32

edges - University of Wisconsin–Madisonpages.cs.wisc.edu/~dyer/ai-qual/huttenlocher-edges95.pdfN cv t T|RUT Y\M _ac ]Qc N _QN NlRsNltlRvY\OaM|]QM cZRsN XvN OaV cvYfc y T N=V XUO&t

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    0

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

Page 1: edges - University of Wisconsin–Madisonpages.cs.wisc.edu/~dyer/ai-qual/huttenlocher-edges95.pdfN cv t T|RUT Y\M _ac ]Qc N _QN NlRsNltlRvY\OaM|]QM cZRsN XvN OaV cvYfc y T N=V XUO&t

���������� ���������������������������������� "!#�$�%��!&�(')'+*

���������������-,.�����$���

/1032�4 5 47684:9;6=<?>-@

A B >:C B 4EDF4HGJI <�K=<�>-@

L7MN-OQPSRUTNWVXZY\[�]QXZ^`_aOa]�b\cHOQPEdebfOhgib\NkjaNlb$m�jnY\cZY\OQMoY\cpRUOqNkr&RsXU]QtlRu_QN�Oa[uNlRUXvYftwYfM�PxOaXU[�]�RvY\OQMoPxXUOa[Yf[F]�_aN�cly=z)Ohg{bfNljQNlb�jnY\cZY\OQM|OaV}N�XU]�RUYfOaMc~YfMtkb\���N�cv�t�T|RUT�Y\M�_ac�]Qc�N��_QN���NlRsNltlRvY\OaM|]QM��cZRsN�XvN�OaV�cvYfc�y� TN=VXUO&t�NlcUc�O�P%N��_QN��NkRsN�tkRUYfOaMHYfc�RUO Yf�N�M�RvYfP�^:bfO#t�]�RUYfOaMc�Y\MH]QM�Yf[�]Q_aN8g�TN�XvN=RsT�N=Yf[F]�_aN�YfM�RsNlMcvY�R�^�$� XvYf_aT�RsMNlcUck��t�T]QM_aNlc��n��Y\t���b�^}�&YfMpOQRUTN�X�g�OaXv�c��aRUO �%M��HRsTN=Y\M�RsNlMcvY�R�^ � Oa�M��%]QXvYfN�c"Y\MHRUTN=Yf[�]Q_aN�y� TN VXUO&t�NlcUc�O�P�cvRUN�XvN�OaVcZY\c=Y\c8RsO�cv^&M�RsTNlcvYf��N:]��N�V�RUTw[�]QV�PxXUOa[�R�g=OHOaX�[uOaXUN�YfMnRUN�McZYfR�^�Yf[F]�_aN�cl�YfM�O�RsTNlX�g=OaXv�c���RUO��NlRUN�Xv[uYfMN�RsTN���YfcvRs]QMtlN�RUO�O ��� N�tkRsc�_QY�jaNlM{[H�#bfRvY\V�bfN�Y\M�RUN�McZYfR�^�Yf[F]�_aN�cly� �_aN.�NlRUN�tkRUYfOaM�RUT&��c|XvN�t�OhjQN�XUc|Y\M�PxOQXU[�]�RUYfOaM�] � Oa��R�RsTN�R�g=O� ��#Y\[uN�M�cvYfOaM%]�b�_aN�OQ[�NkRsXZ^�OQPHRUTNYf[F]�_aNQ�)]�M��cvRUN�XUNlOaVcZY\c:XUNlt�OhjaNlXUcEYfM�PxOaXU[�]�RvY\OQM�] � OQ��R7RsT�NHRsTXvN�N¡ ���Yf[uN�McZY\OaM]�b8_aN�OQ[�NkRsXZ^qOQP�RUTNcUtlN�MN�y8¢�M � OQRsT�t?]QcvN�cl�#g=N�]QXvN N¡r&RsXs]�tlRUYfM_�Y\M�PxOQXU[�]�RUYfOaMF] � Oa��R8RsTN;_aNlOa[uNlRsXZ^�OQP+RUTN;g=OaXZb\��PxXUOa[YfMnRUN�McZYfR�^�Yf[�]Q_aN�c�OQP�RsT�N:g=OaXZb\���£_aNkRURvY\M_E¤¡¥s¦�§©¨�§�ª?«#¬�­E®�¦�«#¬�¦�§w¬k®�¥k¯�y

� TNSY\[�]Q_QN�c�PxXUOa[°[uOacvR�cvN�McZY\M_��Nkj&Yft�Nlc�]�XUNS�n�%]QM�RUYf��Nl� � OQRsT±cvV%]�RvY²]�b�b�^u]QM�±YfMuRUN�Xv[�c8OQP£RUTNj�]�bf�N�c�]�R:N?]�t�T3bfO#t�]�RUYfOaM�Y\M.cUV]Qt�N�yw³%OaXEN¡r]�[�V#b\N���]qd´V�TOQRsOQ_aXs]QV�T�m�R�]Q��N�M � ^.]WjnYf�N�O|t?]Q[uNlXs]]QM�|RsTNlM���Y\_�YfRvY\�lN�� � ^q]�t�Oa[uV�#RsN�X�t�OaMcZY\cZRscEOQP�]wcUNkREOQP�V�Yµr#Nlbfc � ��YfcUtlXUNkRsNHbfO#t�]�RUYfOaMc¡���}gSYfRUT�]QMYfMnRUN�McZYfR�^Fj�]�b\��NE]�R=N?]Qt�TWV�Yµr#Nlb$y � TN�cvN7Y\M�RsNlMcvY�RUYfN�c�]�b\cvOHR�]Q��N7OaM-�#Y\cvt�XUNkRsN�j�]�bf�Nlc�Y\MWcvOa[uN�XU]QM_aN��_aNlMN�XU]�bfb�^3¶� Z·Q¸a¸#y�¹�Oa[u[uOaM`jnYf�N�O|Y\[�]Q_aNlcp]QXvNFO�P�]QVVXvO?r#Yf[�]�RsNkbf^o¸Q¶a¶Wºo¸Q¶a¶|V#Y�r#Nlbfc�y � T�Yfc�YfcNkr&RUXUN�[uNkbf^»b\Ohg¼XvN�cvOQb\�#RUYfOaMqt�OQ[�V]QXUNl�½RsOuRsTN�Tn�[�]QMqNk^aNQ�¾OaXSRsOF[F]�Mn^»OQRUTN�X;cUNlMcUOQXUc � cU�t�Tq]QccUt�]QMMNlXUcp��cUN��3PxOaXEY\MV���RURvY\M_½�O#tl�[uN�M�Rscl��g�T�Yft�ToT%]?jaNFXUNlcUOQbf��RUYfOaMcHOQP � NlR�g=N�NlM�¿a¶a¶»]QM�oÀQ¶a¶V�Yµr#Nlbfc±V¾NlXHY\M�t�T¾��y�³%OaX�Y\McZR�]QM�t�NQ��Y�PS^aOa��TO�b\�`^QOa�X±T%]�M��]�Ru]�XU[ucHbfN�M_QRUT�]QM�`bfO&Oa�`]�RH^aOQ�XRsTn�[ � M%]�Y�b$��RUTN»XUN�cvOQbf��RUYfOaMÁOQP ^aOa��XFPxOhjaN�]`OhjaN�X�RsT�Yfcwcv[�]�bfb ]QXvN?]�Y\cw] � OQ��RuRsTN|cs]Q[uNq]�c�RUTNXUNlcUOQbf��RvY\OaM»OQP�]ujnYf�N�O�t?]�[�NlXs]�y

 NpgSY�b�b�t�OaM�cvYf�N�X�]-Mn�[ � N�X:OQP���Y�þN�XUNlM�R�cvN�McZY\M�_»��NljnY\tlN�cl��]�b�RsT�Oa�_aT�Oa�X g�OaXv�|gSY�bfb�PxO#tl�cVXZY\[�]QXZYfb�^�OaM�jnYfcU�%]�b� ÄXs]QM_QN cvN�McZY\M_±��NljnY\tlN�c � t?]Q[uNlXs]Qc¡��y�Ž]QM�^uOQP+RsTNlcUN�O�RsTNlX=��YfM�c�O�P�cUNlMcUOQXUc]�bfcUOEVXvO#���t�N7de_aXUNk^HbfNljQNlb$maY\[�]Q_aNlc���YfMug�T#Y\t�T±RsT�NSV�Y�r#Nkb\c�R�]��QNSOaM�]7Xs]�M_aN~OQP}��YfcUtlXUNkRsNSj�]�b\��N�c�y�³£OQXYfMcvRs]QMt�N���RUTN�XvN=]�XUN8cUNlMcUOaXvc�g�T#Y\t�T�[�N�]QcU��XUN8RsTN8��YfcvRs]QMt�N8RsOSRUTN8tlbfOacUNlcvR"O ��� N�tkR�ÆE]Ede�N�V�RUT�[�]QV+m� N�ye_�yf���cvYfM_±RUYf[�N�OQP�XUNlÇN�tlRvY\OQM�YfM�PxOaXv[�]�RUYfOaM¾�sy � TN�cvN�cvN�McvOaXUc�XvNlRs��XUM�]QM�]QXvXs]?^-O�P�V�Y�r#Nkb\cSg�TNlXUNRsT�NHj�]�b\��Nu]�R7N�]Qt�T�V�Y�r#Nkb�Y\M���Y\t�]�RsNlc:��Y\cZR�]QM�t�NQ�)XU]�RsT�N�X�RUT%]QMqYfMnRUN�McZYfR�^QypÅ»OacvR:OQP�RUTNpRsNlt�TM�Yf�n�N�cRsT]�R�g=N~��YfcUtl�cUc�YfMHRsT#Y\c�cvN�tkRUYfOaM±OQPRUTN~t�OQ�XUcvNS]QVV�b�^�N��n�%]�b�bf^�g=Nlb�b�RsO�cU�t�T±MOQM# ÄjnYfcU�%]�b�cUV}N�tkRsXU��[cUNlMcvYfM_F�NljnYft�N�clyÈvɾÊlË�ÌhÍ�δÏlÐ�Ñ�ÒÓÕÔvÖlÖl×ÙØQÔUÖkÖlÚÙØaÔvÖlÖlÛ�Ü�ÝkÞ Îeßvàná"âhÑ$Ñ�ß Þ àeÊ Ò ÐhßUÍ

ã

Page 2: edges - University of Wisconsin–Madisonpages.cs.wisc.edu/~dyer/ai-qual/huttenlocher-edges95.pdfN cv t T|RUT Y\M _ac ]Qc N _QN NlRsNltlRvY\OaM|]QM cZRsN XvN OaV cvYfc y T N=V XUO&t

� / 0.2F4 5 47684:9�6�<�>W@

 N�t?]�MwNkr#VXvN�cvc�]QMFYf�N?]�bfYf��Nl�W_aO�]�b}OQP�RUTN�Nl�_aN �NlRUN�tlRvY\OQM-VXUO&t�NlcUc���RsOpVXvO#���t�N�]�b�Y\MN �Xs]?gSYfM_OQP=]-cUtlN�MN±PxXvOa[ ]�M�Yf[�]Q_aNpO�P�RUT%]�REcvt�NlMNQyp¢�M�Y�Rsc�Yf�N�]�bfYf�?]�RUYfOaM���TOhg�NkjaNlX��)RsT�YfcE_aO�]�b�Yfc:]-_aXUOacvcOhjaNlXUcvYf[uV�b�Yf�%t�]�RUYfOaM�]QcEg=N�gSY�b�b=cvN�N�[uOa[uN�M�R�]QXZYfb�^ayWL � cUN�XZjaN�RsT%]�R���YfM._aN�MNlXs]�b$��RsTN � OQ�M�%]QXZY\NlcOQP�O ��� NltlRUc�YfM»]±cUt�NlMNERsNlM�»RUO±VXUO&��tlN7Y\M�RUN�McZYfR�^ � Oa�M�]QXvYfN�cSYfM|]�M�Yf[�]Q_aNEOQP�RUT%]�RScvt�N�M�NQy=³£OQXNkr�]Q[uV�bfNQ����YfþN�XvN�M�RpO ��� N�tkRscp]�XUN��cU�%]�bfb�^.��YfþN�XvN�M�RptlOQbfOaXUc�OaX�T&��N�c��"g�T�Y\t�T`VXUO&��tlN�c�YfM�RsNlMcvY�R�^t�T%]QM�_aN�c�YfMpRsTN~Yf[�]Q_aNQy�¢�Mu]Q���Y�RUYfOaM�����Y�þN�XUNlM�R=cv�XvP�]�t�N�c�O�P+]�M±O ��� N�tkR�XUN�tlNlY�jaN���Y�Ã+NlXUNlMnR=]Q[uOa��MnRUcOQP%b�Y\_QTnR��ag�T�Yft�TF]�_�]�YfMpVXUO&��tlN�c�YfM�RsN�M�cvY�R�^pt�T%]QM�_aN�cly � T&��c�_aN�Oa[uNkRsXvYft�YfM�PxOaXv[F]�RUYfOaM���]Qc�[uYf_aT�R � Nt�OQMnjQNl^QN��±Y\MH]�b�YfMN��XU]?gSY\M_���Yfc"NlMt�O&�N���Y\M�RsTN8Y\M�RUN�McZYfR�^�t�T%]QM_QN�c"YfMp]�M�Yf[F]�_aNQy�� M�PxOaXZRs�M]�RsNkbf^Q�RsT�N�XUN»]QXvN�]�bfcUO3]�b\]QXv_aNWMn�[ � N�XuOQP;Y\M�RUN�McZYfR�^(t�T%]QM�_aN�c±RsT]�R�]QXUN��+¦�®~���NWRsO�_aN�OQ[�NkRsXZ^a��cU�t�T]Qc-cv�XvP�]�t�N�[�]QXU��YfM_acl�;RUNkr&Rs�XvNQ��]QM��cUV}N�tl��b\]QX-XUNkÇ%N�tkRUYfOaMcly Å|OaXvN�OhjaNlX-RsTNlXUN�]QXvN½cvOa[uNlRUYf[uN�ccU��XvP�]QtlN � Oa��M�%]QXZY\Nlc-RsT%]�R-�O�MOQRWV�XUO&��t�N|jaN�XZ^�cvRUXUOaM�_oY\M�RsNlMcvY�R�^�t�T%]�M_aN�cly � TNlXUNkPxOaXUNqRUTNYfMnRUN�McZYfR�^ � Oa�M��%]QXv^�Y\M#PxOaXU[�]�RvY\OaMpRUT%]�R�g=N�Nkr&RsXU]QtlR�PxXvOa[1]QMpY\[�]Q_QN~gSYfb�bRsNlM�±RsO7YfM��Yft?]�RUN�O ��� N�tkR� Oa�M�%]�XvYfN�c�� � �#R�MOQR ]�b�g~]?^&c�y�¢�M|cvOa[uN:cUt�NlMN�c;YfRSgSY�b�b � NERsXv��bf^W]hgSPx�#b�y

³"Yf_a�XUN ã ]�Y\c8]�MpY\[�]Q_aN�OQP¾]�cvYf[uV�b\N�cvt�N�M�NQ�&]QM�u³"Yf_a�XvN ã � cvTOhg�c8RUTNSOa��RUV��R�O�P}]7V%]QXvRvY\tl��b\]QXN���_aN7�NkRsN�tkRsOaXSOQM-RsT%]�R�cUtlN�MN�y  N7t?]�MWcUN�N7RUT%]�R~PxOQX=RsT#Y\c�Yf[�]Q_aN7RUTN7N���_aN7�NkRsN�tkRsOaXSV�XUO&��t�Nlc�]XUNkb²]�RUY�jaNlb�^±_aO&O&�wdeb�YfMNS�Xs]?gSYfM_maO�P}RUTN~cvt�N�M�NQy�� Ohg=NljQN�X��&cs]?^�g�NSt�T%]�M_aN~RsT�N~bfYf_aT�RUYfM_Et�OQM��Y�RUYfOaMcYfM�RUT�Yfc~cUtlN�MN��¾]�c�Yfb�bf�cvRUXs]�RUN���Y\M�³"Yf_a�XvN:·Q]�y�;Ohg�RUTNEN��_QNE�NlRUN�tlRUOaXSVXvO#���t�N�c�]�MWOa��RsV���RSRsT%]�RYfc�cU� � cZR�]QM�RvY²]�b�b�^pb\NlcUc�b�Y\��N;]�bfYfMNS�XU]hgSYfM_�n]�c�cUTOhg�MuY\Mu³�Y\_a��XUN�· � y�L7�X��%XvcvR�bfN�cvcUOaMuY\c"RsTn�c�RsT%]�RY�bfbf�[±Y\M]�RUYfOaM�t�OQM��Y�RUYfOaMcE[�]Q�QNu]FT&��_aN±��Y�Ã+NlXUN�M�t�NpYfMqRsTNHYfM�PxOaXv[�]�RUYfOaM½RUT%]�R:]QM½N��_aN±��NlRsNltlRUOaXNkr&RUXs]QtkRsc�PxXUOa[Õ]QM»Yf[�]Q_aN�y

 T�Y�b\NW]�XvRUYfcvRUcH�O|�cUNwcUT%]Q��OÙg YfM�PxOaXv[�]�RUYfOaM3YfMoVXvO#���tlYfM_½b�Y\M�Nw�XU]hgSYfM_acl��RsTNk^.cUOa[uN�T�OÙgYfM��Yft?]�RUN:g�T#Y\t�T|N��_aNlc;]QXUNE���N:RUOucUT%]Q��OÙg�c � PxOQX~Nkr�]Q[uV�bfN � ^W[�]Q��YfM_ � b\��XUXv^FbfYfMNlc;PxOaX�cUT%]Q��OÙgN���_aN�c¡��y=Å|OaXvN�OhjaNlX��}]QM»]QXvRvY\cZRSRsNlM�cSRsOu�XU]hg�N���_aN�c;t�OaXvXUNlcUV}OaM��YfM_±RsOuO ��� NltlR � Oa�M�%]�XvYfN�cSRsT%]�R]QXvN;RUOQR�]�b�b�^FT#Y\���N�MwYfM-cUT]Q�Ohg:y � TN7]Q�#RsOa[�]�RvY\t�]�bfb�^�_aN�M�N�Xs]�RsN��wN��_aNlc�YfM-³"Yf_a�XvNE· � [uYfcUc=[�]QM�^O ��� NltlRENl�_aNlc�RsT%]�RE]QXvNHT�Yf��NlMqY\M½RUTNpcvT%]Q�Ohg�c��+cU�t�T.]Qc;RsTN � OQRvRsOa[©PxXvOaM�R7t�OQXUMNlX�OQP8N�]Qt�T�OQPRsT�N � b\O&t��nc XvN�cvRvY\M�_FOaM�RsT�N:Rs] � bfNQy

NlPxOQXUN-tlOaMcvYf�NlXvYfM_�cUOa[uN-Nl�_aN-��NlRsNltlRvY\OaM�[uNkRsTO&�c���g=N � XZY\NkÇ^ocv�[u[�]QXvYf��NwRUTN-_aOa]�b\c�OQPRsT�N�cUN [uNlRsT�O#�c=]QM�FcUOa[uN;OQP+RUTN;��Y���tl��bfRvY\Nlc�gSY�RsTFRUTN�[�y � TN;VXZY\[�]QXZ^u_aO�]�b£OQP+N��_QN �NkRsNltlRUYfOaMYfc~RsOuNkr&RsXU]QtlR�YfM�PxOaXv[F]�RUYfOaM�] � Oa��RSRsT�N7R�g�O� Ä��Yf[�NlMcvYfOaM%]�b"V�XUO � NltlRUYfOaM�OQP"cUtlN�MN:_aNlOa[uNlRsXZ^-PxOaX~��cUNYfMWT�Y\_QTN�X�bfNljQNlb�VXvO#tlN�cvcvYfM_�cv�t�T½]�c~XUNlt�Oa_aM#YfRvY\OaM+��M%]?jnY\_a]�RUYfOaM��%]�M�WT%]QM�� �Nl^QN7R�]Qcv�&cly�� Ohg�NkjaNlX��RsT�N�XUNw]QXUN�[�]QM�^�R�^#V}N�cHOQPSVT�^&cvYft?]�b�NljQN�M�Rsc � Y\M3RsTNFcUt�NlMN���RsT%]�RHt�]Q�cUNFY\M�RsNlMcvY�R�^3t�T%]QM_aNlc � OQXN���_aN�c�Y\MWRUTNEY\[�]Q_aNÙ��y=L7M�b�^WcUOa[uN�OQP�RsTNlcUN�VT�^#cZY\t�]�b�NljQN�M�Rsc�]QXUN:_aNlOa[uNlRsXZY\t��

� O �#� N�tlR � Oa�M�]QXv^FÆw��YfcUtlOaM�RUYfMn��YfR�^»YfM|�NlV�RsT|]QM�� �OaXScU��XvP�]QtlN�tlOQb\OQX�]QM��RsNkr&RU�XUN

� cv�XvP�]QtlN � Oa��M�%]QXZ^FÆW�#Y\cvt�OaM�RUYfMn��Y�R�^»YfM»cU�XZP�]Qt�N:OaXZY\NlMnRs]�RUYfOaM|]QM�� �OaXSt�OQbfOaX;]QM�WRUNkr&Rs�XvN

� O&t�tkb\�cZY\OQM � Oa�M�]QXv^FÆ-��YfcUtlOaM�RUYfM&�#YfR�^�YfM|�NlV�RsT|]QM�»OaXScv�XvP�]QtlN�tlOQbfOaX�]QM��RsN¡r#RU�XUNOQRUTN�XvcS�O±MOQRS�#Y\XvN�tlRvbf^wXUNkÇ%N�tkR�_aN�Oa[uNkRsXv^ � RUTOa�_aT-g=N:[�]h^ � N:] � bfN�RsO±�NlXvY�jaN:cUOQ[�NE_QN�Oa[uNlRUXvYftYfM�PxOaXU[�]�RvY\OQM�PxXvOa[ÕRUTN�[��£]�RSbfN?]QcZR�Y\M�#Y\XvN�tlRvbf^%���

� cvV¾Nlt���b\]QXvY�R�^�� ��YfXUNltlR XUNlÇN�tlRvY\OQM|OQP"bfYf_aT�R?�%cv�t�Tq]�c�]�[±YfXUXUOQX

·

Page 3: edges - University of Wisconsin–Madisonpages.cs.wisc.edu/~dyer/ai-qual/huttenlocher-edges95.pdfN cv t T|RUT Y\M _ac ]Qc N _QN NlRsNltlRvY\OaM|]QM cZRsN XvN OaV cvYfc y T N=V XUO&t

³"Yf_a�XUN ã ����M�Y\[�]Q_aN:OQP�]±cvYf[uV�b\N�cUtlN�MNH]QM�WYfMnRUN�McZYfR�^»Nl�_aN�c;Nkr&RUXs]QtkRsN��»PxXUOa[ RsT%]�RSY\[�]Q_aN�y

¿

Page 4: edges - University of Wisconsin–Madisonpages.cs.wisc.edu/~dyer/ai-qual/huttenlocher-edges95.pdfN cv t T|RUT Y\M _ac ]Qc N _QN NlRsNltlRvY\OaM|]QM cZRsN XvN OaV cvYfc y T N=V XUO&t

³"Yf_a�XvNp· � � b\NlcUc�_QO#O&�»Yf[�]Q_aN�OQP�RUTNHcZY\[uV�bfNHcvt�NlMNp]QM��|YfMnRUN�McZYfR�^|N���_aN�c Nkr&RsXU]QtlRUN��½PxXvOa[ RsT%]�RYf[F]�_aNQy

Page 5: edges - University of Wisconsin–Madisonpages.cs.wisc.edu/~dyer/ai-qual/huttenlocher-edges95.pdfN cv t T|RUT Y\M _ac ]Qc N _QN NlRsNltlRvY\OaM|]QM cZRsN XvN OaV cvYfc y T N=V XUO&t

� cvT%]Q�Ohg�c~ÆwPxXvOa[ OQRUTN�XSO ��� N�tkRsc��£OaX�V%]�XvR�OQP�RsTN:cU]Q[uN�O ��� N�tkR

� YfM�RsN�XvXUNkÇ%N�tkRUYfOaMc

� cv�XvP�]QtlN:[F]�XU��Y\M�_ac��%RsN¡r&Rs�XvNQ�£t�OQbfOaXSt�T%]�M_aN�c OQRUN±RsT%]�R:[��t�T`O�P=RUTN±g�OaXv�qY\M�RsT�Nu�Nlbf�3OQP=t�OQ[�V���RsNlX�_QXs]QVT#Y\tlc�Yfc:t�OaMtlN�XvMN��.gSYfRUT.RUTN

YfMnjQN�XvcUN�OQP�RsTNEVXvO � bfN�[ ��N�cUtlXvY � Nl�|T�N�XUN � _�YfjQN�M�RsTNE_aNlOa[uNlRUXv^-O�P�]±cvt�N�M�NQ�%XUNlM�NlX ]pXvN?]�b�YfcvRUYftbfO#Oa��YfM_FYf[�]Q_aN�y;¢�M|b\Ohg¼bfNljaNkb"jnYfcvYfOaMqg=Np]QXvN�_QY�jaNlM�]QM|Yf[�]Q_aN�OQP�]�cUt�NlMNQ��]QM�|gSYfcUTqRUOwXvN�t�OhjQN�XRsT�NF_aNlOa[uNlRUXv^ay � M�PxOaXZRs�M]�RsNkbf^Q�"RsT�N�Yf[�]Q_aN�t�OaM�R�]�Y\Mc�cUO»[�]QM�^3��YfM�c�OQP�YfM�PxOaXv[F]�RUYfOaM���RsT%]�R:Y�RYfc�t�OQMcvYf�N�XU] � b�^½T]QXU�NlX;RUOw_aNkR RUTNH_QN�Oa[uNlRUXv^�PxXUOQ[ÕRsTN�Y\[�]Q_QN�RUT%]QM½Y�R Yfc�RsOwXvN�M��N�X7]�M|Yf[F]�_aN_QY�jaNlM|RsT�N�_QN�Oa[uNlRUXv^ � MOQRSRUT%]�R�RsTN:_aXU]QVT�Yft�c�VXvO � bfN�[ Yfc�N?]QcZ^WNlY�RsTNlX�� ��y����� ��� �������������������� �!���#"¢�MoRsT#Y\c±cvN�tlRvY\OQM�g=N-gSY�bfb=b\O&Oa�3]�RpcvOa[uN-b\O&t?]�b�OaV}N�Xs]�RsOaXvc�PxOaXHYf�NlMnRvYfP�^nYfM_�N��_QN�c���]QM���t�OaMcZY\��N�XcUOQ[�N;OQP¾RsTNkY\X8bfYf[±YfRs]�RUYfOaMcly � TXvOa�_aTOQ��R=RUT�Yfc=cvN�tlRvY\OQM � ]�M�w[��t�T-OQP}RsTN;t�OQ�XUcvN;YfMw_aNlMN�XU]�bx�"g=NgSY�bfb¾XUNkPxN�X8RsOp]�MFYf[F]�_aN7]Qc%$ �'&)(+* ����g�T�Yft�TW�NlMOQRsNlc=YfM�RsN�M�cvY�R�^W]Qc=]�Px�M�tlRUYfOaM-O�P)cUOa[uN � ]QX � YfRUXs]QXZ^%�t�O&OaXv��Y\M]�RsNqcZ^&cvRsNl[�y°¢�M�OQXU�NlXFRsOoYf�NlMnRvYfP�^ N���_aN�cl�;g=N�]QXUN»Y\M�RUN�XUNlcvRUN���Y\MÁ�%M���Y\M�_�XUN�_�Y\OaM�c-OQPRsT�NFYf[F]�_aNFg�TNlXUN-RUTN�XvNFYfcHXs]�V�Y\��t�T]QM_aN�Y\M`RUTNwj�]�bf�N�c�OQP�$ �'&)(+* ��y � Tn�cpg=N-t�OQMcvYf�N�X�b\O&t?]�b��Y�Ã+NlXUNlMnRvY²]�b"V�XUOaV}N�XZRUYfN�c�cU�t�T½]QcSRsTN�«a¥vª-,Q¨�¬ �%®�OQP�RsT�N:Yf[�]Q_aNEYfMnRUN�McZYfR�^Q�

. $0/2143 $3 & ( 3 $3 *6587� T�Yfc�Yfcp]�jaN�tkRsOaX�jQ]�b\�Nl�o�n�%]QM�RUY�R�^�g�T�Yft�T�t?]QM � NuRsTOa��_aT�RpOQP~YfM�Rs��Y�RUY�jaNkbf^o]Qc�V¾OQYfM�RUYfM_½YfM3RUTN��YfXUNltlRUYfOaM»OQP�decvRUN�NlV¾NlcvR �N�cvt�N�M�R�m+]�R�N�]Qt�T�b\O&t?]�RvY\OQM �9&)(+* � � OaX;]�b�RsNlXUM%]�RvYfjQNlb�^�cvRUN�N�V}N�cZR7]�cUt�NlM�Rl��y

� TN:[�]Q_aM�Y�Rs���N�O�P"RUTNE_aXs]���Y\NlM�RSjaN�tkRsOaX�XvNlÇ%NltlRsc;TOhg XU]QV�Yf��b�^wRsT#Y\M_Qc ]�XUNEt�T%]QM�_QY\M�_�YfMWRsT�Yfc��YfXUNltlRUYfOaM-O�P�cvRUN�NlV¾NlcvRS�NlcUtlN�M�R?y ��tkRs�%]�bfb�^ug�N �cU�%]�bfb�^��cUN;RsTN;cU�n�%]QXvN��-_QXs]Q��YfN�M�R=[�]Q_aM�Y�Rs���NQ�#RUO]?jaOQYf��t�Oa[uV��RvY\M�_:RUTNScU�n�%]�XUN�XUO&OQR � [�OQXUN�OhjQN�X�g�N�OQP�RUN�MucvbfOaVV#Yfb�^±XUNkPxN�X�RUO:RUTNScU�n�%]�XUN���_aXU]Q��YfN�M�R[�]Q_aM�Y�Rs���N�]QcSRsTN:_aXU]Q��YfN�M�R;[F]�_aM�Y�Rs��NÙ���

