한국인의 행복과 삶의 질에

관한 종합 연구 - 국제 비교 질적 연구를 중심으로

정해식권지성 ․정선욱 ․김성아전영섭 ․권석만 ․김석호 ․신혜란 ․이봉주 ․채수홍 ․홍석철구서정 ․진예린 ․유지수

경제･인문사회연구회 협동연구총서 19-52-01협동연구 2019-01

【책임연구자】정해식 한국보건사회연구원 연구위원

【주요저서】

삶의 질 개선을 위한 정책과제 개발경제인문사회연구회･한국보건사회연구원, 2018(공저)사회통합 실태 진단 및 대응 방안 연구(Ⅳ): 사회문제와 사회통합한국보건사회연구원, 2017(공저)

【공동연구진】권지성 침례신학대학교 사회복지학과 교수정선욱 덕성여자대학교 사회복지학과 교수김성아 한국보건사회연구원 전문연구원

【협동기관연구진】전영섭 서울대학교 경제학부 교수권석만 서울대학교 심리학과 교수김석호 서울대학교 사회학과 부교수신혜란 서울대학교 지리학과 교수이봉주 서울대학교 사회복지학과 교수채수홍 서울대학교 인류학과 교수홍석철 서울대학교 경제학부 교수구서정 서울대학교 사회복지학과 박사수료연구생진예린 서울대학교 지리학과 석사과정유지수 서울대학교 경제학부 석사과정

경제·인문사회연구회 협동연구총서 19-52-01협동연구 2019-01

한국인의 행복과 삶의 질에 관한 종합 연구

- 국제 비교 질적 연구를 중심으로

발 행 일

저 자

발 행 인

발 행 처

주 소

전 화

홈페이지

등 록

인 쇄 처

2019년 12월

정 해 식

조 흥 식

한국보건사회연구원

[30147]세종특별자치시 시청대로 370

세종국책연구단지 사회정책동(1~5층)

대표전화: 044)287-8000

http://www.kihasa.re.kr

1994년 7월 1일 (제8-142호)

㈜현대아트컴

ⓒ 한국보건사회연구원 2019

ISBN 978-89-6827-668-2 93330

경제･인문사회연구회 협동연구 총서

“한국인의 행복과 삶의 질에 관한 종합 연구

– 국제 비교 질적 연구를 중심으로”

1. 협동연구총서 시리즈

협동연구총서 일련번호

연구보고서명 연구기관

19-52-01한국인의 행복과 삶의 질에 관한 종합

연구 – 국제 비교 질적 연구를 중심으로

한국보건사회연구원

2. 참여 연구진

연구기관 연구책임자 참여연구진

주관연구기관한국보건

사회연구원정해식

연구위원(총괄책임자)

권지성 침례신학대학교 교수정선욱 덕성여자대학교 교수

김성아 전문연구원

협력연구기관 서울대학교전영섭

사회과학대학 경제학부 교수

권석만 심리학과 교수김석호 사회학과 교수신혜란 지리학과 교수

이봉주 사회복지학과 교수채수홍 인류학과 교수홍석철 경제학부 교수

구서정 연구원진예린 연구원유지수 연구원

우리나라가 2018년 1인당 국민소득 3만 달러 시대에 들어섰다. 전 세계 국가 중 28

위에 해당한다. 소득, 교육, 건강의 세 요소로 측정하는 인간개발지수(Human

Development Index)를 보면 우리나라는 전 세계 국가 중 22위를 보이고 있다.

그렇지만 1인당 국민소득 2만 달러의 길목에서 작성되었던 비전 2030의 삶의 질 목표

달성은 요원하다. 소득이 늘어난 만큼, 생활수준이 개선된 만큼 약속했던 우리 국민의

행복 수준에는 도달하지 못하고 있다. 전 세계 각국에서 동일한 문항으로 물은 결과를

이용하는 「2019년 세계행복보고서」에서 우리나라의 행복지수는 2019년 5.895점으로

54위였다(Helliwell, Layard, & Sachs, 2019, pp. 24-26). 우리의 낮은 행복도는

단편적인 사실들로 일부 설명이 가능하다. 인간개발지수와 불평등으로 조정한 인간

개발지수 순위에서 우리나라는 큰 차이를 보인다. 빠르게 진행된 발전 과정에서 격차를

줄이는 데 신경을 쓰지 못했던 것이다. 세계행복보고서는 각국의 행복도를 설명하는

요인을 제시하는데, 우리나라는 삶에서의 자유로운 선택 가능성과 부패 인식이 좋지

않다. 거시적·경제적 측면의 이면에 놓인 개인의 자율성, 정치 거버넌스 측면의 발전이

더뎠던 것이다. 그간 놓쳐 왔던 성장의 이면이 점차 부정적 영향을 키우면서 성장의

발목을 잡는 상황에 이르렀다. 지속 가능한 성장을 위해서는 삶의 질을 향상시키는 것

또한 필요한 것이다.

우리나라가 경제 성장과 삶의 질 향상의 서로 연관된 두 목표를 달성하려면 우리

국민의 행복과 삶의 질에 있어서 단편적인 사실 확인을 넘어설 필요가 있다. 우리 국민의

행복과 삶의 질은 구체적으로 어느 정도이며, 보다 나은 삶과 행복을 위해 중요하고,

중요하게 생각하는 요소가 무엇인지 확인해야 한다. 이로부터 구체적인 실천 계획이

도출될 수 있다. 이를 위해 한국보건사회연구원은 ‘한국인의 행복과 삶의 질에 대한

종합 연구’를 3년간 진행할 계획이다.

