake EngineeringScott: Herein1991,anumberof“themesfordiscussion”arelistedintheadvancepro-gramoftheSecondInternationalConferenceonRecentAdvancesinGeotechnicalEarth-quakeEngineeringandSoilDynamics,tobeheldinMarch1991,tenyearsaftertheFirstInternationalConferencein19�1.Ithoughtitmightbehelpfulforyoutocommentonthesethemesindiscussingtherecentandcurrent
stateoftheartingeotechnicalengineering,andincomparingandcontrastingitwiththestateoftheartinearlierperiods.
Crandall: Thislistingintheadvancepro-gramisaverycomprehensivereviewofthefieldfromtheperspectiveofsomeonewhostartedoutinthesubjectin1940-1941.Therearethingsherethatwehadnotconsideredorthoughtofinthoseearlydays.Oneexampleistheextensivediscussionofcomputerprogramsattheseconferencesnow.
Ithinkthatmuchofwhatisbeingdonenowistheresultofcomputercapability.Whenyouaretryingtodothingsbysliderule,whichwedid,ofcourse,inthoseearlydays,youfindalimittotheextentofmathematicalanaly-sisthatyoucando.Whatwedidnotknowinthosedaysweapproximatedbyassumingboundaryconditions.Inotherwords,wetookalowvalueandanuppervaluefortheshearstrength,andcomputedwhatwouldhappen.
Supposewewereconsideringsettlementofastructure,orthemotionafoundationwouldundergoifsubjectedtotheloadofagenera-tororsomeotherpieceofrotatingequipment,orevenofanearthquake.Wehad,backthen,toestimatethelowestvalueandthehighestvalueoftheshearcharacteristicsthatmightbeanticipatedforthatparticularinstallation.Thenwewouldtrytodeterminewhatkindsofdeflectionswouldoccurundereachofthosevalues,andsomewhereinbetween,youhoped,wasthecorrectanswer.Ifthespreadwastoogreat,thenyoueitherhadtothrowoutyourwholeprocessandflybytheseatofyourpantsentirelyanduseyourjudgmentonly,ortrytorefinetheboundsandimproveonthefirst
Chapter 8 Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
72
estimate.Methodsliketheresponsespectrumweremadefeasiblefortheconsultingengineerbythemoderncomputer.
Thelimitationsonanalysisbeforethenwerewhatyoucoulddoonahandcalculatororasliderule.Asaresult,youcouldnotmakemanyiterationsofallthecalculations.Youtookjustoneortwoshotsatit,andsaid,“Allright,wethinkitisgoingtobeone-halfaninch.”Now,ofcourse,theprocessisgreatlyrefined,althoughmaybeinsomecases,theanswersaren’tanybetter.Isometimeshavedoubts.Themerefactthatyouhaveacomput-erthatwillspitoutallofthesecalculationstotendecimalplacesdoesnotnecessarilymeanyougettherightanswer.OneofthetoughestthingsIfindinhiringyoungengineersjustoutofcollegeisteachingthemnottoaccepttheresultstheygetincomputeroutputonblindfaith.Theinputis,ofcourse,whatcontrolsthevalidityoftheresults.Itistooeasytolookatalotofsignificantfiguresandsay,“Ohboy,thismustberightbecausewearemeasuringittoathousandthofaninch.”Butmaybeyouarereallyonlymeasuringittooneinchwithac-curacy.Beforethecomputer,wecouldnotdoasmuchanalysisasnow,butwebenefitedfromthefactthatweknewhowimportantjudgmentandexperiencewere.
Scott: Whendidthattransformationreallybegin?Iguessittookawhiletoreallyinflu-encetheprofession.
Crandall: Iwouldsayitwasinthemid-1960sandthereaboutsthatthecomputerbegantobeausefultoolinengineeringoffices.
Scott: Ofcourse,thenthereweresucces-sivegenerationsofcomputersand,theygot
cheaperandcheaper,andtheirabilitiesgreaterandgreater.
Crandall: Yes,theycoulddomorethingsinashorterperiodoftime.Theexplosionofcomputerknowledgewasjusttremendous.Thedevelopmentofsoftware,forexample,aspeoplebegantoworkontheseproblems.Today,mygoodness,youcangetasoftwareprogramanaverageofficecanutilizewithacomputer,andputinthebasicknowledge,andevenmorethanthat—makealternativestudiesoftheeffectofdifferentconfigurations,ofdif-ferentconnectionsandbracingsystems.Thatway,onecanselectthemostadvantageoussystemandcomeupwithsomeeconomicfac-torstoindicatewhattheadditionalcostwouldbeofimprovingthedesign.
Intheearlydaysjustdoingthefundamentalsoilengineering,computingsettlementofabuild-ingfoundation,forexample,wasalaborioushandcalculationjob.Asaresult,wedidnotdotoomuchofit.Youmadetypicalfoundationsforabuilding,madeacalculation,andthenyouextrapolatedfromthattoothersizesoffounda-tion.Itwaswellknownatthattimethatthesizeofthefoundationandtheloadorthepressureonit,sayofaspreadfooting,wasverycriticalinthesettlementdetermination.Onceyouknewthesoilcharacteristics,then,ofcourse,youhadtomakesomeevaluationsofwhatsettlementwasgoingtooccur,andparticularlythedifferen-tialsettlementbetween,say,amajorfoundationelementinabuildingandthenearbylighterload-carryingfoundationelementofthebuild-ing.Thosethingswerebasedonalotofseat-of-the-pantstypeofjudgments.Notthattheywerewrong,butitrequiredmoreexperiencetodothat.Nowadays,itissomewhatdifferent.
73
Chapter 8LeRoy Crandall • Soil Engineering and Earthquake Engineering
Scott: Didthecomputeraffectbothpro-fessions,bothstructuralengineersandsoilengineers?Andtheseeffectsintertwined?
Crandall: Yes.Ithinktheuseofcomputersfordynamicanalysisstartedwiththestructuralengineers.Theywereabletotakethelateralforcesandevaluatetheminaneconomicman-ner.Oncethathappened,theystartedaskingquestionsabouttheeffectofthegroundmo-tiononthestructure.
Thestructuralengineersays,“I’manalyzingthebehaviorofthestructureitselftoadegreethatIhadneverbeenabletodo,andnowI’dbetterfindoutsomethingaboutthegroundmo-tion,becausethataffectsit.”Thegeotechnicaltypes,thesoilengineers,wereinasenseforcedintodeterminingthebehavioroftheground,sothatthestructuralengineerswouldhavethatinformationtoutilizeintheirdesign.
Advent of Large Shaking TablesCrandall: Anotherdevelopmentthatstartedtocomeinaroundthetimewhencomputersbecameusefultoconsultingengineers,inthe1960sand1970s,wasthelargeshakingtabletestingcapability.Therearetheselarge-scaleandfull-scalecapabilitiesfortestingmostlystructures,butalsofortestingsoil.Wecannowdosoiltestsforverylargespecimensonshakingtables.Thatgivesyoumuchbetter,firmerresultsthanbefore.
Scott: Youmeaninsteadoftestingasmallsampleofsoil,youtestahugeamount?Givemeanideaofthesize,themagnitudeofthespecimensyouhaveinmindwhenyousay
“large-scale.”Doyoumeanasix-footcube,forexample?
Crandall: Yes,thatisintherealm.Thetypi-calsoilspecimenismaybetwoorthreeinchesindiameter,andmaybesixtoeightinchesinlength.Wecouldpreparelargerspecimens—“remolded”wesometimescalledthem,or“reconstituted”—insayaone-cubic-footbox,anddosometests.Butwecouldnotgiveitthekindofdynamictestingthatwecannowdowithashakingtable.
Scott: Whenyousay“shakingtable”areyoureferringtooneliketheonethattheUniver-sityofCaliforniaatBerkeleystartedtooperateatitsnearbyRichmondFieldStationin1972?
Crandall: Thatisavailableandhasbeenusedforsomesoiltests.Butusuallysmallertableswouldbeusedinsoilengineering.I’mthinkingoftablesmaybefourfeetsquaretosixfeetsquare.
Scott: Aretheremanyofthosearound?
Crandall: TheremustbeadozenorsoinCaliforniaatthevariousuniversities.Maybeevensomeprivatesoillaboratorieshaveequivalenttypesoffacilities.Minedoesn’t.Wehaven’tgottenintoittothatdegree,becauseofthecost.WewouldjusttakeoursamplesintoUCLAandcontractwiththemtomakecertainspecialtests.Itmakessense.Theycanstayupwiththestate-of-the-art,whereasaprivatefirmcouldnotaffordtochangethefacilityasimprovementscomealong.
Eventheshakingtableisnowafunctionofthecomputer,whichissetuptohavetwo-dimensionalmotion,twohorizontalaxes,ascontrolledbythecomputerprogram.Someofthemevenincludethethirdcomponent,the
Chapter 8 Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
74
verticalshaking.Thesemotionsofthetableareallcontrolledbycomputerprogrammingnow.Youcanduplicateanearthquake—anyspecificrecordedearthquakemotion—intheshakingprogramandplayitbackonthetable.
Thathasbeenareallybigadvantageinhelpingunderstandthedynamicpropertiesofsoils.Sinceallbuildingsaresupportedonfounda-tions,understandingwhathappenstothesoilsortheunderlyingmaterialgivestheinputthataffectsthebuildingitself.Alotofpeoplehaveforgottenthattheeffectofanearthquakeactu-allycomesfromthegroundintothebuilding.
Scott: Doengineersstillneedrealearth-quakestoprovidethemwith“testresults”?
Crandall: Yes.Anearthquakeisareal,full-scaletestofabuilding,andunfortunately,westillneedthattypeoftesttoverifyandadvanceourfield.Shakingtablestestmodels.Eventhebiggestshakingtablescannottakeabig,full-sizedbuilding.Therearethingsthatgooninarealbuildingthatyoucannotreproduceinamodel.Forexample,theinteriorpartitions,thewalls,thefloors,thestairways,andthingsthatmakeitverycomplexintryingtomakeacal-culation.Thenthere’sthebehaviorofthesoilthatwehavediscussed.Theactualmeasure-mentthroughstrongmotioninstrumentationletsyouhaveagoodfeelfortheeffectofthesenonstructuralelements.
Measuring Shear Wave VelocityCrandall: OneofthethingsIshouldtalkaboutisearlystudiesofshearwavevelocity.Itisoneofthesimplestparametersinsoildynamics,butanimportantone.Enoughstud-
ieshavebeenmadeinearthquakeengineeringtoknowthatthebehaviorofaparticularsiteisafunctionoftheshearwavevelocityofthatmaterial,thedensityofthematerial,thedepthofbedrock,thevariationofthesoillayersbe-neaththesite,andsuchthingsasthedistancetothefocusofanearthquake.Also,ofcourse,themagnitudeoftheenergygeneratedinthewavesarrivingatthesiteisimportant.
Initially,shearwavevelocitywasestimatedfromlaboratorytestdata,butwesoonrealizedthatwasaverycrudeprocedure,andsowestartedmeasuringsitevibrationcharacteristicswithgeophones.Initially,thiswasdoneonthesurface,measuringthetimerequiredforanimpactatasourcetoreachaseriesofinstru-mentsthatwoulddetectthemotion.
Scott: Usingsensitivelisteninginstruments?
Crandall: Yes.Theywouldpickupthevibration,andthetimecouldbemeasuredtoafractionofasecond.
Scott: Howdidyouproducethevibration?
Crandall: Withasledgehammer.Youhitaplankthatwasweighteddownbythewheelsofatruck,sotheplankwasinintimatecon-tactwiththegroundandthevibrationfromthesledgehammerhittingwentonintotheground.Thetimethatthesledgehittheplankwastimezero.Thevariouswavestraveledthroughthegroundtothestringofgeophonesthatweresetoutatvaryingdistancesfromtheimpactsource.
Thegeophonesrecordedwithaprecisionthatwouldpermitustodeterminetoathousandthofasecond—amillisecond—thearrivaltimesatthevariousgeophones.Fromthat,wedeter-
75
Chapter 8LeRoy Crandall • Soil Engineering and Earthquake Engineering
minedthevelocity,becauseweknewtheonlyothervariable,thedistance.BoththePwaveandtheSwavevelocitiesweremeasured.Thiswaslaterimprovedbymakingadownholemeasurement,inwhichthegeophonewasloweredintoaboringatdepth,andthesledge-hammerwasstruckonthesurface.
Scott: Howdeepwasthegeophoneplaced?
Crandall: Thegeophonewasloweredtovaryingdepths.Someoftheboringswouldbe200feetdeep.Youwouldstartbyputtingthereceiverdownatthebottomofthehole,hittheplankatthetop,andmeasurethetimeforthatgeophonetoreceivethatwave.Thenyouwouldraisethatgeophonetosay150feetdepth,anddoitagain.You’dkeepdoingthatsuccessivelyasyouwithdrewthegeophonefromthehole,get-tingatime-of-traveldeterminationfromwhichyoucoulddetermineboththecompressionwave(orPwave)andtheshearwave(orSwave),astheywerecalled.Knowingthat,youhadinfor-mationthatcouldbeusedtodeterminewhattheeffectsofadistantearthquakewouldbeonthatsite,intermsofthatvelocitymeasurement.
Itwasbackabout1965thatMartinDukeofUCLAworkedonthisgeophysicalprocedure.HegotitfromtheJapanese,andbroughtittotheUnitedStates.Hehadhisstudentswork-ingonit.CrandallandAssociatesprovidedtheboringsandtheothermaterial,andMartinhadtheexpertiseandcrewtodothetechnicalwork.
Scott: Weretheseexperimentsdoneonactualcommercialjobs?
Crandall: Yes.ThefirstoneIrememberwastheMusicCenterfortheCityofLosAngeles.TheMusicCenterwaslocatedonwhatwe
looselyrefertoas“rock”inLosAngelesthesiltstoneformationorshale,asit’sgenerallycalled,oftheBunkerHillareaofdowntownLosAngeles.ThoseexperimentswerethefirstobservationsthatIrecallbeingmadeusingthatprocedurewiththegeophonesandpound-ingontheplankwithasledgehammer.