: . $ :<; / 1 3 $3 & 5 ;4= 1 3 $3 * 5 ; 7>&Yf[uV�bfYfcvRvY\t�]�b�bf^»cUV}N?]��nYfM_�£g�TNlXUN:RsTN�cU�n�%]QXvN��|_aXs]Q�#Y\NlMnR [�]Q_aM�Y�Rs���N�Yfc�b²]QXv_aNQ�RUTN�XvN�Yfc ]QM|Nl�_aN�y� T%]�R Y\cl�¾RUTN�Yf[�]Q_aN�YfM�RsNlMcvY�R�^½Yfc7t�T%]QM�_QY\M�_-�n��Y\t���b�^�]QM��½RsTn�c�RUT�Yfc YfcE] � Oa�M�]QXv^Q�+OaX;N��_QNQ�¾YfMYfMnRUN�McZYfR�^QySL�P"t�Oa�XvcUN��RsT�Yfc � Nl_acSRsTN:�n�N�cZRUYfOaM»OQP"g�T]�R�Y\c;]-deb\]QXv_aNEt�T%]QM_QNQm�y  NEgSYfb�b�XUNkRs�XvM»RUORsT#Y\cSYfcUcU��N � NlbfOhg � ]QM��»M�NljaNlX XvN?]�b�b�^W�%M�|]QM»]QMcvg=N�X�RsT]�R�Y\cSRsO�R�]�b�bf^wcs]�RvY\cZP�]QtlRUOaXv^%�sy

L7MNuM�Y\tlNuVXUOaV}N�XZR�^�OQP�RsTNu_aXU]Q��YfN�M�R�[�]Q_aM�Y�Rs���NuYfcERsT%]�REYfREYfc:XUOQRs]�RUYfOaM%]�b�b�^qcv^&[u[uNlRUXvYftQ��OQX¨\­h¦�®�¥�¦@?}¨BAky � T�Yfc»[uN�]QMcWRsT%]�R-YfRWYfc-YfMcUNlMcvY�RUY�jaN.RsO�RsTN�OQXvYfN�M�R�]�RvY\OQM�O�P�RUTN�_aXs]���Y\NlM�RWjaN�tkRsOaXl�g�T�Yft�T»YfcSOQP�RUN�MW�NlcvYfXs] � bfNQy�¢�MWOQRUTN�X~g=OaXU��c��£]QMWNl�_aN7Yfc�]QMWN��_QN7Y\c�]QMWNl�_aN ÆFXvN�_�]QXv��bfN�cUc�OQP�RUTNOaXZY\NlMnRs]�RUYfOaMuOQP}RsT%]�R8N��_aNSgSY�RsTuXUNlcUV}N�tkR=RUO7RsTN � ]�X � Y�RsXU]QXv^%��¹~]QXZRsN�cZY²]�MFtlO#OaXv��YfM%]�RsNScZ^&cvRsNl[�y � g=ObfN�cUc��NlcvYfXs] � bfN;VXUOaV}N�XZRUYfN�c8OQP}RsTN�_aXU]Q��YfN�M�R�[�]Q_aM�Y�Rs���N�]QXvN~RsT%]�R�YfR8Yfc=] �+¦ �DC ¨ �+¬UªQ¥�OaV}N�Xs]�RsOaXl�n]QM�Y�R�bfOacvN�c:Y\M�PxOQXU[�]�RUYfOaM3] � Oa��R:g�T�Yft�TocvYf�N�OQPS]QM.N���_aN±Y\c � XvYf_aT�RsNlX � ��NuRsOWRsT�NFcv�&�]QXvYfM_|g�T#Y\t�T

¸

Page 6: edges - University of Wisconsin–Madisonpages.cs.wisc.edu/~dyer/ai-qual/huttenlocher-edges95.pdfN cv t T|RUT Y\M _ac ]Qc N _QN NlRsNltlRvY\OaM|]QM cZRsN XvN OaV cvYfc y T N=V XUO&t

bfOacUNlc�cvYf_aMHYfM�PxOaXv[F]�RUYfOaM¾��y � TN�deVXUO � b\Nl[�m�gSY�RsTpMOQM�bfYfMN�]QX�OaV}N�XU]�RsOQXUc"Yfc"RUT%]�R"Y\Mp_QN�MNlXs]�b&g�N��OaM�m R�M��N�XUcZR�]QM��|RsT�NlYfX � NlT%]?j&YfOaX;]QcSg=Nlb�b�]Qc~PxOaX~b�Y\MN�]QX�cv^&cvRUN�[uc�y  T�Y�b\N�]±t�Oa[uV�bfNlRUN:�M�NlXUcvRs]QM��YfM_OQP�cvYf_aM%]�b�VXvO#tlN�cvcvYfM_W]QM��b�Y\MN�]QX�cUT�Y�P�Rv �Y\M�j�]QXZY²]QM�R cv^&cvRUN�[uc�Yfc � Nk^aOaM�»RsTN�cUtlOaV}N�OQP"RsT�Yfc�t�Oa��XUcUN��g=N3gSY�bfb:RsOQ�t�T{OaM�cUOa[uN.OQPHRUTN�Y\cvcU�Nlc � Nkb\Ohg ��� Nlt?]Q��cUN3gSY�RsT�Oa��R»RsTNl[ ^QOa�{t�]QMMO�R½XvN?]�b�bf^�M��N�XUcZR�]QM��½N���_aN:�NlRUN�tlRUOaXUc¡��y

��MO�RsTNlX�bfO&t?]�b���Y�þN�XUNlM�RUY\]�b�OaV}N�Xs]�RsOaX~YfcSRsTN�z�]QV�b\]QtlY\]QM»OQP6$ �9&)(+* ���. ; $�/ 3 ; $3 & ; = 3 ; $3 * ; (

� T�Yfc:cUN�tlOaM�.�N�XZYfj�]�RvYfjQNuOaV¾NlXs]�RUOaX�YfcEXUOQRs]�RUYfOaM%]�bfb�^½cZ^&[�[uNkRsXvYftF]QM�.]�bfcUO�VXUNlcUNlXvjaNlc�RUTNw­k¨µ« ��OQP� XZY\_aT�RUMN�cvc~��Y�Ã+NlXUN�M�t�NE]QtlXUOacvc~]QMFN��_QNQy � TN ��N�XvOpt�XvOacUcZY\M�_ac � cvYf_aM-t�T%]QM�_aN�c¡��OQP . ; $±t�OaXvXUNlcUV}OaM�RsO�Y\M�RUN�McZYfR�^�Nl�_aNlc�Y\M|RsTN�Y\[�]Q_aN���]QM��½RsTN�cvYf_aM½YfM��Yft?]�RUN�c�g�T#Y\t�T�cvYf�NpO�P8]QMqNl�_aN�Yfc � XZY\_QTnRUN�Xly� TNSz�]QV#b²]QtkY²]�MpY\c�RUTN�bfOhg�NlcvR8OaXv�N�X�b�YfMN?]QX�t�Oa[ � Y\M]�RUYfOaMuOQP£V%]QXZRUY\]�b#�N�XZYfj�]�RvYfjQN�c�RsT]�R�Yfc�Y\cvOQRsXvOaV�Yft� XvOQR�]�RUYfOaM%]�b�bf^qcv^&[u[�NkRsXZY\tÙ��y���N�t�]�bfb�RUT%]�R�XUO�R�]�RvY\OaM]�b8cv^&[u[uNlRsXZ^�Y\c:_aNlMN�XU]�bfb�^�jnY\Nkg�Nl��]Qc:�N�cZY\X  ] � bfNQ��OQRsT�N�XvgSYfcUN�Oa�X�Nl�_aN=�NlRUN�tlRUOaX"Yfc�[uOaXvN=cvN�McZYfRvYfjQNSRsO�cvOa[uN�Nl�_aN�c�RsT%]�MpOQRsT�N�XUcly�z�]�RUN�X�OaM���g=NgSY�bfb+cUN�N RsT%]�R=RsTN j&YfcU�]�b�cZ^#cZRsNl[�c�OQP�Tn�[�]QM�cS]QM�WOQRUTN�X�]QM�Yf[�]�b\c�cUN�Nl[ RUOpT%]?jaN � OQRUTwY\cvOQRsXvOaV�Yft]QM�»MOaM& ÄYfcUOQRUXUOaV�YftE�b�RsN�Xvc�y

��������� ���������������������������¢�Mq[�]Qt�T�YfMNpjnYfcvYfOaMqg�NH�OwMO�R7T%]?jaNHt�OaM�RUYfMn�Oa�c7Yf[�]Q_aN�Px�MtlRvY\OQMc�$ �'&)(+* �=RsT%]�R;g=Npt?]QM��#YfþN�X  N�M�RvY²]�RUN YfMwOaXv�N�X8RsO�t�Oa[uV�#RsN��n�%]�MnRvYfRvY\Nlc~cU��t�TW]Qc8RsTN _aXs]Q�#Y\NlMnR=[�]Q_aM�Y�Rs���N7]QM��FRsT�N�z�]QV�b\]QtkY²]QM+y��M�Yf[F]�_aN�Yfc;��Y\_�YfRvY\�lN�� � OQRUT»YfM|cvV%]QtlNH]QM��|YfM»YfM�RsN�M�cvY�R�^a�+V�XUO&��tlYfM_F]QM|]QXUXU]h^ $�� ("!$# OQP=deYfM�RsNlM# cvY�R�^»jQ]�b\�Nlc�m�y � TN�cvNHYfMnRUN�McZYfRvY\Nlc�]QXUN�_aN�MNlXs]�b�b�^|YfM�RsN�_QN�XUc7YfMqcvOa[uNpXs]QM�_aNQ�+]QM�½RUTNlYfX7[�]Q_aM�Y�Rs���N�cv�%]�b�bf^�XvNlÇ%NltlRsc�RsT�N � XvYf_aT�RsMNlcUc�b\NkjaNlb � ¶pYfc��%]QXU��N�cZR7]QM��»RUTN:[F]Ùr#Yf[H��[ jQ]�b\�NEYfc � XvYf_aT�RsNlcvRl�sy

� Tn�c~Y\MWOQXU�NlX�RsOptlOa[uV��RUN7b\O&t?]�b¾��Y�Ã+NlXUNlMnRvY²]�b)OaV}N�Xs]�RsOaXvc��#g=N7�cvN7�%M�Y�RsN7�#YfþN�XvN�MtlN:]QVVXvOhr&Yµ [�]�RUYfOaMc�RsOpNlcvRvY\[�]�RUN�RsTN �N�XZYfj�]�RvYfjQN�cly�³%OaX�Nkr�]Q[uV�bfNQ��PxOQX~]��#Y\cvt�XUNkRsNEOaM�Nk ��#Y\[uN�M�cvYfOaM%]�b+cs]Q[uV�bfN��Px�MtkRUYfOaM��%XvN�VXvN�cUNlM�RsN��q]Qc;]ucvN��n�NlMt�NpO�P"j�]�bf�N�c � cU�t�T½]Qc;]QM»]QXUXU]h^%�&%�� # �g�N:�nMOhg RsT]�R

'(%' &*) %��

=ã #,+ %�� #B(

]QM�' ; %' & ; ) %�� + ã #-+ ·.%�� #

=%��

=ã # 7

� Tn�c�g=N7t?]�MW]QVVXvO?r#Yf[�]�RsN;RsTN�cU�n�%]QXvN��W_aXU]Q��YfN�M�R~[�]Q_aM#YfRU��N : . $ : ; / � 3 $�/ 3 & � ; = � 3 $�/ 3 * � ;]�R~RUTN7tlN�M�RsNlX;O�P�]u·�º»·H_aXvYf�WOQP�V�Yµr#Nlbfc ]�c�PxOQb�b\Ohg�c�y=¹�OaM�cvYf�N�X~RUTN�·�º|·H��YfcUtlXUNlRUN�]QXUXU]h^Q� $�� ("!$# �b\] � NkbfbfN��|]Qc��

� �%� � = ã ���� � �=ã � = ã �� = ã

O�RsN�RsT%]�RWg�N.t�OaM�cvYf�N�X�RsTN0 Q  ]Ùr#YfcWRsO � N�YfMtlXUN?]�cvYfM_(RUO(RUTN�XvYf_aT�R?��]QM��RsTN !  �]�r&Y\cWRsO � NYfMt�XvN?]QcZY\M_F�Ohg�M�g~]QXv�c�y

À

Page 7: edges - University of Wisconsin–Madisonpages.cs.wisc.edu/~dyer/ai-qual/huttenlocher-edges95.pdfN cv t T|RUT Y\M _ac ]Qc N _QN NlRsNltlRvY\OaM|]QM cZRsN XvN OaV cvYfc y T N=V XUO&t

� Y\XvN�tkRUb�^pN�cZRUYf[�]�RUYfM_7RsT�NS_aXs]Q�#Y\NlMnR��cvYfM_7RsT�N��%M�Y�RsNS��Y�þN�XUNlMt�N�]�VVXUO?r&Yf[F]�RUYfOaMucUTOhg�M�] � OÙjQNT%]Qc�RsTN=�M�NlcvYfXs] � b\N~NkÃ+NltlR�OQP%t?]��cvYfM_�RUTN�TOQXvYf��OaM�R�]�b]QM���jaNlXvRvY\t�]�b�NlXvY�j�]�RUY�jaNlc�RsO � N�N�cvRvY\[�]�RUN��]�R"��Y�Ã+NlXUN�M�R�V¾OQYfM�Rscly � Tn�c"g=N�NlcvRvY\[�]�RUN=RsT�N��NlXvY�jQ]�RUY�jaN�c��cvYfM_7]Ùr�Nlc"RUT%]�R�]QXUN�XUOQRs]�RsNl� � ¸S�Nl_aXUNlN�c��� /a·n��y � TNEjQ]�b\�NEO�P�RUTNEV%]QXZRUY\]�b+�XUcvR���N�XvY�j�]�RUY�jaNlc�]�R~RsTNEtlN�M�RsNlX�OQP�RsTN�·Hº½·H_aXvYf� � g�T�N�XUNERUTN_aXZY\��bfYfMNlc;tlXUOacvck�~]QXUNE_�YfjQN�M � ^Q�

3 $3��& ) $�� = ã ("! = ã #,+ $�� ("!(#B(]QM� 3 $3��*�) $�� ("! = ã #-+ $�� = ã ( !$# 7>#O±RsT�N�cv�n�%]QXUNl�½_aXU]Q��YfN�M�R;[�]Q_aM�Y�Rs���N�Yfc

1 3 $3 & 5 ; = 1 3 $3 * 5 ; ) � $�� = ã ("! = ã #,+ $�� ("!(# � ; = � $�� ( ! = ã #-+ $�� = ã ("!$# � ; 7 � ã �

O�RsNqRsT]�R-RsT#Y\cWtlOa[uV��R�]�RUYfOaM ­��&¨ ¤¡®x­q®��%¬-«a¥¡¨',Qy � TNlcUN.Nkr#VXvN�cUcZY\OQMc|_�YfjQN�]��M�YfRUN���Y�Ã+NlXUN�M�t�N]QVV�XUO?r&Y\[�]�RvY\OaM�RsO±RUTNEjQ]�b\�N:OQP�RsT�N�_QXs]Q��YfN�M�R��£]QM�WYfRUc�cU�n�%]QXvN��½[�]Q_QM�YfRU��N��PxOaX�]±_aXvYf�»RUT%]�RSYfct�NlM�RsN�XvN���]�R�RUTN � Oa�M�]QXvYfN�c � NkR�g�NlN�MqRsT�N�tlNlb�b\c OQP $�� ( !$# �£XU]�RsTNlX;RUT%]QM|OaM|RUTN�tlNlb�b\c�OQP $�� ("!$# y³%OaX�[F]�Mn^ ]QV�V�bfYft?]�RUYfOaMcFY�R�Y\c��%MN|RUO3Yf_aMOaXvN|RUT�Y\cFcU[�]�b�b � Y²]Qcl�S]QM� RsO`cZY\[uV�b�^ t�Oa[uV��RUN|RUTN_aXU]Q��YfN�M�R;[F]�_aM�Y�Rs��N:�cZY\M�_wN��n�%]�RUYfOaM � ã ��y

OhgJg=N;t?]QM±g�XvY�RsN ]EcvYf[uV�b\N;VXvOa_aXs]�[1RsO:tlOa[uV��RsNSRUTN�cU�n�%]QXvN��w_QXs]Q��YfN�M�R�[�]Q_aM�Y�Rs���N��cvYfM_RsT#Y\c�N��n�%]�RUYfOaM �

� ��������� ¶�� ������ & + ã���� � ����� ¶�� ��� &�+ ã���� � ("!$# / � $�� = ã ("! = ã #,+ $�� ("!(# � ; = � $�� ( ! = ã #-+ $�� = ã ("!$# � ;

� T�Yfc�^nYfNlbf�cp]QM`]QXUXU]?^ � � ("!$# gSYfRUTJdeb\]QXv_aNQm�j�]�bf�N�c�g�TN�XvNFRUTN�YfM�RsNlMcvY�R�^3Yfc�t�T%]QM_QYfM_|�&�#Y\t���b�^ay� ;OQRsNERUT%]�R�g�NH]QcUcv�[uN�RUTN�]QXUXU]h^&c ]QXUN:�lN�XUO�  � ]QcvN����¾]QM��RsT]�R�RsTN�]QXUXU]?^ � � &)(+*$# Yfc ��M�Nl�MN��PxOaX � / ����� & OaX& / ��� & � � Nlt?]Q�cvNpOQRUTN�XZgSY\cvN�g=N�g=Oa��bf��]Qtlt�N�cvc � Nl^QOaM�½RUTN � Oa�M��%]QXvYfN�c OQP$�� ( !$# y �  N t�]QM|®��&¥s¬�­��%¦ C ,�RUTN;]QXUXU]h^ � � ("!(# RUO�bfO&t?]�RUN:deN���_aN�clmf� � Nlt?]Q�cvN;b\]QXv_aNSjQ]�b\�Nlc=YfM��Yft?]�RUN]QM�N���_aNQy  NEgSY�bfb�cvN�N � Nkb\Ohg�RsT%]�RSRUT�Yfc �O&N�c�MO�RS^&YfNlbf�q]pjQN�Xv^�NkÃ+NltlRvYfjQNHN���_aN:�NlRUN�tlRUOaX�y

� O�NlcvRUYf[�]�RsNWRUTN�z�]QV�b\]QtlY\]QM�� . ; $£��g=N»M�N�N�� ]�¿½º�¿�_aXZY\��OQP;V�Yµr#Nlbfc � N�t�]Q�cvN|]�cpg�N�cs]?g] � OhjaN:RsTN:�%M�Y�RsN���YfþN�XvN�MtlNp]QV�VXUO?r&Y\[�]�RvY\OQM|RsO�RsTN�cUNlt�OaM��q�N�XZYfj�]�RvYfjQN�Yfc�]�VVXUO?r&Yf[F]�RsN��½�cvYfM_¿pj�]�b\��N�c�y � Tn�c�YfP�g�N�t�OQMcvYf�N�X�RsT�N�¿uºq¿�]QXvXs]?^ $�� ("!$# YfM�Nkr#Nl��]Qc~PxOQb�b\Ohg�c��

�   ã ��=ã � �%�

=ã � = ã �%� = ã

�   ã ��� � � � � = ã ����   ã �#�a  ã � ��a  ã � = ã ��a  ã

� TN�cUNlt�OaM�»��YfXUNltlRUYfOaM%]�b"��N�XvY�j�]�RUY�jaNlc�]�R;RUTN:t�NlMnRUN�X�OQP"RsT�Yfc;]QXUXU]h^W]QXUN

3 ; $3 & ; ) $�� + ã ( !$#,+ · $�� ("!$# = $�� = ã ("!(#B(

Page 8: edges - University of Wisconsin–Madisonpages.cs.wisc.edu/~dyer/ai-qual/huttenlocher-edges95.pdfN cv t T|RUT Y\M _ac ]Qc N _QN NlRsNltlRvY\OaM|]QM cZRsN XvN OaV cvYfc y T N=V XUO&t

]QM� 3 ; $3 * ; ) $�� ("! + ã #,+ · $�� ("!(# = $�� ("! = ã # 7>#O±RsT�N�z�]QV#b²]QtkY²]�M��g�T�Yft�T|Yfc � �cZRSRsTNkY\X�cv�[��£Yfc. ; $ ) $�� + ã ("!(# = $�� ("! + ã #= $�� = ã ("!$# = $�� ( ! = ã #-+ � $�� ("!$# � ·��

 N;t?]�M�jnYfNlg�RsT#Y\c � �cvR8YfMFRUN�XU[uc�OQP+RUTN�t�O&N���tlYfN�M�RUc ã ( ã ( ã ( ã ( + � OQP+N��n�%]�RvY\OaM � ·n��]QM���RUTNlYfXXUNkb²]�RUY�jaNWb\O&t?]�RUYfOaMcuOaM�RsTNW_QXvYf��y >#O��cZY\M_�RsT�N»cU]Q[uN»¿|º�¿�_aXvYf�(]Qc � �cZRw] � OhjaN���RUT�Yfcu^nYfNlbf�ct�O&N���tkY\NlMnRUc7]�R�N�]Qt�T�b\O&t?]�RvY\OQM|OQP �

ãã   � ã

ã� TNlcUNWt�O&N���tkY\NlMnRUc±t?]QM � NwjnYfNlg=N��(]QcH]3d´[�]Qcv�£m�OaX�d´cZRsN�M�tlY�b�m�y � T%]�RHY\cl��Y\M�OQXU�NlX�RsO|t�Oa[uV�#RsNN��n�%]�RUYfOaM � ·n��]�R~cvOa[uN�bfO#t�]�RUYfOaM $�� �� ("! � # �nRsT#Y\c~[�]Qcv�FYfc�V�b\]QtlN���t�NlMnRUN�XvN��»]�R � �� ("! �k�8OQMwRsTN�_aXvYf�$�� ( !$# �+]QM�½RUTNHcv�[ OQP�RsTN�VXUO&��tkRsc7O�P�RsTN�[�]QcU��gSYfRUTqRsTN�t�OaXvXUNlcUV}OaM��YfM_-j�]�bf�N�c7O�P $�� ("!(#Yfc~t�Oa[uV�#RsN��+y�¢�MwOQRsTNlX�g=OaXU�cl�#RUT�Y\c�[F]�cU�uY\c � ��cvR�]QM�OQRsTNlX=g�]?^wOQP)g�XZYfRvY\M�_±�Ohg�MWN��n�%]�RvY\OaM � ·n��y

� OutlOa[uV��RsNERUTN:z�]QV�b\]QtlY\]QM�� . ; $£��PxOaX�RUTNEN�M�RUYfXUNEYf[�]Q_aN�$�� ( !$# �RUTNE[�]QcU�FY\cScvT�YfP�RUN���RsO � Nt�NlM�RsN�XvN��»]�R=N?]Qt�T-bfO&t?]�RvY\OaM � ("! �8]QM�FRsTN cU�[iOQP�VXvO#���tlRUc=Yfc�t�OQ[�V���RsNl�-RsOH^nYfNlbf�-RsTN;jQ]�b\�N OQPRsT�N~z�]QV�b\]QtlY\]QMH]�R�RUT%]�R � ("! �sy � T�Yfc�OQV¾NlXs]�RvY\OaM�OQP%V�b\]QtkY\M_7] [�]QcU��]�R"N?]Qt�T�b\O&t?]�RvY\OQM�YfM±]QM�Yf[�]Q_aN��]QM��cv�[u[±Y\M_�RsT�NpVXUO&��tkR:OQP8RsTNH[F]�cU�½gSY�RsTqRUTNpY\[�]Q_QNpY\c�RUTN±��YfcUtlXUNlRUN±jaN�XvcvYfOaM.OQP�g�T%]�REYfc�nMOhg�M`]�c A�¦ ���Q¦ C��#®�¨�¦ �%y  NpgSY�bfb��#Y\cvt��cvc�tlOaM�jaOQbf��RUYfOaM�Y\M�[uOaXvN±_aN�MNlXs]�b�Y�R�^ � Nkb\Ohg:� � N�t�]Q�cUN±Y�RYfc;M�N�t�NlcUcU]QXv^�PxOaXS�M��N�XvcvR�]�M��YfM_ � NlRvRsN�X � MOaM�bfO#t�]�bx��N��_aN�OaV}N�XU]�RsOaXvc�y

OQRUN�RsT%]�R�OaM�]�XvN�tkR�]QM_Q��b²]�X�_QXvYf�:Y�Rsc)T]QXU�ERsO�tlOa[uN���V:gSY�RsT�]QM�]QVV�XUO?r&Y\[�]�RvY\OaM:RsO . ; RUT%]�R)YfcXUO�R�]�RvY\OaM]�bfb�^:cv^&[u[uNlRUXvYft � NkjaN�MpRUTOa�_QT�RsT�N�t�OQMnRvY\Mn�OQ�c�OaV}N�XU]�RsOaX)Yfc�cZ^#[u[uNlRUXvYft��sy�¹�N�XvRs]�YfM�bf^:RUTNt�OQ[�V���R�]�RvY\OQM�cvV¾NltlY��%N�� � ^7N��n�%]�RvY\OaM � ·��£Y\c)MO�R�XUOQRs]�RUYfOaM%]�b�b�^7cv^&[u[uNlRUXvYft�� Y�R��N�V}N�M��c"tlXvY�RUYft?]�b�b�^OaM:RsTN8OaXZY\NlM�R�]�RvY\OaM�OQP&RsTN=]�r#N�cly�³%OaX)N¡r]�[�V#b\N���Y�P�g=N=tlOaMcvYf�NlX�] � ¸���XUO�R�]�RUN���t�O&OaXU��YfM%]�RUN�cv^&cvRUN�[��RsT�N�M�g�N�_aNlR

ã ã  �

ã ã� V]QXvRvY\tl��b²]�Xvb�^`]�t�t���Xs]�RUNw]QV�VXUO?r&Y\[�]�RvY\OQM`RsO»RsTNFz�]QV�b\]QtlY\]QM3Yfc�_QYfjQN�M � ^3]»g=NlYf_aT�RsNl��cU�[

OQP)RUTNE] � OhjaN7R�g=Ou]QVVXvOhr&Yf[�]�RUYfOaMcl��g�TN�XvN7RsTN &   *  �OaXZY\NlMnRUN��wRUN�Xv[ Yfc�g=NlYf_aT�RsN��|]QVV�XUO?r&Y\[�]�RUNlb�^R�gSYft�N�]Qc�[H�t�T½]QcSRsTN:��Y\]Q_aOaM]�bfb�^-OQXvYfN�M�RsNl�|RsNlXU[�y � T�Yfc XvN�cU�#bfRUc;YfM½]±[�]Qcv�-OQP

ã � ã�  Z·�¶ �

ã � ã� � T�NwNkr�]QtkRpXvN?]QcvOaMc�PxOQX:RUTN�cvN-t�O&N���tkY\NlMnRUcpT%]?jaN�RsO|�O|gSY�RsT.RsTNF_aXvYf�`cU]Q[uV�bfYfM_�]�M�`t�]QM � NPxOa�M���YfM � ¿ # y � O�RsNpRsT]�RERsTN±cv�[ OQP8RUTN�cvN�tlO#N ��tlYfN�M�Rsc:Y\c:�lN�XUO���g�T�Y\t�T.Y\cEXvN��n��YfXUNl�.YfM�OaXU�NlX

Page 9: edges - University of Wisconsin–Madisonpages.cs.wisc.edu/~dyer/ai-qual/huttenlocher-edges95.pdfN cv t T|RUT Y\M _ac ]Qc N _QN NlRsNltlRvY\OaM|]QM cZRsN XvN OaV cvYfc y T N=V XUO&t

PxOaX�RsTNEtlOa[uV��R�]�RUYfOaMWMOQR~RUO � N � Y²]�cUN��WRUOÙg�]QXv�cSV¾OQcvY�RUY�jaN:OaX�M�N�_�]�RvYfjQN � Y$yeN�yf�#RsOhg~]�XU�cSYfMt�XvN?]QcvN�cOaXS�Nlt�XvN?]QcvN�c YfM�RsTNEYf[F]�_aNEY\M�RsNlMcvY�R�^%��y

� TN�z�]QV�b\]QtlY\]QM:Y\c�]ScUNlt�OaM��HOaXv�N�X)��Y�þN�XUNlM�RUY\]�bnOaV}N�Xs]�RsOaXly � Tn�c)b\]QXU_aN�t�T]QM_aNlc�YfMERsTN8OaXZY\_QYfM%]�bYf[F]�_aN0$�� !#(��# gSYfb�b � NpXUNkÇ%N�tkRsNl� � ^q�lN�XvO»tlXUOacvcvYfM_acEYfMqRsTNuz�]QV�b\]QtkY²]QM � V�b\]Qt�Nlc:g�T�N�XUNpRUTNpj�]�bf�NOQP�RsTN�z�]QV�b\]QtkY²]QM�t�T%]�M_aN�c;cvYf_aM�PxXUOa[ V¾OQcvY�RUY�jaNERsOuMNl_�]�RUY�jaN�]QM�WjnYft�N:jaN�Xvcs]&�sy&��N�t�]�b�b�]�bfcUOuPxXUOa[] � OhjaN�RUT%]�R�RUTN�cZY\_QMWOQP)RsTN�z�]QV�b\]QtlY\]QMwYfM��Yft?]�RUN�c~g�T�Yft�T�cvYf�N7OQP)]QMWN��_QN Yfc � XvYf_aT�RsNlX~OaX��%]QXv�QN�Xly� Tn�cpYfM�OaXU�NlX�RUO½Y\��N�M�RUY�P�^oNl�_aN�c�Y\M�]QM3Y\[�]Q_aNw�cvYfM_qRsT#Y\cpOQV¾NlXs]�RUOaX���g=Nw�%XvcvR±tlOa[uV��RUN . ; $]QM�WRUTN�M��%M��RsTNE�lN�XvO�tlXUOacvcvYfM_ac � cZY\_aM»t�T%]QM�_aN�c¡��y  NEgSY�bfb�M�OQRSt�OQMcvYf�N�X�RsT�NEt�Oa[uV��Rs]�RUYfOaM»OQP. ; $qY\M3[�OQXUNu�NlRs]�Y�b=T�N�XUN�� � N�t�]Q�cUN�RsTN�[uOaXUN�_aNlMN�XU]�b���Y\cvt��cvcvYfOaMoOQP~t�OaM�jaO�b\��RvY\OQM � NlbfOÙg gSY�b�bcU� � cU�[uN�RsTN±deV%]QXvRvY\tl��b\]QX�m%[�]Qcv�wRsT%]�R;g=N:T%]?jaN��NljQNlbfOaV}N��qTNlXUNEPxOaX~RUTN�z�]�V�b²]�tlY\]QM�y

