Upload
buimien
View
216
Download
1
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
Ecosystems for Life A Bangladesh-India Initiative PROCEEDINGS: Trans-boundary Policy Dialogue on Hilsa Fisheries Management
24 July 2012, Kolkata, India
Dialogue for Sustainable Management of Trans-Boundary Water Regimes in South Asia
Inauguration Trans-boundary Policy Dialogue on Hilsa Fisheries Management
Time Inauguration
10.00 AM – 11:5 AM Welcome Remarks by Mr A P Sharma, Director, CIFRI Introduction to IUCN: by Ganesh Pangare, Head, IUCN Water in Asia, IUCN ARO Speech by Guest of Honour: Mr. Sayed Monowar Hossain, Former Secretary, BIWTA and Navigation Expert Speech by Guest of Honour: Guest of Honour: Md Mokbul Hossain, Member of Parliament, Member, Parliamentary Standing Committee for the MoFL, Bangladesh Speech by Guest of Honour: Mr. Zafar Iqbal Siddique, Member of Parliament and Member, Parliamentary Standing Committee for the MoFL, Bangladesh Speech by Chief Guest : Mr Subrata Saha, State Minister for Fisheries, West Bengal, India
The Trans-boundary Policy Dialogue on Hilsa Fisheries Management organized by Ecosystems for Life:
A Bangladesh-India Initiative started at 10.00 am with the welcoming announcement from Ms Bushra Nishat,
Project Manager (Bangladesh), Ecosystems for Life: A Bangladesh-India Initiative. Ms Nishat invited Mr
Ishtiak Uddin Ahmad, Country Representative, IUCN Bangladesh Country Office to the dais to chair the
Inauguration session, Mr Ganesh Pangare, Md Mokbul Hossain, Mr Zafar Iqbal Siddique, Mr Subrata Saha
and Mr Subesh K Das as Guest of honour.
Welcome Remarks: Mr A P Sharma, Director, CIFRI
In his welcome speech, Mr A P Sharma remarked that the Hilsa, an important fish
species in Bangladesh and India, is difficult to manage efficiently as its habitat is in
public and international waters. This meeting, he said, is an important first step towards
formulating policies that could help foster effective hilsa management.
He thanked IUCN for the efforts towards conservation of this prized species, the Hilsa.
He said that the Ecosystems for Life project has created a platform for discussing legal
and management related issues. Also the project is creating awareness on the pertinent issues needing
immediate attention.
He highlighted a number of issues related to Hilsa & which will be discussed throughout the day; such as
Trans-boundary fishery and Migratory pattern of the species
Finally, he hoped that dialogue will come up with concrete measures directed at preventing unsustainable
fishery practices for improving the population status of the species.
Speech by Ganesh Pangare, Head, IUCN Water in Asia, IUCN ARO
Mr Ganesh Pangare then introduced IUCN to the audience, and emphasized its role as
an international membership organization that focuses on conservation. Ganesh then
gave the audience an insight into the Ecosystems for Life initiative, and how this Hilsa
policy workshop fits in with the overall research themes and objectives of the initiative.
This workshop, he said, is one such method through which scientific, factual outcomes
can be translated into policy and legislation that produce real world results.
Guest of Honour: Md Mokbul Hossain, Member of Parliament and Member, Parliamentary Standing Committee for the MoFL, Bangladesh
Md Mokbul Hossain began his introductory speech by underlining the importance of
Hilsa as a source of food and livelihood, and also as a symbol for Indo-Bangladesh
relations. The economic importance of the hilsa cannot be ignored, he said, citing that
it is the source of livelihood, both directly and indirectly for 2-2.5m people across both
countries. He said that70% of the Hilsa consumed in West Bengal is sourced from
Bangladesh. He then raised concerns over diminishing population size and breakages
in the migratory routes of the fish that bonds the two countries culturally.