2019년 연구에서는 먼저 한국인의 행복에 대한 구체적 인식을 파악하고자 하였다.

이를 위해 우리 국민 5020명을 대상으로 다각도로 행복을 측정하는 설문지를 구성하여

2019년 5월 8일부터 6월 13일까지 조사를 실시하였다. 또한 연령대별 대표를 표집한

후 초점집단면접과 심층면접을 진행하여 보다 구체적인 행복의 모습을 찾고자 하였다.

발간사

마지막으로 높은 행복 수준을 보이는 북유럽 2개 국가의 청년 및 노인 19명을 심층

인터뷰하여 이들의 행복 인식을 우리 행복 인식의 구조를 이해하는 데 활용하고자

하였다. 구축된 연구 자료는 향후 우리나라의 행복 연구의 귀중한 자원이 될 것이다.

이 연구는 한국보건사회연구원과 서울대학교 행복연구팀의 협동연구로 추진되었다.

한국인의 행복을 진단하기 위한 해외 질적 연구의 필요는 명확하다. 여러 매체에서

간간히 소개되었던 외국의 행복한 삶의 모태가 무엇인지를 확인하기 위한 공동연구가

필요한 상황에서 연구를 함께해 준 서울대학교 행복연구팀에 감사의 말을 전한다.

2019년 12월

한국보건사회연구원 원장

조 흥 식

Abstract ········································································································································1

요 약 ·············································································································································5

제1장 서 론 ···········································································································13

제1절 연구 배경 및 연구 목적 ·······························································································15

제2절 연구 내용과 방법 ··········································································································19

제2장 선행연구 검토 ·····························································································27

제1절 행복, 삶의 질의 정의와 측정 ·······················································································29

제2절 행복과 삶의 질 학술연구 동향 ·····················································································39

제3절 행복에 영향을 미치는 요인 ··························································································43

제3장 한국인의 행복 지형 ·····················································································55

제1절 문제 제기 ······················································································································57

제2절 한국인의 행복 지형 분석 ······························································································58

제3절 한국인의 행복 인식 ······································································································69

제4절 소결 ······························································································································78

제4장 행복의 구조방정식: 연령대별 접근 ·····························································81

제1절 문제 제기 ······················································································································83

제2절 선행연구 검토 ···············································································································84

제3절 연령대와 행복 방정식 ···································································································86

제4절 연령대와 행복의 구조방정식 ·························································································92

제5절 소결 ····························································································································102

목차

제5장 한국인의 행복에 대한 질적 연구 ······························································103

제1절 문제 제기 ····················································································································105

제2절 연구 방법 ····················································································································107

제3절 개별 사례의 맥락-패턴 분석 결과 ·············································································113

제4절 소결 ····························································································································145

제6장 선진 복지국가의 행복에 대한 질적 연구 ··················································151

제1절 문제 제기 ····················································································································153

제2절 북유럽 국가 행복 연구 동향: 덴마크와 노르웨이를 중심으로 ···································154

제3절 질적 연구 설계 ···········································································································160

제4절 질적 연구 결과 ···········································································································163

제5절 소결 ····························································································································213

제7장 결 론 ·········································································································217

제1절 요약 ····························································································································219

제2절 정책 제안 ····················································································································221

참고문헌 ···············································································································225

부 록 ····················································································································237

부록 1. 「2019년 한국인의 행복과 삶의 질 실태조사」 가중치 산출 보고서 ······················237

부록 2. 한국인의 행복과 삶의 질 실태조사 조사표 ·····························································250

부록 3. 「2019년 한국인의 행복과 삶의 질 실태조사」 기초 분석 ······································272

부록 4. 한국인의 행복과 삶의 질에 대한 질적 연구 질문지 ···············································469

부록 5. 한국인의 행복과 삶의 질에 대한 질적 연구 동의서 ···············································473

부록 6. 한국인이 경험한 행복의 맥락과 패턴: FGI 범주화 분석 결과 ·······························479

부록 7. 선진 복지국가의 행복과 삶의 질에 대한 질적 연구 질문지 ···································510

부록 8. 선진 복지국가의 행복과 삶의 질에 대한 질적 연구 동의서 ···································514

Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs

표 목차

〈표 1-1〉 연구 방법 체계도 ·························································································································21

〈표 1-2〉 「2019년 한국인의 행복과 삶의 질 실태조사」 조사표 구성(안) ··················································22

〈표 1-3〉 「2019년 한국인의 행복과 삶의 질 실태조사」 개요 ····································································24

〈표 1-4〉 「2019년 한국인의 행복과 삶의 질 실태조사」의 응답자 특성 분포 ············································25

〈표 2-1〉 복지 상황(welfare positions)의 구분 ·························································································32

〈표 2-2〉 삶의 질 접근의 개인적, 사회적 차원의 객관적, 주관적 평가의 기준 ·········································33

〈표 2-3〉 주관적 안녕(subjective well-being) 측정의 핵심 질문 ····························································36

〈표 2-4〉 OECD ‘더 나은 삶 지수’의 영역과 지표 ····················································································37

〈표 2-5〉 행복에 영향을 미치는 요인 ··········································································································44

〈표 3-1〉 연령대별 유효표본과 행복 ············································································································60

〈표 3-2〉 거주 지역별 유효표본과 행복 ·······································································································62