Ohg g=NQm jaNucvN�N�M�R�g=O»bfO#t�]�b � ·wº3·WOQXE¿-º.¿-V�Y�r#Nkb\c¡�7OaV}N�XU]�RsOQXUc�PxOaX��NlRUN�tlRvY\M�_|Nl�_aN�c�Æ»RUTN_aXU]Q��YfN�M�R�[�]Q_aM�Y�Rs���N�]QM�uz�]QV�b\]QtkY²]QM � g�T�Yft�TF]�XUN��%XvcvR8]�M�±cUNlt�OaM��OaXv�N�X��#YfþN�XvN�M�RUY\]�b%OaV}N�XU]�RsOQXUc��XUNlcUV}N�tkRUY�jaNlb�^%��y � M�PxOQXvRs��M%]�RsNkbf^�RUTN�cvNHOaV}N�XU]�RsOaXvc�]�XUN�]�b\[uOacZR7]�bfg�]?^#c;RsNlXUXvY � bfN�YfM½VXU]QtlRvY\tlNQy � T�YfcYfcFRsT�N»�%XvcvRwOQP7[�]QM�^��vcUOa��M�cw_QO#O&� � ��Rw��O#NlcUM�m Rwg=OaXU���ocZRsOaXZY\NlcFYfMJtlOa[uV��RsNlXFjnYfcvYfOaM�y � TNt�NlM�RsXs]�b=V�XUO � bfN�[ gSYfRUT3RsT�N�cUNubfO#t�]�b8OaV}N�Xs]�RsOaXvc:YfcERsT%]�R�RUTN�XvN±Y\c�cU� � cvR�]�MnRvY²]�b�bfO&t?]�b�j�]QXZY²]�RvY\OQM�YfM]p��Yf_QY�RUYf��N���Yf[F]�_aNQ�%]�M��[H�t�T»OQP�RsT�Yfc~j�]QXvY\]�RvY\OaM-Yfc7deMOQYfcUNQm%XU]�RsT�N�X~RsT]QM-Y\M#PxOaXU[�]�RvY\OaMWXvN�_�]�XU��YfM_RsT�N�cvt�NlMNQy  T#YfbfN�]»��YfcUtl�cUcZY\OQMoOQP�RUTN�cvNFM�OQY\cvNucUOa�Xvt�Nlc�Yfc � Nl^QOaM�.RsTN�cUtlOaV¾NuOQP=RsT�Yfc:t�Oa��XUcUN��RsT�Nl^u]QXvNS��NSRsOEP�]QtkRsOaXvc8cU�t�TF]Qc�RsTN���OQY\cvcUOaM�M%]�RU�XUN�OQP}RsT�N~Y\M�#YfjnYf��%]�b}VTO�RsO:cUNlMcUOaXvc�YfMu[�]QM�^cUNlMcvYfM_p��NljnY\tlN�cS]�M�wNlXUXUOQXUc=YfMFRUTN ]QM%]�bfOa_:RsO���Y\_�YfRs]�b}t�OaM�jaNlXUcZY\OaM+y � c�]�XUN�cv��b�R?�nRsTNlXUN7]�XUN�[�]QM�^bfO#t�]�b)t�T%]QM�_aN�c�Y\M|]QM�Y\[�]Q_QN7RsT%]�R ]QXvNEMOQR;��NERUOuRUTN:cUtlN�MN�]�R ]�b�b�y

¢�MHVXU]QtlRvY\tlN�RUT�Yfc�bfO&t?]�b�j�]QXZY²] � Yfb�YfR�^EYfM�]QM�Yf[�]Q_aN8t?]��cUNlc=deN��_aNlc�mhRsO ]QVV}N?]�X)MN?]QXZbf^:NkjaNlXv^ng�TN�XvNQy³%OaX)Nkr�]Q[uV�bfNQ�a³"Y\_Q�XUN�¿ScUTOhg�c�RsTN8XUNlcU��b�R"OQPXv�MM�YfM_ ]�bfO#t�]�bn_aXU]Q��YfN�M�R�[F]�_aM�Y�Rs��N�N���_aN=��NlRsNltlRUOaX� cZY\[±Y�b²]�X RsO�RsTN�cvYf[uV�b\NHVXUOa_QXs]Q[©_QY�jaNlM�] � OhjaN��~OaM|RUTN�Yf[�]Q_aN�cUTOhg�MqYfMq³"Yf_a�XvN ã ]#y�¹�OQMnRUXs]QcZRRsT#Y\c�gSY�RsT±RUTN~N���_aN�c�PxXvOa[1³"Y\_Q�XUN ã � RsO7cvN�N~RUT%]�R�g=NSt?]�M±�OE[H�t�T � NlRvRsN�X � gSY�RsT±cUOQ[�N�MOaM�bfO#t�]�b$�OaX�]�RSbfN?]�cvR;b\NlcUc�b\O&t?]�b$�Nl�_aN:OaV}N�Xs]�RsOaXvck��y

� ����� ��(���0��� ������ �$� (�,������ T�Yfc � XZY\NkP�Y\M�RsXvO#���tlRvY\OaM|RsOFbfO&t?]�b"N��_QNHOaV}N�XU]�RsOaXvc�]�tlRs�]�bfb�^|XUNlÇN�tlRUcE]�b\]QXv_aN�X;[uNlRsT�O#�O�b\Oa_�^a�+OQX]QVV�XUO�]Qt�T+��RsOWXUNlcUN�]QXUt�T�Y\M�tlOa[uV��RsNlX7jnY\cZY\OaM+y  N±cvR�]�XvR7gSY�RsT.]WcvRs]�RsNl[�NlM�R:OQP=]-VXUO � b\Nl[ RsT%]�Rg=NHg~]�MnR�RsOwcvOQb�jaNQ�+cU�t�T�]Qc;�%M�qRUTNHNl�_aN�cl�)]QM�½�N�XZYfjQN±]w[�]�RsT�N�[�]�RUYft?]�b"PxOaXv[H��b\]�RvY\OaM½OQP�RsT%]�RVXvO � bfN�[�y � TNlMug=N~Yf[�V#b\Nl[�NlM�R8cUOa[uNS[uNlRUTO#� � ]QcUNl��OQMHRsTNS[�]�RUTN�[�]�RvY\t�]�b�PxOQXU[H�#b²]�RvY\OQM��aOQP�RUN�M]-��YfcUtlXUNlRUNu]QVVXvO?r#Yf[�]�RUYfOaM�RsOwcUOa[uN±t�OQMnRvY\Mn�OQ�c:[F]�RsTNl[F]�RUYft�c�y � TNpYf[uV�b\Nl[uN�M�R�]�RvY\OQM�Yfc7RsT�N�MRsNlcvRUN��ÁOaM cUOa[uN|�%]�R�] � NkYfRUTN�XuPxXUOa[ XvN?]�b;cvN�McvOaXUc-OQX�cZ^&MnRUTNlRvY\t�]�b�bf^J_aN�MNlXs]�RUN��Á�]�R�]���RsTOQ�_aTXUN�]�b)�%]�R�]pY\cSM�N?]QXZbf^�]�bfg�]?^#c � NlRURUN�X � N�t�]Q�cUN�OQP�RsT�N��#Y���t��#bfR�^�OQP"cv^&M�RsT�N�cvYf�lYfM_»d´XvN?]�b�Y\cZRUYftQm£�%]�Rs]&��y³"YfM%]�b�bf^Q� � ]QcvN��uOaMHRUTN~V}N�XZPxOaXU[�]QMtlN~g�N��N�XZYfjQN�]7XUNl�MN��±cZR�]�RUN�[uN�M�R�OQP%RsT�N~VXUO � b\Nl[��n]QM� � N�_QYfM]Q_�]�Y\M�y � T#Y\cSVXvO#tlN�cvc�Y�RsNlXs]�RUN�cS�M�RvYfb�]p��N�cvYfXUNl�»bfNljQNlb)O�P"V}N�XZPxOaXU[�]QM�t�NEOaM-RUTNEVXUO � b\Nl[ÕT%]�c � NlN�M]�RvR�]�YfMN��+�%OaXS�M�RUY�b)g�N�XU��M|Oa�#R�OQP"Yf�N�]Qc�] � Oa�#R�TOhg{RsOuXvNl�%MN �Yf[�V�XUOhjaN�RsTN:[uNlRUTO#��c�y

� Tn�c OQMN:V%]QXs]���Y\_Q[ÕPxOaXSt�OQ[�V���RsNlX�jnYfcvYfOaM½XvN�cvN?]QXvt�T|Yfc �ã y�cZR�]�RUN:RUTN:VXUO � b\Nl[©]QM�»�NlXvY�jaN�]u[�]�RUTN�[�]�RvY\t�]�b�PxOaXU[���b\]�RUYfOaM·#ySYf[uV�b\Nl[uN�M�R7]u[uNlRUTO#� � ]QcvN��»OaM�RsTNEPxOaXv[F]�b)VXUO � b\Nl[ �NlcUt�XZY\V#RUYfOaM¿�ySRUN�cvR�RUTN:[�NkRsTO&� � �cZY\M_�cv^&M�RsT�NlRUYftp]�M�� �OaXSXvN?]�b��]�R�]&�

Page 10: edges - University of Wisconsin–Madisonpages.cs.wisc.edu/~dyer/ai-qual/huttenlocher-edges95.pdfN cv t T|RUT Y\M _ac ]Qc N _QN NlRsNltlRvY\OaM|]QM cZRsN XvN OaV cvYfc y T N=V XUO&t

³"Yf_a�XUN:¿ �8z�O&t?]�b�N��_aNlc�Nkr&RsXU]QtlRUN��|PxXvOa[ RUTN±d´_QO#O&��m�Yf[�]Q_aN:OQP�RsTN:cvYf[uV�bfN�cvt�N�M�NQy

� y�NkjQ]�b\�%]�RsNERsTN:XvN�cU�#bfRUc�]QM��|XvNl�%MNERUTN:[�NkRsTO&� � OaXSXvN � N�tkR Y�Rl�L7MN±OQP8RsTNpYfM�RsNlXUN�cZRUYfM_�RsT�YfM_acE] � Oa�#R7RsT�YfcEV%]QXU]Q��Yf_a[ Yfc�RUT%]�REYfM�OaXU�NlX7RsO � NpcU��t�t�NlcUcZPx��bfb�^

]QVV#bfYfN��.YfR�XUNl�n��Y\XvN�cH] � XUO�]Q�.Xs]�M_aNuOQP~cv��Yfb�b\cly � TN�[�]�RsT�N�[�]�RUYft?]�b�PxOQXU[H�#b²]�RvY\OQM3OQP~]»V�XUO � bfN�[t?]�M�YfM�jaOQb�jaN:[�]QM�^-�#YfþN�XvN�M�R � Xs]QM�t�TN�c�OQP�[�]�RUTN�[�]�RvY\tlc � ]Qc�g=NEgSYfb�b)cUNlNE��XZY\M_±RUTN7cUNl[uN�cvRUN�X¡��y>#Oa[uN=[F] � OaX�]QXvN?]Qc�RsT%]�R"g=N�gSY�bfb#RsOa�t�THOaM±]QXvN=��Y�þN�XUNlM�RUY\]�bNl�&�]�RUYfOaMcl�abfYfMN?]�X�]�bf_aN � Xs]���RsOaV}OQbfOa_Q^a�_aXvOa�V�RsTNlOaXv^Q�¾tlOa[ � YfM%]�RUOaXvY\]�b�_aNlOa[uNlRsXZ^a�}]QM�|��Y�Ã+NlXUN�M�RvY²]�b�_aNlOa[uNlRUXv^ay � TN�Yf[uV�b\Nl[uN�M�R�]�RvY\OQMqOQP]:[�NkRsTO&�wXvN��n��YfXUNlc�_aO&O#��]�bf_aOaXZYfRUT[±Y\t;cU��Y�bfbfc~]�M�FO�P�RsN�MF]�bfcUO�XUN��n��YfXUNlc~]:_aO&O#�u�M��N�XUcZR�]QM���Y\M�_pOQPMn�[uN�XZY\t�]�b£VXUOQV¾NlXvRUYfN�c�O�P¾�#YfþN�XvN�M�R8[uNlRsT�O#�c � ]Qc�g=Nlb�b}]Qc�_aO&O&�pcv^&cvRUN�[uc=]QM�±t�O&��YfM_EcU��Y�bfbfck�s��RsTn�ccUV]QMM�YfM_q]�gSY\��NFXU]QM_aN�OQPS]�XUN?]�c�YfM`tlOa[uV��RsNlX�cvtlYfN�MtlNW]Qc:g�Nkbfb$y�³"YfM%]�b�bf^Q��RUTNF] � Y�bfY�R�^�RsO�RsN�cZR]QM�FXUNk�%MN ]�[uNlRUTO&�wXUNl�n��Y\XvN�c=Nkr#V¾NlXvYf[uN�M�R�]�b+cU��Y�bfbfc~]Qc8OaM�N _aNlMN�XU]�b�bf^±�%M��c=YfM � Y\OQbfOa_Q^Q�#V�Tn^&cZY\tlc��]QM�FcvYf[±Yfb\]QX8�%Nlbf�c�y � T#Y\c=[F]��QN�c=t�Oa[uV�#RsN�X8jnY\cZY\OQM-]�bfOQR�OQP¾Px�M�� � Nlt?]Q��cUN g=N;t?]QMFt�Oa[ � Y\M�N�cU��Y�bfbfcPxXUOQ[ ]uM&��[ � N�X;OQP��n��Y�RsN:��Y�þN�XUNlM�R �%Nkb\��c�y

�;NkRs�XvM�YfM_�RsOqRsT�NWVXUO � b\Nl[ ]�RHT%]QM���8OQP;XvNl�%M�YfM_�Oa�XHN��_aNW��NlRsNltlRvY\OaM�[uNlRUTO&�c��8g�N-gSY�b�bt�OQMcvYf�N�XScvOa[uN7t�T%]QM�_aN�c�RUOHRsT�NEz�]QV�b\]QtlY\]QMW]QM��-_aXs]���Y\NlM�RS[�]Q_aM�Y�Rs���N7OaV}N�Xs]�RsOaXvc=RsO�^&YfNlbf�W[uNlRUT# O&�c±gSYfRUT b\]QXU_aNlX �U]QXUN�]QcuOQP7cv�VV}OaXvR �y � T%]�R�Y\cl�=g=N»gSY�bfb;�NkjaNkb\OaV RsN�t�T�M�Y\�n�NlcwRsT]�R�t�OaMcZY\��N�X]»b\]QXv_aN�X�MNlYf_aT � OaXUTO&O&�`OQP~RUTNuY\[�]Q_aN���YfM`OaXv�N�X:RsO|t?]QMtlNlb�Oa��R � OaX:cU[uO&OQRsT`Oa��Rl��cU[�]�b�b�b\O&t?]�bt�T%]QM�_aN�cly � T�YfcpgSYfb�b~]�b\cvOqY\M�jaO�bfjQN�]½cU[�]�b�b���NlRsOQ�XHYfMnRUO½b�Y\MN�]QXpcZ^#cZRsNl[�cu]�M�ot�OQMnjQOQbf��RUYfOaMcl�8YfMOaXv�N�X�RsOFN�M%] � b\Np��c RsOF�M�NlXUcZR�]QM�|RsTNlcUNpMNkg [uNlRsT�O#�cly  N�gSY�b�b�NlM�q�V»gSYfRUT½R�g�Ow��YfþN�XvN�M�RXUNlcU��b�RUYfM_±Nl�_aN���NlRsNltlRUOaXUcly�L7MN�� � ]�cUN��WOQMFRsT�N7cU[uO&OQRsTNl�-_aXU]Q��YfN�M�R~[�]Q_aM#YfRU��NQ�&g~]�c~OaXvYf_QYfM%]�b�bf^�NkjaNlbfOaV}N�� � ^o¹~]QMM�^ � · # y � TNwOQRUTN�Xl� � ]QcvN��oOQM3RsT�N-z�]QV�b\]QtlY\]QMoO�P���]��cUcZY²]QM+��OaX . ;�� ��g�]QcOaXZY\_QYfM%]�b�b�^W�NljQNlbfOaV}N�� � ^|Ž]�XUX�]QM� �;Y�bf�XUNkRsT � ¸ # y

ã ¶

Page 11: edges - University of Wisconsin–Madisonpages.cs.wisc.edu/~dyer/ai-qual/huttenlocher-edges95.pdfN cv t T|RUT Y\M _ac ]Qc N _QN NlRsNltlRvY\OaM|]QM cZRsN XvN OaV cvYfc y T N=V XUO&t

� ��� ��� � � � ����� �-��$�L�jaNlX~RsTN�b\]QcZR�·a¸�^QN?]QXvc�RsTNlXUNET%]?jQN � NlN�M�]HMn�[ � NlXSOQP�OQRsTNlX=bfO#t�]�b�Nl�_aN7OQV¾NlXs]�RUOaXUc=�NljQNlbfOaV¾Nl���g�T�Yft�T�t?]QM`[F]�Y\M�b�^ � NF�M�NlXUcZRsO&O#�`YfM3RUN�Xv[�cHOQP~RsT�NF��YfXUNltlRvY\OaM]�b��%XvcvRp]QM�`cvN�tlOaM���NlXvY�jQ]�RUY�jaNOaV}N�XU]�RsOaXvc=RUT%]�R�g�N7T]hjQN � �cZR~��YfcUtl�cUcvN�� � ]�b�RsTOQ�_aTFRUTNl^�g=N�XUN�MOQR�]�bfg�]?^&cSVXUNlcUN�M�RUN��WRsT%]�R=g�]?^YfM(RUTNlYfXFOQXvYf_QY\M]�b��NljQNlbfOaV[uN�M�Rk��y � [uOaXUN��NkR�]�Y�b\Nl�J��YfcUtl�cUcZY\OQM�OQP7cvOa[uN|OQP;RsT�N�cUN|OaV}N�Xs]�RsOaXvct?]�M � N�PxOa�M�qYfM ]�b�b²]�XU��]QM�� XUOhg�M�m c � O#Oa� � ã # y ��c7OQMNpNkr�]Q[uV�bfNQ�¾RsTN >&O � Nkb�OaV}N�XU]�RsOQX YfcE]�%XvcvR:�NlXvY�jQ]�RUY�jaN±OaV}N�XU]�RsOaX Y\M�g�T�Yft�T�RsTNu]QV�VXUO?r&Y\[�]�RvY\OQM�RUO-RsTNH��Y\XvN�tkRUYfOaM%]�b��XUcvR:��N�XvY�j�]�RUY�jaN±Yfc%��

=ã #(+ %�� + ã # ��]Qc~OaVV}OacvN��-RsO %��

=ã #(+ %�� # ]Qc=�cUNl�|] � OhjaN�y � TN >#O � Nlb+OaV}N�Xs]�RsOaX=]�bfcUO

�cvN�cS]HcZY\[uV�bfN7PxOaXv[ O�P�b\O&t?]�b¾g=NlYf_aT�RUYfM_ � g�T#Y\t�TWg=N�gSYfb�b�tlOaMcZY\�NlX�YfM-[uOaXUN7��NlR�]�Yfb}Y\MFRsTN�PxO�bfbfOhg~ YfM_½cvN�tlRvY\OQM��"g�TNlM`g=Nw��YfcUtl�cUcpcv[uO#OQRUT�YfM_#��y � TNF[�]Qcv�£��OaXERsNl[�V#b²]�RUNQ��PxOaXERsT�Yfc � ��Y\XvN�tkRUYfOaM%]�bx�OaV}N�XU]�RsOaX~Yfc

  ã ¶ ã Z· ¶ ·  ã ¶ ã

PxOaX7RUTNu�N�XZYfj�]�RvYfjQNFgSY�RsT.XUN�cvV¾NltlR�RsO & y OQRUNuRUT%]�R:cZY\MtlN�RUT�Yfc�Nl�_aNuOaV}N�Xs]�RsOaX7Yfc:MOQR:Y\cvOQRsXvOaV�Yft� Yfc�cvN�McZYfRvYfjQN±RsOFRUTNpNl�_aNHOQXvYfN�M�R�]�RvY\OQM¾��]wMn�[ � NlX7OQP��#YfþN�XvN�M�REN���_aNpOaV}N�XU]�RsOaXvc [��cvR � N��cUNl���cUNlMcvY�RUY�jaN~RUO�Nl�_aN�c�Y\M�j�]QXvYfOa�c"��Y\XvN�tkRUYfOaMc�y � T�Y\c"t�OaM�RUXs]QcZRsc"gSY�RsT�RsTN�z�]�V�b²]�tlY\]QMp]QM���RsT�N�_aXU]Q��YfN�M�R[�]Q_aM�Y�Rs���N½[uNlRUTO&�c-�NlcUt�XZY � N���] � OhjaN�y{³%OaX�[�]QM�^ � Y\O�b\Oa_�Y\t�]�b jnYfcvYfOaMÁcZ^#cZRsNl[�cl��TOhg=NljQN�X��SY�R]QVV}N?]�XUcwRUTN�XvN�]QXUNqOQXvYfN�M�R�]�RvY\OQM# �cvNlbfN�tlRvYfjQN.��bfRUN�XUc�]�M�ÁRsTn�c-Y�RW[�]?^ � N½RsT%]�RWcU�t�T��b�RsNlXUc�]QXvN�cvN��WY\M�Nl�_aNk Ä�NlRUN�tkRUYfOaM»R�^&V}NEOaV}N�Xs]�RUYfOaMc�YfMWRsTNlcUN:cv^&cvRUN�[uc � RUTN�XvN:]QXUN:]�bfcUOpYfcUO�RsXUOQV�Y\t7��bfRUN�XUc~YfM� YfOQbfOa_QYft?]�b)jnYfcvYfOaM|cZ^&cvRsNl[uc�cUOuRsT�N�NkjnY\�NlMt�N�Y\c�MO�R�t�OaMtkb\��cvY�jaNpOaM�N7g~]?^�OaX~RUTN:OQRsTNlXk�sy

� TN�cvN;bfO&t?]�b%Nl�_aN�OaV}N�XU]�RsOaXvc � ]QM� � º � OaX�¸~ºH¸EjQN�XvcvYfOaMck�"g=OaXU�±cZbfYf_aT�RUb�^ � NlRURUN�X�YfMFVXU]QtlRvY\tlNRsT]QM»RUTN:N��_QN�OaV}N�XU]�RsOQXUcSg�N:T%]?jQNH��YfcUtl�cUcvN��qcvO�P�]QXly � TN�[�]�YfM½XvN?]QcvOaM�Y\cSRsT]�R�RsTNk^��OFcvOa[uNbfO#t�]�b"]hjQN�XU]Q_QYfM_ � OaXSg�NkY\_aT�RUN���cU[uO&OQRsT#Y\M_&�~OQP"RsTN:Yf[F]�_aNH]�c V%]�XvR OQP�RUTN�V�XUO&t�N�cvcvYfM_y  N�MOhgRs��XUM`RUOq]½��YfcUtl�cUcZY\OQM(O�P~b\O&t?]�b�cv[�O&OQRUT�Y\M�_qOaV}N�Xs]�RUYfOaMc���]QM�`RUTN�Mog=N-V�#RHRsOQ_aNlRUTN�X�RsTN�b\O&t?]�bcU[uO&OQRsT#Y\M_�gSY�RsT�RsT�N�z�]�V�b²]�tlY\]QM�]QM��_aXU]Q��YfN�M�R�[�]Q_aM�Y�Rs���N�N��_aN���NlRsNltlRUOaXUcly � TN�XUNlcU��b�RUYfM_[uNlRUTO#��c�g=OaXv� � NkRURsNlXSRsT%]QMWbfO#t�]�b�[uNlRUTO#��c;cv�t�Tq]�c >&O � Nkb�y� � >W@wDF>WG��|6�<�>W@ F@q0 �� >»>u6� .<Ù@�2

 N-cs]?giY\MoRUTN-VXvNljnYfOa�c±cUNltlRvY\OaM�RUT%]�RHRUOq�NkRsN�tkRuN��_QN�cHYfM�]QMoYf[F]�_aNQ��g=NWt?]�M��cUNw�XUcvR±]QM�cUNlt�OaM��½OaXv�N�X�cUV]�RUY\]�b)�NlXvY�j�]�RUY�jaNlc�y�¢�M»V%]QXZRUYft���b\]QXSg=N�tlOaMcZY\�NlXUNl�½RsTN�z�]QV�b\]QtkY²]QM

. ; $ / 3 ; $3 & ; = 3 ; $3 * ;]QM��RsT�N�cv�n�%]QXUNl�½_aXU]Q��YfN�M�R;[�]Q_aM�Y�Rs���N

: . $ : ; /2143 $3 &%5 ; = 1)3 $3 *45 ; 7 N�]�bfcUO�cs]?g TOhg RUO�]QVV�XUO?r&Y\[�]�RUNqRsTNlcUN��n�%]QM�RUY�RUYfN�c�OaM�]o�#Y\cvt�XUNkRsN�_aXZY\�+y L7MN½XUN�[�]�YfM�YfM_VXvO � bfN�[���TOhg=NljQN�X��#Y\c�RsT%]�R=cs]�[�V#b\Nl�-Y\[�]Q_aNlc�tlOaM�R�]�YfMW]�bfOQR=OQP)T�Yf_aT# �PxXUNl�&��N�Mtk^|deMOQYfcUN�mfy  N�cs]?g

ãaã

Page 12: edges - University of Wisconsin–Madisonpages.cs.wisc.edu/~dyer/ai-qual/huttenlocher-edges95.pdfN cv t T|RUT Y\M _ac ]Qc N _QN NlRsNltlRvY\OaM|]QM cZRsN XvN OaV cvYfc y T N=V XUO&t

RsT�N±NlþN�tlRUcEOQP8RsT�Yfc�YfM.³"Y\_Q�XUN±¿#�+g�TN�XvNpRsTNp]QVV�b�Y\t�]�RUYfOaM�OQP=]wbfO#t�]�b�_QXs]Q��YfN�M�R:[�]Q_aM#YfRU��N±N���_aN�NkRsN�tkRsOaXS^nYfNlbf�N��q[�]QM�^Wcv[�]�bfb�Nl�_aNlc�y

� T�YfcFVXvO � bfN�[ t�]QM � N»] � cZRsXs]�tlRsNl� gSY�RsT�RsTN�PxOQb�b\OhgSYfM_.Nkr�]Q[uV�bfNQy�¹�OQMcvYf�N�XF]QM ]QXUXU]?^�OQPMn�[uN�XZY\t�]�b�jQ]�b\�Nlc��

¸ À ÀÀ ¸ À ¸¸ ¸ À À ¸ À

� T�Yfc�]QXUXU]h^�T%]Qc�bfO&t?]�b¾d � Oa�M�]QXvYfN�clmn]�bfb�OhjaN�X�RUTN~V�b\]Qt�N�Æ�MN�]QXvb�^pM�OaMNSOQP£RsT�NSMNlYf_aT � OQXvYfM_EjQ]�b\�Nlc]QXvN�RUTN;cs]Q[uNQy���NkR?��RsT�N t�T%]�M_aN�c=]QXvN�jQN�XZ^Fcv[�]�bfb$�#]QM�uRsTNlXUN ]QXUN�MOQR�deXUNl_QY\OQMc�mnOQP+cvYf[uY�b\]QX�j�]�bf�N�y T%]�R�g=NEg�Oa�#b\�»bfYf�QN:Y\cSRUO�V�XUO&��t�N�]±��Y�Ã+NlXUNlMnR�]QXvXs]?^a�%cv�t�Tq]Qc

À À À ÀÀ À À ÀÀ À À ÀÀ À À À

PxXUOQ[ RUTNWOaXvYf_QYfM%]�b�]�XUXs]?^Qy � T�YfcuVXUO&t�NlcUcuOQP;XUNl[uOÙjnYfM_.cUV%]�RvY²]�bST�Yf_aToPxXUNl�&��N�MtkY\Nlc � cv[�]�bfb�b\O&t?]�bt�T%]QM�_aN�c¡�EY\c��nMOhg�M�]Qc C\¦�� ?�ª�­�­�� C ®�¬k¥k¨ �n«ay  NwgSY�bfb=��YfcUt���cUcu]|V]QXvRvY\tl��b²]�Xp[uNlRsT�O#�oO�P~b\Ohg�V%]�cUc�b�RsNlXvYfM_��g�T�Yft�T�Y\cp��OaMN � ^ A�¦ ���Q¦ C��h¨ �n«-]QM�]QXvXs]?^ � YfM`RsT�Yfcpt�]QcUNwRUTNwYf[�]Q_aN��7gSYfRUT�]|b\Ohg�V%]�cUc�b�RsNlX�Px��MtlRvY\OaM � _QN�MNlXs]�b�bf^»] �:]Q�cvcvY\]QM|OQV¾NlXs]�RUOaX��OQXSMOaXU[�]�b��#Y\cZRsXvY � ��RvY\OQM¾��y

OQRUNERsT%]�RSRUT�Yfc t�]QcUN:cUT�Oa��bf� � NE��Y\cZRUYfM_a��YfcUT�N��½PxXvOa[ ]QM|]QXvXs]?^WOQP�j�]�b\��N�c�cU�t�T½]Qc¸ ¸ ¸ À¸ ¸ À À¸ ¸ À À¸ À À À

g�TNlXUN�RUTN7��Y�Ã+NlXUNlMt�Nlc�]QXUN7cZRUY�bfb¾XUNkb²]�RUY�jaNlb�^-cv[�]�bfb$� � �#R�RsT�N�XUN7]QXUN;R�g�O±��YfcvRvY\M�tlR�XUNl_QYfOaMc � OQP)j�]�bf�N¸7]QM�pj�]�bf�N�À&�sy  N~�OaM+m R�g�]QM�R�RsT�N~�bfRUN�XZY\M_:OaV}N�XU]�RUYfOaMHRUOEXUNl[�OhjQN�RUTN�cvNScUOaXZRsc�OQP}��YfcvRvY\M�tlRUYfOaMcl�]QM�»Y\M»P�]QtlR;g=N�gSY�bfb � N�] � bfN:RsOw��OFRsT#Y\c � ^½]�VVXUOQVXvY\]�RsNkbf^»cvNlbfN�tlRvY\M�_W]�­ AUª C\¬~OaX cvV%]�RvY²]�b�N¡r#RUN�M�RPxOaX~RUTNEb\Ohg�V%]Qcvc;��bfRUN�XvYfM_�OaV}N�Xs]�RUYfOaM�y>#OWg�N�m b�b�cvV¾NlM�3[uOacZREOQP8RsT#Y\cEcvN�tlRvY\OQM3OaM�]½de�NkRsOa�Xlmf��bfO&Oa��Y\M_�]�REt�OaM�jQOQb\�#RUYfOaM.]QM��MOhg1RUOYf[�V#b\Nl[�NlM�R�Y�R8OaMu]7_aXZY\� � OaX�]QXvXs]?^%��y � c�Y\M±RUTNSVXUNkjnY\Oa��c�cvN�tkRUYfOaM���g�NScZR�]QXZR�gSYfRUT±RsTNStlOaM�RUYfM&��Oa�ct?]�cUN � N�t�]Q�cvN�YfR=Y\c=cvYf[uV�b\NlX�RsO�Nkr#VXvN�cUcl�£]QM��RsTNlMwg�N b\O&Oa�u]�R=�%M�Y�RsN7]�VVXUO?r&Yf[F]�RUYfOaMc~OaMw]�_aXZY\�+y