Mokbul also spoke about the fishing ban imposed by the Government of Bangladesh, which aims to allow the
proliferation of jatka (Hilsa juveniles), and the complementary food subsidy programmes offered by the
government to aid fishermen during the ban period. These measures, according to Mokbul, are not sufficient
if implemented sporadically and in select spots – there is a need to implement such measures in a
harmonized and holistic manner. He concluded his speech by expressing his hopes that the outcomes of
dialogue are analyzed critically, and the most useful and implementable of which are adopted into joint policy
and action.
Mr. Zafar Iqbal Siddique, Member of Parliament and Member, Parliamentary Standing Committee for the MoFL
Mr Jafar iqbal started his speech by saying that political border can only isolate the
countries but never has been succeeded in breaking cultural relationship between
Bangladesh and India. He said that the Hilsa has established itself as one of the most
important commercial fishes of the Indo-Pacific region. The species is all the rage in
Bengali cuisine and highly prized in West Bengal, India because of its distinctive taste
and flavor.
He wished that the participants of this meeting would be able to take some legendary
steps so that the people of coming future would consider this meeting as a milestone of bi-lateral
cooperation. He thanked IUCN for conducting such a research and organizing the dialogue.
State Minister for Fisheries, West Bengal, India
Mr Subrata Saha remarked that more needs to be done to save the hilsa, an
internationally valuable species. He requested that IUCN takes the initiative to do so
not only through knowledge sharing meetings, but also in collaboration with (a) the
governments of Bangladesh and India, through policy advocacy exercises, and (b)
with the fishermen, by increasing and deepening awareness on the why the fishing
ban period and the ban of fine mesh nets are implemented. “Hilsa is becoming more
popular,” he said, and shared an anecdote on how the Prime Minister of India, a
staunch vegetarian, made an exception for the hilsa during a trip to Bangladesh. Subrata recommended that
the measures adopted to conserve the hilsa be extended to other fish species. Subrata then concluded his
remarks by congratulating the researchers on their hard work, and asked that this research, dialogue and
advocacy effort is continued.
Mr Subesh K Das then introduced a pilot dam project implemented by the Dept of Forestry of West Bengal,
which began works in 2011 and is hoped to garner a win-win solution. He also urged IUCN to expand its
research finding for larger influence.
Plenary Session 1: Current status of Hilsa fisheries management Session Chair: Dr C Vasudevappa, Chief Executive, National Fisheries Development Board, Government of India
Time Session
11:30 AM – 11:50 AM Presentation on JRT research findings on Hilsa study by Dr. Utpal Bhowmik, Head, Riverine Ecology, Central Inland Fisheries Research Institute and Prof. Dr. Dewan Ali Ahsan, Chairman, Department of Fisheries, Dhaka University Overview of Hilsa fisheries management in Bangladesh by Mr. M. Shamsul Kibria, Joint Secretary (Fisheries), Ministry of Fisheries and Livestock, Government of Bangladesh Overview of Hilsa fisheries management in India by Dr. C Vasudepappa, Chief Executive, National Fisheries Development Board, Government of India Sharing experience by Hilsa fishermen: Bangladesh and Indian fishermen representatives Open discussion by participants Summarize by Chair Dr. K. Vijay Kumaran, Director General, Fisheries Survey of India
Findings from the Joint Research Activity: Professor Dewan Ali Hassan
Professor Dewan Ali Hassan introduced this joint research initiative, which was
initiated in 2011 and performed by a collaborative team of Bangladeshi and
Indian researchers. Dewan explained the rationale for this study and its
objectives, which are to:
i) Assess migration and spawning patterns;
ii) Identify anthropogenic and climate change threats to migration and
spawning; and
iii) Assess extent and depth of said impacts.
Dewan then explained the methodology employed for the research, which included:
i) Determining migration patterns for the hilsa
ii) Assessing water quality at 5 sampling locations which have been identified as important for in the
hilsa life cycle
iii) Performing a stakeholder identification and analysis exercise
iv) Assessing fishing trends and socioeconomic conflicts arising from fishing activities; and
v) Examining and critiquing prevailing policies on hilsa harvesting.
