14
ÄË¿ |ÀÆ» |¸m ,dË Ìv» Á ½Y¼ Ê , ÃZ¼ , ½Zf]Ze ± ÊÅÁa dY{{ZË ÊaZÌa µÂX» Ã|ÀË¿ { d§ZË Ë~a ¶a ʯZy Âa ¶«Y|u É´·Y sÔY ʯZy ÉZÅ Y Ã{Z¨fY Z] ¾ÅM ÃY É{Ó§ {Á|v» LYmY É| ] Ä ¶Ì¸ve ʸÌZ¼Y Êe» , ɯY} ʸZ^m Á ©Y·Y|^ ÊmZu ZËa ZË{ZfY ½YËY d À Á º¸ ÃZ´¿Y{ ,¾ÅM ÃY Ê|ÀÆ» Ã|°¿Y{ ZÌ¿Y{ ´¿Y{ ,¾ÅM ÃY Ê|ÀÆ» Ã|°¿Y{ ½YËY d À Á º¸ ÃZ ½YÆe ÃZ´¿Y{ ,½Y¼ Ê|ÀÆ» Ã|°¿Y{ Éf¯{ ÉÂn¿Y{ Ã|Ì°q µZ { ÃZ ÌyY ÉZŠʯZy ÉZÅ ¶a ½YÂÀ Ä] ¦¸fz» ÉZů { Ê ÌÁ  Ä] É{Ó§ Äf§³ Y« Ã{Z¨fY {» ¾ÅM ÃY Á ÃY ÉZÅ |¿Y ¶a ÉZ/ŠʯZy d ,YmY ºfÌ Ê³{Z dÆm Ä] É{Ó§ ÄÀ˳ µZ°Y Á {Z ]Y ÂÀe Á YmY Ê/» ¾ÅM ÃY Á ÃY t¼Å cZ Z¬e ¥~u ÉY] \ZÀ» ÉY |À/Z] ¾ÌËM ]YÁ Ä»Z¿ ¶a ʯZy Âa ¶«Y|u ¾ÌÌ e ÉY] {Âm» ÉY ʯZy ÉZÅ Ê´fzÌ/³ Y [ZÀfmY ½M Ĩ¸§ Á Ã| ¾ËÁ|e ÃY ÉY~³Z] ZY ] É{Ó§ ó ¤· Á ʯ Ê» ÃZ ÉÁ -Zy ÉY ] |Z { Ê·Zu ¶a ÉY] į Ŀ³ Ä] ÊfËZ] ʯZy Âa ¶«Y|u ]YÁ ,¾ÅM ÃY ÉZÅ Ä/¿ Ä/¯ {Â/ ¾ËÁ|/e ÉY d¿ iY { Z« Ì Á ÊÀ¼ËY Ä°¸] ,{ É̳¸m -Zy Ê´fz̳ Y ZÆÀe |f¨Ì¿ ÃZz» Ä] -Zy Ê·Z¼fuY ÉZÅ Z/n» d/¿ Z/Ì » Ä/] Ä/mÂe Z] Y~· Y|u É´·Y ,ÃZ ¿Z¼¯ µfÀ¯ Á y ¶a ÉY] ʯZy Âa ¶« ʯZy ÉZÅ Á{ {Á|/v» LY/mY Á Y Ã{Z¨f/Y Z] ¾ÌÌa cZ¬Ì¬ve { ¾ÅM ÃY É{Ó§ Ä¿Z³Y|m ]YÁ Á Ã| kYzfY É| ] ¶a ÉY] ÉY ʯZy ÉZÅ Ä^ m ¶° Ä] É{Ó§ dY Ã| ÄWYY Ã|Ì]YÂy Ê« Á ÉY ½Z/°»Y É| ] Á{ ¶Ì¸ve { ¾°Ì· { ¿ Z] ËÂe iY É̳ ÃZ µÂ { ¾ÅM ÃY ¹Â | ] {Y|¿ {ÂmÁ Y ÉÁ /] {Á|v» LYmY É| ] Ä ¶Ì¸ve Y Ã{Z¨fY Z] ªÌ¬ve ¾ËY { ,Á ¾ËY Ì̤e ,¾ÅM y Zn» kZmÂY ,y Zn» d¿ ÉZÅZÌ » Ä] ÄmÂe Z] É| ] Á{ ¶Ì¸ve Y ¶Zu ]YÁ ,ÃZ {| ¿Z/¼¯ µ/fÀ¯ Á ÃZ/ Ê·Â/ ¶°/ ÃYÂË{ Z ÉZÅ dY Ã| sÔY à e Z] ÃZ ŠʯZy Âa ¶«Y|u Y|f]Y ,ZfY ¾ËY { P Ã|/ z/» ,¾/ÅM ÃY ]Y { Ã| ¦Ë e Zn» {Á|u ¾Ì» dY ÃZ Ê»Z¼e Y ¶Zu lËZf¿ b Z/y cZ/ ]» ¶«Y|/u Á ®/¼¯ Ä/] ÊuÔ/Y \ËY/ ½M ÉZÀ^» ] Á Äf§³ ÄËZ¬» {» É| ] Á{ lËZf¿ Z] ZÅ Ë{³ kYzfY dY Ã| ½Z³YÁ É|̸¯ ʯZy ¶a ,ʯZy Âa ¶«Y|u ʯZy Âa ¶«Y|u ¾ÌÌ e ]YÁ sÔY ,É| ] Ä {Á|v» LYmY ¶Ì¸ve ,¾ÅM ÃY É{Ó§ Ä»|¬» ÃZ ÃZ É{Ó§ ʯZy ÉZÅ L/m Á{ Y Ä/¯ |Àf/Å ÊËZ/Å kÂ/» É{ÓÂ/§ cZv¨/ ʸY Ã|/Ë{³ ¶Ì°/e -Z/y Á Y{ |/¿Y k» É{Ó§ cZv¨ Á Ã| ¶f» ´Ë|°Ë Ä] Ĭ¸u c Ä] Y{ Ê/» ¶/¼ ÃZ/ d¸°/Y ½YÂ/À Ä] |/ÀËZ¼¿ Á -Z/y À¯|/¿Y Ĭ¸u Ê» ZÅZ] \ZÀ» ËÂe Á ÉY|ËZa hZ] É{Ó§ ÉZÅ {{/³ ÃZ { Y É]Z/] Ã|/¼ /¬¿ ʯZ/y Lm ,É{Ó§ ʯZy ÉZŠĬ¸u Á ÄfY{ Ä/] Ã{YÁ ÉZ/ÅZ] \ZÀ» ËÂe hZ] É{Ó§ ÉZÅ Ê» ÊZ  c ¿ | Ä] ¶ËZ¼e É{Ó§ Ĭ¸u ,ÉY~³Z] dve {Y{ Ê dÆm { ¶° Ì̤e µZ § -Zy Ê^¿Zm ÉZÅÁÌ¿ Y~· Ê» É{Ó§ Ĭ¸u ¶° Ì̤e Y É̳¸m hZ] Á Ã| ¿ | { ÄnÌf¿ , Ê» d»ÁZ¬» ºWZ« ÉZÅZ] ]Y] { ļn» |ËZ¼¿ ÃZ ÉZŠʯZy °/ Â/Àe ¶/Ì·{ Ä] É{Ó§ ÉZ/Å{]Z¯ ÉYY{ {Z/ ]Y Á ¶ ÃÁa { É{ZË |ÀfÅ Ê¿Y¼ ÉZÅ ¾/ËY Ê^/Y ¶ ¿ ¶° \¸£Y ÃZ Ã|/Ì]YÂy Ê/« ¶°/ Á ¾/ÅM ÃY ÉZÅ~³Ë ÉY] Á Ä^ m ÉY ¾/ÅM ÃY Á ÃY t¼ÅÌ£ cZ Z¬e ÉY] ½M ~/³Ë ÃY Ê» Z¯ Ä] |¿Á /Âa ¶«Y|/u Ä/ ·Z» Ä/] ª/̬ve ¾ËY { ¶a ʯZy Y f³] Ä¿ZÅ{ Z] É d/Y Ã| ÄfyY{a f» Y/q ÃZ ¶° Á{ ¾ËY į ÃZ cZÌ]{Y { ÉY ʯZy ÉZÅ Ä/] É{Ó§ Ê|ÀÅ ¶° Zv· Z/¨eY Ä/] Ä/¿ZÅ{ ±/] d^/¿ ÃZ/ Y ÃËÁ d̼ÅY |¿Y{Ây] ÉY ] [ Ä/] Ä¿ZÅ{ ±] d^¿ ¾ÌÀr¼Å ÃZ ¾ËY Z¨eY /y /Âa dËZ¨¯ ¹| µZ¼fuY ,ZÅ d/Æm Y ʯZ ÃÂ/³ /¤· Á Ê/¯ Ê´fzÌ/³ ]Y] { d»ÁZ¬» ËY/§Y ÉY Ê» |Å{ ¶a ʯZy Âa Ä ·Z» ªÌ¬ve ¾ËY { ,Á ¾ËY Y ÉZ/Å Ä^ m Ä/f§³ Y/« Ä/mÂe {» Zy  Ä] Ã|Ì]YÂy Ê« Á ÉY dY ] [ 1 High- profile arch 2- Low- profile arch 3- Box

Dr. Zakeri - pdfMachine from Broadgun Software, …journals.tabrizu.ac.ir/article_491_0f959706df04effc9e... · 2020. 12. 2. · ÄWY Y ʯZy Âa ¶«Y|u ÉY ] Y Ä ]Y ASTM A796 dË

  • Upload
    others

  • View
    5

  • Download
    0

Embed Size (px)

Citation preview

  • ÄË¿|ÀÆ»��|¸m�,dË�Ìv»�Á�½Y¼�Ê��, �ÃZ¼��,��½Zf]Ze�����±ÊÅÁa�dY{{ZË�����������������������������������������������ÊaZÌa��� ��

    ��

    ����µÂX»�Ã|ÀË¿�����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������{�����d§ZË��������Ë~a�������

    ¶a�ʯZy�Âa�¶«Y|u�É´·Y�sÔY�ʯZy�ÉZÅ��Y�Ã{Z¨fY�Z]�¾ÅM�ÃY�É{Ó§�{Á|v»�LYmY�É| ]�Ä�¶Ì¸ve��

    � �ʸÌZ¼Y�Êe»��,�ɯY}�ʸZ^m ��Á�©Y·Y|^�ÊmZu�ZËa����

    � �ZË{ZfY½YËY�d À�Á�º¸�ÃZ´¿Y{�,¾ÅM�ÃY�Ê|ÀÆ»�Ã|°¿Y{��� �ZÌ¿Y{´¿Y{�,¾ÅM�ÃY�Ê|ÀÆ»�Ã|°¿Y{½YËY�d À�Á�º¸�ÃZ��

    � ½YÆe�ÃZ´¿Y{�,½Y¼�Ê|ÀÆ»�Ã|°¿Y{�Éf¯{�ÉÂn¿Y{��

    � �Ã|Ì°q��

    �µZ�{���ÃZ�ÌyY�ÉZÅ��ʯZy�ÉZÅ����������¶a�½YÂÀ�Ä]�¦¸fz»�ÉZů�{�Ê ÌÁ�Â�Ä]�É{Ó§��Äf§³�Y«�Ã{Z¨fY�{»�¾ÅM�ÃY�Á�ÃY�ÉZÅ�|¿Y��¶a���ÉZ/ÅʯZy����������d�,YmY�ºfÌ�ʳ{Z�dÆm�Ä]�É{Ó§�������ÄÀ˳�µZ°Y�Á�{Z ]Y�ÂÀe�Á�YmY�����Ê/»�¾ÅM�ÃY�Á�ÃY�t¼Å�cZ Z¬e�¥~u�ÉY]�\ZÀ»�ÉY��|À/Z]��

    �¾ÌËM�]YÁ�Ä»Z¿��������¶a�ʯZy�Âa�¶«Y|u�¾ÌÌ e�ÉY]�{Âm»�ÉY��ʯZy�ÉZÅ�����������Ê´fzÌ/³�Y�[ZÀfmY�½M�Ĩ¸§�Á�Ã|�¾ËÁ|e�ÃY�ÉY~³Z]�ZY�]�É{Ó§����ó�¤·�Á�ʯ�����Ê»�ÃZ�ÉÁ�Zy�ÉY�]|Z��{�Ê·Zu���¶a�ÉY]�į����������Ŀ³�Ä]�ÊfËZ]�ʯZy�Âa�¶«Y|u�]YÁ�,¾ÅM�ÃY�ÉZÅ��������Ä/¿�Ä/¯�{Â/�¾ËÁ|/e�ÉY