Wecollectedthedata,knewtheshearwavevelocity,andmadesomefeebleattemptstopredicthowmuchthegroundmotionmightbe.Thefirstthingwedidwasdeterminethenaturalperiodoftheground.Thatiswhatwewereoriginallylookingfor.Theperiodofthegroundcouldthenberelatedtotheperiodofthestructure.
Thestructuralengineerswerenowcapableofdeterminingtheperiodofastructureratherprecisely,ratherthanusingthearbitraryformulasemployedbefore,whentheyjustestimateditfromthenumberofstoriesofthebuilding.We,geotechnicalengineers,werethenabletoprovidewhatwefeltwasgoodinformationofthenaturalfrequencyofthesoil.Thiswasoneoftheearlyfactorsrequiredinthedynamicanalysisofastructure.
Response Spectrum
Crandall: Computerdevelopmentspermit-tedgeotechnicalconsultantstocalculatetheearthquakespectrum,whichcombinesinfor-mationongroundshakingseverityascom-paredtoitsfrequency.Theresponsespectrumplotsthemaximumresponseofavarietyofdifferentstructures,eachofwhichhasitsownperiodofvibration.
Chapter 8 Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
76
Sotheprocessusedthenwastoestimatehowbigtheearthquakemightbe,figureitsdistancefromthesite,andusethatinformationtogetherwiththeknowncharacteristicsoftheshearwavevelocityofthesite,thedepthtobedrockbeneaththesite,andthetypeofmaterial,andprepareaverysimpleresponsespectrumforthatparticularsite.Withthatinformation,thestructuralengi-neer,knowingtheperiodofhisorherbuilding,wouldhaveanestimateofwhatthepredominantperiodofthegroundmotionwouldbe,andtheacceleration,thevelocity,andthedisplacementofthegroundforagivenearthquake.
Thestructuralengineerscouldthenusethisintheircomputerprograms.Again,Igivemuchcredittothecomputer.Thestructuralengineerwasabletousetheresponsespectruminstudiesoftheeffectofthegroundmotiononaparticularbuilding.Sincethosedays,theprocesshasbeenrefinedconsiderably,butessentiallyit’sthesameinformationthatisdeterminedandprepared.
Defining the Design EarthquakeCrandall: Inadditiontothepropertiesofthesite,theotherkeyfactorwasthechoiceoftheearthquake.Therearevariouspossibilities,ofcourse.Actually,thepossibilitiesarevirtu-allyinnumerable.Nobodyknowsexactlywhatearthquakewilloccuronagivenfault.
Scott: Isthatwhensuchconceptsas“maxi-mumcredible”and“maximumprobable”camein?
Crandall: That’swhereallofthatterminol-ogybegantoenterthepicture.It’swellenoughtobeabletosaythatthegroundmotionwill
besomuch,andofsuchacharacterifthisearthquakeoccurs.Butthensomebodysays,“What’sreallylikelytooccur?Wewanttode-signthisbuildingforwhatmayactuallyoccur.”
Theearthquakeengineeringfraternity—whichconsistsofmorethanjuststructuralengineersandincludestheseismologists,geologists,engineeringgeologists,geotechnicalengi-neers—neededtocomeupwithaseriesofde-terminantsastowhatenergymightbereleasedinearthquakesonagivenfault.
Thisiswhere“maximumprobable,”“maximumcredible,”andeventhe“ultimatepossible,”and“maximumpossible”terminologycameup.Thefirsteffortcameupwiththe“maximumpossible”earthquakeactivity—itwasalmostaninfinite-magnitudesortofthing.Youhadnolimitation,really,sothatwasratherquicklydropped.
Scott: Youwouldn’tusethatconcept,unlesspossiblywithanuclearreactor.
Crandall: Right.They,ofcourse,werebeingdesignedforahigherdegreeofuncertaintythanthestructuralengineersofbuildingswerede-signingfor.Butforbuildingdesign,itwasfinallydecidedthatthe“maximumprobable”andthe“maximumcredible”weretwolevelsofpotentialactivitythatshouldbeconsidered.Asaresult,thegeotechnicalengineertypicallyignoresthe“maximumpossible,”anddevelopsgroundmotioncharacteristicsforvariousfaultsforthe“maximumprobableearthquake,”whichgivesalowernumberthanthe“maximumcredible.”
IntheLosAngelesarea,forexample,wealwaysconsidertheSanAndreasactivityonagivensitewithin,saytypically,fortymilesfromthefault.Sothebehavioratthatdistance
77
Chapter 8LeRoy Crandall • Soil Engineering and Earthquake Engineering
ismuchdifferentthanifyou’reclosetothatfault.TheNewport-Inglewoodfault,whichisdirectlybelowalargepartofLosAngeles,istheotherfaultconsidered.Thendependingonthespecificlocationunderstudy,theSantaMonica-Hollywoodfaultorotherfaultsinthevicinityarealsoconsidered,andthegroundmotionduetothosefaultspredicted.11
Scott: Theyconsiderthesetwobigones,SanAndreasandNewport-Inglewood,andthentheotherswouldbeofmorelocalizedconcern?
Crandall: That’sright.LikeinPasadena,theRaymondfaultisusuallyconsidered.InCulverCity,theOverlandfaultisone.Soyouevaluatethegeologiccharacteristicsofagivenarea,anddecidewhichfaultsmighthaveaneffectonyoursite.Youthenattempttodeterminethegroundmotionunderthepossibleeventthatyouexpect—eitherthemaximumprobableorthemaximumcredible.Thosenumbershavebeenprettymuchdevelopedbyseismologistsnowasafunctionofthelengthoffault.
GeorgeHousnerhadmuchtodowiththatdetermination,inwhichthemagnitudeortheenergyreleasedonagivenfaultisrelatedtotheprobablelengthofrupture.Thelongerthe
11. EarthquakesthatoccurredlaterthanthedateofthisinterviewwithCrandall,suchasthe1994Northridge,Californiaearthquake,weretoalsobringattentiontothehazardsofblindthrustfaultsintheLosAngelesregion.UnlikefaultssuchastheSanAndreasorNewport-Inglewood,whichprovidegeologistswithevidenceatthegroundsurfaceoftheirpastdisplacement,“blind”orburiedfaultsthatdonotextendtothesurfacearenowknowntobeasignificanthazardintheLosAngelesregion.
rupture,ofcourse,thenthegreaterthetotalamountofenergy.
Scott: YousayGeorgeHousnerwasonekeypersoninthis?
Crandall: Yes.AsIremember,GeorgeHousnercameupwiththefirstrelationshipoflengthoffaulttothepotentialmagnitudeofanearthquakeonthatfault.Thingsareprettymuchinthatstateoftheartatthepresenttime,althoughwearerefiningmatters.Nowwe’reconsideringthedepthofthefocusofanearthquakeasimportant,withashallowquakeproducingacertainkindofgroundmotionthatisdifferentthanthatofanearthquakeatgreaterdepth,andthenitalsomatterswhetherit’sathrustfaultorastrike-slipfault.Thosearerefinementsthatarebeinggivenconsider-ationatthepresenttime.
Ifeelthatthestateoftheartnowissuchthatwehaveagooddegreeofconfidenceinthedatawe’redevelopingandarepresentingtothedesignprofession,namelythestructuralengineerandthecivilengineer,foruseinthedeterminingwhattheeffectsofthegroundmotionwillbeonaparticularstructure.Again,Idon’twanttosaythistoomanytimes,butthishasbecomepossibleonlybecauseoftheuseofcomputersinthedeterminationoftheseverycomplexfactors.
Scott: Iguessthedevelopmentisstillgoingon,althoughinsomewaysitmayhavemoreorlessreachedaplateau.
Crandall: Yes,Ithinkit’sflatteningout.Nowwehavetheabilitytomaketheseanalyses.It’sjustaquestionofobtainingtheinputdata,refiningthedata,andimprovingthedetermi-
Chapter 8 Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
78
nationofthesevariousfactorsplus,particu-larly,ourunderstandingofthetotalamountofenergyreleased.
Next Breakthrough: Total Energy, Number of CyclesCrandall: Onethingnotyetroutinelyandexplicitlyconsideredasapartofseismicdesignisthedurationoftheshaking.Thathasalwaysstruckmeasvery,veryimportantandfundamental.Theinitialeffortsconcentratedonacceleration,andwe’vetalkedaboutpeakacceleration.Theresponsespectrumgivesyouonepeakvalueforastructureofagivenpe-riod.Butit’sawellknownfactthatoneortwocyclesof,say,50percentgacceleration,arenotgoingtocauseseriousproblemsinawell-constructedbuilding.Butifthat50percentgkeepsupforfive,ten,ortwentycycles,thenithasatremendouseffectonthebuilding.Itisaquestionofthetotalenergy,ratherthanasingleshock.It’srecognizedthatdurationisimportant,buttomyknowledgetherehasnotyetbeenanyspecificwayofincludingthedurationeffect,otherthanasajudgmentintheanalysisanddesignofstructures.
Ihavelongmaintainedthatwhatreallycountsisthetotalenergyimpartedtoabuilding,althoughthatisnoteasytofigure.Itisnotjustthesinglemaximumaccelerationeffect,butalsoinvolvesthedurationoftheaccelerations.Thisisrecognizedbyalmosteverybody,butisnotaneasythingtodealwith.Tomyknowledge,theengineershaveyettosucceedinthinkingofanearthquake’seffectintermsoftotalenergyreleaseanditsimpactonabuilding.
Wemeasureearthquakesthatway,ofcourse—theRichterscaleforexampleisreallyamea-sureoftheenergyreleaseofearthquakes.TheRichtermagnitudeisonalogarithmicscaleoften.Youalwaysreadthatinthenewspapers,butthefactoroftenappliestotheamplitudeofmotionasmeasuredonaseismograph.Thereisafactoroftenbetweentheamplitudeofamagnitude5andamagnitude6earthquake,asitreadsoutonaparticularkindofseismo-graph,withacorrectionforthedistanceoftheseismographfromtheearthquakeepicenter.
Intermsoftotalenergyreleased,however,theratiobetweenamagnitude5anda6ismorelikethirty-twotimes.Soamagnitude6involvesthirty-twotimestheenergythatamagnitude5has,andamagnitude7involvesroughly1,000timestheenergyofamagnitude5(322equalsalittleoverathousand).Thetotalenergyre-leasedgoesupveryfastasyougoupthemagni-tudescale.Andthatisrelatedtotheeffectonabuilding,aswellastheareaaffectedbyshaking.
MyfeelingisthatthenextbreakthroughwillbeinthemannerofconsideringwhatIwillcalltotalenergy.Thatis,thenumberofcyclesofagivenlevelofshaking,andhowtheyaffectthebuilding.Weknowverywellthatafterafewcycles,theperiodofabuildingchanges.And,ofcourse,thestrengthoftheconnectionsandsoonareaffected.Ithinkwhatthatdoestothebuild-ingisveryimportant,butatthemoment,atleasttomyknowledge,itcannotbeadequatelyandthoroughlyconsideredinthedesignprocedure.
Scott: Thatseemslikeaveryimportantpoint.Isn’tthatoneofthebigunknownsaboutpredictingfutureearthquakes—anticipatinghowlongtheywilllast?
79
Chapter 8LeRoy Crandall • Soil Engineering and Earthquake Engineering
Crandall: Weknowempirically,basedonpastearthquakes,thatalow-magnitudeearth-quakeisgoingtoshakeforanestimatedlengthoftime.That’saboutasgoodaswehavedoneuptothepresenttime.Butthathasnotyetbeenworkedintothedesignanalysis.
Structuralengineershaveuseddifferentfac-tors,basedontheresponsespectraandthegroundmotioninterpretation.Ithinkthenextstepinengineeringanalysisofbuildingswillbethemethodsofincludingtheenergyconsid-eration,thenumberofcyclesofshakingofagivenlevel.
Scott: Whatwillittake?Moreactualob-servationsinearthquakesmadewithstrongmotioninstrumentsandotherkindsofinstru-ments?Shakingtableexperiments?Theoreti-calcomputations?
Crandall: Thoseareallimportant,andtheywillgiveabetterunderstandingofhowthisthinghappens.Ithink,however,that(hopeful-ly)computerprogramminginthenearfuturewillbecapableofanalyzingabuildingwithanassumednumberofcyclesofshaking.
Scott: Inotherwords,thedesignerswillsuc-cessivelypluginabunchofdifferentassumedearthquakes,andseewhathappens?
Crandall: Yes,that’sthebasicidea.
Lifeline Earthquake Engineering and TCLEECrandall: We’vetalkedaboutbuildingsandseismicdesign,butdams,bridges,powerplants,storagetanks,andothercivilengineer-ingworksarealsoimportant.AtthispointI
mightdiscussanotherelementofearthquakeengineeringthatIhadahandin,andthatwastheTechnicalCouncilonLifelineEarthquakeEngineering,TCLEE,whichisacounciloftheAmericanSocietyofCivilEngineers.
Scott: IrememberMartinDukeusingthatacronymatEERIconferences.AtfirstIdidn’tknowwhatitwasallabout.
Crandall: Martinisverycentraltothestory.ThewholethingstartedonaplaneridefromSacramentotoLosAngeles.Wewerereturn-ingfromaStrongMotionInstrumentationAdvisoryCommitteemeeting.MartinDukeandIwereseatmatesontheplanegoingbacktoLosAngeles.Heisnowdeparted,havingpassedawayin19��,andwemisshimgreatly.IwasontheboardofdirectionofASCEatthetime.Martinwastalkingaboutalltheseismiceffortputonbuildings,andyetthereweremanyotherimportantstructuresthatshouldbethoughtabout,namelydams,bridges,highways,communicationssystems,andsoon.ThesewereallmattersofthesortthatMar-tinlumpedundertheterm“lifelines.”Idon’tknowifheoriginatedthenameorgotitfromsomewhereelse,butIfirstheardofitthroughMartin.I’llgivehimthecreditforbeingthefirsttoatleastapplythatnameinourearth-quakeengineeringfield.
Scott: Itisalmostuniversallyusednow.
Crandall: Yes.Idon’tknowwhattheexactoriginis,butcertainlyMartinmadeitpopular.Anyway,wegottotalkingaboutthematterontheplanetrip,andMartinsaidhefelttherewasabigneedforinformationonthesecivilengineeringworksthataffectthesafetyandservicesofthepublic.Wetalkedforawhile,
Chapter 8 Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
80
andthenthethoughtcametome,asMartinexpoundedonhisthinking,thatthecivilen-gineerswhodesignandoperatethesefacilitiesshouldbeconcernedwiththis.