Findings from the Joint Research Activity: Mr Utpal Bhowmik
Mr Utpal Bhowmik presented the findings of the study, including:
1. Physico-chemical characteristics in sampling locations
a. Temperature: low in most parts due to marine influence but
high in intertidal area. Variation in temperature and rainfall
patterns in 2010 may have caused breeding failure and
ensuing low catches in 2011
b. Transparency: low during monsoon season, climbed post
monsoon
c. Dissolved oxygen: high in Hooghly area
d. Salinity: low in post monsoon period
2. Hilsa breeding and spawning patterns
a. Sex: higher number of females during the breeding season, higher number of males
otherwise
b. Large mature female individuals found downstream, not common previously
c. Researchers identified three breeding grounds
d. Migration: Farakka Barrage has changed natural migration course; during the early-mid
monsoon periods larger individuals are observed, during the late monsoon period smaller
individuals are observed.
e. There is a concern that there is not enough migration.
3. Fishing patterns
a. Fine mesh nets used by fishermen are producing a negative impact on hilsa reproduction –
jatka are captured by these nets.
b. Changing depths at the estuary are also thought to produce an impact on catch volumes
Hilsa Management in Bangladesh: M Shamsul Kibria, Joint Secretary (Fisheries), Ministry of Fisheries and Livestock, Government of Bangladesh
Mr M Shamsul Kibria argued that to increase hilsa production, there is a need to
return to natural life cycle processes. Shamsul underlined the importance of the
hilsa to the Bangladeshi economy by sharing the following statistics:
- Fisheries contribute 5% to Bangladesh’s GDP, and 8% to its forex market.
Fish also accounts for 60% of the nation’s protein source.
- Hilsa catch constitutes the largest product of fisheries at 12% of 2010/11
production at 340,000 MT
- Hilsa catch shown to be in decline since the early 90s, and this decline is thought to be caused by:
unmitigated catching of jatka and brood hilsa, habitat destruction, insufficient environmental flows,
siltation in migration grounds and declining water quality.
To combat further decline of the hilsa, Shamsul said that the government of Bangladesh formulated an
action plan in 2008/9 that aims to
1. Conserve the hilsa through protection of brood and breeding grounds, and embarking on genetic
diversity conservation initiatives
2. Promote the interest of fishermen by providing food subsidies and introducing alternative income
generating activities during lean periods, providing microcredit facilities for improvements in fishing
practices, and improving hilsa supply chain
3. Solicit the participation of all stakeholders through multicultural involvement for law enforcement, and
promoting regional cooperation
The way forward, according to Shamsul, involves multiple points of entry:
1. Embarking on collaborative transboundary research initiatives, habitat restoration activities, and law
enforcement to protect breeding grounds
2. Ensuring that existing infrastructure are fish friendly
3. Sharing experiences, expertise and transferring technology especially for captive breeding
Shamsul ended his presentation by saying, “As we cannot divide the living organism we should also not
divide Natural systems. Like an animal a contiguous natural system like a river if divided will die.”
Hilsa Management in India: Dr C Vasudepappa, Chief Executive, National Fisheries Development Board, Government of India
Dr C Vasudevappa offered the following avenues to improve hilsa management in India:
1. Improving knowledge of the hilsa through research. Dr C Vasudevappa
said that although hilsa catch volumes in Bangladesh have declined in
recent years, it is unknown whether this indicates declining hilsa
population in India as well as the stocks in Bangladesh may not be the
same as those in India. Furthermore, there is a need to determine if
the breeding grounds identified in the joint study remain the same in
the face of anthropogenically induced changes and climate change in
the riverine ecosystem. Dr Vasudevappa also recommended that
further studies consider the whole ecosystem, including other biota and abiotic components, and
how human activities can impact all ecosystem components.
2. Dr Vasudevappa also recommended improvements in hilsa fishing practices. He commended the
fishing ban imposed in Bangladesh, which is important for hilsa reproduction. Dr Vasudevappa also
urged fishermen to consider sustainable practices, such as limiting the use of mechanized fishing
methods, and aquaculture. Dr Vasudevappa indicated that there is an ongoing World Bank initiative
that promotes artificial breeding and culture of certain fish species.