    �����d¿�iY�{�Z«�Ì�Á�ÊÀ¼ËY�Ä°¸]�,{Â�É̳¸m�Zy�Ê´fz̳�Y�ZÆÀe�|f¨Ì¿�ÃZz»�Ä]�Zy�Ê·Z¼fuY�ÉZÅ��������Z/n»�d/¿�Z/Ì »�Ä/]�Ä/mÂe�Z]�Y~·������Y|u�É´·Y�,ÃZ�¿Z¼¯�µfÀ¯�Á�y����¶a�ÉY]�ʯZy�Âa�¶«��ʯZy�ÉZÅ���������������Á{�{Á|/v»�LY/mY�Á�Y�Ã{Z¨f/Y�Z]�¾ÌÌa�cZ¬Ì¬ve�{�¾ÅM�ÃY�É{Ó§������Ä¿Z³Y|m�]YÁ�Á�Ã|�kYzfY�É| ]���¶a�ÉY]�ÉY��ʯZy�ÉZÅ�����Ä^ m�¶°�Ä]�É{Ó§��������dY�Ã|�ÄWYY�Ã|Ì]YÂy�Ê«�Á�ÉY���������½Z/°»Y�É| ]�Á{�¶Ì¸ve�{�¾°Ì·

    {�¿������Z]�ËÂe�iY�É̳������ÃZ�µÂ�{�¾ÅM�ÃY��¹Â�| ]���{Y|¿�{ÂmÁ��Y��ÉÁ�/]�{Á|v»�LYmY�É| ]�Ä�¶Ì¸ve�Y�Ã{Z¨fY�Z]�ªÌ¬ve�¾ËY�{�,Á�¾ËY��������������������Ì̤e�,¾ÅM�y�Zn»�kZmÂY�,y�Zn»�d¿�ÉZÅZÌ »�Ä]�ÄmÂe�Z]�É| ]�Á{�¶Ì¸ve�Y�¶Zu�]YÁ�,ÃZ�{|�������¿Z/¼¯�µ/fÀ¯�Á�ÃZ/�Ê·Â/�¶°/

    ÃYÂË{��Z�ÉZÅ���dY�Ã|�sÔY�Ã����������e�Z]�ÃZ�Å�ʯZy�Âa�¶«Y|u�Y|f]Y�,ZfY�¾ËY�{P����Ã|/�z/»�,¾/ÅM�ÃY�]YÂ�{�Ã|�¦Ë e�Zn»�{Á|u�¾Ì»dY�����ÃZ�Ê»Z¼e�Y�¶Zu�lËZf¿�b���������Z/y�cZ/ ]»�¶«Y|/u�Á�®/¼¯�Ä/]�ÊuÔ/Y�\ËY/�½M�ÉZÀ^»�]�Á�Äf§³�ÄËZ¬»�{»�É| ]�Á{�lËZf¿�Z]�ZÅ

    Ë{³�kYzfYdY�Ã|���½Z³YÁÉ|̸¯���ʯZy�¶a�,ʯZy�Âa�¶«Y|u�ʯZy�Âa�¶«Y|u�¾ÌÌ e�]YÁ�sÔY�,É| ]�Ä�{Á|v»�LYmY�¶Ì¸ve�,¾ÅM�ÃY�É{Ó§��

    �����Ä»|¬»��

    ÃZ����ÃZ�É{Ó§�ʯZy�ÉZÅ�����������L/m�Á{�Y�Ä/¯�|Àf/Å�ÊËZ/Å������kÂ/»�É{ÓÂ/§�cZv¨/�ʸY��������Ã|/Ë{³�¶Ì°/e�Z/y�Á�Y{��|/¿Y��

    ��k»�É{Ó§�cZv¨����������Á�Ã|�¶f»�´Ë|°Ë�Ä]�Ĭ¸u�cÂ�Ä]�Y{����������Ê/»�¶/¼�ÃZ/�d¸°/Y�½YÂ/À�Ä]��|/ÀËZ¼¿�������Á�Z/y�À¯|/¿Y

    Ĭ¸u���������Ê»�ZÅZ]�\ZÀ»�ËÂe�Á�ÉY|ËZa�hZ]�É{Ó§�ÉZÅ��{{/³���ÃZ�{�������������Y�É]Z/]�Ã|/¼�/¬¿�ʯZ/y�Lm�,É{Ó§�ʯZy�ÉZÅ

    ��Ĭ¸u�Á�ÄfY{�����������Ä/]�Ã{YÁ�ÉZ/ÅZ]�\ZÀ»�ËÂe�hZ]�É{Ó§�ÉZÅ��Ê»�ÊZ �cÂ�{³¿|��������Ä]�¶ËZ¼e�É{Ó§�Ĭ¸u�,ÉY~³Z]�dve

    �����{Y{�Ê�dÆm�{�¶°�Ì̤e�������µZ §�Zy�Ê^¿Zm�ÉZÅÁÌ¿�Y~·����������Ê»�É{Ó§�Ĭ¸u�¶°�Ì̤e�Y�É̳¸m�hZ]�Á�Ã|�{³¿|���{

    ÄnÌf¿,�������Ê»�d»ÁZ¬»�ºWZ«�ÉZÅZ]�]Y]�{�ļn»��|ËZ¼¿��ÃZ��ÉZÅʯZy�������°/�Â/Àe�¶/Ì·{�Ä]�É{Ó§����ÉZ/Å{]Z¯�ÉYY{�{Z/ ]Y�Á�¶

    ��ÃÁa�{�É{ZË���|ÀfÅ�Ê¿Y¼�ÉZÅ���������¾/ËY�Ê^/Y�¶ ¿�¶°�\¸£Y

    ÃZ�ZÅ�������������Ã|/Ì]YÂy�Ê/«�¶°/�Á�¾/ÅM�ÃY�ÉZÅ~³Ë�ÉY]����Á�Ä^ m�ÉY������������¾/ÅM�ÃY�Á�ÃY�t¼ÅÌ£�cZ Z¬e�ÉY]�½M����~/³ËÃY����Ê»�Z¯�Ä]�|¿Á���������/Âa�¶«Y|/u�Ä/ ·Z»�Ä/]�ª/̬ve�¾ËY�{

    �¶a�ʯZy�ZÅ���Y�f³]�Ä¿ZÅ{�Z]�É��d/Y�Ã|�ÄfyY{a�f»�����Y/q����ÃZ�¶°�Á{�¾ËY�į����ÃZ�cZÌ]{Y�{�ÉY��ʯZy�ÉZÅ�����Ä/]�É{Ó§�����Ê|ÀÅ�¶°�Zv·����������Z/¨eY�Ä/]�Ä/¿ZÅ{�±/]�d^/¿���ÃZ/����Y

    �ÃËÁ�d̼ÅY����|¿Y{Ây]�ÉY]�[��������Ä/]�Ä¿ZÅ{�±]�d^¿�¾ÌÀr¼Å��ÃZ�¾ËY�Z¨eY�����/y�/Âa�dËZ¨¯�¹|�µZ¼fuY�,ZÅ��d/Æm�Y�ʯZ

    �����������ÃÂ/³�/¤·�Á�Ê/¯�Ê´fzÌ/³�]Y]�{�d»ÁZ¬»����ËY/§Y�ÉYÊ»�|Å{�����������¶a�ʯZy�Âa�Ä ·Z»�ªÌ¬ve�¾ËY�{�,Á�¾ËY�Y���ÉZ/Å

    Ä^ m������Ä/f§³�Y/«�Ä/mÂe�{»�Zy�Â�Ä]�Ã|Ì]YÂy�Ê«�Á�ÉY�dY]���[���

    1� High- profile arch 2-�Low- profile arch 3-�Box

    id13129328 pdfMachine by Broadgun Software - a great PDF writer! - a great PDF creator! - http://www.pdfmachine.com http://www.broadgun.com

  • �� / ÄË¿��|¸m�,dË�Ìv»�Á�½Y¼�Ê|ÀÆ»���,�ÃZ¼��½Zf]Ze�,�����ÊaZÌa�,��������������������������������������¶«Y|u�É´·Y�sÔY���� �����

    �µZ�Y�Ìa�Ze�ʯZy�Âa�Z¨eY�¶«Y|u�¾ÌÌ e�����]�Ä�Á�Ê]ne�cÂ�ÂedY�Ã|�½ZÌ]�Ä¿ZÅ{�Y�ɯ���¾ËY�{

    ¾ÌËM� ,¾ÅM�ÃY�ÉY~³Z]�ÉY]�ÃÁ³��Ä»Z¿AISI�¹ZÆq�®Ë�Y|¬»��Ä¿ZÅ{]� [¾ÌËM�Á�Ä»Z¿��ÉZÅCALTRANS� ,BD�Á�AASHTO�

    ʯZy�Âa�¶«Y|u�ÉY]� Y�Ä¿ZÅ{�ºnÀa�®Ë�Z]�]Y]�Ã{Y{�ÄWYY�� |¿Y]����[� �� µZ� {����»���Âa� Z¨eY� ¶«Y|u�¾ÌÌ e�

    �{Y{�{ZÆÀÌa�Àe�ËÂe�t�ZY�]� Y�ʯZy]�[� ��¾ËY� {�¶°� Ä]� Z»ÂÌ¿� Á� ®ÀÌÂ]� Á� Ä]� Ã|¿� Z]� Z§� Á

    Ê»� ËÂe� Zy� {� ÊÁz»� ZË� Ê»Å�� {Â]�[� ��{Y|¿ZfYASTM A796� Ä]Y���� �Âa� ¶«Y|u�ÉY]� Y�ÄWYY� ʯZy��Ä]�į�dY�Ã{Y{S�,ÃZ�Ä¿ZÅ{�AL�,ÉÂv»�Z]�d�dËÂv»�½Á]�

    � ,Z]E� Á� cZv¨� ÄfÌÌfÓY� µÁ|»�I�cZv¨� ÊÀËY� ½Z¼»�k»�É{Ó§��{Y{�Ê´f]�Y{]�[���

    ��������������������������� ���������������������

    EI

    dALSH

    )(55.0min

    ���

    ��¾ÌËM�� Ä»Z¿ARTC� Ô¯� Ä]� ÄmÂe� Z]�Ë{Z¬»� ¾ÅM� ÃY� Ây�

    dY�Ã{Y{�{ZÆÀÌa�ʯZy�Âa�Z¨eY�¶«Y|u�ÉY]�Y�Êz»��¾ÌËM�¾ËY�Ë�ʸY�Ây�Á�ʸY�Ây�ÉY]� Ä»Z¿��Ä]� Ì·Y

    �d»Zz�\Ìee���Á�f»����Y�|ËZ^¿�į�dY�Ã{Y{�ÄWYY�Y�f»�� |Z]� f°q¯� Ä¿ZÅ{� ¹ZÆq� ®Ë]��[� �©Â§� ]YÁ��ÉY]� ¯~·Y

    ÃZ�¯� ÉZÅ� Y� f°qÂ�Ê»� {]Z¯� ¶]Z«� f»��Z]À|� ��Ä¿ZÅ{� ÉY]�Y�f³]��{Y|¿ZfY�ļ̼�f»�CHBDC�Y|¬»�j¯Y|u����

    �Ä]Y�Y�¶Zu�Y|¬»�ZË�f»�����Y�|ËZ^¿�į�dY�ÄfY{�½ZÌ]�Y�Y|¬»��|ËZ¼¿�ÁZne�f»���]�,����[���

    ��

    �������� �������Dh�,Ä¿ZÅ{�DvZ¨eY����,21

    )(6 v

    hh

    D

    DD��

    ��»Zm� Äq³� ÌyY� Ä]Y��Âa� ¶«Y|u� ¾ÌÌ e� Ä]Y� ¾Ëe

    Ä¿ZÅ{� ÉY]� ʯZy�� Y� f³]� ÉZÅ�Ê»��|Z],]� Z»Y����ZY�cZz»� Y� ¶¬f»� ¾ÌÀr¼Å� Á� Ã|� kYzfY� ÃY� ÉY~³Z]

    k»�É{Ó§�cZv¨� ¬»�Ê°Ì¿Z°»�Ê»� Y{�|Z]� �Ê·Zu� {�¯��Äk»� É{Ó§� cZv¨� ¬»�Y{¶a� ÉY]� į� É�ʯZy� ÉZÅ��

    ]� ¾ÅM� ÃY� É{Ó§� ÄÊ»� Z¯�dY� Ã|� dˬe� ¿� Y� {Á� ��Y~·�Y{Ây]� ÉfÌ]� Êfz� Y� ¾ÅM� ÃY� {� Ã{Z¨fY� {»� Z¬»

    1-�Moser 2� Australian Rail Track Corporation

    {�¹|�Á�Ã{Â]��Z¨eY�|u�Y�Ì]�ËY§Y�Ä]�nÀ»�½M�É̳¿|� |ÅYÂy� ʯZy�Âa� �� ÉÁ� ]� ,ZfY� ¾ËY� {���¶a� {|�

    Ä^ m�� Á�ÉY��¶a�� Z]� Ã|Ì]YÂy�Ê«���Z¬»�¶»Z�¬»�¿�k»�É{Ó§�cZv¨� Z]� Ã|�dˬe� ,Ã|¿�dˬe��dˬe� Á� Y{

    �¹Zn¿Y�{Á|v»�LYmY�É| ]�Á{�¶Ì¸ve�Êfˬe�Äv¨�Á�¾f]�Z]�Ã|¶a�ÉY]� 0ZfËZÆ¿�į�d§³�Ä^ m�ÉZÅ�¶a�Á�ÉY��Ã|Ì]YÂy�Ê«�ÉZÅ

    Ä¿Z³Y|m�]YÁ�dY�Ã|Ë{³�ÄWYY�ÉY�]�[� �]YÁ�¾ËY� Y�Ê ]Ze�V�� ,Z«�dI�Á�cZv¨�ÊÀËY�½Z¼»�DhÊ»�¶a�Ä¿ZÅ{��|Z]���

    �Ã|�kYzfY�¾ÅM� ÃY�ÉY~³Z]�ZY�]� ¯~»�]YÁ� Äq³Y�¹Â�| ]�{�Y�Z]�ËÂe�Z»Y�dY��Á�{�Z]�Y|¬»�µZj»�ÉY]

    ÁYe��]�Äʼ¿�d{�|Å{��,Á�¾ËY�Y�{�Z]���ÉZÅZÌ »�É̳¿Y� ,y� Zn»�d¿Ì̤e� ,¾ÅM�y� Zn»� kZmÂ��Ê·Â�¶°

    ÃYÂË{�¿Z¼¯� µfÀ¯� Á� ÃZ�¹¿� ®¼¯� Ä]� ÃZ� ÉZÅ��Ä� Y§Y�{Á|v»�LYmY�É| ]PLAXIS 3D��ʯZy�Âa�¶«Y|u�É´·Y�

    ¶a�ÉY]�Ä^ m�ÉZÅ�dY�Ã|�sÔY�Ã|Ì]YÂy�Ê«�Á�ÉY����Ä� ¶Ì¸ve� Y� ¶Zu� lËZf¿� ÄËZ¬»� Y� a� ªÌ¬ve� ¾ËY{

    ¶Ì¸ve�lËZf¿� Z]�É| ]�¶«Y|u�É´·Y�ÊuÔY�\ËY� ,É| ]� Á{��Á� Ã|� kYzfY� Zy� cZ ]»� ¶«Y|u�Á� Ä]� ʯZy�Âa�ÊÀËY� ½Z¼»� Y� Ê ]Ze� cÂ� Ä]� Ã|� sÔY� ]YÁ� 0ZfËZÆ¿

    dY�Ã|�ÄWYY�ÃZ�Ä¿ZÅ{�Á�cZv¨�����

    ��»�¦Ë e�PÄ·������Ê|ÀÅ�cZz»���

    ¶a���ʯZ/y�ÉZÅ��������������~/³Ë�¶°/�Ä/]�Ä/ ·Z»�{Â/»�É{ÓÂ/§�Ä^ m�Y�����Ã|Ì]YÂy�Ê«�Á�ÉÅf|��������ÉÁ�Y�Ä/y�®/Ë�¾/ÅM�ÃY�į�

    ½M��̂�ZÅ//�¼¿�Â//��/e�Z]�Á�Ã{Â/�����/Ë�{�ÃY�ÉZÅ|/¿Z]�{Y|/ e�Ä/]�Äm½M���{Z//// ]Y�ÉYY{�Z////Åm���� m�����,m���� m�����,� �m���� m������,m���� m�����¶a�ÉY]�����Ä/^ m�ÉZ/Å

    �{Z/// ]Y�Á�ÉYm���� m�����,� m���� m������,m���� m�����Á�� m���� m������¶/a�ÉY]�����Ê/«�ÉZ/Å

    Ê»�Ã|Ì]YÂy�|ÀZ]��¹¿�Y�Ã{Z¨fY�Z]��Y§YPLAXIS 3D�¹Â�| ]��ÃZ�¾ËY���������Ê·Â/�Â/v»�ÉZfY�{�ZÅ��������ÃY�/y�Ê/�ÉZf/Y

    ¾ÅM��dY�Ã|�µ|»���˯Zy�Á�dÓZ]�ÉY|ËZa�\Ì�Ä]�ÄmÂe�Z]����Ä]��������,ºWZ«����ʬ§Y�����Âa�Z¨eY�Á�����µ|/»�µÂ�,ʯZy�

    ��dY�Ã|�¾ÌÌ e������]�¾ÅM�ÃY�Ê�¬»������¶°/�Z/Y�����{����dY�Ã|�µ|»�¹Â�| ]�����¾ËY�Ä]�ÄmÂe�Z]������\Ì/�¦Ë e�½Z°»Y�į

    ���¹/¿�¹Â/�|/ ]�{�˯Zy�Á�dÓZ]���Y/§YPLAXIS 3D��{Â/mÁ���dY|¿@��>��Ä¿Z�\Ì�,����Ä/¸a�cÂ�Ä]�˯Zy�Á�dÓZ]�ÉZÅ��ÉY

    �¶°�ª]Z»�����Ã|�¦Ë edY�

    id13140906 pdfMachine by Broadgun Software - a great PDF writer! - a great PDF creator! - http://www.pdfmachine.com http://www.broadgun.com

  • �� / ÄË¿��|¸m�,dË�Ìv»�Á�½Y¼�Ê|ÀÆ»���,�ÃZ¼��½Zf]Ze�,�����ÊaZÌa�,��������������������������������������¶«Y|u�É´·Y�sÔY���� �����

    ���¶°���ºÌ¬f»�Äy�®Ë�¾ÅM�ÃY�{�dÓZ]�Ë�Á�dÓZ]�Ê�¬»��f¼Ìf¿Z�Ä]�{Z ]Y������� �

    ��

    Front

    Pla

    n

    Pla

    n A

    Pla

    n B

    Pla

    n C

    Pla

    n D

    Pla

    n E

    Pla

    n F

    Pla

    n G

    Pla

    n H

    Rear P

    lan

    Section1

    4.5

    5

    4.0

    2

    4.1

    0

    3.5

    0

    2.1

    5

    1.7

    0

    1.3

    0

    0.7

    50.6

    8

    0.0

    0

    Y

    Z

    CL

    Section2 Section3 Section5 Section6Section7 Section9

    Section8

    Section4

    ���¶°���ʯZy�Âa�ÉY]�É| ]�Ä�µ|»�Ê·Â�Z¬»�¶v»�Á�¾ÅM�ÃY�Ê�¬»���f»�

    �ºnu�Á�½Z»�ÅZ¯�dÆm�¬»�`q�ļ̿�¬§�,cZ^Zv»

    dY� Ã|�µ|»�y�Ê� ��y�iR»�µÂ�¾ÌÌ e�ÉZfY� {�¶Ì¸ve� {»�¦¸fz»�µ|»�|Àq� Z]�cYiY�¾f§³� ¿� {�dÆm�Y�| ]�ÁYe� ZÆq�į�dY� Ã|�z»�Á�dY�Äf§³� Y«�y� µ|»� µÂ� ÉY]� Ê^ZÀ»� Ã{Á|v»� ,¶a� Ä¿ZÅ{� j¯Y|u

    Ê»�|Z]���� �����t·Z»�cZz»���

    Å�¶Ì§Áa�ÉY]�©Â§�ÃZ�dÅ�Y�®Ë�mm��� mm�����dˬe� cZv¨� Á�ʸY�cZv¨�¶»Z�¦¸fz»� ¬»� ZÆq� Z]

    ¶v»�Á�Äf§³�Y«�¶Ì¸ve�{»�,Ã|ÀÀ¯��Á�kZe�ÉÁ�]�dˬe�ÉZÅ«�dY�Ã|�Äf§³�¿�{�ZÅYÂË{�ÉZÅ���¿�Y�cZv¨�Àm

    dY� ÃÌ¿Y·Z³� {Ó§� �k»� É{Ó§� cZv¨� cZz»�� ,Y{�Êa�µÁY|m�{�Êa�ÃYÂË{�Á�ÃZ�����Á����dY�Ã|�ÄWYY���cZz»

    �¶Àa�Ê°Ì¿Z°»VIe�§�Z]�¾f]�½{Â]�YY{�Ä]�ÄmÂe�Z]���½{Â]�Y{

    dY�Äf§³�Y«�Ä^Zv»�{»�¬»��k»�É{Ó§�cZv¨��Ä]�Y{Êa� Á�®ÌfÔaÂfÓY� cÂ�ÃYÂË{� Á� ZÅ��®ÌfÓY� cÂ� Ä]� ZÅ

    Ã|�µ|»�|¿Y� ��µÁ|m�{����,Mp�Á�ʼy�ḑ�Pp�ḑ�k»�É{Ó§�cZv¨�ÉÂv»�ÉÁÌ¿�Ê»�Y{�|Z]�

    �µ|»�{����������Ã|�§�¾´¼Å�ÃZ�¥YY�Zy�,É| ]�Ä�ÉZÅdY����������µÁ|m�{�d·Zu�¾ËY�{�Zy�cZz»�������Ã|/�ÄÔydY����e�\zfÀ»�ZyP��������Ê»Z/¼e�{�ÃZ�ʯZy�Âa�Ã|ÀÀ¯�¾Ì»µ|»�����ÄZ»�Zy�¿�Y�,ZÅ����z»�½Á�Z]�ÉY��Â������/]�¾eÂ̿¸̯�

    �Ê»�\ °»f»�|Z]������������d»Zz/�Ä/]�dÓZ]�ÄËÓ�Zy�]�ÃÁÔ��������d/Y�Ã|/�µ|/»�Ä/ËÓ�¾ËyM�½YÂÀ�Ä]�f»�����Á�¶/Ë�cZ/z»

    ������������¾/ÅM�ÃY�ÉZÁ�ʻ¼�Á�ÊÀ§�cZz»�ZY�]�Ì¿�ÁYe����dY�Ã|�¦Ë e�Ä»Z¿]�ÉY]���,¶Ë�¿�UIC60�����,ÁY/e�¿�Á�

    �����dY�ʯ¸]�®e�ÊÀf]@��>�������/�Ä]�Á�Ìe�½Z¼·Y�cÂ�Ä]�¶Ë����¶Ë�kZe���f¼Ìf¿Z�������dY�Ã|�µ|»@��>���ÄÌ^�dÆm���ÉZ/

    ����������d^/¿�Á�Â/z»�½Á�,ÄfÌÌfÓY�µÁ|»�ÉZÅf»YZa�ÁYe�µÁ|m�ª]Z»�½ÂYÂa����Ã|�ʧ »�Ä»Z¿]�Ä]�|¿Y�

  • �� / ÄË¿��|¸m�,dË�Ìv»�Á�½Y¼�Ê|ÀÆ»���,�ÃZ¼��½Zf]Ze�,�����ÊaZÌa�,��������������������������������������¶«Y|u�É´·Y�sÔY���� �����

    �µÁ|m��½Z¼·Y�cZz»��k»�É{Ó§�cZv¨�¥ »�ÉZÅ�Y{� �

    ¶Àa�¿��LYmY�µ|»��¿¶Ì§Áa����¿¶Àa��)( mkNEA��

    EI

    ).

    (2

    m

    mkN ��

    ù�½Á�Âz»�

    )(3m

    kN��

    �\˽ÂYÂa��

    pM��

    ).

    (m

    mkN��pP��

    )(m

    kN��

    Ã{Z�¶Àa��®ÌfÔaÂfÓY��mm���� �mm������III���� �����������������������������������Ã|�dˬe�¶Àa��®ÌfÔaÂfÓY��mm���� �mm������IV���� ������������ ����������������������Ã|�dˬe�¶Àa��®ÌfÔaÂfÓY��mm���� �mm������V���� ������������ ����������������������Ã|�dˬe�¶Àa��®ÌfÔaÂfÓY��mm���� �mm������VI���� ������������� ����������������������

    ���µÁ|m��½Z¼·Y�cZz»��ÃYÂË{�¥ »�ÉZÅ�Êa�Á�ZÅ�ZÅ��

    ���ÉZf§�µ|»LYmY��)( 2mkNfc��)(

    m

    kNEA��

    EI

    ).