¹�OaMcZY\�NlX;RUTNEPxOQb�b\OhgSYfM_�Px��MtlRvY\OaM�� �'&)(+* ���#�Nl�MN��»Y\M�RsNlXU[uc O�P� �9&)(+* ��]QM�� �'&)(+* ���� �'&)(+* �6/ ���� � ���� � � �'& +��!(+* +�� �� ��� (�� � ' � ' � 7 � ¿n�

 N�cU]?^WRsT%]�R���Y\cSRUTN:t�OaM�jaO�b\��RvY\OQM½OQP���]QM��)�g�T#Y\t�T»Y\cSg�XvY�RURUN�M|]Qc��/����� 7

ã ·

Page 13: edges - University of Wisconsin–Madisonpages.cs.wisc.edu/~dyer/ai-qual/huttenlocher-edges95.pdfN cv t T|RUT Y\M _ac ]Qc N _QN NlRsNltlRvY\OaM|]QM cZRsN XvN OaV cvYfc y T N=V XUO&t

��

Ò �

� �

� �

³�Y\_a��XUN � ��¢Äb�b\�cZRsXU]�RUYfOaM»OQP�OQMNk Ä��Y\[uNlMcvYfOaM%]�b�tlOaM�jaOQbf��RUYfOaM � cUNlN�RUTNERsN¡r#Rk��y

¹�OaM�jaOQbf��RvY\OaMpYfc A�¦�§±§ �#®�ªQ®$¨ �Q¬k�Ùg�T�Yft�Tpt?]�M � N=cvN�N�M � ^�]�cvYf[uV�b\N=cU� � cvRUY�Rs�#RUYfOaM�����/ & + � (�� /* +�� RsTNlM|XvN�M%]Q[uN��3RsO � ]QM� � RUO � �� � /� � � 7

¹�OaM�jaO�b\��RvY\OQM|Yfc ]�b\cvOw]QcvcUO&tlY\]�RUY�jaN� � ���� �� �/ � � � � ?� 7

� TNlcUN:R�g�O�VXUOQV¾NlXvRUYfN�c ]QXvN7jaN�XZ^��cUNkPx��b � Nlt?]Q��cUN:RsTNk^�]�b�b\Ohg ��c�RUOuXUN?]�XUXs]�M_aN:t�Oa[uV�#R�]�RvY\OaM�c�YfMg�T%]�RUNljQN�X�P�]QcUT�YfOaM�Y\c�[uOacZR tlOaM�jaNlM�Y\NlM�R � OaXSN ��tlYfN�M�Rl�sy

� TNW�Oa� � b\N-YfM�RsNl_aXs]�b�Y\M�Nl�&�]�RUYfOaM � ¿&�E[F]?^`MOQRpYf[u[�Nl��Y\]�RsNkbf^obfN?]�V(OQ��Ru]�Rp^QOa�(]Qc � NlYfM_YfMnRU��Y�RUY�jaN � NkjaNlXv^�V¾O�Y\M�R�OQP}RsTN�Oa��RUV��R8Yfc8RUTN;cU�[�O�P+RsT�N;V�XUO&��tlR�OQP �gSY�RsTw]:cvT�Y�P�RsN���jaNlXUcvYfOaMOQP��"y � T�Yfc;Yfc;] � YfR;N�]QcvYfN�X�RsO±Y�bfbf�cvRUXs]�RUNEPxOaX�]�OQMNk Ä��Y\[uNlMcvYfOaM%]�b�Px�M�tlRUYfOaM��

� �'& � / � ��� �'& + � � � � � ' � 7

¹�OaMcZY\�NlX � � NlYfM_wRsT�NHcU�n�%]�XUNpg�]hjQN±cUTOhg�MqYfM�³"Yf_a�XvN � ]��+]QM� � NlYfM_wRUTNwd � Nkbfb�cUT%]QV}N��+mt���XvjaN�cUT�OÙg�M»Y\M»³"Yf_a�XvN � � y � TNEj�]�bf�N:OQP�� �9& �l��Y\c~RUTN�M»O � Rs]�Y\M�N�� � ^WYfM�RsNl_aXs]�RvY\M�_ � cU�[u[±YfM_#�RsT�NpVXUO&��tkREOQP ½gSY�RsT �3cvT�YfP�RUN�� � ^ & �hy�¢�M�OQRsTNlX�g=OaXU�cl�+RsOwt�Oa[uV��RUN � �'& �l��g�N±t�]QMqjnY\Nkg ]Qc � NlYfM_-cv�V}N�XvYf[uV¾OQcUN��.OaM �3]�RHd b\O&t?]�RUYfOaM�m & �h��]Qc�Y�b�b\�cZRsXU]�RsNl�qY\M�³"Yf_a�XvN � t�y Nlt?]Q�cvN±OQP � Nlb�bcUT]QV¾NuOQP�RsT#Y\c�V%]QXZRUYft���b\]QXEPx�MtkRUYfOaM���)g�T�Yft�T3Yfc:MN?]QXZbf^��lN�XvO� Äj�]�bf�N���PxOaXE[uOacZR�O�P=Y�Rsc:Xs]�M_aNQ�)Y�RYfc;[�]�YfM�b�^-RsT�N�M�N?]QX � ^Wj�]�bf�Nlc;O�P� �9& �l��RsT%]�R��NlRUN�XU[±YfMN:RsTNEj�]�bf�N:OQP�� �9& �l��y � Out�Oa[uV��RUN � �9& �PxOaX�]�b�b & � �½YfcScUT�Y�P�RsNl�|RUO±N?]Qt�T»V¾OQcvY�RUYfOaM»gSY�RsT�XvN�cUV}N�tkR RUO ��%XUN�cv��b�RUYfM_�YfMWRsTN:Oa�#RsV��R�cvTOhg�M»YfM³"Yf_a�XvN � ��y

¹�OaM�jaOQbf��RvY\OaM�YfcSt�OaMcZY\��N�Xs] � bf^wT%]QXv�N�X~RUOpj&YfcU�]�bfYf��N�]�R=�%XUcZRSRsT%]�MWOaV¾NlXs]�RvY\OQMc~cU��t�T½]Qc�[H��b�RUYµ V�b�Y\t�]�RUYfOaM�� � N�t?]��cUN�RsTN:j�]�b\��NHOQP� � q]�R�]QM�^�V}OQY\M�R;Y\c;RsTN�XUNlcU��b�R7O�P�ª C C�RUTN�V}OQYfM�Rsc;OQP ��]QM�

ã ¿

Page 14: edges - University of Wisconsin–Madisonpages.cs.wisc.edu/~dyer/ai-qual/huttenlocher-edges95.pdfN cv t T|RUT Y\M _ac ]Qc N _QN NlRsNltlRvY\OaM|]QM cZRsN XvN OaV cvYfc y T N=V XUO&t

���MOQR � �cvRpcvYfM_QbfN-V¾O�Y\M�Rsclyq¢ÄR±cvTOa��bf� � NFMOQRUN��oRsT]�RptlOaM�jaOQbf��RUYfOaM�YfM`RsTNwcUV%]�RvY²]�b��OQ[F]�Y\MoYfcN��n��Y�j�]�bfN�M�R RUOu[H��b�RUYfV�b�Y\t�]�RUYfOaM|YfMWPxXUNl�&��N�Mtk^��Oa[�]�YfM��%cUOa[uNkRsT�YfM_uRsT%]�RSg=N:gSYfb�b�XUNkRs�XvM�RUO±b²]�RUN�Xly¢ÄR�Y\cSRUT&��c;N�]QcvYfN�X�RsOu�M��N�XvcvR�]�M�½tlOaM�jaOQbf��RUYfOaM»Y\M�RsNlXU[uc�OQP"Y�RscSPxXvN��n�N�M�tl^»�Oa[�]�YfM|NkÃ+NltlRUc�y

¹�OaM�jaOQbf��RvY\OaM�c�]�XUNHNl�n��Yfj�]�bfN�M�RERUOwbfYfMN�]QX7cUT#YfP�R7YfM�j�]QXvY\]QM�REcv^&cZRsN�[uc � z6>&¢U� � ]FRUOaV�Yftpt�NlM�RsXs]�bRsO±[��t�T»OQP�cvYf_aM%]�b+VXUO&t�NlcUcvYfM_ug�T�Yft�T»g=N7gSYfb�b)OaM#bf^FRsOa�t�T�OaMWT�N�XUN�y�>�]?^w^aOQ�|]�XUN7_QY�jaNlM»] � b²]�t��� Ohr���£cU��t�T½RsT%]�R;g�T�N�M½RUTN�Px��MtlRvY\OaM ����Y\c�Y\M�V��R;RsOuRsTN � O?r�RUTN�Px��MtlRvY\OaM ���=Yfc Oa�#RsV��R��}]QM�g�TNlM|RsT�N:Px��MtlRvY\OaM�� ; Yfc�YfMV�#R?�RsT�N:Px��MtlRvY\OaM�� ; Yfc�Oa��RsV���R?�

��� +�� T +�� ���

� ; +�� T +�� � ; N:cU]h^WRUT%]�R »YfcSbfYfMN�]QX�cUT�Y�P�R�Y\M�j�]QXvY\]QM�R � OaX�z4>#¢U��g�TNlM|Y�R�O � Nl^&c;b�YfMN?]QXZYfR�^Q�

� ��� = � � ; +�� T +�� � ��� = � � ; PxOQX ]�Mn^ � (��]QM��Y�RSY\c�cUT#YfP�R�YfMnj�]QXZY²]�MnR

��� �9& + � (+* + �� +�� T +�� ��� �9& + � (+* + ?�8PxOQX ]�Mn^ � ( 7¢�MpVXU]QtlRvY\tlN~[uOacvR�VT�^#cZY\t�]�b%cZ^#cZRsNl[�c�OQM�bf^�N¡r�T#Y � Y�R�b�Y\MN�]QX�cvT�Y�P�R�YfMnj�]QXZY²]�MnR � NlT%]?jnY\OaX�OÙjQN�X�cvOa[uN

Xs]�M_aN � Y�P£]�R�]�bfbx��y�³%OaX�Nkr�]Q[uV�bfN�bfYfMN�]QXvY�R�^:Y\c�j&YfOQb\]�RsNl�p��N�RsO cs]�RU�Xs]�RvY\OQMHNlþN�tkRsc � [uOacZR�cv^&cZRsN�[uct?]�MMOQR�T]QM��bfNS]QX � YfRUXs]QXZYfb�^�b²]QXv_aN � OaX�MNl_�]�RvYfjQN���YfMV��RUc�y >&Yf[±Yfb\]QXZbf^Q��[�OQcvR�cZ^#cZRsNl[�c�]QXvN~OaM�b�^�cUT�Y�P�RYfMnj�]QXZY²]�MnR7OÙjQN�XEcvOa[uNp�%M�Y�RsNpN¡r#RUN�M�R?y � Mn^|bfYfMN�]QX7cUT#YfP�R7YfM�j�]QXvY\]QM�REcv^&cZRsN�[ t?]QM � NHYf[�V#b\Nl[�NlM�RsN��gSY�RsT»]±t�OaM�jaO�b\��RvY\OQM � g�TN�XvN:RUTN7YfMV��R �½YfcSt�OaM�jaO�bfjQN��|gSY�RsTWRUTN7Px�MtkRUYfOaM Wt�OQ[�V���RsNl� � ^-RUTN� b\]Qt�� � O?r¾�}^nYfNlbf��YfM_-RsTN�Oa��RUV��R ��sy�¹�OQMnjQN�XvcUNlb�^a��]�Mn^»tlOaM�jaOQbf��RUYfOaMqYfc7]Fb�YfMN?]QX cUT�Y�P�R�YfM�j�]QXvY\]QM�Rcv^&cZRsN�[�y

� ��� � "!)���4�!��� �� �� �������� �� ¢�MJRUTNq��YfcUtlXUNlRUNqt?]�cUNQ�;]QcvcU�[uNqg=NqT%]?jaNq]`cU�n�%]QXvN��Áº��¼]QXvXs]?^ � cs]�[�V#b\Nl�ÁPx�MtlRvY\OQM¾� �� � ( # �¶�� ��� ���£¶�� � �"�£]QM� � � � ( # Yfc;]�RSb\N�]QcvR ]QcSb\]QXU_QN:]Qc � ]�RSbfN?]�cvR���º����sy  N:�Nl�MN

��� !#(+*(# /�� � �� ! �� � ��" ! �

� � & +$# � /Q·&% = � (�* +$# ��/a·&% = # � � ( #RsO � NERsTN:��YfcUtlXUNlRUN�tlOaM�jaOQbf��RvY\OaM|OQP��.]QM��� � g�TNlXUN # & %HYfcSRsTNEYfM�RsN�_QN�X;V%]QXvR�O�P & �sy

� T%]�R~Yfc��#N?]Qt�TWV}OQYfM�R & � (+* �~OQP ��� &)(+*$# Yfc~O � Rs]�YfMN�� � ^»d´V#b²]QtkY\M�_m -t�NlM�RsN�XvN��»]�R & � (+* �~OhjQN�X��"�]QM�Wcv�[u[±Y\M_±RUTN7VXvO#���tlRscSO�P)RsTN�YfM��Y�jnY\���%]�b)NlMnRUXvYfN�c�OQP �½]�M���y�¢ÄR~Y\c=RsXvY�jnY²]�b+RsOpg�XZYfRUNE]pcUNkROQP"MN�cZRsNl�|bfO#OaV�c�RUOu�O±RsT�Yfc tlOa[uV��Rs]�RUYfOaM�y

� � & �� �� & � � � � & ��� &���� � * ����� * � � � � * ��� &��('*) � /{¶

ã �

Page 15: edges - University of Wisconsin–Madisonpages.cs.wisc.edu/~dyer/ai-qual/huttenlocher-edges95.pdfN cv t T|RUT Y\M _ac ]Qc N _QN NlRsNltlRvY\OaM|]QM cZRsN XvN OaV cvYfc y T N=V XUO&t

� ��� ����� ¶�� � + ã���� � ����� ¶�� � + ã��('*) � / '*) � = � � & +$# � /Q·&% = � (�* + # ��/a·&% = # �� � ( #��� &)(+*(# / '*) �

O�RsN±RsT%]�R�RUTN�XvN�Yfc�]QM�Y\cvcU�N�OQP~T�OÙg1RsO»t�TO&OacUNuRsTNu[±YfM�Y\[��[ ]QM�.[�]�r&Y\[��[ jQ]�b\�Nlc�O�P=RUTNY�RsN�XU]�RUYfOaM�jQ]�XvY\] � bfN�c & ]�M� * y�¹=bfN?]�Xvb�^�RUTN�cvN~�N�V}N�M��pOaM�RUTN�N¡r&RsN�M�R�O�P � � � ( #¾� � º � ��]QM� �� � ( #� ��º ����� � ��R=RsTNk^-]�b\cvOp�N�V}N�M��WOaMwRsT�N�[uNlRUTO#�FRsT%]�R=Y\c=�cUNl�-RsOp��NlRsNlXU[±YfMN�j�]�bf�N�c�deOa��RUcvYf�NQm#OQPRsT�N�N¡r#RUN�M�REOQP�"y�³%OaX�Nkr�]Q[uV�bfNQ�}YfP & ]QM� * XU]QM_aN�OhjaNlX � �cvR;RsT�N�bfO#t�]�RUYfOaMc�RsT]�R�V#b²]QtlNp]�b�b�OQP YfMcvYf�N~OQP ����RsT�N�M & � � �-]QM� * � � �w]QXUN # � /a· %n�a]QM�� & ��� & ]QM�� * ��� & ]QXvN � + # ��/a·&%ny�� Ohg�NkjaNlX��Y�R;Yfc ]�b\cvOFV}OacvcvY � b\N:RsO�deV%]Q��m£Oa��RUcvYf�N:RsTN�]QXvXs]?^ �"�RsOuO � R�]�YfM½]�M½]QXvXs]?^ �FRUT%]�R�Yfc;RUTN:cs]Q[uN�cvYf��N]Qc �"y � T#Y\cE]�[�OQ�M�Rsc RUO-T%]QM���bfYfM_wRUTNHcZYfRU�%]�RvY\OaM�c�g�TN�XvN |Yfc7V¾OQcvY�RUYfOaMN��½V%]QXvRvY²]�bfb�^»Oa��RscZY\��NpOQP��]Qc�cUV}N�tkY²]�b�t�]QcUNlc�y8¢�M½]�Mn^WYf[uV�bfN�[uN�M�R�]�RUYfOaM��%RsTNlcUN � OQ�M�%]QXZ^-YfcUcU��N�c7]�XUN7jaNlXv^WYf[uV¾OaXZR�]QM�R�y

� T�YfcE��Y\cvt�XvNlRsNutlOaM�jaOQbf��RUYfOaM�YfcF¬ � ª Ak® C ¯�g�T%]�R7g=Npg=N�XUN±��OQY\M�_-gSYfRUTqRsTNHRUN�[uV�b\]�RsNlc7PxOaX7tlOa[p V��RvY\M�_»RUTNuz�]QV�b\]QtlY\]QM�Y\M�RsT�N�V�XUNljnYfOa�c�cUNltlRUYfOaM�y � T%]�R�Yfc��)YfM�OaXU�NlXERsO�t�Oa[uV�#RsN±RsTNu��YfcUtlXUNkRsN]QVV�XUO?r&Y\[�]�RvY\OaM�RsOuRsT�N�z�]QV#b²]QtkY²]�M���g=N�cvNlR�RsTN�]QXvXs]?^��� � ( # RsO � NERsTN:[�]QcU�

ã � ã�  Z·�¶ �

ã � ãPxXUOQ[ RsT�NWVXUNkj&YfOa�c�cUNltlRvY\OaM+�~]QM��[�]Q��N�RUTN»]QXUXU]?^ � � � ( #S� N-RsT�N�Yf[�]Q_aN���$ �'&)(�* �sy � TNlM(RUTNt�OQMnjQOQbf��RUYfOaM���� � ( # Yfc � RUTN:��Y\cvt�XvNlRsN�]QVV�XUO?r&Y\[�]�RvY\OaM|OQP¡��RsTN�z�]QV�b\]QtkY²]QM»OQP�RsTNEYf[�]Q_aNQ� . ; $£�. ; $ ) $�� � ( # � �� � ( # 7

¢�M±RsTNSVXvNljnYfOa�c8cUNltlRUYfOaM±g=N;��N�XvY�jaNl��RUT�Yfc�[F]�cU�p]�c8]QMu]QVVXvO?r#Yf[�]�RUYfOaMuRsO7RUTNSz�]QV�b\]QtlY\]QM . ; �RsTn�c=g�N7T]hjQN�YfM�]�XUOQ�M�%] � Oa��R�cUOaXZR~OQP)g�]?^wcvTOhg�M-RsT%]�R~��YfcUtlXUNlRUNEt�OaM�jQOQb\�#RUYfOaMWt?]QM � N7��cUN��-RUOt�OQ[�V���RsNp�%M#YfRUN±��YfþN�XvN�MtlN�c � ]�VVXUO?r&Yf[F]�RUYfOaMc7RsOw�N�XZYfj�]�RvYfjQN�OQV¾NlXs]�RUOaXUc¡�@� � T%]�R�Y\cl���N�XZYfj�]�RvYfjQN�c]QXvN � �cZRHb�Y\MN�]QXHcvT�Y�P�RHYfMnj�]QXZY²]�MnR�Px�MtkRUYfOaMc��8]�M�3RUT&��cpt�OaM�jQOQb\�#RUYfOaMc±t?]�M � Nw�cvN��oRsO|t�Oa[uV�#RsNRsT�N�[�y`¢�M�P�]QtkR?��RsT�Yfc±Y\cpRUXU�N-YfM�RsTNWtlOaM�RUYfMn�Oa�cut?]�cUN»]Qcpg=Nlb�b �$� �#R±g�N�MNlN���RsOqYfMnRUXUO&��tlN��Px�MtkRUYfOaMc¡��y~¢ÄR�Yfc;g=OaXvRUT|XvN�[uN�[ � NlXvYfM_wRUT%]�R ��YfþN�XvN�M�RUY\]�RvY\OaM»Y\c ]±R�^#V}N�OQP�tlOaM�jaOQbf��RUYfOaM��£RsT]�R�Y\cl���Y�Ã+NlXUNlMnRvY²]�RUYfOaM|Yfc;] C ¨ �+¬UªQ¥H¦@?%¬k¥vªQ®�¦�¥ � z6>&¢�cv^&cZRsN�[-�sy  N�XvNlRU�XUM�RsO±RsT#Y\cSPx�XZRsTNlX � NlbfOhg:y� � � ����� � ��� � �� " � � �� �� �������� �� Ohg1g�Nug~]�MnR:RUO|�cvN±RsTNut�OQMnjQOQbf��RUYfOaM`OQV¾NlXs]�RUOaX7RsO»cU[uO&OQRsT���OaX7bfOhg�V%]Qcvc��b�RsNlX��"]QM�Y\[�]Q_QNuYfMOaXv�N�X~RUO�T]QM��bfN:VXUO � b\Nl[ OQP"T�Y\_QT# ÄPxXvN��n�N�M�tl^Wj�]QXvY\]�RvY\OaM � cs]Q[uV�b�Y\M�_F��Y�þN�XUNlMt�Nlc;PxXvOa[ÕOQMNEV�Yµr�NkbRsO�RsTN7M�Nkr&Rl�sy � T#Y\c~g�]Qc�RUTNEVXUO � b\Nl[ RUT%]�R�[�O�RUY�jQ]�RsN��W��c~RsOptlOaMcvYf�NlXSt�OaM�jaO�b\��RvY\OQM�YfM-RsT�N��%XUcZRV�b\]Qt�N�y �icZY\[uV�bfNk �b\O&Oa��Y\M�_|g�]h^�RUO|��O»RUT�Y\c:cvOaXvR�OQP�cU[uO#O�RsT�YfM_�Y\cERsO»cvYf[uV�b�^.]hjQN�XU]Q_aNuRsOa_aNkRsTNlXMNkY\_aT � OaXvYfM_:j�]�b\��N�c�y � T�Y\c�t?]�M � N;]Qt�tlOa[uV�b�Y\cvTN���gSYfRUTw]QM �±º �|[�]Qcv�HRsT]�R8T%]Qc�RsT�N�j�]�bf�N ã / � ;]�R�N�]Qt�T|bfO#t�]�RUYfOaM�y8³%OaXSN¡r�]Q[uV�b\N��}]±PxOQ�X � ^WPxOa�X~jaNlXUcZY\OaM|OQP"cU�t�T½]�[�]Qcv�wg�OQ��b\� � N

ã ã À ã ã À ã ã À ã ã Àã ã À ã ã À ã ã À ã ã Àã ã À ã ã À ã ã À ã ã Àã ã À ã ã À ã ã À ã ã À

ã ¸

Page 16: edges - University of Wisconsin–Madisonpages.cs.wisc.edu/~dyer/ai-qual/huttenlocher-edges95.pdfN cv t T|RUT Y\M _ac ]Qc N _QN NlRsNltlRvY\OaM|]QM cZRsN XvN OaV cvYfc y T N=V XUO&t

¹�OaM�jaO�bfjnYfM_`RsT#Y\cu[�]QcU�£���� � ( # ��gSY�RsTJ]QM�Y\[�]Q_aN � � � ( # t�Oa[uV��RUN�c�RsTN»]?jaNlXs]Q_aN�j�]�bf�N�OÙjQN�XF]� º � MNkY\_QT � OaXvTO#O&�-PxOaX=N?]Qt�T�XUNlcU��b�RUYfM_±bfO#t�]�RUYfOaMWOQP ��� � ( #���� ^-cvYf[uV�b�^WcU�[u[±YfM_ ã / ã ÀHO�P"N�]Qt�TOQP ã À|j�]�b\��N�ck�sy �;OÙg=NljQN�Xl��RUTNwcv���NlM�RUXU�M�t?]�RvY\OaM`OQP~RsT#Y\cp[�]Qcv�3T]QcH�M#PxOaXvRU�M%]�RUNFPxXUNl�n�N�Mtk^�Oa[�]�YfM½NkÃ+NltlRUc � YfR t?]Q��cUN�c T�Yf_aT# ÄPxXvN��n�NlMtl^|MOQYfcUN � g�T�Yft�TqY\c;�nMOhg�M�]Qc �EY �� c VTNlMOa[uN�MOQM��OaX±XZY\M_�Y\M_&��y  T�Y�b\N»]�PxOaXU[�]�b~�N�XZYfj�]�RvY\OaM�OQP;RsT#Y\c±P�]QtkR�Yfc � Nk^aOaM��(RUTN�cUt�OQV¾N�OQP;RsT�Yfcut�Oa��XUcUN��YfMnRU��Y�RUY�jaNlb�^3OaMN�t?]QM3cUN�Nug�T�^�RsT�Yfc�Yfc�RUXU�N�y ��c:RsT�NF[�]Qcv� � � ( # Yfc�cvT�Y�P�RsN��o]Qt�XvOacUc:RsTNuYf[F]�_aN� � � ( # ��MO�Y\cvNW]�R�RsTNFN��_aNlcpOQP�]»_QY�jaN�M�[�]Qcv��V¾OacZYfRvY\OQM`gSYfb�b~V�XUO&��t�NFcvYf_aM�Y��%t?]�MnRpMOQYfcUNFYfM`RUTNOa��RUV��R�Æ � Nlt?]Q�cvN-RsTNwMOQYfcv^.jQ]�b\�NFgSYfb�b � N-V%]QXZRpOQPSRUTN-cv�[ ]�RHOaMN-V}OacZYfRvY\OaM`OQPSRsTNw[F]�cU�£�]QM�oRUTN�M�tlOa[uV�b\NkRsNkbf^�] � cUNlMnRuPxXvOa[ RsTNWcv�[ ]�RHRsTNWMN¡r&RuV¾OacZYfRvY\OQM�OQP�RsTN-[�]Qcv�£y�L7MNwg�]?^RsO�]?jQOQY\��RUT�Y\cEV�XUO � bfN�[ Y\c RsO-g=NlYf_aT�R�RUTNptlOaM�RsXvY � ��RvY\OQMc:OQP8jQ]�b\�Nlc7P�]QXvRUTN�X PxXUOa[ RsTNHt�N�M�RUN�X:OQP[�]QcU� � ^Fb\NlcUcly � TNlM½]�c~RsTNE[�]Qcv�wY\cScvT�Y�P�RsN��|]�bfOaM_�#RsTNlXUN7YfcSOaM�b�^�]HjaNlXv^Wcv[F]�bfb�t�T%]�M_aN�]�R~RUTN� Oa�M�%]�XvYfN�cSg�TN�XvN�j�]�bf�Nlc�]QXvNpd´M�O�bfOaM_aNlX�cUNlbfN�tkRsNl��m � ^WRUTN:[�]QcU�£y

 N �cUN�] �:]Q�cUcZY²]�MFRsOH�O�RUT�Y\c�g�NkY\_QTnRvY\M�_ � OQRUTN�X8Px�MtkRUYfOaMc�g=OaXU�±RUO#O#�sy�¢�M-OQMN���Yf[uN�McZY\OQM��RsT�N �:]Q�cvcvY\]QM�Y\c�_QY�jaNlM � ^

��� �'& � / ã� · �������

�� � � 7� T�Yfc-Y\c-RUTNqt�]QMOaM�Yft?]�bHd � Nkbfbµ �cvT%]QV}N���m~OQX½d´M�OaXU[�]�b$m���YfcvRUXvY � ��RvY\OaM�]Qcw�cUNl��YfM�cvRs]�RUYfcvRvY\tlc�y � TN[�]�r&Y\[��[ j�]�bf�N~Yfc=]�RUR�]�Y\MNl�u]�R ��� � ¶&���QRUTN~Px�MtkRUYfOaM±Y\c�cZ^&[�[uNkRsXvYft ] � OQ��R8¶��n]QM���� ��� �9& � ' & /ã � RUTN:]QXUN�]p�M�NlXSRsTN7Px�M�tlRUYfOaM�Y\c ã ��y � TN:V%]QXU]Q[uNlRUN�X � t�OaM�RUXUOQbfcSRsTNpd gSY\�#RsT�m%OQP�RUTNEt��XZjaN7ÆRsT�N�b²]�XU_aNlX�RsTN7j�]�bf�N7O�P � RsTNEcZb\Ohg=N�X~RsT�N7Px�MtlRvY\OQM�]QVVXvO�]Qt�TNlc�¶±]Qc & � � � ]QM�� & � +�� �sy

¢�M»R�g=O���Y\[uNlMcvYfOaMcl�}RUTN ��]Q��cUcvY\]QM»t?]QM � N���Nl�%MNl�q]Qc

��� �'&)(+* ��/ 㷠��� ; � ���

���������� � �

OaXSNl�&�#Yfj�]�bfN�M�RUb�^��� ��� ��/ ã

· ��� ; ���� �� � �g�TNlXUN � Y\cSRUTN:��Y\cZR�]QM�t�N:PxXUOa[ RsTN:OaXZY\_QYfM��%XU]�RsTNlX~RsT%]�M|N¡r�V#bfYftlY�R �9&)(+* ��t�O&OaXU��YfM%]�RUN�cly

OQRUN~]Q_a]�Y\M�RsT%]�R���� ��� �9&)(+* ��/ ã y�LEM�N�NlþN�tkR�OQPRUT�Yfc"Yfc�RsT%]�R���� ��� �'&)(+* � � � �'&)(+* � ' & ' * /��� � �9&)(+* � ' & ' * y)¢�MpO�RsTNlX�g=OaXU��c��atlOaM�jaOQb�jnY\M_7] �:]Q�cUcZY²]�M�gSY�RsT±]QM�OQRsTNlX�Px��MtlRvY\OaM�gSYfb�b#VXUNlcUN�XZjaNRsT�N�]�XUN?]±�M��N�X�RsTN:OaXZY\_�Y\M%]�b�Px�MtkRUYfOaM�y

