Upload
others
View
1
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
3
INTRODUCTION
MEDICINAL PLANT WEALTH OF INDIA
The Indian subcontinent with diversified topography from sea level to the Himalayas
and equally diversified climatic conditions offers excellent environment for diverse
plant species to grow and multiply. India being one of the 12 mega biodiversity
centres has about 45,000 plant species. The diversity is more so in Southern Western
Ghats and Eastern Himalayas. Hooker (1872 - 97) has recorded 14,000 species of
angiosperms in the Indian subcontinent.
A large number of country’s rural population depends on plants of medicinal
importance for treating various diseases (WHO, 2002). Nearly 80 % of world’s
population relies on traditional medicine, particularly plant products for their
primary health care (Kamboj, 2000; Sampson et al., 2000; Natesh, 2000; WHO,
2001; Dubey et al., 2004). About 20,000 plant species are considered to be of
medicinal value (Dev, 1997). Around 500 communities make use of about 800 plant
species as medicinal plants for curing various diseases (Ravikumar and Ved, 2000;
Kamboj, 2000).
Traditional systems such as Ayurveda, Siddha and Unani continue to be taught and
practiced. Indian folk medicine includes several herbal preparations for wound
healing, treating inflammations, skin lesions, leprosy, diarrhea, scabies, venereal
diseases, snakebites and ulcers (Perumalsamy and Gopalakrishnan, 2007).
4
Nearly 8000 registered practitioners are there under Indian system of medicine and
about 850 under Homoeopathy. Interest and demand for traditional remedies and plant
based health products are increasing world wide ((Mosihuzzaman and Choudhary,
2008).
About 80 % of the 500 and odd plant species used by contemporary Ayruvedic
industry are procured from the wild (Gupta, 1993). India caters to about 12 % of
global herbal trade and recent years the volume of medicinal plant materials traded
within and outside the country has reached extreme heights (Perumalsamy and
Gopalakrishnan, 2007). This increase in consumption of medicinal plants through
expansion of local, regional and global markets has increased the pressure on the
resource that is largely harvested from depleted wild populations in shrinking wild
habitats (IUCN, 2008).
REVIVAL OF PLANT MEDICINES
Medicinal herbs are moving from fringe to mainstream use with a great number of
people seeking remedies and health approach free from side effects. Recently,
considerable attention has been paid to utilize eco-friendly plant based products for
the prevention and cure of various human diseases. Considering the adverse side
effects of synthetic drugs the western population has switched over to herbal
medicines which are believed to be safe and effective (Pearce, 1993; Dubey et al.,
2004). Medicinal herbs and plant extracts are re-recognized as effective medicines to
be respected, appreciated and they play a major role in modern pharmacy. Although
herbal medicine has existed since the dawn of our civilization, our knowledge of how
plants actually influence human physiology remains largely unexplored. Studies have
pointed out that many drugs that are in use have come from folk-use and use of plants
by indigenous cultures (Anonymous, 1994).
5
Although physicians and pharmacists have began to recognize the relative safety and
efficacy of at least some of the herbs better researched on the market, many have
concerns about contradictions, potential adverse reactions, and possible herb-drug
interactions. Solid market statistics are often elusive, but the general trend towards
increased acceptance of herbs by consumers is undeniable. This has been explicitly
reported by Princeton Survey Research Associates that about 49 % (91 million) of the
entire adult Americans have used herbal products during the year 1998-1999. The
survey also showed that about 24 % (44.6 million) have used herbs regularly
(Johnson, 2000).
Interest in the utilization of medicinal and aromatic plants as pharmaceuticals, herbal
remedies, flavourings, perfumes, cosmetics, and other natural products has also
greatly increased in the recent years (Anonymous, 1994; Ayensu, 1996; Salleh et al.,
1997; Kumar et al., 2000). As with many other economic plants that are still being
collected from the wild and exploited by humans unsustainably, threats to genetic
diversity and species survival have also increased in the case of medicinal plants as a
result of habitat destruction, over-exploitation, land use changes and other pressures
(Arora and Engels, 1993). In India alone, less than 10 % of the medicinal plants
traded in the country are cultivated, about 90 % are collected from the wild, very
often in a destructive and unsustainable manner (Natesh, 2000). The number of
organizations conducting research and other activities related to the use of medicinal
and aromatic plants is large and increasing (Ayensu, 1996; Sharma et al., 2002).
Pharmacognosy and documentation of indigenous knowledge (Leaman et al., 1999;
Kshirsagar and Singh, 2001) is advancing to greater level and has surpassed the work
on conservation of medicinal plants resource, particularly at the level of intra-specific
genetic diversity.
6
Recently, a regional inventory of medicinal and aromatic plants and polyherbal
formulations dealing with 65 Indian medicinal plants, 10 important Indonesian and 25
medicinal plants of Malaysia, along with important traditional and polyherbal
formulations used in these countries has been brought out by CIMAP and supported
by the Department of Biotechnology, Government of India (Anon,1999). It is only in
the last 40 to 50 years that many of the medicines were produced industrially and sold
in shops and markets with trade names (Sasson, 1996; Natesh, 2000).
TRADITIONAL MEDICINAL PRACTICES
The history of traditional medicine in India can be traced to the remote past. The
earliest mention of the medicinal use of plants was found in the rig Veda, perhaps the
oldest repository of human knowledge (Chopra et al., 1956). The Principal aim of
ancient Hindu medicine was to prolong life. The Chinese believed that for every
illness that there was a corresponding natural remedy.
People living in rural areas of the Asia-Pacific are familiar with the medicinal
properties of local plants. Fresh plant materials collected were used either to obtain
the extract from the whole plant or parts like leaves, roots, flowers or fruits. In case of
woody plants, the bark, roots and other parts are used. Carminatives like ginger, clove
and coriander are also usually added as fresh or dried materials. Information about
medicinal plants were passed by word of mouth to the succeeding generation and
usually maintained as a family secret. Very few records or writings were maintained,
leading to the loss of such precious knowledge, through a number of treatises do exist
in various countries (Rao and Rao, 1998).
Refinement of such practices lead to the well established Asian systems of medicines
including Ayurveda, Siddha of India, Unani system of middle and Far East Asia, Ying
7
and Yan principles of Chinese herbal medicines and Jamu of Indonesia (Sharma et al.,
1998; Natesh, 2000). The Foundation for revitalization of local health traditions
(FRLHT) data base lists about 7,361 medicinal plants used in all kinds of traditional
practices in India (Ravikumar and Ved, 2000).
Though herbal medicines used in traditional systems of medicine have been tested
through long historical practice, WHO guidelines (1993) insist on evaluating the
safety and efficacy of herbal medicines is highly necessary and suggests modern
research methodology on pharmacodynamic and general pharmacological studies,
toxicity investigations and clinical trials. Hence, such scientific evaluation will help
us in determining their safety role in health care. To a number of traditional medicinal
formulations importance has not been paid to explore and understand safety and their
genotoxic and mutagenic effects. The damage caused due to the uptake of nature
medicines in the body and consequently in the chromosome has been an efficient and
reliable source of information which was used to measure the genetic toxicity in
organisms. However, medicinal plants, and indeed plants in general, synthesize toxic
substances, which in nature act as a defense against infections, insects and herbivores,
but which often affect the organisms that feed on them. Thus, an assessment of their
cytotoxic and mutagenic potential is necessary to ensure a relatively safe use of
medicinal plants. Therefore, a concern regarding the indiscriminate use of medicinal
plants in folk medicine continues to be extremely necessary (Rosangela et al., 2003;
zeiger, 2002 ).
DIABETES AND HUMAN POPULATION
In the 21st century human beings world wide, have become prone to a major
metabolic disorder – Diabetes. Diabetes mellitus (DM), results from a defect in
8
insulin secretion, insulin action, or both (Bastaki, 2005). This is an ancient Greek
word meaning siphon or running through i.e. passing large amount of urine and
mellitus meaning honey–like (referring to the sweetness of the urine due to excess
sugar as identified by ancient physicians (Powers, 1996). In the 21st century more
people appear to be prone to the major metabolic disorder - diabetes. The incidence of
diabetes is increasing in order forever. Sugar is necessary for the human body to
provide energy but, excess sugar in blood leads to diabetes. One form is diabetes
mellitus with excessive presence of sugar (glucose) in the blood.
