Eastern & Midland Regional Assembly Draft Regional Spatial ... · context for Ireland and all of its regions in the period to 2031 and beyond, looking to a 2040 horizon to support

Eastern & Midland Regional Assembly

Draft Regional Spatial & Economic Strategy

SEA Environmental Report

Tionól Reigiúnach Oirthir agus Lár-TíreEastern and Midland Regional Assembly


[MDR1402Rp0005F01_EMR] i

TABLE OF CONTENTS

NON‐TECHNICAL SUMMARY .......................................................................................................... 7

1 INTRODUCTION ................................................................................................................ 32

1.1 BACKGROUND .............................................................................................................................. 32

2 CONTENTS AND MAIN OBJECTIVES OF THE PLAN .............................................................. 34

2.1 RESPONSIBLE AUTHORITY FOR THE EASTERN AND MIDLAND REGION ..................................................... 34

2.2 REQUIREMENT FOR A REGIONAL SPATIAL AND ECONOMIC STRATEGY ..................................................... 34

2.3 SCOPE AND FUNCTION OF THE REGIONAL SPATIAL AND ECONOMIC STRATEGY ......................................... 35

2.4 GEOGRAPHIC SCOPE ...................................................................................................................... 35

2.5 STRATEGIC VISION FOR THE EASTERN AND MIDLAND REGION .............................................................. 35

2.6 KEY ASPECTS OF THE DRAFT EASTERN AND MIDLAND RSES ................................................................. 36

3 STRATEGIC ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT METHODOLOGY ............................................ 38

3.1 THE STRATEGIC ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT PROCESS .................................................................... 38

3.2 WORK COMPLETED TO DATE .......................................................................................................... 38

3.2.1 Screening ......................................................................................................................... 38

3.2.2 Scoping ............................................................................................................................ 39

3.3 ENVIRONMENTAL ASSESSMENT ....................................................................................................... 51

3.3.1 Assessment Approach ..................................................................................................... 51

3.3.2 SEA Environmental Report .............................................................................................. 51

3.3.3 Links between the SEA and AA Process........................................................................... 52

3.3.4 Links between the SEA and RFRA Process ....................................................................... 53

3.4 SEA STATEMENT .......................................................................................................................... 53

3.5 DIFFICULTIES ENCOUNTERED .......................................................................................................... 53

4 REVIEW OF RELEVANT PLANS, POLICIES AND PROGRAMMES ............................................ 55

4.1 INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................................ 55

4.2 METHODOLOGY ........................................................................................................................... 55

4.3 RELATIONSHIP OF THE DRAFT RSES AND OTHER PLANS, PROGRAMMES AND POLICIES ............................. 56

4.3.1 Sustainability ................................................................................................................... 56

4.3.2 Spatial Planning ............................................................................................................... 56

4.3.3 Flooding ........................................................................................................................... 59

4.3.4 Climate and Energy ......................................................................................................... 59

4.3.5 Health and Wellbeing ...................................................................................................... 61


[MDR1402Rp0005F01_EMR] ii

4.3.6 Air Quality and Noise ....................................................................................................... 61

4.3.7 Water ............................................................................................................................... 63

4.3.8 Water Services ................................................................................................................. 64

4.3.9 Nature Conservation ....................................................................................................... 64

4.3.10 Maritime Planning and Protection ............................................................................ 65

4.3.11 Land Use .................................................................................................................... 65

4.3.12 Waste ........................................................................................................................ 66

4.3.13 Cultural Heritage and Landscape .............................................................................. 66

5 RELEVANT ASPECTS OF THE CURRENT STATE OF THE ENVIRONMENT (BASELINE) .............. 68

5.1 INTRODUCTION ............................................................................................................................ 68

5.1.1 State of the Environment Overview – Republic of Ireland .............................................. 68

5.1.2 State of the Environment Overview – Northern Ireland ................................................. 73

5.2 ENVIRONMENTAL CHARACTERISTICS ................................................................................................ 75

5.2.1 Population and Human Health ........................................................................................ 75

5.2.2 Biodiversity, Flora and Fauna ........................................................................................ 106

5.2.3 Soil, Geology and Hydrogeology ................................................................................... 112

5.2.4 Water ............................................................................................................................. 119

5.2.5 Air Quality and Climatic Factors .................................................................................... 126

5.2.6 Material Assets .............................................................................................................. 136

5.2.7 Cultural Heritage ........................................................................................................... 150

5.2.8 Landscape ...................................................................................................................... 153

5.3 INTERRELATIONSHIPS ................................................................................................................... 155

5.4 EVOLUTION OF THE BASELINE IN THE ABSENCE OF THE RSES .............................................................. 156

6 SEA FRAMEWORK AND ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION OBJECTIVES .............................. 158

6.1 DEVELOPMENT OF GUIDING PRINCIPLES AND STRATEGIC ENVIRONMENTAL OBJECTIVES ......................... 158

7 ALTERNATIVES ................................................................................................................ 161

7.1 INTRODUCTION .......................................................................................................................... 161

7.2 APPROACH TO ALTERNATIVES FOR THE DRAFT RSES ......................................................................... 161

7.2.1 Spatial Based Alternatives ............................................................................................. 163

7.2.2 Climate Based Scenarios ............................................................................................... 167

7.2.3 Economic Based Scenarios ............................................................................................ 169

7.3 POLICY ALTERNATIVES ................................................................................................................. 170

7.3.1 Resource Efficiency & Circular Economy ....................................................................... 171

7.3.2 Key Regional Infrastructure ........................................................................................... 172


[MDR1402Rp0005F01_EMR] iii

7.3.3 Natural Capital ............................................................................................................... 173

7.3.4 Energy Alternatives ....................................................................................................... 174

7.3.5 Transport Alternatives ................................................................................................... 175

7.4 PREFERRED ALTERNATIVE AND REASON FOR CHOOSING .................................................................... 176

8 ASSESSMENT OF PREFERRED SCENARIO .......................................................................... 177

8.1 ASSESSMENT APPROACH .............................................................................................................. 177

8.2 ASSESSMENT PARAMETERS .......................................................................................................... 178

8.2.1 Integration of SEA, AA and RFRA with Development of the Draft Eastern & Midland

RSES ............................................................................................................................... 178

8.3 ASSESSMENT OF POLICIES AND POLICY ACTIONS OF THE PREFERRED STRATEGIC APPROACH .................... 179

8.3.1 Policy Area – Vision (Chapter 2) .................................................................................... 179

8.3.2 Policy Area – Growth Strategy (Chapter 3) ................................................................... 183

8.3.3 Policy Area – Settlement Strategy (Chapter 4) .............................................................. 189

8.3.4 Policy Area – Dublin Metropolitan Area Strategic Plan MASP (Chapter 5) ................... 239

8.3.5 Policy Area – Economy and Employment (Chapter 6) .................................................. 260

8.3.6 Policy Area – Place Making (Chapter 7) ........................................................................ 270

8.3.7 Policy Area – Transport (Chapter 8) .............................................................................. 276