ItoccurredtomethattheAmericanSocietyofCivilEngineerswouldbealogicalplacetodevelopanorganizationwiththissubjectasitsprincipaltopicforconsideration.Martinthoughtthatwasanexcellentidea.HewasalsoactiveinASCE.MartinandItalkedaboutitandcametothejointconclusionthatitwouldbedesirabletosetupacommitteetoexplorethepossibilityofhavingadivisionofASCEtoconsiderlifelineproblemsinearthquakeengi-neering.Theideasjelled,andIpresentedtheconcepttoameetingoftheboardofdirectionheadingupASCE.Theproceduresetupforstartingnewactivitieswas,firsttohaveacom-mitteetostudythematter,seewhatitsscopewas,andestimatetheinterestofthesocietymembers.Iobtainedthego-aheadfromthenationalboardforthat.
Sowesetupastudygroup.MartinDuke,ifmymemoryiscorrect,wasaskedtoserveaschairman,andIwastheboardofdirectionmemberappointedtobetheliaisonbetweenthenewcommitteeandthenationalboardofdirectionofASCE.
Wehand-selectedanumberofpeoplewefelthadaninterest.Thesewerepeoplefromthepublicutilities—forexample,theEdisonCompanyofSouthernCaliforniaandtheLosAngelesDepartmentofWaterandPower.Well,thecommitteemetseveraltimesanddecidedthattherecertainlywasaneedforthis,especiallyamongcivilengineers.Asurveywasmadeofthesocietymemberstoseewhattheir
interestwas.Theresponsewasverygratifying.Thenextstep,then,afterthecommitteerec-ommendedthatASCEtakeactioninthisfield,wastoestablishatechnicalcouncil.
ItwascalledtheTechnicalCouncilonLifelineEarthquakeEngineering,TCLEE.Theformatofthisgroupwasset,andIwasprivilegedtobetheonetointroducethemotionandresolutiontotheASCEboardtogoaheadandestablishthecouncil.
Scott: Roughlywhenwasthetechnicalcoun-cilestablished?
Crandall: Itwasin1974,aftertheSanFer-nandoearthquake.MartinwasEERIPresidentfrom1970to1973andwasveryinvolvedinallthestudieslaunchedafterthatearthquake,includinghisinterestinlifelines.Atfirst,TCLEEwasundertheumbrellaofoneoftheASCEtechnicaldivisions.Later,becauseofthenumberofmembersinterested,itbecameafullformaltechnicalcouncil.Ithasbeenoperatingatthatleveleversince.Ithasitsownpubli-cation,andeveryyearortwoholdsitsownmeetingsinconjunctionwithnationalASCEconventions.TCLEEsponsorspartoftheconventionprogram.Verygoodworkhasbeendoneanddisseminatedbythatorganization.
MartinDukewastheparentofTCLEE—itwashisbasicidea.IparticipatedinthesensethatIcameupwiththeapproachofdoingitthroughASCE,andduetomybeingontheboardasanationaldirector,wasabletointro-duceitandbringthistoanearlyestablishment.
Scott: Lookingback,hasTCLEEaccom-plishedmostof,orevenmorethan,whatyoutwohadinmindwhenyoufirstdiscussedit?
81
Chapter 8LeRoy Crandall • Soil Engineering and Earthquake Engineering
Crandall: Ithinkithasgrownwellbeyondanythingwethoughtpossible.Injustonefield,pipelines,andhowtodesignapipelinecrossingafault,forexample,therehavebeennumerousstudies,andNSFgrantstoresearchinstitutionsforevaluatingthevariousfactors.Shakingisnormallyofnoconsequencetopipelines,be-causethepipelineismovingwiththeground,andthedistanceoverwhichtheshakingtakesplaceislongenoughtoallowapipetobendandaccommodateanydifferentialsoilmotion.Thewavelengthofmostoftheearthquakewavesishundredsoffeet.Sofromonepointwherethegroundmotionisgoingonewaytothenextpointwhereitisgoingtheoppositeway,thereisusuallyasufficientdistancethatithasnoeffectonaburiedstructure.Thediffer-enceinthewaythesoilismovingisspreadoutoveralongdistanceofapipeline,forexample.
But,ofcourse,ifthereisasharpbreakintheground,thatisanotherstory.TheBayAreaRapidTransit(BART)tube,forex-ample,hasacomfortzonebuiltintoitsothatadisplacementofseveralfeetwherethefaultcrossesthelinecanbeabsorbedinthetunnel.Inotherwords,akindofajointwasbuiltatthatpoint.
WehavedonethesamethingonamajorsewerprojectinLosAngelesthathadtocrosstheNewport-Inglewoodfault,theNorthOutfallReplacementSewer(NORS)project.Wecon-sultedwithClarenceAllenabouttheamountofdisplacementthatonemightexpectintheeventofaruptureoftheNewport-Inglewoodfaultatthelocationofoursewerline.IfIre-membercorrectly,togetherClarenceAllenandwedecidedthatthreefeetofpossiblelateral
movement,andofcoursesomeupwardmove-ment,couldoccurthere.
Sowebuiltasoftzone,likeapipewithinapipe,acrossthatfault.Theouterpipeisexpendable.Theinneroneissupportedfreeandclearwithasufficientdistanceoneachsidesothatifthegroundmovedthesewerline,al-thoughitwouldstillhavetobend,wouldbendtoaccommodateafewfeetofbendingoveralengthof100feet,say.Theoutershellwouldbreak,becauseitwasatunnelthroughthesoilandwouldbeshearedoverashortlengthwhereitcrossedthefault.Theinnerpipelinecouldabsorbthedistortionoveralongdistance.
Youcannotdomuchforatrenchedpipelineincitystreetswherethereisgoingtobeliquefac-tion,withveryabruptchangeswherethepipegoesfromsolidgroundintosoftground.Thejointsofthoseoldpipelinesareverybrittle,soitwouldnottakeverymuchtodamageaburiedpipeundersuchconditionsofdiscon-tinuity.Ifthereisnosoildiscontinuity,thentheyarealmostinvulnerabletosuchproblems,inmyopinion,becausetheymovewiththesurroundingsoil.
Highwaysandbridgesareimportantlifelinesalso.WhathappenedtotheCypressViaductinOaklandintheLomaPrietaearthquakewasduetoamplifiedgroundmotion,primarilybe-causethestructurewasofanearlydesignthatitisnowrecognizedasincapableofresistingthiskindofshaking.Butthatdoesnotmeanthatallfreewaydesigns,especiallytheneweronesandthosebuiltfromthistimeon,aregoingtohavethesameexperience.Asimplebridgestructureisthesimplestthingthereistodesign.Youknowtheloadsbeautifully,thegeometryis
Chapter 8 Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
82
elemental,supportedonacoupleofcolumnsateachend.Asfarasdesigngoes,itismuchlesscomplexthanamultistorybuilding.Wearecertainlyabletodesignandbuildthatkindofbridgestructure,whetheronedeckortwo,withanydegreeofsafetythatiswanted.
Scott: Sobanningtwo-levelstructuresislearningthewronglesson?Thereallessonistodoabetterjobofdesigningtwo-levelstruc-tures,nottoavoidthementirely.
Crandall: Yes.
Parkfield ExperimentCrandall: OneexampleistheexperimentalpipelineinstalledintheParkfield,CaliforniaareaalongtheSanAndreasfault,halfwaybetweenLosAngelesandSanFrancisco.Thepipelinecrossesthefaultandisinstrumented,awaitingthepredictedearthquakeinthePark-fieldarea.
Ishouldmentionthattheprincipalgeotechni-calengineeringfirmsinCalifornia—andIwaschairmanofthecommittee—havegottentogetherandmadeinstrumentalreadingsintheParkfieldareaataplacecalledTurkeyFlat.Explorationboringsweredrilledalongthissite.Variousfirmsparticipatedinthatundertheaus-picesofSMIP,theStrongMotionInstrumenta-tionProgramofthestateofCalifornia,andtheCaliforniaDivisionofMinesandGeology.
Wegottogether,andbasedonthedatapro-vided,eachfirmpredictedwhatthegroundmotionwouldbeatvariouspointsadjacentto
thefault.SMIPhasestablishedinstrumentsatthosepoints.Theideabehindthiswastohaveafull-scaletestofhowaccurateweareinourpredictions.
Scott: IfandwhenthepredictedParkfieldearthquakedoeshappen,you’rereadyforitwiththosevariousguesstimatesandpredictions.
Crandall: That’stheidea.Thesewerepre-dictedinadvanceandsubmitted,sonobodycansay,“Ididn’treallymeanthat.”Whenthatearthquakehappens,we’llseewhatproce-duresarebest,whatworkedthebest,andwhichfirmsaredoingajobthatgivesthebestanswers.Thisisaveryimportantstep,becauseyoudoallthesethingswiththecomputer—youdocalculationsbasedonmeasurementsandyouextrapolate.Hereisacasewherewewillgetwhatwethinkwillbeaboutamagni-tude5.5or6,somethinglikethat,inthenearfuture.Theinstrumentationisinplace.Thepredictionshavebeenmade.12
12. OnSeptember2�,2004,amagnitude6earthquakeoccurredontheParkfieldsegmentoftheSanAndreasfault.SeeReal,C.R.,Shakal,A.F.,andTucker,B.E.,“TurkeyFlat,U.S.A.SiteEffectsTestArea:AnatomyofaBlindGround-MotionPredictionTest,”ThirdInternationalSymposiumontheEffectsofSurfaceGeologyonSeismicMotion,Grenoble,France,2006.Inthiscontext,“blind”referstothefactthatthepeoplemakingpredictionsofthestronggroundmotioncouldnotseeanydatafromit,sincetheymadetheirpredictionsinadvanceoftheoccurrenceoftheearthquake.
Chapter 9
Contributions of an Older Generation
83
When something goes wrong, the owner gets
the lawyers to put the noose around anyone
they can find, and with the developer long gone,
often the soil engineer is who they find. We’re in
a terrible business from that standpoint.
Clarence Derrick: A Unique Engineer
Crandall: I’dliketosayafewwordsaboutClarenceDerrick,whowasaverytalentedstructuralengineeroftheoldschoolhereinLosAngeles.Hewaskindofamentorofmine,andtookaninterestinmycareer.Hewasveryhelpfulingivingadvice,forwhichhewasquitefamous.Clarencewouldgiveadviceonalmostanything,whetheryouwanteditornot.
Irecallwithgreatpleasurehavingtheprivilegeofknow-ingClarenceDerrick.ClarencepracticedinLosAngelesandwasagraduateofNotreDame.Hewasauniqueengineerinthathehadaverybroadbackground,includ-ingliteratureandthearts.Hewasnotanartisthimself,buthewasfamiliarwiththem.Itmusthavebeendueto
Chapter 9 Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
84
theeducationhereceivedatNotreDame.HemusthavegraduatedfromNotreDameaboutthetimeofWorldWarI.
Hewasextremelyliterate,andhefelttherewasnoschoollikeNotreDame.ClarencewasanIrishman.HewasveryculturedandwouldquotefromtheBibleandfromliterature.Hewasaveryarticulate,veryimpressiveguy.Hecouldalsogetdownonthefloorandshootcrapswithyou.Clarencecouldcharmyouveryreadily,buthewasalsoamanofsubstance,particularlyinengineering.
WhenIstartedmyownbusiness,Clarenceusedtosay,“Dothejob,don’tworryaboutthemoney,ifyoujustdothingsright,themoneywillcome.Butifyoujustsetyourgoalformakingmoney,youhavethewrongsightsandyouveryprobablywillbeafailure.”
Scott: Youthinkthatwasverygoodadvice?
Crandall: Iknowitwas.Ialreadyfeltthatwayanyway,buthereinforcedmythinking.Inmypracticewehavealwaysignoredthecontractamountanddonethejobthewaywethoughtitneededtobedone,andthewaytheclientexpectedusto.Ifwemadesomemoneyonit,thatwasfine,andifwelost,wellthatwasn’tfine,butweacceptedit.
Weneverevershortchangedajobbecausewehadmadeapoorcostestimateoriginally.Ican’tthinkofanycasewherewedidnotdeliverwhatwethoughtthejobneeded.Nowsometimesyouestimateajobtobeginwith,andmanyclientswantaflatfee.Butyougetoutthereandstartdrilling,andyouhitsomethingunexpected.Whatdoyoudo?Oftentimestheclientwouldbeunderstand-
ing,andwerewillingtoacceptanincreaseinfee.Butmanytimestheykindoffeltmaybeitwasourownfault,thatwehadnotresearchedthejobenough,orforwhatevercause.Anyway,Clarencewasagreatphi-losopher,andthatwasoneofthethingsheimpresseduponme.
Clarencehadknowledgeaboutalmostevery-thing,andwasatremendousengineerwhocutthroughalotofthemysteryofearlyseismicdesign.Hewroteacoupleofbooksthatwerenotwidelycirculated,butwereusedinacoursehetaughtattheUniversityofSouthernCalifornia(USC),whichmusthavebeeninthelate1940sandearly1950s.Heusedaverysimplifiedprocedurefordescribingearth-quakemotioninthegroundandastransferredtoabuilding.
IalsowanttodiscussClarence’sresearchinterestinearthquakeeffects.Atthattimetheydesignedprettymuchbythecode,typicallywithanequivalentstaticlateralforcebasedon10per-centg,or20percentgifyoufeltyouhadareallycriticalbuilding.Therewasn’tmuchunderstand-ingofwhatwasactuallyhappening.Clarence,inhisownbasementlaboratoryathome,didsomeoutstandingmeasurementsofbuildingbehaviorusingmodels.Hedevelopedasmall,one-directionalshakingtable.Oneofhismodelswasafour-storyframemadeofaluminum,scaledataboutteninchesperfloor,aboutfortyincheshighinall,andperhapseightinchesinwidth.Anothermodelwasjustatwo-dimensionalframe.Hehadtwosteelstrips,maybethreefeethigh,andaninchwideandasixteenthofaninchthick.Thenhehadfloorsconnectedacrossatap-propriatelevels,sothemodelwasdividedupintomaybesixlevels.Thewholethingwassomething
85
Chapter 9LeRoy Crandall • Contributions of an Older Generation
liketeninchesinwidth,andsomethirtyincheshigh.Withsixlevels,thatwouldmakeitfiveinchesbetweeneachlevel.