〈표 3-3〉 응답 요일별 유효표본과 행복 ·······································································································63

〈표 3-4〉 삶의 만족 점수별 물질주의와 비교성향 ·······················································································69

〈표 3-5〉 행복의 조건 ··································································································································71

〈표 3-6〉 삶의 만족 점수권별 누리고 있는 행복의 조건 평가 ····································································72

〈표 3-7〉 타인의 행복 ··································································································································73

〈표 3-8〉 성별 행복 동시출현 주요 단어 중심성 ·························································································75

〈표 3-9〉 연령대별 행복 동시출현 주요 단어 중심성 ··················································································77

〈표 3-10〉 소득분위별 행복의 희망: 어제 행복, 기대하는 행복, 5년 후 행복 ···········································78

〈표 4-1〉 한국인의 행복 방정식 ···················································································································89

〈표 4-2〉 청년(19~34세)의 행복 방정식 ······································································································90

〈표 4-3〉 중년(35~49세)의 행복 방정식 ······································································································90

〈표 4-4〉 장년(50~64세)의 행복 방정식 ······································································································91

〈표 4-5〉 노인(65세 이상)의 행복 방정식 ···································································································92

〈표 4-6〉 생활여건과 삶의 만족의 인과모형 ································································································95

〈표 4-7〉 생활여건과 성격의 인과모형 ·········································································································97

〈표 4-8〉 성격과 삶의 만족의 인과모형 ·······································································································99

〈표 4-9〉 완전경로모형 ·······························································································································101

〈표 6-1〉 국가 및 지역에 따른 합계출산율 ·······························································································158

〈표 6-2〉 면접 대상자 요약 ·······················································································································161

부표 목차

〈부표 1-1〉 지역별 집계구 분포 ·················································································································238

〈부표 1-2〉 지역별 성별 연령별 추계 인구(2019년) 분포 ········································································239

〈부표 1-3〉 2019년 추계 인구 분포 ·········································································································240

〈부표 1-4〉 2019년 추계 1인가구 분포 ····································································································241

〈부표 1-5〉 지역별 성별 연령별 비례할당 결과 ························································································242

〈부표 1-6〉 지역별 성별 연령별 표본의 분포 ····························································································243

〈부표 1-7〉 할당 방법별 지역별 상대표준오차 ··························································································244

〈부표 1-8〉 지역별 표본의 크기 및 집계구의 크기 ···················································································245

〈부표 1-9〉 지역별 거처별 집계구 분포 ····································································································246

〈부표 1-10〉 지역별 응답 현황 ··················································································································247

〈부표 1-11〉 최종 응답자 분포 ··················································································································248

〈부표 1-12〉 지역별 성별 연령별 가중치 ··································································································249

〈부표 3-1〉 응답자 분포 ·····························································································································272

〈부표 3-2〉 캔트릴 사다리: 삶의 평가 ·······································································································273

〈부표 3-3〉 종교 유무 ································································································································274

〈부표 3-4〉 종교 믿음 정도 ·······················································································································275

〈부표 3-5〉 어제 경험 정도 ·······················································································································276

〈부표 3-6〉 삶의 만족 ································································································································277

〈부표 3-7〉 어제 행복 정도 ·······················································································································278

〈부표 3-8〉 어제 우울 정도 ·······················································································································279

〈부표 3-9〉 삶의 가치: 에우다이모니아 ·····································································································280

〈부표 3-10〉 일상생활 속 자유로운 선택 가능 정도 ·················································································281

〈부표 3-11〉 생활영역 만족: 생활수준 ······································································································282

〈부표 3-12〉 생활영역 만족: 건강 ·············································································································283

〈부표 3-13〉 생활영역 만족: 삶에서 성취한 것 ························································································284

〈부표 3-14〉 생활영역 만족: 가족관계 ······································································································285

〈부표 3-15〉 생활영역 만족: 사회적 친분 관계 ························································································286

〈부표 3-16〉 생활영역 만족: 안전 ·············································································································287

〈부표 3-17〉 생활영역 만족: 사회 전반적 안전 ························································································288

〈부표 3-18〉 생활영역 만족: 미래 안정성 ·································································································289

Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs

〈부표 3-19〉 생활영역 만족: 좋아하는 일을 할 수 있는 시간적 여유 ······················································290

〈부표 3-20〉 생활영역 만족: 지역사회 환경 질 ························································································291

〈부표 3-21〉 생활영역 만족: 거주하고 있는 지역사회 전반 ······································································292

〈부표 3-22〉 생활영역 만족: 하는 일 ········································································································293

〈부표 3-23〉 생활영역 만족: 경제적 수준 ·································································································294

〈부표 3-24〉 타인의 행복: 가족 ·················································································································295

〈부표 3-25〉 타인의 행복: 친구 ·················································································································296

〈부표 3-26〉 타인의 행복: 동네 이웃 ········································································································297

〈부표 3-27〉 타인의 행복: 대한민국 국민 ·································································································298

〈부표 3-28〉 타인의 행복: 전 세계인 ········································································································299

〈부표 3-29〉 5년 후 행복 여부 ·················································································································300

〈부표 3-30〉 바라는 행복 정도 ··················································································································301

〈부표 3-31〉 행복한 삶의 중요 요소 점수 ································································································302

〈부표 3-32〉 행복 조건 충족 정도 ············································································································303

〈부표 3-33〉 더 행복해질 수 있는 조건 1순위 ·························································································304