    (2

    m

    mkN��

    ù���Âz»�½Á�

    )(3m

    kN���\˽ÂYÂa��

    pM��

    ).

    (m

    mkN��pP��

    )(m

    kN� �

    Êa�ÃYÂË{��®ÌfÓY������������ ������������������������������Êa��®ÌfÓY������������ �������� ���������������������

    ��µÁ|m��½Z¼·Y�cZz»��dÓZ]�Á�ʯZy�Âa�¥ »�ÉZÅ�

    Zy�¿���µ|»��ã unsat� )(3m

    kN ã sat� )(3m

    kN )(2m

    kNEref���\˽ÂYÂa��ö��)( 2m

    kNCref��K0

    Zy��Å»��\¼·Â¯�������������� �����������0 ��������dÓZ]��Å»��\¼·Â¯�������������� �����������0 ��������

    ��µÁ|m��½Z¼·Y�cZz»���¥ »�ÉZÅÁYe�Á�¶Ë��

    LYmY��LYmY�ÉZf§�µ|»��)( 2mkNE��)(

    m

    kNEA��EI ).(2

    m

    mkN��ù½Á��)(

    m

    kN��½ÂYÂa�\Ë��

    ¶Ë��®ÌfÓY����� ��������������������������������

    LYmY��LYmY�ÉZf§�µ|»��ã unsat�)(3m

    kN��ã sat�)(3m

    kN��)(2m

    kNEref��K0��½ÂYÂa�\Ë��

    ÁYe��Êy�®ÌfÓY������������� �����������������ÉY~³Z]�� �

    ¾ÌËM� Z]� ,Ã|� µZ¼Y� Z]�� Ä»Z¿UIC� ÉÂv»� Z]� Z]����¾e�Ê»��Z]� ¦¿� ,y� ļ̿� ®Ë� ½{¼¿� µ|»� d¸� Ä]� į� |Z]

    ³� µZ¼Y� ¶Ë� ]� {Y|¿ZfYdY� Ã|Ë{� �� ´Ë{� cZ^� Ä]��Z]��Z]�]Y]�¯¼f»kN����Á�kN/m���{ÂmÁ�¶Ë�ÉÁ�Ã{f³Z]�

    |¿Y{���¶°����Ê»�½Z¿�Y�ÉY~³Z]�É| ]�Ä�µ|»��|Å{@��>� ��

    ��� �

    �¶°��y�`q�ļ̿�{�¾ÅM�ÃY�ÉY~³Z]�É| ]�Ä�µ|»�

  • �� / ÄË¿��|¸m�,dË�Ìv»�Á�½Y¼�Ê|ÀÆ»���,�ÃZ¼��½Zf]Ze�,�����ÊaZÌa�,��������������������������������������¶«Y|u�É´·Y�sÔY���� �����

    �����������ÃZ�`q�ļ̿�ÉY]�Z«�d¯u�,ÃZ�½{Â]�½Z¬f»�d¸�Ä]�|�µ|»dY�Ã�������d/Ì «Â»�¾Ë|/Àq�{�Z/«�Z/]�ÂÀ»�¾ËY�ÉY]

    ���dY�Ã|�Ã{Y{�Y«������������Ê/a�ÃYÂ/Ë{�{Y|f»Y�{�Z«�wq�¾Ì·ÁY�Y|f]Y����{Y{�Y«�`q�Location1������������{�Á�µ|/»�/Á�{�Z/«�b�,

    ������Ê/»�Y«�ÃZ�kZe�¯»�{Y|f»Y����{/̳�Location2������d/ËZÆ¿�{�Á�������������/«�d/Y�Ê/a�ÃYÂ/Ë{�{Y|/f»Y�{�Z/«�wq�¾Ì·ÁY�Ê/»�Y���{/̳

    �Location3��������������kZ/mÂY�,/y�d¿�,©Â§�cÓZu�Y�®Ë�Å�{ÃYÂË{�¿Z¼¯�Á�ÃZ�Ê·Â�d¿�,y�dY�Ã|�µfÀ¯�ZÅ�

    � �����É»�ËY���

    µ|»�{,�ĸZ§�Ä]�µ|»�ÉZÅ»����Âv»�¥�Á{� Y� f»��¾ÌÀr¼Å�Á�ÃZ�½Z¬e���¿�{�µ|»�Ĭ¿�¾ËeÓZ]�Ë�Y�f»�

    �dY� Ã|� Äf§³�lËZf¿� ]�µ|»�ÉZÅ»� iY�¥~u�½M�ÉZÀ^»� ÁdY�Ã{Â]�¶Ì¸ve��µ|»�ÉZÅ»�{,½Z°»�Ì̤e���ºWZ«�Á�ʬ§Y�ÉZÅ

    ÄÌ°e� {�yq� ¾ÌÀr¼Å� Á�Z³�Ã��dY� Ã|�§� ¨� ]Y]� ZÅ@�>��½Z°»�Ì̤e�¾ÌÀr¼Å��Ê·Â�ÉZÅzǻÊËZÆf¿Y�{�,��Äv¨�¾Ëe

    �Ê·Â�¾ÅM�y�½Z¬e�Âv»�Y�Ã|¿~³�Äv¨���¨�]Y]�dYÊ»�½Z¿�į��Ê�Äv¨�]�{¼�ÉZfY�{�½Z°»�Ì̤e�|Å{ÄÌ°e�{�¶a�ÃZ³��dY�Ã|�|̬»�ZÅ@�>���

    ÄÌ^�¶»Z�ÉZ·|»�Ä»Y{Y�dÆm��ÃZ�ÉYmY�¶uY»�ÉZÃY�ÉY~³Z]�µZ¼Y� Á�¶°�Ì̤e�Ê»Z¼e� ,¾ÅM��Y�¶^«� ÄÌ·ÁY�ÉZÅ

    Ã{Z»M�ÊÀ Ë�ÃZ�ÉYmY�ĸu»�¾Ì·ÁY�¨�]Y]�f]�ÉZ�Y«�¶°�Ì̤e�iY�Ze�dY�Ã|�Ã{Y{��¥~u�¶Ì¸ve�lËZf¿�{�ÄÌ·ÁY�ÉZÅ

    {Â� ������¶Ì¸ve�cZ̧���

    �ÄWYY�cZ̧�]�ÊÀf^»�É| ]�Ä�¶Ì¸ve�ÄÌ·ÁY�cZ̧�Ã|¼�mY»�Âe�Ã|@�>Á��@��>Ê»��|Z]��Y�|ÀeZ^�cZ̧�¾ËY���

    ���µ|»�dY�Äf§³�¹Zn¿Y�É| ]�Ä�cÂ�Ä]�ÉZ���¾ËY�d˻ʻ�dY�½M�É| ]�Á{�Á�Ä]�d^¿�Á��ÃY�Ê�¬»�½YÂe

    �µZ¼Y�¶Ë�ÉÁ� ]� 0Z¬Ì«{� Y� ZÅZ]� Á� Ã{¯� Ã{ZÌa� ½M� {� Y�¾ÅM{¼¿��¶°�Ì̤e�Y~·�Ê»�Y�¶a�Ê·Â�ÉZÅ�d§³�¿�{�½YÂe���Z»Y

    -{Y{�ZÌ¿�¶Ì¸ve�dÆm�ÉfÌ]�d^Zv»�ºnu�����k»�É{Ó§�cZv¨�¾Ì]�¤·�iY�Y��Zy�Á�Y{¥���¿

    dY�Ã|���]Y]�ÊZ¼e�½Z¼·Y�d»ÁZ¬»�ÊÀ Ë�dY�Ã|�§���ºq� ,ªÌ¬ve� {»� ÃÂu� {�ºq� ¹|� ZË�ÊÂa��ÊÂa��¦Ë e

    � Z]� ]Y]� ÊZ¼e� ½Z¼·Y� d»ÁZ¬»��� ��cZv¨� ¾Ì]�¤·� iY� Yk»� É{Ó§�ÃÆ]� ¶]Z«� ¶a� ÉY]� Zy� Á� Y{��¶]Z«� ÌiPe� ,ÉY{]

    �{Y|¿�¶Ì¸ve�lËZf¿�{�ÊÆmÂe@���,��>�-�����µ|»�Ê»Z¼e�{�«�,ZÅ��®ÌfÔaÂfÓY�cÂ�Ä]�ɸ§�ÉZÅ

    ½Z¼·Y� Ê·Z¼fuY� ºÌ¸e� Ze� dY� Ã|� µ|»��{»� Ì¿� «� ÉZÅ-{̳�Y«�Ä ·Z»��

    �� �µ|»�Ê»Z¼e� {�ÃYÂË{� Á�Êa� ,ZÅ��®ÌfÓY�cÂ� Ä]�Êa�ÉZÅÃ|�µ|»�Y|¿-��

    �� �µ|»�Ê»Z¼e� {��§�¾´¼Å� ÃZ�¥YY�\zfÀ»�Zy� ,ZÅÃ|Å»�ZÌ »�ZY�]�Á��-dY�Ã|�µ|»�\¼·Â¯��

    �� ��cYÌ̤e� Á�Ê Ì^�Zy�¿� ,Ä¿Ye�\Ì� iY�¥~u�dÆm�§�¾´¼Å�Zy� ,¶Ì¸ve�lËZf¿� ]� ÃZ�¥YY�\zfÀ»�Zy

    -dY�Ã|�����½Z¼·Y�,É| ]�Ä�µ|»�{��cÂ�Ä]�ZÅ��Ã|�µ|»�Êų���-|¿Y���� �»� Ã|ÀÀ¯�dˬe�cZv¨�{Z ]Y� iY�ªÌ¬ve�¾ËY� {�Ê]�{

    �Êfz�ËY§Y� ]� Ã|ÀÀ¯�dˬe�cZv¨�iY� ZÆÀe� Á� Äf§´¿� Y«½Z¼·Y�-dY�Äf§³�Y«�Ä ·Z»�{»�«�ÉZÅ��

    ���µ|»�Ê»Z¼e�{�¹Z³�Ä]�¹Z³�cÂ�Ä]�ÃZ�ÉYmY�iY�ZÅ��¾Ìu�{�¶Ì¸ve�dY�Ã|�Äf§³�¿���

    ����ʯZy�Âa�¶«Y|u�¾ÌÌ e�ÉZÅZÌ »���

    � ʸY� ZÌ »� ZÆq�ªÌ¬ve� ¾ËY� {�Zn»� ºWZ«�d¿� ¶»Z�¿Z¼¯� Á� ÃZ�Ê·Â�¶°Ì̤e� ,¾ÅM�y� Zn»�kZmÂY� ,y

    ÃYÂË{�{�ÃZ�Å�ʯZy�Âa�¶«Y|u�¾ÌÌ e�dÆm�ÃZ�ÉZÅ�dY�Ã|�Äf§³�¿����

    ������y�Zn»�ºWZ«�d¿�ZÌ »���

    �ÉZÅZÌ »� Y� Ê°Ë� ½YÂÀ� Ä]�d¿� ZÌ »� [Zzf¿Y� Y� ¥|ÅY� Ã{Â]�½M�ʯZy�Âa�¶«Y|u�¾ÌÌ e�Âa�d»Zz�į�d

    �ÃY�Z]�µZ¼Y�Y�ÊZ¿�y�d¿�į�{Â�¾ÌÌ e�ÉÂv¿�Ä]�ʯZy{{´¿�Z«�y�Y�kÁy�\m»�Á�Ã|¿Z»�Ê«Z]�Zn»�|u�{�¾ÅM��

    �� ÄË¿� ZY� ]� Ê^¿� d¿� ZfY� ¾ËY� {����]YÂ�� Ä]Y� Y� ÉZË��� �� d� ÉY]����dZ� ]� f»Â¸Ì¯�

    �½M� {� į�dY� Ã|�[Zzf¿Yf¿� ,-§Z»�ËZM� |u�d�L�,½M�¾Ì]�Ê^¿�d¿�į�Ĭ¿� Á{�¾Ì]� ĸZ§��,dY� ¿�|»� ZÅ