Theframewasmountedonaplatformthathecouldshakebackandforthwithasynchronousmotion.Theframewouldswayashemadethesemotions.Engineersusuallythoughtthebuildinghadjustonemodeshape—itbentover,anditbentback,itbentover,anditbentback.Clarencesaid,“No,thatisn’tright.Thereareotherwigglesthatcomeintoit.”Thatdependedonthedegreeofshakingandthecharacterofwhathehadbuilt.Hehaditsohecouldclipadditionalweighttoeachfloor,andmakechangesthatway,torepresentaheavierstructure,comparedtoalighterone.
Hewouldsubjectthemodeltoashakingmove-mentatthebase.Thiswasbeforewehadhigh-speedcameras,orhadreadyaccesstothem.Hewantedtoseehowthemodeldeformedatvariousintervals,insplitsecondsoftiming.Hesetuphisstillcamerawithaswitch.Theswitchwasactivatedbyaweightthatdroppedinaglasstube.YouknowfromNewton’slawshowlongittakestodropsaytwoinches,fiveinches,teninches,ortwentyinches.Derrickcameupwithatimingmechanismthatwasincredible.Theguywasagunenthusiast—ofthemuzzle-loadertype.Sohetookaleadbullet,andmountedayardstickverticallyalongsidetheshakingtable.Thebullethadasteeljacketonit,andamagnethelditupsaythreefeetabovethetable.Thebulletwasinaglasscylinder,andwouldfallwhenhereleasedthemagnet.
Atacertaindistancedowntheyardstickscale,saymaybeattheten-inchpoint,hewouldhaveawirethathecouldinsertintothecylinder,so
whenthebulletfellandhitthewire,theflashcamerawentoffandtookapictureatthatpre-cisemoment.Hedidaseriesofpictureslikethat.Hesetthebullet,droppeditsayfiveinch-es,tookapicture,thendroppeditteninches,tookanotherpicture,andcontinuedlikethatwithaveryaccuratetimingmechanismthatwassosimpleitwasincredible.
Scott: Itwouldtakeonepictureeachtimehedroppedthebullet?
Crandall: Yes.Thenhewouldadvancethefilm,gettheshakinggoing,anddoitagain.Hecameupwithaseriesofphotographsthatshowedthedeformation,theS-typewave.HeimpressedandamazedengineerslikeSteveBarnes,MurrayErick,whowasaliveatthetime,andOliverBowen.AlsoPaulJeffers,whowasasskepticalashellabouteverythingany-bodyelsedid.Clarenceusedthatshaketableandthephotographstotrainotherengineers,youngerpeople.Thiswasbeforewehadcom-puters,probablyin1948or1949.
Scott: Istheexperimentationwiththemodeldescribedinhiswriting?
Crandall: Yes.HewroteseveralthatIstillhave.Herearethetitles:Damage Potential of Earth Shocks (1954);Elements of Aseismic Design(1955);Aseismic Design by Distortion Analysis (1956and1957);Elements of Aseismic Design, Part II (1959).Theengineeringstu-dentsatUSCwereexposedtothosewritings.Whenyousawthesepicturesinsequenceandthedeformationoftheframeandhowitwasmoving,itreallygaveagraphicillustrationofwhathappenstoasimpleframebuildingdur-ingashakingperiod.
Chapter 9 Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
86
Hedevelopedwhathecalledadistortionanalysissystem,basedonthatinformationandhissimplifiedgroundshaking.Itookhiscourseandreadpartsofhisbook,butithasbeenalongtime.Idon’twanttogointothistoofar,buthisgroundmotionwasinasemi-circle,ahalf-circle.Thenitwentinastraightlineforashortdistance,untilitturnedbackagain.Itwaskindoflikeanellipse.
Iguessithadcircularends,andwaslikecut-tingapieinhalfandseparatingthetwosemi-circularhalvesbymaybesixorseveninches.Thatwastheshapeofhisdescriptionofthepathofaparticleatthebaseofthebuilding.Itshowedthemovementthatwouldbetransmit-ted,andwasrathersimplysolvablemathemati-cally,whichwasthekeytothewholething,findingasimplebasisfordeterminingwhatistheeffectofthegroundmotion.
Derrickdeservesmorecreditthanhehasbeengiven.
Scott: Ihearyou.Youknow,fromJohnBlume,principally,andsomeotherswhoworkedwithhim,IhavegottenbackgroundonsomeoftheworkdoneupatStanford.Johnbuiltamodelofabuilding,theAlexanderBuilding,andatonepointheandafellowstudentdidapainstakinganalysis,usingMarchantcalculators,ofwhathap-pensinsuchabuildingunderearthquakeforces.
ThenfromGeorgeHousnerIgotbackgroundonsomeoftheactivitiesmainlycenteredaroundCaltech.ButnobodythatIrecallmentionedthisworkbyDerrick.IbelieveBillMooredidmentionDerrickassomebodyofconsequenceinearthquakeengineering.Butyouarereallythefirstpersonwhohastalkedmuchtomeaboutthenatureofhiswork.
Crandall: Derrickcameupwithformulasfortheeffectsofthevibration,theacceleration,andthevelocity,andcameupwithadisplacementformula.Hethentalkedwiththeheadofstruc-turalengineeringattheUniversityofSouthernCalifornia,DavidWilson.Thatisanotherstory—IthinkDaveWilsonhadoneofthebig-gestimpactsoncivilandstructuralengineeringinsouthernCaliforniaatthattime,becauseofhisteachingabilityandtheinspirationhewasforhisstudentsatUSC.
Atanyrate,ClarenceDerrickgottogetherwithDaveWilson,whowassoentrancedbywhatClarencewasdoingthatheaskedhimtoteachthesubjectatUSC.SoasInotedearlier,ClarencetaughtatUSC.Foraboutthreeorfouryearshegaveacourseinaseismicdesign.Hewasasticklerforlanguage,andhesaiditshouldbe“aseismic,”not“seismic.”
Scott: Meaningnon-seismic.
Crandall: Non-seismic,yes.Hegotveryfewsupportersontheuseofthatterm,butstrictlyspeaking,Clarencewasright,youknow.Itisalittleliketheword“anti-seismic”thatStephenTobrinerusedwhenhegaveatalkforoneofourSeismicSafetyCommissionworkshops.
Anyway,ClarencetaughtatUSC.Itookoneoftheclasses,eventhoughIwasnotastructuralengineer,becauseithadsomuchinformationforasoils-typeperson.Hedidthatforafewyearsuntilhegotsometraineewhocarriedon,andhegaveuptheteachingbecausehehadotherinterests.
WhenIknewhim,Idonotrecallthatheeverdesignedabuildinghimselfasastructuralengineer.Hehaddonethatinthepast.Hewas
87
Chapter 9LeRoy Crandall • Contributions of an Older Generation
Fritz Matthiesen and Strong Motion StudiesScott: You’vementionedFritzMatthiesentomeafewtimes.Sayafewwordsabouthim.AsIrecall,hewaswithUSGS.
Crandall: Yes.USGShadwhattheycalledtheearthquakegroup,andhewasinit.InitiallyitwasheadquarteredintheBayArea.Beforethat,hewasontheteachingstaffatUCLAwithMartinDuke.ThenheleftfortheCoastandGeodeticSurvey,andthenwentwiththeU.S.GeologicalSurveywhentheearthquakeprogramshiftedthere.FritzwasinchargeofalltheUSGSstrongmotionstations.Atthattime,USGSwaspracticallytheonlyonewhohadthemsetoutinfar-flungplacesinCalifornia,suchasintheElCentroareaintheImperialValley.
Fritzwasintheforefrontofgatheringthistypeofstrongmotionknowledge,andwasveryoutspokenandvehementaboutit.Fritzknewthatstrongmotiondatawereessentialtoun-derstandinganddesigningstructurestoresistearthquakes.Hehadsomeinterestingcharac-teristics.Onewas,heneverworeatietoanyoftheconferencesthatwewerealwaysgoingtointhosedays—meetingsoftheengineeringgroupsandEERIandthatsortofthing.Ire-calloneyearwhentheymadeaspecialsurprisepresentationtoFritz.Theycalledhimuptotheheadtableandpresentedhimwithatie,whichheonlyworethatoneevening.
Romeo R. Martel of CaltechScott: TakealookatthesecommentsbyBillMooreinhisEERIoralhistory.Hesaid“Martel’sworkonmomentdistributionand
inonsomeofthemajorstructuresinsouthernCalifornia,andIthinkheevenworkedontheLosAngelesCityHall,whichAlbertC.Martinwasinvolvedin.
Clarencewasindemandasareviewerandcon-sultantformanybuildings.IknowthedesignsofthecountybuildingsattheCivicCenterinLosAngeles,theHallofAdministrationandtheCountyCourtsbuilding,werereviewedandcritiquedbyClarenceforthearchitects.Bran-dowandJohnstonwasthestructuralengineerforthebuildings,butClarenceDerrickworkedwiththeminimprovingthedesignsandbring-ingintoactualpracticethetypeofthinghehadworkedupinhisstudies.RoyJohnstonknowsaboutDerrick.
Incidentally,ClarenceDerrickwasoneofthefoundersoftheStructuralEngineersAssocia-tionofSouthernCalifornia,oneofthe“dirtydozen”astheycalledthem.Theyweretheguyswhogottogetherandoriginatedthestructuralengineersassociation.ItbeganinsouthernCalifornia.13ThatallbeganwithClarence,PaulJeffers,SteveBarnes,guyslikethat.
13. TheStructuralEngineersAssociationofSouthernCalifornia(SEAOSC),wasestablishedin1929,followedbytheestablishmentofsimilarorganizationsinotherpartsofCalifornia:theStructuralEngineersAssociationofNorthernCalifornia(SEAONC),ofCentralCalifornia(SEAOCC),andofSanDiego(SEAOSD).ThechartermembersofSEAOSCwereRufusM.Beanfield,OliverG.Bowen,WendellButts,RalphA.DeLine,ClarenceJ.Derrick,MurrayErick,MarkFalk,PaulE.Jeffers,R.R.Martel,WilliamMellema,ClarenceE.Noerenberg,andBlaineNoice.See“History,”SEAOSCwebsite,http://www.seaosc.org/about_history.cfm.
Chapter 9 Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
88
analysisshouldbementioned.”Doyouknowanythingaboutthat?
Crandall: IonlyoncehadthepleasureofhearingProfessorMartelspeakatameeting.Thenheleftthescene.HewasastructuralengineeringprofessoratCaltech,andtaughtbothBillMooreandTrentDames.
Scott: DoyourecallwhenyouheardMartel?
Crandall: Yes.IstartedwithDamesandMooreinDecember1941,andjoinedtheStructuralEngineersAssociationofSouthernCalifornia.Thecompanywasverysupportiveofmydoingthat.Theyencouragedmetobe-comeactiveinstructuralengineeringthroughSEAOSC,andincivilengineeringbymem-bershipinASCE.IwassecretaryoftheLosAngelessectionofASCEinabout1945.
TheLosAngeles,orsouthernCalifornia,sectionofthestatewideStructuralEngineersAssociationofCaliforniausedtomeetonceayearattheCaliforniaInstituteofTechnology,thenextyearatUCLA,andthenextyearatUSC.OntheyearswhenwemetatCaltech,Martelgavetheaddress.Ididnotknowhim,buthewasadistinguished-lookingguy,veryimpressive,withaboomingvoice,asIremem-ber.Notverymanypeoplewouldtakeissuewithhisthoughtsorexpressions,eveniftheydisagreedviolently,becausehewaskindofanoverwhelmingpersonality.
Scott: Hewasintimidating?
Crandall: Yes.Thatisonewordforit.Ithinkso.Ididnotseeanyonestandupanddisagreewithhim.Buthewasoneoftheprincipalsinearlyknowledgeofearthquakeandseismicconsiderationsforstructures.I
guessthosewhohadclassesfromhimkindofreveredtheguy.
Hardy Cross Crandall: YoumentionMoore’sreferencetomomentdistribution,whichheprobablylearnedasastudentofMartel’satCaltech.Thatbringsupthenameofanothergreatengineeringprofessor,HardyCross.14IremembertheHardyCrossmomentdistributionmethodthatIwastaughtwhileastudentatBerkeley.You’llrecallIgraduatedin1941,sothiswaswaybeforethemoderncomputersengineersnowuse.HardyCrosshaddevelopedanapproximatemethodthatmadeitpossibletosolvesomecomplexproblemswithsimplifyingassumptions.Sayyouhadallthesestructuralforcescominginonagirderandcolumn.Youputweightonacontinuousframing,frameswithrelativelyrigidcolumn-beamjoints,andthebendingmomentsflowallover.Whatisthedistributionofthemo-mentsandforces?Itwasaperplexingproblemtosolvewithaslideruleunlessyouhadanelegantconceptualapproach,whichCrossdeveloped.
Itwasaveryclevermethod.Ididn’tworkwithitthatmuch,sinceitwasmostlyforstructur-als.Itwasalsoapplicabletohydraulics,where
14. HardyCross(1885-1959),obtainedhismasterofcivilengineeringdegreeatHarvardin1911.AfterbeingaprofessoratBrownUniversityandbrieflyaconsultingengineer,hejoinedthefacultyoftheUniversityofIllinoisatUrbana-Champaignin1921,wherehedevelopedwhatbecameknownastheHardyCrossMomentDistributionMethod(“AnAnalysisofContinuousFramesbyDistributingFixed-EndMoments,”Proceedings of the American Society of Civil Engineers,May,1930).
89
Chapter 9LeRoy Crandall • Contributions of an Older Generation
youhadmultiplepipescomingtogetherandyouneededtofigurehowyoudistributedtheflowfromonepipetotheotherpipes.
Scott: Evidentlyitwasusedconsiderably,probablyfromtheearly1930suptowhenthecomputerscamein.
Crandall: Idon’tknowwhethersomethingelsereplaceditpriortotheageofthecom-puter,butitseemedtomethatitwastheonlywaystructuralengineerscouldgetareason-ableestimateofthedistributionofforcesinaframestructure.