〈부표 3-34〉 더 행복해질 수 있는 조건 2순위 ·························································································305

〈부표 3-35〉 성격 5요인 척도: (1) 모임에서 분위기를 주도하는 인물이다. ············································306

〈부표 3-36〉 성격 5요인 척도: (2) 여러 사람 사이에서도 주눅이 들지 않는다. ·····································307

〈부표 3-37〉 성격 5요인 척도: (3) 모임에서 많은 사람과 이야기를 나눈다. ··········································308

〈부표 3-38〉 성격 5요인 척도: (4) 다른 사람과 있을 때 대화를 먼저 시작하는 편이다. ·······················309

〈부표 3-39〉 성격 5요인 척도: (5) 다른 사람의 시선이 나에게 집중되는 것을 꺼리지 않는다. ·············310

〈부표 3-40〉 성격 5요인 척도: (6) 말을 많이 하는 편이다. ····································································311

〈부표 3-41〉 성격 5요인 척도: (7) 걱정을 많이 하는 편이다. ·································································312

〈부표 3-42〉 성격 5요인 척도: (8) 화를 잘 내는 편이다. ·······································································313

〈부표 3-43〉 성격 5요인 척도: (9) 쉽게 짜증을 낸다. ·············································································314

〈부표 3-44〉 성격 5요인 척도: (10) 자주 우울해진다. ············································································315

〈부표 3-45〉 성격 5요인 척도: (11) 마음이 자주 심란해진다. ································································316

〈부표 3-46〉 성격 5요인 척도: (12) 기분의 변화가 심한 편이다. ···························································317

〈부표 3-47〉 성격 5요인 척도: (13) 다른 사람에게 관심이 많다. ···························································318

〈부표 3-48〉 성격 5요인 척도: (14) 따뜻하고 부드러운 마음을 갖고 있다. ············································319

〈부표 3-49〉 성격 5요인 척도: (15) 사람들을 편안하게 해 준다. ···························································320

〈부표 3-50〉 성격 5요인 척도: (16) 다른 사람의 기분을 잘 이해하는 편이다. ······································321

〈부표 3-51〉 성격 5요인 척도: (17) 다른 사람을 위해 시간을 잘 할애하는 편이다. ·····························322

〈부표 3-52〉 성격 5요인 척도: (18) 다른 사람의 감정을 내 것처럼 여긴다. ··········································323

〈부표 3-53〉 성격 5요인 척도: (19) 어질러지면 즉각 청소를 한다. ························································324

〈부표 3-54〉 성격 5요인 척도: (20) 계획한 것을 그대로 실행한다. ························································325

〈부표 3-55〉 성격 5요인 척도: (21) 일에 대해서는 가혹하리만큼 열심히 한다. ·····································326

〈부표 3-56〉 성격 5요인 척도: (22) 세밀한 부분에도 주의를 기울인다. ·················································327

〈부표 3-57〉 성격 5요인 척도: (23) 항상 무엇이든지 할 준비가 되어 있다. ··········································328

〈부표 3-58〉 성격 5요인 척도: (24) 질서정연한 것을 좋아한다. ·····························································329

〈부표 3-59〉 성격 5요인 척도: (25) 상식이나 어휘를 많이 아는 편이다. ···············································330

〈부표 3-60〉 성격 5요인 척도: (26) 상상력이 풍부하다. ·········································································331

〈부표 3-61〉 성격 5요인 척도: (27) 훌륭한 아이디어를 낼 때가 많다. ··················································332

〈부표 3-62〉 성격 5요인 척도: (28) 깊은 생각에 잠길 때가 많다. ·························································333

〈부표 3-63〉 성격 5요인 척도: (29) 어려운 단어를 많이 사용한다. ························································334

〈부표 3-64〉 성격 5요인 척도: (30) 이해가 빠른 편이다. ·······································································335

〈부표 3-65〉 지각된 스트레스: (1) 예상치 못한 일이 생겨서 기분 나빠진 적이 있다. ···························336

〈부표 3-66〉 지각된 스트레스: (2) 중요한 일들을 통제할 수 없다고 느낀 적이 있다. ···························337

〈부표 3-67〉 지각된 스트레스: (3) 초조하거나 스트레스가 쌓인다고 느낀 적이 있다. ····························338

〈부표 3-68〉 지각된 스트레스: (4) 짜증 나고 성가신 일들을 성공적으로 처리한 적이 있다. ·················339

〈부표 3-69〉 지각된 스트레스: (5) 생활 속에서 일어난 중요한 변화들을 효과적으로 대처한 적이 있다. ····340

〈부표 3-70〉 지각된 스트레스: (6) 개인적인 문제를 처리하는 능력에 대해 자신감을 느낀 적이 있다. ···341

〈부표 3-71〉 지각된 스트레스: (7) 자신의 뜻대로 일이 진행된다고 느낀 적이 있다. ·····························342

〈부표 3-72〉 지각된 스트레스: (8) 매사를 잘 컨트롤하고 있다고 느낀 적이 있다. ································343

〈부표 3-73〉 지각된 스트레스: (9) 당신이 통제할 수 없는 범위에서 발생한 일 때문에

화가 난 적이 있다. ···············································································································344

〈부표 3-74〉 지각된 스트레스: (10) 어려운 일이 너무 많이 쌓여서 극복할 수 없다고 느낀 적이 있다. ···345

〈부표 3-75〉 물질주의: (1) 나는 비싼 집과 차, 옷을 가진 사람들을 존경한다. ······································346