Diabetes – The World Perspective
Diabetes is one of the major health problems of mankind worldwide and an important
cause of prolonged ill health and early death. It was one of the sixteen leading causes
of global mortality in 1990, accounting for 571,000 deaths (Arunachalam and
Gunasekaran, 2002). The number of people with diabetes is increasing due to
population explosion, ageing, urbanization, and growing prevalence of obesity and
physical inactivity (King and Rewers, 1993). Even if the prevalence of obesity
remains stable until 2030, which seems unlikely, it is anticipated that the number of
people with diabetes will be more than double as a consequence of population aging
and urbanization (WHO, 2001). Unless preventive measures are taken, 366 million
people worldwide will have diabetes by 2030, with the largest increase occurring in
developing countries (Wild et al., 2004)
Types of Diabetes
Diabetes is divided into two types, Type-I and Type-II. Type-I diabetes is referred as
insulin dependent diabetes mellitus (IDDM). Type-I diabetes develops when the
body’s immune system destroys pancreatic beta cells, the only cells in the body that
9
make the hormone insulin that regulates blood glucose. This form of diabetes usually
strikes children and young adults, although disease onset can occur at any age. Type-I
diabetes may account for 5 to 10 percent of all diagnosed cases of diabetes. Risk
factors for Type-I diabetes may include autoimmune genetic and environmental
factors (Powers, 1996).
Type-II Diabetes is otherwise called as non–insulin dependent diabetes mellitus.
Type-II diabetes may account for about 90 to 95 percent of all diagnosed cases of
diabetes. Causative reason for this type of diabetes is insufficient secretion of insulin
in the islets of pancreas. As the need for insulin rises the pancreas gradually loses its
ability to produce enough insulin. This is the type of diabetes most prevalent and
occurs over 40 years of age. Due to demand of insulin the stored sugar cannot be
utilized and is represented in the blood and urine as excess sugar. After the onset of
diabetes they may lead to complications like diabetic retinopathy, diabetic
nephropathy and many other disorders (Powers, 1996; Bastaki, 2005).
Treatment and Control of Diabetes
At present there may be no complete cure for diabetes but, may be kept well under
control. People with Type - I diabetes must have insulin delivered by injections or a
pump to keep their level of sugar under control in their blood. People with Type - II
diabetes control their blood glucose by following a careful diet and exercise
programme, losing excess weight and taking oral medication. Some people with
diabetes take medication to control their cholesterol and blood pressure. Diabetes may
cause damage to other parts of body like eyes and lead to vision impairment. Due to
diabetes fat deposition may take place in the arteries and create hindrance in the flow
of blood. Research studies have found that lifestyle changes prevent or delay the onset
of diabetes. Lifestyle interventions including diet control, moderate physical activity
10
like walking, and exercises are more vital which can keep diabetes under control.
Diabetic patients are advised to follow a systematic diet plan which includes more of
cereals, pulses, vegetables and moderate amount of fat free milk, meat and fish. Apart
from controlling diabetes through well planned diet, insulin injection has to be taken
according to the advice of the physician. Although large number of chemical drugs
including insulin are already in use for Type - II diabetes, still there are limitations
such as adverse side effects and high rate of secondary failure and no promising
therapy to cure diabetes (Sumana and Suryawanshi, 2001; Xie et al., 2003).
TRADITIONAL SYSTEMS OF TREATING DIABETES
Ayurveda, Siddha and Unani
Ayurveda, Siddha, Unani, and folk medicinal systems are various traditional systems
where several plant species were used in the treatment of different ailments (Rabe and
Staden, 1997). In India Ayurveda, Siddha and Unani systems were the formal and
most organized amongst the traditional systems of medicine.
Ayurveda one of the ancient forms of Indian medicine utilizes the active ingredients
present in plants for treating various diseases and illnesses (Ravikumar and Anuradha,
1999). The western medicine has been considered as the offspring of Ayurveda.
Ayurveda still remains as one of the most ancient and living tradition of medicine
practiced widely in Asian countries including Sri Lanka (Dahanukar and Thatte, 2000;
Chopra and Diophode, 2002). Knowledge of Ayurvedic medicine has unfortunately
been confined to India and not so prevalent in the west. Even in India, this traditional
medical practice is not in use in the urban areas. One of the main reasons for this is
that much of the early and core medical literature on Ayurveda was in Sanskrit, the
ancient language which ceased to be a day-to-day language in this century, except in
extremely small groups of the vast Indian population.
11
Since oral hypoglycemic agents cause side effects, there is a growing interest in
herbal remedies for the treatment of diabetes mellitus (Kim et al., 2006). Medicinal
plants play an important role in the management of diabetes mellitus especially in
developing countries where resources are meager. An exhaustive review has been
made on medicinal plants with hypoglycemic effects with the aim of collating all
available data in the public domain and to bring out the importance and the interest
placed on medicinal plants in the drive to demonstrate their antidiabetic effects and to
isolate the bioactive agents (Atta-Ur-Rahman and Zaman, 1989; Ivorra et al., 1989;
Bnouham et al., 2002; Al-Rowais, 2002; Grover et al., 2002; Bnouham et al., 2006;
Garg, and Garg, 2008). About 176 species belonging to 84 families are used by
various medicinal systems across the world as antidiabetic plants. In china at least 250
plants were used to treat diabetes as mentioned in ancient literatures B.C. (Garg, and
Garg, 2008; Garg, 2009).
Antidiabetic effect of Swertia densifolia (shilajit) and Ficus bengalensis (Banyan)
have been found to be associated with their weight promoting, anabolic and
pancreatrophic effects. In spite of the long tradition of use very few plants have been
tested for their efficacy by present day technology. Diabecon (D-400) formulation is
based on the ancient ayurvedic references corroborated through modern research and
clinical trials (Dubey et al., 1983). This consists of a mixture of powders from 10
different antidiabetic plants viz., Gymnema sylvestre, Vinca rosea and Curcuma longa
- 80 mg each; Azadirachta indica, Pterocarpus marsupium, Momordica charantia,
Syzygium cumini, Acacia arabica and Tinospora cordifolia - 40 mg each; Zingiber
officinale- 20 mg (Ganguly, 1995).
The Siddha system of medicine is predominantly followed in the state of Tamil Nadu
and is also popular in Andhra Pradesh, Karnataka and Kerala. The Siddha system is
12
also practiced in Sri Lanka, Malaysia and Singapore. The name Siddha oushadha
(siddha medicine) relates to the earlier esoteric medicinal postulates concerning
longevity as conceived and practiced by 18 Siddhars, lived in Tamil Nadu. It is for
this reason the entire Siddha medical literature is in Tamil. The Siddha system has
about 800 texts of which 180 are in print. The Siddha system of medicine is rooted in
the Dravidian culture, of the pre-Vedic period (Kurup, 1983). Siddha system
incorporates minerals and toxic metals like mercury, sulphur, arsenic, and vegetable
poisons. Independent of the Siddha system, India has developed its own tradition of
alchemy and iatrochemistry, called Rasashashtra or Rasa vaidya that employed
minerals, metals and some plants (Bhat and Rao, 1993).
To treat diabetes mellitus Siddha system has recorded a formulation of plant drugs
which includes Avaarai (Cassia auriculata), Kondrai (Cassia fistula), naval
(Syzygium cumini) Ekanayakam (Salacia reticulata), korai kizhangu (Cyperus
rotundus), marutham (Terminalia arjuna), kizhanelli (Phyllanthus amarus). This
formulation seems to be highly effective in controlling diabetes if taken for about four
months without any break and with strict diet control (Nadkarni, 2005).
‘Solaimalai Sarkaraikolli neerizhu churnam’ - a siddha preparation for treating
diabetes consist about 48 herbal mix, marketed by Solaimalai Indian herbal drugs,
Paramakudi, Tamil Nadu. Powder of 3 g has been prescribed before meals (twice a
day) to remedy diabetes. Though the mixture has herbal powders and largely sold in
markets, its efficacy and safety has not been scientifically validated. Similarly there
are several formulations based on sidhha literature prepared in a secrete way to treat
diabetes and marketed. Siddha system does not advocate the use of Gymnema
sylvestre for treating diabetes. However, the other plants such as Terminalia chebula
and Syzygium cumini have been widely used in Siddha preparations to cure diabetes.