Robert V. “Cap” LabarreScott: Whataboutthe[Cap]Labarreand[Fred]Converseconsultingfirm?
Crandall: InevergottomeetLabarre.HepassedonrightafterIcametoDamesandMoore.Heapparentlywasalegend.HisnamewasRobert,buteveryonecalledhim“Cap”Labarre.Heapparentlywasthefirstguytoac-tuallypracticesoilengineeringandfoundationengineeringinsouthernCalifornia.IthinkhecamefromLouisiana.
TheFieldActcamealong,andLabarregotin-volvedintheschoolprogram.Hesawanoppor-tunity,sayabout1935.Hewouldcomeupwithreportsforthefoundationdesign.Essentially,thereportconsistedoftheallowablebearingvalueforthesoilsupportingthefoundation.
Hediditbytheloadtestmethod.Thiswasanearlytechnique.Muchofthetimeyoutooka12"x12"-squarepost,setitonthegroundverticallyandstartedloadingit.Whenthepoststartedpunchingintheground,thatwasthe
ultimatebearingvalueofthatsoil.Youdividedthatbytwoorsomesuchsafetyfactornumber,andwroteareportsaying,“Thissoilisgoodfor1,250poundspersquarefoot,”orwhateveritwas.Thatwasthewaytheydiditoriginally.ThenIthinkLabarregotstartedwiththeexploratoryboringwork.BothTrentandBillworkedforhim,Ithink,whiletheywereinschool.Theygotinterestedinsoilengineeringandgotpart-timeorsummerjobswithCapLabarreandthengraduated.IthinkDamesworkedforLabarre,andBillMoorewenttoworkfortheCorpsofEngineers.ThenTrentstartedhisowncompany,andassoonashegotsomework,BilllefttheCorpsofEngineersanditbecameDamesandMoore.Ithinkthatwasin1938or1939.
Karl Terzaghi: Father of Soil MechanicsCrandall: IhavetodigresstodiscussKarlTerzaghibeforegoingontotalkaboutFredConverse,becauseFredgotinterestedinsoilengineeringandwentbacktoHarvardwhenKarlTerzaghi15—thefatherofsoilmechan-
15. KarlvonTerzaghi,(1883-1963)grewupinPragueandwenttocollegeattheTechnischeHochshcule(technicaluniversity)inGrasz,Austria,receivingadegreeinmechanicalengineering.Hisbook,Erdbaumechanik,orSoil MechanicsinEnglish,waspublishedin1925basedonresearchconductedasaprofessorinIstanbul.In1925hewashiredbyMIT,thenmovedbacktoAustria,thenimmigratedagaintotheUSAjustpriortotheoutbreakofWorldWarII,wherehewasonthefacultyofHarvardUniversitytillhisretirement.Healsoconsultedonanumberoflargedamsandotherprojects.
Chapter 9 Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
90
ics—hadcometotheUnitedStates.Terzaghihadcomeupwithhistheoriesofconsolidationandotherthings,andwasreallythefirstonetoputsoilengineeringonascientificbasis.Uptothattime,ifanadjacentbuildingdidn’tfalldown,youdidwhattheydid,ormaybeyouaddedalittlegreatersoilpressure,untilsome-thinghappened,andthenyoubackedoff.
Terzaghihadcomeupwiththistheoryofconsolidationandsomesensibleapproachestosoilengineering.Hegavethesoilengineertheanalyticaltoolstounderstandhowsoilbehaved.
Hehadafewdisciples,oneofwhomwasnamedArthurCasagrande.CasagrandetookoveratHarvardwhenTerzaghileftthescene.
GoingbacktoLabarreandConverse,FredConversewasacivilengineeringprofessoratCaltech.HehadgonetoHarvardandab-sorbedtheinfluenceofTerzaghiandCasa-grandethere.ThenConversestartedteachingacourseinsoilmechanicsatCaltech.IthinkTrentDamesandBillMooretookthatcoursewhentheygottheirmastersdegreesthere.
FredConversewasdoingalittleconsult-ing,andheandLabarrejoinedforces.TheyformedLabarreandConverse,whichgavealittlemorescientificcredibilitytotheworkthatLabarrehadbeendoing.Atthistime,theystartedtakingso-calledundisturbedsamples.Theydroveacylinder—somethinglikeapipe,abouttwo-and-one-halfinchesindiameter—intothegroundandthenextractedit,andranlaboratorytestsonthesample.Thisiswhatwestilldotoday,althoughtherehasbeensomeimprovementinthesamplingdesignandprocedures.
Cyclicloadingwasdonewithastaticloadtest,whichdidnothavethecapabilityofveryquickonandoffloadingsorvibrationtests.Youdidthestatictestwithadeadweightframesupportingamassofconcreteorsteelorsomething togivetheresistance,thereaction andahydraulicjackpushingagainstthat,andtheotherendispushingonthisbear-ingplatethatisonthesoil.Youcouldcycletheloadingsasfastasyoucouldpumpthejackupandletitoff.Itwasmaybeaminutebetweencycles,ormaybetwominutes,nothinglikethesplit-secondloadingreversalswecandonow.
Warren and ConverseCrandall: Thoseweretheearlyyears.FredConversekepthisjobteachingatCaltech.AfterLabarreeitherdiedorretired,thefirmbecameWarrenandConverseforawhile.DonaldR.WarrenIthinkatonetimewasStateHighwayEngineer,andhaddonealotofbridgesandthingsforthestate.HewasdoingalotofdesigninginLosAngeles,andaddedthesoilengineeringcapabilitybyjoiningforceswithConverse.
WhenIjoinedDamesandMoore,ourcom-petitionwasWarrenandConverse.WarrenandConversecametosomedisagreementsandsplitup,andWarrenkeptoninthesoilbusiness,aswellashisstructuraldesignbusi-ness.Thatfirmwasoneoftheoneshithardbylawsuitsfromworkonthosehousingtractswediscussedearlier.
Long-Term Liability ExposureCrandall: WarrenandConversedidmostofthetractworkinLosAngelesataboutthat
91
Chapter 9LeRoy Crandall • Contributions of an Older Generation
time,in1941,whenIstartedwithDamesandMooreandinthefollowingyears.Believeitornot,asrecentlyasthe1980s,whenthecompanywasstillactive,theywerestillgettinglawsuitsfromthatwork.Alandslidewouldcausedamageandthecrywouldgoout:“Gogetthesoilengineer.”
Scott: Thatwasafullfortyyearslater!
Crandall: Oh,yes.Projectscancomebacktohauntthesoilsengineerdecadeslater.Ofcoursethedeveloperisgone,orthatcor-porationhaschanged.Thedesignerofthebuilding,thearchitect,isprobablygone.Theearthmoverisoutofbusiness.Theonlyguyleftisthesoilsengineer,andthesepoorguysaregettinglawsuits.Well,ithashappenedtoDamesandMoore,andtome,forworkdonewayback.Nowofcoursetheyjudgeitbythecurrentcode.Youthinkthatthestatuteoflimitationsshouldprotectyou,butthatdoesnotdoyouanygooduntiltheproblemoccurs,andthentheystartmeasur-ingfromthattime.
Scott: Theystarttheclockwiththeoccur-renceoftheproblem,notfromthetimetheworkwasdone?
Crandall: Yes.Andusuallywhathappensisthatthehomeownerorpropertyownerchangedsomething,ordidnottakecareofthedrainagesystemorsomethinglikethat,andislookingforsomebodytohelppayforthecosts.
Scott: Buteveniftheownerisresponsible,youhavetofightitthroughincourttodemon-stratehisresponsibility?
Crandall: Right.IfeltsorryforWarrenandConversebecauseinatractofmaybeonehun-dredhomes,ninety-ninemightbeperfect,butonehasaproblem,andmaybethatproblemisnotevenofyourdoing.Buttotheoneguywhoownsthehome,itisthebiggestthingintheworld,beinghismaininvestment.Whensomethinggoeswrong,theownergetsthelaw-yerstoputthenoosearoundanyonetheycanfind,andwiththedeveloperlonggone,oftenthesoilengineeriswhotheyfind.We’reinaterriblebusinessfromthatstandpoint.
Chapter 10
California Seismic Safety Commission
93
I consider the work of the Seismic Safety
Commission an extremely valuable and
important effort on behalf of the people
of the State of California.
Scott: We’vebothservedontheCaliforniaSeismicSafetyCommission.Sayafewwordsaboutyourexperi-enceonit.
Crandall: Well,Stan,it’syouwhoshouldbetalking,sinceyouwereonitfromtheverybeginning.IconsidertheworkoftheSeismicSafetyCommissionanextremelyvaluableandimportanteffortonbehalfofthepeopleoftheStateofCalifornia.TheCommissionhastakentheleadinemphasizingtheimportanceofearthquakepreparedness,properdesign,andeffectivebuildingcodesandtheirenforcement.
Mostofall—Ithinkanygoodpracticingengineerwouldtellyouthis—istheextremeimportanceofinspectionduringconstruction.Beautifulplans,computerprintouts,andstate-of-the-artseismicknowledgewillnotprotectyourstructureifitisnotbuiltinaccordancewiththose
Chapter 10 Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
94
plansandcomputations.Sometimesitonlytakesoneweakpointtocauseacatastrophethatotherwisewouldonlyhavebeenaminorincidentinthelifeofabuilding.TheCommis-sionhashadsomesuccessinincreasingqualitycontrolinconstructionalso.
Mines and Geology Board, the Alquist-Priolo ActCrandall: PrecedingmyrelationshiptotheSeismicSafetyCommission,myfirstassign-mentinstategovernmentasanappointeeofanysignificancewastothestateMinesandGeol-ogyBoard.ThatappointmentwasmadeunderGovernorRonaldReaganin1973.Iservedthereatacrucialtimewithsomeveryfineandtalentedpeople likeDickJahnsandClarenceAllen,twooutstandinggeologists.Iservedasasoilengineer.TheMinesandGeologyBoardispartoftheCaliforniaDivisionofMinesandGeology.OneofitsroleswastoprovideadviceoncarryingouttheAlquist-PrioloSpecialStudiesZonesActof1972.16
TheAlquist-Priolobill—pushedbyAlfredAlquist(whomImentionedearlier)intheCaliforniaSenate,andPaulPriolo,intheotherlegislativebranch,theCaliforniaAssem-bly—cameaboutin1972.ItwaspassedinordertoidentifyactivefaultsintheStateofCaliforniathatposedasurfacerupturehazard,tomakethepublicawareoftheirlocation,andtorequirelocalgovernmentspriortoissuingbuildingpermitstohavegeologistspreparestudiesofsiteslocatedinzonesmappedbythestatewherethehazardmightexist.Afaultzone
16. Thelawwaslaterre-namedtheAlquist-PrioloEarthquakeFaultZoningAct.
designationinanareadoesnotmeanthatyoucannotbuildonthatarea,butitmeansthatageologistregisteredinCaliforniamuststudytheproblem.Ifyourproposeddevelopmentfallswithinthezonemappedbythestate,yourlocalbuildingagencyisrequiredtoreceivethisstudy,paidforbytheowner,todeterminewhetherthedevelopmentissafe.
Believeitornot,oneofthethingsthattrig-geredthatbillwastheknowledgethatsubdivi-sionsinSanBernardinowerebeingbuiltrightontheSanAndreasfaulttrace.Thatissortofastounding,becauseoneofthethingsyoulearninengineeringistoavoidbuildingacrossafault.Thedramaticsurfacefaultinginthe1971SanFernandoearthquakebroughtatten-tiontothiskindofhazard.
Theoretically,youcandesignastructuretoresistmostanylevelofgroundshakingfromanearthquake,butthereisverylittleyoucandotoresistruptureofthegroundbeneaththebuilding.Mostgeologists,fromatheoreticalsciencepointofview,wouldliketoidentifyanycrackintheearthasapotentiallyactivefault.Geologiststhinkintermsofgeologi-caltime millionsofyears andallkindsofthingscanhappeninsuchlongtimespans.Ifyoulookhardenough,youcanfindfaultsal-mostanywhereinCalifornia.Bydiggingdown,lookingatoilwellmapsandlogs,youcanfindfaultsofallsorts,mostofwhichdon’tgettothesurface,andhopefullyneverwill.How-ever,thatdoesn’tgiveyouapracticalbasisforestablishinghazardzonesforsurfacerupture.ClarenceAllen,DickJahns,andIdidmuchscreamingandhollering,andwereabletolimitthedelineationofthefaultstotheonesthatwereactiveinHolocenetime thatis,they
95
Chapter 10LeRoy Crandall • California Seismic Safety Commission
haddisplacedduringthattime.TheHoloceneepochisroughlythelast11,000years.ThatpolicydefinedanactivefaultforpurposesoftheAlquist-PrioloAct.Thatwasforordinarybuildingdevelopments.Forcriticalfacilitieslikedams,thereisarationaleforextendingthatdefinitiontofaultswhosemostrecentrupturemayhavebeenalotfartherback.
Appointment to the Seismic Safety CommissionCrandall: IwasreappointedforanothertermontheMinesandGeologyBoardbyGovernorRonaldReagan.WhenHarrySeedresignedfromtheseatontheCaliforniaSeis-micSafetyCommissionthatwasdesignatedforsoilandfoundationengineering,nowcalledgeotechnicalengineering,Iwasappointed.Theseatisforacivilengineerspecializinginsoilsandfoundations.TheCommissionalsohasseatssetasideforageologistandaseis-mologistalongwithslotsforlocalgovernment,emergencyservices,andsoon.
Scott: HarrySeedhadoccupiedthatpostfromthetimeoftheoriginalformationoftheCommission,whenitwassetupbytheSeismicSafetyActof1975,upuntilheeitherresignedfromtheCommissionordeclinedtobereappointed.
Crandall: Yes.Iwasappointedin1982,whenEdmundG.Brown,Jr.(Jerry)wasGovernorofCalifornia.ThatwaswhenyouwerechairoftheCommission,Stan.
In additiontoattendingCommissionmeet-ings,whichIhavedoneprettyregularly,mymainparticipationinconnectionwiththe
CommissionhasbeenthroughtheStrongMotionInstrumentationAdvisoryCommittee,whichwediscussedearlier.ItookoveraschairafterBruceBoltin1984.
