Upload
kim-keat
View
215
Download
0
Embed Size (px)
Citation preview
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
1/82
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
2/82
Do We Have a Choice?Towards more compassionate eating
Chan Kah Yein, Ph.D
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
3/82
For all the humble birds and beasts.
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
4/82
This book is a gift from others to you.
If you have enjoyed reading it, please pass it on.
Let it be your gift to others.
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
5/82
About the Author
Chan Kah Yein holds a Ph.D in Mathe-
matics Education and teaches in a private
college. She is the founder-coordinator
of AnimalCare, a medical fund for stray
animals. She also gives public talks regu-
larly on ways to lead a simpler and more
spiritually fullling life. To date, she has
written seven books, and many of her
talks have been produced on audio CDs,
all for free distribution. With a love for all
things small and simple, her motto is to
embrace simplicity and travel light in life.
Kah Yein can be reached at
All her e-books can be downloaded free at
http://tiny.cc/paws
Her AnimalCare work is documented in
www.myanimalcare.org
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
6/82
Also by the Author
Books
Pawprints on My Heart, 2008Seven Little Stories about Kindness to Animals
Little Steps, Joyful Steps, 2008The Humble Beginnings of a Dhamma Speaker
A Kite in the Wind, 2008Embrace Simplicity, Travel Light in Life
Indy Jones & the 4 Pillars of Kindness, 2009 A Story about Love, Compassion, Rejoicing and Letting Go
See You at Rainbow Bridge, 2010Saying Goodbye with Love and Serenity
Make Time While the Sun Shines, 2011 Anecdotes on Respecting Time and Tide
Audio Talks in CDs
How to Practise Right Livelihood and Still be Rich, 2006
Kindness to Animals, 2007
Awakening Kindness, 2007Creating Heaven in an Imperfect World, 2008
Dewdrops from My Heart, 2009 A Treasury of 28 Talks
Fragrance of the Violet, 2011 A Treasury of 20 Talks
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
7/82
The love for all creatures
is the noblest attribute of man.
— Charles Darwin
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
8/82
Contents
Acknowledgements
Prologue 1
1 The Lady in the Orange Saree 3
2 The Chick in the Burger 5
3 Are We Natural Vegetarians? 9
4 Old MacDonald’s Farm 135 Lessons from the Cows and the Crabs 21
6 Going Meatless Once a Week 27
7 Let’s Just Do it! 29
8 Of Onions, Garlic and Special Chopsticks 31
9 Hara Hachi Bu 33
10 The PB&J Club (for the Young-at-Heart) 3511 Of Aliens and Futuristic Apes 39
12 Reducing Our Carbon Footprint 49
13 All it Takes is Just 10% 51
14 Of Slaughterhouses and Battleelds 53
15 The Compassion of a Great King 55
16 Who Lives Longer? 59
17 Famous Vegetarians 61
18 Take Your Pick 63
19 A Daily Gentle Reminder 65
Epilogue 67
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
9/82
Acknowledgements
My heartfelt thanks go to TY Lee for his valuable feedback on
my draft and his spontaneous generous sponsorship without
which this book would not even be published; Andy Koh, for
his very constructive feedback and review, and his immense
contribution to Chapter 11; and Lum Woon Foong for her
meticulous editing and proof-reading, a skill which I have yet
to pick up even after writing seven books (!). I also wish to
thank Hor Tuck Loon for spending time away from his very
busy schedule to do the beautiful layout of this book.
And to all of you – thank you for picking up this book, reading
it and passing it on…
May the animals benet from my humble endeavour.
With love,
kahyein 7th August 2011
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
10/82
1
Prologue
This is NOT a book aimed at making you feel bad that you
still eat meat. It is also not a book aimed at trying to convert
you into a vegetarian.
Rather, this is a book that invites you to consider EATING
LESS MEAT. I was motivated to write this book because
I observed that most people have a natural compassion for
animals. Many do want to eat less meat, not just for health
reasons or to reduce one’s carbon footprint, but for the
simple reason that we all know animals suffer so much at the
slaughterhouses. Out of compassion for these animals, most
people do want to eat less meat. But sometimes we just do
not know how to start, or maybe we need some motivation to
push us to do it.
That is the aim of this book – to give us that little push…
towards more compassionate eating.
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
11/82
2
I will not kill or hurt any living creature needlessly, nor
destroy any beautiful thing, but will strive to save and
comfort all gentle life, and guard and protect all natural
beauty upon the earth.
– John Ruskin
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
12/82
3
The Lady in the Orange Saree
I grew up eating meat, but not extravagantly. And not all meats
too. Just chicken, sh and the occasional pork. Like many
Chinese families, we did not eat beef or mutton.
I remember the rst time I ever came across a vegetarian. I
was seven years old then. My mum had brought me to a sports
carnival at her school, and she pointed out this absolutely
stunning Indian lady dressed in a pale orange saree. This
lady was also a teacher in the school. She was so ravishingly
beautiful; I was completely entranced. Her hourglass gure
was “out of this world”, and her complexion was awless,
but what caught my eye was the radiance which shone from
her face. The rst thought that occurred to me was that she
must be a very kind and compassionate person. I decided there
and then that only a kind person could possibly have such a
beautiful face. Then, my mum whispered to me, “She is a lifevegetarian. Her whole family is, too.”
That was the rst time it dawned on me that being vegetarian
might not be such a bad idea, after all.
Till today, I still remember the radiant face of that beautiful
goddess who descended upon this Earth, resplendent in a paleorange saree, and walked in front of me at the sports carnival.
1
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
13/82
4 | Do We Have a Choice?
John Keats was right: A thing of beauty is a joy forever.
My mum observed vegetarianism every new moon and fullmoon day, as did my grandmother. Like all good mothers, my
mum never compelled us to follow what she did. She just let
us watch, and if we asked, she would answer. And so, I grew
up eating meat, but the idea of becoming a vegetarian was
always at the back of my mind.
When I was twelve, my family embraced Buddhism. As withmany Chinese Buddhists, we would observe vegetarianism
every new moon and full moon day, and on our birthdays. I
remember asking the nuns at the temple why they are full-
edged vegetarians whereas we don’t have to be. “It’s because
you are still young and you need to grow, and your parents
need to work, you need the energy”, they told me. That made
sense to me at that time. So I accepted it as it was.
But throughout my childhood I continued to remember the
beautiful lady in the orange saree.
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
14/82
5
The Chick in the Burger
In my twenties, I began to feel very sorry for the pig, so I
stopped eating pork altogether. I had never liked Bak Kut
Teh (a popular Chinese pork dish) anyway, so it wasn’t a big
sacrice.
When I was pregnant with my two children, my parents
turned vegetarians for the entire duration of both my
pregnancies. They believed it would be good for the unborn
child. Similarly, when my brother and his wife were expecting
their child, my brother too observed vegetarianism. He liked
it so much he decided to be vegetarian for life. Soon after, his
family and my parents became full-edged vegetarians as well.
I had always considered going vegetarian. Since I cooked our
meals at home, I was in control of what we ate. Gradually, I
reduced our meat intake at home. I stopped cooking chicken
stew and, instead, only used a small amount of minced
chicken meat as a condiment in our vegetable dishes. Next, I
stopped buying sh. My daughter and I did not miss the taste
of meat. We gured it’s all in the mind. The tongue may want,
but the head and heart can control the tongue.
One day, my son saw a PowerPoint slide I was preparingfor my talk on Kindness to Animals. It showed the picture of a
2
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
15/82
6 | Do We Have a Choice?
live chick sandwiched between two buns, and I had put the
caption “Do we have a choice?”. Straightaway, he then told me
we could dispense with the minced chicken meat. “Let’s not
cook meat at home anymore”, he said.
So that was it.
I stopped buying minced meat, and, from that very next day,
I stopped cooking meat altogether at home. Nowadays,
the only meat I buy is chicken meat for the cats, and that isbecause cats are carnivores and they have to eat meat. We are
omnivores, so we get to choose. We can be total vegetarians,
or we could just eat less meat. We cannot force carnivorous
animals to be vegetarian – that’ll be going against nature and
that wouldn’t be fair.
For us humans, many are of the opinion that we need lotsof protein daily, but do we really? Vegetables are actually
already a very good source of protein. And, if you think about
it, human babies grow perfectly well on mother’s milk alone
for the rst 6-12 months of their lives, and I was told that
mother’s milk is just 3% protein!
