Economic Impact of Refugees in the Cleveland Area

Copyright © 2013 Chmura Economics & Analytics

Economic Impact of Refugees in the Cleveland AreaRefugee Services Collaborative28-Oct-2013


Key Findings• $4.8 in million in per year spending by the Refugee

Service Agencies yields substantial and positive results:– ≈ 66% is federal money

• A total economic impact of $48 million per year• Refugee Spending• Refugee Service Agencies• Refugee Small Businesses

• Supports 650 jobs & 2.7 million in tax revenue• 1 : 10 impact ratio


Other Economic Impacts• Refugee arrivals 2000-2010 averted a 3.1%

greater population decline in Cuyahoga County• Estimated 248 houses purchased from refugees

arriving after year 2000• Refugees more likely to be entrepreneurs &

create small businesses• 17,000+ refugees since 1983 have settled in

Greater Cleveland


Economic ImpactInduced Impact(Worker Spending)

Indirect Impact(Local Supply Chains)

Direct Impact •Refugee Organizations

•Refugee Household Spending•Refugee-Owned Business


Annual Economic Impact in 2012 was $48 million and 650 jobs

Economic Impact Summary of Refugee and Refugee Services in the Cleveland Area

Direct Indirect Induced TotalRefugee Service Organization Spending (Millions) $4.4 $0.4 $1.7 $6.6

Employment 95 3 14 112Refugee Household Spending Spending (Millions) $22.2 $5.2 $5.9 $33.3

Employment 291 40 55 386

Refugee-Owned Businesses Spending (Millions) $7.6 $2.0 $2.4 $12.0Employment 141 15 19 175

Total Spending (Millions) $33.4 $7.6 $7.0 $48.0Employment 526 58 65 650

Note: The total impact is smaller than the sum of the three components as overlapping impacts were removed in aggregation.

Source: Chmura Economics & Analytics


State of Ohio Fiscal Impact, 2012

Annual State Tax Revenue

Refugee Service Organizations

Refugee Household Spending

Refugee Businesses Total

Individual Income Tax $79,805 $837,574 $89,730 $1,007,110

Commercial Activity Tax $0 $57,734 $19,865 $77,599

Sales Tax $0 $529,089 $196,847 $725,936

Total $79,805 $1,424,397 $306,442 $1,810,644Source: Chmura Economics & Analytics


Local Fiscal Impact, 2012

Estimated Local Taxes by County and MunicipalitySales Tax Income Tax Admission Tax Total

Cuyahoga County $296,974 $296,974City of Cleveland $292,968 $18,980 $311,948City of Lakewood $142,533 $7,695 $150,228City of Cleveland Heights $44,979 $1,093 $46,071Rest of Municipalities $91,578 $1,641 $93,219Total $296,974 $572,058 $29,408 $898,440Source: Chmura Economics & Analytics

Annual County and City Tax RevenueRefugee Service

OrganizationsRefugee Household

SpendingRefugee

Businesses TotalMunicipal Income Tax $45,331 $475,758 $50,969 $572,058County Sales Tax $0 $216,446 $80,528 $296,974Municipal Admission Tax $0 $29,408 $0 $29,408Total $45,331 $721,612 $131,497 $898,440


2000 2001 2002 2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 2010 2011 20120

100

200

300

400

500

600

700

521

387

267 260285

199161

258

311350

459 463

598Number of Refugee Settled in Cleveland Area (2000-2012)

Source: Refugee Services Program, OJFS & Chmura

4,518 Refugees Arrived Since 2000


Cleveland’s Welcoming Legacy

Cleveland averaged:• ≈ 570 refugees a year 1983-2004• ≈ 330 refugees a year 2005-2012

Detroit Toledo Columbus Cleveland Akron Pittsburgh Buffalo0.0

0.5

1.0

1.5

2.0

2.5

3.0

3.5

4.0

4.5

0.0 0.0

1.1 0.9

2.3

1.5

4.0

Refugees per 1,000 Population, by City, FY2012

Source: Bureau of Population, Refugees, and Migration, US Census, and Chmura


Thriving In Cleveland• Employment & wage profile of refugees in Cleveland is better than

national norms– 73.5% employed (2012) vs. 58% national norm (2006) & 68.2% in select

cities (2008)– 8.1% receiving public assistance after 2-years (2012) vs. 12.4% in select

cities (2008)– Household income $31,000 (2012) vs. $25,000 in select cities (2008)

• After 5 years, 58% of refugees over the age 16 were employed vs. 63% for U.S. population– 69% of refugee households are completely self-sufficient– No macroeconomic findings that refugees raise unemployment rates among

the native population– Second generation educational attainment is higher than overall population


THANK YOU!

Questions?


Top 15 countries account for 91% of all refugees to the area

Bhut

anUk

rain

eBu

rma

Som

alia

Iraq

Russ

iaBo

snia

& H

erz.

Suda

nSe

rbia

Libe

riaBu

rund

iSi

erra

Leo

neEt

hiop

iaAf

ghan

istan

Dem

. Rep

Con

goBe

laru

sM

oldo

vaIra

nVi

etna

mCo

ngo

Croa

tiaUz

beki

stan

Eritr

eaLa

tivia

Pale

stine

Azer

baija

nM

aurit

ania

Cuba

Geor

gia

Cent

ral A

fric

an R

epu.

..Ky

rgyz

stan

Paki

stan

Yem

enNe

pal

Jord

anLa

osSy

riaYu

gosla

via

Indi

a

0

200

400

600

800

1,000

1,200

Cleveland Area Settled Refugees: By Country 2000-2012

Documents

Economic Impact of Refugees in the Cleveland Area