3. Conservation of hilsa habitats, implemented in a collaborative manner by both countries, would be
useful not only in protecting the hilsa and enhancing the hilsa recruitment process, but will also other
species and the diversity of the riverine ecosystem, said Dr Vasudevappa.
4. Most importantly, according to Dr Vasudevappa, all these efforts need to be harmonized and
coordinated. There is much to gain if Bangladesh and India work together to address these issues
by improving existing policies, and also by improving the methods through which these policies are
implemented and enforced.
Fishermen’s Experiences
The President of the Bangladesh Fishermen’s
Association urged policymakers and scientists to take into
account observations put forth by fisher folk in formulating
policies and arriving at scientifically driven conclusions, as
fisher folk are the first to be affected by changes in the
riverine ecosystem.
The President of the India Fishermen’s Association
commended the fishing ban approach, and suggested that the ban be extended to estuary and marine areas
that are important for hilsa migration and breeding.
Finally Chair of the plenary session Dr. K. Vijay Kumaran, Director General, Fisheries Survey of India
wrapped up by urging both the governments to work together to save the prized Hilsa. He also thanked the
participants for sharing their experience and knowledge.
Plenary Session 2: Joint action plan on Hilsa Fishery Management Session Chair: Dr Vijaya kumaran, DG, Fishery Survey of India
Time Session
02:00 PM – 02:20 AM Presentation on Policy Recommendations of JRT Hilsa study by Professor Sugata Hazra, Director, Department of Oceanography, Jadavpur University and Professor Niamul Naser, Department of Zoology, Dhaka University Joint action plan on Hilsa fisheries management
by Mr M Shamsul Kibria, Joint Secretary (Fisheries), Ministry of Fisheries and Livestock, Government of Bangladesh, Ministry of the Fisheries and Livestock, Government Republic of Bangladesh Mr Dr K Vijay Kumaran, Director General, Fisheries Survey of India Dr C Vasudepappa, Chief Executive, National Fisheries Development Board, Government of India Facilitator Mr Ganesh Pangare, Head, Water Programme, IUCN Asia
Vote of Thanks by Mr Ishtiaq Uddin Ahmad, Country Representative, IUCN Bangladesh
Policy Recommendations
Dr Niamul Naser introduced the draft policy recommendations for
Bangladesh that have been formulated by the joint research team in
collaboration with IUCN. Niamul offered the following addenda to the
following recommendations:
Recommendation #1: Niamul remarked that the fiscal subsidies that are
recommended to be offered in lieu of food support should be provided for
at least the first couple of years of implementation.
Recommendation #2: The bottom up approach is essential in ensuring
beneficiaries are more actively involved.
Recommendation #3: Regular media broadcasts can be instrumental in
heightening awareness on the hilsa
Dr Sugata Hazra then outlaid the policy recommendations for India. Sugata
offered the following addenda to the following recommendations:
Recommendation #13: Sugata stated that national statistics for the number of
vessels allowed in the fi shing zone only account for licensed vessels. Because
of this, unlicensed vessels are under-represented, and thus actual fishing
activities are under-reported. Therefore, according to Sugata, in addition to the quota on fishing licenses and
fish landing limits per vessel as in the recommendation, there needs to be restrictions on unlicensed vessels
to prevent them from entering the fishing zone, and a set schedule for fishing activities to allow the hilsa to
regenerate. There also needs to be a more efficient way of recording accurate fish landing data. Sugata also
remarked that enforcement and governmental will will be instrumental in ensuring compliance to laws.
Recommendation #15: The focused study recommended should also account for water resources
management (e.g. by determining e-flows, water allocation), as water availability, volume and quality play a
role in hilsa conservation. Furthermore, the area to be protected should be done so jointly, as ecosystems,
said Sugata, know no borders.
Although this is not in the draft recommendations, Sugata urged the research and technology transfer in
aquaculture and artificial breeding.