I read that a typical cheeseburger provides 0.05 grams ofprotein per calorie whereas spinach provides 0.12 grams of
protein per calorie and lentils 0.07 grams per calorie. Some
nutritionists are also of the opinion that by eating a variety
of vegetables, we can get most of the essential amino acids
(protein) that our body needs. Variety is the keyword here.
Ever since the day my son said we’d stop buying meat, we do
not cook any meat at home anymore. But, when we eat out,
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
16/82
Do We Have a Choice? | 7
take away or go for dinners, we eat whatever that is served.
This is our personal preference of not being a burden to our
hosts. Sometimes I just pick the vegetables in every dish, and
that’s really a very easy thing to do. There is no need to make
a fuss and announce to the whole world that we choose to be
vegetarian.
Since I give so many talks on kindness to animals, I’m very
often asked if I am vegetarian. To this I answer, “I’m a exible
vegetarian”, and that is the truth. When there are really no
vegetables, I will eat whatever that is available. I am exible.
I eat out for lunch every working day, and I don’t need to go
to any special vegetarian stall. All I do is to pick 2-3 vegetable
dishes at the local chap-fan (“economy rice”, a convenient local
fast food for rice and dishes at a very affordable price) stall
with a plate of rice. It is so easy.
Becoming vegetarian is a personal choice. It is sometimes a
hard one for many because we are so used to the taste of meat,
and our tongue (and brain!) demands it, due to decades of
conditioning. Also, for some people, their bodies may require
some nutrients that are derived from meat.
However, eating less meat is denitely doable. So if you’re
game to try this, if you have enough willpower to do it, for the
sake of saving those poor animals from being slaughtered and
so that we do not contribute so much to the demand for meat,
please read on…
This book is dedicated to you.
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
17/82
8
Oh, my fellow men, do not dele your bodies with sinful
foods. We have corn, we have apples bending down thebranches with their weight, and grapes swelling on the
vines. There are sweet-avored herbs, and vegetables
which can be cooked and softened over the re, nor are you
denied milk or thyme-scented honey. The earth affords a
lavish supply of riches, of innocent foods, and offers you
banquets that involve no bloodshed or slaughter; only
beasts satisfy their hunger with esh, and not even all ofthose, because horses, cattle, and sheep live on grass.
– Pythagoras
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
18/82
9
Are We Natural Vegetarians?
This chapter is extracted from http://www.alternative-
healthzine.com/html/are_we_natural_vegetarians.html
A cat or dog salivates with anticipated pleasure at the sight and smell of
raw meat, but very few humans exhibit this behaviour. For most meat
eaters, their chosen cut needs to be cooked before it becomes attractive. This
is just one factor that might make us wonder whether eating meat is natural
for us, and whether being a vegetarian is a realistic option.
Other clues can be found by comparing the anatomy and physiology ofhumans with different types of animals. It emerges that humans are far more
similar to fruit- and nut-eating animals – vegetarians such as monkeys and
apes, and to leaf- and grass- eating animals such as sheep, cattle, elephants
and koalas, than to carnivores.
The following two lists show the characteristics, rst, of carnivores, and
then of non-carnivores, or vegetarians.
Carnivores generally:
1. Have very short digestive tracts (three times their body length) to
excrete decaying meat waste rapidly.
2. Produce very strong stomach acid – typically 20 times stronger than
that of a non-carnivore – to digest bone, sinews and large quantities of
meat.
3
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
19/82
10 | Do We Have a Choice?
3. Produce small amounts of saliva because digestion does not begin in
the mouth with carnivores.
4. Tend to have jaws that can only move up and down, which means that
they cannot grind their food and can hardly chew at all. Meat is torn
off with their long, sharp incisors and their canines, and is swallowed
in large chunks. The teeth are also shaped and angled to move with a
shearing motion to cut through bone and tough sinews.
5. Show great agility in catching prey, and have sharp claws and strong jaws to bring down, kill and consume prey.
However, vegetarians – non-carnivorous animals and humans –
generally:
1. Have long digestive tracts that are about 12 times the body length.
The great length allows the longer period of time that is needed for fruit and vegetables to be digested completely.
2. Have weak stomach acid, which is all that is necessary for the slow
digestion of grasses, grains and vegetable matter.
3. Produce a larger quantity of saliva, which also contains the enzyme
ptyalin. The plentiful saliva and the ptyalin begin the digestion of
grains, fruit and vegetables in the mouth. Carnivores neither eat these
kinds of food nor do they chew their food, which means that digestive
enzymes in their saliva are absent.
4. Have jaws that move with a grinding motion. This grinding together
of the relatively at teeth reduces the particle size of the food and
exposes it to the saliva and ptyalin in the mouth. Human canine and
incisor teeth are small compared to those of a carnivore and are,
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
20/82
Do We Have a Choice? | 11
perhaps, better suited to biting tough vegetables rather than animal
skin and bone.
5. Have no claws, relatively weak jaws and not a great deal of agility.
For example, if a chicken is placed in an open space it would be
extremely difcult for a human to catch it; we don’t appear to be
designed for that sort of activity.
The evidence seems clear that humans have evolved to eat little or no meat
– to be vegetarian.
To sum it all up, here’s a quote I like:
You put a baby in a crib with an apple and a rabbit.
If it eats the rabbit and plays with the apple, I’ll buy you a new car.
– Harvey Diamond
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
21/82
12
It is certainly not lions or wolves that we eat out of self-
defense; on the contrary, we ignore these and slaughterharmless, tame creatures without stings or teeth to harm
us. For the sake of a little esh we deprive them of sun,
of light, of the duration of life to which they are entitled
by birth and being. If you declare that you are naturally
designed for such a diet, then rst kill for yourself what
you want to eat. Do it, however, only through your own
resources, unaided by cleaver or cudgel or any kind of axe.
– The Roman Plutarch, in an essay “On Eating Flesh”.
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
22/82
13
Old MacDonald’s Farm
Before you read on, please be forewarned that this chapter
describes unpalatable things that happen in some animal
farms, and you might feel discomfort reading it. We can
choose to skip this chapter and not nd out about the
horrible sufferings that go on in factory farms. By doing
that, we choose not to know the facts and probably might
continue eating meat, as much as before. Or we might
brace ourselves for the gore, read on and, at the end of
the chapter, make an informed decision from what ourconscience is telling us.
For the sake of the animals and for the sake of humanity, I
hope you do read on.
Here we go…
If slaughterhouses had glass walls,everyone would be a vegetarian.
– Paul McCartney
I think all of us know that modern-day factory farming is cruel.
In the days of yore, factory-farming was unheard of. Animals
were allowed to grow up naturally, and they lived freely on thefarm. Only once in a blue moon, when festivities arise, would
4
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
23/82
14 | Do We Have a Choice?
the unfortunate animal be caught and slaughtered. Yes, that
was cruel too, but denitely not as cruel as what goes on in
modern-day factory farms, where animals are born and bred to
be slaughtered as food, and in the shortest possible time too.
Most of the meat we eat are baby animals who have never even
had a chance to grow up, what more, to live a natural life. Some
have never even seen the sun or walked on grass.
According to statistics from the book Eating Animals by
Jonathan Safran Foer, people nowadays eat 150 times more
chicken than they did 80 years ago. A survey in the UK
estimates that a meat-eater would end up eating at least
11,000 animals in one lifetime. This means that a meat-eating
person indirectly causes the death of thousands of animals in his
lifetime, if one accepts the supply-demand theory. Staggering,
isn’t it? And the saddest part is how much suffering eachanimal has to endure before it is slaughtered.
A modern-day factory farm is no less than a torture chamber
for these poor suffering animals. What I’m going to share with
you here in this chapter is what I’ve gathered from watching,
albeit reluctantly, some videos, which I never got to nish
because they were too gory, and reading about the conditionsin factory farms. Granted, maybe the practices in every farm are
different, but how humane can killing be? Killing is still killing.
Animals, having a heightened sixth sense, are traumatized
before they get killed. They feel so helpless, so sad and so
fearful. Just imagine for a moment if we are being carted down
an aisle to be slaughtered, and we are watching our friends andrelatives being slaughtered, wouldn’t we be frightened too?
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
24/82
Do We Have a Choice? | 15
I have never visited a factory farm before. I don’t think I would
dare to. I’d probably cry for weeks and be traumatized for the
rest of my life.
Would you dare visit a factory farm or a slaughterhouse?
The following are written based on what I have read. Granted,
these practices may not be implemented in all farms. But as I’ve
written, killing is still killing. And killing can never be humane,
especially when a living being does not even understand whyhe/she is being killed.