13
The Unani Tibb system of medicine is traced to the system of Greek medicine
developed during the Arab civilization and is also called the Greco-Arab system.
Though the European historians call it Arab medicine, now it is prevalent in India,
Pakistan and Bangladesh. Detailed general information on various aspects of the
Unani system of medicine has been reviewed by Baquai, (1977), Said (1983) and
Bhat and Rao, (1993). A very useful glossary of plants used in Unani medicine has
been compiled by Fathima (1994), which includes sources of therapeutic information.
Emblica officinalis has been used as herbal remedy to treat diabetic retinopathy based
on Unani. The tannoids extracted from this plant inhibit aldose reductase, which is
known to be involved in the secondary complications of diabetes such as cataract
(Suryanarayana et al., 2004). Various plants have now been shown to affect
glycaemia. Fenugreek leaves have also shown to affect hyperglycaemia,
hypoinsulinaemia and glycosylated haemoglobin levels in diabetic rats. Key
metabolic enzymes were affected and the effect appeared to be similar to that of the
drug glibenclamide (Devi et al., 2003). The anti-hyperglycaemic effects of three
extracts of the bitter gourd Momordica charantia have been successfully documented
(Virdi et al., 2003). The aqueous extract of the unripe fruit reduces fasting blood
glucose by 48 %, which is equivalent to the figures obtained with glibenclamide.
Anti-diabetic effect of Costus pictus leaves in normal and streptozotocin-induced
diabetic rats has been reported and the leaf extracts do not have any toxicity effect
(Jayasri et al., 2008).
Plant products investigated for anti-diabetic effect have been exhaustively reviewed
and the inhibitory effect of some of the common plant extracts against hyperglycemic
response of anterior pituitary extract in glucose fed rats has been compared (Bnouham
et al., 2006; Garg, 2009). Many ethnobotanical (Atta-Ur-Rahman and Zaman, 1989;
Al-Rowais, 2002; Lin, 1992; Mahabir and Gulliford, 1997) and traditional medicinal
14
plants (Day, 1998; Bailey and Day, 1989; Gupta, 1993) reports on antidiabetic
medicinal plants of the local population have been performed in different parts of the
world. Many studies have confirmed the benefits of medicinal plants with
hypoglycemic effects in the management of diabetes mellitus. The effects of these
plants may delay the development of diabetic complications and correct the metabolic
abnormalities. Moreover, during the past few years some of the new bioactive drugs
isolated from hypoglycemic plants showed antidiabetic activity with more efficacy
than oral hypoglycemic agents used in clinical therapy (Bnouham et al., 2006). It has
been reported that some of the plant extracts restrict the rise of blood sugar caused by
the pituitary hormones responsible for inhibiting peripheral utilization of glucose as
well as causing glycogenolysis in maturity onset diabetes (Garg, 2009).
Leaf extract of Gymnema sylvestre with its constituent gymnemic acid inhibits the
stress responses mediated through the adrenohypophyseal axis 74 as well as the
hyperglycaemic response to adrenaline, corticotropin and somatotropin (Gupta and
Variyar, 1964). This might help in unrestricted utilization of glucose by the peripheral
tissues. Tinospora cordifolia has been found to inhibit hepatic glucose release caused
by adrenaline, (Gupta et al., 1967) while Coccinia indica, Casearia esculenta and
Pterocarpus marsupium besides reducing blood sugar have also been reported to
block glucose absorption from the gut. A flavanoid-epicatechin isolated from P.
marsupium has been reported to promote regeneration of beta cells of islets of
Langerhans in pancreas and on clinical trials beneficial effects have been reported in
maturity onset diabetes (Shanmugasundaram et al., 1990b). Tinospora cordifolia and
Casearia esculenta have been reported that they promote insulin induced glucose
uptake by the tissues and improve glucose tolerance, (Gupta et al., 1967) while M.
charantia also promotes peripheral utilization of glucose. The fresh juice of M.
charantia has been reported to potentiate tolbutamide actions and a crystalline
fraction isolated from fruits of this plant possesses hypoglycemic effect similar to
15
insulin in juvenile diabetes. Many herbal products including several metals and
minerals have been described for the care of diabetes mellitus (Chattopadhyay, 1998a;
Hakkim et al., 2007; Garg, 2009).
Allopathy
Allopathy is also called ‘modern’, ‘western’, or ‘scientific’ medicine. Allopathy is
now both biomedicine and clinical medicine. Developments of the past 50 years or so
in anatomy, biochemistry, physiology, pharmacology, physics, biology, electronics
and engineering have made allopathy radically different not only from the other
systems of medicine but also from its own earlier versions. Descriptions of several
disease conditions like diabetes in the earliest works on Allopathy treatments are also
found in the Vedic hymns of the predecessors of Ayurveda (Canary, 1983).
Allopathy, with very impressive advancements in its numerous areas of specialization,
has performed wonders and achieved a phenomenal popularity throughout the world,
much to the detriment of the indigenous/traditional systems of medicine. However, it
has become increasingly inaccessible to the majority of the world population due to
its dependence on expensive instrumentation and very high costs of drugs and
services. Allopathy is firmly rooted in the products of synthetic chemistry, as its drug
arsenal. Nevertheless, in the rich world 25 per cent of all medical drugs are still plant
based and in the poorer world this is closer to 75 per cent (Principe, 1991). Allopathy
will continue to depend on plants for its drugs and this dependence is more likely to
increase rather than decrease. Thus Allopathy continues to be an area of interest to
those who work on medicinal plants.
A number of allopathic chemical drugs are being used to treat diabetes and are
available in the market. Various oral antidiabetic drugs have been used in the control
of hyperglycemia. The drugs administered are basically classified into Sulphonylureas
16
and nonsulphonylureas (ICMR, 2005). Second generation Sulphonylureas drugs are
currently used in the treatment of diabetes. A few Sulphonylureas drugs used are
glipizide, glibenclamide, glipizide XL, gliclazide MR and gliclazide. The duration of
these drugs ranges between 6 and 24 h. The other groups of drugs are the non-
sulphonylurease drugs including repaglinide, metformin, phenformin, acarbose and
other drugs are currently in use (ICMR, 2005) to treat diabetes.
SIDE EFFECT OF DRUGS
One of the persistent challenges faced by professionals and regulators is on obtaining
information regarding adverse effects potentially associated with herbal medicines
and then, sharing this information in a meaningful way with the public. A much
repeated and significant charge against modern medicine is that, it is fraught with
serious side effects and the defense of traditional medicine is that, it has no side
effects. A side effect of a medicine is the one other than the therapeutic effect desired
in a particular context. Thus, because of less or no side effects with plant based
medicines there is a great deal of revival in usage and drug discovery (Mosihuzzaman
and Choudhary, 2008).
Most of the chemical drugs have been reported to cause side effects by causing cell,
tissue, organ and whole body to react in abnormal condition. A single chemical
compound would have one or several effects on the body and was aimed at using the
most appropriate effect in a given context (disease state). Side effects are also caused
by the administration of an improper drug or by a wrong dosage. All drugs have
certain contraindications, when they should not be used.
Recently the herb Ephedra sinica has received substantial scrutiny regarding its
adverse effect profile. The adverse effect of this plant has been explicitly documented
through legitimate clinical trials (Kingston and Blumenthal, 2003). Ginkgo products
17
were found to contain colchicine (26 µg per tablet) which was observed in blood
samples of pregnant women (Petty et al., 2001).
Since the action of all drugs, whether modern or traditional, is rooted in chemical
interactions between the drug and the body, all drugs, from whatever the system of
medicine, have side effects, small or big. One needs to understand the complete
picture of action of drug in each case to avoid, or at least minimize the side effects
and derive the desired therapeutic benefits.
Ayurvedic drugs were not given much emphasis to evaluate the adverse side reactions
and genotoxicity effect. The efficacy of some herbal products is beyond doubt.
Mutagenic and carcinogenic effects have been reported in some of the herbal
preparations (Dubey et al., 2004; Shah, 1997). In general if a drug is said to combat
severe disease, it must be reasonably powerful. Such drugs will naturally have some
dangerous side effects and after effects. Certain Siddha medicines, particularly more
effective ones consist of metals, minerals and other poisonous ingredients. There is a
chance of these ingredients turning more dangerous than the disease (Pillai, 1979).