¢�MqRsTN���YfcUt�XvNlRUN±t?]QcvN�g=NHgSY\cvT�RsOFPxOQXU[ cUOa[uNpcvOaXvR�OQP�[�]Qcv�}��]QM%]�bfOa_aOa��c RsO�RsTNFd ]?jaNlXs]Q_�Y\M_�m[�]QcU�|t�OaM�cvYf�N�XvN��3] � OhjQNpRsT%]�R7T%]Q�qj�]�bf�N�c:OQP ã / � ; ]�R7N�]Qt�T�b\O&t?]�RvY\OQM�y  T�YfbfNpRsT�N ��]��cUcZY²]QM�Yfc�Nk�%MN��|]QtlXUOacvc�RUTNEN�M�RvY\XvN���Oa[�]�Y\M � +�� ( � # �&Y\M�VXU]QtlRvY\tlN:g=N:t?]QMWRUXU�Mt�]�RsN7RUTN7Px�MtkRUYfOaM|]�P�RsNlXcUOQ[�NSV}OQYfM�R?� � N�t�]Q�cUN~RUTN~j�]�bf�N~OQP ��� � N�tlOa[uN�c�jaNlXv^±cv[�]�bfb � Nk^aOaM���cvOa[uN~j�]�b\��NQy�¢�M±_aNlMN�XU]�b�g=N�cvN�� + � �#( � � # � � Nlt?]Q�cvNERsTN7j�]�bf�N:OQP ��� � � � ��Yfc~jaN�XZ^WtlbfOacvN:RUOu��N�XvOy� O�RsN7RsT]�RSYfP�g=NERsXU��Mt?]�RUNRsT�N �:]Q�cvcvY\]QM�RsO&O��n��Yft���bf^ � cs]?^�]�R"!E· � ���RUTN�M�g=N�_QNlR�RsTN:cU]Q[uN�NkÃ+NltlR;RsT%]�R�O#tlt��Xvc;g�TNlM»g=NcvYf[uV�b�^w]?jQN�Xs]�_aN�ÆpRUTN;j�]�bf�Nlc�M�N?]QX8RsTN�Nl�_aN�OQP+RUTN�[�]QcU�u]QXvN�XUNlb\]�RvYfjQNlb�^�b\]QXv_aN;]QM�uRsTn�c=]�_aO&O&��N�]�b8OQP=T�Y\_QT.PxXvN��n�N�M�tl^.MOQYfcUNuY\c:VXvO#���t�Nl�3g�TNlM.RUTNF[�]Qcv�½Yfc�cvT�YfP�RUN���PxXUOa[ OaMNuV¾OQcvY�RUYfOaM.RUORsT�N�M�Nkr&R?y

� TN:��YfcUt�XvNlRUNlb�^Wcs]Q[uV�bfN���Px�MtkRUYfOaM��OQX~[�]QcU�£�cvTOa��bf��cU�[ÕRUO ã � �cZRSbfYf�QNEYfM-RsTNEtlOaM�RUYfM&��Oa�ct?]�cUN � g�T�N�XUN±RUTNHYfMnRUN�_aXU]�b�OhjaNlX7RsTN±NlM�RUYfXUN±�Oa[�]�YfM�Y\c ã ��y � TNucvYf[uV�bfN�cvR:g�]?^½RsOW��O-RsT�Yfc7Y\c7RUO

ã À

Page 17: edges - University of Wisconsin–Madisonpages.cs.wisc.edu/~dyer/ai-qual/huttenlocher-edges95.pdfN cv t T|RUT Y\M _ac ]Qc N _QN NlRsNltlRvY\OaM|]QM cZRsN XvN OaV cvYfc y T N=V XUO&t

t�OQ[�V���RsN:RsTN:�M& �MOaXv[�]�bfYf��Nl� �:]Q�cvcvY\]QM

� � � � ( # / � ����� ������� �� � �PxOaXEN�]Qt�T.YfM�RsNl_aN�X�_aXvYf��V¾O�Y\M�R � � ( �����g�TNlXUN � ]QM� |Xs]�M_aNuOhjaN�X ! � ��� Y$yeN�yf�)RsT�N�OQXvYf_QY\M � ¶ ( ¶&��Yfc]�RSRUTN:t�N�M�RUN�X;OQP"RUTN:[�]QcU���y � TNlM|N�]Qt�T½Nkb\Nl[�NlM�R Yfc���YfjnYf�N�� � ^wRsTN:cU��[ OQP�]�bfb�RUTN:NlbfN�[uN�M�RUc��YfM�OaXU�NlX7RsO-^nYfNlbf�3]-M�OaXU[�]�b�Y\�lN�� � cU]Q[uV�bfN��¾� �:]Q�cUcZY²]�Mqg�T�Y\t�T.cU��[�cERUO ã y � T%]�R7Yfc�� ��� � � ( # /� � � � ( # /��S�#g�TN�XvN�� /�

� " � � � � ( # y³%OaXSNkr�]Q[uV�bfNQ�Y�P � /�¶ 7 ¸HRsT�N�M�g�N:O � Rs]�YfM|]u¸pº½¸p[F]�cU� � gSYfRUT|tlN�M�RsNlX ]�R � ¶ ( ¶n��]QM��Oa��RSRUO! � � / !:·n�sy � TN:jQ]�b\�Nlc�cU�[ RUO ã ]QM��»RUTN:N�M�RsXZY\Nlc�]QXvN:cv^&[u[�NkRsXZY\t�] � Oa��RSRsT�N�OQXvYf_QY\M �

À#y � À �   � ·#y � ¶ �   ¸ ·#ye¶ �   � ·#y � ¶ �  Z¸ À�y � À �   �·&y � ¶ �   ¸ ¶�ye¶ ãaã ¿ ¶�ye¶ � ¿ ¶�ye¶ ãaã ¿ ·#y � ¶ �  Z¸·&y´¶ �   � ¶�ye¶ � ¿ ¶�yeÀ ã � ¶�ye¶ � ¿ ·#ye¶ �   �

·&y � ¶ �   ¸ ¶�ye¶ ãaã ¿ ¶�ye¶ � ¿ ¶�ye¶ ãaã ¿ ·#y � ¶ �  Z¸À#y � À �   � ·#y � ¶ �   ¸ ·#ye¶ �   � ·#y � ¶ �  Z¸ À�y � À �   �

¢ÄPSg=N�]QcUcv�[uN-RsT%]�R�RsT�Yfcp[�]Qcv� ��� � � ( # YfcHY\M��Nkr#N���PxXvOa[ + � � RUO � � � Y�y NQy���RsT�N-OaXvYf_QYfMoOQPSRUTN[�]QcU��Yfcp]�R�YfRUcHtlN�M�RsNlXk����g�T#Y\t�T�YfM`RsT�YfcHt�]QcUNFY\c + ·»RUO�·#��RsTNlMoRsTNFt�OaM�jQOQb\�#RUYfOaM�OQP~RUTNw[�]Qcv�gSY�RsT�RsTNEYf[F]�_aNEY\c�_QY�jaNlM � ^

$��� &)(+*(# / ���

! � � ����

" ! � � �$�� & = � (+* = # ��� � � ( # 7 � � �

� T�Yfc�XvN�cU�#bfRvY\M_7]QXUXU]h^ $��� &)(+*(# Y\c�];bfOhg�V%]QcUc��b�RsN�XvN�� � OaX�cU[uO#O�RsTNl�¾�+jQN�XvcvYfOaM±OQP�RUTN�O�P�RsT�N�OaXZY\_QYfM%]�bYf[F]�_aN $£y�³�Y\_a��XUN�¸�cUT�OÙg�c~]�cU[uO&OQRsT�N��FjQN�XvcvYfOaMWOQP+RUTN Yf[�]Q_aN�PxXUOa[i³�Y\_a��XUN ã ��g�TN�XvN�RsTN�Yf[F]�_aNT%]Qc � N�NlM|tlOaM�jaOQb�jaNl�½gSYfRUTq] �:]Q�cUcZY²]�M|OQP � / � y�¹�Oa[uV%]�XUN:YfRSgSY�RsT»RsTN:OaXZY\_QYfM%]�b+Y\[�]Q_aN�y

� TN�XvN»Yfc�]�RUXs]Q��N�OQà � NlR�g=N�NlMJRsT�N»cZY\�lN � OQP ��� ]QM��RsTN»] � Y�b�YfR�^�RUO.cvV%]�RvY²]�b�b�^�b\O&t?]�RUN»]QMNljQN�M�R?y½¢ÄP � Yfc�b\]QXU_aN��"g=N-MO½bfOaM_QN�X�XUN?]�bfb�^ de�nMOhg:m"g�TNlXUNFcUOa[uN-NkjaN�M�R � cU�t�T(]Qc�]½t�T%]�M_aNFYfMYfMnRUN�McZYfR�^%�HT%]QVV}N�M�N���� � N�t?]��cUNWRsT]�R±NljQN�M�R�T%]Qc � N�NlM(cv[uO#OQRUTN���Oa�#R � ^o]½P�]QtlRUOaXpXvNlb\]�RsNl��RUO� y � T�Yfc�Y\cvcU�N:gSYfb�b � N�t�OQ[�N:[uOaXvN�]�VV%]QXvN�M�R�g�TN�M�g�N:R�]�b\�w] � OQ��R��cvYfM_�cU[uO&OQRsTNl�»Yf[�]Q_aNlc�PxOQXN���_aN:�NlRUN�tlRvY\OQM��%Y\M�RsTNEPxOQb�bfOÙgSYfM_�cUNltlRUYfOaM�y

�� � ��$� ����� � ����� ���� ��� ��� � $� de��YfXUN�tkR?m�Yf[uV�bfN�[uN�M�R�]�RUYfOaM1O�PF�#Y\cvt�XUNkRsN�t�OQMnjQOQbf��RUYfOaM��±]�cqcUTOhg�M Y\M¼Nl�n�%]�RUYfOaM � � ��XUNl�&�#Y\XvN�c� � � ; � ; ��OaV}N�XU]�RUYfOaMcHPxOQXH]QM � º � [�]Qcv�`]QM���]QM �(º �(Y\[�]Q_aN�y � TNw[F]�cU��Y\cpV}OacZYfRvY\OaM�N��]�R�N?]Qt�T�OQP�RUTN � ; Yf[�]Q_aN�b\O&t?]�RvY\OQMcE]QM� � ; [���b�RUYfV�bf^q]QM��]Q���qOaV}N�Xs]�RUYfOaMcE]QXvNH�OQMN±]�REN�]Qt�TV}OacvY�RUYfOaM�yE¢�MqRUTNpt?]�cUN±OQP �:]Q�cvcvY\]QMc��¾RsTNpOQV¾NlXs]�RUOaX YfcH­h¬ ?�ªQ¥vª���C\¬;]QM�qg=Npt?]�M��cUNpRUT�Y\c P�]QtlR7RUOcUV}N�Nl��VqRUTN�tlOaM�jaOQbf��RvY\OaM � PxOaX�RsT�Yfc XvN�cZRsXvYftlRUN���cvNlR7O�P�cUNlV%]QXs] � b\N�OaV}N�Xs]�RsOaXvck�=RsO�� � � � ; ��y � T�YfcYfc=]EcZY\_aM#Yf�%t�]QM�R�cs]?jnY\M_Qc�� � OQRUT±RsTNlOaXUNkRUYft?]�b�bf^�]�M�±Y\MuVXU]QtlRvY\tlNQ�&OÙjQN�X�RsT�N;�#Y\XvN�tlR8Yf[uV�b\Nl[uN�M�R�]�RvY\OQM�y��M�^|cU[uO&OQRsT�YfM_-[uNkRsTO&� � OQX�N���_aNp�NkRsN�tkRsOaX¡�~RUT%]�R7��cUN�c�cUN�V]QXs] � b\NH��bfRUN�XvYfM_WOaV}N�XU]�RsOQXUc�cvTOa��bf�� N:Yf[uV�bfN�[uN�M�RsNl�½YfM»RUT�Y\c�[�]QMM�N�X�y

ã

Page 18: edges - University of Wisconsin–Madisonpages.cs.wisc.edu/~dyer/ai-qual/huttenlocher-edges95.pdfN cv t T|RUT Y\M _ac ]Qc N _QN NlRsNltlRvY\OaM|]QM cZRsN XvN OaV cvYfc y T N=V XUO&t

³"Yf_a�XUN�¸ �=z)Ohg�V%]Qcvc;��bfRUN�XvYfM_ � cv[�O&OQRUT�Y\M�_#�=]QM�Y\[�]Q_aNEgSY�RsT|] ��]Q��cUcvY\]QM��b�RsN�Xly

 N:MO�RsNERsT%]�R� �'&)(+* ��/ ã

· ��� ; � � �� � ��� ���� ��� / ��� �'&)(+* � ��� �9&)(+* �g�TNlXUN

��� �'&)(+* ��/ ã� · ��� � �

�� � �� ���]QM�

��� �9&)(+* �4/ ã� · ��� � �

�� � ���� ��� 7¢�MqOQRUTN�X�g�OQXU�cl�¾RsT�N�XvOQR�]�RvY\OQM%]�b�bf^�cZ^#[u[uNlRUXvYft �:]Q�cUcZY²]�M�� � �£Y\c � �cvR RsTN�VXvO#���tlR ��� ��� OQP

R�g=OqOaXvRUTOa_aOQM%]�b8OaMN¡ ���Yf[uN�McZY\OQM%]�b ��]Q��cUcvY\]QMcly�¢�M3RsT�Nw��YfcUtlXUNlRUN-t?]�cUNFY�P�g=N-T%]?jQNFR�g=Oqt�OQbf�[uMjaNltlRUOaXUc � � ]QM� � � RsT]�R�t�OaM�R�]�Y\M:j�]�b\��N�c"]QVVXvOhr&Yf[�]�RUYfM_ ��� ]QM� ��� XUN�cvV¾NltlRvYfjQNlb�^a�aRsT�N�M � � �� / �� g�T�N�XUN �-]�VVXUO?r&Yf[F]�RsN�c�RsT�N:R�g=O� Ä��Y\[uNlMcvYfOaM%]�b �:]Q�cvcvY\]QM � ����������

� �

���������� � � # /

�������

���������� 7

� T%]�R;Yfc��£N?]Qt�T|N�M�RsXZ^ � � ( # OQP���Y\c�RsTN�VXvO#���tlR OQP�RUTN �  ÄRUT½NlMnRUXv^�OQP�� � gSY�RsT|RUTN a �RsT�N�M�RUXv^»OQP� � yã �

Page 19: edges - University of Wisconsin–Madisonpages.cs.wisc.edu/~dyer/ai-qual/huttenlocher-edges95.pdfN cv t T|RUT Y\M _ac ]Qc N _QN NlRsNltlRvY\OaM|]QM cZRsN XvN OaV cvYfc y T N=V XUO&t

� OhgÁ��O�g=N��cUN�RsT�Yfc�P�]QtlR�RUO:cUV}N�N��F�VuRsTN�t�OQ[�V���R�]�RvY\OQM��  NSPx�XvRUTN�X8MOQRUNSRsT%]�R � �'&)(�* ��/���� �'&)(+* � � ���� �'&)(+* ����g�T�N�XUN

� �� �'&)(+* ��/ ã� · ��� � �

�� � �� ��� � � * �]QM�

� �� �9&)(+* ��/ ã� · ��� � �

�� � ���� � � � �9& �]QM� ��Y\c�RsTN;�M�Y�R�Yf[uV��bfcUN � OaX � Y\XU]Qt ��Nlb�R�]�Px��MtlRvY\OaM}��y�¢�M�Rs��Y�RUY�jaNkbf^wcUV}N?]Q��YfM_�&RsTN;�M�Y�R�Yf[uV��bfcUNt?]�M � N�RsTOQ�_aT�R�O�P�]Qc � NlYfM_-�lN�XvO-NljQN�Xv^ng�TNlXUNuNkr#tlN�V�R:]�R RUTNHOaXZY\_�Y\M½g�T�N�XUN�YfR;Y\c�deYfM��%M#YfRUNQm�y�¢�MV%]QXZRUYft���b\]QX�Y�R~O � Nk^#c~RUTN�V�XUOaV}N�XZR�^wRsT]�R ���

�� �'& � ' & N��n�%]�b\c ã OhjQN�X�]QM�^�Y\M�RsNlXvj�]�b � � ( # tlOaM�R�]�YfM�YfM_

RsT�N�OQXvYf_QY\M+�%]QM�»N��n�%]�bfc;��N�XvOuOÙjQN�X ]QM�^WOQRUTN�XSYfMnRUN�XZjQ]�b�y � TN:�M�Y�R�Y\[uV�#b\cvN�Yfc�MOQR;]pPx�MtkRUYfOaM»YfMRsT�NEtlb\]QcUcZY\t�]�b)cUNlMcUN�� � Nlt?]Q�cvN7g�NE��O�M�OQRScUV}N�tkYfP�^FYfR � ^-_QYfjnYfM_u]Hj�]�bf�NEOQP � �'& �8PxOaX~N�]Qt�T & y�L7MNg�]h^�RUO»RUT�Y\M���OQP�RUTNF��M�YfR�Yf[�V���b\cvNFYfc�YfM3RUN�Xv[�c�OQP=YfRUc�YfM�RsN�_QXs]�b$�"g�T�Yft�To�Nk�%MNlc�RsT�NF�M#YfR�cvRUN�VPx�MtkRUYfOaM��

) �'& � / � �� � � ��� � ' � (g�TNlXUN ) �'& � / ã PxOaX & ¶�]QM� ) �'& ��/�¶wPxOaX & � ¶�yH¹�OaM�jaNlXUcvNlb�^a�"RUTN±�NlXvY�jQ]�RUY�jaNuOQP ) �'& �SYfc� �'& ��y

¢�MÁNlþN�tkRFg=Nq]�XUN»�cvYfM_3RUTN½��Nlb�R�].Px��MtlRvY\OaMJ]QcF].RsNlt�TM�Yft?]�b�d RsXvYft��£m�RUO3RU�XUM(RsTN»VXUO&��tkR� / ��� ��� YfMnRUO|RUTNwtlOaM�jaOQbf��RUYfOaM � / ���� � ���� y � TN-�NkbfRs]»Px�M�tlRUYfOaM�]�tlRsc�RsO.d´cvNlbfN�tlR�m � �cZROaMN;j�]�b\��N YfM-t�Oa[uV�#RUYfM_HRsT�N�t�OQMnjQOQbf��RUYfOaMFÆ�]�bfb}RsTN OQRsT�N�X8jQ]�b\�NlcS]QXvN �lN�XUO�y �;Nlt?]�b�b¾PxXvOa[ ] � OÙjQNRsT]�R�t�OQMnjQOQbf��RUYfOaM�cU�[uc�RsTNSV�XUO&��tlR8O�P+]�bfbRUTNSNlbfN�[uNlMnRUc=O�P}R�g=OEPx�MtkRUYfOaMc�Y\MuOaXv�N�X�RUOEVXUO&��tlNOaMN�NlbfN�[uN�M�R�OQP)RUTN7Oa��RUV��R=Px�MtlRvY\OQM��cUO�RsTN7��Nlb�R�]HPx�MtkRUYfOaM-t�]QM � N RsTOa��_aT�R~OQP�]Qc�cUNlbfN�tkRUYfM_�]cvYfM_QbfN�NlbfN�[uN�M�R �$� ^W[H�#bfRvY\V�b�^nY\M�_W]�b�b�RsTN:OQRUTN�Xvc � ^��lN�XvO#��y

� Tn�c��� � $ / � � �� � � �� � � $ / � �� � � � �� � $� (

� ^�RsTN�P�]QtlR�RsT%]�R � / ���� � ���� ]QM�3RUTN-]�cUcUO&tlY\]�RvYfjnY�R�^oOQP~RUTNwtlOaM�jaOQbf��RvY\OaM�OQV¾NlXs]�RUOaX�y � T�Yfc[uN?]QM�c�RUT%]�R�YfMFOaXv�N�X�RUO�tlOa[uV��RUN;RUTN�t�OaM�jaO�b\��RvY\OQMwOQP � gSY�RsT $}��g=N t�]QM±Y\M�cvRsN�]Q�F�XUcvR�tlOaM�jaOQb�jaN� �� gSY�RsT $p]QM�FRUTN�M � �� gSY�RsT�RsTN;XUNlcU��b�R � MOQRUN;g=N tlOa��bf�-]�b�RsNlXUM%]�RUY�jaNlb�^��%XUcZR�tlOaM�jaOQb�jaN � �� gSY�RsT$3]QM�oRsT�N�M ���� gSYfRUT�RUTNWXUNlcU��b�R?� � ^`RUTN-tlOa[u[H��Rs]�RUY�jnYfR�^�O�P tlOaM�jaOQbf��RvY\OaM}��y  Tn^3Y\cpRUT�Yfcu]QM]Q��j�]QM�Rs]Q_aN�� N�t�]Q�cUN:[uOacZR�OQP�RsTNENlMnRUXvYfN�c�OQP ���� ]QM� ���� ]QXvNE��N�XvO � ���N7RsOpRsT�NE�Nlb�R�]pPx�MtkRUYfOaMYfM�RUTNW�Nk�%M�Y�RUYfOaM�OQP�RsTNlcUNWPx�MtkRUYfOaMck�s�=[�]QM�^�O�P;RUTNW[H�#bfRvY\V�b�Yft?]�RvY\OaM�cF]�M�(]Q���Y�RUYfOaMc±�O�MO�RMNlN��wRUO � N�V}N�XZPxOaXU[uN��+y�¢ÄR=Yfc�N�]QcvYfN�cZR�RUO�cvN�N RUT�Yfc=YfMFRsT�N ��YfcUtlXUNkRsN7t�]QcUN��#cvOHg�N;MOhg�Rs��XUMFRUO�RUT%]�R?y

 TN�M���Yfcp]QM � º � [�]QcU��PxOaXv[uYfM_½]½��YfcUt�XvNlRUNWcs]Q[uV�b�Y\M�_�OQP � ��RsTNw]QXUXU]?^#c � �� ]�M��� ��� tlOaXUXvN�cvV¾OaM���Y\M�_pRsO�RUTN Px��MtlRvY\OaM�c ���� ]QM� ���� ��OaM�b�^�T%]?jaN � M�OaM��NlXUO±NlMnRUXvYfN�c~N�]Qt�T�y � TN�]QXUXU]h^� �� T]Qc�OaM�b�^WOaMN:XUOhg{OQP�MOQM��NlXUO�N�M�RsXZY\Nlc��}]QM��� �� T]Qc�OaM�b�^WOaMN:t�O�b\�[uM�y � TN�MOaM�lN�XvOFXvOÙg{OQP� �� Yfc � �cvR�RsT�N�OQMNk Ä��Y\[uNlMcvYfOaM%]�b�jQN�tlRUOaX�� � PxXUOQ[ ] � OhjaNQ�}]QM��»RUTN:MOaM�lN�XUO�t�O�b\�[uM|OQP�� �� Y\cSRUTN

ã �

Page 20: edges - University of Wisconsin–Madisonpages.cs.wisc.edu/~dyer/ai-qual/huttenlocher-edges95.pdfN cv t T|RUT Y\M _ac ]Qc N _QN NlRsNltlRvY\OaM|]QM cZRsN XvN OaV cvYfc y T N=V XUO&t

OaMN¡ ���Yf[uN�McZY\OQM%]�b�jaNltlRsOQX � � y � Y²]Q_QXs]Q[u[�]�RUYft?]�bfb�^a���

¶� � � #

� �� �

������� ¶

������� � �

� �������

� �������/

�������

�� ������� 7

>&YfMt�NF]�b�b8OQP=RUTNu��NlXUO»N�M�RsXZY\Nlc�YfM.RUTNut�OaM�jQOQb\�#RUYfOaM`T%]?jQNFMO»NlþN�tkRHOQM�RUTNuOa��RUV��R?�)g=NFt�]QMcvYf[uV�b�^�XUN�V#b²]QtlN � �� gSYfRUT�� � �=]QM� � �� gSY�RsT � � y � Tn�cl��RsTN�tlOaM�jaOQbf��RUYfOaM � � $3t?]QM � N��OQMN� ^��%XUcZR7t�OQMnjQOQb�j&YfM_ $-gSY�RsT�]�t�OQbf�[uM½jQN�tlRUOaX � � ]QM�»RsTNlMqt�OaM�jQOQbfjnYfM_-RsT�NHXUNlcU��b�R�gSY�RsTq]FXUOhgjaNltlRUOaX � � y � TN-R�g�O� ���Yf[uN�McZY\OaM]�b�t�OaM�jQOQb\�#RUYfOaM � � $�YfcpXUNlV�b²]�t�N�� � ^`R�g=O�OaMN¡ ���Yf[uN�McZY\OaM]�bt�OQMnjQOQbf��RUYfOaMcly � ]Qt�T�OQP)RUTNEOaMN¡ ���Yf[uN�McZY\OaM]�b)t�OQMnjQOQbf��RUYfOaMcSYfMnjQOQb�jaN�c � � � � ; ��OaV¾NlXs]�RvY\OQMc���]QM�RsTn�c~RUTNEOhjaNlXs]�b�b�RUYf[uN7RsO±tlOa[uV��RsN7RUTNEt�OQMnjQOQbf��RUYfOaM�T%]Qc � N�NlM»XvN����t�N��WPxXvOa[ � � � ; � ; � � ^wRUTN��YfXUNltlR;[uNlRsT�O#��RsO � � � � ; � � ^WRsT#Y\c�[uNlRUTO#�+y

¢�M:VXs]QtkRUYft�N���RUTN�[uNlRsT�O#��OQP&cU[uO&OQRsT�YfM_ � ^�R�g=O cv�t�tlN�cvcvY�jaN�tlOaM�jaOQbf��RvY\OaM�c�gSY�RsT:OaMN¡ ���Yf[uN�McZY\OQM%]�b[�]QcU�ncSYfcS[H�t�T�P�]QcvRUN�X~RUT%]QM�t�OaM�jQOQb\�#RUYfOaM»gSY�RsT»]pR�g=O� ���Yf[uN�McZY\OQM%]�b�[�]QcU�£y�³%OaX~N¡r]�[�V#b\N��g�TN�M� / ã RsTNpR�g=O� Ä��Y\[uNlMcvYfOaM%]�b�[F]�cU� � Oa��R7RUO ! � � �SYfc � º � �)]QM��qRsTn�c7RsT�Npcs]?jnY\M�_acEY\cE]wP�]�tlRsOQXOQP�] � Oa��Rw¸ � R�g�O ã º � [�]QcU�nc-]�c�OQVV¾OQcUN���RsO.OaMN � º � [�]QcU��syÁ³%OaX � / ·#��YfRuYfcF] � Oa�#Rã ¶FRvY\[uNlc7P�]QcvRUN�X�y ��N�t�]�b�b���T�OÙg=NljQN�Xl��RUT%]�R7RUT�Yfc7[uNlRsT�O#��OaM#bf^|g�OaXv�nc7PxOaX Px�M�tlRUYfOaMc7RUT%]�R�t?]QM � N�Nlt�Oa[uV}OacUNl�|YfMnRUO�RUTN:VXUO&��tkR;OQP"R�g=O�OaMNk Ä��Yf[�NlMcvYfOaM%]�b�Px��MtlRvY\OaM�c � cU�t�T½]Qc~RsTN �:]Q�cvcvY\]QM¾��y

����������� � ������� ��� ��� � $�:]Q�cUcZY²]�MwcU[uO&OQRsT#Y\M_�t?]�M � N ]�VVXUO?r&Yf[F]�RsN��w�&�#YfRUN�]Qtlt��XU]�RsNkbf^±YfM-]�MFNkjaN�Mw[�OQXUN;N���tlYfN�M�R~[�]QM& MNlX�y � TN�tlN�M�RsXU]�bSY\��N?]qPxOaXpRsT�NWcUV}N�N����V Yfc � ]QcvN��(OaM�RsTN-P�]QtkR±RsT%]�R±RsTNWcv�[ OQP�RsT�N»V#Y�r#NlbfcYfM�]�� º `XvN�_QYfOaM�]QXvOa�M�`N?]Qt�T�V�Yµr#Nlb�OQP�]QM`Yf[�]Q_aNFt?]QM � NwtlOa[uV��RUN��oYfM � OaV}N�XU]�RUYfOaMc�V¾NlXV�Yµr#Nlb$���cvYfM_q�#^#M]Q[±Y\t-V�XUOa_aXU]Q[u[±Y\M_�y � T]�RHYfc���RUTN�t�Oa[uV��Rs]�RUYfOaM`Yfc�YfM�NlV¾NlM�NlMnRuO�P�� ]QM���+RsT�N±��Y\[uNlMcvYfOaMc:OQP8RsT�NHgSY\M��Ohg�OhjaNlX7g�T�Y\t�T�RsT�N±cU�[u[�]�RUYfOaM�Yfc7�OaMN�y � T#Y\cEt�]QM�N?]QcZYfb�^ � NcUNlN�MWYfM�RUTN7OaM�Nk ��#Y\[uN�M�cvYfOaM%]�b�t�]QcUN���g�TN�XvN7RsTNEcv�[ YfM�]HgSYfM�Ohg{O�P�gSYf��RUT���t?]QM � N7�V}�%]�RUN��PxXUOQ[ OQMN7cs]�[�V#b\N�RUOHRsT�N7MNkr&R � ^FcvYf[�V#bf^-]Q���YfM_pYfM-OaMN�j�]�bf�N��]QM�Wcv� � RUXs]QtkRUYfM_±Oa��R~]QMOQRUTN�Xly� T�Yfc-Y\c-YfM�NlV¾NlM�NlMnR»OQP���y � cvYfM_�RsT�N�] � OÙjQN��N�tlOa[uV¾OQcvY�RUYfOaM�OQP�cv^&[u[�NkRsXZY\t�Px�MtkRUYfOaMcl�;Y�RYfc�cZRsXs]�Y\_aT�RvPxOaXvg�]QXU�.RsO|cUN�NuRsT]�R�RUTNuR�g�O� Ä��Yf[�NlMcvYfOaM%]�b�t�]QcUNFt?]QM3cvYf[�V#bf^ � NFN¡r�V�XUN�cvcUNl��]Qc�R�g=OOaMN¡ ���Yf[uN�McZY\OQM%]�b�t�OaM�jQOQb\�#RUYfOaMc�y

� �:]Q�cUcZY²]�M±t?]QM � N~]QV�VXUO?r&Y\[�]�RUN���]Qc�RUTN~tlOaM�jaOQbf��RUYfOaM±OQP£cv�t�TucU�[uc�OhjaNlX�gSY\M��Ohg�c � cUOQ[�N¡ RUYf[uN�c�t?]�bfbfN�� � O?rW��bfRUN�XUcl� � Nlt?]Q��cUN:RsTNk^�]Q��»]�b�b�RsT�N:j�]�bf�Nlc�YfM»] � O?r£��y � TN:�NkR�]�Y�b\c�OQP�RsT#Y\c�]QXvNt�OhjQN�XUNl�½YfM�RUTN:V%]QV}N�X � ^  Nkbfbfc�y

� � ���� � <ÙG�0��=476� / 0.2F4 5 4E6�4�9�68>��

� TN3Ž]QXvXZ  �;Y�b\�XvNlRUT�Nl�_aN��NlRUN�tkRsOaX � ¸ # Yfc � ]QcUNl�{OaM�t�OQ[�V���RUYfM_�RsTN���NlXUO�t�XvOacUcZY\M�_ac|O�P�RUTNz�]QV�b\]QtlY\]QM»OQP�RsTN �:]Q�cUcZY²]�M|cv[�O&OQRUTN���Y\[�]Q_QNQ�. ; � ��� � $� 7