At the chicken farm
Broiler chickens – Baby chicks are separated from their mother
at birth and kept in very crowded cages where there is literallyno room to move. Some of these animals become severely
depressed and feel intense stress, so they react by pecking each
other and themselves. To prevent this from happening, the
farmers sever the chicks’ beaks. There is no anaesthesia; there
is even a machine that cuts off their beaks. These animals live
in extremely lthy conditions. Diseases abound. The overuse ofgrowth hormones causes organ failure and the inability of their
legs to support their body weight. Some of the chickens (ducks
and turkeys, too) are forcefed through tubes inserted into their
throats. Finally, in a matter of 45 days or less, they are sent for
slaughter where, in some cases, their throats are cut and they
are left to bleed to death.
Poultry chickens – Hens are starved to increase egg production.
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
25/82
16 | Do We Have a Choice?
The injured are left to die. Male chicks are ground up as animal
feed because they cannot produce eggs.
At the pig farm
Piglets are separated from their mother at birth. The mother-
pigs cry when their babies are separated from them. The
piglets’ teeth and tails are forcibly yanked off with pliers,
the male pigs’ testicles are torn out by force. Again, this is to
prevent the piglets from biting each other and themselves,
so all possible extensions from their little bodies and their
teeth are removed. Sows are articially impregnated with
insufcient recovery time. They live in crowded enclosures
with no room to turn around or lie down. After several
pregnancies, when the sow can no longer produce piglets,they are sent for slaughter. Even during transportation to the
slaughterhouse, conditions are extremely crowded, and this
sometimes results in death. Slaughter can sometimes be very
inhumane; the pigs’ throats are cut and they bleed to death.
Their limbs are severed piece by piece while they are still alive.
The injured and diseased ones are left to die of starvation.
At the dairy and cattle farm
Dairy cows – Dairy cows are hooked onto machines all
their lives where their milk is extracted 24 hours a day.
They are killed after 4-5 years when they can no longerproduce milk. Some are made into soup, animal food or low-
grade hamburgers. Male calves (veals) from dairy farms are
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
26/82
Do We Have a Choice? | 17
separated from their mothers at one-day old and kept in tiny
enclosures that have never seen the light of day. They are fed
a liquid which is decient in iron and bre. This is done to
ensure that their esh would be tender and their leather pale
in colour. That is why veals are known as “tortured calves”.
Cattle – The horns of these cows and bulls are pulled out
by force to prevent them from butting each other. During
transportation, there is sometimes no food and water for
hours. There is overcrowding in the trucks and old cows
starve to death. Slaughter is inhumane; their limbs are severed
piece by piece while they are still alive.
Think occasionally of the suffering
of which you spare yourself the sight.
– Albert Schweitzer
Looking at the terribly crowded conditions that these
poor farm animals are kept in, it is no surprise, therefore,
that diseases abound in the farms. We hear of the Japanese
Encephalitis in pigs, the Mad Cow Disease and the Bird Flu.
When there are such outbreaks, the poor animals are culled,
sometimes in a very brutal and inhumane manner. We blamethem for causing the outbreak of diseases, but aren’t we the
actual culprits?
At the sh farm
Even sh slaughtering can be very inhumane. The sh issometimes killed by crushing its head with a mallet. Even
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
27/82
18 | Do We Have a Choice?
before they are killed, “sh grading” can be a very stressful
and frightening process for the sh. “Death crown” is a term
to describe how the head of the sh is intentionally mutilated
by parasites causing sh to be in deep pain.
Out in the ocean
Sharks’ ns are severed and the sharks are thrown back into
the sea to die a slow death by drowning, because they canno longer swim without their ns. Dolphins and turtles are
sometimes trapped in shing nets resulting in their deaths.
Just before slaughter
I read from somewhere that just before slaughter, the animalis so frightened that its body would generate large amounts
of adrenaline (the ght-or-ight hormone). Some of the
animals are not even dead yet when they are skinned and
dismembered; this gives rise to even larger amounts of the
hormone. This excessive adrenaline remains in the dead
animal which then becomes the meat that is eaten. Excessive
adrenaline is toxic.
I know many people justify meat-eating by saying that the
manner in which the animals are slaughtered is “humane”. My
contention is how can any form of killing ever be humane?
Recognize meat for what it really is: the antibiotic-
and pesticide-laden corpse of a tortured animal.
– Ingrid Newkirk
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
28/82
Do We Have a Choice? | 19
For more information on what goes on in the slaughterhouses,
please refer to www.meat.org.
* * *
You have survived through the most “difcult” chapter
in the book. It took me a lot of courage to actually write
it. These graphic details have to be told so that you know
how meat is produced. And, believe it or not, what I have
written has already been toned down. I would also needto qualify that whatever is described in this chapter may
not happen in all farms, but killing, in any manner, is still
killing. Being killed is very frightening when one does not
understand why one is being killed – the farm animals
face this heart-wrenching situation, by the billions. We
can make a difference to some of them by simply eating
less meat. That’s all it takes, really. If everyone eats a little
less meat, many animals would not have to be bred to be
slaughtered as meat.
A friend who read this chapter before I sent it in for
publication said she would drop chicken, pork and beef
from her diet and only eat sh now, plus lots of vegetables,of course!
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
29/82
20
I’m no shrinking violet. I played hockey until half my
teeth were knocked down my throat. And I’m extremely
competitive on a tennis court… But that experience at the
slaughterhouse overwhelmed me. When I walked out of
there, I knew I would never again harm an animal! I knew
all the physiological, economic, and ecological arguments
supporting vegetarianism, but it was rsthand experience
of man’s cruelty to animals that laid the real groundwork
for my commitment to vegetarianism.
– Peter Burwash, champion tennis player in his book,
“A Vegetarian Primer”.
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
30/82
21
Lessons from the
Cows and the Crabs
I think that spiritual growth compels us at a certain point
to stop killing our fellow creatures for the satisfaction
of our physical wants.
– Mahatma Gandhi
There are four stories here, and they are remarkably similar in
nature, yet they must be told.
The Slaughterhouse Worker and the Animals
Way back when we were living in the small town of Kuala
Kangsar, my parents knew a person who worked in the local
slaughterhouse. There came a point in time in his life when
this person wanted to seek a more spiritual life, so that wasthe time he befriended my parents. Through them, he learnt
that animals have feelings too – they may not be able to
rationalize as intelligently as we can, but they are capable of
feelings like love, loyalty, sadness and fear. He reected on
his experience in the slaughterhouse, and he totally agreed.
He told my parents how the animals would cry and howl
every morning at 5am as he carted them down the aisle to
5
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
31/82
22 | Do We Have a Choice?
be slaughtered. He even told them he had difculty sleeping
at night as he would hear the animals’ cries in the still of the
night. He realized then that that was the reason he had never
been able to sleep peacefully. After some time, he changed
jobs and became a much happier person.
The Convicted Murderer and the Cow
This is a story I heard from an Australian monk. This monk
goes into the prisons to help rehabilitate the prisoners and
some of these inmates range from the mild-mannered to the
most hardcore convicted criminals.
One such prisoner was this extremely hardcore murderer who
had previously killed quite a number of people. Now, over in
the Australian prisons, the prisoners have to work for their
sustenance, and part of this work includes having to plant
their own vegetables, rear their own animals or work at the
slaughterhouse.
Mr Hardcore decided he’d do the job of the slaughter-man.
That would be the “executioner”, so to speak – the personwho stuns the animals and kills them after they are carted
down the aisle every morning.
Mr Hardcore had no qualms about killing animals. After all,
hadn’t he already killed a few humans before he was arrested
and thrown into the slammer? Humans, animals – what’s the
difference, he thought. Killing is killing, and he could do itwithout blinking an eye.
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
32/82
Do We Have a Choice? | 23
So, day in, day out, Mr Hardcore went about his job dutifully.
One shot to stun, one shot to kill. It was routine. The animals
would be howling, screaming and crying for mercy, but Mr
Hardcore was unmoved. Until….
One day, the cows were howling and crying as usual as they
came down the aisle. But there was this one cow who was
absolutely calm as it neared her turn.
Mr Hardcore could not help noticing her unusual and almostfrightening calmness.
When it came to her turn, the cow looked straight into Mr
Hardcore’s eyes…and tears rolled down her face.
There wasn’t a sound. Just tears.
Mr Hardcore was stunned. Immediately, he dropped thestun-gun and ran out of the slaughterhouse, yelling, “I’ve
had enough of killing!! I’ve had enough of killing!”. From that
moment on, Mr Hardcore declared he would be a lifelong
vegetarian.