Some plants have been used for hundreds of years together as in India and China to
treat diabetes and still they are considered as safe and efficient. Though, it is highly
necessary that more research is needed to understand in most cases, the active
principles and mode of action against diabetes (Vogel, 1991; Patwardhan et al., 2004;
Garg, 2009).
Indiscriminate use of crude extracts and over doses of nature medicines have lead to
several severe damages and unknown consequences including irreparable mutations
(Bhisey, 2000). Thousands of tonnes of dried plant materials are sent every year to the
developed countries for this purpose. International export trade in medicinal plants
has been dominated by China which exported 121 900 tonnes a year and India which
exported 32 600 tonnes a year (Rajasekharan and Ganeshan, 2002). More number of
18
researchers and institutions need to be seriously involved in medicinal plants research
and development, not only for the intellectual challenges involved but also the huge
possible profits obtainable over a period of time (Latif, 1997; Osman, 1996; Rates,
2000).
PLANTS SELECTED FOR EXPERIMENTATION IN THE PRESENT STUDY
A large number of plants have found application to treat diabetes. List of antidiabetic
plants as mentioned earlier show that more than 23 of plants used by traditional health
practitioners in the treatment of diabetes. The following three plants viz, Gymnema
sylvestre, Syzygium cumini and Terminalia chebula are used by different systems for
which not much information is available on the safety and efficacy of these plants and
hence the present study was envisaged.
Gymnema sylvestre (Retz) Sm.
Gymnema sylvestre is a large woody climber, belonging to the family Asclepiadaceae.
The climber is extensive, much-branched and some times twining shrubs. Leaves 3-6
x 2-3 cm, simple opposite, ovate or elliptic-oblong, apiculate, rounded at base, sub-
coriaceous. Flowers minute, greenish-yellow, spirally arranged in lateral pedunculate
or nearly sessile cymes. Corolla lobes imbricate. Flowering: August- November;
Fruiting: April – June. Fruits a pair of follicles, up to 8 x 0.7 cm, terete, lanceolate,
straight or slightly curved, glabrous. Seeds ovate-oblong, glabrous, winged brown
(Gamble, 1928; Mabberley, 2005).
This plant grows in the wild as a climber. It is found in the plains in scrub jungles and
in thickets, distributed in the tropical forests of central and southern India, Western
Ghats, Konkan, Deccan peninsula, Assam, extending to parts of northern and western
19
India and some parts of Africa. This has been occasionally cultivated as a resourceful
medicinal plant.
Sushruta describes Gymnema sylvestre as a destroyer of madhumeha (glycosuria) and
other urinary disorders (MacFarlance et al., 1997). The plant is stomachic, emetic,
expectorant, stimulant, laxative, diuretic, refrigerant, astringent and tonic. It is also
said to be useful in cough, biliousness and sore eyes. The leaves when chewed have
the remarkable property of paralyzing the sense of taste for sweet and bitter
substances for few hours (Gamble, 1928; Chopra et al., 1956; Warren et al., 1969).
On account of its property of abolishing the taste of sugar it has been named as
‘gurmar’ meaning ‘sugar destroyer’ and it is believed therefore that it might neutralize
the excess of sugar present in the body as in Diabetes mellitus (Warren et al., 1969).
Even though there is no scientific evidence for the antidiabetic effect of G. sylvestre
the plant has found its continuous usage in the modern age. It has been reported to
increase urine output and reduce hyperglycemia in both animal and human (Bhakuni
et al., 1971).
Phytochemical Components of Gymnema sylvestre
G. sylvestre constituents include two resins (one soluble in alcohol), gymnemic acids,
tartaric acid, gurmarin, calcium oxalate, glucose, saponins, stigmasterol, quercitol,
and the amino acid derivatives betaine, choline and trimethylamine. Many compounds
of G. sylvestre including gymnemic acid are derivatives of triterpene glycosides. It
has long been known that chewing G. sylvestre leaves is a folkloric remedy for
diabetes mellitus in India, and causes temporary loss of the sweet taste (Liu et al.,
1992; Warren et al., 1969). The antisweet principle was precipitated by acidification
with mineral acid was named as ‘gymnemic acid’ (Liu et al., 1992). Antisweet
property of gymnemic acid can be destroyed by boiling with dilute hydrochloric acid.
The effect of antisweetness of gymnemic acid varies from species to species even in
20
mammals (Glaser et al., 1984; Hellekant, 1976; Hellekant and Gopal, 1976). A new
substance gurmarin was isolated from leaves of G. sylvestre. This is a polypeptide
which consists of 35 amino acid residues including three intramolecular disulfide
bonds. Suppression of sweet taste responses in the rat was found to be due to the hot
water extract of the leaves of G. sylvestre (Imato et al., 1991). The inhibitory effect of
gurmarin was highly specific to the sweet taste response to sucrose, glucose, glycine
and saccharin so that the response to the salty taste of NaCl, the sour taste of HCl and
the bitter taste of quinine were hardly affected. The inhibitory effect of gurmarin was
reversible, but complete recovery was studied in rats and the suppressed response
required approximately 2 hours for recovery (Ninomiya and Imoto, 1995).
Gurmarin suppresses the sweet taste response in rats. It is interesting to know that
gurmarin showed either a weak or no effect on the sweet taste sensation in human
beings. Besides gymnemic acid, certain other materials that reduce sweet taste
recognition are known. They include ziziphin from Ziziphus jujube (Meisalman et al.,
1976), another compound hodulcin from Hovenia dulcis and escin from Aesculus
hippocastanum (Miyasaka and Imoto, 1988).
Antidiabetic Activity
G. sylvestre has been widely used in many traditional and folk medicines except for
Siddha to treat diabetes mellitus although its use in Ayurvedha is known from
antiquity. Several studies have been conducted and reported on the antidiabetic
properties and efficacy of G. sylvestre (Baskaran et al., 1990; Shanmugasundaram et
al., 1990a; Murakami, 1996; Chattopadhyaya, 1998). The choice of drug was mostly
crude extract of leaves (Rastogi and Dhawan, 1982) which contains about 70 % of
gymnemic acid. So far no study was performed with isolated pure gymnemic acid.
For such studies only animal models were used to assess the cytotoxic and genotoxic
properties. The mode of treatment had been mostly intra peritoneal and rarely oral
21
feeding (Gupta and Seth, 1962). Gymnema was singly or combination with other
antidiabetic plants such as Momordica charantia, coccinia indica and Pterocarpus
marsupium were tested (Gupta, 1963). Gymnema leaves whether extracted or infused
in to a tea suppress glucose absorption and reduce the sensation of sweetness in foods-
effects that may deliver important health benefits for individual who want to reduce
blood sugar level or body weight. Modern dietary supplements containing G. sylvestre
are typically intended for control of sugar cravings, and weight loss, particularly in
patients with diabetes (Shanmugasundaram, 1990).
Pharmacological, phytochemical and pharmacognosical and clinical trials on G.
sylvestre have been reviewed recently (Gurav et al., 2006). Pharmacological studies
have revealed that the water extracts of the leaves of G. sylvestre was effective to treat
diabetes mellitus (Potwale et al., 2008). Similarly water extract of G. sylvestre leaves
inhibited the absorption of glucose in the small intestine and suppressed the increase
of blood glucose value after administration of sucrose in rat (Miyoshi et al., 1987).
Animals treated with ethanol extract of G. sylvestre at a dosage of 100 mg/kg body
weight resulted in insignificant reduction of blood sugar in normal rats, and
significant reduction in anterior pituitary treated hyperglycaemic rats. Effect of the
drug was comparable to that of tolbutamide (50 mg/kg) in the hyperglycaemic rats.