〈부표 3-76〉 물질주의: (2) 삶에서 성취해야 할 가장 중요한 것들은 물질을 소유하는 것이다. ··············347

〈부표 3-77〉 물질주의: (3) 나는 사람들이 성공의 증표라고 하는 것들에 대해

그다지 중요하게 생각하지 않는다 ························································································348

〈부표 3-78〉 물질주의: (4) 내가 가진 것들이 내 삶을 표현하는 것이다. ················································349

〈부표 3-79〉 물질주의: (5) 사람들에게 과시할 만한 것들을 가지는 것을 좋아한다. ·······························350

〈부표 3-80〉 물질주의: (6) 다른 사람들이 가지고 있는 것들에 대해 그다지 신경 쓰지 않는다. ············351

Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs

〈부표 3-81〉 물질주의: (7) 나는 내가 필요한 것들만 구매한다. ······························································352

〈부표 3-82〉 물질주의: (8) 나는 물건들을 포함해서 내 삶을 단순하게 유지하려고 노력한다. ················353

〈부표 3-83〉 물질주의: (9) 내가 가진 것들이 내게 중요한 전부는 아니다. ············································354

〈부표 3-84〉 물질주의: (10) 실용적이지 않은 것들에 소비하는 것을 좋아한다. ·····································355

〈부표 3-85〉 물질주의: (11) 무언가를 구매하는 것이 즐겁다. ·································································356

〈부표 3-86〉 물질주의: (12) 고가의 사치품을 좋아한다. ··········································································357

〈부표 3-87〉 물질주의: (13) 내가 아는 대부분의 사람들에 비해 나는 물질적인 것을

중요하게 생각하지 않는다. ···································································································358

〈부표 3-88〉 물질주의: (14) 나는 내 삶을 즐기기 위해 필요한 모든 것을 가지고 있다. ·······················359

〈부표 3-89〉 물질주의: (15) 내가 가지지 못한 어떤 것들을 가지면 내 삶이 더 나아질 것이다. ···········360

〈부표 3-90〉 물질주의: (16) 더 좋은 것들을 가지지 않는다면 행복해질 수 없을 것이다. ······················361

〈부표 3-91〉 물질주의: (17) 더 많은 것들을 살 수 있다면 나는 더 행복해질 수 있을 것이다. ············362

〈부표 3-92〉 물질주의: (18) 나는 내가 갖고 싶은 것들을 살 여력이 없을 때 힘들다. ··························363

〈부표 3-93〉 비교성향: (1) 내가 살면서 이룬 것들을 다른 사람들의 것과 비교한다. ·····························364

〈부표 3-94〉 비교성향: (2) 종종 나와 가까운 사람들을 다른 사람들과 비교한다. ··································365

〈부표 3-95〉 비교성향: (3) 나는 다른 사람들과 나를 잘 비교하지 않는 편이다. ····································366

〈부표 3-96〉 비교성향: (4) 나와 비슷한 문제에 처한 사람들의 생각을 알고자 한다. ·····························367

〈부표 3-97〉 비교성향: (5) 내 상황과 비슷한 사람들이 어떻게 행동하는지 알고자 한다. ······················368

〈부표 3-98〉 비교성향: (6) 내가 궁금한 무언가에 대한 타인의 생각을 알고자 한다. ·····························369

〈부표 3-99〉 사회 신뢰 ······························································································································370

〈부표 3-100〉 대인 신뢰 ····························································································································371

〈부표 3-101〉 단체 신뢰: (1) 언론 ···········································································································372

〈부표 3-102〉 단체 신뢰: (2) 인터넷 ········································································································373

〈부표 3-103〉 단체 신뢰: (3) 노동조합 ····································································································374

〈부표 3-104〉 단체 신뢰: (4) 경찰·검찰 ···································································································375

〈부표 3-105〉 단체 신뢰: (5) 사법부(법원) ·······························································································376

〈부표 3-106〉 단체 신뢰: (6) 행정부(중앙부처, 지방자치단체) ·································································377

〈부표 3-107〉 단체 신뢰: (7) 입법부(정당, 국회) ·····················································································378

〈부표 3-108〉 단체 신뢰: (8) 대기업 ········································································································379

〈부표 3-109〉 단체 신뢰: (9) 시민운동단체(환경 단체, 여성 단체 등) ····················································380

〈부표 3-110〉 단체 신뢰: (10) 자선단체 ··································································································381

〈부표 3-111〉 단체 신뢰: (11) 국세청 ······································································································382

〈부표 3-112〉 정치 영역 부패 인식 수준 ··································································································383

〈부표 3-113〉 경제 영역 부패 인식 수준 ··································································································384

〈부표 3-114〉 나에 대한 공정: (1) 능력(두뇌) ·························································································385

〈부표 3-115〉 나에 대한 공정: (2) 일과 관련 기술 ·················································································386

〈부표 3-116〉 나에 대한 공정: (3) 노력 ···································································································387

〈부표 3-117〉 나에 대한 공정: (4) 학력 ···································································································388

〈부표 3-118〉 나에 대한 공정: (5) 경력 ···································································································389

〈부표 3-119〉 타인에 대한 공정: (1) 능력(두뇌) ······················································································390

〈부표 3-120〉 타인에 대한 공정: (2) 일과 관련 기술 ··············································································391

〈부표 3-121〉 타인에 대한 공정: (3) 노력 ·······························································································392