    � Á� f»�\u]Vtr�ÄÌ¿Zi� ]� f»�\u]� Z«�d¯u�d� ,Ê»��|Z]@��>����

    ����� �������������������������������������������������2

    2

    0.625trV

    Lf

    1-�Stage construction

  • �� / ÄË¿��|¸m�,dË�Ìv»�Á�½Y¼�Ê|ÀÆ»���,�ÃZ¼��½Zf]Ze�,�����ÊaZÌa�,��������������������������������������¶«Y|u�É´·Y�sÔY���� �����

    ���¶°�ª]Z»�����������ZÅ{�/Á�¾Ì/]�Ê^/¿�d¿�����Ä/¬¿�Á�Ä/¿����������˯Z/y�ÄÀ/Za�Z/¬»�{�Ä¿ZÅ{�j¯Y|u

    AB����d/ÓZ]�ÄÀ/Za�,CD����ÁYe�Ä^·�,EF�����¶Ë�ÊmZy�Ä^·�,GH��y�Âv»�Á�IJ�

    dY�Ã|�µfÀ¯� ��

    ��

    � �

    �¶°���À¯�Z¬¿�d¿�µf�¦·Y���Ê�¬»�{,[���¶a�Ê·Â�Z¬»�{�� ����¾ÅM�y�Zn»�kZmÂY�ZÌ »���

    ½M�Y��y�µÂ�{�d¿�É| ]�Ä�µ|»�{�įZm��d¿Êa�Á�Ä¿ZÅ{�Á�¾Ì]�Ê^¿���y��{�Á��Âv»�ÉZfY�{

    ¶a�Ê·Â� �Ê»�y�Zn»�kZmÂY� ,dY�Ê]�¶]Z«��ZÌ »�|¿YÂe¿� ¾ÌÌ^e� dÆm� Ê^ZÀ»|Z]� | ]� Á{� Å� {� y� Zn»� d��

    �¬»�Á{�¾Ì]�¾ÅM�y�Ê�Ye�{�Z¨eY�Ì̤e�y�kZmÂY� dY� Ê·YÂf»@��>� Ä]Y� Y� į���� �Ê»� Ä^Zv»��{� į� {{³

    ½MTWS,y�kZmÂY�i�{�y�Ê�Ye�{�Z¨eY�Ì̤e��¬»i�,1 i�¬»�{�y�Ê�Ye�{�Z¨eY�Ì̤e��iÁ�

    L�¬»�Á{�¾Ì]�ĸZ§�i�Á��iÊ»��|Z]�����

    �������������������� �� L

    TWS ii

    1��

    ��d� ÉY]� y� Zn»� kZmÂY��¦¸fz»� ʨ̯� sÂ� Á� ZÅ

    dY� Ã|�ÄWYY�¾ÅM� ÃY�mY»� {�¾ÅM�y� �e� Z]�¾°Ì·�Ä]� ÄmÂ�|Ë|m�Ây� ʨ̯� t� ÊÀ Ë� Ä·P»� {� Ã|�§� ËY

    �d�Á�gY|uÓY����¶«Y|u�[Zzf¿Y�dÆm�,dZ�]�f»Â¸Ì¯��Ä^Zv»�¶Ì¸ve�Å�{�y�kZmÂY�,ÃZ�Å�ʯZy�Âa�Z¨eY

    �Z]�]Y]�,y�Zn»�kZmÂY�Z]�Á�Ã|Ë{³m�mm��Ã|�µfÀ¯�,�dY��������ÃZ�Ê·Â�¶°�Ì̤e�ZÌ »���

    �µfÀ¯� ,kZmÂY� µfÀ¯� Y� ¥|Å� ,|� Äf¨³� į� Â� ½Z¼ÅÊ»� ÃZ� µÂ� {� y� dyYÂÀ°ËÌ£� d¿�|Z]� ��³Y� \¸£Y

    �µÂ�{�ÃZ�¶°�Ì̤e�,|Z]�Zn»�ÃZ�µÂ�{�y�d¿{Â]� |ÅYÂy� Zn»� Ì¿� �� {Y|¿ZfYCHBDC�Ì̤e� µfÀ¯� ÉY]�

    ÃÆ]� ¾Ìu� {� ÃZ� ¶°�Ä]Z� ÉY{]��dY� Ã{Y|¿� ÄWYY� ÉY�Z»YÄ^ m�¶a�ÉY]��Ä]�¶°�Ì̤e� YmY�µZu�{�Ã|Ì]YÂy�Ê«�Á�ÉY

    � Y� |ËZ^¿� \Ìee�� Á� Ä¿ZÅ{� |{���|ËZ¼¿� ÁZne� Z¨eY� |{�@��>� ��Ê·Â� ¶°� Ì̤e� ,ZÌ »� ¾ËY� µfÀ¯� dÆm� ,Á� ¾ËY� Y

    Ä^ m� ¶a� ¾Ëf³]��Y� ¶^«� ĸu»� ®Ë� Ã|Ì]YÂy� Ê«� Á� ÉYÃÆ]�]YÂ�Z]�Z]�Á�Ã|�Ä^Zv»�ÉY{]�CHBDC�ÄËZ¬»�{»�

    Ê»�Y«�{̳���������ÃYÂË{�¿Z¼¯�µfÀ¯��ÃZ�ÉZÅ��

    ¹¿�{��Y§YPLAXIS 3D�®ÌfÔaÂfÓY�µ|»�[Zzf¿Y� Z]� ,ÄÀ˳�,É{Ó§�«�Ìe�½Z¼·Y�ÉY]��ÉZÅPp�Á�Mp�ÉÁÌ¿�ḑ��½Á|]� ÃZ�ʼy�´À·� Á�ÉÂv»�d»ÁZ¬»�ÅZ¯�\Ë� ,

    Ó§� cZv¨k»� É{�� dY� Ã|Ë{³� µZ §� ,Y{@��>��Pp�Á�Mp��µÁ|m�ª]Z»��� �¹¿� Ä]�¦¸fz»�Z¬»�ÉY]��Ã|�ʧ »� Y§Y

    dY���Ä]Y�Y�¿Z¼¯�,f»YZa�Á{�¾ËY�¦Ë e�Z]�����Z¬¿�¹Z¼e�{«�¹¿�Âe�ZÅ�dY�Ã|�µfÀ¯�Y§Y������

    ��������� ���������� ����2( ) | | 1p p

    P M

    P M

    � ���¶Ì¸ve�Y�¶Zu�lËZf¿�� �

    �����������Á�Ä¿ZÅ{�Á�Ĭ¿�¾Ì]�Ê^¿�d¿�,y�d¿�ZÌ »�{

  • �� / ÄË¿��|¸m�,dË�Ìv»�Á�½Y¼�Ê|ÀÆ»���,�ÃZ¼��½Zf]Ze�,�����ÊaZÌa�,��������������������������������������¶«Y|u�É´·Y�sÔY���� �����

    �������Z¬»�{�¶Ë�ÉÁ�]�ÊaFP���Ze�RP���������d/¿�Z/]�Á�Ã|/�¾ÌÌ e����dY�Äf§³�Y«�ÄËZ¬»�{»�Zn»�������/Ì¿�kZ/mÂY�µ/fÀ¯�d/Æm

    �����������Y�Ã|¿~³�Z¬»�¾Ì]�,y��¦¸fz»�Z¬¿�{�Ê^¿�d¿���a�Á�Ä¿ZÅ{�¯»���������Ã|�ÄËZ¬»�Zn»�kZmÂY�Z]�Á�Ã|Ë{³�Ä^Zv»�Ê

    dY������������¾Ë/f¼¯�Y�Y|/f]Y�,ÃZ�ʯZy�Âa�¶«Y|u�¾ÌÌ e�dÆm������Ê/À Ë�¾°¼»�ʯZy�Âa������������d/Y�Ã|/�Z/£M�¶/̸ve�/f»���

    ����Ì̤e�,kZmÂY�,Zn»�Ê^¿�d¿��������¿Z/¼¯�Á�ÃZ/�Ê·Â�¶°ºÅ����dY�Ã|�µfÀ¯�½Z»�������������LZ/Y�©Â/§�/�Z/Æq�Y�Ê°Ë�³Y

    {¿,�����������Ã|/�[Zzf¿Y�ʯZy�Âa�d»Zz�į�dY�ÊÀ »�¾Ë|]

    �ʼ¿�\ZÀ»�������������ËY/§Y�ʯZ/y�/Âa�d»Zz/�dY�¹Ó�Á�|Z]�{Â�Ã{Y{�����d»Zz�ÉY]�|¿Á�¾ËY������ʯZy�Âa�¦¸fz»�ÉZÅ���Z/]

    ���ʯZy�Âa�d»Zz�ËY§Y����dY�Ã|�Y°e�����d»Zz/�¾Ì·ÁY�������,Ê¿Yv]�ÉY~³Z]�{�į�ʯZy�Âa��©Â§�ÉZÅ���º/Å����½Z/»

    ZY�����������Ã|/�[Zzf¿Y�ÃZ�ʯZy�Âa�d»Zz�½YÂÀ�Ä]�,|¿Â�LdY�����µÁ|m�{������������Ä�¶Ì¸ve�Y�¶Zu�kZmÂY�Á�d¿�lËZf¿

    ������������d/�{�É| ]�Á{�lËZf¿�Á�Zn»�Ë{Z¬»�Z]�É| ]������f»Â/¸Ì¯�dY�Äf§³�Y«�ÄËZ¬»�{»�dZ�]�

    �µÁ|m���¶Zu�kZmÂY�Á�d¿�lËZf¿�¶Ì¸ve�Y�Á{�lËZf¿�Á�Zn»�Ë{Z¬»�Z]�½M�ÄËZ¬»�Á�É| ]�Ä�ÉZÅ�É| ]� �

    É| ]�Ä��É| ]�Á{��ÃZ�¿��Ä¿ZÅ{��

    ¶Àa�¿��

    Hmin (m) �kZmÂY

    �m˻�mm˺��Zn»�Y|¬»�

    �m˻�mm˺��ºWZ«�d¿�

    �mm��Hmin (m)��

    ºWZ«�d¿��mm��

    Zn»�Y|¬»��mm��

    ���������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������

    BO

    X�

    ���������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������

    LP

    A�

    ������

    III

    ����������������������������� ��

    ����������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������

    BO

    X�

    ������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������

    LP

    A�

    ������

    IV��

    ����������������������������� ��

    ������� ������������������������������ �������������������������������� ������������������������

    BO

    X�

    �������� ��������������������������������� ��������������������������������� �������������������������������� �������������������������

    LP

    A�

    ������

    V��

    �� ������������������������� ��

    ������� ������������� ���������������� ������������� ������������������ ������������� ���������

    BO

    X�

    �������� ������������� ������������������ ������������� ������������������ ������������� ������������������ ������������� ����������

    LP

    A�

    ������

    VI

    �� ��� �������� ����������

  • �� / ÄË¿��|¸m�,dË�Ìv»�Á�½Y¼�Ê|ÀÆ»���,�ÃZ¼��½Zf]Ze�,�����ÊaZÌa�,��������������������������������������¶«Y|u�É´·Y�sÔY���� �����

    Ä^ m�¶a�¶°�Ì̤e�µfÀ¯�dÆm��ÉYm��� m�����Á��Ã|Ì]YÂy�Ê«�¶am��� m����Ê¿Yv]�{���d·Zu�¾Ëe��¶Àa

    III¶a�Å�Zn»�ʯZy�Âa�¶«Y|u�Z]���¶a�Ê·Â�¶°�Ì̤e�,�Z¬¿�]�{¼�Äv¨�ÉZfY�{�¾ÅM�y�ÉYmY�¹Z¼eY�Y�aA�

    � ÁB� ¶°�����¦·Y� ��Y|¬»� Z]� Á� Ã|� Ä^Zv»mmSpanall 613410 /�Y|¬»� Á� ÉY� Ä^ m� ¶a� ÉY]�mmRiseall 812820 /�{»� Ã|Ì]YÂy� Ê«� ¶a� ÉY]�

    dY� Äf§³� Y«� ÄËZ¬»� �� µÁ|m� Ä ·Z»� Y��� ��Ä]� ¶Ë}� lËZf¿dY�Ã|»M�d{����

    ��ÃZ�ÃÁ³�Zf§�cÁZ¨e�É| ]�Ä�¶Ì¸ve�lËZf¿��Ä^ m�ÉZÅ��Á�ÉYÃZ�ÃÁ³�Ê»�|ÌËPe�Y�Ã|Ì]YÂy�Ê«�ÉZÅ�ËZ¼¿À|�

    ��ÃZ� Zy� Ä|ÀÅ� d¸� Ä]��Ä^ m� ÉZÅ�ÉY,�Âa� ¶«Y|u�Ä^ m� ÃZ� ZÌ¿� {»�ʯZy��Ê«� ÃZ� Z]� Ä]Z»�ËY� {�ÉY

    dY�fÌ]�Ã|Ì]YÂy�� ��Ê»�½Z¿�µÁ|m�lËZf¿��¶Àa�į�|ÀÅ{�ÉZÅ�III�,IV�,V�Á�VI�Ä]�

    ÃZ� Zv·�ÃZ� Ê»Z¼e� ÉY]� ÉY�Ä^ m� ¶a� ÉZÀjfY� Ä]� ZÅ��Ä]� ÉY�Ä¿ZÅ{�����¶Àa�Z]�f»�III¿ZÅ{�Ä]�Ã|Ì]YÂy�Ê«�¶a�,�Ä�����

    �¶Àa�Z]�f»III��Ä¿ZÅ{�Ä]�Ã|Ì]YÂy�Ê«�¶a�Á�����¶Àa�Z]�f»�IV� d� {����|ÀZ]� Ê»� \ZÀ»� dZ� ]� f»Â¸Ì¯�� ��{

    �{�Ây�ʨ̯�t�Z]�y�ÉY]�kZmÂY�ÉY{YÁ�į�ÊeÂÃÆ]� µZu�¶Àa� ,{Â� Äf§³� ¿� {�ÉY{]�� ÉZÅIII� Á�IV�ÉY]�

    ÃZ�Ê»Z¼e�ÃZ�Zv·�Ä]�ZÅ�»�ÉY{Â]�|ÅYÂy�\ZÀ�� ��½Âf�ÄËZ¬»��¶Ì¸ve�Y�¶Zu�ʯZy�Âa�Z¨eY�ÉZÅ��ÉZÅ

    Ê»�½Z¿�É| ]�Ä�Á�É| ]�Á{��{»�ʯZy�Âa�Z¨eY�į�|Å{¶Ì¸ve�{�ZÌ¿�dY�É| ]�Á{�lËZf¿�Y�f¼¯�É| ]�Ä�ÉZÅ���d¸

    Ê»� Y�»�¾ËY��Êfz�¾ÌÀr¼Å�Á�y�Êfz�ÌiPe� {�½YÂe�{�É| ]�Ä�µ|»�Ê^¿Zm�ÄnÌf¿�{�Á�ºfÌ�¶¯�Êfz�ËY§Y

    d¿Y{�d¿�ÅZ¯� ���½Âf� ÄËZ¬»�¶Ì¸ve� ºWZ«�d¿�ÉZÅ��Ä� Á�É| ]� Á{�ÉZÅ

    Ê»�½Z¿�É| ]��Ä�µ|»�Ê^¿Zm�Êfz� Á�y�Êfz�į�|Å{{Y{�ºfÌ�¶¯�d¿�ÅZ¯�{�ÊÆmÂe�¶]Z«�iY�É| ]���dÆm

    ¶a� ,ÄnÌf¿�¾ËY� Y� fÌ]�½ZÀ̼Y�Ä^ m�ÉZÅ�� Ä¿ZÅ{� Ä]�ÉY����,�����Á�����¹¿�{�f»���Y§YPLAXIS 3D�Á{�µ|»�|À¿Z¼Å�

    ÄÌ^�É| ]�|Ë{³�ÉZ� ��ZÌ]� ,µ|»�¹Â�| ]� ´Ë{�cZ^�Ä]{� Z¿�|� Äf§³� ¿� ��Âa� ¹Ó� Z¨eY� Á� d¿� lËZf¿

    µ|»�Ä]Z»� 0Z¬Ì«{�ʯZy�]�É| ]�Á{�ÉZÅ�Ä|»M�d{|¿»�į�R�|ËÉ| ]�Ä�µ|»�Ê^¿Zm�Êfz�ÄmÂe�¶]Z«�iY�d¿�ÅZ¯�{�

    Ê»�ºWZ«�|Z]��

    ���Ê»�½Z¿�É| ]�Ä�¶Ì¸ve�{�y�kZmÂY�½Âf�Ä ·Z»��|Å{¶a� kZmÂY� ÅZ¯� {� ¶Àa� Êfz� ËY§Y� iY� į��Ê«� ÉZÅ

    dY�fÌ]�Ã|Ì]YÂy�� ���Ê»�Zf¿Y�ʸ¯�Â�Ä]��Ä¿ZÅ{�ËY§Y� Z]�y�kZmÂY�į�{Á

    Ä¿ZÅ{� Y� Êy]� {� Z»Y� |]ZË� {ZË{Y�]� Ây� Ä]� ZŶa� ÉY��ÉZÅÄ^ m�ÅZ¯�,ÉY�Ê»�Ã|ÅZ»�kZmÂY�ʠ»�ÉZÅ�{Â���Ä]�»Y�¾ËY

    �½{Â]�fÌ]�Á�Ê·YÂf»�¬»�Á{�{�d¿�¥ÔfyY�½{Â]�½Z°ËÊ»]� ,f³]� ¶a� {� ¬»� Á{� ĸZ§�{{³� ��{� ´Ë{�cZ^� Ä]

    cÂ�kZmÂY�Ä]Y��kz»�Z»Y�Ã{Â]�Ä]Z»�¶a�Á{�ÉY]�¯�ÉZÅÌ]� ,f³]�¶a�ÉY]� ¯�kZmÂY�ÅZ¯� Ä]� nÀ»� į�dY� f

    Ê»�¹Á{�¶a�ÉY]�{Â� ���ʯZy�Âa�¶«Y|u�]YÁ�sÔY���

    � {¶°�� ÉZÅ��� �� Á��� �¶a� ʯZy� Âa� ¶«Y|u��ÉZÅÄ^ m�¶Ì¸ve�Ã|Ì]YÂy�Ê«�Á�ÉY��{»�É| ]�Ä�Á�É| ]�Á{�ÉZÅ

    Äf§³�Y«�ÄËZ¬»�Y|¿��Ê»�½Z¿�Y�Ë�lËZf¿�ZÅY{¼¿�Ä ·Z»�|Å{�������ZÆÀe¶Àa�lËZf¿��ÉZÅVIµ|»�{���Ä]�É| ]�Ä�Á�É| ]�Á{�ÉZÅ

    Ê»�ª^À»�´Ë|°Ë�]�{Á|v»�LYmY�¶Ì¸ve�Zv·��lËZf¿� Á�|ÀZ]µ|»� Y�¶Zu�ÄuÔ»�¶]Z«� Â�Ä]�É| ]� Á{�ÉZÅ��Ä]�d^¿�ÉY

    ħZv»�É| ]�Ä�lËZf¿�dY�Ä¿YZ¯� ��¶Àa�lËZf¿�©Z^¿Y�d¸��ÉZÅVIµ|»�{��Ä]�Ì¿�É| ]�Ä�Á�É| ]�Á{�ÉZÅ{�d¸���¾f§³�¿

    �¾ÌËZa� |u���µfÀ¯�¦«Âe� Á�ʯZy�Âa�¶«Y|u�ÉY]� f»��Y�f¼¯�Z¨eY�{�ʯZy�Âa��f»��dY���

    ���ÊÀvÀ»� ÄËZ¬»�¶Àa� ÉZÅ�Á{� ÉZÅ��½Z¿� É| ]� Ä� Á� É| ]Ê»�¶Àa�į�|Å{��ÉZÅIV�Ze�VI¶a�ÉY]�É| ]�Ä�¶Ì¸ve�{���ÉZÅ

    Ä^ m�ÌÌ e� Ã{Á|v»� {� Ã|Ì]YÂy� Ê«� Á� ÉY�Âe� Ã|� ¾�{Y|¿ZfYAASHTO�Á�CHBDC|¿Y{�Y«����Á{�¶Ì¸ve�{�Z»Y¶Àa� É| ]�� ÉZÅIV� Á�V� Ä¿ZÅ{� ¶a� ÉY]�������j¯Y� Á� f»�

    ¶a�Ä^ m� ÉZÅ�� ZÅ{Y|¿ZfY� Ã{Á|v»� Ë� {� ÉY���f»�� ��Y«Ê¼¿�|¿Ì³���

    ���¶Àa� lËZf¿� ÄËZ¬»��½Z¿� É| ]� Ä� Á� É| ]� Á{� Ä]Z»� ÉZÅÊ»�u�]YÁ�{�į�|Å{�\Ë�®Ë�É| ]�Á{�ʯZy�Âa�¶«Y|

    {{³�µZ¼Y�|ËZ]�ÊÅZ¯�sÔY�������������

  • �� / ÄË¿��|¸m�,dË�Ìv»�Á�½Y¼�Ê|ÀÆ»���,�ÃZ¼��½Zf]Ze�,�����ÊaZÌa�,��������������������������������������¶«Y|u�É´·Y�sÔY���� �����

    BOX

    0

    1

    2

    3

    4

    5

    6

    7

    8

    9

    7.5 8.5 9.5 10.5 11.5 12.5 13.5

    �m��Ä¿ZÅ{

    �m� ʯZy

    �Â

    a�Z¨eY�¶

    «Y|u Panel(IV)-2D

    Panel(V)-2D

    Panel(VI)-2D

    Panel(IV)-3D

    Panel(V)-3D

    Panel(VI)-3D

    AASHTO Max limit

    Bending limit

    Panel(III)-2D

    Panel(III)-3D

    ��� �

    �¶°��¶a�¹Ó�ʯZy�Âa�¶«Y|u�lËZf¿�ÄËZ¬»��Ä^ m�É{Ó§�ʯZy�ÉZÅ�¶Ì¸ve�Y�¶Zu�ÉY��d�{�É| ]�Ä�Á�É| ]�Á{�ÉZÅkm/hr�������

    LPA

    0

    1

    2

    3

    4

    5

    6

    7

    13.5 15.5 17.5 19.5 21.5 23.5

    �m��Ä¿ZÅ{

    �m� ʯZy

    �Âa�Z̈eY�¶

    «Y|u

    Panel(IV)-2D

    Panel(V)-2D

    Panel(VI)-2D

    Panel(IV)-3D

    Panel(V)-3D

    Panel(VI)-3D

    CHBDC Max limit

    Bending limit

    Panel(III)-2D

    Panel(III)-3D

    ��� �

    �¶°���¶a�¹Ó�ʯZy�Âa�¶«Y|u�lËZf¿�ÄËZ¬»��«�É{Ó§�ʯZy�ÉZŶ̸ve�Y�¶Zu�Ã|Ì]YÂy�ÊÂ��{�É| ]�Ä�Á�É| ]�Á{�ÉZÅ�dkm/hr�����

    ��½M� Y�¶Àa�É| ]�Ä�¶Ì¸ve� {�į� Zm�¦Ì �ÉZÅ��Âa�e

    É«�¶Àa�Ä]Z»�ʯZy�]�Y�É| ]�Á{�¶Ì¸ve�{�e�ÄÊ»�d{��,|Å{Ê»��{� |ËZ]� ÊËY§Y� sÔY� \Ë� ®Ë� į� d§³� ÄnÌf¿� ½YÂe

    �]YÁ�ÊÀËY�½Z¼»�Âf¯Z§�kz»�É| ]�Á{�¶Ì¸ve�Y�¶Zu@�>�{Â�µZ¼Y�¶Ë}�¶°�Ä]��ÊÀ Ë�

    ��¶a�ÉY]�Ä^ m�ÉZÅ�ÉY��

    hDeI

    VH 0.33330.4973

    1

    3min )

    54495166.15()

    120(0.0139

    �����

    ¶a�ÉY]�Ã|Ì]YÂy�Ê«�ÉZÅ� ��

    hDeI

    VH 0.16670.4873

    2

    5min )

    54495166.15()

    120(0.0120

    ��� ��

    ����©Â§�]YÁ�{V����,Z«�d�I�������É{ÓÂ/§�cZv¨/�ÊÀËY�½Z¼»�k»��Á�Y{DhÊ»�ÃZ�Ä¿ZÅ{��|ÀZ]�

    � Ä]�dÆm�\ËY�½{ÁM�d{1Á��2�Y]�Á� Y�dY� Ã|� Ã{Z¨fY�cZ ]»� ¾Ëf¼¯�\ˬe� Z]� ÊÀvÀ»� ��¾ËY]ZÀ]

    �d�ÉY]km/hr������

  • �� / ÄË¿��|¸m�,dË�Ìv»�Á�½Y¼�Ê|ÀÆ»���,�ÃZ¼��½Zf]Ze�,�����ÊaZÌa�,��������������������������������������¶«Y|u�É´·Y�sÔY���� �����

    ¶a�ÉY]�Ä^ m�ÉZÅ�ÉY� hDe

    IH 0.33320.4873min1 )10.18

    54495166.15(0.014310.18

    ���������

    ¶a�ÉY]�Ã|Ì]YÂy�Ê«�ÉZÅ���hDe

    IH 0.15820.4873min2 )6.02

    54495166.15(0.01206.02

    �������

    � Á~n»RÄ]Y� ª^� SST

    SSER 12�½M� {� į

    2)( ii YYSSE �Á� n

    YYSST ii

    22

    )()(Ê»���,|ÀZ]

    ¶a�ÉY]�Ä^ m�ÉZÅ�¶Àa�É̳¿{� Z]� Ã|Ì]YÂy�Ê«� Á�ÉY��ÉZÅIII� Ze�V� Z]� ]Y]� \Ìee� Ä]����� Á����{� Z]� Á� �É̳¿¶Àa��ÉZÅIII� Á�IV� Z]� ]Y]����� Á����dY� Ã|»M�d{� Ä]���

    {�d¸��¶Àa�¾f§´¿�¿VI�ÅZ¯�Á�Zy�ËY§Y�2R�d¸�Ä]�Ê»� ZÌ¿� {»�|u�Y�Ì]�dˬe�|Z]� �Å�į�dY� ¯}�½ZËZ�

    � |¬q2R�kYzfY� Ä]Y� į�dY� ÊÀ »� ¾Ë|]� ,|Z]� f³]�ªÌ«{�Ã|�dY�e� �� ,´Ë{�cZ^�Ä]�ʯZy�Âa�¶«Y|u�Ä]Y¶a� ÉY]�dY� Y{Ây]� ÉfÌ]� d«{� Y� Ã|Ì]YÂy� Ê«� ÉZÅ��

    � ÅZ¯� d¸2R�,É| ]� Á{� Ä]� d^¿� É| ]� Ä� ]YÁ� ÉY]��¶Àa�lËZf¿�iY�ÅZ¯V�Á�VI�{�2R�{Y| e�½{Â]�e{ZË�d¸�Ä]�

    Ã{Y{�Á{�¶Ì¸ve� {� ZÅ�dY�É| ]� �M� Y½��LYmY�¶Ì¸ve� {� į� Zm{Á|v»,� Y� f¼¯� ʯZy�Âa� Z¨eY���{� f»���Äf§³� ¿

    �ÉÂXe� Ä]Y� lËZf¿� Á� {Á|v»� LYmY� lËZf¿� ¥ÔfyY� ,dY� Ã|¿Ã{Y{� {Y| e� {�ÊÆmÂe�¶]Z«�ÉZy� {ZnËY�hZ]��Ã|Ë{³�º¯�ÉZÅ

    dY���������������,ʯZy�Âa�ËY§Y�Y�[ZÀfmY�Á�¿Z¼¯�ZÌ »�Ä]�ÄmÂe�Z]

    �Ê»�{ZÆÀÌa������{Y|¿ZfY�|À¿Z¼Å�į�{ÂCHBDC����Ä/]�©Â/§�]YÁ�]�¶Ë}�¶°�Ä|¿Á�Z¯�

    ¶a�ÉY]�Ä^ m�ÉZÅ�ÉY���

    hDeI

    H

    m

    m

    H

    0.33330.4973

    min

    )10.18

    54495166.15(0.0139

    0.5max

    1.5

    min

    ����

    ¶a�ÉY]�Ã|Ì]YÂy�Ê«�ÉZÅ�

    hDeI

    H

    m

    m

    H

    0.16670.4873

    min

    )6.02

    54495166.15(0.0120

    0.5max

    1.5

    min

    ��

    ���� ��¼m��ÄnÌf¿�Á�É|À]�É̳��

    ÃZ�ÊÀ§�cZÌ]{Y�{�ʯZy�ÉZÅ��¾ÌÌ^e�]YÁ�Ã|¼�É{Ó§�� Ã|¶a�ÉY]��ÉY]� ZÅ{Y|¿ZfY� {�¾ÅM� ÃY�É{Ó§�ʯZy�ÉZÅ

    ¶a��Y�f°q¯�ÉZÅ�Ä]Y� ZÆÀe�Á�Ã{Â]�f»��¶a�ÉY]�į�ÉY��ÉZÅ�Y�f³]��{Y|¿ZfY�Âe�f»�CHBDC]� ,dY�Ã|�ÄWYY��

    �dY� Ã|� ½ZÌ]� ÃY� ÉY~³Z]� ZY� ��Zy� ʳËÁ� dÆm� Ä]^Zv»� |Ë|m�É´·Y�¾f§ZË� ,¾ÅM� ÃY�ÉY~³Z]�Âa�¶«Y|u� Ä

    �¿� Ä]� ÉÁ� ¾ÅM� ÃY� ]YÂ� Á� ZÅZÌ »� Ä]� ÄmÂe� Z]� ʯZyÊ»�|� ��{Á|v»�LYmY�É| ]� Á{�¶Ì¸ve� Y� Ã{Z¨fY� Z]� ,Á�¾ËY�Y

    �¾ÌÌa�cZ¬Ì¬ve� {�ʯZy�Âa�¶«Y|u�¾ÌÌ e� |Ë|m�É´·YdY�Ã|Ë{³�kYzfY� ��{�É| ]�Á{�µ|»�{�į�¾ËY�Ä]�¿�Z»Y

    {�Z]�ËÂe�iY�¾f§³�¿½Z°»Y�ÃZ�µÂ���{�-dY�Ã{Â^¿�Ë~a�LYmY�É| ]�Ä�¶Ì¸ve�Y�Ã{Z¨fY�Z]�Ze�|Ë{³�Ôe�ªÌ¬ve�¾ËY�É´·Y�,¹Â�| ]�{�Z]�ËÂe�Á�y�LYmY�½{¯�µ|»�Z]�{Á|v»

    {{³� sÔY�É| ]� Á{�¶Ì¸ve� {� Ã|»M�d{� Ä]� ��ZfY�¾ËY� {dY�Ã|�Ã{¼Ìa�ʯZy�É´·Y�sÔY�dÆm�¶Ë}�¶uY»���

    �� �Yd¿� kYzf�]� ºWZ«� Zn»� ÉZÅ�� d� ZY����dZ�]�f»Â¸Ì¯,��

    �� �]� Zn»� kZmÂY� kYzfY � d� ZY����]� f»Â¸Ì¯�|Ë|m�Ây�ʨ̯�t�Á�dZ�gY|uÓY,��

    �� �¶a� ¶Ì¸ve��Á� d¿� µfÀ¯� Á� ¦¸fz»� ʯZy�Âa� Z]� ZÅÌ̤e�,y�kZmÂY�¿Z¼¯�Á�ÃZ�Ê·Â�¶°,��

    ���y�Âa�¶«Y|u�¾ÌÌ e�-©Â§�ÉZÅZÌ »�Ä]�ÄmÂe�Z]�¶a�Å�ʯZ�����Äf{�]�lËZf¿�É|À]�ĵÁ|m�{�Ã|»M�d{,���� �¶Ì¸ve�ʯZy�Âa�¶«Y|u�lËZf¿�ÄËZ¬»��Z]�É| ]�Ä�ÉZÅ

    ¶Ì¸ve� Y� ¶Zu� ʯZy�Âa�Á{� ÉZÅ�Ä¿ZÅ{� ÉY]� É| ]��ÉZÅÌ¿Á���

    ����Á�Ä]�½M�kYzfY�Á�ÊuÔY�\Ë�¶v»�½{¼¿�z»Ë¬e�Z]�ÊÀvÀ»�Y]cZ ]»�¾Ëf¼¯�\���

    �Âa�j¯Y|u�Z]�É| ]�Ä�¶Ì¸ve�Y�¶Zu�lËZf¿�ÄËZ¬»� Âe� Ã|� ¾ÌÌ e� ʯZyAASHTO� Á�CHBDC�½Z¿�

  • �� / ÄË¿��|¸m�,dË�Ìv»�Á�½Y¼�Ê|ÀÆ»���,�ÃZ¼��½Zf]Ze�,�����ÊaZÌa�,��������������������������������������¶«Y|u�É´·Y�sÔY���� �����

    Ê»�� d� Á� ÉY~³Z]� Ä]� ÄmÂe� Z]� į� |Å{����]� f»Â¸Ì¯�¶Àa�,dZ��ÉZÅIV�Ze�VI«�ÉY]�Ê^ZÀ»�Z¬»���ɸ§�ÉZÅ

    ¶a�Ê»�¾ÅM�ÃY�É{Ó§�ʯZy�ÉZÅ�|ÀZ]� �� Á~n»R�]YÁ�ÉY]�¶a�Ä^ m�ÉZÅ�{�Z]�Ã|Ì]YÂy�Ê«�Á�ÉY�¶Àa�É̳¿��ÉZÅIII�Ze�V�Z]�]Y]�\Ìee�Ä]�����Á����{�Z]�Á��¶Àa�É̳¿��ÉZÅIII��ÁIV�Z]�]Y]�����Á����]��Ä�0Zf^¿�\ˬe�į�dY�Ã|»M�d{

    Ã{Y{�Z]�Y�Ã|�sÔY�]YÁ�[Ây�Ê»�½Z¿�ZÅ�|Å{���Ê»�{ZÆÀÌa�ËY�{Â]�ZÌfuY�Z]�©Â§�]YÁ�{�ÊuÔY�\�Ä

    {Á� Z¯� �ʸ� YË�½M� º£��¹Â� | ]� Êfz� Á� y� Êfz� į{Y{�ʯZy�Âa�¶«Y|u�Ä]Y�]�ÊÅZ¯�iY�,ºfÌ-�Ä�Z»Y�

    �]YÁ� {�ÊÀ¼ËY�\Ë� Á� Z]� Y°e� ,d�¶»Z� ºÆ»� f»YZa�ÊeM� cZ¬Ì¬ve� {� ÊfËZ]� į� dY{� |ÀÅYÂy� ÊËY§Y� iY� ©Â§

    ]�{»|¿Ì³�Y«�Ê���� ��mY»���]�[� ����,©Y·Y|^�ÊmZu_�,���������ÃZ/�É|/ ]�Ä/�¶/̸ve���ÉZ/Å

    �¾//ÅM�ÃY�É{ÓÂ//§�ʯZ//y��//Âa�¶«Y|//u�{//°ËÁ�Z//]ʯZy����½Z/ËZa�,����������Ã|°/¿Y{�,|/Y�Ê/ZÀZ¯�ÃÁ{�Ä/»Z¿

    �����������,½Y/Æe�,½Y/ËY�d À�Á�º¸�ÃZ´¿Y{�,¾ÅM�ÃY�Ê|ÀÆ»�,½YËY�������

    [2] Abdel-Sayed, G., Bakht. B., Jaeger, L. G., "Soil-steel Bridges, Design and Construction", McGraw-Hill Inc, Toronto, Canada, 1993.

    [3] Corrugated Steel Pipe Institute & American Iron and Steel Institute, "Handbook of Steel Drainage & Highway Construction Products",�Canadian Edition, USA, 2002.

    [4] California Transportation Board "CALTRANS Bridge Design Specifications", California, USA, 2000.

    [5] British Design Manual for Roads and Bridges, "Design of Corrugated Steel Buried Structures with Spans Greater than 0.9 Meters and Up to 8.0 Meters", BD12/01, Vol.2, Section 2, Part 6, Great Britain, 2001.

    [6] American Association of States Highway and Transportation Officials, "AASHTO Highway Bridges", Second Edition, USA, 2000.

    [7] Moser, A. P., "Buried Pipe Design", McGraw-Hill, 2nd English Edition, 1993.

    [8] ASTM A 796/A 796M, "Standard Practice for Structural Design of Corrugated Steel Pipe, Pipe-Arches, and Arches for Storm and Sanitary Sewers and Other Buried Applications", USA, 1982.

    [9] ARTC, "Buried Corrugated Metal Structures", Australian Rail Track Corporation, Australia, 1982.

    [10] Canadian Standards Association, "Commentary on CAN/CSA-S6-00,�Canadian Highway Bridge Design Code, S6.1-00�, Ontario, Canada, 2001.

    [11] Brinkgreve, R. B. J., Vermeer, P. A., "PLAXIS 3D Tunnel Manual", Version1, A. A. Balkema Publishers, Netherlands, 2001.