It took a cow to give a hardcore criminal a moment of
enlightenment which changed his entire life.
The Chef and the Crabs
This is a story of my friend, Ah Seong, who now runs a
vegetarian food stall with his mother in the foodcourt near my
workplace. One day, Ah Seong came to sit with me as I was
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
33/82
24 | Do We Have a Choice?
having lunch at his stall, and he told me his story. He said,
“Do you know, sister…I used to be a bigtime gourmet chef in
my heyday. I earned thousands. But, one day, someone took
me to a talk and this lady-speaker spoke about the moral
wrongness in killing. After listening to that talk, I could not
sleep peacefully at night. I kept seeing the live crabs and sh
that I clobber to death every day in the restaurant. I couldn’t
even do my job properly anymore at the restaurant, and this
affected my livelihood. So I went back to the lady and told herit was all her fault for causing me this misery and ill-fortune.
I told her she had to solve my problem for me now. The
lady said: No worries, I’ll teach you how to cook vegetarian
dishes.”
And so, Ah Seong learnt the art of vegetarian cooking and
perfected the skill in no time. He then opened his vegetarianfood stall with the help of his mother. Never mind if he did
not earn as much as he used to, but at least he could now
sleep peacefully at night.
Ah Seong then proudly told me that he used to have very
bad eczema all over his body that no doctor could cure. The
rashes would are up and the itch would be unbearable. But,ever since he switched his culinary skills over to cooking
vegetarian, his eczema disappeared! I looked at Ah Seong,
and his face shone with a radiance that could only come from
a kind heart. He had found happiness in his job now and is
enjoying better health, and all it took was a lady-speaker who
spoke from her heart and a young man who was willing tolook deep within and nd the truths in his heart!
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
34/82
Do We Have a Choice? | 25
The Aged Loyal Cow
This is a story from my colleague, Jas. Jas grew up in Sarawak.Her parents were dairy farmers. They kept cows to provide
milk for the family and also to generate income. Their cows
lived a long life and, even when they could not provide
anymore milk, Jas’ parents continued looking after them until
they passed on.
One day, many years after having served the family, one cowdeveloped a bad infection on her front hoof. Apparently, such
an infection is very hard to heal and would cause great pain.
Many farmers would sell these cows to the butcher rather
than nurse them.
One such opportunist-butcher came to know about this cow
with the infected hoof and offered Jas’ parents a fair price topurchase the cow.
Jas’ parents, despite being in need of the money, atly refused
to sell the cow. They told the butcher, “This cow has served
my family and provided milk for my children for so many
years. How can we sell her now that she is old and injured?”
After the butcher went away, the cow walked towards Jas’
parents.
She held up her injured hoof.
And she cried.
I would like to believe these were tears of gratitude.
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
35/82
26 | Do We Have a Choice?
The cow lived on until she nally passed on peacefully at a
ripe old age.
I think I will let these three cows and those crabs speak for
the billions of animals who are born and bred to be killed in
the slaughterhouses as food for humans.
The question is not, Can they reason?
nor, Can they talk? but, Can they suffer ?
– Jeremy Bentham.
Animals share with us the privilege of having a soul.
– Pythagoras
Are you ready to eat less meat now?
If so, please read on…
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
36/82
27
Going Meatless
Once a Week
On 12 May 2009, the city of Ghent in Belgium declared a
meatless day (Meatless Thursday) once a week in their city.
I believe they were the rst city in the world to ofcially
declare a once-a-week meatless day. Other cities in Belgium
followed after that. Cape Town was the rst African city to
declare a Meatless Monday too.
On 30 June 2011, a total of 29 organizations in Singapore
(including a student environment group in the National
University) endorsed a Veggie Thursday where participations
would go completely meatless for just one meal every
Thursday.
Going veggie once a week has been an age-old practice
amongst many Hindus and some Christians. It is also aChinese cultural practice to go vegetarian twice a month (on
the new moon and full moon day).
Former US President Bill Clinton has recently adopted a
vegan diet. While many people adopt a vegetarian or vegan
diet to reduce their carbon footprint or for health reasons,
which are all valid and noble reasons, let’s also consider itfrom the compassionate viewpoint. Animals suffer so much
6
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
37/82
28 | Do We Have a Choice?
in the factory farms and slaughterhouses. Let’s reduce their
suffering by eating less meat so that the number of animals
born and bred to be slaughtered can at least be reduced.
I read that 269 million chickens are killed each day in the
US alone. What about the cows, pigs, goats and other meat-
producing animals? And these are not free-range animals who
have lived a natural life, but animals that are born and bred (in
terrible conditions) for one sole purpose – to be slaughtered
as food for us.
I know it isn’t easy to drop meat entirely from our diet and
go veggie immediately. Some people, depending on their
body constituency, might also need some meat in their diet.
The Dalai Lama, for example, was a lifelong vegetarian, but
his doctor advised him to take some meat since his health
required it, so he does that now. But minimally, of course.
Hence, for many of us, it may not be easy or feasible for us to
be strict vegetarians. If that is the case, why not go meatless
once a week, for a start? Then, if we like what we do and we
see the benet of doing it, we could gradually increase it to
twice or thrice a week!
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
38/82
29
Let’s Just Do it!
If you’re all motivated to go meatless once a week or reduce
your meat intake every day, let’s get started now.
Whenever you’re supposed to go meatless but you feel the
urge to revert to eating meat, think of how the animal would
be slaughtered and how much it would suffer. Then, remind
yourself that you are a kind person and you do not want
to contribute to the suffering of these poor animals. Your
conscience will discipline your heart, your mind and your
tongue. Believe me, this really works! It wasn’t easy for me to
convert to forgoing meat initially too, and that was when I
realized how much I needed to discipline my tongue and my
brain! Ultimately, your heart will speak to you. Listen to your
heart…it knows the truths.
If you simply cannot go meatless, then reduce your meat
intake. Instead of having two types of meats, cut it down to
one. Instead of having chunks of meat, use sprinkles of minced
meat. Use meat as a condiment and not as the main dish.
When eating out, choose dishes that have lesser amounts of
meat. Here’s a good guideline: Get meat out of the centre of
the plate.
7
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
39/82
30 | Do We Have a Choice?
What to eat
Eat fruit on an empty stomach, in between meals. Not asdessert.
For your meals, eat a variety of vegetables: 5-6 different
colours would be good. For example, you can stir-fry a mixed
veggie dish of cauliower, carrot, red capsicum, pumpkin,
broccoli, and brinjal. Make sure you always eat a green leafy
vegetable every meal.
Chew slowly. If you gulp down your food, you’ll denitely end
up eating more. By chewing slowly, your digestion would be
better as it begins with the saliva in your mouth.
Avoid excessive soya and gluten products, and PLEASE
avoid those fake “vegetarian meats”. I was told these heavilyseasoned fake meats are even more toxic than real meat itself!
My personal favourites are home-made vegetable soup, stir-
fried mixed vegetables, and, if I eat out, Indian vegetarian
dishes.
Remember that going veggie means eating a variety of
vegetables. There is no need for fake meats.
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
40/82
31
Of Onions, Garlic and
Special Chopscks
I’m often asked in my public talks why some vegetarians
abstain from onions and garlic. Well, as far as I’ve been told,
there are two reasons: First, these condiments give us a rather
unpleasant breath. To put it bluntly, it stinks up our mouths!
For monks and nuns who would want to do chanting after
eating, it would be quite embarrassing if one belches in the
company of others, especially during a chanting session.
Second, I was told that onions and garlic are aphrodisiacs.Many vegetarians are aiming to become more spiritual in their
way of life, renouncing sense pleasures and the likes of it,
hence, aphrodisiacs won’t be very helpful in this department.
Then, there are those who insist on special cooking utensils,
special crockery and special cutlery for them to go vegetarian.
Ahh…I will reserve my comments on this, but for me this isunnecessary. Eating a vegetarian meal means not eating meat.
Never mind if the utensil has been used for meats before. But
that’s just my opinion, of course.
So, yes, I do eat onions and garlic, and I only need one dining
set at home!
8
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
41/82
32
Think of the erce energy concentrated in an acorn! You
bury it in the ground, and it explodes into an oak! Bury a
sheep, and nothing happens but decay.
– George Bernard Shaw
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
42/82
33
Hara Hachi Bu
Hara Hachi Bu means eat until you are 80% full.
Instead of adopting a meatless day once a week, you couldalso opt to just consciously reduce your meat consumption
every day.