8.3.8 Policy Area – Environment (Chapter 9) ......................................................................... 291

8.3.9 Policy Area – Infrastructure and Climate Change (Chapter 10) .................................... 304

8.3.10 Policy Area – Implementation and Monitoring (Chapter 11) ................................. 318

8.4 CUMULATIVE EFFECTS ................................................................................................................. 319

8.4.1 Cumulative Impacts ....................................................................................................... 319

8.5 SUMMARY OF OVERALL STRATEGY ................................................................................................. 322

9 CHANGES MADE TO SEPTEMBER 2018 DRAFT RSES PRIOR TO PUBLICATION ................... 325

9.1 CHAPTER 2: STRATEGIC VISION ..................................................................................................... 325

9.2 CHAPTER 3: GROWTH STRATEGY ................................................................................................... 325

9.3 CHAPTER 4: PEOPLE AND PLACE .................................................................................................... 326

9.4 CHAPTER 5: MASP ..................................................................................................................... 331

9.5 CHAPTER 6: ECONOMY AND EMPLOYMENT ..................................................................................... 333

9.6 CHAPTER 7: ENVIRONMENT.......................................................................................................... 338

9.7 CHAPTER 8: CONNECTIVITY .......................................................................................................... 347

9.8 CHAPTER 9: QUALITY OF LIFE ........................................................................................................ 349

9.9 CHAPTER 10: INFRASTRUCTURE .................................................................................................... 351

9.10 CHAPTER 11: ALL IRELAND COHESION ............................................................................................ 356


[MDR1402Rp0005F01_EMR] iv

9.11 CHAPTER 12: IMPLEMENTATION AND MONITORING ......................................................................... 357

9.12 CHANGES MADE TO DRAFT RSES BY COUNCILLOR MOTION ............................................................... 357

10 MITIGATION AND MONITORING ..................................................................................... 361

10.1 INTRODUCTION .......................................................................................................................... 361

10.2 MITIGATION MEASURES .............................................................................................................. 361

10.2.1 SEA and AA Mitigation Strategy .............................................................................. 361

10.2.2 RFRA Mitigation Strategy ........................................................................................ 390

10.3 SOURCES OF INFORMATION FOR MONITORING ................................................................................ 390

10.4 MONITORING ............................................................................................................................. 391

11 NEXT STEPS ..................................................................................................................... 394

APPENDICES [VOLUME II]

Appendix A Other Plans and Programmes

Appendix B Baseline Mapping

Appendix C Settlement Typology

LIST OF FIGURES

Figure 1‐1 – Irish Planning System ‐ An Overview ................................................................................ 33 Figure 2‐1 – Regional Assemblies and the Eastern and Midland Region .............................................. 34 Figure 4‐1 – United Nations Sustainable Development Goals. Source: United Nations ...................... 56 Figure 4‐2 – National Strategic Outcomes. Source: NPF ....................................................................... 57 Figure 4‐3 – Relationship in Spatial Hierarchies in Ireland ................................................................... 58 Figure 5‐1 – Eastern and Midland Region Geographic Hierarchy ......................................................... 77 Figure 5‐2 – Growth Strategy Map for the Eastern and Midland Region ............................................. 82 Figure 5‐3 – Population Density (Census 2016) in the Eastern and Midland Region ........................... 83 Figure 5‐4 – Census 2016 Housing Stock in the Eastern and Midland Region ...................................... 86 Figure 5‐5 – Census 2016 Housing Vacancy (%) in the Eastern and Midland Region ........................... 87 Figure 5‐6 – Key Eastern and Midland Region Economic Indicators .................................................... 89 Figure 5‐7 – Commuter Flows to Dublin Metropolitan Area (2016) by Electoral Division ................... 91 Figure 5‐8 – Mode of Transport to Work/ Education: Green Modes (2016) ........................................ 93 Figure 5‐9 – Mode of Transport to Work/ Education: Public Modes (2016) ........................................ 95 Figure 5‐10 – Mode of Transport to Work/ Education: Private Modes (2016) .................................... 97 Figure 5‐11 – EEA Strategic Noise Maps for Major Roads, Railways and Airports in the Eastern and Midland Region ................................................................................................................................... 101 Figure 5‐12 – Radon Map for the Eastern and Midland Region ......................................................... 105 Figure 5‐13 – Designated Sites (see Appendix B, Vol. II) .................................................................... 107 Figure 5‐14 – CORINE (2012) Land Cover (see Appendix B, Vol. II) .................................................... 115 Figure 5‐15 – Bedrock Aquifers (see Appendix B, Vol. II) ................................................................... 117


[MDR1402Rp0005F01_EMR] v

Figure 5‐16 – Groundwater Vulnerability (see Appendix B, Vol. II) .................................................... 117 Figure 5‐17 – WFD Surface Water Ecological Status (2010‐2015) (see Appendix B, Vol. II). .............. 121 Figure 5‐18 – WFD Register of Protected Areas in the Eastern & Midland Region ............................ 122 Figure 5‐19 – EPA Air Quality Index for Health for the Eastern & Midland Region ............................ 127 Figure 5‐20 – CO2 Emissions (2015) by 1km Grid for the Eastern & Midland Region (see Appendix B, Vol. II) .................................................................................................................................................. 132 Figure 5‐21 – Major Transport Infrastructure Elements (see Appendix B, Vol. II) ............................. 136 Figure 5‐22 – TEN‐T Network (see Appendix B, Vol. II) ....................................................................... 138 Figure 5‐23 – Water and Wastewater Treatment Plants and Priority Areas (see Appendix B, Vol. II) ............................................................................................................................................................ 138 Figure 5‐24 – National Broadband Plan Intervention Map ................................................................. 142 Figure 5‐25 – Broadband Internet Connection (2016) – Eastern & Midland Region .......................... 143 Figure 5‐26 – Electricity Generation Infrastructure in Ireland ............................................................ 145 Figure 5‐27 – Overall Energy Flow in Ireland (2016) ........................................................................... 146 Figure 5‐28 – Gas Pipeline Network (see Appendix B, Vol. II) ............................................................ 146 Figure 5‐29 – Map of Windfarms and Connection Status in Ireland .................................................. 148 Figure 8‐1 – Key Sites and Strategic Corridors in the Dublin MASP .................................................... 259 Figure 8‐2 – Historic and projected CO2 emissions from the electricity generation, built environment and transport (EGBET) sectors ............................................................................................................ 324

