-
8/13/2019 Draft Decision Edited
1/9
REPUBLIC OF THE PHILIPPINESOFFICE OF THE PRESIDENT
HOUSING AND LAND USE REGULATORY BOARD
EXPANDED NATIONAL CAPITAL REGION FIELD OFFICEHLURB BUILDING,
KALAYAAN AVENUE CORNER MAYAMAN STREET
DILIMAN, QUEZON CITY
JOCELYN A. SOLANO, ET. AL.,Comp!"#!#$%,
& V'(%)% * CASE NO. NCRHOA&++-/&01/
MARK MILAN JAGUNAP, ET. AL.,R'%po#2'#$%.
3&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&&3
DRAFT DECISION
Fo( ('%o)$"o# o4 $5"% Bo!(2 "% ! 2"%p)$' 6'$7''# 5om'o7#'(%
o4Go2'# G!$' S)62"8"%"o# Hom'o7#'(% A%%o9"!$"o#, I#9. :GGSHAI;.
T5"%9omp!"#$ "% "#"$"!$'2 6< $5' 9omp!"#!#$% !% 2'("8!$"8' %)"$
!=!"#%$ $5'"#9)m6'#$ o44"9'(% o4 GGSHAI 4o( !'='2< 8"o!$"#= $5'
p(o8"%"o#% o4R'p)6"9 A9$ No. +>, o$5'(7"%' ?#o7# !% $5' M!=#!
C!($! 4o( Hom'o7#'(%!#2 Hom'o7#'(% A%%o9"!$"o#%, !#2 "$%
Imp'm'#$"#= R)'% !#2 R'=)!$"o#%!% 'm6o2"'2 "# HLURB Bo!(2 R'%o)$"o#
No. @00, %'("'% o4 /+.
No$5"#= "% mo(' 2"%!ppo"#$"#= $5!# #'"=56o(% )!(('"#= !=!"#%$
'!95o$5'(. T5' %"mp' 2
-
8/13/2019 Draft Decision Edited
2/9
('9o(2% 9.; P('8'#$"#= $5' 9omp!"#!#$% 4(om p!($"9"p!$"#= "#
!%%o9"!$"o#''9$"o#% !#2 ('4'('#2! 2.; P('8'#$"#= $5' 9omp!"#!#$%
4(om '3'(9"%"#=$5'"( ("=5$% !#2 po7'(% "# 8"o!$"o# o4 $5' (')"('2
9o#%)$!$"o# !#2 !pp(o8!o4 $5' (')"('2 #)m6'( o4 5om'o7#'(% o(
m'm6'(% 6
-
8/13/2019 Draft Decision Edited
3/9
b.! "he complainant alleges with particularity thatreasonable
efforts were eerted to ehaust all remediesavailable under the
associations articles of incorporation# bylaws# laws or rules for
the purpose of obtaining the relief prayedfor$ and
O# $5"%, 7' ('%o8' $5' "%%)' "# 4!8o( o4 $5' 9omp!"#!#$%. I$ "%
9'!($5!$ $5' 9omp!"#$ "% !=!"#%$ $5' "#9)m6'#$ o44"9'(% o4 GGSHAI
4o( $5'"(9o#$"#)'2 2'#"! !#2 ('4)%! $o ('9o=#"' $5' ("=5$% o4
9omp!"#!#$% !%5om'o7#'(%. S"#9' $5'< !(' $5' "#9)m6'#$ o44"9'(%,
m'm6'(% o4 $5' 6o!(2o4 GGSHAI !#2 'mpo :p;, Imp'm'#$"#= R)'% !#2
R'=)!$"o#% o4 R.A. +>.
-
8/13/2019 Draft Decision Edited
4/9
''9$"o# o4 2"('9$o(% !#2 ('mo8! o4 2"('9$o(%. A 2'"#)'#$ m'm6'(
o( !m'm6'( #o$ "# =oo2 %$!#2"#= ('4'(% $o ! m'm6'( o4 $5'
!%%o9"!$"o# 75o5!% 6''# 2'9!('2 !% %)95 4o( $5' =(o)#2% !#2 "#
!99o(2!#9' 7"$5 $5'p(o9'2)('% )#2'( $5' 6< !7% o4 $5'
!%%o9"!$"o#. H'#9', 9omp!"#!#$% 5!8''=! %$!#2"#= o# $5"% #o$'.
' #o7 =o $o $5' m'!$ 9o(' o4 $5' 2"%p)$', $5' 9!)%'% o4
!9$"o#%(!"%'2 6< 9omp!"#!#$%
O# $5' 4"(%$ 9!)%' o4 !9$"o# ('=!(2"#= $5' 2'p("8!$"o# o4 $5'
("=5$% o49omp!"#!#$% $o "#%p'9$ !%%o9"!$"o# 6oo?% !#2 ('9o(2%,
9omp!"#!#$%9o#$'#2 $5!$ $5'< 7'(' ('4)%'2 "#%p'9$"o# o4 $5'
!%%o9"!$"o# 6oo?% !#2('9o(2% 6< $5' "#9)m6'#$ o44"9'(% o4
GGSHAI. I# %)ppo($ o4 $5'"( 9!"m, $5' 9"$'2 6< $5' 9omp!"#!#$%
!#2 $5' Imp'm'#$"#= R)'% !#2 R'=)!$"o#%
5!% #o '=! !pp"9!$"o# o# $5' 9o#%$()9$"o# o4 $5' A##'3 %95oo
6)"2"#= o4S$. M!(?% I#%$"$)$' !#2 $5' op'#"#= o4 $5' p'("m'$'(
4'#9'. T5'< !'=' $5!$!7 "% #o$ !pp"9!6' 6'9!)%' "$ 2"2 #o$
p(o8"2' 4o( ('$(o!9$"8"$
-
8/13/2019 Draft Decision Edited
6/9
Sec. /. 2ights and 3owers of the Association. AnAssociation
shall have the following rights and powers:
4 d. 2egulate access to or passage through the
subdivision,village roads for purposes of preserving
privacy#
tran(uility# internal security# safety and traffic order:
3rovided#that 516 576 eisting laws and regulations are met$ 5&6
theauthority of the concerned government agencies or units
areobtained$ and 56 the appropriate and necessary memoranda among
the concerned parties$
Comp!"#!#$% $o %)ppo($ $5'"( 9!"m $5!$ ('%po#2'#$% !(' "'=! U.
S. /, >>, /> S. C$. -1, -@, >@ L!7. '2.@-+ I#$'(%$!$'
Comm'(9' Comm"%%"o# 8. Lo)"%8"' N!%58"' R. Co., //0 U. S. @@, 1,
11S. C$. @, @0, 0 L!7. '2. >1 U#"$'2 S$!$'% 8. A6"'#' So)$5'(#
R,/@@, >> S. C$. -, -, -@ L!7. '2. +- T!== B(o%. Moo(5'!2 8.
U#"$'2 S$!$'%, /@+ U. S.>/+, >>/, + S. C$. //+, //, 0>
L!7. '2. -/>.