    ]��[� �� ,Äm{Â]� Á� Ä»Z¿]� ½Z»Z��ʻ¼� ÊÀ§� cZz»¾ÅM� ÃY� ÉZÁ�� ÃZ¼� ÄË¿� ,����,ÊÀ§� d¿ÁZ »� ,

    �,½YËY�,½YÆe�,ÊÀ§�ÉZÅZÌ »�Á�cZ¬Ì¬ve�f§{�������]�� [� �� ,Äm{Â]� Á� Ä»Z¿]� ½Z»Z"¾ÌËM�¶a� ÉY~³Z]� Ä»Z¿�ZÅ��,

    ÄË¿� ÃZ¼�����Á� cZ¬Ì¬ve� f§{� ,ÊÀ§� d¿ÁZ »� ,�,ÊÀ§�ÉZÅZÌ »�������

    [14] El-sawy, K. M., "Three-Dimensional Modeling of Soil-Steel Culverts under the Effect of Truckloads", Thin-Walled Structures, 2003, 41, 747-768.

    ]��[� ���,©Y·Y|/^�ÊmZu�_��,�������ÃZ/�Ê°ÌeZf/Y�¶/̸ve��ÉZ/Å���������Z/«�d/¯u�/iY�dve�É{Ó§�ʯZy�����ÃÁ{�ZÀ̼/�,

    ���������ÃZ´/¿Y{�,¾/ÅM�ÃY�Ê|ÀÆ»�Ã|°¿Y{�,|Y�ÊZÀZ¯�,½YËY�,½YÆe�,½YËY�d À�Á�º¸�������

    ]�� [� ������,Äm{Â]�Á�Ä»Z¿]�½Z»Z"��cZ/¿�Á�ÊuY�¶¼ ·YÂf{����Ë�¾ÅM�ÃY�ÉZÁ�]��Ì/·Y�������ÃZ¼/�ÄË/¿�,����,���Z¬Ì¬ve�f§{�,ÊÀ§�d¿ÁZ »��������,½Y/Æe�,Ê/À§�ÉZ/ÅZÌ »�Á�c

    �,½YËY�������]��[� �ɯY}�k�,���,�,Ã{YZ��¹��,���Á�������/y�ÉY|/Æ´¿�ÉZÅ

    ¾ÅM�������������,½Y/Æe�,½Y/ËY�d À/�Á�º/¸�ÃZ´¿Y{�cYZf¿Y�,�,½YËY�������

  • Journal of Civil and Environmental Engineering sŽůƵŵĞ�ϰϯ͕�/ƐƐƵĞ�Ϯ, Summer�ϮϬϭϯ VI-1

    * Corresponding Author E-mail addresses: [email protected] (Morteza Esmaeili), [email protected] (Jabbar Ali Zakeri), [email protected] (Parisa Haji Abdulrazagh).

    EXTENDED ABSTRACTS Modification of Railway Soil-Steel Bridges Minimum Depth of Cover Using Three Dimensional Finite Element Analysis Morteza Esmaeili a, Jabbar Ali Zakeri a,*, Parisa Haji Abdulrazagh b

    a School of Railway Engineering, Iran University of Science & Technologyǡ���ͷͼ;ͺͼͷͷͷͺ, Iran

    b School of Civil Engineering, University of Tehran, ��ͷͷͷͻͻͺͻͼ, Iran

    Received:�Ϭϵ February�ϮϬϭϮ; Accepted: Ϭϵ August�ϮϬϭϮ

    Keywords: Minimum depth of cover, Railway soil-steel bridge, Three-dimensional finite element analysis, Modification of minimum depth of cover

    ͳǤ��

    Soil-steel structures recently have been used extensively in different countries as a highway or railroad bridge. Due to the licity and ease of construction method, these structures were successful variants in the road-railway unleveled crosses projects. Common standard formulas for minimum depth of cover are based on highway loading pattern with significance of preventing soil tensile and wedge sliding failures. Modification of minimum depth of cover for railway bridges is needed not only in respect to different modes of soil failure but also for non-uniform soil settlement which endangers the safety of railway track. Therefore, regarding permissible track settlement and wall buckling control, new pattern of minimum depth of cover was developed for boxes and high-profile arches individually using 2D finite element analysis. However, three dimensional distribution of railroad could not be taken into account by 2D FE method. Therefore, modification of developed pattern with attitudes toward longitudinal distribution of railway load is the scope of this study. In this paper, regarding permissible track settlement, railway twist, longitudinal settlement of the structure and wall buckling control, the minimum depth of 32 structures with spans greater than 8 meters was determined by 3D finite element analysis. Then the resulted pattern was compared to those obtained from 2D analyses. Finally, the modification factors were calculated by least squares method and new formulas were established for boxes and high-profile arches individually. ʹ. Methodology

    The primary objective of the current study is to introduce a new set of minimum soil cover equations for long-span railway bridges based on the numerical interpolation of results of the 2D FE analyses. To determine the variation trend of the minimum depth of cover along with its governing parameters (geometry, length of span and the panel stiffness) through numerical analyses, the permissible settlement of the track, metal structure buckling and soil body failure criteria have been checked initially for each bridge structure for a 0.6 m depth of cover (the minimum limit of cover depth specified by CHBDC). When all of the defined criteria were not fulfilled simultaneously, the depth of soil cover above the crown was increased, and the analyses were then restarted for a new depth of cover. The minimum depth of cover in which all of the criteria were simultaneously fulfilled was chosen as the minimum depth of soil cover for a specific bridge structure. In this manner, the results of the 2D FE analyses present specific patterns for the calculation of the minimum depth of cover for box culverts and low-profile arches. In order to check the applicability of the proposed equations for minimum depth of cover in practical problems, a series of 3D finite element analyses with more realistic idealization of the railway superstructure components and the lateral slope of bridge embankment were carried out-of-plane the out of plan buckling in the steel plates.

    id13155609 pdfMachine by Broadgun Software - a great PDF writer! - a great PDF creator! - http://www.pdfmachine.com http://www.broadgun.com

    mailto:[email protected]:[email protected]:[email protected]

  • Morteza Esmaeili et al. / J. Civ. Enǀ͘��ŶŐ͘�ϰϯ�;ϮϬϭϯͿ V1-2

    .ͷ. FE modeling

    The multi-purpose FEM-based software package, PLAXIS was used for the numerical modeling and analysis. Regarding to the special serviceability criteria for railway bridges, for computing the minimum depth of cover, the permissible settlement of the railway track and the buckling of the conduit walls in different sections along the longitudinal axis of the bridges in 3D analyses were controlled. For these cases, the spans from 8.07 m up to 13.46 m of box culverts and 14.13 m up to 23.40 m of low-profile arches using stiffened and non-stiffened deep corrugated panels have been considered. This study assumes that all the metal structures are buried in well-graded gravel (GW) as engineered backfill material [1]. The material nonlinearity of the soil and metal structure as well as the stage construction effects were accounted for in the numerical analyses, and the railway load model LM71 [2] was applied. ͵. Results and discussion

    ǤͷǤ�The r��������finite element analyses

    As a result of various numerical analyses and satisfying the aforementioned criteria, the minimum depth of cover was evaluated against the span of railway box and low-profile arch bridges using various panel types (stiffness). This is due to the different structural geometry of the boxes and results in a different mechanism of behavior under the loading. In order to account for the moment of inertia, the speed and length of span which are the representative of panel stiffness, the effect of dynamic factor and geometry of metal structure, the basic form of the minimum depth of cover for the railway boxes and high-profile arches is introduced as�

    hDVI eI

    IVH )()

    120(min

    (1)

    Where á, â, ã and µ are unknown constants. These constants were calculated separately for the boxes and low-profile arches by using the least-squares method (LSM) to determine the function of best fit�

    An approach similar to the 2D analysis was used for the results of the 3D FE method, which resulted in modifications to the previously developed equations. The major finding of the comparison between the results of the 2D and 3D FE analyses was that the resulting minimum depth of cover from the 3D FE analysis was smaller compared to the 2D FE results for the same conditions. This difference was due to the stiffening effects of the railway track due to the third dimension of the bridge that was considered for the analysis. Therefore, the difference between the 2D and 3D FE results can be accounted for by using the reduction factor in the (IVI/I) ratio. Consequently, Eq. (1) can be modified as:

    hDeI

    VH 0.33330.4973

    1

    3min )

    54495166.15()

    120(0.0143

    for boxes (2)

    hDe

    I

    VH 0.15820.4873

    2

    5min )

    54495166.15()

    120(0.0120

    for low-profile arches (3)

    where 18.101 and 02.62 were calculated by using the least-squares method for a train speed of 120 km/h.

    The R-squared values of Eqs. (2) and (3) are R2=0.84 and R2=0.97 for the box culverts and low-profile arches with panels (III) and (IV), respectively.

    ǤǤ�Validity range of the derived equations

    The conformity of Equations (2) and (3) with 2D and 3D results was evaluated using an R-squared value that

    was calculated by using R2=1-SSE/SST, where SSE= 2)( ii YY and SST=(2

    iY )-[(Yi)2]/n. For panels III and V,

    the R-squared values for Eqs. (2) and (3) were 0.67 and 0.88, respectively. Panels I and II were eliminated from the calculations because the 2D FE analysis demonstrated that these panels were not suitable for soil-steel railway bridges. The minimum depth of cover calculated from the 3D FE analysis of bridges with panel VI represented a depth of cover less than 0.6 m. A minimum of 0.6 m was maintained for railway track maintenance (complete removal of ballast layer in some operations). Therefore, the data for panel VI was not considered in the calculation of the R-squared values. Consequently, the limited amount of data for 3D FE analysis resulted in equations with less accuracy. The results of the 2D and 3D FE analysis were compared to the standard limits and are shown in Fig. 1. Regarding the maintenance operations, buckling criterion and AASHTO [3] and CHBDC [4] limits, a recommended minimum of 0.5 m and maximum of 1.5 m must be maintained for the depth of cover by using the following expressions:

  • Morteza Esmaeili et al. / J. Civ. Enǀ͘��ŶŐ͘�ϰϯ�;ϮϬϭϯͿ V1-3

    hDeI

    H

    m

    m

    H

    0.33330.4973

    min

    )10.18

    54495166.15(0.0139

    0.5max

    1.5

    min for boxes (120 km/h) (4)

    hDeI

    H

    m

    m

    H

    0.16670.4873

    min

    )6.02

    54495166.15(0.0120

    0.5max

    1.5

    min for low-profile arches (120 km/h) (5)

    Fig. 1. The results of 2D FE analyses in comparison with the values of: (a) Box formula and the AASHTO limit, (b) LPA formula and the CHBDC limit

    Ͷ. Conclusions

    The minimum depth of cover requirements given by different codes are typically based on vehicle loads, non-stiffened panels and only the geometrical shape of the metal structure to avoid the failure of soil cover above a soil-steel bridge. In this paper, the effects of spans larger than 8 meters (using stiffened panels under railway loads) are investigated using an FE analysis. For this study, 2D and 3D FE analyses of four low-profile arches and four box culverts with spans larger than 8 meters were performed to develop new patterns for the minimum depth of soil cover. Using the least-squares method to adopt the best-fit equation of the numerical data, two new sets of formulas were recommended� Based on the numerical results, the primary research findings are summarized as follows� 1) The minimum depth of cover increases exponentially along with an increase in the span of boxes and low-profile arches. 2) The efficiency of the stiffened panels in reduction of the required cover depth is more pronounced for large spans. 3) Different trends of the minimum depth of cover were determined for box bridges and low-profile arches. This difference is due to the various structural geometry of the boxes that resulted in a different mechanism of behavior under the loading. 4) The modified exponential forms of the minimum depth of cover for railway boxes and high-profile arches is applicable for a train speed of 120 km/h and exhibits relatively good conformity with 3D FE results (R2 > 0.6). 5) With respect to the permissible settlement criterion, panels with EI greater than 33062 (kN.m2/m) are found to be the only suitable panels that can be used for high speeds trains (greater than 160 km/h) for railway box and low-profile bridges.

    ͷ. References

    [1] Abdel-Sayed, G., Salib, S. R., Minimum Depth of Soil Cover above Soil-Steel Bridges, Journal of Geotechnical and Geoenvironmental Engineering, 2002, 128 (8), 672-681.

    [2] European Committee for Standardization, Euro code 1: Actions on Structures: Part 2- Traffic Loads on Bridges, prEN 1991-2, Brussels; 2002.

    [3] AASHTO Highway Bridges, Soil-Corrugated Metal Structure Interaction Systems, Second Edition, American Association of States Highway and Transportation Officials, USA, 2000.

    [4] National Standard of Canada, CHBDC CAN/CSA-S6-00: Buried Structures, CSA International, 2006.