〈부표 3-122〉 타인에 대한 공정: (4) 학력 ·······························································································393

〈부표 3-123〉 타인에 대한 공정: (5) 경력 ·······························································································394

〈부표 3-124〉 사회인식: (1) 높은 지위에 오르려면 부패할 수밖에 없다 ·················································395

〈부표 3-125〉 사회인식: (2) 우리나라 소득 격차는 너무 크다 ································································396

〈부표 3-126〉 사회인식: (3) 돈을 많이 벌면서 세금을 적게 내는 사람이 많다 ······································397

〈부표 3-127〉 사회인식: (4) 경쟁이 사회를 발전시킨다 ···········································································398

〈부표 3-128〉 사회인식: (5) 월급만으로 부자가 될 수 없다 ····································································399

〈부표 3-129〉 사회인식: (6) 한국 사회는 갈등이 심하다 ·········································································400

〈부표 3-130〉 정부의 역할: (1) 소득 격차 줄이는 일은 정부가 해야 할 일이다 ····································401

〈부표 3-131〉 정부의 역할: (2) 정부는 실업자에게 적정 수준의 삶을 제공해야 한다 ····························402

〈부표 3-132〉 정부의 역할: (3) 정부는 빈곤한 사람들에게 주는 혜택을 줄여야 한다 ····························403

〈부표 3-133〉 건강 불안: (1) 전염병 ········································································································404

〈부표 3-134〉 건강 불안: (2) 먹거리 문제 ·······························································································405

〈부표 3-135〉 건강 불안: (3) 정신건강 문제 ····························································································406

〈부표 3-136〉 건강 불안: (4) 성인병 ········································································································407

〈부표 3-137〉 건강 불안: (5) 대기오염 ····································································································408

〈부표 3-138〉 생애주기 불안: (1) 노후 ····································································································409

〈부표 3-139〉 생애주기 불안: (2) 가족 해체 및 약화 ··············································································410

〈부표 3-140〉 생애주기 불안: (3) 저출산 ·································································································411

〈부표 3-141〉 생애주기 불안: (4) 고령화 ·································································································412

〈부표 3-142〉 사회생활 불안: (1) 범죄 ····································································································413

〈부표 3-143〉 사회생활 불안: (2) 산업재해 ······························································································414

Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs

〈부표 3-144〉 경제생활 불안: (1) 실업 및 빈곤 ······················································································415

〈부표 3-145〉 경제생활 불안: (2) 주택 및 전세 가격 ··············································································416

〈부표 3-146〉 경제생활 불안: (3) 금융 불안 ····························································································417

〈부표 3-147〉 경제생활 불안: (4) 경기침체 및 저성장 ············································································418

〈부표 3-148〉 희망 시간 사용: (1) 하루에 2~3시간 ················································································419

〈부표 3-149〉 희망 시간 사용: (2) 일주일에 하루 ···················································································420

〈부표 3-150〉 희망 시간 사용: (3) 한 달에 일주일 ·················································································421

〈부표 3-151〉 희망 시간 사용: (4) 일 년에 한 달 ···················································································422

〈부표 3-152〉 또래 대비 사회활동 참여 정도 ···························································································423

〈부표 3-153〉 단체 참여: (1) 정당 ···········································································································424

〈부표 3-154〉 단체 참여: (2) 시민운동단체 ······························································································425

〈부표 3-155〉 단체 참여: (3) 사업자단체 또는 직업조합 ·········································································426

〈부표 3-156〉 단체 참여: (4) 종교단체 ····································································································427

〈부표 3-157〉 단체 참여: (5) 문화단체 ····································································································428

〈부표 3-158〉 단체 참여: (6) 동창모임 ····································································································429

〈부표 3-159〉 단체 참여: (7) 향우회 ········································································································430

〈부표 3-160〉 단체 참여: (8) 친목단체 ····································································································431

〈부표 3-161〉 단체 참여: (9) 인터넷 커뮤니티 ························································································432

〈부표 3-162〉 단체 참여: (10) 기타 모임 및 단체 ··················································································433

〈부표 3-163〉 사회적 지지: (1) 감기에 심하게 걸려 집안일을 부탁할 경우 ···········································434

〈부표 3-164〉 사회적 지지: (2) 큰돈을 빌릴 일이 생길 경우 ··································································435

〈부표 3-165〉 사회적 지지: (3) 우울, 스트레스로 이야기하고 싶은 경우 ················································436

〈부표 3-166〉 사회적 자본: (1) 우리 지역주민은 서로 돕고 산다 ···························································437

〈부표 3-167〉 사회적 자본: (2) 우리 지역사회 이웃을 신뢰한다 ·····························································438

〈부표 3-168〉 사회적 자본: (3) 우리 지방자치단체를 신뢰한다 ·······························································439

〈부표 3-169〉 사회적 자본: (4) 지역사회 문제 공동 대처를 위한 이해당사자들의 의견을 표현한다 ······440

〈부표 3-170〉 사회적 자본: (5) 지역 발전을 위해 각종 지역사회단체는 상호 협력한다 ·························441

〈부표 3-171〉 사회적 자본: (6) 지방자치당체가 지역주민이 필요로 하는 정보를 제공한다 ····················442

〈부표 3-172〉 사회적 자본: (7) 지역 갈등 및 문제를 지역주민이 자체적으로 해결한다 ·························443

〈부표 3-173〉 사회적 자본: (8) 지방자치단체가 지역 문제 해결에 지역주민의 의견을 반영한다 ···········444

〈부표 3-174〉 사회적 자본: (9) 지방자치단체가 지역주민에게 더 나은 서비스 제공에 관심을 가진다 ···445

〈부표 3-175〉 사회적 자본: (10) 우리 지방자치단체는 지역주민의 요구에 잘 대응하고 있다 ················446

〈부표 3-176〉 소속감: (1) 자립적인 개인 ·································································································447