The drug had influenced the disturbed carbohydrate metabolism in hyperglycaemic
animals by limiting the carbohydrate turnover and thus inhibiting the vicious cycle of
hyperglycaemia (Gupta and Seth, 1962). Further studies on albino rats established the
antidiabetic activity of G. sylvestre, which was compared with other conventional
indigenous oral antidiabetic drugs like Coccinia indica, Pterocarpus marsupium,
Momordica charantia. In such a study animals were subjected to subcutaneous
injection with 100 mg/kg dose of the anterior pituitary extract and fed with alcoholic
extract of G. sylvestre and Coccinia indica (100 mg/kg each), aqueous infusion of P.
marsupium (20 ml/kg), extract of M. charantia (5 ml/kg) and tolbutamide (50 mg/kg)
22
orally. Inhibition of the hyperglycaemic response of the anterior pituitary extract at 6,
12 and 24 hours was most marked in tolbutamide and G. sylvestre. The inhibitory
effect was highly significant in G. sylvestre when compared with P. marsupium and
M. charantia (Gupta, 1963).
The importance of G. sylvestre therapy in alloxan induced diabetic rabbits was
investigated by feeding crude leaf powder at a dosage of 250 mg/kg body weight once
a day. This therapy not only produced blood glucose homeostasis but also increased
the activities of enzymes affording the utilization of glucose by insulin dependent
pathways; it controlled phosphorylase levels, gluconeogenic enzymes and sorbitol
dehydrogenase. The uptake and incorporation of glucose into the glycogen and
proteins had increased in the liver, kidney and muscle in diabetic animals when
compared to control diabetic animals (Shanmugasundaram et al., 1983). Prakash et al.
(1986) have reported that the rats fed with G. sylvestre leaf powder during the diet for
10 days prior and 15 days after the treatment of beryllium nitrate significantly
protected the animals from the full fall of blood glucose.
The inhibitory effects of G. sylvestre and purified gymnemic acid on Gastric
Inhibitory Peptide (GIP) release was studied in rats. The GIP gets released into the
portal vein in response to duodenal infusion of D-glucose in presence of leaf extract
of G. sylvestre at a dosage of 0.5 ml/kg. The inhibition of GIP release by gymnemic
acid was attributed to the interaction with the glucose receptor for GIP release which
was similar in specificity to the active glucose transport system. The results suggested
that a glucose receptor interacts with the leaf extracts of G. sylvestre and purified
gymnemic acid (Fushiki et al., 1992).
Gymnemic acid is referred to as GS. Two water soluble extracts GS3 and GS4 obtained
from the leaves of G. sylvestre, were tested in streptozotocin treated rats for their
23
effects on blood glucose homeostasis and pancreatic endocrine tissue. In diabetic rats,
fasting blood glucose levels returned to normal after 60 days of GS3 and after 20 days
of GS4 oral feeding. Administration of 10 g /ml of gurmarin significantly depressed 40
- 50 % of taste response ability to sugar and saccharin in rats. In diabetic rat pancreas,
both therapies led to a rise in serum insulin to levels close to normal testing levels.
Both GS3 and GS4 doubled the islet number and beta cell number in the pancreas of
diabetic rats. This herbal therapy appeared to bring about blood glucose homeostasis
through increased serum insulin levels provided by repair of the endocrine pancreas
(Shanmugasundaram et al., 1990a).
Clinical Trials
As G. sylvestre has been known to control diabetes in traditional systems of medicine,
little scientific validation has been done to ascertain the fact by conducting clinical
trials with diabetic patients (Baskaran et al., 1990). All such trials were performed
using either crude extracts or whole leaf powder among the clinical trials. The results
of such trials do support the antidiabetic properties of G. sylvestre either by increased
hypoglycemic activity or enhanced insulin levels to certain extent. Khare et al. (1983)
reported the hypoglycemic activity of G. sylvestre in ten normal and six diabetic
patients. They were subjected to glucose tolerance test and their blood samples were
collected at 30 minutes intervals up to 2 hrs. Aqueous decoction of the leaves was
administered at a dosage of 2 g thrice a day for a period of 10 days. Administration of
the extract brought about a significant reduction in the fasting blood sugar levels in
normal and diabetic patients, which suggested a definite hypoglycemic activity.
Similarly a clinical trial conducted on 27 patients with insulin-dependent diabetes
mellitus (IDDM) with the administration of GS4 - a water soluble extract of the leaves
of G. sylvestre at a dosage of 400 mg/day for each patient. The level of insulin got
reduced together with fasting blood glucose and glycosylated haemoglobin (HBA1c)
24
and glycosylated plasma protein levels, while serum lipids returned to near normal
level with GS4 therapy. Treatment with GS4 appeared to enhance endogenous insulin,
possibly by regeneration or revitalization of the residual beta cells in insulin-
dependent diabetes mellitus (Shanmugasundaram et al., 1990 b).
Further clinical studies were conducted to test the effectiveness of GS4 therapy an
extract from leaves of G. sylvestre in controlling hyperglycemia in 22 patients with
Type –II diabetes (NIDDM -Non-insulin dependent Diabetes mellitus) on
conventional oral anti-hyperglycemic agents. GS4 (400 mg/day) was administered for
18 - 20 months as a supplement to the conventional oral drugs. During GS4
supplementation, the patients continued to show a significant reduction in blood
glucose level. Five of the 22 diabetic patients were able to discontinue their
conventional drug and maintain their blood glucose homeostasis with GS4 alone.
These evidences suggest the beta cells regeneration and repair in type-II diabetic
patients on GS4 supplementation. This is also supported by the appearance of raised
level of insulin in the serum of patients after GS4 supplementation (Baskaran et al.,
1990).
In another study hypoglycemic effect of G. sylvestre was studied in 16 normal non
diabetic persons and 43 mildly diabetic patients. All the subjects were administered
with leaf powder 10 g per day in divided doses for a period of 7 days. The results
indicate that G. sylvestre leaf powder has a hypoglycemic effect comparable to
tolbutamide. Serum triacylglycerol, free fatty acids and cholesterol levels in normal
subjects were unaffected where as in diabetic patients it was significantly decreased.
Ascorbic acid and iron levels were elevated significantly in both groups, where as
excretion of creatine decreased in diabetic patients, this remained unaffected in
normal healthy volunteers (Balasubramaniam et al., 1992). Absence of antidiabetic
25
and hypolipidemic effect of G. sylvestre in non-diabetic and alloxan-diabetic rats has
also been reported (Galletto et al., 2004).
Syzygium cumini (L.) Skeels
Syzygium cumini (= Eugenia jambolana Lam) is a big tree belonging to Myrtaceae
family, native to southern Asia. This is a smooth tree 4 to 15 m in height. The leaves
are leathery, oblong-ovate to elliptic or obovate-elliptic, and 6 to 12 cm long. The tip
of the leaf is broad and shortly pointed. The panicles are borne mostly from the
branchlets below the leaves, often being axillary or terminal, and are 4 to 6 cm long.
The flowers are numerous, scented, pink or nearly white, without stalks, and borne in
crowded fascicles on the ends of the branchlets. The calyx is funnel-shaped, about 4
mm long, and toothed. The petals cohere and fall all together as a small disk. The
stamens are numerous and about as long as the calyx. The fruit is oval to elliptic, 1.5
to 3.5 cm long, dark-purple or nearly black, luscious, fleshy, and edible; it contains a
single large seed.
The bark of the tree is used against dysentery, hemorrhage and leucorrhea. It is also
used to treat non-insulin dependent Type-II diabetes, because it lowers the blood
glucose level to normal (Moreira, 1985). It is used to treat diarrhea and infections
from the upper-respiratory-tract since it has an antimicrobial property. The seeds and
fruits of this plant have been frequently used to treat diabetes. It has been shown that
the bark, fruits, seeds or leaves of this plant collected from diverse regions of the
world are administered in different pharmaceutical preparations eg., tinctures and
aqueous extracts. Also, infusions (simple aqueous extracts prepared with hot water
but without boiling) and decoctions (boiled infusions) of S. cumini have been used in
popular medicine for the treatment of diabetes mellitus (Elisabetsky, 1987; Pepato et
al., 2001).
26
Phytochemical Components of Syzygium cumini
The seeds do not contain an alkaloid nor an enzyme, but abundance of starch and
tannin. The seeds and bark contain tannins, resins (gambol), terpenes (�-pigeon, �-
pigeon, limonene), acids (gallic, palmitic, stearic, oleic), steroids (phytosterol),
saponinic glycosides (antimelin) and flavanols (Albuquerque, 1989). The interesting
constituent of the resin, however, is a new phenolic substance possessing the
empirical formula C16
H8O
9, which has been designated as ‘Jambulol’. This substance
is a light-brown powder, which is insoluble, or nearly so, in the usual organic
solvents, but separates on crystallization. Another substance acetyljambulol,
C16
H3O
9(CO.CH
3)5, forms pale brown platelets. Pentabenoyl jambulol,
C16
H3O
9(CO.C
6H
5)
5, was obtained in small colorless plates (Anon, 1986).