Scott: Fortherecord,inmyview,ofalltheCommission’scommittees,thatisbyfarthebiggestoperation,andisacontinuingopera-tion.Alltheothercommitteesaresetupandoperateforoneortwoyears,maybeforfiveyearsorso,andthengooutofexistence.
Crandall: Yes,theothercommitteeshaveanassignmenttowriteareport,orsomethinglikethat.Youarerightaboutthescopeanddura-tionofthestrongmotioncommitteework.ThebudgetofthestrongmotionprogramismanytimeswhattheCommission’sbudgetis.
Observations on the CommissionScott: Youhaveprovidedalotofbackgroundonthestrongmotionprogram.ButtellmeaboutyourgeneralobservationsandcommentsontheCommissionitself.
Crandall: Therehavebeenthreeexecu-tivedirectorsoftheCommissionthatIhaveknown.BobOlsonwasthefirst,thenDickAn-drews,andnowasof1991,TomTobin.Ihadsomeexperienceunderallthree.IthinkBobwasjustleavingorhadjustleftwhenIcameonboard,soitwouldwasmostlyDickAndrews,andTomTobin.
Scott: IthinkBobOlsonleftin1982.
Crandall: IrememberIwasappointedatthesametimethatBillIwanwas,aswellasthelovelyladywhohadapositionwiththeRedCrossandlatermovedtoWashington,Ann
Chapter 10 Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
96
Boren.Thethreeofusmetatmyoffice,attherequestofBobOlsonandDickAndrews.Theygaveusalittlebackgroundandkindofabriefingsession,andsoBobOlsonparticipatedinthat.Perhapshehadrecentlylefttheexecutivedi-rectorjobtolaunchhisconsultingcareer,buthecametothemeetingwithDickAndrewsandthetwowerekindofinatransitionalperiod.TomTobinbecameexecutivedirectoralittlelater.
Icansaythiswithoutanyreservation:IthinktheywouldhavetosearchlongandfartofindsomeonethatisbettersuitedforthisjobthanTomTobinis,believeme.Ihavegreatadmira-tionforwhathehasdone.FrommyviewpointeverythingIhaveseenofTom’sworkhasjustbeenmostcommendable.
ThebriefingsessionparticipantswerethenewCommissioners,BillIwan,AnnBoren,andI,plusBobOlsonandRichardAndrews.Wesatintheconferenceroominmyoffice.BobandDickdidthetalking.MostlyitwasBob,ex-plainingalittleofthehistoryoftheCommis-sionanditspurpose,whatitwasdoing,whatitwastryingtodo,andwhatwouldbeexpectedofusasCommissioners.Hedidagoodjobofclueingusinonthenatureofthebeast.
Idon’tknowifthebriefingsarestillbeingdoneatthistime,butitwasaworthwhilethingtohavethatkindofanintroductionbeforeweactuallygotinvolvedinCommissionbusiness.
Scott: Iwouldthinkbriefingswouldbequitevaluable,butIreallydon’tknowexactlywhatisdonenow.
Crandall: Thisdidnothappenwhenyouwereanewcommissioner?Well,youwereoneofthefirstCommissioners,inattheinceptionofit.
Scott: Yes.Iwasonattheoutset,andtherewasnobriefingthatIrecall,beyondameetingwiththeGovernor,andthenwemettogetherasagroupforthefirsttimeandtalkedaboutwhatweoughttodo.
Crandall: RegardingthequalityoftheCommission,itisamazing,thetypeofpeoplethathavebeenappointedtothisCommission,whoinmyopinionareoutstanding.Bothascitizensandasprofessionals.Theywereabletogetreallytoptalenttoserveinthiscapacity.You,forexample,whohaveservedfromthebeginning theonlyonestillserving,Ibelieve.
Scott: OftheoriginalgroupofCommis-sioners,Iamtheonlyoneleft,althoughBruceBolthasalsobeentherealongtime.HemusthavecomealongthreeorfouryearsaftertheCommissionstartedup.SoBrucehasbeenontwelveorfifteenyears,andtheremaybeanotheronewhohasbeenaroundalongtime.
Crandall: Itisagreatpublicservice,Ithink.ThatiswhyIaminterestedinit Ibelievethatthethingstheydoarejustincrediblyimportant.Iamamazedattheamountofoutput,andthequalityofthereportsandtheworkthat’sdone.Iamnotgoodattheworkshops,althoughIrealizethatthoseareveryimportantthings.WhileIhaveattendedeveryone,Ithinkmycontributionshavebeenreallylimited.
Scott: Youaretalkingabouttheannualtwo-dayorday-and-a-halfworkshop?
Crandall: Yes,wherewebrainstorm,ordiscusswhatweshouldbedoing.Idon’tseemtobecreativeinthatkindofthinking.MaybeIrepresenttheordinarycitizeninthatre-gard,whoneedstobeshown,andonceyou
97
Chapter 10LeRoy Crandall • California Seismic Safety Commission
mentsthatestablishedtheinitialmembershipoftheCommission,theregularprocessthenwentintoeffect,definingdesignatedseatsforpeoplefromvariousbackgrounds,andtherewasnoslotforme.
Oftheveryfirstgroupofappointments,halfwerebasicallychosenbySenatorAlquistonbehalfoftheJointCommittee butreallytheywereselectedbyKarlSteinbruggeandSenatorAlquistfollowedhissuggestions.TheotherhalfwerechosenonbehalfoftheGovernorbyJimSteams,theGovernor’sSecretaryofConservation.TheydidnothavetofitpreciselyinthedisciplinaryappointmentslotsthathaveappliedsincethosefirstCom-missionerswerechoseninlate1974orearly1975.Anyway,halfthefirstCommissionerswereappointedonSenator’sAlquist’sside,withKarlSteinbruggecallingtheshots,andtheotherhalfwereselectedbytheadminis-tration’sside.IwasoneoftheSteinbrugge/Alquistappointments.
Thatwashowtheinitialsetofappointmentswasmade.Butlater,whenreappointmentsorreplacementscameup,thebill’sregularlegalformulatookover.TherebeingnoseatwithqualificationsIpossessed,BobOlsonandtheCommissionchair,probablyeitherKarlStein-bruggeorBobRigneyatthattime,arrangedfortheLeagueofCaliforniaCitiestorecom-mendmyappointmentasacitygovernmentrepresentative.
Crandall: Ihavenotreallyevaluatedtheoth-ermembersoftheCommission.IknowthatIhavegreatrespectforseveral,technically.ThoseIhaveknownorknowwellinthefieldincludeBruceBolt,AlBlaylock,whowasa
seewhatthepathis,maybeyouareabletoprovidealittlelightalongtheway,asfaraspickingoutthepath.
Scott: Areyousayingthatyouplaymoreofalisteningorreactingroleintheworkshops?
Crandall: Iguess,inasense,yes.
Scott: Idon’thavethatimpression.AtleastIdon’tthinkofyouasplayingashrinkingvioletrole.
Crandall: Well,ifIgetsteppedon,Iholler.
Scott: AstoyourcommentsaboutthequalityoftheCommissioners,canIaskyoualeadingquestion?Ithasbeenmyimpres-sion,andIhavegottensimilarfeedbackfromsomeotherCommissionmembers,thatwedidnotuniversallygetthebesttalent.Ihaveheardcomplaints,particularlyduringtheJerryBrownadministration,thatsomeappointmentswerenotnecessarilythebestthestatecouldhavegotten.Doyouhavethatfeeling?
Crandall: Mycommentandknowledgehasbeenlimitedtothetechnicaltypepersonnel,likeBruceBolt,LloydCluff,BillKockleman,BillIwan.Allofthoseareoutstandingtechni-calpeople.PerhapsIshouldhavequalifiedmystatement,becauseIamnotthatfamiliarwiththeothertypeofappointees.Iknowyourwork,andIcannotthinkofanyonethatIhavehigherregardforintheworkoftheCommission.Bytheway,whatslotwereyouappointedtofill?
Scott: Surprisinglyenough,Iamrepresent-inglocalgovernment,atleasttheoretically.ThereisaninterestingstoryonthatwhichI’llsumuphere.Afterthefirstroundofappoint-
Chapter 10 Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
98
memberandthenresignedtobecomeamem-berofthestatelicensingboardforengineers.AlsoPaulFratessa—hewasastrongmember.TherewasBillWaste,frominsurance—Ididnotknowhimbefore,butBillWastewasanimpressiveguy.
Ithinkitisagood,well-balancedSeismicSafetyCommission.Youneedviewpointsandvariousperspectives,ofcourse.Iper-sonallythinkinatechnicalwaymostofthetime,butthereareotheraspectsofproblems.SomethingsIdidnotrealizeuntilIgotinvolvedintheCommission—includingthesocialimpact,suchaswiththeunreinforcedmasonrybuildingsandtheirretrofits.AsanengineerIwouldsay,“Hey,thoseoldbrickbuildingsshouldcomedown demolishtheunreinforcedmasonrystructures,getthemoutofhere.”Butthen,aswelearnedbyvisitstoChinatowninSanFranciscoandinotherways,thosebuildingshouselow-incomepeople,andwhatdoyouwiththosepeople?Maybeyoumakeitworseforthem.Oneoftheintervieweestoldus,“Thesedispossessedpeoplearegoingtodiefrompneumoniaonthestreetsfasterthantheywillfromanearth-quakecollapse.”Soyougetabroaderview.Youseethatyoucannottearthingsdownjustbecausetheyarelesssafethansomethingelse,withouthavingimpactsinotherareas.IthinkIhavebroadenedmyunderstandingandtemperedmypositions.
Inmyyearsasanengineer,mostofthetimeIthought,“Hey,engineerscansolvealltheseproblems.”Letusbuildbuildingsthatwillnotcollapse,andgetridoftheoldunreinforcedmasonrybuildingsthatwillcollapse.Thensuddenlyyoustartthinking,“Maybewecannot
dothatovernight.Thereareotherconcernsthatarealsoimportant.”
Scott: DoyouhaveotherimpressionsoftheCommissionoritsactivities,orthingsthatyouhavebeeninvolvedinorthatyouhavewatched,orthatyouthinktheCommissionoughttobeinvolvedin?
“California at Risk”: The Rippleis SpreadingCrandall: YoubringupthingsIhaveneverthoughtabout.Ontheotherhand,IthinktheCommissionisdoingmanythings.Forex-ample,takethe“CaliforniaatRisk”program.Atremendousamountofthinkingisgoingintothat.
Scott: Yes,anditisactivatingallkindsofgroupsandagenciesoutthere,maybeslowlyandgraduallyinsomecases,butneverthelessactivatingthem.
Crandall: Therippleisreallyspreadingnow,believeme.IamtalkingnowaboutthingsIamreasonablyfamiliarwith,andthiscouldbehappeninginothercommitteesanddisciplinesaswell.Forexample,thepeerreviewprocesswaspartofwhatwasdecidedwouldbeagoodthinginthestudyofthestate’sprisonconstructionprogram.Butthepeerreviewprocessnotonlywasadoptedbytheprisoncommittee,buthasalsofounditswayintootherareasoftheStateArchitect’soffice,andtheUniversitysystemhasrealizedtheimportanceofsuchreview.
OnethingthatimpressesmeisthehighregardthattheCommissionmustbegiven,thehighesteeminwhichtheCommissionisheldbythe
99
Chapter 10LeRoy Crandall • California Seismic Safety Commission
legislatureandothersinthestategovernment.TobeanadvisorygrouptothesevariousstateoperationsisaverynoteworthyrecognitionoftheCommission.
WithrespecttothepurposeoftheCommis-sionandthetalentsofitsmembership,IamcompletelyimpressedbythepeoplewhoareservingasCommissioners,andbythecompe-tenceandabilitiesofthesepeople,andtheirwillingnesstocooperate.
Scott: Whydon’twetalkmoreabouttheappointmentprocessforchoosingCommissionmembers?Whatdoyouknowabouthowyourownappointmentwasmade?IthinkinsomecasessomepotentialmembersactivelysoughtmembershipontheCommission,whereasinothercasestheyprobablydidnotadvancetheircandidaciesatall,butotherpeoplewereactiveontheirbehalf.Thereareprobablyallkindsofcombinationsandvariations.
Crandall: Iamprettynaiveaboutallofthis.I’llbedarnedifIknowforsurehowthathap-penedinmycase.TheCommission’sexecutivedirectorprobablyseeksadvicefromorganiza-tionsthatarerepresentativeofthepositioninquestion,andthoseorganizationsputforwardanameortwoaspossibleappointees.Thisprobablyhappenedinmycase,butIdon’tre-memberbeingawarethatIwasunderconsid-erationfortheassignment.
BeforeIwasappointed,ofcourse,IwasaskedifIwouldaccept,andIthinkImighthaveansweredaquestionnaireandwasinformedabouttheethicsandtheconflict-of-interestmattersthatareimportantinsuchapublicposition.ButmyguessisthatBobOlsonorpossiblyDickAndrewsdidalittlesolicitation
forsuggestions,probablyfromtheAmericanSocietyofCivilEngineers.Thestructuralengineersmayalsohavebeenasked,andtheConsultingEngineersAssociationofCali-fornia,andalsotheGeotechnicalEngineersAssociation.Mynameprobablygotproposedthatway,butIamnotsure.MaybesomebodyalreadyontheCommissionwasawareofmybackgroundtothepointthatmynamewassubmitted.
Scott: ThesuggestionswereprobablythensenttotheGovernor’sappointmentsecretary.ThatwasduringtheJerryBrownadministra-tion,wasitnot?JerryBrownhadthereputa-tionofbeingslowonappointments.
Crandall: Ithinkhedidnotbelieveincom-missions,andasaresultdidnotpayattention.Thatwasaterriblethingforthestategovern-ment,Ithink.Manyoftheboardsandcom-missionscouldnotfunctionwithoutaquorum,andifhedidnotappointsomebody,maybeaquorumdidnotexist.
Inanyevent,IguessIwasappointedfirstbyGovernorJerryBrownandreappointedbyGovernorReagan.Idon’tknowexactlyhowitworked,butofcoursebeforeyouareactuallyappointedyoumustsubmitfinancialdisclosureinformation,andbeawareofconflict-of-inter-estregulationsandmattersofthatsort.Iwasneverquestionedaboutmypartyaffiliationorpoliticalviews.