LIST OF TABLES

Table 3.1 – SEA Stages .......................................................................................................................... 38 Table 3.2 – Summary of Statutory Scoping Consultation Responses ................................................... 41 Table 3.3 – Requirement of SEA Directive and Relevant Section in Environmental Report ................. 51 Table 5.1 – EPA Key Challenges and Relevance to the draft Eastern and Midland RSES ..................... 68 Table 5.2 – EPA Key Actions for Ireland ................................................................................................ 69 Table 5.3 – Summary of Current State of the Environment in Ireland (2016) ...................................... 70 Table 5.4 – Summary of Current State of the Environment in Northern Ireland ................................. 73 Table 5.5 – EMRA Settlement Hierarchy ............................................................................................... 78 Table 5.6 – Trends in Population for the Strategic Planning Areas in the Eastern and Midland Region .............................................................................................................................................................. 80 Table 5.7 – Trends in Population for Counties in the Eastern and Midland Region ............................. 80 Table 5.8 – Urban/ Rural Population Change (2011‐2016) in the Eastern‐Midlands Region ............... 84 Table 5.9 – National Planning Framework Phased Population Growth ................................................ 84 Table 5.10 – NPF Targeted Pattern of City Population Growth ............................................................ 84 Table 5.11 – Number and Type of Nature Conservation Sites within the Eastern and Midland Region ............................................................................................................................................................ 107 Table 5.12 – Water Framework Directive Ecological Status (2010‐2015) for the Eastern and Midland Region ................................................................................................................................................. 121 Table 5.13 – Water Framework Directive Register of Protected Areas in the Eastern & Midland Region ................................................................................................................................................. 122 Table 5.14 – Estimated CO2 Emissions (2015) by Regional Assembly ................................................. 132 Table 5.15 – EPA Priority List (2016) of Wastewater Treatment in the Eastern & Midland Region ... 139 Table 5.16 – Number of Listed/ Designated Cultural Heritage Resources in the Southern Region ... 151 Table 5.17 – Inter‐relationships between SEA Topics ......................................................................... 155 Table 5.18 – Likely Evolution of the Baseline without Implementation of the draft Eastern & Midland RSES ..................................................................................................................................................... 156 Table 6.1 – Strategic Environmental Objectives for the Eastern and Midlands RSES ........................ 158 Table 7.1 – Alternatives Discussed for the draft Eastern and Midland RSES ...................................... 162


[MDR1402Rp0005F01_EMR] vi

Table 8.1 – Assessment of Moderate Growth Towns ......................................................................... 226 Table 10.1 – Proposed SEA Mitigation Measures Relating to Assessment of Policies (see Chapter 8 and Chapter 9) .................................................................................................................................... 361 Table 10.2 – Proposed AA Mitigation Measures ................................................................................ 381 Table 10.3 – Proposed Environmental Monitoring ............................................................................. 391 Table 11.1 – Remaining Steps in the draft Eastern and Midland RSES, SEA, AA and RFRA Processes 394


[MDR1402Rp0005F01_EMR] 7

NON‐TECHNICAL SUMMARY

INTRODUCTION

This environmental report has been prepared by RPS as part of the Strategic Environmental Assessment (SEA) of the Eastern and Midland Regional Spatial and Economic Strategy (hereafter referred to as the “Eastern and Midland RSES”), in accordance with the requirements of EU and national legislation on the assessment of the effects of certain plans and programmes on the environment. The Eastern and Midland Regional Authority (EMRA), as competent authority, have developed the draft Eastern and Midland RSES to build on the strategic planning and development context for Ireland and all of its regions in the period to 2031 and beyond, looking to a 2040 horizon to support the implementation of the National Planning Framework. It sets a strategy for the co‐ordination of a range of regional and local authority policies and activities, planning and investment.

The purpose of this environmental report is to:

Inform the development of the draft Eastern and Midland RSES; Identify describe and evaluate the likely significant effects of the draft Eastern and Midland

RSES and its reasonable alternatives; and Provide an early opportunity for the statutory authorities and the public to offer views on

any aspect of this environmental report and accompanying draft Eastern and Midland RSES documentation, through consultation.

This Environmental Report complies with the requirements of the Directive 2001/42/EC on the assessment of the effects of certain plans and programmes on the environment (the SEA Directive) as implemented in Ireland through the European Communities (Environmental Assessment of Certain Plans and Programmes) Regulations (S.I. No. 435 of 2004) and the Planning and Development (Strategic Environmental Assessment) Regulations 2004 (S.I. No. 436 of 2004), as amended.

CONTENTS AND MAIN OBJECTIVES OF THE PLAN

In 2018, the Government launched Ireland 2040: The National Planning Framework as a framework plan to set a new strategic planning and development context for Ireland and all of its regions in the period between now and 2040. The NPF provides the framework for the development of the Regional Spatial and Economic Strategies (RSES) by all three newly formed Regional Assemblies, and the associated enhancement of the economic development focus of local authorities, as per the Local Government Reform Act 2014.

The current Regional Planning Guidelines (RPGs) have been a key aspect of the Government’s programme for spatial planning to date. New planning legislation under the Planning and Development Act 2000 (as amended) allows for the RSESs to replace the RPGs. The regional planning function will therefore be enhanced under the new RSESs through the inclusion of a significant economic strategy. The combined spatial and economic elements will establish a broad framework to allow for integrated local authority policy development and associated actions, outline the roles of government departments and other agencies, and to strengthen and clarify the role of local authorities in economic development and enterprise support/ promotion.


[MDR1402Rp0005F01_EMR] 8

The Eastern and Midland RSES shall be prepared and adopted in accordance with the provision of Chapter III of Part II of the Planning and Development Act, 2000 (as amended).

The draft Eastern and Midland RSES development addresses both opportunities and challenges to deliver policy directions across a broad spectrum. The policy areas to be considered include the following broad headings:

Strategic Vision; Growth Strategy; Settlement Strategy; People and Place Dublin Metropolitan Area; Economy and Employment; Environment; Connectivity; Quality of Life; Infrastructure; All Island Cohesion; and Implementation and Monitoring

The lead authority for the preparation of the Eastern and Midland Regional Spatial & Economic Strategy (RSES) is the Eastern and Midland Regional Assembly (EMRA). The Eastern and Midland RSES itself will cover the geographic area of the EMRA, which includes the administrative areas of twelve local authorities – Longford, Westmeath, Offaly, Laois, Louth, Meath, Kildare, Wicklow, Fingal, South Dublin and Dún Laoghaire‐Rathdown County Councils and Dublin City Council. There are also sub‐regional planning functions through the three Strategic Planning Areas (SPA), namely the Midland, Eastern and Dublin SPAs.

SEA METHODOLOGY

The SEA Directive requires that certain plans and programmes, which are likely to have a significant impact on the environment, be subject to the SEA process. The SEA process is broadly comprised of the following steps, as outlined in Table 1.

Table 1 – SEA Stages

SEA Step / Stage Purpose Status

Screening

The purpose of this stage of the process was to reach a decision, on whether or not an SEA of the Eastern and Midland RSES was required.

This stage was completed in Q4 2017 with a decision to undertake SEA of the Eastern and Midland RSES.

Scoping and statutory consultation

The purpose of this stage of the process was to clarify the scope and level of detail to be considered in the environmental assessment. This was done in consultation with the defined statutory bodies for SEA in Ireland and consultation was also

This stage was completed between Q4 2017 and Q1 2018.


[MDR1402Rp0005F01_EMR] 9

SEA Step / Stage Purpose Status undertaken with the authorities in Northern Ireland.