·Q¶

Page 21: edges - University of Wisconsin–Madisonpages.cs.wisc.edu/~dyer/ai-qual/huttenlocher-edges95.pdfN cv t T|RUT Y\M _ac ]Qc N _QN NlRsNltlRvY\OaM|]QM cZRsN XvN OaV cvYfc y T N=V XUO&t

³"Yf_a�XUN:À � � T�N�z�]QV#b²]QtkY²]�M|OQP �:]Q�cUcZY²]�M�y

 Nq�nMOhg PxXvOa[ RsTN|VXUNkj&YfOa�cWcvN�tkRUYfOaM�RsT%]�R � O�RsTJRUTN �:]Q�cUcZY²]�M�cU[uO#O�RsTNl�ÁY\[�]Q_aNq]QM�JRUTNz�]QV�b\]QtlY\]QM|t?]QM � N:Y\[uV�bfN�[uNlMnRUN�� � ^�t�OaM�jQOQb\�#RUYfOaM���]�M�q]QXvN�T�N�MtlN�b�Y\MN�]QX�OQV¾NlXs]�RUOaXUcly � Tn�c�� � ^]QcvcUO&tlY\]�RUY�jnYfR�^Wg=N�t�]QM»N��n��Y�jQ]�b\NlMnRvbf^»N¡r�V�XUN�cvc;RUTN:t�Oa[uV�#R�]�RvY\OaM½]Qc��

� . ; ��� � � $ 7� TN�Å|]QXUX   �;Y�bf�XUNkRsTÁNl�_aNq�NkRsNltlRsOQXFYfcwRsTn�c-O�P�RsN�MJXUNlPxNlXUXvN��JRUO�]Qc-]`z�]�V�b²]�tlY\]QMÁOQP �:]Q�cvcvY\]QMOaV}N�XU]�RsOaXl� � N�t?]��cUN . ; ��� � RUTN�z�]QV�b\]QtlY\]QM�OQP ��]Q��cUcvY\]QM¾��Yfc tlOaM�jaOQb�jaNl�½gSY�RsT�RsTNEYf[F]�_aNQ�D$£y

� TNwOQMNk Ä��Y\[uNlMcvYfOaM%]�b=z�]QV�b\]QtkY²]QM3OQP �:]Q�cvcvY\]QM.OaV¾NlXs]�RUOaXEY\c:Y�bfbf�cvRUXs]�RUN��.Y\M`³"Y\_Q�XUN�À�y � TNR�g=O� ���Yf[uN�McZY\OQM%]�b�OaV}N�XU]�RsOQX�Y\c�XUOQRs]�RUYfOaM%]�b�b�^|cZ^&[�[uNkRsXvYft�] � Oa��R�RUTNpOaXZY\_�Y\M���]QM�qYfc7OQP�RsNlM�t?]�b�bfN��RsT�Nud Å|N¡r#Yft?]�M½T%]�R�m%OaV}N�Xs]�RsOaX � N�t�]Q�cUN�OQP�YfRUc;]QVV}N?]QXU]QMt�N�y

� TN�z�]QV�b\]QtlY\]QM»OQP ��]Q��cUcvY\]QM»t?]QM � N:]QVVXvO?r#Yf[�]�RsNl� � ^�]±��Y�Ã+NlXUNlMt�N:OQP�R�g�O �:]Q�cUcZY²]�Mc�y8¢�MRsT�N�OQMNk Ä��Y\[uNlMcvYfOaM%]�b�t�]QcUNERsT#Y\c�Y\c

� � � ����� ( � � / ã� · ����� ���

�� ��� � +ã

� · ��� ���

�� � � � (g�T�Yft�Tq]QV�VXUO?r&Y\[�]�RUN�c ]±cUN�tlOaM�»�N�XZYfj�]�RvYfjQN�OQV¾NlXs]�RvY\OaMWg�TNlXUN ��� � �

� _QN�MNlXs]�b�bf^ �

/ ��� ) ã 7 À&��y

�iM&��[ � N�X�OQP � YfOQbfOa_QYft?]�b�jnYfcvYfOaM.cv^&cvRUN�[uc±]QVV}N?]�X7RsO»t�Oa[uV��RUNF�#YfþN�XvN�MtlNFOQP �:]Q�cUcZY²]�Mc�YfMRsT�NlYfX bfOÙg~ �b\NkjaNkb�jnY\cv�%]�b"VXUO&t�NlcUcZY\M_�y � T�Yfc g�]Qc;RsTN�OaXvYf_QYfM%]�b�[uOQRUY�j�]�RUYfOaM|PxOQX�RUTN±Å|]QXUX   �;Y�bf�XUNkRsTN���_aNWOaV}N�Xs]�RsOaX�Æ3RUTN-P�]QtlRHRsT%]�R�] � Y\OQbfOa_QYft?]�bS[uN�t�T%]QM#Y\cv[ T%]Q� � N�N�M�Yf�N�M�RUY��%Nl�(g�T�Yft�T g=Oa��bf�cU��VV¾OQXvR�]`cZY\[±Y�b²]�XwR�^&V¾N�OQP:V�XUO&t�N�cvcvYfM_�RsO`RUTN . ;�� OaV}N�XU]�RsOQX�y ¹�Oa[uV�#RsN�XFj&YfcvYfOaM�XUNlcUN�]QXUt�TT%]Qc~RUOpj�]QXv^nYfM_u�N�_aXvN�Nlc � NlN�M�[uOQRUY�j�]�RsNl� � ^qd g=NlR�g�]QXUN�m � OaX � Y\OQbfOa_QYft?]�b)cv^&cvRUN�[uck� � OQRsTWRUTXUOa��_aTMNl�XUOaV�Tn^&cZY\OQbfOa_QYft?]�b XvN�cv��bfRUcw]�M��Vcv^&t�TOaV�Tn^&cZY\t�]�b7XvN�cU�#bfRUc�y  T�YfbfNWYfR±Yfcu_aN�M�N�Xs]�bfb�^���Y ��t���b�RFRUOPxOaXv[H��b\]�RsNu]WVXvN�tkY\cvN�tlOa[uV��Rs]�RUYfOaM%]�b�[�O&�Nkb�OQP�] � Y\O�b\Oa_�Y\t�]�b�cv^&cZRsN�[���RsTN±N¡r&Y\cZRsN�M�t�N�OQP�V]QXvRvY\t¡ ��b\]QX±VT�^&cvYfOQbfOa_QYft?]�b;[uNlRUTO#��c�t�]QM(cUN�XZjaN|]Qc�]�_a��Yf�NWPxOaX±V¾O�RsN�M�RvY²]�bS]�b\_QOaXvY�RsT[ucly >#Oa[uNWj&YfcvYfOaMXUNlcUN�]QXUt�TNlXUcE]�XU_a�N:PxOaX ]�RvY\_aT�R t�Oa��V�bfYfM_-O�P�t�OQ[�V���R�]�RvY\OQM%]�b�j&YfcvYfOaMq[uNkRsTO&�c RUO � YfOQbfOa_QYft?]�b�cZ^#c  RsNl[uc���YfM½RsT�Yfc7tlOa�XUcvNHg=NHgSYfb�b�jnYfNlg°cU��t�T.cZ^&cvRsNl[uc�]�c�VXvOÙjnYf��YfM_-Y\M�RUN�XUNlcvRvY\M_�XvNlb\]�RsNl�q[uNlRsT�O#�cl�� ��R�gSY�bfb�M�OQR�RsXv^FRsO��Xs]?g{tlbfOacUN:V%]QXU]�b�b\Nkb\c � NkR�g�NlN�M½]QXvRvYf�%tkY²]�b�]QM�»M%]�Rs��Xs]�b�jnYfcvYfOaM½cZ^&cvRsNl[uc�y

� TN . ;���� OaV}N�XU]�RsOaX�Yfc�]�cvN�tlOaM���N�XZYfj�]�RvYfjQNQ�#]QM�uRsTn�c8RsTNSV}OaXvRvY\OQMc8OQP¾RUTN�OaXvYf_QYfM%]�bYf[�]Q_aN��$£��g�TN�XvN-RsTNlXUN�]QXvN-Xs]�V�Y\�oYfM�RsNlMcvY�R�^�t�T%]QM�_aN�cpgSY�bfb~cUTOhg �V�]Qcp�lN�XUO�tlXUOacvcvYfM_acuOQP . ; ��� � $� t�T]QM_aNlc;YfM½cZY\_aM}��y � T�N�cUN���NlXUO�t�XUOQcUcvYfM_ac�]QXUNERUTN�M»RsTN±deN��_aNlc�m}OQP�RUTNEY\[�]Q_QNQy�¢�M�RsT�N���YfcUtlXUNkRsNt?]�cUNQ�%RUTN:VXUO&t�NlcUcvYfM_�cvRUN�Vc�PxOaX~RsT#Y\c;N��_QN���NlRsNltlRvY\OaM|[uNlRsT�O#�|]QXUN��

ã y >#[uO&OQRsT-RUTN7Yf[F]�_aN � ^Wt�OQMnjQOQbf��RUYfOaMWgSYfRUT ��� � �cUN7RUTNEOaMN¡ ���Yf[uN�McZY\OQM%]�b)�Nlt�Oa[uV}OacvY�RUYfOaMPxXvOa[8>#NltlRvY\OaM½¿&��y

· ã

Page 22: edges - University of Wisconsin–Madisonpages.cs.wisc.edu/~dyer/ai-qual/huttenlocher-edges95.pdfN cv t T|RUT Y\M _ac ]Qc N _QN NlRsNltlRvY\OaM|]QM cZRsN XvN OaV cvYfc y T N=V XUO&t

³�Y\_a��XUN �8z�]QV�b\]QtkY²]QM»OQP ��]��cUcZY²]QM»N���_aN�c�PxOaX�]QMWYf[F]�_aNQy

·#y � VV�b�^»RUTNpz�]QV#b²]QtkY²]�M½RsO�RsTN�XUNlcU��b�REOQP�RUTN�VXUNkj&YfOa�c�cvRsNlV � ��cvYfM_-t�OQMnjQOQbf��RUYfOaMqgSY�RsT½RUTN[�]Qcv�wPxXUOa[8>#N�tkRUYfOaMq·���y

¿�y�¢��NlM�RUY�P�^FNl�_aN V�Y�r#Nkb\c�]�R=RUTN � Oa��M�%]QXZY\Nlc�OQP+XUN�_�Y\OaM�c�OQP+t�OaMcZR�]QM�R�cvYf_aMFYfMFRUTN�XvN�cU�#bfR�OQP+RUTNVXvNljnYfOa�c;cvRsNlV�y

� TN��%M%]�b�cvRUN�V�� OQPEY\��N�M�RUY�P�^nY\M_(N���_aN�V�Yµr�Nkb\cl��t�]QM � Nq��OaMN � ^JjnYfNlgSYfM_(RUTN�cvYf_aM�OQP:RUTNz�]QV�b\]QtlY\]QM.OQP�RsTN �:]Q�cUcZY²]�M`cU[uO&OQRsT�N���Y\[�]Q_aN�]Qc:�Nk�%M�YfM_q] � YfM%]QXZ^qYf[F]�_aN � NQy _y���gSY�RsT�j�]�bf�NOaMN-g�T�N�XUNWRUTNWcvYf_aM�Y\c±V}OacZYfRvYfjQN|]�M����NlXUO�g�TN�XvNWYfR±Yfc±MN�_a]�RUY�jaNÙ��y � T�N�M�RsTNW�lN�XUO�tlXUOacvcvYfM_ac]QXvNEcvYf[�V#bf^WRUTN � Oa��M�%]QXZY\Nlc;O�P"RUTNEMOaM# Ä��NlXUO�XUN�_�Y\OaM�c;O�P�RUT�Yfc � Y\M%]�Xv^�]QXvXs]?^ay � TNlcUN � OQ�M�%]QXZY\Nlct?]�M � N�PxOa�M�� � ^uY\�NlM�RUY�P�^&YfM_u]QM�^�MOaM& ���NlXUO�V�Y�r#Nkb+YfMFRsT�N � YfM%]QXZ^w]�XUXs]?^±RUT%]�R=T%]Qc~]�MFYf[�[uNl��Y²]�RsNMNkY\_aT � OaX�g�T�Y\t�T�Y\c���NlXUOy � T&��c"PxOaX�N?]�t�TpV�Yµr�Nkb���YfP�YfR�Yfc"MOQM# ��lN�XUO;g�N�t�OQMcvYf�N�X�YfRUc"NkY\_QTnR"MNkY\_aT � OaXUcly¢ÄP"]QM�^wM�NlYf_aT � OaXZY\M�_±V�Y�r#Nkb�Y\c���N�XvO�#RUTN�MWg=N7tlb\]QcvcvY�P�^-RsTN�V�Y�r#Nkb)]QcS]�MWN��_aN�y8³"Yf_a�XUN Yfb�bf�cvRUXs]�RUN�cRsT�N�XvN�cv��bfRvY\M�_wN���_aN�cSPxOaX~RUTNEY\[�]Q_aNEPxXvOa[ ³"Yf_a�XvN ã y

OQRUN±OaMNpYfcUcv�N±gSYfRUT3] . ; � Nl�_aN±�NkRsN�tkRsOaXEYfc7RsT%]�R7YfRE]�bfg�]?^&c:PxOQXU[ucEtlbfOacUNl�3Nl�_aN±t�T%]�Y\Mcl�� N�t?]��cUN ]QM�N��_aN�Yfc8RUTN � OQ�M�%]QXZ^uOQP+]�XvN�_QYfOaMuRsT%]�R�T%]�c�V}OacZYfRvYfjQN OaX8MNl_�]�RvYfjQN cZY\_aMuYfM . ; � � $}y� � F@3@�� /1032�4 ���(4�� H68>��

� TN�¹~]QMM�^�� · # N��_QN=�NkRsNltlRsOQX�Yfc � ]QcUNl�HOaM�t�OQ[�V���RUYfM_ RUTN�cU�n�%]QXvN��H_QXs]Q��YfN�M�R"[�]Q_aM�Y�Rs���NQy�z)O&t?]�b[�]�r&Y\[�]WOQP�RUTNp_aXU]Q��YfN�M�R:[�]Q_aM�Y�Rs���NpRsT%]�R7]QXUNp] � OhjQN±cUOa[uNpRsT�XUN�cvTOQbf�.]QXUNHRUTN�MqYf�NlMnRvYf�N��3]Qc

·a·

Page 23: edges - University of Wisconsin–Madisonpages.cs.wisc.edu/~dyer/ai-qual/huttenlocher-edges95.pdfN cv t T|RUT Y\M _ac ]Qc N _QN NlRsNltlRvY\OaM|]QM cZRsN XvN OaV cvYfc y T N=V XUO&t

N���_aN�cly � T�Y\c8RsT�XUN�cvTOQbf�N��Fb\O&t?]�b£V}N?]��p�NlRUN�tkRUYfOaMw[uNlRUTO&��Yfc=t�]�b�b\Nl� �+¦ ����§�ª � ¨�§ �&§1­ � ?-?}¥s¬�­�­k¨�¦ �%�OaX �Å >¾y � TN±[uOQRvYfj�]�RvY\OQM�PxOQX:¹~]QMM�^}mec:Nl�_aNuOaV}N�Xs]�RsOaX�g�]Qc7RUOW�N�XZYfjQNw]QModeOaV�RvY\[�]�b$m�OaV}N�XU]�RsOQXYfM»RUTN:cUN�M�cUN:RsT%]�R�Y�R?�

� Å»YfM�Yf[±Y\�lN�c RUTN:VXUO � ] � Y�bfY�R�^WOQP"[H�#bfRvY\V�b�^»�NlRUN�tkRUYfM_w]�M|Nl�_aNQy

� Å»YfM�Yf[±Y\�lN�c RUTN:VXUO � ] � Y�bfY�R�^WOQP�P�]�Y�bfYfM_uRsOu�NkRsN�tkR7]�M»Nl�_aN�y

� Å»YfM�Yf[±Y\�lN�c RUTN:��YfcvR�]�Mt�N�OQP�RsTN:XUNlV¾OQXvRsNl�|Nl�_aNEPxXUOQ[ RsT�N:RUXU�N:Nl�_aN� TN±�%XvcvRER�g=O»O�P=RUTN�cvN�tlXvY�RsNlXvY\]»]���XUNlcUcERsT�NpY\cvcU�N�OQP ,&¬k® ¬@Ak®�¨�¦ �%��RsT]�R7Yfc���_QY�jaN�M�RsT]�R:]QM�N���_aNYfc;V�XUN�cvN�M�R�gSY�b�b)RsTN:N���_aN���NlRsNltlRUOaXS�%M�|RUT%]�R�Nl�_aN � ]QM��MO�OQRUTN�X�N���_aN�c¡��y � TN�RUT�YfXU�»t�XvY�RsNlXvYfOaM]Q���XUN�cvcUNlcpRsTNuY\cvcU�NwOQP�C\¦ AUª C ¨ � ªQ®�¨�¦ �%��RUT%]�R�Y\c�TOhg ]Qt�tl�Xs]�RUNlb�^3RUTNwV}OacZYfRvY\OaM3OQP�]QM`N��_aN�Y\c�XUN¡ V}OaXvRUN���y � TN�XvN�Yfc�]�RUXs]Q�NlOQà � NlR�g=N�N�M`�NlRUN�tlRvY\OQMo]QM��bfO#t�]�bfYf�?]�RUYfOaM�Æ|RsT�NF[uOaXvNF]�t�t���Xs]�RUN�RUTN�NkRsN�tkRsOaXSRUTNEb\NlcUc ]Qt�tl�Xs]�RUNERsTNEbfO#t�]�bfYf�?]�RUYfOaM½]�M�»jnYft�N:jaNlXUcs]#y

¹~]QMM�^�t�OQMcvYf�N�Xvc �%XvcvR;�NlXvY�jQ]�RUY�jaNHOQV¾NlXs]�RUOaXUcly=³�Y\XvcvR;XUNlt?]�b�b)RsT%]�R tlOa[uV��RvY\M_F]u�N�XZYfj�]�RvYfjQN�Yfc]�b�Y\M�N?]QX~OQV¾NlXs]�RvY\OaM+y�¢�MWV%]QXZRUYft���b\]QX�RUTN �%XvcvRS��N�XvY�j�]�RUY�jaN ��� �'& ��t?]QM � N7tlOa[uV��RsNl� � ^-t�OQMnjQOQb�j&YfM_� �9& ��gSY�RsTJ]�cUV}N�tlY\]�b�Px�MtkRUYfOaM���� �9& ����RUTN��M�Y�R��Oa� � bfNlR�y � T�YfcuPx�MtlRvY\OQM YfcF]�V}OacvY�RUY�jaN»�M�Y�RYf[�V���b\cvN.]QM��]oMN�_a]�RUY�jaN��M�Y�RWYf[�V���b\cvN�cUV%]QtlN����o]�V%]QXvR � XUNlt?]�b�b7RUTN��Nl�M�YfRvY\OQM�OQP:RUTN��M�Y�RYf[�V���b\cvN � �'& �;PxXvOa[ >#NltlRvY\OaM3¿-Y\c�]-Px�MtkRUYfOaM�RsT%]�REYfc:��NlXUO�NljQN�Xv^ng�TNlXUN-N¡r#t�N�V#Rp]�RERUTNuOaXvYf_QYfM¾��y� TNEtlOa[uV��R�]�RUYfOaMWOQP"]H�NlXvY�jQ]�RUY�jaN � ^wtlOaM�jaOQbf��RUYfOaM�gSYfRUT�]p�M�Y�RS�Oa� � b\NkR�t?]QM � N�RUTOa�_aT�RSO�P�]Qct�OQXUXUNlcUV}OaM��YfM_HRUOHRsT�N;�%M#YfRUN7��Y�Ã+NlXUN�M�t�NE]QV�VXUO?r&Y\[�]�RvY\OQMwRsOH]��NlXvY�jQ]�RUY�jaN � g�T�Y\t�T � N�tlOa[uN�c~[uOaXvN]Qtlt��XU]�RsN�]QcS_aNlRUc;cv[�]�bfbfN�X¡���

' � �9& �' & ) � �'& � + � �9& = ����/�� �'& � ��� �9& �

]Qc�� � ¶�y¢�M�OaXU��N�XwRUO`Yfb�bf�cvRUXs]�RUNqRsTN½RUXs]Q��N�OQà � NkR�g�NlN�M�b\O&t?]�bfYf�?]�RvY\OQM�]QM���NkRsN�tkRUYfOaM��;t�OaM�cvYf�N�X-RUTN

VXvO � bfN�[ OQP��NkRsNltlRUYfM_W]�OaMN¡ ���Yf[uN�McZY\OaM]�b��M#YfR�cvRsNlV# �Nl�_aN�� ) �'& �sy �;Nlt?]�b�b"PxXvOa[ >#NltlRUYfOaM�¿uRsT%]�R' ) �'& � / ' & / � �'& �s�QRsTN��NlXvY�jQ]�RUY�jaN~OQP#RsTN=�M�Y�R�cZRsNlVpN��_QN=Yfc�RUTN��M#YfR�Y\[uV�#b\cvN � g�T�Yft�T±]�bfcUO N��n�%]�bfc) �'& � � � �'& �v��y8L7MN~V}OacvcvY � b\NS[uNkRsTO&�±OQP£�NkRsN�tkRUYfM_�]�cvRUN�VuN���_aN�g=Oa��bf� � N�RUOE��Y�Ã+NlXUN�M�RvY²]�RUN ) �'& ���^nY\Nkb\�#Y\M_ � �9& ���=]QM��RsT�N�M�RsO�t�OaM�cvYf�N�X�� �

�� �9& � ' & PxOaX±cv[�]�bfbSYfM�RsNlXvj�]�bfc � � ( # y � TOQcUNWY\M�RUN�Xvj�]�bfc

g�TNlXUN�RUTN:Y\M�RsNl_aXs]�b�Yfc;MOaM�lN�XUO � YfM|P�]QtkR Nl�n�%]�b�RsO�OaMN���t�OQMnRs]�YfM|RsT�N�cZRsN�V½N��_aN�y � Ohg=NljQN�X��¾RsT�YfcYfc±]QM%]�bfOa_aOQ�c�RUOqcU[uO&OQRsT�YfM_½RUTN � ��YfþN�XvN�M�RUY\]�RUN��¾�EPx��MtlRvY\OaM � ^`]Q���YfM_qRUOa_aNlRUTN�X�MNlYf_aT � OaXvYfM_j�]�bf�N�cl�£g�T#Y\t�T½]Qc~g�N�cs]?g YfM >#N�tkRUYfOaMq¿pYfc�MOQR ]pjaN�XZ^�_aO&O#�Wcv[�O&OQRUT�Y\M�_F[uNlRUTO&��y

� � NkRURsNlX�cU[uO#O�RsT�YfM_�[�NkRsTO&��Y\cSRsO�t�OQMnjQOQb�jaN�RUTN:OaXvYf_QYfM%]�b)cZRsNlV½N���_aNEgSYfRUT½] ��]��cUcZY²]QM � OQXOQRUTN�XEbfOÙg�V]QcUc:�b�RsN�XEPx�M�tlRUYfOaM¾��]QM��.RUTN�M�R�]Q��N±RsTNu�NlXvY�jQ]�RUY�jaNQ� � �'& � / ' � ��� �9& ��� ) �9& �U� / ' & y� T�Yfc�Px�MtkRUYfOaMqgSY�bfb � N�MOaM�lN�XvOWMN?]QX;RsTN�b\O&t?]�RvY\OQM½OQP�RUTNHcZRsN�V�Nl�_aN�y �7YfjQN�MqRsT]�R7��Y�þN�XUNlM�RUY\]� RUYfOaM�Y\c�]WbfYfMN�]QX:OaV¾NlXs]�RUOaX � t�]QM � N±Y\[uV�bfN�[uNlMnRUN��ojnY\]»tlOaM�jaOQbf��RUYfOaM¾�s��]QM��.RUT%]�R�t�OaM�jQOQb\�#RUYfOaM3Yfc]QcvcUO&tlY\]�RUY�jaN��£g=N�t?]QM»Nkr#VXvN�cUc�RsT#Y\c;N��_QN�OQV¾NlXs]�RUOaX � �'& ��YfM»R�g=OFNl�n��Yfj�]�bfN�M�R;PxOaXU[ucl�

� ��� �9& � � ) �9& �U� � / � � � �'& � � ) �9& � (� g�T�N�XUN:g=N���cUN:RsTN:VXZY\[uN:MOQRs]�RUYfOaMWRsO��N�M�OQRsNER�]��nYfM_uRsTN:�NlXvY�j�]�RUY�jaN��y

·Q¿

Page 24: edges - University of Wisconsin–Madisonpages.cs.wisc.edu/~dyer/ai-qual/huttenlocher-edges95.pdfN cv t T|RUT Y\M _ac ]Qc N _QN NlRsNltlRvY\OaM|]QM cZRsN XvN OaV cvYfc y T N=V XUO&t

��

� �

Ò �

³"Yf_a�XvN � ��LEM�N��#Y\[uN�M�cvYfOaM%]�b��NlXvY�jQ]�RUY�jaN�c OQP ��]Q��cUcvY\]QMcl� � ]&�=]ucvRUN�V# ÄN��_aN�]QM�WY�Rsc;�N�XZYfj�]�RvYfjQNH]�RR�g=OwcUt�]�bfN�c�O�P�cU[uO&OQRsT#Y\M_�� ��� ��]�cZRsNlV# �Nl�_aN:gSYfRUTq]Q���N��½M�OQY\cvNp]QM��»Y�Rsc;�N�XZYfj�]�RvYfjQNp]�R;OaM�N�cvt?]�bfNOQP;cU[uO&OQRsT#Y\M_�� � t���]�cU[uO&OQRsT�N���jaNlXUcvYfOaM(OQP�RsTNWcZRsNlV# �Nl�_aNWPxXUOa[ �$� �E[F]��nYfM_�RsTNWcZRsNlV([uOaXvN]QVV]QXUNlMnR�y

� TNEcU[�]�b�bfN�X�RUTN�j�]�bf�N7OQP � �&RsTN7cv[�]�bfbfN�X=RsTN7��Oa[�]�Y\MWOhjQN�X~g�T�Yft�T � �'& ��gSY�bfb � N�MOaM�lN�XUOpYfMXUNlcUV}OaMcvNpRsO�]-cvRUN�V�Nl�_aNQy�¢�M�OQRUTN�X�g=OaXv�c���RUTNpcU[�]�b�bfN�X7RsT�NHj�]�b\��N±OQP � �+RUTN � NlRURUN�X7RUTNpN���_aNYfc�C\¦ AUª C ¨ � ¬�,Qy � T�Yfc�Yfc~Y�bfbf�cvRUXs]�RUN���Y\M»³"Yf_a�XvN � ]�� g�T�Yft�T|cvTOhg�c ]±cZRsN�V�Nl�_aNQ�£]�M�WRsTNEtlOaM�jaOQbf��RUYfOaMOQP~RUTN-cZRsN�V�Nl�_aN�gSYfRUT � � � �'& ��PxOaXH]|cU[�]�b�b\NlX±]QM��]»b²]QXv_aN�X:j�]�bf�N-OQP � y O�RsNwT�OÙgiRUTNwV}N?]Q�t�OQXUXUNlcUV}OaM��YfM_»RsO�RsTNucvRUN�V3N��_aNuYfc�M%]�XUXUOhg=N�X:PxOaX7RsT�NFcv[F]�bfbfN�X � y � Ohg�NkjaNlX��"RUTN�cU[�]�b�b\NlX�RUTNj�]�bf�N:OQP � �RUTNEb\NlcUc;bfYf�QNkbf^�RsT]�RSg�N:gSY�bfb ,&¬k®�¬@Ak®�]QM|Nl�_aN�y=¢�M|OaXU�NlXSRsO±Yfb�bf�cvRUXs]�RUN�RUT�Y\cl�£t�OaMcZY\��N�X]|cZRsNlVoN��_QN�gSY�RsToM�OQY\cvNwcv�V¾NlXvYf[uV¾OacvN�����]Qc�Y�bfbf�cZRsXs]�RsN��3Y\M`³"Y\_Q�XUN � � y �;N�XvNFY�R�YfcH��Y ��t���b�RHRUOcUNlNFRUTNFcZRsNlV�� � N�t�]Q�cUNuY�R�Yfc�d � �XZY\Nl��m)Y\M.RsTNF]Q���N��`M�OQY\cvNQy�¹�OQXUXUNlcUV}OaM��YfM_Qb�^a�"YfP=RsTN�cvYf_aM%]�b8YfccU[uO&OQRsT�N�� gSY�RsT ]�cU[�]�b�b;j�]�bf�N�OQP � �=RUTN�XvN½]QXvN�XUNlb\]�RvYfjQNlb�^ [�]QM�^�b\]QXU_QN»V}N?]��&cuYfM � �9& � � ]�bfcUOY�bfbf�cvRUXs]�RUN��uY\M�V%]QXZR � OQP£RsTN;³"Yf_a�XvN���y�³£OQX�b²]�XU_aNlX�jQ]�b\�Nlc8OQP � RUTN�XvN ]�XUN~PxNlg=N�X8cv�t�TFbfO#t�]�bV}N?]��&cl�� N�t?]��cUNHRUTNpcvV%]�RUY\]�b�bf^»bfO#t�]�b�t�T]QM_aNlc�Y\MqRUTNHcZY\_QM%]�b�]�XUNHcv[uO#OQRUTN���OQ��R?�£b\N�]?j&YfM_ � �cZR�RsT�NpcvRUN�VN���_aNQy � TN;NlþN�tkR�O�P+cv[�O&OQRUT�Y\M�_�RUTN M�OQY\cZ^ucvRUN�VwNl�_aNSgSY�RsT-] �:]Q�cUcZY²]�MFOQP¾b²]�XU_aN � Y\c�Y�bfbf�cvRUXs]�RUN��³"Yf_a�XvN � t�y � T�Yfc�[�]Q�QNlc�RsTN=�M�NlXvb�^&YfM_:cvRUN�Vu]QV�V%]QXUNlM�R?y � Tn�c��cZY\M�_EcU[�]�b�b\NlX�j�]�b\��N�c�OQP � b\N�]hjQN�c[�]QM�^-bfO#t�]�b�t�T%]QM_QN�c��%g�TNlXUN�]Qc��cvYfM_Fb\]QXv_aN�XSOaM�N�cSb\N�]?jaN�c VXvYf[�]QXvY�b�^-RsTN:cZRsN�V»N���_aN �$� ��R;[�]Q��N�cY�RscpbfO#t�]�RUYfOaM�b\NlcUcut�NlXvRs]�Y\M}��y  N-gSYfb�b�XUNkRs�XvM�RsO�RsTN-YfcUcv�N»OQP;t�TO#OQcvYfM_3cvt?]�bfN�c±PxOaXHcU[uO#O�RsT�YfM_� NlbfOÙg:y