Comments from the panelists:
1. Hilsa policy recommendations take into account indirect agents of change, e.g. climate change,
socioeconomic factors
2. A more extensive study period would be ideal to really capture all impacts of agents of change
3. IUCN should continue to focus on the larger picture i.e. take on a ecosystems perspective on the
hilsa issue by accounting for e-flows, climate change impacts, and fish landings.
Policy Recommendations from Panel
Ms Masud Ara Mome, Department of Fisheries, Government of Bangladesh:
To sustain production levels, there needs to be active collaborative management
between Bangladesh and India. An MOU can divide and seal responsibilities.
Communications between the two countries need to be transparent and ongoing, to
share news and plans to meet national targets
Dr Vijaya kumaran, DG, Fishery Survey of India
In research, there is an important caveat: correlation does not mean
causation. It is therefore important to conduct thorough, extensive,
exhaustive research to truly understand the dynamics driving declining fish
landings. For example, there needs to be a study on fish markets and the
supply chain.
- While formulating the joint action plan, policymakers need to keep in
mind that each country would have different political priorities.
Dr C Vasudevappa Chief Executive, National Fisheries Development Board, Government of India
- In research, the whole ecosystem should be taken into
consideration. There could also be research on other fish species,
not just the hilsa.
- Community participation should be included in the joint action plan.
- It would a lso be good to study the nutritional value of the hilsa for
scientific proof of the adequacy of the hilsa as a source of protein.
The findings of a nutritional cost-benefit analysis could propel policy
towards alternative food sources.
- Fishing in international waters could be controlled through
- International conventions.
- It would be beneficial to conduct research on the hilsa market to determine if there are any a)
possibilities of introducing a value added system to increase the value of the hilsa and b)
improvements for the hilsa supply chain
Concluding Remarks and Vote of Thanks by Ganesh Pangare and Istiaq Uddin Ahmad
Ganesh Pangare thanked the audience for their
comments and input, and remarked that while
the focus of this particular meeting is on the
hilsa, the hilsa is a flagship s pecies and further
studies will consider the entire riverine
ecosystem. Ganesh also remarked that this
meeting is the first step of many, and IUCN will
continue its policy advocacy efforts. Finally, Istiaq
Uddin Ahmad, Country representative, IUCN Bangladesh Country Office thanked the audience and
emphasized that the dialogue today has been fruitful as it received input from all stakeholders, not just
specialists.
Policy dialogue closed.
Annex 1 Trans‐boundary Policy Dialogue on Hilsa Fisheries Management
Ecosystems for Life: A Bangladesh‐India Initiative Date: 24 July 2012
Venue: Indi Smart Hotel, Salt Lake, Kolkata, India
Programme
Time Session
09:30 AM – 10:00 AM Registration
Inauguration (10:00 AM – 11:05 AM)Session Chair: Dr Subesh K Das, Principal Secretary Forests, Government of West Bengal
10:00 AM – 10:10 AM Welcome address Professor A P Sharma, Director, Central Inland Fisheries Research Institute, India
10:10 AM – 10:25 AM Introduction to the Project and objective of the policy dialogue by Mr. Ganesh Pangare, Head, Water Programme, IUCN Asia
10:25 AM – 10:35 AM Speech by Guest of Honour Mr. Md. Mokbul Hossain, Honourable Member of Parliament, Bangladesh and Member, Parliamentary Standing Committee for the Ministry of the Fisheries and Livestock, Government Republic of Bangladesh