Environmental assessment and consultation

The purpose of this stage of the process is to assess the likely significant impacts on the environment as a result of implementation of the RSES and consideration of reasonable alternatives. The output from this stage of the process is an SEA Environmental Report which records this assessment. Consultation on the draft RSES, Environmental Report and appropriate assessment are also part of this stage.

To stage was completed in Q2‐Q4 2018. Subject of this report.

SEA Statement

The purpose of this stage of the process is to identify how environmental considerations and consultations have been integrated into the final plan culminating in the production of an SEA Statement.

To be published with Final Eastern and Midland RSES.

Integration of the SEA and draft Eastern and Midland RSES was achieved through close involvement of relevant team members in all stages of the project including: SEA Scoping; review of the existing situation; and public consultation. The SEA and plan team also worked closely on developing: the SEA assessment methodology; alternatives to be considered in the SEA; SEA objectives, targets and indicators; and mitigation measures and monitoring strategies.

Consultation as part of SEA Scoping was carried out with the statutory consultees for SEA in Ireland and included the development of a Scoping Report. In addition, the scoping report was also placed on public display, alongside an Issues Paper for the Eastern and Midland Region. Taking into consideration feedback from statutory consultees and the public, a broad assessment of the potential for the RSES to influence the environment was carried out. All of the environmental topics listed in the SEA Directive were scoped in for the assessment of the plan. These are:

Biodiversity, Flora and Fauna; Population; Human Health; Soil; Water; Landscape; Air; Climatic Factors; Material Assets; and Cultural, Architectural and Archaeological Heritage.

Scoping for the SEA of the Eastern and Midland RSES was carried out with these statutory environmental authorities, based on an initial draft scoping report for the Eastern and Midlands Region which was provided to the six consultees on 14th December 2017. A scoping workshop was subsequently held on 13th March 2018 at Dublin City Council Offices in Smithfield, Dublin. This was


[MDR1402Rp0005F01_EMR] 10

coordinated for all three Regional Assemblies i.e. Eastern and Midlands, Southern, and Northern and Western. Representatives from all statutory consultees were invited to attend this workshop.

The following groups were represented on the day:

SEA teams for Eastern and Midland, Southern and Northern and Western Regional Assemblies;

RSES teams for Eastern and Midland, Southern and Northern and Western Regional Assemblies;

Department of Communications, Climate Action and Environment; Inland Fisheries Ireland (IFI); and Environmental Protection Agency (EPA).

Comments made at the workshop from the statutory consultees have been taken into account in this Environmental Report.

The Eastern and Midland RSES is a regional strategy and as such the assessment has been focussed at the national to regional level. The plan will cover the period up to 2040 and in line with the SEA Directive, short, medium and long‐term impacts have been considered during the assessment. Based on the requirements of the legislation and guidance, the information provided in the Environmental Report is outlined in Table 2.

Table 2 – Requirements of the SEA Directive and Relevant Section in Environmental Report

Requirement of SEA Directive [Article 5(1), Annex 1] Section of Environmental Report

An outline of the contents and main objectives of the plan or programme, or modification to a plan or programme, and relationship with other relevant plans or programmes.

Chapter 2: Content and Main Objectives of the Plan Chapter 4: Review of Relevant Plans, Policies and Programmes

The relevant aspects of the current state of the environment and the likely evolution thereof without implementation of the plan or programme, or modification to a plan or programme.

Chapter 5: Relevant Aspects of the Current State of the Environment (Baseline)

The environmental characteristics of areas likely to be significantly affected.


Any existing environmental problems which are relevant to the plan or programme, or modification to a plan or programme, including, in particular, those relating to any areas of a particular environmental importance, such as areas designated pursuant to the Birds Directive or the Habitats Directive.


The environmental protection objectives, established at international, European Union or national level, which are relevant to the plan or programme, or modification to a plan or programme, and the way those objectives and any environmental considerations have been taken into account during its preparation.

Chapter 4: Review of Relevant Plans, Policies and Programmes

The likely significant effects on the environment, including on issues such as biodiversity, population, human health, fauna, flora, soil, water, air, climatic factors, material assets, cultural heritage including architectural and archaeological heritage, landscape and

Chapter 8: Assessment of Preferred Scenario Chapter 9: Changes Made to September 2018 draft RSES Prior to Publication


[MDR1402Rp0005F01_EMR] 11

Requirement of SEA Directive [Article 5(1), Annex 1] Section of Environmental Report the interrelationship between the above factors. The measures envisaged to prevent, reduce and as fully as possible offset any significant adverse effects on the environment of implementing the plan or programme, or modification to a plan or programme.

Chapter 10: Mitigation and Monitoring

An outline of the reasons for selecting the alternatives dealt with, and a description of how the assessment was undertaken including any difficulties (such as technical deficiencies or lack of know‐how) encountered in compiling the required information

Chapter 7: Alternatives

A description of the measures envisaged concerning monitoring of the significant environmental effects of implementation of the plan or programme, or modification to a plan or programme

Chapter 10: Mitigation and Monitoring

A non‐technical summary of the information provided under the above headings Non‐technical Summary

In addition to this SEA, there is a requirement under the EU Habitats Directive (92/43/EC) to assess whether the plan has the potential to impact negatively on a European site. These sites include areas designated for the protection and conservation of habitats and of wild flora and fauna and include Special Protection Areas (SPAs) and Special Areas of Conservation (SACs). In parallel to the SEA, an Appropriate Assessment (AA) is being carried out to inform decisions surrounding this issue. Screening for Appropriate Assessment was carried out by EMRA in 2018 and a decision was made to carry out a full AA on the draft Eastern and Midland RSES, which is presented as a Natura Impact Report (NIR).

Alongside the development of the RSES and the accompanying SEA and AA, a Strategic Flood Risk Assessment (SFRA) has been undertaken. It has been prepared in accordance with the requirements of The Planning System and Flood Risk Assessment Guidelines for Planning Authorities (2009) and Circular PL02/2014 (August 2014).1 The findings of the SFRA and the AA processes have directly fed into SEA Environmental Report and all three documents will be placed on public display alongside the draft Eastern and Midland RSES.

REVIEW OF RELEVANT PLANS, POLICIES AND PROGRAMMES

This section of the report has taken into consideration the plan, policy and programme framework within which the draft Eastern and Midland RSES has been developed. The Eastern and Midland RSES is a regional strategy and therefore the review has focused on relevant regional, national, European and international frameworks. It is not intended to be an exhaustive list but rather is focused on those considered key to the draft RSES and takes on board comments made by statutory consultees during the SEA scoping stage.