¢�MqOaMN���Yf[�NlMcvYfOaM���¹~]QMM�^|cUTOhg�c�RUT%]�R�RUTN�OaV¾NlXs]�RUOaX � � � �'& ��Y\c�]QM½OaV#RUYf[F]�b��NkRsNltlRsOQX PxOaX ]cvRUN�V�Nl�_aN�YfM½RUN�XU[uc7O�P�RsTN��NlRUN�tlRvY\OQM� �bfO#t�]�bfYf�?]�RUYfOaMqRsXU]Q�N�O�Ã�y � TNp�NlXvY�j�]�RUYfOaMqOQP�RUT�Yfc�XUNlcU��b�R7Yfc� Nl^aOQM��RUTNScUtlOaV}N;O�P¾RUTN�cvN;M�OQRsNlc�� � ��R�t�]QM � N~PxOa��M�±Y\M � · # y�¢�Mw· � ¹~]�MM�^±cvYf[±Yfb\]QXvb�^u]Q�#jaO&t?]�RUN�c

· �

Page 25: edges - University of Wisconsin–Madisonpages.cs.wisc.edu/~dyer/ai-qual/huttenlocher-edges95.pdfN cv t T|RUT Y\M _ac ]Qc N _QN NlRsNltlRvY\OaM|]QM cZRsN XvN OaV cvYfc y T N=V XUO&t

� gSY�RsT�Oa��R�PxOaXv[F]�b%]QXv_a�[uN�M�Rsc¡��RsTNS��cUN�OQP£�%XUcZR8cUV%]�RUY\]�b�NlXvY�j�]�RUY�jaNlc�y ��c�g=NScs]?gJ] � OhjQNQ�nTOhg�NkjaNlX��RsT�N7�%XUcZR��N�XZYfj�]�RvYfjQN:Yfc�]QMWOaXZY\NlM�R�]�RvY\OaM�cvN�McZYfRvYfjQN�OaV}N�XU]�RsOQX � M�OaM# ÄYfcUO�RsXUOQV�Y\tÙ��y � Tn�c��%XU]�RsT�N�X�RUT%]QM�cZY\M_|RsTN��%XUcZRp�NlXvY�jQ]�RUY�jaNQ��¹~]QMM�^`��cUN�c�RsTNFcU�n�%]QXvN��o_aXU]Q��YfN�M�Rp[�]Q_QM�YfRU��NFOQP~RsT�NwcU[uO&OQRsT�N��Yf[F]�_aNQ�

� �'&)(+* ��/ : . � � � $��� :<; / 1 3 $�3 & 5 ; = 1 3 $ 3 * 5 ;g�T�Yft�T|YfcSY\cvOQRsXvOaV�Yft � g�TN�XvN $���NlMOQRsNlc;RUTN:cU[uO&OQRsTNl�»Yf[�]Q_aNÙ��y

� ]�RsTNlX�RsT%]�M�cvYf[�V#bf^|RsTXvN�cUT�OQb\�#Y\M_ � �9&)(+* �~Y\M�OaXv�N�X RsOwYf�N�M�RvYfP�^½N��_aNlc���¹~]QM�Mn^}m c:[�NkRsTO&��NkRsN�tkRsc~bfO#t�]�b¾V¾N�]Q�nc~Y\M-RUTN�[�]Q_aM#YfRU��N:]QM�FRsTNlM-RsTXvN�cUT�OQb\��c�RUTN7V}N?]Q�ncly � TN � �cvRvYf�t?]�RvY\OaM-PxOQXRsT#Y\c8Y\c8RsT]�R�N��_aN�bfO#t�]�RUYfOaMc8gSYfb�b}T%]?jaN�]�T�Yf_aTNlX=_QXs]Q��YfN�M�R=[�]Q_aM�Y�Rs���N;RUT%]QMwM�OaM# �Nl�_aNlc � Y�y NQy��&gSY�b�b� N7b\O&t?]�b+V¾N�]Q�nc~Y\MWRUTNE_aXs]���Y\NlM�Rl��y��;OÙg=NljQN�Xl�}XU]�RsT�N�X�RUT%]QM�t�Oa[uV%]�XvYfM_±RsTNE_aXU]Q��YfN�M�R�[�]Q_aM�Y�Rs���N]�R~]p_QYfjQN�MWbfO#t�]�RUYfOaMwRUOpRsTN�j�]�bf�NlcS]�R�]�b�b¾MNlYf_aT � OQXvYfM_±b\O&t?]�RvY\OQMc��¹~]QMM�^-O � cUN�XZjaNlc�RUT%]�R~g=NE]QXvNOaM�b�^Ft�OaMtlN�XvMN��WRsT]�R�RUTN�_aXU]Q��YfN�M�R � NE]FdeV¾N�]Q�£m#gSY�RsT-XvN�cvV¾NltlRSRsO�YfRUc~MNlYf_aT � OaXUc�YfMwRUTN7_aXU]Q��YfN�M�R��YfXUNltlRUYfOaM���]QM���MOQREYfM.O�RsTNlX7��YfXUN�tkRUYfOaMcly � O�TNkb\V��M��N�XvcvR�]�M�.RUT�Yfc���t�OaM�cvYf�N�XERsT�Nu]QM%]�bfOa_Q^|OQP� NlYfM_uOaM»]uXZY\��_aNEOQP"]±[�OQ�M�R�]�YfM|XU]QM_aN�y � TN:_aXs]���Y\NlM�R���Y\XvN�tkRUYfOaM|V}OQYfM�Rsc��Ohg�MWPxXUOa[ RsTNpd RsOaV+mOQP=RsTN�XvYf�_aN±RsOhg�]QXU�.RsTNuj�]�b�b\Nk^#c�OaM.NlY�RsTNlX�cZY\�N�y � TN�XvYf�_aNuYfRUcUNkbfPS[�]?^�[uOhjaNw��V`]QM��`�Ohg�McU��t�TFRsT]�R�]�R�]7_QY�jaNlMFbfO#t�]�RUYfOaM±g�N�t�]QM � N�cvRs]QM��YfM_�OaM±RsTNSXZY\��_aN � ��R8MOQR � N;]�R�]7b\O&t?]�b%V¾N�]Q��YfM]�b�b���YfXUNltlRvY\OaM�c � RsTNEXZY\��_aN�RsO � OQRsTWcZY\��N�c�OQP��c~Yfc~T�Yf_aTN�X¡��y8¢�MWRsTNE_QXs]Q��YfN�M�RS�#Y\XvN�tlRvY\OQM��%TOhg�NkjaNlX��g=Nu]QXUNu]�RE]-V¾N�]Q�»g�T�N�MNkjaN�X:g=NF]�XUNpOaMqRUTN±XvYf�_aN � ]QcvcU�[±YfM_»RUT%]�R7RUTN±��YfXUNltlRUYfOaM�OQP�cvRUN�NlV¾NlcvR�NlcUt�NlM�R�Y\c�]�bfg�]?^&c�Y\M�RsO RsTN�jQ]�bfbfNl^Q�aMOQR�]�b\OQM_�RsT�N�XvYf�_aNÙ��y � T&��c��Nl�%M#Y\M_7]�V¾N�]Q�:OQP%RsT�N�_aXU]Q��YfN�M�R[�]Q_aM�Y�Rs���N�gSY�RsTWXUNlcUV}N�tkR~RsOHRUTN7_aXU]Q��YfN�M�RS��YfXUNltlRvY\OaM�]�bfbfOhg�c~�c�RUOH�NkRsN�tkR�cvRUN�VWN���_aN�c�RUT%]�R�T%]?jaNRsT#Y\cSR�^&V¾N�OQP"XvYf�_aN:NlþN�tkR?y

� TN��M�Y�R8jaN�tkRsOaX�YfM�RUTNS_aXU]Q��YfN�M�R���Y\XvN�tkRUYfOaM � g�T�Yft�TwMOQRUN~Y\c8MOQXU[�]�bRUO�]EcZRsN�V�N���_aN���Yfc�_QYfjQN�M� ^

�. �'&)(+* �6/ . � � � $���� . � � � $� ���)7

¢ÄP�g=N��NlMOQRUN �. �'&)(+* � � ^uRUTN ��M�YfR�jaNltlRUOaX � � &)( � * ���aRsT�N�M � �9&)(+* ��Yfc=��Nl�%MNl�-RsO � N ]Eb\O&t?]�b}V}N?]Q�YfM»RUTN:_aXs]Q�#Y\NlMnR;��YfXUNltlRvY\OaM�g�TNlM

� �'&)(+* � � �'& = � &)(+* = � * �]QM�

� �9&)(+* � � �'& + � &)(�* + � * � 7� T%]�RuYfc���g�N»cs]?^�RsT]�R � �'&)(+* �:Y\cF]qb\O&t?]�b�V¾N�]Q�`g�TNlMNljQN�XwY�RuY\cu_aXvN?]�RUN�X±RsT%]�M(RUTNWjQ]�b\�Nlc�YfMRsT�N±_aXs]Q�#Y\NlMnR:�#Y\XvN�tlRvY\OQM3]�M��RsTNpOQVV¾OQcvY�RsN±OQP8RsT�N±_aXs]Q�#Y\NlMnR:�#Y\XvN�tlRvY\OQM�y±¹~]QM�Mn^qt?]�b�b\c7RUT�Yfc7b\O&t?]�bV}N?]Q���NkRsN�tkRUYfOaM�OaV}N�XU]�RUYfOaM �+¦ ����§�ª � ¨�§ �&§ ­ � ?-?}¥�¬�­�­k¨�¦ � � 7Å >£��y OQRUNFRUT%]�RHYfMoVXU]QtlRvY\tlNFY�RHYfc_aNlMN�XU]�bfb�^ � NlRURUN�X±RsO��cvN Y\M(OaMN���YfXUNltlRUYfOaM ]QM���©Y\M�RsTN�OQRUTN�Xl�=XU]�RsT�N�X±RsT%]�M YfM � OQRUT��YfXUNltlRUYfOaMcl�%RsO�]�b�b\Ohg{PxOQX7degSYf�NQm£Nl�_aN�c ]Qc�V}N?]Q�nc�y

� TN 7Å >�OaV¾NlXs]�RvY\OQM»cZRUY�bfb�bfN?]?jaNlc�[�]QM�^WbfO#t�]�b�deV¾N�]Q�nc�m£RsT%]�R;]�XUN:MOQR�jaNlXv^Wb\]QXU_QNQy � TN�cvNH]QXvNRsT�N�MuRsTXvN�cUT�OQb\��N�� � ]QcUNl�FOQMuRUTN�_aXs]���Y\NlM�R8[F]�_aM�Y�Rs��N � OaX�cvRUXUNlM_QRsT�OQP}RsTNSNl�_aNÙ�"RUOEXUNl[�OhjQN;RUTNcU[�]�b�b�V}N?]��&cly � TNEV¾N�]Q�nc~RsT%]�R~V%]Qcvc~RsT�Yfc�RUTXUNlcUTOQbf�»]QXUN RsTNlMWtlb\]QcUcZYf�%Nl�½]�c~N��_QNEV�Y�r#Nkb\cly�¹~]�MM�^�cvN�cu]|RUTXUNlcUTOQbf��YfM_�OaV}N�Xs]�RUYfOaM`RsT]�RpT%]�cHR�g�OqRUTXUNlcUTO�b\�cl��bfO�]QM��oT�YÄy ��M�^`bfO#t�]�b=[F]Ùr#Yf[H��[

·a¸

Page 26: edges - University of Wisconsin–Madisonpages.cs.wisc.edu/~dyer/ai-qual/huttenlocher-edges95.pdfN cv t T|RUT Y\M _ac ]Qc N _QN NlRsNltlRvY\OaM|]QM cZRsN XvN OaV cvYfc y T N=V XUO&t

PxOaX~g�T�Yft�T � �9&)(+* � T#Y)Y\c;�QNlV�R7]�c ]�M|Nl�_aN�V�Y�r#Nkb�y~Å|OaXUNlOhjaN�Xl�}]QM�^Wb\O&t?]�b�[�]�r&Yf[H�[ PxOQX�g�T#Y\t�T� �'&)(�* � b\OF]QM�|cUOa[uNHM�NlYf_aT � OaX�Yfc�]QM|N��_QN�V�Yµr#Nlb�Y\c�]�bfcUO��QN�V#RE]Qc ]QM½Nl�_aN�V�Y�r#Nkb�y ;OQRsN:RsT%]�RRsT#Y\c�Y\c�] XUNlt��XvcvY�jaN~��Nl�%M�Y�RUYfOaM � ]QM�^�V�Yµr�Nkb�RUT%]�R�Y\c"] � OÙjQN�RsT�N�bfOhg�RsTXvN�cUT�OQb\�p]QM�±]Q� � ]Qt�NlMnR"RsO�]QM¬�,?«#¬"V�Yµr�Nkb%Y\c�Y�RscvNlb�P)]QM½¬�,?«#¬"V�Yµr#Nlb$y � T�Yfc8PxOQXU[°OQP+��cvYfM_ER�g�OERsT�XUN�cvTOQbf�c=]�bfbfOhg�c�RsTNStlOaM�RUYfMn�%]�RUYfOaMOQP�g�N�]Q�QNlX�Nl�_aN�cSRUT%]�R ]QXUNEtlOaMMNltlRUN��|RUOFcZRsXvOaM_uN��_QN�c��}]QM��»Yfc;]±PxOQXU[ÕO�P�T�^&cvRsNlXUNlcvYfc�y

� O:cv�[u[F]�XvYf��NSRsTNScZRsNlVc8OQP£VXUO&t�NlcUcZY\M_:PxOaX�RUTN;¹~]QMM�^±Nl�_aNS�NkRsNltlRsOQX��aPxOaX�]7�#Y\cvt�XUNkRsNSYf[F]�_aN$�� &)(�*$# �ã y >#[uO&OQRsT3RsTNwYf[�]Q_aN-��cvYfM_.]�· � �:]Q�cUcZY²]�M � gSY�RsToRsT�NwR�g�O ã � �bfRUN�Xvc���]Qcp�NlcUtlXvY � Nl��YfM>#NltlRvY\OaM|¿&�s�D$ / ��� � $£y·#y ¹�Oa[uV�#RsN:RsTN:_aXU]Q��YfN�M�R ]QM��cU�n�%]QXvN��|[F]�_aM�Y�Rs��N�OQP�RsTN:cv[�O&OQRUTN���Y\[�]Q_QNQ�

. $� / 1 3 $ 3 & ( 3 $ 3 * 5� �9&)(+* ��/ 1 3 $ 3 & 5 ; = 1 3 $ 3 * 5 ;

¿�y �;cUN�RUTN~�M�Y�R�jQN�tkRsOaX������� ����� �/ � � &)( � * ��]�R�N�]Qt�T±V¾O�Y\M�R�RUO7N�cZRUYf[F]�RsN�RUTN~_aXU]Q��YfN�M�R�[�]Q_aM�Y�Rs���N

YfMqRsTNH_aXs]Q�#Y\NlMnR7��Y\XvN�tkRUYfOaM.]QM��OaVV}OacZYfRUNpOQP�RsT�Np_aXs]���Y\NlM�RE��YfXUN�tkRUYfOaM�y � T�YfcEt?]QM � Np�OQMN� ^.]»g=NlYf_aT�RsNl��]?jaNlXs]Q_aNFOQP�RUTN�MNlYf_aT � OQXvYfM_½V�Yµr#Nlbfc�YfM3RUTNF�#Y\XvN�tlRvY\OQM � � &)( � * �s��OQX�[uOaXvNcZY\[uV�b�^ � ^�cUNlbfN�tkRUYfM_FRUTN:MNlYf_aT � OaXvYfM_�V�Y�r#Nkb"tkb\OQcUN�cZR RUO±RsTN:��YfXUNltlRUYfOaM �'& = � &)(+* = � * ��y

� y;z)NlR / � �9&)(+* ���� � / � �9& = � &)(+* = � * ���� � / � �'& + � &)(+* + � * ��y � Nl�%MN�]±V}N?]Q�w]Qc� ����� �� � ��� � � �� ������ 7

¸#y � TXvN�cvTOQbf�Jd´cZRsXvOaM_m�V}N?]Q�nc�YfM`OQXU�NlX�RUO|_aNkRHXZY\�3OQP~b�YfRvRUbfNFV}N?]��&c���NuRsO|MOQYfcUNQ�"NlRUtQy � cvN� . $ � ]Qc�[uN�]QcU�XvNHOQP�N��_aN�cvRUXUN�M�_QRsT�y �;cUNp]�T�^#cZRsNlXUN�cZY\cE[uNlt�T%]QM�YfcU[ ]Qc���N�cUtlXvY � Nl��] � OÙjQNgSY�RsT�R�g�OuRsT�XUN�cvTOQbf�c;OaM|Nl�_aN:cvRUXUNlM_QRsT+�£bfO�]QM�»T�Y$y

� TN�Nl�_aNlc�YfMp³"Yf_a�XvN ã ]QXvN�PxXUOa[ RUTN=¹~]QMM�^�N��_aN��NkRsN�tkRsOaXly�¢�M�VXs]QtkRUYft�N���RsT#Y\c�N��_QN=OaV}N�XU]�RsOQX� OQX~jQ]�XvY\]QM�Rsc�OQP�YfRk�=YfcSRsTN:[uOacZR ��cUNlPx�#b�]�M�WgSY\�Nkbf^���cUN��+y

� � �.Gk6�<�K�9 FG�4 � ��>»9�4:K�K=<Ù@q2

�ÕcvN�XZY\Oa��cpVXs]�tlRUYft?]�b~VXvO � bfN�[ gSYfRUT�]QM�^`Nl�_aN-��NlRsNltlRUOaX�YfcHRsT�Nw[�]�RURUN�XpO�PSt�TO&OacvYfM_qRsT�N»­ AUª C\¬OQP�cU[uO#O�RsT�YfM_ � RsTNuj�]�bf�NwOQP � RUO|�cvN��sy�³£OQX�[�]QM�^.cUtlN�MNlc�����cvYfM_½RsT�N-¹~]QM�Mn^.Nl�_aNw��NlRsNltlRUOaXgSY�RsT � / ã cvN�N�[uc±RsO�V�XUO&��t�N|d´_aO&O&��m�XvN�cU�#bfRUc�� � ��RpRUT�YfcpY\c±MO�RHjaNlXv^�cU]�RUYfcvP�]�tlRsOQXv^ay3¹=bfN?]QXZbf^Q�]Qc � YfMt�XvN?]QcvN�c:b\NlcUc�]QM��bfN�cvc�O�P�RUTN±�NkR�]�Y�b\Nl�3Nl�_aNlc7Y\M.]QM�Yf[F]�_aNu]QXUNHVXUNlcUN�XZjaNl� � ]�M��cUV%]�RvY²]�bbfO#t�]�bfYf�?]�RUYfOaM�_aNlRUcHg=OaXUcvNW]QM�og=OaXUcvN��sy3³%OaX�[�]QM�^�]QV�V�bfYft?]�RUYfOaMcHY�RpYfcp�N�cZY\XU] � bfN-RsO � NW] � b\NwRUO

·QÀ

Page 27: edges - University of Wisconsin–Madisonpages.cs.wisc.edu/~dyer/ai-qual/huttenlocher-edges95.pdfN cv t T|RUT Y\M _ac ]Qc N _QN NlRsNltlRvY\OaM|]QM cZRsN XvN OaV cvYfc y T N=V XUO&t

VXvO#tlN�cUc8]�MpY\[�]Q_aN~]�R�[���bfRvY\V#b\NScvt?]�bfN�cl�nYfM±OaXv�N�X�RUOE�NlRUN�Xv[uYfMN~g�T�Yft�TuN��_QN�c8]QXvN~[uOacvR�cZY\_QM�Yf�t?]QM�RYfM»RUN�XU[uc�OQP�RsTN:XU]QM_aN:OQP"cUt�]�b\Nlc OhjQN�X�g�T�Y\t�T»RsTNk^�]QXvN�O � cUNlXvjaNl�½RsOuO&t�tl�X�y

 YfRU��Y\M � À # T]Qc±Y\M�jaNlcvRvY\_�]�RsN��J[�OQXUNWRsTOQXUOa�_QT�bf^�RUTNWY\��N?]�OQP7[���bfRvY� ÄcUt�]�b\N»cvYf_aM%]�b\c��N�XZYfjQN��PxXUOQ[ cU[uO&OQRsT�YfM_3].cZY\_QM%]�b�gSYfRUTÁ] ��]��cUcZY²]QMJ]�Ru��Y�Ã+NlXUNlMnRwcUt�]�b\Nlc�y �;N|t�]�b�b\cuRsT�Yfc-­ AUª C\¬-­ ?�ª A�¬� g�T#Y\t�TÁYfcW].Px��MtlRvY\OaM���Nl�%MNl��OhjaN�XFRsTNq��Oa[�]�Y\MJOQPERsTN|OaXvYf_QYfM%]�b;Px�MtkRUYfOaM��SV�bf�cW]QM�OQRsTNlX��Yf[uN�McZY\OaM�tlOaXUXvN�cvV¾OaM���Y\M�_3RsO.RsTN»cUt�]�bfN½V%]QXU]Q[uNlRUN�X�y�³%OaXuN¡r]�[�V#b\N��Scs]?^�g�N|T%]?jaNq]�M Yf[F]�_aN$ �'&)(+* ��y � TN�tlOaXUXvN�cvV¾OaM���Y\M�_Fcvt?]�bfNk ÄcUV%]QtlN�Px�M�tlRUYfOaM�Y\c

� �'&)(+*�( � ��/ $ �9&)(+* � � ��� �'&)(�* � (g�TNlXUN � YfcSRsTN:cvt?]�bfN�V]QXs]Q[uNkRsN�Xly

�ÕMn�[ � NlXpOQPSM%]�Rs�XU]�b�cvRsXv�tlRU�XUNlcpt?]�M � N�Nkr&RUXs]QtkRsN��oPxXvOa[ RsT�NwcUt�]�bfNk �cvV%]QtlNwPx�MtkRUYfOaM���RUTN[uOacvRwt�Oa[u[uOaMÁO�P7g�T�Yft�TÁY\c�RsTN.d´Nl�_aN�clm�]�RwN�]Qt�T�cUt�]�b\N�y � T�N�cUN½N��_aNlc-t?]�M � N|Yf�N�M�RUY��%Nl��]QcNkr&RUXUN�[�].OQP7_aXU]Q��YfN�M�RF[F]�_aM�Y�Rs��N � ]�cuYfM�RsTN½¹~]QMM�^�OaV}N�XU]�RsOaX¡��OaX�]Qcu��N�XvO`tlXUOacvcvYfM_ac�OQP�RUTNz�]QV�b\]QtlY\]QM � ]Qc8Y\MwRUTN�Ž]QXUX   ��Yfbf�XUNkRsT-OQV¾NlXs]�RUOaXk�sy�¢�MwNkYfRUTN�X~t�]QcUN��#RUTN XvN�cv��bfR�Y\c�] � YfM%]QXZ^n �j�]�b\��N��Px�MtkRUYfOaM � OQX�cUV]Qt�NÙ��� �9&)(+*#( � ��y�³"Y\_Q�XUN � cUTOhg�c�]H_aXvNl^� ÄbfNljQNlb)Yf[�]Q_aNE]QM��wRsTN�N��_aNlc�]�R�j�]QXZY\OQ�ccUt�]�bfN�c;OQP�cv[uO#OQRUT�YfM_y

OQRUN±RsT%]�R�]�c:g=N±g�OQ��b\�3Nkr#V}N�tlR���PxOQX7b²]QXv_aN�X7j�]�bf�Nlc�O�P � RsTNlXUN�]QXvNpPxNlg=N�X�N��_aNlc � Nkr&RUXUN�[�]OQP�RsT�N7�%XUcZR��N�XZYfj�]�RvYfjQN�O�P�RUTNEcU[uO&OQRsT�N���Px�MtlRvY\OQM¾���%]�M�WRsTNEcvV%]�RUY\]�b�bfO&t?]�b�Y\��]�RUYfOaMWOQP�RUTNEN��_QN�c� N�t�OQ[�Nlc�V}O#OQXUN�Xly � MOQRsT�N�X�Y\M�RsNlXUNlcvRUYfM_WO � cUN�XZj�]�RUYfOaM|Yfc�RsT%]�R�RUTN�Nl�_aNlc��OFMOQR;cvYf[uV�bf^½]QVV}N?]�XOaX;��Yfcs]QVV}N?]�X7]�R Xs]QM��Oa[ ]Qc�RsTN�cUt?]�b\N�V%]QXs]�[�NkRsNlX�t�T%]QM�_aN�cly  Y�Rs��YfM�cvR�]�RsN��|R�g�OW]�cUcU��[�V#RUYfOaMc] � Oa��R�cv�t�T½cvt?]�bfN�cvV%]QtlN:RUXUNlN�c��%g�T�Yft�T|g=N�XvN�[uOaXvN:OaX~b\NlcUc�jaNlXvY��%N��½b\]�RUN�X � ^�OQRsT�N�XUcã y��+NlXUOwtlXUOacvcvYfM_ac7tlOaMMNltlRUN��.]�R�]Q� � ]QtlN�M�R7cvt?]�bfN�c7tlOaXUXvN�cvV¾OaM��qRsOFRUTNFdecs]�[�N�m+NkjaN�M�REYfM � �9& �ÆwMO�MNlg{��NlXUO�t�XUOQcUcvYfM_w]QXUN7YfM�RsXUO&��tlN��½]Qc � YfMtlXUN?]�cUN�cly

·#y � TN7bfO&t?]�RvY\OaMwOQP�]p��NlXUO±t�XvOacUcZY\M�_uYfM�� �9& � � ��� �9& ��RsNlM�c~RUOpYfRUc�RsXv�N�bfO#t�]�RUYfOaMwYfM � �'& ��]Qc��� ¶#y

� TN:P�]QtlRSRUT%]�R�MO�MNlg{N��_QN�c ]QXUNEYfMnRUXUO&��tlN��|]Qc � YfMt�XvN?]QcvN�cl�}[uN�]QMc�RsT%]�RSRUTN:N��_QN�c�PxOaXU[] �ZRUXUNlN ��+gSY�RsTqRUTNpXvO#OQR7]�R�RUTNHb\]QXU_QN�cvR�jQ]�b\�NHOQP�cvYf_a[�]wPxOaX g�T�Yft�T�RsTNlXUNHYfcE]QM�Nl�_aN�y � T�Y\c7YfMVXZY\MtkY\V#b\NF]�b�b\Ohg�c�]W_QYfjQN�M3N��_aN±RUO � N±RsXU]Qt��QNl�o]QtlXUOacvc�cvt?]�bfN�c � PxXvOa[ tlO�]QXvcUN±RsOW�%MNÙ���"]�b�RsTOa��_aTRsT#Y\c;N��_QN�RUXs]Qt���YfM_-VXvO � bfN�[ Yfc MO�R N�]Qcv^Qy O�RsN:RsT%]�R;cvt?]�bfNHcvV%]Qt�N�N��_QN�c;cvRUY�b�b"��OwMOQR;cvOQbfjQN�RUTNVXvO � bfN�[°OQP%g�T%]�R�cvt?]�bfN�RUO7V�Yft�����L7MN�OaV�RUYfOaMHYfc�RUO7�O�Px�XZRsTNlX�VXvO#tlN�cUcZY\M�_���cvYfM_7RsTN�N�M�RUYfXUN~cvt?]�bfNcUV]Qt�NwRUXUNlNQ��]QM��3RsTn�cp]hjQOQYf�oRsTNFVXUO � b\Nl[ O�PSNljQN�XpV�Yft���Y\M�_�]|cUt�]�bfN-OQPSVXvO#tlN�cvcvYfM_y � T�NW]QXUN�]g�TNlXUN�RUT�Yfc�T%]Qc;g�OQXU�QNl�qRsTN � N�cvR Y\c;Y\M|[�]�Rst�T�YfM_-OQMNk Ä��Y\[uNlMcvYfOaM%]�b�Px�MtkRUYfOaM � �9& ���£g�TN�XvN�RUTNN�M�RvY\XvNpcUt�]�b\NHcUV%]QtlNpRsXvN�NHO�P8��N�XvOWt�XvOacUcZY\M_Qc�Y\c�t�Oa[uV%]QXvN��qYfMqOaXv�N�X�RUO-�NkRsN�Xv[±Y\MN�RsTNpcZY\[±Y�b²]�XvY�R�^OQP�� �'& ��]QM���� �9& ��y

� TN½cvt?]�bfN½cvV%]QtlN½]QV�VXUO�]�t�TÁ�O&N�c�V%]QXvRvY²]�bfb�^(]Q��XvN�cvcFRsT�N»YfcUcv�N�c-O�P�RsT�N»RUXs]Q�NlOQà � NlR�g=N�N�M�NkRsN�tkR�] � Yfb�YfR�^J]QM� b\O&t?]�b�Yf�?]�RvY\OaM+y � c � _aNlRUcwcU[�]�b�bfN�X��SRUTN»bfO&t?]�b�Y\��]�RUYfOaMÁ_QNlRsc � NkRURUN�X-]�M� RUTN�NkRsN�tkRUYfOaM»_aNlRUc~g�OaXvcUN � ]�c~��YfcUt���cUcUNl�½YfM >#N�tkRUYfOaMq¸���y  Y�RsT-RsT�NEcUt?]�b\N:cUV]Qt�NERsXvN�N7g=N7Y\M�V%]�XvRS_aNkRRsT�N � NlcvRHOQP � O�RsT`g=OaXvbf�c � N�t�]Q�cvN-YfR�Y\cpV}OacvcvY � b\NFRsOqV�Yft��o]»jQ]�b\�NFOQP � g�TNlXUN-RUTNw�NkRsNltlRUYfOaMYfc-_aO&O#���~]QM�ÁRsT�N�MÁPxOQb�b\Ohg RsT�N½N���_aNqt�OQMnRUOa�X-��OÙg�MÁYfM�cUt�]�bfNq�M�RUY�b�RUTN½bfO#t�]�bfYf�?]�RUYfOaMÁY\cw]�bfcUO_aO&O#�+y � TNw[F] � OaXHVXvO � bfN�[ gSYfRUT`RsT#Y\c±]�VVXUOa]Qt�T`YfcHg�TN�M�]|_QYfjQN�M�Nl�_aN-tlOaM�RsOa�X�cUV�b�Y�RscHYfM�RsOR�g=OH��Yfc � OQYfM�R~Nl�_aN�c�]Qc � �Nlt�XUN�]QcUNlc�� � Nlt?]Q�cvN�RsT�N�MFg=N7]�XUN�b\NkP�R�gSY�RsTFRsTN�Y\cvcU�N OQP�g�T�Yft�T-V%]�RsTFRUO