Antidiabetic and genotoxic properties of Syzygium cumini
Achrekar et al. (1991) have reported the hypoglycemic activity of the extract of
Syzigium cumini seeds and fruits produced the same effect after 24 hrs. The oral
administration of the extract resulted in the enhancement of insulinemia in
normoglycaemic and diabetic rats. The incubation of isolated pancreatic islet cells of
normal and diabetic animals with this plant extracts resulted in increased insulin
secretion. This extract inhibited insulinase activity from liver and kidney. Conversely
oral administration of 2.5 and 5.0 g/kg body weight of the aqueous extract of the
seeds of S. cumini for six weeks in alloxan-diabetic rats resulted in a significant
reduction in blood glucose concentration and an increase in total haemoglobin, but in
the case of 7.5 g/kg body weight, the effect was not significant. It also resulted in
decreased free radical formation in tissues (Prince et al., 1998). The isolated
compound mycaminose and crude extracts of S. cumini seeds in ethyl acetate [EA]
27
and methanol [ME] were reported for the anti-diabetic activity against streptozotocin
(STZ) induced diabetic rats. The compound ‘mycaminose’, crude extracts and
methanol extracts were shown to cause significant reduction in blood glucose level
and the anti-diabetic effects of the seed extracts were authenticated (Kumar et al.,
2008; Rajasekar et al., 2009). In human phytotherapy about 1.9 g of seed powder or
30 seeds per day was recommended as daily dose. LD-50 values were determined as 4
g/kg bw for oral administration and 0.4g/kg bw for intra peritoneal administration in
mice (EMEA, 1999). Genotoxic assessments were reported by Vicentini et al. (2001)
where very mild dose of 0.07mg/ml and 0.7mg/ml were injected intraperitoneally. At
these concentrations S. cumini neither induced chromosomal damage nor altered the
cell division cycle in both plant and animal models.
Terminalia chebula (Gaertner) Retz.
Terminalia chebula belongs to the family Combretaceae. It is a flowering evergreen
commonly known as the black myrobalan. It is also known as Haritaki (Sanskrit and
Bengali), Harad (Hindi), Karkchettu (Telugu), Kadukkai (Tamil), and Harada
(Marathi and Gujarati). It is native to Indian subcontinent and the adjacent areas such
as Pakistan, Nepal and the South-West of China and Sri Lanka where it is called
Aralu. The flowers are monoecious, dull white to yellow, with a strong unpleasant
odour, borne in terminal spikes or short panicles. The fruits are glabrous, ellipsoid to
ovoid drupes, yellow to orange brown in colour. The fruits give a valuable tannin
material and a yellow dye. T. chebula is found throughout the deciduous forests of the
Indian subcontinent, on dry slopes up to 900 m elevation (Gamble, 1928;
Chattopadhyay and Bhattacharyya, 2007).
Phytochemical Components
28
The presence of large amount of tannins in the fruit and bark is a characteristic feature
of this genus (Evans, 1996). The chief constituents of tannin are chebulic acid,
chebulagic acid, corilagin and gallic acid and it is of pyrogallol (hydrolyzable) type
(Bruneton, 1995; Chevallier, 1996). Fructose, amino acids, succinic acid,
betasitosterol, resin and purgative principle of anthroquinone and sennoside are also
present (Creencia et al., 1996). The tannin content of T. chebula varies with
geographical gap (Jayaramkumar, 2006).
Antidiabetic and genotoxic properties of Terminalia chebula
The seeds of this tree are used in the treatment of diabetes. The fruits were reported to
have dose dependent reduction in blood glucose of streptozotocin induced diabetic
rats both in short term and long term study and also had retinoprotective activity (Rao
and Srinavas, 2006; Periasamy et al., 2006). Methanolic extract of T. chebula, T.
belerica and Emblica officinalis in combination named ‘Triphala’ (equal proportion of
above three plant extracts) are being used extensively in Indian system of medicine.
They are known to inhibit lipid peroxide formation and to scavenge hydroxyl and
superoxide radicals in vitro. Oral administration of the plant extracts reduced the
blood sugar level in normal and in alloxan induced diabetic rats significantly within 4
hrs (Sabu and Kuttan, 2002). Arseculeratne et al. (1985) have stated that feeding trials
in rats with T. chebula produced hepatic lesions that included central vein
abnormalities and marked renal lesions. Cytotoxicity and genotoxicity studies based
on Ames test were reported by Mehmood and Mohammad (1998) and Arora et al.
(2005). In both the studies no cytotoxic and genotoxic effects of T. chebula was
reported.
TOXICOLOGY AND GENOTOXICITY ASSESMENTS
29
Since time immemorial, toxins in general have been recognized by the human beings,
and used both beneficially and destructively. Like morphine and other pain relievers,
toxins have often been used in medicine to combat various diseases or disorders.
From the ancient Vedic time, toxins in various herbs and plants have been most
thoroughly studied by Indian herbal physicians (known as the Vaidyas) and their
acquired knowledge (Ayurveda) is still a yardstick for the (western as well as oriental)
medical system; the basic difference between the two lies in the accidental use of
toxic chemical compounds (inorganic toxins) instead of the organic toxins in herb and
plants. The entire foundation of the homeopathic medicinal system is based on the
impact of toxins on human body as well as mind, and is a classical example, how a
form of a toxic element can be used to nullify some other toxicity in our body.
Although there are some controversies over the doctrine of homeopathic medicine
system, there is no doubt about the neutralizing capacities of toxins of different kinds.
Toxins are characterized by their toxicity, in some form or the other, in relation to
their reactions on living organisms including man. In a traditional sense, toxicity
relates to the poisonous effects which are associated with specific substances such as
potassium cyanide. Rather, the more complex types that often progress slowly and
invisibly, and in that process invite other activities, such as genotoxicity and
carcinogenicity, have a far greater need for statistical appraisal (Sen, 2001).
Genotoxicity assay is a useful technique in ascertaining the genetic damage directly or
indirectly caused to organisms by any chemical and physical agent. There is a
growing concern about the genotoxic effects induced by a number of chemical
substances such as herbicides, pesticides, synthetic medicines, herbal medicines,
cosmetic products, food and dietary supplements as we use in every day life. The
assessment helps to identify the interaction of physical and chemical agents with the
genetic material of living organisms. Chemical substances which induce cytotoxicity,
genotoxicity and chromosomal damage are designated as genotoxins (Grant, 1978;
30
ADA, 1997; Albertini et al., 2000). Genotoxic monitoring finds its way in assessing
the limitation in usage of chemical substances. Genotoxic responses focus on
cytological end points like chromosomal aberrations (CA), micronucleus (MN) and
sister chromatid exchange (SCE) (Bolognesi, 2003). Genotoxicity assessments have
been carried out by methods which include apoptosis (Kerr et al., 1972),
micronucleus assay (Schmid, 1975) and higher plant genetic system (Mazrooei and
Kabarity, 1984), animal models (Sing et al., 2003) and Ames test using microbes (Lah
et al., 2005), DNA fragmentation (Gavrieli et al., 1992), and the advanced technique -
comet assay (Singh et al., 1988).
Moreover, such toxicity studies at the molecular level may sometimes provide clues
for cancer etiology, and modern molecular biology has indeed come up with a
challenging task to incorporate genetic toxicology in deeper understanding of
progression of genotoxicity in living organisms (MacGregor, 2003).
Genotoxicity Assay Using Plant Models
Genotoxicity occurs commonly in human beings due to the continuous usage of
clastogenic substances either from nature or synthetically manufactured. Assays for
genotoxicity are used as predictors or biomarkers of disease, especially cancer (Hulka
and Margolin, 1992; Sen et al., 1995). For the evaluation of genotoxicity, higher
plants have been used as test organisms. Allium cepa is considered as one of the best
models to detect the chromosomal aberrations induced by different agents (Levan,
1938). Apart from Allium cepa, mutagenic activity of various chemicals including
medicines (Mazrooei and Kabarity, 1984), herbicides (Yoshida et al.,1983), pesticides
(Bolognesi, 2003) and herbal drugs (Sreeranjini and Thoppil, 2001) have been
analyzed in different plant systems such as Vicia faba, Arabidopsis thaliana and
Hordeum vulgare. Plant extracts have been found to cause some chromosomal
31
aberrations because of the presence of strong chemical substances which inhibit
mitosis (Sreeranjini and Thoppil, 2001).