The traditional Okinawa diet, with its emphasis on
vegetables, whole grains, fruits, legumes and sh with
limited amounts of lean meats, serves as a model for healthy
eating and healthy aging. It is purported to reduce our riskof cardiovascular disease, and it also helps to minimize free
radical production.
Stopping at 80% capacity is actually a very good strategy to
avoid obesity without going hungry, because the stomach’s
receptors take about 20 minutes to tell the body how full it
really is. So when you feel 80% full, you are actually already full!
In Okinawa, heart disease rates are 80% lower, and stroke
rates are also lower than in the US. Cholesterol levels are
typically under 180, homocystein levels are low and blood
pressure is at goal levels. Rates of cancer are 50-80% lower
– especially breast, colon, ovarian and prostate cancer. Hip
fractures are 20% lower than mainland Japanese and 40%lower than in the US. Dementia is rare.
9
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
43/82
34 | Do We Have a Choice?
However, Okinawans who adopt Western eating styles
have similar rates of heart disease as in the US. Young
Okinawans, eating more processed foods, have a higher
risk of heart disease than their elderly relatives. A study of
100,000 Okinawans who moved to Brazil and adopted local
eating habits showed a life expectancy 17 years lower than in
Okinawa.
The Okinawans are known to be the longest-living and
healthiest humans on Earth.
The longer we live healthily, the more good we can do.
So, let’s hara hachi bu, and eat less meat!
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
44/82
35
The PB&J Club
(for the Young-at-Heart)
How One Lunch Helps the Environment AND Saves
Animal Lives!
It’s all based on eating lower on the food chain. Everything we eat
comes from plants. No matter what you eat – beef or barley,
chicken or chickpeas, pork or peanut butter – all of it comes
from plants. We eat some plants directly – the vegetables, the
peanut butter – and we eat some of it converted by animals
into meat, eggs and milk.
Animals are inecient at converting energy
The basic problem is that animals are inefcient at converting
plants into meat, milk, and eggs. Relatively little of what they
eat ends up in what you eat because animals use their food tokeep them alive – to fuel their muscles so they can stand up
and walk around, to keep their hearts beating, to keep their
brains working.
The result is that it takes several pounds of corn and soy to
produce one pound of meat, or one pound of eggs, one pound
of milk, etc. The same goes for protein, other nutrients orcalories.
10
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
45/82
36 | Do We Have a Choice?
It also takes several times more resources than what it took to
grow those plants: several times more land; several times more
water; a lot more fertilizers and pesticides; not to mention
diesel and gasoline to operate the machinery, pump the water
for irrigation and produce the chemicals.
What about seafood? Skip the sh and prawns and help the
planet just like you do by avoiding other animal products. It
takes a lot of fuel to catch sh. We catch about half of the
seafood we eat, and that shing produces greenhouse gases
because shing boats use fuel.
Concerned about the environment?
If you would like to slow global warming, do your part to save
water, slow deforestation and overgrazing, and cut back on
the pesticides and fertilizers used to grow your food, what
you could do is to change your lunch today (or tomorrow, if
you’re reading this after lunch).
Make a dierence one lunch at a time
Every time you eat lunch, you’ve got the option of cutting
out the middleman, or the middle-cow, middle-chicken or
middle-pig, and helping the environment.
This is where it gets really easy.
Pack a peanut butter and jelly (PB&J) sandwich instead of
buying a lunch based on animal products, like a meatburger,
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
46/82
Do We Have a Choice? | 37
fried chicken or tuna sandwich. Want to do more? Have
another PB&J sandwich tomorrow.
Tired of eating the same thing….?
Make your own veggie sandwich!
All you need is bread, butter/mayonaise/tomato sauce, lettuce,
cucumber, carrot, tomato, or any of your favourite vegetables.
Be creative! Have fun!!
Concerned about animals in our food system?
If every meatburger, box of chicken nuggets, or bak kut teh meal
is a signal to slaughter more cows, chickens or pigs (by way of
telling the restaurant or the market to buy more meat), a mealthat doesn’t have any animal products is a vote to stop.
Animals endure so much suffering in the modern-day factory
farms. Let’s help them by not eating them, shall we?
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
47/82
38 | Do We Have a Choice?
Not everyone can change their entire diet, but every decision
like that, where you eat a meal based on plants instead of one
based on animals, has a big environmental impact and is a vote
for animal welfare. You are saving lives. You are practising
compassion!
As custodians of the planet it is our responsibility to deal with all species
with kindness, love, and compassion. That these animals suffer through
human cruelty is beyond understanding. Please help to stop this madness.
– Richard Gere
Websites to motivate you:
www.loveusnoteatus.com
www.themeatrix.com
www.meat.org
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
48/82
39
Of Aliens and Futurisc Apes
After I completed the rst draft for this book, I sent it to
my friend, Andy Koh of PetFinder.my, for feedback since
Andy had indicated to me some months back that he was
supportive of eating less meat.
Andy sent me very constructive feedback and further
thoughts on this issue, which I’d like to share with you in this
chapter.
Here are Andy’s thoughts:
One key reason why meat consumption has increased signicantly is our
conditioning by the meat-producing industry for their nancial benets.
They are making meat so abundant and affordable by introducing mass-
production methods – at the expense of the animals’ well-being and
humane treatment.
Second is the powerful marketing-in-action. From elegantly packaged
meat at the supermarkets to fun-lled experience at fast-food chains to
delicacies portrayed as prime at ne dining restaurants, people are far
detached and shielded from the ground zero cruelty of how the animals
are treated before ending up on their plates.
For those of my friends that cannot properly visualize the cruelty ofeating animals, I like to tell them a slightly gross Alien Invasion Theory:
11
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
49/82
40 | Do We Have a Choice?
Imagine Earth was invaded by carnivorous aliens that consider humans
as delicious food. We are being hoarded into pens packed with thousands
of people lined up every single day to be decapitated, skinned alive or have
our throats slit, and to have our bodies dismembered, packaged and graded
separately for sale. Babies a few months old are taken away, fried crispy
and served as a delicacy (think suckling pig, or spring chicken). Food stalls
have half-mutilated human bodies hanging around for aliens to choose the
parts they’d like to devour.
This is exactly what we’re doing to the animals every day, but we do not see
anything wrong with it as we’re always on the winning side of the bargain.
Then again, on the contrary, when animal lovers tell me how disgusted and
inhumane people are in eating dogs and cats (as some people in certain
cultures do), I would tell them that is only as wrong or as right as us eating
pigs, cows, sheep or chickens. We only feel disgusted because we are very
emotionally attached to dogs and cats as pets, but the lives of other animals
we eat are in no way less precious nor are they dumber or deserve to die
more. So, whether we eat a dog, cat, chicken or cow, we are still equally as
bad or good.
If children grew up with cows and pigs as friends, I doubt they would ever
want to eat these animals.You are absolutely right, Andy. I’ve always felt that way, too.
Meat-eaters cry foul when they hear of other humans eating
dogs and cats but do not realize that they themselves eat
chickens, cows, pigs and goats. That is precisely why my vet, a
dog- and cat-lover, does not despise people who consume dogs
and cats. He says he has no right to do so when he himself is ameat-eater.
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
50/82
Do We Have a Choice? | 41
This also brings to mind a young boy who attended one of my
talks. I had asked for a show of hands to see who, amongst
the audience, were animal-lovers. The boy later told me that,
although he loved cats and dogs, he could not bring himself
to say he was an animal-lover because he still ate meat (other
animals). I told him I salute him for his honesty, something I
seldom see in adults.
As for Andy’s alien invasion theory, I love that too! In my rst
book, Pawprints on My Heart, written in 2008, I shared a similar
alien story taken from the Vegetarian Society of Singapore:
Humans eat other animals for food, even though we humans can be perfectly
healthy without eating meat. We continue to eat other animals despite the
fact that these fellow animals are thinking, feeling beings who suffer greatly,
who are deprived of any semblance of a natural life. Why do we humans do
this to other animals? One reason we continue to unnecessarily use other
animals for food is that we have the ability to do so; our intellectual gifts
have allowed us to achieve dominance over other animals.
One way to help humans empathise with the plight of our fellow animals
would be to encourage us to imagine another species coming to Earth, a
species more intelligent than humans, a species who decide to eat us becausewe taste so good, a species that can do with us what they want because they
are more intelligent. The members of this species don’t hate humans; in fact,
they think we’re cute, at least some of us. Furthermore, this species aren’t
monsters, any more than we humans are monsters because we eat other
animals. It’s just that eating humans has become a tradition for them; it’s
what they’re accustomed to. It’s easy and convenient, plus, many of their
doctors tell them that human meat has lots of essential nutrients. (VSSeNewsletter (2007)).