Key policy areas such as maritime and land use spatial planning, climate change, renewable energy, flooding, agriculture, water and wastewater services, waste, and conservation have been explored. In exploring the relationships between the draft RSES and key plans/ programmes the following two questions have framed the review:

1 The Planning System and Flood Risk Assessment Guidelines for Planning Authorities (2009) and Circular PL02/2014 (August 2014) hereafter will be referred to as ‘the Guidelines’


[MDR1402Rp0005F01_EMR] 12

Does the Eastern and Midland RSES contribute to the fulfilment of environmental protection objectives set in other Plans/ Programmes/ Policy/ Legislation; and

To what degree are the environmental protection objectives set in these other Plans/ Programmes/ Policy/ Legislation impacted by the Eastern and Midland RSES?

For national spatial planning, the NPF presents the overarching framework under which the RSES sits. The Local Government Reform Act 2014 has established the three Regional Assemblies, covering the East and Midlands, the South, and the North‐West of the country and alongside the NPF, the Regional Assemblies will each develop, finalise and adopt their Regional Spatial and Economic Strategy to outline in more detail how the NPF will be implemented in each Regional Assembly area and in the local authority areas that make up each assembly.

Other key influencing plans and programmes include: the Irish Water Investment Programme up to 2021 and beyond; the National Clean Air Strategy; the National Climate Change Mitigation Plan; the National Renewable Energy Action Plan; Eastern and Midland RSES will also have to align itself with planning in the maritime environment and the Marine Strategy Framework Programme of Measures 2016, as well as the forthcoming Maritime Spatial Plans (in prep and due in 2021) which are of key significance.

RELEVANT ASPECTS OF THE CURRENT STATE OF THE ENVIRONMENT (BASELINE)

This section of the Environmental Report examines the relevant significant issues of the current state of the environment in relation to Biodiversity, Flora and Fauna, Population, Human Health, Water, Soil and Geology, Air Quality, Climatic Factors, Material Assets, Cultural Heritage, Landscape and the interrelationship between these factors. The baseline has been compiled using available datasets and indicators developed through scoping and review of relevant supporting documentation. It is noted that the Eastern and Midland RSES is a regional strategy and as such the assessment is focussed at a regional to national strategic level and this is mirrored in the level of detail presented for the baseline description in the main Environmental Report.

The baseline description is focussed in the first instance on the Republic of Ireland however given that the EM region shares a land boundary with Northern Ireland, there is potential for environmental impact on air quality, water quality and biodiversity which are transboundary. As such the baseline chapter includes reference, where relevant, to baseline conditions and pressures in Northern Ireland.

Ireland’s natural environment, although under increasing pressure, generally remains of good quality and represents one of the country’s most essential national assets, however pressures have increased significantly (EPA, 2008, 2012 and 2016) and it is acknowledged that problems and challenges still remain. In their sixth and most recent state of the environment review, the EPA has reiterated the four priority challenges for the environment, which, if addressed successfully, should benefit the present and future quality of Ireland’s environment. These comprise:

Valuing and Protecting our Natural Environment; Building a Resource‐Efficient, Low Carbon Economy; Implementing Environmental Legislation; and Putting the Environment at the Centre of Our Decision Making.


[MDR1402Rp0005F01_EMR] 13

These challenges are summarised below in Table 3.

Table 3 – EPA Key Challenges and Relevance to the Eastern and Midland RSES

Challenge Relationship to the Eastern and Midland RSES Challenge 1: Valuing and Protecting our Natural

Environment

As the draft RSES is focussed on long‐term, sustainable, consolidated spatial planning within the EM region. However, development associated with housing, infrastructure and services provision has the potential to impact on the natural environment. In this regard, the draft RSES has been developed to ensure that the regional policy objectives associated with spatial planning and related activities are carried out in compliance with all existing EU and national objectives, policies and legislation which also seek to protect the natural environment.

Challenge 2: Building a Resource‐Efficient, Low

Carbon Economy

The National Policy Position on climate action and low carbon development sets a fundamental national objective to achieve transition to a competitive, low‐carbon, climate‐resilient and environmentally sustainable economy by 2050. The draft RSES is being prepared with consideration given to this objective and the supporting legislation. It will aim to maximise coordination of land use planning in a sustainable way which will have positive implications for increasing resourcefulness and helping to tackle climate change by increasing efficiencies at multiple levels within the planning hierarchy.

Challenge 3: Implementing

Environmental Legislation

The draft RSES is undergoing SEA, AA and SFRA in line with existing EU and national legislation. Plans, measures and projects arising from the RSES in many cases will require further environmental assessment (SEA, EIA, SFRA, EPA licensing). Where development is below the thresholds of this legislation and regulation, this Environmental Report will make recommendations to protect the environment.

Challenge 4: Putting the Environment at the

Centre of Our Decision Making

As noted previously, the draft RSES is undergoing SEA, AA and SFRA in line with existing EU and national legislation. This is ensuring that the broader environmental consequences are taken into account as part of the framework’s development. These assessment processes are helping to shape the evolution of the draft RSES.

State of the Environment Overview – Ireland

Following on from the four key challenges, seven key actions for Ireland on the state of the environment have also been listed, and comprise the following:

Environment, health and wellbeing: recognise that a good quality environment brings benefits to health and wellbeing.

Climate change: the response to climate change needs to be accelerated ‐ we need to act quickly, transform our energy systems and a shift to a more sustainable transport system.

Implementation of legislation: there needs to be an improvement in tracking plans and policies, as well as compliance with several directives and continued targeting of non‐compliances by environmental enforcement bodies.

Restore and protect water quality: measures should continue to be implemented to achieve at least Good Status in all water bodies, while also acknowledging that while Ireland’s marine waters are relatively unpolluted, pressures continue to increase.


[MDR1402Rp0005F01_EMR] 14

Nature and wild places: habitat and biodiversity loss continue ‐ initiatives need to be developed which incorporate nature protection at the core of decision‐making.

Sustainable economic activities: the economy can be competitive, but in a sustainable way having regard to finite resources. Issues include the increase in exported residual waste, the need to phase out subsidies and exemptions which encourage unsustainable activities/emissions as well as the challenge of intensifying agricultural output in a sustainable way.

Community engagement: a strong evidence‐base and good communication strategies are key for keeping stakeholders and citizens reliably informed ‐ sustainable growth requires changes to the way all consumers act.

The quality of Ireland's environment is generally good though it has been under increasing pressure over the last decade as a result of economic changes, population growth and urbanisation, and changing consumer patterns. In Ireland the main changes in land use since 2012 have been an increase in the amount of forested lands, semi‐natural areas and artificial areas, and a decrease in the total amount of agricultural land and peatland. The main land use type in Ireland is agriculture, while forestry cover remains very low compared to other European countries although forestry policy is to increase current cover. The main policy drivers of land use change over the coming decade will include such areas as the agricultural policy of Food Wise 2025, afforestation policies associated of the Forestry Programme 2014‐2020 and bioenergy policy associated with the National Bioenergy Plan. The main challenges for these policies will be to increase primary production in a way that is sustainable and does not adversely impact the environment. This challenge is even greater when considered in the context of climate change which may increase the intensity of impacts unless adaptation and mitigation strategies are built into such policies. For example, diffuse loss of nutrients to water remains a major environmental pressure but this could be exacerbated into the future in areas experiencing low flows for longer periods as a result of climate change.