The chromosome abnormalities produced by copper fungicides in somatic cells in
plant models have been documented (Tara Mohan, 1979; Sahu et al., 1981). Topsin a
fungicide has been used to control the fungal infections in crop plants. Even at lowest
concentration (100 µg/ml) topsin has induced severe antimitotic effect. This also
interferes with the spindle fibers and produces C– metaphase (Somashekar et al.,
1984). Chromotoxic activity and mitodepressiveness in crop plants have been widely
reported. Turbutryn is an herbicide used to eradicate a number of dicotyledonous
weeds. This has induced a wide range of chromosomal abnormalities in the root tips
of Vicia faba (Badr, 1986).
Herbicides have also been reported to cause chromosomal abnormalities by producing
stickiness, spindle poisoning and alterations in the number of chromosomes (Liang et
al., 1967). The herbicide carbamate is known to cause disorganized chromosomes in
root tip cells of Vicia faba. Yoshida et al. (1983) have reported that increase in the
duration of treatment using carbamate inhibits the growth of root tip cells and
autoradiographic studies revealed suppression of RNA synthesis.
Majority of insecticides have a direct or an indirect effect on plant systems.
Metasystox -R is an organophosphate contact insecticide, which controls sap feeding
insects and mites. The potential cytogenetic activity of this insecticide and pollen
fertility was evaluated in Allium cepa where in a number of somatic cytogenetic
abnormalities have been reported (Pandita, 1986).
Zinc is an essential element for the growth of plants. The toxicity of zinc in Nigella
sativa and Triticum aestivum was studied in concentrations higher than 25 mg/l.
32
Reduction in mitotic index in T. aestivum was more evident than in N. sativa. A
variety of mitotic anomalies including C–metaphase, lag chromosome and multipolar
anaphase were frequently observed (EL-Ghamery et al., 2003).
Administration of synthetic drugs has become a serious problem in human society. A
number of analgesics are presently being used on medical dependents. Parahypon is a
strong analgesic which is largely made up of paracetomol and caffeine. In Allium cepa
dividing and non dividing cells and their nucleic acid synthesis were inhibited due to
parahypon treatment (Mazrooei and Kabarity, 1984).
Plant substances have also been found to induce abnormalities in chromosomes
resulting in cytotoxic or genotoxic effects in plant models. Spilanthes ciliata is a
common weed from which an oil spilanthol is derived and used to treat toothache.
Severe mitotic inhibition and several other aberrations were produced by this plant
extract in Allium cepa (Sreeranjini and Thoppil, 2001). Cytotoxic effect of leaf extract
of Ipomoea carnea on root tips of Trigonella foenum-graceum has been reported. The
leaf extract of this plant produced considerable abnormalities in the root meristem of
T. foenum-graceum and mitotic frequency was also inhibited (Anis et al., 1999).
Ophioglossum oil extracted from species Ophioglossum costatum has been found to
influence the mitotic cell division in Allium cepa and Vicia faba. A complete arrest in
the cell division has been observed indicating, a concentration that promotes
inhibition of growth in roots (Kandhelwal, 1986). The water extract of Ammi majus
seeds is found effective in the treatment of leucodermia and certain other skin
diseases. Extract of Ammi seeds caused delay in completion of mitotic cycle and
prominent abnormalities in the chromosomes (Shehab et al., 1984).
Genotoxicity Assay Using Animal Models
33
Wide ranges of genotoxic substances are present in the environment and influence
human health, thus many eukaryotic systems were developed for evaluation of DNA
damage. The response of plant cells used in bioassays should be as close as possible
to that of animal cells, and especially to human beings (Juchimiuk et al., 2006). For
cytogenetic tests, the commonly used cells are derived from Chinese hamster ovaries,
human lymphocytes and bone marrow cells of rats and mice.
Fungicides constitute an important group of environmental contaminants and
genotoxicants. Cytogenetic effect of a fungicide ediphenphos has been studied on the
bone marrow cells of mice. Dose, route and duration of exposure influence the
percent of aberrations (Bhunya and Behera, 1984). The genotoxic effect of pesticides
used in Italy has been documented in the lymphocytes obtained from 5 healthy donors
were nonsynchronous centeromeric separation was reported. Severe disturbance to the
spindle fibre was the reason for the centeromeric separation (Dolara et al., 1994). The
pesticide benomyl was also embryotoxic and teratogenic (Hogenboom et al., 1991;
Cummings et al., 1992). In human beings agricultural pesticides have increase the
frequency of sister chromatid exchange (Carbonell et al., 1990).
Genotoxic effect of lomefloxacin - an antidiabetic drug has been studied in germ cells
of Swiss albino mice. The capacity to reduce mitotic index and also increase
frequency of chromosomal aberrations was reported and the agent was projected as a
weak clastogen in the bone marrow cells as it did not have any genotoxic effect in
germ cells (Singh et al., 2003).
The clastogenic effect of Rosmarinus officinalis extract was studied in Wistar rats. No
significant activity was reported confirming that the extract was non cytotoxic (Gaiani
et al., 2006). 2-Hydroxy -1, 4-napthoquinone (HNQ) - a hair dye extracted from
34
Lawsonia inermis at about 20 g of leaf paste preparation or about 200-300 mg of
HNQ was used to analyze the genotoxicity effect in animal model. At higher
concentrations the plant based chemical induced significant level of genotoxicity
(Kirkland and Marzin, 2003). Similarly a natural food colour yielding annatto (Bixa
orellana) was also tested for mutagenic and antimutagenic properties. The results
concluded that based on the test in bone marrow cells of mouse, the dye was neither
mutagenic nor antimutagenic at lower concentrations. However, it has been cautioned
to have genotoxicity effects in higher concentrations (Lima et al., 2003).
The occurrence of micronucleus during cell division has been recognized as a
genotoxic assay. Chromosomal fragments and lagging chromosomes lead to the
formation of small nuclei covered by a membrane known as micronuclei (Schmid,
1975). Bisht and Uma Devi (1994) have reported the genotoxic effect and formation
of micronucleus due to Misonidazole – a radio sensitizer.
In the past two decades, the single-cell gel electrophoresis (comet) assay has become
a method of high esteem (Collins, 2004; Folkmann et al., 2008). This was a technique
originally developed for the measurement of DNA strand breaks, but further
modifications have increased the range of lesions that can be measured. This is a
simple, rapid, visual and reliable technique for the assessment of DNA damage in
organisms. This method was developed to measure low levels of strand breaks with
high sensitivity (Forcehhammer et al., 2008). The mutagenic, chromosomal damaging
and carcinogenic properties of several chemicals and mutagens were determined using
the comet assay employing blood cells of animal models (Collins et al., 1997; Rank
and Jensen, 2003). Induction of comet by certain genotoxic substances like hydrogen
peroxide, mitomycin, cycloheximide, ethyl methane sulphonate, nitroquinoline, 9 –
aminoacridine, N – nitroso-N-ethylurea, trypsin and 4-nitroquinoline oxide were
35
investigated. The assay was able to detect DNA damage induced by an alkylating
agent, an intercalating agent and oxidative damage (Henderson et al., 1998).
CHROMOSOMAL ABERRATIONS
The analysis of chromosomal aberrations (CA) was exclusively restricted to mitotic
cells arrested in metaphase, because only in this phase of the cell cycle the DNA is so
condensed that it can be observed as chromosomes under the light microscope
(Johnson and Rao, 1970). Chromosomal aberrations have long been recognized as an
important biomarker of genotoxic chemicals. Chromosomal changes leading to
mutations were first described in Oenothera by De Vries (1922). In earlier studies in
Drosophila, relatively a few translocations but numerous paracentric inversions were
reported (Morgan, 1922; Bridges, 1923). Both structural and numerical aberrations
have been associated with human chromosomes. The spontaneous frequency of
chromosome aberrations was about 0.6 % in live births. Chromosome analyses of
spontaneous abortions indicate that about 50 % of them are chromosomally abnormal
(Natarajan, 2002).
Most of the known mutagenic agents induce chromosomal aberrations. Thus, it is
important to understand the mechanism by which the chromosomal aberrations are
induced and exhibited. It has been generally agreed that DNA is the main target for
the action of the chromosome breaking agents. Several different types of lesions are
introduced in the DNA such as DNA strand breaks, base damages and DNA cross
links. The damage depends on the type of mutagenic agent employed (Natarajan and
Boei, 2003).