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
51/82
42 | Do We Have a Choice?
Remember the movie Planet of the Apes? Way back in the early
seventies, it was my all-time favourite movie. The movie was
so popular, it had four sequels and even became a television
series. At the point of writing this book, a remake has just hit
the silver screen.
The original 1968 movie tells the story of an astronaut crew
who crash-land on a strange planet (which they later found
out was our Earth) in the distant future. Although the planet
appears desolate at rst, the surviving crew members stumble
upon a society in which apes have evolved into creatures with
human-like intelligence and speech. The apes have assumed
the role of the dominant species and humans are mute
animals.
In the series, the apes did not eat humans (because apes are
vegetarians!). Rather, their scientists kept humans in cages
and used them as specimens for testing in their laboratories
(exactly as how humans use guinea pigs, rabbits, monkeys,
dogs and cats for animal-testing). They also used humans in
sport-hunting, like what humans have been doing for ages in
fox-hunting.
When I watched the movies and the subsequent television
series, I remember overhearing some adults saying that the
apes were such “savages”. How could they do such things
to the humans, they bellowed. As a child, I did wonder why
these adults did not reect on how we humans have been
(mis)treating animals. What the apes did were exactly what
we humans have been doing to the animals for a long, longtime. Why couldn’t they see this?
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
52/82
Do We Have a Choice? | 43
I also read that when the Nazis used human-Jews for testing
at their laboratories during World War II, the world was
appalled at such “uncivilized and brutal” acts, yet isn’t this
exactly what (civilized) scientists do with animals in the
laboratories – pump chemicals into their eyes, stick electrodes
into their brains, lop off their limbs, while they scream in pain
and agony?
Animal-testing (or vivisection) is another issue which I
speak out against. With modern technology and advances
in medical science, there are alternatives to animal-testing
for our food and drugs. Qualitative Structure-Analysis
Relationship (QSAR) uses mathematical modelling to
calculate the efcacy of a product. Using cultured human
tissue is another alternative, and would denitely be more
accurate too, since we are biologically different from rodentsand other animals. Why are we testing our products on
animals when they are so different from us? Is it because
supplying animals to the laboratories is yet another money-
making venture for humans? What works for the animals may
not work for us, as proven, so tragically, in a drug developed
way back in the fties to combat the effects of morning
sickness in pregnant women. This drug worked beautifully
when tested on animals, but became a disaster when used
on humans. It was reported in 46 countries that thousands
of babies whose mothers had taken this drug were born
with deformed limbs, ngers and toes. The deformity did
not happen when tested on animals, but it did when used on
humans. One wonders if there was a retributive factor at playhere…
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
53/82
44 | Do We Have a Choice?
Animal-testing is required by legislation before a drug can be
approved, but some scientists and biotechnologists are of the
opinion that animal-testing is not necessary.
I have studied the question of vivisection for thirty-ve years
and am convinced that experiments on living animals are
leading medicine further and further from the real cure of the
patient. I know of no instance of animal experiment that has
been necessary for the advancement of medical science; still less
do I know of any animal experiment that could conceivably be
necessary to save human life.
– H. Fergie Woods, M.D.
Consider the following facts taken from http://
whitecoatwelfare.org/aat-text.shtml: Penicillin kills cats and
guinea pigs but has saved many human lives.
1. Arsenic is not poisonous to rats, mice or sheep but is
deadly to humans.
2. Morphine is a sedative for humans but a stimulant for
cats, goats and horses.
3. Digitalis dangerously raises blood pressure in dogs butcontinues to save countless cardiac human patients by
lowering heart rate.
Animal experiments confuse the issues and their results will
never have scientic precision. There is absolutely no connection
between vivisection and human health. The general belief in the
value of animal experimentation is the result of brainwashingthat the public has been submitted to for a long time. Behind
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
54/82
Do We Have a Choice? | 45
it are the pharmaceutical industries, which spend fortunes on
publicity and nance the research institutes and the universities.
– Arie Brecher, M.D.
As for using animals to test cosmetics, there are many
companies that do not use animal-testing anymore these
days. Patronize and support these companies, please. Animals
are tortured and mutilated for the sake of human vanity. It
doesn’t make sense to me why they have to die just becausewe want to look more beautiful. That is why I made the
decision not to use cosmetics when I was fourteen. I only
use toothpaste, soap and shampoo, and only those that have
not been tested on animals. For me, there is no need to look
younger than my age. I want to grow old gracefully!
Animals are already suffering so badly and being killed toprovide food for us, they should not have to be tortured for
the sake of our vanity. Remember that these poor guinea pigs,
rabbits, monkeys, dogs and cats are bred for this purpose and
they endure agonizing pain while being trapped in stereotaxic
devices in the laboratories.
And what about the cows, crocodiles, snakes, minks and dogsthat are being skinned alive to provide leather for handbags,
furs and other products. There is practically no end of ways
humans exploit, ill-treat and mutilate animals to satisfy their
wants.
On this note, Albert Schweitzer, Nobel Peace Laureate, 1952,
hit the nail on head when he said:
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
55/82
46 | Do We Have a Choice?
Until we stop harming all other living beings,
we are still savages.
– Albert Schweitzer
My parents had a friend who simply refused to wear or use
leather. He wore sneakers to work (I do that, too!). He was
making his personal statement for animals just as I make
my personal statement by refusing to wear cosmetics. If you
feel strongly for the animals, make your personal statementand lead by example. Never underestimate what one person
can do or how a gesture, no matter how small, can make an
impactful difference.
Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful,
committed citizens can change the world.
In fact, it’s the only thing that ever has.– Margaret Mead
In 2001, Planet of the Apes was selected for preservation in
the United States National Film Registry by the Library of
Congress as being “culturally, historically, or aesthetically
signicant”.
Personally, I think the movie is very culturally signicant.
It offers us the opportunity to open up our minds and reect
upon how we humans, as a race, have been exploiting and ill-
treating, or, to put it bluntly, bullying the animals, just because
we are bigger, stronger and more capable of rational-thinking
and using tools.
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
56/82
Do We Have a Choice? | 47
We often claim to be superior to the animals, but should
that superiority only be measured in might and cognitive
intelligence? What happened to superiority in compassion
and love? That, in my opinion, should be the measure of
humanity.
Are we able to put ourselves in their place, and feel for them?
Are we able to put aside our own needs and selsh desires,
and make some sacrices to reduce their suffering?
Christiaan Barnard, the South African cardiac surgeon
who performed the world’s rst human-to-human heart
transplant, shares his experience:
I had bought two male chimps from a primate colony in Holland. They
lived next to each other in separate cages for several months before I
used one as a [heart] donor. When we put him to sleep in his cage in preparation for the operation, he chattered and cried incessantly. We
attached no signicance to this, but it must have made a great impression
on his companion, for when we removed the body to the operating room,
the other chimp wept bitterly and was inconsolable for days. The incident
made a deep impression on me. I vowed never again to experiment with
such sensitive creatures.I believe it is not just chimpanzees alone that can feel and
suffer emotional heartache. All animals can, because all
animals are also feeling beings, just like us.
Now what is it that moves our very heart, and sickens us so much
at cruelty shown to poor brutes? First, that they have done us no
harm; next that they have no power whatever to resistance; it is
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
57/82
48 | Do We Have a Choice?
the cowardice and tyranny of which they are the victims which
makes their suffering so especially touching.
– Cardinal Newman
Once you admit that we have the right to inict unnecessary suffering,
you destroy the very basis of a humane society.
– John Galsworthy
Before I get carried away with aliens and futuristic apes, allowme now to get back to Earth and address the connection
between meat-eating and our carbon footprint…
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
58/82
49
Reducing Our
Carbon Footprint
Our carbon footprint is a measure of the amount of green-
house gas emissions caused by us. This carbon footprintcollectively contributes to global warming.
Shortly after the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change
(IPCC) was co-awarded the Nobel Peace Prize in 2007, they
issued a report which said that if we want to help put a brake
on global warming, there are three essential things which we
must embrace in our daily lives:
(1) Don’t eat meat.
(2) Ride a bike.
(3) Be a frugal shopper.
Not that difcult to do, is it? We could gradually reduce
our meat intake for a start (and gain better health), cycleto nearby places (and gain better health too), and buy only
essential things (and save money!). Isn’t that a win-win
situation for us and the environment?