Scott: YoucansayinJerryBrown’sfavorthatwhenhefinallygotaroundtoappointingsomebody,apparentlyhedidnotletthedeci-sionbeinfluencedalotbypoliticalregistra-tion,atleastinmycase.
Chapter 10 Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
100
Crandall: Somebodydidagoodjobingettingacross-sectionofbothtechnicalandsocialconcernsontheCommission.Itisverywell-balanced.BarbaraRiordan,thecurrent
chairperson,forexample,isacountygovern-mentrepresentative,andyourepresentcitygovernment.
Chapter 11
Concluding Words in 2000
101
…while the computer can do many things, it
must have reliable data with which to work.
Such data are now available from strong
motion records…
Scott: It’sbeenafewyearssincewerecordedourinter-viewsbackin1991.Thisisachancetobringthestoryuptodate,asofearly2000.Whatwouldyouliketoaddtocompletetheinterviewseries?
Crandall: First,letmesayIgreatlyappreciatethetimeandeffortthatyouhaveputintothis,Stan.IhaveseenthefinalproductforseveralofyourotheroralhistorypublicationsintheEERIConnections series,andtheyareindeedsuperb.Ijusthopethatthisonewilldevelopatleastpartoftheinterestthattheothershavegenerated.
Ithinkitwouldbeworthreviewingsomeoftheimpor-tantseismiceventsthathaveoccurredsincewelastspokein1991.ProbablythemaineventwastheNorthridge,CaliforniaearthquakeinJanuaryof1994.Ibelievethatmoreusefulrecordswereobtainedofgroundmotionandbuildingbehaviorfromthatearthquakethaneverbefore.
Chapter 11 Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
102
TheinstrumentsoperatedbySMIP—thestate’sStrongMotionInstrumentationProgram—andalsothoseinstalledbyotheragencies,providedthekindofinformationforwhichstructuralen-gineershavelongyearned.Ifeelmorethaneverthatthestrongmotionprogramwillcontinuetoprovidegreatbenefitstothepublicinthebetterunderstandingoftheperformanceofourbuild-ingsunderearthquakeconditions.Notonlywillthebuildingsbesafer,butalsowewillbeabletodesignfortheactualforcesinamoreeco-nomicalmanner.ThoseresultshavebeenverygratifyingtothoseofuswhoworkedformanyyearstoseethestateestablishacomprehensiveStrongMotionInstrumentationProgram.Ihavenot,however,beendirectlyinvolvedintheSMIPNorthridgeearthquakedatautilization,asmymembershipontheSMIPAdvisoryCom-mitteeterminatedshortlybeforetheNorthridgeearthquake,whenmyserviceontheSeismicSafetyCommissionendedin1993.
Scott: YouhadbeenassociatedwiththeSMIPprogramsince1972,andyoualsoservedontheCommissionatotalof11years.Thosepioneeringeffortshavecertainlypaidoffinusefulresultsthathaveservedtheprofessionverywell.Whatothercommentswouldyouliketomakeaboutsomeofthemainseismicdevelopmentssinceourlastinterview?
Crandall: YouandItalkedadecadeagoabouthowtheadventofthecomputerhasprovideddesignengineerswithaverystrongtool,anopinionthathasbeenmorethanjustifiedbysubsequentdevelopments.Computerusageandprogramshavefarexceededwhatappearedtobeonthehorizonbackatthetimeofourlastinter-view.Again,however,whilethecomputercandomanythings,itmusthavereliabledatawith
whichtowork.Suchdataarenowavailablefromstrongmotionrecordsthatshowthedetailedbehaviorpatternsofvarioustypesofstructures.Giventhestructuralbehaviorasrecordedbythestrongmotioninstruments,thecomputercannowbeusedtoperformincrediblydetailedanal-ysesofsuchbehavior.Thisisdefinitelyleadingtomuchbetterdesign,andimprovedconstruc-tiontechniquesforfuturebuildingperformanceunderearthquakeconditions.
Injustmyownfieldofgeotechnicalengineer-ing,thepotentialforpredictingthegroundmotionconditionsatindividualsiteshasbeengreatlyenhanced.TheanticipatedearthquakeintheParkfieldareahasfailedtooccur,pre-ventingusfromobtainingresultsoftheseveralexperimentsprogrammedforthatexpectedearthquake.Withluck,valuableinformationmaystillbedevelopedwhenandiftheParkfieldeventdoestakeplace.Irealizeitmaysoundalittlestrangetoappeartobehopingforanearthquaketooccur.Wehadgreatexpectations,however,forthekindsofinformationthatthevariousParkfieldtestinstallationswillprovidewheneverthenextearthquakedoesoccur.Nev-ertheless,asIsuggestedabove,thedatawedidgetfromactualstructuresinstrumentedintheSMIPhavebeenverybeneficial.
Scott: BobWallacediscussedtheParkfieldearthquakepredictionexperimentinhisEERIoralhistory,publishedinlate1999.17Accord-ingtoBob,muchhasbeenlearnedfromthatexperimentaleffort,despitetheearthquake’s
17. Connections: The EERI Oral History Series — Robert E. Wallace,StanleyScott,interviewer.EarthquakeEngineeringResearchInstitute,Oakland,CA,1999.
103
Chapter 11LeRoy Crandall • Concluding Words in 2000
failuretohappen.Butofcourse,themostim-portantkindsofthingsstructuralandgeotech-nicalengineershopedtolearnaboutdodependonearthquakeshaking,whichhasnotoccurred.
Sincewelastspoke,anumberofmajorearth-quakeshaveoccurredindifferentareas,amongtherecentonesbeingthe1999earthquakesinTurkeyandinTaiwan.Doyouhaveanycom-mentsonthose?
Crandall: Ihavenotbeentoocloselyin-volvedinthosemajorrecentearthquakes.Theycertainlyweredevastatingintheareaswheretheyoccurred.FromwhatIhavereadinreportsbytheinvestigatorsfromtheUnitedStateswhovisitedthosesites,muchofthedestructionwasduetothenatureofthestructuresinvolved.Thatkindofstructuraldestructionissimilartowhatwehaveobservedinothercountrieswheretheconstructionmethodsused,especiallyintheolderbuildings,donotprovidemuchearth-quakeresistance.Still,theteamsthatvisitedthesesiteslearnedusefulinformationthatwillbeapplicabletosomeoftheconditionsinourownarea.Also,whathasbeenlearnedfromtheliquefactionandgrounddisplacementthatoccurredduringthoseearthquakesisapplicabletoallareashavingsimilarcharacteristics.Asaresult,thegeotechnicalinvestigatorswereabletoobtainimportantinformationthatwillbedirectlyapplicabletositesinCalifornia.
Scott: Talkalittleaboutwhathashappenedtoyoupersonallyintheyearssincewelasttalked.
Crandall: Whenwelastspokein1991IwasanemployeeofLaw/Crandall.Youwillrecallthatthecompanyincreasedthescopeofitsservicestoincludeenvironmentaland
constructionmaterialsservices,amongotherfeatures.Asaresult,itseemeddesirabletochangetheoriginalcompanynamefromLe-RoyCrandallandAssociatestoLaw/Crandall.Thistookplacein1991.
Ihavefunctionedindependentlyofthemaincompanysince1987.Mydirectofficewasconcernedentirelywithforensicmatters,spe-cializinginconstructiondefectlitigation.OnJanuary1,1999,IretiredfromLaw/CrandallandformedanewcompanycalledCrandallConsultants,Inc.Underthatdesignation,Iamstilloperatingasaforensicconsultantingeo-technicalengineering.Myactivitiesarealmostcompletelyconcernedwithlitigation,withverylittleinvolvementinthedesignaspectsofgeotechnicalengineering.
MyoneregretisthatIhavebeensotiedupinthebusinessactivitiesthatIhavebeenunabletoattendandbeactiveintheprofessionalsocietiestothedegreethatIhavebeeninthepast.Istillmaintainmembershipinallofthem,butitisdifficulttofindtimetoattendthemeetingsandconventions.Theprincipaldrawbackinthelitigationfieldisone’sin-abilitytomaintainadefiniteschedule.Ifacasegoestotrial,theexpertsareexpectedtobeavailabletomeetthecourtrequirements.Also,arbitrationandmediationsessionsareobligatory,andareoftenscheduledatthelastminute.Asaresult,itishardtoplanforat-tendingprofessionalmeetingsandengaginginrelatedactivities.
Istillfindtheworkveryinteresting,somuchsothatIstillputinatleastfortyhoursaweek.MyoneconcessiontogettingolderisthatInowtrytoavoidworkingonSaturdaysandSundays.
Photographs
105
Graduation from San Diego High School, California, 1935.
Photos Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
106
LeRoy Crandall (left) and his brother Clifford with their grandfather, Jefferson L. Crandall, 1922.
LeRoy Crandall, with fiancée Eileen Exnicios, at Crandall’s graduation from the University of California at Berkeley, 1941.
107
PhotosLeRoy Crandall
Crandall at the office of LeRoy Crandall and Associates at 1619 Beverly Boulevard in Los Angeles, California, 1955.
Eileen and LeRoy attend a costume party for the Structural Engineers Association of California, 1959.
Photos Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
108
Partial excavation for a high-rise being built
in downtown Los Angeles, California.
LeRoy Crandall and Associates did
the geotechnical engineering, 1965.
Disneyland was one of the first geotechnical engineering projects the new firm of LeRoy Crandall and Associates undertook, 1954.
109
PhotosLeRoy Crandall
The aerial tramway at Palm Springs, for which LeRoy Crandall and Associates provided the geotechnical engineering, 1961.
The tie-back shoring system (partial depth) for the Century City Theme Towers, which was the deepest excavation ever attempted at that time, 1970.
The San Bernardino County Foothill Communities Law and Justice Center, Rancho Cucamonga. This was the first building in the United States to use base isolation. LeRoy Crandall and Associates provided the ground motion design criteria, 1987.
Photos Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
110
Elected to honorary membership in the
American Society of Civil Engineers, 1984.
LeRoy Crandall and Associates moved their office to Glendale, California in 1986.
111
PhotosLeRoy Crandall
Crandall in his office at 711 North Alvarado Street in Los Angeles. LeRoy Crandall and Associates commissioned the building and maintained their headquarters office there from 1966 -1986 (photo circa 1984).
Aerial view of downtown Los Angeles, California. LeRoy Crandall and Associates was the geotechnical engineering firm for all but two of the high-rise buildings (photo by Marshall Lew).
Photos Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
112
Left: Eileen and LeRoy on a cruise in 2000.
Above: Eileen and LeRoy at the Taj Mahal, 1993.
113
PhotosLeRoy Crandall
Marshall Lew and LeRoy Crandall, January 2008.