·

Page 28: edges - University of Wisconsin–Madisonpages.cs.wisc.edu/~dyer/ai-qual/huttenlocher-edges95.pdfN cv t T|RUT Y\M _ac ]Qc N _QN NlRsNltlRvY\OaM|]QM cZRsN XvN OaV cvYfc y T N=V XUO&t

³"Yf_a�XvN � �p¹~]QMM�^3N��_aNlcp]�R�[H�#bfRvY\V�bfNwcvt?]�bfN�cHOQP~cv[�O&OQRUT�Y\M�_� � / 7 ¸ ( ã ( · ( � ( � ( ã À#y � TNFcUt�]�b\N¡ cUV]Qt�N:N���_aN�c ]QXUN:]-decvRs]Qt��£m}O�P"RUTN�cvN � Y\M%]�Xv^-Yf[�]Q_aN�c � PxOaX�]�b�b�j�]�b\��N�c�OQP � �MOQR � �cZRSRsTOQcUN:cUTOhg�MTNlXUN���PxOaXv[±Y\M_F]pRsTXvN�N¡ ���Yf[uN�McZY\OaM]�b � Y\M]QXv^�cvV%]Qt�N � �'&)(+*�( � �sy

· �

Page 29: edges - University of Wisconsin–Madisonpages.cs.wisc.edu/~dyer/ai-qual/huttenlocher-edges95.pdfN cv t T|RUT Y\M _ac ]Qc N _QN NlRsNltlRvY\OaM|]QM cZRsN XvN OaV cvYfc y T N=V XUO&t

t�TO&OacUN�y�L�jaN�X�XU]QM_aNlc8OQP � g�T�N�XUN;]Et�OQMnRUOa�X��O&N�c�M�OQR8cUV�b�Y�R?�nTOhg�NkjaNlX��#RUT�Yfc�Y\c�]7_aO&O#�pRUN�t�TM#Y\�n�NPxOaXSOhjaNlXUtlOa[±Y\M_�RsTN:�NkRsNltlRUYfOaM� Ùb\O&t?]�b�Yf�?]�RvY\OaM»RsXU]Q�N�O�Ã�y

� M%]�RU�Xs]�b��n�N�cZRUYfOaM�RUT%]�R�]�XvYfcUN�cWYfc-RsT%]�RWOQP�XUNlt�OaMcZRsXv�tlRvY\M_ $ �'&)(+* �±_�YfjQN�M�RsTN�Nl�_aNlc|]�R[H�#bfRvY\V�bfNwcvt?]�bfN�cl� � �'&)(+*�( � �sy � T�YfcH�n�N�cZRUYfOaM`T]Qc � N�NlM3YfM�jaN�cZRUYf_�]�RUN�� � ^.]�M&��[ � N�XHO�P~]Q�#RsTOaXvc� N�ye_�yf� � � # �sy � NlXUN±g�NF]QXvN±MOQR�t�OaM�t�N�XvMN��.gSYfRUT.RUTNu�NlRs]�Y�b\c:OQP�RsTNlcUN�XUNlcU��b�Rscl� � �#R�cZY\[uV�b�^�MOQRUNRsT]�RWPxOaXWt�NlXvRs]�Y\M�tlb\]QcUcvN�c»OQP�Px�MtlRvY\OQMc $ �9&)(+* �±t?]QM � N�XvN�t�OQMcvRUXU�tkRsN��{�V�RUO�[H��b�RUYfV�b�Y\t�]�RUY�jaN]QM��]Q����YfRvYfjQN�t�OaMcZR�]QM�RUc�y Å|OaXvN�Y\M�RsNlXUNlcvRUYfM_Qb�^a� YfRWYfc�cU� ��tlYfN�M�R»RsO��nMOhg � �'&)(�*#( � � � �cvRWPxOQXt�NlXvRs]�Y\M�j�]�b\��N�c�O�P � YfMwOQXU�NlX�RUO�XvN�t�OQMcvRUXU�tkR�$ �'&)(+* ��Y\M�RsT�Yfc�[F]�MMN�Xly � TN�cvN�j�]�bf�N�c=]QXUN;cvYf[uV�b�^�Oa� � bfYfM_acEO�P ��� OaX�O&tlRs]hjQN�c¡����cU�t�T3]Qc7RUTNpN���_aN�c:cUT�OÙg�M�YfM�³"Y\_Q�XUN � � g�NpgSY�bfb�XUNlRU�XUM�RUO-RsT�Yfc� XZY\NkÇ^ � Nkb\Ohg�g�TN�XvN���^a]Q��Yft�g�]?jaNkb\NkR�RsXU]QMcZPxOaXU[uc;]QXUN7YfM�RsXvO#���t�N��}��y

�*���� ��(���� TNWNlMnRvY\XvNWY\cvcU�N�OQP;[H�#bfRvY� ÄcUt?]�b\N�XUNlVXUNlcUNlMnRs]�RUYfOaMcF]QM��RUTNWt�T%]QXU]QtlRUN�XvYf�?]�RUYfOaM�OQP;cvYf_aM%]�bfc±PxXUOa[RsT�NlYfX;Nl�_aNlc ]�R�[H��b�RUYfV�bfN�cvt?]�bfN�c;t?]QM � N7j&YfNlg=N��|Y\M�RsNlXU[uc�OQP"g�]?jaNkb\NkR�RsT�N�OaXZ^ � tkP y � � # ��y��;N�XvN:g=N� XZY\NkÇ^���Y\cvt��cvc=g�]?jaNlbfNlR�RsXs]�McvPxOaXv[uc�]QM��FTOhgÁRUTNl^�]�VV�b�^±Y\M�RsT�Yfc=tlOaM�RsN¡r#R�y���g~]?jaNkb\NkR~Px�MtkRUYfOaMYfc ]pPx�M�tlRUYfOaM�g�TOacvN�YfM�RsN�_QXs]�b)Yfc���N�XvO�

� �� � �'& � /�¶ (

]QM��g�T�Yft�T½T%]�c ]±cvt?]�b�Y\M�_FVXvOaV}N�XvR�^Qy � T�Y\c;cUt�]�b�Y\M_�VXvOaV¾NlXvR�^WYfc�cvYf[�V#bf^

�'& � / ã' �� & '�� 7

� TN:g~]?jQNlbfNlR;RsXs]�McvPxOaXv[ OQP���]�R;cUt?]�b\N ' YfcSRsTNlM|�Nk�%MNl�q]Qc�� � �9& � / � �9& � � �'& � (

g�TNlXUN �Yfcu]½g~]?jQNlbfNlR�Px�MtlRvY\OQM � T%]QcpYfMnRUN�_aXU]�bS�lN�XUO.]QM���RUTNWcUt�]�b�Y\M_�VXvOaV}N�XvR�^%�sy � T%]�R±Yfc��=]g�]hjQNlbfNlR-RUXs]QM�cvPxOaXv[ OQPE]�Px�MtkRUYfOaM���� �'& ���=Y\cut�OQ[�V���RsNl� � ^ tlOaM�jaOQb�jnY\M�_`RsTN�Px�MtkRUYfOaM gSY�RsTJ]g�]hjQNlbfNlR�Px�MtlRvY\OQM3]�R:cUOa[uNucUt�]�b\N�y  TN�M�RsTNpg�]?jaNkb\NkRHPx�MtkRUYfOaM �Yfc�tkb\N�]QX7PxXUOQ[ RsT�N�tlOaM�RsN¡r#R��g=N�gSY�bfb�_QN�MNlXs]�b�bf^-�N�MO�RsN:RsTNEg�]hjQNlbfNlR RsXs]�McvPxOaXv[ � ^ � � �9& ��Xs]�RUTN�XSRUT%]QM � � � �'& �sy

� TN ��]��cUcZY²]QM�RUT%]�R-g=N�T%]?jaN � N�N�M��cZY\M�_�PxOQX-cU[uO&OQRsT�YfM_(]QM��Nl�_aN��NkRsN�tkRUYfOaM�T%]Qc-RUTNcUt�]�b�Y\M_�VXvOaV¾NlXvR�^

��� �9& � / ã� · ����� � �� � � � �

g�TNlXUN�RsTNSdecUt�]�b\N�P�]QtkRsOaXlm ' Yfc � y ��M%]�bfOa_aOQ�cvb�^7RsT�N���N�XvY�j�]�RUY�jaN � OQX��} ÄRUT:�N�XZYfj�]�RvYfjQN��¾OQP�] �:]Q�cvcvY\]QMYfc�cU��t�T�]�cUt�]�bfN��wPx�M�tlRUYfOaM�y � T�N7�N�XZYfj�]�RvYfjQN7OQP�] ��]��cUcZY²]QMw]�bfcUOpT%]�c=RsT�N�VXvOaV¾NlXvR�^uRsT]�R=Y�Rsc�]QXUN�]YfcW��N�XvOy � Tn�cWRUTN��N�XZYfj�]�RvYfjQN�OQP�] �:]Q�cvcvY\]QM�Y\c�]`g�]?jaNkb\NkR|RUXs]QMcZPxOaXU[�y � T�Yfc»[uN�]QMcWRsT%]�RRsT�NHcUt�]�bfN�cUV]Qt�NuN���_aNHXvN�VXvN�cUNlM�R�]�RvY\OaM�OQP�]QM½Yf[F]�_aNQ� � �9&)(+*#( � ���%YfMnRUXUO&��tlN���] � OhjaNHYfcE]�PxOQXU[ OQPg�]hjQNlbfNlRuRsXU]QMcZPxOaXU[ OQP $ �'&)(+* ��yq¢�MoP�]�tlR?��OQMNWt�Oa�#b\�oRUT�Y\M��`OQP;]�b�b~O�P;RUTN-Nl�_aN-�NkRsNltlRsOQXUc±RsT%]�ROaV}N�XU]�RsN � ^`cv[�O&OQRUT�Y\M�_q]QM�`��YfþN�XvN�M�RUY\]�RvY\OaM � g�T�Yft�T�T%]?jaNwOQV¾NlXs]�RUOaXUc�g�TOacUN�Y\M�RUN�_aXU]�b=YfcH�lN�XvO#�YfM(RUN�XU[ucuOQP;g~]?jQNlbfNlRscly ;OÙg g�N�R�]��QN»]qb\O&Oa�o]�R±g�Tn^�Y�R�[±Y\_aT�R � N-g�OaXZRsT�RsT�YfM��YfM_`OQP N���_aN�NkRsN�tkRUYfOaM|YfM�RsN�Xv[uc;O�P"g�]?jaNlbfNlRUc�y

· �

Page 30: edges - University of Wisconsin–Madisonpages.cs.wisc.edu/~dyer/ai-qual/huttenlocher-edges95.pdfN cv t T|RUT Y\M _ac ]Qc N _QN NlRsNltlRvY\OaM|]QM cZRsN XvN OaV cvYfc y T N=V XUO&t

³"YfXUcvR�OQP~]�bfb$��g~]?jaNkb\NkRpRsXU]QMcZPxOaXU[ucp]�XUN�]|T�Yf_aT�b�^�XUNl��M�]QM�RpXUNlVXUNlcUNlMnRs]�RUYfOaMoO�PS]»Px��MtlRvY\OaM+yL7MN±�cvNlPx��b8XvN�cU�#bfR�XUNl_�]QXv��Y\M�_�g�]?jaNkb\NkRsc�YfcERsT%]�R7RsTNucvO� �t�]�bfbfN�����^a]Q��Yft�g�]?jaNkb\NkR�RUXs]QMcZPxOaXU[ � RUTNcU[uO&OQRsT#Y\M_�]�RE�Oa� � bfYfM_ac7YfM�cUt�]�b\N��)OaX�O&tlRs]?jaN�c¡�;Y\cE]-tlOa[uV�bfNlRsN � Y\MqP�]�tlREXvN���M��%]QM�Rl�;XvN�VXvN�cUNlM# R�]�RUYfOaM½OQP�]uPx�MtkRUYfOaM�y � T�NpcUNl�&��N�MtlN±OQP�g�]hjQNlbfNlRUc�]�R��OQ� � b�Y\M_Qc�Y\M½cUt?]�b\NHYfc�XvNlPxNlXUXUNl�qRsOw]Qc RUTN��^a]Q��Yft�g�]?jaNlbfNlR RsXU]QMcvPxOQXU[�� � � / � � ; � � �'& �v� "����g�TNlXUN�� XUN�V�XUN�cvN�M�Rsc�RsT�N�V}OacZYfRvYfjQN:YfM�RsNl_aN�Xvc�� ã ( · ( ¿ ( 7�7 7� y8³%XUOa[ RsT�YfcSRsXU]QMcvPxOQXU[�]�RUYfOaM

� �½YfRSYfcV}OacUcZY � bfNHRUOwXUNlt�OaM�cvRsXv�tlR �"� � ��R7[uOaXvN�YfMnRUN�XvN�cvRvY\M�_Qbf^|YfR;Yfc7OQP�RsNlM½V}OacUcZY � b\NHRUO-XUNlt�OaM�cvRsXv�tlR � � OQX]ucUt?]�b\Nl�|jaNlXUcZY\OaM}� � �cZR PxXvOa[ PxXvOa[ÕRUTN±d´Nl�_aN�clm¾O�P

� �"y � TN�cvNFdeN��_QN�c�m}]QXvNERsTN�Nkr&RsXvN�[�]FO�P"RUTNg�]hjQNlbfNlR:RsXU]QMcZPxOaXU[ g�TN�M�RsT�NHg~]?jQNlbfNlR:Px�MtkRUYfOaM �Yfc:]F�%XvcvR:�NlXvY�jQ]�RUY�jaN±OaX�RUTN±��NlXUOWtlXUOacvcvYfM_acg�TNlM�Y�R~YfcS]pcUNlt�OaM��»��N�XvY�j�]�RUY�jaN�y�>&�t�T»]HcUNkR�OQP�N��_QN�c~YfcScUTOhg�MWY\M�³�Y\_a��XUN � y � T#Y\cS[uN?]�Mc~RsT%]�R� �cZRSRsTN:N���_aN�cl�%O � R�]�Y\MNl�»]�R�cUNkjaN�XU]�b�cUt�]�bfN�c��£t�]QV�Rs��XUN:[uOacvR�OQP�RUTNEY\M�PxOQXU[�]�RUYfOaM-YfMWRsTN:OaXZY\_QYfM%]�bYf[F]�_aN � OQX�Px�MtkRUYfOaM¾��y�¢�M�OQRUTN�X7g=OaXU��c��)cvYf[uV�b�^�XUNlVXUNlcUN�M�RvY\M_|]QMqYf[�]Q_aNpYfMqRsN�Xv[ucEOQP8YfRUc7N��_QN�cPxOaX �Oa� � b�YfM_ac7OQP � Yfc7cv� ��tlYfN�M�RERsO-XvN�tlOaMcvRUXU�tkRERsTN�Y\[�]Q_aN � �V½RUO-OhjaNlXs]�b�b�YfMnRUN�McZYfR�^qcUt?]�bfYfM_#�sy� TNW�NkR�]�Y�bfc±OQPSRsTNlcUN�XUNlcU��b�Rscu]�XUN � Nl^QOaM��RsTNWcvt�OaV}NWOQPSRUT�Y\c±tlOa�XvcUNQ� � �#R±[uOaXUN-YfM�PxOaXv[F]�RUYfOaMt?]�M � N7PxOa�M��»YfM � � # y� O�RsN7RsT]�R�cvYf[±Yfb\]QX�XUNlcU��b�Rsc�T%]?jaN�]�bfcUO � N�N�M��NlXvY�jaNl�|gSY�RsTOa�#R;RUTN7g�]hjQNlbfNlRPxOaXv[H��b\]�RUYfOaM�y

��cUNlt�OaM�����]QM��V}N�XvT%]QVc7[uOaXvNHYfMnRUN�XvN�cvRvY\M�_��VXUOaV}N�XZR�^½O�P�g~]?jaNkb\NkR:RsXs]�McvPxOaXv[uc7Y\c�RUT%]�R7RUTNl^t?]�M � Nu�cUNl�.RUO|XvN�VXvN�cUNlM�R�RUTNWd´�Nl_aXUNlNFO�P���YfcUtlOaM�RUYfMn��YfR�^}m"]�RERsT�N�Nl�_aNlc � cUT%]QXvV3t�T]QM_aNlck� Y\M3]Px�MtkRUYfOaM�y � TN�cvNW[uNlRsT�O#�c�NljQN�M(]QVV�b�^�RsO|��Y\cvt�XvNlRsN � cs]Q[uV�bfN��}�EXUNlVXUNlcUNlMnRs]�RUYfOaMc±O�P~Px�MtkRUYfOaMccU��t�T�]QcHO&t�tl�X�YfMo��Yf_QY�RUYf�?]�RvY\OaM+y|¢�MoOQXU�NlX�RUO½Y\M�jQN�cvRvY\_a]�RsNwRUT�YfcH�cvN-OQP~g�]?jaNlbfNlRUc±g�NF[H�cZRp�%XUcZRYfMnRUXUO&��tlNpRsTNpM�OQRUYfOaM�OQP�z�YfVcUt�T�Y�Rs�uXvN�_a��b\]QXZYfR�^Qy�z)NkR � �'& � � N±]½de_aNlMN�XU]�bfYf��Nl�.Px��MtlRvY\OaM+mf�+g�T#Y\t�TYfMtlbf��NlcF]�Mn^3Px�MtkRUYfOaM(]QcHg=Nlb�b�]QcpRsT#Y\M_Qc±cU�t�T(]QcpRUTN � YfXs]Qt-��Nlb�R�]�� � �'& �EYfM�RsXUO&��tlN�� ] � OÙjQN� Y$y NQy���� �9& � [F]?^ � NF��M � Oa�M��N�� � ��R ���

�� �'& �;Y\c � Oa�M�Nl�3PxOaX�]QM�^��%M#YfRUN�YfM�RsN�XZj�]�b � � ( ��U�sy  N

cs]?^�RsT]�R � �9& ��Yfc���M�YfPxOQXU[±bf^|z�YfVcUt�T�Y�Rs� ��OhjaNlX7]QM½YfM�RsNlXvj�]�b � � ( ���Y�P�]QM�|OaM�b�^�YfP�RUTN�XvNpNkr&YfcvRUcE]t�OQMcvRs]QM�R� cU�t�T»RsT%]�R;PxOQX�]QM�^ & � (�& ; � � � ( ��

� � �'& �s� + � �9& ; � � �� � & � + & ; � �(g�TNlXUN + ã � � � ã y

 N�XUNlPxNlX�RsOpRUTN7�M#YfPxOaXv[Õz�YfVcUt�T#YfRU��¥s¬$« � C�ªQ¥¡¨�®$¯ OQP � �'& �8]Qc�RsT�N7�VV}N�X � Oa�M�� � �SOQP�]�bfb+cU�t�T��y � TN-b\]QXv_aN�XHRUT�Yfcp�VV}N�X � Oa�M��]�R & �h��RsTNW[uOaXvN½deXUN�_Q��b²]�X�m� �'& �EYfcu]�R & �hy.³%OaXHN¡r�]Q[uV�b\N��Y�P � �9& �HYfcF�#YfþN�XvN�M�RUY\] � bfNq]�R & �FRUTN�M(YfR�Yfcwz�YfVcUt�T�Y�Rs� � / ã ]�R & �?yÁ¢�M�Rs�#YfRvYfjQNlb�^a�Sg�TN�M ��Yfc��Y�Ã+NlXUNlMnRvY²] � b\N�Y�RscucvbfOaV}N�Yfc � Oa�M�Nl� � ^�cvOa[uN� ]QM� � � �'& �s� + � �'& ; � � Y\c±RUT&��c � Oa�M��N�� � ^ � & � + & ; � y L7M�RsTN�OQRUTN�X�T%]�M����Y�P � �9& �uY\c»��YfcUtlOaM�RUYfM&��Oa�c � ��R � Oa��M�N���]�R & ��RsTNlM�Y�RYfc�z)YfVcvt�T�YfRU� �8/ ¶�y ¢�M�RU��YfRvYfjQNlb�^a�7RUTN�cvbfOaV}N�YfcWMOQR � Oa�M��N���� � ��R�RsT�N�[F]�_aM�Y�Rs��N�OQP:RUTN��Y�Ã+NlXUNlMt�N � � �9& �s� + � �'& ; � � Y\c � Oa�M��N�� � ^WcvOa[uN�tlOaMcZR�]QM�R � Nlt?]Q�cvN�RUTNEPx�MtkRUYfOaM»Yfc � Oa��M�N��+y³"YfM%]�b�bf^3YfP � �9& �EY\c±�#Y\cvt�OaM�RUYfMn�Oa�cF]QM���M � Oa�M��N�� ]�R & � � cU��t�TJ]Qcu] ��Px�MtlRvY\OQM¾�:RsTNlM�YfR±Yfcz�Y\V�cUt�T�Y�Rs� ��/ + ã y�¢�M�Rs��Y�RUY�jaNkbf^Q�#RUTN���YfþN�XvN�MtlN � � �'& �U� + � �'& ; � �Ù� N�t�OQ[�Nlc�]�X � Y�RsXU]QXvY�bf^Hb²]QXv_aNQ� � ��ROaM�b�^�]QcSRUTN7Y\M�RUN�Xvj�]�b�_QNlRsc;]QX � Y�RsXs]�XvY�bf^Wcv[�]�bfb$y � T%]�R�Yfc��Y�RSY\c � Oa�M�Nl� � ^�cvOa[uN�tlOaMcZR�]QM�R�RUYf[uN�c� & � + & ; � � � y

� RsTNlOaXUNl[ ] � Oa��R�g~]?jaNkb\NkRsc�Y\c~RUT%]�R � �9& ��YfcS�M�Y�PxOaXU[±b�^Wz�Y\V�cUt�T�Y�Rs���3OhjaNlX � � ( ��8YfP"]QM��»OQM�bf^Y�P"RUTN�XvN�N¡r#YfcvRUc�]±tlOaMcvRs]QM�R� cU��t�T|RsT]�R�PxOaX�]�b�b & � � � ( ?�8RUTNEg~]?jQNlbfNlR�RUXs]QM�cvPxOaXv[ cs]�RvY\cZ�%N�c� ; � � �'& ���� � · " � � 7

¿a¶

Page 31: edges - University of Wisconsin–Madisonpages.cs.wisc.edu/~dyer/ai-qual/huttenlocher-edges95.pdfN cv t T|RUT Y\M _ac ]Qc N _QN NlRsNltlRvY\OaM|]QM cZRsN XvN OaV cvYfc y T N=V XUO&t

¢�M�V%]QXvRvY\tl��b\]QX��ÙRsT�Yfc)Y\[uV�b�YfN�c�RsT%]�R�Y�P#RUTN8�M�Y�PxOaXU[ z)YfVcvt�T�YfRU��XvN�_a��b\]QXZYfR�^EtlOaM��Y�RUYfOaM�]�R & ��Yfc�V¾OQcvY�RUY�jaNRsT�N�M-RsT�NE]Q[uV�b�YfRU��NEOQP�RsT�N�g~]?jQNlbfNlR�RsXU]QMcvPxOQXU[ ]�R & �ScvTOa��bf���N�tlXUN?]�cUN:]Qc�RUTN7cvt?]�bfNE�N�tlXUN�]QcUNlc�yL7M»RUTN:OQRsT�N�XST%]QM��»Y�P�Y�RSY\c��lN�XUOuRsT�N�[�]Q_QM�YfRU��N�cUTOQ��b\� � N:YfM�NlV¾NlM�NlMnR�OQP"cUt?]�b\N��£]QM��YfP�YfR�YfcMNl_�]�RUY�jaN���RsTNH[F]�_aM�Y�Rs��NHcUTOa�#b\���Nlt�XUN�]QcUNu]�c�RsTNHcUt?]�b\NpYfMt�XvN?]QcvN�cly � T#Y\cEVXvOhj&Yf�Nlc�]F[�NkRsTO&�OQP=tlb\]QcUcZYfP�^nYfM_½RUTN±R�^#V}N�OQP�Nl�_aN � ��Y�þN�XUNlM�RUY\] � bfNQ��cZRsNlV`N���_aNuOaX:�Nlb�R�]WPx�MtkRUYfOaM¾� � ]QcvN��`OQM.RUTNNljQOQbf��RUYfOaMJO�P�RsT�N»g�]?jaNlbfNlRw[�]Q_aM�Y�Rs���N½]QcF]�Px�MtlRvY\OQMJOQP cUt�]�b\N � �O#Nlc±RsTN»[�]Q_aM�Y�Rs���N|OQP7]V}N?]Q�pYfMFRUTN�cU[uO#O�RsTNl�-�N�XZYfj�]�RvYfjQN _QNlR�b²]QXv_aN�Xl�ncU[�]�b�b\NlX�OaX8cvRs]?^±RsTN;cs]Q[uN ]Qc8RsTN;cUt�]�b\N;t�T%]QM�_aN�c � T�Y�b\N:PxOaXScU]Q[uV�b\Nl�|Px�M�tlRUYfOaMc � N�ye_�yf�£��Yf_QY�RUYf��N��»Y\[�]Q_QN�ck�=MO�RUYfOaMc;cU�t�T½]Qc���YfþN�XvN�M�RUY\] � bfNH��OFMO�R[�]Q�QN�cUNlMcUN��+RsTNlXUN�Y\c�]QMq]QM]�b\OQ_aOa�c;VXUOQV¾NlXvR�^�PxOaX�cs]Q[uV�bfN��qPx��MtlRvY\OaM�c g�TNlXUN�RUTN�XvN�Yfc7]�cUNlR�OQPcUt�]�bfN�cHOhjQN�X:g�T�Y\t�T`]QM.N��_aN�d´]QVV}N?]QXvc�tlOaM�RUYfMn�Oa�clm"OaX±d´]QVV}N?]QXvc�RUO � NF]W��Y\cvt�OaM�RvY\Mn��Y�R�^}mfy � T�YfcXs]�M_aN�OQP£cUt�]�b\Nlc�t?]�M � N��NkRsN�tkRsNl� � ^�Nkr�]Q[±YfM�YfM_�RsT�N�NljQOQbf��RUYfOaM±OQPRUTN�[�]Q_QM�YfRU��N=OQPRsT�N=g�]hjQNlbfNlRRsXU]QMcZPxOaXU[©Nl�_aN�c OhjaN�X�]FXU]QM_aN�OQP�cvt?]�bfN�cly � T#Y\c�] � Y�bfY�R�^�RsOwtkb²]�cUcvY�P�^»N��_QN�c � ]QcUNl�qOaM|RUTNlYfX R�^&V}Nt?]�M � N7O�P�t�OaMcZY\��N�Xs] � b\N:��RvYfb�Y�R�^ay�³%OaX�N¡r]�[�V#b\N��N��_QN�c � NlR�g=N�N�M|]QMWO �#� N�tlRS]QM�-RsT�N � ]Qt��n_aXvOa�M�]QXvN�_QN�MNlXs]�b�bf^wY\M�RsNlMcvY�R�^»��YfcUt�OQMnRvY\Mn��Y�RUYfN�cl�¾g�TNlXUN�]Qc cvT%]Q�Ohg{N��_aNlc�]�XUN:_aN�M�N�Xs]�bfb�^Wt�OQMnRvY\Mn�OQ�c�y

¿ ã

Page 32: edges - University of Wisconsin–Madisonpages.cs.wisc.edu/~dyer/ai-qual/huttenlocher-edges95.pdfN cv t T|RUT Y\M _ac ]Qc N _QN NlRsNltlRvY\OaM|]QM cZRsN XvN OaV cvYfc y T N=V XUO&t

� 4��Q4 ��4H@q9�4:K

� ã # � y ��y ]�bfb\]QXU�J]QM��¹�y´Å3y XUOhg�M����=¦�§ ? �&® ¬k¥���¨\­k¨�¦ �%� ��XvN�M�RUYft�N¡  ��]�bfb$� � M_�b\Nkg�O&O#��¹=bfY�Ã+cl��y���y�� ã � � ·#y

� · # ��y´³�y¹~]QMM�^a� � �°¹�Oa[uV��R�]�RUYfOaM%]�b � VVXvO�]Qt�TWRsO � �_aN � NkRsN�tkRUYfOaM ���� � ���¥vª ��­�ª Ak®$¨�¦ ��­�¦ �� ªQ®�® ¬k¥ ��� �}ª C ¯h­k¨\­�ª ��,��qª A��&¨ �+¬� �%®�¬<C C ¨µ«#¬ � A�¬k���8OQb$y � ��;Oy%À��%V�V�y£¿ �   � ¿�� ã � � À�y

� ¿ # y��±y �"y��;OaXUM���;¦��k¦�®��)¨\­k¨�¦ �%�£Å|¢ � ��XUNlcUcl�+¹~]�[ � XZY\�_QNQ�¾Å½]Qcvc�y�� ã � � À�y� � # >¾y�Å|]�bfb\]�R7]QM� >¾y �+TOaM_�� �s¹�T%]�Xs]QtkRsN�XZY\��]�RUYfOaM�OQP�cvYf_aM%]�bfc�PxXUOQ[ Nl�_aNlc ����� �����¥vª ��­! � ªQ®" � �}ª C# �ª ��,���ª A��$ %��%® ¬<C# \� ã � � ���VV+y ã ¶ÙÆ ¿�·#� ã � � ·#y

� ¸ # � y+Å|]QXUX�]QM� � y ��Yfbf�XvNlRsT+� � � TNlOaXv^|OQP � �_aN � NlRsNltlRvY\OaM �� � ¥s¦ A! ~¦ ¤�®��%¬���¦�¯Qª C%&�¦ Ak¨�¬k®�¯|¦ ¤' ¦ ��,&¦ �)(S�$�8OQb$y}·Q¶ �V�V�y ã �   · ã � ã � � ¶�y

� À # �Hy �"y  Y�Rs��YfM�� �+>#t?]�b\N >#V%]�t�N�³"Y�bfRUN�XvYfM_ ��� � ¥�¦ A! �¦ ¤* �%®�¬k¥ �}ªQ®$¨�¦ �}ª C,+#¦�¨ �%®-�=¦ �?¤?¬k¥s¬ � A�¬H¦ ����¥ �®�¨ ��Ak¨�ª C.��%® ¬<C C ¨µ«#¬ � A�¬k�#VV�y ã ¶ ã �   ã ¶a·a·#� � �_a�cZR ã � � ¿�y

¿�·