Dr Rajendra Pachauri, one of the two recipients of the coveted
Nobel Peace Prize, in his acceptance speech in Oslo, Norway,
attributes his life-long philosophy to the Hindu principleof Vasudhaiva Kutumbakam. It means “the whole universe is one
12
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
59/82
50 | Do We Have a Choice?
family”, and hence global efforts must be garnered to protect
global commons.
Reducing our meat intake and the use of motorized
vehicles, and buying only what we really need (not what we
want) can signicantly reduce the emission of greenhouse
gases that come from the animal-farming and meat industry,
the use of vehicles and the manufacture of goods.
Reducing our meat intake also contributes signicantly toslowing down the death of our planet.
Deforestation – Between 1960 and 1985, nearly 40 percent
of all Central American rain forests were destroyed to create
pasture for beef cattle.
Soil erosion – More than 4 million acres of cropland are lostto erosion in the US every year. Of this staggering topsoil loss,
85 percent is directly associated with livestock raising, i.e.
over-grazing.
Pollution of rivers/lakes/seas – Much of the excrement from
animal farming (which amounts to 20 times as much faecal
matter as human waste) ows unltered into our lakes andstreams.
Nothing will benet human health and increase chances for survival
of life on Earth as much as the evolution to a vegetarian diet.
– Albert Einstein
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
60/82
51
All it Takes is Just 10%
I read that if people in the US were to reduce just 10% of their
total meat intake (which could mean going meatless for one
meal per week), it would free as much as 12 million tonnes
of grains. This is enough to feed all the hungry and starving
people in the world. World hunger would then disappear
altogether.
Consider this fact: It takes 10kg of plant protein (grains) to
produce 1kg of animal protein through the meat industry. By
doing so, we effectively lose 90% of the energy value of the
original crop. Doesn’t it then make more sense for us to eat
less meat so that the grains can be channeled to feed more
humans and fewer animals need to be bred for slaughter?
This is how the meat industry works: Grains are used to feed
the animals. The animals are slaughtered to provide meat for
humans. In the process of doing this, large amounts of energy
is wasted, and large amounts of greenhouse gases are also
emitted.
According to a report published by the United Nations
Food and Agriculture Organization, the livestock sector
generates 18% of greenhouse gas emissions as measured inCO2 equivalent. That’s more than the pollution generated
13
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
61/82
52 | Do We Have a Choice?
by transport. It is also a major source of land and water
degradation.
My friend, Andy, alerted me to this very interesting newly
released July 2011 report on carbon footprint of eating meat by
the Environmental Working Group:
http://breakingnews.ewg.org/meateatersguide/a-meat-eaters-
guide-to-climate-change-health-what-you-eat-matters/
They listed some fun facts of what can be achieved over a year:
• If you eat one less burger a week, it’s like taking your
car off the road for 320 miles or line-drying your
clothes half the time.
• If your four-person family skips meat and cheese one
day a week, it’s like taking your car off the road forve weeks – or reducing everyone’s daily showers by 3
minutes.
• If your four-person family skips steak once a week,
it’s like taking your car off the road for nearly three
months.
• If everyone in the US ate no meat or cheese just one
day a week, it would be like not driving 91 billion
miles – or taking 7.6 million cars off the road.
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
62/82
53
Of Slaughterhouses
and Baleelds
As long as there are slaughterhouses, there will be battleelds.
– Leo Tolstoy
For as long as men massacre animals, they will kill each other.
– Pythagoras
There is a hypothesis that if humans can be kind to animals,
there is a greater likelihood that they too would be kind toother humans. An international team of scientists has found
that vegans and vegetarians are more empathetic to both
human and animal suffering than non-vegetarians. In this
study, empathy quotient (“EQ”) was measured through a
60-question test, and researchers used functional MRI to
observe brain activity while the subject was shown a variety
of images, including images of human and animal suffering.
Researchers started with the hypothesis that ethical vegans
and vegetarians may experience empathy differently from
non-vegetarians, because the vegans and vegetarians in the
study had all chosen their diets based on certain moral beliefs.
They were correct. The study found that both vegans andvegetarians had a higher empathy than non-vegetarians when
14
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
63/82
54 | Do We Have a Choice?
shown images of human and animal suffering. Interestingly,
the study found that both vegans and vegetarians had more
empathy for non-human animals than for humans!
The information above is extracted from http://animalrights.
about.com/b/2010/06/03/vegans-and-vegetarians-have-more-
empathy.htm
Not to hurt our humble brethren is our rst duty to them,
but to stop there is not enough. We have a higher mission –to be of service to them wherever they require it.
If you have men who will exclude any of God’s creatures
from the shelter of compassion and pity, you will have men who will
deal likewise with their fellow men.
– Francis of Assisi
You might also have noticed that vegetarian animals like the
giraffe, deer, sheep and cow are tame and mild-mannered
while carnivorous animals like the lion, tiger, shark, snake
and T-Rex are ferocious. Interestingly, vegetarian animals
also generally have a much longer lifespan compared with
their carnivorous friends of the same size (see the chapter on
lifespan comparison).
Hmm…eat less meat, live longer, do more good with our lives?
That sure sounds like quite a good deal, doesn’t it?
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
64/82
55
The Compassion
of a Great King
According to the history books, King Asoka of the Mauryan
Dynasty in ancient India was a ruthless warrior. But shortlyafter conquering Kalinga, he realised the error of his ways.
And upon his conversion to Buddhism, he introduced
many changes to inuence the Indian society to be more
compassionate, often leading by example.
On one of his many famous rock edicts, thus it is written:
Hundreds of thousands of living creatures were formerly slaughtered
every day for curries in the kitchens of his Majesty. As this edict is being
inscribed, only three living beings are killed daily: two peacocks and one
deer. And the deer is not slaughtered regularly. In the future, not even
these three animals will be slaughtered.
It was recorded that 2000 animals used to be slaughtereddaily at the King’s palace for the consumption of his family
and the staff at the palace. Upon the King’s decision to
practise compassion to animals, the 2000 animals were
drastically reduced to only three, and from three to almost
zero.
Such was the compassion of a great king.
15
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
65/82
56 | Do We Have a Choice?
I have no doubt that it is a part of the destiny of the human race,
in its gradual improvement, to leave off eating animals,
as surely as the savage tribes have left off eating each other.
– Henry David Thoreau
Some people argue that as long as they do not do the killing,
meat-eating is justied and they have not contributed in any
way to the killing. That, of course, is a matter of personal
opinion. But the supply-demand theory still holds. The killingwill not stop until the eating stops.
All beings fear death.
Putting oneself in the place of another,
one should not kill or cause others to kill.
– The Buddha
Not only did King Asoka promote vegetarianism to his people
by setting a shining example, he also forbade the mutilation,
hunting and sacrice of animals. He built hospitals for
animals, planted Banyan trees along the roads to provide
shade for them, built watering holes for them to drink from,
had a team of ofcers who would feed the animals in the
jungle and protected mother-animals and their young inspecial enclosures during the nursing period. Soon after,
the Cakkavatti Kings in ancient Sri Lanka, Thailand and the
Indo-China region followed in King Asoka’s footsteps. Some
even became veterinarians to serve the animals. These kings
built the rst wild life sanctuaries in the world. Their people
avoided hunting and shing and were largely vegetarians.
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
66/82
Do We Have a Choice? | 57
All these changed when colonization set in.
If you want to know why there are wars in the world, just listento the cries from the slaughterhouse at night. Eating animals for
food has numbed our hearts to the suffering of other living beings.
It is truly inhumane. We must cease the killing of animals and
cherish all lives---not just the lives of human beings but the lives
of all beings. Everything has a life of its own, be it the trees or the
mountains, and taking good care of them in fact safeguards our
own health.
– Master Cheng Yan
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
67/82
58
Vegetarianism preserves life, health, peace, the ecology,
creates a more equitable distribution of resources, helps
to feed the hungry, encourages nonviolence for the animal
and human members of the planet, and is a powerful aid
for the spiritual transformation of the body, emotions,
mind, and spirit.
– Gabriel Cousens
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
68/82
59
Who Lives Longer?
It appears from the list above that vegetarian animals
generally have a longer lifespan compared with carnivorousanimals of the same size and species. Some of the animals
on the list may not be strict vegetarians and are actually
omnivores. We humans are also omnivores, but I have a
feeling that at the rate the modern-day human devours meat,
we may just be eating more meat than the lions and tigers!