There is no single national or indeed regional scale baseline dataset of land use or land cover for Ireland. The CORINE dataset is the nearest proxy, but has resolution issues (the smallest unit of mapping is 25 hectares), however more detailed sectoral mapping is available for agriculture and forestry. According to the latest CORINE dataset (2012), artificial and built surfaces nationally account for approximately 2.46% of Ireland’s land cover. The actual figure is likely to be higher given that built surfaces less than 25ha in area (including one‐off housing), sections of the road/rail network, and smaller quarrying sites are not captured at this resolution.

The majority of Ireland’s most important habitats are reported to be of inadequate or bad conservation status; most species are considered to be stable however a number of key species are declining. Aquatic species such as freshwater pearl mussel and bees are reported to be most at risk. Pressures from changes in land use, intensification of agriculture, pollution and climate change, as well as the impacts of a growing economy, are likely to bring additional pressures on a number of species and habitats in Ireland in the coming years. In addition, the spread of invasive alien species also poses a threat to native biodiversity. Species such as the zebra mussel for example was recorded in 70 lakes, which is an increase of 20 lakes from the known populations in the previous report.

While air quality in Ireland is of a good standard compared to other EU member states, monitoring shows that local levels of some pollutants (e.g. nitrogen dioxide) are at concentrations that may impact on health and trends in others such as polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAH), particulate matter (PM10 and PM2.5) are a concern. A 2017 EEA report indicates that around 1,510 deaths in Ireland in 2016 were directly linked to air pollution. Irish per capita greenhouse gas (GHG) emissions remain among the highest in Europe, with agriculture the largest source accounting for 32.3% of


[MDR1402Rp0005F01_EMR] 15

total national emissions in 2016. Sectors such as energy are showing decreases in GHGs due to increased use of renewables and improving standards. In 2016, Ireland is just over halfway to meeting its Renewable Energy Directive target and the new Climate Action and Low Carbon Development Act will also help transition to a low carbon economy.

Current water quality trends nationally in both monitored river water bodies and lakes indicate that those at satisfactory ecological status (high or good) appear to have declined overall by 3% since 2007‐2009. However, whilst the national figure of 3% suggests only a slight decline; this doesn’t reflect a significant number of improvements and dis‐improvements across monitored river water bodies and lakes since 2009. The main pressures including eutrophication, urban waste water, diffuse agricultural sources and impacts to the marine environment (e.g. overfishing, by‐catch, pressures from aquaculture) persist. Measures to improve water quality are being implemented through the River Basin Management Plan. However there has been little overall improvement since the last river basin management cycle; in the latest water quality assessment period (2013‐2015) there has been a decline in the number of high status sites.

State of the Environment Overview – Northern Ireland

The second State of the Environment Report for Northern Ireland (2013) is titled “From Evidence to Opportunity” and provides a five year update and commentary on forty‐four indicators across eight themes to provide an evidence‐based assessment of the state of the environment. The Northern Ireland Environmental Statistics Report (2018) provides an annual update to the figures and provides commentary around the trends outlined in the State of the Environment Report. The current state is mixed. Air quality continues to improve, water quality is benefitting from improved effluent controls and there are increases in municipal waste recycling rates. However some declines in quality have been recorded for biodiversity, freshwaters, landscapes, habitats and heritage. Like Ireland, Northern Ireland has experienced the effects of recession in recent years which has in turn reduced some of the pressure on the environment but this has been replaced by new pressures and challenges associated with trying to stimulate an economy and reliance on natural resources.

The overall status of water bodies in Northern Ireland has not significantly changed from that recorded in 2009 but improvements have been identified in water utility discharges and drinking water quality. In 2015, 32.7% of the river waterbodies were classified as ‘high’ or ‘good’ quality. There has been an increase in the number of water incidents reports but substantiated incidents have fallen. The key challenges for the water bodies relate to diffuse nutrient pollution, chemical status of the water environment and measures to address physical modifications of beds, banks and shore of surface waters. For the second cycle of River Basin Management Planning in Northern Ireland there are 496 surface water bodies including 450 rivers, 21 lakes and 25 transitional and coastal waters.

Despite continued action many key elements of biodiversity continues to decline. Between 1994 and 2016, the wild bird population has increased by 41%, however the underlying bird populations are not all increasing. The total wetland bird population is estimated to have decreased by 19% between 1994/95 and 2015/16. The proportion of marine area under favourable management in 2016/17 has decreased 11.65% compared to 2015/16. In 2017/18, 60 parks and green spaces achieved Green Flag Award status, compared with 51 in 2016/17. The key pressures identified relate to land‐use changes through agriculture and development with additional pressures such as pollution, invasive species and fisheries practices. The Northern Ireland Environmental Statistics Report 2018 reported that as of 31st March 2017, a total of 390 sites had been declared as Areas of


[MDR1402Rp0005F01_EMR] 16

Special Scientific Interest (ASSI), 57 sites as SACs, 17 sites as SPAs and 21 sites as Ramsar sites (areas of wetland and waterfowl conservation).

Interrelationships

In accordance with the SEA Directive, the interrelationship between the SEA environmental topics must be taken into account (Table 4). The key interrelationships identified in this SEA are set out below.

Table 4 – Interrelationships between SEA Topics

Population & Human Health

Soil

Water

Air Quality X

Climatic Factors

Material Assets

Cultural Heritage X X

Landscape X

Biodiversity Flora, Fauna Population & Human Health Soil Water

Air Quality

Climatic Factors

Material Assets

Cultural Heritage

Evolution of the Baseline in the Absence of the Eastern & Midland RSES

The SEA legislation requires that consideration is given to the likely evolution of the current baseline where implementation of the Eastern and Midland RSES does not take place. Initiatives such as the Irish Water Investment Programme, Food Wise 2025, urban/ suburban development and sprawl, and the hollowing‐out of rural settlements are still likely to occur even without the Eastern and Midland RSES. Table 5 summarises the key issues.

Table 5 – Likely Evolution in the Absence of the Eastern and Midland RSES

Key Issue Likely Evolution in the Absence of the draft Eastern & Midland RSES Biodiversity,

Flora and Fauna Without the draft RSES, the pressure on aquatic and terrestrial flora, fauna and habitats is likely to continue with key drivers continuing to occur at the regional level from development and land‐use changes, in addition to intensification of agriculture through national initiatives such as Food Wise 2025. This is likely to lead to habitat loss and/ or fragmentation. In addition, there are changes expected to occur through climate change that may alter species and habitat ranges, with potential for range expansion of some invasive alien species which are an increasing concern. In the absence of the draft RSES, measures to address these pressures may not be coordinated or focussed at the regional level in relation to the most sensitive habitats and species, leading to permanent loss of key species.