115
IndexLeRoy Crandall
AAccelerographs, 49–50
Airfields and airport facilities, 16–17
Allen, Clarence R., 81, 94
Alquist, Alfred E., 53, 58, 94–95, 97
Alquist-Priolo Special Studies Zones Act of 1972, 94–95
American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE), 53, 79, 99
award from, 7
Crandall member of board of directors of, 79
Andrews, Richard, 95, 99
Asphaltic sands, La Brea Tar Pit, Los Angeles, California, 46
Attenuation of strong ground motion, 61
BBanville, Joe, 11
Barnes, Fred, 23, 26, 29, 30
Barnes, Steve, 85, 87
Base isolation, 68–70
bridges, 69
San Bernardino County Foothill Communities Law and Justice Center, Rancho Cucamonga, California, 68, 109
University of Southern California Hospital, Los Angeles, California, 69
Bay Area Rapid Transit (BART), 81
Beanfield, Rufus M., 87
Bearing ratio tests of airfield pavings, 16
Beerman, Paul, 7
Bentonite clay, 35, 44
Blaylock, Al, 97
Blume, John A., 49, 50, 53, 86
Bolt, Bruce A., 57–58, 95, 96, 97
Boren, Ann, 96
Bowen, Oliver G., 85, 87
Brandow and Johnston, engineers, 87
Brewer, William (Bill), 7, 9, 12, 16
Bridges
base isolation of, 69
Caltrans, 59–60
Golden Gate Bridge, 59
lifelines, 81
San Francisco-Oakland Bay Bridge, 59
Vincent Thomas Bridge, Los Angeles, California, 59
Brown, Jr., Edmund G. (Jerry), xiv, 95, 99
Brown, Glenn A., xiii, 30
Brown, Glenn A. and Associates, merger with Crandall firm, 30
Brugger, Walter, 55
Buildings, modeling of, 85
Butts, Wendell, 87
CC.F. Braun & Co., 20
California at Risk program, 98
California Division of Mines and Geology (CDMG), 54, 71, 82, 94–95
Crandall board member of, 95
California Office of Statewide Health Planning and Development, 61
California Seismic Safety Commission (CSSC), 54, 60, 68, 86, 93–99
California at Risk program, 98
Crandall member of, 56–59, 93–99, 102
Index Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
116
Scott member of, 56–59, 97
Caltrans (California Department of Transportation)
Crandall early employment at, 13–14
SMIP, inclusion of under, 59–61
Strong Motion Instrumentation Advisory Committee (SMIAC), 56, 60, 95
Casagrande, Arthur, 90
Century City Theme Towers, Century City, California, 109
Chamber of Commerce, U.S., Crandall member of, 26
Chi-Chi, Taiwan earthquake (1999), 103
Chieruzzi, Robert, xiii
Chiu, Seymour, xiii, 29, 30
City of Los Angeles, California
building code, dynamic analysis requirements, 66
building instrumentation ordinance, 50–51, 54
City Hall, 87
County Courts building, 87
Department of Building and Safety, 55
grading ordinance (1952), 33–34
Hall of Administration, 87
leadership in instrumentation of buildings, 51–56
leadership in soil engineering requirements and building codes for hillsides, 32–33, 44
Music Center, 75
Cloud, William K., 51
Cluff, Lloyd S., 97
Coastal facilities, 21, 24, 26
Coast and Geodetic Survey, U.S., 49, 87
Computers, influence of on engineering, 71–73, 74, 77, 79, 102
Contamination, environmental, 45–47
Converse, Fred, 89, 91
County of Los Angeles, California
grading ordinance (1952), 34
Crandall, Eileen Exnicios, 13, 15, 26, 106, 107
Crandall, Jefferson L. (grandfather), 106
Crandall, LeRoy
ASCE member of board of directors of, 79
awards, 110
California Seismic Safety Commission (CSSC), member of, 56–59, 93–99, 102
college education
Fresno State University, California, surveying class, 7
San Diego State University, California, 5–7
University of California at Berkeley, 9–12
Crandall and Associates. See Crandall, LeRoy and Associates
Crandall Consultants, Inc, 103
Dames and Moore, 14, 15–24
established own firm, 24, 25–30
expert witness, 103
National Youth Administration (NYA), employment by in UC soil mechanics lab, 10
Crandall, LeRoy and Associates, 24, 25–30
base isolation. See Base isolation
engineering geologists, in-house, 30
headquarters offices, design and construction of, 28–30
117
IndexLeRoy Crandall
highrise buildings, 108, 111
incorporation, 28–30
Law Engineering, acquisition by, 29–30
merger with Glenn A. Brown and Associates, 30
name changed to Law/Crandall, 103
Crandall Consultants, Inc, 103
Cross, Hardy, 88
Cross, Hardy, Moment Distribution Method, 88
Cupp, Miss, 2
Cut and fill techniques, 33–34, 39
DDames, Trent, 17–18, 19–20, 22–24, 88, 89
Dames and Moore
airfields and airport facilities, 16–17
career with, 14, 15–24
partnership, 22–24
separation from, 24
World War II, impact of on workload, 16
Dams
criteria for as more stringent, 95
damage to in 1971 San Fernando, California earthquake, 52
Davis, Harmer E., 10–12
Davis, Raymond E., 11
Degenkolb, Henry J., 49, 58, 70
DeLine, Ralph A., 87
Derrick, Clarence, 83
Disneyland, 108
Division of the Safety of Dams, California Department of Water Resources. See California Division of Mines and Geology (CDMG)
Doughty, Rex, 2
Douglas Aircraft, Dames &Moore work for, 17
Downhole arrays, 64, 75
Duke, C. Martin, 29, 52, 53, 75, 79–80, 87
Dynamic analysis, 66, 71–75
EEarthquake Engineering Research Institute
(EERI), 52, 87
Earthquake faults
Alquist-Priolo Act, 94–95
length of relative to potential magnitude, 77
New Madrid, Arkansas, 68
New Madrid, Missouri, 68
Newport-Inglewood, 65, 77, 81
Overland, California, 77
Raymond, California, 77
Rose Canyon, California, 68
San Andreas, California, 65, 77, 82, 94
Santa Monica-Hollywood, California, 77
Earthquakes
Chi-Chi, Taiwan (1999), 103
El Centro, California (1940), 49, 62
El Centro, California (1979), 61
focus, depth of, 77
ground motion. See Strong ground motion
Loma Prieta, California (1989), 48, 59, 81
Long Beach, California (1933), 60
maximum probable, 76
New Madrid, Arkansas (1811), 68
New Madrid, Missouri (1812), 68
Northridge, California (1994), 102
Index Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
118
prediction of, 65–66, 82, 102
rupture length, 77
San Fernando, California (1971), 50–53, 60
seismic return period, 67
seismic waves, subsurface, 81
total energy, 78
Turkey (1999), 103
Whittier Narrows, California (1987), 61
El Centro, California earthquake (1940), 49, 62
El Centro, California earthquake (1979), 61
Embankment failure, 52–53
Engineering Geologists Qualifications Board, 40–42
Engineering judgment, importance of, 71–73
Erick, Murray, 85, 87
Excavations, 37, 108, 109
FFalk, Mark, 87
Foundation engineering, 18, 31, 42, 73
base isolation, 68–70
basements, 63
design, 66
liquefaction, designed to resist, 48
loads, 71
residential buildings, 53
tieback anchor, development of, 37–38
Fratessa, Paul F., 98
GGasoline storage tanks, leaking of into
groundwater, 45–47
Gates, James, 59
Geology
different from soil engineering, 39
engineering geologists, 40–43, 94
Geotechnical Earthquake Engineering and Soil Dynamics, International Conference on Recent Advances in, 67, 71
Geotechnical engineering
computers, influence of on, 71–73, 74, 77, 79, 102
dynamic analysis, 66–68
engineering geologists, 40–43, 94
instrumentation. See Instrumentation
liability, long-term, 91
maximum probable earthquake, estimate of, 76–77
multi-lot solutions to soil problems, 43–44
naming of the profession, 30, 42
prediction of ground motion at a specific site, 65–66, 82, 102
seismic waves, subsurface, 81
shear wave velocity, 74–75
testing. See Geotechnical testing
Geotechnical testing, 10–11, 22, 40, 73–75, 89–90
contributions of older engineers, 83–90
Giersch, Louise, 58
Gleason, John, 6
Golden Gate Bridge, 59, 60
Grading problems, 32–34
City of Los Angeles hillside ordinance, 32–34
Portuguese Bend, Palos Verdes, California, 44
119
IndexLeRoy Crandall
Ground failure, 44, 47
dam embankment, 52
erosion, 32
landslides, 32, 43, 44, 47
liquefaction, 47, 71, 81, 103
Portuguese Bend, Palos Verdes, California, 44
settlement, 47–48, 71
slopes, 33–35, 44
Ground motion. See Strong ground motion
Groundwater contamination, 45–47
monitoring wells, 46
HHardy Cross Moment Distribution Method,
88
Harmon, Thomas, 10
Henderson, Mary, 58, 59
Highways as lifelines, 81
Hillside development. See Grading problems
Hirschfeldt, Leopold, 23, 26, 28, 29, 30
Hospitals
SMIP, included under, 59–61
University of Southern California, 69
Housel, William (Bill), 17
Housner, George W., 58, 77, 86
Hyperion sewer outfall, 21, 24, 26
IInstitute of Governmental Studies, U.C.
Berkeley, 26
Instrumentation
accelerographs, 49, 50
bridges, 60
downhole arrays, 64, 75
early days of, 49
free-field, 61, 64, 82
geophone, 75
Golden Gate Bridge, 60
Lotung Array, 61
Parkfield, California array, 82
shake tables, 73–74
SMART-1 Array, 61
Strong Motion Instrumentation Advisory Committee (SMIAC), 56, 95
tie-back anchors, 63
Instrumentation of buildings, 50–56, 61
practical limit to, 56
privacy of records questions, 55
unique structures as unsuitable for, 60
Insurance liability, 91
Iwan, Wilfred D. (Bill), 95, 96, 97
JJahns, Richard, 40, 94
Jeffers, Paul E., 85, 87
Johnston, Roy G., 58, 87
Jones, Jerve, 58
KKelly, James, 70
Kirkgard, James, xiii, 29
Kockleman, William, 97
Index Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
120
LLabarre, Robert V. (Cap), 89, 90, 91
Labarre and Converse, engineering consultants, 89
La Brea Tar Pit, Los Angeles, California, 46
Landslides, 32, 43, 44–47
Law/Crandall, 103
Law and Justice Center project, 70
Law Engineering, acquisition of Crandall firm, 29
Lebarre, Robert V. (Cap), 89
Lee, Kenneth, 52
Leps, Thomas, 11
Lew, Marshall, 113
Liability, long-term, 91
Lifeline engineering, 79–82
Lipow, Joseph, 37
Liquefaction, 47, 71, 81, 103
Litigation, tract housing, 35–36
Lockheed Aircraft, Dames &Moore work for, 17
Loma Prieta, California earthquake (1989), 48, 59, 81
Cypress Viaduct, collapse of, 59, 81
Long Beach, California earthquake (1933), 60
Los Angeles, California. See City of Los Angeles, California
Luckenbach, Ralph, 13
MMaley, R.P., 51
Maljian, Perry, xiii, 29
Martel, Romeo R. (R.R.), 87–88
Martin, Albert C., 87
Matthiesen, R.B. (Fritz), 87
McLean, Ralph S., 49
McWee, James, xiii, 29
Mellema, William, 87
Mendenhall, Irvan, 7, 27
Microzonation, 47
Microzonation maps, 71
Montgomery, James M., 25
Moore, William W., 13–14, 19–20, 22–24, 87, 89
Murphy, Leonard, 52
NNational Oceanographic and Atmospheric
Association (NOAA), 52
National Science Foundation (NSF), 81
National Youth Administration (NYA), 10
Newport-Inglewood fault, 65, 77, 81
Noerenberg, Clarence E., 87
Noice, Blaine, 87
North American Aviation, Dames and Moore work for, 17
North Outfall Replacement Sewer (NORS), 81
Northridge, California earthquake (1994), 102
OOakeshott, Gordon, 54
Offshore projects, 21
drilled friction piles, 21–22
Hyperion sewer outfall, 24, 26
Olson, Robert A., 95, 97, 99
Overland, California fault, 77
121
IndexLeRoy Crandall
PPalm Springs, California tramway, 109
Parkfield, California, strong motion array, 65, 82, 102
Piles, drilled friction, development of, 21–22
Pipelines, 47, 81–82
Portuguese Bend, Palos Verdes, California, 44–47
Priolo, Paul, 94–95
Property lines, adjustment of for ground movement, 44
RRaymond, California fault, 77
Raymond Concrete Pile Company, Chicago, Illinois, 18
Reagan, Ronald, xiv, 94, 95, 99
Refineries, 21
Registration and certification of engineering geologists, 40–42
Response spectra, 71–73, 76, 79
Return period, 67
Richter scale, 78
Rigney, Robert, 58, 68, 97
Riordan, Barbara, 100
Rose Canyon, California fault, 68
SSan Andreas, California fault, 65, 77, 94
San Bernardino County Foothill Communities Law and Justice Center, Rancho Cucamonga, California, 68, 109
San Fernando, California earthquake (1971), 60
dams, damage to, 52
Lower San Fernando Dam, 52
strong motion records from, 50–53
San Francisco-Oakland Bay Bridge, 59
Santa Monica-Hollywood fault, 77
Scott, Stanley, 26
California Seismic Safety Commission (CSSC), member of, 56–57, 93, 97
Seed, H. Bolton (Harry), 52, 57–59, 95
Seismic Safety Act of 1975, 95
Seismic zoning maps, 71
Seismographs, 50
Settlement. See Ground failure
Shakal, Anthony F., 58, 82
Shake tables, 73–74
Shear wave velocity, 74
Slosson, James, 30, 40
Smoots, Al, 24
Soil-structure interaction, 64
base isolation, 68–70
experiments, early, 83–86
Soil contamination, 45–47
Soil engineering, 31–38, 39–47, 62–63, 89. See also Geotechnical engineering
airfields and airport facilities, 16–17
City of Los Angeles, leadership in requiring, 32–34
computers, influence of on, 71–73
contaminated soil, 45–47
drainage, 33–35
dynamic analysis, 66, 74
embankment failure, 52
excavations, 37
expansive soils, 36
Index Connections: The EERI Oral History Series
122
geology, different from, 39
grading. See Grading problems
ground failure. See Ground failure
landslides, 32, 43, 44–47
liability, long-term, 91
litigation, 35
multi-lot solutions to soil problems, 43
Portuguese Bend, Palos Verdes, California, 44–47
saving clients money, 32, 36, 63, 66
slope failure, 33–36, 44
tie-back anchor, development of, 37
Soil mechanics, 18–19, 90
contribution of older engineers, 83–90
landslides, 32, 43, 44–47
soil conditions, effect of on subsurface seismic waves, 65
UC graduate course in, 10
Steams, James, 97
Steinbrugge, Karl, 52, 53, 97
Strong ground motion, 42, 47, 50–56
attenuation of, 61
calculation of in design of buildings, 62–63
characteristics of, 61, 76
CSSC Strong Motion Instrumentation Advisory Committee, Crandall member of, 56, 61
cycles, 78–79
free-field, 64
instrumentation. See Instrumentation
miner’s anecdotal reports of, 65
Parkfield, California array, 102
period, natural, 75
prediction of at specific site, 65, 82, 102
records
El Centro, California (1940), 42, 49, 62
San Fernando, California (1971), 51
response spectra, 71–72, 76, 79
seismic return period, 67
seismic waves, subsurface, 50, 74
shake tables, 73–74
shear wave velocity, 74
site-specific, 71
SMIP. See Strong Motion Instrumentation Program (SMIP)
subsurface, 61, 65
total energy, 78–79
Strong Motion Instrumentation Advisory Committee (SMIAC), 56, 60, 61, 95
Strong Motion Instrumentation Program (SMIP), 50–56, 82, 102
Caltrans included under, 59–61
funding of, 58
hospitals included under, 59–61
practical limit to number of instruments, 56
public schools, 60
schools included under, 59–61
Structural engineering. See also Foundation engineering
base isolation, 68–70
basements, 63
computers, influence of on, 71–73, 79, 102
design of buildings, 62–63
dynamic analysis, 66
Structural Engineers Association of Southern California (SEAOSC), 87, 88
123
IndexLeRoy Crandall
TTarics, Alex, 70
Technical Council on Lifeline Earthquake Engineering (TCLEE), 53, 79–82
Terzaghi, Karl, 90
Tie-back anchors, 109
development of for shoring, 37
instrumentation of, 63
Tobin, L. Thomas, 95
Tobriner, Stephen (California Supreme Court Justice), 86
Tract housing, soil problems with, 35–36, 44
Turkey earthquake (1999), 103
UU.S. Chamber of Commerce, Crandall
member of, 26
U.S. Coast and Geodetic Survey, 51
U.S. Coast and Geodetic Survey, U.S., 87
U.S. Geological Survey (USGS), 58, 65, 71, 87
Uniform Building Code (UBC), 70
University of California at Berkeley, 9–12
Davis Hall, 11
soil mechanics lab, 10
University of Southern California Hospital, Los Angeles, California, 69
Vvan Beveren, James, xiii
WWallace, Robert, 102
Warren, Donald R., 91
Wastewater, treatment of, 46
Webb-Lipow tieback system, 38
Weber, Russell, 27, 29, 30
Whinier, Eldon (Whit), 11
Whittier Narrows, California earthquake (1987), 61
Wilson, David, 86
World War II
bearing ratio tests, 16
Crandall prevented from enlisting during, 17–18
impact of on work at Dames and Moore, 16–19
postwar surge in construction, 20–21