Animals eat only when hungry. Humans eat for pleasure.Check out any RM50++ eat-all-you-can buffet on a weekend,
Reptles
Tortoise – 152 years
Turtle – 123 years
Alligator – 63 years
Crocodile – 45 years
Cobra – 28 years
Mammals
Elephant – 70 years
Camel – 50 years
Horse – 50 years
Orang Utan – 50 years
Tyrannosaurus-Rex – 45 years
Deer- 35 years
Lion – 35 years
Tiger – 25 years
Wolf – 16 years
Fox – 14 years BirdsSwan – 102 years
Eagle – 55 years
Vulture – 39 years
Marine Animals
Whale – 116 years
Shark – 30 years
16
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
69/82
60 | Do We Have a Choice?
and you’ll see what I mean. For some, it is all about queuing
up before the doors open, and having brunch, lunch, high-tea
and an early dinner, all rolled into one. And one wonders why
obesity, heart diseases, high cholesterol, diabetes and cancer
are on the rise!
Eat to live, or live to eat?
The choice is ours.
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
70/82
61
Famous Vegetarians
Peace-loving vegetarians – Mahatma Gandhi, Aung Sang
Suu Kyi, Rosa Parks, Jane Goodall, Princess Diana, etc.
Pure genius vegetarians – Albert Einstein, Pythagoras,
Leonardo da Vinci, Socrates, Darwin, Plato, Sir Isaac Newton,
Benjamin Franklin, Thomas Edison, Confucius, Nikola Tesla,
Ramanujan, Leo Tolstoy, Albert Schweitzer, Rabindranath
Tagore, George Bernard Shaw, Anthony Robbins, Steve
Jobs, Kalpana Chawla, etc. (many of them are Nobel Prize
laureates)
Sportspeople vegetarians – Martina Navratilova (nine time
Wimbledon champion), Carl Lewis (nine time Olympic
champion sprinter), Edwin Moses (Olympic champion
hurdles), Billie Jean King (39 Grand Slam titles in tennis),
Joe Namath (professional footballer), Stan Price (world
record bench press), Bill Pearl (four time Mr. Universe),
Dave Scott (six time winner Ironman Triathlon), Charlene
Wong Williams (Olympic champion gure skater), Jack La
Lanne (world-famous tness instructor and swimmer), Tony
Gonzales (All-Pac 10 footballer), Mac Danzig (boxer, martial
artist, athlete), Salim Stoudamire (NBA basketball player),
etc.
17
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
71/82
62 | Do We Have a Choice?
Actor vegetarians – Brad Pitt, Leonardo DiCaprio, Tom
Hanks, Forest Whitaker, Jackie Chan, John Cleese, Dustin
Hoffman, Tobey Maguire, Willem Dafoe, Pierce Brosnan,
Richard Gere, Alec Baldwin, Robert Redford, Danny De Vito,
Christian Bale, etc.
Actress vegetarians – Jessica Biel, Natalie Portman, Anne
Hathaway, Liv Tyler, Ashley Judd, Cameron Diaz, Gwyneth
Paltrow, Pamela Anderson, Kim Basinger, Alicia Silverstone,Alyssa Milano, Jennifer Connelly, Reese Witherspoon, Daryl
Hannah, Candice Bergen, Kate Winslet, Joanna Lumley,
Brigitte Bardot, etc.
Singer vegetarians – Leona Lewis, Shania Twain, Carrie
Underwood, Sade, Tracy Chapman, Vanessa Williams, Annie
Lennox, Avril Lavigne, Justin Timberlake, Sir Paul McCartney
and the Beatles, Bob Dylan, Tina Turner, etc.
The list above is not exhaustive. There are SO many famous
vegetarians in the world – then and now.
If anyone wants to save the planet, all they have to do is just stopeating meat. That’s the single most important thing you could
do. It’s staggering when you think about it. Vegetarianism takes
care of so many things in one shot: ecology, famine, cruelty. I am
a vegetarian because I realise that even little chickens suffer pain
and fear and experience a range of emotions.
– Sir Paul McCartney
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
72/82
63
Take Your Pick
Ready to eat less meat? Here’s what you can be…
Vegans – Vegans avoid ALL animal products. They don’t eateggs, dairy products or even honey. They also avoid using
leather, fur and wool.
Fruitarians – Fruitarians eat only fruits, seeds, nuts and other
plant components that can be gathered without harming the
plant.
Lacto-vegetarians – They eat dairy products but not eggs.
Lacto-ovo-vegetarians – They eat both eggs and dairy
products. They just avoid meat. These would be the most
commonly found vegetarians.
Pesce-vegetarians – They are vegetarians who eat sh.
Pollo-vegetarians – They eat chicken and turkey but avoid
beef and pork.
Flexitarians – They are vegetarians who occasionally eat
some meat.
As stated earlier in this book, a survey conducted in the
UK showed that an average meat-eater would consume
18
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
73/82
64 | Do We Have a Choice?
about 11,000 animals in his lifetime. So, when you choose to
reduce your meat consumption, do give yourself a pat on the
back. You’re already making a difference to the animals and
reducing the suffering of many animals in the factory farms
and slaughterhouses.
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
74/82
65
A Daily Gentle Reminder
Why should I eat less meat?
Reduce Meat to Reduce the Cruelty in Animal Farms –The killing will not stop until the eating stops. The killing can
be reduced if the eating is reduced.
Reduce Meat for Better Health – Meat has saturated fat and
cholesterol, factory-farmed meat is toxic and may contain
Salmonella, E.coli and excessive adrenalin. Factory farming
also contributes to bird u, Japanese Encephalitis and madcow disease. Meat-eating has been associated with a higher
chance of heart disease, high blood pressure, cancer, etc.
Reduce Meat for Conservation of the Environment –
Reduce our carbon footprint and save the forests, our land,
the rivers and the very air that we breathe.
Reduce Meat to Alleviate World Hunger – Food for
livestock cultivation can be channeled to alleviate world
hunger if people eat less meat.
Reduce Meat for World Peace – It is sometimes said
that world peace begins at the dinner table. Vegetarians
are generally more gentle and peace-loving. That’s food forthought!
19
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
75/82
66
True benevolence, or compassion, extends itself through
the whole of existence and sympathizes with the distress of
every creature capable of sensation.
– Joseph Addison
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
76/82
67
Epilogue
In this little book, I have shared with you many reasons why
we might like to consider reducing our meat consumption.
For me, personally, I only need one reason – compassion for
the animals.
The suffering that goes on in factory farms is horrendous. We
can make a difference in reducing the number of animals that
need to be bred to be slaughtered even if we just go meatless
once a week.
So, let us make a conscious, conscientious and well-informed
choice towards more compassionate eating.
Remember that we ALWAYS have a choice.
To my mind, the life of a lamb is no less precious than that of ahuman being. I should be unwilling to take the life of a lamb for
the sake of the human body.
– Mahatma Gandhi
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
77/82
68
Bumper Scker Quotes
We don’t need to eat anyone who would run, swim,
or y away if he could.
– James Cromwell
One may not eat what has a face.
– Paul McCartney
A vegetarian is a person who won’t eat anything
that can have children.
– David Brenner
How can you eat anything with eyes?
– Will Kellogg
We all love animals. Why do we call some “pets” and others “dinner?”
– K.D. Lang
Animals are my friends, and I don’t eat my friends.
– George Bernard Shaw
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
78/82
69
Prayer of gentleness to all creatures
To all the humble beasts there be,
To all the birds on land and sea,
Great Spirit, sweet protection give
That free and happy they may live!
And to our hearts the rapture bring
Of love for every living thing;Make us all one kin, and bless
Our ways with Nature’s gentleness!
– John Galsworthy
(1867 – 1933)
Nobel Prize winner (Literature) 1932
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
79/82
70
I am sometimes asked “Why do you spend so much of your time
and money talking about kindness to animals when there is so
much cruelty to men?”
I answer: “I am working at the roots.”
— George T. Angell
8/17/2019 DoWeHaveAChoicee Book
80/82
Working together for the animals
AnimalCare is a charity that promotes caregiving to strayanimals and helps in their spay-neuter and medical needs.
Our Mission
1. To encourage people to be caregivers to animals.
2. To help in the spaying-neutering and medical needs ofstray animals.
3. To cultivate compassion to animals through education
How you can help and participate:
a. Be a caregiver to stray animals – feed the animals, getthem spayed/neutered and continue looking after themin a responsible manner. If you require help in spaying/neutering, please contact us.
b. Be a volunteer – help foster and rehome rescued animals,and contribute your expertise and skills so that we canwork together to provide more help to the animals.
c. Be our supporter – tell your friends about our work and
encourage them to start a similar programme in their owncommunities. Educate children from young to be kind toanimals.