There are two main theories on the mechanism of chromosome aberration formation,
namely the breakage and reunion theory (Sax, 1941). According to breakage theory
the primary event caused by any mutagenic substance or agent is a chromatid or
36
chromosome break. The types of aberrations observed during mitosis depend on the
fate of chromosomal breaks. Either they restitute or rejoin (illegitimate fusion) with
another break if two breaks are close enough in space and time. If two lesions are
close together in space and time they may enter a more stable stage called exchange
initiation stage (Revell, 1959). The effect of a toxicant on chromosomes may be large
enough to be visible microscopically, and manifest as structural aberrations or as
changes in their number. Aberrations include deletions, duplications, and
translocations which result in the chromosomal anomalies such as gap, break,
fragment, bridge, polarity changes, abortiveness, lag and C-metaphase (Boei et al.,
1996).
Movement of nucleus towards the poles in different directions during division is
termed as affected polarity. The nucleus about to abort after division is called abortive
anaphase. Segregation of chromosomes in the middle is C-metaphase. A small gap
which appears in one arm of the chromosome is termed as chromatid gap. An
achromatic region from one of the chromatids, larger than the width of chromatid can
be called as chromatid break. A gap which is found in both the arms of a chromosome
which may be equal or smaller in size than the arm length of chromosome is called
chromosome gap. A chromosome break is a large gap found in both the arms of
chromosomes. A part of a material getting deleted from one of the chromatid is a
deletion. A single piece of a chromatid in the absence of an evident centromere is
called as a fragment. The two chromatids aligned parallel without a prominent
centromere is called as acentric fragment (Gaiani et al., 2006)
However, chemical mutagens which do not induce directly DNA strand breaks but
cause other lesions were shown to induce only chromatid type of aberrations
irrespective of the DNA synthesis stage treated. An intervening ‘S’ phase is necessary
to visualize the aberrations (Evans, 1969).
37
Genetic damage at the chromosomal level entails an alteration in chromosome
number or chromosome structure and such alterations can be measured as CA or MN
frequency in both plants and animals. Micronuclei are acentric chromosomal
fragments or whole chromosomes left behind during mitotic cellular division and
appear in the cytoplasm of interphase cells as small additional nuclei. In contrast to
the CA evaluation, the scoring of micronuclei in lymphocytes is simple and fast
(Bolognesi, 2003). Aneuploidy involves a decrease or increase in the number of the
chromosomes. Some of the effects are heritable. The mode of action underlying these
effects may involve molecular cross-linkage, which may cause an arrest of the
synthesis of DNA, thereby leaving a gap in the chromosome. An unsuccessful repair
of the DNA damage may also be responsible for the above mentioned anomalies.
Consequences of chromosomal aberrations, DNA Damage and Repair
Organisms exposed constantly to exogenous and endogenous mutagens are subjects
for DNA–damage in due course of time. In such cases DNA repair mechanisms have
evolved to repair different types of DNA damage and to maintain genomic integrity
(Ron, 1998). Multiple repair mechanisms have evolved in all organisms to minimize
the consequences of cellular exposure to endogenous and environmental agents that
inflict deleterious alterations in DNA. The versatile process of nucleotide excision
repair (NER) removes many structurally unrelated DNA lesions that can cause
mutations, abnormal differentiation patterns, cancer or cell death (Hanawalt et al.,
2003). Among the many types of damage that arise in DNA, the most dangerous are
the double strand DNA breaks (DSBs), where both phosphate back bones are not
repaired. Such damage can result in chromosomal defects and lead to inborn diseases
or cancer (Hartwell and Weinert, 1989). DNA repair is not merely an extraordinary
scheme needed by organisms that are exposed to DNA damaging ultraviolet
38
wavelength in sun light. Rather, it is an essential set of mechanism required to
maintain genomic stability in the face of a plethora of threats, deriving from
endogenous exposure to radiation and noxious chemicals (Friedberg et al., 1995).
The early research and discovery in DNA was on restriction endonucleases, enzymes
that protect various bacterial species from invading foreign DNA. The fundamental
research that led to the discovery of excision repair in E. coli in the early 1960s has
now developed to the point that the DNA repair is ubiquitous and essential for life.
Further more it has been learnt that DNA repair interferes in some manner with each
of the other cellular DNA transactions (Hanawalt, 1995).
Most chromosomal aberrations are believed to result in lethal events. It is known, how
ever, that some aberrations persist in cycling cells as stable events. Reciprocal
translocations have been found in some tumor types adjacent to known oncogenes and
in the case of colon cancer may compromise distinct to colon cancer (Vogelstein et
al., 1988). Increased levels of CA have been associated with higher cancer risk
(Hagmar et al., 1994). The fate of aberrant cells depends on the type of aberration
induced. Cells carrying unstable chromosomal aberrations (such as dicentrics and
fragments) are eliminated during subsequent cell divisions, whereas cells containing
stable aberrations such as translocations might proliferate for a long period (Boei et
al., 1996).
Impact of Mutations
Knowledge about mutation rates can shed light on issues relating to the mechanism
and basis of germ line mutation (Ellegren et al., 2003). Mutations in somatic cells or
germ cells of mammals often lead to a decrease in the fitness of the organism or its
offspring. Mutations in dividing somatic cells may cause cancer, whereas mutations
39
in germ cells may result in defective offspring. Human beings experience both
spontaneous mutations and induced mutations and are exposed to mutagens
throughout life. Mutagenesis can occur as a result of interaction between mutagenic
agents and the genetic materials of organisms. Source of mutagen exposure include
toxicants from nature, dietary constituents, industrial chemicals, medicines and drugs
(Malling, 2004).
The eventual effects of human exposure to these mutagenic substances cannot be
predicted at present. However, some of the spontaneous abortions, stillbirths, and
heritable diseases have been shown to be related to changes in DNA molecules and to
chromosomal aberrations. In earlier studies, mutagenic activity was demonstrated
mainly in fruit flies and onion root tips because of the simpler techniques involved.
More recently, many new test systems have been developed, which range from
complex microorganisms to intact mammals. The use of such widely different
organisms is based on the fact that all double – stranded DNA share the same
biochemical characteristics (Rank and Neilson, 1993; Grant, 1978; Niida and
Nakanishi, 2006). An increase in somatic mutations has been documented in aged
cells and tissues of both humans and mice (Harman, 1956; Ames et al., 1993). A
major issue in the field of genetic toxicology has been the question whether general
relationships can be established for adverse effects of genotoxic chemicals and cancer
and hereditary damage (Vogel and Natarajan, 1995.)
RATIONALE AND OBJECTIVES OF THE PRESENT STUDY
Gymnema sylvestre, Syzygium cumini and Terminalia chebula are some of the most
commonly used medicinal plants for treating diabetes in south India. The extracts and
crude powders are either prescribed individually or in combinations to combat
diabetes by the traditional systems of medicine and local medicinal practitioners.
40
Though, these three plants are known to have antidiabetic properties in traditional and
modern systems of medicine, their efficacy and safety have not been tested and
proved scientifically. Further, the dosages of individual or combined prescriptions
vary among practitioners and standardized doses are lacking by and large. The basis
of suggesting G. sylvestre in traditional practice may be attributed to transient
inactivity of taste buds. The other two plants are being used in treating diabetes for
their astringent properties.
Prior to commencing the experimental study, a random survey (Questionnaire
Enclosed in Annexure) was conducted among the diabetic patients to evaluate the
frequent usage of antidiabetic plants as well as the mode of uptake. Nearly 70 % of
the diabetic patients rely on the above mentioned three plants for controlling sugar
level following prescriptions given by traditional healers and physicians. Hence, the
present study was envisaged to determine the genotoxic properties of above
mentioned antidiabetic plants.
The objectives of the investigation are as follows:
• To asses the genotoxicity of selected antidiabetic medicinal plants
• To determine the chromosomal aberrations through mitotic analysis in
Allium cepa
• To analyze the chromosomal aberrations and micronucleus induced by
plant extracts in bone marrow and blood cells of Wistar rats
respectively
• To establish the ideal concentration of plant extracts for safe usage
• To understand the DNA damage due to plant extracts through comet
assay
41
• To detect the occurrence of colchicine like compounds if any among
the plant extracts tested