〈부표 3-177〉 소속감: (2) 소속 읍·면·동 ·································································································448

〈부표 3-178〉 소속감: (3) 소속 시·군·구 ·································································································449

〈부표 3-179〉 소속감: (4) 소속 시·도 ······································································································450

〈부표 3-180〉 소속감: (5) 대한민국 ··········································································································451

〈부표 3-181〉 소속감: (6) 전 지구 ···········································································································452

〈부표 3-182〉 자원봉사 횟수 ·····················································································································453

〈부표 3-183〉 사회단체 및 기관에 기부 횟수 ···························································································454

〈부표 3-184〉 정치 참여: (1) 정치·사회 문제에 대해 주변 사람들과 이야기 ··········································455

〈부표 3-185〉 정치 참여: (2) SNS 등에 의견 올리기 ·············································································456

〈부표 3-186〉 정치 참여: (3) 정부와 언론에 의견 제시 ··········································································457

〈부표 3-187〉 정치 참여: (4) 불매 운동 참여 ··························································································458

〈부표 3-188〉 투표 경험: (1) 2016년 총선거 ··························································································459

〈부표 3-189〉 투표 경험: (2) 2017년 제19대 대통령선거 ······································································460

〈부표 3-190〉 투표 경험: (3) 2018년 지방선거 ······················································································461

〈부표 3-191〉 주관적 소득계층 ··················································································································462

〈부표 3-192〉 사회 이동: 15세 무렵에 비해 계층 변화 ···········································································463

〈부표 3-193〉 지난 10년간 생활수준 변화 ·······························································································464

〈부표 3-194〉 향후 10년 이내 생활수준 변화 기대 ·················································································465

〈부표 3-195〉 우리 사회에서 노력에 따른 개인의 사회경제적 지위가 높아질 수 있는 가능성 ···············466

〈부표 3-196〉 본인 세대에 비해 자식 세대의 사회경제적 지위 변화 예상 ··············································467

〈부표 3-197〉 이념적 성향 ························································································································468

〈부표 6-1〉 남성 집단 범주화 분석 결과 ···································································································479

〈부표 6-2〉 여성 집단 범주화 분석 결과 ···································································································492

Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs

그림 목차

〔그림 1-1〕 객관적 삶의 조건과 주관적 삶의 질 분포(2017년) ·································································17

〔그림 1-2〕 한국과 스웨덴의 삶의 만족 점수 분포 ·····················································································18

〔그림 2-1〕 주관적 안녕(subjective well-being)의 모델 ··········································································31

〔그림 2-2〕 복지 개념과 각각의 목표 차원 ·································································································34

〔그림 2-3〕 행복 영향요인의 위계적 구조도 ································································································38

〔그림 2-4〕 경제학 분야 행복과 삶의 질 학술논문 초록의 워드 크라우드 ·················································41

〔그림 2-5〕 사회복지학 분야 행복과 삶의 질 학술논문 초록의 워드 크라우드 ··········································42

〔그림 2-6〕 심리학 분야 행복과 삶의 질 학술논문 초록의 워드 크라우드 ·················································42

〔그림 2-7〕 통계청 사회조사의 연령대별 주관적 만족감 ·············································································46

〔그림 2-8〕 성격(부정적-긍정적)별 행복도, 삶의 만족도, 우울도 ·······························································51

〔그림 3-1〕 한국인의 행복 측정 결과 ··········································································································59

〔그림 3-2〕 연령대별 삶의 만족: 사회통합실태조사와의 비교 ·····································································60

〔그림 3-3〕 연령대별 행복지표 히스토그램 ··································································································61

〔그림 3-4〕 경제활동상태별 응답 요일별 삶의 만족 ····················································································64

〔그림 3-5〕 인구사회학적 특성별 생활영역 만족 ·························································································65

〔그림 3-6〕 거주 지역 특성별 생활영역 만족 ······························································································65

〔그림 3-7〕 성격 5요인 척도를 활용한 성격 유형 구분 ··············································································66

〔그림 3-8〕 성격 유형과 행복 ······················································································································67

〔그림 3-9〕 삶의 만족 점수별 물질주의와 비교성향 ····················································································69

〔그림 3-10〕 타인의 행복 ·····························································································································72

〔그림 3-11〕 성별 행복 동시출현단어 네트워크 ··························································································75

〔그림 3-12〕 연령대별 행복 동시출현단어 네트워크 ····················································································76

〔그림 4-1〕 행복 영향요인의 구조 ···············································································································85

〔그림 4-2〕 외향성과 신경증 점수 분포 ·······································································································87

〔그림 4-3〕 행복의 구조방정식 기본 모형 ···································································································93

〔그림 5-1〕 한국인의 행복에 대한 질적 연구 방법 ···················································································110

〔그림 5-2〕 사례 1. 1945년생 75세 남성의 행복 ····················································································114

〔그림 5-3〕 사례 2. 1945년생 75세 여성의 행복 ····················································································118

〔그림 5-4〕 사례 3. 1958년생 62세 남성의 행복 ····················································································120