Population and Nationally, the population of Ireland has been predicted to grow up to 5.3 million over the


[MDR1402Rp0005F01_EMR] 17

Key Issue Likely Evolution in the Absence of the draft Eastern & Midland RSES Human Health period to 2051, an annual average population growth rate of up to 0.8%. The draft RSES

projects that the Eastern & Midland Region will be home to an additional 490,000 to 540,000 people by 2040. These projected population increases will increase pressure on land use, water/ wastewater and transport services. In the absence of the draft RSES, this increased pressure will not be accounted for in terms of integration with evolving policy giving rise to pressure on existing infrastructure and inadequate provision for future changes.

Soils In the absence of the draft RSES the soils, geology and hydrogeology would continue to exist in much the same pattern. There is currently little or no legislation relating directly to soils and soil protection.

Water The eleven existing directives outlined under Article 11 of the WFD would continue to be implemented and enforced for the second cycle of the River Basin Management Plan (RBMP) covering the period 2018‐2021, also taking account of the most recent status of water bodies, the outputs of the risk characterisation process as well as the lessons learned from the implementation of the first cycle. The Irish Water Business Plan, Water Services Strategic Plan and Investment Programmes, would take place independently of the draft RSES with the expected investment in the period up to 2021 resulting in the provision of new or upgraded plants in 105 agglomerations, leading to some improvements in some water bodies. The existing planning system will need to account for water quality and refer to the programme of measures implemented through the RBMP.

Air Quality and Climatic Factors

Air quality in Ireland is of a high standard across the country, meeting all EU air quality standards, according to the EPA however localised issues have arisen, particularly in urban areas where challenges are emerging. The National Clean Air Strategy has identified the following as key areas: transport emissions, especially road transport emissions of NOx, fine particulate matter (PM2.5) and black carbon arising from increase in diesel cars and buses in our cities and towns; emissions from industry, agriculture and shipping; and the persistent problem of ‘smoky’ emissions from the use of solid fuel in homes. National estimates indicate that they are a key source of PM2.5. They are responsible for around 60% of all national emissions, though providing less than 5% of national energy demand. The National Clean Air Strategy will provide the strategic policy framework necessary to identify and promote integrated measures across government policy that are required to reduce air pollution and promote cleaner air while delivering on wider national objectives. The absence of the draft RSES is not expected to affect this trend, however uncoordinated infrastructure development would be likely. As a result of manmade GHG emissions, climate change is predicted to occur in the future regardless of action. The UN Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC) in their Climate Change 2014: Climate Change Impacts, Adaptation and Vulnerability Report predict sea level rise, changes in rainfall patterns and temperatures as well as changes in the frequency of droughts and extreme weather events. Climate change impacts are projected to increase in the coming decades and during the rest of this century. The EPA notes that uncertainties remain in relation to the scale and extent of these impacts, particularly during the second half of the century. The greatest uncertainly lies in how effective global actions will be in reducing greenhouse gas emissions.

Material Assets The draft RSES acknowledges the requirements of existing directives, regulations and measures. It provides for the coordination of these controls at the regional level to reduce impacts to the environment and examines how activities are impacting the wider environment and the measures needed to address these negative effects. In the absence of the draft RSES, Irish Water would continue to invest in water services bringing improvements to water bodies, particularly where urban wastewater is the single pressure, and the NTA’s Transport Strategy for the Greater Dublin Area would still be in place. As the population will continue to grow with the associated demand for infrastructure as well as municipal and community services, in the absence of the RSES,


[MDR1402Rp0005F01_EMR] 18

Key Issue Likely Evolution in the Absence of the draft Eastern & Midland RSES the broad growth targets outlined under the NPF would still be mandated but likely with less coordination and detail at the lower planning levels. Without the draft RSES these complex scenarios would continue to be managed in a less coordinated manner, thus the cumulative and synergistic impacts on the environment would continue. Critically without the draft RSES there would be a less approach to priortising and targeting those resources (particularly capacity issues) to areas with the greatest need.

Cultural Heritage In the absence of the draft RSES the uncoordinated approach to measures could result in unnecessary impacts on existing cultural heritage resource. However at a local level the existing development planning processes should provide a level of protection.

Landscape In the absence of the draft RSES, the uncoordinated approach to measures could result in unnecessary impacts to protected or sensitive landscape and seascape. However at a local level the existing development planning processes should provide a level of protection.

ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION OBJECTIVES AND SEA FRAMEWORK

In developing an SEA framework for assessment of the RSES, consideration has been given to, in the first instance, guiding principles which drive the plan and its objectives toward greater sustainability. The SEA team, working with the Regional Authority, have devised a set of overarching principles to link from the SEA through to the RSES. Falling out of these principles, specific Strategic Environmental Objectives (SEO’s) have been devised. These will be used to assess the objectives included in the RSES.

The SEO’s are aligned with the environmental topics listed in the SEA Directive. Each SEO specifies a desired outcome e.g. reduce CO2 emissions, against which the future impacts of the plans can be measured. These high‐level SEOs are paired with specific targets which can be monitored using indicators in due course.

Table 6 – Strategic Environmental Objectives

Guiding Principle SEO

BIODIVERSITY FLORA AND FAUNA Guiding Principle: No net contribution to biodiversity losses or deterioration

To preserve, protect, maintain and, where appropriate, enhance the terrestrial, aquatic and soil biodiversity, particularly EU designated sites and protected species.

Ensure no adverse effects on the integrity of any European site, with regard to its qualifying interests, associated conservation status, structure and function.

Safeguard national, regional and local designated sites and supporting features which function as stepping stones for migration, dispersal and genetic exchange of wild species.

Enhance biodiversity regionally in line with the National Biodiversity Strategy and its targets.

To protect, maintain and conserve the regions Natural Capital POPULATION AND HUMAN HEALTH Guiding Principle: Improve quality of life for all ages and abilities based on high‐quality, serviced, well connected and sustainable residential, working, educational and recreational environments

To create an environment where every individual and sector of society can play their part in achieving a more healthy Ireland.

Consolidate growth and limit urban sprawl. Enhance human health and promote healthy living through

access to active travel opportunities, especially walking and cycling.

Promote economic growth to encourage retention of working


[MDR1402Rp0005F01_EMR] 19

Guiding Principle SEO age population.

Ensure that existing population and planned growth is matched with the required public infrastructure and the required services.

Safeguard the regions citizens from environment‐related pressures and risks to health and well‐being.

WATER Guiding Principle: Protection, improvement and sustainable management of the water resource

Ensure that the status of water bodies is protected, maintained and improved in line with the requirements of the WFD and MSFD.

Ensure that economic growth of the marine resource and its ecosystems are managed sustainably.

Ensure water resources are sustainably managed to deliver proposed regional growth targets in the context of existing and projected water supply and wastewater capacity constraints ensuring the protection of receiving environments.

Avoid inappropriate development in areas at risk of flooding and areas that are vulnerable to current and future erosion, particularly coastal areas.

Integrate sustainable water management solutions (such as SuDS, porous surfacing and green roofs) into development proposals.

LAND AND SOILS Guiding Principle: Ensure the long‐term sustainable management of land

Protect soils against pollution, and prevent degradation of the soil resource.