10:35 AM – 10:45 AM Speech by Guest of Honour Mr. Zafar Iqbal Siddique, Honourable Member of Parliament, Bangladesh and Member, Parliamentary Standing Committee for the Ministry of the Fisheries and Livestock, Government Republic of Bangladesh
10:45 AM – 10:55 AM Speech by Guest of Honour Mr Subrata Saha, Honourable Minister of State, Department of Fisheries, Government of West Bengal
10:55 AM – 11:05 AM Speech by Chair Dr Subesh K Das, Principal Secretary Forests, Government of West Bengal
11:05 AM – 11:30 AM Tea break
Plenary session 1: Current status of Hilsa fisheries management (11:30 AM – 01:15 PM) Session Chair: Dr. K. Vijay Kumaran, Director General, Fisheries Survey of India
11:30 AM – 11:50 AM Presentation on JRT research findings on Hilsa study by Dr. Utpal Bhowmik, Head, Riverine Ecology, Central Inland Fisheries Research Institute and Prof. Dr. Dewan Ali Ahsan, Chairman, Department of Fisheries, Dhaka University
11:50 AM – 12:00 PM Overview of Hilsa fisheries management in Bangladesh by Mr. M. Shamsul Kibria, Joint Secretary (Fisheries), Ministry of Fisheries and Livestock, Government of Bangladesh
12:00 PM – 12:10 PM Overview of Hilsa fisheries management in India by Dr. C Vasudepappa, Chief Executive, National Fisheries Development Board, Government of India
12:10 PM – 12:40 PM Sharing experience by Hilsa fishermen: Bangladesh and Indian fishermen representatives (4 pers)
12:40 PM – 01:10 PM Open discussion by participants
01:10 PM – 01:20 PM Summarize by Chair Dr. K. Vijay Kumaran, Director General, Fisheries Survey of India
01:20 PM – 02:00 PM Lunch break
Plenary session 2: Joint action plan on Hilsa fisheries management (02:00 PM – 04:30 PM)Session Chair: Dr Sailendranath Biswas, Deputy Director Fisheries, Government of West Bengal
02:00 PM – 02:20 AM Presentation on Policy Recommendations of JRT Hilsa study by Prof. Sugata Hazra, Director, Department of Oceanography, Jadavpur University and Prof. Dr. Niamul Naser, Department of Zoology, Dhaka University
02:20 PM – 03:20 PM Open discussion by participants
03:20 PM – 03:30 PM Summarize by Chair Dr Sailendranath Biswas, Deputy Director Fisheries, Government of West Bengal
03:30 PM – 04.00 PM Tea break
04:00 PM – 04:20 PM Joint action plan on Hilsa fisheries managementby
Mr. M. Shamsul Kibria, Joint Secretary (Fisheries), Ministry of Fisheries and Livestock, Government of Bangladesh, Ministry of the Fisheries and Livestock, Government Republic of Bangladesh Mr. Dr. K. Vijay Kumaran, Director General, Fisheries Survey of India Dr. C Vasudepappa, Chief Executive, National Fisheries Development Board, Government of India Facilitator Mr. Ganesh Pangare, Head, Water Programme, IUCN Asia
04:20 PM – 04:30 PM Vote of Thanks by Mr. Ishtiaq Uddin Ahmad, Country Representative, IUCN Bangladesh
Annex 2
Introduction to the Project and objective of the policy dialogue
Mr. Ganesh Pangare, Head, Water Programme, IUCN Asia
Presentation on JRT research findings on Hilsa study
Dr. Utpal Bhowmik, Head, Riverine Ecology, Central Inland Fisheries Research Institute and
Prof. Dr. Dewan Ali Ahsan, Chairman, Department of Fisheries, Dhaka University
Overview of Hilsa fisheries management in Bangladesh
Mr. M. Shamsul Kibria, Joint Secretary (Fisheries), Ministry of Fisheries and Livestock, Government of Bangladesh
Presentation on Policy Recommendations of JRT Hilsa study
Prof. Sugata Hazra, Director, Department of Oceanography, Jadavpur University and Prof. Dr. Niamul Naser, Department of Zoology, Dhaka University
INTERNATIONAL UNION FOR CONSERVATION OF NATURE Asia Regional Office 63 Sukhumvit Soin 39 Bangkok 10110 Tel: +66 2 662 4029, Fax: +66 2 662 4389 www.iucn.org/asia Bangladesh Country Office House 16, Road 2/3, Banani, Dhaka 1213, Bangladesh Tel: +8802 9890423 Fax: +8802 9892854 www.iucn.org/bangladesh India Country Office 2nd Floor, 20 Anand Lok, August Kranti Marg, New Delhi 110049, India Tel/Fax: +91 11 4605 2583 www.iucn.org/india