〔그림 5-5〕 사례 4. 1958년생 62세 여성의 행복 ····················································································125

〔그림 5-6〕 사례 5. 1971년생 49세 남성의 행복 ····················································································127

〔그림 5-7〕 사례 6. 1971년생 49세 여성의 행복 ····················································································131

〔그림 5-8〕 사례 7. 1984년생 36세 남성의 행복 ····················································································133

〔그림 5-9〕 사례 8. 1984년생 36세 여성의 행복 ····················································································138

〔그림 5-10〕 사례 9. 1997년생 23세 남성의 행복 ·················································································140

〔그림 5-11〕 사례 10. 1997년생 23세 여성의 행복 ···············································································144

〔그림 5-12〕 한국인이 경험하는 행복의 맥락과 패턴 ···············································································146

〔그림 7-1〕 한국의 웰빙 수준: 강점과 약점 ······························································································222

Korea Institute for Health and Social Affairs

A Comprehensive Study of Happiness and Quality of Life in Korea

1)Project Head: Jung, Haesik

The purpose of this study is to comprehensively diagnose Korean’s hap-

piness and quality of life. In 2019, the first year of the study, which was

planned as a three-year study, we tried to grasp the detailed perception of

Korean happiness.

In the past, many governments felt that people’s well-being should be at

the center of policy. Several initiatives aimed at improving quality of life

generally point out that Korea has successfully achieved improvements in

material conditions, but not at the subjective well-being. In order to over-

come the gap between the objective quality of life and the subjective

well-being, it is necessary to accumulate empirical evidence on how

Koreans are happy and why not happy.

This study attempted to derive the elements of happiness to through the-

oretical studies on happiness and quality of life and reviews of previous

studies(in chapter 2). Based on theoretical review, a questionnaire was de-

veloped to measure the happiness of Korean. 「Korean’s Happiness and

Quality of Life Survey」 was conducted from May 8 to June 13, 2019 by a

face-to-face interview. In addition to reviewing theories, chapter 2 pres-

ents research trends on happiness and quality of life in Korea, which out-

lines different academic approaches to the comprehensive concept of

Co-Researchers: Kwon, Jisung ․ Jeong, Sunwook ․ Kim, SeongaCo-Research Team: Chun,Youngsub ․ Kwon, Seok-man ․ Hong ․ Kim, Seok-ho ․ Shin, Haeran ․ Lee,

Bong-Joo ․ Chae, Suhong ․ Sok-Chul ․ Gu, Seojeong ․ Jin, Yerin ․ Yu, Jisu

Abstract 〈〈

2 한국인의 행복과 삶의 질에 관한 종합 연구: 국제 비교 질적 연구를 중심으로

happiness and quality of life.

In chapters 3 and chapter 4 present the results of a quantitative analysis

of Korean happiness and quality of life using the original data on the

Korean’s Happiness and Quality of Life Survey.

In order to measure happiness as a complex concept, we identified the

topography of Koreans happiness using various questions such as cantril

ladder, life satisfaction, positive and negative affection, and the value of

Eudaimonia(in chapter 3). The results show that happiness and quality of

life differ according to the individual’s economic and social characteristics.

And the quality of life covering various living conditions was not in-

dependent of subjective well-being. The analysis of the happiness and

quality of life of Koreans identified in chapter 3 will be the basis for dis-

covering the specificity and meaning of Korean happiness.

Multidimensional living conditions such as the economic resource of

households and the conditions of residential environment, have a sig-

nificant relationship on happiness. A fluent standard of living conditions

contributes to increased happiness. On the other hand, however, an in-

dividual’s psychological capacity can intervene in the relationship between

living conditions and happiness. Chapter 4 analyzes how the psychological

capacities of extroversion and neurosis affect the path of living conditions

and happiness perception by age group. The results suggest the need for

academic and policy attention to psychological competencies in pursuing

an individual’s happy life.

In addition to the findings from the quantitative analysis, it is necessary

to understand Koreans’ perception of happiness from various angles. In

order to confirm Koreans’ perception of happiness, focus group interviews

Abstract 3

and in-depth interviews were conducted to pay more attention to the

characteristics of each individual, and the results were derived through

context-pattern analysis(in chapter 5). The analysis shows that Korean

happiness is a complex construct that cannot be measured or understood

in a single dimension. This means that Koreans understand happiness in

different dimensions according to age and gender. Also, in the context of

happiness, there are views that act as prisms in the process of connecting

the conditions and elements of happiness. A representative point of view

was to compare others with others, and culture, values, and ideologies

appeared.

How different is the viewpoint that affects the relationship between the

material condition of life and the state of happiness for Koreans? In order

to confirm this difference, 19 citizen interviews were conducted in

well-known welfare states, Denmark and Finland. First of all, we tried to

understand the macroscopic characteristics as a condition of happiness.

We have confirmed that they have a culture in their daily lives that they are

satisfied with or at least satisfy with their material conditions. Next, we

looked at the background of personal characteristics. They placed autono-

my and freedom of choice at the source of subjective happiness.

Independence and autonomy in their lives have considerable implications

for the low happiness of Koreans who tend to be comparable.

This study is the first year of the third year study plan. The purpose of

this study was to grasp the concrete situation in order to enable improve-

ment of subjective well-being of Koreans. Therefore, although the specif-

icity of policy alternatives is low, some of the facts identified in this proc-

ess can be found. First of all, since the element of promoting happiness is

multidimensional, efforts to focus o