Promote the sustainable use of infill and brownfield sites over the use of greenfield within the region.

Safeguard areas of prime agricultural land and designated geological sites.

AIR Quality Guiding Principle: Support clean air policies that reduce the impact of air pollution on the environment and public health

To avoid, prevent or reduce harmful effects on human health and the environment as a whole resulting from emissions to air from all sectors with particular reference to emissions from transport, residential heating, industry and agriculture.

Maintain and promote continuing improvement in air quality through the reduction of emissions and promotion of renewable energy and energy efficiency.

Promote continuing improvement in air quality. Reduction of emissions of sulphur dioxide, nitrogen oxides,

volatile organic compounds, ammonia and fine particulate matter which are responsible for acidification, eutrophication and ground‐level ozone pollution

Meet Air Quality Directive standards for the protection of human health — Air Quality Directive

Significantly decrease noise pollution by 2020 and move closer to WHO recommended levels.

CLIMATE Guiding Principle: Achieving transition to a competitive, low carbon, climate‐resilient economy that is cognisant of environmental impacts.

To minimise emissions of greenhouse gasses. Integrate sustainable design solutions into the regions

infrastructure (e.g. energy efficient buildings; green infrastructure).

Contribute towards the reduction of greenhouse gas emissions in line with national targets.

Promote development resilient to the effects of climate change. Promote the use of renewable energy, energy efficient

development and increased use of public transport.

MATERIAL ASSETS Guiding Principle: Sustainable and

Optimise existing infrastructure and provide new infrastructure to match population distribution proposals in the region.

Ensure access to affordable, reliable, sustainable and modern


[MDR1402Rp0005F01_EMR] 20

Guiding Principle SEO efficient use of natural resources energy for all which encourages a broad energy generation mix

to ensure security of supply – wind, wave solar, tidal, biomass, EfW [Energy from Waste], and traditional fossil fuels.

Promote the circular economy, reduce waste, and increase energy efficiencies.

Ensure there is adequate sewerage and drainage infrastructure in place to support new development.

Promote the circular economy, reduce waste, and increase energy efficiencies.

Reduce the energy demand from the transport sector and support moves to electrification of road and rail transport modes.

Encourage the transition to a zero carbon economy by developing grid infrastructure to support renewables (onshore and offshore), and international connectivity.

Reduce the average energy consumption per capita including promoting energy efficient buildings, retrofitting, smart‐ buildings, cities and grids.

CULTURAL HERITAGE Guiding Principle: Safeguard cultural heritage features and their settings through responsible design and positioning of development.

Protect places, features, buildings and landscapes of cultural, archaeological or architectural heritage

LANDSCAPE Guiding Principle: Protect and enhance the landscape character

To provide a framework for identification, assessment, protection, management and planning of landscapes having regard to the European Landscape Convention.

ALTERNATIVES

The consideration of alternatives is a requirement of the SEA Directive (2001/42/EC). The term ‘reasonable’ is not defined in the legislation. Good practice points to the analysis of ‘alternatives’ as being a constructive and informative exercise for the policy makers, and that only ‘possible’ options for policy are examined.

Alternatives are required to take into account the objectives of the draft RSES. The alternatives study therefore must operate within the strategic objectives, set out for the draft RSES, and provide an examination of alternative means of implementing the RSES. Section 3.14 of the DEHLG Guidelines2 notes that the higher the level of the plan, the more strategic the options which are likely to be available.

From the outset it has to be recognised that some strategic alternatives have already been considered and decided upon as part of the higher level planning already undertaken for the NPF. These higher level decisions have set the framework for the RSES to follow. Early discussion of possible alternatives was undertaken during the scoping stage for the RSES. Alternatives discussions were undertaken at two workshops between the RSES Team and the SEA Team in March and July 2018. At these workshops a number of alternative types were discussed with a view to identifying

2 Implementation of SEA Directive (2001/42/EC): Assessment of the Effects of Certain Plans and Programmes on the Environment, DEHLG 2004


[MDR1402Rp0005F01_EMR] 21

and assessing reasonable alternatives for the EM RSES. Given the nature of the RSES, alternatives have been focussed at the strategic regional level.

Following the consideration alternatives were developed as presented in Table 7.

Table 7 – Alternatives Considered

Alternative Type Alternatives Discussed for Eastern and Midland RSES

Strategic Consolidated urban growth has been identified in the NPF as the preferred national policy approach and this strategic approach has set the framework for the RSES.

Spatial

Alternative locations for the implementation of RSO relevant to the regional level include:

Polycentric vs monocentric growth patterns Ribbon vs node development Site based alternatives in context of flooding, conservation areas, and

contamination. MASP site options for economy / employment / residential Settlement strategy for economy / employment / residential

Value and Effects Orientated

Key issues which were identified in feedback from both the RSES issues paper and the SEA scoping report which address policy and stakeholder priorities include:

Climate change and climate resilience Circular economy and better use of natural resources Nature based and ecosystem services Energy security Better alignment of services with population growth, residential

development and economy.

Sectoral and Temporal Prioritisation

Alternatives that look at sectoral feasibility and needs were identified as those relating to:

Alignment of services with population growth, residential development and economy.

Strategic infrastructure delivery timelines e.g. Greater Dublin Drainage Project, Water Supply Project for the Eastern‐Midlands, MetroLink

Modal Alternatives Different technical/mode alternatives to achieve the same objective include:

Renewable energy options Transport modes

Based on these discussions, EMRA identified three key areas for further strategic consideration. These key areas are:

Spatial based alternatives; Growth dictated by different levels of polycentrism; compact growth and distributed growth in the development of a growth strategy.

Value and effects based alternatives focussed on climate and biodiversity; growth dictated by policies of different ways to drive transition to low carbon/climate resilience and adaptation/mitigation of likely impacts e.g. sea level rise, increased flooding and extreme weather events.

Economic based scenarios including sectoral prioritisation; growth dictated by different economic policy approaches to sectoral specialisation and the distribution of investment across the region.


[MDR1402Rp0005F01_EMR] 22

An objectives‐led assessment was undertaken on the options presented and each alternative was assessed against the SEOs outlined in Table 6.

The preferred strategy for the Eastern and Midlands RSES promotes selective polycentric development policies which identify a limited number of self‐sustaining settlements that play a significant role for their catchments and have the assets, capacity and potential to act as engines to drive wider growth based on a diversification of existing economic base and the promotion of smart specialisation and clustering. Policies to accelerate climate action and integrate adaptation/mitigation measures are to be integrated throughout the draft RSES. The selection of growth settlements which have the capacity to promote the greatest socio economic and environmental benefits is informed by the development of an evidence driven settlement typology and asset base for the Region.

ASSESSMENT OF PREFERRED SCENARIO

This section evaluates as far as possible the likely significant effects on the environment and to set out measures

Documents

Eastern & Midland Regional Assembly Draft Regional Spatial ... · context for Ireland and all of its regions in the period to 2031 and beyond, looking to a 2040 horizon to support